Pod Insights The Vergecast God will be declared by a panel of experts About this episode If you want to understand the full spectrum of AI software, from "straightforward problem-solving tool" to "never-ending slop machine," all you need to do is pay attention to everything Adobe launched at its conference this week. David and Nilay run through the news, which will change how people use Photoshop but also maybe change our social feeds forever. After that, they talk about OpenAI's conversion to a for-profit business, and specifically the truly wild way OpenAI and Microsoft talk about the future of AGI. Finally, in the lightning round, they discuss Brendan Carr, Cybertrucks, the Trump Phone, Ghost Posts, and more.
Help us improve The Verge: Take our quick survey at theverge.com/survey.
Further reading:
Photoshop and Premiere Pro’s new AI tools can instantly edit your work
You can tell Adobe Express’s new AI assistant to edit designs for you
Adobe’s AI social media admin is here with ‘Project Moonlight’
Mark Zuckerberg is excited to add more AI content to all your social feeds
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg defends AI spend: 'We're seeing the returns'
OpenAI completed its for-profit restructuring — and struck a new deal with Microsoft
The next chapter of the Microsoft–OpenAI partnership
OpenAI lays groundwork for juggernaut IPO at up to $1 trillion valuation | Reuters
OpenAI has an AGI problem — and Microsoft just made it worse
OpenAI made ChatGPT better at sifting through your work information
Sam, Jakub, and Wojciech on the future of OpenAI with audience Q&A
The Kingmaker | WIRED
Congratulations to the Tesla Cybertruck on its 10th recall.
Trump℠ Mobile | All-American Performance. Everyday Price. $47.45/Month
Threads is getting disappearing posts
Ads will arrive on Samsung Family Hub smart fridges next month.
The FCC is going after broadband nutrition labels.
Brendan Carr is a Dummy
Bending Spoons is buying AOL for some reason
Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed. We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 20,724 words · 19 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. AMX Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMX Corporate. Get started at go.amex slash AMX Corporate. Terms apply.
0:24 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends. Like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an Ultra. Because it's not just a superior light beer. It's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser Busch in Bev, Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
0:53 Speaker 02 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard, confessions.
1:02 Speaker 03 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
1:10 Speaker 02 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:25 Speaker 04 Welcome to the Vergecast, flagship podcast of Generative Fill. We're going to make 25 minutes of this podcast, and then we're going to click a button, and it's going to be three hours of this podcast. And that's what we're doing here.
1:36 Speaker 05 What you've all been asking for the whole time.
1:39 Speaker 04 I'm your friend David Pierce. Neil Patel is here. Hey, buddy. We got to do one together, and then I was gone, and now we're back.
1:45 Speaker 05 And then my house lit on fire. You can never leave again.
1:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, I really, like, I learned about this from like a Blue Sky post and then a social video that has been everywhere on my feeds from you being like, PSA, throw your surge protectors away.
1:59 Speaker 05 I learned a lot about what happens when my face goes viral from that video. So, you know, surge protectors expire. This is just a thing. All the manufacturers will tell you after three to five years, like, get rid of them, or maybe even shorter. If you are the type of person who knows you have the kind of surge protector that doesn't expire, don't leave comments. Like, you are one of one. Like, if you know your surge protector is a serious surge protector that don't expire, that means you know that. Everyone else just buys the regular kind. But the comments on the search pressure video, I was like throwing away, were like, "This guy's paid off by Big Surge." It was very good. And they're like, "Yeah, just trust me because you had a bad experience." It's like, "No, you just read the other comments, or everyone is agreeing with me." It was very good. Again, I learned a lot about what virality can accomplish.
2:45 Speaker 05 If one person got rid of some old search protectors that expire, we've met our goal.
2:51 Speaker 04 I'm now looking at the search protector that is like, all my stuff is plugged into one search protector down here, and it is like, old and dusty. And I'm just like, I always thought the space heater was gonna be the thing that eventually burned my house down, and now I'm like, it's probably the search protector.
3:04 Speaker 05 I heard a story from another person. Again, you know, the people on TikTok and YouTube Shorts are gonna say this all conspiracy, but another person that we know, that Becky and I know, was like, "Oh, my search protector also exploded, but it did significantly more damage to my home."
3:20 Speaker 04 Yikes.
3:20 Speaker 05 So the stories are out there, man. It's not just me. It's not, this is not just chemtrails.
3:24 Speaker 04 If you do work for Big Surge, and you want a whistleblow on Big Surge, get at us. Firstcasttheverge.com.
3:30 Speaker 05 It's just like, people see like, exactly what they want to see in all, in all things. And this one was like, a perfect inkblot test for like, "My search protectors are made in the USA 20 years ago, and they're never going bad." I'm like, "I don't know, man."
3:45 Speaker 04 Good for you, I guess. Congratulations.
3:47 Speaker 05 That's really not the point I was trying to make.
3:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, fair enough. All right. Well, we have a bunch of stuff to do today. There's, it's like, it's basically just a week full of AI stuff. This is like, the world we live in. We have AI business to talk about. Adobe Max is this week, which is like, all about AI. But first, I should mention right up top, Decoder is now a video podcast. This is the only time I will mention Decoder. And it's very good on video, actually, and you should watch it, because you get to watch Neelai make a lot of faces at Rick people, which is the thing I enjoy most about him.
4:15 Speaker 05 Actually, it's the other people's faces that are very good.
4:17 Speaker 04 They, I mean, there are faces in both directions, for sure. Just, there's a version of Decoder that is just the reaction shots. That might be a more compelling podcast.
4:27 Speaker 05 Uh, yeah, no, we should definitely start super cutting. Just know I, and then, um, in particular, there's a slight look off camera at the PR people in the room. And when I see that, I know it's time. Like Decoder is always Neelai versus media training. But when I see that slight off axis worry, it's like, um,
4:46 Speaker 04 Sit up in the chair a little bit.
4:47 Speaker 05 Yeah, exactly.
4:50 Speaker 04 Also, uh, thank you to everybody who's reached out about ad free podcasts. We, we keep talking about this because people keep discovering it and it is like, the, I, the emails that I've gotten, the social posts from people who, my favorite is I keep hearing from people who are like, I keep instinctively skipping ahead to get through ads when you say, we'll be right back. And then there's no ads, so I have to go back.
5:09 Speaker 05 Oh, that's really good.
5:10 Speaker 04 It's very funny, but, uh, go get the ad free podcast if you're a Verge subscriber. If you're not a Verge subscriber, verge.com/subscribe. It's a good website. Make us ungovernable. Um, and also, before we get into it, um, it's Halloween. As you're listening to this, if you're listening to this on Friday, and Neelai, I, I need to tell you my Halloween story, but I want to know what you're doing for Halloween.
5:30 Speaker 05 Well, I'm taking a K-pop demon hunter around town.
5:32 Speaker 04 Incredible. I assume that's going to be like the number one, like five to 15 Halloween costume this year.
5:40 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah. My town is full of seven-year-old K-pop demon hunters. Um, so is our staff, by the way. Hayden Field is dressing up as a K-pop demon hunter. She told, I sent her a picture of Max's costume and she's like, me too. Um, yeah, that's what we're, that's what we're doing. We already, and we already had like the Halloween fun run and da, da, da, da, da in this town. It was very cute.
5:56 Speaker 04 That's awesome. So we're doing, my whole family is doing Toy Story. Uh, I've talked about the Toy Story obsession recently. So, uh, our, our youngest is going to be Rex, the dinosaur. Arthur's going to be Buzz. I'm Woody and Anna, my wife, is Jessie. And I just want to tell you a very short story. So Anna bought all these costumes for us because she's wonderful. And, uh, basically went on Amazon, searched, you know, the name, costume, and bought the first thing that came up that had good reviews. Um, and it turns out that Amazon is a tricky thing to buy clothing on. And so what Anna accidentally bought is what I can only describe as a sexy Jessie costume.
6:33 Speaker 05 Yes.
6:34 Speaker 04 And so Anna got duped by a confusing Amazon listing into essentially buying Jessie-themed lingerie.
6:42 Speaker 04 Just came to our house and she would like, she gets like four seconds into trying on the first part of her Jessie costume and she's just like, I don't think this is.
6:52 Speaker 05 We're not going to the preschool Halloween party like this.
6:55 Speaker 04 I have a 10 a.m. Halloween party on Friday. Like, I don't think, I don't think we're gonna be doing that. So it's a PSA to everybody. Like, look at all the pictures before you buy your Halloween.
7:03 Speaker 05 I was really hoping that you were the one who ended up with the sexy costume. I knew this was gonna end with sexy costume.
7:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:08 Speaker 05 And I'm disappointed it's not David got the sexy.
7:11 Speaker 04 Sexy Woody is just like, he's just sitting right there, you know what I mean? We've just been waiting for this. Toy Story 6 is like sexy Woody all the way down.
7:18 Speaker 05 That's very good. We needed to dress up for the fun run. So Max went as a rainbow, which was like her thing that she can run in, which is a thing. Becky always goes as a hot 80s lady, because she can just wear her workout clothes and look like a hot lady. And then I was like, oh, I didn't get anything. So I was like, I'll be like hot 80s guy. And then I also just put on most of my own clothes.
7:39 Speaker 05 And I just had like slightly bigger hair and I was like, this works. Pop the collar, let's call it a day.
7:43 Speaker 04 That's the, that's the Patel commitment I'm looking for. All right, let's get into the news. So the, the first thing we should talk about is basically like what Adobe did, because I think there's, there's this fascinating sliding scale of what is going on in the AI world and what AI is for, that you can kind of chart the whole spectrum from what I would call like interesting tools to do interesting stuff using new infrastructure technology, all the way down to like disastrous slop, what if it ended the world?
8:17 Speaker 05 Yeah.
8:17 Speaker 04 That whole story was at Adobe Max. So let's, let's start at one end of the spectrum and just sort of work our way down. Does that sound good?
8:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, that seems right.
8:26 Speaker 04 Okay. So, which means we should probably start with Photoshop and Premiere Pro. And the big news, I would say, I'm particularly, Chris, you're a big Lightroom user, right? And, and you've been. Kind of convinced by some of the AI stuff that Adobe is doing.
8:41 Speaker 05 More than convinced.
8:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:42 Speaker 05 Totally integrated in a workflow, don't know how to use my cameras without some of the AI features in Lightroom.
8:48 Speaker 04 Okay, so there's a lot of that kind of all over Photoshop and Premiere Pro now, right? There's the, there was a big update to Generative Fill, uh, which people love. It's the like, just sort of assume what's going on around the edges of whatever you're, people love it. There's a new thing that you can basically use all of Photoshop's features and menus just with AI prompts. Like you can just sort of tell it what you want to do rather than going and finding the button for it, which I think is like, just straightforwardly genius. Like, go use the app for me because I don't want to figure out how to find this one tool hidden three menus down. Terrific idea. Uh, there's a thing called assisted culling that is, uh, it's a Lightroom feature and it's supposedly gonna just go through all the photos that you took and find the ones that are like the sharpest and in the right color range
9:33 Speaker 04 and sort of whittle the giant library down to just the ones you should actually pay attention to. Um, again, interesting, like, simple feature stuff. Uh, there's a thing called layered image editing that is basically like, when you do some of the other AI stuff, it tries to solve for the sort of downstream effects of it. Like, one of the examples that Jess by the bed gave in a story she wrote for us is if you, uh, move an object in a photo, which you can now do in Photoshop, just pick it up and move it pretty easily, uh, it'll automatically reshape the shadows to make it make sense in the new place. So it's this like contextual awareness of the whole thing that makes AI just kind of work around it. As far as I can tell, this is the kind of stuff that is like, if not universally beloved and popular among the creative community,
10:18 Speaker 04 like, pretty close to it.
10:20 Speaker 05 Yeah. If you were, if, we didn't live in a world poisoned by generative AI and Adobe just announced some of these tools in the context of Photoshop, the way they used to announce some of these tools, we would be writing stories that people would universally be excited about. But we've done it before, like when Adobe first started showing off variations of generative fill years and years ago, people were like, that's amazing. Contextual object removal when they first started showing off years and years ago, people were like, that's amazing. Yes, we wrote all the stuff about the nature of reality and what is a photo, but the professionals using these tools for work, they were just generally excited that their work and particularly
11:03 Speaker 05 tedious parts of their work were getting more exciting. When I say Lightroom is totally baked in my workflow, what I mean is that my old cameras have taken on new life because the AI-based noise reduction in Lightroom is so good that I can shoot my Nikon D7500, which has the most expensive lenses I've ever bought for a camera, I can shoot it at its highest ISOs, which were all but unusable before, and Lightroom just fixes it. It's incredible. It's just, I've taken the old Nikon image processing pipeline out of the equation. I just shoot raw with an old camera, expensive glass.
11:39 Speaker 04 Wow.
11:39 Speaker 05 And Lightroom is a new image processing pipeline. That is incredible. None of that is like AI, the way that we're talking, like Sam Altman talks about AI.
11:47 Speaker 04 Right.
11:48 Speaker 05 That is just really advanced machine learning. That is, yep, there are some models in the background. But like, the point of that is my, my old stuff got new life breathed into it, and I'm taking more and better pictures than I was before. Reflection removal in Lightroom, totally just baked into my workflow. Like, there's just stuff that's really cool. My favorite feature in Photoshop, by the way, is sort of like a straightforward LLM feature. You can make a big, you can look at a big messy list of layers and then say, just rename all these layers, the way that I would do it. And it just does it. That's incredible. Like, there's this stuff here where it's like, oh, we can make the task easier and make it more straightforward and make using the things simpler so more people can do
12:32 Speaker 05 it, or the people who are really good at it can do it more efficiently.
12:34 Speaker 04 My favorite example of this stuff is always the, the like, automatic masking stuff in Photoshop, which is like, it's the sort of thing that theoretically anybody can do, but for so many years it involved like diligently and slowly drawing a line around an object, which is Like just a bad way to spend your time and is not a thing that anybody would argue is like a useful professional skill to have. It's just a thing you had to do. And now like there were, there were some updates to that this time where it's just like now these apps are shockingly good at just like, we know what the object is and we can actually just pull it out of the image for you. And then there's new features now, this new feature called harmonize that will put it into something else. And basically adapt it to its new surroundings. So it'll, it'll change the lighting, it'll change the shadows, it'll change
13:18 Speaker 04 sort of everything about it to make it look like it belongs in its new place. And this is the kind of thing that it's like, if you want to extend that far enough out and be like, okay, what does it mean that you can convincingly put an object in another place? Fine. But this, like you said, this is the kind of stuff people are doing and have been doing professionally for a very long time. And this takes like a very tedious task that didn't need to be tedious and makes it not tedious.
13:41 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:41 Speaker 04 And that's very powerful.
13:42 Speaker 05 I mean, and you know, your smartphone can, if you take a picture on your smartphone and open it in photos, Apple photos or Google photos, like both of them are like, we, we cut out the people.
13:50 Speaker 04 Right.
13:50 Speaker 05 Like Apple's own imaging pipeline and Google's own imaging pipeline have semantic awareness, like this is the sky and that's the ocean and we'll make all the colors correct. And actually it's very funny because often when you shoot a pink sky, it's like, that's the sky. It makes it blue anyway. But like semantic, understanding what's happening in image and all this compositing, it is happening at the consumer level. And then you can see what Adobe is doing with AI at the professional level. I think this is all really interesting, but the turn that is happening with Adobe is they're going from, we're going to make the tedious part easier or automate the tedious thing that people are already doing. And they're getting to, we're doing stuff that you could never do.
14:30 Speaker 04 Like what? Give me an example.
14:32 Speaker 05 I honestly think AI powered noise reduction is just one of those things like you can be as good at Lightroom as anyone has ever been. You can be as good at Photoshop as anyone has ever been. You cannot de-noise a noisy raw image.
14:43 Speaker 04 Right.
14:44 Speaker 05 Like you as a person simply cannot do that. You have to throw an AI model at that problem and it can do it. And like I said, I think it has revolutionized how I think about my cameras. Then in some of their AI audio tools, they're doing stuff that no human can possibly do.
14:57 Speaker 04 See, this is where I think we like if we're if we're on the scale of like tools to slop, we're like, this is where we start to inch inch down the scale. We're still on the right side of the scale, but we're slowly inching down it. So there's like, like you were talking about, there's a bunch of new stuff in the in the Firefly app in particular, that is like, you can, you can generate a soundtrack out of nothing. You can generate speech out of nothing. And crucially, you can now like, really fine tune audio of all kinds. Like, you can decide the tone of voice that you want someone to have who did a voiceover. You can do unbelievable things with the audio that you've found. Like, this is the thing you're like, what was it called, Project Clean Take? Is this the thing you were talking about?
15:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, we got to run this audio. I mean, this is, you can be as good at an audio engineer as has ever existed in the world. You could not just take sounds out of the background, the way that Adobe has made it possible with one click to take a sound out of the background. Let's just run the clip.
15:54 Speaker 04 I deliberately have not heard this clip. Travis, can you just play this?
15:56 Speaker 06 This next clip was an interview with my coworker, Matt.
16:01 Speaker 06 He was speaking outside of the Adobe Seattle office in front of the Fremont Bridge. And let me just play a few seconds.
16:07 Speaker 05 We're in the Fremont neighborhood of Seattle, where the Adobe office is located. And the cool thing about this office is where it's located.
16:14 Speaker 06 So you can obviously hear that bell. That's because this bridge is a drawbridge that was actually opening while he was talking about it. So what we can do using our new and updated source separation technology is to take the audio from the video and break it up into its individual components directly in the timeline. Well, that bell ringing was actually on the sound effects track, so I can just mute it.
16:38 Speaker 05 This is located, and the cool thing about this office is where it's located. No way! It's between Lake Union and the Fremont Bridge behind me. That's just bananas.
16:47 Speaker 04 Okay, the no way is a little much, but that's still really cool.
16:50 Speaker 05 I mean, I like that they had to go outside and shoot that video exactly when the drawbridge was going up. And there's a part of me that says that Adobe rented a boat to go under the bridge exactly when they were shooting that video.
17:00 Speaker 04 And I like to think of it, it's like the opposite of when you're trying to shoot something and every time you do it, somebody like fires up the leaf blower in the background. They're like, you just have to, every time they're doing it, they're like, god damn it, the drawbridge didn't go, we have to do it again.
17:12 Speaker 05 So, you know, contrived and you can't hear it perfectly. And I don't know how much clipping is actually happening because usually when you do some of that AI STEM separation, there's like some weird clipping and some weird artifacts that occur. But you couldn't do that.
17:24 Speaker 04 No.
17:25 Speaker 05 You could not do that before to rescue that audio. And there's a part of me that says those are the capabilities the next generation of creators will lean into. There are stuff we simply could not do before that we can do now. I can take an old camera and make it new again. I can take unusable audio that I shot anywhere on location with all kinds of stuff happening in the background and make it usable. Even on our podcast here at The Verge, like I know our audio engineers get horrible audio from some of our sources.
17:52 Speaker 04 Yes.
17:53 Speaker 05 For the number of tech CEOs and everyone decoder, the number of tech companies that cannot make a podcast recording work. Like the number of voice memos on your iPhone backup recordings we have published coming from CEOs is is much higher than you think. And we just kind of rescue them with these tools. That is incredible. Like I honestly think that stuff is incredible. It makes me more excited about just AI in general than the slot factory. But the slot factory just keeps coming for the ride.
18:23 Speaker 04 It does.
18:24 Speaker 05 And you can see it like in their earnings this, this, this quarter. Like the slot factory is winning.
18:29 Speaker 04 The slot factory is where everybody very clearly thinks the money is. And this is, this is a good way into the, the, again, we're just running down this scale with, with Adobe products. The next thing, which I think is like dead center of this scale, and I'm curious how it makes you feel is the new AI assistant in Adobe Express, which is basically, it's, it's Adobe's simpler image editing tool. It's like Photoshop for babies. It's like, yeah, it's their camera. And essentially what it is now is it's this public beta of a new assistant that you just tell it what you want to do to your image and it will do it. And you can be very specific. You can be like, you know,
19:08 Speaker 04 change this color or move this thing over here. Or I think one of the examples they gave was like, give it a jungle theme and it'll just do that. And so like, On the one hand, this is not out of no, this, this is still in the realm of like, this is an editing tool, right? And this is like a thing that you made that you're doing stuff to, that you are deciding what to do. But at the same time, like, make it a jungle theme, it hands a lot of work off to this AI assistant. And I think this is where we start to tip into, like, is this, is this a useful tool that you're giving to people who need it? Or are we starting to make things that maybe we shouldn't need to make here?
19:47 Speaker 05 Well, you know, I would say that you can prompt Photoshop to do stuff for you is right in the same zone, right? You open a file in Photoshop, you're like, I just, can you just mask the stuff and do the stuff? And you can just type it in prompt and Photoshop will do it? That is, you know, as close to the same vision as everyone else has. Well, that's an agent.
20:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
20:04 Speaker 05 And she's using Photoshop for you. You get all the way to, we'll democratize that, we'll take away the Photoshop of it. And you just say, make it a jungle theme. You haven't, it's still an agent, right? It just might not have any taste. I think it's really interesting. Canva doesn't get as much crap for AI as Adobe gets. They're very differently situated companies that the CEO of Canva, Melanie, she's been on the cutter. She's like very charming in her way. But Canva is explicitly for not artists.
20:35 Speaker 04 Right.
20:36 Speaker 05 Right? It is explicitly to democratize design and art and particularly marketing design for like everyone else in a company. And so when they automate stuff, and when they make it easier to use AI to prompt Canva, like, they don't face the same backlash because their audience is already not doing it. They all compete and maybe they're going to run into each other. But Adobe's audience, like, that's who it's for.
21:01 Speaker 04 Right.
21:02 Speaker 05 And so I think this stuff just feels more threatening.
21:04 Speaker 04 Well, yeah. And I think what's strange for Adobe is like, its audience actually large, like Express is not sort of a Adobe class leading product. Like, that's where Adobe is playing catch up to this other generation of things that came along. Whereas like, there are people who've been using Photoshop professionally for literal decades, right? And so that's where you're going to find people with much stronger opinions about everything. Whereas Express, you get the sense Adobe feels just utterly free to do whatever it wants.
21:32 Speaker 05 It does. I just, I think, again, we're on, we're on this like spectrum of slop. And like, oh no, the marketing people will make more Twitter ads more quickly with an AI tool. It's just like, doesn't, whatever, man. You know, like.
21:45 Speaker 05 Like that's, to me, is not the problem. The problem is when you start automating both the production and the distribution of it. And then the platforms are like, this is the future, which is very much the sort of next two turns we're going to talk about here.
21:59 Speaker 04 Yep. Let's, I mean, yeah, you, we just dive headlong into that with this thing called Project Moonlight. And if I'm understanding Project Moonlight correctly, it basically, it is a sort of holistic social planner for you in that it will, it will look at your various assets that you have in Creative Cloud. It will look at your existing social channels and then it will just make things for you. You just say like, here is what I have done in the past. Here's some stuff and it will just design a whole slop factory of social media stuff for you. I think we have a clip of them explaining this too. Let's, let's just play this real fast.
22:39 Speaker 07 Here's a sneak peek at something we call Project Moonlight as an AI assistant that acts like a social strategist for you.
22:46 Speaker 08 I'm going to go ahead and ask Project Moonlight to help me brainstorm some fun post ideas that I can do with these images of my dog Bosco. So you can see those idea cards coming in super quick. Let's take a look. So I have three different ideas from Bosco's birthday bash to life with a Shiva and sunbeam snoozer. You can even see in the Bosco birthday bash, it's suggesting an Instagram carousel, the content and caption. I love idea, this idea, let's dive a little deeper. So I'm going to go ahead and ask Project Moonlight for some more suggestions. I want to make this Instagram carousel a little bit more visually interesting. So we have ideas from speech bubbles saying another year closer to world domination coming from Bosco's mouth. That's super funny. We're even getting this kind of best strategy to incorporate this Bosco post, like keeping
23:31 Speaker 08 it authentic and fun. Maybe mention how Bosco fits into your creative life. You know, he definitely sleeps in my design studio when I'm designing and the doodle overlay openers would be perfect.
23:40 Speaker 04 This sucks. Like I just, there's something, there's something that just dies inside of me when, when she laughs at another year closer to world domination, which is just objectively not funny.
23:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, we've trained our AI model on a millennial cringe and now it can do that as much as anyone has ever done it. Here's what I'll say, there's a reason I wanted to start with Adobe. I think Adobe is a criminally undercovered company. And so we spend a lot of time covering Adobe, just weatherbed, RSTM in particular, spends a lot of time covering Adobe. The reason I say it's undercover is that everyone thinks of Adobe is the Photoshop company. And what Adobe figured out ages ago is that just having advertisers make the images in Photoshop was not enough. They wanted to own that image or own what happened to that image all the way down to you, the consumer, see it and then maybe buy something. So Adobe owns a giant ad network.
24:36 Speaker 05 Like bizarrely, at the end of every Prime Day, we get reports from Adobe. Adobe sends out the press release that's like, here's how Prime Day went because they own this huge advertising tracking system. And what they have really figured out is if you make images commercially or videos commercially, right? If you're in the business of making money by being a creative, it's not just making the asset that matters. It's like the whole life of the asset that matters. This is a big deal and it's sort of like underreported and undercover about Adobe. So Adobe's saying, oh shit, we can just have the AI do that whole thing. Beginning to end, we're going to take the data from the end about how the thing performed on Instagram and feed that back into Photoshop so that you just give us a photo and we make
25:21 Speaker 05 a million little ads or Instagram captions or whatever. And then we publish variations that to Instagram. We track it and we make another one. Yeah, dude, that is, that's the slot machine. That slot machine, by the way, is what everyone else sees as the opportunity.
25:34 Speaker 04 Yeah, I was just about to say this, what you just described is the exact business plan of a number of other very large companies that we cover. Like that's what Meta is doing with ads especially, but increasingly also with just content all over Facebook. It's what YouTube seems to be running rapidly towards. Like this, this idea of, oh, we can own the whole stack and then we can just do it for you. And all you do is press the, I don't know, the do it button. And just assume that this stuff will happen at such scale that it'll work anyway. That like, I, I think the underpinning theory of so much of this is like, the internet is so big, and there is so much opportunity that your stuff doesn't have to be that good.
26:15 Speaker 04 We will just spray it so efficiently around the internet that the volume will outweigh the quality and you will get paid. And because you don't see any of it, you'll never see any of your ads. You'll never see how, how they look in context. It all just happens in the background and money pours into your account. And that, and what a, what a perfect terrific creative outcome that would be.
26:35 Speaker 05 There's a quote from Zuckerberg a few months ago where he's like, the future of Meta is you give us some money and we generate you some business results.
26:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:43 Speaker 05 And what he means by that is you give us some money and maybe a picture of your product, and we will just generate ads until you sell as many products as you told us you want to sell.
26:51 Speaker 04 Yeah.
26:52 Speaker 05 And that is fine, like, in one sense, it's already Meta's business model, right? Like, you pay them for, to target some ads and then you make some money and you can direct sell as much stuff as you want.
27:05 Speaker 04 Sure.
27:05 Speaker 05 The part where you take all the creatives out of the loop and Meta's just generating infinite creative, to the point where Nvidia gives demos of just, we'll just 3D model the shampoo for you. We'll never even take a photo of the shampoo bottle. We'll just do, we'll just generate the shampoo bottle and then generate the ads around it. That stuff is wild. And I look at Adobe here and I'm like, oh, it's very cool that you do the denoise in Lightroom. Very cool. But their business model is create the image, distribute the image, track the image, help you make money. And they're like, we're going to automate that. And things like Project Moonlight are as clear of a statement of how they want it to go as anyone. I think that the challenge, and I think they're really interesting, next turn of the, like the social internet, is all the social platforms are like, we don't need Adobe for that.
27:49 Speaker 05 We'll just do it ourselves.
27:51 Speaker 04 Right.
27:51 Speaker 05 And then that leads us directly into, boy, a bunch of these companies had gigantic earnings this quarter.
27:59 Speaker 04 Yeah, they sure did.
28:00 Speaker 05 And I don't, I don't know how, I don't really care about earnings, but boy, does that make me worry that the slot factory is just cranked to high.
28:08 Speaker 04 Yeah. I mean, the, the two that really jumped out to me on this front were Meta, which had like a weird earnings call because they took some giant stock hit that I don't, I'm not interested in or care about.
28:20 Speaker 04 But I mean, Mark Zuckerberg just like got on the earnings call and was basically like, we think the next era of Facebook is AI-generated content. Like just in as, in as many words, that's what it is. And I think I keep wanting to draw this line between like, it's fine if we're going to do this for ads, right? Like a perfectly efficient advertising system that doesn't involve good creative is like, fine, right? Like, I don't know that that affects me in a huge way. And, and the fact that all these companies spent all this time saying perfectly targeted, really great ads are actually good for users and are now on to this is just like, thank you for admitting the thing you told me for 20 years was a lie, Mark Zuckerberg. But it's like, I'm tempted to leave that to the side and be like, the actual problem is
29:06 Speaker 04 when we're pointing these tools at like people doing creative expression sort of for its own sake. But then I look at TikTok and all of that is the same thing, right? Like half the TikTok videos I see are ads. And so it's like, all of this stuff is just running directly at each other. And it's like, okay, if everybody's trying to sell me something, what is the difference? And is, does that line between somebody doing art and somebody doing ads even exist on these platforms anymore? And I think the platforms think it doesn't.
29:34 Speaker 05 All right. Well, you know, my hottest tick is that the creator economy is about to implode. And the pressure on any individual creator is so high that I have nothing but sympathy for individual creators. You thought you were going to run a business on YouTube. And at any moment, YouTube can take your business away from you. Right. My, my joke is that every YouTuber gets their wings when they make the video about how pissed off they are at YouTube because they realize that they have no power in that relationship whatsoever and YouTube can just destroy them on a whim. And that's been true for years and years and years. And what's coming now is the platforms are going to destroy the creators. It is just coming. The pressure on any individual creator to do brand deals to pay the rent because the platforms don't pay them enough money is
30:19 Speaker 05 so high that, and I mean this with a lot of love towards all the creators that we are friends with. Most creators, if you look at their business, they're just ad agencies. Yeah. You're just running a bunch of single person ad agencies across the internet and you are starting to, you know, cut off your like authentic relationship with your audience because the ad agencies and the brands are telling you what to say. And because the platforms aren't paying you enough money, that's the revenue you rely on and you're going to start making compromises to preserve that revenue. That's bad. And increasingly, there's no other move. And there's no other move. Right. And when we hear it from creators over and over and over again, and the brands
31:00 Speaker 05 and the companies are so aggressive that they are starting to turn the screws over tighter. Like I have heard a million stories that are like, we'll give you this product in exchange for a good review and that's how you're going to get your brand deal. Millions of these stories everywhere. Again, I have nothing but sympathy for like the individual creators. I just see the pressure across that market broadly. So that's bad. Then you add in the pressure of, well, what if you don't need a creator? What if YouTube can just make a synthetic creator who will say whatever you want and generate millions of clips of this fake creator saying that your camera is the best and then you can just pay to put that in everyone's feeds? Right. Which is the promise that these companies are making to these companies about their
31:45 Speaker 05 AI advertising tools. We will make you infinite creative, infinitely targeted and deliver you business results. Well, that sucks.
31:53 Speaker 05 The pressure on the creator rates is going to be incredible. Once that happens.
31:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
31:58 Speaker 05 So that's one more pressure.
31:59 Speaker 04 Well, and then as a creator, you're forced to play that exact same game, right? Because you're like, well, now what I need to do is run a perfectly efficient content targeting business, or else I know literally no one's ever going to see my videos.
32:09 Speaker 05 Or yeah, or I need to play to the algorithm even more to build a channel big enough so I can generate these results, which means I'm going to be even less authentic and do whatever the algorithm says.
32:17 Speaker 04 Mr. Beast.
32:17 Speaker 05 But then the algorithm is now flooded with AI content made by the platforms at massive scale because they think that that will keep people more engaged than their creator content. So you see the pressure from the from an individual creator standpoint is the platforms have never paid enough money. Your standard per view rate on YouTube or Tik Tok or whatever has never been worth a damn. The pressure to cave to like marketer demands for your sponsorship deals is higher than ever, but those rates are going to drop. Because the AI influencers are coming for those dollars. And then to get a big enough audience, you have to compete in the algorithm with AI content generated by the platforms itself.
33:00 Speaker 05 That is all a mess. And I just see that pressure on the whole creator economy and it it feels very bad. And again, I'm not on an individual basis, every creator is making the right choices. They're rationally responding to a bunch of pressure that they face, but we are not part of that economy. We don't do that stuff. And so we can just step outside of it and say, boy, the creator economy as it is currently composed is about to implode under the like the triple pressures of AI.
33:31 Speaker 04 Yeah.
33:32 Speaker 05 Like Zuckerberg is not being shy about it. We have a clip from him from the earnings call where he's just straight up like, I'm going to dump a bunch of AI slop on you. We should just run the clip.
33:40 Speaker 09 Social media has gone through two eras so far. First was when all content was from friends, family and accounts that you follow directly. The second was when we added all of the creator content. Now, as AI makes it easier to create and remix content, we're going to add yet another huge corpus of content on top of those.
33:59 Speaker 04 The thing he says essentially over and over that he doesn't say there, but clearly believes is that that third thing will just wipe out all of the first and second and that that's okay.
34:11 Speaker 05 Well, here's, I mean, like, there's only so many people in the world, Mark. And they only have so much time in the day. So just supply and demand dictates that you add much more content to the feeds. The attention will be taken from something else.
34:29 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:30 Speaker 05 I know where the attention will be taken from because you're not paying friends, family and, and, and, you know, the elementary school parents group. You're paying the creators. You're going to take the money away from the creators with your, you know, universe of your corpus. You're going to take the money away from the creators with your corpus of AI content. By the way, whenever anybody opens Instagram, I know what they're thinking is I can't wait to access a third corpus of content.
34:58 Speaker 04 I've been meaning to get a new corpus. But what I think is interesting about that, and this is like, we should, we should talk about this big YouTube reorganization that I think you're really interested in too, is the platform bet is that it won't cost the platform anything, right? Like, I think there's a certain feeling that I have as a user that like, at the, at the end of the process you just described, not only is there nothing left on those platforms for creators, there's nothing left for me except like AI generated ads. And you, you don't get any sense that any of these platforms fear that outcome at all. In fact, they're organizing themselves around making it happen more quickly.
35:38 Speaker 05 Yeah. And I can't tell if that's just because they don't have any taste. Like I, I can tell it's because Mark Zuckerberg doesn't have any taste. You can look at Zuck's like t-shirts and his like UFC phase and his haircut. And you, you can be like, I can maybe identify taste here. But you can't actually, you can't tell me what Zuck likes. Right? He doesn't have this like forward taste that dictates what's good and what's bad. Zuck, Zuck's taste is that he wants to win. That's it. He just doesn't want to miss another era and he wants to win whatever he thinks is nice.
36:10 Speaker 04 Even his t-shirts often communicate that fact.
36:13 Speaker 05 Yeah.
36:13 Speaker 04 That that is what he wants to do is win.
36:16 Speaker 05 YouTube stays, we can talk about YouTube. YouTube actively tries not to have taste.
36:22 Speaker 05 Like they describe themselves as infrastructure and pipes.
36:25 Speaker 04 Right.
36:25 Speaker 05 And I think organizing themselves around distributing AI is very much in keeping with Google, but also in keeping with the sense that this is happening and we better, we had better make sure our infrastructure can support it. And there's a lot to say about YouTube in that way, but like
36:38 Speaker 04 It's interesting.
36:39 Speaker 05 That's YouTube's self conception. So whether or not the people who run YouTube have a whole bunch of like individual taste, sort of secondary to the fact that they constantly describe themselves as infrastructure.
36:48 Speaker 04 I think YouTube wants you to believe it's infrastructure. I think the experience of being a viewer or creator on YouTube suggests that it is
36:55 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah.
36:55 Speaker 04 far from infrastructure. Like it is not a dumb pipe in in any way, shape or form. But it desperately wants you to think that it is. And I think like you talk about Adobe as a company that gets under covered. I think YouTube gets vastly under covered.
37:09 Speaker 05 Yeah.
37:09 Speaker 04 For that reason, because YouTube is like, we're just, we're just a website people post videos on. Like, what do you mean?
37:15 Speaker 05 The only website people post videos.
37:18 Speaker 04 But now, especially with this AI stuff, YouTube is getting so much more proactive and involved, like you said, in in this whole process. Like, there's a, there's a whole new thing in Adobe Premiere that just lets you one click, publish directly to YouTube Shorts. Like, they've just, they just, they had built a partnership, they built this pipeline and it is like, YouTube has gone from being a place you upload a video you already made to like, they're increasingly taking that whole pipeline you just described and pulling it into YouTube. And that changes what that platform is. And when it's AI, you can just do it because there's nothing, there's nothing else there. You just, you make whatever you want inside of the YouTube Studio app and you're good to go.
37:59 Speaker 05 Why do I keep saying the creator economy is going to implode? Because there's some analysis of Google's earnings this quarter that suggests YouTube Shorts now makes more money than YouTube proper. That's bad, that's bad news for the creator economy, right? The way YouTube Shorts is monetized is vastly different than the way traditionally YouTube is monetized. Second, YouTube Shorts, just like TikTok or Instagram Reels, not built on a follow model. So to the extent that any creator owned an audience on YouTube by having lots of followers and notifications, all that goes out the window and it's just algorithmic swiping content. And maybe you'll get some followers, probably you won't. Like, the vast majority of people who see your stuff are not going to be your followers. This is a huge problem.
38:37 Speaker 04 Yep.
38:37 Speaker 05 And then you're like, and then we can flood that algorithm with AI content generated directly by marketers in Adobe Premiere. All that's bad. Like, it is just, it's, it's bad in the sense that I think aesthetically, it will be a disaster. I think we're all just gonna look at a lot of weird slop. And I think it's, it's just bad for the creator economy. It's bad for all the creators that people actually like on these platforms. And to your point, I don't think the platforms have thought through what happens when they kill the creators. I, I really don't. I think they think that people are gonna just open Instagram no matter what's there.
39:07 Speaker 04 I think that's right. There is, there is a, like, there is a real sense among all of these apps that they are, they are too big to delete, right? That like, the muscle memory of opening Instagram is so big 25 times a day that you're gonna keep doing it even if there's nothing there for you. And it, it might be true. Like, it honestly, it might be true. I still go on TikTok a lot, even though the TikTok shop is 60% of the videos I see, and I don't like that. I still open TikTok more often than I, like, the inertia is super, super strong, but it feels like eventually, eventually it's gonna break.
39:45 Speaker 05 Except all of them are reacting to Sora being the number one app in the App Store, and it's full of nothing but slop.
39:51 Speaker 04 Yes, which suggests that there is a version of it. I actually give Sora a lot of credit because it is the most interesting idea in this space that anyone has had by a mile. Like, the cameo thing, feel however you wanna feel about it in like grand terms. The idea of like, I can upload a video and then put myself in other videos, fabulous idea. It's such a good growth hack. Like, it's, it's, it's, the, the whole thing where like, what everybody wanted when Instagram came around was to take pictures of themselves, right? And then when we made videos, it's people made videos of themselves. And being able to post that thing becomes very sticky and very valuable and very important. I think the, anecdotally, the sense I get is the Soya novelty is already kinda wearing off. Because
40:35 Speaker 04 the like, I can make myself an astronaut thing is like fun once, and then not anymore. Because it's like, not that fun to be a fake astronaut. I don't know.
40:46 Speaker 05 But I, I can do disinformation at massive scale. Very useful to a lot of people.
40:50 Speaker 04 Pretty fun.
40:51 Speaker 05 I will say the videos of Mr. Rogers talking shit with Tupac Shakur are incredible. I feel very bad about laughing.
40:57 Speaker 04 All of your feeds are so much more fun than mine.
40:59 Speaker 05 They're, it's, I mean.
41:02 Speaker 05 Listening to Mr. Rogers just do D's nut stroke after D's nut stroke with Tupac Core is very wrong. I want to be clear. I feel bad when I consume this content. I also laugh my ass off every single time.
41:17 Speaker 04 And it's bad for the world and very funny. Like it's like the both of those things can be true.
41:20 Speaker 05 It's, you know, when, um, you don't know, because you're a good eaters. You know, when you smoked your first cigarette in like eighth grade?
41:27 Speaker 04 Eighth grade? God, Racine, Wisconsin. What are they doing up there?
41:31 Speaker 05 We had more bars per capita than anywhere else in the country. That's, that's my town's claim.
41:35 Speaker 04 Fair enough.
41:36 Speaker 05 It's like exactly that feeling. Like I know this is bad. I know my parents will be mad. I should feel ashamed. Also, this rules. And whatever that swirl of emotions is, is Mr. Rogers and Tupac deep face.
41:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, that sounds right.
41:51 Speaker 05 You will go, go find him. Let me know what you think about that.
41:54 Speaker 04 If you, if you're a person who made those videos, make another one where Neel is just ripping a cig in the background and send it to me. That's all I want in the whole world.
42:03 Speaker 05 Every now and again, someone asks me like, did you play sports in high school? I'm like, no, I smoke cigarettes.
42:10 Speaker 05 That's what I did.
42:11 Speaker 04 That's, you're too cool for sports. That's what everybody says about Neel. If you want a link to Neel's band on YouTube, get at me. I'll happily send it to you at any time. Um, all right. Well, so the, the reason underneath all of this is money.
42:25 Speaker 05 Yeah.
42:26 Speaker 04 And at least, at, at least at this moment, there is a whole lot of money in saying AI out loud on earnings calls. And there's a particular version of the money story that I think we should tell here. But first I think we should take a break and then we're going to come back and we're going to talk about OpenAI and the swirling trillions of dollars in all of this. We'll be right back.
42:49 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an ultra because it's not just a superior light beer. It's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser-Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
43:17 Speaker 02 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline. That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
43:27 Speaker 03 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
43:34 Speaker 02 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
43:48 Speaker 10 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
44:20 Speaker 05 What I want you to know upon return is that I played a number of Mr. Rogers and Tupac clips for David, and now David is broken.
44:28 Speaker 04 This is, how am I supposed to podcast now? Oh, God. That was, this is really something.
44:35 Speaker 04 I'm just, I'm, it's gonna, I'm gonna end up just like word vomiting the things from that video in the middle here. Okay.
44:42 Speaker 04 Miss, from Mr. Rogers to OpenAI. This is what we do on the first cast.
44:46 Speaker 05 This is, OpenAI's entire valuation is Mr. Rogers doing D's not strokes with Eazy-E and Tupac Shakur.
44:52 Speaker 04 That's real. So, the big, like, business news of the week was that OpenAI finished its restructuring into a for-profit company. This has been, what, 18 months in the works and had a pretty hard deadline of the end of this year. It's been, it's been a big controversial thing. Elon Musk is suing, everybody's mad. The details are whatever, but essentially now OpenAI is a for-profit company, sort of theoretically controlled by a nonprofit called the OpenAI Foundation. OpenAI, the OpenAI Foundation owns 26%, which, according to OpenAI, is worth about $130 billion. All the numbers are fake and they're about to get much bigger, as we will talk about, but that's what the OpenAI Foundation has.
45:35 Speaker 04 Microsoft has a little more, about 27%. And then the rest is basically split between, like, existing investors and OpenAI employees. It's a lot of money. But the reason we have brought this up is because, Neelai, I would say this announcement elicited your favorite press release of 2025.
45:55 Speaker 05 Easily.
45:56 Speaker 04 Would you say that's fair?
45:57 Speaker 05 Easily. I want to, but can I start by just laying some foundation here? Walt Mossberg is as close to like a mentor as I've ever had. And there's a story about Walt in his heydays reviewer that I think about maybe every single day. It is a profile of Walt in Wired magazine from years and years and years ago. And it opens with him walking through the Consumer Electronics Show, CES in Vegas. And the CEO of Sirius XM is screaming at Walt in the trade show about how a bad review of the latest Sirius XM radio tanked their stock price. And he's like screaming at Walt and Walt's not paying attention. He's screaming at Walt. And finally Walt, and this is literally in the story. It's in the Wired story. So it's the last sentence of the first paragraph of the Wired story. Walt screams back at the CEO of Sirius XM.
46:42 Speaker 05 I don't give a fuck about your stock price.
46:44 Speaker 04 Iconic, iconic moment for Walt Mossberg.
46:47 Speaker 05 You know, I say a lot of things are the mission statement of The Verge, but I don't give a fuck about your stock price is like as close to being the beating heart of our, of our mission here. And I bring this up because it's so easy to get lost in the numbers. It's so easy to get lost in the idea that any given quarter is the win or the loss. It's so easy to treat the entire economy like gambling. We don't, you know, we like, our ethics policy forbids us from having investments in these companies. Like, whatever, we're just not tied up in their financial returns. We are very focused on are these products good? And in many ways, are these press releases written by a rational brain that is not on drugs?
47:29 Speaker 05 You know, like, I don't, I don't care about your stock price. I don't, I don't care what you're saying about the diluted value on an as convert, what, who cares? It's interesting in the sense that it affects your products and who builds them and who's winning. Fine.
47:43 Speaker 04 Right.
47:43 Speaker 05 But I don't actually care about that.
47:44 Speaker 04 The reason I bring it up, I just, the only frame I would add to this is the, the reason I bring this up in this way is that I think you can explain a vast amount of the AI focus of the tech industry.
47:58 Speaker 04 Just by the fact that there is so much money in it. Like, if you open your mouth in downtown San Francisco and say, AI technologies, somebody just hands you a billion dollars.
48:08 Speaker 05 Right.
48:08 Speaker 04 Like, and it's been a long time since we have had that specific thing. And so I think the money is all fake. The money is all insane. I continue to be on the record that I think OpenAI is like a house of cards that is going to tear itself and the economy down with it. But the money is the thing. And the money, in so many ways, is the story of this thing that they've dressed up in the funniest press release of 2025.
48:31 Speaker 05 Right. And the gap is that the products can't do what the money suggested. That's what I'm trying to point out. Like, everyone is so focused on the money and the stock prices, da-da-da-da-da, but the heart of, I don't give a fuck about your stock prices, but your product was bad.
48:44 Speaker 04 Right.
48:45 Speaker 05 Great. Okay. I'm bringing this up just to set the stage for, I read this press release, which is just about the conversion of OpenAI from one structure to another and Microsoft's new deal terms with OpenAI. And I was like, did anyone sane read this press release? Because it sounds like the rantings of someone who is fully high and drunk.
49:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, it does. But in like a very lawyerly way. You know what I mean? It's like a high and drunk lawyer.
49:16 Speaker 05 Well, that's most lawyers. It's not a sober profession.
49:19 Speaker 04 Should we just dramatically read this press release together?
49:21 Speaker 05 I want to, but what I want to say is, yes, we should. And the thing to know as we read it is that the heart of the disagreement between Microsoft and OpenAI in the past was that OpenAI had a get out of jail free card, where when they developed AGI, the exclusivity of Microsoft was over. So this is really what they've been negotiating the whole time.
49:38 Speaker 04 Yeah. OpenAI was like, you have to get, we are beholden to you until we do AGI. And that was like vague and complicated. And Sam Altman has spent the last couple of years like, kind of rapidly bringing down the bar for what qualified as AGI.
49:55 Speaker 04 But it's still, they all still call it the thing, like the world will change when we get to AGI. So anyway, let's, let's, let's do this press release.
50:02 Speaker 05 So why don't you read the press release and I'll just read it another way that you can interpret it.
50:06 Speaker 04 Okay.
50:06 Speaker 05 Just line by line. Just, let's start with what has evolved.
50:08 Speaker 04 Stop me when you'd like to.
50:10 Speaker 05 Okay.
50:10 Speaker 04 Uh, yeah. So they talk about the money and then here's a bulleted list of what has evolved. Once AGI is declared by OpenAI, that declaration will now be verified by an independent expert panel.
50:20 Speaker 05 Once Jesus has been developed by OpenAI, that declaration will now be verified by an independent expert panel. Right? What are you talking about? Once we, once we develop digital god and a verified panel of experts will be like, yep, there he is.
50:35 Speaker 04 God.
50:37 Speaker 05 What? That's the first bullet.
50:41 Speaker 05 Who's on your panel?
50:44 Speaker 04 Other gods.
50:45 Speaker 05 The Pope?
50:47 Speaker 05 Like, what are you talking about?
50:49 Speaker 04 Once AGI is developed, it will bring several religious leaders.
50:53 Speaker 05 It doesn't even say, it says declared.
50:55 Speaker 04 Declared, you're right.
50:56 Speaker 05 I just keep seeing that picture from the office of Steve Carell saying, I declare bankruptcy.
51:00 Speaker 04 AGI.
51:01 Speaker 05 Like, what are you talking about? This is the first bullet.
51:07 Speaker 04 Wait, oh man. Okay. So it's, it's, it's Sam Altman staying up, standing up, saying, I declare AGI. And then Satya Nadella just off to the side going, you can't just say that and expect something to happen.
51:17 Speaker 05 Right. He's like, okay, call the Pope and the Dalai Lama, you know, like who else is cool? Like, let's see.
51:23 Speaker 04 Should we invite Bella to the deed?
51:26 Speaker 05 What, what are you talking? Like, how is this the first bullet? And I know that this is the first bullet because in the minds of the people who crafted this press release,
51:37 Speaker 05 the verification by an independent expert panel is the win.
51:41 Speaker 04 Right.
51:42 Speaker 05 Cause they didn't have that before.
51:44 Speaker 04 That's the thing they've clawed back from OpenAI.
51:46 Speaker 05 Right. You can't just declare AGI. All right. That's the first one. That's the first one.
51:51 Speaker 04 Okay. Number two, Microsoft's IP rights for both models and products are extended through 2032 and now include models post AGI with appropriate safety guardrails.
52:01 Speaker 05 Microsoft's IP rights for both models and products are extended through 2032 and now include models post-Jesus with appropriate safety guardrails. What? Like, oh my, oh, good. I'm glad that we have appropriate safety guardrails after we've invented digital god.
52:16 Speaker 04 Once, once technology has subsumed us all.
52:19 Speaker 05 What are the appropriate safety guardrails for the post AGI models? Like, are you just gonna be like, no, you know, you're, you're very powerful Vishnu, but I don't think you should destroy the world like.
52:32 Speaker 04 There's just a button that says, please don't do that.
52:34 Speaker 05 This is the second bullet point and it's, you just look at it, you're like, this is nonsense.
52:40 Speaker 05 Like, what are, truly, what are the appropriate safety guardrails? Also, through 2032 and now models post AGI. So you've already sort of said, we don't think there's gonna be AGI by 2032.
52:57 Speaker 05 Right? Our, our IP rights for models and products extended through 2032 and now include models post AGI. So somewhere in this timeframe is Sam Altman saying, I declare, we've made digital God.
53:08 Speaker 04 I think Microsoft thinks that's about to happen really soon. And they're like, we're, he, he thinks that's his get out of jail free card and we're gonna make sure that it's not.
53:18 Speaker 05 I'm just saying, these are the first two bullets and both of them require OpenAI to say that they've achieved the singularity. Like, in a real way.
53:26 Speaker 04 Here, here's an even better version of the timeline. Microsoft's IP rights to research, defined as the confidential methods used in the development of models and systems, will remain until either the expert panel verifies AGI or through 2030, whichever is first.
53:41 Speaker 04 So not only are we doing God, we're doing God in the next five years.
53:46 Speaker 05 Yeah, whichever's first.
53:47 Speaker 04 Whichever's first.
53:48 Speaker 05 By the way, the expert panel has to get called in and verify AGI on this timeline. So.
53:58 Speaker 05 Let's say Sam Altman declares that he's developed digital God in, I don't know, mid 2029. You gotta get the Pope, the Dalai Lama, you know, whoever else, Melania, whoever are you gonna throw on your panel? And be like, is this digital God? You've got six months to decide.
54:15 Speaker 04 Who of the two of us do you think would be a fairer panelist on the AGI verification panel?
54:21 Speaker 05 I mean, your dad's a minister. I feel like, you know, you've got, you can, you can phone a friend.
54:27 Speaker 04 What does that god think of the, is it, is it, did they do the same? Do you know him?
54:34 Speaker 05 Does this seem familiar?
54:36 Speaker 04 Exactly.
54:37 Speaker 05 He's making a lot of AI slop. That doesn't, you know, WWJD.
54:43 Speaker 05 It's just, okay, fine.
54:45 Speaker 04 Here's a free idea. Somebody make WWAGID bracelets and I will wear them.
54:51 Speaker 05 Like a Livestrong bracelet.
54:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, like a, like a sort of rope braided bracelet. Yeah, this is, you're gonna kill on the streets of San Francisco. Okay. And then there's a bunch of stuff about research IP and it's essentially like all Microsoft gets to do whatever it wants.
55:07 Speaker 05 It's the two, the ones you should hear are Microsoft can independently pursue AGI and Microsoft uses IP to develop AGI.
55:12 Speaker 04 Yeah. So, okay. Well, one we have to do is Microsoft's IP rights now exclude OpenAI's consumer hardware. So.
55:20 Speaker 05 Sure. Johnny Ives.
55:23 Speaker 04 I'm gonna guess Microsoft gave that one up pretty easily.
55:27 Speaker 04 It's the one where you're just like, sure, you can have this win so that I can get all the stuff that I actually want. Like, yeah.
55:32 Speaker 05 Also, Microsoft is like, when we do consumer hardware, everyone around it dies.
55:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
55:38 Speaker 05 That's just a, that's just a barren wasteland of ideas.
55:42 Speaker 04 Okay, let's see.
55:42 Speaker 05 Except for the mice. The mice are very good.
55:44 Speaker 04 Couple more here that we should get to. Oh, here's one. This, this is my, maybe the most matter of fact delightful one of all of them. Microsoft can now independently pursue AGI alone or in partnership with third parties.
55:56 Speaker 05 Microsoft can now independently pursue Jesus alone or in partnership with third parties. Sure. Sure.
56:03 Speaker 04 Microsoft's walk with Christ is now its own.
56:07 Speaker 05 That's fine. I hope everyone is pursuing the singularity. I really do. And we're gonna come out on the other side and, you know, the, the, the real AGI is the partnership with third parties we made along the way.
56:18 Speaker 04 Yeah. Okay. And then, and then very next.
56:23 Speaker 04 If Microsoft uses OpenAI's IP to develop AGI prior to AGI being declared.
56:29 Speaker 04 You, you wanna just, you wanna just take that one before I even finish this sentence?
56:33 Speaker 05 What are you talking?
56:36 Speaker 05 Like no normal person like going about their day in America is like, man, I'm happy Microsoft and OpenAI clarified what happens that they invented digital god. But yes, if Microsoft uses OpenAI's IP to develop digital god prior to digital god being declared, the models will be subject to compute thresholds.
56:55 Speaker 05 Yes, very important term.
56:57 Speaker 04 Digital god only gets one GPU.
56:59 Speaker 05 Can't wait. Can't wait for the meeting after the Dalai Lama declares that Sam Altman has developed digital god, being like, all right, um, we've got to subject everyone to compute thresholds.
57:11 Speaker 04 How many Nvidia racks do you get for digital god?
57:17 Speaker 04 Okay. And then, um, two, two associated ones here. The revenue share agreement remains until the expert panel verifies AGI, though payments will be made over a longer period of time, which is Microsoft's way of saying you are going to continue to give us a tremendous amount of money, no matter what happens. And then another way of saying exactly that, OpenAI has contracted to purchase an incremental $250 billion of Azure services and Microsoft will no longer have a right of first refusal to be OpenAI's compute provider, which is to say, OpenAI wrote us a $250 billion IOU in exchange, it can go write other people IOUs.
57:51 Speaker 05 Yep.
57:51 Speaker 04 For digital god.
57:53 Speaker 05 Sure. I just like, all of this is fine. Like they needed to restructure the company. And I, you know, if I'm doing like the, the business analyst stuff, I'm like, Microsoft got a bunch of commitments that they will preserve the agreement in a way that makes them money until OpenAI decides that it's achieved its mission, which is to develop AGI.
58:16 Speaker 04 Right.
58:16 Speaker 05 And then you're like, okay, but if I look at what they're saying, it's, we will invent digital god and the revenue share will take place over a longer period of time. And like, you're just like, what?
58:29 Speaker 04 I mean, I think the you're right that there's one way to read this that is a high-end drunk lawyer. There's also another way to read this that is like so deeply spectacularly like eye-rollingly cynical about this whole thing where they're like, this is a Microsoft person being like, these clowns think they know what they're doing. And we're just like, oh, AGI, like, great job. We're so proud of you and your AGI. That's so cool.
58:54 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah. Nadella totally took Altman for a ride here. Like, again, if you want to do winners and losers and stock prices, yes, right? Like, that's how I would read this, that I don't think LLM technology is presently deployed. You can do it. But then you actually, these are some of the richest companies in the world, and they put out this press release, totally straightforwardly, totally seriously to be like, we've done it. We've run this by the attorneys general of both California and Delaware, and they approved our plan. That is all basically like this deal until Sam Altman declares AGI, and an expert panel verifies that it's true. And you're like, I don't, that really turns on what Sam Altman thinks AGI is, first of all. But second of all, it depends on him convincing that his
59:36 Speaker 05 definition is the one this expert panel should use. And no one has told us who's on this panel or who gets to appoint them.
59:42 Speaker 04 Right.
59:43 Speaker 05 This is all just silly. This is just silly talk to pump up these valuations.
59:48 Speaker 04 It is kind of just nothing. Like, everything you just said amounts to essentially nothing. And I think even Sam Altman is out here undercutting that. And I think, like, for a long time, he was at the forefront of like, we are building God. Like, the thing that we are making will be the thing that when we declare AGI, everything immediately will change. Like, he was out here talking about universal basic income, right? Like, the economy is going to change, the day-to-day ways that we live our lives will change when we do AGI. And he has just walked that back in the biggest ways that he possibly can. He did, actually, he did a live stream this week alongside this announcement and actually talked about this. Can we just play this one short clip where he talks about AGI?
1:00:32 Speaker 11 Yeah. I would say I think it's, the AGI term has become hugely overloaded. I think it's much more useful to say, our intention, our goal is by March of 2028 to have a true automated AI researcher,
1:00:44 Speaker 11 and define what that means than it is to sort of try to, you know, satisfy everyone with a definition of AGI.
1:00:50 Speaker 04 What?
1:00:51 Speaker 05 So he said this, like, maybe an hour after Microsoft released that press release. Saying that their deal terms change when Sam Altman declares AGI and the timeline on that is 2030. So who do you think has overloaded the term AGI, Sam?
1:01:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, right.
1:01:07 Speaker 05 It's not me.
1:01:10 Speaker 04 I mean, but I think the the difference between artificial general intelligence and truly automated AI researcher is so vast. And and and he says, even in the sentence, he says, a true automated AI researcher and define what that means. So even we're in this phase of like, oh, I've come up with a much less interesting word for what this thing is that we're building. And I also, we're not going to define that yet until 2028. Like, the the meaningless buzzword count is just absolutely off the charts with all of this stuff.
1:01:46 Speaker 05 Right. But again, just this bonkers press release.
1:01:50 Speaker 05 Microsoft has the IP rights to research that will remain until either the expert panel verifies AGI or through 2030, whichever is first. And Sam is saying in 2028, we'll have an automated researcher. So that gives him another two year window to have a panel verify that he's made digital God. A panel that no one has ever met and no one knows who will be appointed to or how they will get like, what are you talking about?
1:02:17 Speaker 04 I'm imagining this this panel as like the the American Idol judges. And and Satya Nadella is going to make sure that like he is the Simon Cowell, who is just like sitting there leaning back in his chair. And he's always just like, no.
1:02:30 Speaker 05 What's the Bojack Horseman celebrities? Do they know anything? What do they know? Let's find out like that's the AGI panel.
1:02:35 Speaker 04 Yes. Yeah. And as long as you have the one person who Satya is going to just like slip him 100 every time to just be like, no, that's not it.
1:02:42 Speaker 05 Yeah, you're not very smart at all, actually.
1:02:45 Speaker 04 I don't think that's it.
1:02:45 Speaker 05 The answer is not 42.
1:02:47 Speaker 04 Doesn't seem like God.
1:02:49 Speaker 05 I'm just saying like the this press release until the expert panel verifies AGI or through 2030, whichever is first. Those are words in a press release that OpenAI and Microsoft put out together. An hour later, Sam Altman is saying, our goal is by March of 2028 to have a truly automated AI researcher and define what that means than to sort of satisfy everyone with the definition of AGI. So he's already lost, right? I mean, the implication is that an expert panel could potentially validate the existence of AGI before 23rd. You wouldn't put in a term that says one or the other, whichever is first.
1:03:24 Speaker 04 Right.
1:03:24 Speaker 05 Unless you thought they were, either one was likely. And then Sam's like, no, it's not likely.
1:03:29 Speaker 04 Yeah. I mean, I do think the, the, a lesson he seems to be learning pretty quickly is the dangers of being overhyped, right? And like even as we've gone through the sort of GPT levels, he has started to be louder and louder about like, you shouldn't expect the leap from four to five to be the same as the leap from three to four was like, this stuff is not linear. It's not just magically going to get vastly better forever.
1:03:58 Speaker 04 And, and yet at the same time, if you're Sam Altman or Dario Amade at Anthropic or Sundar Pichai or any of these people, you have to be out there in earnings calls, talking about how this is going to change everything that you do. And I mean, Amazon goes out and lays off 14,000 people and is blaming AI for doing it. And I think there are lots of reads of that, but one thing that happens when you do that is you fire a bunch of people will say, AI is going to change the way that we do everything and the stock price goes up. And it's like, again, I don't care about the stock price, but like the reason these things happen is because the more you talk about AI, the more money there is in it for you at this particular moment in time. And so if you're Sam Altman and you're the, you're the face of this movement in a very real way,
1:04:43 Speaker 04 and also running a private company that hasn't already turned into like the unbelievable money fountain you want it to be. It, you have to do both things at the same time. Like he has to both sandbag the AI movement and champion it louder than anybody at exactly the same time, because otherwise stuff just gets really messy. And I think he's put himself in this really hard and potentially untenable place. Going forward.
1:05:10 Speaker 05 Oh, I mean, I I talked to finance people who are like, yep, there's two economies. There's whatever else feels, which is there are layoffs and the economies in tatters and their tariffs have made prices high. And then there's the Nvidia economy, right?
1:05:25 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:05:26 Speaker 05 There are two economies and they're like, the entire AI economy will fall apart if OpenAI doesn't pull it. And then I'm like, what does pull it off mean? And they're like, we don't know yet.
1:05:35 Speaker 04 Well, yeah, and now OpenAI is Reuters had a report this week that OpenAI is already starting to talk to people about a trillion dollar IPO, which would be one of the biggest ever like, it it only works if it keeps getting this much bigger, but ironically, it can only keep getting this much bigger if there isn't some spectacular disappointment coming, right? Like if if Sam Altman is like, I've made God and it's not God, the bubble bursts like that.
1:06:02 Speaker 05 Well, we have, again, the expert panel will verify.
1:06:08 Speaker 04 If Simon Cowell tells me it's God.
1:06:10 Speaker 05 I would love to hear you tell me I this is like, it's so funny. They said an expert panel will verify it without even a whiff of how you might compose such a panel. Email us, you call us, whatever it is. Tell us, let's say it's five people. Five is a good number, right? That's the number of voice judges, I believe. That's how I'm going with it. Did you tell us who you think those five people should be? Like, do you think Blake Shelton should be on a panel that verifies CGI? Like, who is it? Who would you put on it? Because it can't just be other AI researchers.
1:06:40 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:06:40 Speaker 05 That immediately invalidates the the claim that an expert panel has verified AGI, right? A bunch of the world's best drunks have verified that you made whiskey is like not a thing that you can do. You you have to have like people outside of the industry say, okay, this this big claim, the singularity, this is, um, uh, oh, God, what's the contact when Jodie Foster is like, should have sent a poet? Like, who's the poet? Right? Like, give me your list. What's the number?
1:07:10 Speaker 04 866 verge 11, vergecast at the verge.com. Cast the expert panel for us. I love this idea. Give us one name. Give us five names. We're gonna, we will, we will come up with the correct answer and we will figure it out.
1:07:21 Speaker 05 I will point out, um, you know, somebody who's spent a lot of time in Chicago, the Pope is from Chicago and having Chicago Pope verify that Sam Altman made digital cheeses is like very funny
1:07:33 Speaker 05 That's all I want in the world.
1:07:35 Speaker 04 Listen, there are a lot of people out there with conspiracy theories about who's winning the World Series because of the Chicago Pope. Like, there's a lot going on right now. It's good stuff. All right, we should take a break and then we should come back. We have like a lot of lightning round to do this week, so we're gonna give ourselves lots of time to lightning round. We'll be right back.
1:07:54 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Michelob Ultra. Good times mean competitions between you and your friends, like seeing who can throw some pigskin the farthest, or rush the field the fastest. Winner gets an Ultra. Because it's not just a superior light beer, it's also giving fans superior access to their favorite sporting events. Superior is worth playing for. Visit michelobultra.com/superioraccess to enter. Enjoy responsibly. Copyright 2026 Anheuser-Busch InBev Michelob Ultra Beer, St. Louis, Missouri.
1:08:23 Speaker 02 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out. In. Dashboard. Confessions.
1:08:33 Speaker 03 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
1:08:40 Speaker 02 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:08:53 Speaker 10 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Wanna make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
1:09:26 Speaker 04 All right, we're back. Time for the lightning round. The lightning round, just to be clear. Everybody's stopping emailing me about the thunder round. I get it. I've heard, I've heard all of your complaints. Tell them to chat GPT. Leave me alone.
1:09:38 Speaker 05 What are the complaints?
1:09:39 Speaker 04 I don't know. There's just some people who I think like Jake better than me is essentially what I'm reading from this. And that's fine. I also, I also fully understand that.
1:09:47 Speaker 05 He's very charming.
1:09:49 Speaker 04 He's, Jake's delightful. It's the lightning round. You and I have a bunch of things each that we're very excited to talk about. So we're going to try to go through this very quickly. Neil, I'm just going to guess. Is your first one, is it what I think it is?
1:10:00 Speaker 05 You know what it is.
1:10:00 Speaker 04 Okay, it's time once again for America's favorite podcast within a podcast. Brendan Carr is a dummy.
1:10:06 Speaker 05 He's such a dummy. He's such a dummy.
1:10:09 Speaker 04 How does he keep doing this? Every week I'm like, it can't possibly be time for Brendan Carr as a dummy.
1:10:14 Speaker 05 And I will say this week, he's a dummy in like classic dummy. You know, like.
1:10:21 Speaker 04 Playing the hits?
1:10:22 Speaker 05 I don't have to like tie you into metaphysical knots to explain why he's a dummy. This is just straightforward sort of like corruption. You know, like he's just doing a bad dumb thing that no one likes because he can't help himself.
1:10:38 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:10:39 Speaker 05 He's a dummy. He's like, what if I was even less popular? I'm Brendan Carr. So in the Biden administration, the FCC passed rules that said broadband providers had to put labels. They called them nutrition labels. They modeled, they modeled them after the labels on food. Just laying out how much things cost. Cause you know, if you've ever paid for mobile internet access or home internet access, you know that there's just like a litany of weird fees.
1:11:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:11:05 Speaker 05 And taxes just glommed onto your bill. And so they will advertise that it's 79.99 a month for a gig and you actually end up paying $150. It's like a universal experience.
1:11:17 Speaker 04 Cause there's like a sidewalk fee and you're like, what does that mean? And they're like, who's to say?
1:11:20 Speaker 05 Yeah. And then they'll blame the government no matter what. Like that's how they do it. So in the Biden administration, the former chair of the FCC under Biden, Jessica Rosenmiller, still led the charge. Where to put nutrition labels on broadband service. So when you go to buy broadband, there's going to be a standardized label that says how much it costs, what you get, what the maximum speed is, all the extra fees. You've probably seen one because you bought broadband recently, you have been forced to see a broadband label.
1:11:47 Speaker 05 It's hard to find fault with this idea. In the free market, consumers should know how much things cost. And then you can, even in a market as anti-competitive as broadband, where you have very few options, you'll at least be able to compare. Again, I don't know how you can find fault with this idea.
1:12:04 Speaker 04 This seems like, this not only seems fine, it seems like incredibly boring and uninteresting to talk about. This is just like, it's, it's fine.
1:12:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, and this is about as much as the Biden FCC was able to accomplish. Right, like for a variety of reasons, they were not able to accomplish much. They kept their heads down and they got to, we'll put labels on the prices. We're gonna put price tags on the products. That's what Joe Biden did not accomplish a lot in the broadband arena. He accomplished price tags.
1:12:32 Speaker 04 Great.
1:12:32 Speaker 05 Brendan Carr, our man, is like, you know what consumers hate is price tags. Passed a notice to propose remaking just this week, saying they're going away. We're getting, we're gutting the broadband labels. And his reasoning is that the service providers find them too onerous and complicated to figure out.
1:12:50 Speaker 04 It's too hard to write down a list of dollar figures?
1:12:53 Speaker 05 We can't possibly find all the fees that we might charge you. We can find them when we bill you for some reason. That's very easy to do. We have no problems with that. But telling you what they are beforehand, oh my God, the broadband, I mean, we just, the letters and the calls, I'm out in the field on the poles, the service workers, and they're complaining about these nutrition labels. And he really, like, he truly expects us to believe this.
1:13:15 Speaker 04 As if every Comcast employee, disclosure, you know, Comcast is, NBC Universal is a minority investor in Vox Media, they're a big fan of ours. As if every Comcast employee has to carry around like huge, like Moses on the mountaintop stone tablets with the nutrition label on it. It's like, this is just cruelty to employees.
1:13:38 Speaker 05 It's on the side of the Xfinity Vans.
1:13:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, exactly.
1:13:41 Speaker 05 No, it's just like on the website and he's like, it's too onerous. It's too complicated. We've heard all these complaints. No mention of the fact that when the broadband providers charge you money, it is not too complicated for them to find all of the taxes and fees that they tack on to your bill. There's not a broadband provider in the world that's ever been like, you know what? Our billing system is too complicated. We should simplify it for the benefit of the consumer. No, they're like, we can find all of the fees. You whispered at the wrong app on your phone. You're signed up for text killer. Like it'll just do it, but telling you beforehand, too onerous. So they, they, they passed this rule during the open commission meeting. The FCC is stacked with Republicans right now. That's the way it goes. The only dissent, Anna Gomez, the sole remaining Democratic Commissioner on FCC,
1:14:23 Speaker 05 who is, I would say, pretty fiery in what is usually a very boring, like government, open commission meeting. We have a clip, let's run it.
1:14:32 Speaker 12 This is one of the most anti-consumer proposals I have yet to see. The broadband labels are about empowering consumers. The goal of the label is to inform you, consumer at home, so that you know clearly what is included on your bill. And what adds insult to injury is that the FCC does not even explain why this proposal is necessary. Make it make sense. The more information is available to consumers, the less there is a need for regulation.
1:15:00 Speaker 04 Make it make sense feels like Anna Gomez's slogan right now.
1:15:04 Speaker 05 The, uh, the official notice of proposed rulemaking from Brendan Carr, uh, reads, "We believe that itemizing can lead to a proliferation of labels and of labels so lengthy that the fees overwhelm the other important elements of the label." So broadband providers have created so many fees to itemize that they've made the labels too complicated to read.
1:15:26 Speaker 05 Make it make sense.
1:15:27 Speaker 04 Listen, Brendan Carr, you're now obligated to go after CVS for having receipts that are too long? And then, then we can talk.
1:15:35 Speaker 05 He's a dummy, Brendan Carr. As always, Brendan, you're welcome to come on the show. The Google results for your name are polluted by my ranting at you, and I know it's true. And I know you read it. I know you look at it. So you're welcome. Anytime you want this show, the other show. If you want to just do a live stream on Twitch, mono-y mono. Let's go, buddy. Because I don't think you can defend this one. There's not a consumer in the world who thinks more opaque pricing is good. And somehow, you're such a dummy that you've convinced yourself that you've done everyone a favor. That's when Brendan Carr's a dummy, America's favorite podcast within a podcast.
1:16:10 Speaker 04 It's good to be back. For my first one, I'm going to, do you know how when you play beer pong, sometimes you bring in your friend to take a shot for you and just throw the ball in and see if they can do something cool? That's what I'm going to do with our producer Travis Larchuk, who is going to take one of my lightning round stories. Hi Travis.
1:16:27 Speaker 13 Hello.
1:16:28 Speaker 04 Travis, you were fired up this week, and I would like to know why.
1:16:30 Speaker 13 I was so fired up on Monday. This is the most important thing that happened on the internet to me and tens of other people. So do either of you play Connections, the New York Times puzzle?
1:16:43 Speaker 04 I probably play like five days a week, I would say. Not enough to have like a streak, but I play a lot.
1:16:48 Speaker 13 The setup of it, there's a four by four grid of words. The words, you need to put them into four separate categories. So you need to figure out like what the categories are and the groups of the four words that belong to them. So this was Monday's Connections puzzle. I'm going to share it with you. The first row, Only Connect Olive Branch. That is a secret message to a very specific subset of people who play New York Times Connections and are also fans of a British quiz show that premiered in 2008 and still runs today. And I just want to play you this first clip from the show and see if it sounds familiar to you.
1:17:34 Speaker 14 Time now for the connecting wall. 16 jumbled up clues that need sorting into four connected groups of four. There are red herrings. There are clues that might fit into more than one category, but there is only one correct solution.
1:17:46 Speaker 04 That's just a British person describing connections.
1:17:48 Speaker 13 So this, this has been a round of this British quiz show called Only Connect since 2008. 2008 has been essentially the same game that the New York Times
1:18:01 Speaker 13 Launched in in 2023 with no credit, no acknowledgement. And they they have have been very sure to say that this was developed independently. Meanwhile, the the day after it launched, the host of the show who we just heard from, Victoria Corin Mitchell, tweeted at the puzzle editor, do you know that this has been a TV show in the UK since 2008? It's so similar, I guess you must.
1:18:29 Speaker 13 So so I believe that what this message on Monday, this olive branch is responding to was that about a month ago on Only Connect, they finally acknowledged the existence of of connections on the show. And Victoria said this.
1:18:44 Speaker 15 Have you played Connections, the New York Times game? I mean, I must say, obviously, I would say this because it's just our format. Do you not find it annoyingly weak? Like, the connections don't really hold. I'm good at it now because I figured out where they cheat and what that'll do. Do you not find that frustrating? Yeah, definitely inferior. It is inferior.
1:19:09 Speaker 05 You can say any shit you want if you have a British accent.
1:19:11 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:19:13 Speaker 05 I believe for 100%.
1:19:16 Speaker 13 I reached out to the New York Times for comment. They have not responded to my email.
1:19:20 Speaker 05 I just love it that you can you can you can dunk on someone. They made our thing for stupid people, but if you have a British accent, you're like, it's inferior. And it's like, fine. No wonder these people had an empire. That's how I'm saying it.
1:19:35 Speaker 13 Anyway.
1:19:36 Speaker 05 It's very good. I love that for you, Travis.
1:19:37 Speaker 13 Thank you.
1:19:38 Speaker 04 Did you get? Did you get Connections that day?
1:19:41 Speaker 13 Oh, for sure.
1:19:42 Speaker 04 I did not, and it was very upsetting. And I assumed, so I I was first alerted to this because Travis posted something on Blue Sky like being mad at Connections. It turns out it was about this and that that the New York Times is finally tacitly acknowledging that it ripped off this this superior British game. I then went and just failed Connections because all of the connections were weak and stupid and didn't make any sense and raged to Travis, assuming that he had also failed Connections. But I guess he didn't.
1:20:12 Speaker 13 I've failed Connections one time and my stats are still 99% success rate.
1:20:19 Speaker 05 I just love that. I mean, that she's like, it's like our show, but it's stupider. And I had to make myself dumber to be good at it. It's such a thunderous dunk that came off so politely. It's very good.
1:20:30 Speaker 04 Yeah. And so the times only connect olive branch.
1:20:33 Speaker 05 Was that the connection?
1:20:34 Speaker 04 It was not. It should have been, but it was not.
1:20:38 Speaker 13 All right. That's all I have. Thank you for, thank you for hearing me out. Thank you.
1:20:41 Speaker 04 Thank you very much. All right, Neelai, what's your second one?
1:20:43 Speaker 05 I'm cursed to update the audience on the fact that AOL, my former employer, has been once again purchased.
1:20:51 Speaker 04 Yeah. Does it even count as your former, like, how many owners has AOL had since you worked there?
1:20:56 Speaker 05 It's, it's, I believe it's at least five. And that's counting all the, the random private equity groups. Verizon was one of them for a hot minute in an organization called Oath, you might recall. Very confusing.
1:21:11 Speaker 04 Oh, memory. That was the like AOL Yahoo combination, right?
1:21:15 Speaker 05 AOL Yahoo were combined by Verizon into a unit called Oath. Their strategy was that they were going to bundle AOL Yahoo Oath content onto mid-range Android phones. The plan that everyone has. Every, everyone goes through your, what if we just shove this shit onto mid-range Android phones? And that we're just doomed, you know? Another generation of wireless executives is going to grow up one day and they're going to have the same plan. And we're just doomed to see it. But AOL spun off from Oath with Yahoo. They went to another private equity company. Who knows what's going on? They were owned by Apollo Global Management as of 2021. And then Apollo has now sold it. AOL, not Yahoo. They've held on to Yahoo. Can't let go of Yahoo.
1:22:00 Speaker 05 They've sold AOL to Bending Spoons. The company which buys everything and ruins it. I don't know how else to describe Bending Spoons.
1:22:08 Speaker 04 Bending Spoons. Is the most confusing and fascinating. So Bending Spoons recently bought Evernote. It recently bought Vimeo. It bought WeTransfer. It now owns AOL. It apparently raised a bunch of debt to buy AOL, which seems like a real bold choice. It owns a bunch of other like brands that I would say out loud and you would go, oh, I haven't thought about that in a while. Like, that's who Bending Spoons buys.
1:22:32 Speaker 05 Right. It buys these things. It weighs off most of the employees and it raises prices and that's the strategy.
1:22:37 Speaker 04 It's a move.
1:22:37 Speaker 05 Great. And they claim, so Richard Lawler and I worked at Engadget together. There's a deep, meaningful bond between the two of us because we went through that experience together.
1:22:49 Speaker 05 And so we were reading the press release and we got to this line.
1:22:55 Speaker 05 Bending Spoons has never sold an acquired business and will continue to serve AOL's large loyal customer base for many years to come. And it's like, you guys, you're gonna sell AOL in like three years. Like, you don't, you don't like buy the cursed amulet and then like break the curse. Like, the amulet wins every time.
1:23:13 Speaker 04 I mean, somebody has to be the one to fully run it into the ground, right? Like, I actually, I read that as Bending Spoons being like, no, we're gonna kill it for good this time. It's gonna be, it's full dead by the time we're finished with it.
1:23:27 Speaker 05 God bless AOL, man. You know, we talked about Warner last week and, you know, buying Warner Brothers is also a cursed amulet that every media company apparently has to go through. AOL was the other side of that. They were the, they're the original zombie owner of Time Warner.
1:23:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's right.
1:23:44 Speaker 05 And it just hasn't been great since that happened. Good luck. By the way, the CEO, but the CEO of Bending Spoons is named Luca Ferrari, which is objectively the best name in history.
1:23:55 Speaker 05 Good luck, Luca.
1:23:55 Speaker 04 That's a real person's name?
1:23:57 Speaker 05 CEO of Bending Spoons, Luca Ferrari.
1:23:58 Speaker 04 Never mind, I'm in. AOL's gonna be a huge success. This is gonna go super great. I love this for everybody.
1:24:04 Speaker 05 It's just a lot, man.
1:24:08 Speaker 04 Can I interest you in a Trump phone update?
1:24:10 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:24:11 Speaker 04 I don't have one for you.
1:24:11 Speaker 05 Can you interest me?
1:24:12 Speaker 04 No, I don't.
1:24:12 Speaker 05 Please, I've been in the market for several years.
1:24:15 Speaker 04 So the, it is now, as you're listening to this or watching it, it is the last day of October.
1:24:22 Speaker 04 The Trump phone does not exist. Trump Mobile first launched in June with big promises about service launching and then a phone, the T1 phone, which we had a lot of questions about at the time because all it appeared to be was a bad, ugly render of a gold phone with camera lenses that were weirdly spaced. And it was supposed to be coming in September. September comes and goes, and between June and September, the only thing that happens is all mentions of September were just removed from the website. It was like, it was like later this year. It still says later this year. What phone the Trump phone is has changed. Now you can get several other Trump phones, including a refurbished iPhone 14 or 15.
1:25:05 Speaker 05 Sure.
1:25:06 Speaker 04 Which the Trump Mobile folks will happily tell you is brought to life right here in the USA.
1:25:13 Speaker 05 Oh, I see. So if you refurbish a two-year-old phone that was originally made in China, it's now made in the United States.
1:25:17 Speaker 04 I like to think of it as like they, they fished it out of a lake and just like dried it off with a hairdryer, put it in some rice and it came back to life. And they're like, we did it right here in the USA. Only $629. But yeah, so it is, it is now the end of October, which means we are now a full month late on the Trump phone and there has been just absolutely no sign of the thing.
1:25:41 Speaker 05 The second Trump administration is full of a lot of bombastic promises that don't come to anything. There's a ceasefire in the Middle East. Did you know that?
1:25:49 Speaker 05 It's a lot of that. No one learned from doing this the first time that this is how it goes. Like, we covered Foxconn every day because he said there was going to be an LCD factory in my hometown. And they, it just never was going to happen. And we were like, it's not happening. And we did it every day. If Veritas listeners will remember, he announced randomly at the beginning of COVID that Google was going to build a website to let people find testing.
1:26:16 Speaker 04 I think he said thousands of engineers were working on it.
1:26:19 Speaker 05 Yeah. Google did not know that they were doing this until Donald Trump announced. And then we tracked it every single week, like it just didn't occur. And we're doing it again at scale with him. And the Trump phone is like a little example of this or bigger ones. The Trump phone is particularly like I ended up on CNBC the day the Trump phone was announced.
1:26:38 Speaker 04 It was a big deal.
1:26:39 Speaker 05 Whether or not phone manufacturing could return to the United States. And I was just like, guys, what are you talking about? It can't and it won't. And there was like, you know, some conversation about whether I was to, but like here we are. And we're refurbishing the iPhone 14 here in the good old US of A. And it's like, yeah, you can just hold them to their promises. You can just say, did you make a phone? And so now every week, David, I believe we're going to just ask the question. Does the Trump phone exist? Because it is as clear of an example of what the Trump administration, both the first one and this one are like.
1:27:14 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:27:14 Speaker 05 They just say stuff.
1:27:15 Speaker 04 Yep. Dominic Preston on our team and I have both willingly signed up to send the same email. Basically every seven days to an email address that I'm confident no one checks. That's basically just like, huh? Do we have a, is there a, is there a phone? I do know a lot of people pre-ordered the phone. Well, I know some people, at least one person pre-ordered the phone. Many of those people presumably as a bit. But Trump mobile took their money. Like it's, it's not like this is a fake website. Like people have paid money for this thing. And so despite all of the deep insanity of it, like they owe people a product.
1:27:57 Speaker 04 They owe the world a product and a poorly refurbished old iPhone. A doesn't count and B also doesn't exist right now. Like you can't buy anything from Trump mobile. And this thing, we're going to keep tracking it. And we continue to get a mix of silence and no comments. And I will be bringing those to you once a week, presumably until it kills me.
1:28:21 Speaker 05 It is very funny that you have your own Fox condo here in Trump, too, David.
1:28:27 Speaker 04 I'm excited about it. I, uh, it's, it's very rare that I am perfectly willing to call my shot on something being bullshit four minutes after it's announced. But I did that on our website and I am, uh, very much enjoying how correct I have been in this whole thing. Nothing would make me happier than for me to be proven wrong on this. Like as a, as a, as a journalist, as a tech enthusiast, as somebody who has reviewed many smartphones in the past, I want nothing more than to hold the Trump T1 phone in my hand and try to figure out what the hell it is and if it's any good. It existing is so much more fun than it not existing, but it doesn't exist. And so here we are.
1:29:07 Speaker 05 Yeah. Um, okay. I've got, I've got one more. I was gonna do the wonky metadata story that Jess wrote about C2PA and Sora, but the answer is that Meta doesn't care to tell you whether or not anything is AI. And I think we've run that to ground here on this episode of the Verge.
1:29:21 Speaker 04 There are lots of standards. No one is interested in any of them.
1:29:23 Speaker 05 Yeah. Meta doesn't want to tell you it's AI. They want to feed you slop until you die.
1:29:27 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:29:27 Speaker 05 Mark Zuckerberg experience. So I'm just gonna read this headline from Andy Hawkins. Congratulations to the Tesla Cybertruck on its 10th recall in two years.
1:29:38 Speaker 04 That's a really good headline. I will say, we, we have a lot of debates at The Verge about headlines and I don't think we always write the best headline. That's a great headline.
1:29:46 Speaker 05 It's very good.
1:29:47 Speaker 04 Great job, Andy Hawkins.
1:29:48 Speaker 05 Uh, it's, you know, it's, uh, this one is just for the light bar that can detach while driving, which doesn't seem great. Uh, I will note that some of them have been for the wiper, the, the singular engineering achievement of the Cybertruck. Uh, but oh man, what a disaster that thing has been. Uh, I know, I know some Cybertruck owners, they love it. Again, I will point you to, uh, Verge expat Zoe Schiffer's article in Wired recently, just interviewing Cybertruck owners, one of whom was a convicted Gen 6 guy.
1:30:20 Speaker 04 Oh, cool.
1:30:21 Speaker 05 Choice. All of its choice. And another one who's like, yeah, the, the, the card does not attract women. Like just straightforwardly said it to a Wired reporter. It's very good.
1:30:30 Speaker 04 What, what was the recall this time?
1:30:32 Speaker 05 Uh, it's the, the light bar. The off-road light bar can detach while driving.
1:30:37 Speaker 04 Seems bad.
1:30:37 Speaker 05 If you're behind a Cybertruck, just be careful. Cause either the wiper or the light bar might be flying at you.
1:30:46 Speaker 04 Congratulations, Tesla.
1:30:49 Speaker 04 All right, I'm gonna, I'm gonna do two in very rapid succession.
1:30:52 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:30:53 Speaker 04 One is I am going to say a nice thing about Mark Zuckerberg, which is that Threads rolled out ghost posts,
1:31:01 Speaker 05 which are- Oh, they're great.
1:31:02 Speaker 04 24-hour expiring posts on Threads. I think it's fabulous, like such a good idea. I have been a long-term believer that all social media posts should expire by default. I think like the world would be a better place if we were not all held to everything we've ever posted on social media in all of our lives. And this, it looks a little weird because it has like a sort of dotted-
1:31:28 Speaker 05 I know, I love the way it looks. It looks like you're whispering onto the platform.
1:31:31 Speaker 04 Oh, I like that. Okay. Thinking about it that way, I'm okay with it.
1:31:33 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:31:34 Speaker 04 It just, it stands out in a way that threw me a little bit, but I'm okay with that way of thinking about it. But this idea of like an expiring 24-hour post that if somebody replies to it or likes it, it goes to your DMs. Is such a like small twist on the way that we communicate on social media that I love.
1:31:54 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:31:55 Speaker 04 And I think like the, this idea that actually if I'm gonna post something and if you want to engage with it, we are going to engage with it, just the two of us, not in public in front of everybody, is actually such a healthier way to think about social media. And I think this is one of the reasons that Stories has been so successful on other platforms is that it's not, I'm doing a thing in public, but we're not doing the whole thing in public forever. And the fact that like the actual engagement and interaction is just between us and not for everyone to see is better. And we've just never put that in text posts before. And I think it's a great idea and I like, I hope every other text platform gets something like this soon. Like, I love it.
1:32:35 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's very good. Threads secretly has been his best product. It's huge. No one gives it any credit for being huge because it's not where stuff goes down.
1:32:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:32:44 Speaker 05 Like, no drama goes down on Threads. It all goes down on X or it all goes down on Blue Sky. Lots of drama goes on Blue Sky.
1:32:51 Speaker 04 But Blue Sky's drama is so like specific and exhausting. I mean, so is X is like, you sort of know exactly the fight you're getting into in both of those places. I find Threads to be handily the most pleasant social-
1:33:03 Speaker 05 Yeah, because it's a meta-product and it's designed to keep you engaged forever.
1:33:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's very milquetoast in a way that I think is like, fine.
1:33:09 Speaker 05 But it is huge. Like, it is huge. Like, yeah, they, I, I think like they're onboarding one blue sky like every hour or something. Like, it's like, it's just this massive platform that's taking advantage of the Instagram graph. If you open Instagram, there are threads posted in Instagram now and it kicks you to threads to look at them. Um, and then they have all these products that they use, which are just great.
1:33:29 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:33:30 Speaker 05 And so it, it has in Instagram, like from Adam and Siri on down, they know that the action on Instagram happens in DMs.
1:33:37 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
1:33:37 Speaker 05 So you can see that they're like, how do we get people on threads to slide to DMs and like ghost posts is just a great way to do it.
1:33:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think it's, I think it's working. Like the, the clear goal of threads was to copy that thing that was like the sort of default public chat space on the internet from what Twitter used to be. And I think it is like, it is rapidly heading in that direction. Um, I should have ended on that note because that's a happy note. Now I'm going to end on a just sheer rage, uh, which is, um, we, we talked about Samsung fridges getting ads. Um, and now we know what they look like. Can I show them to you? Do you want to see what the ads coming?
1:34:14 Speaker 05 And I will describe them to the, the radio audience.
1:34:17 Speaker 04 I assume you have many fridges with screens.
1:34:19 Speaker 05 I won't, I won't have screens on a fridge, man. We're not doing that. No, thank you.
1:34:23 Speaker 04 That's where you draw the line.
1:34:24 Speaker 05 No, I, uh, I don't, I hate and fear computers. I don't know if you've met me.
1:34:31 Speaker 04 Uh, all right. So I just put a picture in our, in our, in our chat here. Tell me what you see.
1:34:36 Speaker 05 I, I see an ad on the bottom of a slow Tyson screen for water filters. I mean, the reason I won't have, every computer gets slow and I, as, as many of Rich Castle listeners know, one of my mottos, in addition to, I don't give a fuck about your stock price, is that life's too short for slow computers. So if you're going to put something in my kitchen that's hard to get rid of, like a refrigerator, and then eventually I know that it will be a slow computer that is just out of bounds. No, thank you. I'd rather just like command strip an iPad to that thing.
1:35:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:35:04 Speaker 05 And the idea that they're going to junk it up with targeted advertising is horrible. And that is a big ad. That is not a small ad. It's like the bottom, uh, it's not quite a third. It's like the bottom fifth of the screen is ad.
1:35:17 Speaker 04 But it's like a big beige screen. Like if you're, if you imagine a refrigerator with two doors, the whole right door is a screen and the bottom strip of it is just an ad. And so that's one version of it. This is called the cover screen, which the fact that you have a cover screen on your fridge is just deeply hilarious. So they call this a widget and it's actually a rotating thing. And the ad is one of four things in the rotation. So there's one that's news, one that I think is your calendar, one that's the weather. And then one that is, they call it curated advertisements, which is just what advertisements are. And it rotates every 10 seconds. So every 40 seconds, this ad is just going to pop up on your screen. And you can remove the widget.
1:35:59 Speaker 04 So you can PSA, go into settings and then advertisements and then toggle the advertisements off. But it also kills the whole widget, which is very funny. So you either get the good stuff and the bad stuff or you get nothing.
1:36:10 Speaker 05 Does that count as a dark pattern or is that just like a hostage situation?
1:36:14 Speaker 04 Uh, yes.
1:36:15 Speaker 05 You can, it's not like quite, they're not tricking you. They're just like, do you want this to be useful or not? Cause then you have to have the ads.
1:36:21 Speaker 04 But then there's another way to get these that I think is even more offensive, which is this one here. It's called the daily board and it has six tiles. And it's basically, one of the things these fridges are supposed to do is be like a hub of your house. Right? They show you what's going on, where people are, you can do timers. So it's supposed to be the sort of family central. And I think that's what this screen is supposed to do. So it has six square widgets, basically one is a timer, one is the weather, one is your calendar. One is a memo that just says pizza day exclamation point in this ad. One says my house, which is presumably some like smart home controls and one is an ad. And it just, it's just a big ass ad for a water filter.
1:37:05 Speaker 04 And these are, these are your options. And again, if you, if you want to not see ads, you don't get. Any of the other stuff either. So like it's, it is a dark pattern in that sense. It's like, if you want the good stuff, you have to get the ads for this incredibly expensive refrigerator that you've already bought.
1:37:21 Speaker 05 In my mind, this should inspire as much outcry as when BMW tried to put heated seats behind a subscription.
1:37:27 Speaker 04 I agree.
1:37:28 Speaker 05 I will say that my fridge has a screen is one of the most bougie problems in the world. So maybe it won't.
1:37:34 Speaker 04 But I do think this, the advertising bait and switch that is happening in a lot of people's houses is worth being mad at and people are mad. Like the, the thing that has happened with Alexa devices in recent weeks, where they've started just putting ads on the sort of standby screen of people's Echo shows all over their house after not having them. So it's like, I bought this thing. I installed it prominently somewhere in my house. And then oops, one day ads is so outrageous to me. That it's like, if they wanted to start saying, if everyone that is sold from today on will start to have ads and there's nothing you can do about it, they just have ads. Fine. Like at least now you're letting people make a eyes wide open decision. Or like what you see Amazon do a lot where they're like, you can buy the cheaper one with ads
1:38:19 Speaker 04 or you can pay more money and have no ads. I'm actually fine with all of those trade offs, but to install a refrigerator, which is like, I'm, I'm moving house and we are taking everything that we own, but we're leaving our refrigerator because who like, it, that's not an easy thing to remove from your home. It is, it is a like crucial appliance to your life. And Samsung knows that and it knows it essentially has you and can do whatever it wants because what are you going to do about it? And that feels gross.
1:38:46 Speaker 05 If you are the sort of person who thought to yourself, I should put a giant Tizen screen on an appliance that is essentially immovable in my home, to let us know. Cause I've been dying to know why people have these things. I'm, I'm a huge nerd who can't stop making the home smart and it has never occurred to me to have one of these screens.
1:39:04 Speaker 04 Yeah. You can see inside your fridge without opening the fridge.
1:39:07 Speaker 05 I can do that with my LG fridge. It has a window. You just knock on it twice and it lights up and you can just see through the door. It's great.
1:39:13 Speaker 04 But that's, that's less exciting. What if I can do it from my phone?
1:39:16 Speaker 05 My LG fridge does have wifi for no reason. Every now and again, it tells me the ice is old and I'm like, screw you. Ice doesn't get old.
1:39:23 Speaker 04 The ice is old, sounds like a like a code word that you would say to the president when something terrible has happened.
1:39:30 Speaker 05 You haven't used all the ice in seven days. I've used enough ice. Shut your mouth. That's it's not a useful app in any in any sense of word. Jen Tuohy reported on the the ads on a Tyson screen. This is Samsung's official explanation. The pilot further explores how a connected appliance can deliver genuinely useful contextual information. The refrigerators are at a daily hub and we're testing a responsible user control way to make that space more helpful. Ads do not make things more helpful.
1:39:59 Speaker 04 Nope.
1:40:00 Speaker 05 It's just straightforwardly, they don't make things more helpful, especially when the ad is the water filter in your refrigerator is going bad and we want you to buy a new one from us. It's just not helpful. Like, I don't know what they're doing. Like, that's a bad explanation. The other thing that's very funny about this Jen piece is that Samsung doesn't know what its own products are called. So in announcing this pilot, they said it won't, it will come to these screens, but not AI home screens. And so technically, the fridge is not an AI home screen because only the nine and seven inch screens are AI home screens. And then Jen has this line, and Jen's been on the show a lot. I'm sure you're familiar. She's very dry, very British. And she goes, I've asked numerous Samsung folks about the distinction here and no one has a straight answer.
1:40:46 Speaker 04 I would say she comes to the same conclusion I do, which is that it's safe to say there will eventually be ads everywhere and this distinction will be meaningless.
1:40:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, but it's just very funny. I can just imagine Jen being like, do you know what an AI home screen is? And like 10 different Samsung people are like, we don't.
1:41:00 Speaker 05 We just, we just started calling some stuff that.
1:41:03 Speaker 05 It's great.
1:41:03 Speaker 04 Somewhere someone at Telly is like, okay, we're gonna do a free fridge with a screen full of advertisements. We're gonna, we're gonna crush. And they will, and I will buy it.
1:41:14 Speaker 05 I'm just saying, as much outcry as BMW saying heated seats, which to this day, every car or company executive I talk to, whether they work at BMW or not, like burned, completely burned by what happened with BMW and heated seats subscriptions.
1:41:28 Speaker 04 They are in the best way. Like, that's a good thing.
1:41:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, they're not gonna do it.
1:41:31 Speaker 04 That is a cautionary tale inside of the car industry that is such a giant win for consumers as a result.
1:41:37 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:41:38 Speaker 04 Like, keep being mad.
1:41:41 Speaker 04 That's the story of the first.
1:41:41 Speaker 05 I will not buy your water filters and this ice never gets old. It's just water that's cold.
1:41:46 Speaker 04 Exactly. All right, we should get out of here. We've gone way over, as we are wanting to do. It's nice to be back. We just like you and I have not gotten to do this this much in like several months. It's fun to do this again.
1:41:55 Speaker 05 It's great.
1:41:56 Speaker 04 Glad to be back with you. All right, we are out of here. This Sunday, we have you and I on an episode of Version History about the Microsoft Zune.
1:42:06 Speaker 05 I'm very excited.
1:42:07 Speaker 04 I think if if memory serves, this was the first episode of Version History that we made. So if you if you watch it or listen to it and you're like, gosh, why is this so bizarre and chaotic? And everyone's all over the place. It was completely deliberate. Don't worry about it. Everything's fine. And then on Tuesday, actually, Jen is coming back on. We're going to do a big mega hotline of smart home questions. We're doing a two episode thing with Jen over the next two Tuesdays, all about smart home stuff. It's gonna be very fun. In the meantime, remember to subscribe to The Verge. You can get this podcast and Decoder and Version History all ad free. Go find Decoder on YouTube. All of our stuff is increasingly everywhere. Our goal is to make Neelai ubiquitous. In your everywhere you go, you should see Neelai's face. This is what we're doing here. I'm very excited about it.
1:42:51 Speaker 05 It's fine.
1:42:53 Speaker 04 And if you have questions, email us, [email protected] . Call the hotline 866-VERGE11. Tell us who should be on the panel. This is if you take nothing away from this, tell us who should be on the AGI Expert Panel. Simon Cowell is my nominee and you have to beat that to get on this panel.
1:43:10 Speaker 05 I was gonna say Jennifer Lopez.
1:43:12 Speaker 04 Also, pretty good. Honestly, anybody if who has been through the American Idol school.
1:43:17 Speaker 05 That's what I'm saying.
1:43:17 Speaker 04 Is ready for this. I think I think I believe in them. The voice less so. American Idol is the training I'm looking for.
1:43:24 Speaker 04 All right, The Vergecast is a Verge production and part of Vox Media Podcast Network. The show is produced by Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer and Travis Larchuk. We will be back with so much stuff next week. We'll see you then. Neelai.
1:43:34 Speaker 05 Rock and roll.
1:43:38 Speaker 16 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
1:44:07 Speaker 17 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher, featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Offer valid through October 21st. U.S. only. Search online for details.
1:44:38 Speaker 18 Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes. A 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from DoorDash, and Best Buy. Pill and play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag.
1:44:56 Speaker 05 No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. age 18 plus. See playatmcd.com for rules and playatmcd.com slash A M O E for info and playing without purchase by mail by November 2nd. Chances card game ends November 8th. Game ends November 22nd, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro.
Previous An Apple Shortcuts masterclass Next Version History: Zune Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated