Pod Insights The Vergecast Version History: Harmony remote About this episode The Harmony Universal Remote was supposed to be the only controller you needed for all the devices in your life. So what happened? David Pierce is joined by The Verge’s Nilay Patel and John Higgins, as well as Nest co-founder (and current Harmony user) Matt Rogers, to follow the Harmony's timeline from its origins as the "Easy Zapper," through Logitech's acquisition, all the way to its slow death at the hands of smart TVs. And their vastly inferior remotes.
If you like the show, follow the Version History audio podcast feed to get every new episode.
Version History is also on video! Check us out on YouTube.
Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed.
We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 16,269 words · 13 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome to The Vergecast, the flagship podcast of IR Blasters. I'm your friend David Pierce and our regular show is off today, but we want to play you an episode from the new season of Version History. Version History, if you don't know, is our show about old technology. We tell the story of some of the most important products in tech history. On this episode, it's one of our favorites. It's the Harmony Remote, the universal remote that promised to give you one thing to control everything. It's me, Neelai Patel, The Verge's John Higgins and Matt Rogers, the former co-founder of Nest. Nest, by the way, another episode we're doing this season, but Matt demanded to talk about Harmony. It's a really fun episode. I think you'll enjoy it. Here it is. Around the turn of the century,
0:42 Speaker 00 two guys in Canada had an idea that maybe they could build a product that could simultaneously control your TV, your home theater, your VCR, your DVD player and everything else in your living room. And that maybe if they could get that product into your living room, all that would be just the beginning. From The Verge of Vox Media, this is Version History, a show about the best and worst and strangest and most important products in tech history. I'm David Pierce and today it's time for the story of the Harmony Remote.
1:23 Speaker 01 Companies shouldn't have to choose between speed and control. Amex Corporate connects cards with flexible spending controls and real-time visibility to help teams adapt faster. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
1:47 Speaker 02 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an Ultra. Because it's not just a superior light beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser-Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
2:16 Speaker 03 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
2:25 Speaker 04 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
2:33 Speaker 03 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
2:46 Speaker 00 All right, we're back. It is time for what I think is going to be a strangely heated conversation about TV remotes. Joining me in the studio, Neelai Patel.
2:53 Speaker 05 Hello.
2:54 Speaker 00 How many Harmony remotes would you say you've owned and used over the years?
2:57 Speaker 05 Over half a dozen, which is a lot. I mean, a lot. This category lasted maybe 10 years and I had over six is what I'm going to say.
3:03 Speaker 00 Also here, John Higgins, our TV and audio reviewer. You have as long a history with Harmony stuff as just about anybody, it seems like.
3:11 Speaker 06 Harmony remotes were one of the first things that I reviewed back 20-plus years ago when I was at Home Theater Magazine.
3:17 Speaker 00 Also joining us remotely, Matt Rogers, CEO of Mill, the co-founder of Nest back in the day, who I will just say fairly straightforwardly demanded to be on this episode. Matt, welcome to the show.
3:27 Speaker 07 I have a lot of opinions about this.
3:29 Speaker 00 Yeah. Tell us briefly about your Harmony history.
3:33 Speaker 07 I had no choice. There's nothing else out there like this. And even though this product has been gone for a long time, still user.
3:39 Speaker 05 That's amazing.
3:40 Speaker 00 That is.
3:40 Speaker 05 Nest had a lot of Logitech people at it, from what I recall.
3:44 Speaker 07 Many.
3:44 Speaker 05 Was that you saying, "I gotta get some of this Harmony juice at Nest"?
3:48 Speaker 07 Yeah, look, and their product marketing team, I thought, was one of the best in the business. And this was kind of the golden age of Logitech, 2000s, early 2010s.
3:56 Speaker 00 Also in studio with us, we have, I think, three different Harmony remotes which go from a few buttons and a screen on the bottom, which is weird, to a lot of buttons and a screen on the top, which is more or less the Harmony story, as we're about to get into. So let's dive in here, because there's actually a fair amount of history to get into, and then we are just going to litigate the best Harmony remote model for one to seven hours. So I want to go back to 1999, which is where our story starts. And actually, Neelai, I need you to do just a tiny bit of level Setting for us for people who were not alive or paying attention or buying home theater gear.
4:30 Speaker 05 Why am I always the old guy on this show?
4:32 Speaker 00 All of us could do this, I will say, but but you, I'm betting of the four of us may have owned the most home theater gear at this time. Like, if I just had a guess.
4:40 Speaker 05 Yeah.
4:40 Speaker 00 So a thing that was happening right around now is there's this explosion of stuff in your in your living room that you might be using and needing to control in some way. Can you just paint us a picture of what that ecosystem started to look like in your living room right around this time?
4:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, you know how now if you have kids and they're into sports, you buy a lot of sports gear? My parents had me. So in our living room, we had a giant Toshiba rear projection TV that was connected to a, at that time, cutting edge Dolby Pro Logic 2 receiver. So these are immediately two things you need to control. That thing had four inputs like that mattered. So there was the VHS player, which was still very relevant at that time, the DVD player, the CD player, and of course, the tape deck. The only thing that we cut out in that period of time was we we set aside the record player. Which has now made a ferocious comeback. But so you just had this proliferation of devices.
5:38 Speaker 05 All of them came with their own IR remotes. And the individual manufacturers all had their own weird proprietary control systems. So we were a pioneer family, so most of our stuff was pioneer. And you could plug headphone cable in between the receiver and the CD player. And that would let you use the receiver's remote to control the CD player.
6:00 Speaker 00 Good lord.
6:00 Speaker 05 This was a total nightmare.
6:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:02 Speaker 05 And so you just had the coffee table with six remotes on it. Because sometimes what you wanted was to play a CD. And sometimes what you wanted was to play a VHS. And sometimes what you wanted was to play a tape. And you had to switch inputs on the receiver. You had to tell the TV what what thing was going to happen because often your game console is plugged directly into the TV. And then you had to control playback on whatever device. And you're just now you're five remotes.
6:25 Speaker 06 And always had the volume with the receiver.
6:27 Speaker 05 And you definitely wanted the volume on the receiver.
6:29 Speaker 06 Yeah.
6:30 Speaker 05 And so that that remote just was there for one function alone. Would to control the volume and then all of your transport controls, your playback controls were usually somewhere else. And then on top of it.
6:40 Speaker 00 Oh, my God.
6:40 Speaker 05 If your life was like a pure kind of hell. You also had a cable box or a satellite box. And that remote was just its own kind of nightmare at all times.
6:53 Speaker 05 And none of this stuff could talk to each other in any meaningful way.
6:56 Speaker 00 Matt, you've been nodding along. Does this all feel about right to you? Can you best in Eli's chaos?
7:00 Speaker 07 It was an awful time.
7:03 Speaker 07 What would happen is inevitably, one of the batteries would have been taken out of one of the remotes, of which, you know, like teenage Matt would have to say, like, why is nothing working? It was usually someone left the batteries out. It was not a good time.
7:16 Speaker 00 The reason I wanted to do this upfront is because like, this is such an obvious problem, with an obvious solution that everybody understands to be a better idea. What if I just had one remote to control everything? So this is, this is, this starts to happen. There had been this big explosion in this market in the 1980s, when Sony won a lawsuit about the VCR. People start wanting to record and watch stuff in different ways. So this is just like exploding. Steve Wozniak, at one point, leaves Apple to go found a company doing a universal remote. Philips was making remotes. Harman Kardon was making remotes. Like, this was a thing that was out there. But then these two guys named Glenn Harris and Justin Henry decide that they want to make their own. They get super annoyed at all these remotes and decide to make something better. And they create a company. And this is, the first product ends up with this name.
7:57 Speaker 00 And this is a true test of your Harmony knowledge. It was not called the Harmony. Do any of you remember what it was called?
8:03 Speaker 07 This is the Easy Zapper?
8:04 Speaker 00 It is the Easy Zapper. Good work.
8:07 Speaker 07 Throwback.
8:08 Speaker 00 So they, they, they start a company called Easy Zapper. And this is, this is the thing that they want to do. They, they eventually changed their company name to Intrigue Technologies, which I would argue was like vastly worse than Easy Zapper.
8:18 Speaker 05 It's a, that's a real toss up.
8:20 Speaker 00 So they decide to start building a, a remote. And actually, um, in a certain way, this is an easy problem. And in a certain way, this is a very hard problem. Because all the stuff you just described, Neelai, is like fundamentally uncomplicated technology.
8:33 Speaker 05 That makes people think it's an easy problem is why it's a hard problem.
8:36 Speaker 00 Explain.
8:37 Speaker 07 It is a super hard problem. Like, remember, no one publishes their specs.
8:41 Speaker 05 No one publishes their specs. All of them use different IR codes. The IR codes conflict. And Matt, I'm curious if this is your read on it as the actual technologist here. There's no feedback loop to validate that you've done the right thing, except the dumb person sitting there holding the remote, who has no idea what's going on.
8:58 Speaker 07 Yeah, this is wild. Like, this is an era before Bluetooth. Yeah, for the kids at home. Back in the day, us grandparents, the way our devices would communicate is they would blast light to each other, but light you could not see. And it was a very bad technology. Uh, very, very slow.
9:15 Speaker 00 It was all we had.
9:16 Speaker 07 Very unreliable.
9:17 Speaker 05 Yeah, there is a little light bulb, like a little LED at the tip of the remote. And you would push a button and it would flash in a sequence that would indicate volume up. It's in all these remotes today. There's just more Bluetooth in the world. But you would hold the two remotes and the whatever universal remote, including the Harmony's, had a sensor in them. So the fallback, if the codes online didn't work, was you would put it in like a learn mode and you would hold the volume up on your remote. And it would watch the flashes and learn the code for volume up.
9:47 Speaker 00 So it's essentially just like doing Morse code with light.
9:49 Speaker 05 Yep.
9:49 Speaker 07 He's doing Morse code with light. Exactly. To your point on like, the devices didn't know if it worked or not. There was no like check, check codes. There was no acknowledgement. It was just like sending your Morse code out into the ether and hoping it got there.
10:02 Speaker 05 So everything about it that makes it seem easy, I just have to clone this set of IR codes, is actually why it's impossibly hard and everyone who's ever tried it has failed in some kind of comical disaster.
10:13 Speaker 00 Yes. So that's actually a perfect description of the problem that they set out to solve. And one of the biggest problems is like, how do we know what's happening with any of your devices? And this ends up being like a foundational piece of the technology that they build is they actually patent a system that allows the remote to store information about the state of your other devices. So it, rather than just-
10:34 Speaker 05 Does it?
10:35 Speaker 00 Again, does it work? Who knows?
10:37 Speaker 05 I think what I'm-
10:37 Speaker 00 Did they get a patent for it? Hell, yeah.
10:39 Speaker 05 I think what I can preview for the audience here is Matt and I feel very differently about the Harmony remotes.
10:47 Speaker 07 I can't tell you how many hours have been spent on getting this thing right. Or even like the timing is like, you know, adding delay between commands. Whew.
10:57 Speaker 05 It's a lot.
10:58 Speaker 07 It's tough.
10:59 Speaker 00 So they, they set out, there's also this thing happening, right? There's a, the, the personal computer revolution is happening. Lots of people are getting computers. Lots of people are getting access to the internet. So they, they decide like, oh, one way we can solve a whole bunch of this problem is to take the, the systems for controlling all of these different devices. And rather than make you program each individual one yourself, or just press a button and hope and pray something good happens, we can let you sort of build these systems for yourself. And I just want to read you a line. This is from a Washington Post story at the- And I want to point out, this is describing a good idea that works well. This is how they describe it. Instead of adding control codes for new gear through sequential button pushing on the remote, you can use a more or less friendly computer interface, then transfer the new smarts to the remote with a serial cable. These come with control codes stored onboard, so you don't need a computer to start using them.
11:44 Speaker 00 Once you're done downloading or editing new control codes, you can then rearrange the on-screen buttons on these remotes backladed, touch-sensitive PDA-style displays. This is the absolute state-of-the-art remote technology.
11:54 Speaker 05 Simple.
11:55 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:55 Speaker 05 Totally simple.
11:57 Speaker 00 They, I think, knew, it seems like the very beginning, that they're building like an absolute power user system here, right? Like, this is not for the faint of heart, right? And at this time, John, you were like, you were in this space early on. There were not like a bunch of other easy takes at this. There doesn't seem to have been a way to do this that was easy.
12:16 Speaker 06 No, none of them were easy.
12:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:17 Speaker 06 All of them were designed for people that at least thought they knew what they were doing.
12:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. So again, this is, the team calls it smart state technology.
12:28 Speaker 05 Perfect.
12:28 Speaker 00 And again, did it work? Who's to say? But boy, was it a thing that they patented and made a big deal out of. We have one of the first remotes that they made. I think not the first one, but one of the first ones here in the studio with us. And it is just one of the most bizarre remotes you will ever see. Because there is a screen on the bottom of it.
12:46 Speaker 05 This is the most upside-down remote I've ever seen. I walked into the studio and constantly said, "That's upside-down."
12:52 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:52 Speaker 05 And it absolutely is.
12:53 Speaker 00 Sure isn't.
12:54 Speaker 05 So the screen is at the bottom. Then there's the numb pad zone, which has arrows around the 8, which makes no sense because the 8 itself is not directional. The buttons under the arrows, like the 5 has an up arrow under it, but the 5 is up. That makes no sense. Then you've got a button labeled "Zap." Unclear what that does.
13:12 Speaker 00 Oh, I got answers for that one.
13:13 Speaker 05 Then you've got, you know, mute, recall. Then you've got your transport controls at the top. Again, the play button has directional arrows around it, but it's not directional.
13:22 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
13:22 Speaker 05 So this makes no sense. And at the very top, you have the red IR window. Any human being would look at this and think it was upside-down. Even the way the mold lines and the plastic are oriented make you think it's upside-down. Like, there's no way this thing is upside-down.
13:36 Speaker 06 It's more comfortable.
13:38 Speaker 05 They took an existing remote and they just printed all the buttons upside-down.
13:42 Speaker 06 It naturally puts your hand further forward.
13:46 Speaker 07 Which means you can't get to the number pad.
13:48 Speaker 05 It's very good.
13:49 Speaker 00 This one we have is not the very first one. Um, I can show you a picture of the very first one, which is an incredibly simplified version of the same thing. So you can see it has, it has two Easy Zapper logos on it, which I appreciate. By the time they started selling them, they were calling them Harmony remotes. They seemed to really chicken out on Easy Zapper as a name.
14:08 Speaker 05 Yeah.
14:09 Speaker 00 Progressively over time as a company.
14:10 Speaker 05 They left the zap button.
14:11 Speaker 00 But they did. So would you like to talk about zaps?
14:14 Speaker 05 I would love to.
14:15 Speaker 00 So one of the things that this remote could do, uh, and I, I want to underscore the ambition behind Harmony and Easy Zapper and all of the things that this is supposed to be. This was not just supposed to be a universal remote for all of your stuff. This had such enormous dreams for what it might be. So the very first thing it could do is it had this screen down at the bottom. And when you connected it to the internet, by which they meant literally plug it into a wire.
14:39 Speaker 05 Into your PC.
14:39 Speaker 00 Into your PC. It could download program listings for your TV onto your, onto the four line screen on the remote. Uh, and you could actually scroll through the TV guide on your remote, press something and have it basically deep link you right to the thing that you wanted to watch. So it's like a little tiny TV guide on your remote. And that was what, it was called zapping programs. But again, this is, this is only the very beginning. They had, they had this idea and, and remember this is like 1999, 2000, 2001. They had this idea that maybe if you're watching a cooking show, you should be able to press a button on your remote and immediately be taken to a webpage containing the recipe for the thing that they're making. Or maybe you should be able to.
15:21 Speaker 05 Oh boy.
15:22 Speaker 07 This is the era of TiVo, right? Like this is like, I think we all forget about what was going on in, in the world this time. Like this was a really important feature. Like, you know, we had just started having the ability to like record shows at our houses. Like everything was appointment viewing back in the day.
15:37 Speaker 05 Web TV was everywhere.
15:39 Speaker 07 Yeah, it's a different era.
15:40 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, this is like, there is this term, the digital living room. That is such a thing at this moment, and kind of forever. Like, everyone has always tried to figure out, how do we put technology in your hands while you sit on your couch? How do we access you while you're watching TV? Is like a huge, everybody understands how much money there is at. This becomes a big part of the Alexa pitch. You can go watch a show on Amazon now, and all it does is give you links to buy the things in the show. This is what Google ends up being up to with Google TV. There is this idea that if we can just put an internet-connected device within reach while you sit on your couch, something will happen.
16:20 Speaker 05 No, it's not something. We all know what it is now.
16:22 Speaker 00 We'll make tons of money.
16:22 Speaker 05 You'll buy something.
16:23 Speaker 00 Right.
16:24 Speaker 05 By the way, this idea that there will be these feedback loops to your TV, it's gonna come up over and over again in this story. You're watching something on TV, and you want to close the loop and buy the shirt that Rachel was wearing on Friends. How are we gonna close that loop? How are we gonna detect that shirt and then give you a buy button? And the answer at the time, as Matt is pointing out, is like, we're gonna put a computer on the TV, and it's gonna run MSN. And it's like, why are you doing that? Don't do that. And the whole industry chased this dream forever. And on the other end is, you're gonna hold the device in your hand that has no idea what's going on on the TV. And that's gonna control everything.
17:05 Speaker 05 And you can see, even to this day, the feedback loops are not perfectly closed. Like, it is the dream of the industry.
17:12 Speaker 07 I mean, this is also a moment in time before Facebook, before YouTube, where most of advertising dollars were putting things on TV. Like, TV advertising was all of the money in marketing. So you think about, like, you know, in the spirit of building startups, like, chasing where the money is, like, that is where the money was then.
17:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, and again, this is like the early internet days when there's a real sort of internet 1.0 belief that maybe one of the most important computers you own will be your television. Like, you might have a computer on your desk or whatever, but maybe you'll come home and you'll do a computer on your TV. That didn't pan out. But it was, this is the thing they're trying to do and, and the easy zapper idea is maybe we can be the literal remote for that, that this can be the way that you watch television and the way that you buy things. So even in their press release launching this thing, and again, this is what zapping is, that you're zapping things to and from the internet, which I think is a cool phrase that we should bring back.
18:12 Speaker 00 It says, it says with this feature, zaps, you can buy a music video, link to new sports equipment, or lift a recipe from your favorite cooking show. You will never have to do a web search for something you saw on TV again. Well, then.
18:24 Speaker 00 What an idea. So again, this is like, they're, they very much are thinking about this as more than just a way to control all of your stuff. But they have to control all of your stuff in order for this to work. Like, Matt, you have a long history in smart home stuff, and I just want to know your read on this as a smart home guy. Cause like, in a very real way, this is not a TV product, this is a smart home product.
18:43 Speaker 07 Yeah, it really, it really is.
18:43 Speaker 00 25 years ago, is there, is there something to this?
18:46 Speaker 07 Oh, absolutely. Again, also, and this is an era in history where the other side of kind of smart home was extremely high-end custom integration. You know, wealthy people spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to have these control boxes that allowed them to change the channel and have all their systems work with one remote. The era of Creston, for example, you know, custom integrators. So the, this idea that, that everybody could get that technology and control all of their home theater with one thing is, I mean, it's kind of a bold statement at the time.
19:19 Speaker 00 John, do you remember in these early days, like you, you were covering this stuff from the TV side? Did this actually have legs at the time, did you think?
19:25 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely. Because it was, as Matt just said, they were trying to cater to the people that wanted the control for the Creston systems.
19:35 Speaker 06 And have them be more accessible in their homes that they could do. They didn't have to pay somebody to come in and set up their TV, their curtains, their lighting.
19:45 Speaker 05 I just want to take a pause here and point out that the smart home integrator market is bigger and more lucrative than ever because this problem has not been solved.
19:54 Speaker 06 I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I tried. I tried. I tried.
19:59 Speaker 05 I'm just saying like Crestor didn't go anywhere. They just got bigger.
20:03 Speaker 00 So yeah, so in addition to all of this, it goes about trying to find smart ways to control all of the stuff in your house. And it winds up with this system that sort of fails gracefully by design, but I think in most practical cases fails sort of spectacularly, which is that on the one hand, you can go and download the various control systems for various devices. And so somebody would do the learn mode thing and say like, this is how you control this Toshiba receiver. They would upload it to the Harmony website and then you could go and download it and then you would already have all the controls baked into your remote. So it ends up being this sort of crowdsourced problem, which as far as I understand winds up being really good and useful because this is like how the Harmony remote winds up having more compatibility than anything else. Because my assumption
20:48 Speaker 00 would be, I didn't have nearly as much cool home theater equipment as you guys did. But in those days, if you have a remote that solves half of your living room problem, but not the other half, you've kind of solved no problems.
21:00 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
21:00 Speaker 00 Like if I'm going from six remotes to four, I've spent a bunch of money for no reason. And this seems to be one of the like main issues with a lot of the universal remotes at the time, right?
21:08 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely.
21:09 Speaker 00 So the Harmony gets way ahead of this by basically letting people solve this problem for themselves and share it with each other, which I think is very cool. And then it comes down to, I would say, smartly trying to guess what you're doing. When you press the volume button, for instance, it would actually try to guess what, based on what you had done recently, which device you might be trying to control.
21:30 Speaker 05 This is where this all falls apart.
21:31 Speaker 00 Yes. And then, and then from there, it just goes straight down to just pointed at things and hope.
21:37 Speaker 00 What I wonder is like, was this just a completely unsolvable problem in that sense? Like, how could you have done this better?
21:44 Speaker 05 There's some stuff you know. So like, as John pointed out, you almost always want volume to happen on the receiver. So they would just hard map the volume buttons to receiver, and that's that. Then there's, as the product line got more and more complicated and more and more developed over time, they developed what can only be described as macros. So you would push "watch TV", and it would just issue sequences of IR commands. And as Matt was saying, like, they would adjust the timing. So it's like, you turn on the receiver, and then the receiver would take a second to boot up. And then, at the right instant, it would send the input code to the receiver. If you sent it too early or too late, you'd miss the window because the receiver was on to whatever next thing it was doing. And then you also got to turn the TV on and make sure this happens. And like, watch a movie, if you just imagine yourself as a person doing it with six remotes.
22:29 Speaker 05 You're going to pick up the receiver remote, turn on the power, the TV remote, turn on the power, the DVD, right, you're going to do all that stuff with your hands. The Harmony is like, "That's a sequence we can automate. It's a macro. We'll just issue all those commands with like, little time delays to make sure it works." The problem is, we've been pointing out over and over again, is it has no idea if any of these things happened. So then you end up with this remote that's perfectly programmed for maybe nothing being in the right state.
22:53 Speaker 07 Yeah, it was right maybe 80% of the time. It was like, you know, you'd spend all this time to program it and get it right. And then, you know, obviously, these are a lot of analog systems too. So, timing maybe variable, timing changes, or, and then you have to reprogram all over again. I used to tell my wife this all the time. She's like, "How come the TV's not turning on?" I'm like, "Hit the off button, it'll all go off, start over again. Start over again."
23:17 Speaker 05 It was the key move. And the weird dynamic here, one, is the software was horrible. Particularly if you were a Mac user, the Logitech software to program these remotes was just garbage. I believe it was made in like Macromedia Director. Like, it wasn't even like a Mac app. It was like a fake app that would go talk to the web in like weird ways and like, totally crap. Like, none of this was good. Like, eventually Steve Jobs was like, "I'm not going to have Flash on the iPhone", and I think it's because he tried to program a Harmony here. But like, it was that level of bad. Right? So you'd end up in this weird, and it was wizard based. So even if like you're like, I know what to fix. I just need to go fix it. It'd be like, it looks like you're trying to program your remote. And you're like, I hate you. Like, get out of my way. I just need to change this one button.
24:00 Speaker 05 So this is a nightmare. And then there's this huge, boy, do I have a lot of feelings for this, right? Then there's this huge gap in what's actually happening here, which is the biggest nerd in the family has a toy. And they have bought the toy and they've fought through macro media director to program the toy. And then when they're done screwing with the toy, everyone else in the house is compelled to use the toy. And the toy is brittle in ways that delight the nerd and absolutely frustrate everyone else. And no one has the, just the straight up honesty to admit that they have become a underpaid systems administrator for a piece of junk. They're like, I can fix it. And like, you're just off to the races because the primary user of all that automation does not care about any of this.
24:44 Speaker 00 Right.
24:45 Speaker 05 Like for one second. And you, as the big nerd, are totally fine dealing with six remotes.
24:49 Speaker 00 Right. This is like the famous babysitter test, right? Like, can a person who has no experience with your system come and sit down and use it? And I feel like in theory, universal remotes are supposed to be the solution to that problem, right? Instead of a tray of remotes in front of you, here's the one that you use for everything.
25:05 Speaker 07 I cannot believe how many times the babysitter would be texting me saying, I can't figure out how to.
25:11 Speaker 07 Like, this was my house, literally.
25:13 Speaker 05 Yeah. Well, it's a matter, you have like, you're still using the thing. You have much of a positive view of this. Give me the pitch.
25:19 Speaker 07 There's literally no choice. This is like, this is, this is the problem. It's like, literally no other option. Because I refuse to give Crestor on a hundred thousand dollars to fix this problem. And we'll get to it. Like, the, the, the ebbs and flows of the Harmony business over the years, like, there's still nothing else like it out there.
25:36 Speaker 00 So actually, this is, this is a good moment. Let's take a quick break and then we're going to get into it. And then the, the fate of Harmony changes very quickly. We're going to get into that. We'll be right back.
25:48 Speaker 02 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends. Like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest, or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an Ultra. Because it's not just a superior light beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
26:17 Speaker 03 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
26:26 Speaker 04 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
26:34 Speaker 03 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
26:47 Speaker 08 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
27:18 Speaker 00 All right, we're back. The Harmony ships in 2001. It costs $299 Canadian, $199 US dollars, which I would argue is a pretty solid price as universal remotes go.
27:30 Speaker 06 It held that price for a little while.
27:31 Speaker 00 It did for a long time, yeah. And then in 2004, Logitech buys Intrig Technologies, nay, Easy Zapper, for $29 million in cash plus performance-based bonuses. Pretty good deal. And in this, in this deal, Logitech is very clear that it wants the full vision of the thing. It's not just a controller for your television. They want this digital living room thing. They want the big ideas about what they're up to. And Neelai, I have a sentence that is going to make you feel so many feelings. And I would like everyone to react to this sentence. This is from Gherino De Luca, who was the Logitech CEO at the time. He said, and I quote, "We see the remote control as the mouse of the digital house."
28:12 Speaker 00 I believe he said that earnestly and with a straight face. John, how does that make you feel? I don't know, a little dirty, maybe?
28:20 Speaker 07 Never rhyme in like, it's just like, what is this? Oh, gosh.
28:26 Speaker 00 The mouse of the digital house.
28:27 Speaker 05 Green DeLuca, he has like a bunch of these. Like, he's a character in the industry at this time.
28:31 Speaker 00 Well, very much so. And Logitech is also like, kind of on top of the world. This company is making very good stuff. The other phrase they use a lot is, they like last inch devices. They make a lot of mice and keyboards and it's like, they talk about, you know, last mile with, with delivery stuff. He's all about the last inch.
28:47 Speaker 05 Nope.
28:47 Speaker 07 We used to call those accessories when we were in Apple.
28:50 Speaker 00 What fun is that?
28:52 Speaker 05 That's great.
28:53 Speaker 00 Maybe my computer is an accessory to my keyboard, Matt.
28:58 Speaker 05 The mouse for your digital house really, really misses on where the computer of your digital house will be. This is, this is a vision that's like, you gotta operate a computer somewhere.
29:09 Speaker 00 So this is a fascinating thing because this is 2004, right? So this is before the iPhone. This is before, smartphones even are ubiquitous everywhere, but like, we're deep in like the BlackBerry age by now. We're doing phones with internet access. It's already clear to some people who are paying attention that we are starting to move into a new kind of device with a new kind of powers. And they're here being like, it's the remote control. And so this is, I just want to pause at this moment and ask, in 2004, was, should Logitech have bought this company for this giant vision of what it was going to do for the home? Or was it already barking up the wrong tree?
29:50 Speaker 07 I think, I think they got sold the dream. Yeah, I think, look again, knowing how the accessory business works, like you sell these very high margin accessories, they're probably, you know, 50, 60% margin on these things, but they were, they're chasing this dream of, you know, can we be a services business, can we be an advertising business? You know, TiVo had gone public a few years earlier.
30:10 Speaker 00 Uh, web TV what got bought by Microsoft for a gazillion dollars. So they're probably looking at that as, hey, like, we need to get a piece of that market, too.
30:16 Speaker 05 Yeah, and owning and controlling the user interface is always where the power is, right?
30:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
30:20 Speaker 05 So all those things came with remotes before, like, my remote will have a screen on it and control all that stuff because you can't stop me because it's all I are. Sure, you could, you can get there. Then there's whatever other automations that you might wish to link to your harmony. And you're like, we're going to sell this out of the box control system to consumers and that's going to be a big market. That said, if you are looking at the things people are buying that computerized their house at that time, man, you run right into the fact that the TiVo remote is really good.
30:46 Speaker 00 Hmm.
30:47 Speaker 05 Right, like, it is just a really good remote that people love. It's not the best selling DVR, but that's the high watermark for remotes.
30:53 Speaker 00 Right.
30:53 Speaker 05 It was far more ergonomic than any of these harmonies ever, ever turned out to be. Then you run into the fact that actually, your real problem is the cable company is shipping universal remotes with all their cable boxes because they know that their customers, they just need the TV to turn on and the volume to go up and down. And they can solve that problem with a very cheap universal remote that everyone remembers, like, plastic gray bubble remote.
31:14 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
31:15 Speaker 05 This is your, this is your real competition.
31:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:18 Speaker 05 You gotta do better than that. It is surprisingly hard to do better than free plastic bubble remote for 90% of people.
31:24 Speaker 00 The one that comes with my cable box is pretty much good enough.
31:27 Speaker 05 And that thing defeated TiVo. Like, it just, we did the TiVo episode and that thing just defeated TiVo.
31:31 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:32 Speaker 05 So I, I think they, they bought into a vision, there's certainly a market. I think what they truly missed is that eventually, the computer would end up inside the TV.
31:43 Speaker 00 Hmm.
31:43 Speaker 05 Right, and then the TV's remote would do everything. And because the, your, the interface is actually going to be on the television. And I don't think anybody saw that happening at the rate at which it happened, but the TV going from dumb to smart, I, like, I, the second that happened, the harmony was done.
31:59 Speaker 00 Right. John, are there any glimmers of this happening in the TV industry yet? Like, at this moment, what's going on in TV world?
32:05 Speaker 06 2004? Um, no, I mean, we're still staunchly dumb TV.
32:11 Speaker 00 Okay.
32:11 Speaker 06 Area, uh, and the remotes that are coming with those TVs, for the most part, aren't behaving well with others.
32:19 Speaker 00 So most people still have this real need.
32:22 Speaker 06 Yeah, I believe so.
32:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
32:23 Speaker 06 At that point, there was still the dream of wanting to be able to control everything at once with one remote.
32:29 Speaker 05 Yeah, definitely two boxes. You had a cable box and some sort of VHS player, DVD player. Like, at the very least, you had three things. Right? Like, that was a pretty standard setup for most people.
32:38 Speaker 00 One of the fascinating personal revelations of preparing for this episode has been that my family had just like a giant-ass CRT TV with rabbit ears and nothing else for way longer than it was like cool or appropriate. We got cable for the first time in 2007, and it was like life-changing.
32:54 Speaker 07 Yeah, look, this is a, it was, again, it was a real problem back then. Especially if you had game consoles, stereo, these things really made this so complicated. But the core problem here is like, there's not a real business selling remotes. I think this is why they had to sell the dream.
33:11 Speaker 00 Yeah.
33:11 Speaker 07 That, you know, we could do more than just be a remote company, because the remote business is not a good business.
33:16 Speaker 00 Yeah. No, I think that's right. So, but Logitech buys this company, and I would say pretty immediately, we enter what you would call the golden age of the Harmony Remote. This remote in front of us, the Harmony 880, comes out in 2005, a year later. They just turn around and ship this thing. And there are people who would argue this is the best Harmony Remote ever.
33:36 Speaker 05 This is, I would say, the canonical Harmony Remote.
33:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, I agree.
33:38 Speaker 05 This is the one most people remember as the Harmony Remote. They've oriented it correctly.
33:42 Speaker 06 Screen's at the top now.
33:43 Speaker 05 The screen is at the top. It is reasonably ergonomic. It's got the, like, trigger fingers, the bottom here, so you can really, you can really zap with abandon. Great D-pad, and then the screen here shows macros and the control buttons are on the side. So you're like, watch TV, and you push this button, and like, things happen.
34:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is, I think, when pretty much every Harmony Remote after this looks like this, in some sort of big structural way. And this just becomes the look of Harmony remotes. This also-
34:11 Speaker 05 By the way, the fundamental error of this remote, as cool as it is, just try at a glance to identify where the volume buttons are.
34:20 Speaker 00 I found him.
34:21 Speaker 05 Yeah.
34:21 Speaker 00 That took a long time.
34:22 Speaker 05 They're hidden on the side as part of like a design element. And the plus button is, in a monumentally stupid decision, smaller than the minus button. I could not tell you why that is.
34:34 Speaker 07 It's also really hard to use in the dark. Yeah, like if you're like watching a movie, like it's, it's, it was hard. It was really, yeah, they, they didn't, they didn't nail that.
34:43 Speaker 05 Uh, but it did come with this killer charging dock, which is very cool.
34:46 Speaker 00 So from here, the, the story sort of speeds ahead. Uh, until about 2013, when stuff starts to get wacky. But I would just like to give all of you an opportunity. This is, now is the moment that if you have deep and abiding love for a particular Harmony Remote, I would like you to profess it right now, before the whole thing starts to fall apart, and it does so very, very, very, very, very quickly. John, now is your time.
35:09 Speaker 06 Harmony One.
35:10 Speaker 00 Tell me.
35:10 Speaker 06 It felt great in my hands. Actually, I'm gonna, I'm gonna pause for a minute because I feel...
35:16 Speaker 05 He's getting emotional.
35:16 Speaker 06 Well, I, I definitely have some rose colored glasses on.
35:21 Speaker 00 Okay.
35:21 Speaker 06 Cause as I'm starting to think about the touchscreen where it, it broke it up, there were like four buttons you could fit on each screen. I, I was about to say, it's great, you could hit your watch TV or play, play games. It was very inaccurate in my experience.
35:38 Speaker 05 It was resistive, right?
35:39 Speaker 06 A little bit. And I can't say the number of times that I went to hit, maybe it's the size of my hands, I went to hit watch TV and play games was what my thumb hit instead.
35:51 Speaker 00 I remember a lot of those, those touchscreens in general, when it was like I, you actually have to press a half inch to the right of the thing that you're trying to press, because that's the way the sensors work. The Harmony One is the other one that, when we told people we're doing this episode, the two that we got the most feedback on were the 880, which a lot of people had for a very long time and had really great feelings about, and the Harmony One, which a bunch of people sent me like borderline rude emails about how much they loved the Harmony One. Like, that thing just has a, a special place in people's technological histories.
36:22 Speaker 06 I still have friends, other reviewers, TV reviewers, that are still using their Harmony Ones, or, or lament the fact that they don't have their Harmony Ones anymore. I mean, I...
36:35 Speaker 00 Think I have my Harmony one somewhere.
36:37 Speaker 06 Wow.
36:38 Speaker 00 I found my Harmony hub, which was basically your IR hub that you had, which was awful. Cause it would always, for whatever reason, it would move.
36:50 Speaker 06 And then it couldn't see your stereo anymore.
36:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:53 Speaker 06 It was the worst. It defeats the purpose.
36:55 Speaker 00 Absolute worst. So then you're getting up off your couch to moot. You're not getting up off your couch to actually use your devices. You're getting up to move the Harmony hub a little further forward to then go sit back down on your couch and not have your remote work properly.
37:10 Speaker 05 Okay. So I looked it up. The Harmony one indeed had a 2.2 inch resistive touchscreen, which meant that when you pushed it, the top layer of the screen had to contact. This is why it was inaccurate.
37:20 Speaker 00 Right.
37:21 Speaker 05 And so this was at the time, there was a big fight in smartphone world about capacitive multi-touchscreens like they had on the iPhone and resistive screens, which in particular Nokia insisted was better for Finland, because it was cold outside and people wore gloves. And I can't tell you at Engadget, as gadget bloggers, just the religious wars we would have in our comments about resistive versus capacitive touchscreens. And we would just be like, no, the resisted ones cuts because they're always inaccurate.
37:52 Speaker 00 Yep.
37:52 Speaker 05 I think it's safe to say that that argument was well and won by capacitive touchscreen.
37:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, I don't think that was.
37:56 Speaker 05 Matt, are you still seeing a lot of resistive touchscreens out there in your line of work?
38:00 Speaker 06 Not a decade. They're gone. Yeah.
38:02 Speaker 05 And then the other piece, the IR hub, is just like a doomed technology. Like I can't, so much of Harmony is like a huge bet on IR, all the way to we need to make a breakout box and communicate with it. I think the Harmony one is like Bluetooth to the breakout box. Like this made no sense.
38:17 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, and it got, it got wackier and wackier over time because like this is also a phase of unbelievable, like technological expansion, right?
38:24 Speaker 05 Yeah.
38:25 Speaker 00 Smartphones come out, we start doing some sort of proto smart home things. Matt, you're working on Nest and working with things like Zigbee and Z-Wave and, and, and working on Thread. Logitech eventually tries to incorporate all of this into, in many cases, very old remotes. And they do it by just selling you more and more gear.
38:41 Speaker 05 Yep.
38:41 Speaker 00 So they have extenders, they have a hub that you can put stuff in. They are like, I think in a sort of earnest and good way, desperately trying to continue to be a universal remote.
38:52 Speaker 05 Yes.
38:52 Speaker 00 When the whole idea of a universal remote is just exploding in front of their faces.
38:57 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's turning into a smartphone.
38:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:58 Speaker 05 So my favorite remote, I'm just, I'll just say, because I think Matt's holding it, is the 900. Which is the, in my view, the platonic ideal of the Harmony line.
39:08 Speaker 07 You could see why I use it for so many years. Like, I got my Android TV macro, I got my Apple TV macro, my Sonos macro, my Blu-ray macro, my mini PC macro. Like, you couldn't do this any other way.
39:20 Speaker 05 You finally achieved convergence. You put a TV under your PC, under your TV.
39:24 Speaker 00 This one, if I have my timing correct, this one comes out well into the "we should be doing more stuff on screens" era. Like, that remote you're holding is much more screen than some of the older Harmony's.
39:36 Speaker 07 Yeah, they did a, it even has some macros for like, turning the lights on and off. And this is around the era where Harmony was actually a works-with-Nest partner. Like, they
39:46 Speaker 00 Oh, nice.
39:47 Speaker 07 They wanted to go all the way.
39:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, they really did. And I think, I think ran into the question of, do we need a universal remote for anything? And I want to come back to that question. But I also want to point out, to Harmony's credit, all of this is very complicated. There's a lot going on, the things don't work all the time, and yet they are by a country mile the best product for this thing for a very long time.
40:12 Speaker 05 Well, we have to remember, we're talking about the 1 and the 900, this is the top of the range.
40:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:18 Speaker 05 The Harmony 700s and the 600s.
40:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
40:21 Speaker 05 Which are just straightforward IR-based, universal remotes that don't even have PC features. They're the sellers.
40:28 Speaker 00 Yes. And even those, like, I went back and was reading old, like, wirecutter recommendations of them, and it's literally just like, oh, you want the best one? Buy a Harmony. You want the expensive one? Buy the more expensive Harmony. Best budget option? Buy the cheaper Harmony. Like, John, did just no one ever catch up to this? How did no one ever catch up to this?
40:44 Speaker 06 Well, why would you?
40:45 Speaker 00 I guess fair.
40:46 Speaker 06 I mean, I think other companies probably saw the writing on the wall in that this isn't a good direction to go in 2012.
40:56 Speaker 00 Right. And if, but if you're Logitech, you're completely permitted at this point.
40:59 Speaker 05 And if you look at these remotes, you look at the 900 Mad has or the picture of the 1, it's just turning into a smartphone. That's the thing that's happening to this device. You're like, oh, we should put a touchscreen on it. Oh, we should link it up with a bunch of external radios to control your smart home. Oh, it should have some compute in it. Oh, it has an internet service. It's like, so it's an iPhone?
41:19 Speaker 07 iPhone plus HomeKit. Yeah, it's like, Apple plus HomeKit just basically solves this.
41:24 Speaker 05 What does it?
41:25 Speaker 06 Exactly.
41:28 Speaker 07 That sounds like another episode.
41:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, agreed. So, okay, so we keep going and then in 2018, Logitech basically starts to just tear the thing down. They turn off the Harmony link that made a lot of the stuff work. You can still do some of the basic IR stuff, but all of the sort of advanced ideas at this point are gone. And then Bracken Daryl, who was at that point the CEO, comes on your podcast, Neelai Patel, and I would say kind of just puts a knife through the hole.
41:58 Speaker 05 Very casually. This is a series of Logitech CEOs showing up in Dakota and just stepping in it. It's a longstanding tradition. That's what we do. But yeah, he was like, yeah, I don't, why would we make remotes? That seems dumb.
42:11 Speaker 00 I have a, I have a clip where he describes it and this, this traveled in a big way. And this was when a lot of people went, oh, this thing is dead. Let me play it.
42:19 Speaker 05 You have the market leader in that space in Harmony remotes. What on earth is going on with Harmony remotes?
42:25 Speaker 09 Well, you know, Harmony is a phenomenal product, as you know, if you want to really simplify a complex living room stack of stuff and, and get it down to a single remote and really simplify it.
42:37 Speaker 00 Sounds good.
42:38 Speaker 09 That is what it's, that's what it was originally conceptualized for, and it does that better than I think anything else. And we like that it does that. Now, now the future world is changing. It's really, you know, as you know, more and more is going through the internet. You know, you're, you're getting, in a way, it's just as complex, but now you've got all these different streaming services and which are exciting, you know, but you're getting more and more all the time. And so much of it's
43:00 Speaker 00 Say it, Bracken.
43:01 Speaker 09 Coming directly, you know, directly through the internet and it's, it's moved on. So, you know, I think, I think Harmony has a place to play in that, but I, I also think we, we are not focused on, on trying to figure out how Harmony can solve all that, that problem beyond that. I think that's probably the domain of other people.
43:19 Speaker 00 I mean, there it is. That's, that's the knife through Harmony.
43:22 Speaker 05 Boy, did he not want to say what he said.
43:23 Speaker 00 No.
43:24 Speaker 05 And then he said it anyway. And I, I think that there was like a walk back for a while.
43:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, they, they tried to pretend that they were still very committed to it. He also said to you on that show that the remote business for Logitech was about 6% the size of Logitech's keyboard business. It was, it was very clear that it was just like, we know that people have these and like them. We don't really care. We're not investing in them anymore. We are moving on.
43:45 Speaker 05 Bracket no longer the CEO of Logitech.
43:46 Speaker 07 Too small of a business. Doesn't make sense. And this is probably why there were no big competitors either. You know, like, market is shrinking. It just, you know, it just doesn't make sense anymore for anyone.
43:56 Speaker 00 Although I will say ironically, he identifies another problem in that clip, which is that it's really hard to find stuff to watch. Which is correct and true. And like, all the way back to the what if we could zap program guides to your remote is like, no one has solved this problem, but he literally says to you that's somebody else's problem.
44:18 Speaker 07 Sounds like Netflix's problem.
44:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:21 Speaker 05 Every episode in this smart home series of version history boils down to where's the computer in your house gonna be? And the answer is in the TV. Like, it just, for this problem, the answer is your TV is gonna have an ARM chip in some variant of Linux, and it's gonna run apps, and it's actually just a giant tablet. And that's gonna have a computer in it, and maybe you can control your voice, or maybe you can control it with whatever weird remote Vizio is gonna dream up at this time. And boy, did they have a bunch of weird ideas at this time. But the idea of an IR-based controller talking to multiple devices because your content is in multiple places was just dwindling. And then, you know, the buttons for lights and shades, that market had not
45:07 Speaker 05 even begun to be even a glimmer of what it is today. So now you're like selling an even smaller number of people a solution they probably don't even want. I get why he's saying it, but at the same time, there were, because there's no competitor, I mean, it literally was, they just unplugged the service from a lot of people.
45:25 Speaker 00 Yeah.
45:26 Speaker 05 And they just called it and walked away. And I think a lot of people are still furious about it.
45:30 Speaker 00 So, this is, this is actually kind of my last question on this front, is why people are so furious about it? Like, even, I am the least experienced with Harmony remotes of anybody on this episode. None of you have made any of these products sound any good, and like, anyone should have ever liked them. And yet, they had this incredibly dedicated group of users who loved them and have moved heaven and earth to continue to use them. John, why? Make this make sense to me.
45:56 Speaker 06 Oh, we want things to work out.
45:59 Speaker 00 Okay.
46:00 Speaker 06 We want them to be a successful remote.
46:02 Speaker 05 The innate optimism of human beings.
46:03 Speaker 00 I know, maybe.
46:04 Speaker 06 We want all of our things to work together. It's why HDMI interconnect.
46:11 Speaker 06 We still want it to work properly. There's a home theater dream that was born in the 80s, where we want all of our things to talk together and we want them all to work properly together.
46:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:23 Speaker 06 And I just think there was a lot of people that, you know, Matt, you brought up, it was, you know, 80% of the time it worked. But that 80% felt great.
46:34 Speaker 00 It's because you've accomplished something. You like, I have orchestrated.
46:37 Speaker 06 You're a magician.
46:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
46:39 Speaker 06 All of these things that shouldn't talk together, talked and started up in the order that you told them to. And that one time will drive you through the next six times that it doesn't work.
46:51 Speaker 05 I like how you've been like, it's the golf of technology.
46:56 Speaker 00 Every once in a while, you pure it and it's gorgeous.
46:59 Speaker 06 Yep.
46:59 Speaker 00 Matt, what are you, I mean, you're still using one. What you like build products at Apple that destroyed this thing. It's your fault that these don't exist anymore. Why do you still use them?
47:10 Speaker 06 No choice. My harmony has broken. And I will go on eBay and buy someone's used model that is the same model so my macros could all transfer over because their service is down.
47:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
47:22 Speaker 06 Because literally I have no choice. Like, look, if I went the kind of all in on the smart TV route, I think this would be a solved problem for me. But I'm still holding on to this home theater dream of having a fancy stereo system, having my PlayStation, my Xbox, and having them kind of all work with one button. Maybe I need to give up the dream.
47:40 Speaker 05 Yeah.
47:41 Speaker 00 Hold on to it, Matt.
47:42 Speaker 05 So this is important. And I think this is real for a lot of people. So I described my setup when I was a teenager at my parents' house in Wisconsin. My setup now, when I have children, is there's a TV, there's a receiver, there is an Apple TV, there's a kaleidoscope, which John and I are about to screw in with.
47:59 Speaker 00 Nice.
47:59 Speaker 05 There's a Switch and there's a PS5. This is a lot of devices.
48:03 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:03 Speaker 05 All that need to be routed, input switched, and. 80% of the time HDMI CEC works.
48:10 Speaker 06 Yep.
48:10 Speaker 00 Hmm.
48:10 Speaker 06 That's, that's the trick is that.
48:12 Speaker 05 And it works. It works. It's like just good enough for me to be like, I can mostly just have the Apple TV remote and the game controller is out. And I can, I can get pretty much, this is gonna work.
48:21 Speaker 06 Yep.
48:22 Speaker 05 But then there's a box sitting on the coffee table with the receiver remote and the TV remote in it. Because when it doesn't work, you gotta, you just gotta turn things off.
48:29 Speaker 06 I still leave a sheet of instructions for the babysitter.
48:33 Speaker 05 That's bad.
48:34 Speaker 06 It should, I mean, because of those, that 20%, when it doesn't work, okay, well, this remote will help you do this and this remote will help you do that. If the TV remote doesn't do it.
48:45 Speaker 05 So the, the worst failure mode in our house is because it's a Sony TV, so it runs Android. And so what you, I swear to God, this is true. If nothing else works, you can just tell Google Assistant to turn off the TV. And it, it, it's like you're, it's like you're praying to heaven. Like, just turn off the TV.
49:05 Speaker 05 Like somehow that will always work. I don't know why, but that's the one, if all the remotes give up, that's the one that works.
49:11 Speaker 00 That's really funny.
49:11 Speaker 06 And that's really the direction we're going, right? We're not.
49:14 Speaker 05 Screaming to heaven.
49:15 Speaker 06 Screaming to heaven, praying. But the, the remotes are going away. The whole idea is that you use your voice to do all of this stuff.
49:23 Speaker 00 Right. And this is, this is sort of the, the train that moves through this industry, right? Cause it's, it's, we get the voice assistants, we get smartphones, we get the sort of ambient like Alexa computing stuff. We get smart TVs that build this stuff in. There's just, if, if your goal is to turn on your television, you now have sort of infinite ways to do that. And what happens when Logitech gets out of this game is it just, the game dies. There are essentially at this point, zero good universal remotes. There are a few companies that try after. Nilay and I both got very excited about a company called Kavo for like 10 minutes. That was a thing, but no one, no one has stepped in or even really tried. And.
49:57 Speaker 05 Can I explain the Kavo thing for one second? So the Kavo, this is pre-AI boom.
50:04 Speaker 05 Their solution to the problem of not knowing what was happening on the TV was that you would plug all of your devices into their device and it would use computer vision to click around the Apple TV interface for you. And this was very slow and very clunky and it sort of worked but didn't work. And they totally pivoted to be a totally different kind of business because they put a bunch of hardware in a bunch of TVs. But they were like, how do we close the feedback loop? We're gonna literally watch the Apple TV. And none of this was ready at the time. This is like years and years ago. None of this was ready at the time. But this is the level of like, solutioning they had to do to use the TV for you. Then they ran into the immediate problem of people are buying smart TVs. They're using the apps on the smart TVs and we can't see them.
50:48 Speaker 05 Our business is dead. It was like the last gasp of the universal remote multiple sources idea. And then they're like, yeah, we don't. Everyone's just using Tizen now. We're done.
50:57 Speaker 00 Theory, AI blast, AI agents. Theory, Agentic AI is the IR blaster of 2026.
51:07 Speaker 07 I mean, I'm holding that hope that I still get this like universal smart home app with Agentic AI. Our universal remote days are dead, but like, at least maybe we'll get an app to rule them all one day.
51:18 Speaker 00 So this is actually, Matt, you have to leave us here in a minute, but this is actually my last question for you, which is, there's a world in which you are sort of living an unsolved problem, right? And you've, the best thing that you have found is this harmony setup for what you have. If somebody software their way out of this and built you the app you're describing on your phone, does that completely solve your problem? Or is there something about the hardware of this thing that actually is meaningful in your setup still?
51:40 Speaker 07 I think we still need something in the home, you know, especially for like legacy stereo systems. There's no way to solve the IR problem. This is, you're gonna build a robotic button that pushes the buttons maybe. But then again, you still have the same issue. Like, do you know you hit the button? Is it actually on? It's, this is, it's tough. Like, there's a reason why this is like one of these unsolved problems with like a rabid loyal following because. Still don't have a solution out there.
52:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
52:05 Speaker 05 There's no solution, but also it's the kiss of death. Dude, when the Xbox One came out and they're like, here's what we're gonna do. We're gonna integrate with your cable box and we're gonna have this weird, long IR blasters with the little cords and the bubbles. Everyone got mad at me because I think this product is doomed. Like, I don't even need to read past the spec sheet. Like, I saw IR blaster and weird, long bubble repeaters. Oh, this is, what are you doing?
52:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
52:26 Speaker 05 And it was the same exact idea as web TV, which is also a Microsoft product, which is, I'm gonna horsepower a Windows PC under your TV, but I don't have access to your actual TV. So I have to control your cable box in some way. And it's not gonna work because I'm putting an overlay. I could just, I could talk about this forever. This basing your vision around IR because it's the last universal standard for control means you're dead. And I'm not saying this is a problem in 2026. I don't, I don't suspect there are a lot of startups out there being like, we're gonna do IR blasting. But there was a minute when everyone was like, we can, we're gonna figure it out.
52:59 Speaker 00 But you also didn't have a choice. I mean, like, it's not like the REZ Zapper friends missed some new technology that was sitting there available to them. It wasn't like, Matt still can't control his stereo with anything other than IR. Like, this is just, this is maybe a problem without an elegant solution. Everybody understands what the answer ought to be, and it might be, as it turns out, fundamentally an unsolvable problem.
53:21 Speaker 07 Gotta get up and push the button.
53:22 Speaker 05 Yeah, but for your vintage stereo matter, you gotta, you gotta be in the moment. You know, there's other, there's other audio components that you can control remotely. You know, like, you should, you go, go put the, this is why the vinyl is made to come back in my household. I was never trying to Logitech Harmony the record player.
53:38 Speaker 00 But the robot arm will do it for you.
53:40 Speaker 05 They, we should do an old episode of the robot arms.
53:44 Speaker 00 We should. All right, Matt, we need to take a break and you need to go, but before we do, Harmony remotes, version history hall of fame, yea or nay? What do you think? Now's your chance to vote.
53:54 Speaker 07 I'm a nay.
53:55 Speaker 00 Okay.
53:55 Speaker 05 Wow. The last Jedi.
53:58 Speaker 00 I know.
54:02 Speaker 05 Wow.
54:03 Speaker 00 Today might be the true end of the Harmony remote. All right, we're gonna take a break and then we're gonna come back. We're gonna do the eight version history questions. Matt, thank you so much for joining us. This has been super fun.
54:12 Speaker 07 Thanks for having me.
54:13 Speaker 00 We'll be back.
54:17 Speaker 02 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends. Like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest, or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an Ultra. Because it's not just a superior light beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
54:46 Speaker 03 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great, till the CFO sees them. That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out. In. Dashboard. Confessions.
54:56 Speaker 04 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand", when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
55:03 Speaker 03 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
55:16 Speaker 08 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Ooh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
55:47 Speaker 00 All right, we're back. It's time now for the eight version history questions, the question we ask to determine the legacy of every product. The first question is, where does the Harmony Remote fit on the time matrix? And the time matrix, everybody's favorite concept, makes perfect sense. It charts idea versus time. Was it the right idea at the right time? Was it the wrong idea at the wrong time? Or somewhere in between? I actually think the Harmony is an unusually fascinating version of this, because I could argue into any one of these quadrants.
56:14 Speaker 05 Well, which Harmony?
56:16 Speaker 00 Uh, let's start at the beginning. We can even go with the very first one if you'd like to. My argument would be actually, we should pick the 880 because again, it is the sort of canonical one.
56:26 Speaker 05 This episode breaks all of your rules.
56:27 Speaker 00 It does. I'm fine with it. Move on. We're doing fine.
56:29 Speaker 05 Because usually you force me to talk about one product.
56:31 Speaker 00 We did hoverboards as a concept too, and it's like, we're never gonna do another Harmony episode. So it's fun to, we're doing the whole thing this time. For this one, I would say, like, I'll let you choose if you'd like to. But it's either, we're either gonna do the first one, or we're gonna do the 880, which is again, the sort of canonical Harmony remote in a lot of people's minds. Do you think that changes things?
56:51 Speaker 05 Yes.
56:52 Speaker 06 Yeah.
56:52 Speaker 00 Really?
56:53 Speaker 05 Yeah.
56:53 Speaker 00 Okay. John, you go first. Where would you put it on this, on this square?
56:57 Speaker 06 So for, to go, let's do the 880. It's right there. I do think it was the right time.
57:05 Speaker 00 Okay.
57:05 Speaker 06 I think it was a misguided idea.
57:08 Speaker 00 Okay. So you would be wrong idea, right time?
57:10 Speaker 06 Think, yeah. Yeah. I think so.
57:12 Speaker 00 Why do you think it's the right time?
57:15 Speaker 06 Because there wasn't anything else that was accomplishing it.
57:18 Speaker 00 Fair. Fair.
57:19 Speaker 06 It was the right time for the type of product. I don't know if the type of product necessarily needed to exist.
57:25 Speaker 00 Interesting. That's a good way of looking at it. It was like, they tried to solve the right problem. Wrong.
57:32 Speaker 06 Yeah.
57:34 Speaker 00 I would say I am squarely at wrong idea, wrong time, no matter what. Like, I think there is a case to be made in those early days that it, the timing was right. But even then, it's like, this thing is just running into all of the things that will obviate it almost immediately. Like ironically, I think Steve Wozniak had the right time. In 1989, my guy tried to ship a universal remote, and I think that, if he had not made such a weird one, might have had a chance to last a long time. This thing is just immediately shipping into a world that doesn't need it anymore. And maybe, I don't know, maybe I'm overstating it.
58:10 Speaker 05 It's like my version of this has a fourth dimension.
58:13 Speaker 00 Of course it does.
58:14 Speaker 05 Do you know what I mean? Like, it just becomes increasingly more the wrong time overtime.
58:19 Speaker 00 Okay.
58:20 Speaker 05 Do you know what I mean? Like, it starts kinda edging at like right idea, right time. And then like, as the years pass by.
58:28 Speaker 06 Oh, it definitely.
58:29 Speaker 05 And so like, over the course of 10 years, it just spirals into the bottom corner and like explodes into flames.
58:37 Speaker 00 So, it seems to me like, we all agree, it belongs on the wrong idea side of the spectrum. Because as, as, as happy as it makes all of us, it couldn't and maybe wasn't ever going to do the thing it aspired to do.
58:51 Speaker 05 But some people loved it. I don't know how to account for that.
58:53 Speaker 00 This is the problem. Like, it had such a devoted.
58:57 Speaker 05 This is why you need the fourth dimension of time.
58:59 Speaker 06 Wrong things.
59:00 Speaker 05 That's true.
59:00 Speaker 00 That's true.
59:01 Speaker 06 Love does not fall into those simple categories.
59:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, and what you were saying about the, the sort of magic of solving the problem, I do think there is something underrated in this story about just the nerd project of it all.
59:13 Speaker 06 Oh, 100%.
59:14 Speaker 00 That there is just like, you know.
59:15 Speaker 06 You were sitting in front of your computer attaching a remote by a thin cable.
59:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
59:22 Speaker 06 And.
59:22 Speaker 00 And that is both a pain in the ass and fun as hell all at the same time.
59:25 Speaker 06 It is. It is. I mean, for sick individuals, it absolutely is.
59:28 Speaker 05 Again, if they had just gotten away from the macromedia wizard interface, it would have been even more fun.
59:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
59:34 Speaker 05 But that thing was a dogfight.
59:35 Speaker 06 The wizard was awful.
59:36 Speaker 05 There was an era of computing where every app was like, I know what you're trying to do and I won't let you just do it. You will have to answer a flow chart of quiz questions before I do what you want. It's like, I don't need this kind of help.
59:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, this sounds awful.
59:48 Speaker 05 And it was just absolutely that experience over and over again.
59:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's rough. Okay, so I think for the time matrix, we're gonna leave it at wrong idea. And we'll, we'll put it kinda towards the middle, but like lightly on the side of wrong time.
59:59 Speaker 05 Again, this cube should be spinning through the cosmos.
1:00:02 Speaker 00 No one's listening, Neil. Question number two.
1:00:06 Speaker 00 Question number two, was this peak anything? I have a couple I'd like to offer you. Was this peak universal remote? I think pretty clearly, yes.
1:00:13 Speaker 06 Sure.
1:00:14 Speaker 00 Was this peak IR blaster?
1:00:15 Speaker 05 No, that was the Xbox One. The Xbox One was like a company-wide bet on IR blasting that like everybody should have known better.
1:00:24 Speaker 00 Fair. So was this peak TV remote? And I will allow you to pick any Harmony you want for this. Is a Harmony, any Harmony, the best TV remote? Just as a pure remote to hold in your hand and use?
1:00:39 Speaker 05 No, we did a whole TiVo episode.
1:00:40 Speaker 00 You don't think so either?
1:00:42 Speaker 06 No.
1:00:42 Speaker 00 This wasn't peak TV remote?
1:00:43 Speaker 06 No, because it doesn't do what it needs to do 100% of the time.
1:00:50 Speaker 00 Fair.
1:00:50 Speaker 05 Rough.
1:00:51 Speaker 00 That is fair. And actually, that's a good distinction from TiVo, which
1:00:55 Speaker 06 It worked.
1:00:56 Speaker 00 Did its job exceptionally well.
1:00:57 Speaker 06 Yeah.
1:00:58 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:00:58 Speaker 06 But you also weren't expecting it to do everything else.
1:01:02 Speaker 00 It wasn't a magic wand for your house.
1:01:04 Speaker 05 TiVo would hard map the volume controls to your TV or receiver. It gave you a power button that was hard mapped to your TV. And that was the limit of its designs on other devices in your house.
1:01:14 Speaker 06 And for 90% of the people in the world, that's all they needed. That was probably more than they needed.
1:01:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah, okay. Do you guys have anything else? Peak anything?
1:01:22 Speaker 05 In many ways, it's peak gadget.
1:01:24 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:01:24 Speaker 05 Right? It's a product of that smartphone era where everything became kind of a computer gadget.
1:01:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:01:28 Speaker 05 This is why people like it, right? It's like one of the gadgetiest gadgets you can get in your house. So like in many ways, it still is that dream.
1:01:36 Speaker 00 Yep.
1:01:37 Speaker 05 Like, what if you can gadgetify a remote control? And like, there's no
1:01:40 Speaker 00 That's pretty good.
1:01:41 Speaker 05 That's what it looks like.
1:01:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:01:42 Speaker 05 So I think that that one's pretty good there. Yeah, I think that's the one. It's
1:01:47 Speaker 05 It's just such a weird pre-smartphone device.
1:01:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:01:51 Speaker 05 And then it eventually just got killed by the smartphone.
1:01:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. It's definitely peak zapping.
1:01:56 Speaker 00 No one has ever zapped like this remote zapped. It is also peak screen in the wrong place on a thing.
1:02:01 Speaker 05 Yep.
1:02:01 Speaker 00 I don't think anything has ever had a screen in such the wrong place. They made a whole case for why it was ergonomically better to have your, the screen on the bottom, and they're just dead wrong.
1:02:11 Speaker 06 Yep.
1:02:11 Speaker 00 Just dead wrong. All right, moving on. Question number three. If you could time travel back, and then in this case, we're going all the way back to like 1999, and develop it yourself, could you make the product more successful? Could we tell our Canadian friends something that would have made this thing do better and hit harder?
1:02:28 Speaker 06 There were too many problems to overcome.
1:02:31 Speaker 00 Interesting.
1:02:32 Speaker 06 I don't think it necessarily could have happened better with
1:02:36 Speaker 00 Your advice is just don't do this.
1:02:37 Speaker 06 With the technology of the time.
1:02:38 Speaker 05 Run away. You've got the simpler one behind you. That's like a 500 or 700. What's that one? That's the simpler Harmony.
1:02:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02:45 Speaker 05 So this is the vastly more successful product.
1:02:47 Speaker 00 Yes, this is a 520.
1:02:48 Speaker 05 520. So this one, it has a tiny screen. It just has the four little buttons at the top, but the rest of it is dead simple universal remote control. Once again, the volume buttons are just an abomination on this thing. They're teeny tiny and they're on the... The volume control should always be the biggest buttons on a remote. But it, you know, has transport controls. It has a bunch of control menus. You can map this stuff, but it was just simpler. It did not have all the grand designs of this remote, and so, and it was cheaper. So this one, I think for a lot of people, is the canonical universal remote. This is the one that they had. This is the one that they worked. You programmed it once. It wasn't trying to run 500 macros. Again, if it was, maybe you'd actually never even set them up. Do you know what I mean? Like
1:03:28 Speaker 00 So, so do you think the answer, like if you're, if you're time traveling back, are you telling these guys like, do less?
1:03:32 Speaker 05 Do less.
1:03:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:33 Speaker 05 Actually, the funniest part on this, I think the 880 has it too, but it might be smaller. So you can see, it's the same layout really on both remotes, but in this one, the word "help" is printed at the top.
1:03:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:44 Speaker 05 And it's, if the macro failed, you could push "help" and it would run the macro. It would do all the IR commands again. But I, it's like this thing, they needed to land here more than they landed there.
1:03:54 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:03:55 Speaker 05 Right? They needed to land at the 520, the simpler, more focused, more effective product, and they put all of their resources chasing the smartphone with the 900 and the one and everything else.
1:04:05 Speaker 00 This is actually a good segue to the next question, which is, will the youth ever make it cool again?
1:04:09 Speaker 05 So there already have, there's a company called Sofa Baton that is basically just-
1:04:13 Speaker 00 You just made that up. That can't be-
1:04:14 Speaker 06 No, that's true. That's one of the major ones.
1:04:16 Speaker 05 But like, there are, you know, Matt's saying this is like not a market, this isn't a thing. Like, there are companies in this space still that make consumer products that people like. I agree that cool is a challenge, but if you think you're gonna be in a more offline mode in some way, or less phone sense, like, centric, you're gonna end up at a device like that.
1:04:35 Speaker 00 So, John, the reason I bring this up is, is I think we are in a moment where people are eager to spend less time staring at their phone to do things. And I think a thing that is true, and has been particularly true with televisions, is that using your phone as a remote for your TV mostly sucks.
1:04:52 Speaker 06 It's awful.
1:04:52 Speaker 00 And everybody tried to do it for a while, and I think has largely pulled back. And now we just have like the crappy remote you get with your Roku that is most people's experience of their TV. But do you think this idea of a physical remote to do TV things, but also potentially some other basic smart homey things, has a place in our lives right now?
1:05:10 Speaker 06 I mean, I, I think it can have a place in our lives, but I don't think it's gonna come from a remote that doesn't come with your TV.
1:05:17 Speaker 00 Interesting. So you think like accessory remote, just-
1:05:20 Speaker 06 I just don't think-
1:05:20 Speaker 00 non-starter.
1:05:21 Speaker 06 I, I think it was hard enough, especially for the more expensive ones, to sell a general consumer on the idea of spending $200-
1:05:30 Speaker 00 Fair.
1:05:30 Speaker 06 -on an extra remote. And I think it's just as hard now. I mean, I, there are, the TV remotes that are out now are fine, as long as they're not controlling tithes, then things are good.
1:05:42 Speaker 05 I mean, this comes back to where is the computer, right? My Apple TV is deeply integrated into the smart home and system in our house. Like, it's mostly HomeKit, and I can talk into the Apple TV remote and turn off all the lights. And like, that's because the computer is over there, connected to the bigger computer that is the house.
1:05:59 Speaker 00 Well, and it's interesting to see at various points, the, the Rokus and Amazons and Apples of the world have tried to poke at some of these ideas. Roku went down this road for a while of how do we use your TV remote that comes in the box to control other stuff? And I think, like we've been saying with all of this, I have deep skepticism of the attach rate of any of that stuff. Does anybody set up any of these devices that require any work to get working? I assume not. But it just doesn't seem to have become a priority for anybody. Like, you just need to turn on your TV. The end.
1:06:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, then you need to get to some streaming video. And at the end, when you're there, it is all largely the same.
1:06:36 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:06:36 Speaker 05 So even the path from here to there does, kind of doesn't matter, which is why all these interfaces are bad.
1:06:40 Speaker 00 So we don't, we don't think there's a future for interesting, thoughtful, physical remotes?
1:06:46 Speaker 06 No, I don't think so.
1:06:47 Speaker 05 Yeah, you need a power button, a volume control, and transfer buttons.
1:06:49 Speaker 06 It does.
1:06:50 Speaker 00 I'm not happy about it. It bums me out.
1:06:51 Speaker 05 That's what all the remotes are now. They're a power button, they're a volume button, and they're transport controls.
1:06:55 Speaker 06 And a microphone.
1:06:56 Speaker 05 That's it. That might be all that you need.
1:06:59 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:07:00 Speaker 05 You want it to be, you guys should get a sofa baton. Come on.
1:07:02 Speaker 00 But I'm even looking at the sofa baton, and I'm like, I have no, I have no use for this. Like, I think, I think there's something to simple controls for things like this. I actually, it's really interesting to look at the picture of the sofa baton. Because it has a lot in common with very old, like, easy zappers. It's a few buttons.
1:07:20 Speaker 05 Yep.
1:07:21 Speaker 00 It doesn't do a lot. It is very clearly designed to do a couple of things for you very simply and well. Like, control the volume of your television. And that's it. And that's actually maybe all we need from some of these things. All right, moving on. Question number five.
1:07:36 Speaker 00 This is a tricky one, given that we just declared the final death of physical remotes. What feature of the Harmony remotes would you put on current remotes?
1:07:46 Speaker 05 Oh, I know, I know what it is. It's the help button.
1:07:48 Speaker 00 It just tries it all again?
1:07:50 Speaker 05 I mean, I wouldn't execute it that way. But the, the idea that, like, the thing is broken, I can't get it to work, and like, you should figure it out? Perfect.
1:07:59 Speaker 00 Interesting.
1:08:00 Speaker 05 Like, the idea that more devices in your life should have a button that is just clearly marked "help", and it's not like a weird chatbot interface, like, whatever that thing is, but like, it will actually try to solve the problem for you? That's great. We should bring that back.
1:08:12 Speaker 00 That's not bad. John, what do you think?
1:08:14 Speaker 06 I would love for macros to work.
1:08:16 Speaker 00 Fair.
1:08:17 Speaker 06 I mean, I would love to be able to just do that, but, um, yeah, I think the help is probably the most useful.
1:08:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, one of the ones that drives me the most crazy is like you use, I have a Roku TV through which I almost exclusively use the Google TV streamer because Roku's interface is awful and makes me angry. And you can go in and you can set the default HDMI thing that it's supposed to go to. And boy, does that not work correctly. And so all of these things are just, they do constantly make you do more things. And I think the idea of like, all the remotes now, they have, you know, there's a Netflix button and a like a Disney plus button or whatever. And all these companies pay to be on the remotes. I would so much rather have those be like programmable macros. That'd be amazing. Some of them are, some, some remotes will come with. Yeah. The programming capability. You get a star button. Yeah. Great, thanks. And now I have a Paramount plus button for a service I don't have.
1:09:09 Speaker 05 Not buying the cheapest ad-supported TVs on the market.
1:09:11 Speaker 00 Why would I?
1:09:11 Speaker 05 Because if you spent money, you would get features.
1:09:13 Speaker 00 I bought a Frame TV because you told me to, and it's ruining my life.
1:09:19 Speaker 05 Because you were gonna buy an even cheaper knockoff of the Frame TV.
1:09:23 Speaker 00 That's fair. But now at least my TV knows when it's on and when it's off. All right, three more questions. The Virgin History Hall of Fame, three questions, three tests that the product has to pass to get in. And again, to be the most generous we can, we can consider the whole Harmony lineup. I'm willing to give you 25 years of Harmony to make it past these. And I, spoiler alert, I think I'm with Matt. I don't think it's gonna make it. Question number one, did the Harmony do something truly new?
1:09:48 Speaker 05 Yes, the answer to that one is yes.
1:09:50 Speaker 00 What?
1:09:50 Speaker 05 The idea that they were gonna link together everything with macros and like solve the, they tried. They legitimately tried.
1:09:56 Speaker 00 Yep, not what it says. So this is, this is actually, I'm being pedantic for a reason here because like, did this product have new, interesting, important, big ambitions? Unquestionably yes.
1:10:06 Speaker 05 No, I mean literally, we're gonna link together all the macros to turn on everything in sequence and you can push, watch a movie and we'll fire the macro off. That was new.
1:10:14 Speaker 00 It did that.
1:10:15 Speaker 05 And I guess it legitimately new and it did that, yeah.
1:10:16 Speaker 00 Okay. And 80% of the time.
1:10:20 Speaker 00 It worked. Did this product parentheses, kinda, sorta, mostly, end parentheses, do something truly new?
1:10:25 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:10:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:10:26 Speaker 05 I buy that.
1:10:27 Speaker 00 Okay. Hall of Fame question number two: Was it either remarkably good or remarkably bad?
1:10:32 Speaker 05 No. This is brutal.
1:10:34 Speaker 06 Middle of the road.
1:10:35 Speaker 05 It was as middle as it gets.
1:10:36 Speaker 06 Yep.
1:10:36 Speaker 05 Yep.
1:10:37 Speaker 00 Ironically, I feel like it was, it was both things, right? It wasn't just that it was, it was down the middle because it was both remarkably good and remarkably bad.
1:10:44 Speaker 05 80% of the time it was remarkably good. The 20% it was remarkably bad.
1:10:47 Speaker 00 Collapse spectacular.
1:10:48 Speaker 05 It was heartbreakingly bad.
1:10:49 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah, like, I don't know anyone who has medium feelings about the Harmony Remote. Do you know what I mean?
1:10:53 Speaker 06 Yeah, that's true.
1:10:54 Speaker 00 This is not, it's not like a milquetoast television experience. It is either doing magic, or it's utterly infuriating because it broke for reasons you can't figure out.
1:11:03 Speaker 06 Were enthusiastic about it. And they were either excited about the 80% of the time, or they were furious about the 20% of the time.
1:11:12 Speaker 00 So, okay, here's actually an unrelated question I've been thinking about a lot in doing the research for this. Should Logitech have tried to make deals to become a default remote? And basically, like, instead of Comcast shipping you its crappy membrane remote, try to ship a remote like this as your default cable box remote? But then add on this additional vision to it? That it's like, okay, we're gonna sort of Trojan horse our smart home idea into your cable box remote?
1:11:38 Speaker 05 So they, they absolutely tried to do this.
1:11:39 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:11:40 Speaker 05 Uh, I think they might have even succeeded in a handful of places. The problem is that the cable companies were cable companies. And they were not interested in spending one additional penny on any customer.
1:11:53 Speaker 00 Fair. Which is also kind of the downfall of remotes in general.
1:11:57 Speaker 05 Right. I mean, like, they were gonna ship you the good enough remote. They would remain unchanged for 25 years. Like, you, you can't have a vision that depends on the cable company being like, "We're gonna invest in innovation." It's not a choice.
1:12:08 Speaker 00 "We're going to make good hardware products."
1:12:10 Speaker 05 That's like, that's not gonna happen, like...
1:12:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's fair. Which I guess is why that was also the demise of TiVo, was starting to make that particular decision.
1:12:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
1:12:19 Speaker 00 Fair enough. All right. Hall of Fame question number three: Not that it matters, sorry, Harmony Remotes. Uh, did it change history? Was it, is there a world before it and a world after it?
1:12:27 Speaker 05 If it had changed history, Microsoft would have never shipped the Xbox One. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know how much more clearly I can say this.
1:12:35 Speaker 00 So in that sense, it did. It killed Microsoft.
1:12:38 Speaker 05 No, it didn't prove the point that IR was the kiss of death enough.
1:12:42 Speaker 00 It's fair.
1:12:42 Speaker 05 To dissuade one of the largest companies in the world from destroying the legacy of its gaming division.
1:12:48 Speaker 00 So I really do, this all makes me wonder, Neil, like, do you look at this as a completely unsolvable problem that Easy Zapper and then Logitech gave, like, a real earnest college try to, but that nobody was ever gonna do it? And actually, we needed a different kind of technical innovation to get away from this?
1:13:05 Speaker 05 Yeah, you could probably build a product like this today that looks a lot closer to the vision, is a lot more successful, built on HDMI CEC.
1:13:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, like with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, you can get, you can much more easily connect to many more things.
1:13:19 Speaker 05 Yep, you can probably get there. And then the problem, as Matt said over and over again, is the market for that is zero, because everyone already has a smartphone, which is 100% that thing, right? Like, if you wanna control my TV, you can open the horrible Sony app on my smartphone, and you can just do that thing, and it can also control the house. And you can also look at the catalog of movies and actually buy one and send it to you. Like, there's a whole universe of things you can do with a phone.
1:13:43 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:13:44 Speaker 05 Being like, here's a dumber phone that only works in your living room.
1:13:49 Speaker 00 But it has buttons.
1:13:49 Speaker 05 What are we doing?
1:13:50 Speaker 00 Buttons!
1:13:51 Speaker 05 Buttons are great, but then you're like, okay, what is, what buttons do I need? You need a power button, a volume button, and some transport controls.
1:13:58 Speaker 00 Yeah. John, what do you think? Like, would, you're, you have a thousand TVs in your house right now. I want everybody to close their eyes and picture John just surrounded by televisions. That is his earnest day-to-day life. Like, the, the version of this that exists on today's technology with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and HDMI CEC, and like, even go back to the, the, we're gonna zap program guides, we're doing deep link search into this, but it is a hardware product. Does that do anything for you?
1:14:20 Speaker 06 No. For my nostalgia only.
1:14:23 Speaker 00 Okay. Why not? Why does it not compel you?
1:14:25 Speaker 06 Because I don't, I don't need it. I, I mean, the phone would be fine. The remote that comes with the TV would be fine. I mean, honestly, the Apple TV remote.
1:14:39 Speaker 00 Sure.
1:14:39 Speaker 06 Is fully functional for what I need it to be.
1:14:42 Speaker 00 So we really have just kind of good enoughed our way out of this being a useful product at all?
1:14:48 Speaker 06 Yeah, I think so, unfortunately.
1:14:51 Speaker 00 The fact that Roku gets to have a good remote and be the one that everybody uses just fills me with rage.
1:14:55 Speaker 05 I mean, they're the new cable company.
1:14:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:14:58 Speaker 05 Are you going to spend one extra penny on your customers, Roku? And the answer is no, we're going to put more ads into their face.
1:15:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, fair enough. All right, well, Harmony, you didn't make it in, but we all love you bizarrely.
1:15:08 Speaker 05 Everyone wanted you to be good.
1:15:11 Speaker 00 Everyone, that's really true. We all wish you had been there.
1:15:15 Speaker 06 I do still really want to find my Harmony 1 and try it.
1:15:19 Speaker 00 It'll work once, it'll feel incredible, and then you'll put it away and never use it again.
1:15:23 Speaker 06 Yeah, probably.
1:15:23 Speaker 00 That's the dream, that's what we're here for. All right, we are done here. Thank you both for being here, this is delightful. I feel better about never having owned a Harmony remote. Thanks to this episode, so it's been great. I'm going to go home.
1:15:33 Speaker 05 I'm going to get you an Xbox One. We're going to put a cable box under it and we're going to really, really experience something.
1:15:38 Speaker 00 I'm going to go home and scream into my Frame TV, which makes you push a rocker to mute the...
1:15:43 Speaker 05 Good stuff.
1:15:44 Speaker 00 Horrible. Somebody make me a better remote, I promise I'll buy it, but nobody else will, so don't make it anyway. All right, we are out of here. Thank you to both of you, thank you to everybody for watching and listening, and a reminder that the best thing you can do is subscribe to The Verge, you get all of our podcasts ad-free, you get to make sure that we get to keep buying old gadgets to keep doing stuff with. Thank you as always, we'll see you next time. Version History is a production of The Verge and the Vox Media Podcast Network. It's produced by Victoria Barrios, River Branson, Eric Gomez, Owen Grove, Brandon Kiefer, Travis Larchuk, Andrew Moreno, and Alex Mckernan. Our editorial director is Kevin McShane. Studio support from Matthew Heffron and Joe Nevers. Our theme music is composed by Brandon McFarlane. You can follow the dedicated Version History podcast feed for all of our episodes as soon
1:16:26 Speaker 00 as they arrive, and you can watch full episodes on our new YouTube channel, @VersionHistoryPodcast. And to support everything we do and get access to this and all of our other podcasts ad-free, become a paid subscriber to The Verge. Thanks.
1:16:43 Speaker 10 Close your eyes, exhale, feel your body relax, and let go of whatever you're carrying today. Well, I'm letting go of the worry that I wouldn't get my new contacts in time for this class. I got them delivered free from 1-800-CONTACTS. Oh my gosh, they're so fast! And breathe. Oh, sorry. I almost couldn't breathe when I saw the discount they gave me on my first order. Oh, sorry. Namaste? Visit 1-800-CONTACTS.com today to save on your first order.
1:17:11 Speaker 11 1-800-CONTACTS. Finding a doctor is hard enough. Finding the right doctor, even harder. Someone who takes your insurance, has an available appointment when you need one, and feels like someone you can actually open up to. That's where Zocdoc comes in. Download the Zocdoc app to search and compare doctors by specialty, insurance, and availability. Read real patient reviews, find the right fit for you, and book instantly. Because getting seen by the right doctor matters. Zocdoc. Ready to be seen? Download the Zocdoc app today.
1:17:44 Speaker 12 Online Deal Days are back at Kroger. Don't miss your chance for extra savings when you shop, pick up, or delivery. You can save $30 on your first online order of $75 or more with your digital coupon. Plus, enjoy unlimited free delivery by starting a Boost Free trial today. But hurry, these extra savings end October 20th. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Kroger. Fresh for everyone.
Previous Snap's Specs look good on nobody Next Is the Steam Machine worth the wait? Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated