Pod Insights The Case Of 6 | “She seemed to really like mushrooms” About this episode Erin Patterson's Facebook friends describe her as a woman who loved her kids, seemed to really like mushrooms and was at the center of a strained relationship.
As Erin Patterson’s triple murder trial enters its second week, Kristian Silva and Stephen Stockwell talk through how Erin repeatedly brought up mushrooms and asked for advice on how to cook beef Wellington.
If you’ve got questions about the case that you’d like Kristian to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:16 Speaker 01 It's sometimes said you're not friends unless you're Facebook friends. Today Erin Patterson's friends testified in her murder trial. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:26 Speaker 02 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It's Monday the 5th of May and we've just finished the fourth day of Erin Patterson's triple murder trial. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
0:35 Speaker 03 The prosecution argues she had travelled to nearby Locke and Outrim where there'd been sightings of death cap mushrooms.
0:42 Speaker 04 She told doctors she fed her children leftovers but scraped the mushrooms off. Police allege Ms Patterson refused medical treatment for both herself and her children. Ms Patterson admits she lied to police about foraging for mushrooms and getting rid of the dehydrator.
0:58 Speaker 02 So we are back for week two of the Erin Patterson trial. We had a huge week last week. We heard the opening statements which took up all of Wednesday, rolling through that, hearing the story of, you know, Erin Patterson, her relationships, how this lunch unfolded and the aftermath of that. And then we spent two days hearing from Erin's estranged husband, Simon Patterson. He was in the stand, taking questions from both the prosecution and defence. And now we are here for week two. It is Monday, the first day of this week. And Christian, today it took a bit of a turn. Things were a little bit different to what we've heard so far. Can you give us like a 60 second rap of what's happened and unfolded today?
1:39 Speaker 01 Stocky, some of Erin Patterson's Facebook friends were called to give evidence in court and they described how she regularly made comments about loving mushrooms. They also said Erin was pretty critical of her estranged husband, Simon. Speaking of Simon, his evidence on the stand continued. It was the third day that he'd been answering questions. Again, he was quizzed about his strained relationship with his wife and some of the disagreements they had over money.
2:11 Speaker 02 It was a really interesting day. We got through quite a bit. Again, we've had Simon giving evidence for, you know, two and a half. This was the third day of his evidence. And then we heard from, yeah, like you were saying, some of Erin Patterson's Facebook friends. And I want to get into these Facebook friends. I'd like to talk about this kind of community that Erin was a part of because these were true crime Facebook groups. So it started with a Facebook page around, related to the Kelly Lane story. So that was a very high profile murder in Australia. And so she was chatting with these women. There were other groups that kind of like popped off to the side of this. And the thing that surprised me as I was listening and following along to some of this was that it didn't really seem to be much conversation about true crime in these groups at all.
2:52 Speaker 01 It seemed like it evolved and the three friends that were called to the stand broadly said the same things about how these groups were formed and sounded like initially there was quite a large group and then they were whittled down to smaller groups. And in the end, there was a core group of five who were chatting. And yeah, it sounded like the conversation moved to things like politics, current affairs, their own personal lives as well. This was also during COVID. So obviously, a lot of people going through some tough times during the pandemic. And the friends said that Erin regularly talked about her difficult relationship with her estranged husband, Simon.
3:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. And there was also a lot of talk about her relationship with her kids as well, like really painting her as someone who loved her kids. We'd talk about her kids a lot.
3:43 Speaker 01 That's right. One of the friends, Daniella Barclay, described Erin as a wonderful mother and said that Erin's life, according to what she was told anyway, heavily revolved around her children.
3:56 Speaker 02 Yeah. Yeah, nice. And it was interesting as well because, you know, obviously lots of talk about family, life, you know, all the things going on in that and associated with it, but also mushrooms.
4:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, it is the biggest topic of this trial.
4:13 Speaker 02 Yeah.
4:13 Speaker 01 And I guess we've been focusing on it in the context of the lunch. But it turns out, according to these witnesses, that the topic of mushrooms and Erin Patterson go hand in hand and are linked well before the lunch. Um. So we can go through some of that now.
4:31 Speaker 02 Hmm. Cause there was a talk about like the dehydrator. And this is, this heard, this we heard a little bit about in the, in the opening statements. But um, this is something that Erin seemed like quite proud of acquiring uh, and talking about it in these Facebook groups.
4:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, one of the friends said that Erin, quote, seemed to really like mushrooms. And, and several of them said that she was really happy about this dehydrator that she had bought um, in twenty twenty three. And they said she'd been using it to dehydrate mushrooms on several occasions. Um. There was a message that was actually flashed up on the court screen. And this is a message that Erin Patterson, I think, has sent to the group or perhaps just to one of them. Where she says, I've been hiding powdered mushrooms in everything. Mixed it into chocolate brownies yesterday. The kids had no idea. Uh, yeah. And, and on top of that, um, Erin Patterson was posting pictures of the dehydrator to the chat group.
5:29 Speaker 01 There was a grainy sort of black and white photo, which was again flashed up on the court screen. And from what I could tell from my vantage point, um, the dehydrator had several shelves. And we were told that there were mushrooms on those shelves. It was a little bit difficult to see. There was also another photo um, of chopped up button mushrooms that Erin has sent to this group. So it did come up. And the other thing that came up in this chat group before the fatal lunch was the topic of beef Wellingtons.
6:04 Speaker 02 Yeah. So this was really interesting because it sounded like, you know, when we're talking about this group, and this is something I, I found really interesting about this group, was that it was much more of a community than like a general like, you know, kind of, you know, posting about this and then having a little conversation.
6:18 Speaker 01 Saying all sorts of things.
6:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. They were really sort of asking each other for advice and talking about things. And there was this point where Erin was like, hey, I'm thinking about cooking a beef Wellington. Has anybody ever made one of these before?
6:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, she was seeking advice and several of these friends said cooking was another one of those topics that they liked to chat about. And one of the witnesses said that several of them owned a cookbook, a recipe tin eats. I'm told it's a pretty popular cookbook. I believe the chef behind it all was at the centre of another news story last week, unrelated to the case, but a weird coincidence. But yes, apparently a shared love of cooking and Erin Patterson was asking for advice also around the kind of meat to use in the Beef Wellington. Admittedly, I'm not a expert on this, but she was, she was asking what kinds of cuts would
7:12 Speaker 01 work. And another friend also said that she gave Erin Patterson some advice about how to do the pastry and when to put it in the oven. Again, this is all kind of above my head, but people who know Beef Wellington probably will understand what this whole discussion was about.
7:28 Speaker 02 Yep. I think people who know Beef Wellington will also be horrified at one of the jokes from one of the witnesses today who talked about the idea of having a tofu Wellington.
7:35 Speaker 01 Yes, the tofu Wellington.
7:37 Speaker 02 Which sounded like it went down like a lead balloon in this Facebook group.
7:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and that got a few laughs from people in the court. So it was a, one of the lighter moments. I, I think she was vegetarian.
7:48 Speaker 02 That was the purpose of it. Yes. Yeah. So she was not just generally opposed to Wellingtons. It was, yeah, her approach to it. And like I was saying before, like there was this sort of social space that these groups kind of existed in, I suppose. And as well as cooking and family and like, there was also a lot of conversation about Simon. And it seemed to kind of paint us a pretty different picture of the way that Simon had been talking about his relationship with Erin.
8:13 Speaker 01 Well, up until this afternoon, we only had one witness giving evidence in this trial, and it was Simon Patterson. So we're starting to see some different perspectives come out. Now, bear in mind, these witnesses, Erin's Facebook friends, they've never met her in person. So. They're going off what she's telling them and, and she was telling them that Simon was the kind of person who apparently, according to one witness, Christine Hunt, was coercive. And um, the word Christine Hunt used was abusive.
8:46 Speaker 02 Ooh.
8:46 Speaker 01 And, and Miss Hunt said that there was this tension that Erin Patterson had with her husband because Erin was an atheist, Simon Patterson is a devout Baptist. And, and Miss Hunt said that effectively Erin Patterson was holding herself out to be this sort of churchgoing Christian, but behind her extended family's back, she was telling her, her mates in the Facebook group that she didn't necessarily believe in God. So clearly a, another point of tension there.
9:18 Speaker 02 Yeah, there was that, that sort of religious side of it was, was again discussed in relation to the um, to that Facebook group and stories that Erin was telling the people in these groups. Um, also a lot about, um, well, not a lot, but a part of it about Simon's, Simon Patterson's lack of cleanliness.
9:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, that came up and that was awkward. And again, this was in the context of Erin complaining about her estranged husband. So one of the witnesses said that she did complain that um, she didn't think he kept a clean house. And that was all said while Simon Patterson was in the public gallery, having finished his evidence. So he heard that said about him. I think the one thing that made it less awkward were all of these Facebook friends, perhaps fittingly, were giving evidence virtually via video link. They weren't there in the flesh and seemingly to this day have never laid eyes on Erin Patterson, but have plenty to say about her and have spoken to her in the past.
10:18 Speaker 02 Simon, when he was hearing this, was he reacting in any specific way or is he keeping a bit of a poker face?
10:23 Speaker 01 Simon was pretty level headed. There was no visible reaction and even from what I could tell from Erin Patterson, who was sitting about two metres behind me, I didn't see any big noticeable reactions from her as she heard her friends talking about um. Their past interactions.
10:42 Speaker 02 Yeah. Was there any conversation um with the uh Facebook friends about the lunch or like any conversations following the lunch? There were bits I was sort of dipping in.
10:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, a lot of con- a lot of conversations in the lead up to the lunch about recipe preparation. But only one witness, Jenny Hay, was asked about the aftermath. Now, this witness said that Erin Patterson actually spoke to her over the phone a couple of days after the lunch. And Erin Patterson said that she was sick in hospital. And she also said that she got the mushrooms from an Asian grocer. Now, people will remember this is one of the topics that came up at the start of the trial in the prosecution openings. It's not something that we've had in detail in the evidence yet, but given the prosecution and the defence have flagged
11:31 Speaker 01 the origin of the mushrooms in the meal as part of their openings, it will be something that we'll get to explore later on.
11:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, um it's worth understanding as well today that, you know, while we had these Facebook friends giving evidence, they were giving evidence for about twenty minutes or so each. We also had um the testimony of Simon Patterson wrapping up today as well. And Simon, by comparison, has given evidence now for two and a half days. So we've got a lot more detail from Simon. Uh what was he talking about in the the last parts of hi- his evidence?
12:01 Speaker 01 Simon Patterson was quizzed again by Colin Mandy, the defence barrister. And he was taken to his conversations that he had with Erin a couple of days after the lunch when she was in hospital. Uh and the kids were also in hospital as doctors tried to check to see if um they were also sick from from poisoning. And Colin Mandy put to Simon Patterson that he said something to her. And that was that Simon brought up the dehydrator and said to Erin, is that what you used to poison them? And the them being a reference to the lunch guests, of course. Now, Simon responded to say, I did not say that to Erin.
12:47 Speaker 01 Um. Now, I guess to put this in a bit of a timeline, this conversation happened a couple of days after the lunch.
12:54 Speaker 02 Hmm.
12:55 Speaker 01 About five or six days after the lunch, when the police went searching for items at the local tip, they found the dehydrator. So that's just a little bit of context there. He's allegedly raised this with her. Of course, he denies that.
13:12 Speaker 02 Hmm, hmm.
13:13 Speaker 01 And then fast forward a few days and the dehydrator ends up in the tip.
13:18 Speaker 02 Interesting. Where else did the, the conversation with Colm N D S C and Simon Patterson go today? I mean, I, I was sort of getting in and out of some of the, the conversations and some of the hearings today, but there was a bit of talk, I think, around um some money that Erin Patterson missed out on because of their relationship status?
13:36 Speaker 01 We did bring this up earlier and it has popped up a few times. It's really about the tension that these two had over money.
13:43 Speaker 02 Hmm.
13:44 Speaker 01 And I'm no tax expert, uh, so you'll excuse me for my sort of lack of total understanding of this issue, but um Simon Patterson changed his relationship status on his tax return to separate it. The net effect of that seems to be that Erin Patterson feels like she's suffered financially as a result. In text messages that were shown to the court, she said she believed that that change meant she could no longer claim about fifteen thousand dollars a year in tax benefits. But then she also claimed that because they'd been separated for quite a long time, but had not actually listed that separation, that
14:24 Speaker 01 there was probably in excess of, I don't know, maybe ni- in excess of ninety thousand dollars of child support payments that she felt that she missed out on.
14:34 Speaker 02 Yeah.
14:35 Speaker 01 And she was venting about this in a different chat group. This was a group with the Patterson family themselves. So Simon and his two parents were also in that group. And Erin wrote, and I quote, and this is also in front of the parents, by the way, I foolishly trusted him to do right by me and the kids when it came to the crunch. And she said that in front of Simon's parents. Obviously, I'm sure he wasn't too thrilled about that.
15:01 Speaker 02 Hmm.
15:02 Speaker 01 There was another reference to a message which we didn't really get to the bottom of, but the reason I bring it up is that Simon Patterson became kind of emotional when this. Topic emerged, Simon said that Erin Patterson sent some kind of extremely inflammatory message to this group chat. That message was not shown through the court and Simon Patterson did not explicitly say what it was about, but he was saying that it was a message that was having a crack at him. And he said that if his mum had seen the message, she would have been really upset by it. But it sounds like she, she might not have seen the message. So a bit cryptic there.
15:46 Speaker 02 Yeah.
15:47 Speaker 01 But that was probably the most emotional Simon was while on the stand today.
15:54 Speaker 02 Yep, yeah, well.
15:55 Speaker 01 One other thing he said, actually, and you'll remember back to the fake cancer claims that Erin Patterson made.
16:03 Speaker 02 Yep.
16:04 Speaker 01 Simon was also asked about why he didn't really seem to take this seriously. And he said, well, Erin Patterson flagged having some medical issues about two weeks before the lunch and had said this was the reason why she wanted to get everyone together.
16:20 Speaker 02 Yep.
16:20 Speaker 01 And he basically said that, well, if she organised this thing two weeks ago and it was about medical stuff, he didn't feel it was that serious if it wasn't going to be discussed properly for two weeks. And he said he didn't feel fully confident that there was a serious medical issue to discuss at all. So again, that topic rears its head.
16:44 Speaker 02 Yeah, so we've heard about that a couple of times now. So that's interesting. Well, Simon Patterson has finished his evidence now. We have a couple of audience questions I'd love to quickly jump into because one of them does relate to Simon. It's from Susan. She's emailed [email protected] and she's asked, a quick question, forty dollars a month maintenance from Simon seems odd. Are you able to throw more light on why it was such a little amount?
17:09 Speaker 01 This is the child support payments that. He started paying after this whole separation thing.
17:14 Speaker 02 Hmm.
17:15 Speaker 01 What Simon's told the court is that that figure was set by whoever it is that sets the child support payments, I'll say the government to make it easy.
17:24 Speaker 02 Yep.
17:25 Speaker 01 Um. That wasn't a figure that he set and he fully acknowledged that forty bucks a month is not going to really go very far when it comes to covering kids' private school fees. Um. There was a dispute over the school fees, but he says that eventually he ended up paying fifty percent of them.
17:41 Speaker 02 Okay, yep. Um. We've also had another question here from the um, the legal studies students.
17:46 Speaker 01 Oh, hello.
17:46 Speaker 02 Penley and Essendon Grammar School. Hello, Penley and Essendon Grammar School. Thank you for getting in touch. Uh. They would like to know, how do we know that the jury can be impartial, given how widely publicised the case was prior to trial?
17:58 Speaker 01 A great question and very, very relevant. This goes back to the very first day of the trial when that jury was impaneled. Justice Christopher Beale was speaking to the entire jury panel and told them, if you cannot be impartial, you cannot sit on this trial. So that means if they've already forged opinions about this case, if they've been obsessively reading the stories or listening to the podcasts or whatever it is, they're not suitable for this jury. They need to be the kinds of people that can weigh up the evidence, um, also ignore all of the media reporting and, and, and even just the conversations at the weekend with their family. They need to put all of that aside and just look at
18:42 Speaker 01 what's presented to the court to make a decision. The courts do give juries a fair amount of trust. There's a belief in the legal system that juries can follow the instructions set by judges and there's faith put in them for that. So that is why we have a jury trial and they're given those instructions and expected to follow them.
19:05 Speaker 02 Thank you. If you have any questions you'd like us to answer, please get in touch, [email protected] . We are reading all of your questions. There are a lot of them, I must say. So, you know, it's taking us a bit of time.
19:15 Speaker 01 It's been great.
19:16 Speaker 02 But we are getting to all of them, yeah. There's a few that we're getting through that are things that we just can't get into. We can't speculate around aspects of the case and things like that. So if we haven't read out some of your questions, that's why.
19:27 Speaker 01 And there are some questions that we've received, which I'm confident we'll be able to address. It's just not right at this minute. It may come up later on in the trial.
19:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, I've got a very detailed spreadsheet that we can refer back to, but I won't bore you with that. But yes, thank you for getting in touch. Please reach out if you have any questions you'd like us to answer.
19:44 Speaker 01 So we're expecting more witnesses tomorrow. We haven't been told who they are. So it'll be a bit of a surprise when we rock up to court tomorrow and find out who'll be taking the stand.
19:54 Speaker 02 Whoever it is, we'll be here with another episode of Mushroom Case Daily tomorrow.
20:01 Speaker 01 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silva, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
20:11 Speaker 02 Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson, and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, audio studios manager, Eric George, and our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh, Rachel Brown, and Yasmin Parry, for helping make this show a reality. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Kurnai people.
20:29 Speaker 04 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 5 | A tragic accident or ultimate betrayal? Our Friday wrap Next 7 | Lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson speaks Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated