Pod Insights The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast 507. The Insanity of Woke Psychologists | Lee Jussim About this episode Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with researcher and Rutgers University Professor of Psychology Lee Jessim. They discuss the denial of Left-wing authoritarianism across academia, how Lee’s research proved such authoritarianism exists, the backlash and attempted cancellations he received for his work, and how he not only survived the battle, but also garnered a promotion as a result.
This episode was filmed on December 7th, 2024.
| Links |
For Lee Jussim:
On X https://x.com/PsychRabble?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 16,621 words · 7 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Who answers America's call for more energy? Our people do. Chevron's U.S. energy production has increased by nearly 60% in the past three years.
0:11 Speaker 01 Hi, my name is Aaron and I'm a WealthSite representative at Chevron. I'm proud of the work that I do every day. It gets more American oil out of the ground and it brings America more energy security.
0:22 Speaker 00 Learn more about what our people do at chevron.com/america.
0:30 Speaker 02 Have you heard the news? Balance of Nature's Fiber & Spice Supplement is everything nice. No synthetics, no additives, and no flow agents. Just 100% ingredients of whole food. It isn't just your average fiber supplement. It also has a wide variety of 12 amazing spices. Just two scoops of the Fiber & Spice Supplement stirred into 16 ounces of your favorite drink daily, that's all it takes to get a wide variety of ingredients of real whole food every single day. Here's how Balance of Nature Fiber & Spice Supplement worked for one customer.
1:04 Speaker 03 I have been taking Fiber & Spice for over three years. When I first started taking it, I could smell the cumin and the turmeric and the different spices. I tell all my friends about Balance of Nature.
1:17 Speaker 02 Call now and save 35% on your first order when you subscribe. Use discount code WIRE. Call 1-800-246-8751. That's 1-800-246-8751.
1:30 Speaker 00 Share comfort and enjoy this holiday season at Tacovus. Our boots are handcrafted in over 200 meticulous steps and have a broken-in feel right out of the box with styles for everyone in the family. Our expert staff can help you pick the perfect gifts and we have free in-store gift wrapping to help make the holiday season truly special. See you soon at your local Tacovus store or shop with us anytime at tacovus.com.
2:08 Speaker 04 Así que el podcast de hoy tomó una vuelta hacia la psicológica, que es una mejora sobre la política, en lo que me preocupa, en general. Probablemente porque el tema de la concentración tiene más significancia a largo plazo, en todo caso. Así que, en cualquier caso, hablé hoy con Lee Jussim. Lee es el profesor de psicología destacado en Rutgers, y ha sido el presidente de la Departamento de Psicología y, separadamente, de la Antropología, que es una situación peculiar que discutimos en el podcast. Estaba interesado en el trabajo de Lee porque hay mucho problema en el campo de la psicología social.
2:52 Speaker 04 Muchas de las afirmaciones del campo no son verdaderas. Ahora, hay que esperar a eso en la investigación científica, porque muchas de las cosas que creemos que son falsas, y la razón por la que practicamos como científicos es corregir esas falsificaciones. Y también es el caso de que mucho de lo que se publica no va a ser verdad, porque la alternativa sería que todo lo que se publicó era una descubrimiento que era verdad, y estaríamos abrumados por la novedad tan rápido que sería inútil si eso sucediera. Lee es uno de los raras psicólogos sociales que es realmente un científico. Y ha hecho mucho trabajo interesante y también controversial.
3:37 Speaker 04 Eso es parte de cómo puedes decir que es interesante y válido, porque también es controversial. Una de las cosas que ha establecido, que es de gran importancia, es que nuestras percepciones de otras personas no son principalmente sesgadas. ¿Verdad? The contrary claim is rather preposterous, which is that all of the categories that we use to structure our interactions with other people are based on the power distortion of our perceptions, let's say, which is essentially a Marxist and postmodern claim. And Lee became infamous, at least in part, because he showed that our perceptions, our
4:18 Speaker 04 stereotypes, if you will, are mostly accurate. There are sources of bias, and they do enter into the process, and they're relevant. But that's a very different claim than that the foundations of our perceptions themselves are indistinguishable from the biases we hold as motivated agents. And so, his work is extremely important. It's core to the culture war that is tearing us apart. So, if you're interested in the definition of perception, the relationship between perception and reality, and the analysis of bias in
4:58 Speaker 04 a manner that's credible, then pay attention to this podcast and get things cleared up. So I guess we might as well get right to the point. And the first thing I'm curious about is, and this is something I think that can be like fairly definitively laid at the feet of of social psychologists, was that there was an absolute denial that anything like left-wing authoritarianism existed, even conceptually, literally until 2016. Yeah, that's right. It's like... For 60 years. I came across that and I thought, "What do you mean there's no such thing as left-wing authoritarianism?" We know there's... It's like, that's insane. It's insane. That's absolutely insane. It's insane. And so, and then there were a couple of papers published in 2016 on left-wing authoritarianism
5:43 Speaker 04 in the Soviet Union. That was the first breaking of that damn idea of masters. I supervised a master's thesis at that time. It's a very good thesis on left-wing authoritarianism. And, uh, because we showed that there were statistical clumps of reliably...
6:01 Speaker 04 Characterizable, left-wing authoritarian beliefs that did in fact associate statistically and that identifiable groups of people with identifiable temperamental proclivities did hold.
6:13 Speaker 05 Right.
6:14 Speaker 04 I really wanted to follow up on that because it was very rich, potential source of new information, but my academic career exploded at that point. It became impossible. So.
6:25 Speaker 05 Well, people have taken that ball and run with it.
6:28 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. So, well, tell us about it.
6:30 Speaker 05 What have you found?
6:32 Speaker 04 Well, okay. How do you, let's start with some definitions, like what constitutes left-wing as opposed to right-wing authoritarianism, let's say.
6:39 Speaker 05 Right. So, there are measurement there are measurement issues across the board, but they, that is with respect to both left and right-wing authoritarianism. There are questionnaires, commonly used questionnaires to assess right-wing authoritarianism and to assess left-wing authoritarianism. They're different. Um, the reason, let me give a little context. For a long time, people tried to develop a nonpartisan authoritarianism scales. If authoritarianism
7:22 Speaker 05 was a psychological construct rather than a political one.
7:25 Speaker 04 Right.
7:25 Speaker 05 And they couldn't really do it because one of the core toxic elements of authoritarianism is a motivation to crush, deprive of humanity and human rights one's political opponents. So you need to assess either right or left-wing authoritarianism vis a vis the attitudes towards one's opponents in order to measure the construct.
7:51 Speaker 04 Okay, so that's, okay, that's a very interesting, that's a very interesting definition though, because you're pointing to the fact that.
7:59 Speaker 04 Arguably, and tell me if you think this is right, the core of authoritarianism, which as you said can't be measured outside the political, isn't precisely political. It's your attitude towards those who don't agree with you.
8:12 Speaker 05 Yes, it is.
8:13 Speaker 04 But you have to have some beliefs for that to be...
8:15 Speaker 05 But I didn't say can't. I say they have not succeeded. Actually, one of my current graduate students is, for her master's thesis, in the process of trying to develop a non-partisan authoritarianism scale...
8:27 Speaker 04 Based on that idea?
8:28 Speaker 05 Yes, based on that idea. I don't know if she's gonna succeed, but yes.
8:31 Speaker 04 Okay, so I'm thinking about that clinically. It's like, well, that's where you'd start to look at overlap between Cluster B personality psychopathology, narcissism, borderline personality disorder, histrionic, because those are the people who are very likely to elevate their own status at the cost of other people, including their children, and those they purport to love.
8:56 Speaker 05 So the first step to do that is to develop scales that adequate... survey questions that adequately get at left- or right-wing authoritarianism, and then correlate them with things measuring narcissism, or sadism, or whatever. People have done that on the left, and it does correlate with left-wing authoritarianism. I don't know, you know, you never know for sure the limits of your own knowledge. I don't know if anyone has even tried to do this on the right, or maybe they have, and it doesn't actually correspond with narcissism on the right. You know, it corresponds with other things on the right, but not so much with...
9:37 Speaker 05 If there's evidence on narcissism correlating with right-wing authoritarianism, I don't know it.
9:44 Speaker 04 Nothing at the moment comes to mind. I have a memory of a memory of something associated with that, because I've tried to follow the literature, but I've definitely seen it emerge on the left. Correlations on the right, well, from what I remember...
10:01 Speaker 04 And I'm vague about this because I can't give you sources is that dark tetrad traits stand out quite markedly as associated with authoritarianism. And I thought that was somewhat independent of whether it was left or right. But I can't provide the sources out there.
10:16 Speaker 05 Yeah.
10:17 Speaker 04 I reviewed them in this new book I wrote on We Who Wrestle With God. There's a lot of reference to the dark tetrad personality constellations and its and the political manifestations. But okay, but you've been studying it. Okay, so when we looked at the way we developed our measure, because I'd like to know how you developed yours, is we took we took a very large sample of political opinions and then factor analyzed them to find out if we could identify first clumps of left wing and clumps of right wing belief, which you can clearly identify.
10:48 Speaker 05 Yes.
10:48 Speaker 04 And then to look within the left wing constellation to see if there is a reliable subcategory of clearly authoritarian probabilities. And we found, you know, we found the biggest predictor of left wing authoritarianism was low verbal IQ. It was a walloping predictor, negative point four zero, immense predictor.
11:08 Speaker 05 Yeah.
11:09 Speaker 04 So that's something to, because you know, one of the things we talked about at the beginning of the podcast was that some of these ideas sound good in the absence of further critical evaluation. So then you might say, well, if you lack the capacity for deep verbal critical evaluation, what apparently moral ideas would appeal to you? And well, you can imagine that there might be a set of them and one of them would be, well, don't be mean to people who aren't like you, you know, which is a perfectly good rule of thumb.
11:38 Speaker 05 Yes.
11:39 Speaker 04 But that doesn't mean it's the, it doesn't mean that everyone who says that's what they're for are in fact agitating on behalf of that principle.
11:46 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
11:46 Speaker 04 Okay, so back to your research.
11:48 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, okay. So first was let me be clear. Where other than my student Sonia, who is trying to develop a nonpartisan authoritarianism scale, the work that we have done using either left wing or right wing authoritarianism scales are scales developed by other people. We haven't developed the scales.
12:06 Speaker 04 So for left. And do you think there are good scales now for left and right wing authoritarianism?
12:13 Speaker 04 Adequate scales?
12:14 Speaker 05 Adequate for right, yes, and pretty good for left. Even though left, the research on left is much more recent.
12:23 Speaker 04 Right.
12:23 Speaker 05 You might think it would be therefore less well established. The, there's two teams, one led by Luke Conway and a different one led by Tom Costello, um, have done a lot of very good, both psychometric, the sort of statistical assessment of how things hang together, and also validity assessment of their two slightly different, somewhat different scales.
12:47 Speaker 04 You can tell if someone's belief is part of a set of identifiable beliefs. If they hold that belief, the fact they hold that belief predicts reliably that they hold another belief, right? And then you want to see a pattern like that emerge across a lot of people. Then you see that there are associations of ideas, right? Those would be something like the, the manifestation of an ideology. You want to see if that's identifiable, what its boundaries are, that it can be distinguished from other clumps of ideas, so left could be distinguished from right. This can all be done statistically and very reliably.
13:21 Speaker 05 Yeah.
13:21 Speaker 04 Right. Now, it wasn't done by social psychologists from the end of World War II till 2016, right? Shameful lacuna in the history of political analysis within the psychological community. It shocked me when I first discovered it.
13:36 Speaker 05 Me too, me too.
13:37 Speaker 04 It was shocking.
13:38 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
13:39 Speaker 04 Really?
13:39 Speaker 05 But talk about blind spots.
13:41 Speaker 04 Oh, my God. It's like, oh, do you guys miss Mao and Stalin?
13:45 Speaker 05 Yeah, I know, right.
13:46 Speaker 04 I don't know, how do you miss that? It's like, it's fairly obvious.
13:48 Speaker 05 And then they're denied.
13:49 Speaker 04 You're a social psychologist, the biggest social movements of the 20, the biggest pathological social movements of the 20th century had their existence denied for 70 years.
14:03 Speaker 05 Right.
14:03 Speaker 04 Mind boggling.
14:04 Speaker 05 It's mind boggling.
14:05 Speaker 04 It's mind, it just, I never recovered from discovery.
14:08 Speaker 05 Yes.
14:08 Speaker 04 It took me like a year to even believe it was true. Okay, so you're using other people's questions.
14:13 Speaker 05 Yes.
14:14 Speaker 04 So what's your approach? What are you, how are you investigating this?
14:16 Speaker 05 It does depend on the study. So, so, uh, this is one good one that I think I can describe shortly, uh, quickly. The, the, um, uh, we administered.
14:30 Speaker 05 Cartoons, like political cartoons, as if they were memes, like social media memes, to an online sample, about a thousand people, and ask them how much they liked the cartoons and memes, and which, and we told them
14:52 Speaker 05 to vote for the one, for their favorite, because the one that received the most votes, we would actually post on social media. Now, that was a lie, it was deception, and we explained that at the end. But we wanted them to believe that when they were selecting something, that this was as close as we could get to a behavior. It was close to them posting it. They believed their vote could influence what would be posted.
15:18 Speaker 04 Right, right, so it was a real-world outcome.
15:20 Speaker 05 A real-world quasi behavioral.
15:21 Speaker 04 Of something that would be promoted.
15:22 Speaker 05 Rather than just like liking or disliking.
15:24 Speaker 04 Right, okay. Or self-report that they believed something.
15:27 Speaker 05 That's right. So two of the, I'm going to describe two of the cartoons, which were quite a contrast to each other. We actually had a set, kind of like the first, and a set like the second. But I can describe the two quickly enough.
15:40 Speaker 05 The first was actually a political propaganda cartoon from the Soviet Union. We didn't tell them that. From the 1930s, 1940s, anti-American propaganda. But we didn't tell them that. We just presented the cartoon, which showed a long-distance shot of this, in the top panel was a long-distance shot of the Statue of Liberty. The bottom panel was a close-up of her head and her crown, and the spires of the crown were KKK members. People dressed in KKK whatever.
16:18 Speaker 04 Right, right, right. So the true nature of American liberty.
16:22 Speaker 05 Yeah, American liberty is just...
16:23 Speaker 04 So that's a power, right? It's typical Marxist trope.
16:25 Speaker 05 Yes, right, okay. That was one.
16:27 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:28 Speaker 05 And then this second was an image of a diverse group of people. People, different racial and ethnic groups, wearing clothes for different professions. Someone might be a bus driver, or a businessman, or a secretary, or a teacher, or whatever. A whole bunch of different kinds of people, in obviously different roles, kind of in a crowd with their arms around each other, under an American flag. Sort of pluralistic diversity, that's kind of a humanistic form of diversity. And then we simply ask people, you know, we ask them, which ones do you like the most? Which ones do you want to share on social media? And.
17:10 Speaker 04 So was that a benevolent left view?
17:13 Speaker 05 Yeah, sort of.
17:14 Speaker 04 And then authoritarian left view?
17:16 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly. Right, right. That's right.
17:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
17:18 Speaker 05 Demonizing America versus.
17:20 Speaker 04 We did find in our analysis that there were, there's a liberal left that's, that's clear. And there's a authoritarian left. And the liberal left, this is part of our investigation, the liberal left isn't. Now, did we figure that out? The liberal left doesn't partake of the attitudes of the radical authoritarian left.
17:42 Speaker 05 Yes.
17:42 Speaker 04 But they're the ones that I also think that they're.
17:45 Speaker 05 Sort of oblivious.
17:45 Speaker 04 Denies. Yeah, they're oblivious.
17:47 Speaker 05 Yes, I think that's true. And that is what we found. That's what we found in the study.
17:51 Speaker 04 I got a research idea.
17:52 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
17:53 Speaker 04 That's relevant to this. Well, with regards to these questionnaires, it's something that I wanted to do. You know, the large language models track statistical probability. So you can take those left wing questionnaire sets and you can ask ChatGPT. Here's an item or here's three items, generate 30 more. And it does it.
18:10 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
18:11 Speaker 04 Right. So if you wanted to improve the statistical reliability of the measures. So you can imagine, take the measures that already exist. Put them in clumps of three in ChatGPT, have it expanded out to like 300 items. Administer it to a thousand people and distill it. Because the thing.
18:29 Speaker 05 That's a great idea.
18:30 Speaker 04 This will speed things up radically because the thing about the large language models is they already have the statistical correlations built in. When you ask ChatGPT to generate 40 items that are conceptually like these four, that's what it does.
18:45 Speaker 05 Yeah.
18:45 Speaker 04 It's not an opinion.
18:47 Speaker 05 This is great.
18:47 Speaker 04 So you can use ChatGPT to purify the questionnaires. And you can do that on the left and on the right. And you can, it takes like 10 minutes instead of two years.
18:56 Speaker 05 I'm going to bring this back to Sonya. This is great.
18:58 Speaker 04 So yeah, and tell me.
18:59 Speaker 05 Sonya's a fan of your podcast. She's, I'm sure she's going to see this.
19:02 Speaker 04 Okay.
19:02 Speaker 05 I'll probably talk to her before, but hi Sonya.
19:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, we should be doing this with all the questionnaires, like it's the same. With narcissism, if you put, see, the other thing you could do with ChatGPT is you could say, here's twenty items significant of narcissism, okay? Which is the central item? And can you generate twenty items that are better markers of that central tendency? And the thing is, it can do it because it's mapped the linguistic representations.
19:28 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
19:28 Speaker 04 So all the factor structures already built into the ChatGPT systems, like all of it.
19:33 Speaker 05 That's great.
19:34 Speaker 04 Yeah, so, okay, so, so let, I, this is one of the things I would pursue if I still had a research lab, right? These things are hard to pursue without having that infrastructure in place. But I think this radically
19:47 Speaker 05 Speed up the, yeah, yeah.
19:48 Speaker 04 Radically speed up the process of
19:50 Speaker 05 I totally see that.
19:50 Speaker 04 And also make it much more reliable and valid.
19:53 Speaker 05 Yeah.
19:53 Speaker 04 Right, so.
19:54 Speaker 05 I think that's right.
19:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, okay.
19:56 Speaker 05 Well, we'll have to try it, we'll have to try it.
19:57 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, try it out, try it out, okay.
19:59 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
20:00 Speaker 04 All right, so back to
20:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
20:01 Speaker 04 All right, so now, you've got people voting for one comic or the other.
20:05 Speaker 05 And, and it was exactly as you described before we went down the large language model path, that liberals who are not, so we use statistical regression, we can separate out being liberal but not authoritarian from being a left-wing authoritarian but not liberal.
20:21 Speaker 04 Yeah.
20:22 Speaker 05 Liberalism predicted endorsement of the sort of humanistic diversity image.
20:26 Speaker 04 Right, right.
20:26 Speaker 05 The people together under an American flag, we're all, you know, we're all different, but we're all in it together, we love America, blah, blah, blah. It was left-wing authoritarianism powerfully predicted endorsement of the Soviet propaganda. The, the Statue of Liberty is KKK.
20:41 Speaker 04 And so the questionnaires predicted that?
20:43 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
20:43 Speaker 04 Oh, that's good, that's good.
20:44 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, it was, it was, it's a great study, so.
20:47 Speaker 04 Another thing you might want to do is take that questionnaire, do an item analysis with regards to preference and rank order the items in terms of their predictive validity in relationship to the cartoon because you might be able to see which of the items are central.
21:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
21:02 Speaker 04 Especially if you saw that pattern across multiple cartoons.
21:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
21:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, okay, okay, okay.
21:07 Speaker 05 Yeah, so that's one, that's, yeah, we did this kind of thing.
21:10 Speaker 04 Well, how many studies have you done now on left-wing authoritarianism?
21:13 Speaker 05 Well, it's a lot, I mean, it's a lot, and we include it in almost everything, and we Include measures of left and right wing authoritarianism in most of the studies we've been
21:23 Speaker 04 Right, right, right.
21:24 Speaker 05 So.
21:24 Speaker 04 Well, so, so tell us, tell us what we found.
21:26 Speaker 05 So, the, the, the most recent splash, and I think that's what got your staff member interested in having me on here, were three experimental studies assessing the psychological impacts of common DEI rhetoric and heterosexuality.
21:48 Speaker 04 Right, right.
21:50 Speaker 05 And we did it with three types of, three different kinds of DEI rhetoric.
21:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, those are probably studies that I'd run across of years. I remember that now.
21:59 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's one of the, this is fairly recent, and they've made more of a splash than I would have expected.
22:04 Speaker 04 Well, it's one thing to say that DEI programs work. It's another thing to say they don't work, and it's a completely different thing to say they do the opposite of what, yeah, that's not good, and it seems to me highly probable. You know, suicide prevention programs, the kind the government's always running, they make suicide rates go up. Well, because, why? Well, you're advertising and normalizing suicide. Right. And you think, well, we're going to put up a prevention program. It's like, first, are you clinically trained? Second, did you do the research? Third, did you ever stop to consider that your conceptualization of the problem might be inadequate in relationship to its solution?
22:47 Speaker 05 Yeah.
22:47 Speaker 04 There's so many things like this that happen. Clinicians have become, the research-oriented clinicians have become very, very sensitive to such things, because it's frequently the case that a well-meaning intervention will make things worse.
22:59 Speaker 05 Right.
22:59 Speaker 04 And, and then you might ask why. It's like, well, there's 50,000 ways something could be worse, and like, one way it could be better. And so just, it's an overwhelmingly high probability that whatever you do to change something that works, makes it worse.
23:16 Speaker 05 Yeah.
23:16 Speaker 04 Right. Okay, so now, so do you, what was your evidence that the DEI interventions made, what was made worse, what interventions, and what was your evidence linking them?
23:28 Speaker 05 Yes, okay, so, um, let me walk through.
23:35 Speaker 05 Let me qualify this a little bit.
23:38 Speaker 05 We examined the rhetoric that is common to many DEI interventions.
23:45 Speaker 04 ChatGPT can do a very good job of that, by the way.
23:48 Speaker 05 Kind of. The problem is, a lot of the materials used in DEI trainings aren't publicly available. So it's actually hard, and we can say they're common to things we had access to, but we don't, a lot is not publicly available.
24:04 Speaker 04 Okay, so where do you find it?
24:06 Speaker 05 And that's an important limitation, that your listeners, viewers should understand. It's not like we evaluated the effectiveness of the DEI training program instituted by the HR department of the city of Milwaukee. We didn't do that. We took the intellectual ideas from three different kinds of sources: anti-racism rhetoric, anti-Islamophobia rhetoric, and anti-caste, the Hindu caste system, anti-caste oppression rhetoric. And there are, for race, we used passages from Kendi's "How to Be an Anti-Racist" and from D'Angelo's "White Fragility."
24:49 Speaker 05 These books were widely required for our colleges. You know, there's sometimes, she is paid $40,000 a session to come in and give her training. So and we also actually used this sort of large language model, this sort of language network analysis to examine the extent to which this type of rhetoric was common throughout the training materials we had access to, and it was very common.
25:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, okay, okay, fine. Fine. So you use that as a validation?
25:22 Speaker 05 You know, I have, so just so, I have this here. So let me give an example from, from the race.
25:33 Speaker 05 And this is just a short excerpt. So people would read, so they would read, say, an anti-racist passage or a control passage. The control passage in these studies, in two out of the three, was about how to grow corn on the farm. It was completely separate. And this is only a short excerpt of a longer passage.
25:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, okay.
25:51 Speaker 05 White, this is the anti-racism. White people raised in Western society are conditioned into a white supremacist worldview. Racism is the norm. It is not unusual. This went on for a full paragraph. And it was quotes, smooth together with a little writing by us, of Kendi and D'Angelo.
26:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, okay.
26:12 Speaker 05 All right. So they then were presented with a very brief scenario in which a college admissions officer interviews an applicant, and ultimately, the applicant is rejected from admission.
26:30 Speaker 04 Okay.
26:31 Speaker 05 That's the whole scenario.
26:32 Speaker 04 Yep.
26:32 Speaker 05 I mean, the words are slightly different because I'm doing that piece from memory, but that's basically the whole scenario. They were then asked a series of questions assessing how much perceived racism and bias was
26:47 Speaker 04 Was the causal factor.
26:48 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah. On the part of the admissions officer.
26:50 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
26:51 Speaker 05 Okay. And, and what we found is when they got the Kendi D'Angelo essay, they claimed to have seen or observed the admissions officer committing more microaggressions, treating the applicant more unfairly, and that the admissions officer was more biased.
27:16 Speaker 00 Share comfort and joy this holiday season at Tacovus. Our boots are handcrafted in over 200 meticulous steps and have a broken-in feel right out of the box with styles for everyone in the family. Our expert staff can help you pick the perfect gifts, and we have free in-store gift wrapping to help make the holiday season truly special. See you soon at your local Tacovus store, or shop with us anytime at tacovus.com.
27:41 Speaker 04 Okay, so I'm gonna put on my devil's advocate hat.
27:44 Speaker 05 Yes.
27:45 Speaker 04 And I'm going to play Robin D'Angelo, despite wearing this Trump badge. And I'm gonna say, "Well, the effects of institutional racism are so pervasive that they even invaded your experimental material. And the consequence of being exposed to the contents of my writing, speaking as Robin D'Angelo, was that the scales fell from the eyes of your experimental subjects and they were able to perceive the racism that we claimed was there in a manner they couldn't before."
28:19 Speaker 05 Uh, yes, that is probably what D'Angelo would say. Actually, I can tell you a little bit what Kendi did say, because he was asked about it. He did not say that. If someone said that, I would say, "Well, in our scenario, none of that was evident. You had to read that into the scenario." And that is the point.
28:37 Speaker 04 How do you know that your own implicit bias didn't stop you from seeing the bias that was there?
28:43 Speaker 05 Because anyone can look at the scenario. People didn't even have racial information about the admissions officer and the applicant. So you don't...
28:53 Speaker 04 Okay, so you regarded it as highly improbable that what they were reading into the situ... That what they were... You regarded it as highly probable that they were reading into the situ... Okay, let me ask you a couple more technical questions.
29:06 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
29:08 Speaker 04 How much of this material were they exposed to before they did the evaluation?
29:11 Speaker 05 About a paragraph.
29:12 Speaker 04 Oh, just a paragraph?
29:14 Speaker 05 Just a paragraph.
29:14 Speaker 04 How soon before the evaluation?
29:16 Speaker 05 Pretty soon.
29:17 Speaker 04 Okay, do you have any idea what the lag time? Like, if you did a dose-response study, so to speak?
29:23 Speaker 05 Yeah.
29:24 Speaker 04 Is there a decay? Like, how permanent are the effects? I know I couldn't expect you to do all that in one study, but it's germane, right?
29:32 Speaker 05 Yeah, it... Well, it is... Kind of. So, on the narrow issue of how long do the effects we observed in this study last? We didn't study that.
29:44 Speaker 04 Right.
29:44 Speaker 05 So I have no answer to that.
29:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, of course.
29:46 Speaker 05 Okay.
29:48 Speaker 05 But given that we observed the effects that we did, the sort of people concocting racism where there was no evidence of it, on the basis of a very minor intervention, that's like reading a single paragraph.
30:04 Speaker 04 Right, right.
30:05 Speaker 05 It at least raises the possibility that when people are in a culture or organizational context in which this type of rhetoric is pervasive, that they are constantly being exposed or primed to think about race in these terms. And because of the steady diet of this kind of rhetoric, the effects are likely to be
30:33 Speaker 04 The heightening of racial.
30:34 Speaker 05 More enduring than anything we could possibly observe.
30:37 Speaker 04 Right, right, fair enough. Well, I would also say probably you evaluated some of the weaker systemic effects of that kind of rhetoric, because it isn't merely exposure to the rhetoric, it's the fact that post hoc detection of such things as microaggressions, let's say, are radically rewarded by the participants in those ideological systems.
30:59 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
31:00 Speaker 04 That being even more, that's a more powerful effect. So you got it with weak exposure fundamentally.
31:05 Speaker 05 Yes. And no reward, right? I mean, you're picking to the social reward.
31:09 Speaker 04 Exactly.
31:10 Speaker 05 Yes, yes, yes.
31:11 Speaker 04 So, so I would say, and that's a, that's a, the weakness of your intervention demonstrated the power of the rhetoric. Okay, what did Kendi have to say about this?
31:22 Speaker 05 He described us as racist pseudoscientists.
31:25 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, oh, yeah, okay. Well, that, that pretty much covers the territory. Did he say why? Or was that unnecessary?
31:32 Speaker 05 You know, it, that quote.
31:35 Speaker 04 How are you at wasting money? My sense is that he was particularly good at that, so, yeah, university money, counter productively, yeah.
31:42 Speaker 05 Well, I think most of his was from, actually, what's his name? Jack, uh, Jack Dorsey from Twitter, I think gave him $10 million, so at least it wasn't state money, right?
31:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, right, right, right, okay, well, then, you can just let it go. So, okay, okay.
31:59 Speaker 04 Okay, you said that produced quite a splash.
32:01 Speaker 05 Yes.
32:02 Speaker 04 Including enhanced probability of being on this podcast, for example.
32:06 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
32:06 Speaker 04 So I'd followed your work for a long time before coming across that. So what effect has it had? When was the study published, first of all?
32:15 Speaker 05 Well, so...
32:15 Speaker 04 And is it a sequence? Is it a single study?
32:18 Speaker 05 No, it's three studies. So it's essentially the same structure for an anti-Islamophobia intervention and an anti-caste oppression. And it's essentially the same results. There's little minor differences. But it's essentially the same pattern of results. They're not published. So these studies I conducted in collaboration with the N C R I. N C R I is the Network Contagion Research Institute. They are a freestanding research institute that main... Started out mostly doing research along the lines of this sort of large language model stuff that you were talking about earlier. Analysis of social media and analysis of
33:01 Speaker 05 radicalism, conspiracy theories, hate, sort of groups and individuals mobilizing online. And they've done it with all sorts of stuff. They've done it with COVID conspiracies. They've done it with QAnon. They've done it with Islamophobia. They've done it with anti-Hindu hate. They've done it with anti-Semitism. They were the first group of any kind, as far as I know, in the summer of 2020, the height of the George Floyd social justice protests, which, as you remember, the rhetoric on the left is consistent with what you were talking about earlier, about how the left is... The reasonable left is in complete denial of the far left.
33:44 Speaker 05 It is literally true that most of the protests were peaceful.
33:50 Speaker 05 Whenever someone would present evidence of some protests not being peaceful at all, like firebombing a police station, or capturing downtown Seattle, or all sorts of, you know, setting, by creating, sort of, setting the stage for lawlessness, you would have looting and robberies that weren't really part of the protests, but people were taking advantage of the sort of police-free zones and stuff. When you would talk about that, the response was, "This is all just..."
34:22 Speaker 04 Right, right. Oh, yeah, I talked to moderate Democrats who told me that Antifa was a figment of the right-wing imagination.
34:31 Speaker 05 Yes, right.
34:31 Speaker 04 I thought, but you know, there's something weird about that that's very much worth pointing out, is, I believe, is that we radically underestimate the effect a very small minority of people who are organized can have in destabilizing a society.
34:47 Speaker 05 That's right.
34:48 Speaker 04 So, for example, in the flux of the aftermath of World War I, Russia was chaotic enough so that a very small minority of people, that would be the Bolsheviks, destabilized and captured the entire country. So even if the true radicals on the left are 3%, say, "Well, 97% of them are peaceful", it's like, "Fair enough, but you're..."
35:14 Speaker 05 Yes.
35:15 Speaker 04 "You're suffering from the delusion that a demented minority is harmless."
35:19 Speaker 05 Yes, that's right.
35:20 Speaker 04 And that's seriously wrong.
35:22 Speaker 05 Okay, so this, enter the NCRI. So, in summer of 2020, when this was all the record, most of the protests are peaceful, complete denial, mainstream media that there was violence and bombings and all sorts of other stuff, the NCRI, this is the first project I did with them, produces an analysis finding that the far-left groups, not conventional liberals or Democrats, but these far-left radical groups...
36:01 Speaker 05 Were exploiting the earnest commitment to anti-racism or the social justice on the part of people justifiably upset about George Floyd's murder and the implications about that for racism beyond that. But these far-left groups were exploiting that to both gin up supporters and to mobilize online. This is all occurring on social media to capture protests, to ratchet up and inspire more aggressive violence at the protests.
36:39 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's exactly what you'd expect. Of course, that's going to happen.
36:43 Speaker 05 I know, right?
36:44 Speaker 04 Clearly, if you believe in criminals.
36:46 Speaker 05 Right, right. Okay. So, and then, so, and NCRI would, in this report, would then link the increased online activity, you know, there would be memes like "ACAB, all cops are bastards," you know, so there'd be things like that. And some of the groups were actually using social media to coordinate their, you know, this sort of violent protest activities. So, live, I'm making this up, but it was this kind of thing. People would be, you know, at these protests on their phones. They would get instructions from a central, some sort of central place, that the cops
37:31 Speaker 05 were over here, so everybody needs to go over there. And that's how they would have, so they were getting tactical instructions live via social media, in addition to sort of ginning up the rhetoric to garner support and adherence. Okay. So, before they brought me on, maybe two or three months before, the NCRI had posted a report on how far-right groups do essentially the same thing, you know, sort of mobilize online, using memes and catchphrases and, you know, garner adherence, you know, gain adherence and stuff. So, they bring me on, we do this thing, and this paper on the far-left, which really
38:15 Speaker 05 looks to me, it looked to me like the far-left groups... Were seeking to ignite an actual revolution.
38:24 Speaker 04 Well, that is what they do.
38:25 Speaker 05 I know, right? Yes, this doesn't seem farfetched, right?
38:28 Speaker 04 They can dance in the ashes that way.
38:30 Speaker 05 Right, yes.
38:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, the real criminal psychopaths, the short-term guys, the narcissists, they thrive in chaos.
38:37 Speaker 05 Yeah.
38:38 Speaker 04 Because their niche is chaos.
38:42 Speaker 05 Yeah, it was, yes. So I was kind of new to that at the time, but in hindsight, yes, absolutely.
38:48 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, it's a shocking thing to know.
38:51 Speaker 05 The N C R I, to no credit to me, I'm an academic, I'm a professor, I don't do this kind of thing, had access to journalists that I, at the New York Times and Washington Post, who ran stories on this report. And it was the first time there was any acknowledgement in the mainstream media that there was any level of violence and danger in the protests. I felt really good about it. This was like September 2002. We did the work over the summer, the thing came. But what, but that report is not published in a peer-reviewed journal. N C R I has its own website. And they publish these reports, kind of like old time.
39:33 Speaker 04 And that's where your studies were, were what?
39:35 Speaker 05 Yes and no. So as of right now, that's where they are. They're available on the N C R I website.
39:40 Speaker 04 Okay, and who did that? Was it postdoc, a doctoral student?
39:44 Speaker 05 But it was a bunch of all, it was, so it was me, two of my grad students. Although one of my, both of my grad students also work closely with the N C R I.
39:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
39:55 Speaker 05 And then there were a series of analysts at the N C R I, including their head researcher.
39:59 Speaker 04 Okay.
39:59 Speaker 05 So a bunch of us are co-authors on this. We have this, so I've not been working with them for several years. And it took a while for us to get used to each other. You know, their strength is this online, social media, large language model, topic network stuff. You know, with an eye towards threats and conspiracy theories and hate. And my strength is conventional social science.
40:22 Speaker 04 That's a nice overlap.
40:23 Speaker 05 It is.
40:24 Speaker 04 It's a nice overlap.
40:25 Speaker 05 We needed to figure out the best synergies.
40:27 Speaker 04 No doubt.
40:27 Speaker 05 It took a while, but we have this rhythm.
40:30 Speaker 04 So why, why that approach with regards to the dissemination of this information, this particular experimental information, rather than the more standard journal approach?
40:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, so, so one of the things, first is, let me give context. A little more, little more context. So our rhythm is first we post stuff as a, essentially as a white paper, as a report on the NCRI site. It gets some attention, some public vetting, we get some feedback on it, and then we scale it up for peer review.
40:57 Speaker 04 Well, that's not unlike doing a pre-release on a, in a convention.
41:02 Speaker 05 Yes, okay. Now, it's a little different. It's different, it is like, it's, I have taken to calling it a homespun pre-print. And here is why I call it a homespun pre-print. It's like a pre-print in that it's a report of empirical studies that is posted online that haven't been peer reviewed.
41:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
41:21 Speaker 05 It is unlike a conventional pre-print in that it is perp, and this is the answer to your question, why did we do it this way rather than made for peer review? This is part of the answer. It is, even though some of it is highly technical, a lot of the worst of the technical stuff is stripped down so that it is comprehensible to the lay intelligent audience. And, and that has a value in and of its own right because the problem with peer review is that it could ease, well, there are many problems with peer review, especially now. You're right, there's many, yeah, right, okay. But one of them is that it could take a year, a few years.
42:01 Speaker 04 Oh, no, lagged public.
42:02 Speaker 05 Right. It's horrible.
42:03 Speaker 04 It's, it's unforgivable.
42:06 Speaker 05 Yeah, that's right.
42:07 Speaker 04 It needs to be, that whole system, I've been thinking.
42:10 Speaker 05 Needs to be upended.
42:11 Speaker 04 Completely. It's like, in this day and age, a two-year lagged publication is, it's completely insane.
42:19 Speaker 05 It's crazy, that's right.
42:20 Speaker 04 You spend 30% of your time writing grant applications that go nowhere, and two years to lag to publication that almost no one is likely to read.
42:28 Speaker 05 That's right.
42:29 Speaker 04 Yeah, not good. How the hell have you not been canceled? Why is that? Because it's weird.
42:36 Speaker 05 There have been repeat attempts to cancel me that have failed.
42:40 Speaker 04 Okay, well, so why don't you tell me and everybody else, first of all, why you're, what would you say, why you so richly deserve canceling? That's the first, that's the first issue. And then the next issue, which is of equal importance, is how you've managed to not have that happen, because that's actually really hard. So, because if people try to cancel you, especially given the things that you've researched and have insisted upon and said, if people try to cancel you, there's an overwhelming probability in academia in particular, that that will be successful. So, let's start by talking about the sorts of things that you've been pointing to in,
43:24 Speaker 04 well, in academia in general, and then more specifically in psychology and social psychology.
43:30 Speaker 05 Sure. There are probably too many of these attempts for me to go through, so I'm going to pick one.
43:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, pick the cream of the crop.
43:38 Speaker 05 Yeah, this is probably the cream of the crop.
43:40 Speaker 04 Okay.
43:42 Speaker 05 It is, I refer to, so I have a very active Substack site, Unsafe Science, and I have several posts on this. You can find it under the POPS Fiasco Racist Mule Trop. There's a whole series on this. Okay, so what is POPS? POPS is Perspectives on Psych Science, one of the very prestigious journals within the field of psychology for publishing reviews and commentaries and the like. The short version is that I was invited by the editor to do a commentary on a main
44:25 Speaker 05 paper that was critical, the main paper by a psychologist named Homel, Bernard Homel,
44:34 Speaker 05 was critical of prior work in psychology advocating for diversity in a variety of ways.
44:43 Speaker 05 The nature of his critique was that much of the rhetoric in psychological scholarship around diversity was narrowly focused on, and the terms are constantly changing, underrepresented minority, minoritized, disadvantaged, oppressed groups. And that, from a scientific--
45:06 Speaker 04 Intersectionally--
45:09 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, right, exactly, that's right. And so--
45:12 Speaker 04 Intersectionally deprived.
45:14 Speaker 05 And there was a recent article which argued that on scientific grounds, we need to do exactly that. Hummel's critique was that, was really multiple, but two of his key points were that, well, there are some types of things, it's irrelevant, diversity is irrelevant for certain kind of theoretical scientific tests. And then the other point is that if diversity matters, it matters for scientific purposes, it matters extremely broadly, and it's not restricted to underrepresented groups. And a very simple example would be if you would compare a study based on undergraduate psychology students versus one based on a nationally representative sample, the research
45:56 Speaker 05 based on the nationally representative sample is going to be broader, more generalizable, and more credible. A nationally representative sample represents the population. It's not focused entirely on any subset of the population. That would be a very simple example of Hummel's point. I was asked to do a commentary. I did.
46:17 Speaker 04 And there's, okay, there's a distinction there, too, that we should draw. Clearly, it's the case that if you want to draw generalizable conclusions about human beings from a study, that the study participants should be a randomly selected and representative sample of the population to whom you're attempting to generalize, obviously, because otherwise it doesn't generalize. That's very different than making the case that underrepresented groups should be preferentially hired, or employed, or promoted, or--
46:50 Speaker 05 Completely different. Yes, completely different, completely different. That was sort of part of Hummel's critique.
46:56 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
46:57 Speaker 05 But I guess, so again, the editor invited me to publish a commentary on this exchange, and-- The title of my commentary was, is, it eventually got published, is "Diversity is Diverse." Because there's lots of different kinds of diversity. And if we're arguing for diversity on scientific grounds, then what the science needs to be is fully representative of the, whether it's the participants, or the topics, or it goes way beyond oppression. I mean, oppression is a part of that, and shouldn't be excluded, but it's only one piece of that. So I basically was in agreement with Hamel's critique and augmented it.
47:41 Speaker 05 As part of that, I critiqued progressive academic rhetoric around diversity as disingenuous and hypocritical. And the way I framed that, the way I captured it, was using a quote from "Fiddler on the Roof." So in "Fiddler on the Roof," which is what early 20th century Jewish life in the...
48:06 Speaker 04 One of the great movies of all time, everyone should watch it.
48:11 Speaker 05 Probably its most famous song is "Tradition," which is about the importance of tradition and keeping the community together. But then there were exceptions. So there's an interlude in the song "Tradition" where the, whatever, the villagers get into an argument, because one chimes in, "There was a time he sold him a horse, but delivered a mule." And I use that to frame my discussion of progressive disingenuousness.
48:42 Speaker 04 They all disintegrate into fractions, arguing in the middle of this song about unity to when that comes up.
48:49 Speaker 05 When that comes up, that's right. And I argued in this paper that the way, and the reason that's a good metaphor for progressive rhetoric around diversity, is that diversity sound, you know, superficially, it sounds good to a lot of people, right? Because who doesn't want to be included? No matter what group you're a member of, the idea that someone is advocating for diversity, you, you know, it's kind of appealing. And so, for example...
49:17 Speaker 04 Yes, with two seconds of thought, it's a positive thing.
49:20 Speaker 05 Yes, with two seconds of thought, it's a positive thing.
49:22 Speaker 04 Or that people should be free of... Arbitrary exclusion.
49:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, of arbitrary exclusion. That's right. That's right. And for example, one thing you might one might think if one had a little bit of knowledge is that, especially in the social sciences and humanities, but really in academia writ large, there's hardly anyone who is not left of center. I mean, the range goes from sort of center-left to the far, far left. I have a former-
49:48 Speaker 04 And that's very well documented.
49:49 Speaker 05 It's very, I have-
49:50 Speaker 04 No one disagrees with that claim.
49:53 Speaker 05 Well, so Nate Honeycutt, my former student, he's now a research scientist at FIRE, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, did a dissertation on this. Surveyed almost 2,000 faculty nationwide at the top colleges and universities. And found that 40% self-identified, not just as on the left, not on the left was about 90, 95%, but 40% self-identified as radicals, activists, Marxists, or socialists.
50:27 Speaker 04 Yep.
50:27 Speaker 05 40%. This is the extreme left. This is no longer just like Democrats or liberals. This is nearly half on the far left.
50:37 Speaker 04 And that was a sample of how many people?
50:38 Speaker 05 It was almost 2,000. Yeah.
50:41 Speaker 04 Now, how many faculty members at colleges and universities do you suppose there are in the United States approximately? Do you have any idea?
50:50 Speaker 05 I have looked into this. It's hundreds of thousands. I don't know the number.
50:54 Speaker 04 Okay, so let's say-
50:55 Speaker 05 I don't remember. I have looked into it. It's very large.
50:57 Speaker 04 200,000. So that means there's 80,000 academic activists who are being employed full-time in the United States.
51:04 Speaker 05 I don't know if you could go that far, because he looked at the top colleges and universities. If you wanted to generalize to all colleges and universities, you would have to include community colleges and, you know, primarily liberalized teachers.
51:16 Speaker 04 Do you think they'd be less?
51:20 Speaker 05 I don't know.
51:21 Speaker 04 Bias? Okay, we don't know.
51:22 Speaker 05 I don't know.
51:23 Speaker 04 Okay, so it's not eighty thousand, but it could easily be fifty thousand.
51:26 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
51:28 Speaker 04 Okay, so that's a number I want to return to. Okay, okay. Yeah, because there's implications.
51:33 Speaker 05 So one might think, for if someone is advocating for diversity, given the extreme political skew, and given the extent to which academia deals with politicized topics, that there would be an embrace of people, an attempt to bring into academia, professors, researchers, scholars, teachers, from across the political spectrum. That has never gotten any traction in academia, and in fact, it's gone in the complete opposite direction. If you go back fifty, sixty years, I think it's fair to describe the way academia has functioned is to produce a slow-moving purge of conservatives and even people-centered and libertarians from its ranks. So, my point in this commentary was using things like that as examples
52:18 Speaker 05 of the disingenuousness of progressive rhetoric around diversity, that it wasn't really diversity in the broadest sense. It was a very narrow...
52:28 Speaker 04 See, that's actually the fundamental flaw of intersectionality, is intersectionality devolves into combinatorial explosion, almost immediately, right? Because, once you start combining the categories of oppression, you don't have to make, your list of combinations, black, women, gay, etc. Every time you add another variable to that multiplicative list, you decrease the pool of people that occupy that list radically, right?
52:59 Speaker 05 Right.
52:59 Speaker 04 But there's also an infinite, there's literally an indefinite, this is your point, an indefinite number of potentially relevant group categories.
53:09 Speaker 05 Yes.
53:09 Speaker 04 So, how in the world are you going to ensure that every possible combination of every possible group category is... You can't even measure it, much less ensure it.
53:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, you can't do that.
53:21 Speaker 04 Right, so there's this underlying insistence, which you're pointing to, I believe, that there are privileged categories of oppressed people, right?
53:30 Speaker 04 And it's a weird thing, right? It's like, why is it that it's race and sex? And you might think, well, those are the most obvious differences between people. And maybe you could make that case. But then it's also gender, which is a very weird insistence. Because whether the idea of gender is valid. I don't think the idea of gender is a valid idea at all. I think it's super. It's, what would you say? It's a warped, misconceptualization of everything that's captured by temperament much more accurately and precisely. We could talk about that. But also sexual orientation. I can't see at all why that would emerge as a privileged category of oppression alongside something like sex. Like, it could, but it's not obvious why.
54:14 Speaker 04 Okay, so you're pointing some of it. And then you said, well, there's important elements of diversity.
54:19 Speaker 05 Yes.
54:19 Speaker 04 Especially intellectually.
54:21 Speaker 05 That's right.
54:24 Speaker 04 Adequate distribution of political or ethical views across the spectrum. That's completely off the table.
54:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's completely off the table. It's like rejected. It's worse than off the table. So, so that was my paper. And there's more to the story than this. But to keep this succinct. Eventually, what happened was almost 1,400 academics, probably mostly psychologists, signed an open letter denouncing. So my paper was one of several commentaries. All of the commentaries were critical of this oppression framing of diversity.
55:10 Speaker 04 All of them?
55:10 Speaker 05 All of them were.
55:11 Speaker 04 And this was in POPS?
55:13 Speaker 05 It was in, yeah, Perspectives on Psych Science.
55:15 Speaker 04 Okay, so I just want to provide people some background on this. And correct me if I get any of this wrong. So. Scientists publish in research journals and they generally publish articles of two types. One type would be a research study, an actual experiment, let's say, or a sequence of experiments. And the other, I guess there's two other types. There's reviews and there's commentaries. And so, and then there's a variety of different journals that scientists publish in. And some of those cover all scientific topics, science and nature. The world's premier scientific journals used to do that before they became woke institutions. And then there are specialized journals that cover fields like psychology.
55:59 Speaker 04 And then there are subspecialized journals. And the less specialized the journal, all things considered, the more prestigious it is. Anyways, that's where scientists publish. And they do publish commentaries on each other's material, especially if it's a review of something contentious or something that's emerging in a field. And now, this journal, Perspectives on Psychological Science, there's also an interesting backstory here because that's an American Psychological Society journal.
56:28 Speaker 05 Yes.
56:29 Speaker 04 Okay, so there's two major organizations for psychologists in, especially research-oriented psychologists in North America. There's the American Psychological Association, which has its journals. And then a newer organization, which is now a couple of decades old, American Psychological Society. And the American Psychological Society was actually set up, at least in part, because the American Psychological Association had started to become ideologically dominated, particularly in the leftist and progressive direction. And that that was having a arguably negative effect on research, reliability, accuracy, and probability of publication. That was set up 25...
57:13 Speaker 05 Okay, so that's a little off kilter.
57:14 Speaker 04 Okay, okay.
57:15 Speaker 05 Yes, I do know this history.
57:16 Speaker 04 Okay, okay.
57:17 Speaker 05 First place, APS started out as the American Psychological Society. They changed their name to the Association for Psychological Science. In an attempt to be broader. And what triggered the breakaway of APS from APA?
57:36 Speaker 05 In the 90s, maybe?
57:37 Speaker 04 90s, yeah, I think so.
57:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, it wasn't political. It was the scientists who formed APS believed that APA was too focused on clinical practice and practitioner issues.
57:52 Speaker 04 Right.
57:52 Speaker 05 And it was becoming unscientific, but not because of the politics.
57:56 Speaker 04 Well, okay, so, yeah, yeah, yeah. Fair enough. But, see, I was watching that happen because I knew some of the people who were setting up the APS at the time. And my sense, though, also, was that part of the reason that the APA was tilting in a more and more clinical direction was because there was an underlying political ethos that was increasingly skeptical of science as the privileged mode of obtaining valid information.
58:24 Speaker 05 Yeah, I think that's fair. I think that's fair, yes, yes.
58:26 Speaker 04 Okay, so the proximal cause was the overemphasis on the clinical.
58:32 Speaker 05 Yes.
58:32 Speaker 04 But, you know, it's also the case that, as you've seen, is that certainly, the clinical psychology has, and the whole therapeutic enterprise, has taken a cataclysmic turn towards the woke direction in the last, especially in the last 10 years.
58:48 Speaker 05 Yeah.
58:48 Speaker 04 It's been absolutely devastating. And, I don't know, is social psychology, I think you could probably say the same thing about social psychology. Maybe you can say, maybe that's even worse. Anyways, we'll get into that.
59:00 Speaker 05 Well, it's probably worse politically, but it's probably not worse practically because social psychologists don't really, aren't responsible for helping anybody get on with their lives. I mean, they're responsible for teaching and students and things. They're not, typically, they're not.
59:13 Speaker 04 They are responsible for implicit bias.
59:16 Speaker 05 That's all we can, you're gonna get me, you are gonna get me distracted. You started by asking me to tell the story of my transition to TAN.
59:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, let's continue with that.
59:23 Speaker 05 Yes, that's it.
59:24 Speaker 04 Okay, so now you're, there's 1,400 people who write a letter.
59:28 Speaker 05 Yes, declaring all of us, me, as well as the other commentators, we're all racists.
59:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
59:37 Speaker 05 The editor should be fired, and our articles should be taken down. They shouldn't, they shouldn't be published.
59:41 Speaker 04 Right, so I presume that these 1,400 are a subset of the 50,000 activists that are now, right now. I'm curious about the 1,400, too, because you often see legacy media headline news that 1,400 scientists have signed some petition or other. But then, when you look into it, you know, it's often... I know the distinction between graduate student and let's say full-fledged scientist is
1:00:07 Speaker 05 fuzzy.
1:00:07 Speaker 04 murky.
1:00:08 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:00:08 Speaker 04 But part of the issue is always, well, exactly who were these 1,400 people, right? And out from under which rocks did they climb? And so who were the 1,400? Like roughly speaking, who were these people?
1:00:21 Speaker 05 So there were 1,400. I mean, I didn't recognize many of the names.
1:00:24 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:00:25 Speaker 05 But if you assume the first five or 10 names are the likely organizers, those were all well-established psychologists, especially social psychologists.
1:00:35 Speaker 04 Okay, social, okay.
1:00:36 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:00:36 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:00:36 Speaker 05 Yeah, there were social psychologists.
1:00:37 Speaker 04 So you got a backlash from?
1:00:39 Speaker 05 Huge backlash. And part of the accusation for me in particular was that by using this line from Fiddler on the Roof, there was the time he sold him a horse but delivered a mule, as a frame for progressive disingenuousness around diversity, I was comparing black people to mules.
1:00:59 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I see. I see.
1:01:01 Speaker 05 And so that drove.
1:01:03 Speaker 04 That was your subtext, was it?
1:01:04 Speaker 05 Yeah, I was explicit in part of the denunciation.
1:01:08 Speaker 04 Right, right.
1:01:08 Speaker 05 And so this is an immediate firestorm.
1:01:13 Speaker 04 This was when? What year did this happen?
1:01:16 Speaker 05 2022.
1:01:18 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
1:01:18 Speaker 05 2022.
1:01:19 Speaker 04 So this is very new.
1:01:19 Speaker 05 There is actually, part of this backstory is very interesting. The editor of the journal at the time is a European psychologist named Klaus Fiedler. Klaus Fiedler is very accomplished. He's an unbelievably honored, hundreds of journal articles, multiple editorships and awards. He was the editor overseeing all this. And my and the other commentaries that he eventually accepted started out as simple reviews. So when Hamel submitted his paper, it was subjected to peer review. I was one of the peer reviewers.
1:01:57 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah.
1:01:57 Speaker 05 So was one of the other. Fiedler so liked the reviews that he asked all of us to scale them up to full-length articles.
1:02:06 Speaker 06 There are a few things I love more than Good Ranchers, but there are not many. I'll tell you that. It might, I think it might make it on the top five of all things in the world. It's just the best quality meat at the very best price from the very best people. Meanwhile, you go to the grocery store, you ever ask yourself, hey, where was this meat raised? Because American beef on the package does not necessarily mean everything that that company sells is American. Good Ranchers makes it very simple. Every cut they sell is labeled, born, raised, and harvested in the USA. They partner with more than 100 local American farms and ranchers to deliver 100% American meat straight to your door. Beef, chicken, pork, even seafood, you know what you are feeding your family, you know
1:02:49 Speaker 06 where it came from, you're supporting American farmers and ranchers producing it. And I love supporting Americans and I love a good price. For me, though, it all comes down to the quality. The Good Ranchers quality is just next level on certainly all the beef. Even, I'm not a huge chicken guy, the chicken is like the best chicken you're gonna get, whether we're talking about the chicken breasts, whether we're talking about the CDO free chicken nuggets, it's all just magnificent. The people are great, too. Start a plan at GoodRanchers.com/wire, get 50 bucks off plus free meat with every order. You can build your own box, starting as low as under 29 bucks. That's GoodRanchers.com/wire, 50 bucks off plus free meat with every order. GoodRanchers.com/wire. GoodRanchers.com, American meat, delivered.
1:03:32 Speaker 04 Scientists publish their research findings and their reviews of the literature in scientific journals, and it's one of the ways that the quality of these articles is vetted is by submitting the manuscripts before they're published to, well, first of all, the editor reviews them to see if they're even vaguely possibly suitable for publication in that particular journal on the basis of, let's say, topic and quality and apparent integrity of research. Then they're sent out to experts in that area, multiple experts.
1:04:10 Speaker 04 For analysis, and that's part of the quality control process. And that's worked, that worked pretty well up until about 2015, I would say, or maybe even spectacularly well, all things considered. So that's the peer review process. And what's, what happened in this case was the reviews of this, the peer reviews of this particular article were of sufficient quality so that the editor decided that they might-
1:04:36 Speaker 05 It turned into commentary.
1:04:37 Speaker 04 Right, they might turn into standalone pieces with some development.
1:04:41 Speaker 05 But I warned Fiedler, the editor, in my review, before anyone had the idea that a version of my review would get published, that if he accepted Homel's critique of the way in which psychologists write and think about diversity, what they've been advocating with respect to diversity, that he would be at heightened risk of people coming after him, demanding the papers be retracted, and coming after his job. This is in my review. And Jordan, that is- Exactly.
1:05:10 Speaker 04 Was that part of, was that included when it was published? Or was that-
1:05:14 Speaker 05 I don't remember. I'd have to go by, I don't, I think I may have taken it out because it wasn't really appropriate because the commentary wasn't, um, it was about the exchange, it wasn't the message to the editor.
1:05:26 Speaker 04 No, fine, I mean, it's not necessarily the case that it would stick.
1:05:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, so, so, Firestorm, APS, the like executive director committee of APS, whatever that group is, of committee, put an immediate kibosh on this, the, the, it was going to be all published as a, as a discussion forum. That's how Fiedler framed it, as a discussion forum about diversity issues. They put, they, immediate halt.
1:05:57 Speaker 04 Okay, who's "they"?
1:05:58 Speaker 05 It's, it's, I get, the, the officers of the American, of the Association for Psychological Studies.
1:06:04 Speaker 04 Okay, so now they're broadly overseeing the group of journals that publish under their agents?
1:06:10 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:06:11 Speaker 04 Okay, but they generally don't have an editorial say?
1:06:14 Speaker 05 No, they don't.
1:06:15 Speaker 04 And shouldn't?
1:06:15 Speaker 05 And shouldn't, right. But the editor is, to some extent, beholden, I mean, that's who he's working for. So the-
1:06:24 Speaker 04 Right, but it's still the case that generally they don't do such things.
1:06:27 Speaker 05 Yeah, they don't do this, right.
1:06:28 Speaker 04 Right, partly because often-
1:06:31 Speaker 04 Well, they don't have the specialized expertise, at least in part, which is partly why they hire the editors to begin with, who then they give pretty much carte blanche.
1:06:39 Speaker 05 Yes, right.
1:06:40 Speaker 04 As they should, because that's part of academic freedom.
1:06:43 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:06:43 Speaker 04 Right.
1:06:44 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:06:44 Speaker 04 Okay, but they decided that they're not going to proceed with the publication?
1:06:47 Speaker 05 Well, or... So, the open letter had two main demands. They won't even work out their demands. That Fiedler be fired and the papers be retracted.
1:06:58 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:06:59 Speaker 05 They conducted what looked to me, and really to all of us involved, like a kangaroo court, you know, into what happened. They concluded that Fiedler had somehow violated editorial ethics and norms and...
1:07:17 Speaker 04 Which is a serious accusation.
1:07:19 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:07:19 Speaker 04 Like a career-ending accusation, if it's true.
1:07:22 Speaker 05 Yes. Well, he's had a very nice career since, so it did not succeed.
1:07:27 Speaker 04 Well, that's good, but that doesn't detract from the seriousness of the allegation. The fact that he was able to successfully wend his way through the thicket.
1:07:38 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly, that's right. So, he was ousted almost immediately. And then, the papers, mine included, that were part of Fiedler's discussion forum...
1:07:48 Speaker 04 And that had been published.
1:07:50 Speaker 05 They had been accepted but not published.
1:07:51 Speaker 04 I see, okay, okay.
1:07:52 Speaker 05 Accepted but not published, that's right.
1:07:54 Speaker 04 So, how the hell did the complainants get access to the papers? Like, how did they know what the papers were if they hadn't been published?
1:08:02 Speaker 05 Someone must have, you know, maybe through the... The editorial process is largely online, so I'm sure they could have accessed the papers through the online editorial process. I'm sure they could have asked Fiedler for the papers. Had they asked us for the papers, I would have...
1:08:17 Speaker 04 Well, they wouldn't be a secret. They weren't secret.
1:08:19 Speaker 05 Yeah, they weren't secret.
1:08:20 Speaker 04 I mean, people want... They're publishing their papers so that people can read them. I was just curious, because it's strange that a brouhaha of that sort would emerge prior to publication. But, there was quasi-publication.
1:08:32 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, it was, right, exactly. It was accepted but not published.
1:08:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, okay, got it, got it.
1:08:36 Speaker 05 So, they ousted him almost immediately. And then, the papers, they brought in two special editors to figure out what to do with the papers accepted as part of the discussion forum. And
1:08:50 Speaker 04 And who were these special editors and what made them special?
1:08:53 Speaker 05 Well, there was Samin Vazir and E.J. Wagenmachers. And both of them, I think Samin is now the head editor at Psychological Science. So they both have had long careers advocating with some success for upgrading the quality and credibility and rigor of psychological science. They both have made important contributions that way.
1:09:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
1:09:19 Speaker 05 And so I think that's why they were brought in. They had a certain cachet as able to figure out what to do. I think that's what the APS directory believed.
1:09:29 Speaker 04 On what grounds do you think this investigation was justified? How was the progression of this investigation justified? I mean, there's no, there's no established precedent in the scientific community for reevaluating an editorial decision based on political objection, right? Like, there's no, will reevaluate if 500 people sign a petition? Like, this isn't the domain of rule or principle or tradition, right? So, so, so it's, what, what's the fear here, do you think? These 1,400 people signed this petition, which is something that takes like two seconds and costs you nothing and has no risk to you whatsoever.
1:10:11 Speaker 04 And so it's not an ethical statement of any profundity unless you're an activist. So what was it, do you think, that raised people's hackles about the mere fact that these complaints had been raised?
1:10:24 Speaker 05 To this second, I don't really know. Like, from their perspective.
1:10:27 Speaker 04 Are you willing to speculate?
1:10:28 Speaker 05 Well, so, sure. The, um, the main object of Hummel's critique was a
1:10:44 Speaker 05 Black or biracial social psychologist at Stanford, Stephen Roberts. And Roberts denounced the whole process as racist publicly.
1:10:58 Speaker 04 Okay, okay.
1:10:59 Speaker 05 Publicly. And I do think that-
1:11:03 Speaker 04 On what grounds? The mere fact of questioning the diversity agenda-
1:11:08 Speaker 05 Well, I would say-
1:11:10 Speaker 04 Constitutes racism.
1:11:11 Speaker 05 He probably had three main grounds.
1:11:13 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:11:13 Speaker 05 That was one of them, absolutely. You know, you criticize this. This shows-
1:11:18 Speaker 04 That you're racist.
1:11:19 Speaker 05 The racism inside that is pervasive throughout psychology.
1:11:22 Speaker 04 Right.
1:11:22 Speaker 05 That would be one grounds. Second ground was my use of this, me comparing blacks to mules. With, you know, there was the time he sold a horse and delivered a mule. And then the third was, there was a considerable, so Fiedler offered-
1:11:37 Speaker 04 Kind of missing the point of that.
1:11:39 Speaker 05 I know, yeah, right. Fiedler offered Roberts the opportunity to respond to the full set of papers, which were supporting, were generally supporting Homel's critique, which was really about diversity in general, but its jumping off point was a prior paper by Roberts.
1:11:59 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:11:59 Speaker 05 So, but it gave Roberts a chance to reply to the critiques. But that, there was a considerable back and forth between Roberts and Fiedler about whether, when, and how to publish Roberts' response.
1:12:16 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:12:17 Speaker 05 Fiedler was probably kind of a pain in the ass. But in my experience, editors, I don't know how many times, I don't have enough fingers and toes to count the number of times I have subjectively experienced editors' comments as pains in the ass. But.
1:12:35 Speaker 04 One, at least once per paper submitted.
1:12:38 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, yeah, right, but whatever. So, but those were his grounds for denouncing all of us as racist. Fiedler made his life difficult. This whole critique of diversity is a testament to white supremacy pervasive in psychology and me comparing black people to mules.
1:12:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, okay, got it.
1:12:56 Speaker 05 Right, that, that, that was the grounds. And you, you asked me to speculate. I have no, I don't have, I have a best very circumstantial evidence. I may not even have circumstantial evidence. I strongly suspect, I would really like to test this, uh, in the lab or in surveys, that, uh, liberals, especially white liberals, are so racked with guilt and shame over the bona fide history of white supremacy and discrimination and oppression in the United States, in Europe, and especially in the UK, it's more about colonialism, right? Are so racked with guilt that there is a vulnerability to just believing anything
1:13:35 Speaker 05 a person from one of these oppressed, stigmatized groups says, denouncing others.
1:13:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, it's a very quick and easy way to signify the fact that you're not part of the oppressor camp.
1:13:47 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:13:47 Speaker 04 Yes, well, that, has no one, has that not been formally tested as a hypothesis?
1:13:52 Speaker 05 If it has, I don't know. I, I don't know.
1:13:54 Speaker 04 Well, it needs to be.
1:13:54 Speaker 05 I guess, I agree, it totally needs to be.
1:13:56 Speaker 04 Well, that's something like, it's something like, from more broadly speaking, is that, are there, it's a mechanism of gaming the reputation domain, right? Because obviously, our reputations are probably, arguably, the most valuable commodity, so to speak, that we possess. And every system of value is susceptible to gaming in a variety of ways. And one way of gaming the reputational game is to make claims of reputational virtue that are risk-free, broad, immediate, and cost-free.
1:14:35 Speaker 05 Right.
1:14:36 Speaker 04 Right, and for me, if you're accused of something, and I can say, accused of transgressing against... A group towards whom I feel guilt, I can signify my valor as a moral agent by also denouncing you. And it costs me nothing.
1:14:53 Speaker 05 Right.
1:14:53 Speaker 04 Right, which is a big problem.
1:14:55 Speaker 05 Right.
1:14:55 Speaker 04 Right. It's like, maybe it's the problem of our time. It's a very big problem.
1:15:00 Speaker 05 It's a huge problem.
1:15:00 Speaker 04 Well, especially now, because there's something else that's happened, right? Is that groups of denunciators can get together with much greater ease than they ever could.
1:15:10 Speaker 05 Yes, because of social media.
1:15:11 Speaker 04 And the effort necessary to make a denunciation has plummeted to zero.
1:15:17 Speaker 05 Right.
1:15:18 Speaker 04 And the consequences of making a false denunciation are also zero.
1:15:22 Speaker 05 Yes, zero.
1:15:23 Speaker 04 This is not good.
1:15:24 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:15:24 Speaker 04 It's like denunciation firestorm time. And that's certainly happened.
1:15:28 Speaker 05 Well, so, you know, I mostly agree. Certainly in the short term, the personal consequences of engaging in this sort of denunciation behavior are nonexistent. But the consequences are not nonexistent. So the credibility and trust and faith in academia has been in decline for a very long time. People hate this kind of stuff, so there was...
1:15:57 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, just because something's advantageous for some people in the short run does not mean that it's good for the whole game in the medium to long run.
1:16:05 Speaker 05 Right.
1:16:05 Speaker 04 That's for sure.
1:16:06 Speaker 05 Yes, that's right. That's exactly...
1:16:08 Speaker 04 Well, that's actually, I think, in some ways, the definition of an impulsive moral error. Like, if it accrues benefit to you in the short run, but does you in in the medium run, that's not a very wise strategy.
1:16:19 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:16:19 Speaker 04 Right, and that's what impulsive people do all the time. So...
1:16:22 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:16:23 Speaker 04 Right, right, that's even the definition of what constitutes a temptation.
1:16:27 Speaker 05 I was recently listening to your interview for this podcast with Keith Campbell on narcissism.
1:16:35 Speaker 04 Yes.
1:16:36 Speaker 05 And... That was one of the things you talked about, this sort of impulse control and short-term benefits versus long-term benefits, especially regarding social relations, right?
1:16:46 Speaker 04 Reputation's a long-term game.
1:16:48 Speaker 05 It's a long-term game. And there has been emerging evidence that people high in left-wing authoritarianism, sort of extreme.
1:16:58 Speaker 04 Now that we all agree that that exists, which only started in 2016.
1:17:03 Speaker 05 I know, I know. That's a whole backstory.
1:17:05 Speaker 04 That's for sure.
1:17:06 Speaker 05 So, but is correlated with narcissism. And that this pleasure that people, that people on this sort of cancel culture that has emerged, I mean, the right is not immune to cancel culture-type activities, but it emerged primarily, originally, on the left.
1:17:24 Speaker 04 Any place infiltrated by narcissists is going to be susceptible to exactly... Narcissists will use whatever political stance gains them the most immediate credibility, completely independent of the validity of the ideological standard. See, one of the things I've, we'll get back to the story right away. See, one of the things I've observed, this is very interesting, because I've talked to, I've talked to a lot of moderate progressives, let's say, or moderate, or actually even genuine liberals within the Democrat. Congressmen and senators, many of them. And I've been struck by one thing, and I'm curious about what you think about this. We know that a tilt towards empathy, so agreeableness, trade-agreeableness, a tilt,
1:18:07 Speaker 04 tilts you in a liberal direction and maybe in a progressive direction. And there are concomitants of being more agreeable on the personality side. But I think one of them is that the moderates that I've talked to always denied the existence of the pathological radicals on the left. And I've really thought, I mean, this is to a man or a woman. Yeah, yeah. And I think what it is, I think it has something to do with the unwillingness or inability of the more liberal types to have imagination for evil.
1:18:43 Speaker 04 I would make the case that most criminals, you could validly interpret most criminals whose criminal history is sporadic and short as victims. They're... they've come from abusive families, alcoholic families, often multi-generational, antisocial families, etc. But there's a subset of criminals. It's 1% of the criminals, 65% of the crimes. There's a subset of criminals who are not victims. They are really monsters. And I don't think there's any imagination for the monstrous among the compassionate left. It's all victims. It doesn't matter how egregious the crime. Now, I would have...
1:19:27 Speaker 04 That's something I would have tested as a social psychologist if I still had an active research lab, which I don't. But the problem with what we know that... We know from simulations that networks of cooperators can establish themselves in a way that's mutually beneficial and productive. But that if a shark is dropped into a tank of cooperators, then the shark takes everything. So the problem with being agreeable and cooperative is that the monsters can get you. And if you're temperamentally tilted towards denying the existence of the monsters, so much the worse. Now, I made that case because you talked about the relationship between narcissism and left-wing authoritarianism.
1:20:09 Speaker 04 I mean, narcissism shades into sadism as well. And so this is a very big problem, especially with online denunciation.
1:20:17 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:20:17 Speaker 04 Okay, so, back to 2022. Now, there's debate about whether these papers are going to proceed to publication.
1:20:26 Speaker 05 Right.
1:20:26 Speaker 04 And there's allegations made against the people who wrote the reviews.
1:20:29 Speaker 05 Yes, absolutely. We're all racist, and the whole thing is racist, and abuse of editorial power, and it's all these accusations.
1:20:35 Speaker 04 Right, and the editor loses his position.
1:20:37 Speaker 05 He loses his position, and these two special editors are brought in.
1:20:40 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:20:40 Speaker 05 Negotiations go on for almost two years. Like, what are they negotiating about? Who's gonna... So, part of Robert's denunciation, public denunciation of all of us, was he posted the draft of his commentary response that was headed for the discussion forum, and the full set of emails he exchanged with Fiedler.
1:21:11 Speaker 05 About publishing it. And those are typically confidential communications between an editor and an author. And so...
1:21:20 Speaker 04 Or at least typically private.
1:21:22 Speaker 05 Yes, right, they're typically private. So, that added to the difficulty on the part of the special editors to decide what to do. Because they didn't want to just publish those. Robertson agreed not to at first. Fiedler, they wanted Fiedler's permission to publish the correspondence. He wouldn't grant it.
1:21:53 Speaker 04 So why did Smith have such an outsized say in all this? Like, that isn't how the scientific process generally works.
1:21:59 Speaker 05 So, they, once APS blew up the journal by firing Fiedler.
1:22:08 Speaker 04 Right, right, which is like an admission of fault.
1:22:11 Speaker 05 So, and about two-thirds of the editorial board resigned when he was ousted. So, Hux was without...
1:22:20 Speaker 04 That was protest resignation.
1:22:21 Speaker 05 Yeah, I don't know whether it was protest. We know they resigned, whether it was protest or not. So, so they were...
1:22:28 Speaker 04 Maybe they also thought it was trouble they didn't need.
1:22:30 Speaker 05 Yeah, right.
1:22:31 Speaker 04 Right, I mean, these are generally, if you're, when you're working for a scientific journal, you're not doing it for the money, right? It's a lot of work. And the editors, was he paid? Was that his full-time job?
1:22:42 Speaker 05 It was not his full-time job, and I don't know whether he was paid.
1:22:45 Speaker 04 Right, right, okay. So, that just illustrates the point, is that people are doing this because that's actually what you do as a scientist. There's not a lot of, you know, you, it's a prestigious position and you meet people, you have a certain say over the direction the field might go. And those are perks, but generally, people do this like they do peer review. Because it's part of the tradition of scientific activity.
1:23:09 Speaker 05 Right.
1:23:10 Speaker 04 Right, right.
1:23:10 Speaker 05 Right, that's right.
1:23:12 Speaker 04 And so, you can see why people might bail out if it was gonna just be nothing but reputation and catastrophe.
1:23:17 Speaker 05 Right, exactly, right.
1:23:18 Speaker 04 Because they'd be thinking, why the hell am I gonna expose myself to, like, this dismal risk? When there's like, it's already hard, and there's very little upside.
1:23:27 Speaker 05 Right, exactly, right, okay. So, the journal was a mess for a long time, and...
1:23:34 Speaker 05 These editors, and there was this exchange between the editors, Roberts, Fiedler, and the other contributors, myself and the other contributors, about whether and when to publish it. And they, again, this went on for almost two years. So there was like, first a discussion, we're gonna publish it. Then there was radio silence. Well, it turns out we've run into an obstacle. Can we resolve? And it just went on for almost two years. Eventually, that was resolved, and it was all published. It's all published. And, you know, your original question was framed as, you can't believe I haven't been subject to cancellation. In fact, I have, I have. You then ask, well, how did you survive it? So let me add this little punchline.
1:24:18 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:24:19 Speaker 05 At the time that all this was happening, my immediate associate dean, so I was chair of the psychology department at Rutgers, and Rutgers is in the School of Arts and Sciences. The School of Arts and Sciences has a dean. Under the, but the School of Arts and Sciences at Rutgers is gigantic. Even as chair, I had very little direct contact with the dean. The dean was doing big deanly things. But the department chairs have a lot of contact with an associate chair. So there might be an associate chair for the sciences.
1:24:52 Speaker 04 Associate dean?
1:24:53 Speaker 05 Associate dean, yes, sorry. Associate dean, yes, sorry, sorry. Associate dean. So there'd be an associate dean for math, for STEM, associate dean for social science, and associate dean for humanities. I had a lot to do with the associate dean for social sciences, who was a psychologist from the psychology department. Okay, so I never actually had this conversation exactly with him, but I'm pretty sure he knew about the whole thing. A year, so at the end of my term, so this is now 2023, I go on sabbatical. Remember, this event occurred, the POPS event occurred in 2022. It's not till almost two years later that the stuff is published. So I complete my term as department chair 2022.
1:25:35 Speaker 05 2022, 23, I go on sabbatical, still not published. And then, at the end of that sabbatical term, the associate dean approaches me with an offer to chair the anthropology department.
1:25:53 Speaker 05 Okay, so this is very weird.
1:25:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, definitely.
1:25:55 Speaker 05 It's very weird. There was an internal political snafu, which is beyond the scope of this discussion. And they couldn't appoint an internal chair. And they wanted an external, you know, they need, the department needed a chair. The dean's office had a lot of faith and confidence in my ability.
1:26:15 Speaker 04 Despite this, despite the...
1:26:17 Speaker 05 Because of it. One of the things they said to me was, you know, "This is gonna be a difficult situation because the department is not gonna be happy about having an outside chair imposed on them, but we know you have a thick skin."
1:26:31 Speaker 04 Hmm, wow.
1:26:32 Speaker 05 And I parlayed that into a very large raise. Jordan, it was one of the best things I've ever done. So, not only did I escape cancellation, I parlayed it into an improvement in the quality of...
1:26:47 Speaker 04 Well, this is a good thing for people to know, too. You, you know, if you've watched my podcast, you know, because I say this all the time, that mythologically speaking, that every treasure has a dragon, right? And that's a representation of the world, because the world is full of threat and opportunity. And the co-association of the dragon and the treasure is a mythological trope indicating that there's opportunity where there's peril. But there's a corollary to that, which is a very interesting one, which is where there's peril, there's opportunity. And so you might think, when something negative happens to you, let's say on the social side, that you become the brunt of a cancellation attempt, you might think, "Oh my God, my
1:27:32 Speaker 04 life's over." It's like, yeah, that's one possible outcome. That's the same outcome as, you know, ending up as dragon toast, let's say. But the other outcome is that you find the treasure that's associated with the dragon, and that can definitely happen. And that's a good thing to know, because it means that when things become shaky around you, one of the things you convalibly ask yourself is, "There's something positive lurking here if I had the wisdom to see it and the..." What would you say? "The capacity for transformation necessary to allow the challenge to change me." Yeah, that's right.
1:28:10 Speaker 05 Jordan, I, I wouldn't wish that, at the time that was happening, it was horrible.
1:28:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:28:15 Speaker 05 I wouldn't wish it on anyone. In hindsight, it has made me a better person. And I would not, I wouldn't undo it now if I could.
1:28:26 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, you know what Nietzsche said, if it doesn't kill you.
1:28:30 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:28:30 Speaker 04 It makes you stronger. Now, unfortunately, there's an if. Well, seriously, right?
1:28:35 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:28:35 Speaker 04 So, and the if is that the dragon is real. It's not a game.
1:28:39 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:28:39 Speaker 04 Right.
1:28:39 Speaker 05 Well, no, FIRE, the same outfit, Foundation for Indigenous Rights and Expression, keeps a faculty under FIRE database of faculty who have been subject, usually to mobs, sometimes administrative investigations, seeking to punish them for what should have been legitimate academic, speech protected by academic freedom or even free speech. U.S. state colleges, they're subject to the First Amendment, which means they shouldn't be in the business.
1:29:06 Speaker 04 However, it's very pathetically.
1:29:07 Speaker 05 Well, yeah, well, yeah. But they have documented that hundreds of faculty have been fired for what should have been legitimately protected speech. So, your point about the whole.
1:29:18 Speaker 04 Get rid of the remaining conservatives.
1:29:19 Speaker 05 Well, I will.
1:29:20 Speaker 04 Poor liberals.
1:29:22 Speaker 05 Your metaphor about the dragon is dead on, that there's no guarantee. You know, people have lost their livelihoods running into these dragons. So, that's not.
1:29:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, the other thing, so there's some concrete recommendations that can be brought out of that, too. I would say, like, if you find yourself in serious trouble, this is one of the things I learned about, I learned from dealing with, like, very dangerous people in my clinical practice, let's say, dangerous and unstable people. It's a very bad idea to lie when you're in trouble. Like, it's a seriously bad idea. And so, if the mob or the monster comes for you, your best defense is extremely cautious playing truth. Now, that's very different than trying to, what would you say, strategize and manipulate your way out of a difficult situation. It's also very different than apologizing.
1:30:13 Speaker 04 And my experience on the woke mob cancellation side is, if you lie in your own defense or falsify your speech, you're in serious trouble. And if you apologize, a different mob will just come for you. That'll be the post-apology mob that comes for you. It's not a good idea. So, you know, what we've been outlining here is the fact that if you're in serious social peril, there's two outcomes. One is that.
1:30:42 Speaker 04 Perversely enough, in retrospect, it might turn out to be an opportunity and one you wouldn't forego now that you know the consequences. That's not impossible, but it's difficult. The other one is, is you're seriously done. And so then the question is, what can you do to maximize the possibility of the former and minimize the latter? And those are some things that I know. So, okay, okay, so let's back up a bit then. We still haven't exactly described why the cancellation attempts weren't successful for you. Now, you said, you demonstrated your ability to keep a calm head under fire, and that
1:31:24 Speaker 04 you did that well enough so the university actually recognized that, and that turned out to be of substantive benefit to you. But we don't know why it was that you maintained a calm head under fire, or how you did that without, well, having the reputation damage that was certainly directly implied by the accusation take you out. Like, do you have, was it good fortune? Were there things you did right? Like, how do you assess that?
1:31:53 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah, so, that was not my first, as I mentioned at the beginning, this was not my first go around with this kind of thing. It helps to have some experience. It helps to have done some reading. The people have addressed, there are some good articles and essays out there about what to do when you're subject to these attacks. Some of them have very good, make very good points. And, so, about six months ago, I, again, I posted an essay on my Substack.
1:32:27 Speaker 04 What's the name of your Substack?
1:32:28 Speaker 05 Unsafe Science.
1:32:29 Speaker 04 Unsafe Science.
1:32:30 Speaker 05 It's called my Vita of Denunciation.
1:32:32 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:32:33 Speaker 05 And it's called my Vita of Denunciation because I've been, it goes through several of these sorts of attacks that I have been through. And how, first place, it also goes through the tactics, it's a short version, I have a longer version in a different place, but it goes through a short version of how to deal with these attacks. So... The very first piece is that if you're, if you find yourself in the midst of such an attack, go silent. Go silent. Do not engage. Do not engage with your attacker, because nearly all of these cancellation-type attacks are massive, brutal, and short.
1:33:16 Speaker 04 Right, right, right. Two weeks.
1:33:18 Speaker 05 Yeah, and most.
1:33:19 Speaker 04 That's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And people forget, that's the weird thing, because the present is so large, you're gonna panic. Yeah, yeah. Don't panic.
1:33:27 Speaker 05 Don't panic.
1:33:28 Speaker 04 That's right. Don't panic. Don't assume that it's gonna be successful.
1:33:31 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:33:32 Speaker 04 Because people, they might be interested in you today, but they weren't interested in you yesterday. They probably won't be interested in you tomorrow.
1:33:40 Speaker 05 And it's like, as a kid, we used to go to the beach and body surf, and occasionally, like a wave that was way bigger than you could handle would, and there was nothing you could do, except let it wash over you and knock you around, and you come out and it washes you on shore, and you're fine.
1:33:54 Speaker 04 As long as you don't do anything to make it worse.
1:33:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
1:33:56 Speaker 04 Like apologize, for example.
1:33:58 Speaker 05 You know, I would add this. If you genuinely, in your heart of heart, believe you have done something wrong, then maybe you should apologize. But you should not apologize.
1:34:09 Speaker 04 Let me add something to that. No, not if you genuinely believe it, because you might not be your own best defender. That's why you have a Fifth Amendment. No, seriously. Conscientious, guilt-prone people will accuse themselves very... So then I would say, if you feel that you've done something wrong, remember the presumption of innocence before provable guilt. Remember that. It applies to you too. And then go talk to five or six people that you trust, and lay out the argument on both sides, and see if they think you're the bad guy. Right?
1:34:44 Speaker 05 That's good. I agree with that. That's good. I'm completely on board with that.
1:34:49 Speaker 04 Don't assume that you're morally obligated to apologize, even if you think, even if you feel guilty.
1:34:54 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:34:54 Speaker 04 Because your guilt feelings are not an unerring indication of your guilt.
1:34:59 Speaker 05 That's right. And may distort how you think about your culpability. Yeah, no, that's a very good point.
1:35:04 Speaker 04 That is, see, this is why I think too, the council mob is particularly effective against genuine conservatives. Because genuine conservatives tilt towards higher conscientiousness. And it's very easy to make conscientious people feel guilty. Right, right. So that can be weaponized. Okay, so go silent.
1:35:22 Speaker 05 Yeah, go silent.
1:35:23 Speaker 04 Including, you can always apologize in a month.
1:35:26 Speaker 05 You can.
1:35:27 Speaker 04 Because you've thought it through.
1:35:28 Speaker 05 Absolutely.
1:35:29 Speaker 04 If anyone still cares.
1:35:30 Speaker 05 That's right.
1:35:30 Speaker 04 Yeah. Okay, go silent.
1:35:32 Speaker 05 Go silent.
1:35:33 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:35:34 Speaker 05 Record everything.
1:35:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's for sure.
1:35:37 Speaker 05 Right?
1:35:38 Speaker 04 And you're
1:35:39 Speaker 05 Everything.
1:35:39 Speaker 04 Everything.
1:35:41 Speaker 05 You don't know how you're gonna use it. You may use it to defend yourself going forward, depending on how things unfold. You may decide after the wave of the attack passes, that you want to counter-attack.
1:35:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, right.
1:35:59 Speaker 05 You want some level
1:36:00 Speaker 04 Carefully and strategically.
1:36:01 Speaker 05 Carefully and strategically. And by recording everything, you have the raw material to damn your attackers. So that's, right, so go silent.
1:36:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's especially true if someone's interviewing you. Yeah, it's like, record all of it.
1:36:17 Speaker 05 Record all of it, yeah, record all of it. Seek allies.
1:36:22 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:36:23 Speaker 05 Because you're, you may feel alone.
1:36:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:36:27 Speaker 05 Mobs are very good at coming after somebody who seems alone. But if you can, if you have networks, support networks, activate those networks. If you don't have them, and, you know, if you're in the intellectual type of professions, whether it's academia or mainstream media, could be in something else, you probably have a support network. Let them know what's going on. Most, my experience has been, at least the kind of networks that I have, they will, people will stand up for you. I mean, I had numbers of people writing essays that got posted in some pretty good places, Real Clear Politics, I think, was one, right? On this pops fiasco. Um, so
1:37:11 Speaker 05 Actually, of all places, the Chronicle of Higher Ed did a great, some great reporting on it. And it really kind of damned the mob and the...
1:37:20 Speaker 04 Right, that's also why you need that time of silence, is to muster your resources.
1:37:24 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:37:25 Speaker 04 And you could also assume, even if people are nervous in the aftermath of the accusations for two or three days, or a week even, they may come to their senses as the temperature drops.
1:37:39 Speaker 05 Yes, that's right. Yes, that's absolutely right. And then, right, so, go silent, record everything, activate your support networks.
1:37:47 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:37:48 Speaker 05 And then, if, again, it depends on the situation, it's gonna be, it's gonna vary from person to person, and situation to situation, it depends in part on what your skills and resources are.
1:38:01 Speaker 00 Who answers America's call for more energy? Our people do. Chevron's U.S. energy production has increased by nearly 60% in the past three years.
1:38:11 Speaker 01 Hi, my name is Aaron, and I'm a wealth site representative at Chevron. I'm proud of the work that I do every day, it gets more American oil out of the ground, and it brings America more energy security.
1:38:22 Speaker 00 Learn more about what our people do at chevron.com/america.
1:38:32 Speaker 05 But then you are ready to either defend yourself and/or counterattack.
1:38:36 Speaker 04 Okay.
1:38:36 Speaker 05 And I don't, Jordan, I don't know how many essays I posted on unsafe science surrounding this event. One of them is titled, "There Is No Racist Mule Trop." So the argument, the grounds for denouncing me as a racist, for comparing black people to mules, was that there was a historical trope of making an equivalence between black people and mules. This, Roberts was the, presented this, and he had one reference to support this.
1:39:07 Speaker 04 Right.
1:39:08 Speaker 05 Which I was not familiar with.
1:39:09 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:39:10 Speaker 05 So, I tracked it down.
1:39:11 Speaker 04 That's what you say.
1:39:12 Speaker 05 I know, I know. Let's see what this, let's see what the article actually says.
1:39:15 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:39:17 Speaker 05 This article was a really good article, and...
1:39:21 Speaker 05 What it documented was that there was a historical linkage between black people and mules, because originally, American blacks were overwhelmingly in the American South, in the agrarian South. And so, the mule was a symbol of both the kind of work that was done in the South, this agricultural work, and it was a symbol of the flawed liberation of black people from slavery, because one of the promises that they never delivered on was forty acres and a mule.
1:39:57 Speaker 04 Right.
1:39:57 Speaker 05 And even though that was never delivered on, for a very long time, until you had the mass migration into the North, the black people living in the American South aspire to be successful farmers, and getting a mule was one way to have a successful farm. And so, you would see images, paintings, even if you go to Southern museums, there's some very famous paintings of black people in fields with a mule pulling a wagon, or a, I don't know, you know.
1:40:33 Speaker 04 Plow?
1:40:33 Speaker 05 Yeah, like a plow, or, yes, right. That's very, very common. And in fact, the mule figures fairly largely in African-American folk stories from the American South. So it documents all this.
1:40:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:40:50 Speaker 05 So much so that the mule really became a symbol of people who were oppressed, and part of the liberation of people who were oppressed. So that when, after Martin Luther King's assassination, his casket was pulled in a wagon pulled by mules. Okay, so there is, it's not a myth, right?
1:41:12 Speaker 04 So it's, okay, so given all that, it's less surprising that that speculation might have arisen in relationship to your analogy.
1:41:21 Speaker 05 Right, right.
1:41:22 Speaker 04 Things you find out too late.
1:41:24 Speaker 05 Yes, right, right. So, but it is ironic, because the mule is the symbol of the liberation from the oppression, rather than the oppression.
1:41:34 Speaker 04 Right, right.
1:41:35 Speaker 05 You know, right, so.
1:41:36 Speaker 04 Okay, so let me ask you a question about strategy there, too. Like, I've spent a lot of time strategizing with people, because that was a big part of my clinical practice, but.
1:41:48 Speaker 04 In terms of silence and then mustering your support network, right? And then you said, "Well, you can, you can start your defense." It's like, my sense is that a good offense is a very strong defense.
1:42:08 Speaker 05 Yes.
1:42:09 Speaker 04 Right? Because you can, if you're careful. Now, you know, you can defend yourself or you can turn the tables. And I would say, if you're turning the tables because you're angry, that's not a good idea. Because you're gonna make mistakes in your strategizing, right? I think you can distinguish the, the search for justice and truth from the search for revenge by the intermediating role of especially resentment. If you're resentfully angry, your head isn't clear. But if you can quell that, and you want to establish the truth, and you can do that with a certain amount of detachment, then a good defensive strategy is offense. It's like, what's actually?
1:42:51 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:42:52 Speaker 04 You can flip the tables, so to speak. And the problem with a defense is there's something, well, there's something defensive.
1:43:00 Speaker 05 Defensive, absolutely, yes, yes.
1:43:02 Speaker 04 Well, I might have made a mistake.
1:43:04 Speaker 05 Yes, right, absolutely, right.
1:43:06 Speaker 04 No, no, you're, you're seriously wrong.
1:43:08 Speaker 05 Yeah, yeah.
1:43:09 Speaker 04 And in a manner that's actually detrimental to the cause you purport to be putting forward.
1:43:14 Speaker 05 Yeah, okay. Yeah, well, so that and some of the prior experiences fueled what my, what was then very early interests in left-wing authoritarianism and far-left radicalization and its consequences. And so I've been doing all sorts of studies on that.
1:43:42 Speaker 04 All right, look, we have to stop this part of the discussion, even though there's like 50 other things I want to talk to you about, but we'll continue. I'm going to, I think, focus the discussion on the Daily Wire side. You guys listening on YouTube know about this, that we do another half an hour there. I think I'm gonna talk about categorization and implicit bias, and delve a little bit more into social psychology's role, for better or worse, in...
1:44:11 Speaker 04 Promoting many of the policies, the DEI policies, for example, and justifying them hypothetically on scientific grounds. I want to delve into that because it's definitely been social psychologists who've been particularly interested in the issue of implicit bias, even though to some degree that notion came from the clinical world, including from people like Carl Jung, who were very interested in the idea of complex and implicit association back in the 1920s. Anyways, there's a veneer of scientific respectability that's been laid over the diversity, inclusivity, and equity claims, the notion of implicit and systemic bias. And that's always bothered me because I think the social psychologists
1:44:54 Speaker 04 have done a terrible job distinguishing between categorization, which is like the basis of perception itself, bias, because you can't consider categorization bias. It's like, that's insane. That's insane, even though the postmodernists really do make that claim. And Lee's done work too, looking at the accuracy of such things as so-called stereotypes. Because what's the difference between a stereotype and a category? Like, that is a hard question. You could spend a thousand years trying to figure that out. Anyways, I think that's what we'll delve into if you want to join us on the Daily Wire side. And so, thank you very much, sir, for offering what you know and also your story to the more general public.
1:45:39 Speaker 04 And join us on the Daily Wire side if you want to continue with the discussion.
1:45:55 Speaker 02 Have you heard the news? Balance of Nature's Fiber and Spice Supplement is everything nice. No synthetics, no additives, and no flow agents. Just 100% ingredients of whole food. It isn't just your average fiber supplement. It also has a wide variety of 12 amazing spices. Just two scoops of the Fiber and Spice Supplement, stirred into 16 ounces of your favorite drink daily. That's all it takes. To get a wide variety of ingredients of real whole food every single day. Here's how Balance of Nature Fiber & Spice Supplement worked for one customer.
1:46:29 Speaker 03 I have been taking Fiber & Spice for over three years. When I first started taking it, I could smell the cumin and the turmeric and the different spices. I tell all my friends about Balance of Nature.
1:46:42 Speaker 02 Call now and save 35% on your first order when you subscribe. Use discount code WIRE. Call 1-800-246-8751. That's 1-800-246-8751.
1:46:56 Speaker 06 Everyone wants healthcare to be simpler and easier. That's why UnitedHealth Group is fast-tracking more than 60% of children's procedures that used to need pre-approval. So more kids get the care they need when they need it. And speeding up procedure approvals and payments for more than 1,500 rural hospitals. So they can focus on caring for their communities. And that's just the start. Learn more at UHG.com/Access.
1:47:26 Speaker 00 Who answers America's call for more energy? Our people do. They've helped boost Chevron's U.S. energy production by nearly 60% in the past three years. Helping fuel national energy security. And drives down the open roads that make America. Learn more about what our people do at chevron.com/america.
Previous 506. Europe Imploding | Andrew Doyle & Graham Linehan Next 508. Anti-Semitism and the Fall of Trudeau's Canada | Terry Glavin Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated