Pod Insights The Case Of 15 | Death caps, DNA and drama. Our Friday Wrap About this episode Three weeks into Erin Patterson's triple-murder trial, we review the key evidence the jury has heard, and the pressure they are under to absorb enormous volumes of expert evidence.
Investigative reporter Rachael Brown joins Kristian Silva and Stephen Stockwell for our weekly wrap, where she champions the trial’s “cool nerds” and explores what’s driving the growing public interest in the case.
If you’ve got questions about the case that you’d like Kristian and Stocky to answer in future episodes, send them through to [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
-
It's the case that's captured the attention of the world.
Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police allege the beef wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson says she’s innocent.
Now, the accused triple murderer is fighting the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Court reporter Kristian Silva and producer Stephen Stockwell are on the ground, bringing you all the key moments from the trial as they unravel in court.
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, the Mushroom Case Daily podcast is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
Keep up to date with new episodes of Mushroom Case Daily https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/mushroom-case-daily, now releasing every day on the ABC listen app.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Unravel is the ABC's hit true crime podcast where we investigate a new case each season. There are six seasons waiting for you to binge right now. That's six mysteries to unravel, including cold cases, disappearances and a mysterious globe trotting con woman. The Australian Podcast Awards have crowned Unravel Best True Crime Podcast twice. So if you haven't heard it yet, find out what you're missing out on. Follow the Unravel podcast now. Find it on the ABC Listen app.
0:37 Speaker 01 ABC Listen. Podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:52 Speaker 02 It's the week that's taken us from beef wellingtons to biochemistry. I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:59 Speaker 03 And I'm Stephen Stockwell. It's Friday the 16th of May and we've just finished the third week of Erin Patterson's trial. Welcome to Mushroom Case Daily.
1:07 Speaker 04 The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world.
1:11 Speaker 05 As Patterson admits, she lied to police about foraging for mushrooms. A doctor says he told Erin Patterson she could die without urgent treatment.
1:19 Speaker 03 At the heart of this case will be the jury's interpretation of Erin Patterson's intentions.
1:25 Speaker 06 It's a tragedy what happened. I love them.
1:30 Speaker 03 Christian, we have found ourselves at the end of the third week of this trial.
1:34 Speaker 02 Dragged ourselves to the end.
1:35 Speaker 03 Crawled our way here. Before we go back through what we've seen this week, can you take us through what we've heard in court today?
1:42 Speaker 02 We started the day with 14 jurors, which was a relief after yesterday's drama. Thankfully, all that finished the day yesterday were back this morning. This morning, Dr. Dimitri Gerasimoulas returned to the stand to finish his evidence. He's the state's leading toxicologist and he was talking again about the leftovers retrieved from Erin Patterson's house. And the day was rounded out by more scientific discussion, this time around mushroom DNA.
2:16 Speaker 03 Great start to the day, Christian. All 14 jurors, as you mentioned, returning into the jury box. 14 leave, 14 enter.
2:22 Speaker 02 Yes, but still actually an empty seat for juror number 84, who was the one who was punted yesterday.
2:30 Speaker 03 Yep. Once they were all seated, we started getting into the evidence for today. And we spoke yesterday about the evidence from Dr Dimitri Jarostamoulas. He is from the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine. And he was being cross-examined today by Colin Mandy, who's representing Aaron Patterson's defence. And it sounded like Colin Mandy, with a lot of the conversation, was trying to get into this idea there may have been contamination with the beef Wellington that was found in Aaron Patterson's bin, because he was going through, doing a bunch of testing on that. And lots of questions about, you know, how was the state of this? Was there leakage? All of that. Like, you know, where do you think he was trying to go with some of that?
3:07 Speaker 02 I think what he was trying to do was to clarify the testing methods and any possible shortfalls that may exist with those. So the professor was asked about some of the testing methods that were used. And he said, look, these are tried and true methods. And, you know, the people doing them have good expertise. He said, it's not possible to sample the entire contents of, let's say, the beef Wellington that they found, or some of the other samples. But when he was addressing some of the positive results for the death cap mushroom toxins, which are known as alpha and beta amanitins, he said that if they
3:50 Speaker 02 record a positive result on one of their tests, that means it's met a certain reporting criteria. So he conceded that it's possible for these toxins to exist, but for them to be below the reporting threshold. So when he was taken, for instance, to the human samples that were taken from Don Patterson and Ian Wilkinson, he said that when they found these toxins from these samples from these men, it was obviously above that threshold.
4:24 Speaker 03 Right, yep. And because he didn't find some of those toxins in um Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson. So is he saying, look, they could still be there, but they might just be below this level that we're looking for?
4:36 Speaker 02 In theory, and crucially, those toxins were not found from Erin Patterson either. And she was tested about two days after the lunch which was held at her house.
4:46 Speaker 03 He he made a kind of important clarification around something he said yesterday too, because yesterday, I believe Dr Jerystamullah said that, you know, you can only find these toxins in death cap mushrooms. And today he was like, oh, actually, sorry, made a mistake there. You will actually, you can actually find them in other mushrooms as well.
5:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, you can get them in the Ammonita genus, which is basically the family that the death cap mushroom belongs to. So it's it's not just one type of mushroom that contains these toxins that are really, really dangerous to humans.
5:14 Speaker 03 And and and Colin Mandy also during his cross examination of Dr Jerystamullah, kind of started pointing out or referring to these kind of like levels of death cap mushroom poisoning.
5:25 Speaker 02 There was a study that he was taken to, which was done in 2017 by some German researchers. And that actually looked at death cap mushroom poisoning in Europe, where there has been more reported cases than in Australia. And according to this study, uh, the doctor conceded that there are some grades that have been given to the level of poisoning. Grade one being patients who might suffer some gastro but don't go on to to have organ damage, all the way to grade four where they die.
5:54 Speaker 03 Right.
5:55 Speaker 02 So according to the study, they can sort of be um ranked.
5:58 Speaker 03 And did they sort of line up any of those levels with what we saw from the lunch guests during Patterson?
6:03 Speaker 02 No, they didn't go through an exercise in grading the lunch guests and Erin Patterson. But um the doctor was taken to some potential scenarios and he agreed there are plenty of variables that can impact the symptoms that one experiences if they do consume death cap mushrooms. For instance, Um. The amount that you consume or the concentration within a meal, for example, or it could be the makeup of your own body, um, your general health, your age, your weight. These are all factors that um can influence how you react to consuming death caps.
6:42 Speaker 03 It was interesting hearing today about, you know, the different levels of this, um, and how different people can be affected. Um. And was there any conversation about, um, you know, kind of similarities between the guests? Like, we know, you know, we heard yesterday how much people were eating. We heard Erin ate about half. We know that Gail ate about half of her serve as well. Was there any comparison done on, you know, similar impacts that they might have felt or they might have, maybe should have seen?
7:05 Speaker 02 There was a question asked by one of the prosecutors, Sarah Lenthall, and she asked the doctor that if you had two adults with no serious pre-existing health conditions, if they consumed the same amount of death cap mushrooms, if one of those people died, but the other didn't, what would you expect the outcome to be for the survivor?
7:27 Speaker 03 Hmm.
7:27 Speaker 02 And the doctor said it's likely there would be adverse outcomes for the person who survived. So, negative.
7:37 Speaker 03 Okay, yeah, implying that they'd be, they'd be sick, right, right?
7:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
7:40 Speaker 03 Yeah. Um. As well as the evidence we heard around, um, you know, from Dr. Jairus de Mulas, we also got into some DNA evidence, mushroom DNA. Uh, so we're getting deep into the, the scientific fields this week. Um, it has been a dense week. There's been a lot of scientific terms. Again, I will admit, um, that this one didn't really sink in too deeply with me. What did we hear from, from this witness? And, you know, was there anything that you're keen to, keen for us to kind of get across now?
8:05 Speaker 02 It's really technical stuff and it's kind of like, this is what you're being given on a Friday. It's the end of the week. Um, if we're finding it dense, imagine the jury, um, who has to, has to sit through all of this. But this was a third method of analyzing leftovers that were retrieved from Erin Patterson's property in the aftermath of the lunch. So earlier this week, we heard from Dr. Camille Chirong, who did effectively a visual inspection of some beef Wellington leftovers. Now, from what she could see under a microscope, she couldn't see death cap mushrooms. Um, then we had Dr. Juris de Mulas, who did a chemical test and he found the toxins.
8:50 Speaker 02 That come from death cap mushrooms. So not exactly the mushrooms themselves, but the toxins that flow from them.
8:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:56 Speaker 02 And then you've got this third expert, Dr David Lovelock. He is a plant DNA expert. So he said that he was contacted by the police in the aftermath of this lunch and he was sent the same samples to look at. In effect, what he does is uses DNA barcoding to detect fungi.
9:17 Speaker 03 Right.
9:18 Speaker 02 And he was also sent samples from the dehydrator at the tip, which was dumped by Aaron Patterson after the lunch. And what he said was, he was able to detect ammonita phloidis, death cap mushrooms, in samples from the dehydrator, but he wasn't able to find it in the beef Wellington leftovers he received. So it's pretty interesting, you know, three sets of tests, which don't yield consistent results across the three.
9:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, you're kind of hearing, you know, you're not seeing it, but you're getting this toxin, but you're not finding, you know, these other elements as well. It's really interesting kind of how that all breaks down. And that kind of brought us to the end of the week for this week. We've had, you know, it's been a big week. We had a juror discharge. We've had mycologists, Dr Tom May, Camille Tron, we had toxicologists, we had medical professionals reviewing records. You can hear all about all of these witnesses and the evidence they presented in our other episodes from this week. So just jump on the ABC Listen app and have a run through there. And one of the things that kind of stuck out with me from what we've heard over the course of this week, Christian, is that we've started having objections. You know, on Monday, we did this episode, we answered a bunch of questions that you've sent in to [email protected] . We mentioned that we hadn't
10:31 Speaker 03 had any of these kind of objections yet. We've had a couple of days of them now. We had objections today, we had objections yesterday. Why are we seeing them pop up?
10:40 Speaker 02 I think what we've seen from this trial is there's so much information and there's a lot of nuance. And certain bits of information have to be extremely precise. And it's not just the information itself, it's also the imputations of that information. So I guess, yeah, when one side feels that the other side is straying into slightly unfair territory, that's when we see those objections. And sometimes when that happens, it means that the trial is halted.
11:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's been really interesting. The thing I didn't realise about objections is that, you know, there's then a conversation about what has to happen from there. And sometimes that happens with the jury in the room. Sometimes the jury is asked to leave the room. Um, and what happens when the jury is not in the room, we can't talk about. But the objections do really slow things down. It felt like, you know, the last couple of days have kind of been, you know, almost, um, punctuated by these sort of delays and these procedural discussions popping up.
11:37 Speaker 02 There was an almost comical moment today when the jury came back from one of their breaks. And they filtered back into the room, sat down, heard one question and there was an objection raised. And they were dispatched back, um, to the room behind the court, um, within a minute. So, um, it does happen. But, um, actually what I would say is that while there have been some objections, while there has been times where the jury has been cleared out of the room, what we haven't seen are the kinds of objections that have taken days to resolve or hours to resolve. Um, I think what we've seen is people have been brought back in a reasonable time.
12:20 Speaker 02 And I think we cross our fingers that that continues for the rest of the trial.
12:23 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Keep up the, uh, the pace that we've been working out over the last, uh, last week or two would be, would be nice. Uh, Christian, as we find ourselves at the end of the third week of this trial, uh, what moment of this week, uh, have you, have you found yourself thinking about coming back to?
12:40 Speaker 02 I don't know if it's a particular moment, but it's probably the vibe of Dr. Tom May, the mycologist, the mushroom expert, internationally renowned, a man that not only knows mushrooms back to front, but just loves his work.
12:58 Speaker 02 A guy who has claimed that he's made 30,000 posts on the iNaturalist website where citizen scientists, along with professional scientists, go to mark observations of the world. And seeing him up on the stand for a combined total of about a day was illuminating and really interesting because a lot of the trials in the Supreme Court, they're about violent killings. You don't normally see mycologists giving evidence and his crash course into the world of mushrooms really was brilliant.
13:35 Speaker 03 And I should say as well, Tom May, if you're looking for him on the iNaturalist website, look for Funky Tom.
13:42 Speaker 02 F U N K E Y T O M, Funky. And the point of Dr. Tom May's evidence was that identifying ammonitophyllitis is a challenging task. It's an easy thing to confuse ammonitophyllitis with the stubble rosegill or Urdomansiella gigaspora, or Clophilium brunum, or Ammonita chieri, or mushrooms from the genus Armorilla group. So as he said, you've got, if you're going to collect wild fungi, you really have to get to know the features of mushrooms and you have to be able to identify the toxic species as well as the edible ones, which are perfectly safe.
14:20 Speaker 03 If you're doing your Latin on Duolingo, you can just jump back about 30 seconds in the pod and listen to Christian's pronunciations. That'll get you right to speed. Well done.
14:29 Speaker 02 Thank you, thank you.
14:29 Speaker 03 There's a couple of things I want to get to about this week, but before I do, Christian, you're talking here about Funky Tom, Tom May. You know, we talked about iNaturalist, we have not talked about his catchphrase.
14:40 Speaker 02 That is what is written here.
14:42 Speaker 03 What, what is, what was he referring to? We heard Dr. Tom May say this, was it like seventeen, eighteen times, uh?
14:49 Speaker 02 I tallied it up. It was about nineteen times and it was towards the end of his evidence. And I was sitting in the media overflow room, watching the, the live stream of this as it was playing out and it definitely did elicit a few chuckles. Um, defence barrister Sophie Stafford took Dr. May to a coroner's report, which is unrelated to the Erin Patterson case. And it's a report that Dr. May says he has seen before. Uh, it was a report that the jury, I don't believe, had in front of them. And Sophie Stafford was taking him line by line through this report about another death cap mushroom poisoning.
15:29 Speaker 03 Hmm.
15:29 Speaker 02 And, uh, as she took him through line by line, he would say, that is what is written here. And then she would take him to the next line and he would say exactly the same. That is what is written here. And it just continued for minutes.
15:45 Speaker 03 It was one of the more humorous moments of this trial. You know, the first kind of one or first, you know, one, two, three times this happens. It's like, okay, this is a bit strange. Let's go through it. After about fifteen, this was very hard not to laugh at.
15:59 Speaker 02 It was. It reminded me of, um, it's a bit random, but there was a press conference done probably about twenty years ago, one of those political doorstops where the former minister, Peter Garrett, uh, said about ten times that he had a short jocular conversation with somebody. And this was turned into a thing by the chaser. It just took me back to that.
16:21 Speaker 03 That's fantastic. I mean, the thing I have been thinking back a lot this week, thinking about a lot this week, is the, the kind of changing face of the evidence or the, the way that the, you know, different details revealed through the course of the week. So we spoke about this a bit earlier. We had, uh, Dr. Camille Tru on talking about what, um, she found when she investigated the leftover beef Wellington from the lunch. She didn't see any death cap mushrooms in there. Then we had a toxicologist the following day talking about how he had found amine toxins in there. And then today we've heard from a DNA expert that he Hasn't found that in the leftover beef Wellington. And I just think it's really, it was a really nice reminder that we are just progressing through this evidence. We don't get all of this at once. We're hearing what the jury's hearing.
17:03 Speaker 03 This evidence is still unfolding. It's a reminder that, you know, certainly to the jury that they can't be making up their minds at this point. They've still got more to hear and still more to to think through. And I kind of think on the jury jury as well, you know, there was that moment this week with the juror discharged. A reminder just how fragile is not the right word, but it just felt in that moment that there was a risk to the trial. And there was this really stark reminder like, oh, it's not a guarantee that we will progress through this. There are risks and there are threats to this, and we need to be really careful about how we progress through, you know, the
17:34 Speaker 02 It's a reminder that everyone involved in the trial, from the jurors to the parties, to even the media covering it, uh, need to be really careful about what they say and do.
17:46 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. I've got to admit, as soon as we heard that there was some news that, um, you know, around the trial, my first thought was, oh God, what have we done on the podcast that we're going to get called in front of the court for? Fortunately, nothing. And then my second thought was, okay, who else has done something? And then it was like, oh, okay, it's a juror. It's a sort of like step through process in my mind.
18:05 Speaker 02 I think what we saw yesterday was a reminder that Justice Beal does not want the jury's minds to be contaminated by information from the outside world. And possibly it's a reason why at the end of this trial, when they go out to deliberate that they're actually going to be sequestered.
18:21 Speaker 03 Yep. No, thank you, Christian. Um, we are also joined by the ABC's true crime investigative reporter, Rachel Brown. Rachel is the, uh, the wonderful mind behind the Trace podcast series. Uh, and he's working on another podcast at the moment for unravel. Rachel, it's a pleasure to have you back on Mushroom Case Daily.
18:37 Speaker 07 Thanks, Doki.
18:38 Speaker 03 What is the moment from this week that, um, yeah, you found yourself thinking about a lot?
18:43 Speaker 07 Because it's been such a dense week, as Christian said, I think I've really become to appreciate the people I'll call my cool nerds. I hope that I say that with affection.
18:55 Speaker 03 Oh, look, I think nerds are very affectionate terms. So, yeah, you're in, you're, you're fine.
18:59 Speaker 07 Uh, Christian took us through, you know, cool nerd funky Tom, Dr. Tom May. And it's just incredible to me, the people that have devoted their life to something that is so tiny, like a mushroom, for example. So this week, we've been hearing from Victoria's chief toxicologist, Dimitri Jerastamoulos. Now, I've met him previously in my work, he's at VIFM, and I love VIFM. So that's the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine.
19:26 Speaker 03 Hmm.
19:26 Speaker 07 And I know that makes me a nerd as well, but it's just the people that I've met in there over the course of my time, working in the kind of crime and justice field. He's one. Um, he's given evidence that we heard, you know, in terms of the specifics of, you know, did you know how much of a death cap could kill a person?
19:44 Speaker 03 No, not at all.
19:45 Speaker 07 No.
19:45 Speaker 03 I did not have a clue until he was going through that the other day.
19:49 Speaker 07 So we learnt yesterday, it's fifty grams.
19:51 Speaker 03 Yep.
19:51 Speaker 07 Or three tablespoons for a seventy kilogram adult. And that kind of amazing information just blows my mind. Other people I've worked with over the years, there's Daddna Hartman. So she is the chief molecular biologist there, and I find it interesting that DNA is actually in her name, D A D N A. Hi, Daddna, if you're listening, she helped me with the Trace podcast, she was very kind and tested some exhibits for me.
20:15 Speaker 03 Yep.
20:15 Speaker 07 Um, in the review of that Maria James cold case from nineteen eighty. Uh, I've worked with Dr. Soren Blau, who's a forensic anthropologist at VIFM. She, many people might remember her from the Greg Lynn trial recently, the other big trial that Christian and I have been covering. And she studied some of the bone shards that were found in that case.
20:33 Speaker 03 Hmm.
20:34 Speaker 07 So I just. I love them. I I just think, and we wouldn't have a clue about some of these people. Christian and I were talking and he said, you know, you wouldn't recognise Dimitri Deras Demolos if he walked past you on the street like you would a C grade celeb or a footy player, but they are rock stars of their industry.
20:51 Speaker 03 Hmm.
20:51 Speaker 07 And I think to give their life over to one particular expertise and it's such an amazing skill to crystallise and synthesise such dense information and to translate it for the jury, because they have a lot to wade through. And I saw one yawn this afternoon and I thought, I feel you, buddy. This is hard.
21:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:10 Speaker 07 We are three long weeks in and we're in the weeds now of medical and toxological evidence. So to have the advantage of hearing from experts like Dimitri is amazing.
21:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's fantastic. Uh Rach, it's always a pleasure to have you on the pod. Um. The work you've done with Trace is fantastic. If people are keen to check out Trace, where can they, where can they track that down?
21:29 Speaker 07 On the ABC Listen app.
21:31 Speaker 03 Great.
21:32 Speaker 07 Or wherever you get your podcasts.
21:34 Speaker 03 Oh, look, uh, go the ABC Listen app, you know, keep it, keep it inside the ABC family. Um, Rach, we would usually, you know, kind of kick you out of the chair at this point and um talk to Christian about some of the questions, but we've had a question sent in that I think, given your experience with Trace uh and the true crime reporting you've done, you're kind of like actually pretty uniquely suited to answer. So this is a question from Jackie who's listening from Darlington in the north east of the United Kingdom. She's been following this case with interest, but asks, why do people like her who are listening have such an interest in true crime? Is there something about us as human beings, beings that intrigues us or, you know, want to try and understand all of this and why?
22:10 Speaker 07 I think humans are just fascinated in human behaviour. You know, the longer I spend covering the courts and the justice system, that's the answer. Um, what makes people tick? What makes people behave they, the way they do? What makes them react the way they do? So I'm not just talking about Erin Patterson here, I should say, just society generally.
22:30 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:30 Speaker 07 Are fascinated by the human psyche, by our reactions. And we also like to tie neat bows around things, which I think is very difficult in some cases in life, but we strive for answers that sometimes might be impossible to get.
22:43 Speaker 03 Hmm.
22:44 Speaker 07 Um, with this case, you know, we're seeing everyone, as you would probably know, has an opinion.
22:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
22:50 Speaker 07 On this case and we hear it, you know, friends, family, people in the cafe down the road, everyone has an opinion. And it's, it seems to me that society wants to believe the more fantastical angle. When it comes to cases like this, rather than the mundane.
23:05 Speaker 03 Right.
23:06 Speaker 07 So there are some elements of this case that I find very Chamberlain-esque. Do you remember that Chamberlain trial of Lindy Chamberlain in the early eighties?
23:14 Speaker 03 I'm broadly familiar with the trial of Lindy Chamberlain and all that, but I wasn't around to actually, you know, follow the news coverage as it was unfolding. So like when, when you say it matches the hysteria, kind of what are you meaning? What are you comparing that to?
23:25 Speaker 07 Thank you for revealing my age. Um, it just, there was so much hysteria, you know, and you, even you, even though you were born after me, you would know the dingo stole my baby line. It's been everywhere from Seinfeld to The Simpsons. You know, I saw Lindy Chamberlain speak at a library, state library event a couple of years ago. And she said that thirty-three percent of Australians still think she's guilty. Like that case just got so much coverage. And there are lots of memes flying around the internet about this case, you know, and so I just wanted to say we haven't heard all the evidence yet. We're still in the prosecution witnesses. The defence hasn't had its turn. So we've only really largely heard one side of it.
24:10 Speaker 07 Um, the other thing I'd say to Jackie's question is the defence says it's a terrible accident, a tragedy. And that might make some people uncomfortable with this idea that it could happen to them, you know, that they could make dinner for their family, make people sick and end up on trial for murder. So I think that's a big consideration of this case as well. But it'll be interesting when it's the defence's turn, if it puts up any witnesses and what we hear from them.
24:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, it will be. Uh, Rach, thank you so much for sitting down for a chat, Mushroom Case Daily, uh, talking us through your week and helping us with that question. Um, Rachel Brown is the ABC's true crime investigative reporter, um, the voice on the mind, as I mentioned earlier, behind the wonderful Trace podcast. You can track that down on the ABC Listen app. If you find yourself with some time after listening to Mushroom Case Daily, definitely dive into that. Thank you, Rach.
24:57 Speaker 07 Thanks, Jockey.
24:58 Speaker 03 We have continued to have, uh, a just deluge of questions to the Mushroom Case Daily inbox, which we are very appreciative of. mushroomcasedaylyabc.net.au is where you can fire us a message, uh, as well as the one, um, that we've just had from, uh, from. Just had from Jackie that Rach has taken us through. Christian, I'd love to go through a few more with you. One here we've had from Ange in the Nimbin Valley is around Aaron Patterson's, you know, false cancer diagnosis. And Ange has asked if she's understood correctly, Heather and Ian Wilkinson were not regular visitors to Aaron Patterson's home.
25:33 Speaker 02 Correct.
25:33 Speaker 03 And their invitation to lunch was unusual. Could it be that they were lured there under the false pretence of a cancer diagnosis?
25:40 Speaker 02 Thanks Ange. Well, yeah, the way I understood the evidence is that, yes, Heather and Ian Wilkinson were not regular visitors to Aaron Patterson's home. And I believe Ian Wilkinson said that both he and his wife were rather chuffed to get an invite. And we saw Heather's diary, where she's marked the lunch in her diary and even written that she's going to bring a fruit platter along. Now regarding the cancer diagnosis, the evidence that we've heard is that Aaron Patterson told her estranged husband, Simon, that she had some medical information that she wished to share at the lunch. Now, we know Simon
26:22 Speaker 02 didn't end up going. But Ian Wilkinson did not say that he knew that there was important medical information or a cancer diagnosis or anything like that before the lunch.
26:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:36 Speaker 02 It very much sounded like when Aaron Patterson allegedly told him this, it was the first time he was hearing it.
26:43 Speaker 03 Right. Okay. Thank you, Christian. We have another question here from Nick, who is loving the daily updates. He's wondering if at the end of the trial, are we likely to get any insights from jurors as to their own or the jury's thinking behind their verdict? Or once the trial is over, some kind of ongoing embargo on them discussing what was said behind closed doors?
27:01 Speaker 02 That's a great question from Nick. And unfortunately, the answer's no. Jury deliberations and discussions are confidential during the trial and also afterwards. So we never actually get to know the reasons why they found someone guilty or acquitted them.
27:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, interesting. Okay. Thank you, Christian. And again, thank you, Nick, for your wonderful question. And a last question for the week, we're going overseas across the pond for this one. This is from Charlie, who says, hello, thank you for the great podcast, Utterly Compelling. Thank you for listening, Charlie. We appreciate you. He is listening on a beautiful island in North Carolina, Bald Head Island, which was the location of the film A Weekend at Bernie's, for any of the film buffs listening. His whole extended family is following every day. They're in Sydney, California, Paris, the UK. Even his American mother-in-law in Georgia is listening. He has a quick question and is wondering how big the courtroom in Morewell is, how much public seating?
28:00 Speaker 03 And how's it laid out? He wants to know where everyone's sitting. Is Erin sitting with her legal team or separately in a more traditional dock?
28:07 Speaker 02 Thanks, Charlie. Well, we're not allowed to take photos in the courtroom, but I can see that the court themselves actually did snap a photo of this room and it's online. So if you were to enter La Trobe Valley Magistrates Court into your search engine of choice, you will probably see the Magistrates Court of Victoria website pop up and you'll be able to see a picture of the room. Now, to those who aren't going to take the trouble to do that, let me describe what it's like. It's relatively modern room by court standards. It's not, it's not something that was built, you know, a hundred years ago. So you've got some wood panelling throughout, but it's also mixed in with, you know, your standard office carpet.
28:51 Speaker 02 Down, down the bottom, there's a very nice window at the side, which allows a lot of natural light into the room, which is a blessing when you've got a trial that runs for six weeks to get some natural light is fantastic. So at the back of the room is the court dock.
29:06 Speaker 03 Yep.
29:06 Speaker 02 And that's where Erin Patterson sits in front of the dock. About three rows of seats, the media tend to take up one of the back rows right in front of Erin, which is rather awkward when people go to sort of turn around to see Erin's reactions to various things. They crane their necks and end up staring right into her eyes. In front of them, yeah, there's a couple of seats for the public. As I mentioned, the Wilkinson and Patterson extended families have been filling up some of those rows.
29:38 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
29:39 Speaker 02 In front of that, so you're sort of, the centrepiece of the room, if you like, is the bar table.
29:44 Speaker 03 Right.
29:45 Speaker 02 And this is a big, nice wooden table on the left-hand side of the bar table, um, looking from the back of the room. So that's where the defence sits. So you've got Colin Mandy, Sophie Stafford, uh, on the left. And in front of them, so, uh, there's a couple of people that actually face the wrong direction almost. Looking back towards Erin, there are a couple of solicitors. Um, on the right-hand side of the table is the prosecution team. So you've got Nanette Rogers, Jane Warren and Sarah Lenthall. They've also got a couple of solicitors facing them, uh, on the other side of the table. At the front of the room is the judge, Justice Christopher Beale. He's got a couple of court staff who sit in front of him.
30:29 Speaker 02 Then to the right-hand side is the jury.
30:31 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
30:32 Speaker 02 And there are two rows, uh, one row is seven seats, one row is eight.
30:36 Speaker 03 Yep.
30:37 Speaker 02 All those seats used to be occupied, now there's one spare.
30:40 Speaker 03 Great. Thank you, Christian, and, uh, thank you, Charlie, and, uh, your whole family who was listening, uh, from various places around the world. That brings us to the end of Mushroom Case Daily for this week. Christian, we'll be back in everyone's feed next week.
30:53 Speaker 02 Indeed, we will.
30:54 Speaker 03 If you are listening on something outside of the ABC Listen app, please leave us a review and give us a rating. And if you are listening in the ABC Listen app, make sure you're following Mushroom Case Daily because that way you won't miss an update.
31:05 Speaker 02 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, court reporter Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
31:21 Speaker 03 Our executive producer is Claire Rawlinson, and many thanks to the Victorian newsroom and our audio studios manager, Eric George. Shout out to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh, Rachel Brown, who was a guest on the pod today, and also to Yasmin Parry. This episode was produced on the land, the Gunai Kurnai people.
31:42 Speaker 04 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
31:52 Speaker 08 Hi there, Yumi Steins here, host of the podcast Ladies We Need to Talk. We're all about health and wellness, sex and relationships. If it's going off in your group chat, we're going to talk about it on Ladies We Need to Talk. Perimenopause, fertility, your love life, the mental load, Ozempic. Nothing's off limits. Find Ladies We Need to Talk on the ABC Listen app and all the usual places.
Previous 14 | Juror kicked out of Erin Patterson's trial Next 16 | Erin Patterson's movements traced by location expert Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated