Pod Insights The Imperfects Dr Emily - Hope About this episode Today, Dr Emily talks about hope.
And in a world where things can feel a little bit hopeless, this really couldn’t have come at a better time.
In contrast to all of our understanding up until this point, hope is not an emotion.
Expertly defined by Dr Emily, hope is a belief. And most significantly, it can be learned, and it can be cultivated.
Psychological mic-drop.
This episode delves into strategies for creating both a sense of collective and individual hope, and in a discovery which happens to be VERY on-brand for this podcast, Dr Emily talks to the significance of vulnerability and connection in living a hopeful life.
We hope you enjoy this one as much as we did.
If you would like to watch this full episode on YouTube, follow this link - https://bit.ly/41j0pT1
📚To pre-order Dr Emily’s book Unstuck, click here - https://bit.ly/4bhmCp2
🫖 Other Imperfects episodes mentioned in this episode
Dr Julia Baird - An Awe-full Conversation - https://www.theimperfects.com.au/episode/dr-julia-baird-an-awe-full-conversation/
📖 Things to read
Martin Seligman - Theory of Learned Hopelessness - https://bit.ly/3EY1oR2
Rick Snyder - Hope Theory: Rainbows in the Mind - https://bit.ly/4bAbu6Z
Jamil Zacki - Hope for Cynics - https://www.jamil-zaki.com
Robyn Walser - Heart of ACT - https://amzn.to/4izIv5x
Barbara Frederikson - Reflections on Positive Emotions and Upward Spirals - https://bit.ly/3EY2yfl
Nick Cave’s letter - https://bit.ly/3ETlr2O
Victor Frankl - Man’s Search For Meaning - https://bit.ly/4iizuNM
💻Things to check out
Dacher Keltner’s work - https://bit.ly/3XfJpfe
Obama’s ‘Hope’ poster - https://bit.ly/4kgkvG4
The Imperfects is not a licensed mental health service and is not a substitute for professional mental health advice, treatment or assessment. The advice given in this episode is general in nature, but if you’re struggling, please see a healthcare professional, or call lifeline on 13 11 14.
Transcript 12,848 words · 5 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 And there's a quote that I wanted to read from an environmental thinker, David Orr. He says, "Hope is a verb with its sleeves rolled up. Hopeful people are actively engaged in defying the odds or changing the odds. Optimism leans back, puts its feet up and wears a confident look."
0:23 Speaker 01 Quick, is anyone here a doctor? Yes, her name is Dr Emily and she's a psychologist. Please welcome to The Imperfect, our very own psychologist.
0:37 Speaker 02 Oh, it's exciting.
0:39 Speaker 03 Could we add a lyric to our very own psychologist?
0:43 Speaker 02 Yeah.
0:44 Speaker 03 Our very own bestselling, and the book still isn't even out yet, psychologist?
0:48 Speaker 02 Yes, we'll find a quicker way to say it.
0:50 Speaker 03 I'm holding the book up to the camera now.
0:52 Speaker 02 Okay, we're jumping right into it.
0:56 Speaker 02 So Dr M is back. This is so exciting, M. And as Hugh has pointed out...
1:04 Speaker 03 Wasted no time getting into... What's making you nervous? You're not comfortable with the promotion. So I want to get it over and done with because, yeah, M's not into promotion of herself, but we are into promotion of M. The book is called Unstuck.
1:17 Speaker 02 She's all of a sudden on a television show. Holding the book up like he's Jay Leno.
1:26 Speaker 02 Very lucky to have a Dr Emily psychologist with a brand new book, Unstuck.
1:32 Speaker 03 Emily, how are you?
1:34 Speaker 02 Oh, the American accent, a great touch. Please do one more paragraph in American accent.
1:41 Speaker 03 We are so grateful to have Dr Emily Musgrove from Melbourne, Australia.
1:46 Speaker 02 It's really good.
1:46 Speaker 03 On the couch. Emily, welcome to the US. How are you?
1:53 Speaker 02 Okay, yes.
1:54 Speaker 00 Very disarmed.
1:55 Speaker 03 So where can people get the book now?
1:58 Speaker 00 I should have a spiel for this. It's available for pre-order online at Penguin and through all good book retailers.
2:04 Speaker 02 Yes.
2:05 Speaker 00 It's out on the 20th of May.
2:06 Speaker 03 The bad ones too, they'll have it.
2:08 Speaker 00 Correct. Yep. And I have to emphasise that, yes, I am narrating the book and I have had a lot of people asking whether that is the case for the audiobook. So you'll hear my dulcet tones for a long time.
2:20 Speaker 02 That's gonna be great. Have you done it yet? Have you done the narration?
2:24 Speaker 00 No, in a couple of weeks. Yeah.
2:26 Speaker 03 Well, congratulations.
2:27 Speaker 00 Thank you.
2:28 Speaker 03 I'm 123 pages in and it's made me cry a lot.
2:31 Speaker 02 Are you really?
2:32 Speaker 03 Yeah.
2:32 Speaker 02 Oh, where'd you get that? It's not even out yet.
2:35 Speaker 03 Well, Emily gave it to me.
2:39 Speaker 02 Oh, it's cool, Em.
2:41 Speaker 02 I'm cool.
2:43 Speaker 02 I'm cool. I don't need it. I'm reading heaps of books. Still getting through Tolkien. But yeah, I'll definitely jump on yours next. Definitely jump on yours next when I get it. I'll preorder. I'll pay for it like everyone else. Like a plan, but cool.
3:00 Speaker 02 No, genuinely so exciting out here.
3:03 Speaker 00 Oh, thank you.
3:04 Speaker 02 So it's called Unstuck. What is it about? Like, what's the sort of focus of the book?
3:08 Speaker 00 So I guess when I was thinking about what would be helpful and useful for people, like as a self-help genre, one of the things that I've come across, like in the time working as a psychologist, is that very rarely do I work really exclusively with a diagnosis. What I would work with is what the problem is that is here in this moment, or that what brings people to therapy. And so what brings people to therapy is most often that they are stuck in pain. And so the book really is around how we become unstuck from the struggle that we're in at the moment. So it could be unstuck from making decisions, it could be unstuck from relationships, it could be unstuck in patterns of thinking,
3:53 Speaker 00 of ways of working with emotions.
3:55 Speaker 02 So like, super practical.
3:57 Speaker 00 It's really practical. It's, I hope, it's very hopeful. I genuinely have a very strong belief, and I think that this hopefully comes across in the podcast too, and that is that. There is always a space for choice in there. It's just how we uncover it. And I think it's with this choice that we then can really move forwards. And so that's kind of the premise of this book is that we we zoom in and we have a look what's here. And then we work out how we can move forward with this new kind of in-depth awareness of our experience and the actions that we're currently taking to manage them.
4:34 Speaker 02 Whoa. Cannot wait to buy my book full retail price.
4:40 Speaker 02 From a good retailer, cannot wait.
4:41 Speaker 03 In Emily's defence, my copy is printed out on A4 pages, not even staples, just with a with a rubber band around them.
4:49 Speaker 02 So. Amazing.
4:50 Speaker 03 Um, I would add to that, the book is also, I think what a lot of people would really like is the experience of just listening to Em without three guys interrupting her and asking silly questions. Um, it's.
5:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, actually, that that might keep me away. That might deter me, but yeah, I'll give it a go.
5:07 Speaker 03 But it's, it's also, I think you make the really nice observation that so many of us at certain points of our lives feel broken.
5:16 Speaker 00 Hmm.
5:17 Speaker 03 And you point out that we're not broken and we're just stuck. And you give so many beautiful stories of people in therapy who have come to you stuck and then you have, you finish the book with this practical advice on how we can become unstuck. And it's just, it's so beautifully written.
5:33 Speaker 00 Thank you very much.
5:35 Speaker 03 Hundred and twenty-three pages, not all, but congratulations.
5:37 Speaker 00 Thank you, really. And I, and as I've said to all of you at some point, that I just would not have had this opportunity had you not all trusted me to be on here with you from the very beginning. So, yeah, it's like a mutual love.
5:48 Speaker 02 It's, um, I'm sure like we'll link to it and I'm sure we'll get a clip of of that. So that would be great. Just ten, five percent, two, two to five percent would be great.
5:57 Speaker 04 Each or?
5:58 Speaker 02 Of sales. Um.
5:59 Speaker 04 All of them.
6:00 Speaker 02 Probably have to split it.
6:01 Speaker 04 Split it.
6:01 Speaker 02 Yeah.
6:02 Speaker 04 Maybe ten then.
6:03 Speaker 02 It did play a big part.
6:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
6:06 Speaker 02 We'll work it out, we'll work it out later.
6:08 Speaker 00 Good.
6:09 Speaker 02 But anyway.
6:09 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:10 Speaker 02 Em.
6:11 Speaker 00 I'm here.
6:11 Speaker 02 We're back. So before we jump straight into hope, which is what you're talking about today, just to quickly point out to everyone, we have traditionally had eight Dr. M episodes a year for the last few years, or since you started with us. And this year, we're upping the ante to 12?
6:33 Speaker 00 I believe 12, yeah.
6:35 Speaker 02 We're doing monthly, all year round, baby.
6:40 Speaker 02 So that's very exciting for everyone.
6:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:43 Speaker 02 So thanks, Em.
6:43 Speaker 00 I'm very excited to be here.
6:44 Speaker 02 More Em.
6:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. Em, hope.
6:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:47 Speaker 02 What do we need to know?
6:48 Speaker 00 Okay. Well, to begin with, the reason that I wanted to do this particular theme and this particular topic is, is twofold. The first is that, um, hope and hopefulness is a key foundation to human flourishing. Um, it's a key factor in all of the work that I do as a psychologist is finding and cultivating hope. But the second part of this is also the deep acknowledgement of some very current feelings of despair, of mistrust, of cynicism, based upon.
7:25 Speaker 02 Worry.
7:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, and deep fear, um, based upon the current world circumstances. Um, and what is so paramount in, in this work is that when we lose hope, progress stops.
7:43 Speaker 02 Hmm. Yeah. So do you mean on a global level, like on a large level?
7:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
7:48 Speaker 02 When a group of people, like a population loses hope collectively?
7:52 Speaker 00 Yes.
7:53 Speaker 02 Yeah.
7:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. And the same can be said for an individual. When we lose hope, we move into hopelessness and we move into despair.
8:04 Speaker 02 Jeez.
8:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:05 Speaker 02 Okay.
8:05 Speaker 00 And from a, I mean, I'll get into some definitions and, and how to work with this, but psychologically, a place of despair is a place of immobility, of non-movement, of freezing. And when we look at all of the research, you know, decades of research around this, like even back to the earlier, you know, kind of nineteen fifty's, um, sixty's, Martin Seligman, looking at the, the theory of learned Hopelessness. It's kind of this similar notion that when we lose hope, we stop moving. And from that place of not moving, we lose a will to live. And so it's a very significant risk factor for suicide.
8:49 Speaker 00 It's probably one of the most, um, most predictive factors for suicide risk is despair and a loss of hope. When we think about it from a global point of view, if we all lose hope, if we all move into despair and helplessness, what happens next?
9:13 Speaker 02 Hmm, hmm, not good things.
9:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so.
9:18 Speaker 02 You can quote me on that.
9:21 Speaker 00 And so it's like, this is why this, this feels so important. And that is that, that we need to bring awareness to how we're feeling as a, a community, as a global collective. And we also need to bring awareness to how hope is felt on an individual basis.
9:36 Speaker 03 Can you explain practically how?
9:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:38 Speaker 03 You do that, because it's like something you might hear someone in your industry say.
9:42 Speaker 00 Yes.
9:43 Speaker 03 But like, what is that? Practically, how do I do that?
9:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay.
9:47 Speaker 03 Is it what you did just before we turned the microphones on without revealing too much? How you talked about how you were feeling?
9:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, I said I was feeling nervous today and I, and it's because I haven't done this since last May, actually, probably.
9:58 Speaker 02 Really?
9:58 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah, the last time we recorded was last May. So it's been quite a while. And I was also nervous about the book. Um, and so I said to you guys before, and it's so interesting, I'll tell you in a second. I said to you, I just have to tell you that I'm feeling really nervous today. And then I kind of named a couple of reasons and then we joked that we name it to time it. Um, and I'll, so I'll get into what that means. But if I was to track my feelings of anxiety right now. They've moved. I've moved with them. And if I was to really tune in right now, they're not really present.
10:31 Speaker 03 Because you're able to say them, or?
10:34 Speaker 00 I think, yes. And we can look at the research around what's called affect labelling, which is the capacity to be able to label and articulate verbally how we're currently feeling. And that, from a brain activity point of view, what happens when we label verbally and put a language to our emotional or internal experience is that it increases activity in the prefrontal cortex. So prefrontal cortex, front part of the brain, it's responsible amongst many other things for emotion regulation. Now, when we think about anxiety, for example, or fear, we're getting a really dominant activity in the, kind of at the back or the lower parts of the brain, often referred to as the limbic system,
11:18 Speaker 00 part of the threat centre. We get big lighting up of activity in that part of the brain. Now, when we bring language on board, it's like the prefrontal cortex dampens down the activity of the limbic system or the threat centre. So it's kind of like when we bring language, we're dampening down the threat response.
11:36 Speaker 03 Awesome.
11:37 Speaker 00 And in addition, we're also bringing meaning to our experience. So I can now start to make meaning of the fact that I was feeling nervous. And it's as though it can now sit out here rather than pushing me around internally. Yep. So, yes, that is certainly a big component when it comes to working within cultivating hope. And that's one strategy which we'll look at. Before we get there, I think it might be really useful to get a sense of some definitions. Because hope, I think, is a term that we use theoretically speaking, technically speaking, often incorrectly. And so I think it might be useful, even if we just start with what hope means.
12:20 Speaker 00 So one of the most prominent, I guess, theoretical conceptualisations of hope comes from Rick Snyder's Theory of Hope, or Hope Theory, which I think was developed around 1999, early 2000s. And the title of one of his research articles, which I think is just so beautiful, is that hope is like the rainbows of the mind.
12:43 Speaker 03 That's really cool.
12:45 Speaker 00 And like even as you sit with that image, what do you notice that that brings up?
12:50 Speaker 03 I just saw a unicorn.
12:53 Speaker 02 Dancing through my brain. Because of the rainbow, it's they're like synonymous for some reason.
12:59 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:59 Speaker 02 It sort of feels childlike.
13:01 Speaker 04 I just think of colour and I know from my own personal experience, but anecdotally for me, I feel like when I'm not doing well, the first thing, well, not so much the first, I think the first thing to present itself is low mood and sort of depressive thoughts. But I think when I, to use the phrase used before, sit with it and kind of listen to what's going on, the thing I think that really gets me is that hope disappears. And I think the absence of hope is more damaging than the presence of the depressing
13:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:35 Speaker 04 feelings.
13:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:36 Speaker 04 And I have often felt like I genuinely can't see colour as well. Like just literally can't see colour as well.
13:44 Speaker 02 Really?
13:45 Speaker 04 Mood. Yeah. And so the rainbow to me is like, because I know the feeling of coming out of that mood.
13:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:51 Speaker 04 Often is accompanied through light and being able to see colour or plants or nature more vividly. And appreciate them again. Um, and it comes with a feeling of hope coming back. Yeah.
14:05 Speaker 00 That's a, it's a really beautiful, um, image, really. It's interesting too that you say that it's the hope. It's actually the absence of hope more than the depressive symptoms that, that is more significant. And the research is absolutely, would absolutely back that up.
14:20 Speaker 04 Right.
14:20 Speaker 00 Um, it's, it's a much greater predictor that the lack of hope for suicide than depressive symptoms. And what is particularly interesting about, um, hope theory or Snyder's hope theory is that hope is not an emotion. It's, it's actually a belief or a cognition. And what is so powerful and paramount to that is that when it's a belief, when it's a cognition, it can be learned and it can be cultivated. As opposed to feeling states or mood states which come and go, which we often have zero control over.
14:55 Speaker 02 Almost reacting to them, they kind of wash over us a little bit.
14:59 Speaker 00 The emotions?
15:00 Speaker 02 The emotion?
15:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, they can, I mean, they can.
15:02 Speaker 02 Okay, yeah, exactly. They can. I don't always do that. Exactly. They just do the words out of my mouth. Cut me off. Yeah. They don't always do that, but they can, yeah.
15:11 Speaker 00 So I'll be a bit more explicit. So when we, like from this theory, basically, hope consists of a belief in my ability to work towards a desired pathway and destination. And it involves two main cognitive features, or three actually. The first is goals, having goals. That's the first one. So hope instinctively involves some kind of goal for the future.
15:39 Speaker 02 And when I, when I think goal, sorry to cut you off, but when I think goal, I immediately think professional goal, but I'm assuming it doesn't have to be a professional.
15:48 Speaker 00 No, absolutely. It could be anything. Like, for example, if, and we'll get into this too, but it could be something like maybe you have a terminal illness and a hope might be that there's a cure. And then that hope over time becomes reimagined or recalibrated. And hope now becomes the goal to reach my daughter's birthday.
16:10 Speaker 02 Amazing.
16:11 Speaker 00 For example.
16:11 Speaker 02 Yep.
16:12 Speaker 00 So there is some sort of goal directed behaviour that is there. And if you think about the rainbow notion, it's that, well, we always think about like the notion of the, the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. It's almost like we're following this pathway here to some desired outcome, that there's some sort of meaning and purpose at the end there for us. So the first part is the goal. The second part, again, a cognitive feature is pathways, what's called pathways thinking. And that is that I can see and I can create pathways towards that goal. So it's like looking forward and seeing what obstacles
16:53 Speaker 00 might be there and thinking about how I'm going to get from this present to a desired future.
17:01 Speaker 02 And then the problem solving to get to that goal.
17:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. The third part, and this is really integral, because if we don't have this, then hope doesn't manifest itself in the same way. The third part is what's called agency thinking. And that is our motivation and our willingness to follow the pathway. So we could, for example, see that there is, let's just say, we have a hopefulness of getting a new job. And I can see that the pathway is I go and update my C V. And then I put my applications in to this job. But if I'm lacking in the agency, my belief in my ability to act on this, then hopefulness can't exist.
17:43 Speaker 02 Hmm, ah, can you explain that? So you mean your agency is in like your control of it or your?
17:50 Speaker 00 So my, my motivation.
17:51 Speaker 02 Your motivation.
17:52 Speaker 00 My energy and my willpower. So what is like propelling me into action?
17:57 Speaker 02 Gotcha.
17:58 Speaker 00 So there is an inherent action component to hopefulness and to hope. And that's where it differentiates itself from optimism.
18:10 Speaker 00 Because I think the two are often conflated.
18:12 Speaker 02 Definitely, yeah, yeah, I would find it hard to separate the two.
18:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, so there's lots of varying understandings and theoretical underpinnings to both of these concepts. I want to be clear, and this is just kind of the way that I would work and one, one part. But optimism has often been viewed as like even for example, as a trait. This may not be a surprise to you, I'm very optimistic, I'm a very optimistic person.
18:36 Speaker 00 And I also find hopefulness to be something that I can really enact as well. So optimism basically is the belief that a good outcome will happen. Okay?
18:47 Speaker 02 Yep.
18:49 Speaker 00 By contrast, hope is the belief that a good outcome could happen.
18:56 Speaker 02 Oh.
18:57 Speaker 00 Right, so optimism.
18:58 Speaker 02 Kind of blind optimism.
19:00 Speaker 00 Exactly, yeah, so optimism does not involve action. It's just a belief that good things will happen.
19:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
19:07 Speaker 00 And there are big problems with that. Um, which we can come to. Hope is very different. Hope inherently involves uncertainty. I don't know if this is possible for me. But I hope that it is and that that is supported by my actions, by my motivation and my willpower.
19:30 Speaker 04 So if you don't have all three of that, almost like the three legs of a stool or something, hope collapses?
19:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, we could technically say that.
19:44 Speaker 04 Yeah, maybe that's not the right word to use, but I'm thinking of my, in to a very specific example in my life of like wanting to be, well, I've said wanting to lose weight, even though I don't like thinking those terms and admitting it, but it's true for me. I know what the goal is. I know what I need to do to get there, but I don't have the internal motivation or agency to do it. And therefore I don't have much hope that I'll ever change.
20:18 Speaker 00 That moves into helplessness.
20:20 Speaker 04 Yeah, in that specific area. Yeah.
20:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. And yeah, so you can see, you can see in that example, and, and I know there's a lot of pain in there with that, Josh, that, that the absence of that kind of belief in, in your agency also then brings you into a lot of internal, probably a lot of internal dialogue and negative criticism.
20:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
20:45 Speaker 00 Which then kind of puts us into a spiral, a negative spiral.
20:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
20:50 Speaker 00 Of less hopefulness.
20:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, absolutely. And it's, that's probably the first time anyone has ever been out. It explains to me why it is that when I start to exercise, it feels worse.
21:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
21:02 Speaker 04 Yeah. You just got unstuck.
21:06 Speaker 04 What date?
21:08 Speaker 04 She's good. She's good. But no, that, yeah, I'd never really thought of it that way. That's, yeah, that feels very true to the experience.
21:17 Speaker 00 There's something really powerful about, about the agency.
21:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:21 Speaker 00 I want to be careful around the word of willpower because I think it can also trip us up a lot too. And I think what happens is that it can move us into, into blaming and shaming.
21:31 Speaker 04 Yep.
21:32 Speaker 00 And so there is a reluctance on my part to use it as like this term that we have, the willpower, as though it's something that is superior. But really it's talking about my belief in my ability to do it.
21:44 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:45 Speaker 00 And that what comes with that is a motivation.
21:48 Speaker 04 Yes. Yeah, yeah.
21:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:52 Speaker 00 This is kind of coming back to, again, this kind of action oriented notion of hope. And there's a quote that I wanted to read from an environmental thinker, David Orr. And hope plays a very, very big part in our understanding of climate change. And what's being done to address that incredibly large and ominous issue. And he writes, as do many others, that hope is so integral to us changing the future and changing a projected outcome. And I like the way he differentiates hope from optimism. And so I might read it to you. He says, "Hope is a verb with its sleeves rolled up. Hopeful people are actively engaged in defying the odds or changing the odds.
22:37 Speaker 00 Optimism leans back, puts its feet up and wears a confident look."
22:43 Speaker 03 So good.
22:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:44 Speaker 03 So good. I feel like the analogy of hope having its sleeves rolled up is all you need to know.
22:49 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:49 Speaker 03 It's great.
22:50 Speaker 00 Yeah. It's, I think it really is around the fact that hopefulness absolutely involves action. And that's something we have a choice over. And what's interesting, if we look at that kind of collective experience of hopefulness and in the current climate, this being a particularly strong issue, is the very natural and very understandable vulnerability towards feeling mistrusting and very cynical. And if we look at the research around cynicism, we could say, in fact, the research suggests that if you were to survey people about their views of someone that is cynical
23:31 Speaker 00 and ask them whether they think that cynical people have a greater intelligence or cognitive capacity, and whether they're more socially intelligent, most people will say that cynics are more intelligent and have more social intelligence. Do you have a sense of why that might be?
23:46 Speaker 03 Maybe you feel like they're more intelligent, but you wouldn't want to have a pickle over them or any coffee.
23:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think that that is absolutely.
23:55 Speaker 02 He's a piccolo man. I was gonna say beer, but I don't drink beer anymore, so.
23:59 Speaker 04 I think it's easy to be quick witted and, and fast speaking and dominate an intellectual argument if all you're doing is tearing something down.
24:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
24:09 Speaker 04 So therefore you come across as more intelligent, but I actually think it requires more intelligence to, to build something or create something than tear other things down, which I think is inherently cynical.
24:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
24:21 Speaker 04 Uh, so I think it, I can see how it appears more intelligent, but I feel like it's not.
24:26 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
24:27 Speaker 04 Yeah, I don't know if that's helped at all.
24:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, well, yeah, I think, I mean, that's actually correct. And there's some really awesome work, um, by Dr. Jamil Zaki. And he also does some really great podcasts too. And he talks about the notion of cynicism. And in contrast to cynicism, the idea of hopeful skepticism, particularly when it comes to this kind of collective, um, community hopefulness. But he, in his work, discovered that when surveying people, that most people believe that cynics are more intelligent and they have more social intelligence. And in fact, the opposite is actually true.
25:02 Speaker 02 Like proven?
25:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. So the opposite is true. And that is that.
25:07 Speaker 04 Is he satisfied?
25:08 Speaker 00 And I'll explain why. So if you hold a very cynical view, and I want to emphasize also, and I'll say this upfront, it is very, very understandable, again, in the current world, that you may genuinely feel a sense of cynicism. It's very well placed to feel that. But when we look at its utility, we're going to encounter some problems. So we've, like, I really want to validate, it is absolutely normal and understandable that you might be feeling cynical about the goodness of humanity, for example. But as a cynic, what happens is, we bring a lens through which we view the world with negativity and threat. So
25:51 Speaker 00 as a cynic, I sit back here and I am, I'm moving away with my friend, and I am, I'm scanning the environment for threat based cues. Now, what we know, like, across so many different experiences for individuals and for collective groups, is that the more focused we are on threat, the more likely we will see it and the more likely we'll experience it in even the benign behaviour of others.
26:17 Speaker 04 That's almost like we attract it.
26:19 Speaker 00 Exactly. So if I go in expecting for you to be dismissive or rude, or for you to not help me, then my, for example, my body language going in, my tone of voice as I'm speaking to you, um, the way I might express something, so I might maybe even be more blunt or more demanding or more defensive. All of those micro behaviours, in addition to where my attention is being placed, is going to make it more likely that this turns into a self fulfilling prophecy.
26:52 Speaker 03 And also, yeah, that, but I feel like you were talking to Ryan hypothetically then, like, if you're looking for threats from Ryan, you're more likely to act in that way to him, but I feel like to everything that happens around you, not just to Ryan.
27:05 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
27:06 Speaker 03 Anyone else in your world who maybe has the best of intentions or whatever is still going to get caught up in that.
27:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so it can be a lens through which we are viewing the world and are experiencing it. And then we just get confirmation that this is true and we get confirmation that I shouldn't have high expectations of people. I should lower my expectations because I don't have faith in humanity. I don't have faith in the goodness of people.
27:35 Speaker 03 Hmm.
27:36 Speaker 00 And what happens then, when we're cynical, is that we stop taking action
27:43 Speaker 00 and we move again, quite potentially into despair, or sometimes we can move into um, that kind of like, uh, more aggressive, uh, hating space. And we see this all the time on social media.
27:59 Speaker 04 I feel like it's getting worse too in social, uh, online.
28:03 Speaker 00 Yes, and that is such a key point there, and that is that it's, it's actually, online is not representing the actual goodness in humans, right? So we begin through exposure to social media and media and general journalism as well, is that we're actually getting a very thin slice of the world. But that thin slice is is taking over our whole perception of what's currently happening. And it's as though like the intel we're getting is not accurate.
28:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
28:36 Speaker 02 And that's us who knows life without social media.
28:40 Speaker 00 Yes.
28:40 Speaker 02 Then there's the whole generation of people who don't know life without it, and that is their world.
28:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. And so if we're only gathering information from these sources, then I think it certainly adds such a vulnerability to us feeling cynical and hopeless and despairing.
28:57 Speaker 04 It's, I love the way you say the thin slice, because I feel like it's the way you talked about it is like a thin slice that then gets stretched out across your entire twenty four hours.
29:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:06 Speaker 04 Of your day.
29:07 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
29:07 Speaker 04 Because I I often hear people talk about it like social, like saying it's not real, or it's just one aspect. But then you think about the amount of time, especially younger people, but people are immersed in it. It is very real to them.
29:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:18 Speaker 04 But it's such a beautiful way of saying it, that it's like one
29:20 Speaker 00 Hmm.
29:21 Speaker 04 thin slice of the human condition.
29:23 Speaker 00 Exactly.
29:23 Speaker 04 That then gets stretched out over everything.
29:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
29:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
29:27 Speaker 00 And it begins to colour our, again, colour our sense that we can, we have capacity to change. And we have within us this ability to, like, if we slow down enough and look at, look at our experiences like a curious scientist, so that can bring a skepticism, but is not layering on with threat and disillusionment and anger and hatred. So there was some interesting research that Dr. Zaki did around the notion of trust. And like, as you can imagine, our trust in institutions, in the government, in the media has plummeted.
30:07 Speaker 00 And what is interesting is that trust and hope tends to track experiences of inequality. So when there are big, like when there's big exposure to inequality and discrimination, for example, which is what we're definitely being exposed to, and what people are genuinely experiencing in the current world, is that the the more cynical we will begin to feel. So it tracks inequality. Does that make sense?
30:34 Speaker 04 Yep.
30:34 Speaker 00 Yep, okay. So when Dr. Zaki asked about trust, there was this broad question that was for US respondents, and it was, do you think you can trust most people?
30:49 Speaker 00 And thirty percent of respondents said yes, but seventy percent said no, we cannot trust most people. But then the question was, when you zoom down and you ask, can you trust people in your local community and your neighbours? The response doubled. So the response of yes doubled.
31:12 Speaker 02 That's interesting.
31:13 Speaker 00 Well, it's really important because when we come down to our, what is within our control is how we are showing up in our individual lives and in our communities. And we can see people passing by and we can have engagements with them. We notice that these are just average people, that they're not megalomaniacs and narcissists and, you know, I don't want to be too transparent about what I'm saying here. But, but when we zoom in and look at what is in our current environment, in our local community, we actually notice that trust is pretty good. That we can actually trust most people when it's within our local communities and our neighbourhoods.
31:57 Speaker 02 It's so, it's funny, isn't it? That thing of, I've always been really bad at getting to know my neighbours. Like around where I live. It's just not something that was a big part of growing up and it's just not a big part of my life now. But recently, there's like, there's one woman and she's got a couple of kids and she lives a few doors down. And when I see her and I speak to her, there's like a real sense of like warmth to this person just because she lives close.
32:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, yes.
32:26 Speaker 02 Like, I don't necessarily, I don't really know anything about her.
32:28 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:29 Speaker 02 Except for like the three quick conversations that I've had with her in the street. But the sense that she's like, like the buildings are connected by a few, like by like twenty metres or something. It's, I don't know, it's just like.
32:45 Speaker 02 It's really nice to see her. It's so weird, isn't it?
32:48 Speaker 00 It is.
32:48 Speaker 02 Why is that?
32:49 Speaker 00 Well, I think we're all craving, we're all yearning for a sense of belonging and a sense of community. Um, and it's just not felt in the same way online. Like, for example, our nervous systems regulating with each other, like that I can pick up how you're feeling and you can pick up how I'm feeling. I can notice your body language, I can read more, I've got more cues to take in when I'm with you. And so, yes, I have very strong beliefs around the importance of face-to-face contact. And the research obviously very much is in line with that.
33:24 Speaker 02 Hmm.
33:24 Speaker 00 And this is also kind of, if we come full circle, it's coming back to. So a collective hopefulness is how we start in our communities. Rather than looking at the broader picture, which feels so dire.
33:38 Speaker 02 Hmm.
33:38 Speaker 00 Because if we look at that dire picture, we will feel despair and it will feel like nothing has changed. Or that we're regressing in some way.
33:46 Speaker 02 Hmm.
33:47 Speaker 00 So if we, if we just to look for a second at, at this kind of collective hopefulness and then we'll move on to the individual because that's particularly important. But um, one of the ways in which we can start to almost like facilitate and cultivate this greater faith in humanity that, that we will get through and that we will be able to cultivate and create a life that is worth living and a life that is approaching these adversities in a way that's helpful. So there's a, a number of things that we can do there. The first is, um, is, is having an attunement to your own internal experience and to be able to notice and name what is here. So I'm noticing I feel a deep grief.
34:30 Speaker 00 This is the first thing is that when hopefulness is being threatened and helplessness and hopelessness is, is like really at the fore. Is to deeply acknowledge that there is a loss here. And this is particularly the case for things like climate change is the grief. And, and this might sound big, but there's a grief for the planet. Um. But if we keep our heads in the sand and we deny that this is here, or we get fused with anger and rage, w- we actually don't move towards action.
35:03 Speaker 03 There's no progress.
35:04 Speaker 00 There's no progress.
35:06 Speaker 03 Hmm.
35:06 Speaker 00 And so this first part here, and this does apply with individuals very, very much, is being able to acknowledge the truth that is here. So that requires us to zoom out from the social media that we're consuming and to really bring a curious lens to what is this truth that's here. Can we have a whole picture perspective of the facts now? I could reel off a whole lot of um very optimistic and very hopeful stats around how much the world has changed, particularly and how it's progressed, but I know that that actually could also feel uh like it's being naive.
35:42 Speaker 03 Hmm.
35:42 Speaker 00 Um. But even just little, small things that you can notice, like for example, the other day I was watching um the first Bridget Jones' Diary and and this will be the same for any early two thousands or even like well beyond that kinds of movies. And in the movie, like they are very, very obvious and alarming attitudes towards women.
36:06 Speaker 03 Hmm.
36:06 Speaker 00 That in, so I was eighteen, nineteen in my early, like in the early two thousands, that we had brought no attention to whatsoever. It was just status quo that
36:17 Speaker 03 Hmm.
36:17 Speaker 00 this is how women were treated.
36:19 Speaker 03 Is it as bad as never being kissed?
36:21 Speaker 02 I haven't seen it.
36:22 Speaker 03 Drew Barrymore, in her late twenties, admits that she's never kissed someone as a journalist. So her boss sends her undercover to school, so she's a schoolgirl undercover. She then has a crush on a boy at school as a twenty eight year old and starts dating him, but then a teacher like falls in love with her.
36:39 Speaker 02 Thinking she's a student.
36:41 Speaker 00 Oh, God.
36:42 Speaker 03 And then she, and then he gets angry
36:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:44 Speaker 03 at her at the formal because she's into this kid she's dating. Then she reveals that she's an undercover journalist as a teach, as a, but like, and then the teacher gets angrier again.
36:56 Speaker 02 Teacher loses interest.
36:58 Speaker 03 Well, he says, how dare you, like, I fell in love with you as a student and now I'm finding out that you're.
37:02 Speaker 04 And now I'm betrayed that you're an adult.
37:05 Speaker 02 That is.
37:06 Speaker 04 Wow.
37:06 Speaker 03 That's.
37:07 Speaker 02 Fuck.
37:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
37:08 Speaker 00 But I think like that's so representative of the fact that we can also really lose sight of actually what has changed and how we've progressed. Um, and it feels really disarming when you do get exposed to like 20 years ago, this is how we were living in the world. You know, even statistically, if we look at life expectancies, if we look at science, medicine, if we look at, um, even obviously all the science that's going into climate change, we have come an enormous way and that we have come from is hopefulness and action.
37:41 Speaker 04 That's, that's brought along that change.
37:43 Speaker 00 Exactly. Yeah. Yeah.
37:45 Speaker 04 I agree with you and I think about it quite a bit and I, I, I think about it when I see people in the specific area of like, uh, sort of healthcare.
37:55 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
37:56 Speaker 04 Being very angry and questioning, uh, medical authorities and stuff. And I think, yes, they've made mistakes over the years, but you're ignoring all the things they've gotten right and not looking at the ledger equally.
38:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:08 Speaker 04 But I imagine for a lot of people, what you just said would be a very challenging thing to hear because they see everyday, uh, mistakes or even regressions on some social issues, some, in some places. So for people who, and I, I probably count myself in this batch that find it, get distracted by the, the, um, the bright, shining awful lights of bad things happening. How do you train yourself to look for?
38:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:39 Speaker 04 The good things and, and, and am I being naive?
38:45 Speaker 00 Hmm.
38:46 Speaker 04 To hold on to those things and, and, and what do I do with the bad stuff? Does that make sense?
38:50 Speaker 00 Yes, absolutely. I think this is a really, really important point. We have to have both. And we have to hold on in some ways to both. And I'll explain what I mean by that. And that is that we do not want to deny or, um, ignore or push away the suffering that is here.
39:12 Speaker 00 And if we don't witness it, if we are not witness to the suffering that is happening, both in our local communities and also in the world, then no action will happen. So, and this is where I'm coming to this, this kind of acknowledgement of the truth, is being able to bring a lens of it, like, again, this kind of curious scientist, that we can step back and really check what our intel is. And also then, when we can see, and I mean, we all know, we all know what's happening in the world, and it's deeply devastating, but if we turn away from it, again, nothing happens. Um, and so in that space of seeing what is here, we have to also acknowledge and grieve the loss that is here for a future that we may have hoped for.
39:57 Speaker 00 Um, and so that, like, that's doing some acceptance work. And, um, you know, from, from the way in which I would work would be really slowing down and being able to open to what's here and to, to give it space and to honour it. And then to bring in some compassion for the suffering that we're encountering. So this is this first bit is we, is acknowledging the truthfulness of this experience. We do not, and I do not want to be sitting here naively saying, like, don't worry about that. It's not about that. We have to acknowledge the suffering that's here and then we recalibrate. So then it's, let's reimagine what hope looks like.
40:39 Speaker 00 Let's reimagine and reorient ourselves to what is a possibility. And so that, that is going to come back then into action and goals.
40:51 Speaker 02 The image that has been like screaming at me in my head this whole time is, it makes so much more sense to me now knowing what hope is and what it means to people and how important it is. But it makes so much sense that Obama used it as his, like, first campaign word. It was just like huge post, all it said was hope. And I think at the time I was like, yeah, hope. But clearly that was like well researched and very intentional.
41:23 Speaker 04 Like it didn't say optimistic.
41:24 Speaker 02 Exactly. It was very much intentional, obviously.
41:28 Speaker 04 Yeah.
41:29 Speaker 00 The other part of this, I think that we really need to be very acute to or aware of is that there is enormous vulnerability in hoping for something.
41:38 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:39 Speaker 00 Run.
41:40 Speaker 04 Yeah.
41:40 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:40 Speaker 00 Because being hopeful exposes us to uncertainty. And it exposes us to like a yearning that we might have for something and the possibility that it won't happen.
41:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
41:53 Speaker 02 Is this, is this sort of adjacent to, is it coming up for me now, adjacent to like the foreboding joy that Brené Brown talks about? Like, I know, like, I'm always really careful not to hope for something that I really want.
42:05 Speaker 00 Yes.
42:05 Speaker 02 Um, particularly out loud.
42:07 Speaker 00 Yes.
42:07 Speaker 02 Because I'm worried that I'll like jinx it or get disappointed or whatever.
42:11 Speaker 00 Yes, that's exactly it. It's exactly it because when you turn the mind to this sense of belief of hope, like that there is a, a hope that this could happen, it exposes us deeply to the possibility it won't. And that, that would feel like on the one end of the scale, it might feel disappointing. On the other hand, end of the scale, it might feel deeply traumatic.
42:34 Speaker 02 Hmm.
42:35 Speaker 00 Um, and so, so it is, there's a risk involved in hoping, but the alternative
42:44 Speaker 00 is being cynical.
42:45 Speaker 04 Hmm.
42:46 Speaker 00 And lowering expectations and actively denying a yearning that we might have.
42:51 Speaker 02 There's a real, I think there's a real, I know, speaking from my own perspective, I think there's a real sense of like self-protection.
42:59 Speaker 00 Hmm.
42:59 Speaker 02 In, in not hoping for something.
43:01 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah. And my question with that is always, how much does it protect you from disappointment?
43:09 Speaker 02 No, well, I guess it, it, I guess it doesn't ultimately, but for the specific thing, I, I can't help but think like, oh, but if I just don't hope for it too much, and if it happens, it happens, that's great.
43:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
43:21 Speaker 02 But if I'm out there saying, I, if I'm out there telling people, I really hope that, you know, I win an award or whatever. I really hope. And if I'm telling people that and I'm making that known, then it's like, well, I do really hope for it, like as an example. But if I keep saying it, I'm going to be really embarrassed.
43:41 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
43:42 Speaker 02 If it doesn't happen.
43:43 Speaker 00 Hmm. Mm hmm.
43:45 Speaker 04 Uh, I also think built into that, when talking about the way you defined hope earlier, that there's an action sort of plan.
43:52 Speaker 00 Yeah.
43:52 Speaker 04 I think it's also a, for me, the idea that I put myself out there and was wrong. Like I.
43:58 Speaker 02 Yeah.
43:59 Speaker 04 The plan was wrong or like.
44:00 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
44:01 Speaker 04 I, I commit, yeah.
44:03 Speaker 02 You didn't do it right.
44:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
44:04 Speaker 02 Or you failed.
44:05 Speaker 04 I failed. Not that.
44:08 Speaker 04 Because it feels like it has to be paired with that plan of action that I've come up with.
44:11 Speaker 00 Yes.
44:12 Speaker 04 Then, and yeah, I was wrong. And the fear of being just wrong, I guess, but I, but to answer your question before, I guess if you don't have any hope and you're cynical, then you, then you never get there anyway.
44:24 Speaker 00 Exactly.
44:24 Speaker 04 So the outcomes that.
44:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:26 Speaker 04 The, yeah, the outcome's gonna be the same.
44:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:29 Speaker 04 Yeah.
44:29 Speaker 00 So another thing that I wanna mention or really kind of pay attention to, you know, whenever we're talking about hope, um, is really acknowledging, deeply acknowledging the complicated grief and the despair that comes also with losing someone through suicide. So whether this is losing a child or losing a friend or a partner. And really acknowledging, you know, how we find hopefulness in a place of such great sorrow and despair, knowing also that that person that you loved so deeply had lost hope.
45:05 Speaker 04 Hmm.
45:06 Speaker 00 The kind of really, I just really wanna pay attention there to how hard this might feel and how challenging this might feel to be listening to this today.
45:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
45:15 Speaker 00 Um, perhaps thinking about your loved one and wondering how it was that they, that they felt so hopeless. Um, that that was the action that was taken. You know, we do know that, you know, the research tells us that experiencing the loss of someone through suicide is also a risk factor for your own. Um, increased vulnerability towards suicide as well. It's profoundly impactful, um, and it absolutely erodes. It erodes our hopefulness and I, I wanna be really clear that there's, that when we think about moving into hopelessness, this is not an attribution of blame as though we can choose to be hopeful or not to be hopeful.
45:59 Speaker 00 Um, I, I wanna be very, very clear about that. It is, it is not a choice we're making to lose hope. Our circumstances, the lives we've experienced, the trauma we've faced is leading us to a place where it feels very hard to be alive. Um, and the work that we do, you know, as therapists and the work that we do as friends and parents is being able to, to very gently and very slowly find a way of one small slither.
46:32 Speaker 00 Of moving, moving forward with one step. And so again, I want to emphasise that this can feel very, very challenging. If you're hearing this and you've had your own experience of losing someone to suicide. Equally, losing someone in general, finding hopefulness can feel nearly impossible. And so, you know, I think for a start, we have to, as I've mentioned before, we really have to pay attention to grieving. And accepting the loss and finding a way to make sense of this loss. To make meaning of this person's life. And then this question that always shows up for me.
47:13 Speaker 00 Uh, in the face of great adversity and great loss and challenge is what is it that I want to stand for in the face of this loss? I can't change what's happened. I can grieve what's here, but what do I want to stand for now? And that I think can open us up to something that is in my control.
47:36 Speaker 03 Hmm, wow, beautiful.
47:39 Speaker 02 Yeah.
47:39 Speaker 03 Um, I've been trying to work out the right time to bring this up. I do this thing every single night before I go to sleep in bed. It's the, I don't, I never knew what it was, but now I think it's probably. Link to hope, but.
47:51 Speaker 02 He's had the birds and the bees chat.
47:58 Speaker 02 Just worked it out.
47:58 Speaker 03 It's an interesting time to bring it up, but go on.
48:01 Speaker 02 We all know about it, but yeah, go on. It'll be interesting to hear your take.
48:05 Speaker 03 Every night.
48:07 Speaker 02 Still haven't worked it out. This weird thing I've been.
48:14 Speaker 03 So before I go to sleep and I'm lying there, just before I start dozing. I imagine two or three things. That I would love to happen. I imagine them happening and what it would feel like. And the three things that keep happening to me. They're, they're three goals that I have.
48:34 Speaker 02 You intentionally think about it, like you choose to think about it.
48:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's a nice way to fall asleep.
48:37 Speaker 02 Whoa.
48:38 Speaker 03 So for example, and this is like a very trivial one.
48:41 Speaker 02 You are so the resilience project sometimes.
48:47 Speaker 02 Sometimes I'm like, seriously? You actually do that? Wow.
48:52 Speaker 03 But I'd like, I would, I bring this up to a lot of people to try it. It's a lovely way to fall asleep. But this will sound trivial after what I've just talked about, but it's at a, at a personal level. So I am mad, I have a goal of running the 400 metres under 52 seconds.
49:09 Speaker 03 And I imagine, as I'm falling asleep, what it would feel like to do that. I just imagine it and just think, gosh, imagine you could run that fast. And I've had that goal for the last three years and I've gone close, but I haven't yet done it. But it does, but it's so, it's, it's driven my behaviour, which is to train really, really hard in hope that would happen. Hasn't happened yet. Like I've failed every Saturday in summer for the last three, more than that for five years now. I've failed every single Saturday of summer. I don't get there. But I don't, I don't feel like a fad at all. It's just that, it's that hopeful thought has driven really positive behaviour. There's another one that I think about on a much deeper level.
49:49 Speaker 03 Again, it's about our family and it will make a lot more sense in a week's time when another episode comes about, uh, out about some stuff our family's going through. But I imagine one of our kids as a young adult thriving in the world. And that feels like it's a long way off, both, you know, from the time point of view, but also the way they're going at the moment. I, I just imagine them thriving in the world as I fall asleep. It's a very hopeful thought, but it, it inspires, the thought is so wonderful on both counts, but probably more the second one. The thought is so wonderful that it inspires the hard work that has to get done to get there. It inspires it every single day and it drives it.
50:34 Speaker 03 And it's, yep, it's another appointment. Yes, it's another issue we need to deal with or it's another, but you do it because the thought every night of it, you know what it feels like. We don't exactly know, but you imagine it before you go to sleep. So, and then like, yeah, that's just a practical thing that I've, you know, I did, I wasn't going to bed going, right, time to practise, hopeful. But it's just, that's just what I do.
50:54 Speaker 00 That's beautiful. And it's also so incredibly spot on with the way that we work with hope.
51:01 Speaker 00 Cause part of this is opening up the mind to, to imagining a better future. And that's something that we will actively avoid doing. And now this is not certainly about like manifesting. I want to be clear that this is not woo woo. And I don't want to woo, oh God, I don't want to woo woo manifesting it.
51:21 Speaker 00 How the manifest is coming for me. No, what I'm, from a, like an evidence based point of view is that, is that there is something so powerful about us turning our mind to the possibility and to envisaging it as an outcome. Because you're absolutely right. It drives our action and it inspires us, like you said. It's, it's a very vulnerable thing to do, but it also deeply reflects usually our values and this valued direction that we want to head in. If you were to ask any elite athlete, being able to imagine themselves winning a race, then envisaging and imagining and viewing themselves in those
52:02 Speaker 00 moments is a very, very common practice. Now, again, this is not about being unrealistic. So we need to actually think about when we're, we're looking at hopefulness, what is within our capacity and what is within our environment and our resources. Now for me to hope for something like, I don't know, to hope to win the Lotto, I mean, that's actually a wish for a start. That's just a wish. There's nothing I can do aside from buying a ticket. There's nothing I can do towards that. Equally, I can't hope to live to a thousand because it's not actually reasonable or possible, right? So we need to make sure that when we're thinking about hope is that it is, that there is a possibility in there that
52:47 Speaker 00 this can happen.
52:48 Speaker 02 I think that's, for me, that's where it's scary to hope.
52:51 Speaker 00 Exactly.
52:52 Speaker 02 It's scary to hope for the things that you can, that you can make happen. Because I think it, like what I was saying before, but also what Josh was saying about the, the fear of failing to, failing to do it.
53:03 Speaker 00 And now it doesn't protect you from failing. So when failure or when an outcome happens that is undesirable and it's not what we're hoping for. Then this is again such an important moment to slow down and to give ourselves some grace and compassion for the disappointment, for the sadness, for the loss that's here.
53:26 Speaker 02 Hmm.
53:26 Speaker 00 And then, and once, once we've been able to do that, whether that's with support from other people or not, is then to realign and to look forward again to what is the next thing I can do? What is my next goal? And usually, and this is particularly the case, for example, when we're looking at palliative care or terminal illness or medical diagnoses. And that is that at the start of a diagnosis, you might hope for cure. And then as time goes on and things unfold, then our pathways of hope change. But hope is so instrumental to the quality of life of that person.
54:05 Speaker 02 Hmm.
54:06 Speaker 00 So we then recalibrate and we look at what is the new pathway of hope here? What is it that I'm, almost like again, like checking in with our values, like where is this value direction? And I hope to be able to show up to the family that I love and to let them know that I love them and I care for them. So the pathway changes. It doesn't have to cling on to the one outcome that we originally started with.
54:33 Speaker 02 Unstuck, I'm unstuck. That, that got me. I think that, that, I think I get it, I get it. Now, I didn't really understand, but I think that example of uh the, the, the quality of life.
54:48 Speaker 00 Yes.
54:48 Speaker 02 On the pathway to the thing you're hoping for. That's the kind of like um uh process over product.
54:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
54:57 Speaker 02 Sort of uh theory as well, where it's like journey, not destination.
55:02 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
55:02 Speaker 02 And make, make sure that the, if hope really is, uh which it clearly is, improving the quality of life and our general.
55:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
55:10 Speaker 02 Mental wellbeing, then why not?
55:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
55:15 Speaker 02 Why not hope uh if it's going to make the journey, the quality of the journey that much better?
55:21 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
55:21 Speaker 02 Because often the destination is something that's sometimes out of your control anyway.
55:25 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
55:27 Speaker 02 Yeah.
55:27 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
55:27 Speaker 04 When you mentioned, and this is a lot more trivial than what you were talking about then, but to, with terminal illness, but to go back to a much more, I guess, um. Black and white example of the athlete that imagines a hopeful outcome of winning, say, a gold medal at the Olympics. I immediately thought of all the athletes that had imagined it and lost and didn't win. But as you were talking then, it seems to me that the, of course, like if you hope and imagine winning an Olympic medal in four years' time and you work, you have a, you work towards it for four years and you don't win, I'm sure, I'd have to ask athletes, but I'm sure there are some that it's absolutely devastating.
56:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
56:11 Speaker 04 But I guess in the long term, you've lived your life the way you wanted to for the last four years to get there.
56:17 Speaker 00 Yes.
56:17 Speaker 04 And regardless.
56:18 Speaker 03 Performed a hell of a lot better because of that hope.
56:21 Speaker 04 But, but, yeah, exactly. And you wouldn't have any regret about hoping?
56:25 Speaker 00 Yeah. You may actually have regret.
56:28 Speaker 04 Okay.
56:29 Speaker 00 Because you may, in the moment, of feeling so deeply upset at the loss, you may have, you may, like, that critic is going to come in and say, like, why did you bother hoping?
56:39 Speaker 04 Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, maybe in the long run.
56:40 Speaker 00 Yes, in the long run, like, when you zoom out, like, I'm so proud of myself for, for the effort rather than the outcome. And hope got you to this place. Now, if, if we take the example of an elite athlete, if there wasn't hope, if they didn't want, yearn for, expect this outcome.
57:02 Speaker 04 Have an action plan.
57:03 Speaker 00 Then there would be no, there would be no action. Like, my suspicion is that they would stop.
57:08 Speaker 04 Yeah.
57:09 Speaker 00 Or turn their attention to something else. So, hope never protects us from pain, but the pain of staying stuck and staying still is so much more profound.
57:20 Speaker 04 Yeah.
57:22 Speaker 00 It's, it's a really complex, it's a really complex notion and concept. And it sometimes feels intangible. You know, I've spoken, I guess, more broadly around this kind of collective idea and then obviously kind of individually, like how we cultivate more hope. There are a couple of key strategies I wanted to mention to kind of give this a sense that, that there's something that I can do to really cultivate this. The first one comes back to what, what's already been a theme here, and that is this idea of, of social connection. And what Dr. Zaki refers to actually as social savouring.
58:00 Speaker 00 And when you look at all the research on awe, Dacher Keltner is a very prominent researcher in this area, and I know Julia Bead's come on and spoken so beautifully about awe. And in the research, in terms of awe, one of the biggest predictors of our experience of awe, and therefore hopefulness, is moral beauty. Now, moral beauty is the beauty that comes from the goodness of people and witnessing them. And so that means, for example, being able to savour and to be present and attuned to
58:38 Speaker 00 an act that someone is doing in your presence that is beautiful, kind or caring. And the thing that is so important in that is that acts of moral beauty, this will make me tearful, acts of moral beauty are most likely to show up for us when we're deep in pain and darkness. Hmm. Because we experience the kindness of others and we experience a sense that we are not alone. And that feeling that I am not alone is what allows us to keep going. So my, I guess, invitation is to see if you can just keep your eye out and to slow down
59:23 Speaker 00 to notice, like, these moments here when people are being good. Hmm. Then people are showing up to you when people just do things that you never expected them to do. Hmm. There's a, this is quite a small moment, but it's always stuck in my mind. I had, when I was about twenty-three or twenty-four, I was in- The Bourne Cinema? It was probably around that time, actually, maybe a little bit later. Tick. Yeah. Got that mention every episode. I was in a, I would probably say, rather, um, a toxic relationship at that time.
1:00:01 Speaker 00 And I had made the decision that I was going to go overseas to meet his family, because he wasn't from Australia, and that it was at Christmas time. And- That the relationship had been quite distressing and very unhelpful and I could go into that, but I won't. Um, and so I made this decision with a, in retrospect, an optimism that things will be okay and things will work out. And that this would be a good thing for me to do, to go over there for Christmas. But as I was leaving, I knew so deep down in my gut that this was, uh, this was not a relationship I should be in.
1:00:40 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:00:41 Speaker 00 And that I was leaving my family, my very loving family, um, for Christmas, which for me is, and for many people is a particularly important time. And so I said goodbye to my parents and I'm always very tearful in airport. And then I got on the plane. And I was sitting on the plane before we'd taken off and I had kind of like silent tears coming down my face. Cause there was this deep acknowledgement that I shouldn't be in this relationship. And.
1:01:04 Speaker 02 Were you with him?
1:01:05 Speaker 00 No, I was meeting him over there.
1:01:07 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
1:01:07 Speaker 00 And so I was kind of silently crying there and then someone three rows ahead of me, we still hadn't taken off yet. Um, a man, he might've been in his sixties, perhaps around that age, passed a note to me and I opened it up. And to be honest, I can't even really remember what it said, but it was something like, um.
1:01:30 Speaker 00 It wasn't this, but it was like, this too shall pass.
1:01:33 Speaker 02 Whoa.
1:01:34 Speaker 00 And you're not alone. And.
1:01:37 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
1:01:37 Speaker 04 Wow.
1:01:38 Speaker 00 Like in that moment, it was such a small, tiny thing that this person did. But even to this day, like almost 20 years later, the, like, they're the moments that tell us.
1:01:52 Speaker 02 Oh my god.
1:01:53 Speaker 00 There's so much goodness here that we can hope for.
1:01:56 Speaker 02 I'm gonna pre-write some of those notes. That's incredible thing to do.
1:02:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
1:02:02 Speaker 02 What a hero.
1:02:03 Speaker 00 And I didn't speak to him, like, we didn't have any discussions. We were on the plane and everyone went off and did their thing.
1:02:07 Speaker 03 I hope he listens to our podcast.
1:02:10 Speaker 00 He has always stuck with me and I think we can really underestimate. Really deeply underestimate the power that we have to also cultivate hope for other people.
1:02:22 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:02:22 Speaker 00 That our small actions can also allow someone to feel really hopeful.
1:02:27 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah. Seeing, seeing someone, that's an amazing story. Like, I'm sure, I can, I can just think of a few times where I've seen strangers do something nice, or it's like a, a person has clearly stopped to have a conversation and being engaged and interested. And like, what a great person that is. And it just does, and it makes you feel hopeful about moral people and the world. Yeah.
1:02:49 Speaker 00 And so even you witnessing, and the research is very clear about this too, even you witnessing other people doing kind acts.
1:02:55 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:02:55 Speaker 00 It like elicits a feeling of hopefulness as well.
1:02:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, it does. Wow.
1:03:00 Speaker 04 It can be such a, like, that's an incredibly profound moment that you've said, but I feel like I can get that feel, almost like a lump in my throat from seeing someone, like as simple as like, I don't know, someone's trying to carry like a few boxes into their car and they're struggling and a stranger stops to help them put it in.
1:03:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:18 Speaker 04 Hmm. Like even that gets me a bit like.
1:03:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:21 Speaker 04 I can tear up over that. Like, it doesn't have to be a very profound act.
1:03:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:24 Speaker 04 That I witness, uh, or have experienced myself that changes everything.
1:03:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:30 Speaker 02 Yeah. Particularly if I see a kid doing something really nice for another kid, but I can't even imagine if it was your own kid doing something really kind. That would be like an explosion of hopefulness.
1:03:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, tears.
1:03:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. So, you know, so, social, social savouring is a, a really integral part of us being able to really create more hopefulness for us as individuals.
1:03:54 Speaker 03 Hmm. Just to, on that, um, I picked Benji up from school the other day and a boy came running out of the classroom, not Benji, and said to me, um, he said, um, can Ben, can Benji and I have a playdate? And that's always very like moving as a parent and someone else. And I said, yeah, of course. He said, yeah. Cause Benji and I have actually become very close recently.
1:04:15 Speaker 03 That's a beautiful thing to say. I mean, it was such a lovely, but coming out of an eight year old's mouth, it just.
1:04:23 Speaker 04 I uh, I wanna mention a thing, just cause I wanna make sure we put in the show notes as a link for people to watch. Um, and I've been trying to work out when to bring it in to the episode. Uh, Nick Cave on Colbert, uh, on The Late Show, Up Late? The Late Show, yeah. Um, and he, Nick Cave has these, uh, the red hand files where anyone can write to him and he'll write back to you at some point. I think he's working his way through all of them. And there's a guy who writes in about how he's growing cynical, um, and skeptical of the world. And he's really scared he's gonna pass that cynicism on to his son.
1:05:01 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:05:02 Speaker 04 And Nick Cave's response to that is one of the most beautiful, and he reads it out loud on Colbert, but we could link to the actual letter on the show. Um, his response to that is one of the most incredible pieces of writing I've ever read and is full of so much of what you've spoken about today.
1:05:17 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:05:18 Speaker 04 Um, and I, yeah, I just highly recommend people to read it and maybe hear him read it out loud, cause it's, um, it represents a lot of what you've talked about today. And there's a lot of moral beauty in what he
1:05:30 Speaker 00 That is incredible.
1:05:30 Speaker 04 talks about, yeah.
1:05:33 Speaker 00 I mean, there are so many, there are so many examples, and I think that this is the thing we, we, we also just need to be on the lookout for them. Um, there are many, many things that we could do to cultivate this, but we, I don't wanna like have you talking for another 20 hours. There is a really important part that is to do with action taking. Um, so when we think about those three cognitive parts originally from the very beginning of like theorizing hope, we've got goals, pathways and agency.
1:06:04 Speaker 00 When we set a goal, there's our goal. We then have a pathway so we can see the, the route that we're gonna take. We also have the energy. Now it's time for the action. So now it's time for the movement. There is, um, a wonderful therapist called Robin Walsa. She's an act therapist, acceptance and commitment therapy. And she has a beautiful saying, and I use it all the time, and it has a great deal of resonance for me. And that is that in life, we live from the feet up. We live life from the feet up and what that means is that we move first and then our head and our heart follow. So in essence, we take action and then the action creates the feeling.
1:06:47 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:06:47 Speaker 00 The action creates the belief.
1:06:49 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:06:50 Speaker 00 Um, now, like in lots of different aspects of psychology, you know, there's the notion of action before motivation or act better to feel better. It's this idea that nothing changes in stillness. We have to move.
1:07:04 Speaker 02 Oh.
1:07:05 Speaker 00 In order to create and cultivate what we're looking for, rather than waiting for the feeling to then act on it.
1:07:12 Speaker 02 Right.
1:07:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:07:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, so you have to sort of do the thing and experience the thing.
1:07:17 Speaker 00 Yes.
1:07:17 Speaker 02 To then understand it or feel it.
1:07:19 Speaker 00 Yes.
1:07:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, okay.
1:07:21 Speaker 00 So an example that I might have, like in therapy, could be something like, um, if we're gonna live life from the feet up, we actively shift our feet first in the direction of our values. So it's like a literal turning of the feet to the direction that is important to me. Now, if we use exercise, and I'll use this all the time, it's a very applicable example. It might be something like my, my values are around health and longevity, being alive so I can care for my kids, for example. And part of that would be a goal to exercise three times a week. But I'm coming from a basis of not doing any exercise at all. So for me, and in therapy, is that the goals have to be very, very small. The goal is to put your exercise clothes on and walk to the front door.
1:08:06 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:08:06 Speaker 00 That is you shifting your feet in the direction, that is you moving your feet and your head and your heart will follow.
1:08:13 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:08:13 Speaker 00 Um, now, you may get to the door and not do it today, but the action and the willingness to do it was you putting the clothes on.
1:08:22 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:08:22 Speaker 00 And so over time, we would see, okay, so I put the clothes on and no, I didn't get there. That's okay. There was a shifting of the feet, there was a willingness there. And then the next day, you go out the front door and then it's walking down a hundred metres down the street. So we have to really kind of be very small in our goals initially when things are feeling particularly helpless and hopeless.
1:08:44 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:08:44 Speaker 00 Um, you know, for anyone that has suffered from depression. And a sense of despair, those small movements can feel extremely overwhelming. And so we really need to be checking in with what our capacity is. But that movement needs to happen, otherwise nothing will change.
1:09:02 Speaker 02 Hmm. It it may, and this may or may not be contextual to what you're talking about. But, and I think I've spoken about this at some point on the podcast, but years ago, I kind of realised that what I, from like a creative point of view, when I, if I wanted to make something, I always had dreams and goals of making like a full TV show. Or, you know, people have dreams of making a, writing a play or making a film or something like big goals that require lots of things to go right and either money or people to help or whatever. And the thing I kind of realised is like, oh, it's actually, I need to set some really, really achievable goals for myself. And that goal might be making a video on Instagram or it might be like
1:09:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:09:47 Speaker 02 writing a, I don't know, like 200 word article or whatever. But what I found from doing that was the, the sort of self-worth, but I guess what it also was, was hope and belief. I got from actually finishing those things.
1:10:03 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:10:04 Speaker 02 Was immense.
1:10:05 Speaker 00 Yes.
1:10:06 Speaker 02 And I, and from finishing even these really small things, because I set it as a goal and then I did it. It's like, huh, I did something.
1:10:15 Speaker 00 Yes, yes.
1:10:15 Speaker 02 And I think that kind of like helped me build hope within myself and just like my self-worth went up and like confidence in my abilities and and it just, and it's, and I didn't, I never thought it would come from doing such little things. But I, I, whenever anyone makes the foolish decision to ask me for advice and when it comes to some creativity, I just say like, set the smallest goal you can think of.
1:10:39 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:10:39 Speaker 02 And just do that and just keep doing small little things. Cause it does, for me at least, it did really build my, my confidence and, and, and hope.
1:10:47 Speaker 00 Yeah. And it's interesting because that's really reflective of what the research shows us too. And this notion, and I think it, I have a feeling it's Dr. Zaki that says this, but it's the same concept. And that is that hope begets hope. So when you complete that, you feel hopeful, it makes you wanna hope for more?
1:11:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:11:05 Speaker 00 Um, it actually makes you, and like it's a catalyst for more.
1:11:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, cause you've shown yourself, you can do it.
1:11:10 Speaker 00 Exactly. Yeah. And it's similar to Barbara Fredrickson's upward spiral of, of happiness and wellbeing. And that is that the more we do, the more we want, the more we get, that kind of notion that it actually kind of becomes very self reinforcing.
1:11:24 Speaker 04 Hmm.
1:11:24 Speaker 00 Obviously, the opposite is also true in terms of depression and helplessness and despair as well.
1:11:29 Speaker 04 Mm hmm.
1:11:30 Speaker 00 Is that the more we don't like it, the more we don't want it, the more we look out for danger, the worse it becomes.
1:11:35 Speaker 04 Yep.
1:11:35 Speaker 00 Yep.
1:11:36 Speaker 04 For me, I, and for, I think for a lot of people, the act of ending up in a position of handing someone a note on a plane who needs help is such a huge thing. And the idea of doing that is so far outside the remit of, requires so much hope.
1:11:51 Speaker 00 Mm hmm.
1:11:51 Speaker 04 And bravery to do something like that. But for me, I've recently, like the first step for me of trying to cultivate hope, and I didn't realise I was doing this, is when I wake up in the morning, rather than opening my phone, I walk out the back door. And that's ever into our backyard. And that's a difference that I've found has, and a, a course of action that's motivated.
1:12:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:12:15 Speaker 04 It's small things. So like, now I'll get a coffee and go out the back door. And then I might grab a hose and start watering the garden another day.
1:12:22 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:12:22 Speaker 04 They're tiny little things, but the difference it has on my outlook for the world.
1:12:27 Speaker 00 Hmm.
1:12:27 Speaker 04 Is enormous and it gets me out of an online environment and that wedge of the world that's pretty toxic to me.
1:12:34 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah. That's beautiful. And such a small moment of choosing.
1:12:40 Speaker 04 Yeah.
1:12:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:12:41 Speaker 04 Yeah. Because I'm not sucked into the device yet. I've got that window of going, no, don't pick it up quickly, get outside before it sucks you in. Yeah.
1:12:50 Speaker 00 There's, I'm sure you're all familiar with Viktor Frankl, um, Man's Search for Meaning, author and Holocaust survivor and psychoanalyst. And, you know, if you were ever to look for a resource or a. A feeling of inspiration, like his book is a, is a book of hopefulness. Um, in it, he talks about, you know, his experience in a prisoner camp. And what it was that got him through and what he observed was that when despair arrived for a person in the camp. When a person was overtaken with despair. It was almost as though their life was over and their life would end.
1:13:34 Speaker 00 And he talks about what it is that got him through and that hope is central to his survival. And we can see this in terms of the statistics around holding a hopefulness um for medical patients. How integral hope is for our psychological wellbeing, that it buffers against so many things. It is a resource that we can create and that we can cultivate. And I just want to read a quote from Viktor Frankl that, that I think really exemplifies exactly what we're talking about here. In his book, he says, "Everything can be taken from a man but one thing. The last of the human freedoms.
1:14:15 Speaker 00 To choose one attitude in any given set of circumstances. To choose one's own way."
1:14:26 Speaker 02 Beautiful. So, so good. Well done, Viktor.
1:14:30 Speaker 00 Indeed.
1:14:31 Speaker 04 And well done, Em.
1:14:32 Speaker 00 Thank you.
1:14:33 Speaker 02 Hmm.
1:14:34 Speaker 03 That's a, uh, the timing of this episode is just.
1:14:36 Speaker 02 Yeah, stunning.
1:14:38 Speaker 03 It's a great choice of topic, Em. Thank you so much. I feel like at a time where so many of us, um, as Josh was saying before, when you go online or watch the news or anything outside your community, really, it, it does feel, it can feel quite hopeless. Um, but you have so beautifully and articulately pointed out the ways we can discover hope in our life. Um, so thank you.
1:14:59 Speaker 00 Oh, it's my pleasure.
1:15:00 Speaker 02 So good to have you back.
1:15:02 Speaker 00 So good.
1:15:03 Speaker 03 The book is unstuck.
1:15:05 Speaker 00 Thank you, everyone.
1:15:06 Speaker 04 Thank you.
1:15:08 Speaker 02 If you enjoyed this episode, there's a very good chance you'll love the Vulnerability Mail, our weekly newsletter to help you remain imperfect. Each week we'll send you one vulnerable question inspired by the current episode to help you unpack your own imperfect life. Subscribe at www.theimperfects.com.au
Previous Matthew Murphy - A Sober Wombat Next Hannah Diviney - Disabled in an Able-Bodied World Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated