Skip to content

Ep. 960: Illegal Sheep Nuts and Another Record Buck Controversy

The MeatEater Podcast

Hosted by Steven Rinella

1h 15m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode covers several wildlife news stories and controversies, beginning with a Montana hunting guide fined twenty thousand dollars for selling a bighorn sheep scrotum containing genetic material to a captive breeder. Steven Rinella and the crew trace the breeder's history of illicit Marco Polo sheep imports and cloning schemes, comparing the low financial rewards and high legal risks typical of wildlife crimes. Later segments examine the disputed record status of the Sam Aiuppa whitetail buck in Illinois, highlighting missing hunting licenses, contradictory kill dates, and a family connection to notorious Chicago mob figures.

  • Wildlife poachers often face disproportionately large fines compared to the low financial return of their illegal sales. 17:07
  • Historical records show that Sam Aiuppa lacked a valid deer hunting license for the year he claimed to have killed his record whitetail buck. 1:11:50
  • Boone and Crockett records originally listed November first as the kill date for the Aiuppa buck, which fell outside the legal firearm season. 44:07
  • Oklahoma's proposed rules for releasing captive CWD-resistant deer require landowners to meet strict acreage, testing, and monitoring criteria. 1:14:31

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Intro and Advertisements

    The episode opens with a series of sponsor messages before the host begins the main story.

  2. 3:00
    Introduction to Illegal Sheep Nuts Story

    The host introduces the Montana bighorn sheep hunting guide and the controversy over selling a nutsack.

  3. 6:05
    Jack Schubarth’s Background and Early Schemes

    The host details Jack Schubarth’s history, including his pet store, breeding operations, and early illegal imports.

  4. 6:52
    Illegal Importation of Marco Polo Sheep Genetic Material

    The story explains how Schubarth smuggled genetic material from Kyrgyzstan and used it to breed exotic sheep.

  5. 9:36
    John Luton’s Fine and the Nutsack Sale

    The host discusses the $20,000 fine imposed on hunting guide John Luton for selling a bighorn sheep nutsack.

  6. 24:25
    Legal Consequences and Fines for Schubarth

    Schubarth faced federal fines, a prison sentence, and probation for his wildlife crimes.

  7. 31:39
    Sam Ayuppa Whitetail Buck Controversy

    The episode shifts to the disputed record of a massive whitetail buck killed by Sam Ayuppa.

  8. 42:34
    Legal Investigation into Ayuppa’s Kill

    The host presents findings from the Illinois DNR investigation and questions about the kill’s legality.

  9. 47:41
    Boone and Crockett Record Status and Statute of Limitations

    Discussion of Boone and Crockett’s stance on the buck and the expiration of legal action.

  10. 52:44
    Sam Ayuppa’s Mob Connections and Family Ties

    The host reveals Ayuppa’s uncle’s Chicago mob background and its implications.

  11. 55:31
    Muskie Story Introduction

    Steven and a guest discuss Joey Ayupa’s alleged world‑record muskie catch and its controversial background.

  12. 59:51
    WeatherTech Floor Liners Ad

    Host promotes WeatherTech floor liners as essential for keeping vehicle interiors clean during outdoor adventures.

Highlights

  • 4:30

    Bighorn Scrotum Fine and Breedingstory

    Steven Rinella discusses a Montana hunting guide fined $20,000 for selling a trophy bighorn ram's scrotum to an alternative livestock ranch. This connects to a larger, years-long investigation into illegal Marco Polo sheep imports and cloning schemes run by an 81-year-old breeder.

  • 17:07

    Low Reward and High Riskinsight

    The hosts analyze the economics of wildlife crime, noting that the guide received only $400 for the bighorn testicles yet faced a $20,000 fine and commercial hunting prohibitions, illustrating an extreme imbalance between reward and risk.

  • 43:02

    Missing License and Date Discrepanciesdata

    Outdoor writer Craig Mitchell explains that an Illinois DNR investigation found no record of a deer license issued to Sam Aiuppa in 1991, and the reported kill dates fell outside the legal firearm season.

  • 52:44

    Mob Connection to the Aiuppa Buckstory

    Craig Mitchell reveals that Sam Aiuppa's uncle was Joey Aiuppa, a high-ranking leader in the Chicago mafia who worked for Al Capone and had his own history of major wildlife violations.

  • 1:14:24

    Strict Oklahoma Release Rulesstrategy

    Nate Mason details the heavy restrictions in Oklahoma's proposed rules for releasing captive CWD-resistant deer, which include owning at least 1,000 contiguous acres and securing written affidavits from every neighbor within three miles.

Quotes

  • “The trouble is I read it from a guy that I don't know how the guy would know that price.”
    Steven Rinella · 15:42
  • “Oftentimes with wildlife crimes, you find where there's exceptionally low reward and outside, outsized risk.”
    Steven Rinella · 17:07
  • “He was a very, I mean, he worked for Capone. I mean, he was one of the, at one time, the head of the Chicago mafia.”
    Unnamed speaker · 52:51
  • “If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it's probably a duck.”
    Unnamed speaker · 58:58
  • “The releases are only allowed if harvest has fallen below 50% of the 10 year average.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:14:39
  • “You have to have at least 1,000 contiguous acres, private, owned outright, outright and entirely in Oklahoma.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:14:31
  • “They would, even releasing 7,500 resistant deer in a year for 10 years would have no effect.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:10:34
  • “I think that that's, that seems to me the most likely thing.”
    Steven Rinella · 1:22:02
  • Grainger 0:00–0:32
  • Murad 0:56–1:42
  • Tacovas 1:47–2:54
  • MeatEater.com 27:20–27:31
  • WeatherTech 28:57–30:31
  • Montana Knife Company 29:43–30:51
  • OnePay 30:51–31:34
  • WeatherTech 59:55–1:01:30
  • Montana Knife Company 1:00:41–1:01:44
  • One Pay 1:01:06–1:02:25

About this episode

Steven Rinella and the MeatEater Crew Discuss: a sheep breeder and a sheep hunter are in hot water over a sheep scrotum; controversy over the legitimacy of the Aiuppa buck; Oklahoma continues down the road to releasing captive deer; and more! Connect with Steve https://www.themeateater.com/authors/steven-rinella and The MeatEater Podcast Network https://www.youtube.com/@MeatEaterPodcastNetwork Steve on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/stevenrinella and Twitter https://twitter.com/stevenrinella?lang=en MeatEater on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/meateater, Facebook https://www.facebook.com/StevenRinellaMeatEater/, Twitter https://twitter.com/MeatEaterTV?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor, and YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@MeatEaterPodcastNetwork See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript

0:00
1:15:49

14,194 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Montana
  • Boone and Crockett
  • Doves
  • Marco Polo sheep
  • Great Falls
  • Chicago
  • Coastal Community Bank
  • Lead Bank
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Argali sheep

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated