Pod Insights The Case Of 03 | Individual wellingtons, coloured plates, and a false cancer claim About this episode The prosecution laid out its case against Erin Patterson today, but no motive was offered. The defence fired back in its opening, saying the deaths were a terrible accident but the jury must focus on whether Erin Patterson intended to poison her relatives.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:16 Speaker 01 For so long, this has been a case that has captured the attention of the world. People have had questions for so long. Today, we got some of those answers, but there's still a very, very long way to go in the trial of Erin Patterson. Hello, I'm the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver.
0:33 Speaker 02 And I'm Stephen Stockwell, and you are listening to Mushroom Case Daily, a podcast that is covering the trial of Erin Patterson. And today, that has officially started. We have got so much to go through. There's been a huge amount of news that has come out of this, and I hope you're ready for an absolute bumper episode.
0:50 Speaker 03 The small town mystery that's gripped the nation and made headlines around the world. Just a week after four people sat down for a family lunch in rural Victoria, three of them were dead.
1:01 Speaker 04 On the menu was beef wellington, a pastry filled with beef and a pate made of mushrooms.
1:06 Speaker 05 Three people are dead and one man is fighting for his life this morning after a suspected mushroom poisoning in South Gippsland in Victoria.
1:13 Speaker 06 But Erin Patterson has strongly maintained her innocence. It's a tragedy what's happened.
1:18 Speaker 02 I love them. You're listening to Mushroom Case Daily. Christian, to get us into today's episode, can you give us a quick recap of what's unfolded?
1:28 Speaker 01 It's impossible to sum this up quickly, but I'll try my best, Stocky. Today, we learned fresh details about this lunch at the centre of this case, why the lunch was organised, what happened with the meal. We also learned graphic details about how those lunch guests suffered in the aftermath from the illnesses that they got from eating this beef wellington, which had death cap mushrooms in it. Then, we learned about Erin Patterson's actions in the aftermath.
2:01 Speaker 01 Then we got into some of the analysis that the prosecution and its experts have done, which has led them to reach their conclusion and their argument that she is guilty of charges of murder and attempted murder. Finally, Erin Patterson's barrister, Colin Mandy, took to the stand to provide a brief defence on behalf of his client.
2:24 Speaker 02 You've summed up what was a huge day in incredibly short period of time. We're not going to leave you with just that. We're going to give you a really detailed explanation of how all of this unfolded. But I was following along with bits of this, Christian. I was in the media overflow room for parts of it. I was listening from the studio here for other parts. It was so compelling. And I want to start this podcast with a conversation about the lunch because we got so much detail that we had not heard before. And I want to start with finding out why that lunch took place. Can you tell us why it was arranged? What the purpose behind it was?
2:59 Speaker 01 Certainly, Stocky. I think it's good to just zoom out a little bit and just refresh people about who the characters are in this story. So obviously Erin Patterson is the central figure of this trial. She has an estranged husband, Simon Patterson. Mr Patterson's parents, Don and Gail, also live nearby to Erin in a regional community in Gippsland in Victoria. Now, the Pattersons also have some other relatives, the Wilkinson's, Heather and Ian. So remember them as well. So all of these people live in the communities of Leeangatha and Corumburra, all fairly close to each other.
3:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, Corumburra is like a 15, 20 minute drive from Leeangatha, right?
3:43 Speaker 01 That's correct. That's right. So to sum it up, the prosecution says that Erin Patterson organised a lunch at her house and she invited those five people I've just mentioned. And she'd hinted to them that it was to discuss some medical issues that were serious. Simon Patterson, the estranged husband, turned down the invitation. He said he was too uncomfortable to come.
4:07 Speaker 02 Right.
4:07 Speaker 01 The other four did go along. And I guess what happened next is at the centre of this entire case.
4:15 Speaker 02 Yeah. I mean, Simon not going to this lunch, was that something that was discussed a week or two out? When did Erin find out that he wasn't going to be there?
4:22 Speaker 01 Simon sent her a text the night before, uh, saying that he wasn't interested to come along. The prosecution says she expressed some disappointment with that, but ultimately pressed ahead with her plans. Um, apparently she had said that she was quite disappointed, given the level of effort she'd gone into to preparing the lunch for the day.
4:42 Speaker 02 And the lunch in question is the beef Wellington with, uh, you know, allegedly death cap mushrooms in it that we've been talking about for a very long time is.
4:50 Speaker 01 Not allegedly anymore.
4:52 Speaker 02 Right. Okay. Yeah, of course. Right.
4:53 Speaker 01 We can say it.
4:54 Speaker 02 We can say it. And obviously, you know, beef Wellington is quite a complicated meal to make. So it would explain why Erin might be a bit frustrated that Simon would be coming to that lunch. What do we know about that meal and how it was prepared and served?
5:06 Speaker 01 So the way that the prosecutor, Nanette Rogers, tells the story, I'll try to paint a bit of a picture. The, the guests rock up to this lunch on the 29th of July, 2023 at Erin's house. And they're given a bit of a house tour and she shows them around and eventually they all start milling around the kitchen island bench. A- as many people do when they, um, meet for a gathering. And Erin, um, according to the prosecution, then serves each of the guests individual beef Wellingtons.
5:39 Speaker 02 So not one beef Wellington, not like a large log. We're talking small, little, like, I guess, chicken keb size.
5:45 Speaker 01 Pasties, pasties. Is that, is that what you call them?
5:47 Speaker 02 Yeah. Yeah. So like a small parcel. Okay. Right. Okay. That's, okay.
5:51 Speaker 01 So, uh, according to the prosecution, Erin starts plating these up. The beef Wellingtons go on four gray plates, but there's five guests, remember?
6:01 Speaker 02 Hmm.
6:01 Speaker 01 So Erin's plate, according to the prosecution, is the orange plate. So anyway, uh, there's some other things on the side, some beans, some mashed potatoes. And everybody sits down to eat this meal. According to the prosecution, they say grace.
6:19 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
6:20 Speaker 01 This is a family with, this is a family with strong religious ties. Uh, Ian Wilkinson's actually a pastor at, at the local church.
6:30 Speaker 01 They eat the meals. Apparently, there's even some banter about how much some people ate and how much other people didn't eat. And then Erin Patterson drops a bombshell. She tells the guests that she's got cancer and the reason why she's invited them over is to seek advice about how to break this news to her kids. And she just doesn't know what to do.
6:56 Speaker 02 What was, I mean, this is obviously slightly aside from, you know, the case, but I mean, what was the advice from the guests around that?
7:03 Speaker 01 Nanette Rogers, the prosecutor, said that the guests were of the view that she should be upfront and they prayed again for her to find the wisdom to do the right thing. And it sort of sounded like that was the end of that particular topic. Eventually, the guests went home for the evening and everything changed after that.
7:24 Speaker 02 Yeah, so we know that they all got incredibly sick after this meal. How soon did they start to feel sick? When did, when did, when did they start to, yeah, experience the symptoms associated with death cap mushroom poisoning?
7:35 Speaker 01 By the following morning, all four of those guests were starting to feel really sick. Initially, to them, it seemed like food poisoning, you know, diarrhea, vomiting, but this started getting really, really bad. So the Patterson parents decided to go to hospital. They also called their son Simon to let him know that they were quite sick. Simon then contacted the Wilkonsens. Turns out they were also very sick too. And Simon drove them to the hospital. Now, there was interesting comments that the prosecution said occurred made by Heather Wilkinson, where Heather apparently was questioning this plate arrangement. She
8:18 Speaker 01 was wondering why we all ate off one set of plates and Erin ate off the other. And Heather was said to have been a little bit confused by that arrangement.
8:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, because there was the grey plates and the orange plate that the, the Wellingtons were served on, Erin eating off of the orange plate. What happened once they, these, you know, the, the diners went to hospital?
8:42 Speaker 01 Long story short, they ended up at the local hospitals and their conditions started to get really, really bad and deteriorating. These sorts of symptoms of diarrhea and vomiting becoming incredibly serious.
8:56 Speaker 02 Yeah. Did Erin get sick?
8:59 Speaker 01 Erin said that she did get sick and this is going to be one of the points of dispute in the trial and we'll have more to say about this, but I think what's abundantly clear and no one will dispute Erin did not get sick to the level that the lunch guests did. Now, the prosecution claims that Erin Patterson did not eat the same beef Wellington recipe as the other lunch guests. They are saying that her beef Wellington did not contain death cap mushrooms and that's why she didn't fall sick in the same way that they did.
9:37 Speaker 02 Did Erin present hospital? Did she go in there and talk to anyone and, you know, raise concerns about how she was feeling?
9:44 Speaker 01 Erin Patterson did end up in the local hospitals. So this lunch happened on a Saturday.
9:50 Speaker 02 Yep.
9:51 Speaker 01 Um, the lunch guests fell quite sick and were in the hospital by the Sunday. Erin Patterson only first came to hospital on the Monday, so an extra 24 hours. And she was complaining of having symptoms when the doctors realised that she was connected to these other four who were by this point getting even worse.
10:13 Speaker 02 Hmm.
10:13 Speaker 01 They, these doctors began to really worry for Erin Patterson's safety.
10:19 Speaker 02 Hmm.
10:20 Speaker 01 And they, and the prosecution said, she was told by a doctor, look, you've potentially been exposed to a lethal dose of what they believed was death cap mushrooms at that point.
10:32 Speaker 02 Was she worried?
10:34 Speaker 01 Well, according to the prosecution, seemingly not as worried as she should have been. Nanette Rogers was saying that Erin Patterson was very reluctant to check herself into hospital to stay there. And then when Ms Patterson allegedly told the hospital staff that her kids had also eaten leftovers of the mushroom meal, that raised even more concerns for the hospital staff that these children have also potentially been poisoned. But Erin insisted to them, no, I scraped the mushrooms off the plate. Um, they didn't consume any mushrooms, they're fine, there's nothing to worry about here.
11:15 Speaker 01 And there was a lot of arguments between Ms Patterson and the hospital staff about that issue.
11:21 Speaker 02 Did the kids end up getting checked out?
11:23 Speaker 01 They did eventually, and according to the prosecution, they were found to be healthy and fine. So the implication being they didn't eat the beef Wellington with death cap mushrooms or have any portion of that meal.
11:37 Speaker 02 Did they end up getting any of the leftovers to test and check to see if that's what it was?
11:43 Speaker 01 They did, and this is one of the things that we were able to see by being in the courtroom. They flashed up on a screen some of the leftover beef Wellington that the police were able to retrieve from a bin. Um, look, this is food that's about four days old, that's been recovered from a bin. So when I say it was a stale looking pastry with some brown filling inside, take that with that context. Uh, it wasn't too pretty to see what had been fished out of that bin, but the jury did see a picture of the leftovers.
12:20 Speaker 02 Wow. And so they're, they're now, you know, they've now shown us that it was death cap mushrooms in this beef Wellington. Do we know where they came from?
12:29 Speaker 01 That's a really good question. And according to the prosecution, Ms Patterson gave varying accounts of where these mushrooms came from. The story seemed to change. Uh, I think we'll have to step through it.
12:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. So what do you mean it changed? Like, what was the first time, when she was questioned about this the first time, what, what was presented?
12:50 Speaker 01 So there were two sources of mushrooms offered up as the initial explanation, some from Woolworths and some from an unnamed Asian grocer in Oakley, which is a suburb in Melbourne.
13:02 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
13:04 Speaker 01 But Ms Patterson wasn't able to say which Asian grocer it was. Initially, she denied using any mushrooms that had been picked from the wild. Now, during the subsequent investigation, lots of people asked Sarah and Patterson where the mushrooms came from, and the prosecution say the story chopped and changed. So initially it was Oakley, then the suburb changed to others in the area. Still, she couldn't really remember. Um, local council officers started going around to all the shops, trying to figure it out, but still the, the shop was never really identified. Um, she said she got some of the mushrooms from a, a local Woolworths in Leeangatha as well.
13:50 Speaker 02 Right. What kind of emerged after that?
13:53 Speaker 01 Well, during the investigation, obviously a suggestion that a retail shop is selling deadly mushrooms is is absolutely shocking. And understandably, the health authorities conducted a very serious investigation to this. And ultimately, the prosecution say this investigation showed that there were no such death cap mushrooms being sold by Asian grocers or by Woolworths. And in their view, this was a lie that Patterson was telling.
14:26 Speaker 02 Where could these mushrooms have come from then?
14:28 Speaker 01 The prosecution has made some suggestions that they might have come from either a place called Locke or a place called Atrem. These are locations nearby to where Erin Patterson lives. The reason they've pointed out these spots is that there is a website called iNaturalist, which is a place where science enthusiasts go and document various things. And on that website, people have posted confirmed sightings of death cap mushrooms. Prosecutors say Miss Patterson went to these areas shortly after these posts went up.
15:11 Speaker 01 Strong implication being she went there to pick the mushrooms.
15:15 Speaker 02 Oh, right. Okay, so we we now know, you know, the story or the, you know, what the prosecution's presenting around where these mushrooms have come from. I mean, what about the cancer diagnosis, though?
15:27 Speaker 01 Her barrister today admitted it was fake.
15:31 Speaker 02 That she had lied about having cancer to her, you know, basically extended family.
15:37 Speaker 01 That's correct. And the prosecution added further weight to that. They said that there had been no records that Miss Patterson had ever been found to have had cancer. There's a cancer registry, her name wasn't on that. And there were further medical records which showed that while she had gone in for some testing, she had been told that she did not have cancer.
16:01 Speaker 02 Wow. Um. You've been in the room all day. You've been sitting there in the room with Erin and with the jury as all this is going on. Um. Yeah. How did she look? What was the mood?
16:13 Speaker 01 There was definitely a tense atmosphere in the room, understandably, on the opening day of a trial like this. So, so it did go all day. It wasn't over in a couple of hours. For most of the day, Erin Patterson was in the dock, looking pretty composed, obviously taking everything very seriously and listening closely. When it came time for her defence barrister, Colin Mandy, to provide a response, I think she showed a little bit of emotion. I could see that at one point she appeared to be fighting back tears when Mr. Mandy conceded that there were certain things that she had done.
16:57 Speaker 02 And speaking of Erin Patterson's defence, after we heard from the prosecution, there is an opportunity for the defence to make their opening statements. What did we hear from them?
17:07 Speaker 01 The defence's response is never as long as the prosecution's opening. So Nanette Rogers, I didn't add it up, but it must have gone for about three hours. Colin Mandy's response was about 20 minutes. The reason for that is that technically, these opening addresses are not the evidence. So the prosecution has the onus of proof. So Nanette Rogers laid out an overview of the evidence to come. And once that evidence is presented, that's when Colin Mandy and his team can properly attack that evidence. So he said, I'm going to run through some things that are in dispute and not in dispute.
17:46 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
17:48 Speaker 01 But the, the bigger, um, but the more fulsome response from the defence will come later.
17:55 Speaker 02 What did we hear about the motive for these crimes?
17:59 Speaker 01 Not a whole lot. And I think that's interesting. Everybody wants to know not just the how, but the why, when it comes to anything like this. The thing with a charge of murder is you don't have to prove a motive. So prosecutor Nanette Rogers said there wasn't a specific motive that they could point to. However, she said the four elements of murder.
18:27 Speaker 01 Can be proved beyond reasonable doubt. I can run you through what those four elements are.
18:33 Speaker 02 Yeah, go for it.
18:34 Speaker 01 The jury was given this checklist and these are the things that they have to be satisfied of to find Erin Patterson guilty. They have to be satisfied that she caused the deaths by serving a poisoned meal. That seems to not be in dispute. That's agreed. That did happen. This is the next one that's in dispute though, that her actions were conscious, voluntary and deliberate. Prosecutors say she did act deliberately because she picked death cap mushrooms and served them to her relatives. The defence says, no, it wasn't a deliberate action at all.
19:15 Speaker 01 The third point is also in dispute, that at the time of the alleged conduct, that Erin Patterson intended to kill or cause really serious injury. Prosecutors obviously say that's the case. The defence totally disagree. The fourth point that the jury must be satisfied with is essentially that Erin Patterson wasn't acting in self-defense. You've got to have all of those elements ticked before you can find someone guilty of murder.
19:44 Speaker 02 Okay, so it's reasonably prescriptive. I mean, how did the defence kind of wrap up their day?
19:53 Speaker 01 Mr. Mandy asked the jury a pretty simple question and he said, did she intend to kill these four people? And he said, the defence case is what happened was a tragedy and a terrible accident. And he said, she's innocent. And he went on to then explain some of Miss Patterson's conduct in the aftermath, some of the lies to police. And another thing that she did, which was to dump a mushroom dehydrator that had been used in the preparation of the meal. She actually dumped it at the tip and the cops found it later on. So Mr. Mandy said that Erin Patterson panicked, given what had happened,
20:35 Speaker 01 that the shocking consequences of the lunch had sent her into a mode where she did things that weren't rational. And he said that, at the end of the day, Miss Patterson is innocent until proven guilty. And he said to the jury that innocent until proven guilty is not just a phrase that people say, it's a fundamental principle that protects all of us. And he says that prosecution allegations are easy to make, but what really matters is proving them. And I guess at the end of the trial, we'll get the ultimate answer as to whether the prosecution can prove it.
21:17 Speaker 02 Christian, thank you so much for taking us through all of that detail. Thank you to everyone who's been listening to this podcast, has been getting in touch, sending us emails, [email protected] . We will get to a whole bunch of them over the next little while, obviously on days that are very busy like this one, it is hard to fit them in. I do want to come back to Joanne's question from yesterday.
21:36 Speaker 01 Yes.
21:36 Speaker 02 Who asked, what did they have for dessert after the lunch? You were talking about maybe that's something we will hear in the opening statements. Did we get any detail on that?
21:44 Speaker 01 We actually did, Stocky, and Nanette Rogers, the prosecutor, said that for dessert, the group ate a cake that had been brought by Gail Patterson. And there was also a fruit platter that had been brought by Heather Wilkinson.
21:59 Speaker 02 Interesting. Well, there we go, Joanne, hopefully that's, well, that has answered your question. If you have a question, get in touch, [email protected] . We very much appreciate you listening to this podcast, getting us to number one on the podcast charts. It's a very nice feeling and something very nice to see as we're going into the opening statements today. Please tell your friends and family about Mushroom Case Daily. If you're enjoying this, share it in the group chat.
22:22 Speaker 01 Thank you so much for your support. It means a great deal. And this is only the start of this trial. There's a very, very long way to go. Opening statements were done today. Tomorrow, we get into the evidence.
22:33 Speaker 02 That's right. And we can keep you up to speed with everything that's happening in that case. If you jump on the ABC listener app and follow Mushroom Case Daily.
22:43 Speaker 01 Mushroom Case Daily is produced by ABC Audio Studios and ABC News. It's presented by me, the ABC's court reporter, Christian Silver, and producer Stephen Stockwell.
22:53 Speaker 02 Our executive producer is Claire Rollinson and props to Christian's boss, Sarah Gensh, and audio studios manager, Eric George. Also thanks to our true crime colleagues, Tim Roxburgh and Yasmin Parry. This episode was produced on the land of the Gunai Kurnai people.
23:12 Speaker 07 You've been listening to an ABC Podcast. Discover more great ABC podcasts, live radio and exclusives on the ABC Listen app.
Previous 02 | Patterson no longer charged with trying to kill husband Next 4 | 'Hope you'll change your mind': Erin pleads with husband to attend lunch Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated