Pod Insights The Rest Is Politics 187. The Left and Israel About this episode Has Keir Starmer caused lasting damage to his leadership over his stance on Israel-Gaza? What will Biden be saying behind the scenes to other world leaders? Can the UK become a world leader in AI?
🌏 Get our exclusive NordVPN deal here ➼ https://nordvpn.com/restispolitics It’s risk-free with Nord’s 30-day money-back guarantee! ✅
TRIP Plus: Become a member of The Rest Is Politics Plus to support the podcast, receive our exclusive newsletter, enjoy ad-free listening to both TRIP and Leading, benefit from discount book prices on titles mentioned on the pod, join our Discord chatroom, and receive early access to live show tickets and Question Time episodes. Just head to therestispolitics.com to sign up, or start a free trial today on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/therestispolitics.
Instagram:
@restispolitics
Twitter:
@RestIsPolitics
Email:
[email protected]
Producers: Dom Johnson + Nicole Maslen
Exec Producers: Tony Pastor + Jack Davenport
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,297 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:04 Rory Stewart? This episode is brought to you by NordVPN.
0:06 Alastair Campbell? And I must thank NordVPN because on my Grand European Tour with Fiona, I was away from the Hawthorns for West Bromwich against Burnley, but I managed to watch it. There you go.
0:19 Rory Stewart? I actually had a NordVPN thank you. I was in the new Starbucks here in Crete. And of course, the thing flashed up, saying this is an unsecured public network. And I was able to go to my VPN. It was a little reminder of something we often forget when we're in all those cafes and things, which is actually genuinely, people can do all kinds of weird cyber attacks and spying if you don't have a virtual private network when you're sitting in that Starbucks.
0:42 Alastair Campbell? Well, I think, are you not really sort of proud of me that I managed to do this? Or should I say Fiona managed to do this?
0:49 Rory Stewart? I'm incredibly proud of you. That's a tech transformation. So to get the best discount off your NordVPN plan, go to nordvpn.com/rustispolitics. That's nordvpn.com/rustispolitics. And the link is in the episode description.
1:05 Speaker 02 A BetterHelp ad. Imagine carrying a backpack every day, every conversation, every mistake, every expectation. You probably wouldn't notice how heavy it was until someone asked if you wanted to put it down. Sometimes feeling better starts exactly like that. Better isn't one size fits all. Better is personal. It's therapy tailored to you to help lighten what you've been carrying. Match with a therapist who truly gets you. Visit betterhelp.com/rustpolitics.
1:35 Speaker 03 Mr. President, my company told me of the explosion on our rig on October 2nd. Causing massive water displacement and triggering a tsunami. They all heap the blame on me. Tom Cruise is.
1:46 Speaker 04 Digger got us into this mess. And Digger's gonna dig us up. From the director of Birdman and the Revenant.
1:52 Speaker 05 What would happen if I stopped going? You stall, you freeze in there, that's what.
1:56 Speaker 04 With great power comes great deniability.
1:59 Speaker 05 I'm not the earth nanny.
2:00 Speaker 04 Digger. See the trailer online. Only in theaters October 2nd. Rated R. Under 17. Not a minute without parent.
2:13 Alastair Campbell? Welcome to The Rest Is Politics with me, Alastair Campbell.
2:15 Rory Stewart? And with me Rory Stewart.
2:17 Alastair Campbell? Now, we're going to do lots on the Middle East, obviously, not just what's happening there, but also what's happening in the UK politics around it. We're speaking shortly before Keir Starmer's going to make a big speech on the whole issue. And then Rory, I know you want to talk about AI ahead of Rishi Sunak's Bletchley Summit, at which I hear Elon Musk, amongst others, will be appearing. But I think sticking on the domestic policy front as well. I know that's global, but it's about Rishi Sunak. I'd also like to talk about the environment. But shall we start with the Middle East?
2:49 Rory Stewart? Absolutely. So just as a very, very brief reminder of where we are now, Israel has begun its ground operations, not at huge scale. So it's more tentative than people were expecting, but tanks have crossed the border, ground forces are beginning to engage. And so we're getting now into the phase in Gaza, which many people have been warning about and worrying about, which is the beginning of a ground war with all that that means, which is street fighting, people being able to use rubble as cover, this amazing tunnel network, which is sometimes described as being larger than the London Underground, which allows Hamas fighters both to hide from attacks, but also to be able to come up behind Israeli troops as they advance.
3:34 Rory Stewart? And you'll see any number of statements by different types of military analysts talking about Mosul or Fallujah, or even Stalingrad, about the problems of these kinds of urban warfare.
3:46 Alastair Campbell? So look, I think we're into that phase. I mean, it's only, you know, three weeks really, but we're already into that phase that we saw in the war in Ukraine, where suddenly what appeared to be utterly abnormal, literally just a few weeks ago, becomes kind of part of everyday life for all of us. You wake up, you turn on the radio, you turn on the TV, you go online, and you hear and see stuff that a few weeks ago would have been virtually unthinkable. And look, I wonder if we're going to talk about the domestic situation, but I wonder just for listeners, we should have a little reflection on what's happening inside Israeli
4:29 Alastair Campbell? politics at the moment. You had an extraordinary situation at the weekend where
4:35 Alastair Campbell? Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister, seemed to be distancing himself from those who had been in charge of the intelligence. He was essentially saying that he'd been assured that things were quiet, et cetera. And then, almost instantly, Benny Gantz, who is a different politics to Netanyahu, but he's one of the three key members of the war cabinet. There are six members of the war cabinet. Three are kind of the leaders of it. That's Netanyahu, Gallant, the Defence Minister, and Benny Gantz, who's a, you know, pretty decorated soldier, but also a senior politician as well, and clearly brought in to sort of, you know, give this sense of unity. And then the three observers.
5:19 Alastair Campbell? So the six strong cabinet, but three really powerful figures within it. And Gantz essentially attacked Netanyahu for what he said. And I think this reveals something of the weakness of Netanyahu's position, although he's kind of the strong man leader and he's projecting himself as the war leader right now. Gantz essentially made him withdraw what he'd said. And Netanyahu, something pretty rare for Bibi, he apologised for what he'd said. And so there's a vulnerability going on around Netanyahu at the moment. And I keep seeing more and more voices who are actually calling for him to go. Now, there was even one, I
5:59 Alastair Campbell? heard one of the, a former military guy, this is in France, I heard this, on the radio in France, who's, who's basically saying that Netanyahu should do what Chamberlain did. Yeah. Make way for somebody more appropriate. So there's something very, very fragile going on, at a time when it looks like, because of the scale of the bombardment, and as you say, the beginnings of these ground operations, that the, the military side of things is really, really, really been stepped up. And of course, I guess because people know Netanyahu for so long. They see somebody who's a survivor who won't waste this crisis in terms of his own political survival. I think there's a worry about Netanyahu that maybe isn't reflected
6:43 Alastair Campbell? in what we see when he comes on with the black shirt and the big flags behind him and he makes these sort of big strident speeches to camera.
6:50 Rory Stewart? So just a couple of things there. So Benny Gantz was the army chief of staff and along with Gadi Eisenkot is part of this very, very strong tradition of heads of the Israeli army entering politics, these sort of decorated war heroes, which goes back to Yitzhak Rabin and well before that too. And again, as with some of these figures, he represents more moderate forces. His blue and white coalition was a centrist party that was calling for limits on corrupt politicians entering the Knesset, protection for minorities, et cetera. The challenge, though, in all of this is, of course, as we've talked about a lot, that
7:31 Rory Stewart? Netanyahu is running a fragile coalition, which at the moment is dependent, of course, on these extremists such as Smotrich and Ben Gavir to hold him together. If he would have stepped down, and Israel has had many, many elections in the last seven years, it's had a very, very febrile politics because of the inability to form these strong, stable coalitions. Harretz at the moment is predicting, and this is a Jerusalem Post poll, is that Ben Gavir's party would win 10 Knesset seats and probably end up as the next leader. So the decision to bring in Benny Gantz into the coalition was Benny Gantz, who previously refused to serve with Netanyahu, came in because of the national emergency. But there
8:16 Rory Stewart? will be strong pressure to try to keep this fragile coalition together rather than allow Netanyahu to go and potentially create much more dangerous fractures.
8:24 Alastair Campbell? Yeah, by the way, I'm not I'm not saying that Gantz was suggesting that he should he should go. But I think it's been interesting there. There's been this kind of, you know, kind of growing sense around the place that that Netanyahu is not the right guy. And it's been interesting as well to watch Joe Biden, who is coming from a position of absolute support, but at the same time is starting to up the dial in terms of protection of civilian life and humanitarian access and and so forth. And this may seem inappropriate to some people, but I do think it's interesting that we start perhaps start to have a discussion about the nature of this conduct. There's a very interesting piece that I that I read that we should put in the in the newsletter
9:08 Alastair Campbell? from a guy called Clive Baldwin, who's the he's the legal advisor to Human Rights Watch. I think some of the legalities around what's called international humanitarian law, which is what governs the conduct of hostilities, the actual fighting, as opposed to the law that governs the decisions that have been made to use force. And I just wonder whether we're now in that phase of this war. And again, this is something that we saw at the outset in in Russia and in Ukraine. And it's what you see at the start of most military conflicts, where the attempt to to have the kind of shock and awe impact,
9:51 Alastair Campbell? to quote Donald Rumsfeld back in the time of the Iraq War, is such that you lose sight sometimes, I think, of the of the humanity of what's happening. When you look at some of the aerial footage of the state of those parts of Gaza that have been bombarded, it's hard to see, even whilst the Israelis keep saying that Hamas use these buildings, they hide themselves amongst the civilian population. It is part of the conduct of the laws of war that you must not target civilians. It's accepted in war that there will be civilian casualties. And just because there are civilian casualties doesn't necessarily mean that you're in breach of international humanitarian law.
10:36 Alastair Campbell? But there does seem now to be a scale of bombardment that doesn't seem to me to be linked in any clear way, certainly not a way that I've understood or seen properly explained, as to what the specific objectives of the current military combat are.
10:52 Rory Stewart? Really good, and let's just stick on this for a second. So before we get into the law bit of it, I think listeners will now be very, very familiar with some of the facts and figures. But there were now 1,400 Israelis killed in this Hamas terrorist attack, 200 hostages taken. And in the response since, Israel has so far dropped at least 8,000 munitions. So that's a huge number. And to put it in context, in the height of the fighting in Mosul, in March of 2017, about 5,000 munitions were used. And I was in Mosul last February, and it is astonishing looking at a city that's been hit like that.
11:32 Rory Stewart? I mean, you see hospitals jaded to the ground, craters everywhere. I mean, as people will have seen from some of the images from northern Gaza, that number of munitions hitting is absolutely unbelievable. And if you go back to the controversy over the hospital, much of the reporting that said the hospital was almost certainly hit by a rocket fired from within Palestine rather than by an Israeli bomb, a lot of that reporting was just saying the damage wasn't enough, that the damage numbers are much, much larger, the craters they leave are much, much larger. So again, facts and figures on this stuff difficult, but I think the Israelis claimed to have hit 450 military targets in 24 hours on
12:14 Rory Stewart? Sunday, that already 200 schools and universities have been destroyed, of which 29 are run by the UN.
12:20 Alastair Campbell? And just on that, Rory, when they say military targets, have they been explaining what they mean by military target? Are they just saying that somewhere that they imagine that somebody within the command structure of Hamas happens to be?
12:32 Rory Stewart? Yeah, so that the definition normally is that it's either a place where a Hamas fighter is launching attacks from, so it could be somewhere where a rocket is being fired from, or from a Hamas soldier is firing at you, or it could be a communications centre, command and control centre. And again, I mean, this is the problem, I think we talked about this a week or so ago, that Within the way in which the US, the UK and Israel conducts war, if there is any form of communication centre, which could be a few Hamas people using a radio in a building, if you hit that building, that's considered, under these rules, legitimate. And the civilians that are killed are not even counted. Which is why, as I say, the RAF claimed that I think there were only one or two civilian casualties during some of these Iraq bombing campaigns.
13:16 Rory Stewart? Of course, many thousands of civilians were killed, but they weren't counted as civilian casualties because they were considered to be close to the site of military operations.
13:25 Alastair Campbell? So I remember during the Kosovo War, when I was seconded to work at NATO, and I found myself in this very bizarre position where I was at certain meetings, sitting at the right hand of General Wes Clark, who was the Supreme Allied Commander in charge of Europe. And at one point, he called me in after the Bina meeting, and he showed me this building that they were about to hit, or they were planning to hit. And he explained that it was where Milosevic was running part of his communications machine, i.e. television, propaganda, et cetera. And then he explained that there was a possibility
14:08 Alastair Campbell? that this would at the same time be being used by British, American, French, German journalists who were covering it. And I suddenly realised he seemed to be asking me whether I thought that would be justifiable, given the target that he was about to hit. And I can't pretend that I was terribly comfortable being in that position. And I said, look, ultimately, that's a military decision. But the reason I say that is that it showed me that in that context, he and the military in that war were going to pretty considerable lengths, at least to try to minimise the loss of life of civilians. And this is something we discussed with the Palestinian ambassador
14:53 Alastair Campbell? when he got angry that some British politicians were saying Hamas are so evil that they hide people in hospitals. Because the Palestinian ambassador was saying that gives... Netanyahu and his war cabinet, the green light to say that is a legitimate target.
15:09 Rory Stewart? Remember that the US, the UK and the coalition that supported the Iraqi attack on Mosul jaydammed the main general hospital in Mosul on the grounds that it was an ISIS bomb factory. So it's by no means unheard of for terrorist groups to use these places, understandably, from their point of view.
15:27 Alastair Campbell? But should they not be, do you not think that there needs to be some explanation? I can remember back, you know, sorry to keep going on about personal experience, but I remember in Kosovo, part of what we did was trying to explain why certain facilities were being targeted, why we saw them as legitimate, whereas what seems to be happening at the moment is that we're just very quickly getting normalized to the idea that we see what looked like residences, people's homes, being demolished. There's a, you mentioned Mosul, I sent you, I don't know if you had time to read, but an article that I saw in The Conversation from a guy called Ammar Azuz, who's at Oxford University School of Geography and the Environment. And he, I don't know, I wasn't aware of this word.
16:11 Alastair Campbell? He wrote a piece about this thing called "domicide". Have you heard of "domicide"?
16:15 Rory Stewart? No, I hadn't heard of "domicide" before your piece, no.
16:18 Alastair Campbell? Well, but it's so "domus", which means "home", "side", which means "deliberate killing" and essentially it's destroying people's homes, destroying where people live, destroying where people have a sense of identity, where they come from. And he was writing about his own experience because he was a resident of homes. And that, of course, was wiped out. And, you know, you can rebuild these places, but they're never going to be the same. So in a sense, you're removing people's sense of belonging to a home, to a place. And I, look, I don't want to overstate it, but I just wonder, if you're on the receiving end of this at the moment, it's hard to think that this is not what's happening to you.
17:03 Rory Stewart? Yeah, and the costs of rebuilding are going to be unbelievable. And the question is, who's going to pay for it? You know, hundreds of billions of dollars of damage will have been done already. And the cost of rebuilding an entire city that's been, or half a city that's been flattened by aerial bombardment is unbelievable. And it's absolutely vital. I mean, any hope for any long-term peace.
17:29 Rory Stewart? Would require the people of Gaza to have decent housing, water, electricity, schools, clinics, public infrastructure, roads, and that will have to be reconstructed at a cost of hundreds of billions of dollars. If it doesn't happen, Israel will face itself with an even more radicalized population living in the midst of a humanitarian crisis in rubble and ruin. Who then is picking up the bill for that rebuilding, which is ultimately in the interests of Israel because it's vital for Israel that there is decent humane conditions in Gaza. Otherwise, really, the next five, 10 years is going to be more and more horrifying. We talked about damaged buildings. I mean, it's also worth thinking
18:13 Rory Stewart? about the fact that something like 8,000 people appear to have been killed, at least according to the Hamas Health Ministry. And, you know, we add that coda because it's very difficult to get information on the ground. And you remember, one of the disputes were going to get on to us about the fact that telecoms were shut down, so it's difficult to get reports out of Gaza. But in proportional terms, in a population of 2.2 million, that is like 244,000 people being killed in the UK. And to put that in context, the total UK deaths in World War II were 450,000. So these numbers, in other words, will touch so many individual lives, so many people will know people now who've been killed
18:56 Rory Stewart? or wounded. And then we've got the point about the humanitarian relief. So Israel is denying there's a food shortage, but the number of trucks getting into Gaza, and remember Gaza is this strange place with basically no access, that the borders are largely being closed. There used to be 500 trucks a day before the war. Currently, there's about nine trucks a day getting in. And so we've had essentially a situation where the UN has been looted, as people have tried to get hold of food and basic supplies. Law and order is breaking down. People are living in makeshift shelters with little food or water. And this is the background against which this ground assault is now being launched. And I think the final thing to talk about, and we haven't seen it yet, but it's the
19:38 Rory Stewart? one thing that, from a geostrategic point of view, keeps people awake at night. And maybe they're exaggerating because as I say, we haven't seen it yet and it may turn out not to be the case. But the real fear is what happens if Lebanon gets going, if Iran gets going, if the West Bank gets going, or other Iranian proxies such as the Houthis in Yemen get going. So what happens if this campaign becomes much more internationalised?
20:02 Alastair Campbell? Well, look, we talked last week about the skirmishes going on in and around Lebanese border. There has been an uptick in the killing of Palestinians and of the skirmishes with settlers. And when we get on to talk about Keir Starmer's speech, I noticed that he was saying there's got to be an end to the extension of settlements. But just to stick on this piece from this guy who was from Homs, I'll just read you a section of his article, Amar Azuz. "Domicidal campaigns like this," he's talking about Homs in Syria in 2014, "work to erase evidence that a community actually existed in a particular place and that it had a history and culture there. This is an attempt to write people
20:47 Alastair Campbell? out of history through destroying their homes and heritage in a way that's systematic and deliberate." Now, I'm not saying that's what the Israelis are doing. I am saying that is what the people on the receiving end feel that is happening to them. And of course, as the guy explains, you can't, there's no direct comparison between them. But I think that when you've had this situation, for example, where we talked about this, was it last week or the week before, where the Israelis told people in North Gaza, "move south." And lots did, lots didn't, but lots did. And we've heard stories of people, including from Hamza Youssef's family, people now in homes built for five, six, seven, putting
21:31 Alastair Campbell? up 100, 150 people. Heaven knows what it's like living in those circumstances when you're running out of food and water because of the other problem that you've talked about. And yet now, we seem to be seeing a situation, there was this, you know, and again, we've got to be careful because these are just snapshots that you see because this is the stuff that gets filmed. So I don't know if you saw yesterday the the footage of a of a tank literally taking out a car. Now that was happening around a place where they think, or there is a fear now that Gaza is essentially being split into two. So if you haven't by now left the north, you you're now considered, if you are still in the north, that you're kind of
22:13 Alastair Campbell? fair game. But equally, the people who've gone south are reporting increased bombardment as well. So this is, I think, at a stage where, and I think it's reflected in some of the responses that we're beginning to see from from Biden, from others, essentially there's got to be an understanding that Hamas terrorist organisation, there's no doubt, and this this is something that appears in this piece from the Human Rights Watch guy, Clive Baldwin, what Hamas did was a war crime. For example, taking hostages, that is a war crime. For example, attacking civilian population, that is a war crime. But now
22:55 Alastair Campbell? there has to be an understanding that Israel is operating according to international humanitarian law as well. And I think there's a risk if they don't, and if they're not seen to be doing that, that they will lose international support more quickly than they realise.
23:09 Rory Stewart? Well, and of course, also very important to see the way in which this is viewed in the Middle East. I mean, already, this is becoming the most incredibly divisive issue. And the family of a very prominent out of zero correspondent in Gaza was killed. And many, many tens of millions of people in the Middle East have seen pictures of Wehla Abdul standing there, looking at the bodies of babies on the ground as he mourns his family that's been killed.
23:38 Alastair Campbell? And then reporting, then he went out to work the next day.
23:41 Rory Stewart? Yeah.
23:42 Alastair Campbell? That was pretty extraordinary.
23:44 Rory Stewart? I think every day that this continues, this issue becomes more and more radicalised and the alienation becomes more and more profound.
23:53 Alastair Campbell? Can I just give you a line from this article by the lawyer at Human Rights Watch? Giving warning does not absolve parties from the requirement to protect civilians. Civilians who do not evacuate following a warning continue to be protected. They still must not be targeted and attackers must take all feasible measures to protect them. So he's quoting there from, you know, sort of accepted international law. Now, the point is, I heard an absolutely heartbreaking interview yesterday with somebody who is working inside one of the hospitals where they have been told by the Israelis they need to evacuate. And essentially, he was saying, how do you evacuate somebody who's in the middle of having a baby?
24:37 Alastair Campbell? How do you evacuate somebody who cannot live without the dialysis that they're getting at that time? And so, look, the Israeli government are very, very good at communication. They've got some amazing communicators who go out on the radio, they go on the television. I'm not criticising them for this because it's part of the job that you have to do in these combat situations. But I think sometimes there has to be proper explanation of the military objective that is being pursued and why a particular bombardment or a particular attack lends itself to the pursuit of that military objective. That's the bit at the moment that I'm not seeing.
25:14 Rory Stewart? Now, moving on to the UK dimension, I mean, you raised Kestama, and one of the things that, of course, is very striking is the way in which this conflict, much more than many other conflicts, I mean, this has been true for 50 years, much more than the conflict in Sudan, for example, becomes domestic as well as international. And that's partly some of the stories that we've been talking about. So that was the very large Palestinian demonstrations. And elements in those Palestinian demonstrations waving flags, calling for death to Jews, even if it was a small element, was widely publicised and horrified, very understandably terrified, many members of the Jewish community in Britain. And now we find ourselves with the Labour Party. Very much caught up in this. As as part of this, we want to bring in different voices.
25:58 Rory Stewart? And so on our recent leading podcast, which I hope many of you have listened to, I thought it was a really excellent conversation with Said Awasi, who's a current Conservative but former Cabinet Minister, who takes a very, very strong line on what she sees as the spread of Islamophobia. And of course, this is spreading across. I mean, there's been something like the police in Britain are suggesting a 14 fold increase in antisemitic hate crimes and a three fold increase in Islamophobia in Britain. So big increase of this abuse. Anyway, in it, she criticised a tweet written by Jake Wallace Simons, editor of the Jewish Chronicle, and Mr Wallace Simons has been in touch with us, asking us to clarify that he was condemning jihadism, not Islam. So in the spirit of trying to create a platform where all views can be reasonably expressed,
26:41 Rory Stewart? we've asked Mr Wallace Simons to make a short on the record statement, and he said, I'm now quoting him, "I made the argument on Twitter that parts of Muslim society were, quote, 'in the grip of a death cult that sacralises bloodshed.' I continued, 'Not all, but many Muslims are brainwashed by it. That is a big part of the problem.'" He then goes on to say, "Clearly, I was not talking about Islam. I was talking about the death cult of jihadism in response to scenes of jubilant crowds celebrating the savagery on the streets. Many people took my comments in bad faith and suggested that I was calling Islam itself rather than jihadism a death cult. This is categorically untrue. Islam is a wonderful, rich world religion
27:24 Rory Stewart? that holds many treasures, and I wish only to be friends and allies. It is jihadism that is the death cult, and it needs to be destroyed." So that is from Jake Wallace Simons, editor of Jewish Chronicle.
27:36 Alastair Campbell? Yeah, and I think I think it's right that we should give him the opportunity to to to say that because Said was pretty strong about him. We got amazing feedback from Said's interview. I think partly because she was on Question Time, BBC Question Time at the same time, so people were aware of her as a strong voice on this. And what I think is really difficult at the moment is having this debate in a non-confrontational, non-polarising way. And if we maybe go on to the, you talk about the domestic political scene, and it is fascinating in a way that, Sir Rishi Sunak is the Prime Minister, and the British government, clearly, you know, we're not as powerful as we were maybe, but, you know, the British
28:19 Alastair Campbell? government is still an important voice in this. And yet, in terms of the political media oxygen, as it were, it seems to all be about Labour. And I don't think that's just because people think, well, maybe Labour are going to be in power. I think it's also because there's an overhang there from Corbyn's era.
28:38 Rory Stewart? There is a very interesting story about the relationship between the left, not just in Britain, but throughout Europe and Palestine.
28:45 Alastair Campbell? Mm hmm.
28:46 Rory Stewart? Partly because, going right the way back, left-wing socialist movements were associated with anti-colonialism, international solidarity, fighting Western imperialism. And that meant that, particularly from the early 70s onwards, so I think after the 67 War, and the moment at which the occupation of these territories took place, most of the dominant left-wing movements became very, very pro-Palestine, particularly communist movements in France, Italy, et cetera, slightly less in Germany.
29:14 Alastair Campbell? Yeah, but Rory, if you go back a bit further, who do you think in 1946 wrote a pamphlet entitled A Palestine Munich, which accused the Atlee government, the government led by Clement Atlee, of betraying Jewish statehood? Answer, Michael Foot.
29:33 Rory Stewart? There we are. So, left-wing, for younger listeners, the Jeremy Corbyn of his period, much more left-wing Labour politician. At that stage in the 40s, Labour very much supportive of Israel, weren't they?
29:44 Alastair Campbell? Yeah.
29:45 Rory Stewart? I think things shifted, though, after the 67 War, didn't they, in the early 70s?
29:48 Alastair Campbell? Hold on, let me give you another one. 1980, Tony Benn, writing in his diary, "I am against PLO recognition, not because I am anti-Palestinian, but because the annihilation of Israel is the PLO's objective, and they are associated with terrorism."
30:06 Rory Stewart? Yep. No, it's not as simple. By the early eighties, though, the French recognised the PLO, didn't they? The French left recognised the PLO. So, Alison, let me talk to you a little bit about Tony Blair, because this is a very interesting thing. So my sense is that what we're looking at now in the Israel attack on Gaza is very similar in its international consequences to the Israel attack on Lebanon in 1982, which was a big, big defining feature that really shook even some of the traditional more right-wing support for Israel. And actually, famously Ronald Reagan was so horrified by some of the images he was seeing, he pushed very hard for Israel to cease the Lebanon attacks in 82. So Labour went through this long evolution, and one of the things that changed, I think, just before we come to
30:50 Rory Stewart? Tony Blair, that made the situation more complicated for the left, was the emergence of Islamist groups, of which Hamas is the most prominent, because traditionally Palestine and that movement in the seventies and early eighties was secular. It wasn't associated with radical Islam.
31:06 Alastair Campbell? Yeah.
31:06 Rory Stewart? In fact, it was very much something supported by the non-aligned movement by communist countries. It was seen as part of a general socialist movement, anti-colonial. And then, of course, it became confused with the question of Islam and the war on terror, at the point at which Tony Blair took over. And so tell us a little bit about Tony Blair's evolving views on Israel. And I wondered also whether we should get him back on the podcast, because he was the Middle East envoy, wasn't he? He was deeply embedded in this for many, many years.
31:34 Alastair Campbell? He was. And I think that that was a period of his life that I think he was incredibly motivated and unbelievably frustrated. I remember he's constantly complaining is the wrong word, but sort of lamenting the nature of the negotiations, the nature of the discussions that he was involved in. If you look at his own account of this, in his own autobiography, Journey... He does describe the Israel-Lebanon war in 2006. He says this, "That event and my reaction to it probably did me more damage than anything since Iraq."
32:09 Rory Stewart? What was his reaction?
32:10 Alastair Campbell? Well, his reaction was basically, it was very, very on the side of the Israelis. He was very pro-Israel. And that is something that I think was pretty hardwired into him. I think a little bit like David Cameron, he had a real sense that he understood the Israeli perspective and he gave it far more sympathy than a lot of people on the left perhaps do. But he then did say this, this was perhaps one of the more self-reflective pieces of the book in a way, he said, "It showed how hard I had swung from the mainstream of conventional Western media wisdom and from my own people. But also," he said, "how set, open brackets, stuck, question marks, close brackets, in my own mode of thinking I had become."
32:55 Rory Stewart? Okay, unpack that a bit. So it talks about his own people and his own mode of thinking. I mean, there's a lot going on there.
33:00 Alastair Campbell? Well, I can remember talking to Sally Morgan, who was obviously one of the kind of central team around Tony, you know, as it were, before, during and after. I remember she and I having conversations about how worried we were, about how Tony was so far out on the issue, where the Labour Party was not in the same place and he just had to adapt a bit. And he wasn't really up for that because he felt so strongly that there had to be voices standing up for Israel. And we're seeing something similar now where at the start, and you know, this is something you and I talked about from day one. And this was my worry from the Labour Party's perspective from day one, is that of course you've got to go absolutely out and be very, very firmly on the side of Israel when they're
33:45 Alastair Campbell? being attacked in this vicious manner as they were in October the 7th. But how quickly... Things can move in terms of, if you like, the body politic, where opinion is. So I think what Tony was saying there was that everything in him felt that the position he held was the right position to hold. And he's not an opinion form, he's a leader in this, in this context. And yet, he could sense the body politic had moved, moved away from him.
34:13 Rory Stewart? So I think within the Labour Party, there are clearly different traditions. And Keir Starmer, I think in his leadership run, had a video with Palestinian flags being waved and was very much drawing on some of that part of the traditions of the Labour Party. And then since he's come in, he's very much defined himself by challenging Jeremy Corbyn's antisemitism. And that's a complicated issue, as we've discussed in the past, because there's a fine line between the question of genuine antisemites and people like Jeremy Corbyn, who would argue, and I'm quite sympathetic to him on this, that fundamentally what drives him is sympathy for the Palestinian cause.
34:49 Alastair Campbell? I think it's what's driven a lot of the tensions within Labour in recent days, has been the sense that in this Twitter world, where, you know, everything's black and white and you just have one strong view, that the view that has emanated from the Labour leadership has been, as with the government, so strongly supportive of Israel's right to defend itself, that the other side of the argument, the justness of the Palestinian cause, as it were, is not being heard. And I think that's what, in part, what Keir Starmer's, we're recording this Tuesday morning, and Keir Starmer's making a speech later today, setting out the whole picture from the Labour perspective.
35:30 Rory Stewart? Just to, I mean, expand on that. So Andy McDonald, Middlesbrough MP, made a speech referring, using this phrase, "from the river to the sea", which is very much associated with Palestinian demands essentially to take over the whole of Israel.
35:43 Alastair Campbell? Yep.
35:44 Rory Stewart? Ian Lavery and John McDonnell came out in favour of him. Thirteen junior shadow ministers attacked the Labour leadership for refusing to endorse a ceasefire. This is one of the big, big debates across the world, whether or not you should be endorsing a ceasefire. And then you had Andy Storr, Yasmin Khorshi, Jess Phillips, and then later Sadiq Khan, Anna Sawa, your friend who we saw in Scotland, Andy Burnham, our friend who we interviewed on Manchester. All talking about the need for a ceasefire. And Shabana Mahmood, who's the Shadow Justice Secretary, accusing Israel of imposing collective punishments. So this is a difficult moment for Keir Starmer, isn't it?
36:18 Alastair Campbell? It is, it is, because we've come through the party conference season, Rishi Sunak's conference really not going very well for the Tories, Keir Starmer's conference went very well for Labour. And then along comes this issue and suddenly it looks like the Labour Party, which was very united, is not quite united after all. And I think that's why people should take a good look at Keir Starmer's speech today. I think it, I had no part in the writing of it, Rory. But because, because I knew that we'd be recording before the speech, but the episode wouldn't go out until afterwards, I did sort of ask a friendly contact there, whether I could have a little look at one of the drafts.
37:01 Alastair Campbell? And the first of all, he makes a very important point, which is very hard for politicians to make. He says that we should not overestimate Britain's capacity to influence what's going on, but we should do what we, what we can. I think that is an important point because there's a danger that once you end up with the debate on, well, should you call for a ceasefire? Shouldn't you call for a ceasefire? As if Benjamin Netanyahu is sitting around there saying, I wonder what, you know, Hampstead and Highgate CLP is going to say.
37:30 Rory Stewart? The problem is, in a political speech of this sort, it can sound a little bit like making an excuse. So it can sound like a preface to saying, well, it doesn't really matter what I think because Britain doesn't have much influence anyway. It's an excuse for not really coming down clearly on one side or the other.
37:44 Alastair Campbell? No, but interestingly, when I, when I read the speech, I had little echoes in my head of Macron. Remember when Macron was, was in his en même temps phase? When everything he said was, you know, well, on one hand, but en même temps on the other hand. And there's a little bit like that. So for example, he talks about the events of October 7th being terrorism on a scale and brutality that few countries have ever experienced, certainly not this one.
38:12 Alastair Campbell? And then saying that is an immutable fact that must drive our response to these events, as must the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, which again is playing out on a previously unimaginable scale. And similarly, at every stage, he says, my approach is driven by the need to respond to both these tragedies, to stand by the right to self defence of any nation which suffers terrorism like this, alongside the basic human rights of innocent Palestinians. So that is very much kind of en même temps.
38:39 Rory Stewart? Let's see if he pulls it off, because I think Macron's en même temps is very much part of his brand, isn't it? And it's a pretty peculiar thing. And generally speaking in politics, on the one hand, on the other, is not usually what we associate with clarity from political leaders. But I think the thing he'll be hit on, I mean, I think he can make a good speech, but if you look at those figures of the rebellions and people have come out, is he going to join the Labour leader in Scotland, the Labour mayor of Manchester in calling for a ceasefire or not?
39:07 Alastair Campbell? No, he's not. He actually is very, very clear. He says, well, I understand calls for a permanent ceasefire at this stage. I do not believe that is the correct position now. And he goes on to explain, a permanent ceasefire would freeze the conflict in the state where it currently lies. He does say, in the draft I saw, right at the end of the speech, that we live in this black and white world where everybody has to have sort of strong views this way, strong views that way. But actually, the only way we're going to get to a settlement of this is through a political process. Now, I think what's really, what was quite impressive in its own way, I mean, Keir Starmer's getting a lot of flak at the moment. People just want him to stand up and essentially be the commentator, say there should be a ceasefire. Well, there isn't going to be a ceasefire. You know, that's,
39:51 Alastair Campbell? I think, why he was admitting.
39:53 Rory Stewart? Now, can I come in on this? Because we keep coming up, why doesn't he just say it? What's the problem with saying it?
39:58 Alastair Campbell? The problem with saying it is that it makes him a commentator rather than a political leader. And I think part of his mindset is thinking-
40:04 Rory Stewart? So why does Andy Burnham say he's a political leader?
40:07 Alastair Campbell? Because he's the mayor of Manchester, and he's not the guy who most people think is going to the Prime Minister quite soon. If he's the Prime Minister- Then one of the most important relationships he's going to have immediately is with the President of the United States. If he suddenly finds that that relationship is defined by him coming out essentially criticizing the approach of the United States on this thus far. Joe Biden, I think, is absolutely adamant, no ceasefire, Israel's right to defend itself. And meanwhile, back behind the scenes, he's saying, heaven's sake, Bibi, just, you know, watch the way you're working on this. And I think, and the other, the other alliance, which is going to be there, whether it's Netanyahu, whether it's another leader, in terms of coming to terms with the consequences of this war that's going on now, the consequences of this are going to be with
40:52 Alastair Campbell? us for decades. And Keir Starmer's thinking, I'm not just the leader of the opposition on this right now, I'm the guy that these people are expecting to be the Prime Minister. So I think part of what he's trying to do with his speech today, and it will get a lot of attention, it will probably live on the news channels unless Dominic Cummings is sort of, you know, blathering away, he'll be wanting people to look at him and think, well, I may wish he says this and wish he said that, but actually, part of the thinking is, can I imagine this guy as the Prime Minister in a year's time?
41:21 Rory Stewart? But, but, but France, Spain, the Netherlands, Ireland, Slovenia, Luxembourg have all gone further than him, haven't they? And is that because they, they're less worried about their relationship with the US?
41:30 Alastair Campbell? Has Macron come out and called for a ceasefire?
41:31 Rory Stewart? They've all backed the idea of a humanitarian pause, which Starmer still hasn't done.
41:35 Alastair Campbell? No, he has done, he has done. This is the thing. He's backed the idea of humanitarian pauses, plural. This was the, this was the debate.
41:43 Rory Stewart? Let's share this. But if you, if you look at the, the Guardian reports on this stuff, clearly this, the sense is, and he needs to get out and make this very clear if this is true, the sense amongst journalists is that the EU is ahead of Starmer on this stuff and is taking a bolder position. If that's not true, he needs to clarify that he's in line with the EU position.
42:01 Alastair Campbell? I was in France last week and, and I was following the German media quite closely on the European summit. The European Union is in a very, very strange position on this because there's a very big divide going on between Ursula von der Leyen, who's the head of the Commission, and Charles Michel, who's the, essentially the President of the Council, as it were. And the reason this thing became so important is, and they, they appear to be at odds. They're usually quite close on things, but they do appear to be at odds. And there's no doubt there is a range of opinion across the European Union. But I think Keir Starmer is clearly saying there should be humanitarian pauses.
42:37 Rory Stewart? I love your S that keeps coming in.
42:41 Alastair Campbell? It is the S because a pause.
42:43 Rory Stewart? Which is what the EU wants. They want a pause.
42:47 Alastair Campbell? No, they want pauses. They agreed on pauses in the end because they had several countries who wouldn't side up to pause.
42:54 Rory Stewart? Let's, let's keep watching this.
42:55 Alastair Campbell? We've barely talked in our discussions in this about the current Palestinian leadership because Mahmoud Abbas, the leader of the Palestinian Authority is, he barely figures in these conversations now. And that's the other problem in this, which of course the Israelis have been, have been exploiting. You have Hamas in Gaza, you have the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank. Because the other voice is very strong in terms of our prime ministers. David Cameron was, was very, very pro-Israel. He made very strong statements in favor of Israel whenever they got into these, these situations.
43:26 Rory Stewart? I think the Conservatives have a very complicated tradition around this. And this is right, people should, if you have the time, listen to Saadawi's interview with us on leading. Because on the one hand, you have Saadawi saying that Mohammed was a Conservative and that she's very proud of some Muslims to be a Conservative. On the other hand, she's acknowledging that David Cameron very much supported Michael Gove's very passionately pro-Israeli position within his cabinet.
43:53 Alastair Campbell? Can I make one final point on the, on the kind of linking the domestic to the international? The first thing I got, when I got back home last night, I turned on the news and the first thing I saw was Suella Brathman calling these marches and these demonstrations that have been marches of hate. I mean, that woman, honestly, at least what Keir Starmer was trying to do today, he celebrates the fact that actually, yes, there's been a rise in Islamophobia, yes, there's been a rise in antisemitism, but actually it's almost, we are, we are pretty good at living together as the United Kingdom and we shouldn't lose that. And yet she seems to want to turn these things into, to call it marches of hate, as if every single person on those marches wants to sort of eradicate Israel from the face of the map.
44:37 Alastair Campbell? It's, I'm afraid this horrible exploitation of problems rather than trying to fix them. And I think at least what I saw in Keir Starmer's speech today. Was a serious analysis of a British opposition leader rather than a British politician trying to exploit it.
44:52 Rory Stewart? Let's let's see how this plays out. My prediction is that he's in trouble and he's in trouble with the left of the Labour Party and he'll be in trouble with a lot of the Muslim community in Britain, but we'll see whether the speech manages to address that.
45:03 Alastair Campbell? Rory, there's no doubt. I've talked I've talked to some MPs who are in seats with large Muslim population and they say that, you know, they are under real pressure, real pressure, genuine political pressure. And of course, you know, the Lib Dems are moving in pretty hard to say, well, that's because Labour this and Labour that and we're the only people you can trust. So it's for some MPs, this is politically very difficult, but I think Starmer has made the decision. Ultimately, this is about him being tested as a leader and standing up for things that are difficult as well as things that are easy.
45:32 Rory Stewart? Very good. Okay, time for a break.
45:34 Speaker 03 Mr. President, my company told me of the explosion on our rig on October 2nd. Causing massive water displacement and triggering a tsunami. They all heap the blame on me. Tom Cruise is.
45:46 Speaker 04 Digger got us into this mess and Digger's gonna dig us up. From the director of Birdman and the Revenant.
45:52 Speaker 05 What would happen if I stopped drilling? You stall, you freeze in there, that's what.
45:56 Speaker 04 With great power comes great deniability.
45:59 Speaker 05 I'm not the first man.
46:00 Speaker 04 Digger, see the trailer online, only in theaters October 2nd. Rated R, under 17, not a middle without parent.
46:05 Speaker 05 Priceline Negotiator.
46:07 Speaker 06 It's me, the. Priceline Negotiator. We don't need the jingle twice. What about a third time? Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights and rental cars.
46:20 Speaker 05 Seems like you decided.
46:22 Speaker 06 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Time to read the tagline. Fine, no one deals more deals than. Priceline. Please stop. Priceline. Touche. Priceline. Priceline.
46:36 Speaker 07 This episode is brought to you by Tic Tac. Lace up and get your game on because the Tic Tac lineup just got a new teammate. Dr Pepper Tic Tac. This new double threat puts two of your favorite flavors into one box of mints. And when two iconic flavors come together, the result can only be iconic. Score big. Try Dr Pepper Tic Tac today.
47:05 Rory Stewart? Welcome back to The Rest Is Politics with me Rory Stewart.
47:07 Alastair Campbell? And me Alastair Campbell.
47:09 Rory Stewart? And we are talking now at the launch of a very, very interesting initiative, which is Rishi Sunak is hosting a huge international AI summit at Bletchley Park, Bletchley, of course, being the place where all the code breaking took place during the Second World War, so a big iconic nod to British security and technology. And it is a big deal. It's a really, really big deal. And he'll be very pleased with it. It's not perfect. I mean, he's got the Vice President of the United States, not the President. He's got the President of the European Commission, but not Macron. But as I think you mentioned at the beginning, he's got Elon Musk flying over. Reid Hoffman, who we interviewed a couple of weeks ago, is flying over today. And an enormous number of the most significant AI minds in the world
47:52 Rory Stewart? are gathering. And that's quite a thing for Britain to pull off. And Reid was joking with me yesterday that Biden is sufficiently competitive about this to have rushed out an executive order on Monday on AI to try to preempt the British summit, because they're all deeply, deeply competitive on who makes the first moves on AI. All the world leaders are desperate to be seen as being ahead of the game. And there are many, many things that we've talked about which are Rishi Sunak's weaknesses. But this is something which I think, given all the criticisms and all the things that we're acknowledging, and given the fact that I think he's almost certainly not going to be Prime Minister again in a
48:31 Rory Stewart? year's time, if he's remembered for things positively, if in 15, 20 years' time, he becomes the sort of national treasure, a kind of John Major that we put on leading, it'll be because of this sort of stuff.
48:45 Alastair Campbell? Rory, I'm glad to see that you've moved from, everybody in Number 10 tells me that Rishi Sunak is the grown up, to one day he might be a national treasure.
48:56 Rory Stewart? Anyway, if he is a natural, I think it'll partly be because of this, because I think this is something where he has a natural interest. He studied at Stanford. He's very interested in technology. He knows how to talk to these people and he has, and I think that genuine intellectual interest comes across and it's quite an achievement for Britain, given all that we talk about, given how many problems we're in, that they've managed to pull this together since June and that this may be the beginning of a real, proper annual process. He wants it to be like the International Climate Change Committee, but something that really could become not just the US putting out legislation, but international legislation.
49:31 Alastair Campbell? Well, I see that one of the, one of the things that is going to come out of it, I saw in something I read about it, was that there will be an agreement about where the next international AI gathering should be. So it could well become an annual thing and that would be a good thing. And look, I agree with you here. You and I have both been saying for months that there seems to be no sense of political momentum behind getting a grip of some of these issues. And when we talked with Reid Hoffman, he was very strongly of the view, he was very critical, for example, of the European Union trying to sort of, you know, regulate this stuff. He says, no great technology has been regulated until it's been fully formed. But the trouble with this stuff is it's so powerful and so complicated and so potentially dangerous, Reid did admit that, and Mustafa Suleyman,
50:16 Alastair Campbell? his colleague and friend, admitted it even more, that I think politicians are negligent if they don't get on top of this. And Joe Biden, the executive order that he rushed out on Monday, it's pretty big stuff because it's basically saying to all developers of AI systems that they have to, before they release anything to the public, there has to be an analysis of risk, the national security, the economy, public health or safety, and that all the tests, results of tests that they do have to be shared with the US government. So that's quite a big thing. And Elon Musk, this is a risk that Sunak's taking, he's doing a, I mean, I've kind of lost it with Elon Musk for all sorts of reasons, but Rishi
50:56 Alastair Campbell? Sunak is doing a, a live chat on Twitter or X, whatever it's called. And, you know, I think that they were, they were sort of panting. Breathlessly about it on the radio this morning, but it's quite a risk because I think Musk is so unpredictable in these circumstances. Heaven knows what he's going to say.
51:14 Rory Stewart? Yeah, that that's right. Well, just on Biden's executive order, I think one thing that's great about it is that the US are going to be red teaming, which is something the US does very well, and I wish we did more of in Britain, which is that one of the best ways of stress testing something is to set up a team of very bright people and get them, as it were, to be devil's advocates. And really work out how to work through the worst case scenario. You know, I always felt we should have done more of that in Afghanistan, have people red teaming, you know, as it were, playing the Taliban against us. And the US will really put money behind this. Seriously smart people trying to work out how, what the very worst case could be on a new AI release. The other thing is watermarking.
51:53 Alastair Campbell? Yeah.
51:53 Rory Stewart? And this is, this is about deep fakes. One of the things that's changed just in the last few days, I think, on this UK AI summit is initially the threats they were focused on understandably were things like biosecurity. So, you know, the fact that AI could pretty quickly allow someone even like you and me without an advanced doctrine in biochemistry to begin putting together some pretty nasty biological weapons. I mean, I think as Yuval said, we need to think in terms of, maybe it's somebody with a bit more scientific training than you and me, but anyway, it enabling somebody, as it were, to put together COVID and Ebola together. So bio risks.
52:29 Alastair Campbell? Just on the point about the watermarking, the White House were briefing that one of the reasons Biden was getting more exercised about this issue is because he'd been given a presentation about some of the fake stuff that was circulating about himself and about the use of his own voice.
52:45 Rory Stewart? Which you, which you've talked about, haven't you?
52:47 Alastair Campbell? Yeah.
52:47 Rory Stewart? You've, you've seen some of that.
52:48 Alastair Campbell? I've seen some of that stuff. Yeah, yeah.
52:50 Rory Stewart? So this, this summit will now, has now inserted a session on deep fakes and elections. I mean, next year is, as I think we've talked before, a really big year for international politics because next year is going to be the UK election, the US election, the Indian election, the EU elections, almost certainly Pakistani elections. So I think this question of how deep fakes are going to be used by AI and the way in which you try to, so watermarking obviously is there to try to allow you to distinguish. Between something that's genuine and something that isn't. And of course, the only way you can do that is, as it were, by using AI against AI. So there's a sort of element of arms race in all of this.
53:29 Alastair Campbell? Yeah, yeah.
53:30 Rory Stewart? Couple more things quickly. I mean, so this is obviously something that Rishi Sunak is desperate for the UK to be relevant to AI. It's really difficult to do because the sums of money involved are completely eye watering.
53:44 Alastair Campbell? Hmm.
53:45 Rory Stewart? Microsoft, for example, which I think had over a hundred billion dollars of cash in the bank, is now in a situation where for the first time, certainly in my memory, they're actually moving into a technical deficit this year. And quite a lot of that is their enormous investment in computing capacity to get into the right position on AI. Because the next iteration of ChatGPT, these large language models, will be spending 10 times as much on training the model. But then you need this immense banks of computers, electricity, et cetera, to simply run and power these models. And these Titanic fights between these companies like Google and Microsoft that can spend tens of billions of dollars against each other.
54:29 Rory Stewart? The UK is deciding to go for a particular niche. So they've committed nine hundred million dollars in AI funding. A lot of that is going to a supercomputer facility in Bristol, where I think they're going to put four hundred million into chips. And and they've just got, there's also a big investment in genetics database. I mean, we should talk about this a bit more. I mean, there's both a risk and a potential here for the UK. So the NHS is obviously the most extraordinary database in the world because we have data going back, universal healthcare going back to the mid nineteen forties, covering every part of British society with incredibly rich information in a way that countries like the US simply don't have because they've got fragmented private systems.
55:11 Rory Stewart? So in theory, if you could safely get into those databases, you could find the most amazing medical insights through AI. You could find correlations between, I don't know, people's eye color and their diabetes or correlations between their height at the age of ten and their. Development of cancer at the age of fifty or goodness knows what, right? The problem, on the other hand, of course, is, and Palantir, which is a extraordinary computer company with initially links to the US intelligence services and to Peter Thiel, who's this very bright but very right wing former friend of Reid Hoffman that we were talking about in the leading interview ten days ago, has now got the contracts to do an enormous amount of the data analysis for the NHS. But of course, privacy campaigners
55:56 Rory Stewart? are very, very worried because they're saying this is letting people in on our data. And a lot of the potential around technology, its ability to develop these amazing productivity benefits, you know, people are talking about fifty five point eight percent productivity improvements, depends on whether or not we're actually prepared to allow AI to do this stuff and in particular, access private data.
56:17 Alastair Campbell? Yeah, and I think this goes back to the point about, we're talking about such big stuff here, that the politicians do have to get on top of this sooner rather than later, because the technology is developing so quickly that there is a risk that these guys just outwit the politicians. I mean, I noticed in some of the business responses to Joe Biden's order, for example, it was very much a sort of, you know, well, we know better how this stuff works than the politicians do, and people won't want to share all the data that they have. I agree with you. I think that Sunak is to be commended for trying to make this issue and to try to bring all these people together. One other point, if I can, though, Rory, I think that Rishi Sunak getting on top of this, in a sense, projecting
57:00 Alastair Campbell? himself as a guy who understands the future, I think it does sit rather badly with the continuing attempt to turn the net zero and the future of the planet into what he calls a wedge issue, which I see, according to the papers, he's going to be using the King's Speech to do, in terms of actually focusing on this as a political issue rather than as actually something that really matters for the future of humanity. So I'd be more convinced of Sunak, the modern leader, addressing these modern issues if he wasn't backtracking the way that he is on his commitment on the environment.
57:34 Rory Stewart? Yeah, there's a huge amount to talk about there. I mean, I think one of the things that remains a massive international scandal is the way that international development finance, so the money that we lend to other countries at cheap rates, continues to support coal, oil and gas. So forty one billion dollars. A year, five times the support for clean energy going into coal, oil and gas 2018 to 2020. And this is something that when I was a diff minister, I tried to stop. I tried to say it's ridiculous that we're using British development money or concessional loans to build heavy oil plants or coal plants in Africa. But it remains a huge issue, even within the EU.
58:14 Rory Stewart? Fossil fuel subsidies have increased from 56 billion to 122 billion during 2022, partly because of the response to the Russia crisis.
58:24 Alastair Campbell? So, yeah. I mean, I'm actually later today going to be speaking at a net zero conference. And part of the speech I've written was driven by the response to something that you said on the podcast a while back when we were talking about the environment. The problem is that we'd kind of got the low hanging fruit. And now it was focusing much more on cost, you know, the cost of heating your home, the cost of cars, et cetera. And I got a wonderful email, I should forward it to you actually, from Corinne Soares, who's a, she co-authored a very good book called Supercharge Me, Net Zero Faster. And she was, she was making the point actually that the low hanging fruit is going to get
59:05 Alastair Campbell? lower and lower and pointing to the impact of the Inflation Reduction Act in America. And I dug into this a bit and Credit Suisse, for example, described the Inflation Reduction Act as the most ambitious, comprehensive legislative action ever taken on addressing climate change. And this goes back to a point that Mustafa Suleiman made when we talked to him, that the more that stuff gets used, the cheaper that it becomes. Whereas with fossil fuels, that is not the case. Fossil fuels, when you take inflation into account, coal roughly is getting sold at the same kind of price as it always was, whereas the new technologies get cheaper and cheaper and cheaper, the more that they get used. So the point she was making about America, for example, is that transport and energy
59:49 Alastair Campbell? is already getting cheaper. And the more that we can persuade people to go down the clean technology route, ultimately the more we're going to save for ourselves and the more we're going to save for the economy as a whole.
1:00:01 Rory Stewart? Good. Well, lots more to talk about on the environment, but thank you. And I think we're maybe coming to the end of the pod.
1:00:06 Alastair Campbell? We didn't cover the COVID inquiry, but maybe we can do that in, in question time.
1:00:11 Rory Stewart? Yeah, let's do, let's do COVID inquiry in question time tomorrow.
1:00:14 Alastair Campbell? All the best.
1:00:14 Rory Stewart? Bye bye.
1:00:20 Speaker 03 Mr. President, my company foreme of the explosion on our rig.
1:00:23 Speaker 04 On October 2nd.
1:00:24 Speaker 03 Causing massive water displacement and triggering a tsunami. They all heap the blame on me.
1:00:29 Speaker 04 Tom Cruise is. Digger got us into this mess.
1:00:32 Speaker 03 And Digger's gonna dig us out.
1:00:34 Speaker 04 From the director of Birdman and The Revenant.
1:00:36 Speaker 05 What would happen if I stopped drilling? You stall, you freeze to death, that's what.
1:00:40 Speaker 04 With great power comes great deniability.
1:00:44 Speaker 05 I'm not the first then.
1:00:45 Speaker 04 Digger. See the trailer online. Only in theaters October 2nd. Rated R. Under 17. Not a middle without parent.
1:00:50 Speaker 08 This episode is brought to you by Jira by Atlassian. Jira isn't just for tracking work anymore. It's how dev teams stay in control when AI agents are executing on the work. Assign to your favorite agent and the agent gets full context from across your stack right away. A pull request surfaces when it's ready. You stay in the loop and out of the weeds. See how teams are shipping with agents at jira.dev. That's J-I-R-A dot D-E-V.
1:01:17 Speaker 09 Espolone Tequila. Balanced, delicious. 100% acave, 0% ego. Just add ice, lime, and your mouth. For a real margarita, ride the rooster.
1:01:27 Speaker 04 Espolone Tequila, 40% alcohol by volume, 80 proof. Copyright 2026, Campagna America, New York, New York. Drink responsibly.
Previous 186. Question Time: Nigel Farage’s plan to become Tory leader Next 188. Question Time: What the Covid Inquiry says about Britain Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated
