Pod Insights The Rest Is History 557. 1066: The Norman Conquest (Part 4) About this episode What happened in the aftermath of the Battle of Hastings? What horrors did William the Conqueror have to inflict upon his Anglo Saxon subjects in order to consolidate his new realm? And, what role did castles, the Harrowing of the North, and the Doomsday Book play in the creation of a new England?
Join Tom and Dominic as they discuss William the Conquerer's new reign in the wake of the Battle of Hastings, and the true nature of the Norman Conquest.
_______
Twitter:
@TheRestHistory
@holland_tom
@dcsandbrook
Producer: Theo Young-Smith
Assistant Producer: Tabby Syrett + Aaliyah Akude
Executive Producers: Jack Davenport + Tony Pastor
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,268 words · 6 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:03 Tom Holland? This episode is brought to you by Mint Mobile. Right now, all of Mint's plans are $15 per month, even unlimited. So go to mintmobile.com/history.
0:16 Dominic Sandbrook? Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for 12 months, plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50GB may slow when network is busy. Includes up to 20GB of hotspot. Capable device required. Availability, speed and coverage varies. See mintmobile.com.
0:44 Tom Holland? This episode is brought to you by AutoTrader. Now, if car shopping feels like a massive faff, buying your car online at AutoTrader makes it way easier, really.
0:55 Dominic Sandbrook? So you can shop loads and loads of cars online. You can compare prices. You can check the financing and trade-in options. And of course, you can do it from wherever you are. You start online, go to the dealer for your test drive and finish wherever works for you. Your information, your data stays with you, so there is no starting over. Plus, you are working with local dealers and there are real people there to help.
1:21 Tom Holland? So buy your car online on AutoTrader, really.
1:29 Dominic Sandbrook? This episode is brought to you by TikTok. We obviously love history here. It's always a treat to make a new discovery, especially in unexpected ways.
1:38 Tom Holland? Which is exactly what happens on TikTok. Like, you know coffee. You make it, add milk, drink it. Nothing more, except...
1:49 Dominic Sandbrook? Except, when you hop on TikTok, you don't just learn how to make an authentic cappuccino. You can also discover videos about how in the 1700s, people would pour their coffee into saucers to let it cool before drinking it.
2:04 Tom Holland? And suddenly, you're imagining how people lived, drank, socialised.
2:10 Tom Holland? Makes you wonder what will baffle historians about us? And that's the joy of TikTok. You look for one thing and find yourself somewhere completely different.
2:19 Dominic Sandbrook? Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok.
2:23 Tom Holland? Visit tiktok.com forward slash discover more.
2:39 Dominic Sandbrook? Harold had fallen, as his valiant brothers had fallen before him. The event too truly showed that England had fallen with the sons of Godwin. That as ever in this age, everything turned on the life of one man. And that the one man who could have guarded and saved England was taken from her. Such being the case, it is from that memorable day that we may fairly date the overthrow. What we know to have been only the imperfect and temporary overthrow of our ancient and free Teutonic England.
3:21 Dominic Sandbrook? In the eyes of men of the next generation, that day was the fatal day of England. The day of the sad overthrow of our dear country. The day of her handing over to foreign lords. From that day forward, the Normans began to work the will of God upon the folk of England. Till they were left in England, no chiefs of the land of English blood. Till all were brought down to bondage and to sorrow. Till it was a shame to be called an Englishman. And the men of England were no more a people.
3:59 Tom Holland? So that was one of the great historians. It was Edward A. Freeman. It was the man with whom 10 episodes ago, we began our account of the Norman conquest. Now, you can't argue with Edward A. Freeman because he was Regis Professor of History at Oxford.
4:14 Dominic Sandbrook? Book on the Norman conquest, the history of the Norman conquest in England. Not just the best, but more importantly, the longest history of the Norman conquest at six volumes, published to mark the 800th anniversary. And he correctly identified the Normans as the absolute filth of Europe and England and its Teutonic traditions and its traditions of freedom and democracy and love of country. He identified those, Tom, as the motor of all history. And what is more, he pointed out quite rightly that it doesn't matter about the masses in history and millions of people, it's really about one man and that man is Harold Godwinson, the one man who could have guarded and saved England.
4:58 Dominic Sandbrook? This is the best episode of The Rest is History we've ever done, but are you going to now say that this is all tosh and rubbish?
5:03 Tom Holland? Yeah, so very, I mean, very much your kind of guy. He loves Harold Godwinson, he writes enormously long books, just go on and on and on and never stop. Yeah, very much your kind of guy. So clearly he is mourning the death of Harold. He sees the two as being, you know, interfused. Harold is the one man who could have guarded and saved England and now he is dead. So is he right that Hastings was a catastrophe for England? I mean, did it result in the extinction of her ancestral freedoms? Was everything that Anglo-Saxon England had been destroyed at Senlac Hill?
5:42 Dominic Sandbrook? Do you know who'd agreed with this bloke Freeman? The roundheads, people in the 17th century who believed in the Norman yoke.
5:49 Tom Holland? Dominic, we will be coming to that, we'll be doing a bonus on the way that 1066 and the Norman conquest was interpreted. So there will be more about that if you're a member of The Rest is History Club, but for now, we're going to try and answer some of those questions that I just put. But a reminder first of all, of where we ended the previous episode. So it is 1654 on the 14th of October, St Calixtus's Day, 1066, and the sun has just set.
6:21 Tom Holland? And the sun, Dominic, has also set on the fortunes of the Godwins and of England.
6:29 Dominic Sandbrook? Oh, terrible.
6:30 Tom Holland? The slopes and the summit of Senlac Hill are piled with the bodies of the dead and the dying, and the mud reeks of blood and emptied bowels. Cries fill the darkening twilight, and already you've got to imagine pillagers creeping up through the dark, starting to strip corpses of their mail shirts, their weapons, their clothes, anything that might be of any value. And the killing is not yet over, even though darkness is now over Sussex, because the the English have turned and fled. But this, of course, is when the Norman cavalry comes into its own, because they can pursue the fugitives and hump them down.
7:12 Dominic Sandbrook? Hmm.
7:13 Tom Holland? You'll be glad to hear, Dominic, they don't have it all their own way, because it it does seem, despite the garbled nature of the various accounts, there seems confusion as to exactly what happens. But it's clear that a body of of English warriors, either fugitives or perhaps new arrivals, make a stand, perhaps on some ancient earthworks, it's not entirely clear, and they inflict a number of casualties on the Normans. And there is one report that useless of Boulogne, William's mate, who, according to the earliest account we have, was actually responsible for the death of Harold, that he received a blow between his shoulders that led to blood gushing out from his nose and mouth in the great fountain.
7:56 Dominic Sandbrook? That's good news. That's great news. I'm very pleased to hear that.
8:00 Tom Holland? And there are later accounts that report an entire ditch ending up filled with Norman casualties, and that it was called the Malphoss, so the the evil ditch, a great ditch that had been covered with brambles. So the killing does go on through the night. But when dawn comes on the 15th of October, what it reveals is a spectacle of carnage that is
8:20 Tom Holland? So terrible that even the Normans are are kind of stunned by it. A bit like the English after Agincourt, and we should remind ourselves that the English will go on to win a victory over the French in due course.
8:34 Dominic Sandbrook? We had the last laugh.
8:35 Tom Holland? William of Patie writes about the battlefield of Sedna Cale. Far and wide, the earth was covered with the flower of the English nobility and youth drenched in gore. And William orders the Norman dead to be buried, but does he order the English dead to be buried? Dominic, he does not. He leaves them as food for worms and wolves, birds and dogs, as the Carmen puts it. He does, however, give orders for the bodies of Harold and his two brothers, Geth and Leifwine, to be found, and they are treated with more respect, although there are so many differing stories about what happens to them and how William chooses to treat them. It's actually, again, very hard to to make sense of what may actually have happened.
9:16 Tom Holland? So there is one brilliant late story that Harold's body has been left so mangled that no one can identify it. And so they send for Edith Swanneck, his lover mistress, concubine, first wife, whatever you want to call her.
9:29 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah.
9:30 Tom Holland? In the words of the chronicler, she had a more intimate knowledge of his body than anyone else.
9:34 Dominic Sandbrook? If those previous accounts in the last episode are true, then, I mean, that would avail her nothing.
9:38 Tom Holland? Right, well, but maybe they found them as well and kind of brought them back and stuck them on. We don't know. The Carmen, which is the source closest in time to Hastings, recounts how William has Harold's body wrapped in purple linen. And then Harold's mother, Githa, comes and offers to pay William Harold's weight in gold if she can be given the body. Again, a possible classical allusion there to Achilles and Hector and everything. I mean, is it being modeled directly on them? Is Githa thinking of that? We don't know, but according to the Carmen, William doesn't give Githa her son's body. And instead, he orders it to be buried on top of a cliff, looking out over the channel.
10:19 Tom Holland? And somebody raises a stone, one of the Normans, and scribes on it, by command of the duke, you repose here, King Harold, so that you may remain guardian of the shore and ocean. And if that's true, I mean, what's interesting is that William is being described as a duke and Harold is still being described as a king, so. I don't think that would have lasted very long. There are other accounts of what happens to Harold's body. So a late account says it was given to Githa, who buried it in Waltham Abbey in Essex, which Harold had refounded under his own kind of patronage in 1060. So that's, I mean, we don't know. And there is a modern theory that it's in the Sussex port of Bosum, which had been Harold's birthplace and is shown in the Beotapestry. Harold sails from it for his disastrous trip to France.
11:05 Dominic Sandbrook? So within a arrow's flight of Keith Richards's house in West Wittering.
11:09 Tom Holland? Yes.
11:10 Dominic Sandbrook? That's the version I like to believe.
11:12 Tom Holland? Yeah. And I imagine Keith Richards would be interested in this.
11:15 Dominic Sandbrook? Keith Richards loves this history.
11:16 Tom Holland? So he'd have been all over the fact that in 1954, there are an Anglo-Saxon coffin was found in the church there. And it apparently was the skeleton of a formidable looking warrior. So who knows?
11:28 Dominic Sandbrook? I think of Keith Richards because he seems to me very much an Anglo-Saxon man, not a Norman.
11:33 Tom Holland? Yes. I think Mick Jagger more of a Norman.
11:36 Dominic Sandbrook? Agreed.
11:36 Tom Holland? Very interested in money.
11:38 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah, exactly. Cold eyed.
11:39 Tom Holland? Cold eyed.
11:40 Dominic Sandbrook? But Keith Richards is very much a man who would have sported an excellent moustache in the 11th century.
11:45 Tom Holland? There are Norman accounts that the the English on the night before Hastings spend it getting wasted.
11:51 Dominic Sandbrook? Brilliant. There you go.
11:53 Tom Holland? That's quite Rolling Stones. Anyway, however, all these stories, we don't really know which of them is true. There's inevitably an also report that Harold survived the battle and became a hermit, which is traditional in such cases. But whatever, whatever the truth, he is gone. And the big question that everyone presumably is asking at this point is, does this mean the war is over?
12:11 Dominic Sandbrook? Right, because it could continue, right? I mean, William only has the tiniest, tiniest bit of England, a little foothold. And there's a lot of England and England has a very sophisticated state and it's got a lot of people and it's got a martial tradition.
12:24 Tom Holland? Yeah.
12:24 Dominic Sandbrook? So why does, this is an interesting question. Why does the Norman conquest basically? Why is this game over?
12:31 Tom Holland? Well, we laugh perhaps at the way that Victorians insist on, you know, great men, the fate of great men affecting the course of nations. I think in this case, he's not far wrong. I think the war absolutely could have still been prosecuted and won. Had there been anyone left in England competent to continue the resistance to William and by implication be accepted as as king. So you need someone who's competent and can rule as a legitimate king. But the problem is, is there isn't really anyone. So Geth and Leifeyne are dead. Edwin and Morcar, if they were at the battle, nobody mentions it. They certainly haven't hung around. Whether they're coming from Hastings or whether they're coming from the Midlands,
13:14 Tom Holland? they go to London and they rescue their sister, Harold's widow, and take her away up to Chester. There is Edgar Atheling, who is Edward the Confessor's great nephew. You know, he has the the blood of the West Saxon kings in his veins. And we're told in the Anglo Saxon Chronicle, Archbishop Aeldred, so that's the Archbishop of York, and the people of London wished to have him as king, as indeed was his right by birth. But, you know, he's a teenager. He he lacks any military resources of his own whatsoever. And he is now facing the best general in Europe, who's just won a very, very bloody battle.
13:50 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah.
13:50 Tom Holland? So I think that when Freeman says the one man who could have guarded and saved England was taken from her, namely Harold, I mean, he's not exaggerating really. Had Harold survived, even the loss at Hastings might have been, you know, might not have been fatal.
14:04 Dominic Sandbrook? Quick question. Is this not the moment where Edwin and Morcar could step up and claim their place in history? And actually, they don't. And this was their opportunity?
14:12 Tom Holland? Maybe, but they don't. I mean, that's the salient thing. And presumably they don't because they feel they haven't got backing.
14:17 Dominic Sandbrook? Okay.
14:18 Tom Holland? Does this mean then that William has has won? Again, not necessarily. Because as you said, England is huge. It has immense resources of manpower. William's force relative to the manpower available to a native English king is small and smaller than it was when it landed because they've, you know, lots of people have died in the Great Battle. He still has no declared allies in England. And of course, winter is closing in. So he's still not in a secure position. And effectively, he has to seize command of the kingdom, which means being recognised by the Witan, by the magnates and the leading bishops and archbishops of the kingdom before winter sets in, or he's in real trouble. So what does he do? First of all, he sits
15:00 Tom Holland? and waits for the Witan to offer him the crown. And a week passes, two weeks pass, and still there is nothing from the Witan. So he decides, I'll hang this, I'm not putting up with this. So he raises camp and he heads eastwards for Dover. And on the way, he makes sure to proclaim to the English what the fruits of opposing him will be. So they go past the coastal town of Romney, where some of the Norman ships had landed by mistake and the locals had slaughtered them. And William now exacts a terrible vengeance on them by putting the town to the torch. He then advances on Dover, which surrenders at the very sight of his army. And so clearly, despite all the casualties that the Normans
15:44 Tom Holland? had suffered at Hastings, they're still a very, very intimidating sight. And William stays there, maybe for a week, one source says for three weeks, improving its fortifications, getting reinforcements. Dover, of course, is, you know, I mean, it's, it's the shortest crossing, so a very useful stronghold for an invader of England to control. And then having secured Dover, he then goes on to secure two crucial prizes. So the first of these is Canterbury, which submits to him in person. So William is marching from Dover to Canterbury towards London. And Canterbury, of course, is the seat of the Archbishop of Canterbury. So the great focus of English secrality. And he also gets Winchester,
16:26 Tom Holland? which falls to a flying column of men that he sent. And Winchester, you know, it's the capital of Alfred the Great. It's been slightly displaced as the capital by London, but it's still a very, very significant place for the West Saxons. And so to control that, that's a very good sign. And it's all the more significance, because it is now, as both Canterbury and Winchester submit to him, that news reaches William that Edgar Atheling has been elected king by the Witan.
16:54 Dominic Sandbrook? So that's a moment that's often elided in the stories of the Norman conquest, that's barely mentioned in a lot of accounts, which is that suddenly we do have an alternative king. And yes, you said he was a teenager. That said, teenagers have often won thrones before and Edmund Ironside had been a teenager when he'd been fighting Canute.
17:15 Tom Holland? And William had been a teenager when stamping down resistance in Normandy.
17:20 Dominic Sandbrook? So a lot of listeners to this would be like, well, who's this bloke? I've never heard of this bloke. I mean, don't try and pretend he's a big player in this story because I've never heard of him. And again, it's a dog that doesn't bark. I mean, Edgar Atheling is in London, which is the great prize, which is the capital. So, and actually, when William marches on London from Canterbury and says surrender, London does not surrender. So why does this story not go anywhere? Why doesn't Edgar Atheling hold out, raise an army? And then the next 10 years be a great civil war between Edgar Atheling and William?
17:51 Tom Holland? So he's one of those kind of ambivalent kings. I suppose he's kind of the Anglo-Saxon Lady Jane Grey. You're never quite sure whether to include him in the list of English kings or not. I mean, I think the answer is that clearly he lacks the charisma and the resources to meet William in the field, which is why when William marches on London, he stays immured within the walls. William occupies Southwark, so the southern stretches of the Thames, south of London Bridge, does not try and force London Bridge and enter London. But he makes sure to put Southwark to the torch so that everyone in London who are around Edgar can witness the fact that this new king is powerless to resist William's advance.
18:30 Tom Holland? And he then carries on heading westwards into the heartlands of Wessex. And he adopts this policy that we've already quoted, but I'll quote it again. William of Poitiers describing the Norman way of war, striking fear by laying waste the crops, fields and domains, capturing all the towns that lay in his path, putting garrisons in them, in short, to assault a given region relentlessly and engulf it in a great multitude of troubles. And this is now the fate that is visited on Wessex, which is the heartland of England, of course. It's the kingdom that had been ruled by Alfred and by Athelstan. And it was the great stronghold of the Godwins. Harold had been Earl of Wessex. And so William is making, you know, he is a
19:15 Tom Holland? The noses of the English in the fact that the the heartbeat of the English kingdom is now his to do with as he pleases. And so he ravages the whole way westwards as far as Wallingford in Oxfordshire. And as the name of Wallingford suggests, it's a Ford, a fortified Ford across the Thames. Alfred had built walls around it. It was one of his kind of fortified burrs. But the local thanes surrenders it to to William. He's just one one glimpse of William at the head of his army and he's, hey, please come in. You know, I'm not, I'm not hanging around here. And so William occupies Wallingford. And it is there that he receives a key submission. And this is Stigand, the Archbishop of Canterbury.
19:58 Dominic Sandbrook? And that must be a big moment because Stigand brings the authority and the legitimacy of the English Church.
20:04 Tom Holland? Well, bear in mind that Stigand is a very controversial figure. The fact that he is simultaneously the Bishop of Winchester has been used as one of the reasons for why William should be given a papal banner. So the fact that that Stigand, who knows that he is in the the crosshairs of William, that he chooses to surrender is, I think, doubly significant. As you say, he represents the English Church, but also he's a figure who has every reason to try and continue the fight. And he hasn't. He's basically kind of given in.
20:35 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah.
20:35 Tom Holland? Edgar, though, still no sign of him. And so William continues with his ravaging. And from Wallingford, he now turns back eastwards towards London, kind of closing in on the city from the north. And the news of what is happening, of course, you know, reaches London, everyone is thrown into a state of absolute terror. You've got refugees fleeing the advance of the Norman Knights. They are bringing tales of all the horrors that are being inflicted by the invaders. People, you know, beg Edwin and Morca to march and and defend them. They refuse. And clearly, the whole situation is hopeless. And Edgar essentially realizes he has no prospect of holding out. And so he ailed to the Archbishop of York.
21:20 Tom Holland? Edwin, Morca, they all congregate and they go in procession to Berkhamsted in Hertfordshire where William's army has camped. There isn't a burr there and so they're busy building a motte, great mound of earth on which they will build a bailey, a fort. You can still see it to this day. And in fact, Geoff, my fishing coach lives there and he's very proud of the of the motte and bailey there. So good to get Geoff in. Anyway, so Edgar Atheling and all the chief men of London, Edwin and Morca, the Archbishop of York, they all come to William at Berkhamsted. And the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle describes their submission in tones of naked contempt. They submitted out of necessity after most damage had been done. So that's
22:03 Tom Holland? all the ravaging that William has inflicted. And it was a great piece of folly that they had not done it earlier, since God would not make things better because of our sins. And they gave hostages and swore oaths to him, and he promised them that he would be a gracious liege lord. And yet, in the meantime, they ravaged all that they overran.
22:23 Dominic Sandbrook? They being the Normans.
22:24 Tom Holland? They being the Normans.
22:24 Dominic Sandbrook? So just a quick question before we move on to the submission of London. Clearly Edwin and Morca, they'd lost that battle to Harold Haradada, listeners may remember. Edgar Atheling is clearly just a bit of a waste of space. He just hasn't got the killer instincts. Had one of those three men be what Logan Roy would call a serious person, i.e. they would see the opportunity and they would say, right, I'm the man, rally the people of England, we're going to fight this guy and really, you know, we're going to drive him from our shores and let's do this. Edmund Ironside, let's say. Is it plausible the Norman conquest might, you know, William could have lost a second battle?
23:01 Tom Holland? I think they would have had to be a very serious man, because William, he is a very, very serious man. I mean, he is completely ruthless. He is completely convinced of His own justice and he feels that he has a licence from God to do whatever it takes to force the English to submit. And when you're up against someone as able as that and with as formidable a war machine behind him, I mean, as I say, you've really, really got to be a serious person. And I think it's clear that Edwin and Morca both probably look in the mirror and think, I don't really think I've got what it takes.
23:35 Dominic Sandbrook? So here's the thing, Edward Augustus Freeman was quite right. Individuals do matter in history. And this is an example where the lack of such an individual really matters for England. But anyway, I took you off the narrative.
23:43 Tom Holland? No, because I think you home in from the English point of view, the great tragedy of the situation. They could have fought if someone had been there to command the resources that England still undoubtedly has. But because they don't, because William is, you know, he has a strategy, a campaigning plan that is tried and tested. And the English don't know what's hit them. They have never come up across armoured horsemen with the capacity to build castles. And this, of course, was what Harold had been so worried about. It's what had led him to make the ultimately disastrous decision to go and fight the Normans in front of Hastings. But Harold had understood what the English were facing. I don't think anyone else had. And so I think the impact of, you know, reports
24:26 Tom Holland? coming into London of towns and farms on fire. I mean, it's a kind of war of the world situation. Terrifying invaders burning all around. These are more formidable, more terrifying even than than Harold Audrada's army. So you can see why they would submit. And of course, with the submission of London and of Edgar Atheling, we come to the climax of 1066, of this most fateful of years. William has achieved what he set out to achieve. He has secured the heart of the kingdom. Before winter sets in very badly and by the time it is Christmas, so Christmas was the day that Charlemagne, of course, had been crowned, William is ready to be crowned
25:11 Tom Holland? himself. So he enters London a few days before Christmas. There is a massive military presence. No one in London can have any doubt that they are living in a city under occupation. And immediately and inevitably, William orders the construction of a castle on the southeast corner of the city walls by the Thames. And this castle is the castle that today we know as the Tower of London. Right. But of course, it's not only London itself behind its Roman walls that has fallen into his hands. So too has the great palace complex built by Edward the Confessor to the west of London. And it's not just a palace, it's a minster or an abbey.
25:53 Tom Holland? So Westminster, and it is in Westminster Abbey on Christmas Day that William is crowned. Almost a year since Harold had presumably been crowned there and everything seems utterly changed. So outside the abbey, as William is being crowned, you have ranks of mailed French-speaking foreigners standing guard over the coronation of a King of England. Inside the abbey, you have another French innovation. The Archbishop of York and then a Norman bishop both step forward and ask the congregation if they will accept William as King. Eldred, the Archbishop of York in English, of course, but the French bishop in French. And there is a great answering acclamation from the congregation in the abbey.
26:36 Tom Holland? And outside the abbey, this results, it is reported in chaos. William of Poitiers claims that the guards who are standing outside the abbey interpret the acclamation as English treachery. I mean, it's equally possible, in fact probable, that they've already, that they're just going on the rampage, that they've just begun attacking people. And certainly, whatever the reason for it.
26:59 Tom Holland? There is looting and there is burning of houses around Westminster Abbey.
27:03 Dominic Sandbrook? An incredibly ominous and dramatic scene.
27:06 Tom Holland? Very ominous and members of the congregation hurry out to help fight the flames. And Ordrick Vitalis, who is this Anglo Norman, identifies as English, writing in Normandy. He says of this, that only the bishops and clergy, along with the monks, stayed terrified in front of the altar. But the service still goes ahead and William is anointed, crowned, and then he sits on his throne, even though the pews are pretty much empty and there are screams and the crackling of flames coming from outside the abbey doors. But he could sit there and think, well, you know, my gamble, the odds were so immense, but his gamble has succeeded. He's no longer a duke, he is now an anointed king.
27:52 Tom Holland? And when his followers salute him, as they do, now that he's been crowned, they do so in terms that place him on a level, basically with only two other rulers in Latin Christendom, and that is the Emperor and the King of France. So this man has gone from being a duke to being an anointed king, whose followers hail him in these terms, to the most serene William, the great and peace-giving king, crowned by God, life and victory. So for William to be hailed in this way, I mean, it is the ultimate fruit of conquest.
28:37 Tom Holland? And yet the weird thing is, so we talked about whether Hastings finishes Anglo-Saxon England off for good. The weird thing is, is that William's coronation in Westminster Abbey is actually a symbol of continuity as well as of rupture.
28:53 Dominic Sandbrook? Explain that.
28:54 Tom Holland? Well, let's see what William is thinking. So Ordrick Vitalis tells us that as he's being consecrated, so as he's being anointed, he trembled violently. And people have often wondered, you know, why?
29:08 Tom Holland? Lots of people have suggested that perhaps he was reflecting on everything he'd done to seize the throne, you know.
29:14 Dominic Sandbrook? He knows he's going to hell.
29:15 Tom Holland? And maybe the flickering of flames outside the doors of the abbey only enhanced that. But I think it's unlikely. I don't think William is the kind of person to have doubts at the climactic moment of his triumph, because I think it's much more likely that he is feeling awe before the God-given scale of his responsibilities that God has entrusted into his hands against all the odds. So he is a conqueror. He will come to be known as the conqueror, but he's not being crowned as a conqueror. I think that the sense in which, in William's own opinion, he is being crowned as the heir of Edward the Confessor tends to be obscured, because everything about that coronation
29:59 Tom Holland? is proclaiming that he is being crowned not by virtue of the victories he's won with his sword, but by right, that he is the legitimate heir, not just to Edward the Confessor, but to the line of kings that stretches back to Alfred, all the way to Kerdic, that he is truly the anointed king of England. So it's being held in Westminster Abbey, built by Edward the Confessor. The coronation ritual, although there are a few interpellations that come from French practice, in the main, it's exactly the consecration rite that had been staged at Bath when Edgar had been crowned, right back at the beginning of our story.
30:44 Tom Holland? And he is consecrated as the ruler of the Anglo-Saxonarchy, the Anglo-Saxons. And this is a formula that goes back to Alfred. So he is being crowned as king of the Anglo-Saxons, of England.
30:59 Dominic Sandbrook? Just to be clear, they absolutely use the term Anglo-Saxons. So if there's any very excitable American academics listening. Listen to those words and reflect on your behaviour.
31:10 Tom Holland? And I think you're right to fix on that. I mean, it doesn't gel with our sense of what the Norman conquest is about, that William is being crowned as king of the Anglo Saxons. And that's because, of course, 1066 is probably the profoundest rupture in English history. It's a year of invasion, of bloodshed, absolutely of conquest. But it is also a year which ends with this very public, very ringing insistence that there is continuity as well as rupture. And even though it's obvious that William's rule depends on mailed force, that's what all those soldiers are doing outside the abbey, it does also depend on him showing respect for the history and the traditions of his new kingdom. Because it's
31:52 Tom Holland? that history, it's those traditions that give him his status as a consecrated king. If he dumps on them, then that status means nothing. For William himself, clearly a very difficult balance to strike. And I don't think that we can really finish an account of 1066, this remarkable year, without looking at how in the years that followed 1066, William did try to strike a balance between his role as conqueror and as anointed king.
32:20 Dominic Sandbrook? Brilliant. Let's do that after the break, Tom. So come back after the break to find out how William strikes the balance and ends up ruling his kingdom.
32:30 Tom Holland? This episode is brought to you by Mint Mobile. Right now, all of Mint's plans are $15 per month, even unlimited. So go to mintmobile.com/history.
32:43 Dominic Sandbrook? Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for 12 months. Plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50GB may slow when network is busy. Includes up to 20GB of hotspot. Capable device required. Availability, speed and coverage varies. See mintmobile.com.
33:09 Dominic Sandbrook? This episode is supported by Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Now, history's biggest leaps started as hard questions that people didn't want asked. Yeah, there's a classic example of that at the end of the 15th century. And the hard question in particular was, what is out there beyond the Atlantic Ocean to the west? And as you will know, the man who found the answer to that question was the explorer Christopher Columbus. And he realizes, or rather, everybody else realizes, that there is a vast continent out there. And it is, of course, the Americas. So Anthropic knows the importance of questions. And it's why Anthropic is founded on one hard question above all. How can we ensure that the AI revolution really goes well for ordinary people? So they asked over 100,000 people.
33:54 Dominic Sandbrook? And what came back wasn't just fear, there was hope as well. People wanted to know, will cancer ever be cured? Can kids have a better future? It turns out that there is hope in hard questions. Ask yours at claude.ai/RestIsHistory and keep thinking.
34:13 Speaker 02 Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones, like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job. Then sometimes you make great ones, like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Not available in all states.
34:47 Dominic Sandbrook? After Pentecost, the king traveled about so as to come to Salisbury at Lamas. And there his counselors came to him and all the people occupying land who were of any account over all England, whosoever's vassals they might be. And they all submitted to him and swore oaths of allegiance to him, that they would be faithful to him against all other men. That was the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, which was still going after the Norman conquest and is describing an event on the first of August 1086. So we have moved on, we've jumped forward in time, two decades since that tragic year when William of Normandy became king of the English people.
35:30 Dominic Sandbrook? So 20 years on, this is a good point for us to stop the narrative and to say, What's happened in the intervening period? How deep and how profound has the rupture in English history really been? So Tom, why that scene in particular?
35:48 Tom Holland? Well, partly it's it's set in Salisbury. So always good to get Wiltshire and the Salisbury area into the into the podcast. But also because this is a key moment in understanding what has happened to England and how William's regime is functioning. And I think we can begin by trying to work out what has changed by imagining that we are riding with the great crowds of landowners who have been summoned to Salisbury and are flocking from all corners of the kingdom. And as, you know, if we imagine ourselves riding with them, we could look around and see who, you know, what do these landowners look like? Well, they don't have moustaches. They don't have long hair.
36:31 Tom Holland? Lots of them are wearing their hair in a fashion that derives ultimately from hipsters in Aquitaine in the south of France. So they have a kind of floppy fringe and the back of the head shaved. And this marks them out as as Normans, not as English. And why is it that there are no English? Why is it that all the landowners are Norman? And we get an answer from Henry of Huntingdon, this Anglo Norman historian, so like William of Malmesby, writing in the the early 12th century, about 50 years later. He spells out in a single sentence what has happened over the course of William's reign since his coronation in 1066. There was scarcely a noble of English descent in England, Henry writes, but all had been
37:11 Tom Holland? reduced to servitude and lamentation, and it was even disgraceful to be called English.
37:17 Dominic Sandbrook? But is he exaggerating? Is that was that really true?
37:20 Tom Holland? Okay, well, so let's look at the facts and the figures. So the great dynasties who had dominated England in 1066, before Hastings, they have gone. So the Godwins, Harold, Tostig.
37:35 Tom Holland? Leifwine, Gith, they all died in 1066. Harold's mother, Githa, who had tried to get their bodies and probably been refused by William. She had fled into exile in 1067 after encouraging an abortive uprising in Exeter. Various of Harold's sons, who had fled to Ireland and there tried to raise armies to reconquer England. They've either been killed or taken prisoner and are languishing in William's jails. Really, the only prominent member of Godwin's family who has survived is Edith. So Edward the Confessor's wife. And she survives because she is Edward the Confessor's wife. So that gives her a status. William claims his descent from Edward.
38:20 Tom Holland? And so that enables Edith to to kind of continue to enjoy a sort of spectral authority in Winchester as Edward the Confessor's widow. And she had lived in Winchester and had died in 1075. So 11 years before this great ceremony in Salisbury. What about the great Mercionel? So Edwin and Morcar, we've been talking a lot about them. Well, they had missed their chance, I think it's fair to say, to stop William. They could have done it in 1066 perhaps, but they definitely can't by the time that William has established his regime more securely. And 1071, they try and raise a rebellion and it all goes horribly wrong. And Edwin is forced to flee to Scotland, but en route, he is murdered by a member of his
39:02 Tom Holland? own retinue and Morcar is captured and again is imprisoned and is languishing in prison in 1086.
39:08 Dominic Sandbrook? They were not serious people?
39:10 Tom Holland? No, they were not. And also, a man not as serious as his father is this guy called Waltheoff, who was the son of Earl Seward. So Seward was the Scandinavian Earl who had helped overthrow Macbeth. He appears in Shakespeare's play, had died and had left a son who hadn't succeeded him because of course Tostic has. But William had looked after Waltheoff, had kind of talent spotted him, had thought that, you know, he could employ him as the Earl of Northumbria. So in 1072, had appointed him in that role. But three years later. He's implicated in a plot against William, perhaps a little bit unfairly. It seems that he confessed that he had been approached. He hadn't actually participated in it, but William is having none of it.
39:56 Tom Holland? So Woolthioff had been arrested, tried, convicted and beheaded. So all the great Earls have been eliminated in one way or the other. And in fact, of the 1,000 richest landowners in England. So these are all the people who are coming towards Salisbury in 1086. Only 13 are English. So the Thanes, you know, this, this body of, of the, the kind of the elites have effectively been destroyed as a social order. And there is barely a corner of England where Norman lords have not replaced the native landowners. And there are some amazing figures to illustrate this.
40:36 Tom Holland? So 200 Normans hold half the land in England and 10 Normans hold a quarter of it.
40:42 Dominic Sandbrook? So 10 Normans hold a quarter of England. I mean, this looks like, that looks like a colonial takeover. There's no other way of putting it. I mean, we would describe this as the, the epitome of colonialism.
40:54 Tom Holland? Yeah.
40:54 Dominic Sandbrook? And a foreign elite have moved in, displaced the original people who owned the land and taken it all for themselves, right?
41:01 Tom Holland? And so where have the English landowners gone? Well, lots of them have fled to Constantinople where they have enrolled in the Varangians as Harold Hardrada had done.
41:10 Dominic Sandbrook? So that stuff about the Varangians, English Varangians in Constantinople, that's one of the big themes of The Last English King, the brilliant novel about this by Julian Rathbone, which is full of anachronisms and stuff, but is absolutely brilliant on the sense of this is a seismic shock, isn't he?
41:26 Tom Holland? Yeah, so the Normans in that are kind of Nazis. He's casting it as, as the equivalent of the Nazi occupation of Poland. And I mean, the, the, the stories of the English lords who, who flee to Constantinople, I mean, are really very dramatic in themselves. The Byzantines often find themselves fighting the Normans and the poor old English keep losing. There's one terrible battle where they all get trapped in a barn and get burnt to death. And some of them, some of them end up in Crimea where they've, they found a city called New York. So it's the first New York to be founded.
41:56 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah, I love that fact. That's a very good fact.
41:59 Tom Holland? So it is effectively a complete decapitation of the native aristocracy. And was this always William's plan? So was it always his intention to replace the English aristocracy with with his own men? Or was he aiming to do as Canute had done? And try and arrive at accommodation with the native aristocracy?
42:19 Dominic Sandbrook? What makes this different from, because that's 1016, right?
42:21 Tom Holland? I think the evidence makes it pretty clear that William was not what he did not want to eliminate the English aristocracy. I mean, he wanted, clearly he had to reward his followers with lands. And the death of the Godricens gave him perfect opportunity to do that. But he was hoping that the English aristocracy would collaborate with him. But instead, they just keep rising in insurrection after insurrection. And so year after year, there are these bushfires of rebellion across England. And year after year, brutal man that he is, William stamps them out. And it's not just the native aristocracy who suffer terribly from this process. So lots of the of the peasantry in England suffer as well.
43:02 Tom Holland? And the most notorious example of this is a series of campaigns that were waged in Northumbria, southern Northumbria, in the winter of 1069 to 70, which is remembered as the Harrying of the North.
43:15 Dominic Sandbrook? Right.
43:16 Tom Holland? Very, very notorious, kind of mass destruction, mass looting, the deliberate targeting of food supplies. So that over the course of the winter, maybe 150,000 people may have died of starvation, 80,000 oxen. These are the kind of the likely figures. And even William's admirers were shocked. So to quote Alderich Vitalis, famous, famous passage, he wrote, "My narrative has frequently had occasion to praise William. But for this act which condemned the innocent and guilty alike to die by slow starvation, I cannot commend him. For when I think of helpless children, young men in the prime of life, and hoary greybeards perishing alike of hunger, I am so moved to pity that I would rather lament the grief and sufferings of the wretched people
44:01 Tom Holland? than make a vain attempt to flatter the perpetrator of such infamy." So that's punchy stuff.
44:07 Dominic Sandbrook? It is punchy and it's not my normal thing to sort of defend William, but I'm reminded of the thing we talked about with Harald Haradada in Norway. You remember when he was chastising the farmers of the uplands who had not paid their taxes? And maybe you could argue this is simply what a ruthless 11th century king does when he's, you know, it's part of the assertion of royal authority, you know, when you've got the emergence of stronger and stronger kingdoms and you've got kings who are serious people as Harald Haradada and William the Conqueror clearly were. And, you know, you step out of line and they will, I mean, they will kill you.
44:43 Tom Holland? Well, the other thing, and this again is a contrast with Harald Haradada or indeed with Canute, is that the harrying of entire populations, which Harald Haradada absolutely had done, is not the only thing that William can do to secure his rule over England. Because of course, William comes as the representative of this new military culture that is hugely investing in the construction of castles. So again, let's go back to imagining that we're travelling with the Norman landowners to this great assembly convened by William in Salisbury on the 1st of August 1086. And what would we see ahead of us? So we are
45:26 Tom Holland? not, those who know Salisbury, now the town is down by the Water Meadows where the great cathedral with its tall spire stands. There's nothing there at this point. Salisbury is a great Iron Age hillfort at the place that is now known as Old Sarum. And it had been refortified by Ethelred and he'd set a mint up there. So it was a fortified point for the Anglo-Saxon kings. But William has inevitably made it even more impregnable. He's built a massive motte and bailey right in the centre of Old Sarum and it is ruled directly by the king. So we've mentioned the Norman landowners, but by far the largest landowner is William himself. So huge, huge, direct control over vast arrays of estates and of fortifications.
46:10 Tom Holland? And Salisbury is one of them. Windsor is another. The Tower of London, another, still royal fortresses to this day. But William, of course, is not the only castle builder. Pretty much every Norman landowner is building them. And Of course they're doing this because they're a tiny minority surrounded by exceedingly hostile natives and the fact that they are able to protect themselves in these fortifications. I mean, that sets them apart from, say, the Viking warlords who had done this before and who very rapidly had kind of merged into the mass of the English who surround them. This is not the case with these Norman landowners. They are very obviously physically separate from the people they're ruling because they're surrounded by, you know, these ramparts.
46:54 Tom Holland? And this is recognised by the English themselves straight away. So the entry for 1066 in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, it recorded how Norman warlords built castles far and wide throughout this country and distressed the wretched folk, and always after that it grew much worse. May the end be good when God wills.
47:17 Dominic Sandbrook? But here's a thing. So visitors to a major English town and what was what would have been a major medieval town, if they go today, there are actually two structures that will often dominate the town. So one will be the castle or the ruins of the castle, but the other is often obviously the cathedral or a big church. And that's the other side of this, isn't it? So it's partly military power, but there's also, as you've described so often, a kind of spiritual power. So there's a, there's a religious dimension to this conquest as well.
47:48 Tom Holland? There is. And so again, if you're, you're coming up to Old Sarum, you're coming up to Salisbury, you'd see the castle, but you would also see a half completed cathedral, which is massive. Workmen have been toiling away for, for pretty much a decade. And as you say, it's part of a huge programme of church building in England that is, I mean, completely unprecedented in the scale of its ambition. And most of the medieval cathedrals that still dominate English cathedral towns to this day were, almost all of them either founded or actually constructed in the main in the immediate wake of the conquest or, you know, a generation or so after it. And of the Anglo-Saxon minsters.
48:32 Tom Holland? I mean, barely a brick of those was left standing. And the Norman cathedrals that were built on the site of the Anglo-Saxon cathedrals, I mean, they don't just obliterate the memory of the Anglo-Saxon church, but they establish an imprint on the country that was designed to last. And in fact, the cathedral that's being built on Old Sarum, I mean, it's one of the very few examples of a cathedral over the course of the Middle Ages that gets replaced in its entirety because ultimately people decide that Old Sarum is too inconvenient. And so they move down to the lowlands below Old Sarum, which is where Salisbury Cathedral, as it stands today, is then kind of rebuilt. So this programme of church building is the kind of the physical expression,
49:15 Tom Holland? as you said, of a kind of great revolution in the affairs of the English church more broadly. And so just as the aristocracy, the English aristocracy has been eliminated, so too have English bishops been removed from the commanding heights of the church. And in fact, by 1086, you have only a single English bishop still in office. And the justification for this is the sense that the English church had been very, very sick and corrupt. So the fact that Stigand, the Archbishop of Canterbury, had surrendered to William doesn't stop him from being deposed in 1070. And he gets replaced by this Italian monk who had been talent spotted by William
49:56 Tom Holland? and recruited to serve him in Normandy as the abbot of an abbey in Caen.
50:04 Tom Holland? And this is a guy called L'Enfranc. And if Stigand had been a byword for corruption, L'Enfranc is the greatest theologian of his day. I mean, an incredibly impressive figure. And he is the embodiment of everything that is most radical, most innovative, most kind of spiritually impressive, to be honest, about this kind of process of reformation that is associated with Gregory VII, the extraordinary Pope, and this kind of reform movement. And which the English, now that they've been defeated, have no choice but to submit to. And I think because they are demoralised and, you know, we every Time we quote an English chronicler commenting on their defeat, they all say,
50:48 Tom Holland? you know, this is because of our sins. This is what God wants. We are being punished for our sins. And so I think for that reason, they are prepared to accept the fact that clearly their church was not pleasing to God. And therefore perhaps the, you know, the Aegean stable has to be cleansed. So that is also part of the Great Revolution that the Normans have brought. And that castle, that half completed cathedral, they are absolutely symbols of the rupture that the conquest has precipitated. And a further evidence for the scale of the rupture is there in the reason that these landowners have been summoned to Salisbury on Lamas, so the first harvest of the year,
51:33 Tom Holland? so the first of August, 1086. So we're told by the Anglo Saxon Chronicle, why were they gathered there? To submit to him and swear oaths of allegiance to him, that they would be faithful to him against all other men. So this is, again, a consolidation of William's power as king that is radical and revolutionary. The Anglo Saxon king, we talked about this, did not hold all of the land of England. But effectively, this is what William is instituting. Because with this oath, every landowner in England is now accepting publicly that that he holds his land directly from William.
52:13 Dominic Sandbrook? Tom, I fear that we're teetering on the brink of a discussion of the feudal system, which would be a terrifying prospect.
52:20 Tom Holland? It would. So let's, let's not use abstract nouns. I mean, you'll find it unusual for me to say that. Let's just look at what, what it means in practical terms for these landowners who are coming and swearing this oath. So what it does is these landowners have gone through Enormous turbulence. You've had rebellions, you've had the native aristocracy kind of rising up, being eliminated, being forced into exile, whatever. And so the legal documents that might enable these new Norman landowners to feel secure in their possessions are not really there. And so this is what William has been trying to rectify. And for seven months, his agents have been going around England and recording who owns what land.
53:03 Tom Holland? And these agents are recording two key details. So they're recording who owned the land when Edric the Confessor died on the 5th of January 1066, and who are the landowners now? And observant listeners will note that that completely eliminates Harold. So Harold has been erased from the historical record. And these records, after this great meeting at Salisbury, will be copied out by a single scribe and come to be known in due course as Doomsday Book. And it's likely that that name is being applied to it very, very early on. And it is called Doomsday Book because the presumption is that what has been recorded is unalterable, like the judgments that will be delivered at the end of days, you know, the day of
53:48 Tom Holland? judgment.
53:49 Dominic Sandbrook? And what the Doomsday Book stands for is the recognition that there's an entirely new order, right? That there's been a massive transfer of property and power from one social group to another, from the English aristocracy to the Norman aristocracy. And the point is that like the cathedrals and the castles, this is going to last forever. There's no turning back now. That was 20 years ago, and there's like, it's set in, it's set in stone, literally, in the, in the case of the castles and the cathedrals.
54:16 Tom Holland? Absolutely.
54:17 Dominic Sandbrook? And everybody accepts that, do you think, by this point? So, I mean, there may be a few people who, in their cups late at night, look back to the old days, but by and large, everyone accepts the world has changed.
54:29 Tom Holland? Yes, maybe, although one of the things that has precipitated William's desire to compile this great legal record is the fact that for about a year, William's hold on England has actually seemed quite precarious. And the reason for that is one that you touched on in your account of Harold Hardrada, where you said, is he the last of the Vikings? Well, actually, no, he's not, because there are still Scandinavian kings who aspire to conquer England. And this is very evident in the circumstances that give birth to the Doomsday Book. So what prompted it is the prospect of an invasion by the Danish king Canute. So this is the Canute, the nephew of the famous Canute, who'd been the great adversary
55:11 Tom Holland? of Harold Hardrada and is still very much on the scene, and is threatening to launch a full-born amphibious invasion of William's kingdom. And so William, very like Athelred, wants to know how much money he's got and where he can obtain it from. And he does this in the full consciousness that Scandinavian warlords are still on the scene. So in 1069, Svein, the Danish king, had sailed up the Humber, and William had paid the Danes off, just as Athelred might have done. And obviously, William is not Athelred, but again and again throughout his reign, he is doing as Athelred had sought to do, which is essentially to exploit to the full the
55:52 Tom Holland? incredible wealth and administrative know-how of his kingdom. And so in that sense, the Doomsday Book, as well as being the final nail in the coffin of Anglo-Saxon England, as you said, kind of a public proclamation that everything has changed, is also the kind of the last hurrah of that Anglo-Saxon state. And the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle writing about it, I mean, he expresses shock at how intrusive William's agents are. It writes, "So very narrowly did he have everywhere investigated that there was no single hide nor yard of land, nor indeed, it is a shame to relate, but it seemed no shame to him to do, one ox, nor one cow, nor one pig was there left out and not put down in his record."
56:36 Tom Holland? But even as the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle is complaining about this, what it is recording is a measure of governmental sophistication.
56:45 Tom Holland? That is only possible in a kingdom like England. It could, you know, Doomsday Book could not have been compiled anywhere else in Latin Christendom, which is why it's so exceptional. And it marks William out, not just as someone who is a conqueror, but also as someone who is exploiting the resources of his kingdom far more ably than Athelred, or you know, or the Confessor had been able to do, you know. And, and so in a sense, the strength of his monarchy is a reflection of the very kingdom that he's conquered. And I, I think you could, I mean, you know, there are other examples as well where things that's, that are notorious as markers of, of William's conquest of England,
57:28 Tom Holland? you can place it in a line of descent from what Anglo-Saxon kings were doing. So the Harrying of the North, for instance. I mean, the most notorious episode of his reign as king. But he's behaving as Edgar had done. You know, we began this series with Edgar.
57:45 Dominic Sandbrook? Edgar the peaceable.
57:46 Tom Holland? Edgar the peaceable, the Pacificus. Uh, and he's Edgar is called Pacificus because he guaranteed order. And William is called Pacificus. You know, those anthems that get sung to him after his coronation. He's hailed as peace giving, exactly as Edgar had been. And William is peace giving because he also deals out death and destruction to those who rebel against him. And that is very Anglo-Saxon.
58:09 Dominic Sandbrook? And yet, maybe we could push that too far because we do know, because it comes up in English chronicles and things, that the English, the native born English do have a profound sense of trauma that is passed down the generations because of this. So we could dress this up and say, oh, it's a lovely balancing act. And, you know, the, the, the working of the Anglo-Saxon state. But this is a, a genuinely kind of traumatic and it's a massive rupture. For if you're living through this, you feel it as a huge rupture, don't you? And William, he, I mean, he, he knows this as well as anybody.
58:44 Tom Holland? I think it's pretty clear that William does suffer a, a slightly guilty conscience about it. So we've already mentioned how, um, he pays penance for the slaughter at, at Hastings by building. Great Abbey on the site of the battle with the altar supposedly marking the place where Harold had made his last stand. And according to Aldrich Vitalis, on his deathbed, he confessed that he had persecuted the people of England beyond all reason. But it is traumatic. It's devastating, particularly if you're, you know, an Anglo-Saxon landowner. I mean, completely traumatic. But I think it is something to put in the counterbalance that
59:24 Tom Holland? the Norman conquest does end up bringing an end to many of the tribulations and evils that we have been describing over the course of this entire series. So William's reign does effectively see the end of Viking invasions, of disputed successions, of feuding among rival magnates within the Kingdom of England. There's no equivalent of the rivalry between the Earls of Mercia and the Earls of Wessex. Both those ranks have gone. And more than that, I think it's a mistake to see the new regime that the conquest ushers in purely as characterized by brutality and greed. So Julian Rathbone in The Last English King
1:00:08 Tom Holland? compares the Normans to the Nazis in Poland. I think that is grotesquely unfair on the Normans. I mean, they are fearsome adversaries, but they are also, and this may sound very strange to people, but they are, they are the embodiments of a change in attitude towards victory and conquest in war that will become hugely significant over the course of the centuries to come. So we talked about the possibility that William may personally have been involved in the butchery of Harold at Hastings, but possibly covered it up. And whether that's true or not is by the by. That it can even be counted as a theory reflects the fact that
1:00:52 Tom Holland? The age when slaughtering your enemies and cutting them up into pieces. And this could be praised, that this is fading into history. Because the codes of what will become chivalry are already making their mark in France. William does not actually slaughter large numbers of magnates. The only one he has executed is Wolfioff, the son of the Earl of Northumbria, who had been in rebellion against him. Edgar Atheling, despite being implicated in countless insurrections, kind of lives to a ripe old age. He's the kind of the Richard Cromwell of Anglo-Saxon England. Even Stigand, I mean, he's in prison, but he's not, he's not executed. And when Aldric Vitalis condemns the harrowing of the North,
1:01:35 Tom Holland? he's judging it by William's own standards. The standards that had prevailed in the Anglo-Saxon period no longer prevail. It's, it's no longer seen as acceptable to go around harrying entire counties.
1:01:49 Dominic Sandbrook? You don't think that the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle would have reported it in a similar vein if it had been done by Edward the Confessor or by Ethelred the Enready or whoever?
1:01:56 Tom Holland? I don't know. I mean, the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle reports a lot of harriings and ravagings. I mean, just, just to quote a really fascinating essay by Malcolm Strickland in a recent book of essays on the Norman conquest. And he, he observes how in Britain and Scandinavia in the, in the 11th century, enemy warriors were generally killed without quarter in combat or executed on capture, while women and children were enslaved. And any who might hinder the effective transport of this human booty, such as the old, sick or very young, were put to the sword. By contrast, in Normandy, as in France, the enslaving of captives in wars between fellow Franks or other Christians had become regarded as unacceptable. And in that light, it's interesting to note
1:02:40 Tom Holland? that one of the most vivid social changes that is revealed by Doomsday Book is the decline of slavery. We know that the English kings, the Anglo-Saxon kings, were absolutely in the habit of enslaving their enemies. Bristol, long before it became a great centre for the Atlantic slave trade, was a massive booming autropo for slaves who'd be exported to the Caliphate or wherever. And lots of these are harvested from England. So Harold at Hastings is certainly not defending the freedom of the 10% of the population of England who lived as slaves, whereas William as king does take active steps to prohibit the slave trade. So William, in a sense, is the first great abolitionist in English history.
1:03:21 Dominic Sandbrook? This is a direction I did not expect this serious taking. Woke William the Conqueror.
1:03:25 Tom Holland? It highlights why this story is so brilliant. I mean, it is clearly a thrilling story. We've, you know, we've, we keep harping on that. It's one that extraordinary tales of heroism and sodden through with bloodshed. But it is, I think, a morally complex one, too, which is what makes it so fascinating.
1:03:44 Dominic Sandbrook? Wonderful story, Tom, and brilliantly narrated. We've done 10 episodes in total on the last days of Anglo Saxon England, on Knut, on Harold Hardrada, on William of Normandy, Harold and so on. I've learned an enormous amount and enjoyed it hugely. So congratulations to you, hats off to you. And actually, this isn't the end of the Normans and the rest is history, right? Because you have plans for future Norman episodes.
1:04:08 Tom Holland? Well, we might as well carry on the story. So we could look at how William dies, famously horrible.
1:04:14 Dominic Sandbrook? Yeah.
1:04:15 Tom Holland? Horrible accident involving a swelling corpse in a coffin. So that's fun. And his two sons, William Rufus and Henry the First, are great figures. And then England gets torn to pieces in another civil war by Henry the First's daughter, Matilda, and William's grandson, Stephen. So we've got that to look forward to. There's this extraordinary story of how the Norman adventurers, who we've occasionally been referring to in southern Italy and Sicily, conquered a great kingdom there. And also lurking behind all this, the notion of holy war, the idea that warriors can do God's purpose by felling their enemies, is extraordinary story of the First Crusade. And that also we must definitely do at some point.
1:05:00 Tom Holland? But I think in the meanwhile, we've had enough of Normans. So we will say goodbye.
1:05:04 Dominic Sandbrook? We will say goodbye.
1:05:05 Tom Holland? Goodbye.
1:05:17 Speaker 02 Are you ever shopping online and suddenly a discount that helps you save pops up? It makes your day, sometimes even your week. Want that feeling month after month? Well, new customers who save by switching their home and auto insurance to Progressive, save hundreds. Cue your happy dance. Get your quote today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states.
1:05:44 Speaker 03 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
1:05:56 Speaker 04 Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
1:06:00 Speaker 05 What's the secret to being a great host this season? Keeping things deliciously simple, like mixing Simply Cranberry into a festive drink as guests arrive, or serving up a warm mug of Simply Apple on a chilly night. That means less time behind the scenes and more time in the moment with everyone. Crafted with real fruit, Simply juices and fruit drinks make any holiday drink effortless, inviting, and completely delicious. Simply: Say yes to simple.
Previous 556. 1066: The Battle of Hastings (Part 3) Next 558. The Rolling Stones: Sex, Drugs and Rock ‘n’ Roll (Part 1) Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated
