Pod Insights The Martin Lewis Podcast Plan 2 Student Loans Pod Extra: Stop the repayment freeze – and should you overpay? About this episode Bonus Podcast - Martin Lewis gives his advice for people on a Plan 2 Student Loan. With the Government freezing the repayment threshold he explains if you should overpay now (spoiler: for some yes, many no).
The pod features Martin speaking to Victoria Derbyshire about UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves's decision to freeze the student debt repayment threshold for three years and the experience of graduates paying interest on a Plan 2 student loan.
You can get in touch with the team by emailing [email protected] mailto:[email protected] – make sure to send in your burning questions and any successes you’ve had following Martin’s advice!
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:06 Speaker 01 Cheers to fall savings at Whole Foods Market, home of higher ingredient standards. This Halloween, share chocolates and candies made without that spooky high fructose corn syrup. Throwing a party? Make it easy with a berry chantilly cake. Ready to cook pizza? No antibiotics ever chicken wings. And sushi made fresh daily. Fall gatherings never tasted better. Save through November 3rd at Whole Foods Market.
0:33 Speaker 02 Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with the tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is an AI for just that. It's a collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task like turning a folder or scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or deck right in front of you, and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and
1:16 Speaker 02 Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai/solve. That's claude.ai/solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. claude.ai/solve.
1:44 Martin Lewis? Hello, welcome to a special extra podcast all about Plan Two student loans, where there is a body of anger growing up around the country, and there's been much debate and stories covered on this. Now, Plan Two student loans are for those from England who started university between the 2012-13 academic year and the 2022-23 academic year, and those from Wales who started university. From the 2012-2013 academic year, right on up until now. Much of the anger is about the amount of interest people are seeing on their statements. In some cases, they're paying off a lot, but still seeing the total amount that they owe grow. And I get why people are annoyed about it.
2:29 Martin Lewis? So what I want to talk through today is, first of all, I'm going to play you a Newsnight interview that I did with Victoria Derbyshire on the politics of this. And then we're going to morph from the political to the practical about what it means for you and what you can actually do. Now, it's very important to be clear, we're talking only about Plan Two student loans. Current English students who've started since 2023 are on Plan Five loans. Their terms are different. The interest rate is lower, but they repay at a lower threshold and they repay for 40 years rather than 30 years. So it's wiped at a later date. And all that means, even though the interest rate is lower, the new Plan Five loans likely
3:11 Martin Lewis? mean most students going now will pay even more back than those on Plan Two. But we've covered that before and we will cover it again. Today, it's on Plan Two. So, as it's the podcast, let's play the theme tune and then we'll go straight into Victoria Derbyshire from Newsnight.
3:34 Speaker 04 Martin Lewis is calling on graduates to write to their MP about their student loans. The founder of money-saving expert knows everything there is to know about this issue. And it's a good thing because there is a lot of anger amongst students absorbing the changes announced in the last budget. And in a moment, we'll talk to a graduate and trainee paediatrician who now owes £20,000 more than what he initially borrowed, despite paying off hundreds of pounds each month. So. Martin, I want to ask you first of all, as I head over there, why are so many up in arms?
4:09 Martin Lewis? So there's a growing anger, especially amongst those who have Plan Two student loans, those who started in England and Wales in the 2012 to 2013, up to 2023 in England and still going in Wales. Now, they're the loans that have above inflation interest added on top. And I would say there are four reasons for the problem here. The first is for now well over 40 years. We've educated our youth into what we call the debt, but never educated them about debt. There should have been formal education at the point in senior school when you're applying for university, and universities should have done formal education in the first when you get there, so people understood this. Second, fiscal drag. Freezing of the tax thresholds means effectively people are paying more money in tax. Graduates are feeling that.
4:54 Martin Lewis? Many of them are moving to the higher rate band far earlier than they would have done before. Third, the big one, inflation. Obviously, the cost of living is hard for everybody. But people on Plan Two loans have above inflation loans that are linked to inflation. So when we've had high inflation, their interest rates have gone up. And that has been particularly painful. And even though those rates have come down a little, well, you've still got a lot more now added on top of your loan, which makes it more difficult. And the final one is we're starting to see the graduate premium diminish. The extra money you earn from going to university, for some there isn't any, but for everybody has come down a little bit. And with the threat of AI to jobs, which is going to hit the professional classes most of all, that is looking even more scary for people in this particular cohort.
5:39 Martin Lewis? And I think add that all together, that's the big picture. There's nuts and bolts too, but that's the big picture of anger.
5:44 Speaker 04 Can I hone in on something that was announced by the Chancellor in the budget? Which is, she announced the freezing of the repayment thresholds.
5:55 Speaker 04 What impact does that have? And also, is the government just allowed to do that and change the sort of terms of the contract?
6:02 Martin Lewis? So the impact is everybody who is above the threshold will effectively pay more. It's frozen from 2027 to 2030. As a rough guess, and it's only a guess because I don't know what inflation will be, by 2030 you'll be paying £300 a year more than you do right now.
6:15 Speaker 04 Right.
6:16 Martin Lewis? It's another form of fiscal drag. It's a freezing of the threshold. So they will, these graduates will be facing double drag in effect. And I think that's a real problem. It's also particularly dangerous for low and middle earning graduates because they will be paying more, but it won't affect what they pay in 30 years. They will just be paying more. The very highest earning graduates, they will be paying more each month because the repayment threshold is frozen, but because they will be clear in the 30 years before the debts wiped, they will actually pay less interest because of it. So arguably it's beneficial for the highest earners, but not for the majority. As for whether they can do this, well, look, in 2012 when these loans were launched, the Conservative government said, and these are contractual loans, your loan will rise
6:58 Martin Lewis? the repayment threshold with average earnings from 2016-17. In 2015, they announced they were going to freeze it. I took legal advice over a judicial review at the time to try and take them to court, and we did a big campaign to stop the freezing of the threshold. The government caved in and they increased the threshold at the time. I can tell you now, the truth is, I was very glad because my legal advice said you will not win.
7:25 Speaker 04 Really?
7:26 Martin Lewis? You will not win.
7:27 Speaker 04 Okay.
7:28 Martin Lewis? Now, we tried to change this in 2016. We had a campaign that said there should be no negative changes for existing contracts. You want to change for future students, that's a political issue, but it's an issue of natural justice if you change them on the existing contracts. And these loans should be regulated by the FCA. Do you know, we did a campaign, and do you know who the MP who tried to do amendments in Parliament to support it was? Then he was just a not that well-known backbench opposition MP. His name is Wes Streeting. He is now the Secretary of State for Health. He is a big name, and he said no negative retrospective changes, and it should be FCA rules. And now his colleague, the Chancellor, is freezing the repayment threshold. It shouldn't be happening.
8:09 Speaker 04 Right. What do you say about some people watching who will say, look, you want to go to university? You take out the student loan, you have to pay for the tuition fees, you pay for your own education and that's exactly how it should be. You know what the terms are because, okay, you didn't know about the freezing of the repayment thresholds, but you know what the terms are generally. You signed up to it.
8:33 Martin Lewis? While the student loan system is called a loan system and works more like a tax, most people are going to pay 9% of what they earn for 30 years, 70 to 80%, regardless.
8:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:42 Martin Lewis? You know, it is a contractual loan. You go abroad, you have to pay it. That's why it's not a tax. It was a contract. In the terms of that contract, when people signed up, they were told the repayment threshold would go up with average earnings. The maths was done on the back of that. I would say to anybody who's saying out there, well, hold on, people who didn't go to university are going to have to pay for these people. You can have that argument.
9:03 Speaker 04 Yeah.
9:03 Martin Lewis? I'm talking about natural justice.
9:05 Speaker 04 Right.
9:05 Martin Lewis? Freezing the repayment threshold is a breach of natural justice. It would not be allowed for any commercial lender. It would go against all forms of consumer law. It's a breach of contract. It's a breach of promise. And while I don't think technically there's a legal leg to stand on here, there's a moral leg to stand on. The Chancellor knows what she's done, so writing to her won't help. But if all these people, these Plan Two graduates who are affected by it, write to their MPs and say, this isn't on, this isn't what we were promised. We've got a contract with you and you are unilaterally changing the terms. And you tell companies they can't do that, you shouldn't do it either. I think that's a pretty strong argument. Who funds higher educations? A totally different story.
9:42 Speaker 04 Okay. So that's your message to graduates, write to your MP, put some pressure on. If Rachel Reeves is watching this evening, what would you say?
9:51 Martin Lewis? I would say, Chancellor, you know, you know that you're doing this as fiscal drag, as if student loans were a tax, but it's not a tax. It's a contract that the government signed with young people who had not been given any education on these loans. I do not think it is a moral thing for you to do, to be freezing the repayment threshold in this way. It's not like tax that we know is variable. You didn't say the terms are variable. This isn't right. Please have a rethink.
10:18 Speaker 04 Martin Lewis, thank you very much. We are going to hear actually from Rachel Reeves right now because she defended the system. She said it was fair.
10:26 Speaker 05 You only pay it back if you afford, if you can afford to do so. And obviously after a period of time, that gets written off entirely. So if you are able to get a job that pays a good wage, you'll pay that money back quicker. But if you're never able to repay, that loan will eventually be written off. I think that is a fair system. Around half of people go to university today, but half don't. And it is not right that people who don't go to university are having to bear all the cost for others to do so.
10:56 Martin Lewis? Well, that was the Chancellor. And while the argument about the structure of the system is right, that isn't an argument for why you change what has effectively been a contract that people signed up to. I also think it's important that as we lower the repayment threshold relative to minimum wage, when this originally came out, I explained this as effectively a no win, no fee form of education. Because those people who earned a lot after university would have to pay a lot, and that was how I always phrased it, and that is certainly coming to fruition now. Those people who didn't earn much, which was the main worry in the questions I got at the time, it's interesting, it's slightly morphed now. The questions I got for, I don't want my kids going to university with £40,000 of debt and then they come out and they've got a very low paying job, how will they repay it?
11:40 Martin Lewis? And the answer then was, well, they probably won't have to repay it. But as we have lowered the repayment threshold, the point at which you start repaying that 9% above the threshold, so that it effectively is not that much more than someone working full time on minimum wage. I think we have, one of the problems is what is going on is we have diminished the no win, no fee, because effectively if you're only getting minimum wage, that's not a graduate premium and you're still going to have to repay some of the loan. I think some of the language the Chancellor used is starting to become outdated with the way that the loan now works. Anyway, I'll let others debate the Chancellor. I wanted to talk about a few more different things. I want to try and move us. From the politics into the practical, but before I do that, a couple of notes.
12:24 Martin Lewis? Some people who heard me in that Newsnight interview got in touch and they said, "I'm confused. You've always said this works like a tax. Now you're arguing that they shouldn't change the repayment threshold because it's a contract. It's a loan." And you are quite correct. There is a duality in what I'm talking about. And I've had to deal with that duality for 15 years, so it isn't new for me. This isn't an inconsistency. For a graduate who takes a student loan, well, a student who takes a loan and becomes a graduate, in practice, for the majority, this will work like a tax.
13:04 Martin Lewis? You will repay 9% of what you earn above a threshold. And the vast majority on Plan Two student loans will do that for 30 years until it wipes. Only those who took smaller loans or who are on the very higher end of the graduate earning spectrum will clear this within the 30 years, in which case it starts to resemble more of a loan. That is how graduates should view it for financial decision making. But that is separate to the more political and legal side of what do you actually have? And this is where that split between my practical explanation and the political status comes from.
13:49 Martin Lewis? The first thing is, it can't be a tax because not everybody pays it. Those people who come from families wealthy enough that they didn't have to take a student loan because they would have paid it for them, they don't have this. So it isn't a tax because it doesn't apply to all graduates. It just, in practical finance, works more like a tax. It's also not a tax because it's done by contract. And the reason that governments do it by contract is so that if you were leave the UK, while you wouldn't have to pay UK taxes if they left the UK, you would still have to repay your student loan under the contract that you signed up to. And that was a choice of government to do it via a contractual form. So, and it's also not a tax because it's hypothecated to an individual student, but that's getting a bit arcane.
14:32 Martin Lewis? So the reason the split works is because one is about how you must consider this practically in making your decisions of whether you should overpay or how it works or how much you're going to pay. The other is technically what your deal was with the government. And your deal with the government is you signed up to a contract. Now, it seems fundamentally unfair that you, as an individual who signed up to get a Plan Two student loan, couldn't suddenly say, actually, I want to pay less, so I'm going to start paying you less. I mean, you wouldn't be allowed to do so. But the government has said, we want you to pay more each year by freezing the repayment threshold, even though when you signed up, especially if you signed up in 2012, you were told in all the government documentation that you were signing up to a loan that would go up with average earnings. Well, it hasn't gone up with average earnings already, and a repayment threes will make
15:17 Martin Lewis? that even worse. So that's why there is a sort of, some people got a confusion between when do I call it a loan, when do I call it a tax? Well, legally, it was a loan contract. In a practical sense, you need to think of it more as a graduate tax in most cases. Let me move on to the main practical point that people are saying at the moment, and I 100% understand the anger, frustration, and psychological damage that the above inflation interest rates on Plan Two loans have caused. What's happening for some people at the moment, even some people on decent earnings paying off relatively substantial amounts, is they check their student loan statement and they
15:58 Martin Lewis? see that it's still going up, even though they're paying it off. And they're finding that incredibly frustrating and difficult. Now, I need to say that since 2012, student loans were launched, and in fact before, I have always had a principled objection to above inflation interest on student loans. I think it's psychologically damaging, and more so, the line I was using way back when, when it first started, is it is wrong that we are charging students for the financing of their loans as well as for the loans themselves. And that's what above inflation interest does. Inflation interest, while people still don't like it, ultimately means if you borrow £40,000, you pay back £40,000 in...
16:45 Martin Lewis? Whatever the currency is worth in future times, it's still, it's just gone up, the number's gone up, but it's still, your earnings have gone up and inflation's gone up. I mean, the fact they use the RPI not CPI inflation is a problem in that. But the big problem with Plan Two student loans is the rate of inflation that has been set, and that's why it works this way. But, part of the way that it is presented is absolutely psychologically damaging, because we need to go back to that original thing that I said, that we've known since the very beginning, and I've been reading my blogs back in 2012 when this launched, saying the vast majority of students who take this will not repay in full in the 30
17:23 Martin Lewis? years. So for the vast majority of students, you simply have to perceive this as a 9% tax above the threshold for 30 years. Now, the fact that the threshold isn't going up and hasn't gone up as much means you're paying more tax than you should be and more tax than it works like, but it doesn't change the way that it works. And therefore, when you're looking at the interest on your statement, what you actually have to understand is the interest, people refer to it as, "I'm being charged this amount of interest." Well, actually, within student loans, perversely, because of the way the system operates, the amount of interest added to your statement is not automatically the same as the amount of interest
18:05 Martin Lewis? that you have to repay. And this is for a very simple reason. Most graduates will not pay it off within the 30 years. Therefore, the sole thing that dictates what they pay is how much they earn. You pay 9% above the threshold. If you were to, let's reduce this to absurdity, I'm not saying this happens, but this is to try and explain the concept. If you were to never earn over the threshold, then you would never pay back what you originally borrowed, and you would certainly not pay back any interest. If you were to only earn slightly over the threshold over 30 years, then you might pay back some of what you borrowed, but you would not pay back all of it, and you would not pay any interest. At a bit of a higher earnings level, you'd pay back all of what you borrowed and not any interest. At a level above that, you'd pay back all of what you borrowed and some
18:50 Martin Lewis? interest, but not all the interest added. The only people who will repay all the interest added to their loans Are the people who will clear it in full within the thirty years. Everybody else will pay less than the interest that is added. Now, please, no one see this as me saying it's cheap. A nine percent additional tax above what is going to be a frozen threshold of twenty nine thousand pounds from twenty twenty seven is very expensive and more expensive than it was when you got it out originally and what the people were promised it would be. But it works like a tax. So for those who aren't high earners or didn't borrow a smaller amount, in reality,
19:35 Martin Lewis? you just need to look at it as a tax. And the fact that your interest is not shrinking is irrelevant because the interest does not dictate what you pay. The likelihood is you're just going to pay nine percent of everything you earn over thirty years. Now, this isn't a sop. This isn't me saying that's good or anything like that. This is me just saying there's no point in panicking over it because actually it's not going to affect what you pay in many cases. And you have to get that in your head. And the reason I'm so militant on getting that and explaining that to people and have been explaining it this way for a very long time is because if you start to panic over the interest being added to your statement when you're not going to pay it, the next logical thing that comes into your head is you think I should probably be overpaying this. Now, the rules on overpayment on student loans, you can do it whenever you want.
20:20 Martin Lewis? You can voluntarily overpay more of your student loan whenever you want. But if you overpay voluntarily as opposed to accidentally, and we've talked before about reclaiming overpaid student loans. There's millions of cases of people have accidentally overpaid and they can get the money back. But if you overpay voluntarily, the rule is once you've overpaid, you cannot get your money back. So I have met people who have been panicked into overpaying their student loan. And they're just paying off a thousand or two thousand pounds when they've come into a little bit of money. But the fact that they have paid off a thousand or two thousand pounds will not be enough to change the fact that they won't clear the loan within the thirty years before it wipes. And that means they will not pay a penny less in future because they overpaid by a thousand pounds or two thousand pounds.
21:05 Martin Lewis? That money has been thrown away. And that's my concern about the focus on the interest for some people who won't pay it, that it might scare you into overpaying. So I'm just going to talk you through now the circumstances where overpaying may help you and the circumstances where it is less likely to help you. For the majority of Plan Two holders, it's likely smaller overpayments of, say, a few thousand pounds will still leave you repaying nine percent of your earnings for the full 30 years, in which case the overpayments won't have any impact. And you will have just flushed that money away. Being very clear, I'm deliberately repeating. Now, as well as your income, obviously, the higher income you have, the more likely to clear within the 30 years and the more likely, therefore, overpaying becomes realistically
21:50 Martin Lewis? beneficial for you, there are other things that affect that, too. Overpayments are more likely to help, as you're more likely to clear within 30 years, if you borrowed materially less than the full tuition and living loan. If you're on a career path where incomes accelerate rapidly. If you're likely to work the full 30 years with few breaks or time off or out of work, including long parental leaves.
22:15 Martin Lewis? And if you have a substantial amount you can overpay. I mean, for most typical English students with bigger loans, I'm talking tens of thousands of pounds, which would actually mean you would get to the point where you can clear it. If you have smaller amounts, they are less likely to help you. And of course, the opposite is true. Long career breaks, you borrowed the full amount, then you're less likely to get from overpaying. How to work it out is a nightmare. There is no way to do it accurately. I have put information online that you'll be able to find where I have created an AI prompt calculator, which gives you all the questions you need to ask and you can put it into AI. Of course, AI is not foolproof, but it gives you an idea of whether you're likely to clear or not. If you're close to it looking like overpaying works for smaller amounts, I would still err on the side of caution.
23:00 Martin Lewis? Because you can't change your mind. And I would probably suggest in that case, if you're not sure, simply take that money, put it into the highest interest savings account that you possibly can, paying hopefully over 4%. That will mitigate some of the current 6.2% interest that you may be in charged, because the interest on Plan Two student loans, the exact amount depends on what you earn. It starts at just RPI inflation, it goes up to RPI plus 3%, which this tax share is 3.2%. And again, those thresholds, the amount where you start paying the highest interest, that has not gone up as it should have done. They haven't increased those and indexed those as they should have done, which is another problem in the way that the loans have actually materialised compared to what we were originally told it would work. But anyway, I digress, as I often do.
23:45 Martin Lewis? So you'd have that money in a savings account so that you could pay off the loan any time if it looked more likely that overpayment would help you and it would mitigate the fact that you're paying some interest. You'd still be, you know, 2.2% down on it, but it wouldn't be that bad. Now let's move into the situation where overpaying is a clear winner. You've done the maths, you're a high earner, or you borrowed a lower amount, you're going to clear within 30 years. This is you're paying interest at 6.2% because you're a higher earner in that bracket. Then you're going, I want to pay this off because I don't want to see the interest accruing. And if you're right, then this could save you a significant amount, overpaying. There are some buts though. Do think about where you are in your financial life path. Are you going to need a mortgage deposit, or to pay
24:29 Martin Lewis? off a mortgage, or other borrowing in future? If so, then unless you have such very substantial funds, that that's all going to be fine too. Overpaying the student loan now may just mean you need to borrow back in future via a different form of lending. And while the interest rate on the student loan may be higher currently than some mortgages, it isn't higher than most personal loans. And it does have the crucial advantage that if something unexpected happened, that your income dropped, or you lost work, or were unable to work, your repayments would drop or stop altogether on the student loan, which would not happen on a commercial loan, nor will they be wiped at some point. So again, if it all seems good for you, then go for it, save yourself some money.
25:15 Martin Lewis? If you're not sure, then putting money into a savings account while you wait and see what happens may be a safer route. So there we go. I hope I have managed to move from the political to the practical. And while these loans, people are feeling they are very expensive at the moment, absolutely, for all the reasons I discussed on Newsnight, the fiscal drag and the cost of living and graduate premium. Ultimately, when you're going to make a decision about the loans, it needs to be done in a clinical, financial way as to what is right for you in the future. And if you do it on an emotional way because of fear over the interest, you could get it wrong. That doesn't mean you shouldn't be fearful. I think the whole way it's presented is psychologically damaging. The way it's designed is psychologically damaging.
26:00 Martin Lewis? Again, I've been saying it for 15 years until I'm blue in the face, but that is the way that the system works. And if you're unhappy about the repayment freeze, as I said in Newsnight, this is something that will work for people to write to their MPs about. Some people have asked me to provide template letters to write to the MPs. Well, I'll be honest with you, the problem with that is if MPs receive a lot of obviously similar letters, they tend to discount it as some form of campaign that's gone on. An individualised letter is a much more effective tool that people see in their mailbags and go, uh-oh, there's something going on here. And I would suggest you write it that way. I hope this has been helpful. I hope I'm allowed to say I have a very detailed step-by-step blog that I've just published on my website for help for people with Plan Two loans, as you can see what's
26:45 Martin Lewis? going on. If you're unsure, that may be helpful on top of the podcast and you can have a read of it. And I think that's probably where I should stop. I could go on and talk about this subject for hours more, but this is meant to be a special mini podcast. Thank you very much for listening.
27:16 Speaker 06 Martin Lewis is the founder of MoneySavingExpert.com. But of course, other consumer and price comparison websites are available. You can get in touch with Martin's podcast production team by emailing [email protected] . The offers and rates mentioned in the podcast are correct at the time of recording. However, if you are listening on demand, it's worth double checking as details can date. Remember to subscribe on BBC Sounds and leave us a review however you listen.
27:52 Speaker 07 Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task, like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or deck right in front of you, and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack.
28:37 Speaker 07 And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategising your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai/solve. That's claude.ai/solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai/solve.
29:07 Speaker 00 Welcome to the haunted library. Join me. Colin Morgan As I Read Frankenstein By Mary Shelley A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human.
29:26 Speaker 00 Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.
Previous New first-time buyer ISA: what happens to the LISA & Help to Buy ISA? Is AI good for consumers? Next Question Time: Best kids’ savings or investments? Pension at 50? Which mortgage to overpay? Snakes, or an angry gorilla? Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated