What Are the Masculine Virtues?
The Permanent Questions With David Brooks
Hosted by David Brooks
- 56m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
David Brooks and Marine veteran and author Phil Klay discuss the state of modern masculinity, military service, and the search for purpose and honor in an era of endless invisible wars. Klay reflects on his service in Iraq's Anbar province, the disillusionment and rage that follow failed military campaigns, and how institutional codes and humanistic ideals shape civic life. The conversation examines why young men are struggling, the limits of amoral views of power, and how a hard-headed idealism and love for family and country can survive contact with harsh realities.
- Institutions like the Marine Corps provide thick ethical codes and diverse models that help shape individuals. 12:22
- Military training provides deep moral formation because the stakes of hard power are so high and immediate. 13:35
- Real historical change often relies on writers, intellectuals, and human rights manifestos rather than pure hard power. 25:02
- Forging a hard, realistic idealism is essential for taking American citizenship and responsibility seriously. 28:33
- Love for one another in tight-knit units is often the true driver of courage under extreme fire. 51:01
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Introduction
David Brooks opens the episode and sets the stage for a discussion on masculine virtues.
- 0:45Defining the Crisis of Masculinity
Brooks outlines three societal crises affecting men, setting the stage for a discussion on masculine ideals.
- 1:34The Failure of Trump‑Era Masculinity
The conversation critiques the Trump administration’s promotion of a narrow, warrior‑style masculinity and its impact on culture.
- 2:15Phil Cline’s Military Experience
Cline shares his background as a Marine, writer, and PEN president, framing his perspective on honor and service.
- 3:00Historical Models of Masculine Virtue
Brooks and Cline trace masculine ideals from ancient Greece to the 19th‑century American frontier, highlighting shifts over time.
- 9:06Honor and Institutional Roles
The pair discuss how honor is defined differently across military, civilian, and political institutions and the tension between them.
- 20:00Purpose, Virtue, and Modern Masculinity
Brooks and Cline explore what virtues—courage, humility, love—should guide men in contemporary society.
- 40:02The Cost of War and Disillusionment
Cline reflects on the emotional toll of Iraq, the sense of failure, and the broader disillusionment among young men.
- 45:11Conclusion: Reimagining Masculine Identity
The episode closes with reflections on how to cultivate a healthier, more inclusive masculine ideal for the future.
- 47:36Education, Utilitarianism, and Moral Development
The discussion turns to how modern education’s utilitarian focus erodes the humanistic disciplines that foster purpose and virtue.
- 53:07Exploring Eternal Virtues
Brooks reflects on timeless moral truths and their relevance to modern society.
- 53:58Phil Clyne’s Military Insight
Brooks introduces Phil Clyne, a veteran, and delves into his experiences in Iraq.
Highlights
- 5:54
Advertising a Cartoonish Masculinityinsight
The guest explains how political figures perform narrow, image-focused roles of warrior culture rather than embodying full human wisdom like Socrates.
- 14:09
The Military as a Modern Monasteryinsight
Samuel Huntington's observation is discussed, noting how the military is an anachronistic institution deeply interested in moral formation.
- 20:15
Fighting for Abstract Ideasdebate
The host debases the claim that people do not fight for abstractions, citing historical letters from Civil War soldiers proving deep idealism.
- 24:48
Charter 77 and Moral Forcestory
The guest details how a small group of writers issuing a human rights manifesto helped bring down communism, proving moral factors matter in geopolitics.
- 29:17
A Tragic Sensibility and Humilityinsight
The host and guest discuss the ancient Greek tragic view of human flaws, noting that screwing up brings pain far greater than benefits.
- 35:51
Enlisting at the Bottom of Warstory
The guest reflects on his decision to join the Marines in 2005 during the height of the Iraq insurgency, driven by humanitarian concerns.
- 42:45
The Pure Heroin of Purposeinsight
The discussion turns to how war provides intense purpose and identity, making normal civilian life feel flat and devoid of high stakes upon return.
- 49:47
Love as the Ultimate Virtueinsight
When asked for his core virtue, the guest answers love, explaining it is what everything decent flows from and what truly drives battlefield courage.
Quotes
“There are at least three important things going on in America right now.”
David Brooks · 0:45 “I think Abraham Lincoln was a humble man, but he also knew he was kind of special in some ways.”
David Brooks · 49:27 “The most powerful innovations don't connect us to everything. They connect us to each other.”
Unnamed speaker · 56:14 “If you don't have the courage to overcome risks, you're not going to take chances in life, you're probably not going to ask somebody out on a date, like things like courage is really important.”
David Brooks · 48:54 “And the word that came out of his mouth was rage.”
David Brooks · 54:05 “he did not respond with bitterness, he did not respond with alienation, he just said love.”
David Brooks · 55:13
Sponsored segments
- Lexus 0:00–0:15
- MintMobile 0:27–0:33
- Lexus 18:52–19:24
- SimpliSafe 39:29–39:58
- SimpliSafe 39:34–39:58
- Lexus 56:36–57:04
About this episode
One of the things that President Trump seems to admire most about his embattled defense secretary is Pete Hegseth’s vision of warrior masculinity, a vision Hegseth has attempted to impose on the military, through the firing of qualified high-ranking female officers, the denigration of long-established rules of engagement, and even the proposed screening of service members’ testosterone levels. These efforts are taking place at a time when many young American men are facing a very real crisis, but they don’t seem to have landed among their target audience: Male voters under 30 swung 40 percent toward Democrats in the midterms, one of the election’s largest such demographic shifts. In this episode of The Permanent Questions, David Brooks talks with Phil Klay, a Marine Corps veteran, National Book Award–winning novelist and story writer, and close observer of the effects that our 21st-century wars have had on American soldiers. Klay explains why Hegseth’s version of manhood is bad for men (and the military), why warfare can never be stripped of its moral meaning, and why love is the greatest masculine virtue. - - - Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Atlantic subscribers also get access to exclusive subscriber audio in Apple Podcasts. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/Listener. “The Permanent Questions” is produced and edited by The Atlantic in partnership with Yale University. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
9,616 words · 7 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Iraq
- Afghanistan
- Czechoslovakia
- Uncertain Ground
- Helsinki Final Act
- Anbar province
- Iraq war
- Afghanistan war
- Iran war
- National Book Award
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated