Pod Insights The Case Of High Court has last word on Obeids' corruption appeal About this episode The Obeids' made $30 million in a corrupt conspiracy to profit from mining, and that money has never been recovered.
Until yesterday, Eddie Obeid, his son Moses, and former NSW Labor Minister Ian McDonald continued to protest their innocence through the courts.
In this episode, the ABC's High Court reporter Elizabeth Byrne joins Stephen Stockwell in Canberra to break down the Obeid's and McDonald's final attempt to appeal their convictions, and how it was shut down.
If you have any questions, please email [email protected] mailto:[email protected] .
The Case Of is the follow-up to the hit podcast Mushroom Case Daily, and all episodes of that show will remain available in the back catalogue of The Case Of.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 In a tiny Victorian town, the football club isn't just a weekend ritual.
0:04 Speaker 01 It's country footy. You get there really early. You leave late.
0:07 Speaker 00 But then, one day, something happens.
0:09 Speaker 01 In the back of a caravan, just over the road from this footy club. Once I realised what was going to happen, it like, yeah, it was not good.
0:19 Speaker 00 And suddenly, everyone must pick a side.
0:21 Speaker 02 I just felt angry. Those blokes were meant to be my mates.
0:25 Speaker 00 Hometown Boys, a new series by Background Briefing. Listen now on the ABC Listen app.
0:30 Speaker 03 ABC Listen. Podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:47 Speaker 04 Today's episode is a story about two disgraced former NSW South Wales Labor ministers. One of their sons, an idyllic slice of country land that made them $30 million, and a trip to the highest court in the land to try and clear their name. I'm Stephen Stockwell, this is The Case Of.
1:06 Speaker 03 One of Australia's most colourful corruption cases is over.
1:09 Speaker 05 A conspiracy that reaped the Obeids' $30 million.
1:13 Speaker 01 That brought great shame on the Labor Party. The Obeids were motivated by money.
1:17 Speaker 04 Public office is about serving the people, not serving your pocket. It is corruption on a scale probably unexceeded since the days of the rum call.
1:30 Speaker 04 On the surface, the Bylong Valley is beautiful. It's in New South Wales, there's lush grass, beautiful trees, a winding creek. But underneath that land, there are some very valuable coal reserves. And it was this land, bought and sold by Eddie and Moses Obeed, with the help of then Mineral Resources Minister Ian McDonald, which saw them convicted of corruption in 2021 and sent to jail. They appealed in New South Wales, they lost. And yesterday, the final ruling on their case was made in the High Court. It found its way into the patch of ABC Canberra court reporter Elizabeth Byrne. Elizabeth, welcome to The Case Of.
2:08 Speaker 03 Thank you.
2:09 Speaker 04 I am so looking forward to talking through this with you. Liz, you're a legend among the court reporters in the ABC. Everyone we have had on the pod that I've mentioned you will be joining us is so excited about it. And I'm so excited you're here because you've been doing this for years. And this is such an interesting story that we have here, this one. This is a, it's sort of a coal deal, it's sort of a property deal, but I'm, I will admit, I do get a little bit lost in the detail of what has happened with the Obeids and Ian McDonald. So can you give me the background of this case? What, what do they, what did they do?
2:42 Speaker 03 Well, essentially, they rigged the allocation of a mining exploration licence for coal in the Bylong Valley, in an area that included a farm and a couple of other properties that were eventually owned by the Obeids. Now, there is no suggestion that that grazing property that the Obeids had was bought with illegal money or anything like that, there was anything illegal about that. It's what happened after that that became the subject of this case. And like you, I have, I sort of half followed it for years and years. There's some very good colleagues of mine, including Jamel Wells, who covered this for many years.
3:27 Speaker 03 And so I was a bit at sea with the detail of it until it arrived in the High Court, and I had to then go back and understand what had gone on here. But essentially, the charge was always conspiracy to commit misconduct in public office.
3:44 Speaker 04 Right.
3:45 Speaker 03 And this was a case of Ian McDonald was the Minister for Minerals, so it was his sort of bellywick to be granting exploration licences. So he was the, he was the person who had that power in New South Wales at the time. And his former colleague, Eddie Obead had actually been a minister in a Labor government, but he'd also been a member in the New South Wales upper house for many, many years, from 1991 to 2011. But at the Time of these offences, he had left Parliament.
4:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, and this is, this was kind of a political scandal of the highest order in, in New South Wales. This was a, a huge deal. You had a current resources minister doing these deals with a former colleague effectively, and his son to, to net them a lot of money. I think it was thirty million dollars that they made out of this deal, the obeys?
4:43 Speaker 03 Well, the obeys did make thirty million dollars out of it, and some of the inquiries afterwards suggested that they were to make even more than that. But that was the sum total at the end of it, and it was a, a very serious political scandal at the time. Uh, and it was gone into in great detail over the years about how the, the arrangements were made, how the conspiracy emerged, and whether Ian McDonald had actually done the wrong thing. I mean, there's, there are suggestions that he was just enthusiastic about his job.
5:24 Speaker 03 Um, I, I have to add that this was not his only, if you can call this sort of thing a rodeo. He also spent time in jail for another similar arrangement where he granted a licence directly to another group and was found guilty of that and is jailed for that as well.
5:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, so basically we have a, you know, a politician, a minister, using their power, using their authority to favour friends, more or less. I mean, what did he stand to gain from this? The obeys got thirty million dollars. What did Ian McDonald get?
6:00 Speaker 03 Well, the only thing he seems to have gotten from this particular thing was jail time. There was some suggestion at the time of the ICAC inquiry that they were all involved in before they were ever charged, that he was in line to receive some kind of benefit. Uh, that didn't seem to go anywhere, uh, and, and there was a suggestion that arrangement had fallen over. So he really didn't.
6:31 Speaker 03 On any public document anyway, receive anything for this. He's simply got sent to jail because the conspiracy was alleged and and eventually found to have taken place.
6:46 Speaker 04 Yeah, and I mean, Liz, this deal is pretty complicated. You know, you've got properties being bought and sold, mining leases being slightly extended in favour of the Obeids. How does that make someone thirty million dollars?
6:59 Speaker 03 Well, the property itself bought legitimately. The plan was to sell the farm and the couple of adjoining properties that were covered by the exploration licence to the winner of the rigged tender, and that was Cascade Coal. And that amount was was a lot more than they'd paid for the farm. Because of course, it had a mining exploration lease over a lot of coal. Then it was said that the Obeids had had a secret stake in Cascade Coal from which they would reap more money once mining began. So that was basically the mechanics of how they were to go about it.
7:44 Speaker 03 Some of this got stopped in its tracks. But clearly, the Obeids did come out of it with thirty million dollars.
7:53 Speaker 04 Hmm. And that thirty million dollars, that was never recovered, was it? The, you know, the the New South Wales Crime Commission never got that money off of them, even though it was found that they obtained it through corrupt practices.
8:04 Speaker 03 Yes, this is interesting because after the ICAC inquiry, the Crime Commission went looking for that money. Now, this was two thousand and thirteen. So it's a long time ago.
8:14 Speaker 04 Yeah.
8:15 Speaker 03 And it was only last year, in April last year, we received a press release which said that they'd been unable to find the thirty million dollars because the examination had found that the Obeids' financial arrangements were so deliberately complex that they were unable to trace the money.
8:37 Speaker 04 Wow, that is, I mean, to me, that sounds like it has been what you would in other circumstances call very effectively laundered.
8:45 Speaker 03 Well, I don't think we can say that it was laundered because that would be a criminal charge and they were never charged with that. But I think it has been mixed up with legitimately obtained money and the Obeids did have, you know, they're very wealthy from legitimate activities as well. And this is what the Crime Commission has said, that the money was so mixed up with legitimate funds that they were unable to trace it through and recover it.
9:16 Speaker 04 Yep, yep. And, you know, at the moment, the Obeids aren't actually in prison, they are on parole. Ian McDonald is still in prison. They had, you know, been convicted in 2021, they had appealed in New South Wales, that was rejected and this went all the way to the High Court, the kind of final opportunity to challenge this conviction. And the decision yesterday in the High Court was one that was really highly anticipated. You know, this is the last chance for it, but on, on the line, the High Court was going to rule in favour of the appeal, it would have released Ian McDonald from prison. Liz, can you talk me through what happened at the High Court yesterday?
9:52 Speaker 03 Well, yesterday in the High Court, the case was thrown out, basically. The Obeids and Mr McDonald had argued that the case against them for the conspiracy to commit misconduct in public office had not been made out because you couldn't have proved that there was a conspiracy. They've said the prosecution couldn't show that there was an agreement for Mr McDonald to do certain acts to bring about the gains that the Obeids obtained in this deal.
10:28 Speaker 03 So the High Court has thrown that argument out. And said that, in fact, the case by the prosecution was sound. And they've talked about how there were actions done by Mr. McDonald. They they didn't have to be specified, but the actions done by Mr. McDonald sort of make the case for the prosecution. And just, there's a number of things that he did. And I'll just give you a couple of examples. One of them was that he sought confidential information on the coal volumes in that area around Mount Penny. Um, from his department.
11:08 Speaker 03 And then after that, uh, he had the department move the exploration permit to cover the land owned by the Obeids, despite objections from the bureaucrats. And then it goes on and there's, there's a number of things. So all of those actions, even if there was no agreement to do those particular things. All of those actions led to the consequence of the Obeids making thirty million dollars.
11:37 Speaker 04 Right, so basically, they couldn't see anything that said he was doing this because he had a deal with the Obeids. But it looks so favourable to the Obeids and so against the advice of the department that basically the whole thing was like, well, look, based on what we've got here, this is, this looks pretty sound and we're very comfortable with this.
11:55 Speaker 03 That's right. And the conclusion that the High Court came to was that there was uh, an abuse of public trust contemplated by the conspirators. And that was very clear and that Mr. McDonald had used his official position to grant the exploration licence to them and that the kernel of the offence was there. And so, uh, they couldn't get away with it, basically.
12:20 Speaker 04 Right, um, thank you so much, Liz, for kind of taking us through this and explaining it so simply as well. Because even in twenty twenty one, when the Obeids and McDonald were convicted, Justice Elizabeth Thornton, you know, spent two hours delivering a verdict reflecting on how complex this was. Now, of course, that was appealed, that was rejected, it's now gone to the High Court, which has rejected it again. You know, am I right in thinking this is the highest court in the land? This is, this is the end of the road for the, the kind of appeal process for the Abides and McDonald? Is that right?
12:48 Speaker 03 Yes, it is.
12:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
12:50 Speaker 03 They're the ultimate empire.
12:51 Speaker 04 Yeah, and, you know, forgive my ignorance here because this is the first time I've been, you know, doing an episode about the High Court, so I'm still learning how this all works. And, I mean, when these arguments are being made to the High Court, when you have the Abides and McDonald, you're kind of appealing this decision, you have the New South Wales Office or Department of Public Prosecutions kind of defending their, their original case. How does that happen? Are they in the High Court arguing about this? Are they just writing written submissions? How does this whole process unfold to reach this decision?
13:18 Speaker 03 Well, it is a process, as you say. First of all, they had to convince the High Court that it was a case worth hearing a challenge to. Um, and most applications to the High Court are rejected.
13:33 Speaker 04 Right.
13:33 Speaker 03 They, they got through. Um, and they got a hearing date in November last year. Now, in advance of that hearing date, they had to publicly release their submissions to the High Court, which they did, so we had an idea about what they were going to argue. Um, I thought it was interesting, Ian McDonald planned to, or he did argue, his lawyers argued in the High Court, that if the High Court were to accept the prosecution version of events, then it would be widening the concept of, of this conspiracy. Um, and that it should be wary of that.
14:15 Speaker 04 Yep.
14:15 Speaker 03 Um, as it's turned out, uh, maybe the High Court, uh, has narrowed it. But they've certainly drawn a line, but that's for others to decide. But I think it has absolutely drawn a line in the sand under this. And that, uh, you know, people who might be involved in a conspiracy like this are now on notice.
14:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, it, Liz, it's really interesting to hear how this kind of characterises the, the definition of conspiracy.
14:43 Speaker 03 Yes, well. You would think you'd need a smoking gun to to prove something like this. But after the High Court ruling, and even before it really, but the High Court has underlined the fact that you don't need it, that a string of actions can be proof enough that a conspiracy has occurred.
15:05 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:05 Speaker 03 Um, the High Court usually takes quite a while to deliver its rulings.
15:11 Speaker 04 Hmm.
15:11 Speaker 03 And I was a bit perplexed when I saw, like, it's not even, they haven't had very long to think about it.
15:19 Speaker 04 Because this was, you know, only heard by the High Court, was it November last year?
15:23 Speaker 03 Yes, that's right. So when they said they were coming back in the first week of the sittings with a result, I actually wondered if the O B S and Mr McDonald had won.
15:35 Speaker 04 Oh.
15:36 Speaker 03 Um, and that they were going to get out of jail because one of the things the High Court does is if there's any urgency in a case.
15:42 Speaker 04 Hmm.
15:43 Speaker 03 And one of the things about urgency is if somebody's liberty is at stake.
15:47 Speaker 04 Yes.
15:48 Speaker 03 They do come back with a a quick decision. So people aren't left wondering. The other thing, of course, they do is is if it's a slam dunk, they come back quickly as well. So I knew either either outcome was a possibility and it was the slam dunk.
16:04 Speaker 04 That's, it is fascinating, though, the way that the High Court considers liberty, though, the way you're describing that, that, you know, potentially one of the reasons that they would have, you know, turned this around in just a couple of months, you know, obviously a lot of material to go through, a very complex case, could have been that they've looked at it and gone, oh dear, there's someone in prison who isn't supposed to be in prison, we need to act fast to get them out. So fascinating.
16:24 Speaker 03 The classic case in this regard is the is the case where they decided that uh indefinite immigration detention was not legal anymore. Um, and that that overturned a 20 year precedent that they had set themselves.
16:41 Speaker 04 Right, yep.
16:42 Speaker 03 And uh they didn't even wait a day. They waited 15 minutes while they had a quick discussion and they came back and delivered that on the spot. So they do take the detention of people very seriously.
16:55 Speaker 04 Speaking of people's liberty, people's freedom, you know, Eddie and Moses Obeid, as we mentioned, out on parole, Ian McDonald, he will remain in prison, is that right?
17:05 Speaker 03 Yes, he will. The best information I could come up with when I was looking into this is that he could be eligible for parole next year. So, but he's spent quite a bit of time in jail. And when he was, there's been some toing and froing because of the two sentences he's received, and they've kind of been rolled together a little bit. So he has served time for these two things that he was convicted of. He's been through a number of appeals and resentences, but 2027 looks like the year he'll get his parole.
17:44 Speaker 04 Liz, this feels like such a dramatic case. I mean, I mentioned before how this was a kind of a scandal of the highest political order, but it was a case as well, as it was unfolding, that was just full of drama and just kind of incredible exchanges in courtrooms as well. Can you, can you give us an insight into a bit of how, you know, just the original trial and some of this has unfolded and some of the colour around this as well?
18:10 Speaker 03 Yes, it was terribly colourful. I mean, the characters in it are colourful. But the charges took a long time to come to court because along the way, there were public inquiries into what had gone on here in the ICAC in New South Wales. And there were some fairly tense moments in that. And these were the moments that I suppose made me sit up and take notice when, you know, my colleagues were reporting on it. One that really stuck in my mind is when Geoffrey Watson, who was the counsel assisting in the ICAC inquiry, asked Eddie Obeid about money that he'd been squirreling away. Mr.
18:54 Speaker 03 Obeid said, well, don't come and say, I'm squirreling away anything. I've spent more money than you've made in a lifetime. And that prompted the Commissioner, David Ip, to say, Mr. Obeid, if you've spent more money than Mr. Watson has earned in a lifetime, where has the money come from? And then even outside, there were some fairly interesting comments. The police minister at the time, David Elliott, said, I don't care if the ATO strip him bare. As far as I'm concerned, the Crime Commission can take his socks and jocks. So, you know, it was fairly, it was fairly entertaining, but it was all about something very serious.
19:38 Speaker 03 And it was about an abuse of public office. And that's where the High Court landed yesterday.
19:45 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, a kind of incredible story and one of the biggest scandals in Australian politics over the last, really, kind of 20, 30 years. So, thank you, Liz, for joining us and taking us through the High Court's decision, how it's, you know, am I right in saying that it's put a full stop on this saga now?
20:02 Speaker 03 Yes, except for when Ian McDonald gets out of jail, I'm sure there'll be a little press pack to meet him.
20:10 Speaker 04 I'm sure there will be as well. I was with Bern, thank you so much for joining us on The Case Of. And thank you as well to Claire Rollinson, who stepped into the Case Of hot seat earlier this week while I was at Haywire. And as always, if you have any questions, please get in touch, send us an email, [email protected] and jump on ABC Listen, best place to enjoy The Case Of. We have some, some big things coming very soon. Liz, hoping to get you back on the pod in the, in the next couple of weeks. Can we talk much about that at the moment or do we need to keep mum?
20:39 Speaker 03 We should try to keep mum about it. There is something interesting happening in Canberra. It was to have started. There's no firm start date yet, but it is imminent. Not next week, but perhaps the week after.
20:54 Speaker 04 That is a wonderful, what we call in the business, a forward promote or tease. So, thank you, Liz. Hopefully have you back on the pod very, very soon. But while we've got our little project up our sleeve, next week, we're going to be taking you inside another courtroom. There are so many cases that we have our eyes on at the moment around the country. So, grab yourself ABC Listen because we are here to keep taking you inside the biggest trials, appeals and other moments in courts all around Australia.
21:32 Speaker 04 The Case Of is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. This episode was reported by Elizabeth Byrne and presented by me, Stephen Stockwell. Our supervising producer is Greg Muller and our executive producer is Claire Rollinson. This episode was produced on the land of the Ngunnawal, Namburi and Muruntri people.
Previous What happened when Andrew Tate sued an Adelaide YouTuber Next Trial tests accused's mental competence in random killing Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated