Pod Insights The Vergecast Brendan Carr is a dummy About this episode Åhead of our last Friday episode of 2025, FCC Chairman Brendan Carr did The Vergecast an enormous favor: he went in front of Congress and said a bunch of wild things about regulation. So, of course, Nilay and David have to talk about them. For a really long time. After that, the hosts look at all the ways YouTube and Netflix are becoming more like one another, and then update the Go90 Scale of Doomed Streaming Services to round out the year. Finally, in the lightning round, there's talk of web apps, EVs, Bluesky, and the metaverse.
Further reading:
The Vergecast live at CES
Brendan Carr doesn’t regret his threats to broadcasters
Former FCC Chairman Michael Powell: ‘Cable companies are at the mercy of content companies’
The Oscars will stream on YouTube in 2029
Netflix’s next big TV game is FIFA soccer
My Favorite Murder and The Breakfast Club podcasts are ditching YouTube for Netflix
Warner Bros. wants its shareholders to reject Paramount’s latest offer
Netflix is “100% committed” to releasing WB films in theaters.
Even Jared Kushner thinks the Paramount WB bid sucks.
Peacock will bombard you with ads as soon as you open the app
HBO Max’s new channels keep Friends and Game of Thrones playing 24/7
Instagram is putting Reels on your TV
LG forced a Copilot web app onto its TVs but will let you delete it
Mercedes-Benz discontinues feature that syncs music to driving
Ford’s big bet on EVs didn’t pan out — now it’s pivoting to hybrids and energy storage
Bluesky claims its new contact import feature is ‘privacy-first’
Gemini 3 Flash is here, bringing a ‘huge’ upgrade to the Gemini app
The ChatGPT app store is here
Alexa Plus’ website is live for some users
Meta pauses third-party Horizon VR headsets program
Subscribe to The Verge for unlimited access to theverge.com, subscriber-exclusive newsletters, and our ad-free podcast feed. We love hearing from you! Email your questions and thoughts to [email protected] or call us at 866-VERGE11.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 25,599 words · 14 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:05 Speaker 03 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
1:37 Speaker 04 Welcome to Vergecast, the flagship podcast of the Senate Commerce Committee. This is, we're just...
1:42 Speaker 05 That sucks so bad.
1:44 Speaker 04 You and I are going to sit here on the dais and we're going to yell at each other for three hours.
1:48 Speaker 05 Can I just tell a story? When I was a baby and I worked at AOL.
1:52 Speaker 04 I'm David Pierce, he's Neil Appertel.
1:54 Speaker 05 What's up? Let me tell you a story for my youth. So I'm a little baby. I'm like, I don't know, I'm 25, 26. I work at AOL for Engadget. And I'm covering like the early innings of net neutrality and like mobile broadband and I get the bright idea that I should testify in front of Congress.
2:13 Speaker 04 This becomes like a life goal.
2:15 Speaker 05 I was drinking a lot of the time. I was full of, full of extreme confidence. And I was like, these dummies, they need to hear from like the consumers on the ground. Like I will channel the Engadget commenter base and tell Congress what's up.
2:31 Speaker 05 Actually, now that I say that, that would have been sick. I should still do this.
2:34 Speaker 04 That would have been.
2:34 Speaker 05 So I'm like, how do I do this? And I was like, well, I work for AOL. So I get a meeting like AOL's general counsel and I'm like, I want to testify in front of Congress. And legitimately, they were like, about what? And I was like, internet access. And they're like, you know, we run dial up internet. Like, no, absolutely not. And like, we went back and forth and at the very end, they're like, what specifically is your ask? You have to ask me for something. And I was like, put me in front of Congress. And they were like, that is not an ask. No. Sent me out of the room.
3:07 Speaker 04 I love the theory that you can just like apply to speak in foot. Like Congress has office hours and then like once a week you can just go.
3:13 Speaker 05 I was like, this would be great publicity for us. And he's like, you're going to tank our dial up business that we don't want anyone to pay attention to.
3:19 Speaker 04 It's like Shark Tank, but Congress.
3:23 Speaker 05 It was a good idea then. You know, now that I've said it out loud, it would be a good idea now.
3:27 Speaker 04 It's pretty good. Um, all right. We have a lot to get to today. We have, I think, the, the surprise that will not be a surprise to anyone who has ever listened to this podcast before. First, one very quick piece of housekeeping. A lot of people have been asking, so I should tell you that we are in fact doing a live Vergecast at CES. Neel, it's going to be you and me. We're going to be on stage. We're going to have a blast. It is going to be 3:30 PM in Vegas at the Brooklyn Bowl, which is like not on the strip, but it's a cool place near the strip.
3:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's great.
3:55 Speaker 04 You'll figure it out.
3:56 Speaker 05 You want to, you want to get away from the vibes of the strip and come to where we are. It was great last year. It was so much fun last year.
4:01 Speaker 04 It was really fun. And, uh, we're, we're, we're, we have a link. You can RSVP. You can come. And if you're a Verge subscriber, um, I have on good authority that you're going to get to go bowling with us after.
4:12 Speaker 05 David keeps making this promise, and I think he's just trying to make it true.
4:15 Speaker 04 I it's in it's in the invite.
4:17 Speaker 05 David, you can just say stuff Pierce.
4:20 Speaker 04 This is what I'm here for. I am just speaking 2026 David speaks all of his desires into existence. This is what we're doing here. There have been pitches for what if we bowl during the show? And I think a series of people have made clear that that's not a good idea. So anyway, Wednesday, January 7th, 3:30 Brooklyn Bowl. If you're gonna be in Vegas, come hang out. We would love to see you. All the infos in the show notes, we finally have a page for it. So come hang out. If you have questions, you know how to find us.
4:48 Speaker 04 Neelai, this is the last Vergecast you and I are doing together in 2025. We're gonna disappear into the holidays for a while. We have the spectacular coming next week, but we've already recorded that. So that's done. This is the last time you and I are gonna make a podcast together for a couple of weeks.
5:02 Speaker 05 I have a number of notes for you. It's time for your performance conversation.
5:05 Speaker 04 Someone that we talk about a lot on this show did us an enormous favor.
5:09 Speaker 05 Oh, no.
5:10 Speaker 04 Because this this you could call the season finale of the Vergecast, which means it is the season finale of America's favorite podcast within a podcast. Brendan Carr is a dummy and Brendan Carr, for us, went in front of the Senate Commerce Committee and said a bunch of insane things. The people have demanded that we talk about this. They have demanded that we talk about this. So we need to talk about it. So it is, my friends, once again, time for Brendan Carr's dummy. Neelai.
5:37 Speaker 05 Oh, boy.
5:38 Speaker 04 Welcome, my friend.
5:39 Speaker 05 He was a real dummy this week. He was an explosion of Brendan being stupid this week.
5:44 Speaker 04 For three hours in a row. Yeah.
5:46 Speaker 05 Can I can I just preface this?
5:50 Speaker 05 Can I just try to lay a foundation here?
5:52 Speaker 04 Sure.
5:52 Speaker 05 For all of the names I'm about to call Brendan Carr.
5:57 Speaker 05 By the way, you know, you know, it's hot when we get more emails about Brendan Carr than party speakers in a week. We get a lot of emails about party speakers.
6:04 Speaker 04 There's one particular clip that we're gonna get to in a minute that that a bunch of people sent us. And they were like, this is this is perfectly packaged for David and Eli and the Vergecast. And it is like, it's one of those moments where it's like, well, we've we've built something here. If you understand this as Vergecast fodder, we have accomplished something.
6:20 Speaker 05 Look, if I have a criticism of the Democrats as a whole, it's that they have no idea about how to create or shape public opinion. And I'm telling you, it's just repetition. And if you just say a person's a dummy every week for a year, you're like, oh, that guy's a dummy. You can just do it. Anyhow, um, let me lay the foundation because I'm going to call them a lot of names. And I think, you know, people have whatever feelings about my politics or the virtues politics that they want to have. But I'm going to point everyone before we begin to an interview I did in 2012. 13 years ago with Michael Powell, who was at the time the head of Nikta, which is the big cable television lobby. And before that was the Republican chairman of the FCC.
7:02 Speaker 05 Michael Powell, it's Colin Powell's son. His name might as well be Steve Republican. And, you know, 13 years ago, I had a lot of ideas with the internet and a lot of ideas about how, you know, cord cutting would take over and everything should be streaming and Apple should make a TV. And like, we talked about all this stuff in this interview. And I'm reading it again today, and I'm going to tell you that 13 years ago, the former Republican head of the FCC and the, at the time, head of the Cable Industry Lobbying Association was right about everything. Like dead on accurate about how everything would play out and what would happen for consumers. And the point that he made to me over and over again, which I disagreed with him at the time. And you can read that interview and you can see us go back and forth on this.
7:46 Speaker 05 The point he kept making to me was that regulating broadcast television differently than regulating cable and internet was stupid and causing problems in the markets for consumers. I'll just read you this quote. This is from Michael Powell to me in 2012. "There are entirely different regulatory benefits and burdens applied to distribution that are meaningless to the consumer. Under the law today, a cable company is required to let broadcasters onto their platform, not because the market says so, not because you want to buy it, but because the government says that's what has to be in the dial. The government says I'm not allowed to sell you subscription tiers until I provide you the basic tiers. My criticism from a consumer perspective is why is the government placing so much regulatory emphasis on one kind of distribution to the detriment of another?"
8:30 Speaker 05 And that's wonky. I understand it's wonky, but what he was saying that entire time was you're all watching the internet anyway. Right. Treating the broadcasters differently than Netflix or HBO Max or whatever is stupid, and we should stop it.
8:45 Speaker 04 And his point was that the user experience of those things is so functionally and fundamentally the same that treating them differently is a total waste of time and energy.
8:54 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's fundamentally the same and it's meaningless for it to be different to the user. And this is a fundamentally conservative thing to say because what he was arguing to me was we should deregulate this, right? We should deregulate it and let the market pick what they want to pay for and that will be fine. And at the very end of this, he goes, the à la carte model where you just pick your services is deceptively attractive until you do math. He said, you've done a good job writing about this. I read your piece about the Apple TV, which after my own heart, good politician. And he said, unless you're really disciplined in what you subscribe for, I will get you to your capable and beyond really fast. That's the prices of benefit from the cable subsidy.
9:28 Speaker 04 He's right about that, too.
9:29 Speaker 05 He was right. And I want to start here because I'm going to call Brendan a lot of names. But 13 years ago, the Republican chairman of the FCC had a conversation with me, and I'm just telling you right now, he was more right than wrong about the fact that we treat broadcasts differently and regulate it differently than cable and internet distorted the market. And he was absolutely right that unbundling and going to streaming would lead to prices that were higher than cable in the end. And his argument was we should deregulate broadcast, let it compete fairly with cable. And if people pick cable over broadcast, that's fine. We'll do something else about those airways. I'm saying all of this because we're going to go through Brendan's testimony in front of Congress
10:11 Speaker 05 today, 13 years later in 2025. And all of his argument sums up to, I have the power to treat broadcasts differently and I am going to use it. And I, first of all, you can just see, that's not what Michael Powell, Colin Powell's son, the Republican chair of the FCC and the head of the cable lobby, that's not what he was saying 13 years ago. So this is a massive sea change in Republican policymaking and conservative policymaking towards regulation and control of speech. It is also so stupid.
10:48 Speaker 04 Yeah, so, okay, let's get into some of the stupid here. So, the setup is this. It's the Senate Commerce Committee. They brought all three FCC commissioners, Brendan Carr, Olivia Trustee, and Anna Gomez, and sat them down and asked them questions. I think they mostly were there, pretty clearly, to talk to Brendan Carr. But everybody would also throw a question at the other commissioner that they, who was on the same side as them politically, just to sort of score points, which is a thing that I always enjoyed. They would, like, ask Brendan Carr a question. Brendan would say something insane, and then they'd be like, "Anna Gomez, what do you think?" And she'd be like, "That's insane." And this is, like, the whole tenet of this.
11:23 Speaker 05 There's a reason we're not gonna run a lot of clips. And it's because all the clips are kind of, like, long and, like, theatrical and whatever.
11:28 Speaker 04 And, like, so many hearings that a lot of it is just politicians not even pretending to ask a question, but just sort of grandstanding in front of him for three minutes and then relinquishing their time. But, anyway, the topics that came up were kind of what you'd expect. It was a lot of Jimmy Kimmel. It was a lot of stuff about rural broadband. It was a lot of stuff about 6G, which really bummed me out. Some questions about satellite, internet, some, a lot of stuff about spectrum allocation, just sort of the things you would talk to the FCC about. But I think if you had to pick a theme for this, it was Jimmy Kimmel. Like, Jimmy Kimmel's name came up over and over and over again. And so, the very brief backstory here is that Jimmy Kimmel went on his show after Charlie Kirk was killed
12:12 Speaker 04 and said, uh, let me just quote this. He said, "The MAGA gang was desperately trying to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them." This became a whole thing. Brendan Carr comes out and says, um, essentially, Disney should get rid of, should get rid of Jimmy Kimmel, and they should stop airing his show. "We can either do this the easy way or the hard way." It's what he said, I believe, on Benny Johnson's podcast. Still the weirdest fact of all of this to me. This becomes, like, the undercurrent of this whole thing, right? Am I overstating the extent to which this was kind of a hearing about Jimmy Kimmel?
12:46 Speaker 05 No, you're not at all. I mean, they came back to it over and over again. I think, um, you know, Carl Bodie, who is a friend of The Verge, has written for us many times. He pointed out, there's a bunch of other stuff they could have asked him. They could have asked him about totally dismantling all consumer protection in broadband. And they just did.
13:01 Speaker 04 Which, like, one person did.
13:03 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:03 Speaker 04 And they moved on.
13:04 Speaker 05 And that stuff, I think, just doesn't grab the attention. These hearings are, you know, performances for TikTok more than anything these days. And so asking the questions about Kimmel and doing the back and forth gotcha stuff. All of that is made for social media now. And why do you dismantle consumer protection? It just isn't going to get the views. You can talk about Taylor Swift, or you can talk about censoring Jimmy Kimmel, and that's what gets you the views. And I think you can see that in our own content strategy.
13:28 Speaker 04 Yeah. So the way we're going to do this is, um, do you remember the, the Keegan-Michael Key's like Obama anger translator thing? Where Obama would say something and, and Keegan-Michael Key would like, explain what he was really trying to say. We're going to do that in reverse, and I'm going to make you do something impossible, which is make sense out of words that come out of Brendan Carr's mouth.
13:50 Speaker 05 This is not the thesis of the show.
13:53 Speaker 05 America's favorite broadcaster and podcast is not, here's why Brendan made sense.
13:58 Speaker 04 Listen.
13:59 Speaker 05 What are you doing to me now?
14:00 Speaker 04 Uh, this is, this is the season finale. This is a bottle episode, you know what I mean? But, but first, I think there are, there are two useful things to understand as we get into some of the specifics here. One is what you just said, which is this idea that Brendan Carr gets to regulate broadcast differently from anything else because it is broadcast television. That's a fact that comes up over and over. We're going to get into that more, but that is one thing that is very important. The other is that Brendan Carr believes himself to be a stooge doing Donald Trump's will.
14:31 Speaker 05 Yes.
14:32 Speaker 04 Um, and, and to just, this clip is not really germane to a lot of the rest of what we're going to talk about. But this is the clip that everybody sent to us, and I just feel the need to very briefly play it so that everyone can understand what we're doing here.
14:44 Speaker 06 You sent it to Luhon.
14:45 Speaker 07 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Chairman Carr, yes or no, and please, yes or no, is the FCC an independent agency? Senator, thanks for that question. Yes or no is all we need, sir. Yes or no, is it independent? Well, there's a test for this in the law, in the key portion of that test. Yes or no, Brendan? The key portion of that test is... Okay, I'm gonna go to Commissioner Trustee. So just so you know Brendan, on your website, it just simply says, man, the FCC is independent. This isn't a trick question. Okay, the FCC is not, is not, is not... So is your website wrong? Is your website lying? Possibly. The FCC is not an independent agency. Okay, can I read this to you? The FCC's mission on the homepage of the FCC, man.
15:26 Speaker 05 First of all, props to Senator Lujan for just calling in Brendan.
15:28 Speaker 04 This goes on for a while.
15:30 Speaker 05 Yeah.
15:30 Speaker 04 It's delightful. This turns, he ends up regretting how long he spent talking about a website because he doesn't get to ask Brendan Carr his other question. But the other thing that happened here is the word independent has now disappeared from the FCC's website.
15:43 Speaker 05 Within minutes. I think it happened in real time during that back and forth.
15:46 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:47 Speaker 05 Like Brendan's various stooges were like, edit the website.
15:49 Speaker 04 Yeah. And Carr's argument is essentially, Trump can fire me whenever he wants without cause, thus it is not an independent agency, which is like, on its face, insane.
16:01 Speaker 05 I mean, it currently being litigated with Supreme Court that is, seems very excited about buying that idea. Not the law as it stands today.
16:08 Speaker 04 Sure.
16:09 Speaker 05 Soon to be the law, I would say.
16:12 Speaker 04 That's how we do laws here.
16:13 Speaker 05 Not, I can try to make this make sense. This one I can make, I can try to make sense, because Sarah Jeong and I talk about it all the time.
16:18 Speaker 04 Please.
16:19 Speaker 05 The idea embodied in the Trump administration and, very importantly, in our Supreme Court, which is full of justices, conservative justices, that worked for George W. Bush and in some cases like Nixon and Reagan, is of, is of a theory called the unitary executive, where there's like one line in the Constitution that says the executive power shall be vested in the president, and that means every single agency is the executive and it's unitary. It's one, it's one org chart, like decoder phrase, right? And that is pretty controversial. The idea is if you don't like how it's going, you can fire the president and he'll restaff all the agencies. And that means that's how the agencies are accountable to you.
17:02 Speaker 05 The unitary executives, the FCC is just another part of the presidency. The FTC is just another part of the presidency. And on and on and on. There's a lot of law, like case law, that says that is not the case, that our current Supreme Court, which really believes in the unitary executive, is slowly dismantling.
17:18 Speaker 04 Yes.
17:19 Speaker 05 Also, that's not how Congress set these things up, or necessarily even how you'd interpret the Constitution. Like, this is a big fight. Who is more accountable to you? The Congress, where the House gets voted in every two years? Or the president, gets voted every four years and has much more power than an individual member of Congress? I don't know. I do know that what you don't want is to change the censorship police at the whim of the president if the president feels bad. And that's, that is the best argument for the FCC being independent and having the structure it has, where you have three members of the majority and two members of the minority party. And the reason you set all this up is to insulate it from political pressure, because you don't want control of communications to be political.
18:03 Speaker 05 But that's not what Brendan thinks, because Brendan is a dummy who wants to keep his job. And in this Trump administration, being a stooge is an easier way to keep your job than abiding by the ideals that set up the agency that you currently run.
18:15 Speaker 04 Right. All right. So let's get into some of these.
18:17 Speaker 05 I did make that make sense. I just called him a dummy along the way. That's all. I can do this.
18:21 Speaker 04 Things can make sense and everybody can be. I'm gonna do this, like, imagine this like around the horn on ESPN, where I'm just kind of randomly giving you points for no reason. The, the first one I want to read you is Brendan Carr answering a question, a thing that came up a lot, is a thing that he tweeted, I believe in 2019, saying essentially, comedy and satire are a key bit of free speech and should be protected at all costs, more or less. This has been thrown back in Brendan Carr's face many times, as he has done the opposite to people over and over and over again professionally. But this is, this, I think, gets to what you were talking about at the very beginning. He was asked the question, do you still agree that political satire should be protected speech? And he says, whenever that satire or any other programming is over the public airways
19:05 Speaker 04 for broadcasters, there's a public interest standard and there's a news distortion rule, a broadcast hoax rule. And then it got cut off because everybody kept talking. But this is, this is the foundation of the argument, right?
19:16 Speaker 05 Yes, the argument is, think of all of the inputs on your TV. And you've got the cable input and then, and it's marked antenna. And then you've got your HDMI ports and your HDMI ports are probably hooked up to some box that gets video over the internet. Right? This is almost certainly how it works. And anything that comes over the air, the government gets to interfere with. And anything that comes over the other stuff, whether that's cable or whether that's, you know, the internet through HDMI ports gets treated differently. If you put that in front of a consumer, they would not believe you.
19:49 Speaker 04 I'm just realizing, literally for the first time, that I've never processed that you literally actually mean over the air versus over a cable. You don't mean cable, the sort of idea of a cable, you mean literally the, the
20:00 Speaker 05 Yes.
20:01 Speaker 04 The mechanism via which it arrives at my house.
20:04 Speaker 05 Yes, that is what we regulate because that used to be the only mechanism. And I, I understand why, when it was the only mechanism, we put a lot of rules in place. The public airwaves are a scarce resource owned by the citizens of the United States. We don't sell them to AT&T and Verizon and whoever else, we lease them. And you, they have to buy the leases and the leases expire and we can reform them in
20:26 Speaker 04 For now, we'll come to that.
20:27 Speaker 05 2013 or 14, we, whenever LTE was coming out, we took the 700 megahertz spectrum away from television broadcasters and said, this is for LTE now. And we sold it, we resold it to AT&T and Verizon and whoever else could buy it. This is a big deal, right? That we own the airwaves, the people, you and me, we own it. Brendan is the steward of that ownership. That's his job is to act in our public interest in managing those airwaves. Now you can make a lot of arguments about what the public interest here is. But I would just submit to you in 2025, going to anyone, any random consumer of media and saying, hey, because Jimmy Kimmel comes over your TV antenna, the government gets a say in what he can do.
21:11 Speaker 05 And because whoever, Joe Rogan comes over IP through Spotify, the government can't say what he can do. No, first of all, you're like, what's an antenna? Right. That's just the first thing that's gonna happen. Second, they're gonna say, well, Joe Rogan is way more powerful than Jimmy Kimmel. He has vastly more reach.
21:29 Speaker 04 And also, I watched Jimmy Kimmel on YouTube. Does that change anything?
21:31 Speaker 05 Right. It's just like, doesn't matter.
21:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:34 Speaker 05 So he just keeps asserting this authority that was designed for a world in which all media was only distributed over the airwaves. And sure, maybe at that time, when there's only three stations, you have some big public interest in saying, okay, well, you have to cover both parties. Right? And you can't actually just buy the local TV station, which is the only media anyone can consume and distort it your way. And we have some interest in letting people sue you for that. Sure, maybe. But over time, as more and more media sources proliferated, that became stupid. We stopped enforcing those laws. In fact, in many cases, the only times those laws were enforced, there were lawsuits, the FCC was ruled against. Like, this is stuff, this is power that we give the government that we have decided over time that we don't want the government to use.
22:19 Speaker 05 And what Brendan has been doing is finding these little bits and bobs of unused power and consolidating them to say, I have this power over broadcasters, and I'm going to use it to shape the content how I want. And it's gonna come up over and over again in this hearing that he keeps saying that he's not doing that. But it's obvious that every time he brings up news distortion or public interest, what he's saying is, I am the person who understands the public interest. I understand what the news should be and when it's being distorted. And because I have this power over this distribution, I will use it. And I'm just saying over and over again, the idea that the broadcaster should be treated differently than any YouTuber makes no sense to anyone anymore.
23:01 Speaker 05 And it's why I keep saying Brendan is a dummy, because if you rewind the clock to Michael Powell in 2012 to me, he was saying, this makes no sense. If you are actually a conservative, you would deregulate this and that all this content compete freely, because that will actually equalize the market. And Brendan, 13 years later, is saying, no, I have this power and I don't want to give it up, even though it's causing this massive distortion in the market.
23:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, he had a really interesting back and forth with Ed Markey, where Senator Markey was basically like, you're leaning on this, you know, public interest broadcast TV thing to let you do whatever you want. And he goes, yeah, I'm enforcing the rules. And Markey goes, no, you're weaponizing the rules. And that's, that's a back and forth I've been thinking about.
23:41 Speaker 05 I think Markey, he practiced that line of attack on Decoder the week before.
23:46 Speaker 04 It's pretty good. And there was another one. So Brendan Carr was, they continue to like make threats at local news stations, essentially. And the question is, this is government censorship, plain and simple. Was it a mistake in retrospect for you to instigate an investigation of that San Francisco radio station? Was that a mistake? And Brendan Carr says, Senator, broadcasters understanding perhaps for the first time in years that they're going to be held accountable to the public interest to broadcast hoax rules to the news distortion policy. I think that's a good thing. Like these, he just, he keeps leaning on the idea of, these are the rules, they haven't been enforced, now they're being enforced. Thank God.
24:22 Speaker 05 Yeah, let me, let me compare this into the crypto industry. Every Verchass listeners' favorite industry. What was the complaint of the crypto industry about the SEC, you know, in 2020, 2021, when, when wild ideas are flying around? The single complaint, Brian Armstrong, the CEO of Coinbase made this complaint. Just done a lot. Everybody made this complaint. This is regulation by enforcement. Right? You're taking all these rules that existed, and you're selectively applying them to us to kill our industry. And if you want to regulate us, that's fine. Write a bill that treats crypto like what it is in the market that it exists in, and we will do our lobbying and we'll get the bill that we want written. But regulation by enforcement is corruption, pure and simple. This is, the
25:06 Speaker 05 crypto industry still says this to this day. We don't want regulation by enforcement, even though they're not even being regulated or enforced right now. Regulation by enforcement is bad. That's why people say it. The idea that you have this wide power in the government to do a lot of things and you selectively apply them, politically apply them to get the outcomes you want, goes against the rule of law. It makes the government less predictable, more political, and it certainly uses the power of the government in ways that an average public radio station cannot afford to fight. So Brendan is saying the law is finally being enforced would maybe hold up if he was enforcing it against the local Fox affiliates for distorting the news, the local Sinclair affiliates for distorting the news. There's a lot of ways you could point that arrow in the opposite direction politically, and maybe you should. Maybe you should.
25:51 Speaker 05 You can make that argument, and certainly there are people who make that argument every day, that you should point this gun at Fox. But he's not doing that. He's not making that argument at all. He's saying, when you criticize this government, when you criticize this president, and you happen to do it on the airwaves, which no consumer can distinguish from the internet, then I have the power and I can stop you. That is just not, I mean, fundamentally, it's not just stupid. It's like borderline traitorous because it flies in the face of the Constitution and the rule of law in such a direct way that everyone understands it. Should the cops arrest you because they don't like you? Should the cops arrest you for speeding just because they don't like you? Or should they arrest everyone for speeding? Or, in my case, should you argue the cops arrest no one for speeding? So you can drive fast cars.
26:34 Speaker 04 There's neolos politics right there.
26:37 Speaker 05 It's like a weird combo platter of policies from the Patel campaign. Vote for me. It'll be fun regardless. All I'm saying is Brendan's argument is, I have this power, and if you don't let me use it, that's wrong. And I would just say, the real argument is, you should never have this power, and even if you do, you should have the discretion to use it equally or not at all.
26:58 Speaker 04 Yeah. So to that end, here's another one for you that I would like you to make sense of. This question is long, so I will summarize it as, they brought up what President Trump posted on Truth Social after Rob Reiner died. And basically, what he said is, Rob Reiner died because he had what I believe he said he called Trump derangement syndrome, and he was a bad person. Truly heinous, awful response. And then he says, um, do you think that's appropriate for the President of the United States to do that? And if Jimmy Kimmel would have said that, would you have threatened to take him off the air? And to that, Brendan Carr says, Senator, look, Democrats on this day are accusing me of engaging in censorship, and now you're trying to encourage me to police speech on the internet. I'm simply not going to do that.
27:42 Speaker 05 Okay. So first of all, whoever asked that question is also done for not asking the obvious follow. Sorry, it's equal opportunity. I'm not here, I'm not here valorizing Michael Powell today. You have no idea what's coming. Um, but there's an obvious follow up to this question. And Brendan is dodging this question in such ham-fisted way that he's not even clever about doing it. He's saying, you want me to police speech on the internet? That's not the question. The obvious follow up question is, I wasn't asking you about speech on the internet. I was saying, if Jimmy Kimmel said these words on broadcast television, would that rise the level of news distortion? Because when Jimmy Kimmel said, I believe, uh, everyone in MAGA is trying to get away from the shooter, or pretend the shooter isn't one of them, you thought that was horrible.
28:27 Speaker 05 And you were going to block a merger over it. That's the easy way or the hard way, right? So that's really bad. You, you can find a reason to enforce the rules on that. If Jimmy Kimmel repeated what Trump said, which everyone thinks is horrible, on the airwaves, would that meet your standard? And Carr, because he does not want to answer that question, ham-fistedly dodges out of it by saying, I'm not going to censor the internet. But no one's asking him about censoring the internet. And whatever Democrat asked him, who was it?
28:53 Speaker 04 It was Amy Klobuchar, I think.
28:54 Speaker 05 Oh, Klobz. Look, Sarah Klobuchar, she's a monster. If she comes back on the show, I'll be like, you blew it. Cause she blew it with that one. Cause that wasn't the question.
29:01 Speaker 04 Fair.
29:02 Speaker 05 She's really better than that. But she blew it, because the question is, no, no, no, you keep making this distinction between the internet and broadcast. So if you move these words from the internet to broadcast, the president's words, if you move them from internet distribution to broadcast distribution, would that make them illegal or subject to some investigation? Because over and over again, he's saying, when you do things on broadcast, I get to say whether or not they're true or not. Because over and over again, he's saying, if you say these things on broadcast, I get a say. And the question is, and I think the heart of that question is if it's okay on the internet, why is it not okay on broadcast? Because you're the one who makes the rules over there.
29:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, there was a version of this question where they asked something about the difference between the 60 Minutes interview that was quote unquote selectively edited that became a whole kerfuffle and a Fox News thing that did essentially the exact same thing. And he very matter of factly was like, Fox News one was on cable. I have no jurisdiction. What are you talking about? So allow me to just briefly do something completely unthinkable and slightly quickly defend or say, give you a real worst person you know makes a good point moment in Brendan Carr's testimony. Brendan Carr says, "We have a public interest standard that Congress has put into the law, and there's a number of very specific rules and doctrines that flow from that. The broadcast hoax rule, the news distortion rule. In my
30:21 Speaker 04 position, and I think the Trump administration position, is that we should be enforcing those rules and policies. If Congress wants to change it, you're free to change it." Is that, is there not like a teeny tiny glimmer of a reasonable point there? Like 13 years ago, Michael Powell would have been right. We've had a Congress the whole time.
30:36 Speaker 05 Yeah.
30:37 Speaker 04 What are we doing?
30:38 Speaker 05 You know, I, do we have a Congress is a good first question.
30:42 Speaker 04 I mean, we have at various times had a Congress.
30:46 Speaker 05 You know, I think Brendan has gone far enough to irritate some Republican members of Congress. Bizarrely, to your point about the worst person you know makes a good point, Ted Cruz, all over this hearing, saying you've gone too far. There are, you know, there are ideological members of the Republican coalition who are like, government speech regulations are bad. Like, I agree with them. That has been my position on this show forever. Government speech regulations are bad. And he's running into some of that across the Republican coalition. I think the Democratic coalition, less interested in that idea, but also less interested in doing stuff. You know, there's one thing to learn from, you know, the first year of Trump 2.0, it's, boy, the government actually has a lot of power.
31:32 Speaker 05 It can do a lot of things. They, if the various people empowered to do things just decide to simply start doing things, it takes a lot to slow them down or stop them, including, you know, Trump just firing people at agencies. He, he just does, he's not supposed to be able to do that. No one's in his way. Right. There are lawsuits. Some of the lawsuits are getting thrown out. Some lawsuits are continuing. Some lawsuits get stayed on the Supreme Court's emergency docket because they have to figure out how to throw out the laws that they're supposed to uphold. Like, there's a lot going on there. Democrats have not learned that lesson. They don't just do things. And so, yeah, to the point where he's like, if Congress wants to change the law, you should change it. He's basically saying, fuck you. Right? Like, you, you won't do this thing. And so I'm just gonna run
32:14 Speaker 05 crazy with the power they have that comes from the Telecommunications Act of 1934. And that's the mistake, right? The reason you want these independent agencies is so that they have discretion that is divorced from politics. And they can look at the world as it exists today and make determinations about which, which power is actually in the public interest, which enforcement is actually going to get the results people want. And not, we have all of the power and we use it all the time. Because otherwise, you would be beholden to the speed at which Congress can act. And again, you can have a lot of philosophical debates about this. This is the heart of political science, especially as it relates to like, the American government. But Brendan is just putting a bulldozer through
32:57 Speaker 05 it without a second's hesitation. I think this is gonna come back to bite all of us in the end, because we've taught a generation of would-be mini dictators that can do whatever they want. And I don't think that's, I don't think that's how it's supposed to work. Or at least they're supposed to be competing with each other for power, which is sort of like how the framers designed it. But that's not what we have today either.
33:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. Yeah. All right. I have two more for you. Um, this one I worry is gonna take you between four and six hours to wade through, but I'm gonna, I'm gonna do this anyway.
33:25 Speaker 05 Look, the reason we cover policy diverge is because the iPhone 3GS was dropping calls. And to explain that, you had to be like, there's not enough spectrum and explain that you explain spectrum auctions on the FCC. And now here I am being like, this isn't what the framers intended.
33:36 Speaker 04 Oh, good.
33:37 Speaker 05 At once, I apologize.
33:39 Speaker 04 Let's briefly talk about spectrum auctions.
33:42 Speaker 05 There we go.
33:43 Speaker 04 Here, here's a long quote. I'm going to read you the whole thing. Democrats at the time, this is back in the Kimmel time, were saying that we explicitly threatened to pull a license if Jimmy Kimmel wasn't fired. That never happened. That was nothing more than projection and distortion by Democrats. What I am saying is any broadcaster that uses the airwaves, whether radio or TV, has to comply with the public interest and licenses are not sacred cows. Yes, you can do things to lose a license, but if we want to change that, that's up to Congress. And one idea, for instance, is why don't we put all the broadcast TV licenses up for auction? And if people want to buy them without the public interest obligation, they can do that. Neela Patel, your thoughts?
34:18 Speaker 05 How? First of all, how would you do that? Like, you would be like, here's my bid. I want less rules.
34:26 Speaker 05 I want you to enforce the, the power that you have less.
34:30 Speaker 05 I just don't know how you would mechanically do that today without even more acts of Congress or desire from the president to have less power. Again, I, I think what Brandon is saying is like, go, go fuck yourself. Like,
34:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:42 Speaker 05 And he can, because Congress is fundamentally incompetent at this moment in time, and they're, they won't do anything about it. And so he's issuing a dare that they can't even accomplish. And he's issuing a dare that he would, I, I agree with him. Do you know what I think we should do? We should probably get rid of broadcast TV, subsidize wireless service for more Americans, make it cheaper and more prevalent for them to access, and move the sort of like, public interest, local news functions to some sort of subsidized model that pays for local newsrooms around the country. This is a half-formed idea. I had it five seconds ago. Doesn't it sound better than Sinclair owns all of the broadcasters and does what the president wants? I don't know if that idea will work, but you can come up with some solution that's
35:26 Speaker 05 like, we need to make sure we support local newsrooms because they hold local parts of the government accountable. There are vast news deserts in this country, and people aren't watching broadcast TV anyway. They're watching their phones. Make the phones cheaper. I can get there. I can, I can come up with some idea that gets you more of the way there than we need to make sure that Sinclair and Tegna do what we want, or we won't let them merge. No one cares about that. And Brendan has lasered in on this thing that no one cares about because there's enormous amounts of money in letting big companies merge or not merge. There's enormous amounts of power in controlling the local news broadcasts all across this country and at a time when local news is dying. And he gets to wield power and he gets to make himself appear to be the censorship police, even though
36:11 Speaker 05 his power is very, very deeply constrained.
36:13 Speaker 04 Right. Because to go all the way back to the beginning, my guy is absolutely obsessed with not getting fired by Donald Trump.
36:23 Speaker 05 I don't, I don't like that.
36:27 Speaker 04 One more. And this is, I think, maybe one that is going to need a fair amount of Neelad translation here. He says, "One of the things I'm trying to do with our media policy as a general matter is to re-empower those local broadcasters to invest in local news. Because what's happened over the years, we've had a consolidation of power into what are national programmers, Comcast, Disney, and others." I guess I should say here, disclosure, Fox Media is, Comcast is an investor in Vox Media through its subsidiary NBC Universal. They're big fans of ours. It's all really fine.
36:56 Speaker 05 Let me tell you about my FCC coverage.
36:58 Speaker 04 So then Brendan continues, "And effectively, a lot of local broadcast stations are just mouthpieces for that national programming made in New York and Hollywood." This feels like some crux of Brendan Carr's sort of theory of the case about media right now. Can you explain what's going on here?
37:13 Speaker 05 This is so rude that you keep framing all of this like that. I'm so mad at you. No, I can't make any sense of what he's saying.
37:20 Speaker 04 Okay, good.
37:21 Speaker 05 But I can, I can, I can translate from idiot to Vergecast.
37:26 Speaker 04 There you go.
37:27 Speaker 05 It's impossible to make sense of what he's saying because the consolidation of power into national programmers is the consolidation of all of the local news stations in many markets being owned by one company.
37:39 Speaker 04 Those are the mergers Brendan Carr keeps allowing.
37:42 Speaker 05 Those are the mergers. Sinclair Broadcasting owns a lot of broadcast stations. Tegna owns a lot of broadcast stations. They wanted to merge. There were markets in which they would have owned all of the broadcast stations in a given city. And those are supposed to be competitors, right? Your local ABC News is supposed to compete with your local CBS News. They're supposed to have more men on the street interviews and choppers. Like, that's what they're supposed to do. They're supposed to be Anchorman. That's the competition you want, right? Competing for local news to be the best eyes and ears of your community that you can get. The internet has obviously broken this, right? It's no longer lucrative to be the best local news in San Diego.
38:23 Speaker 04 Right.
38:24 Speaker 05 And like, I think we've lost something for that. I think we all yearn for the simpler days of Anchorman, for sure. Bring us back, Ron Bargendy.
38:32 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:32 Speaker 05 That's all gone, man. Those stations are underfunded. They are owned by private equity in a lot of different ways. They're owned by Sinclair, Tegna, which have a bunch of private equity in them. The costs are being cut. The stations are being consolidated. They themselves are broadcasting enormous amounts of centralized news programming.
38:48 Speaker 04 Yep.
38:49 Speaker 05 You can't make this argument without being an idiot to reality. It's not Comcast and Disney and whoever else. There, yes, they are producing a lot of the sitcoms. They produce the national news broadcasts, but the local news on these stations is essentially being produced by a handful of enormous conglomerates that most people don't know, cannot possibly hold accountable, and quite honestly, have miserable taste. But just go to any local news station's website and be like, do these people have good taste? And the answer is no. They have private equity taste, right? It is lowest common denominator slop across the board. And so you remember when Deadspin did that video ages ago?
39:32 Speaker 05 And it was just the same broadcast on every single station. They're all reading the same script. That's the danger.
39:39 Speaker 04 Yeah. That was like some truly dystopian stuff, too.
39:41 Speaker 05 And this is, I think even that's like a decade ago.
39:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:45 Speaker 05 That's the danger, right? Is that you will consume this news that you perceive to be made in your community, but it is actually being made by a national broadcaster with national interests that is playing a culture war that is a million miles away from you, literally and figuratively. And so Brendan's saying, I'm protecting you from the big evil NBC and Comcast and Disney and ABC, whatever. But at least you can see those. Those are legible to you. Sinclair and Tegna are not legible to you. So when Brendan exerts his power over them... You might not even know it. You might not even know how to hold them accountable because they're running under the ABC News branding. And so, again, this is, to me, this is incoherent nonsense, because the reality is nothing like what he's describing. It is also dangerous,
40:30 Speaker 05 because he's continuing to assert his censorship authority over a thing that is diminishing the value every day, because the people who own it are diminishing its value anyhow. And I just look at this, I'm like, why do you want to be known as the censor in chief? To what end? And maybe it's because, you know, he doesn't want Donald Trump to fire him. But I would say his, his next move, and he's got this comment here about Section 230. His next move is to say, you know what else runs over the public airwaves? Mobile Internet service. Do you know else the government operates in the public trust? The Internet. We should not have news distortion on YouTube. We should not have news distortion on, on the TikTok algorithm. This criticism of our, our nation's greatest ally, Israel, has gone over the top. We're gonna make sure X shuts it down. That's all coming. It's, there's
41:15 Speaker 05 a reason he's in using this power now. He's saying, I have this power and I need to use it. The only next move is to say, I should have more power. In this line about 230, where he wants to reinterpret 230, that, that's, that's his shade at it.
41:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, let me, let me read this one to you, and then, and then this can be the last one, because I do think this hints at the 2026 season of Brendan Carr as a dummy. He says, I think I've expressed concerns over the years about how courts have sort of misinterpreted and given expansive new readings to Section 230 that aren't in the statutory text. And I think there's some of those issues in your legislation as well that are worth looking at. This is in response to a senator who was basically like, am I doing a good job making Section 230 go away? And that's essentially what he says. My, my response to this was, why on earth are you talking about Section 230, Brendan Carr? And then I looked, and I guess there is some precedent precedent for the FCC having some interest in Section 230. But I agree with you, it seems clear that...
42:11 Speaker 05 Oh, there's not some precedent. You know what there is? There's a chapter of Project 2025 written by Brendan Carr, in which he says, the FCC should be given jurisdiction over Section 230. Again,
42:22 Speaker 04 This feels like where we're headed.
42:23 Speaker 05 He's not a savvy operator.
42:25 Speaker 04 Yeah.
42:25 Speaker 05 Like, I can just, I can just read his plans. I'm like, these plans are stupid. And then he does them.
42:31 Speaker 05 And I'm just saying it's coming. The reason that he's making this enormous stand about being able to regulate speech on broadcast is so that he can make the same argument about the internet. And he will find the authority. And again, he keeps daring Congress to stop him. And I suspect Congress will remain as dysfunctional as ever, and they will not. And so 230 is one way into it. There are other ways into it, some of which run into his own policymaking from the past, as we've discussed. You know, a G-Pie and in the first Trump administration, disclaimed a lot of authority about the internet. But I suspect Brendan is going to try to find a way next year to take it back and actually aggressively try to start regulating speech on platforms.
43:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's coming. All right. That is it. This has been-
43:15 Speaker 05 You're a real dummy, Brendan.
43:16 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
43:17 Speaker 05 As always, I'd like to welcome you onto our show. I know you're going to be at CES. You can be the surprise live guest at the Vergecast at CES.
43:22 Speaker 04 Fun fact, Brendan Carr doing a thing the morning after the Vergecast Live at the Brooklyn Bowl. So we know confidently that Brendan Carr is likely to be in Vegas and not busy. I'm just saying.
43:33 Speaker 05 If you, if you got a line on Brendan, tell him that he's always welcome.
43:37 Speaker 04 You a good bowler, Brendan? Hit us up.
43:40 Speaker 05 We'll bowl for free speech. But you know what? We can hang out in the casino. We can, we can do it however you want. But as always, you're welcome on our airwaves. I just refuse to be polite because I'm an American. I have free speech, you big dummy.
43:55 Speaker 04 That's it. That's the end of the 2025 season of Brendan Carr is a dummy. Neil, it's, it's been a pleasure hosting this podcast with you. I don't do much on this podcast, but it's, it's a joy to be here with you. We actually, this, this veers perfectly into a bunch of streaming war stuff that has happened this week. So let's take a break and then we're going to come back. We're going to talk streaming. We'll be right back.
44:32 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
44:46 Speaker 03 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
45:17 Speaker 08 Low energy, unfocused, foggy? You might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body. With a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors, great tasting hydration no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade: Hydrates Better Than Water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
45:50 Speaker 09 Hey, Bose here. When your next track starts, listen for the decisions that the artist makes. The vocal push right up front. The bass that waits half a beat. That sample from a 70s underground gem. Every choice deliberate. With Bose, you'll hear it all. Your music deserves Bose.
46:18 Speaker 04 All right, we're back. Uh, Neelai, weird week in the streaming wars. There's, there's just a lot of like stuff happening. You know what I mean? Everybody's just doing things.
46:29 Speaker 05 And there's a lot of stuff, also all of it proves my thesis, that broadcast is dead and the future is on the internet.
46:34 Speaker 04 Yes, and at the very least, that all of these things are becoming precisely exactly the same thing. So let me, let me just run through some headlines here and you can, you can stop me when you find something interesting.
46:46 Speaker 05 Oh, boy.
46:46 Speaker 04 We're going to stop here very quickly because thing number one on my list is that YouTube will now be the streaming host of the Oscars, starting in 2029.
46:55 Speaker 05 I was right. What else do you want me to say?
46:58 Speaker 04 This to me is actually like a perfect example of the thing we were talking about because I think like other than live sports, I think the most TV TV thing continues to be award shows. Right. It's, it's one of the few things that still commands like a big live audience at a specific time on a specific day. It's one of the, it's, it's just Hollywood people celebrating themselves. Like there are lots of these award shows. Uh, Netflix, I think got the SAG Awards. So this is a thing that's been happening, but the Oscars is like, the Oscars is a big TV moment every year in a, in a winnowing list of big TV moments every year. And now it's just going to be on YouTube. Does that feel weird to you?
47:38 Speaker 05 Um, it doesn't feel weird to me. Like you mentioned, Netflix took the SAG Awards. The, the Grammys moved to quote Disney platforms.
47:45 Speaker 04 Oh, right.
47:46 Speaker 05 Uh, we had the president of Recording Academy, Harvey Mason, uh, on Decoder a while back, and he was in the midst of changing from CBS. They've been on CBS for a million years. And he was basically like, I gotta go where the kids are. And he hadn't announced it yet. And I was like, on YouTube. And then he was like Disney Plus. I'm like, oh, that's equally good. Like, that's where the kids are. Like, these awards need to be near their relevant audiences.
48:06 Speaker 04 Right.
48:06 Speaker 05 And the Oscars have a real problem, which is no one has ever watched any of these movies. And so you're just like back into, should we give Endgame the Oscar for Best Picture again? Like, I think if they just gave Avengers Endgame an award every year, like more people would watch the Oscars.
48:22 Speaker 04 This, I just get such a kick out of this because like I, I did this big story about YouTube for its 20th anniversary, which was earlier this year. And one of the things they're very honest about is that a, a big next moment for YouTube is going to be to start winning some of these big Hollywood awards. Like it has the audience. They got on the Nielsen ratings, which was a huge deal and a real sort of legitimacy thing. They have all the advertisers they wanted. They were like, we have all the pieces of this puzzle, but we've never won an Emmy. We've never won an Oscar. And now it's like, you just have to wonder if Neil Mohan just ran around and was like, well, okay, well, we're never going to win an Oscar, but we could do the Oscars. Does that count?
48:58 Speaker 05 Um, so you know, I have some questions about this, which we'll see. You know, Apple took over Major League Baseball. They were in charge of producing it and they did a bad job.
49:07 Speaker 04 Yes.
49:08 Speaker 05 They might still be doing a bad job, but they got, it got better, but initially like a horrible job.
49:12 Speaker 04 They're also taking over Formula One and a lot of people I know are, uh, I would say curious and nervous about how that's going to go.
49:19 Speaker 05 Although Formula One is owned by Liberty Media. So I, I, I don't know if Apple's just a distributor there, but I think the actual show is still produced by, by Liberty.
49:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, we'll see.
49:26 Speaker 05 Amazon does Thursday Night Football. I would call that messy. Right. Like if you've ever wanted to hear Al Michaels take a nap, you should watch Thursday Night Football on Prime.
49:35 Speaker 04 Or to see retired NFL players take their shirts off at the halftime show.
49:39 Speaker 05 Vastly more exciting than most of the games. Um, so like, there's just some like, do you have the muscles to do this? Do you know how to do production in the way that the big broadcast networks did production, which is a big part of making these award shows feel big?
49:52 Speaker 05 Uh, but I, I think what this actually points to is that these award shows are declining assets.
49:56 Speaker 04 I think that's probably right.
49:57 Speaker 05 Because the broadcast networks will pay the money for sports. They are not going to lose the NFL until they are, until they are dead and gone.
50:04 Speaker 04 Right.
50:05 Speaker 05 And so you see the sports leagues are creating more games to sell to the streamers. Like, fine, there's football on Thursday and Sunday morning in Brazil, like whatever, whatever it takes, you can buy it. But the core broadcast rights, you know, the big networks will continue to overpay for, because that's all they have left. And I think they're all looking at the ratings for the Grammys and the Oscars and everywhere else and saying, this isn't worth it to us.
50:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
50:27 Speaker 05 And so I, I do think until there's monoculture again, these award shows are basically going to devolve into, we give an award to the movie most people have heard of, and we are going to make up new categories for Beyonce to win every year.
50:39 Speaker 04 Yeah. I mean, it's like the, the Golden Globes added a, uh, achievement in box office category over the last couple of years, literally just so that they could say, here's the biggest movie of the year, and hopefully we'll get big A-list celebrities to come.
50:52 Speaker 05 Yeah.
50:53 Speaker 04 So, okay, so that's one. And then also this week, um, Netflix announced that it's making a FIFA game, which is a big deal to me personally. But is also, so Netflix has been sort of like dabbling in video games for a while now. They've done a lot of resurrecting of old games. They've done some sort of indie game stuff. But this, so EA, which had the license to make like the official global soccer game for years, lost its FIFA relationship last year. So now EA still makes a game, but it's called EAFC and not FIFA. And Netflix is now apparently going to make the FIFA game. Like they're just gonna go try to make a rival sports game. Neel, to put this in terms you understand.
51:32 Speaker 05 No, I get it. I get it. You're saying they can make Madden. I know where you're going.
51:35 Speaker 04 They're gonna make a Madden. That's exactly right.
51:39 Speaker 04 That is such a like several orders of magnitude leap from any of the gaming stuff Netflix has been doing in the past. And to me suggests that like you only do this if you're dead serious about really trying to compete in video games. Like if they're gonna make a triple A sports simulation game, you're not messing around.
51:58 Speaker 05 Are they gonna make a triple A sports simulation game?
52:00 Speaker 04 We'll see.
52:01 Speaker 05 Or like, do they even have to?
52:02 Speaker 04 Maybe not.
52:03 Speaker 05 Is EAFC any good? Like if you wanted to compete with Madden today, Madden 26, what I've been playing, which is so hard. You could just tell me that you've made Madden 2001 with the current rosters. I'm like, that's better.
52:16 Speaker 04 Yes. I play this game called Retro Bowl that is essentially that. The graphics are awful, but it has the NFL players' names right there. And I love it very much and I play it all the time. It's it. It's great.
52:29 Speaker 05 I get a lot of TikTok videos of legendary Packers backup quarterback Kurt Benkert. Two never played, but his legendary Packers quarterback Kurt Benkert. And he's playing Madden. And I'm just like, I don't, I'm not playing that game. I don't know. I've never seen that game before. What are you doing?
52:47 Speaker 04 Amazing.
52:48 Speaker 05 And so like, and I get their skill levels and whatever, but like, I'm just saying, I think the market for some of these games that have been pretty lazy for a long time is huge.
52:57 Speaker 04 Yes.
52:58 Speaker 05 Plus, if the license in there, a lot of people know what FIFA is. And a lot of people, I think Netflix is very interested in being sports adjacent.
53:05 Speaker 04 Yes. Well, Netflix also is gonna have the Women's World Cup starting in 2027. So it is like, it's, it's starting to buy into this in a pretty real way.
53:14 Speaker 05 Yeah. And they're figuring it out live. I would just say, is, if this game lives inside of Netflix, that is a huge mistake.
53:22 Speaker 04 I agree with that.
53:23 Speaker 05 They need to put this game where people play these games. In their own apps on phones and as standalone games on consoles and I will see. Did they say anything about that?
53:33 Speaker 04 Um, just the, they said it'll be available on mobile, but the exact machinations of it all, I think, remain to be seen. But I agree with you and I think Netflix has done it kind of in all possible ways. Like there's some stuff that is buried, but then there's other stuff that you can just go get and you just log in with your Netflix account and that's fine. I have been of the mind for a couple of years now that this was like a fake thing that Netflix would eventually just kind of give up on the minute. Like it, the interest rates went up a little. That no longer seems to be the case. I actually think Netflix might be serious about doing games.
54:06 Speaker 05 Well, particularly, we're going to get to this, as YouTube encroaches more and more on Netflix. Netflix has to find stuff that YouTube want to. And YouTube is not going to publish games.
54:14 Speaker 04 Or can I interest you in Netflix just buying a bunch of stuff that used to be on YouTube? The other thing that happened this week was Netflix made deals with Barstool Sports and with iHeart Radio to get a bunch more video podcasts onto Netflix. And there, there's reporting out there that says the deal with Barstool is eight figures a year. Pardon my take, a big and very popular football podcast is moving exclusively to Netflix. This is like an ongoing thing. Again, there's a lot of sports here. This is like Netflix is spending an awful lot of money to get video podcasts off of YouTube and onto Netflix. And I just, I have two things to say about that. One is what the hell, why haven't we got a phone call? What are we doing here?
54:56 Speaker 05 I feel like Disclosure, I made a Netflix show that didn't make it to a second season.
55:01 Speaker 04 You're the problem. They're like, we're never working with Neel I again.
55:08 Speaker 04 But also, like, again, we're in this moment where it feels like YouTube has sort of conquered the world, except for winning Oscars and Emmys, right? And Netflix has conquered Hollywood and now wants to go be YouTube. Like these, these two things are just running at each other so directly and so fast. It's almost bizarre to watch.
55:30 Speaker 05 I feel like there's some strategy confusion on Netflix's part here. Video podcasts are great. Obviously people are spending a lot of time on them. They dominate YouTube's time spent charts. A video podcast on Netflix without the YouTube commenting ecosystem feels way less valuable to me.
55:46 Speaker 04 I think I agree with that.
55:46 Speaker 05 There's some, even, you know, our own show, like, you can comment on our show on our site, and you can comment on YouTube, and you just look at the comments, and you're like, well, there's more action on YouTube, like, more people are incentivized to do it there. There's something about that that seems important in the context of a podcast, which is, you know, before creators became creators, we were podcasters before there was a creator economy, and the relationship that we have with our audience was very direct in a way that the relationship of like Netflix TV show runners is not as direct. And so I think Netflix wants to buy the time, but they can't get the relationship without the back and forth. And I can say this very, like, I can make this example very concrete.
56:28 Speaker 05 We launched the entire Verge off the back of the Engadget podcast.
56:33 Speaker 04 Fair.
56:34 Speaker 05 Right? We had, we had Engadget, we were unhappy there, we had the podcast, we left, we didn't take the feed. I mean, this is ancient history now, but this is stuff that you see playing out over and again now. But in 2010, we were like, we're gonna leave, can we have our podcast feed? And AOL said no. And we told our audience on Twitter, we're leaving. Here's a new podcast feed called This is my next podcast, and the entire Verge is built off of that audience relationship, which is very direct, very two-way, right? It was a little community. That's not the relationship anybody has with Shonda Rhimes, I don't think. Right? Like, it's just different. Like Netflix is Hollywood in that way. So they can buy all these video podcasts, but if they don't understand that what they're taking is the sort of direct parasocial audience relationship that creators have with their
57:17 Speaker 05 communities, I think they're gonna make some missteps. I put that right next to them buying Warner and say, I think they actually might know what to do with Warner. The big, who knows? But like, you know what I mean? Like, they're better at that than YouTube running a social network.
57:32 Speaker 04 Yeah. Some news on that front, by the way. This keeps just getting more and more bizarre. Netflix continues to say it is very serious about putting Warner Brothers movies in theaters, like this, this thing where Netflix is gonna destroy the movie economy, continues to burble, and Ted Sarandos has to keep saying, no, I like movies, I like Hollywood, we'll put stuff in theaters. Whether, whether we, I think I still believe that slightly more than you do, but they keep saying it. But then the other thing, I think the more important thing that happened this week is Warner Brothers is telling its shareholders to reject the hostile offer that is coming from Paramount. We talked through kind of what these deals look like last week, but essentially Paramount wants
58:15 Speaker 04 the whole company thinks it can get the regulatory side of this done. Has a lot of funky financing things going on, had Jared Kushner involved, but even he now thinks the deal is out.
58:26 Speaker 05 It's pretty good.
58:27 Speaker 04 It's, it's a big mess.
58:28 Speaker 05 Jared Kushner dropping out of the Paramount bid is like very funny.
58:31 Speaker 04 It's a tough look for Paramount, which is not a thing I ever thought I would say about, you know, getting out of business with Jared Kushner. But anyway, um, yeah, so Warner is essentially saying, we want to do the Netflix deal. We are going to do the Netflix deal. You should turn down this Paramount offer. There is a lot of continuing smoke. Elizabeth Warren was just on a podcast, I Like the Town, talking about why this is a total antitrust disaster and neither Netflix nor Paramount is a good home for Warner Brothers. Like this thing is going to keep being a mess, but it actually looks like it might pretty quickly become just Netflix's mess. Is that your read?
59:11 Speaker 05 Liz wrote a piece this week, great headline, Larry Ellison's big dumb gift to his large adult son.
59:16 Speaker 04 That was good.
59:17 Speaker 05 You know, the thing I don't understand about the Paramount bid for Warner is that it is backstopped by a bunch of Saudi money, but also fundamentally by the Ellison family's own stock in Oracle.
59:28 Speaker 04 Right.
59:29 Speaker 05 And, you know, if you are the CEO of Oracle, you have no choice but to pretend that AGI is around the corner. And so saying, I'm willing to trade in my AGI valuable stock for your garbage Warner Brothers stock is cra- it's a crazy on its face. And that, you know, that's Liz's piece is like, you can't believe this. You know, a lot of commenters on people are saying they just want to buy political influence, which is sort of like, well, then why Jared Kushner back? But like, maybe.
59:59 Speaker 04 But also they have plenty of political influence. Larry Ellison is not hurting for access to the Trump administration.
1:00:04 Speaker 05 Right. Like maybe what you want is culture war political influence, but you can just get it, especially if you're also trying to buy TikTok. Which is arguably more influential than Warner Brothers. So it's just like unclear what Paramount's upside is. It's unclear why you would trade in Oracle stock for Paramount Warner Brothers stock, which already sounds like it's worth $0. And then you have to do the whole integration of these two things and not screwed up, which every single person that has ever bought Warner Brothers has done. So I do think it'll probably eventually be Netflix's mess. I just think we're two years of, talk about regulation by enforcement, like two years of Trump administration concessions away, which is why Netflix doesn't want CNN. They don't even want to be in that conversation. They want someone else to deal with that fight.
1:00:46 Speaker 04 Yeah, Netflix is very happy to have like sports podcasts and not interested in CNN.
1:00:52 Speaker 05 But, and I think the reason Ted Sarandos is running around saying he's committed to keeping movies in theaters is because Hollywood prefers him over Paramount, but still doesn't prefer him.
1:01:00 Speaker 04 Right.
1:01:00 Speaker 05 So he's trying to become the winner by saying, no, we're going to give you the things you want. Like you like us better than those guys, but like, let me sweeten the pot by saying we'll keep movie theaters alive.
1:01:09 Speaker 04 Right, right. Rather than just being the lesser of two eagles, which at this point they are, but only like slightly. Um, okay, two more things, and then I have a little game I want us to play here at the end of 2025. I have a bit of news that sucks and a bit of news that rules. The bit of news that sucks is Peacock is, is launching new ad format. I don't know if you've seen this, they call them arrival ads. And the idea is now when you open Peacock, you know, that first screen you land on where you, you pick your profile, it's going to have a big ass ad on it. Because that's what everybody wanted. And I just like.
1:01:48 Speaker 05 Yeah, I keep saying these companies are dead. They're, they're already dead.
1:01:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:01:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's death. And by the way, disclosure, NBC, Universal, Comcast are investors in our parent company. They're dead. They're already dead.
1:02:02 Speaker 04 Yeah. I don't think our podcast will be on Peacock anytime soon. Just say that. I think I'm fine with that.
1:02:08 Speaker 05 I'm going to go ahead and doubt that. Um, look, they're like, the money in advertising is under such pressure. Connected TV is one of the few places where. Like you can deliver good advertising or brand advertising, like fancy ads. And so the TV players are like, what if we increased our inventory of that? And they're not doing it by getting more people to sign up for their streaming services and watch more shows. They're doing it by just stuffing ads in more places.
1:02:35 Speaker 04 More ads, more fun.
1:02:37 Speaker 05 This is why, this is, this is a death spiral. This is the same death spiral as the Samsung Frame TV. Eventually you're going to be happier when the TV is off and eventually you're not going to have it at all.
1:02:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, this is a way of suggesting that like, okay, we can't actually win this game on its merits. So we're just going to bleed you on the way out.
1:02:54 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:02:54 Speaker 04 And that's a bummer. Better news. HBO Max rolled out a new thing that it calls channels, which is basically just endless feeds of your favorite show. This is the best idea I've ever heard in my entire life. So I'll just read you the lists of the shows. So there are based, there are 12 themed channels. Some are themed like adult animation, true crime and holiday specials. But then the ones that I'm very excited about are just endless running 24 hour feeds of shows like Friends, The Lord of the Rings, Rick and Morty, The Sopranos, Game of Thrones, The Big Bang Theory. It's basically, this is the hotel room experience where you roll into a hotel room and you're like, okay, what episode of The Office is on?
1:03:40 Speaker 04 I'mma watch it. That is ideal television. Neel, as we have discussed, most of my TV watching is just, I like six shows and I will watch any episode of them at any time. Just inject this into my veins. I'm going to turn on HBO Max. It's going to be like, we have an episode of Friends for you. Do you want to watch it? And I'm gonna say, yeah. And it's gonna say, do you care which one? I'm gonna say, no, I don't. It's a dream. This is cable again. We're just doing cable, but what if it's only shows I like?
1:04:08 Speaker 05 It's cable, it's just vastly more expensive. This is like MTV just canceled Ridiculousness, which they were just showing over and over again for, for five years. I think they've only shown Ridiculousness and it's because they did the math and spending money on any new show was too risky compared to the guaranteed audience. And people are just like, screw it, Ridiculousness. And then I think they got mathematically to the point where even buying new episodes of Ridiculousness was less worthwhile than just running their enormous existing catalog of Ridiculousness.
1:04:38 Speaker 04 Speaking of death spirals.
1:04:39 Speaker 05 Very good.
1:04:40 Speaker 04 But this, I just want to say, we're, I think we're about to say some mean things about HBO Max. But I just want to say HBO Max has done two, three very good things this year as part of a total disaster of a company. They went back to being called HBO Max. Kudos. They switched to the correct reviews format on the internet, which is two thumbs up, one thumbs up and thumbs down. That is the only review system that should exist on the internet. Love it, like it, nah, perfect. And this, the channels, great job HBO Max. I'm so sorry you're going to be dead in six months.
1:05:14 Speaker 05 I would say, I would say again, in, in a sense that everything just proves that I'm right. One strategy.
1:05:21 Speaker 04 The thesis of the Vergecast.
1:05:23 Speaker 05 Everything is confirmation bias. That's my 2026 editorial strategy.
1:05:30 Speaker 05 Trying hard is an option.
1:05:33 Speaker 05 It's a choice you could make. You could try hard. I will point to AT&T tried to buy T-Mobile. The government blocked it. T-Mobile did receive a giant breakup deal and then they tried hard. They hired John Ledger and they tried hard. And now they are in fact, everyone's favorite Wow Scare because they tried hard.
1:05:47 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:05:48 Speaker 05 Whereas if they'd bought, been purchased by AT&T, I think maybe that would have not happened. In fact, I can guarantee that would have not happened.
1:05:56 Speaker 04 It is really true that do a good job is a remarkably unexplored option in most markets.
1:06:02 Speaker 05 Every time. We're going to talk about Amazon buying Ira out here and like do a good job was just not on the table.
1:06:10 Speaker 04 Okay. So all of this brings me to.
1:06:11 Speaker 05 But can I just connect that to one other headline here?
1:06:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:06:14 Speaker 05 Instagram is putting the Reels app on TV because everyone just wants to be on their TV. One of these companies is going to figure out that the actual experience is building a TikTok discovery app on your phone. That you're just like, get into the middle of some movie that's in their catalog and you push a button and it starts playing on your TV. That's all I want.
1:06:33 Speaker 04 Yes, 100%.
1:06:35 Speaker 05 I don't want the HBO Max app on my phone to have HBO Max in it. I want it to be a TikTok feed of clips of movies that are on HBO Max. And I'm like, screw it. I'm watching The Dark Knight again.
1:06:45 Speaker 04 I 100% agree. I could, I literally could not agree anymore with that take. And Netflix is probably best set up to do this. And there are like glimmers that Netflix actually might get this. They've done some of this stuff in various places. But like, yeah, forget the guide, forget showing me the icons. I want to open the thing up and I'm just going to flip through clips until I find something that seems cool. And then I press play and it shows up on my TV. That's the remote of the future, man.
1:07:09 Speaker 05 That's the game.
1:07:10 Speaker 04 I'm so in.
1:07:11 Speaker 05 Someone's going to figure it out.
1:07:12 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:07:12 Speaker 05 It's not going to be Paramount.
1:07:14 Speaker 04 I was going to say it's super.
1:07:15 Speaker 05 Paramount Plus hasn't figured out starting the stream within five minutes of pressing play.
1:07:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, tell me about it.
1:07:22 Speaker 05 They also haven't figured out what any of the characters on Landman should be doing here in season two. I'm just, this is a better side.
1:07:28 Speaker 05 There is your argument against letting Paramount Plus, like Warner's, watch, watch this season of Landman and be like, this company was like Taylor Sheridan, knows how to write a TV show.
1:07:39 Speaker 04 All right, let's, let's get to the game I want to play here. It's been a minute since we have revisited the go 90 scale of streaming services. And we're just going to do that.
1:07:48 Speaker 05 Here's my question. Do Billy Bob Thornton and Ali Wutter like each other on that show? It's unclear, yet they just keep banging away. Go ahead, go ahead.
1:07:57 Speaker 04 Okay, I have to tell you, your, your pitch for Landman recaps as our new podcast within a podcast has been resoundingly rejected.
1:08:03 Speaker 05 They might hate each other.
1:08:07 Speaker 04 I will, however, accept a pitch more geared around the various goings on of Billy Bob Thornton. But that's, we'll come back to that in 2026. For now, Travis Larchuk, our producer, come, come join us, Travis. Hello. Hi. So we have not revisited. The Go90 streaming scale.
1:08:26 Speaker 05 Oh, man.
1:08:27 Speaker 04 In a while, and it is time for us to do that here at the end of 2025.
1:08:31 Speaker 05 Maybe we should have been doing this every week.
1:08:33 Speaker 04 So Travis, you, as you or want to do, are not only our producer, but you are the vibe coder in chief of the Hurdcast, I would say. You've made something for us today.
1:08:43 Speaker 10 I've done more for vibe coding than anyone making vibe coding has done.
1:08:49 Speaker 10 I have made a Go90 scale that we can interact with. So here it is for the listeners.
1:08:58 Speaker 04 We have eight streaming services here and the scale, Neil, do you want to describe the origins of the Go90 scale?
1:09:05 Speaker 05 So Verizon once started a streaming service. It's called Go90. Their pitch was that you would join a gang. I believe it was a gang and that these gangs would roam their service. And then when you started watching a video, you would rotate your phone to fully experience the video, thus going 90. Go90 failed immediately. It went 90. It went. And so you see the scale is from zero, which is alive to 90, which is dead.
1:09:33 Speaker 05 Degrees, you understand? 90 degrees, you're dead because you're lying down. That's the Go90 scale of doom streaming services.
1:09:39 Speaker 04 It's very good. It has been very useful for us over time. And here at the end of 2025, we're going to put, let's see, eight streaming services on that list. So the eight are in no particular order. HBO Max, Peacock, Netflix, Paramount Plus, Apple TV, YouTube, Prime Video, and we're doing the Disney bundle, the Disney plus Hulu ESPN as all one thing.
1:09:58 Speaker 05 So just to iterate, zero is alive and 90 is dead. And the closer you are to 90, the closer you are to death. Many services have hit 90.
1:10:06 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:10:06 Speaker 05 Over the years. Famously, Quibi went 90 in just under 10 minutes.
1:10:10 Speaker 04 Yep. Quibi, there was a time that we needed to rename this the Quibi scale of streaming services. But Go90 is just too good a vision. So let's start with HBO Max because we were just talking about it. Travis.
1:10:25 Speaker 04 Where would you put this on the Go90 scale of streaming services? Knowing everything we know?
1:10:31 Speaker 05 Not streaming, no, no, of doomed streaming services.
1:10:34 Speaker 04 Get my branding right, Pierce.
1:10:36 Speaker 10 Listen, there's been a lot of doom and gloom around HBO Max, but a few weeks ago, they debuted a new TV show that is sweeping the internet called Heated Rivalry, about two professional hockey players who are secretly in a relationship with each other. And let me tell you, as a person who's been gay his whole life, this has been crazy to watch. And so I cannot in good conscience, put this anywhere past 60 on the scale. So that's where I'm starting at.
1:11:13 Speaker 04 So I've not watched one second of the show, but it has been everywhere. And it's one of those shows that shows up all over my various feeds and it's all just like two hockey players sort of smoldering. Like, I couldn't tell you anything about the show.
1:11:26 Speaker 05 Wait, is this a reality show?
1:11:28 Speaker 04 No, it's.
1:11:28 Speaker 10 No, this is a drama.
1:11:30 Speaker 04 Okay. But is it just, it appears to just be nonstop sexual tension between hockey players.
1:11:36 Speaker 10 It's more than tension. It is full on Skinamax style butts in every episode. And the internet loves it. Yes.
1:11:48 Speaker 05 Okay. I guess you're skating. I always think of hockey players as a shoulder situation.
1:11:54 Speaker 10 It's both.
1:11:55 Speaker 05 I guess I've revealed a lot about how I think about hockey players.
1:11:57 Speaker 04 You have.
1:11:58 Speaker 05 I grew up in like, you know, Wisconsin's like Minnesota adjacent. There's a lot of hockey floating around.
1:12:01 Speaker 04 That's true.
1:12:03 Speaker 05 I lost to a number of hockey players in my youth, is what I'm trying to say.
1:12:06 Speaker 04 Okay, so Travis, Travis is capped at 60. I kind of feel like 60 is as low as I am interested in going. Because if this is all in the guise of going to Netflix, Netflix keeps saying that it's going to keep HBO Max alive, that it'll keep being its own thing. I have a very hard time imagining that's going to be the case. But I suppose it's going to be a while. Whatever, whatever will kill HBO Max is probably not going to happen in the next, let's say 12 months.
1:12:35 Speaker 05 85.
1:12:37 Speaker 05 So Travis is 60, I'm at 85. David, that means you get the final call.
1:12:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think we're gonna split the difference. We're gonna put it, we're gonna put it at like 75. Because I think, I think there is, it has begun its inevitable demise, but it's gonna take a while.
1:12:53 Speaker 05 Right, because 90 is actually dead. So we agree that it's not 90.
1:12:57 Speaker 04 Correct.
1:12:57 Speaker 05 It is not currently dead. Let us know if HBO Max is currently dead.
1:13:02 Speaker 04 You can only go 90 the once.
1:13:04 Speaker 05 You don't go back. You can live at 89 for a long time. So my argument is that death is imminent. But I think, I think death actually will take several years.
1:13:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think death is looming, but it's not, it's not yet in the room with us.
1:13:17 Speaker 05 75 is a good looming?
1:13:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:13:18 Speaker 05 Alright, fine.
1:13:19 Speaker 10 Heated rivalry did get picked up for season two, so, you know.
1:13:24 Speaker 04 That buys you at least another 12 months.
1:13:27 Speaker 10 Yeah, exactly.
1:13:28 Speaker 04 Alright, next on the list, uh, let's do one that definitely isn't going to be as high or higher. Let's go with YouTube.
1:13:37 Speaker 05 YouTube is at zero.
1:13:39 Speaker 04 Right?
1:13:40 Speaker 05 It's default alive forever.
1:13:43 Speaker 04 We were talking about this earlier, like, the, the sequence of things that I would have to imagine in order for YouTube to be above like a 20, seems essentially impossible.
1:13:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, there's no way.
1:13:54 Speaker 04 Like, you'd have to, you'd have to break up Google, there would have to be some gigantic economic catastrophe, like, so many, the, the heat death of the universe would have to be in range before YouTube would go away from a zero. Travis, any, any disagreement there?
1:14:10 Speaker 10 No disagreement on this end.
1:14:11 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:14:13 Speaker 05 What's the hockey player situation on YouTube, Travis?
1:14:16 Speaker 10 There are no gay hockey players on YouTube, so, you know what, for that reason,
1:14:21 Speaker 05 45, baby.
1:14:22 Speaker 10 I'm gonna put it at one.
1:14:28 Speaker 04 I'll allow it. Um, alright, next up, let's do, let's do Peacock next, the other one we were just talking about.
1:14:35 Speaker 04 Neelai, where do you land on this?
1:14:37 Speaker 05 Peacock is over a 45, but it is under 75. It's, it's in the, like, you're not default alive.
1:14:47 Speaker 04 I would have thought you wanted this to be in like the high eighties.
1:14:51 Speaker 05 Well, no, because they have the Olympics.
1:14:53 Speaker 04 They do have the Olympics.
1:14:54 Speaker 05 Right. And it's also like NBC just split up the company or Comcast just split off all the cable channels into MS Now and whatever CNBC rebrand exists that honestly makes it looks like a healthcare services firm. I don't know what that is. Um, uh, and they, they think the business is Peacock.
1:15:14 Speaker 04 Right.
1:15:14 Speaker 05 Right. Like Universal Studios and NBC Television and Peacock is the business and the cable networks are left to, I mean, when they do these splits in Hollywood, they refer to these like ancillary businesses as shitcos, which is very funny. Um, and so Peacock is more alive than not because they, they have executed the split. They got rid of the stuff they don't want. They're all in on this is the future, but then they have the taste that they have and they are still subscale, right? They're not as big as Netflix. They're not as big as YouTube. And they're going to put arrival ads on the home screen and basically bully you into watching the Olympics on it. Like that's closer to death than not, right? It's not, it's not a given that it will survive.
1:15:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:15:52 Speaker 05 But it is, they have more assets in their favor than not.
1:15:57 Speaker 04 Travis, what's your, what's your Peacock stance?
1:16:00 Speaker 10 My Peacock stance, they have the most popular reality TV show called The Traitors. So that's something.
1:16:08 Speaker 04 Isn't Love Island also on Peacock?
1:16:10 Speaker 10 Yes, it is on Peacock. There you go. They've got Love Island. They've got The Traitors.
1:16:16 Speaker 10 Yeah, but do they have gay hockey?
1:16:20 Speaker 04 My personal experience with Peacock is very weird because I watch Peacock a lot because.
1:16:26 Speaker 05 You have horrible taste in television.
1:16:28 Speaker 04 Well, no, it's because there was that run of NBC sitcoms that was like 30 Rock, The Office, Community, The Good Place, uh, New Girl, like they had this run of shows that are now on Peacock. And so I watch them a ton because it's like easy background viewing while I'm doing other stuff. I literally don't think I could name you a thing that has premiered on Peacock in the last like three years. It just doesn't, it's purely a library streaming service for me, which is very strange.
1:16:55 Speaker 05 Let me ask you the other, the most important, what are you doing when you like need New Girl on in the background? You say this a lot, and I think about like my day to day, and I'm never like, I'm doing something that requires New Girl.
1:17:06 Speaker 04 So I mean, this is all gonna reveal a lot about my personality.
1:17:11 Speaker 04 I generally will, like when, when a lot of people would listen to music, I will often just watch a show. So like if I'm cooking, instead of listening to Music Girl Podcast, I'll often just like put a show on. I usually play video games with the sound off and I'll watch a show.
1:17:29 Speaker 04 I do it while I'm cleaning. It's just like, it's, it's, it's background noise. And I would actually, you know, funny way, this has changed since we had kids, so we like, we're trying, we do less TV. So there's a lot more music in our house than there used to be. But like Anna with downtime will fill it with episodes of Law and Order SVU. And for me, it's NBC sitcoms from like the 2000 ish era. So that's where.
1:17:53 Speaker 05 Okay, here's my recommendation, my, my wholehearted recommendation and advice. Stop doing the TV shows while you play the video games. Instead, play very dramatic instrumental music. Playing Madden with explosions in the sky in the background is like, ah, it's very good.
1:18:10 Speaker 04 I used to exclusively write with the Pirates of the Caribbean soundtrack playing, and it made everything feel so sick.
1:18:18 Speaker 05 That's a streaming service I could get behind.
1:18:20 Speaker 04 That's incredible. Just he's a pirate on repeat makes every blog post seem unbelievable.
1:18:28 Speaker 04 All right, I'm, I'm good with, I'm good with Peacock in the 60s. Travis, any, any objection? Love it. No objection. I think this is a great spot. Okay. I think it is a less good streaming service than HBO Max, but it has many fewer corporate shenanigans. So this feels about right. All right, let's do Prime Video next. This is a weird one.
1:18:48 Speaker 05 I'm putting Prime Video at 70.
1:18:50 Speaker 04 Really?
1:18:51 Speaker 05 Yeah. Yeah, higher than Peacock. There is just a chance they get bored.
1:18:56 Speaker 04 Yes, that's the case.
1:18:57 Speaker 05 Meaningful chance that Amazon is like, whatever, we resell Apple TV and Peacock here. We do not need to make any of our own stuff. So I guess I'm splitting this. The idea that Prime Video exists as a reseller of content and video store.
1:19:10 Speaker 04 No, this, we're talking like original streaming service.
1:19:12 Speaker 05 Like Prime Video, the thing that makes Fallout?
1:19:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:19:14 Speaker 05 It's definitely 70. There's a very high probability that Amazon just gets bored of being in this business. It sucks.
1:19:21 Speaker 04 But they just paid all this money. They paid all this money for MGM and they paid a bunch more money for Bond. Like for James Bond alone, you would think Prime Video would have some runway.
1:19:29 Speaker 05 This is like, this is like 10 minutes of Amazon retail sales. Who cares?
1:19:32 Speaker 04 I mean, that is true. I never watch Prime Video. Travis, do you?
1:19:37 Speaker 10 I do watch some Prime Video. I will tell you that they had a movie called Red, White and Royal Blue about the president's son getting into a relationship with a Prince Harry type figure in the UK.
1:19:53 Speaker 05 We have to start a show where Travis just recommends what to watch.
1:19:57 Speaker 04 This is our new podcast.
1:19:58 Speaker 10 Not hockey players, though.
1:20:02 Speaker 05 Oh, I see.
1:20:03 Speaker 10 So I would put them a little bit higher on the scale, maybe a 72.
1:20:08 Speaker 05 You get like the two point penalty for not hockey players?
1:20:11 Speaker 10 Yep.
1:20:12 Speaker 05 All right. That's amazing. If they made a show that was about like incestuous royal family shenanigans, but like some of them are hockey players, I'd watch that.
1:20:24 Speaker 04 And it would instantly bring you down five points on the scale.
1:20:28 Speaker 10 I also don't like that Mr. Beast has a show on Prime Video. I'm not a huge fan of that. So I'm happy with them where they are there.
1:20:38 Speaker 05 I will say that I went to watch the first episode of the new season of Fallout. I really enjoyed the first season of Fallout. And I watched it and I was like, I have no recollection of what happened during this first season.
1:20:48 Speaker 04 Same.
1:20:49 Speaker 05 So now I have to watch all the first season again, because bizarrely, all the recaps are bad.
1:20:53 Speaker 04 That's how I feel about Stranger Things.
1:20:55 Speaker 05 Yeah. And there's something there where they, they make these shows and they're events in the minute that they're live and then they just vanish from your brain.
1:21:03 Speaker 04 Yeah. Every time I watch an episode, I'm like, this is really good. And then like four hours later, if you were like, what happened in that episode? I'd be like, I don't, I got nothing.
1:21:10 Speaker 05 Yeah. I just, I could not tell you what happened in the first season of Fallout.
1:21:13 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:21:14 Speaker 05 Okay, so yeah, that's the argument that they survived like just people being like that show is good, right? I should watch it again about keep them alive.
1:21:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, I would. I would have put it lower just because Amazon so thoroughly doesn't need to worry about the money from Prime Video, but the the risk of like, and this has been true forever, that at some point, if Andy Jassy ever needs to cut budgets, this is the obvious one he will cut.
1:21:40 Speaker 05 I say 70. We've been moving between 67 and 72. We split the difference.
1:21:44 Speaker 04 Split it at 70. All right.
1:21:47 Speaker 04 All right, deal. Next on the list, Paramount Plus.
1:21:56 Speaker 04 Yeah, I will hear nothing lower than about 85.
1:21:58 Speaker 05 Put it at 89.
1:21:59 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:22:00 Speaker 05 Uh, yeah, based again, just on the total incoherency of Landman season two. And on top of that, they've lost Taylor Sheridan. They took, you know, history's greatest writer of women and lost him somehow. Um, 89. This is this is a company that they're lost. They don't know what they're doing. And even like, you know, I have like very conservative family. That's like, what is going on with this show? It sucks now.
1:22:24 Speaker 05 That's all I'm saying. No taste. Zero taste.
1:22:27 Speaker 04 Yeah, this is the thing that like, the its backer has so much money and is so much pride, right? Like David Ellison is will will keep this thing alive as long as he possibly can. But like, what what on earth is there on Paramount Plus for anybody at this point?
1:22:44 Speaker 05 I'm sure we're gonna get notes from people who watch Paramount Plus all day. There's a universe of.
1:22:48 Speaker 04 They're Star Trek. We always hear from people who love Star Trek.
1:22:51 Speaker 05 Star Trek is there. There's apparently there was a Matlock reboot.
1:22:54 Speaker 04 They have the Mission Impossible movies. They're stuck.
1:22:57 Speaker 05 Top Gun is there, but there they have the smallest catalog, the smallest service.
1:23:03 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:23:06 Speaker 05 It is not yet clear whether they can execute well and make much watch things. They don't have the Olympics. It's messy over there, man.
1:23:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. Yeah, I agree. Eighty-nine feels right to me.
1:23:18 Speaker 05 I think eighty-nine is a little too high.
1:23:20 Speaker 04 As you said, you can live at eighty-nine for a long time, but like eighty-nine suggests that to me that there is no, there is no path back. Like you are, this is, it's not getting better, but you can stay at this place for a long time. And that's how I feel about Paramount Plus.
1:23:35 Speaker 05 I would give them the eighty. Eighty-nine suggests like tomorrow it's gonna die. No, as you said, you can live at eighty-nine for a long time. Travis, yeah, Travis.
1:23:46 Speaker 04 Where in the eighties?
1:23:47 Speaker 05 What's the hockey player situation on good old Paramount Plus?
1:23:50 Speaker 10 In terms of Star Trek, they did just announce that Strange New Worlds, which I think is widely agreed to be the best new Star Trek content, ever since they started putting things back on television, is ending after its fifth season. So it seems like we have maybe two years left there. So I would, I would put it at an eighty-five.
1:24:14 Speaker 05 Sure.
1:24:15 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:24:16 Speaker 10 There are no hockey players on Star Trek.
1:24:19 Speaker 04 Taylor Sheridan's gone.
1:24:20 Speaker 05 This is a Star Trek reboot I would watch. We've landed on a planet of hockey players.
1:24:26 Speaker 05 I don't, I'm not, I'm not tracking by any stretch of the imagination.
1:24:30 Speaker 10 Beam me up.
1:24:31 Speaker 04 Fun.
1:24:36 Speaker 05 Why did this get me so bad? We gotta end the show.
1:24:42 Speaker 04 Oh, boy. All right. Three more to do here. We're all gonna recover. It's gonna be okay. Let's do the Disney bundle.
1:24:49 Speaker 10 Great.
1:24:50 Speaker 04 Which I think is also very.
1:24:51 Speaker 05 From Beam Me Up.
1:24:55 Speaker 05 I think it's unfair that you bundled these.
1:24:57 Speaker 04 Really? Why?
1:24:58 Speaker 05 Because Hulu is at eighty-nine.
1:25:00 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's why I bundled it. Like, I'm, I'm, I'm, like, it is.
1:25:04 Speaker 05 Disney Plus is at zero and Hulu is at eighty-nine. Like, how do you, it's at forty-five.
1:25:09 Speaker 04 Hulu, I think Hulu is at like eighty-nine point, even Disney would tell you Hulu is a dying entity and will eventually just become a tile on the Disney Plus app.
1:25:16 Speaker 05 I'm just saying, in your thing, you have one thing that's at eighty-nine and one thing that's at zero. How do you place this tile?
1:25:23 Speaker 04 Okay, fine. Then we'll just call this Disney Plus. And, and then you can, you can be annoying because technically you can watch Hulu inside of Disney Plus. Like, sure. But this is Disney Plus. We will just call this Disney Plus.
1:25:34 Speaker 05 Zero.
1:25:37 Speaker 04 I think that's.
1:25:38 Speaker 05 It's it's at zero.
1:25:39 Speaker 04 I think that's right.
1:25:40 Speaker 05 Again, it's their business. Now, Bob Iger is making some astonishingly stupid moves lately.
1:25:45 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:25:46 Speaker 05 I think licensing the IP to OpenAI, paying OpenAI a billion dollars in investment money and then giving the IP up is as stupid a move as I've ever encountered in all of our years of covering this business. At the same time, sending Google a cease and desist, like you know, it's worth some money, right? That's why you're threatening Google. You want to get paid.
1:26:08 Speaker 04 Right.
1:26:08 Speaker 05 But then idiotically, you've paid OpenAI to use your IP is nonsensical. If anything, you should do that in reverse. You should invest in Google, which is good at making money. So then you will get some money back. Investing in OpenAI is like, Sam, we're going to buy you some more runway to do nothing.
1:26:27 Speaker 04 But it's like, cool and fancy. And I think Bob Iger really likes being cool and fancy.
1:26:32 Speaker 05 I don't know. He's usually he's smarter. Like, if you were like David Zaslove, it's like Sam Altman can have a billion of my dollars and all of the rights to Batman. You'd be like, yep, he's an idiot. Iger's usually a little bit smarter than that.
1:26:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:26:44 Speaker 05 Yeah, but that's the argument away from zero for Disney Plus, but it's their whole business. They don't, there's not another bet. It's at zero until they waver from that bet.
1:26:52 Speaker 04 And to for what we were talking about earlier, like you could just do a good job. Disney continues to do a good job, right? Like, there is just, Disney owns Hollywood in a pretty meaningful way, still. Travis, you just made a face.
1:27:06 Speaker 10 Ah, I don't know. Have you poked around Disney Plus lately?
1:27:09 Speaker 05 Just wait till it's full of weird sore slop.
1:27:12 Speaker 10 I guess if you have kids, it's great.
1:27:14 Speaker 04 I know.
1:27:15 Speaker 10 Uh, I mean, if you like Disney movies and you like Marvel and you like Star Wars, great. Otherwise, there's not a lot of original stuff on there.
1:27:25 Speaker 05 If you're a young American.
1:27:27 Speaker 04 This is Taylor Swift's six-part era's tour documentary Erasure, and I will not stand for it.
1:27:32 Speaker 10 Fair enough.
1:27:33 Speaker 05 Should we have an entire conversation about how that documentary completely suffers from the lack of any critical distance whatsoever? I can do that for you all day and all night. That's the Vergecast, everybody.
1:27:42 Speaker 04 That's what we do. All right, two more. Let's let's blast through this and get out of here because I actually think both of these are pretty easy. Let's do Apple TV next. Apple TV, I think, kind of has to go next to Prime Video for exactly the same reasons. It is the exact same thesis.
1:27:59 Speaker 05 No, it's a little lower. It's it's over 45 for the thesis. But you know, they just redid the sounds. Pluribus is a hit. Eddie Hugh seems happy. You know, like, they're not going to get bored because they they like it.
1:28:14 Speaker 04 Sure. But again, for for the same reason, Apple is is a couple of executive turnovers away in a season full of executive turnover from all of the people who believe in this thing maybe not being there anymore.
1:28:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, but those
1:28:26 Speaker 04 Like, if Eddie Q leaves Apple, does Apple TV still exist like that?
1:28:29 Speaker 05 I will move the number if Apple, if Eddie Hugh leaves Apple.
1:28:31 Speaker 04 Interesting. Okay.
1:28:32 Speaker 05 Do you know what I mean? Like, if when when Tim Cook and Eddie Hugh leave shortly, when that's why I'm moving, that's why Prime Video is up. Because I think Jeff Bezos liked having a movie studio.
1:28:41 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
1:28:41 Speaker 05 I think Andy Jassy likes cloud computing.
1:28:44 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:28:45 Speaker 05 Apple, I think they, I think Tim Cook likes that he can summon Oprah. He can just do it. Like, very few people can summon Oprah, and Tim is one of them.
1:28:54 Speaker 04 That's true. Travis, you were saying a bunch of really mean things about Ted Lasso before we started recording. What do you think?
1:29:00 Speaker 05 I think not enough hockey players.
1:29:02 Speaker 10 The third season of Ted Lasso was bad. I'm not excited for the fourth season of Ted Lasso. I will say on Apple TV, there is a fantastic animated show for kids called Shape Island. If you haven't checked it out, definitely worth checking out. And the video that they put out about how they made the new Apple TV motion graphic that appears, have you seen this video?
1:29:26 Speaker 04 It's very cool.
1:29:26 Speaker 10 They actually made it physically. So that thing that you see when the app, when you, when you turn on Apple TV, the Apple logo going do, do, do, do, like, that happened in real life, which is pretty cool.
1:29:37 Speaker 05 Yeah, and they got Phineas to do that little sound. Yeah, this, I mean, they're not bored. They're they're like having a good time.
1:29:43 Speaker 10 They're having fun.
1:29:44 Speaker 04 They are. They do seem to be having a good time. I will give you that. All right. So this puts Apple TV at a 60. I feel all right about a 60. Travis, you feel good about a 60?
1:29:52 Speaker 10 I feel great about a 60.
1:29:53 Speaker 04 All right. And then last but not least, and I think maybe the single easiest one on the board, we have Netflix.
1:29:58 Speaker 05 Okay, so here's what I thought of Netflix. Based on the fact that we moved YouTube to a one due to its lack of hot hockey players. You put Netflix at zero. There's hotties on Netflix. And then I think you got to scoot D plus to one.
1:30:14 Speaker 10 Yeah.
1:30:14 Speaker 05 Right. Netflix is less dead than both YouTube and Disney Plus.
1:30:17 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:30:18 Speaker 05 Or or you you remove the penalty from YouTube, you put YouTube at zero, and you put both Netflix and Disney Plus at one.
1:30:27 Speaker 04 No, I think Netflix is for sure a zero.
1:30:32 Speaker 05 If Netflix is a zero, then I think YouTube is a zero, minus the hockey penalty.
1:30:36 Speaker 04 This was my assumption as we were coming in, was that it was gonna be Netflix and YouTube all the way at one end of the spectrum, and then mostly a fight on the other side of the spectrum. Like, the fascinating takeaway to me about this, and if you're listening, we'll post this graphic in the show notes so you can see it. But there's nothing in the middle. And this has been true for a while now. This stuff is so stratified now. Like, we have the winners of the streaming wars. I think it's Netflix, and it's YouTube, and then Disney, realistically, in this world, should probably be like a five, just because it hasn't sort of set the world on fire in the way that Netflix and YouTube have. They have more resources, they have more stuff, they have broader ambitions.
1:31:21 Speaker 05 When Disney makes a move, it's not like, ooh, right? Like, it doesn't reshape the industry, but Disney has Andor.
1:31:28 Speaker 05 You should sign up to Disney Plus just to watch Andor. It's very good.
1:31:30 Speaker 04 For sure. And yeah, and so I think, I'm fine with Disney plus landing at a one. Like, I'm not upset about that. But it is very clear, and this is like the stuff we were doing this week, that not only are YouTube and Netflix ahead, they're now sort of playing a different game than everybody else is.
1:31:46 Speaker 05 Well, to be fair, this list does not have the usual suspects in the middle. Right? Your Tubi and your Crunchyroll, which sort of like live at 45, aren't on here.
1:31:56 Speaker 04 Sorry, did you just call Crunchyroll a usual suspect in the streaming wars?
1:31:59 Speaker 05 When we've done this chart, Crunchyroll's been on the chart a long time. I don't even know if Crunchyroll's still alive. Did Crunchyroll go 90?
1:32:05 Speaker 04 This is why it's not on the list, buddy.
1:32:08 Speaker 05 Can you Google Crunchyroll?
1:32:10 Speaker 04 Crunchyroll is still around. So is Tubi, for that matter. And no, you're right, there are a bunch, but these are the players, right? Like, for a long time, this has been the perceived kind of A-list group of streaming services.
1:32:24 Speaker 05 Sure, yeah, I agree with that. I'm just saying, the usual things in the middle are not here, which is all the mid-tier stuff that is just sort of puttering along.
1:32:32 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's fair. I'll give you that. All right, Travis, any objections to any of this before we get out of here?
1:32:38 Speaker 05 Well, you gotta read it off for people.
1:32:39 Speaker 04 I will.
1:32:41 Speaker 10 Let's lock it in, David.
1:32:42 Speaker 04 Okay. So, on the Go90 scale of Doom streaming services, we have Netflix and YouTube at a zero. We have Disney at a one. We penalized and then unpenalized YouTube for its hot hockey players. And I feel okay about that.
1:32:57 Speaker 05 I'm confident you can find hot hockey players on YouTube.
1:32:59 Speaker 04 I'm sure you can. Please send Travis links to hot hockey players on YouTube.
1:33:02 Speaker 05 Don't do that. This is a workplace, everyone.
1:33:06 Speaker 04 We have Apple TV at a 60. We have Peacock at a 64. We have Prime Video at a 70. We have HBO Max at a 75. Those four together, by the way, feels very right to me. I actually like that both as like a group together and in the specific order. That feels good. And then we have Paramount Plus, I would say generously, at an 85. And that is the list of the Go90 scale of Doom streaming services at the end of 2025.
1:33:31 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:33:32 Speaker 04 Thank you both. Travis, your vibe coding is getting, it gets better every time.
1:33:36 Speaker 05 Travis, the next test is to make these games playable for everyone. I would love a version of this where everyone could play and there's like consensus.
1:33:43 Speaker 10 We invite all the listeners live in real time to move these things around the chart.
1:33:49 Speaker 05 Yeah, we can get there by the end of next year so that everyone can open up a good phone app and move the things around. And at the end, we like display it at a live show. Choice.
1:33:57 Speaker 10 Love Drive to the Verge.
1:33:58 Speaker 04 It's a good idea.
1:33:59 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:34:00 Speaker 04 All right, we're gonna take a break and we're gonna come back and do a live. We'll be right back. Bye.
1:34:05 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
1:34:15 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it, it wasn't.
1:34:22 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:34:35 Speaker 03 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
1:35:06 Speaker 08 Low energy, unfocused, foggy, you might be dehydrated. Gatorade Zero powders have been scientifically designed to help improve hydration balance in the body. With a clinically proven electrolyte blend and no artificial colors or flavors. Great tasting hydration, no matter where you're going. Shop now online or at retailers nationwide. Gatorade, hydrates better than water. Is it in you? Symptoms noted are signs of mild to moderate dehydration. Consult a healthcare professional if symptoms persist.
1:35:39 Speaker 09 Hey, Bose here. When your next track starts, listen for the decisions that the artist makes. The vocal pushed right up front. The bass that waits half a beat. That sample from a 70s underground gem. Every choice deliberate. With Bose, you'll hear it all. Your music deserves Bose.
1:36:08 Speaker 04 All right, we're back. It's time for the lightning round. Eric Gomez, I believe we have a sponsor this week.
1:36:12 Speaker 11 That is correct. This week's lightning round is presented by AWS. How leading businesses use AI for next level innovation.
1:36:21 Speaker 04 Neelai, we don't have to do Brendan anymore. Are you so excited? We did Brendan already.
1:36:26 Speaker 05 It's always one of my lightning round ones, right?
1:36:28 Speaker 04 I know. So you go first. What's outside of Brendan Carr as a dummy? Open your mind once again.
1:36:35 Speaker 05 Okay, this is a true, a true lightning round item.
1:36:38 Speaker 04 All right.
1:36:39 Speaker 05 In a piece of, only The Verge cares enough to break this story.
1:36:44 Speaker 04 Sure.
1:36:45 Speaker 05 A bunch of people who own LG TVs.
1:36:47 Speaker 04 Oh, God.
1:36:48 Speaker 05 Recently noticed that an icon for Microsoft Copilot appeared in their like WebOS doc.
1:36:57 Speaker 04 What?
1:36:57 Speaker 05 And they couldn't delete it. So this is obviously very bad. Like, first of all, your TV maker just like installing apps you can't delete is bad. Installing without asking, all very bad. Installing Copilot on TV is like so dumb. So.
1:37:13 Speaker 04 You start a show, it's like, did you want to make a spreadsheet out of this?
1:37:15 Speaker 05 So this story breaks, I kid you not, on the "are mildly infuriating" subreddit.
1:37:23 Speaker 05 Which is perfect.
1:37:24 Speaker 04 That's so good.
1:37:25 Speaker 05 It has 36,000 upvotes of people who just want to get rid of this thing. So what is the verge for? We do the reporting, we get the companies on the record, they say, they say what they say and they have to stand by it. That, that's what the money's for, that's why they pay this subscription. So we reached out to LG and they confirmed to us that they had in fact, put Copilot on all these TVs. But, and this is so sad, it's not actually an app. It's just a, like a browser shortcut, like a bookmark.
1:37:54 Speaker 04 Oh God.
1:37:54 Speaker 05 That opens the TV's built in browser and goes to Copilot on the web. Which is just the saddest, saddest AI integration of all time. First of all, can you imagine being on your TV and be like, what I really want to do right now is open the TV's built in browser? To go and use Copilot on the web. And also, the company that, that sold me this TV thinks that that should be on the home screen by default. Second, this is the worst outcome for WebOS in history. If you recall, WebOS, remember Palm reinvented itself with WebOS, they were like, the whole internet is the web. We're in a, our application environment is the web, this is the future of the phone, they collapsed and now LG runs WebOS.
1:38:32 Speaker 04 Cause it's a tough beat for web apps, that one.
1:38:33 Speaker 05 You know what I mean? It's real bad when you're like, well, it's WebOS, just do a web link. Anyhow, because we asked LG and we pushed them and they saw the stuff, LG has also confirmed, and I'm just going to read the quote. LG, quote, "Respects consumer choice and will take steps to allow users to delete the shortcut icon if they wish." So you can't delete it now, but due to LG's respect for, for consumer choice, they will take steps to allow you to delete the Copilot bookmark that opens the built in browser on your LG TV that they have placed in your dock by default.
1:39:06 Speaker 04 This is such Tim Robinson in a hot dog suit going, we're all trying to find out who did this energy.
1:39:11 Speaker 05 It's so bad.
1:39:12 Speaker 04 Oh my God.
1:39:13 Speaker 05 I love, I love that they're like, we just, people want, uh, they just want to open Copilot on the web.
1:39:18 Speaker 04 This also on the heels of a bunch of news about how all of Microsoft's AI tools are bad and nobody likes them. And it's just, it's a tough times.
1:39:27 Speaker 05 Antonio did another round for us. Microsoft put out a Copilot on Windows ad. It's always during football, so I always see it. They put out a holiday one where people are asking Copilot a bunch of questions about like, putting the other IKEA furniture. And there's one specific one. Where someone says, here's my HOA rules. Here's a picture of my holiday light display. Tell me if the light display meets the rules. And I saw that in the middle of just a devastating, heartbreaking Packers loss. And thought to myself, that can't do that. And you should not trigger that reaction to me in the middle of Packers game. Right? Like, I shouldn't be thinking Microsoft is lying in the middle of Packers game. That we're losing in which Michael Parsons got hurt. Like, I was like, Antonio, you're writing about this now. Uh, and it just absolutely can't do that.
1:40:11 Speaker 05 In fact, it can't do it to the point where one of the demos in the ad is, uh, how do I make my light sync to the music? And Copilot in the ad goes and opens an app called like Rela Cloud, which is a fake company.
1:40:27 Speaker 04 Oh, Jesus.
1:40:27 Speaker 05 It's one of Microsoft's, like, Microsoft has all these fake companies that they famously use in demos for years, like Contoso and all this stuff. Um, and it's one of those. So Microsoft is showing Copilot do a thing that you literally cannot do because it is just abstract nothing. How? This is all very bad. Like, I don't know what Microsoft is thinking. Like, not only can I not do it, what it's showing in the ads can literally not be done because it's showing things that are not real.
1:40:52 Speaker 04 Microsoft is like not the only company that does this. It's, everybody does this. Google runs ads that are like concept videos. Apple got in trouble because they did the, the Siri video with Bella Ramsey in which they did a bunch of stuff that you can't do with Siri. Like, this, this is a problem and everybody needs to stop doing this.
1:41:11 Speaker 05 Because it, in particular, the AI companies are just all in on pretending the AI is so much more capable than it is. To the point where it's trivial for us to assign the, can Copilot do this? Cause we just ask the same questions and it is obvious that it cannot do these things.
1:41:28 Speaker 04 Yeah. Um, all right. My first lightning round item is one of the most wacky controversies of the week. I don't know how much you saw this, but Blue Sky rolled out a new thing where you can import your contacts and see who else is on Blue Sky. Um, this is the sort of thing that like every social network does. So if you go on TikTok, it will relentlessly try to get you to upload your contacts to find people on TikTok. So this became sort of a mini controversy. I don't, again, I don't know how much this like crossed your path, but there were a lot of people who were like, don't do this. This is gross. I hate this. Why would you make me upload my contacts? I don't want to do that. Don't be like these other social networks. And Blue Sky then had to go way, way, way out of its way to be like, no. We've done this in a way that is useful and also privacy preserving.
1:42:12 Speaker 04 And basically, Blue Sky's case is the way that their system works, it only works if you've both uploaded each other's numbers. So it's essentially a sort of like half baked two way authentication system, right? So if I upload my contacts, it will only ping you that I'm on Blue Sky and me that you're on Blue Sky. If you also upload your contacts with my number in it. So if we have each other's phone numbers and we both upload our contacts to Blue Sky, Blue Sky will make the assumption that we probably want to connect because we are probably in some way also connected. That is one full leap better than all of the other services. It just is, right? Like if you upload your stuff to TikTok or Snapchat or whatever, it will snitch on all of those people
1:42:57 Speaker 04 and tell you who is there and what they're doing. I also don't think this is great still. Like I don't, I just, A, I think on principle, you should never upload your contacts lists to a service. Just period. I just don't think you should do that. But I also think like me, I don't know. What's your read on this? Is this the best you could do if you're Blue Sky? Or is this just a bad idea that they should stop doing?
1:43:20 Speaker 05 I think they did it in weird ways. Like you opened the app and it showed up in a way that reminded a lot of people of Facebook in the beginning. And so I think what people are reacting to is they don't want Blue Sky to be the big social platforms and make all those mistakes and act with the same dark patterns. And you can explain how technically it's different. And Blue Sky is always in the trap of explaining how it's technically different. It just is. And because it hasn't meaningfully federated yet, like there isn't another service on that protocol that's as big as Blue Sky. You know what I mean? Like until the thing happens and they've proven out that their decentralized model actually enables all this other stuff. And if you hate them, you can leave. Then they're just, they're just running Twitter again.
1:44:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:44:03 Speaker 05 Hearing all Twitter's problems and like, that sucks. And I don't think they want to. I think they're actively trying to make people so mad at them that they go and build other protocols or other apps on that protocol. But yeah, this one's weird. They need to grow, like in a very real way, they need to grow. They're small. They're not growing as fast as they were before. I heard a rumor that every single day Threads onboards one full Blue Sky.
1:44:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:44:24 Speaker 05 But Threads is just not, not relevant in any way, but Blue Sky has some relevance. So they need to grow, they need to grow faster. This is one way to do it, but I, I think as you and I have both mentioned on the show dozens of times now, all the growth in social network is not by people finding their friends. It's by finding other interesting accounts.
1:44:39 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:44:39 Speaker 05 Like, that's not what public social networking is for anymore. Your friends are all in your DMs. So I don't know, I just don't know why this was their idea. They should make discovery across the network much more interesting. Cause that's where I think you'll get growth and you'll get what you want, which is organic growth by people saying, I saw this on Blue Sky and other people saying, okay, I need to sign up for Blue Sky account.
1:44:57 Speaker 04 Yeah, I agree. And Blue Sky has had good ideas about this, right? Like it did the starter packs thing that everybody has since copied. Like this sort of, how do you find stuff on this network thing? Is actually something Blue Sky seems to have some aptitude for. And I totally agree. It's like, find me good stuff. Lean into this idea of lots of different algorithms and lots of different feeds and like, show me more things on Blue Sky. Don't try to like, make me find my high school friends. Like, I don't know.
1:45:22 Speaker 05 The real win, right, is when Blue Sky is more connected to the other networks. And when other networks are more connected to Blue Sky. Because what you want is for Threads and Blue Sky to actually be one big network that all work together and they're not close.
1:45:35 Speaker 04 Right. Someday, Neil, someday.
1:45:38 Speaker 05 I'm a believer.
1:45:39 Speaker 04 All right. What's your next one?
1:45:42 Speaker 05 It's CES time, David, which means we are, we are but weeks away from will I am, America's foremost tech innovator, will I am, announcing yet more products. And so it is only befitting that we check in on will I am's previous CES announcements from last year. And so you might recall America's foremost car audio innovation, will I am's M box sound drive.
1:46:05 Speaker 04 No, I don't. Where have you been?
1:46:08 Speaker 05 What rock have you been sleeping on?
1:46:10 Speaker 04 I know, it's crazy.
1:46:10 Speaker 05 Uh, M-Box Sound Drive announced at CES last year was a feature in Mercedes-Benz EVs whereby every time you accelerated or braked, the car, the M-Box system, would dynamically generate orchestral music as you drove.
1:46:28 Speaker 04 What?
1:46:29 Speaker 05 Yep, this is a real thing. And they announced this with great fanfare. Will.i.am's M-Box Sound Drive.
1:46:34 Speaker 04 That sounds like-
1:46:35 Speaker 05 Will.i.am said the feature turned the whole car into its own orchestra. You selected Sound Drive through the infotainment screen, and then you would, in-car signals would enable the music playing to react to the car in real time. So, so driving a movie, that was the idea.
1:46:50 Speaker 04 On the Mount Rushmore of solutions looking for a problem, we might have to make room for M-Box Sound Drive. That is, that's for no one, ever.
1:46:59 Speaker 05 It launched with 30 pre-selected tracks, although Mercedes wanted it to be an open music platform for other artists to participate in. In the context of our ongoing review and further strategic development of our portfolio of digital extras, we have decided to deactivate M-Box Sound Drive and remove it from our offerings at the end of this year.
1:47:16 Speaker 05 This adjustment allows us to continuously optimize our offerings and focus on developing future-oriented innovations. You have been killed in the most corporate way possible, M-Box Sound Drive.
1:47:28 Speaker 04 I'm sorry, Andy Hawkins wrote about this for us, and I'm just reading his story now. And Andy calls it a fun but superfluous gimmick, and then writes this, "For example, if you slow down, the vocals would fade, and when you accelerate, the bass kicks harder." Andy, I love you, that is neither fun nor superfluous. That sounds awful. That sounds like actively unpleasant. Be like, "Oh, I'm stopping at a stoplight, and the music's gonna get quiet." That's not what I want.
1:47:50 Speaker 05 There's a notable friend of the show who I love very much, they know who they are, and they are the ones who forwarded me the email from Mercedes saying it was canceled. And I was like, "Dude, you had this?"
1:48:03 Speaker 05 So very good.
1:48:04 Speaker 04 That's awesome.
1:48:05 Speaker 05 Um, uh, also, I didn't realize this. M-buck's sound drive was not running locally in the car. It was streaming from the internet, which is why Mercedes killed it.
1:48:16 Speaker 05 Like, think about this. Will.i.am was like, here's my idea. When you drive, the bass kicks in harder when you accelerate, which is a perfectly Will.i.am thing to say.
1:48:24 Speaker 04 Yes, it is.
1:48:26 Speaker 05 Fine. And Mercedes was like, the way we're going to implement this is not by making that happen on the car. We're going to send data about your car to the cloud where we will dynamically generate music and then stream it back to the car. That is an open platform that artists will participate in. Less than one year later, they're like, that was stupid. And they shut it down because no one was using it.
1:48:50 Speaker 04 Do you think someone at Suno is looking at this and being like, we can do this with AI? What if, like?
1:48:55 Speaker 05 Look, Will.i.am is going to be at CES. And he's going to say some AI stuff and, you know, anything could happen.
1:49:03 Speaker 04 Like, we talk a lot about, you know, the Sam Altman's and Elon Musk's of the world, who are like, maybe their greatest skill is just being able to raise money at all times. Will.i.am deserves a spot in that conversation.
1:49:14 Speaker 05 We've been doing this for so long.
1:49:16 Speaker 04 Do this.
1:49:17 Speaker 05 We've run multiple Will.i.am is the kiss of death stories.
1:49:23 Speaker 05 Like, over the past 15 years, I'm guessing it's at least three. Don't let Will.i.am near your tech product stories.
1:49:31 Speaker 04 Yeah. Um, all right, my next one is, um, so one of the stories you and I have been talking about that I think is like a big theme of 2026 is basically how do we computer?
1:49:42 Speaker 04 The, if, if there's this big bet happening on all these new interfaces and all of these new app store-like things and all these new services that this, if the question is, how is AI going to change our computers? If you grant the premise that it's going to, what is it going to look like? And there is just like an infinite number of ideas.
1:50:02 Speaker 04 But all of them right now are chatbots. And so there was a bunch of news this week. The Alexa.com website is live. You can now do a bunch of Alexa plus interacting on Alexa.com. It's not alive. It's not live for everybody, but it's live for a bunch of folks on our team, which suggests that it's probably live for a lot of folks.
1:50:21 Speaker 05 It's not for me. Yep, it's just a chatbot.
1:50:23 Speaker 04 It's just out there. It is just a chatbot. You can do some Alexa things through it. Part of the idea is like you can control your house through the website in the same way that you would through the app or on the speaker like.
1:50:34 Speaker 05 That's a good idea.
1:50:35 Speaker 04 These things are fine. There's also the ChatGPT App Store is now out. There's a bunch of like Instacart and DoorDash and a bunch of other things you can now do inside of ChatGPT.
1:50:47 Speaker 04 The biggest one of all, I think, I've been talking to a lot of people about like, how do you put AI into your app? And over and over, people keep telling me, we spend all of our time talking about the the pro models and the stuff at the high end of things and the really expensive things, but it's the small, eventually local AI models that are going to be the thing that actually work for everybody, everywhere. Like it's going to run on your device. It's going to run offline and whoever builds that good first is going to be the one who wins.
1:51:15 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:51:15 Speaker 04 And so in that vein, Google launched Gemini three flash, which is the the little version of Gemini, much cheaper to run, much faster, can run on more things. Developers are going to be able to use it for a lot of stuff.
1:51:28 Speaker 04 That, from what I hear, is going to be a big deal. Everybody I talked to is so very excited about Gemini. And I think we're about to hit a point next year where we have at least a set of models that is going to start to get better less quickly. So if you like are happy with Gemini, you're probably going to stay with Gemini. And Claude is out there doing stuff and ChatGPT is out there doing stuff. And MCP, the Model Context Protocol, that's being turned into a true standard and sort of used across the industry. And now I keep talking to these app developers who are like, okay, now we know what the technology is. Now we can just go build stuff with it and see what it can actually do, rather than just constantly like reinventing our whole tech stack because somebody put out a new model.
1:52:10 Speaker 04 So I think all of this is like, we're still just doing chatbots, but we are like very slowly pointing at something that might be after chatbots.
1:52:18 Speaker 05 Hayden wrote a piece for us this week and noted that all the big tech companies have stopped talking about AGI, or at least they've rebranded it because they can't do it. You missed the most important one.
1:52:27 Speaker 04 Where I missed?
1:52:29 Speaker 05 Amazon is integrating Alexa Plus with Ring doorbells. So it can like recognize who you are and then the person at your door will end up talking to a chatbot through your doorbell. Which is at once dystopian. I'll grant you the dystopia of that. Also, the funniest thing I can possibly think of. Like the endlessly cheery chatbot voice being like, that's a great idea, but have you considered?
1:52:54 Speaker 05 Like you might have been thinking about getting in, but have you considered getting the hell out?
1:52:57 Speaker 04 Are you gonna take David's package? Please don't do that. I'd love it if you wouldn't.
1:53:02 Speaker 05 It's very good. So for example, in Rings visually, I can already do this. So it can distinguish a person and deliver a uniform from someone casually stopping by and then it can talk to them differently. I'm dying to try this out. I'm also dying to invite Kevin Roost to my house to see if he can get my doorbell to fall in love with him.
1:53:23 Speaker 04 Kevin, you heard it here first. We'll have you anytime. I can give you Neil's address.
1:53:28 Speaker 05 This is kind of what you mean. They're like, Amazon's in the like, let's put a chatbot in it phase. Everyone else is like, okay, we have a thing that can do natural language interface and natural language output. We're going to put it in our app in the smallest, cheapest way we can, and that will enable some new things.
1:53:41 Speaker 04 Right.
1:53:41 Speaker 05 And that might be as far as this goes. That might be how the bubble pops.
1:53:45 Speaker 04 Might be.
1:53:46 Speaker 05 Cause all this agentic stuff, even this chat GPT app store is like, we, we're, we're, all next year, we're going to write about app developers doing the like small AI stuff to make your apps more interesting and the big model companies like on the risk of crashing the economy.
1:54:02 Speaker 04 Yeah. An experiment I'm very excited to run is I'm going to have chat GPT buy me groceries.
1:54:09 Speaker 04 I don't know what your household is like, but Anna, my wife, is very particular about groceries. She is the type who will like stand there and read the ingredients on every bag of granola to decide which granola to buy. Even though we've bought the same one the last 25 times we went to the grocery store. So I'm just going to go on Instacart and just be like, I want a bunch of stuff. Can you buy me some groceries? And we're just going to see what appears at my house and I could not be more excited about it. It's going to be a disaster.
1:54:31 Speaker 05 I'm excited for you, you know?
1:54:33 Speaker 04 Well, it's great because when I grocery shop, I get sort of a point by point review on all of the things that I bought when I get home. And now that's going to be Instacart's problem. It's going to be great. I'm thrilled.
1:54:44 Speaker 05 This is gonna go so badly.
1:54:46 Speaker 04 I will report back in the new year. Don't you worry. All right. What's your last one?
1:54:50 Speaker 05 Uh, I just want to briefly talk about Ford, kind of pulling back from EVs. You know, they announced this new stuff. Um, Jim Farley put out a thing. He's like, I'm restructuring the company. We're putting all of our battery capacity in a new energy storage division, which is like the thing you do when you invested in battery capacity, but you're pulling back in EVs. Do you have to kind of do the same thing? And they're saying they're gonna do more hybrids and all this stuff. But the one thing I want to call out is they they quote unquote canceled the F-150 Lightning and they're gonna put out a new one in this new fashion called ER EVs, Extended Range EVs.
1:55:22 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:55:23 Speaker 05 And everyone is like, they're giving up on the Lightning and they're gonna put an engine in the new Lightning. And this is just wrong. And the reason it's wrong is they're doing the thing that I think all of the pickup truck makers should have done with their pickup trucks in the beginning. They're gonna put an engine in the truck as a generator for the electric powertrain. So the engine is never gonna drive the wheels. And there's been other hybrids that work this way in the past. Actually, the Cybertruck was gonna do this. You know, they had to spend their engineering hours on the wiper instead, or whatever happened with that thing. Ram was gonna do this, but this is like a big idea that actually you need the range, you need the towing capacity in these pickups. And people have all kinds of feelings about pickups and maybe you're never gonna tow anything, but you still care about the towing capacity. I don't, I don't care.
1:56:06 Speaker 05 There's a reason people buy these trucks and these are the stats that people care about. And so the idea is you get vastly more efficiency from an electric powertrain. You're probably on it most of the time, but when you actually need to go on a road trip or you need to tow, you spin up the engine, you run the engine at the most efficient part of its power band. And you make electricity to charge battery and run the powertrain. And this is like a genius idea. And I know it's a genius idea because this is how every diesel electric locomotive in the world works. Right? Like, this is actually a very solid problem. There's a really interesting company in Canada called Edison Motors. It's a startup. It is like retrofitting semi trucks this way.
1:56:48 Speaker 04 Right.
1:56:48 Speaker 05 And they're running into like weird regulatory problems because the Canadian government wants to like regulate the engines as engines and not generators. And there's no framework for them being generators and like it's fast. You should follow them on TikTok. It's a fast thing to watch them figure it out. But this is the idea. And so I actually would. Look at this and say Ford is finding a way to park a bunch of its EV investment into energy storage because you know, the regulatory environment has changed and they have done the thing that they should have done and managed to play it off as back walking back from EVs in a way that probably makes the Trump administration happy and whatever political noise, culture war about EVs like calm down, but they're actually still shipping an electric truck. They're just adding the feature to it that they maybe should have
1:57:33 Speaker 05 had from the beginning that everyone else has been circling. Scout Motors, other startup truck company, they're going to do an ER EV with a generator powering the electric powertrain. That's the solution to the range and you just get to run the engine way more efficiently, which obviously helps with emissions, all this other stuff. But it's like, you can see a lot of cars are going to get there instead of being true hybrids. I think it's super fascinating.
1:57:53 Speaker 04 That seems like, yeah, that seems like a good outcome. It's definitely a less ambitious version of the EV, but it also seems like we spent the last few years realizing maybe we overshot on the idea of what we were going to be able to do out of the gate.
1:58:06 Speaker 05 I think a lot of people are going to end up buying these ER EV trucks and never run that engine. And then they might realize they don't need the engine at all.
1:58:13 Speaker 04 Yeah. All right. My last one is just a tiny bit of news that has made me think about our predictions conversation from the other day. The news is that Meta is pausing its word, pausing its program to license out its VR operating system to other manufacturers. I find this very funny because this suggests that there are other hardware manufacturers who are interested in licensing Meta's VR operating system. But it's also just a fascinating moment in sort of the whole Metaverse project at Meta, right? Like Meta built out a huge amount of resources and infrastructure to make the Metaverse happen. They were all
1:58:57 Speaker 04 in, they did Horizon, they bought game studios, they started doing the hardware. Like for a really long time, Meta was not only the company most invested in doing the Metaverse, it was kind of propping up the rest of the industry by itself. It was making the hardware, it was making the software, it was building the games, it was buying any good game that came out. Like Meta was Just determined to brute force this thing happening. And then the meta Raybans were a hit and AI started to happen. And it feels like all of the momentum for the metaverse, both in and out of meta is just gone. And so now I'm like, okay, if I had thought about it, one of my 2026 predictions should have been that the whole metaverse idea is just gonna die.
1:59:40 Speaker 04 Because it feels like, again, like we were talking about with the streaming services, like if you eventually have to look around and be like, oh, look at this thing we're spending a lot of money on. It's that is completely ancillary to our business. Let's spend our money on something else. It would have to be the metaverse, right? Like, at what point does Mark Zuckerberg just say, we're doing glasses? And we're doing AI and let that be enough. Goodbye.
2:00:00 Speaker 05 I mean, they will tell you. Andrew Bosworth, the CTO of Meta, who runs Reality Lab, will tell you that it's still going strong.
2:00:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, that's what they, even in their statement, pausing the thing, they say, we're gonna, we're gonna, you know, re-investigate this as the category changes. Sure.
2:00:19 Speaker 05 Yeah, no, you're right. It's, it's dead. They, they just, Mark Zuckerberg can't lose that much face that fast.
2:00:25 Speaker 05 Right? Because that would put a lot of heat on his AI investments. Because everyone would be like, well, you just sell this on the metaverse. We sold our money. Are you gonna be right about AI? Isn't this bubble popping? So I think, I think he's got to keep face over here. I will continue to say, I think everyone is deeply confused about why the meta glasses are popular. They just like having a camera that's convenient. They do not like talking to Mark Zuckerberg's AI.
2:00:48 Speaker 04 I agree with that.
2:00:50 Speaker 05 But I think Meta is deeply confused about that. I think they think they can shoehorn in an AI assistant to their camera glasses in a way that is just not gonna happen.
2:00:59 Speaker 04 Well, and what's funny is I think, I think a display will add something in a meaningful way. And I think that will confuse everybody even further that actually what everybody wants is AI on that display. And I think they're wrong.
2:01:11 Speaker 05 Yeah, I mean, I know people who bought the display glasses and they they're like, why did I do this?
2:01:16 Speaker 04 Well, they're not any good, right? But that's, that's, that's a solvable problem.
2:01:19 Speaker 05 Is it?
2:01:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
2:01:21 Speaker 05 Let's go through the stack once again to make the display glasses.
2:01:24 Speaker 04 We're two hours into this first casting.
2:01:27 Speaker 05 Put up the vibe coded chart. Let's go.
2:01:30 Speaker 04 But no, I, I agree that you're right. This, this is a hard problem to solve and there is no guarantee that they will solve it anytime soon. But I just think, like, even if you think at this point, at the end of 2025, that you're Mark Zuckerberg, you have unlimited power and unlimited resources and you want to skate to where the puck is going. It's obviously not the metaverse anymore. Like, it just clearly, there's no case to be made anywhere that the metaverse is the next thing.
2:01:54 Speaker 05 So I have this underlying theory that Silicon Valley just desperately wants us all to be brains and bats. If they want it real bad, in a way that they, they talk about it more.
2:02:03 Speaker 04 Well, and eyes. You have to have eyes.
2:02:05 Speaker 05 No.
2:02:05 Speaker 04 They have to show you stuff.
2:02:06 Speaker 05 They can, they can screw with your optic nerves. Brains and bats.
2:02:08 Speaker 04 That's fair.
2:02:08 Speaker 05 They want the matrix.
2:02:09 Speaker 04 Yeah.
2:02:10 Speaker 05 And then, you know, then your, your entire life is just a series of databases they can control. I, right, this is another show. Anyway, the point of all this is the metaverse was the ultimate sort of pandemic fueled brains and bats fantasy. Like, everyone's home all day long. They're using the computer. All the numbers are up. What if I put them in a reality that I can control? And now there'd just be brains and bats. And it's like, yeah, then we all went back outside, bro. Like, sorry, like, I have no interest in this.
2:02:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
2:02:37 Speaker 05 And the one good thing that they bought was Supernatural, the fitness app, which people are still using and they're still sort of iterating on. But it's just sad to me that because they bought that company, that company isn't fighting for relevance anymore. Do you know what I mean? Like, if they hadn't bought Supernatural, would Supernatural be actually driving some sort of like more awareness of the art fitness? Would they be marketing? Would they be doing stuff? And like Meta is just like, we're not, you're fine. You're not spending a dime.
2:02:59 Speaker 04 Or would Supernatural have like loudly gone out of business and hurt the whole project for Meta?
2:03:05 Speaker 05 I feel like we should end here by calling out Jen's incredible reporting on iRobot this week. Which failed because both the American and European governments did not let Amazon buy it. Then they didn't do the thing they should have done, which is try to do a good job. And now they're being sold to a Chinese company. Yep. Jen, every ounce of that story, Jen has broken. You should go read all of it on the Verge.
2:03:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, it's very good. And it's a super sad story. We'll have to come back to that as that continues.
2:03:29 Speaker 05 And if you want to argue about the effects of antitrust law, it's like, it's all there for you. It's an inkblot test of how you feel about antitrust.
2:03:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, it's real. All right, but we need to get out of here. It's the end of 2025. This has been our longest Vergecast in a while. It feels good.
2:03:43 Speaker 05 Thanks, Brendan.
2:03:44 Speaker 04 Thing to end on. Yeah, seriously.
2:03:46 Speaker 05 I'll see you in Vegas, bro.
2:03:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, we're gonna stalk Brendan along the strip in Vegas and just see what happens.
2:03:52 Speaker 05 I'll outdrink Brendan anytime, anywhere. And I haven't been drinking for a minute, so it's gonna get messy.
2:03:59 Speaker 04 Listen, I'm getting three hours of sleep at night. I'm ready for whatever you got for me, Brendan.
2:04:02 Speaker 05 I'm gonna get so drunk, I only refer to him as the chairman derisively.
2:04:07 Speaker 04 I love that. But a couple of housekeeping things before we go. Again, Vergecast Live at CES in Vegas, January 7th, 3:30 in the afternoon at the Brooklyn Bowl. We'll put the link to RSVP with all the information in the show notes. Please come out. It's gonna be really fun. And a big part of it is just to hang. Like, Vergecast is fine. We like doing it. We'll talk about CES. But like, being there with all of you is the point. And that is very fun. It's one of the most fun things we did this year. I'm very excited to do it again. We're gonna have a blast. Also, we are gonna be gone as of Tuesday. We have the Holiday Spectacular coming up on Tuesday, which was a super fun episode that I'm very excited for everyone to watch and listen to. But you and I are done professionally forever. This is it.
2:04:51 Speaker 05 Get out of my face, Pierce.
2:04:53 Speaker 04 But there is, there's lots of Decoder to catch up on. If you all haven't listened to Neelai's Mailbag Decoder, in which he tells you all of his feelings about everything. It's delightful. I enjoyed it very much. I've known you a long time and actually learned some like instructive things listening to that episode. Also, some Virgin History coming out. There's gonna be a couple of Virgin History episodes on this feed, but all of the episodes are on the Virgin History feed and on the Verge's YouTube channel. So there's lots of stuff for you to do over the holidays.
2:05:18 Speaker 05 We're ending Virgin History, can I say it? Running with TiVo.
2:05:21 Speaker 04 Yeah, which I don't have favorites. I love all my children equally, but that, I have never had more fun making a Virgin History.
2:05:28 Speaker 05 That was a really good one. I mean, Walt with the iPhone 4 is a highlight.
2:05:31 Speaker 04 It was, it was very good.
2:05:33 Speaker 05 I mean, I'm just saying the ones I was on.
2:05:35 Speaker 04 TiVo, TiVo was a blast. It's a really good episode. I think you will, you will really enjoy it when it comes out in a few weeks. But until then, Neelai, we're out of here. It's been, it's been a year. God, has it been a year.
2:05:46 Speaker 05 Brendan.
2:05:46 Speaker 04 We both had kids this year.
2:05:48 Speaker 05 We did.
2:05:51 Speaker 05 And the kids are good, just in case you're wondering. They're fine.
2:05:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, things are good. I think neither of our kids like sleeping right now. So apologies for whatever that has done to us on this show and in general. But now we're gonna go hang out with our families for the holiday. I hope all of you have good holidays, too. You can always email us, vergecasttheverge.com, call the hotline, 866-VERGE-11. If Brendan Carr keeps being a dummy while we're out, we require you to tell us. You need to keep the information coming because the holidays may come, but Brendan Carr never stops. The Vergecast is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Show is produced by Eric Gomez, Brandon Kiefer, and Travis Larchuk. We will see you on Tuesday. And then in 2026, Neelai?
2:06:34 Speaker 05 Rock and roll.
2:06:37 Speaker 12 New and exclusive holiday decor just launched online at The Home Depot. Check out the viral Grand Duchess collection with smart holiday lights you can control from your phone. Easily customize the twinkle across trees, wreaths, and garlands to match your holiday vibe. Create stunning light effects, then switch it up with the tap of your fingers. Even the man in red will be impressed. Shop the holiday decor you want, online only, at homedepot.com.
2:07:07 Speaker 13 Close your eyes, exhale, feel your body relax, and let go of whatever you're carrying today. Well, I'm letting go of the worry that I wouldn't get my new contacts in time for this class. I got them delivered free from 1-800-CONTACTS. Oh, my gosh, they're so fast. And breathe. Oh, sorry. I almost couldn't breathe when I saw the discount they gave me on my first order. Oh, sorry. Namaste. Visit 1-800-CONTACTS.com today to save on your first order.
2:07:35 Speaker 06 1-800-CONTACTS. Online deal days are back at Kroger. Don't miss your chance for extra savings when you shop, pick up, or delivery. You can save $30 on your first online order of $75 or more with your digital coupon. Plus, enjoy unlimited free delivery by starting a Boost Free trial today. But hurry, these extra savings end October 20th. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Kroger, fresh for everyone.
Previous Everything is gambling now Next Version History: Google Glass Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated