Pod Insights The Rest Is Classified 130. How Russia Made Trump: Putin Hacks The 2016 Election (Ep 1) About this episode Did Russia really interfere in the 2016 US presidential election? Did the election of Donald Trump benefit Vladimir Putin? And how did the scandal begin?
Listen as David and Gordon begin their exploration of the role of the Russians in the 2016 election and the dramatic rise of Donald Trump.
-------------------
Sign-up for our free newsletter where producer Becki takes you behind the scenes of the show: https://mailchi.mp/goalhanger.com/tric-free-newsletter-sign-up
-------------------
Join the Declassified Club to go deeper into the world of espionage with exclusive Q&As, interviews with top intelligence insiders, regular livestreams, ad-free listening, early access to episodes and live show tickets, and weekly deep dives into original spy stories. Members also get curated reading lists, special book discounts, prize draws, and access to our private chat community.
Just go to therestisclassified.com or join on Apple Podcasts.
-------------------
Get a 10% discount on business PCs, printers and accessories using the code TRIC10. Visit https://HP.com/CLASSIFIED for more information. T&C's apply.
-------------------
EXCLUSIVE NordVPN Deal ➼ https://nordvpn.com/restisclassified Try it risk-free now with a 30-day money-back guarantee
-------------------
Email: [email protected]
Instagram: @restisclassified
Video Editor: Joe Pettit
Social Producer: Emma Jackson
Assistant Producer: Alfie Rowe
Producer: Becki Hills
Head of History: Dom Johnson
Exec Producer: Tony Pastor
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 For exclusive interviews, bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to series, first look at live show tickets, a weekly newsletter, and discounted books, join the Declassified Club at therestisclassified.com.
0:24 Speaker 01 Did the Russians interfere in the 2016 US election?
0:29 Speaker 00 Yes.
0:30 Speaker 01 And were Trump and Putin working together? Well, welcome to The Rest Is Classified. I'm Gordon Corera.
0:36 Speaker 00 And I'm David McCloskey.
0:37 Speaker 01 And you've just given away the whole series.
0:40 Speaker 00 Oops. Spoiler alert. Spoiler alert. The Russians interfered in the election, people. Case closed.
0:48 Speaker 01 Well, believe it or not, that is the subject we're going to be exploring in this series in a little bit more depth than just the one-word answer that we just had from David. But I guess, David, it's a big subject. It's a contentious subject. But it's also a really interesting subject from the Rest Is Classified perspective because it's going to allow us to get into a particular type of Russian intelligence operation, what's called an active measure. We'll get into what that is in a few moments. The aims of these kind of operations, the deep mechanics of how they happen, and crucially, the consequences. How much impact do they actually have? And there is, as we'll see, a long tradition of this in Russia. But this is a really interesting case,
1:32 Speaker 01 which has drawn a huge amount of attention and controversy in recent years, hasn't it?
1:36 Speaker 00 I think, Gordon, it's fair to say that this is the Rest Is Classified lens on the 2016 election. And this is a story, really a spy story, that shaped the politics of that really tumultuous year in American democracy. And I think we probably would be remiss if we didn't start with a brief word on the politics, which you alluded to, Gordon, which is this is a hugely partisan issue in the United States. Anything that has to do with the nexus of Trump and the Russians is going to be hugely divisive. This is not. Out of politics show, we don't claim to have the expertise of our friends at The Rest Is Politics or The Rest Is Politics US. But yeah, we are going to look at the intelligence story.
2:21 Speaker 00 We're going to focus on the espionage here. And at its heart is a Russian intelligence operation, a Russian active measure. Now, one of the major questions this story will raise is how do we make sense of Trump's connections to Russia? And we have a treat for members of our Declassified Club, because we are doing a mini-series that is going to run alongside this sort of main series on the pod, examining Trump's ties to Russia and really helping, I think, in a very fact-based and chronological way, helping people make sense of the Trump-Russia connection.
3:01 Speaker 00 What's hype? What's actually fact? How do you think about the relationship that Donald Trump has with Vladimir Putin and with Russia?
3:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, because it is one of the questions we both get asked, I certainly get asked almost every time I'm doing a public event or a Q and A is, is Trump a Russian agent? Question. What's the nature of the relationship? How we understand it? It's a question that comes up again and again. It's a complicated one, and it's one we're going to explore in that mini-series. But that does allow us to focus much more in this series on what we know the Russians were doing to try and influence the election and some of the real details about the espionage and influence and intelligence side of things, particularly in terms of what the Russians were aiming for.
3:48 Speaker 00 That's right. So if you want to listen to that mini-series, go ahead and go join the club. Go to therestisclassified.com, join the Declassified Club. We'll be putting out three episodes of that mini-series to run alongside this series on the Russian active measure. I think going back to that, though, Gordon, you could probably make the case that this Russian intelligence operation is one of the most consequential espionage operations ever conducted. It has massive impact, not only on the process of the election, we'll talk more in detail about what exactly that means, but on US institutions, on perceptions of our intelligence system and
4:30 Speaker 00 our political elite. And the ripple effect, and this is why I make the case that it's so consequential, is We're still seeing the impact of it today. It has been almost 10 years. And I think a lot of the dialogue around a deep state, the Russia hoax, Russiagate, all these terms will be familiar to, at least to Americans who were engaged in the politics around this. They all originate in this 2016 operation.
4:59 Speaker 01 And in many ways, I think what's so interesting is it's an operation which has an outsized impact. I mean, a far greater impact than I think even the Russians may have predicted, precisely because of the way it plays into politics, into the psychology of Donald Trump, into American politics, and the way it has a tsunami of fear and perception about what are the Russians doing? What might they be doing? Is the Russian hand everywhere? Is it nowhere? Is it being overstated? All of those questions spring out of this very specific intelligence operation. And I think it's a really interesting case as well of how intelligence spill into wider society and politics with an unpredictable impact, I think.
5:42 Speaker 00 Well, it also raises what I think is a very big and uncomfortable question, which we are going to attempt to answer throughout the series, which is, did a Russian active measure operation turn the tides in the election and help elect Donald Trump? Now, that question in and of itself, in some quarters, at least in the US, would be very incendiary, but I would say you don't have to argue that the campaign colluded with the Russians to make that point. It should be an apolitical statement to argue that the Trump campaign may have benefited even indirectly from what we'll see as a Russian operation
6:26 Speaker 00 that is going to end up being designed in large part to weaken his opponent, Hillary Clinton.
6:31 Speaker 01 But I don't think it's a straightforward answer, or as straightforward as some people think, actually, the impact. I think it is worth, by the time we get to the end of it, really drilling down on that question of impact. Because I think sometimes it is maybe overstated. But that's one of the things we'll get to, isn't it?
6:44 Speaker 00 I mean, even the fact that we have to... Pose the question or that the question comes out of the discussion of a Russian intelligence operation, I think, is an indication of just, you know, how big of a deal that operation actually was and is. I also think that the 2016 operation is it's a great example of a kind of newish sort of intelligence operation, one that, as we'll see, has a very long tradition, particularly in Russia. But in many ways, it's the fusion of a very old school political warfare and disinformation campaign alongside modern telecommunications, infrastructure and technologies. And the blending of those things together
7:29 Speaker 00 is something that I think very much defines the geopolitics of our world today. And we kind of see an early indication of this in this Russian operation in 2016. So again, we're going to focus on the espionage. And as we've said, we've teed this word up a few times now. The thing we're going to look at is a particular type of operation. It's not a recruitment. It's not an assassination. It's an active measure.
7:56 Speaker 01 This episode is sponsored by HP. Most people are not counter espionage experts, but that won't stop them getting targeted by cyber criminals seeking to extract their secrets.
8:07 Speaker 00 HP understands that approximately four in 10 UK businesses have reported cyber breaches in the past 12 months alone. That's why HP business laptops, desktops and workstations bought directly on HP Store are secure straight out of the box with their endpoint security.
8:23 Speaker 01 No more stressing about dodgy emails or unexplained pop ups. HP's independently verified Wolf Pro Security works alongside your existing security tools to protect your business, users and reputation from malware and evolving cyber threats with your first click.
8:41 Speaker 00 You don't need an alias or a secret hideout to stay safe, just Wolf Pro Security working tirelessly to protect your hard work. It's security that's built in, not bolted on.
8:51 Speaker 01 Find out more about how HP can protect your business at hp.com/classified. Podcast listeners benefit from a 10% discount on all business PCs, printers and accessories using the code TRIC10. Terms and conditions apply.
9:10 Speaker 02 Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? Zepbound Terzepatide may be able to help. Zepbound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity, or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems, to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off. Zepbound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15-milligram injection. Zepbound contains Terzepatide and should not be used with other Terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Zepbound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens, or reuse needles.
9:52 Speaker 02 Don't take if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop Zepbound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia, if you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking Zepbound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor.
10:32 Speaker 02 Call 1-800-545-5979, or visit zepbound.lily.com.
10:41 Speaker 03 This episode is brought to you by Petivity. Cat parents are basically mealtime detectives. Who actually ate? Did they finish? Was that less than yesterday? The new Petivity Smart Feeder for cats turns everyday meals into meaningful health insights, helping you identify changes in your cat's habits and be more proactive about their health. Plus, you can feed them from anywhere. Take the mystery out of mealtime. Visit petivity.com, P-E-T-I-V-I-T-Y.com/catfeeder to learn more.
11:10 Speaker 01 Okay, David, let's try and explain and explore what that is and what the history of it is, because I think it's really interesting and really significant for this case.
11:18 Speaker 00 Well, it's certainly better than a passive measure, isn't it, Gordon? If we have a measure, we want it, we want it to be active, right?
11:24 Speaker 01 Definitely.
11:25 Speaker 00 Definitely. That is something you and I don't agree on much, Gordon, but we can, we can agree on that. So this is, this is absolutely vital for understanding the entire story to come, because an active measure is a very particular type of intelligence operation. And I think it is one of the dynamics that really does distinguish Russian espionage from Western espionage, because in a lot of the stories that we've done on this program, Gordon, we've talked about intelligence gathering essentially as going out and trying to steal secrets and in some cases covert action. So you could think about, you know, the things that the CIA has done, well, in our first
12:09 Speaker 00 episodes, right, on Iran, covert action to overthrow the Iranian government. We think about intelligence as being sort of stealing secrets and those types of covert actions, but the Russians think more broadly about influencing events and people. So that, that is an active measure. And it is so fundamental to the Russian understanding of intelligence that a retired KGB general by the name of Oleg Kalukin, who I think you've met, is that right, Gordon? He said that this type of subversion has long been the, quote, "heart and soul of Russian intelligence." And what it does is it aims to create division within an adversary country or between allies
12:54 Speaker 00 to weaken them. It can involve influencing politics and elections, sowing division in a society, discrediting opponents, and it often involves using fake documents and fake agents. So it is a massive kind of disinformation and political warfare campaign that is designed to sow chaos essentially in a, in a target system country.
13:19 Speaker 00 Nation, whatever.
13:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, and it's got deep roots in Russia, even pre-revolutionary intelligence. But in the Cold War, the KGB really did have a machine to do this. I mean, there was a whole part of the KGB service, A, which was dedicated to using forged documents and disinformation. In 1980, the estimate was that the Soviet Union spent $3 billion, so about £2.5 billion a year, on active measures. It was that intrinsic to the idea. And political KGB officers, based in embassies abroad, were expected to spend a quarter of their time doing active measures, as well as all the political reporting, political espionage they were doing. I mean, it was that central to it.
14:03 Speaker 01 And I looked a lot into this when I was working on the Mitrokin Archive, you know, the KGB archivist, who detailed many of these operations. And there's many interesting cases where the KGB is doing things like spreading conspiracy theories. For instance, the extraordinary conspiracy theory that the CIA might have been behind the JFK assassination.
14:24 Speaker 00 Which has infected your brain, Gordon.
14:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm still reading books about that. But what's so interesting is you go back to the 60s and the KGB is covertly financing books to be published in America within a year of the assassination, using its agents, who are publishers, to push the idea the CIA is behind it. Also, in the 60s, trying to discredit J. Edgar Hoover, stir up racial tensions in the US. They try and discredit Martin Luther King. They hope more radical divisive voices in the civil rights movement will come to the fore. I mean, they even go so far. I mean, sometimes active measures goes from information to action. Because they even, at one point, plant small bombs in black areas, African-American areas of New York, and fake claims it was Jewish groups to try and spread division.
15:11 Speaker 01 So this is something which is deeply rooted and a real core part of particularly KGB doctrine.
15:18 Speaker 00 There's an author, Dvadaslav Bitman, who wrote a book on active measures called The Deception Game. And he noted that when he was working for an Eastern Bloc intelligence service. That the key was mixing kind of accurate details with forged ones. So this is kind of another feature of many active measures campaigns is there might be a measure of truth that's swirled into the disinformation that is coherent and sort of partially responds to reality, or at least accepted views. And so it can look initially credible. And then, this is interesting, you know, because he's writing decades before the 2016 operation that we're talking about, as he explains how leaking stolen documents had
16:02 Speaker 00 been a standard procedure in disinformation activities. So again, you can, you see this long, long tradition of many of the sort of elements of an active measure go, go back decades. And in fact, listeners to the Russia's Classified will know, Gordon, that you are very fond of when I have long setup sections that go deep into the history. Gordon Corera loves to cut them. Mentions of family. Listeners to the Bin Laden series will know that I had extensive things prepared about Bin Laden's wives that Gordon was completely disinterested in.
16:32 Speaker 01 We kept them in.
16:33 Speaker 00 I had, I had examples of, I guess you could say, active measures adjacent activities that had been conducted by the Tsarist Intelligence Services, the Cheka in the first years of sort of the revolution. Gordon, mercilessly struck them from the script.
16:50 Speaker 01 Well, I, I, I put in some more recent examples.
16:54 Speaker 00 Slightly more relevant points, allegedly more relevant. Yeah.
16:58 Speaker 01 Because you made that point about stolen material. There's a good case, I think in the seventies where a US classified military manual gets stolen and then they copy it and insert some extra lines into a genuine classified military manual suggesting that the US intelligence services might be willing to plot violence amongst allies in allied countries as false flags to blame communists and build support for the US military presence in those countries. And this is in the 1970s, when there's a lot of suspicion about US intelligence post Watergate and some of the revelations. So you can see that's the modus ...perand they're using. One of the realities, though, we should say, is that they weren't
17:43 Speaker 01 always effective, partly because the KGB wasn't always that subtle in its understanding of how the media space or how the information space in the West worked. So often, they would fall flat. I do remember Oleg Kalugan, the former KGB general who left for the West at the end of the Cold War, told me that they actually used our friend Kim Philby to help them.
18:07 Speaker 00 Yes, friend of the pod.
18:09 Speaker 01 Friend of the pod. They'd run things by Kim Philby. And they said, look, we're planning this active measure against Britain, this piece of false information. And he would say, oh, that won't work. That sounds too Soviet. So you can see how they need some help to work out how to plant information, because they're cultivating journalists or intellectuals to push out these stories, information laundering, it would be the modern word. There's one, I think, really interesting example, which was something called Operation Denver. I'm not sure why it was named Denver, whether it started there. But it spread the idea that secret US military researcher, Fort Dietrich, was behind the creation of the AIDS virus. And this is in the 1980s, when AIDS is just emerging. And the challenge
18:51 Speaker 01 was getting that story out. And they plant it in a small journal in India first, which is funded by the KGB, in 1983. And it takes years for it to be picked up. It takes another couple of years before Soviet news outlets start to push it, citing the Indian journals. Then they can claim they're not the source, it comes from this Indian journal. And then you see it start to spread. And by 1987, over 40 countries are reporting this claim. But it's taken four years to get it spread. But it does have a real impact eventually in how people see the potential for US malfeasance behind AIDS.
19:29 Speaker 00 Well, that's another theme, I think, of this series, is that that 40-year stretch from the KGB initially planting the story to it really catching fire.
19:44 Speaker 00 Is no longer kind of a feature of the active measures and disinformation landscape, right? Because our modern technological infrastructure, the internet, social media, allow these kind of claims to spread, to go viral much more quickly and effectively than the tools the KGB, you know, had at its disposal in the 1980s. I also think, I mean, Gordon, it's worth mentioning that, you know, political interference has long been a part of active measures. I mean, getting agents or intelligence officers to infiltrate campaigns and using information as a weapon. I mean, this was the case, for instance, in 1968, when the Russians used this against Nixon, they think Nixon's too hardline and anti-communist.
20:29 Speaker 00 The KGB, not a big fan also of Ronald Reagan. So they, they want to undermine his campaign in 1984. KGB issues orders to do whatever they can to stop him, you know, work with any other campaign, use front groups, use journalists, another feature of an active measures campaign to kind of attack and stop Reagan. Right? So I, I think the 2016 campaign that we're going to talk about can seem like it's unique, but the reality is that the Russians have attempted to politically interfere in US presidential campaigns going back, you know, decades.
21:06 Speaker 01 One of the things to say as well, David, is that we don't always learn from the history. I think we forgot the history of what the KGB was up to at the end of the Cold War. We thought it was over. And in fact, there is this continuity in Russian intelligence operations, in its desire to use active measures, to influence, to undermine, to sow dissent. It continues. And now maybe it's a bit quieter in the 1990s, but as you hit the start of the 21st century, you've got two things really. One is technology is going to transform the ability to do active measures because you've got the internet, which is going to offer this new vector to spread information. And of course, in Moscow, in Russia,
21:51 Speaker 01 there's a new leader, Vladimir Putin. And so there, David, with Vladimir Putin coming to power in the Kremlin in 2000, let's take a break. And when we come back, we're going to see how Putin is driven to use active measures in a new, potentially transformative way, and eventually directed against the United States.
22:13 Speaker 04 Shaq here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvana 100% online and get it delivered to your door? Let me tell you. Your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvana guy. Can't wait to take it for a spin. Only the best for you, Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big, tall and handsome? Not always. I was 6'10" once. Seven days to love it or return it, Mr. Shaq. Not that I would. You never do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven-day return policy at carvana.com.
22:43 Speaker 05 When you're building a company, you learn that trust is what closes deals. You may have the best product, but buyers won't sign without proof that your product is secure, especially if it has AI. Vanta gets you compliant fast with SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring. Hyperbound, a YC-backed startup, used Vanta to unlock the Fortune 100 in under a year. Snowfire got audit-ready in a month and closed a multimillion-dollar deal. Trust matters. Get started at vanta.com.
23:17 Speaker 01 Well, welcome back. Vladimir Putin has come to power in Moscow in 2000. We looked a bit at his rise, didn't we, in the mini-series we did for club members with Mark Galliotti, the expert, at the formative experiences for this former KGB officer and what molded him. And it is the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 and the chaos and humiliation of the 90s which really shapes him. It's interesting because a lot of people, I think, in the KGB blamed the CIA for the collapse of the Soviet Union. They thought that actually the CIA had been secretly trying to divide and undermine the
23:56 Speaker 01 Soviet Union, which of course was a multi-ethnic, multi-nationality state at that time, and that it broke up into its constituent parts, Russia being only one of them, Baltic States, Ukraine, all these others. And I think it's true that many KGB officers thought this was all the result of an American active measure, if you like, although the Americans wouldn't call it an active measure. Now, that's not necessarily the case, but that was part of the perception, I think.
24:22 Speaker 00 The Soviet Union would have definitely held together if it hadn't been for the CIA. You know, it wasn't, it wasn't, it wasn't because you couldn't make toilet paper or anything like that. But right, it's, it's, this is the mentality, right, of Putin and the KGB officers around him. Now, we talked a bit in our series with, with Mark Aliati about how Putin in those first few years in office, I mean, takes power in 2000, he's relatively solicitous of the West, at least not openly confrontational. And then it flips and it doesn't flip overnight, but there's a series of events that I think kind of reshape the relationship between Putin and the US and the West more broadly. There's, of course, the Iraq war, the invasion of Iraq in 2003.
25:06 Speaker 00 There's criticism from the West, I think rightly so, Putin's extremely brutal war that he's prosecuting in Chechnya throughout much of the early 2000s. There's NATO expansion, which, as, you know, as we've seen Putin is not a fan of. So by 2008, Putin becomes the prime minister rather than the president. Dmitry Medvedev is the president for four years between 2008 and 2012. And there's maybe some speculation that Putin might fade away and let a new generation take over. Oops, that did not happen. In 2011, there are elections for the Duma, Russia's parliament,
25:49 Speaker 00 and those elections are absolutely rife with manipulation. Now, one of the things that I think is interesting, Gordon, is that essentially the Russian intelligence services perform an active measure on the Russian population itself. I think the initial Petri dish for a lot of what we're talking about actually originates inside Russia because Putin's party doesn't perform very well. Protests break out. It's clear that there is. Opposition to Putin returning as president. And Putin is very shaken by all of this. And again, that mindset that we're talking about of all of this being a CIA, a Western plot.
26:31 Speaker 01 KGB paranoid mindset, isn't it?
26:34 Speaker 00 He basically sees this as another domino in these color revolutions that had been sweeping ex or former Soviet states and kind of the Russian near abroad. So places like Georgia, in Ukraine in 2004, there had been these so-called color revolutions, bringing to power political parties and politicians that were anti-Russian. And again, Putin sees all of this not as a sort of expression of the popular will that the people around Russia, or even some Russians inside Russia, don't want to be subjugated by Putin and the people around him. He sees this as a CIA plot.
27:17 Speaker 00 This is the CIA using active measures against Russia. And I think that's a really important point for the mindset that's going to frame the 2016 election, is that wrongly, I would argue, Putin has come to the conclusion that he has been the victim of a very elaborate CIA and Western active measure already.
27:41 Speaker 01 And it's really interesting, isn't it? Who he blames specifically for inciting some of the protests and supporting some of the protests. It's the US Secretary of State at the time, who is Hillary Clinton, Obama's Secretary of State. And he views her as having legitimized and supported some of these opposition groups and protests. Even the idea she might have been giving signals to them through their speech to rise up and protest against him. And so I think this is where some of the very personal antagonism starts between Vladimir Putin and Hillary Clinton.
28:18 Speaker 00 When Putin actually announces his presidential campaign in 2011, he's sitting around a table, speaking to all of these kind of. Stony-faced political allies. And he says that Clinton, quote, "set the tone for certain actors inside the country," meaning the protesters. "She gave the signal." There's kind of two big points here, right? One of them is that Putin believes he has been the target of an ongoing series of US active measures. And two, he sees Hillary Clinton as being, to some degree, the mastermind of those active measures. During Putin's presidential campaign announcement, he's sitting right at a table, speaking to a group of political allies.
29:03 Speaker 00 And he says, Putin says, quote, "that Hillary Clinton had set the tone for certain actors inside the country." He's referring to the protesters who were angry that Putin is going to return to power and that he is, you know, and his party have essentially rigged the election. "She," Clinton, "gave the signal." There's kind of two big points here. One of them is Putin, by the time you get to 2011, 2012, believes strongly that he has been the target of an active measure. And I think it's not just Russia, but his, his control, his political control over Russia has been the target of a CIA or Western active measure.
29:45 Speaker 00 And then the second point is that one of the primary Western politicians behind this is Hillary Clinton. Those are two, two very important points to frame what's going to happen in 2016 is he's been victimized and he's been victimized by Hillary Clinton.
30:02 Speaker 01 That's right. And now he's back as president, as leader of Russia, and it is a different Putin. I think it took a while for people in the West to understand it was a different Putin after 2012. He's more aggressive. He's more nationalistic. He's reaching deeper into social conservatism, into religious currents. And he's starting to see Russia as in conflict, maybe not war, but a conflict with the West. And he's more willing to use aggressive tools, what are sometimes called gray zone activities against the West. It's interesting because as we get into 2013 and the run-up to 2016.
30:44 Speaker 01 Putin has been worried that the internet, that technology, that a free information space is a threat to his hold on power. He views the internet as dangerous. He famously calls the internet a CIA project at one point. And by that, I think he means, you know, it was created by the US government to spread Western ideas. It's a vector for subversion and protest, for Western information warfare. And he's starting to think about how to fight back against that and looking for ways and tools of doing it. And you get this very interesting article in 2013 by General Valery Gerasimov, who we encountered in our Prigozhin series, didn't we?
31:26 Speaker 01 As a T figure, still there as the Chief of General Staff and Head of the Russian Military. He publishes this article, which in a relatively obscure journal, but it becomes seen as a definitive article about what gets called the Gerasimov doctrine. Now, Mark Galiotti, who we've spoken about, is one of those who comes up with that term. And he thinks it's been slightly overstretched as a term. But the key thing to know is Gerasimov is arguing, isn't he, that the West is using new tools and information warfare against Russia. And there is a new information environment, thanks to things like the internet and social
32:06 Speaker 01 media, which is allowing a new form of warfare to be waged by reaching out to populations and mobilizing them potentially for protest, as seen just a couple of years ago in the Arab Spring, which would be really 2011, 2012, hadn't it?
32:24 Speaker 00 The interesting, I think, again, to the Putin mindset is as he's realizing and his intelligence services are beginning to kind of use information warfare quite broadly.
32:37 Speaker 00 He again, I think, sees himself as being a target of these exact same tools on the part of the West. Now, you remember Gordon, in the spring of 2016, the Panama Papers, when that kind of scandal broke, which is basically this massive document dump from a Panamanian law firm called Mossack Von Seka that showed the techniques that Putin himself and a lot of other wealthy people use to kind of hide money. It showed in some cases Putin and Putin affiliates, including, I think, a, was it a violinist or cellist with the
33:16 Speaker 00 St. Petersburg Orchestra who had accounts, you know, in the Caribbean that were worth millions and millions of dollars. And it's sort of where did this come from? And it's quite obvious it came from Putin. So Putin was angry, to say the least, about this document dump. And he's asked at a press conference in April of 2016. So just as this election interference story is gonna start, he's asked about the release of those papers. And he says, officials and state agencies in the United States are behind all this, right? The Americans, Putin says, are trying to weaken Russia from within. It's a spread distrust for the ruling authorities and the bodies of power within the society. So it's an active measure, in his mind.
33:59 Speaker 01 And what's so interesting is there isn't any evidence I've seen that it was an active measure. Like so many things we're talking about, Russia interprets it as such because you've got a KGB officer who's trained in active measures, running the country and a bunch of other security officials around him. They are obsessed with active measures because this is what they've spent their career doing. So when they see these Panama Papers, they assume it must be. When, as far as I know, and I could be wrong, there could be a hidden hand somewhere in it, it was just a, someone who worked in the company leaking this information. But it is an example where Moscow and Russia and Putin are becoming paranoid. You also get, we glossed over one character as well, who we should probably just mention briefly, which is a friend of the show, Edward Snowden, who also makes
34:43 Speaker 01 his appearance in Moscow and ends up after leaking. Lots of American intelligence secrets in Moscow. But I guess the crucial thing about about Snowden is not so much the fact he ends up in Moscow, but the fact that he reveals the extent to which the US is controlling the internet and has the ability to spy on the world through the internet, which again feeds into this idea that the US is using information as a weapon. That's the mindset which has grown, isn't it?
35:15 Speaker 00 That's right, and I'll refer listeners, those who might be new to the program. We did a six episode series on the Edward Snowden debacle. I think it was last spring and Gordon throughout that series expressed a very worrisome affection for the young Edward Snowden.
35:31 Speaker 01 That is a that is a mischaracterization.
35:34 Speaker 00 It's all on tape. It's all on tape and you can go, you can go listen to it.
35:39 Speaker 01 Go judge for yourself.
35:40 Speaker 00 I mean, the other, the other thing that I, we probably shouldn't gloss over is that in 2013, 2014, there were massive protests in Ukraine about essentially whether Ukraine would be looking toward the EU or would be looking back toward Russia. And there was a massive people power movement that came out into Maidan Square in Kiev to essentially say, we don't want to live under the Russian thumb. And at that point in time, there was a quite pro Russian Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanukovych, who essentially makes a decision to take,
36:21 Speaker 00 I think what you could call more or less a cash bribe from the Russians, from Putin, to scrap an EU association agreement. And that that triggers this protest movement. Putin sees, again, a US hand behind those protests as being yet another active measure against Russian power, control and influence in Ukraine. And I think we should say that, you know, your point, Gordon, on we've been talking about Putin's mindset here for a bit. I think one of the very interesting themes of this entire story is that.
37:00 Speaker 00 Both sides, the Russian and the American side, because they conduct intelligence work in very different ways. There's a very different culture and mindset and historical experience with intelligence in both countries. The mirror imaging that is done in both societies makes it very hard to analytically understand what's happening. So in Putin's world, he's been victimized by US active measures going back to the mid 2000s, right? Which I think is not true, but he's interpreting all of this to the lens of the way that he is a former KGB officer
37:42 Speaker 00 and the way that the Russian intelligence services operate, which is active measures are a big part of what they do. We'll see, as we get to it in the US response, that I think one of the reasons why we struggle to understand what actually happened is we don't have a long tradition of active measures in this country. I think we're actually quite bad at information operations. It's not ingrained in the sort of intelligence DNA.
38:06 Speaker 01 Culturally different.
38:06 Speaker 00 Culturally, it's different. And, and so when we, when we are facing down a Russian active measure, we don't see the full scope of it because we view intelligence work as, well, you're, you're stealing secrets and it goes far beyond that. So both sides, I think, really throughout the story will have a very hard time grappling with what they're dealing with because of that mirror imaging.
38:30 Speaker 01 A lot of this does go back, we're picking up that point and also going back to that issue of Ukraine and Maidan and the change of regime in Ukraine. Of course, then you get the start of the first wave of the Ukraine conflict and Russia seizing Crimea. What you also get is a sense within Russia that it is in conflict with the, the West at this point. Something which I don't think the West recognizes on our part, because we don't recognize what they're willing to do. But Ukraine is important, it will be important to our story in lots of ways. Because you can start to see as well, can't you, that Russia will start to fight back and use information operations and active measures in the context of that conflict in Ukraine. That's where things are starting to heat up as we get through 2014, isn't it?
39:16 Speaker 00 That's right. In one instance, the Russians intercept a phone call between a very senior State Department official named Victoria Nuland, who I believe was the most senior State Department official on Russia at the time. She's talking to the US Ambassador to Ukraine and Victoria Nuland on the call says, "Bleep gun, Becky, [bleep] the EU." And then the Russians collect this. Unbelievable. Well, that's why I asked Becky for the bleep gun.
39:43 Speaker 01 Well, I meant the sentiment.
39:44 Speaker 00 Oh, the sentiment. Oh, yeah. Well, I mean, the EU can be very frustrating, Gordon. Let's, we could all...
39:49 Speaker 01 Let's not get into that. We'll get into whether there was a Russian hand in Brexit. That's not the point.
39:55 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:55 Speaker 01 That's Alistair Campbell's big thing. But yeah, sorry, back to the story.
39:58 Speaker 00 And Victoria Nuland, by the way, is the one who, during the protests, wasn't she like handing out muffins to some of the protesters? And the Russians just latched on to that as like evidence of US supporters. You know, Victoria Nuland is handing out baked goods to protesters on the Maidan. Anyhow, the Russians take that intercepted phone call, they dump it out on the internet and put it up on YouTube. And I think it's a great example of an old school intel collection method. Obviously intercepting phone calls, that happens all the time. But the new one, which is, let's put it out there. Let's put it on social media. Let's make it available to create tension with the EU. So make it, make it hard for Victoria Nuland
40:40 Speaker 00 to deal with, you know, and the State Department more broadly, to deal with European officials. And, and create a political kind of wildfire around that content as opposed to what the Russians are actually doing in Ukraine. And it's picked up by obviously Russian TV stations, but ultimately a bunch of American and European news agencies who are just, just all over it.
41:05 Speaker 01 Yeah. And it's, I think it is the first sign we get of Russia, and it's often in Ukraine, as we'll see also with cyber hacking as we come to it, that Russia trials a lot of these techniques. As you said, sometimes domestically to try and sway opinion at home to support the regime, but often in Ukraine abroad as the first place they try things out. And then... Then they're going to try it further afield. So by the time we get to 2016, you can see that Putin is getting paranoid. He thinks the West is trying to undermine him. He thinks it's using the internet to do that. He thinks he's in a conflict with the West, and he particularly hates Hillary Clinton.
41:43 Speaker 00 That's right. And interestingly enough, Gordon, some of the first inklings, I think of what is going on in the run up to 2016 come from a contact of the US State Department. Now, we have not spoken much on this podcast about diplomatic reporting, have we, Gordon? We've mostly talked, we've talked about Sigint, we've talked about Hument. Embassy reporting, State Department reporting, in some ways is quite similar to Hument, right? I mean, it is a, it is a State Department officer in a foreign embassy. You know, a political officer, an economic officer who has contacts in that society, right?
42:23 Speaker 00 In that country, they could be business leaders, they could be Ministry of Foreign Affairs officials, right? They could be kind of members of the sort of cultural, political, business elite, whomever. The difference, so they're going to go out, the State Department officers will go out and they'll, they'll meet and talk to these people. And then they will write that up in cables that are usually classified secret. But what differentiates that from kind of the Hument that CIA collects is that it's usually not collected clandestinely. The host government understands that the Americans are meeting with members of their government. And even if it's not information that is going to be made public, it usually is not.
43:04 Speaker 00 It's not clandestine. You're not stealing a secret
43:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:09 Speaker 00 from the foreign government. And folks who want to look at state cables, I, you know, there have been a bunch that have been leaked over the past decade, which can be, you know, obviously, they can be quite embarrassing because the diplomats will write up reports and send them back to Washington. And sometimes those reports include details on foreign leaders that are not particularly flattering.
43:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, we'll get to the leaks. We'll get to the leaks maybe soon, a bit further on down the story, yeah.
43:37 Speaker 00 That's right. Now, this story comes from a terrific book on the Russian active measure called Russian Roulette by Michael Isikoff and David Corn. And they write in their book that in early 2014, A US diplomat assigned to the US Embassy in Moscow, reached out to someone, they call it a secret source in Russia. I'm not quite sure what to make of that because again, usually these contacts are, you know, known to the host government. And this diplomat was, was trying to understand Russia's plans toward Ukraine and Crimea. Again, it's not a paid source, but this person had ties into the Kremlin and had provided useful information in the past. In the spring of 2015, so the State Department officials had a bunch of interactions with this person.
44:21 Speaker 00 The source comes back with something that's particularly interesting. And he tells the State Department official that the Kremlin is planning a wide-ranging campaign to attack Western institutions and undermine Western democracies. So again, it's, it's an active measure. It would include cyber attacks, information warfare, propaganda, social media campaigns. The source offered general reports on Russian penetration of media organizations, lobbying firms, political parties. It's interesting because I think while it in retrospect paints a picture of what is going to come, it's not particularly surprising at the time to US officials. Again, consider the history we talked about.
45:04 Speaker 00 Russian active measures are just sort of part of the game. But State Department wrote, you know, the size and magnitude and the seriousness of their intent was disturbing because it showed this kind of growing capacity for mounting influence operations and active measures against the US. Now, the US official who's meeting with the source ends up filing more than a dozen embassy cables with this intelligence. I think these are what are called a no-dis cables, Gordon. No dissemination, very limited kind of distro. Like usually if a diplomatic cable was sent back to Washington and then got distributed at CIA, it would be quite easy to access because again, it's usually just classified secret. The notice cables would sometimes, if my memory is correct, come to you just hard copy
45:49 Speaker 00 and be harder to get, they'd be harder to get your hands on because it would typically be written by the ambassador or a very senior official inside the embassy and would include information that would be particularly sensitive. So kind of getting closer to human, but, but not, not quite.
46:04 Speaker 01 And it was seen as, as significant and, and interesting reporting, but it maybe doesn't feel like it has the impact you might expect.
46:12 Speaker 00 I can understand why it wasn't really acted upon because on the one hand, it is. It is giving kind of high level plans and intentions for what the Russian government intends to do. It's explaining that an active measure is coming or underway, but it doesn't give you enough specificity about the targets, I think, or maybe even the broader intent in order to be able to stop it. It's not particularly actionable and does seem to fit in line with what at that point must have seemed like, you know, just an ongoing wave of Russian active measures that are directed against the US and the West.
46:52 Speaker 01 That's right, and I think there was a bit of complacency about, well, the Russians might try and do this kind of thing, but it never really has much impact, doesn't work, won't sway anything. I just think that there was a complacency about the potential impact of these kind of operations at the time.
47:09 Speaker 00 Well, that's right. And one US official later said, anybody who had any doubt about Putin's intentions just wasn't reading what we reported. And I think it's maybe not quite true, because to your point, there was a sense that, well, we understand Putin's intentions. It just might not make much of an impact. In speaking with a number of former CIA and former FBI officials who were involved in the story, the complacency point was a big one, because whether it was a failure of an imagination, an intelligence failure, we just didn't, we didn't see this coming. But in any case, the stage is set for a very audacious Russian active measure, one that
47:53 Speaker 00 is going to end up targeting all of American society. And maybe there, Gordon, we'll end this first episode exploring Russian active measures and Vladimir Putin's intentions. And next time, we will see how that active measure is unleashed on the United States.
48:08 Speaker 01 But of course, if you don't want to wait for that next episode, you can hear it right now and the rest of the series, and you will get access to the very special bonus series looking at Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin and 2016. All of that, if you join the Declassified Club at therestisclassified.com. Lots of other benefits there as well, including a weekly newsletter. But otherwise, we'll see you next time.
48:38 Speaker 00 We'll see you next time.
48:45 Speaker 05 When you're building a company, you learn that trust is what closes deals. You may have the best product, but buyers won't sign without proof that your product is secure, especially if it has AI. Vanta gets you compliant fast with SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring. Hyperbound, a YC-backed startup, used Vanta to unlock the Fortune 100 in under a year. Snowfire got audit-ready in a month and closed a multimillion-dollar deal. Trust matters. Get started at vanta.com.
Previous 129. Al Qaeda’s Deadliest Plot: Why You Can’t Bring Liquids On Planes (Ep 4) Next 131. How Russia Made Trump: Stealing Washington’s Secrets (Ep 2) Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated