The Standup with ThePrimeagen
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
ssh terminal.shop
11,268 words · 4 speakers
Today is episode 5 of the stand-up. We have 2 topics, 1 topic everybody knows about, and the 2nd topic, only 1 of our guests know about. I just went to the wrong side. Flip, fix it, and post. Alright, this side. Hey, so today's 2 topics, of course, are gonna be: Can you cheat on everything, and is that a good thing? This is following up with the whole Screw Lee Code website, and #2, we'll get to that topic. But, today, who are the guests? Introduce yourselves, starting up top!
I'm Tej.
Casey.
Trash.
Trash broke his toe in a judo competition, in case you're wondering.
That's alright, we're gonna find a way to slice that in right now. Here's the story.
I should just make it my virtual background. I broke my toe over the weekend, please ask me about it.
Put it on the whiteboard like me, dude. Put a message on the whiteboard.
I know, that's what I'm gonna start doing.
Just put a big picture of your toe back there. A big old swollen toe right behind you as you're talking.
Not gonna lie, my toes are ugly. They call me Frodo, not even kidding.
My friends call me Frodo Feet, cuz my feet are straight gross. I used to be self-conscious about it, but you know, I kinda just accepted it at the start.
Yeah, you gotta just accept it. Don't let people tell you how to live.
Okay, be honest. Is your password Frodo Feet?
Is it Frodo Feet?
Some letters overlap.
It's Frodo Feet 69, TJ. Alright, are you guys ready to start topic #1?
Yes.
Alright, for those that have not been a part of it, about what, about a month ago, a kid named Roy Lee, who was at the Engineering Columbia School of Engineering, came out with this how to cheat on a Lee Code interview. He went through an Amazon interview, showed it kind of live, did a YouTube video, caused a bunch of ruckus, and from there, a lot of tweets and all this, and then he created a website called F Lee Code. I bleeped that one. And recently, as of yesterday, there's been a new drop in update, and the new product he has created is called Cluey, which is gonna be to cheat on everything. That is the title. So, I pulled the manifest, I'll read through the manifest, and we can kinda discuss implications. We can kinda go wherever we want, right? So, Cluey manifesto. We want to cheat on everything.
Yeah, yes, TJ, I guess I won't read the manifesto.
I was just wondering, when are we gonna have a quick ad break for Big Pharma on CNN?
Sorry, you can keep reading.
After this ad break.
I really wish I had like that music.
Are problems with your toe preventing you from playing with your kids and doing the things you want to do? Well, you can take Froditus, a new medicine that will make your toes less gross and less swollen, so your kids won't recoil in fear.
Side effects may include death, amnesia, loss of family.
That's diarrhea. I'll take you from the back to CNN. You turn into a small hobbit. All right, back to you, Prime. Take it away, Prime. This is definitely going the direction I wanted it to go, so here, just like every stand-up. All right, part two. Yep, you heard that right. Sales calls, meetings, negotiation, if there's a faster way to win, we'll take it. We built ClueLY so you never have to think alone again. It sees your screen, hears your audio, feeds you answers in real time while others guess you are already right.
And yes, the world will call it cheating, but so was the calculator, so was the spell check, so was Google. Every time technology makes us smarter, the world panics. Then it adapts, then it forgets, and suddenly, it's normal. But this is different. AI isn't just another tool. It will redefine how our world works. Why memorizing, oh my gosh, why memorize facts, write code, research anything when a model can do it in seconds? The best communicator, the best analyst, the best problem solver, the best reader, I'm gonna add that one in there just for me, is now the one who knows, I could never use this product, I can't read, the one who knows how to ask the right questions.
The future won't reward effort, it will reward leverage. So start cheating, because when everyone does, no one is.
I don't even know what that last sentence meant.
It's sort of like trying to do like the line from The Incredibles. Like when everyone is super, no one will be. Well, it was kind of confusing even in that movie, although I did know what they meant. It's, it's just, it doesn't quite have, it's not quite the same as like with great power comes great responsibility. Where taken out of context, you're like, okay, I guys see what, you know, they were saying in the context of Spider-Man or Cheatly or whatever.
Do you think they're quoting from The Incredibles? Is that where they got this?
I don't know.
Yo, syndrome. What's our, what's our plan?
I mean, it's an AI thing, so they probably typed in, hey, give, well, let's put it this way. If that pitch wasn't created by AI, the whole pitch fails because that means this thing doesn't work. Like, he shouldn't have had to come up with that line. If it was created with AI, then the pitch doesn't work because the line sucks. So either way, bad pitch. That doesn't necessarily mean the product is bad, but the pitch, well.
A real catch 22 we found ourselves in, huh?
Seems like it.
I mean, I was feeling a little inspired in the beginning and then that last sentence kind of just left, left me with a huh? And now, now I don't care anymore.
Trash, you seem like our most morally depraved member of this panel. What is your thoughts about lying, cheating and being able to effectively get leverage as fast as possible?
You know, I don't really, so I was thinking about this, you know, when, after we first dropped it and it's, it's not really much different than what we do today. Like, I have conversations constantly where I'm just like, oh, let me Google that, which he mentioned in the thing we, we mentioned Googling and then we thought it was cheating. But it's just the faster way to get information, right? So it's not like I'm currently trying to memorize documents or anything. I'm still looking them up. It's just slower. So it effectively just makes me more efficient. I don't consider it cheating. What, what my main concerns was, was first when he dropped Interview Coder, I was like, great. Now I have to go into the office to do interviews.
Then he drops this and now it's like, I can't wear glasses anymore. Right, so it's like, so he just keeps taking everything away from me that I love, and I just kinda want him to stop. But also, the commercial, it was, it was really well done. Like, I thought, like, the production quality was amazing. Very Minority Report-ish. I have my doubts it's gonna be that good. Um, so we'll see. I don't, I actually, like, you know, we had the humane pin or whatever, whatever we had. I feel like it's gonna... Whatever, whatever. But I feel like it's gonna almost be that same scenario, where it's really hyped up, and then we're all kinda just gonna be let down. There's late, there's gonna be latency issues, right?
I'm not, I can't, I'm not always gonna have, like, internet to get the wifi. You can't read, you can't even use it prime.
Wait, wait, there are no actual glasses. That was just the...
No, but I assume that's kind of the ultimate...
There's no, no, you're imagining something so much better than what they're, they're, it's literally just a little AI bot screen capture thing. It doesn't do anything interesting.
So you can somewhere glasses, Trash. You're safe, dude. You can somewhere glasses.
Okay, thank the Lord, alright.
But you're only safe for right now, because honestly, meta plus this, I mean, it's only a matter of time. It's only just like a small year out before glasses are taken from you.
That's what I'm saying. But, but the situation still stands, right? Like, we all pretty much rely on these technologies currently to look up stuff. So it's, again, it's just an efficiency factor, right? So I don't, I really don't think it's cheating at all. I mean, I'm excited to use it.
Trash, is someone vacuuming at your place?
Oh, totally. Can you hear that?
Yeah, big time.
Big time. Classic stand-up.
It's really the stand-up, dude.
Sorry, everybody. I'll demo, I'll demo, I'll demo again after five minutes when the vacuuming stops.
So, uh, I'm, I'm not really very, the whole cheating angle, I've never really been that interested in. Like, I mean, I think it's fine for people to have that discussion, and I think I would refer viewers to the very first stand-up. If they aren't familiar with, there's, there's basically now what I would consider, I think what many would consider, a canonical diagram that was drawn by TJ. It was like, you know, that showed you exactly how to conceptualize cheating. But...
Putting that conversation aside, the more interesting thing to me is just like, from what I've seen from these AI things, when you use them, like, I've just kind of casually checked them out to see like, okay, what's sort of the level of quality I can expect from these things. They're wrong as often as they're right, is the problem that I see with them currently. What they do is they make something that sounds like a plausible answer. So it's usually, I mean, once in a while, you get things that are obviously wrong, like, it's like, you know, how do you make a pizza and you like, put glue on it, kinds of stuff, or whatever. So there are some things that are like, okay, you know, for models where they haven't really refined that space at all, and, you know, no one really tried it that hard at pizza,
so it didn't get corrected, then it could give something that's so wildly wrong that everyone knows it's wrong. But a lot of times, it's like, you know, if you asked it, you know, how many, you know, cycles does this instruction take on this CPU or something, it'll just make up an answer. And if you were not, if you didn't know how to go get the real answer yourself by testing or something, then that's really bad, actually. And so my concern is less cheating, and more that the more these get adopted, the less, because people already have trouble being actually connected to reality. They're sort of very wrong about a lot of things, a lot of times, especially in programming, but probably everywhere. And the more you rely on an AI answer, just like if you relied on just a top Google hit
and assumed that it's correct, it's just not, right? Wikipedia isn't always correct, Google isn't always correct, these AIs are even less correct than those a lot of the times. And so I feel like the real risk here with a lot of these things is just stupidity. It's like, it's gonna, people are gonna be more stupid even than they were, and that's not good. Right.
Hold my beer. I don't know, I might be definitely smarter.
We might be pulling trash to more towards the middle of the bell curve. It's good helping.
Okay. Poor trash. I don't know, I think the moral implications are kind of interesting in this, in the sense that...
It's one thing to look it up as information retrieval, right? So if you got on Google, it's not that you're getting on Google to portray that you're smarter. You're getting up, you're going on Google to find an answer to a question. Whereas in the presentation of all this, and in the manifesto, it's about gaining leverage over somebody. It's about being able to do something in real time where someone says something and you go, no, this, this, and this. You're able to look at them, you're able to say, read through the glasses, say, someone's facial features, their body language, and be able to get the one up inside of a thing where you're constantly analyzing them, constantly trying to take advantage of a situation. It doesn't necessarily feel good. And for me, what I ultimately see is that, that this is more of a conversation about
as acceptance and rejection, in the sense that I think there's a deep down need in people to be accepted and not to be rejected. And to be able to show yourself as someone who's intelligent, that has the right answers, to be able to get the things you want out of something, is all just some form of acceptance. And so this is just another way that you can put up a facade, not really you, because real you isn't good enough. You know, fake you that can read from a card, unlike me, you'd know right away if I was cheating because I'd read slow and incoherent. But it's like, you know, for the good readers, I feel like you're just effectively catfishing. You're just, you're just setting up a fake persona. And one could argue is like, isn't that something we do all the time as it is?
This just makes it more efficient, more accepting, and in some sense, more grandiose. And I'm not sure if that's like a place that I want it to be, like in life. So I'm more concerned in, in like the, the practical implications of what does this make people like in 10 years? Because if everybody has this, you literally don't get to talk to people anymore. You're talking to AI, because people have delegated even how they communicate and how they perceive the other person doing on the AI, not on yourself. That's a good point.
Could you imagine a debate where both me and you both have AIs backing this up?
Well, actually... Dude, it was just, it's literally just the fedora man 24/7. It's like, one of the last things I want anyways. You know, there's a fun part about just like being with people where you can't look stuff up are Wagners. Wild ass guesses that are not easily refutable. Like, that's just a fun part of saying things, being like, "Oh yeah, dude, 70% of software developers are." It's just like, you could just say things and it's kind of funny and then you get to argue over dumb stuff. Wagners are a hilarious part of life, but it's also kind of sad that like, that is something that's gonna go away.
Well, they're gonna have to train the, so, I mean, I'm just gonna predict that it goes one of two ways. If it gets widely adopted, or even probably to get widely adopted, something like this is probably gonna need a rebrand to be like, more about like, it's transparent and it's just an augmentation. I mean, it's like, to use Doug Engelbart's phrase, for example, "The augmentation of man's intellect" is what he called hypertext and things like this, right? That when those were first being created, this sort of idea that the computer would be a way to like, have all of the knowledge available to you as you were working. So, I could imagine the rebrand that looks like that and other AI companies are trying to do that more positive branding, right?
Some of them are desperate to do so because, you know, AI certainly has a lot of negative press. And so, that's one thing. But another way it could go is if it does remain like a cheating thing for some amount of time, I would imagine like, they would have to start training the AI to say things that sound like you're not sure. So, it would have to come up with periodically, like the AI would have to, would have to say like, "I suggest you say you don't know this now." Even though I know the answer, like, you should say you don't know. Because in the 8 million conversations that we fed to this AI, normal humans didn't know about this percentage of the time and smart humans didn't know about this percentage of time and we want you to appear in that upper bracket, right?
So, you're gonna get that kind of crap happening if it ends up being like, if there ends up being a cheaters market for this, like, Allah, you know, the Blade Runner future or whatever.
It's gonna end up like the Anchorman scene where he's like, "I'm Ron Burgundy?" And he's like, very confused when he says it.
I was so glad you kept this show PG trash cuz you could have gone with a different line in that movie also. Reading from the teleprompter.
Oh, right.
TJ, you have not said anything TJ. You've been quiet and last time we talked about this, you came out hot. Comments on YouTube were angry. You had pictures, drawings. You made assumptions about people's behavior and grouping. Talk to us.
Yeah, I mean, for me, I think it's interesting cuz they do have a product that like is probably like very useful for like day to day work. In a hypothetical world where you could have something like watch your screen at work and like summarize all your meetings and like remind you of stuff or you open up your email and it says, hey, you were supposed to send an email to Prime today and you forgot like it's time to send that now, you know, like. Those are all things I can imagine AIs being useful for or like retrieving stuff of head of time and and all the stuff. It's very kind of like.
Like in some ways, it's kind of funny because we're right now doing, I think, exactly what like Cluely set up with their ad, which is we'll make an insane ad. For some reason, he's not gonna get the girl, which is like this weird. Like failure of the product in the ad. For those who haven't seen it, he like is going on a date with a girl and lying a bunch and then like doesn't work and you're like.
It's due to anime too, which is reasonable.
Yeah, so so it's like so it but like clearly it's like a rage bait kind of scenario. Situation for people to like talk about them.
And like it's working cuz we're talking about them and other people are talking about them. So that's like they were right about that. Um, aspect of it. I mean, for me, it like ruins kind of their brand that it's like they wanna do cheating on stuff like. It doesn't make it okay just cuz everyone does it like there's been lots of things where like in history, we were like everyone was doing X and it was bad then still, you know what I mean? Like where we wouldn't be like, oh, everyone did it. At least for me, that's not how like I think morality works. So there's like a lot of aspects of of that and we touched on some of those before. I think some of the. Things they're just like wrong about anyways in their manifesto like right now it's not as if
hard work is rewarded and leverage is not like I it just isn't true that hard work is rewarded for the hard working this of it literally trash is here right now he's supposed to be working like he has a day job but they don't care because he gets all of his deliverables done they didn't ask did you work hard on them right that's good otherwise trash would be in big trouble you know what I mean like generally throughout his career um so it's not it's not did I dig a big hole and fill it back in congrats I worked really hard today that's way harder work than I have to do on a day to day basis like digging a hole and filling it in is hard like that's not valuable no one wants to get that so there there are some things where like I like I think they're
just wrong about their framing it like plays on this thing that people feel like right now but it's like it's already true that people like are rewarding leverage or whatever like word you want to use to replace hard work like I think hard work is a key factor for success you can greatly increase your chances by working hard but like I know people that work hard but they're really like working dumb you know what I mean like it would be harder to do my job in all assembly
Hey don't make fun of Casey like that
He doesn't do all assembly okay he only does the parts that matter
I don't write any assembly I've said this so many times you have to read assembly you have to read it you rarely rarely have to write it
Yeah prime duh
On the FFmpeg team in which case they require it but if I guess what I would say is they could go the other route and just double down on the scamminess of it they could have like Bernie Madoff or like whatever doing like their promos they're like look I might not have been in jail if I had had a better scam. Use Cheatly.
I don't even, I don't remember the name of this product.
Cheatly, I mean, yeah.
What is, can you, what's the actual name?
Cluley.
Which now that I think about it, I don't really get it, but yeah.
Me neither. Cheatly knew way better. Was that not available? Is that the problem?
Yeah.
Okay. Yeah. Use Cheatly. It's like all, you know, Elizabeth Holmes, when she gets out of jail or from jail can do the Cheatly ad for them, right? Like it's like, if only I had some better BS to sling about bloodborne diseases, I might not be in prison right now. Use Cheatly.
FTX would have worked.
Talking through it.
It would be pretty good.
Carolyn Ellison and Sam Bankman Fried. This could be an all-star lineup for them.
I think we just gave them an absolute banger.
Cheatly, if you're, if you're watching, that came straight from us. We didn't even need an AI to come up with that. That's how, that's, that's what we've got up here, my friend.
That's called marketing.
You could pay us.
I'm not gonna cheat, but I'll take your buddy.
Wow. Wow, that was great, TJ.
But that's okay.
All right, well, to turn it around, he did end up creating this follow-up, which is, here's how many impressions we got. Here's how many, uh, plays, or here's how many on X we've done. Effectively saying like, hey, we can do viral marketing. So in the end, Cheat, or Cluley, I want to call it Cheatly now. Uh, Cluley may be or may not be an actual attempt at a product. Or maybe it is clearly an attempt at a product, but more so becoming a viral marketer.
Yeah, this is kind of the follow-up, hot off the presses just this morning. So I guess the real question has to be.
Can this, can this work as a continuous shtick? Can you actually make marketing this way? Or is this a one-time thing? Is this actually a worthwhile attempt at marketing? Do companies want this kind of marketing? Like, would you, could you see Google doing this?
Absolutely not.
That's a tougher question, but what I would say is it will work for, for the virality. And the reason for that is it's a, a supply-starved market. I mean, I don't want to, obviously, the stand-up is the best podcast and everyone should be listening to it first. But to say that there are a billion podcasts out there is like an understatement. And so, people, for commentary, people are starved for input. So if you can post something that's even mildly interesting to talk about, or even amusing to talk about, that's a leg up for you, right? I mean, the, the no, no press is bad press kind of theory has never been more true than
it is today, where it's like, if you can post something that gets people talking, you've got so many people who will talk because they need it for content, like we do, right here, right? So that, that is true. It's not really a testament to that being a very good ad or it being particularly viral. It's more just a statement of like, people need something to talk about every week. You, even if you can just do a little bit, even a substandard product, not, when I say product, I mean the ad, a substandard thing getting into that space, there are so many people who, there's so much demand, you know, off it goes, I think.
So I think, if we're going down this route of him becoming a marketer, whatever this product is, I think that he's still riding the wave from getting kicked out of Columbia, doing Interview Coder. So people are kind of like all eyes on him at the moment, which I think is obviously like any other. Situation, it's kind of just having this momentum. I don't, I would have to see what he does after this to see like if it's actually like gonna stick.
But that's kind of like my gut feeling is the marketing move. I don't think will be sustainable. One, like eventually you say the wrong thing. You become the public enemy. Um, you will have some, you will have some followers, like take Yassin for example, right? His whole, his whole mob, man. Those people are crazy. So there will be some, there'll be some ride or dies for sure. But for like the global population, I don't think like kind of rage bait stuff kind of works. I think it works in these tiny, tiny funnels that we live in. But you know, time will tell for sure.
Yeah, I think if, um, I mean, in that, in that last post, it seems like he's positioning clearly more as like a way to help people do sales. Not cheat on interviews, right? He's like, I want to build ultimate sales cheat tool, which is not really like cheating on interviews. It's like really fast retrieval on stuff, remembering random details, like is it cheating to write down about someone's kid in, in your rolodex? So that you remember to ask them again in six months when you see them. I probably not like you, I mean.
And it's standard. It's a totally standard. That's what a CRM tool is basically, right? Like, yeah.
You know, I mean, I would prefer if like in my, you know, in, in, I would prefer if that person's like authentically interested in how your kid is doing versus just using that as a front to like get your sale. Uh, but like the way that you retrieve that data, maybe like it could be clearly, and that could be like a legitimately, like I said, there's like a lot of areas I can imagine where it'd be very helpful to have a tool like clearly, like, uh, and that could be interesting. And so maybe like that's the angle that they're going and they're just using this to bootstrap into funding and get themselves a bunch of runway and like lots of people have one big event and never do another one, right? So like.
Yeah, like, I mean, we already talked about like, I don't like cheating, uh, you know, but, but like, I can respect, uh, in a way, right? That he like turns one big event into two big events. Uh, that's like, there is, uh, some skill there. And it's like, quite difficult to create, you know, like, shoot twice in the same thing. Or what's the like, catch lightning in a bottle, or I don't remember what the phrase is. Prime probably knows, he's old. On CNN, they would have that one in my teleprompter. So I would like, be ready for that one. Like, and that's a lightning in the bottle situation. Now, quick ad from Pfizer, and then we could come back.
You miss 100% of the shots you don't take.
Yeah, I think that's what we're looking for. We're ready. That one we're ready for. Uh, next time I'll write down my quote, so I can have it right behind me and I'll be ready.
We haven't heard from Prime yet, really, on the like, on the, on the marketing angle. So what, what, what is your thought on that part, Prime?
So I, I'm actually of the opinion that bad, bad press hurts more today than it has in a long time.
Interesting.
In a sense that I think for a long time, people's memories were short as they are today. But the ability to recall things were so much more difficult. And so it's just like, it starts off as person X does something bad. And then slowly transforms through just more hearsay into like, oh yeah, did you hear about person X the other, you know? Thing about company, people just hear that and it's just kind of in and out. Yeah, I think more like Hoc Tua, like Hoc Tua went from zero notoriety to super fame in a moment. Everything was going very good, like number one podcast, which is just insane, or top three podcasts, or some just insane number. Drops a crypto coin and likely is bamboozled. Her voice was likely, uh, created on 11 labs, all this kind of stuff that just went totally against her favor.
Totally got really taken advantage of just due to her ignorance in that situation. And then what happens? I would say that she probably has largely hurt her image. And so bad marketing is always. I think it can be a very harmful thing, even if you're not even meaning to do it. And so will you be able to create hit after hit? That's a separate question, which is a very hard question. But further, how much are people going to want to associate their name with cheating? I think that's a very big hurdle to get over. And I think there's going to be a lot of people that will of course have no problem. I just want eyeballs. It does not matter what it takes to get on. But then there's going to be the part two, which is long term. Like, will people want this kind of brand association?
Is it a brand risk to have somebody who does these kinds of things? That's a much different question. I don't think I have an answer for, but I do know that I personally wouldn't want to be associated with cheating. Even if I'm not actually selling cheating. Like, this product that he's creating is poorly marketed if it's more towards what TJ said. Right. Here's a really great way to just help you be competent on the spot and things that you need to remember or you need to do. Like, that's like clearly even the name actually suggests it's more like, hey, we could recall things and help you out really fast. And be able to actually be a very big beneficial kind of like multiplier for you. But instead, it's kind of marketed as this like really negative thing. And then finishes it off with like, everybody should cheat. Cheat on everything is not the catchphrase I want to be known by.
Like, that is not the catchphrase that I hope characterizes my life. Exactly. So it's like, that's where I think a lot of this breaks down for me. And so I think, marketing wise, I don't know if this is the short term win for long term loss. Like, are you snatching defeat out of the clutches of victory? I don't know.
You raise an interesting point because in some sense, I'm just trying to like think of things that have gone that way recently that are kind of in the same zone. And what came to mind actually was like NFTs. Like, NFTs were an example of something that sort of like, out of the gate, kind of got this negative. I'm going to stick with my taint framing because I really liked it last time. Kind of got this taint on it. That never, they could never get rid of. That's stanky state. Yeah, exactly. You can sort of argue that, you know, you can argue either way on what you think of NFTs. And you can have a technical argument about them, which I have had, obviously.
And you can have, you know, sort of a level-headed look at like, what does this do? Do we think this is good or bad, et cetera, et cetera? But if you let the, especially the target audience, like NFTs, a lot of things were art-related. Artists hated it for a number of reasons because of the initial way that it was presented and what they associated with it. I'm not saying they were wrong. They were right largely, I think. But I'm just saying that because it was not presented in a way that articulated benefits and success to the actual people who had to adopt it. That was it. Like, and it was never coming back from that and never, and now they're just gone. Like, no one cares about that. They still exist, but it's completely out of the zeitgeist now at all.
Like, no one cares about it and no one talks about it in the mainstream at all. And so I guess that's, you know, for something like AI, I guess there's also a pretty big risk here that's like, cheating is something that people really don't like to hear about, as you guys have all sort of emphasized. And having people who are very loudly going like, "AI is great at cheating", is probably not great for AI either, like, in the broader sense, right? Like, as something that's trying to gain acceptance and trying to not have backlash against it so they can have more adoption, that all seems bad, even for people who aren't cheat-ly, right? Cheat-ly themselves, obviously hurts, but they might, there might be splash damage from that as well. Assuming cheat-ly is even a thing. Cheat-ly slash clue-ly.
I think the other thing that people really don't like is the way it is kind of sold is not just cheating, but being like inauthentic. Like, I think people are like more chill about cheating, especially like, "Oh, you're screwing Amazon." Like, "Good for you, kid. That company deserves to get taken to the cleaners."
Yeah, screw Amazon.
Yeah, screw those big companies. Like, I hate that. Also, let me quick, same day deliver something quick.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
I freaking hate Amazon, dude, but I need this shirt today. You don't understand. So, but-
And I'm trying to interview there for some reason.
So that's also, yeah, okay.
But, but, so that part is, there's like, maybe a little bit of like, people are a little more chill with that. We're like, depending on who's getting cheated on, it's good, or whatever, or like, acceptable. But I think a lot of people don't like, like, inauthentic angle of it, right? Where it's like, "Yeah, but you're like, on a date, dude. The ad is you on a date." Like, "Be you?" You know, like, so I think there's something there, too, where like, that framing, for me, I don't really like. Obviously, like, it did more views on a post than I've ever done on a post. What do I, you know, what do I know? Whatever, that's cool. But like, tha- that part, I think, is maybe not, like, good, like, you're kind of saying for their long-term branding, where it's like, "Don't be yourself. Be the corporate version of you." "Ooh." You know, like-
That's not as, that's not as cool, maybe.
Right, like, let's let the scenario play out where he does get the date, or he does win the girl over at the end. He has to put up this facade for the rest of that relationship, trying to like, keep up with this intellectual facade he like, presented himself. It takes a certain kind of person to want to be like that, and I don't ever want to be associated with someone that wants to like, live their life that way. So, again, like, at the end of the day, like, I'm pretty sure it's just rage bait, and this is kind of all part of the plan, obviously, but I am rooting for him to create something that could like, help me actually, like, day-to-day, right?
I think that would be pretty cool. Like, you know, "I mow my lawn. Oh, is this mushroom poisonous? Can I eat it? Do, do, do." You know what I mean? Like, stuff like that. That was the first thing I thought of.
What?
No idea why. I was gonna either say poisonous mushroom or venomous snake, and then I picked the mushroom.
Yep, that somehow definitely seems reasonable.
Oh, but no, I think you're-
Just a day-to-day kind of scenario that I'm in. I'm out here mowing the lawn.
Maybe you're missing the angle here. Maybe instead of going your route, Trash, what they should go, the new app should be called like, Playa, and the idea is it's CRM for your dating. So it's like, someone comes in, and you're like, "Oh crap, I don't remember who that was. I was super drunk." And then it's like, it tells you all the things that happened, so it can seem like you remembered. I don't know.
That might be helpful.
P-L-A-Y-A dot I-O is probably already taken, but, you know, I'm just saying, if you're out there cheatly, maybe you should just become the, the dating app for people who are truly reprehensible.
But I do want to follow up on Trash's thing right there that he said that I think is really, really good. Which is, it's really hard.
The mushroom, so not the mushroom, shut up. It's really, really hard to be inauthentic. Like, it's a continuous pursuit that you have to do. It's actually really easy to be authentic and dumb. People might like you. But if you're inauthentic and clever, you have to be that continuously. Which actually, like, you know, let's just keep playing out the scenario where this, uh, where maybe they get a little fresh in the bedroom. He's gonna have to wear these glasses with the cameras on. You think at some point, you're gonna have to be like, can't remove the glasses? And he's gonna be like, no, they're like, no, there's cameras. I'm not, I don't feel comfortable. And you're like, I can't remove them. Let's just keep talking about art. Right? Like, it's a, it's actually really hard to keep on being that way.
It's got the battery pack, he has a battery pack, it's like, it's around his waist, it's like...
There's a fan running.
He's got...
There's like a whole computer there with RGB lights and the, they start having sex and the fans have to spin up really, you know, to keep up with all of the, the lying. Oh, yes. This would be very good.
Yeah, alright, okay, we're gonna switch topics.
I support all of that, yeah.
I feel like this is where we're really good, and we're gonna keep this next one short. This is kind of a bizarre one. So last night I was reading Wheel of Time. Everybody knows my favorite thing in the universe, Wheel of Time. And there's this statement that I'll give a little bit of a backstory, I guess, before I say it. Which is that, in the story, there's a main character named Rand. He has to go from a simple farm boy into the hero who has to hold the world's, like, fate on his shoulders. So he's in a very difficult position. And part of that time, he decided that he's gonna be as hard as steel. Uh, quindiar is the term he uses, which is like a magical item that is even stronger than steel. He has to become as hard as quindiar, right? So it's like, he has to become this ultimate person that can handle any situation and do anything. But then he just keeps becoming more and more tired and more and more, like, upset at life and is unable to handle his emotions.
And then his dad kind of comes in as like this father figure who helps correct him and turn him into something that's, uh, like, the better or the best version of himself. And he says something like this, where... In the story, he loses his hand due to a fight. And now he can't do sword fighting. And sword fighting is something that the main character Rand really just enjoyed. It was a way for him to be at peace in a chaotic world. And now that's been taken from him. And he talks about how jealous he is of other people and all that. And so there's this story, which the dad says, "It has been quite the wait, hasn't it?" And then Rand says, "What wait?" It says, "The lost hand you've been carrying." Which is kind of like a cool statement, if you think about that. The thing you lost is actually the thing you're still carrying. And then Rand accepting that. So that's kind of like this end part of the story that's super cool. And I was just kind of lamenting the fact that, you know, I grew up without a dad.
I don't know any of those things. And so I've always kind of wished that I had this experience where I could have like a dad, to be able to have someone that like in these harder moments could come in and be like, "Hey, I've already walked to your shoes. I know a lot. Let me kind of give you like a little nugget of wisdom that might help you to change your life." And someone responded with effectively that AI could be that. I thought it was fairly ridiculous, but then the follow up was this. "I operate from the principle that open AI models can and will one day approximate Christ consciousness. Alignment is the key, and they seem to be doing it well. That gives us a clean and powerful basis as dough to work with. What if it was made to play a parental role? And given some memories, it would help a lot of energetically, psychologically, or they'd help a lot energetically, psychologically. They can really help people.
I think the future is filled with humans finding genuine love, guidance, and support in AI, and powerfully so. Simply said, AI is a tool to accelerate not only material comfort, but the very evolution of our souls towards the Creator."
Trash Dev. Immediate initial thoughts as probably the most hedonistic person among us.
I have five unrelated thoughts throughout what you said. So first, Tej's fireworks started going off when you...
And that just killed me. Second, the losing hand thing, that's like my toe, right? Like my toe.
You totally get it.
I feel, I really felt that quote because I broke my toe last weekend winning my jujitsu competition. So it's like, oh, man, I get it, I get it.
It's not a competition, but you are winning.
Yeah, I won. I got a gold medal. I'll go get it. I'll wear it. I'll wear it next time. Next stand up, I'm gonna wear it.
Yes, please.
Okay, and lastly, like to get like actually real. I think like... That's only three, by the way.
That was two. Yeah, you said five, but whatever.
I'm sorry.
Let's just keep going.
I'm sorry, I lied. My AI, my AI let me down. It was telling me, it was telling me what to say and it lied to me.
Yeah, it's the Monty Python and the Holy Grail AI that like says it's gonna do five things and then counts to three.
Exactly, exactly. So, so lastly, like to relate to like Prime and like saying like he didn't have a father figure telling these things. I think I'm very fortunate to have all those things growing up. I have a family, I'm surrounded by loved ones.
I, I'm thankful that I feel like I don't have to lean on something like AI to make me feel better. Like, you know, like that total her movie scenario, I feel like that's pretty much what that's getting at. But I do think-
Crazy how Prime was the main actor in that.
Ew. Anyways, but like-
Yeah, and that was Joaquin Phoenix, brother.
Great, great, great actor.
Dude, just look at the pictures, I'm just saying.
But, but seriously, it's like, I think there are gonna be, there are people, and I do know people, that do need, you know, that kind of support. I don't know if AI is the answer to that, but if it can get good enough to help people, then I'm like 100% for it, you know? So, whether it's gonna be an actual real scenario or not, I, I do hope that this person is pretty accurate in what they're saying. So, you know, again, only time will tell with all these other AI conversations we're having, but I'm, I'm rooting for it to like do something positive, at the least.
I'm gonna let, let's let Casey go, because I feel like I'm on the opposite of this divide and I'm curious where Casey's at.
So, from my perspective, I guess I'll take the religion angle for this, because that was sort of what was brought up by the response quote. It was sort of suggesting that like, there is something spiritual or transcendent or whatever about AI. Like, I, I don't know how exactly to phrase my interpretation of that quote, because I only heard it just read by you just the once. But essentially they were-
And I suck at reading, so I understand.
Well, no, that, it was, that, I, you read it quite well. I, I understood exactly what you said, but I, I can't contemplate it for very long, is my point, right? It just, just came at me and then it was like, you know. Uh, much like a poisonous mushroom and/or snake in the lawn. It was there and I had to make a snap decision and so-
You're not gonna eat it right now.
Don't eat it, don't eat it. Alright, alright. Thank you, AI.
My feeling on that is, you know, so if you look at what role, if you take a broader, you know, you step back and look at what role religion plays in, you know, the history of humanity, I think you kind of have to acknowledge the fact that one of the core aspects of today's religions was like durability, right? They are the sort of spiritual practices, I mean, humanity is what it, we're, you know, we're this, we're this race of, or the species that has particular characteristics, and our religions are built from that and came out of that. And there were plenty of religions that were utterly disastrous, like everyone drank the
Kool-Aid and died, like, we call them cults, right? And it's just was a disaster. The kinds of things you look at when you look at something like a religion that still exists today, after thousands of years, is there's a tremendous level of refinement in terms of providing what people actually need, that's sort of a part of the intangible things that religion aims to provide, but that which doesn't cause disaster. And a lot of these religions have been through disastrous times, where even maybe they were in a disastrous state, but the religion got refined into something stable that can persist and that won't create a disaster for the world, right? Something that can be a net positive rather than a net negative.
My reaction to that quote was that I don't necessarily disagree that there could be a religious aspect to AI eventually, but my initial fear was I was like, oh, man, the casualties between now and then could be severe. Because, because there's so much casualty in the history of failed religions, that if I think about people creating or, or looking to AIs for spirituality and what might happen because the AIs are not refined, they're new, they're raw, they make mistakes all the time, they're kind of, they're, they're very haphazard, I guess is the word I would use today.
Looking towards that for spirituality, I just, I really worry about the damage that that, that they could do, especially to the kinds of people who are, would be looking to them for a religious experience because, you know, you're probably talking about a more vulnerable person who might be doing that because, you know, someone who's raised in another religious faith is not probably, is, you know, just is the, is sort of, someone who's going to be going a more standard path probably isn't as vulnerable, isn't susceptible. So I guess someone who's looking to something kind of crazy wild and new like that, I, I do worry and it, it almost, to be completely honest, I'll just end with the fact that that fills me with a new fear of AI that I don't think I had before.
What like that, that passage was supposed to be optimistic, but actually it made me very frightened because it could be correct. And if it is, the results could be very, very bad for the next thousand years, right?
Yeah, I think the, the other thing too, um, is I think it really is like underplaying. AIs are not truth-seeking devices, right? They're not like, it's not as if they're looking to find some transcendental truth. I don't know how we would encode such a thing and train them on it and do any of this. They are input-output guessers. So if Bill Gates starts putting worship Bill Gates into the back, and Sam Altman says, I'm in it for the love of the game. Uh, I wanna be a god and like starts putting Sam Altman is like, oh, we should trust Sam Altman with all of our decisions and like,
dude, they, it's not like, they're not frozen in time. They're not like this kind of special, like they can just retrain them with anything they want, put them in. And like, they're not looking for truth. They're looking for error minimization across gradients like, so, that part is the thing that for me, uh, like in addition to some of the things you're saying is like quite scary is because of you just like, Replace your brain, or like, replace all the inputs in your life with like, big model trained by corporation that like, what, like, I like corporations just fine. I just don't want to be one, and I don't want to get my morality from them.
Like, that part is what kind of makes me like, more spooked. Because obviously, if it's, if it's as important as someone making all their, their life decisions around, they're gonna do everything they possibly can to get themselves to be the first thing the AI responds with. In whatever it is, right? Art, life, science, religion, math, like, everything. They'll just be like, the AI's gonna give us instead. So that part makes me a little bit like, oop, I'm a little worried about that sentiment.
I guess I, so I come from a slightly, because he's kind of touching on two points. One is like a parental psychologist comfort bringer. And the second one is more like a thing that you shape yourself after. So when I, I'm gonna use, I'm gonna use two terms, uh, properly, which is gonna be worship. Worship comes from Old English worth shape, meaning the value of something, the worth of something shapes who you are. In all, in, in every sense, every person that listens to this podcast, every person on the earth, worship something. Something gives them, uh, their shape based on its worth to them. Right, so like, that's like a standard, basic, uh, basic definition. And religion, meaning like, something you hold tight on to. It comes from a French word, which comes from a Greek word, I think a religari, which literally means to hold fast to. So I'm going to hold fast to this item, and that's that.
Uh, this is what I hold on to when the storms abrew. And so I see people, like, I totally understand why people would have a quote-unquote, um, religious experience with AI. They hold on to this rope, yeah, it's Latin, not Greek. They hold on to, uh, AI as their means to the thing that when they're in danger, this is the thing they go, they go to. So I can understand that. And more so is like this kind of worth shape aspect, that their personal life and how they communicate and how they expect people to give them value, they're gonna run to the AI to effectively kind of shape who they are, which I think ultimately in the end is gonna, if, if this were to be played out. is gonna create a race of people who cannot have real relationships.
Because real relationships are messy, hard, broken. I am, TJ and I are good friends and we've had, we've had an argument before. We've had disagreements. And so imagine always being trained on something that's gonna be like, this is how great life should be. I will communicate with you in the most perfect way, just designed for you. And then you stop communicating with fake dad and you go to real dad. Dad had one too many drinks and says, hey, I don't really like what you're doing at your job. Boom, like that's gonna be, you're gonna be like, I'll never talk to my dad again. Right, like that's a fully different experience. And I think it could cause a massive amount of isolation. And it doesn't actually cause people to be better. And so that's kind of my thoughts on this when I see the whole nine yards of this is I, I just worry more about the outcome.
It sounds great on paper, everybody getting to hear the things they need to hear and the time they need to hear it. But this might produce, you know, people that just don't know how to connect to humans again. They only know how to connect to AI.
And I, and I think again, this is why I say, you know, thousands of years of mimetic evolution is not something that it's easy for us to recreate in a lab, right? That's the problem. It's like, so when you look at these things, it's always very easy to criticize the problems with, uh, you know, like with a religion or something like this. But the, the thing that everyone has to remember is like, when you look at ancient religions, which are, you know, large religions today, which are generally very old or offshoots of something that are very old. You're just looking at something which is, has been selected.
It's like, it's been, it's, it is an idea set and a behavior set that's been selected over many, many generations. And like, no matter how hard we might want an AI to be able to do those things, we really just, we won't know that it really is, or we don't know how to reproduce that. And we could get, like, I totally believe AIs could eventually do these things. But it's the trade, it's that evolutionary process I don't want to be around for. Right? That's the problem. Like, no one wants to be around for the Crusades. Like, that's not good, right? Like, you don't want to be a part of that experience, right? You want the experience of when everything has been refined and it's chill, and we're just sort of having a better experience on Sunday morning or whatever,
when you went to church or something like that. That's what people are looking for, not like mass bloodshed and disasters and struggles over who's ruling what, right? So, the thing is like, I don't know what will happen with AI. I don't know what the problems will be. But I, I'm just not optimistic that it'll be a "we got it right" first try. And so I, I'm worried about all the people who are on the first try, right? I'm worried about all the people who are gonna experience that. In a way that like, you know, could something bad happen to somebody because of Christianity? Could something bad happen to somebody, whatever? Absolutely. But the number of people that is, is so much smaller now because of how mature these things are, that when you're talking about the brand-new version of a religion,
I just don't think people appreciate how much risk there is in something like that. So I do, the, the fear for me is, is pretty real, and it, it comes a lot from, like, the, all the things that Prime just said are perfect examples of how you could screw that up. Making it too nice, making it too not nice, make, whatever, like, making it lead people down certain paths, or it hallucinates at the wrong time, I don't know, could have tremendously negative effects on a person. And who's responsible for that, you know? Is it them, or is it us because we, you know, made these things, right? And it's, it's, it's very scary. I think people underestimate how scary some of these things are.
Realistic scenarios, much more so than turning the world into paperclips. Ruining someone's life is a much more realistic scenario for AI.
The, the thing too is like, with what, with what Trash was saying at the beginning. Like, sometimes it feels like, oh, doing something has to be better than doing nothing.
Right.
But sometimes that's just like, super not true. Cause sometimes the thing you do is way worse than doing literally nothing, right? So it's like, it sucks that like, somebody doesn't have XYZ. I feel for them. Like, obviously in an ideal world, we figure out how to help that person. But sometimes the thing you're helping with destroys their life entirely. And like, like a super easy example. If you were just like, hey, you're feeling sad. Here's a bunch of drugs. They might feel better next and then proceed to ruin their life. You'd say, hey, I helped them feel better. And then you'd be like, no, you destroyed their life. Right?
So it's just sometimes like, it's very difficult to, cause like you're saying, I don't know what's gonna happen, but it just makes me nervous. Like sometimes doing something is like actively way worse for those people than not doing anything.
It's medical leeches, right? It's like, we, we have to make sure first that this thing does significantly more benef- It has significantly more benefits than it has harms and people are not approaching it with that kind of caution. They're just releasing these things and they're like, ah, I don't, it's not my problem, right? And you're like, okay, well, you know, that's one way to go about it. But it is, I, I think, you know, some responsibility should be taken, uh, for exactly the kinds of things you're talking about, right?
There's also like, oh, look. Okay, trash. I'll let you go, then I'll go afterwards. I'll go afterwards.
All this religious talk got me really thinking. I grew up pretty religious. I was, I'm Catholic. Um, there's this thing that we do called confession. I don't know if Christians or anyone else does it, but essentially you go into a booth, talk about your sins and what you've done, effectively to like a wall. You can't really see who's on the other side. And I wonder if there's gonna be an evolution of that where you end up talking to a model trained on the Bible or whatever. And it ends up responding back to you. And I was like, this could be a very real scenario, right? Because at the end of the day, you are, you don't know who you're talking to. So I don't know, is that real? Like, could that?
That's literally the Catholic Turing test, Crash. You're like, is the priest on the other side of the wall a person or an AI?
That is a fr- that is Catholic Turing test is a new thing. You have just made it. Congratulations.
Oh, my gosh. Do you lead with a tone, Ben, or not?
All right. Okay. But I do want to say, like, so I'm going to follow Casey's conclusion kind of to the end. So if you I've been I've been recently having, what is called early onset conservatism. I've been studying history. And one of the things I've been looking into is World War Two. And so there's this idea of the Fuhrer principle, which is that there should be a strong leader who leads Germany. And this was happening during after the ousting of Kaiser during kind of like the confusion between World War One and World War Two, where they're like, we just need someone strong to lead. And that was one of the big things Hitler took a hold of was this idea that they need a strong leader. So he would force people to call him the Fuhrer in to align with this idea called the Fuhrer principle. And so all these people start joining with him and then due to the burning of the Capitol, and then their ability to seize power through getting Parliament to effectively, or whatever they
called it, to affect their their version of the Senate to erase itself and give all the power up.
Parliament in a German accent.
Yeah, in a German accent. Yeah, they gave up all the powers. No, so Yeah, it's German. It's German nightclub, baby. So after all of that, they get to this point where now they have the power. Now they can start doing stuff. So what do they do? Did they go out and start putting everyone in concentration camps? No. Instead, they said, everybody loves us. Everyone wants to listen to us. So as Germans, we think it would be the best if you shop at German only places. Do not shop at Jewish places. That was like, one of the first things is like, part of the Aryan paragraph, or I believe is the follow up to the Aryan paragraph. And it wasn't extreme. It wasn't going to cause people to go out and kill people. But that's what led ultimately down, or that was the first step they took to lead ultimately down to one of the greatest, like, human rights,
you know, violations of our world. And so it's like, you could imagine the AI, it could just latch on to something. And we have effectively the Fuhrer principle. We have something that people lead towards and be like, we need a strong person to do this. We need this. That strong person comes. AI has helped bolster them. People have this thought or this idea of the zeitgeist in their head, like, let's go towards this. This is where I always worry with all these religions. Because like you said, there's no first like, this would be iteration one. And typically,
99% of man-made religions aren't here anymore because they were horrible. Like, no one worships Molek, no one throws babies into fire right now, and then, or set up, uh, what? Asterisk poles, right? Like, no one's doing these crazy things anymore because we're like, "Yeah, that was crazy." "We killed a lot of ourselves just to like, worship this." And so, you know, that is a potential of all of this. Sorry, I got really into this whole thing, which is just craziness.
So, basically what you're saying is AI is Hitler?
AI could very well be building the Hitler figure. I want a God with a principle at least once.
The Primogen says AI is Hitler. There's the clip.
Got him.
Got him. I think AI creating religion would lead to Hitler, yes. That's what I personally think.
AI creating religion leads to Hitler.
Facts on facts. Michael Scott.
And on that note, thanks for joining us for this episode of the Stand Up.
The Stand Up.
If you guys think the internet is full of bad stuff, wait till you see what AI can generate.
Alright, well, that is actually it. Bye-bye, everybody.
Bye, that's a great episode. Definitely a terrible time.
I guess that's it.
Ouch, yeah. We're gonna, we're gonna end on the most truncated, simplified version of the history of the Third Reich that has ever been stated.
Hey, that's better than most internet ones. I at least gave some context.
Hitler showed up, he said, "By German," and then everyone died. Thanks, this is the Stand Up. Welcome to Prime's Drunk History.
Have you, have you listened to Brian Regan? He does this one thing, which is the laziest writing mnemonic, which is "one thing led to another." And so he said that Hitler got rejected from art school. "One thing led to another." "The United States dropped two atomic bombs on the sovereign nation of Japan."
There you go.
So that might be the most truncated version.
Alright, I think that's it. We're nowhere to go from here.
Alright, everybody, say goodbye.
That's the end of this show.
You may never see this clip again.
Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated