Pod Insights The Case Of 20 | Everything you need to know about Erin’s messages: Our Friday Wrap About this episode As the fourth week of the trial comes to a close, we walk through all the key messages Erin sent to her Facebook friends, and how they fit into the timeline of events the prosecution has presented to the jury.
Rachael Brown also joins Kristian Silva and Stephen Stockwell for our Friday Wrap, recapping the biggest moments of the week in court. Finally, we bring you a bonus length audience Q&A, because the inbox is overflowing with your curious questions.
If you've got questions about the case that you'd like Kristian and Stocky to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
-
It's the case that's captured the attention of the world.
Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police allege the beef wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson says she's innocent.
Now, the accused triple murderer is fighting the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Court reporter Kristian Silva and producer Stephen Stockwell are on the ground, bringing you all the key moments from the trial as they unravel in court.
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, the Mushroom Case Daily podcast is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
Keep up to date with new episodes of Mushroom Case Daily https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/mushroom-case-daily, now releasing every day on the ABC listen app.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 If you like your true crime podcasts with real investigative journalism, you'll love Unravel. Unravel is the ABC podcast that investigates a new case each season. It's won podcast awards, journalism awards, and it's had millions of downloads. Unravel will have your headphones glued to your ears. Search for the Unravel podcast now for award-winning true crime. You can find it on the ABC Listen app.
0:29 Speaker 01 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:45 Speaker 02 It was slow and painful. Once the lunch guests ingested death cap mushrooms, their slide towards death was almost impossible to stop. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:57 Speaker 03 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It is Friday, the 23rd of May. We've just finished the fourth week of Erin Patterson's murder trial. Just a warning, there is some strong language in this episode. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
1:09 Speaker 04 The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world.
1:13 Speaker 05 On the menu was beef wellington, a pastry filled with beef and a pate made of mushrooms.
1:18 Speaker 06 At the heart of this case will be the jury's interpretation of Erin Patterson's intentions.
1:24 Speaker 00 Erin Patterson has strongly maintained her innocence. It's a tragedy what's happened. I love them.
1:33 Speaker 03 Christian, we've wrapped up the final day of the fourth week of Erin Patterson's murder trial. Very keen to talk through some of the bigger moments of this week as we get into the episode. But before we do that, can you take us through what we heard in court today?
1:46 Speaker 02 The key witness up today was an intensive care specialist from the Austin Hospital in Melbourne. This was the doctor who was in charge when the lunch guests were in a critical condition. And he was there when three of the four died. He outlined the steps doctors took as they desperately tried to save their lives. We did hear, however, about Ian Wilkinson's story of survival.
2:14 Speaker 03 Thank you, Christian. It was a shorter day in court today, as you mentioned, hearing from the doctors who cared for the lunch guests. The length of the hearing kind of belies the weight, I guess, of what we heard today, though.
2:30 Speaker 02 Fridays are typically shorter court days, but what we heard today, the evidence from Dr Stephen Warlow was incredibly sad and it was a piece of the timeline that we hadn't quite got to yet. We'd heard previously about how the four lunch guests felt really sick in some of the hospitals that they went to, but we hadn't got to the final hospital, which is the Austin in Melbourne. And this witness was called to talk about that.
2:58 Speaker 03 He really took us through those kind of like the final moments, really.
3:03 Speaker 02 He charted us through the slow decline to death. And this is part of the trial, the evidence in the case, you've got to go through it, but it was really sad to hear how these people suffered in their final days. And basically, he said, once they'd come to hospital and they'd done the testing and they kept monitoring, it really didn't matter what they did. It was just never going to stop this slide into death. The doctors sounded like they tried everything. So three of the four guests died and he spoke about Ian Wilkinson, who quite seemingly pulled off a miraculous recovery.
3:41 Speaker 03 Yeah, he spoke about how close he got. He was, you know, pretty much on the edge there, right?
3:47 Speaker 02 Yeah. What Dr Warlow said about Ian Wilkinson was, we thought he was going to die. He was very, very close. We can go through a bit of this timeline. So this lunch happened on a Saturday and within about three days, these guests had made it to the Austin.
4:06 Speaker 02 And the story for for four of them is incredibly similar, according to this doctor. They all came with what appeared to be liver damage, organ failure. They were put on some liver-saving medications. One was called NAC, N A C. There was another one called silobinin and also activated charcoal was also used. They were hooked up to machines, but the doctor said that these injuries were basically irreversible. Don Patterson underwent a liver transplant, but that didn't do anything. And with Don's wife, Gail, she was just too sick to even have a transplant. And Gail's sister Heather was also there, similar position.
4:51 Speaker 02 And the two sisters actually died within about three hours of each other on the fourth of August, twenty twenty three. So this is, yeah, about five days after the lunch. And Don Patterson died the following day, the fifth of August.
5:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, the three deaths. The reason that we're going through this trial of Aaron Patterson accused with murder and attempted murder. The attempted murder referring to Ian Wilkinson, who did recover.
5:16 Speaker 02 He did. And when you're hearing about the deaths of people, naturally, it's really sad. And I think the only sort of positive that you could draw from hearing this very sad story was that the one guy who did survive was actually in the courtroom and it felt nice to see him there. He's the guy who pulled through and Ian Wilkinson listened as the doctor talked about his recovery. So he also came in incredibly sick, just like all the others. After four or five days, he was not looking good. But he turned a corner and very, very slowly recovered. And eventually he was released from hospital about six weeks later and he made it home.
5:59 Speaker 02 And we've seen Mr Wilkinson during the trial, he actually gave evidence early on. So, yeah, it was it was nice to see him there. Just a reminder that. Someone made it.
6:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, positive moment in, in what was, yeah, some, some quite sad evidence that we heard in the court today. Uh, Christian, it's been a very busy week as we've gone through the fourth week of Aaron Patterson's trial. Um, one of the things that we've spent a lot of time with this week is, um, basically, you know, the tracking of locations using devices, a lot of electronic evidence. We've heard as well of, um, you know, about what was recovered from Aaron Patterson's home by police. And you've been doing a little bit of work to try and, you know, collate some of the devices that we've been hearing about this week. What can you kind of tell us about this? What can you break down for us?
6:45 Speaker 02 Before I get into trouble, I must stress not additional research, just looking through transcripts. Not, not doing anything that the jury is told not to do.
6:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, reviewing the evidence, a better way to phrase it.
6:56 Speaker 02 Reading, reading over the transcripts, just like the jury is able to. Um, so yesterday, I think we were talking about phones and messages. And it can get really confusing because there's a few different devices in the case. So I'll try to step through, um, some of these devices and cross-reference it to our previous episodes. So if we start with computers, so when police searched Aaron Patterson's home, they seized a number of computers and phones. And there's a tablet as well. So there's a computer which has been called the caller master computer. Now, I actually think the right term for this is cooler master. The judge has been calling it caller master. Anyway, that doesn't really matter.
7:40 Speaker 03 Right.
7:41 Speaker 02 This was a computer which had three hard drives on it, which was checked by police. And this is the computer where police say there were searches in 2022 for the iNaturalist website. Now, the iNaturalist website is the same website where about five to six months later, people have made online posts saying that they've spotted death cap mushrooms near Aaron Patterson's house. So police, uh, so police allege that on this computer, um,
8:11 Speaker 02 Somebody went to the iNaturalist website and looked up a page about death cap mushrooms
8:19 Speaker 02 in twenty twenty two. So that's that device. There was a Samsung mobile phone seized from Erin Patterson's house, the court was told. This is the device which contains some Facebook messages that Erin Patterson had with some online friends. And we'll get to that later. We mentioned it yesterday as well. So that's that's a Samsung mobile phone. There's a Samsung tablet. This is a device that was also seized from Erin Patterson's house by police. And on this tablet, police said that they found photos of mushrooms that were on some kitchen scales, and they also found some screenshots
9:01 Speaker 02 of what appeared to be Google searches or, you know, Bing searches or something like that. Um, searches for cancer diagnosis. Right. We know from earlier in this trial, the topic of Erin Patterson allegedly claiming she had cancer came up. So so that's on on that device. Um, there's another phone too. And this is a phone which has been nicknamed Phone B. But this is also another Samsung phone. And this is the phone that was factory reset three times in the week after the lunch, according to police. Prosecutors said earlier in this trial that this phone was used by Erin Patterson from about January twenty twenty three, so about
9:46 Speaker 02 six months um before the lunch. Right. I went back to the transcript of the prosecution openings. Hmm. And I actually found references to two more phones. Um, there's a phone which has been dubbed Phone A. Prosecutors say this phone was never recovered, and they say that Erin Patterson also used this in twenty twenty three. And there's another phone, which has been called a Nokia handset. Um. This phone was used by Erin Patterson after um the lunch. It was used about a week later. I'm pretty sure we haven't heard about Phone A or the Nokia handset since the opening day of this trial.
10:29 Speaker 03 Okay, and so just to quickly recap, we've got the computer with the uh unnatural searches uh for death caps in twenty twenty two. We've got the Samsung phone with the Facebook messages that we'll talk about in a second. We've got a Samsung tablet with photos of mushrooms, screenshots, screenshots, I should say, of the searches of uh cancer diagnoses. And then the phone that was reset, plus these other two phones that we're, you know, seeing if we're, they might pop up at another point.
10:55 Speaker 02 Hmm.
10:55 Speaker 03 Yep, um I'm keen to talk about the phone with these Facebook messages on. Because this was a moment uh yesterday afternoon, it came up quite late, we were working towards the last hour of the day. Uh. And so this was something that, you know, if you listen to Thursday's episode, the entire structure of that and the order of that changed as soon as we heard these things. Because we realised it was the the most compelling part of that day. And these are messages, Christian, with um some of Erin Patterson's Facebook friends. And these are, these are some of the women that we heard from earlier in the trial, right?
11:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, the likes of Danielle Barclay and Jenny Hay.
11:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, uh and this conversation, there's messages over the course of about three days. This happened in December twenty twenty two, so about eight months before the lunch. Um. Can you, Christian, can you paint me a picture of what is happening in Erin Patterson's life at this point?
11:41 Speaker 02 So this is a period where there's great tension between Erin Patterson and her husband, Simon. Uh. This is according to evidence we've heard in this trial. The two of them were arguing over things like child support payments, they were arguing over other finances. And what these messages.
12:01 Speaker 02 Show is that Erin Patterson was pretty frustrated with Simon and also with his parents.
12:07 Speaker 03 Hmm. And there's, like I mentioned before, three days of messages. So I think we can sort of step through the day. So the first one is on December 6th. And so we know Erin has these, you know, concerns and frustrations around child support and her relationship with Simon. And it sounds like she has raised them with Don and Gail Patterson, who's Simon's parents. And she's had a call with them. And it sounds like that Don and Gail spoke to Simon. Um, and he just didn't engage, didn't agree that with what Erin was saying. And Erin was basically told that, look, if he doesn't talk to, you know, Don and Gail, his parents, a bit more about it, they're not going to be able to help. And they offered this suggestion that, you know, maybe they should pray about it. Uh, and as Erin is sort of recapping this in this group chat, there's, there's three emojis that go in.
12:50 Speaker 03 Uh, and then a language warning, there's the line, this family, I swear to fucking God. Um, I mean, that language is quite strong. Uh, the, the context that I think is sort of missing a bit from this as well is that there were these emojis. What?
13:03 Speaker 02 Yeah.
13:03 Speaker 03 Do we know what these emojis were?
13:04 Speaker 02 Good question. I think we couldn't really work out what they were. Um, so when this was flashed up on the screens in the courtroom, the lawyers and the judge, um, seemed to not understand what that emoji displayed. And we quickly moved on and it was sort of accepted that, um, we'd just skip over whatever the emoji is. Now, in the media overflow room, we also have a screen and we all sort of rushed up to the screen to try to see what the emoji was. And honestly, I can tell you, I couldn't tell what it was either.
13:37 Speaker 03 Right.
13:38 Speaker 02 It wasn't, um, wasn't, you know, the common emojis that we normally see and that we use in our everyday texting life. So, yeah, I think it's fair to say that, uh, between the lawyers and even many of the reporters, we couldn't quite work out what it meant. So, um, it was kind of, the, the emoji was kind of disregarded and people just focused on the text.
13:58 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yeah. And these are messages that, yeah, Erin is sending in a Facebook chat with, with some of her friends, clearly frustrated with not just Simon Patterson, her husband, but also his parents, um, Don and Gail Patterson. Um, and then there's another message where the person messages says that, you know, Don and Gail don't want to, don't want to adjudicate anything. Um, and then there's a kind of frustration that they don't want to help. Uh, and then there's a, another quote, you know, basically saying the family is a lost cause.
14:26 Speaker 02 Yep.
14:27 Speaker 03 Um. And this is important because again, it's getting to this child support conversation, right? So there's another question um where there seems to be this kind of ask for Erin to withdraw a claim for child support. Because she's applied for child support at this point, right?
14:43 Speaker 02 What it sounds like is that Erin is retelling this story to her friends. And these messages are pretty long in the group chat.
14:51 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:52 Speaker 02 Um, like, yeah, they go for ages. And and as she's talking about this fight over child support payments, she calls Simon's conduct unconscionable. Then again, another language warning, she says, I'm sick of this shit. I want nothing to do with them. Fuck them.
15:08 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, this is again after a kind of suggestion from Don Patterson, uh, her father in law, the the father of her husband. Uh, Simon Patterson kind of again saying, look, we can't really, you know, mediate this. Um, you know, again, maybe you should just just pray about it, this kind of frustration um that she sees again uh with that.
15:28 Speaker 02 And it continues for the next couple of days.
15:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, there's another one. So December seven, um, you know, she jumps back into the group chat and updates saying that she got a message from Don and Gail overnight. And then another one from Simon as well. These are separate messages that she gets. And she says she's actually just not going to read them because she knows that Simon's will be gaslighting and abusive and review and will ruin her day. And that Don and Gales will be weasel words and basically says, I don't need anything more from these people. Um, they say they don't want to take sides, but by their very actions here, she seems to think that they have.
15:58 Speaker 02 And she carries on and she said that if this was relating to Don and Gail's actual daughter, not their daughter in law, they'd act differently.
16:06 Speaker 03 Yep, yeah, and then there's a day break. So, you know, we're talking over the course of three days. So we've had messages on December six, another one, another couple on December seven that we've just gone through. And then there's a day break and on December nine, uh, there's this this final message uh talking about how Gail Patterson, who is Simon Patterson's mother. Um, saying that she was horrified that Erin Patterson had claimed child support. Um, and then saying, why wasn't she horrified that her son is a deadbeat? Um, and then that's the that's the kind of run of those messages. Now, now, Christian, we just saw these messages from Erin Patterson. Are these the ones that I'm kind of across? Were there were there replies from the group chat? Was there conversation going back and forth?
16:42 Speaker 02 We were shown some conversation and some replies from a group member.
16:49 Speaker 02 I'm not entirely sure whether we saw all of the replies. But I think what's worth remembering is that with this evidence that's been presented, the prosecution's job is to present evidence that's relevant to the case. So if there's some belief that some of these replies, potential replies, I don't know if they exist, but if it's, you know, unrelated, then maybe it doesn't need to go in there. At the end of the day, all the evidence that's put before the court is stuff that has been deemed admissible by the judge, so it's appropriate for the jury to see it when they consider this entire case.
17:26 Speaker 03 And this was during someone's evidence in chief, so that was under questioning from the prosecution. So the prosecution is the one who's presenting these messages to the jury so they can have a look at them, right?
17:35 Speaker 02 Correct, yeah.
17:35 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, yeah. Also, just a reminder, this isn't the first time that we've spoken about group chats and messages in the trial. And we heard earlier in the trial when Simon Patterson was on the stand that there was a Signal group chat, Signals, a messaging app that they used. So we heard about that chat that the family would use to communicate. And that Simon claimed at one point that Erin used to send abusive and accusatory messages. And we didn't see that message, though. That wasn't able to be produced when Simon was asked about it.
18:02 Speaker 02 And for clarity, it's not this set of messages either, because this is Erin's group chat with her friends. It doesn't involve members of the Patterson family.
18:11 Speaker 03 Yep, yeah, this is a private group chat. Christian, you know, as well as this, we have had, you know, quite a bit of other stuff going on this week. We've also heard a lot about location data, prosecution alleging that a phone belonging to Erin was near places that death cut mushrooms have been spotted. You can hear more about that on Monday and Tuesday. We also saw CCTV footage of Erin Patterson entering a petrol station just after, I think, a day or two after the lunch.
18:36 Speaker 02 A day after.
18:37 Speaker 03 Yep, this is a time where she said she was feeling very sick. She was, you know, suffering from diarrhoea. And I just want to note that we have received your emails about Erin Patterson wearing light coloured pants on that day. Christian, is there anything that I've missed?
18:52 Speaker 02 You've done a good job. That is a key summary of the evidence we saw this week.
18:55 Speaker 03 Great, thank you, Christian. That's all I was after, really, just fishing for compliments. What was the moment this week that has kind of stuck with you, that you've found yourself thinking back to or reflecting on?
19:06 Speaker 02 This week really felt like it was all about tiny little details. We saw so many charts, diagrams, tables flashed up in court and we had to try to make sense of them. Like the previous weeks have often been people talking about their recollections or their memories. Or we've seen pictures of beef Wellington leftovers. This has been really drilled down to the micro level. And I guess what sticks with me is how I consumed that information. So in the courtroom, there are some seats for the media and members of the public. And there are some screens where you can see these exhibits put up.
19:52 Speaker 02 But some of these tables, they're zoomed out so much that it's impossible to read the text. So what we've actually done on some occasions is we've gone to the media overflow room. Where there's also a screen where you can see these exhibits. And what I think I'll remember from this week is when some of Dr Sorrell's mobile phone reception charts were put up. How all the reporters would run to the front of the room to the screen and frantically write down all the metadata and all the details that we could make sense of from these reports. Because sometimes they only flash up on the screen for a few seconds. This is information that the jury has, by the way, but they've got it on their iPads.
20:36 Speaker 02 They can refer to them, they can zoom in. We unfortunately don't have that luxury. So just the sight of ten to fifteen reporters sitting really way too close to a screen with their legs crossed and laptops typing frantically will be something that remains with me. Because that's not something we do normally. And it really felt like I was taken back to grade two, but.
21:02 Speaker 03 One thing that's different is, man, my legs are sore from that cross-legged sitting. It's uh in the media overflow room, it is quite a sight because that's where I will often spend a bit of time working because I can work on scripts and other things in there uh while while watching the proceedings. And it's like seeing everyone crowded around a little campfire, um just all, you know, tight knit little group, uh all all peering up earnestly at the screen.
21:23 Speaker 02 Yeah, well, it does look a bit silly. The reason we do it is we want to get these small details to people at home. And sometimes things are not said out loud.
21:32 Speaker 03 Hmm.
21:33 Speaker 02 So it's that information that you can pull off the screen and we'll do whatever it takes to get it within the law.
21:38 Speaker 03 Yep. Uh I think my highlights for this week are a a couple of small things and then one medium sized thing. So um small thing uh was Troy from the Monash Council's Council's spreadsheet. I love a spreadsheet.
21:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, you've mentioned that a few times.
21:53 Speaker 03 Just so about it. Uh I've got some for this as well, don't worry. Um but the way that he sort of method- methodically worked around the Asian grocers that he was looking at, the way he kind of put it in a spreadsheet, love that. Um also uh yesterday, when we were hearing about Aaron Patterson's stool samples, the thing that I found fascinating about that was the way they gather the stool samples. We heard about the basically like an upside down witch's hat that goes in the toilet and is designed so it can either sit at the front or the back of the toilet. I just thought that was a very clever.
22:20 Speaker 02 Depends on what kind of sample you're trying to collect.
22:23 Speaker 03 Exactly, whatever they're collecting. And then the kind of medium sized thing this week that I found um really, really quite interesting to watch is um Colin Mandy, the defence barrister who's working for Aaron Patterson, kind of really going to work a bit more this week. He was doing a lot of cross-examination, particularly of Dr Sorrell, really kind of questioning him about the methods, what all of that data meant.
22:46 Speaker 02 And the accuracy, most importantly, the accuracy of his mobile phone tower evidence.
22:52 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:52 Speaker 02 And whether his analysis can precisely pinpoint Aaron Patterson's movements and activity. I thought it was very interesting, too.
23:00 Speaker 03 Yes, and um also, I mean, I know I said only two small things. I do have another small thing that I found, um you know, really sort of did catch my imagination this week uh when we were hearing about the. Search has done on a computer seized from Erin Patterson's house. Um, I just can't stop thinking about the fact that they were done um on the Bing search engine, but through a Chrome browser. That just, the chaos of that has uh has captured my imagination. Um, but enough of that, we uh welcoming back uh Rachel Brown, the ABC's investigative true crime reporter, because I'm very keen to find out uh what has been sticking in uh in your mind this week, this week. Rach, have you been finding yourself gathered around the, the TV in the media overflow
23:44 Speaker 03 room, uh gazing forlornly at exhibits displayed on the screen?
23:48 Speaker 07 No, my quads aren't so like Christians. I've been in the courtroom for most of this week, Stocky.
23:53 Speaker 03 And how's it been in that room? What has the emotion been like? What's the energy been like? Because it has been, look, it's been dense. We're getting through a lot of very technical evidence this week.
24:03 Speaker 07 Um, in terms of energy, it's been a roller coaster week because we've gone from the mechanics of cell tower evidence and computer evidence, which is so dense, which Christian has walked you through, to the human pain and fractures of a family. So I find that roller coaster really interesting and the lengths of human extremes, really. Have you found the same thing?
24:25 Speaker 03 Uh, it's been, you know, the, the, the wide range of what we get. You know, you have a whole day of Dr. Matthew Sorrell, uh, kind of giving you the particulars of how a phone network works. And then you have days like today where you're, you're hearing about someone's final moment. So as you say, it is this kind of roller coaster. But I find that over the course of a week, I guess, kind of easier to manage. I think that I find the days very distinct. I think probably because we're doing this podcast daily, right? So like all the days to me get kind of quite compartmentalized. So it's broken apart a little bit more.
24:51 Speaker 07 Yeah, I know you like your structure. You mentioned spreadsheets and we have seen a lot of them. And I should say, tip for you, you should watch the doco on the world spreadsheet championships.
25:00 Speaker 03 I will, uh, it's on the list, don't worry.
25:02 Speaker 07 If spreadsheets are your thing. No, but it is interesting that we go from that dense evidence to what we have seen in the messages, the text messages with uh Erin Patterson's Facebook group of friends and the insight into her family, the Patterson family and the fractures. You know, we've just heard about.
25:26 Speaker 07 Her frustration at Simon's parents, Don and Gail, refusing to adjudicate on whether she should claim child support or not.
25:33 Speaker 03 Hmm.
25:33 Speaker 07 Now, I'll just read you one of those messages. I wonder if they've got any capacity for self-reflection at all. I mean, clearly the fact that Simon refuses to talk about personally choosing parts stems from the behaviour of his parents and how they operate. According to them, they've never asked him what's going on with us, why I keep kicking him out, why his son hates him, et cetera. It's too awkward or uncomfortable or something. So that's his learned behaviour.
25:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
25:58 Speaker 07 Just don't talk about this shit.
25:59 Speaker 03 Hmm, and, and so that's, you know, it's a really, I mean, it's, it's, you know, we've spoken about this before, but it's such a detailed insight into someone's life that you'd never expect to be kind of broadcast to, you know, you know, not just that room, but you know, to everyone through, through a podcast like this.
26:16 Speaker 07 And all these messages, I've been wondering, you know, would I react like this? Would you react like this? Would my friends, you know, would listeners do the same?
26:24 Speaker 03 Hmm.
26:24 Speaker 07 Maybe, you know, it's interesting, the reactions I've heard from different colleagues, but also through different gender optics as well. What the different responses are, you know. One is like, well, she didn't like the hand that she'd been dealt, so she went to someone else to complain about it, as in, you know, don't like mum's decision, so you'd go to dad, that type of thing.
26:44 Speaker 03 Hmm.
26:45 Speaker 07 But it does illustrate the very human need to vent, to vent to friends. And I wonder what people would find if they went through my phone or, you know, our reactions to things when we're under pressure, you know, like, would you like to hand over your phone right now? Like, maybe living in close quarters with me for a week has driven you crazy.
27:02 Speaker 03 Well, luckily my phone's in the other room, so unfortunately I actually can't hand it to you at the moment. Sorry, Raj.
27:06 Speaker 07 But it's just, um, it's this stark reminder, I spoke to you, I think, the first week of this podcast about the human detritus we're seeing, you know, the, the.
27:16 Speaker 07 These bones of relationships that we're all now picking over and making judgments about rightly or wrongly. And I wonder whether the jury will read them as a woman who wants nothing to do with her in-laws, or will they read it as a woman who is isolated and lonely? Because here's another one I want to read to you. They've had Simon for tea every night for three months and never once picked up the phone to me since the separation and asked if I'm okay and need help. So that tells me their choices.
27:42 Speaker 03 Hmm.
27:42 Speaker 07 So I guess to answer your question, I've spent a lot of time wondering about things we might never know.
27:46 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:47 Speaker 07 Because the courtroom is a house of facts, not feelings.
27:51 Speaker 03 Yep.
27:51 Speaker 07 And so, but nonetheless, I've been wondering, where was Erin Patterson's mind at? You know, I wonder how her kids are doing. I wonder how Ian Wilkinson dealt with today, listening to things like a doctor saying we thought he was going to die.
28:03 Speaker 03 Hmm.
28:04 Speaker 07 You know, I wonder what he was thinking about Heather, his wife we lost. You know, there's just so much pain being laid bare in that courtroom. And even when the verdict comes, whatever it ends up being, there will be certain absolutions that might never come.
28:17 Speaker 03 Yep. Yeah, it's, um, reminds me of what we heard Justice Beal talking about to the jury at the, the start of the trial, that this is something that you make decisions with your head about. You know, you're basing this on the, on the facts that are being presented, not the feelings that you're feeling at any point throughout.
28:30 Speaker 07 And that is so important. That's all they have to go on and, and should go on. But in, as he said, you need to push aside empathy, you need to push aside prejudice. We're dealing with cold, hard facts here.
28:41 Speaker 03 Hmm. And it's really interesting because a lot of the time that does feel really kind of like, you know, unhuman, very, very unemotional. Yeah. Uh, Rachel, thank you so much for joining us.
28:49 Speaker 07 Thank you.
28:49 Speaker 03 On, uh, Mushroom Case Daily. Uh, Rachel Brown is the ABC's true crime investigative reporter, is the, uh, the brains and the voice behind the fantastic Trace podcast series. You can find it on the ABC Listen app. Go and track that one down. It is a, it's a wonderful series. Christian, we continue to hear from so many of the Mushroom Case Daily listeners, listening from all over the world. Uh, [email protected] is our email address. If you have a question, you can send it to us. And that is what these people have been doing. I would like to start with a question from Ebony. Uh, she asks, does Erin know what evidence is being presented prior to the commencement of the trial with her lawyer? Or does she find that out during the trial? Love the podcast. Thank you, Ebony.
29:32 Speaker 02 Thanks Ebony. Broadly, yes, Erin Patterson does have some idea. The prosecution is obliged to provide the defence with its, what's called a brief of evidence. Um. Which contains the information that they plan to use or potentially use in the case.
29:50 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you, Christian. Um. Have another question here from Kate in Greensborough in Victoria. Uh. She listens to the pod as she's driving around in the evening, uh, while her two-year-old falls asleep. Uh, so apologies for the swear words, Kate. Um. Kate says, we're in week four of what I understand is set down as a five-week trial. When will the defence get its chance to call witnesses? What happens if they run out of time?
30:11 Speaker 02 We all go home. Just kidding. Just kidding. Thanks, Kate. It is a five to six-week trial, but, uh, don't worry, we will not have a situation where, um, we run out of time and the trial has to be called off for time limitation reasons. Um. That is just an estimate that the, the, the judge gave. And once the prosecution has gone through all of its evidence, the defence will then get the chance to call their witnesses if they would like. Um. After that, we go through the process of what's called closing arguments, where both sides get to sum up the case again. The judge will give what's called the charge, but it's basically another set of legal instructions and then the jury goes out to deliberate.
30:56 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you, Christian. Thank you, Kate. Uh. I have a question here from, uh, Tashara. They say, hi, Christian and Stephen. Thank you for your hard work on the podcast. Thank you. Um. They also appreciate little details that we share about the day-to-day happening, happenings like the beetles and the temperature. Um. Just so you know, it's warmed up a bit. Fifteen degrees today.
31:13 Speaker 02 Yeah.
31:13 Speaker 03 Barmy. Um. One of the things, their question is basically around, um, Erin Patterson. Uh. They say earlier this week, we mentioned there might be the possibility that police interview with Erin Patterson will be used as evidence. Uh. They were wondering if the prosecution is allowed to call Erin Patterson to the stand as part of their case, or is this generally not done?
31:31 Speaker 02 The prosecution can't call the defendant as a witness for their case, but what they may choose to do is play a record of interview.
31:39 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
31:40 Speaker 02 Now, the prosecutors did say earlier on in this trial that there was one of those. It hasn't come up yet.
31:47 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
31:47 Speaker 02 Um. But we know that, uh, the prosecution case isn't finished yet, so there's more to come.
31:52 Speaker 03 Yeah. And, uh, if anyone, uh, can call Erin Patterson, the defence can call her, but, you know, it's a, you know, we don't know if that will happen yet. And, uh, there, there won't be any adverse influence if Erin Patterson doesn't, uh, step up and give evidence in this trial.
32:04 Speaker 02 That's right. The onus of proof is on the prosecution. The prosecution has got to satisfy the jury that Erin Patterson is guilty. If that's what they're to rule, if the prosecution can't do that, she's not guilty.
32:19 Speaker 03 Yep, yep. We have a question here from Tanya. Tanya, thanks us for our reporting of this case. And their question is whether or not a juror can seek clarification from the judge or from the representing parties via the judge. For example, if they don't understand terminology or scientific detail.
32:37 Speaker 02 Great question. So what happens is the jury has appointed a foreperson, one of their own, who is effectively the captain of the jury. If there's some questions, they can write a note, which the foreperson will then pass on to Mr Hastings, the tip staff, who will then inform the judge. And this is actually what Justice Christopher Beale told the jury about this very issue on day one. He said that he will discuss any notes they provide with lawyers in the absence of the jury. And he said they'll formulate the appropriate answer or response. We did see one moment, I think, earlier on in the trial, when one of the members of the jury might have yelled out a question, though.
33:21 Speaker 03 This, I think this was quite early and this was maybe in the first or second day. We were talking about the Signal group messaging app. And it was just being referred to as Signal. And a juror said, excuse me, what's Signal? Not quite following the proper protocol, but they did get an answer.
33:36 Speaker 02 Yep.
33:36 Speaker 03 And it was clarified that it was a messaging app. So it is working and we are seeing that clarification made when they have questions.
33:43 Speaker 02 The only note we have seen, I believe, is when there was a Monday where the jurors were given off and then they passed a note very quickly after asking if it would be every Monday.
33:53 Speaker 03 Every Monday do we still have to go to work?
33:55 Speaker 02 And unfortunately, it was not every Monday and they have been back.
33:59 Speaker 03 They have been back. A question here from Sarah. Thanks us for the covering, thanks us for our coverage of the case. They are wondering about how things work with members of the public who may be in the courtroom, listening to the details of the case regarding obligations to treat the information with the same sensitivity that we're obligated to. For example, what is preventing them from disclosing further details externally? Are they treated like the jury with the same rules around not discussing the case with others? What happens to them during times when the jury is not in the room during legal discussions?
34:28 Speaker 02 Thanks, Sarah. It is an open justice system. And as we've talked about earlier, it's not completely open to the point where things are broadcast on TV. But it's definitely open to the extent where people can come in and watch proceedings. So this is like a fundamental part of our justice system. Now, obviously, when it comes to things that happen when the jury's not in the room, they certainly shouldn't be going around and telling other people what occurred in the absence of the jury, just like we wouldn't do either. And members of the public certainly would be ill advised to go and post things online about what happened in the courtroom while the jury was not there. Obviously, they're
35:09 Speaker 02 not allowed to interact with the jury or with the parties or go up to Aaron Patterson either. It's the same rules that apply to the rest of us.
35:17 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, the the rules around reporting on on stuff like this are actually the same for kind of everyone. We're just more aware of them as the media because it's stuff that's specifically kind of applied to us as we're the ones that are usually doing it, but everyone else has to has to follow the same rules as well. And we have another entry in our more of a statement category. It is from Natalie. It is an excellent statement because Natalie is a lawyer working in the criminal justice system in Australia. And she just wanted to highlight one thing. Me and a number of listeners sending in questions often refer to witnesses as taking the stand. This is an Americanism. In Australia, witnesses give evidence from the witness box. They do not take the stand. Natalie, that is a fantastic point to make because I am very guilty of doing that. So I appreciate the clarification.
36:01 Speaker 03 And from here, I encourage anyone to email if I say, take the stand again.
36:05 Speaker 02 I think you've been put into your box.
36:07 Speaker 03 I've been put into my box. I have.
36:09 Speaker 02 Thanks, Natalie.
36:10 Speaker 03 Thank you so much for all of your questions. If you have one that you would like to send in, you'd like us to answer, you can get it to [email protected] . And our Christian, as well as all of these questions, we've got people listening from all over the world that have been writing in. I'd love your help going around the grounds to some of these far-flung listeners. I'll I'll start. We've got a few listeners in the UK. Sarah in Norwich, Violet on the England-Wales border, Manisha in Manchester.
36:34 Speaker 02 We've got Steph and Simon listening from Kilmartin Castle in Scotland.
36:39 Speaker 03 We've got Itzasso listening from Donatia in Spain. Also, even Kat, who have been walking the Camino de Santiago Portuguese, they wrote in from Pardon in Spain. They only had 25 kilometres left as well when they emailed on Monday. So even Kat, I hope you have finished your walk now. Congratulations.
36:56 Speaker 02 And in the US, Christie in Philadelphia and Jessica in San Diego.
37:00 Speaker 03 And finally, Adrian from Geelong is listening in. Christian, am I right in saying from Mannheim, Germany?
37:07 Speaker 02 That is what is written here.
37:09 Speaker 03 Fantastic. Anyone you'd like to say hello to before we wrap up the pod today?
37:12 Speaker 02 Yes, I'd like to give a small shout out. Someone came up to me in court today and told me about one of our listeners who lives in London. Her name is Abby. I'm told she listens to the podcast every morning when she wakes up. Thank you, Abby. But the interesting thing that got me was Abby's 10 years old.
37:31 Speaker 03 And listening to a daily podcast about a triple murder trial.
37:33 Speaker 02 Yes, yeah. Look, if Abby, thank you very much for listening. We really appreciate it. Thank you to Abby's parents for letting her listen to it as well.
37:45 Speaker 03 Hopefully to all the other parents who are letting their children listen to this as well. It is just as an educational activity as it is for Abby in the UK.
37:52 Speaker 02 And sorry for swearing for the last couple of episodes too.
37:55 Speaker 03 Yes, apologies about that. We'll clear that up next week. That's such a not a promise. Speaking of next week, Christian, where are we going?
38:01 Speaker 02 Well, the prosecution case isn't over yet. And you'll remember to our episode yesterday, we talked about the digital forensic analyst, Sharman Fox Henry. So the prosecution actually finished with his evidence today. It was all of one question, but we didn't get to his cross examination. So that will inevitably happen next week when Colin Mandy, the barrister for Erin Patterson, quizzes Sharman Fox Henry.
38:27 Speaker 03 Thank you so much for joining us on Mushroom Case Daily. I highly recommend getting your hands on the ABC Listen app and following Mushroom Case Daily there. It's the best way to listen. If you are listening on a different podcast platform though, please give us a review, leave us a rating. It makes it much easier for other people to find us.
38:50 Speaker 02 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, court reporter Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
38:59 Speaker 03 Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson, and many thanks to the Victorian newsroom and audio studios manager, Eric George, also to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh. Today's guests, Rachel Brown and Yasmin Parry, helping make this show a reality. Also, shout out to Jasmine Sims, our legal queen. There is no way that this happens without you. Thank you, Jas. And finally, thank you for listening. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Koni people.
39:35 Speaker 00 Ever been hit with a tricky question from your child? Like, whether it's okay for parents to lie to kids to make them do something?
39:43 Speaker 03 We're the hosts of Short and Curly, a fun podcast for children and their adults to untangle life's curliest questions.
39:50 Speaker 00 Should you be punished for something you did a long time ago?
39:54 Speaker 03 Is it wrong to leave all of your money to a cat? I personally think it's fine.
39:58 Speaker 00 Ugh, no surprise there, cat people. Short and Curly is philosophy with a pantomime twist.
40:04 Speaker 03 Perfect for car trips, or for kickstarting dinner debates.
40:07 Speaker 00 Search for the Short and Curly podcast now. You can find it on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 19 | "I want nothing to do with them" - Erin’s messages about lunch guests Next 21 | Tracking down the mushroom source Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated