Pod Insights The Case Of Mushroom Lunch: Erin Patterson's appeal confirmed About this episode In an administrative hearing today, Erin Patterson's legal team confirmed her plans to appeal her murder conviction.
In this episode, Kristian Silva joins Stephen Stockwell to explain what we learnt from this hearing, how Patterson's appeal could unfold and the new faces on her legal team
If you've got questions about the case that you'd like Kristian and Stocky to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected] .
To recap the story of Erin Patterson's mushroom lunch, check out this series:
Mushroom Recap: The Lunch https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/mushroom-recap-1-the-lunch/105587148Mushroom Recap: Who is Erin https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/mushroom-recap-who-is-erin/105591752Mushroom Recap: The Murder Weapon https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/mushroom-recap-the-murder-weapon/105597000Mushroom Recap: The Deadly Decline https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/mushroom-recap-the-deadly-decline/105602606Mushroom Recap: The Cover Up https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/mushroom-recap-the-cover-up/105602680To catch up on how the trial of Erin Patterson unfolded, you can listen back to all our Friday Wrap episodes:
A tragic accident or ultimate betrayal? Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/a-tragic-accident-or-ultimate-betrayal/105245906What happened to the leftovers? Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/what-happened-to-the-leftovers-our-friday-wrap/105276400Death caps, DNA and drama: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/deathcaps-dna-and-drama/105303264Everything you need to know about Erin's messages: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/week-four-wrap/105330890Key moments in the case so far: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/key-moments-in-the-case-so-far-week-three-wrap/105360478Explaining Erin's evidence: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/explaining-erins-evidence-week-six-wrap/105387996The biggest moments of Erin's evidence: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/the-biggest-moments-of-erins-evidence-our-friday-wrap/105415288Kill them all, or reconnect? Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/kill-them-all-or-reconnect-our-friday-wrap-/105441452Judging Erin's lies: Our Friday Wrap https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/the-case-of/judging-erins-lies-our-friday-wrap/105470888
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:16 Speaker 01 We thought it was coming and today it was confirmed. Erin Patterson will be appealing. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:24 Speaker 02 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. Welcome to The Case of the Mushroom Lunch.
0:28 Speaker 03 Just a week after four people sat down for a family lunch in rural Victoria, three of them were dead.
0:34 Speaker 02 Homicide detectives are still piecing together what exactly happened at the lunch.
0:38 Speaker 04 It's certainly looking like, you know, the symptoms are consistent with death cap mushrooms.
0:43 Speaker 05 Erin Patterson said she bought the dried mushrooms at a supermarket and an Asian grocery store months earlier.
0:49 Speaker 04 I cannot think of another investigation that has generated this level of media and public interest.
0:59 Speaker 02 Less than a month on from the sentencing of Erin Patterson, we have suddenly found ourselves back in court today. And to bring you the latest on that hearing, her legal team and her plans for appeal, I've roped in Christian Silver to give us an update. Welcome back.
1:13 Speaker 01 Pleasure to be here. It was a very short hearing, but there's a bit to unpack.
1:17 Speaker 02 Yeah, more than you would expect to come from a, I think, a three minute hearing or four minute hearing that we had in the Victorian Supreme Court today. We had been planning on bringing you an episode of The Case of the Romance Scam today, but we did promise Patterson updates when they come. So we'll have that Q and A episode in your feed on Tuesday next week instead, which will give you the weekend to catch up on that series if you missed it. Today though, Christian, this hearing came about very quickly.
1:44 Speaker 01 It did. It was an administrative hearing, which we only found out about yesterday. Look, since the sentencing, we have been putting a bit of a timer on because the 28 day deadline to lodge an appeal was coming up. It was going to be at 11:59pm on Monday, the 6th of October. So we kind of had this date in mind, but then we found out about this hearing that was on today. And it was at that hearing where Patterson's new barrister.
2:19 Speaker 01 Confirmed that they will be lodging an appeal. But we didn't get to hear the details of that and the case was adjourned until the next time.
2:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, and yeah, the thing to kind of clarify here is that today was not an appeal hearing. But it kind of, I guess, sort of ended up being appeal related because we, yeah, we got that confirmation that Erin Patterson would be appealing her, her murder conviction.
2:41 Speaker 01 Correct. So what's going to happen now is that deadline of eleven fifty nine P M on Monday still stands to some extent. What we understand is that Patterson's lawyers will have to lodge some paperwork. But they will be granted an automatic twenty eight day extension to get the rest of it done. This is coming about because the Victorian Supreme Court is trialling something new. They've received feedback from lawyers that basically after people are sentenced, the lawyers are finding they're not having enough time to get all the paperwork ready for appeals within twenty eight days. So this is kind of saying, start the process, but we'll give you
3:22 Speaker 01 another four weeks to, to get it done properly. So I expect that's what will happen in this case too.
3:29 Speaker 02 Okay, cool. So yeah, they'll start, you know, get a couple of documents in by, by Monday next week. Date actually came around really quickly, didn't it? So they get some of that in and then I guess we, we slowly find out what, what the grounds of the appeal are because at this stage we, we don't know the grounds, do we?
3:44 Speaker 01 We don't know the grounds and, and that's the key thing. When they file the documents, they tend to give a fairly abridged version, but it's got enough in there for us to get a good sense of where they'll be heading. So I, I'm intrigued to hear what it is. I mean, usually you can't just say the jury got it wrong. We don't like their decision. They're going to have to find some sort of error in the law or something that Justice Beale did while running the trial that, you know, was very unfair to Erin Patterson or maybe something the prosecution did. Look, I'm sure over that course of that ten week trial, Colin Mandy and co were
4:24 Speaker 01 probably making a note of every time there was something they didn't like. But yeah, we'll just have to wait and see.
4:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. And yeah, like you say, these are the kind of the grounds of an appeal are basically the sort of the points of law are the various bits that they are going to try and challenge Erin Patterson's guilty verdict on. Erin Patterson guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder for the, the lunch that she held in twenty twenty three. You know, we don't know what the grounds are in this case, Christian, but from other cases that you've covered, what what could they be? And how might it look?
4:56 Speaker 01 Often, defence lawyers will go after something the prosecution did. They might say that there was an unfair tactic that's been used. You know, sometimes someone may slip up,
5:09 Speaker 01 say something that they shouldn't in front of the jury and the trial proceeds, but then the defence has a long memory and comes back to it. So they'll be maybe looking at those kinds of things. They look very closely at the judge's directions as well, and you'll remember those directions went for a week. Our listeners will definitely remember that week of the Mushroom Case Daily series, where it was just Justice Beale talking to the jury. So the defence lawyers will definitely take a look at that.
5:42 Speaker 01 They'll see, did Justice Beale say anything that was unfair to us? I wonder too, and I'm just purely speculating here,
5:51 Speaker 01 even before this trial started, Justice Beale made a number of pre-trial rulings, including evidence and knocking things out. I I'm not a lawyer, obviously, but I wonder, can they come back to some of that? And say that it was unfair, that it's something made its way into the trial that put Patterson at a major disadvantage. And this thing has also stuck in the back of my mind. Again, I don't know whether it carries any weight, but you remember right back to the very first day of the trial, when Justice Beale told the jury members, "Look, Erin Patterson was actually also charged with attempted murder in relation to her husband, but that's no longer happening. Put that out of your mind and let's proceed."
6:36 Speaker 01 And it was never spoken about again in front of the jury. But I do wonder, like, Is that a ground for appeal? Because surely some jury members didn't forget hearing about that. So I'm intrigued. I can't wait to see what it is that they'll be challenging those verdicts on.
6:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. And in terms of when we might get the grounds, when we find out exactly what those challenges are, I mean, you're saying that the deadline is Monday coming, and then there's that period where they can finish the paperwork. When do you think we will know in that period exactly what this is?
7:13 Speaker 01 I suppose it's either going to be in a few days or maybe in about a month's time when we'll get those details. So the initial deadline of the 6th of October, if you add 28 days to that, it brings you to the 3rd of November, which is just before the Melbourne Cup. Having said all that, if generally someone misses a deadline by a day or two in these courts, they're fairly forgiving. But still a very long way to play out in the process.
7:42 Speaker 02 Yeah. And how does this process play out? I mean, imagine they file the grounds for appeal, then that appeal gets heard, I assume the appeal court is in the name. And then if that's successful, another trial? How does it look?
7:55 Speaker 01 Potentially, yes. So what happens is they file the paperwork, it goes to the Court of Appeal, which is the state's highest court. And judges of the Court of Appeal will take a look at the written material that's been filed. And actually, the very first decision they'll make is, will we even consider this?
8:16 Speaker 02 Oh.
8:17 Speaker 01 If they believe, yeah, there could be some merit to this, we'll give this a chance. If they think that's the case, then they'll get the lawyers in for a proper hearing where they'll have the proper legal argument about the grounds for the appeal. And this will all just be done before a panel of the judges. There won't be any jury involved in this process. Once that's done, then those judges have to weigh it all up if they feel that Erin Patterson has been unfairly wronged to the extent where it's just so bad that it's. Basically voided her right to a fair trial.
8:57 Speaker 01 They'll order a fresh trial, you would imagine, because in Victoria, um, we don't tend to have judge only trials. So they're usually done with a jury and, and if the court of appeal was to, to rule that, then yeah, we'd be back for another mushroom trial.
9:14 Speaker 02 Uh, so more well, twenty twenty six?
9:17 Speaker 01 Definitely not twenty twenty six. I, I think at best, if it would happen, and it's a big if, it's twenty twenty seven at the earliest, but
9:28 Speaker 01 that's not to say it will be an exact repeat of the trial that we just had, you know, it could be that the prosecution reframes its case. We know Patterson took the stand. If there's another trial, maybe she decides not to.
9:42 Speaker 02 Hmm.
9:43 Speaker 01 And obviously this case has drawn attention that has just not been seen for decades.
9:53 Speaker 02 Hmm.
9:54 Speaker 01 And I'm sure that if the court of appeal saw some merits to Patterson's legal challenge, that her lawyers will say, this woman can't get a fair trial, um, she should just be let go.
10:08 Speaker 02 Wow.
10:08 Speaker 01 I'm speculating here.
10:10 Speaker 02 Hmm.
10:10 Speaker 01 But I've seen it done before where they've tried that tactic. It's pretty hard to get up.
10:14 Speaker 02 Yeah.
10:15 Speaker 01 But this is a special case.
10:17 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, I guess if there was any case or any situation where that may get up, I mean, this would be the one you would be looking pretty closely at, I imagine, so.
10:25 Speaker 01 And it is, and, and there's people who'll be listening to this podcast from other states in Australia and, and other places around the world where there is a bit of a dual system where some cases are heard by a judge only and some are by a jury, but here um, the murder cases are almost always jury cases.
10:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, right. Okay, great. Thank you, Christian. Um, you know, I think one of the interesting things about today's hearing as well, it was an administrative hearing with one very notable absence in the room. Um, listeners to this podcast would be incredibly familiar with the name Colin Mandy S C. Uh, today, he was not going to work for Aaron Patterson. We had a, a new bloke in his place, a barrister, Richard Edney.
11:07 Speaker 01 Correct. Long live Colin Mandy. I think he he served Aaron Patterson to the best of his ability, but for whatever reason, there's a change. And we've also been told that there's another barrister that's going to be joining Patterson's team. He wasn't there today, but his chambers did confirm to the ABC that he is involved. His name is Julian McMahon SC. To people who followed Australian law for a while, that name may be familiar. He's actually a lawyer who represented members of the Bali Nine on death row. He's a human rights advocate.
11:46 Speaker 01 He was Victoria's Australian of the Year in 2016. So he's a highly respected barrister. And it will be interesting to see what his involvement in all this will be going forward.
12:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, okay. Interesting to hear about the the people that are going to be working with Aaron Patterson as this goes forward. I mean, you know, the defence had this deadline of appealing the conviction of Monday. Is there anything the prosecution will be doing at this point? Are we waiting for anything from them?
12:17 Speaker 01 We are, actually. They have the option to also appeal Justice Beale's sentence. Obviously, the prosecution's not going to be challenging the jury's verdict. But they did call for Aaron Patterson to be sentenced to life in prison with no parole. And Justice Beale gave Patterson a 33-year non-parole period. So now it's up to the Office of Public Prosecutions and its director to decide whether they want to actually challenge that. We would expect to hear about a potential challenge by the end of Monday. That may or may not come. Jane Warren, one of the prosecutors that we saw during the trial, was in court today. She didn't
13:00 Speaker 01 say anything about it. So it's just a matter of waiting now.
13:04 Speaker 02 We will keep in the loop with any developments here on the case of. As soon as we have some more news for you, Christian will will drag you back into the studio and get the latest. But thank you so much for joining us for this pod.
13:15 Speaker 01 Pleasure. It feels like it will never end. And I sort of cast my mind back to that sentencing hearing where Justice Beale kind of hinted at Patterson, to me anyway, kind of saying. Don't appeal. That was the vibe I got. He didn't use those words, of course. But the fact that she's reopening this, or trying to, means that it's going to be difficult for the victims' families. They can't put a full stop on this. They'll now be wondering what comes next. It's going to take up more time for the police as well, obviously, and lawyers, taxpayers. So it does drag us all back into the fray again.
13:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely. There's a lot happening with it. And again, yeah, thinking of what this would mean for the victims' families in all of this. Ian Wilkinson as well, who was the surviving lunch guest from that meal in 2023. All of them having to think through this and, yeah, kind of relive it all again after they had probably hoped it was all over.
14:19 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, can you imagine if there was another trial and all of these witnesses would have to be called again? I don't want to think about it, to be honest.
14:29 Speaker 02 No, no, let's not think that far ahead. There's a number of steps in the way, and we'll keep you in the loop of all of them as we get to that point. The Case of will be back in your feed on Tuesday next week with the Case of the Romance Scam, a Q and A episode with James Oden and Olivia Rusay. There's that coming for you in this feed next week. And speaking of updates and appeals, there's been quite a bit of news in the case of the crock wrangler as well. So we'll be back with Ollivanna next week to catch up on some of that. There has been an appeal filed by Matt Wright's lawyers. They're also back in court next Tuesday too, so plenty to catch up on there. And we'll soon be moving on to our next case as well, the case of Snowtown Parole. One of the murderers involved in those serial killings
15:11 Speaker 02 could soon leave prison. So we're going to find out how that parole process works. This will be coming to you first through the ABC Listen app, so make sure you chase up The Case of on that, so we can be first in your ears when we come out.
15:30 Speaker 01 The Case of the Mushroom Lunch is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, Christian Silver, and Stephen Stockwell.
15:38 Speaker 02 Supervising producer for this episode is Tamar Krenzwick. Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson. Thank you to our legal queen, senior lawyer Jasmine Sims, for her legal advice, to the Victorian newsroom, and to Audio Studios manager Eric George for their support. This episode was produced on the land of the Runjri people.
16:05 Speaker 06 What do Rasputin, Tupac, and Pharoah Ramses III have in common? No, it's not the weirdest boy band ever. They all met their end at the hand of an assassin. Assassins with me, Aslan Pahadi, tells the stories of history's most shocking assassinations. From seizing power to silencing dissidents, Assassins unpacks the moments in which someone decides that murder is the move. Search for Assassins with Aslan Pahadi on the ABC Listen app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous 05 Romance Scam | Donna's path home Next 06 Romance Scam | Answering your questions Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated