Pod Insights The Case Of 17 | Doubt cast over location data placing Erin near death caps About this episode Erin Patterson's defence team got to work today, casting doubt over evidence that places the accused near death cap mushroom sightings.
In today's episode, Kristian Silva and Stephen Stockwell talk through the defence’s strategy, explain some CCTV vision the jury was shown, and honour an uninvited visitor to the courtroom.
If you've got questions about the case that you’d like Kristian and Stocky to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
-
It's the case that's captured the attention of the world.
Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police allege the beef wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson says she’s innocent.
Now, the accused triple murderer is fighting the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Court reporter Kristian Silva and producer Stephen Stockwell are on the ground, bringing you all the key moments from the trial as they unravel in court.
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, the Mushroom Case Daily podcast is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
Keep up to date with new episodes of Mushroom Case Daily https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/mushroom-case-daily, now releasing every day on the ABC listen app.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 If you like your true crime podcasts with real investigative journalism, you'll love Unravel. Unravel is the ABC podcast that investigates a new case each season. It's won podcast awards, journalism awards, and it's had millions of downloads. Unravel will have your headphones glued to your ears. Search for the Unravel podcast now for award-winning true crime. You can find it on the ABC Listen app.
0:29 Speaker 01 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:45 Speaker 02 Sowing the seeds of doubt. Erin Patterson's defence team was busy today. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:53 Speaker 03 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It is Tuesday, the 20th of May, and we've just finished the 14th day of this trial. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
1:01 Speaker 04 The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world.
1:05 Speaker 05 Ms Patterson admits she lied to police about foraging for mushrooms.
1:08 Speaker 06 A doctor says he told Erin Patterson she could die without urgent treatment. At the heart of this case will be the jury's interpretation of Erin Patterson's intentions.
1:19 Speaker 03 It's a tragedy what's happened. I love them. Christian, today, as you've mentioned, we saw Erin Patterson's legal team go to work, really pushing some of the witnesses that we saw. Can you give us a rundown of the day's events?
1:33 Speaker 02 Stocky, it was pretty dense and pretty dour. Dr Matthew Sorrell, the mobile phone expert, was back on the stand today, talking about Erin Patterson's phone records. And he was cross-examined by Erin's barrister, Colin Mandy, for what seemed like forever. Maybe it went for about three or four hours. It was long and drawn out. We did get to another witness towards the end of the day, a police officer, who showed the court some CCTV footage of Erin Patterson taken one day after the lunch.
2:11 Speaker 03 Thank you, Christian. We saw Dr Matthew Sorrell, the mobile phone location expert, continuing to give evidence today. At the start of the day, prosecution was asking him a few questions, and then we saw the defence step up for cross-examination. And the defence barrister who's leading Erin Patterson's defence is Colin Mandy SC. And I think I saw him work with an energy that we haven't seen so far. He leapt up as soon as Jane Warren had finished her questioning the witness, and immediately launched in, following a similar line of questioning, just asking Dr Matthew Sorrell how certain he could be that, you know, what the evidence he was presenting meant that Erin Patterson was in these areas, spending hours questioning him about this data. He's basically trying
2:54 Speaker 03 to cast doubt over that evidence in the mind of the jury, right?
2:57 Speaker 02 Yeah. So just to recap, people who may have missed yesterday's episode, the prosecution has talked about death cap mushrooms being in the beef Wellington lunch which Erin Patterson served the guests on the 29th of June 2023. And I'm going to say the dates just so we can step through the timeline. Now prosecutors say that a couple of months before that lunch, there were some online postings made on this website called iNaturalist, where death cap mushrooms were sighted in an area called Locke and an area called Outtrim. And these are fairly close to where Erin Patterson lives. Her house is in a town called Leeingatha.
3:37 Speaker 02 So the prosecution has got a hold of pretty detailed phone records from Erin Patterson's mobile device. And what they've done is, is they've looked at cell towers that her phone has connected to. So on the 21st of May, one of these posts goes up on the website about possible death cap sighting in Outtrim. Then on the 22nd of May, the prosecution says that Erin Patterson's phone pings in Outtrim, and it also pings in Locke.
4:13 Speaker 03 Right.
4:13 Speaker 02 One of the other areas. So that's just the quick explanation as to how we got here.
4:17 Speaker 03 Yep.
4:18 Speaker 02 Now, Dr Sorrell concedes that his analysis has some limitations because what it does is, it looks at phone towers that mobile phones connect to.
4:29 Speaker 03 Hmm.
4:29 Speaker 02 And using that evidence, he provides some analysis about a person's possible movements and potential time that they may or may not have spent somewhere.
4:41 Speaker 03 Right, okay. And today, we saw the defence, Aaron Patterson's defence team, just trying to cast doubt on how accurate that is and if that places someone in those locations.
4:53 Speaker 02 Exactly, because the prosecution is essentially claiming that Aaron Patterson went to places where death cap mushrooms were growing.
4:59 Speaker 03 Hmm.
5:00 Speaker 02 Um, now Colin Mandy very methodically took Dr Sorrell to his entire methodology of how he analyses the data to ask him about the accuracy of it and whether he can be truly certain that Aaron Patterson did go to these areas. And Dr Sorrell conceded there are a number of limitations when it comes to um his analysis and whether it can clearly tell you what a person's doing. So perhaps a phone might connect to a different base station to the one that's closest to it because the signal's not as good, or the weather's bad, or the antenna's not pointed in the right direction, or um signals may change between stations because the phone's moving.
5:45 Speaker 03 Hmm.
5:45 Speaker 02 So all of this kind of led up to a final conclusion that your phone may connect to a base station in a particular spot, but that does not necessarily mean you are in that spot.
6:00 Speaker 03 Right.
6:01 Speaker 02 We heard this rehashed time and time again, it felt like for hours.
6:04 Speaker 03 Hmm.
6:05 Speaker 02 Confirmation over and over again that there's this qualification to what the analysis can show.
6:11 Speaker 03 Yep, right.
6:12 Speaker 02 It must have been hammered home thirty times, at least.
6:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, and different examples given of what might influence um the reason for a phone connecting to a certain tower, you know, like the weather, the the thickness of the walls in a house, a valley, all of that kind of stuff. We went. We went into incredible detail today.
6:30 Speaker 02 We did, and the point was even made that inside a house, signal can be different from one end of the house to the other. And I can say from my own experience, sitting in the courtroom, on one side of the courtroom, the phone signal is atrocious. And on the other side, I'm talking like seven or eight metres away, the phone signal is perfect. So that's just, yeah, my observation from, uh, sitting in court.
6:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. And I think it's interesting as well, you know, we're talking through this detail, um, we're listening to this. The jury has to sit through this as well. They've got to digest this. They've got to take all of this into account as they're considering the evidence, you know, for and against Erin Patterson in this case.
7:09 Speaker 02 And the jury's being shown really detailed charts, tables. Um, they're taken to maps which have got tiny dots on them. They do have iPads where the exhibits are uploaded to. So the expectation is, is that they're going to keep up with this and scroll through on their iPads. Um, I must say, when we sit in the courtroom and we see these exhibits put up on the screen, sometimes we can't even read the lines on these tables because there's that many rows. It's, um, it's pretty dense.
7:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. Um, as well as hearing from, uh, Dr. Matthew Sorrell today, we also had evidence from a, uh, police officer. Uh, this is a police officer who went to a service station and, um, got some CCTV footage of Erin Patterson. I think in the days after the lunch, um, what did we see on that video?
7:56 Speaker 02 This was footage taken a day after the lunch. You're talking about twenty six, twenty seven hours after the four lunch guests came to Erin Patterson's house. And it was CCTV from a service station in a place called Caldermead. Erin Patterson is seen in the footage, her car pulls right up to the entrance of the service station and parks in one of the bays right at the front door. Erin is then seen getting out of the car, walking into the service station quite calmly, it appears.
8:25 Speaker 03 Yep.
8:26 Speaker 02 She then enters the toilets.
8:29 Speaker 02 About 10 seconds later, she reemerges from the toilet, goes and browses at what appears to be like a sandwich section of the service station, you know, those that have them on display there.
8:41 Speaker 03 Hmm.
8:41 Speaker 02 And she meanders over to a fridge where there's about a million drinks in there.
8:47 Speaker 03 Yep.
8:47 Speaker 02 Looks around there for a while. I think she buys a, buys a product from the service station because she's at the counter for a bit.
8:53 Speaker 03 Yep.
8:54 Speaker 02 And then she walks out the door and jumps into the car and heads off. This entire thing lasts for about three minutes.
9:00 Speaker 03 And this day, this is the day after lunch, this is the day that Erin Patterson reported feeling quite sick, right?
9:05 Speaker 02 That's right. We heard evidence earlier in this trial from Erin's kids, who said that she reported feeling sick the night of the lunch. And then the following day was complaining about having diarrhoea. Having said that though, she, according to her son, insisted on taking him to a flying lesson, which is why they've come through that Caldermead area, it would seem. And, and this stop at the service station is, is along the way, either there or back.
9:38 Speaker 03 Hmm.
9:39 Speaker 02 Um, as I said in the footage, Erin appears to be quite calm. She's wearing a grey jumper, some white pants, and she's got a small bag, which has got like a cross body strap.
9:52 Speaker 03 Right. Yep. Um, I thought it was interesting when we were hearing this evidence, um, sort of put into court today, um, through the police office that we heard from, that, I mean, I guess it just occurred, occurred to me that this is how the prosecution is introducing evidence. They're calling these witnesses and going, okay, so you got this CCTV footage. Is that right? Have I, have I understood that properly?
10:12 Speaker 02 The way that the prosecution runs any case is that when they have evidence to present to the court, there's usually a witness that accompanies that. Almost like the evidence is introduced through that witness. So when we saw certain medical records, they called specific doctors who either compiled those records or had something to do with the generation of those records. We had Dr Sorrell, he was analysing the phone data. And likewise with this police officer, he was the person who went and collected the CCTV footage.
10:46 Speaker 03 Yep. Also, Christian, before we get into some of the questions that we've been sent from our audience, quite a dramatic moment in court today. There was an uninvited visitor who disturbed proceedings while Dr Sorrell was giving evidence.
11:00 Speaker 02 Staggering, really. You see a lot of things in this job. I never thought I'd see the Beatles in court.
11:06 Speaker 03 During Dr Sorrell's evidence, we did have a beetle calling across the microphone.
11:13 Speaker 02 Quite incredible. I'm not really sure how it got up into the courtroom and then onto his microphone. But he did get a bit of a fright and there was a chuckle that went around the courtroom. But then he got over it, he composed himself and carried on.
11:31 Speaker 03 I mean, Christian, it is incredible that it was able to make it into the room.
11:35 Speaker 02 The little beetle that could.
11:36 Speaker 03 Little beetle that could. With Mr Hastings, the tipstaff who keeps ordering the courtroom, obviously let his guard down for a moment and it snuck in.
11:42 Speaker 02 Shh. If he hears that, we'll be in big trouble. Yeah, I've heard about animals getting into court before. There was apparently a mouse that got into the Supreme Court in Melbourne a couple of years ago and it frightened some jury members. But the beetle was a first. The flora and fauna and the insect life in Morewell thriving despite incredibly cold conditions in this town.
12:08 Speaker 03 Today was one of the coldest days in something like 40 years, negative four degrees overnight here in Morewell.
12:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, I went out at about 7am and the visibility was 25 to 30 metres, just a sheet of white.
12:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, the fog here is, it's a real sight. You know, it's a beautiful place to wake up to. Today was beautiful, by the way. Once the fog cleared, cold but just a cloudless sky. We have had a number of questions sent into us, [email protected] if you'd like to get in touch and if you've got something that you think we can answer or help you with, if you've got questions about this case. Christian, first honour I'd like to get to today is from Eliza in Bendigo. She asks, is there any other evidence besides cellphone tower pings that put Aaron Patterson in the areas that the mushrooms were?
12:54 Speaker 02 Thanks, Eliza. Based on the evidence that we've heard so far in the trial, all we've heard about in terms of Aaron Patterson potentially travelling to an area where mushrooms were comes from that cellphone tower evidence. Looking back at the prosecution openings, which feels like an age ago, but it was three weeks ago, prosecutors did flag that Aaron Patterson did a police interview. Now, we haven't seen that yet, so if it is played to the court, we don't know whether there's questions about that in there. We'll just have to wait and see. But yeah, to answer the question, just the cellphone towers potentially connects Aaron to those areas.
13:37 Speaker 03 Thank you, Christian, and thank you, Eliza, for that question. We have another question here from Peter in Bonville, which is south west of Coffs Harbour. He says, hi, Christian and Stephen, wonderful podcast, excellent work. Thank you, Peter. He asks, or he says, there's been a lot of time spent talking to experts who have detailed the toxins in the death cap mushrooms. What is the relevance of this, given both the prosecution and defence teams acknowledged that there were death cap mushrooms in the beef Wellington?
14:03 Speaker 02 Thanks, Peter. I'd say there's probably two components to answer that question. Firstly, the prosecution still has to lay out the evidence in the case. So they need, if they're going to allege that there were death cap mushrooms in the meal, they need to show the jury evidence of that. So that, I would say that's the first thing. But the second thing that's relevant, I think, is that despite both prosecution and defence agreeing that the lunch guest suffered from death cap mushroom poisoning.
14:35 Speaker 02 The way that their bodies reacted were different. When you compare Erin Patterson's illness not being as serious as the other lunch guests. And prosecutors claim that Erin Patterson did not ingest death cap mushroom toxins because they allege she ate a meal that was uncontaminated. Now, the defence has said in its openings that Erin did fall sick, but obviously not to the extent as the others. So I think that's why we've had to go through the motions and go through what the toxins are, what they can do and the impacts on people's bodies.
15:12 Speaker 03 Thank you, Christian. Thank you, Peter. Wonderful question. And our last question for today's episode is from Wanda in Ottawa in Canada. She says, thanks very much for absorbing daily podcast on this interesting trial. Thank you, Wanda. At the moment, we're listening to prosecution witnesses. When the defence begins its case, will any of these witnesses return to the stand or is their part in the case now over?
15:33 Speaker 02 Thanks, Wanda. Well, the defence has had its chance to question witnesses who've been called by the prosecution. Been talking today about how Dr Sorrell was subjected to a very lengthy cross-examination, probably as long as his examination in chief. So they wouldn't be then calling those same witnesses to return to the stand. They're given this opportunity to question them now. Of course, they have the opportunity to call their own witnesses, though.
16:01 Speaker 03 Yep, yeah, yeah. Thank you, Wanda. Thank you, Christian. That brings us to the end of today's episode. If you have any questions that you'd like us to answer, please get in touch, [email protected] . And if you're joining this podcast and you're listening on something that isn't the ABC Listen app, please leave us a rating, give us a review. That helps other people find us. And, you know, I will, of course, recommend that you do find yourself with the ABC Listen app, track down Mushroom Case Daily on there and hit follow. That way you won't miss an update. Also, if you need any more true crime to help you get through your day after you finish Mushroom Mushroom Case Daily, check out the ABC's podcast, Unravel. This is a wonderful true crime podcast. Each season, they're investigating an unbelievable Australian crime.
16:42 Speaker 03 It's everything from love scams to mysterious deaths in country towns to cold case disappearances. I don't want to tell you too much about the most recent season, Mr Big, because if I do, I'll probably give it away, but there is a huge twist in it and you won't see it coming.
16:56 Speaker 02 Is it that Mr Big is that character from Sex and the City?
16:59 Speaker 03 You will need to get yourself on the ABC Listen app and search for Unravel there and Listen to Mr Big to find out for yourself. Christian, what have we got coming up tomorrow?
17:10 Speaker 02 Stocky, Detective Senior Constable Kwong Tran, the police officer who introduced the CCTV footage of Aaron at the service station, his evidence is going to continue. It was cut a little bit short today because there was some legal arguments. So we'll hear more from him tomorrow, I think.
17:27 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you, Christian. And make sure you are keeping an eye on the ABC Listen app. So you get that episode when it pops up.
17:40 Speaker 02 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, court reporter Christian Silva and producer Stephen Stockwell.
17:50 Speaker 03 Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson and many thanks to the Victorian newsroom and audio studios manager, Eric George. Also, shout out to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh, Rachel Brown and Yasmin Parry, who we couldn't make this show without. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Kurnai people.
18:08 Speaker 04 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
18:18 Speaker 07 An hour. One hour. So I had this pig and I'm rubbing its stomach. Two mics. Two microphones.
18:23 Speaker 06 So sound wave travels into the ear canal and it hits the eardrum. Unforgettable stories. Strutting, fluffing up your neck feathers, making booming sounds in your throat.
18:33 Speaker 02 And you use the word really? And the answer to these reallies is always yes.
18:39 Speaker 02 Hear the latest from conversations. Find it on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 16 | Erin Patterson's movements traced by location expert Next 18 | Erin Patterson’s alleged search history examined Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated