Pod Insights The Case Of 27 | Erin accepts that death caps were in the lunch About this episode Today, during her second day in the witness box, Erin Patterson accepted that the mushroom meal must have contained death caps.
The accused triple murderer also told the jury she foraged for mushrooms for several years leading up to the lunch, spoke about how traumatic hospital experiences in the past had shaken her trust in the health system, and gave details about her financial situation.
In today's episode investigative reporter Rachael Brown and Stephen Stockwell talk through Erin's evidence, including the moments that brought her to tears.
If you've got questions about the case that you'd like Rachael and Stocky to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
-
It's the case that's captured the attention of the world.
Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police allege the beef wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson says she's innocent.
Now, the accused triple murderer is fighting the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Investigative reporter Rachael Brown and producer Stephen Stockwell are on the ground, bringing you all the key moments from the trial as they unravel in court.
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, the Mushroom Case Daily podcast is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
Keep up to date with new episodes of Mushroom Case Daily https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/mushroom-case-daily, now releasing every day on the ABC listen app.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Hi, Jules and Jez here. And every week on Not Stupid, we unpack the news of the week.
0:07 Speaker 01 From the stuff that matters, to the stories you're obsessed with.
0:10 Speaker 00 My friend Lucy has got a moose obsession, and she's really got me right on to it. So you can see on Reddit, there's all these like...
0:16 Speaker 01 Can I, sorry, how does someone develop a moose obsession?
0:19 Speaker 00 Mate, how does one develop anything in life? You can find Not Stupid on the ABC Listen app.
0:26 Speaker 02 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:42 Speaker 00 Today, in the witness box, Erin Patterson was asked, do you accept there must have been death cap mushrooms in the meal? Her answer? Yes. I'm ABC investigative reporter, Rachel Brown.
0:53 Speaker 03 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It is Tuesday, the 3rd of June. We've just finished the 24th day of this trial. The content and language warning on this episode, welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
1:03 Speaker 04 The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world. On the menu was beef wellington, a pastry filled with beef and a paté made of mushrooms.
1:13 Speaker 05 At the heart of this case will be the jury's interpretation of Erin Patterson's intentions. Erin Patterson has strongly maintained her innocence.
1:22 Speaker 06 It's a tragedy what's happened. I love them.
1:26 Speaker 03 We've now been making Mushroom Case Daily for five, six weeks at this point. You may be wondering where Christian Silva has disappeared to. Wonderful news, Christian's gone to become a father. If you missed Friday's episode, never fear though. We are joined by the outstanding Rachel Brown, ABC investigative reporter. Rach has been in court with us this whole time through the trial, through this podcast. And on Rach's second day hosting Mushroom Case Daily, we have seen the second day of Erin Patterson's evidence. Rach, before we kind of dive into it and pull it apart in all the various angles, can you give us an overview of what we heard in court?
2:02 Speaker 00 Stocky, we kicked off the day with Erin Patterson's financial position, generous loans that she gave to the siblings of her then-husband, Simon Patterson. Gave a few of them 400k each. Then we heard a lot about health. So her health concerns, her playing Dr. Google, issues with her children that ended up breeding a distrust of the medical profession, and then issues about weight gain and self-esteem. We then moved on to disputes that she had with Simon, things like child support payments and issues about her feeling left out of family parties and things like that. And then we heard who she vented all that to, her Facebook friends, because she said it was either that or sheep in the paddock. At the end of the day, and this is where the rubber meets the road, she says she did have an interest in foraging.
2:50 Speaker 03 Thank you, Rach. Things got really interesting this afternoon in court. This is a trial that revolves around a meal that was served to four people in late July 2023, a meal featuring mushrooms. This is a podcast called Mushroom Case Daily. This afternoon, right at the end of the day, we heard Erin Patterson tell the court that she accepts that there were death cap mushrooms in the meal she served. Where did she say those mushrooms came from?
3:19 Speaker 00 So she mentioned two sources, mushrooms from Woolies that we've heard a lot about, button mushrooms that she bought in the week before the lunch. She also mentioned buying dried mushrooms in April of 2023 from an Asian grocer somewhere in Melbourne. So we've heard a lot about a potential Asian grocer in Glen Waverley. And then the conversation moved on to a dehydrator that she bought in April 2023.
3:47 Speaker 03 And foraging. And this is a point that came up towards the second half of the day. We started learning from Erin Patterson that she had a keen interest in mushrooms. And it seemed to be something that she was doing kind of around her house in her local area, right?
4:02 Speaker 00 So Erin Patterson told the court that her interest in picking mushrooms started during the COVID period in 2020, when everyone was bored out of their brain. That's my words, not hers. But she said, you know, when we were allowed out for an hour a day, she would go on a walk with the children. And she mentioned places that she'd walk, like the Botanic Gardens in Corombe Borough. Uh. She said she'd noticed mushrooms on her property, first in Corumburra, and then at the property she had in Lee and Gathar.
4:31 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
4:31 Speaker 00 And then she also mentioned the rail trail that leads out of Lee and Gathar. You can often find mushrooms along that trail. And she said she loves mushrooms. They taste good, they're very healthy. She said she just developed an interest in trying all different kinds from Woolies, farmers' markets, that led her to start buying from Asian grocers. And she had a place in, uh, like a Melbourne bolt hole in Glen Waverley. So she'd often buy, she said, from Asian grocers there. And she said she'd use them in things like curries or pasta dishes or soups.
5:03 Speaker 03 What kinds of mushrooms are we talking here?
5:06 Speaker 00 She said she mainly picked field and horse mushrooms, that they were found at the Shellcot Road property.
5:13 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
5:13 Speaker 00 And that, if you'd remember, was in Corumburra. So that was before she moved to Lee and Gathar.
5:17 Speaker 03 I mean, I didn't remember that, but thank you for clarifying.
5:19 Speaker 00 Uh. And she said there was a couple of other interesting ones that she saw at the Corumburra Botanic Gardens.
5:25 Speaker 03 Yep.
5:25 Speaker 00 But then she mentioned ones like slippery jacks and honey mushrooms, which she said are very nice to eat.
5:31 Speaker 03 She was talking at one point, I think it was the Shellcot Roadhouse, so you might have to correct me here, but she was walking around, it sounded like a decent sized property, right? I think it was a couple of hectares. Um. And she's walking around some of the paddocks and she starts finding these ones. And the ones that I I remember hearing about were these like field mushrooms and horse mushrooms, I think.
5:47 Speaker 00 That's right. And then, so, but there was a paddock out the back of the Gibson Street place, which was the place of the lunch.
5:53 Speaker 03 Okay.
5:53 Speaker 00 And she said she mainly picked field mushrooms there. Um. This was around the April twenty twenty three time.
5:59 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
5:59 Speaker 00 But she said there was another type up the back that weren't field mushrooms.
6:03 Speaker 03 Okay.
6:03 Speaker 00 But she said, look, I couldn't figure out what they were, so I didn't eat any of them.
6:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. And there was also a conversation, this was, you know, slightly earlier in the day. Um. And, you know, we've been talking a lot about, obviously, the dangers of mushrooms in this trial. And, you know, as Erin is developing this interest, she says, in foraging. Um. She is trying some of these mushrooms. She's foraging mushrooms and she's she's cooking them up. I think at one point, like slicing a bit off, chucking it in a pan with some butter, right?
6:29 Speaker 00 Yeah. And but first she'd go on certain sites to ask or to try to find out if they were safe, she says.
6:36 Speaker 03 Yep.
6:36 Speaker 00 Uh. Wait for that information back. And then if it looked like they were safe, yeah, she'd throw them in some butter and slice a little bit off and. Try it out.
6:45 Speaker 03 The exchange around her trying this for the first time, I think she said something like, you know, they tasted good and I didn't get sick uh after trying one of the forage mushrooms for the um for the first time. Um was it just her that was eating them?
7:00 Speaker 00 So initially, I think, yes, she was trying them and, you know, she saw the same ones, she'd pick them and eat them. Uh she said there were lots of them in autumn going into winter. And then she said, I put them in meals that we all ate. Um she mentioned the children and she said that she chopped them up very small so that they couldn't pick them out.
7:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:20 Speaker 00 Now, at this point, Dr. Nanette Rogers jumped up from the prosecution.
7:26 Speaker 03 Yep.
7:26 Speaker 00 And said, Your Honour, there's an issue that I'd like to discuss in the absence of the jury. So the jury stood up, filed out, and then we went into legal argument that lasted way beyond lunchtime and we didn't see the jury again until four P M.
7:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. And we we also, in the conversations around uh the mushrooms, I want to talk about some other stuff as well, but before I move on, you know, we we heard a lot about the dehydrator. We started talking about Erin's habits um with the dehydrator and some of the mushrooms that she says she was foraging.
7:56 Speaker 00 So she bought a dehydrator in April twenty twenty three. She said, for a few reasons, I liked eating them. They have a very small, short season.
8:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:04 Speaker 00 So they don't last too long in the fridge. So if you want to keep them, you essentially have to dehydrate them.
8:10 Speaker 03 It's actually something we heard from Dr. Tom May.
8:12 Speaker 00 Um. Funky Tom.
8:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, earlier on in the trial, saying that fried mushrooms don't tend to last long, mostly because they've got a lot of insects on them. Sorry.
8:18 Speaker 00 So that is one way to have them available for later in the year. You dehydrate them. So she buys a dehydrator and uses them for a whole range of things, like the meals that I mentioned earlier. We've seen some photos during this trial of mushrooms lying on a dehydrator, um also on digital scales.
8:38 Speaker 03 Hmm.
8:39 Speaker 00 Near a dehydrator. She was just really interested. She was doing lots of experiments with them. One lot, she said she tried, they were, they stayed quite mushy, like she felt like not enough moisture had come out of them. That wasn't such a good batch. So she was experimenting with how long they needed to dry. What volumes they needed to be dried in or what sizes and things like that.
9:00 Speaker 03 Hmm.
9:00 Speaker 00 So we learnt about that, but we also learnt about where she would keep them. And what the courts heard is what she usually does with these dehydrated mushrooms is that she puts them in a Tupperware container in the pantry.
9:11 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
9:12 Speaker 00 So sometimes she'd already have a container going.
9:14 Speaker 03 Yep.
9:14 Speaker 00 With Woolies mushrooms, things like that.
9:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
9:17 Speaker 00 Uh, if not, she'd start a new one.
9:19 Speaker 03 Right, okay. And this kind of, we had a sort of like a world's colliding moment almost here. Cause we heard with, from Colin Mandy, he starts asking Erin, okay, so you know, these Asian grocery mushrooms that you've told us about. Um, where did they go?
9:35 Speaker 00 Same deal. So she buys them in April twenty twenty three, when she's at her house in Glen Waverley. She opens them and she said they smelt a bit pungent and wouldn't, she didn't think they would have been appropriate in the meal that she'd picked them for.
9:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, right.
9:47 Speaker 00 So she put them in a Tupperware container. That was at the house in Glen Waverley. That Tupperware container gets moved to the pantry in Lee and Gatha.
9:55 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
9:55 Speaker 00 And so as far as we know, she's got a whole range of mushrooms in Tupperware containers in Lee and Gatha.
10:03 Speaker 03 Yep.
10:03 Speaker 00 And so Colin Mandy put to her, well, were you putting wild mushrooms that you dehydrated in May or June twenty twenty three? Into a container that already contained other dried mushrooms. And she said, yes, I did.
10:19 Speaker 03 Right.
10:19 Speaker 00 And that stocky is how we finish the day.
10:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. Okay. Um, I want to go back to a few things we heard earlier in the day. I mean, particularly, you know, if we, we're kind of finishing with this moment of drying mushrooms. We saw again today messages that she had with Facebook friends, talking about how, you know, talking about getting this dehydrator. How she was really enjoying the fact you take out like ninety percent of the, um, the weight of mushrooms when you buy them. When you dehydrate the ones from Woolies, asking if she could take it in there potentially. Um, that's one of the kind of the funnier ones that we heard from the Facebook group. We also got back into some messages that were, um, really quite disparaging around the Patterson family. Now, this is Erin Patterson's in-laws. Uh, this is coming at a time where she is, does not have a great relationship with her estranged husband, Simon. And she's basically sending these messages, language warning on this, consisting of stuff like.
11:08 Speaker 03 This fucking family. Um.
11:10 Speaker 00 Um.
11:10 Speaker 03 And this was put to Erin today. She was asked about these messages and it was a moment that brought her to tears.
11:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, quite. This would be quite an awkward thing to be pressed on and she did look very uncomfortable. We've heard about some of these text messages before in this podcast. I'll read you a couple.
11:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:26 Speaker 00 That have really stuck with me. So one of the big ones, and this is around the time, just to remind everyone, that there was a dispute over child support payments. So all this time, Erin and Simon, who now estranged husband, they'd been sharing payments for their two children.
11:45 Speaker 03 Right.
11:45 Speaker 00 You know, even though they were separated, you know, she was putting his income down on her tax return. She wasn't applying for some of the benefits that you could apply for if you were separated. They were just going through the motions, doing things how they'd always done it.
11:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, right.
11:59 Speaker 00 So this comes to a point at the end of twenty twenty two, he says on his tax return that he's separated, which has tax implications for Erin. So that's the context of all of this. And she was frustrated, uh, because the, she says she was frustrated that Don and Gail refused to adjudicate in all of this because it got to a point that the child support payments, which was something like forty dollars a month. Now, both children are going to private schools, one had just had surgery. So she reached out to Simon to ask him to help with the surgeon's bill and he said, oh, no, no, no, no. Government says this is exactly the type of thing that I shouldn't pay for.
12:38 Speaker 03 And just for some context, um, Don and Gail are Simon's parents. So these are Erin's in-laws.
12:43 Speaker 00 Yes. And so she asks them, look, can you, she basically asks them to step in. And when they refuse to, when they refuse to adjudicate, she gets frustrated. So she's telling her Facebook friends things like this. This is a message, Facebook message. Simon's dad contacted me this morning to say that he and Gail had tried to talk to Simon about the matters I raised and to get his side. But he refused to talk about it, other than that to signal he disagreed with what I said. Beyond that, he won't talk about it. So Don said they can't adjudicate if they don't know both sides and Simon won't give his side. So he said all he can do is ask Simon and I to get together to pray for the children. Emoji, emoji. This family, just a language warning here.
13:24 Speaker 00 I swear to fucking god.
13:26 Speaker 03 Why did we see such a strong reaction from Erin when, when that's read out?
13:30 Speaker 00 Well, imagine hearing that back. Remember I said to you a few weeks ago, imagine if someone just went through your phone now and read out messages from any time period. I think she felt ashamed. She told the court she felt ashamed. She started shaking her head before she even started speaking.
13:46 Speaker 03 Hmm.
13:46 Speaker 00 And said, I wish I never said that. I'm ashamed for saying it and I wish the family didn't have to hear. I said that. They didn't deserve it. And she explained to the court that this chat, this Facebook chat group had been going on for four years. So to her, it was a safe space. She said, I felt heard, I felt validated. I knew they'd latch on and support me like a cheer squad.
14:07 Speaker 03 Yep.
14:07 Speaker 00 You know, and I think that's something that she didn't feel like she had at that time.
14:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, it didn't sound like she really had anyone that she could kind of share this stuff with, right?
14:14 Speaker 00 Well, his in-laws, she said she'd always had a good relationship with, and now she probably feels a bit cut off, bit of an island. I'll just read you another one. She says, nobody bloody listens to me. At least I know they're a lost cause. I'm sick of this shit. I want nothing to do with them. I thought his parents would want him to do the right thing, but it seems their concern about not wanting to feel uncomfortable and not wanting to get involved in their son's personal matters are overriding that. So, and a language warning here again, so fuck them. So she says she looked incredibly embarrassed when these messages were getting read back out. She said to the court that she needed to vent this frustration because otherwise it was going to the paddock and tell the sheep.
14:57 Speaker 03 Right.
14:57 Speaker 00 You know, or vent to these women. She says, I regret the language I used, but I knew they'd rally around me. And I, I did play up a little bit to get that support.
15:05 Speaker 03 Hmm.
15:06 Speaker 00 She was asked if she meant these things. And this is when today she really started crying.
15:12 Speaker 03 Hmm.
15:12 Speaker 00 I noticed, like, this was the, the lowest point for her of today's evidence. She said, no, I didn't. She barely got those words out.
15:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:20 Speaker 00 She said, I was frustrated with Simon, but not Don and Gail. It's not their fault, all the family's fault. And then she said, it's not entirely Simon's fault either. I played a part too. And she said in hindsight, she thought back about this and she said, I thought I was right and he was wrong. But it was wrong to involve Don and Gail and I should have approached it differently.
15:40 Speaker 03 Yep. One of the things I kind of stuck with me today, we started hearing a bit more about Erin Patterson's financial situation. Um, she had quite a bit of money going around. She inherited money from her grandmother who passed away. I think it was like mid to late two thousands. Um, had a lot of commercial properties that the kind of money came in from over a period of several years as the kind of like the assets were sort of sold off and distributed amongst the beneficiaries, beneficiaries of that. And she talked about how, you know, she was very generous with this money, seemingly in a way to kind of maintain this relationship with Simon.
16:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, not just the grandmother's money. So her mother died in twenty nineteen and she inherited half of that money between her and her sister. And that went into properties, the block in Lee and Gatha that she ended up building on and a house in Mount Waverley. Now, both those properties she put in Simon's name.
16:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:35 Speaker 00 And she was asked, why would you do that? You was, you'd been separated for four years. And she said, well, I always thought that, you know, we would bring the family back together and that's what I always wanted. And so to her, that was a way of demonstrating that to Simon, that she still saw a future for them together. And then she was also very generous to his siblings. So his three siblings, she says she gave them loans of around four hundred K that they could choose when to pay back and how much and only pay back with inflation. So no interest.
17:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. When Simon and Erin separated, they kind of just sort of put all the assets down on a bit of paper. Like, and this literally it sounded like they got a bit of paper and they wrote down all the things they had, all the various assets, the houses, the money. And Erin and Simon just split it right down the middle. No lawyers, no one else.
17:24 Speaker 00 Most couples that I've spoken to going through divorces, they would think that that's insane, but this is what they did. And I don't think money was a big issue for them. You know, it wasn't a matter of conflict up until. The dispute over child support.
17:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, that that did seem to kind of get resolved a bit though, right?
17:40 Speaker 00 It did. By the end of twenty twenty, it sounds like that was resolved. She went on a holiday to New Zealand. She was watching her children do this luge, like toboggan.
17:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
17:51 Speaker 00 And she said she had really nice memories of family holidays that she'd spent together with Simon. So she messaged him videos of the kids going down the luge and she's just said, oh, it was my, it was kind of like a bit of an olive branch. And her trying to get communication back on track. So that was at the end of twenty twenty two.
18:08 Speaker 03 You mentioned Erin Patterson's mother earlier. Um, briefly spoke about Erin's parents in yesterday's episode, talking about how they didn't go to her wedding, her and Simon's wedding, because they were on a train in Russia on a holiday, in Erin's words. Um, today, you know, the financial stuff was interesting, but the thing that really stuck with me was just kind of her experience growing up, because it didn't sound like a particularly healthy one.
18:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, certainly the inheritance helped financially, but emotionally, we've only heard these two big clangers, which is not being there at the wedding.
18:40 Speaker 03 Hmm.
18:40 Speaker 00 And then what we learned today, which is Erin Patterson told the court that she had body image issues. And I should say, before I continue, a bit of a content warning, this touches on eating disorders, what I'm about to say. Uh, Erin Patterson told the court that she's had these issues since she was a teenager. And she said, my mum used to weigh me every week to make sure I wasn't putting on too much weight. And she said she did that with her sister as well. And so Erin said, and she used her arms to explain, like lifted them out beside her.
19:10 Speaker 03 Hmm.
19:10 Speaker 00 Um, and she said, I went from this extreme of barely eating uh, to the other end of the spectrum in adulthood and going the other way, you know, and binging. And she said, I've never had a healthy relationship with food. And that's when she starts struggling again in the witness box.
19:26 Speaker 03 If this evidence of um, the discussion of body image um, is challenging for you, you can access the Butterfly Foundation. They're online. I say you can search for them. There's a web chat, also a phone number, one eight hundred thirty three forty six seventy three. Um, and as Erin's talking through these body image issues, you know, this is something that's continued into adulthood.
19:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. And what really got me from today's evidence is that she said, nobody knew. And then she looked up, she said, well, everybody knows now, but nobody knew then. And she dabbed at her eyes with the tissue. So that was another big moment of her life, just being laid bare to the world. But she was asked how often this happened, that she would eat and bring it back up again.
20:09 Speaker 03 Yep.
20:09 Speaker 00 Um, and she said, look, leading into July twenty twenty three, it was maybe happening, you know, two to three times a week, maybe more.
20:19 Speaker 03 Earlier in the day, Rach, there was this conversation, again, while we're kind of on this sort of like medical issues, um, we heard, you know, we heard a bit of this yesterday, her skepticism of doctors and medical professionals following the birth of first son in two thousand and nine. Today, we heard more stories that kind of, you know, help explain, I suppose, Erin Patterson's uh skepticism and reluctance to engage with with medical professionals.
20:45 Speaker 00 We did, first we learned about a mass that was discovered on the stomach of her daughter.
20:51 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
20:52 Speaker 00 And she said, no one really believed her, but she was giving her daughter massages because she thought she was in a lot of pain. She was crying a lot. Uh, Erin said to Simon, her husband at the time, we have to take her to hospital. And she said, they still dismissed me. And she said it was hard enough to get her in the first place, as in for her to be born.
21:11 Speaker 03 Yep.
21:12 Speaker 00 Um, and she, her voice wavered when she said, I didn't want to lose her. And so an ovarian mass was found when her daughter was about eight months old. So it looks like she carries that still, that no one believed her, even though she was trying to tell them, I know what I can feel.
21:28 Speaker 03 Yep, yep.
21:29 Speaker 00 That's with the daughter. And then there was another issue with the daughter, which I won't go into. And then one with her son, that after he'd had an accident, they X-rayed the wrong side of his body.
21:42 Speaker 03 And she's there kind of going, hang on a second, I think you, I think you're doing this wrong.
21:45 Speaker 00 Correct.
21:45 Speaker 03 And these doctors are like, no, no, don't, you don't know what you're talking about.
21:48 Speaker 00 We know, we know what we're doing.
21:49 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:50 Speaker 00 So because of that, she starts to develop a distrust of medical professionals.
21:54 Speaker 03 Hmm.
21:55 Speaker 00 And this goes to perhaps why she discharged herself on the thirty first of July. We've heard a lot about that story.
22:00 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:01 Speaker 00 She rocks up at Lee and Gather Hospital, she's told she has to be admitted. And she discharges herself and we've heard from the medical staff thinking this is crazy. You know, everyone else from the lunch is sick, why would you go home? So that feeds into some of that.
22:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:17 Speaker 00 It also back then fed into a lot of concerns she had about her own health.
22:21 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:22 Speaker 00 We heard a lot about her using Dr. Google, which we all know.
22:26 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:26 Speaker 00 Is advised, but things like, you know, she, she told the court she was never diagnosed with ovarian cancer. Now, this is important because the issue of cancer was raised at the lunch.
22:37 Speaker 03 Yep.
22:38 Speaker 00 We've heard it was potentially the purpose for the lunch.
22:41 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:41 Speaker 00 So she could work out, you know, with her in-laws, how to tell the kids if there was something wrong with her. She suspected there might be. It seems like Erin Patterson has a pattern from what she told the court of thinking there might be something wrong with her.
22:55 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:56 Speaker 00 So she's often worried about cervical cancer, she said. Uh, she's had in the past fatigue, abdominal pain, headaches, put a lot of weight on in a short period of time. She, she gave an example of going to have her rings resized because her fingers had got bigger.
23:11 Speaker 03 Hmm.
23:11 Speaker 00 And in the two weeks after getting it resized, it already didn't fit.
23:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:15 Speaker 00 You know, and she said, I do have a history of ovarian cancer in the family on both sides.
23:20 Speaker 03 Hmm.
23:20 Speaker 00 And then you'll remember that her daughter had the ovarian mass, as we've just spoken about when she was eight months old. So there's all that playing in her head and so she'd often Google things and what symptoms might lead to other things.
23:34 Speaker 03 Hmm.
23:35 Speaker 00 Uh, she once convinced herself she had a brain tumour. So it sounds like she was often very worried about what she may or may not have.
23:42 Speaker 03 Yeah. Uh, Rach, thank you so much for taking us through what was a really full day of, um, of evidence, uh, from Erin Patterson, sitting in the witness box today. Um, before we get to questions, I mean, you've been in the court so many days of this trial. You've been with us here with Mushroom Case Daily since the trial started. Um, and I just wanted, I was just wondering, I mean, you've been in that room. Has the, has the, the tone or the vibe in the courtroom changed with Erin in the witness box?
24:10 Speaker 00 There is a different feeling in there. There's a different. Level of tension, I would say, it's always very quiet when Erin Patterson is speaking.
24:18 Speaker 03 Hmm.
24:19 Speaker 00 It's a lot harder to get in the courtroom.
24:21 Speaker 03 Okay.
24:22 Speaker 00 There's a lot of interest in this court case, Doki, and when you and I first started this case, which feels like thirty weeks ago, but it was, what, six?
24:31 Speaker 03 Five and a bit, yeah.
24:32 Speaker 00 Uh, there wasn't any lines, but now a line starts building outside court from about six AM.
24:38 Speaker 03 Hmm.
24:39 Speaker 00 People wait to be led into the court at nine AM and then they line up outside the courtroom itself. So it's much harder to get a seat. The other interesting thing I've noticed is Erin Patterson used to sit behind us, used to sit behind the media.
24:51 Speaker 03 Yep.
24:52 Speaker 00 So there used to be a lot of craning around of necks, people trying to see, but now she's in, right in front of us in the witness box.
25:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, the um, the courtroom in Morewell, the media seats are kind of on the left hand side of that room. Um, you know, just in front of the dock. And then the witness box is on the left hand side of the room as well, so she's sitting, sitting yeah, basically directly in front of where you've been sitting today.
25:12 Speaker 00 Physio bills have gone down, there's not as much rubbernecking, but it has, the tone has changed.
25:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
25:18 Speaker 00 Definitely.
25:19 Speaker 03 We have been getting so many questions from people listening to Mushroom Case Daily. The email address is [email protected] . Um, we love hearing from you, there are so many incredible insights, so much great feedback, so many great questions. Um, Rach, you want to start today with a question from Marty? Marty is from Fish Creek in South Gippsland. Hello, neighbour. Um, Marty is loving the content, thank you all, thank you, Marty. And Marty's question is, how much warning did the prosecution have that Erin was going to take the stand? Were they aware she would be called by the defence witness, by the defence as a witness prior to the court case starting? Were they surprised yesterday, like everyone else in the court?
25:54 Speaker 00 I wouldn't say surprised, but I think they would have always had to bank on the fact that she could be called. So it would have to be prepared, just in case, like the rest of us, we don't know. We don't know whether the defence would call Erin Patterson or not. No adverse findings if it doesn't.
26:11 Speaker 03 Yep.
26:11 Speaker 00 That's a strategic decision that it has to take. But I did notice the days before Erin Patterson was called, that Dr Nanette Rogers hadn't been in court for those couple of days. So we were all wondering whether she's prepping for another witness or prepping for the main event.
26:29 Speaker 03 Right, thank you Rach, thank you Marty. Another question here from Karen. G'day, I'm wondering why the court allows the defence to ask all these background questions about Erin's life that seem a bit irrelevant to the facts surrounding the day of the mushroom lunch.
26:42 Speaker 00 Karen, I think it just sets the scene and her behaviour and her background and because of the people involved at the lunch, you know, and the potential issues about intention that the jurors will have to address. It needs to know the relationships she had with certain people, any changes in that relationship. You know, I think her background is important because our backgrounds for all of us lead us to where we are today and why we do or don't do the things we do. So I do think it's important for context.
27:10 Speaker 03 Yep, and also I think, you know, there's so much we don't know where the prosecution and the defence are often going with some evidence. You know, we'll find out kind of those exact things in their closings, right?
27:21 Speaker 00 Yes, I think, you know, a lot of us like things being tied up with neat bows, but I've noticed some seeding being done. Like today, you get to a certain point, I expect to hear something else and then we move on to a different topic. So again, that's strategy, certain things will be seeded
27:41 Speaker 00 and it will all go towards, hopefully, a very neat closing from both the defence and prosecution that might answer a lot of the questions that we don't feel have been answered yet.
27:51 Speaker 03 Thank you Rach, thank you Karen. A great reason to listen to Mushroom Case Daily every single day. So you can, you know, when the trailer breadcrumbs is revealed, you can say to your friends in the group chat, oh, well. That's what Rach was saying on Mushroom Case Daily. Um, final question here from Renat, listening from Greece. Uh, Renat says, love the podcast. Thank you for the intelligent, in-depth coverage. Thanks, Renat. That was it. Just wanted to read that. No, I'm kidding. Renat has a question. Um, Renat was wondering if it's possible for the defence to recall a witness to the stand? For example, Simon Patterson. What if new testimony comes up that requires his response? Or a witness mentions something on the stand that only he can refute or corroborate?
28:28 Speaker 00 Interesting question. I think it is, but it would have very good reason to do so. Because as you know, all the witnesses so far have been prosecution ones. And now we're in the defence case. The prosecution has closed its case. So I think you'd have to have good reason to call someone back because Colin Mandy SC has had this opportunity already in cross-examination. So I'll need to study up on that, Renat. But I think possibly, but it would only have to be done with very good reason.
28:54 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you, Rach. Thank you, Renat. Uh, thank you for listening to Mushroom Case Daily. We will be back in your feed tomorrow. If you want to get the, um, the first drop of Mushroom Case Daily, uh, the first squeeze, if you will, uh, you grab yourself the ABC Listen app. The podcast appears there slightly before it appears on your other podcast platforms. And there's all this wonderful other ABC content you can find yourself diving into through that app. Um, if you have a question for us, please get in touch. [email protected] . Uh, Rach, tomorrow, am I right in assuming more Aaron Patterson?
29:27 Speaker 00 You are right. Can't wait to hear what we learn tomorrow.
29:30 Speaker 03 Absolutely. Uh, and as soon as court wraps up, we'll be back in your feed with another rep.
29:41 Speaker 00 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, investigative reporter Rachel Brown and producer Stephen Stockwell.
29:49 Speaker 03 Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson. And huge thanks to court reporter Christian Silva and our true crime colleagues who continue to help us out. Our commissioning executive producer, Tim Roxburgh, supervising producer, Yasmin Parry. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Kurnai people.
30:12 Speaker 07 Hello, I'm Manoushka Matandadawati, the presenter of Diddy on Trial from BBC Sounds. Sean Diddy Combs is facing a fight for his freedom as his hugely anticipated trial starts for sex trafficking, racketeering with conspiracy and transportation for prostitution. He denies all the charges. I'll be bringing you every twist and turn from the courtroom with the BBC's correspondents and our expert guests, so make sure you listen and subscribe wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
Previous 26 | Erin Patterson takes the stand Next 28 | The lies of Erin Patterson explained – in her own words Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated