Pod Insights The Binge Crimes The Arsonist Next Door | 4: The Bait About this episode The only hope of ending the arson spree for good is to lure the arsonist out of hiding. Law enforcement sets a trap they’re certain he won’t be able to resist.
Binge all episodes of The Arsonist Next Door, ad-free today by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge Crimes on Apple Podcasts and hit ‘subscribe’ or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access.
From serial killer nurses to psychic scammers – The Binge is your home for true crime stories that pull you in and never let go.
The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
A Sony Music Entertainment and Novel production.
Find out more about The Binge and other podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts and follow us @sonypodcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Ally here with cash when you need it. You know, for the taxi that saved you, the guy who helped you move. Wait, are you supposed to tip at the car wash? Don't be in... Ally's 75,000 fee-free ATMs mean you always have cash when you need it. Ally Bank Member FDIC.
0:15 Speaker 01 Listen to all episodes of The Arsonist Next Door ad-free right now by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge channel on Apple Podcasts and hit subscribe at the top of the page, or visit getthebinge.com to get access wherever you listen. The Binge: Feed your true crime obsession.
0:38 Speaker 01 The Binge.
0:45 Speaker 02 Novel.
0:50 Speaker 01 It's January 2001, and for 28-year-old reporter James Hibbard, the year has started with a bang.
1:01 Speaker 01 He managed to do what an entire task force of over 40 cops and FBI agents could not.
1:07 Speaker 03 The headline was "Exclusive Interview With The Preserve's Arsonist."
1:10 Speaker 01 His front-page interview for the Phoenix New Times blew up, and the task force is not happy about this. They put the screws on James, pressuring him to cooperate. And they offered him a $76,000 reward if he does.
1:26 Speaker 03 They said, "You can still be the journalist hero while being an actual hero and help us catch him. Nobody needs to know that you helped us."
1:36 Speaker 01 Now, the young reporter has a decision to make. Take the reward money and set up another meeting with the arsonist, or stick to his journalistic guns and protect his source.
1:50 Speaker 01 So what happens next?
1:52 Speaker 03 I would never sell out my profession by helping cops catch somebody who called a journalist to tell their story.
1:58 Speaker 01 Did you give that spiel to the cops?
2:00 Speaker 03 No. They would definitely not care about the importance of media and society. That was not these guys vibe.
2:11 Speaker 01 Lieutenant Rob Handy felt complicated about this.
2:14 Speaker 04 He was reporting the news, reporting a story and didn't feel any obligation to help us identify the person and felt it was against his journalism standards.
2:24 Speaker 01 Was that frustrating?
2:25 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah. We were angry, we were frustrated for sure.
2:28 Speaker 01 As a journalist, I respect James's decision, but decisions have consequences. Not only would James lose out on 76 grand, the decision will impact him in ways he never expected.
2:44 Speaker 04 We looked into James quite a bit, not as a suspect out there lighting the fires, but we saw James as facilitating and promoting criminal activity.
2:53 Speaker 01 James Hibbert, the guy who interviewed the arsonist, is about to fall under the microscope of the task force.
3:00 Speaker 04 We looked into everything we could about him.
3:04 Speaker 01 Did you surveil him at any point?
3:05 Speaker 04 Sure. We're going to try to figure out was there a relationship there? Did he actually get a tip? How did this work?
3:11 Speaker 03 Sometimes you think maybe you're being followed. I remember saying to friends that I thought something might be up. And then you wonder if you're just being paranoid.
3:23 Speaker 01 It's not just James in the crosshairs. The entire Phoenix New Times is now a target.
3:30 Speaker 04 We did several search warrants on the New Times. We did all kinds of things.
3:35 Speaker 01 Rob Handy and his task force, with the help of the county attorney, take the New Times to court. Trent Crump says the team suspected the newspaper might have information that could blow the whole case wide open.
3:48 Speaker 05 Listen, if we serve subpoenas on the New Times and try to compel them to give us information, it tells you how we felt.
3:54 Speaker 04 We surveilled every New Times jewelry truck and we surveilled all the New Times stands in the Phoenix area we could.
4:01 Speaker 01 Even readers of the paper are viewed with suspicion.
4:03 Speaker 04 We followed a few people that picked up papers. We'd get their plate number or figure out who they were or get them ID'd and they'd go on our list.
4:12 Speaker 01 The task force is casting a wide net.
4:14 Speaker 04 We were searching for needles in haystacks. And we were literally grasping at anything we could.
4:21 Speaker 01 Did it turn up anything?
4:23 Speaker 04 No.
4:25 Speaker 01 By this point, it's safe to say that James Hibbert is really feeling the heat.
4:30 Speaker 03 I'll never forget a column in the Arizona Republic slamming the interview, which said, "The next time this guy burns down a house, it's Hibbert's fault."
4:39 Speaker 05 Other reporters in town, probably a little bit more law enforcement friendly, were now starting to bash him.
4:46 Speaker 01 Rival newspaper, the Arizona Republic, published an editorial that said, quote, "If you meet with an egocentric firestarter, you become part of his gang. You not only spread his message for him, you let him walk away, zippo in hand." In the face of all this, the pressure on James begins to take a toll.
5:08 Speaker 03 Every morning, I would wake up with this pit in my stomach, this dread of wondering if he burned down another house, if he hurt someone during the night. Because if that happened, look, I would still be able to defend what I did professionally. But privately, as a human being, you know, I would have felt horrible.
5:27 Speaker 01 This experience had a lasting impact on James. He was blamed from all sides for prolonging the arson investigation. But looking back on it now, it's clear that that's not really what happened. Because back at the task force HQ, investigators are starting to see a silver lining in James's interview. Was there anything in that article that helped you guys?
5:51 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah. There were things in there that we felt were probably truthful.
5:55 Speaker 05 The more information you have, the better off you probably are.
5:58 Speaker 04 We dissected every word of that article.
6:01 Speaker 01 And there is a lot to dissect.
6:05 Speaker 01 The arsonist told James that he's a management professional with an advanced degree. He has a healthy income and works in downtown Phoenix. Plus, the whole piece is littered with James's impressions of the guy.
6:17 Speaker 04 His confident demeanor suggests he's ambitious and educated.
6:21 Speaker 01 The fact that this man wanted to do an interview at all, and the way he organized the meeting, that's also a clue. And in the opinion of Special Agent Ken Williams, a big mistake.
6:33 Speaker 06 He shouldn't have said anything. He should have just been quiet. But he thought he was so smart that he could taunt law enforcement by manipulating the media. Thank God the guy went to the reporter. The bad guy made a mistake.
6:45 Speaker 01 When the task force really digs in to the arsonist's quotes, they notice a key detail. This man is adamant that none of the fires were personal. Except for one. The second fire at Lee Benson's place. He tells James that fire was personal. Quote, "That monstrosity stuck out like a sore thumb. We warned him not to come back." That's how they realize.
7:13 Speaker 04 There was some special affinity for the area around the Lee Benson fire. We felt that that area was very special to that person.
7:29 Speaker 01 After weeks of surveilling James Hibbard, The Phoenix New Times, their delivery trucks, and random people reading the paper on their lunch break, they decide to try something new.
7:39 Speaker 04 If we set a trap in that area, they may come there.
7:41 Speaker 01 A trap in what they're hoping is CSP's own backyard, where one rookie officer will soon find herself in the heart of the action.
7:50 Speaker 02 Is this him? This is him. I know this is him. This has got to be him. Is this him?
7:56 Speaker 01 From Sony Music Entertainment and Novel, I'm Sam Anderson. You're listening to The Arsonist Next Door.
8:21 Speaker 01 Episode four, The Bait.
8:37 Speaker 04 We're trying to put together a group to do surveillance and was going around to different squads in the precinct asking for volunteers.
8:42 Speaker 01 When this arson spree first began, back when only a couple of houses had been burned, there was no task force. There was just Lieutenant Rob Handy, his small team, and anyone else who might be up for helping out in their spare time.
8:56 Speaker 04 I was trying to get like one volunteer off every squad.
8:59 Speaker 01 It was the early days of the investigation, and there doesn't seem to be a single officer interested in Rob's vague request to help with some long hours of overnight surveillance.
9:10 Speaker 04 They wanted to know the hours, they didn't want to be flexible, they wanted to know if they're getting overtime and all these things. I'm like, "Look, I have no idea. I don't have any idea how this is going to work, I'm just looking for people who might be interested. No takers."
9:21 Speaker 01 Except for one.
9:24 Speaker 02 "Oh, I'll do it."
9:27 Speaker 02 And he looked at me like, "Come on, really?" And like, "No, I'll do it."
9:31 Speaker 01 This is Carrie Miaso.
9:33 Speaker 04 And I'm like, "Sure, Carrie, you're in."
9:35 Speaker 01 Carrie is a rookie officer, fresh out of the Phoenix Police Academy. She has no idea that in just a few months, she'll end up playing a pivotal role in the investigation. In fact, she's only recently completed her first solo patrol.
9:53 Speaker 02 So I leave the precinct, and there's a hot call.
9:58 Speaker 02 It was like somebody throwing rocks at a car, or something silly like that.
10:01 Speaker 01 Something was going down at a local fast food restaurant, and Carrie was the closest officer to the incident.
10:08 Speaker 02 I'm like, "Oh my God, what am I gonna do? Oh, pick up the mic, hands shaking, and I'm like, 'Okay, I'm gonna answer this call.'"
10:17 Speaker 01 Ever felt the fear of public speaking? Now imagine you have to speak in front of an audience made up entirely of cops.
10:24 Speaker 02 I'd be scared to even get on the phone and call somebody, you know what I mean? And so now I'm a police officer, and I gotta get on a radio and let people know that something's going on.
10:35 Speaker 02 This is outside my comfort zone, big time.
10:43 Speaker 01 That's why, when Rob pops his head into her daily squad briefing with a mysterious offer of more work on a local arson investigation, Carrie, unlike her more senior colleagues, is all in.
10:55 Speaker 02 I am a firm believer in just getting as much experience as you can.
11:01 Speaker 01 What happens next is the part you've heard already. This case snowballs into a massive joint task force investigation. Houses are burning down left and right, the media is in a frenzy about God-fearing eco-terrorists running wild. The FBI has made this one of their top priorities. And rookie Officer Carrie? Before long, she's doing the kind of stuff that senior officers dream of.
11:26 Speaker 04 She's working with the FBI, she's working at the FBI office, she's doing all kinds of fun things.
11:30 Speaker 01 She's working undercover, conducting surveillance, generally having a ball.
11:35 Speaker 02 If you want me to be honest, I do remember there was some jealousy that happened there. They were mad at me for being gone that long.
11:43 Speaker 01 It wasn't just that Carrie was missing from her usual duties. Suddenly, she was working crazy shifts, six days a week, with overtime pay.
11:51 Speaker 02 That's money in the bank, and some of them didn't like that.
11:55 Speaker 01 Now, the same senior officers who refused Rob's request at the start of the investigation are beginning to grumble. Why does this rookie get to be part of the biggest case in town?
12:05 Speaker 04 She didn't volunteer. I got my volunteer. You're not bumping her now that it's fun and that she's making money and having a great time. We're not doing that, you know?
12:15 Speaker 01 Rob remains loyal to this rookie volunteer, and his loyalty is about to pay off big time. Carrie and the rest of Rob's team are gathered in the main briefing room of the arson task force. FBI case lead Terry Kearns is there.
12:29 Speaker 02 He kind of was brainstorming.
12:31 Speaker 01 Ideas on what we could do. Special Agent Ken Williams is there.
12:34 Speaker 06 We had a really good team on this.
12:36 Speaker 01 Trent Crump is there, too.
12:38 Speaker 05 We're doing all sorts of stuff, trying to figure out who's involved, who's not involved.
12:42 Speaker 01 And coordinating all of them is Lieutenant Rob Handy.
12:45 Speaker 04 We all would sit in a room once a week and get on a whiteboard and try to refocus and restrategize.
12:52 Speaker 01 It's the same room where, not long before, the team was enraged to find out they'd been scooped by a Cub reporter. And before that, where they discussed that local man caught masturbating in a construction site. And before that, where a police sketch was handed around that bore a striking resemblance to one of their very own lead investigators. We'll never know exactly what it felt like to be in that room. But if I had to guess, I'll bet it smelled strongly of coffee and unprocessed emotions. But through all the highs and more often lows, they gathered here and tried their best to figure things out.
13:30 Speaker 04 We'd sit in those meetings and talk, and then all of a sudden, somebody would come up with a theory. We'd all walk out of there thinking, yeah, it's one guy. You know, then we'd meet the next week after we worked the leads for the week, and we'd be like, yeah, it's a group.
13:41 Speaker 01 By the time Spring 2001 rolls around, after more than 12 months of investigating and a budget that was quickly approaching a million dollars, they still aren't even sure if CSB is one guy or a group of terrorists. They have nothing solid.
13:58 Speaker 05 I mean, we have FBI who are breathing down our necks. We've got council people breathing down our necks. We've got our Phoenix Police Department brass that's breathing down our necks. And everybody's telling us what they want done.
14:10 Speaker 04 The haystack's getting bigger and bigger, but the needle's still the same size.
14:14 Speaker 01 So what do you do when you can't find the needle in the haystack? Well, you could try making the needle come to you by setting a trap.
14:27 Speaker 06 I don't know who came up with that concept.
14:29 Speaker 07 But whoever did was a great idea.
14:32 Speaker 04 We started penciling it out on a whiteboard. How does this look? What can we do? All of us felt like this has got a good chance of working.
14:39 Speaker 01 The idea is this.
14:42 Speaker 01 Stage a fake construction site and see if they can get the arsonist to come to them.
14:48 Speaker 05 Let's rent some heavy equipment. Let's get a sign going.
14:52 Speaker 04 We need a property. We need fencing. We need this. We need that.
14:55 Speaker 05 Let's make this thing look like a construction site.
14:58 Speaker 01 In the aftermath of James Hibbard's interview, with CSP's line about that second Lee Benson fire being "personal", they know exactly where to set this thing up. Just around the corner from Lee Benson's house. One of the neighbors has offered to help. He owns an undeveloped lot just around the corner from Lee. This neighbor agrees to let the task force stage the beginnings of a construction site on his property.
15:23 Speaker 04 While we were doing that, the tech people at the FBI were setting up surveillance cameras in the desert for us.
15:28 Speaker 01 They also set up a big metal shipping container in the desert, close by, with monitors to watch the surveillance footage live.
15:35 Speaker 04 Cameras that were transmitted over the cell frequency then were very new and they weren't real advanced. So we had to have people sit in these Conex boxes and watch cameras all night, every night.
15:45 Speaker 01 The trap is almost ready.
15:47 Speaker 04 The fence was supposed to go up like on Friday and the surveillance was supposed to start that night.
15:58 Speaker 01 The very first night the cameras are installed, the sun sets over Phoenix and the moon begins to rise over the desert.
16:07 Speaker 01 Sneaking through the cul-de-sac, under the cover of darkness, a shadowy figure makes their way towards the fake construction site and starts attaching notes to the fence.
16:18 Speaker 05 Four white sheets of paper with CSP on all four sides of the fence.
16:25 Speaker 01 All the cops need to do now is swoop in and grab the guy.
16:39 Speaker 01 Honey, that flu keeping you up? Yeah, I don't got this.
16:42 Speaker 05 You need Nyquil Intense Flu. Undo your flu symptoms with Nyquil Intense Flu. The nighttime sniffling, aching, aching fever best sleep with a flu medicine. You do got this. Uses directed, keep out of reach of children. Hey, it's Brianna Stewart here with Ally Bank. Whether it's at work or with family, life never calls a timeout. Sometimes you're ready and sometimes you have to react on your feet. Unexpected travel, retail therapy, and of course, the kids need new kicks right now. Ally gets it and they build banking around real life. So even in those clutch money moments, you can spend and save confidently with the bank that's got your back. Ally, do it right. Ally Bank, member FDIC.
17:27 Speaker 01 When Rob wakes up the next morning, he learns that the arsonist took the bait. CSP came to the fake construction site and left their signature threats. The plan worked, except for one minor detail.
17:42 Speaker 04 There was an IT-related issue with the cameras. Something was amiss.
17:48 Speaker 05 The camera is put up by the FBI surveillance team, but they didn't know where to point it, thinking this isn't going to happen overnight. The cameras, they were facing out into the mountain preserve and it wasn't aiming at our site.
18:03 Speaker 04 We missed them. We missed our opportunity.
18:06 Speaker 01 With the cameras pointing uselessly into the desert, CSP slipped away into the darkness.
18:13 Speaker 04 Here we come up with a perfect plan, put it all in motion, and we fumbled it.
18:17 Speaker 01 Wow, how did that feel?
18:18 Speaker 04 Oh, it was devastating. It's like fumbling on the goal line, ready to score the winning touchdown and the other team picks it up and runs the other way and wins. That's really what it felt like. It was horrible. I was irate. Terry was upset.
18:32 Speaker 07 Who is this guy? You felt like you were one upped all the time.
18:36 Speaker 04 Trent was upset.
18:37 Speaker 05 Now if he hits again and we missed that opportunity, that's a big deal.
18:43 Speaker 01 But out of everyone on the task force, Rob is the most upset.
18:47 Speaker 04 That was probably the one time where I melted down a little bit. We've worked so hard to get to this point. We looked at so many things to get to this point and now we missed our one opportunity we're going to get. We were getting sloppy. We'd lost our focus on details. I brought everybody in a room and chewed everybody out and was ticked.
19:09 Speaker 01 After all those false leads, countless dead ends, and who knows how many sleepless nights, Rob feels like things are really starting to fall apart.
19:17 Speaker 04 We were missing important things. In hindsight, that was my fault. At the time, I didn't realize that. I was mad at everybody else.
19:26 Speaker 04 I just said, "How many more ways can we fuck this thing up?"
19:28 Speaker 05 And I said, "Hey, it's only 9:30, Rob."
19:30 Speaker 04 And I said, "What?" And he said, "There's infinite ways we can F this thing up." And then everybody laughed, and the whole temperature came down.
19:38 Speaker 01 The team takes a couple days to recover, and then they regroup. They're hopeful that with a few adjustments, they can lure the arsonist back to the construction site again. So the cameras stay up, and now they're pointing in the direction of the fake construction site.
19:56 Speaker 04 Several weeks went by, no activity on the cameras.
19:59 Speaker 01 After monitoring the cameras for weeks, at considerable expense, Rob and his team are beginning to lose hope. They're just about ready to take the whole operation down and try something else. But before they move on, they've got one last idea up their sleeve.
20:17 Speaker 04 We decided to come up with a sign to try to entice him again.
20:21 Speaker 01 A sign with a big colorful drawing of a gaudy mansion, just to make it super clear exactly what type of house would be going up on this property.
20:30 Speaker 04 This big, massive mansion that was gonna take up the whole lot.
20:34 Speaker 05 Let's put the square footage on it. Let's put a picture on there, and let's put it up.
20:38 Speaker 04 Coming soon kind of a thing.
20:40 Speaker 01 And right below the mock-up of the house, they put a message addressed specifically to the arsonist. It says, "We promise to live here in harmony with all the wildlife, nature, plants, and you." They mount the sign on the fence, right in view of the camera.
20:58 Speaker 02 I could see the front of the fence, and I could see the sign on the fence.
21:10 Speaker 01 It's late at night and rookie police officer Carrie Miaso is crouched over a tiny desk inside a repurposed shipping container in the desert.
21:19 Speaker 02 And you're just like looking at a screen, there's nothing going on.
21:22 Speaker 01 It's April 20th, 2001, and it's not Carrie's first shift in the shipping container. She's actually been doing this for weeks.
21:31 Speaker 02 And you're like, how long are we gonna be doing this? Nothing's happening. I mean, literally, the wind's blowing, you can see that.
21:39 Speaker 01 Outside, the desert is quiet, but inside, she's sharing the cramped space with another officer, John. John is a former Marine turned cop, more senior than Carrie, who just finished her probation.
21:53 Speaker 01 Hour after hour, Carrie and John stare at the screen showing the fake construction site with its fancy new sign.
22:02 Speaker 02 All of a sudden, I see this subject walk towards the sign. And I'm like, John, you see that? And he goes, "Yeah."
22:12 Speaker 01 Carrie squints at the grainy monitor as the shape of a person comes into view.
22:18 Speaker 02 My heart's starting to race now, because I'm like, is this him? This is him. I know this is him. This has gotta be him. This is him. Is this him?
22:26 Speaker 02 I could see the hand go up. I'm like, John, is he writing on the sign? No, he's just looking at it. I'm like, are you sure? I'm like, I think he's writing on the sign. John's, "No, he's not writing..." I'm like, "I think he is." And so we're having this argument about what's going on. I'm like, anyway, it's the first person at this sign since we've been sitting here.
22:44 Speaker 01 Carrie knows she cannot miss this opportunity. Everything the task force has been doing for over a year has all built up to this one single moment. This is it. John leaps into action, dialing headquarters to let them know what's happening. Meanwhile, hands shaking, Carrie reaches for the police radio, her old nemesis.
23:06 Speaker 02 I don't know what I'm saying. I have no idea what's coming out of my mouth. My brain is freezing. I can't figure out where I'm at now. I'm like, I'm just so excited. Uh, oh, we need the air unit. We need it down here now. We got, we, we, we got, we got somebody over here. We might be the arsonist. And I'm just...
23:26 Speaker 01 Just bumbling it.
23:26 Speaker 02 Just, yeah. You know what's funny is, I think I still have a recording of that.
23:32 Speaker 01 No.
23:33 Speaker 02 Yeah.
23:37 Speaker 01 This is the actual recording of Carrie calling in the report.
23:41 Speaker 06 Ma'am, we need to see if we can get an area in the mountain preserve.
23:46 Speaker 02 Dispatchers, you know, where are you at right now?
23:48 Speaker 06 Six seventy-nine, ma'am, do you have a hundred box?
23:51 Speaker 02 And I'm like, I, I, I don't.
23:53 Speaker 06 It's about, um.
23:54 Speaker 02 I'm at the, you know, just south, just go south on Thirty-second Street.
24:00 Speaker 06 And it's Thirty-second Street, um.
24:03 Speaker 02 He's leaving the sign now. He went this way. I'm stupidly giving descriptions of colors of clothes.
24:10 Speaker 06 Um, he has black clothes on, short brown hair, even white nails.
24:14 Speaker 02 I told you it was black and white. I can't see colors. And I'm saying, I think he's got pink shorts on. I'm like, how do I know he's got pink shorts on? I don't know.
24:25 Speaker 01 The call goes out from dispatch for the nearest unit to respond immediately. But the nearest unit was kind of in the middle of something.
24:33 Speaker 02 If I remember correctly, they had just stopped at Jack in the Box or something like that.
24:38 Speaker 01 They're in the drive-thru of a fast food restaurant.
24:41 Speaker 02 And they hauled ass.
24:47 Speaker 02 Hamburgers were flying across the dashboard. Cokes were all over the place.
24:52 Speaker 01 By the time these guys reached the mountain preserve, not only are they probably covered in ketchup and coke, the suspect has fled the scene.
25:03 Speaker 01 But the officers know these trails like the back of their hand. So they charge off into the darkness to cut him off.
25:12 Speaker 01 Minutes later, Carrie's on the dreaded radio again.
25:14 Speaker 06 Okay, copy, short brown.
25:16 Speaker 02 I remember as I'm on with the dispatcher, trying to tell her where we need the air unit. They cleared over on their other radio and said.
25:25 Speaker 06 We've got him in custody, ma'am.
25:27 Speaker 02 We got him in custody.
25:41 Speaker 02 Cool fall nights always make me want to entertain more. A few friends.
25:45 Speaker 00 Around the table, maybe a fire outside when the sun goes down. Before everyone comes over, I stop at Total Wine & More. Right now, there's a cranberry-flavored wine, a crisp apple wine, even a pumpkin spice cream that's perfect in coffee after dinner. And with the lowest prices, I can bring home a few different fall flavors for everyone to try. Find your favorite fall flavors at the lowest prices at Total Wine & More. Spirits are not sold in Virginia and North Carolina. Drink responsibly. Must be 21.
26:15 Speaker 03 Observe. The North American Dad. 50s. Great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, "Dang, that's a good offer." The highest form of approval. No haggling, no hassle, no one called him "boss." He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
26:52 Speaker 01 The man who wrote on the sign has been arrested. In the shipping container, Carrie and her partner John are ecstatic.
27:00 Speaker 02 It felt really good.
27:04 Speaker 01 After a full year of mind-numbing surveillance, fruitless dead ends, failed operations, and constant media pressure, now, finally, they have someone in handcuffs.
27:16 Speaker 04 I got called in the middle of the night. We all went and met out there and we just set up a command post and started working it from there.
27:22 Speaker 01 FBI case lead Terry Kearns gets a call too.
27:25 Speaker 07 You've put so much time and effort and work. And this person who you feel has been outsmarting you, you finally were able to catch them in the act.
27:34 Speaker 01 There's an undeniable excitement in the air.
27:37 Speaker 07 But a kind of a conservative excitement? Because you don't know for sure. Is it really him? And is it only him?
27:51 Speaker 01 A few minutes later, FBI Special Agent Ken Williams pulls up to the scene.
27:56 Speaker 06 I see the decoy sign that we had up there designed depicting the Scouting House. I see that there's some graffiti written on it.
28:03 Speaker 01 The suspect has left a message for the builders of this fake construction site. In response to their pledge to live in harmony with the plants and animals of the desert, he wrote two words: "Okay, thanks." Followed by that familiar acronym: CSP. And there, in the middle of the street, is their perp.
28:25 Speaker 06 I see the subject standing in the street with handcuffs on him in the back with the patrol officer. And I remember him standing there in his underwear.
28:32 Speaker 01 The suspect is wearing nothing but a light t-shirt and boxer shorts. In his hands is a red marker.
28:39 Speaker 06 This is a grown man. He's in his 40s. Put him in the back of the patrol car, and I followed patrol car down to police headquarters.
28:53 Speaker 01 When Ken arrives at the station, the suspect is waiting for him in the interrogation room. Ken knows he has to work quickly. Because even though this guy was caught at the scene of the crime, he was not caught committing arson. Ken has a limited window to get this guy talking, or he'll be set free.
29:12 Speaker 06 You know, if they spill it up, then we got all the time in the world to talk to him.
29:16 Speaker 01 According to Ken, there are three types of jail interviews.
29:21 Speaker 01 There's the tough guy.
29:23 Speaker 06 Somebody that's gonna lawyer right up, guy that doesn't wanna talk to the cops.
29:26 Speaker 01 The remorseful type.
29:27 Speaker 06 They're devastated. They know the gig's up. They've been caught. They're gonna cough it all up.
29:31 Speaker 01 And then, there's a third type.
29:33 Speaker 06 They waive their rights. They're gonna talk to you, but they are not really wanting to talk to you. They wanna find out what you know about them. That's the challenging one. That is a guy that's basically saying, "Okay, bring it on." You know, that's what he was. It's like, "Okay, this guy wants to play."
29:54 Speaker 01 At 6:33 in the morning, on the 20th of April 2001, the interview begins.
30:08 Speaker 01 In the room is Special Agent Ken Williams and another investigator from the Phoenix P D.
30:13 Speaker 04 And I'm Ken Williams with the FBI here in Phoenix.
30:16 Speaker 01 What you're hearing is a police recording I got ahold of, Ken's actual interview with the suspect. The suspect is shivering, wearing nothing but a T-shirt, so they bring him a space blanket.
30:28 Speaker 04 Uh, you want your blanket?
30:29 Speaker 03 Yes.
30:30 Speaker 04 I'll call you.
30:31 Speaker 03 Sixty-two.
30:33 Speaker 04 And where you at?
30:34 Speaker 03 I'm in.
30:35 Speaker 01 The man has brown hair, beginning to gray. He wraps the silver blanket around his shoulders. You can hear it rustling in the tape.
30:43 Speaker 04 Are you willing to discuss what you hear about the criminal damage?
30:49 Speaker 03 Without an attorney?
30:50 Speaker 04 Yeah.
30:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:53 Speaker 01 They start with a simple question: What the hell happened tonight?
30:57 Speaker 04 What the hell happened tonight? I mean, uh, why? What's the rationale behind it?
31:06 Speaker 03 I did a real stupid thing, guys.
31:07 Speaker 01 He says, "I did a real stupid thing, guys," but he can explain.
31:11 Speaker 03 Um, I read the story.
31:13 Speaker 01 He read an article in the New Times about the guy whose house burned down and how he wanted to rebuild.
31:19 Speaker 03 And I got pissed off.
31:21 Speaker 01 Pissed off not at the guy wanting to rebuild, pissed off at the guy burning those houses down.
31:27 Speaker 03 The guy has a right to build his house, though. I just wanted to leave a message, say, "Hey, it's okay to build your house here."
31:33 Speaker 01 So why sign it CSP?
31:36 Speaker 03 And I did it to the guys that I was part of that group. And I guess I thought it would have more credibility, like, the group is backing off if I use their initials.
31:46 Speaker 01 That's his story, and he sticks to it.
31:49 Speaker 03 I like the desert. I respect private property, too. I live on the desert.
31:54 Speaker 01 He's done something stupid, he admits, impulsive, criminal even, but he's not the arsonist. And tonight's message was just an isolated incident.
32:05 Speaker 03 I had to leave a message, calling off the guards.
32:09 Speaker 04 Are you part of the Dawns? No, sir.
32:13 Speaker 01 They start asking the man about his life. Do you have a family? What do you do for work?
32:18 Speaker 04 I became a family man. I had a good career, but I was working hard. You know, I was working six days a week.
32:23 Speaker 01 They learn that he lives just a couple of streets away from Lee Benson. His backyard connects directly into the preserve. They ask the suspect if he's been following the fires.
32:34 Speaker 04 Sure. I mean, people ask me about it. Could you live so close? I live close, you know.
32:38 Speaker 01 The man tells them he's an avid hiker and jogger. A bit of a night owl. He's self-employed, in marketing, in PR. He's a soccer referee. He's married, with a daughter, and they have quite a few pets.
32:51 Speaker 04 Two dogs, two cats, thirteen hamsters.
32:55 Speaker 01 He's on the board of the local homeowners association. He doesn't exactly fit the mold of an eco-terrorist. The investigators ask him how he feels about the environment. He says, "He thinks we should all recycle." But what about the Earth Liberation Front? Ever heard of them?
33:12 Speaker 04 Where have you read about it, ELO? Oh, I think there was a story in the New Times when they were writing about the arson group.
33:21 Speaker 01 The suspect tells them he might have had a look on their website briefly, after reading about them in the New Times. Or, perhaps it was an episode of 60 Minutes. He recalls that their spokesperson looked like a tree hugger, a granola eater.
33:34 Speaker 04 You would not put yourself in that area, do you? I care about the environment.
33:39 Speaker 01 They ask the man about his educational background. The suspect studied journalism.
33:44 Speaker 04 You went to journalism school? A long time ago. Have you done any journalism work, any reporting work? I had a college, while I was a radio news guy.
33:53 Speaker 01 Interesting, Ken suggests. Because whoever set these fires would have to be pretty media savvy.
34:00 Speaker 04 Are you calling me a suspect in the fires? Well, I'm telling you that we're going to investigate to try to confirm. You're not a suspect in the fires?
34:07 Speaker 01 The conversation goes around in circles.
34:10 Speaker 04 Is it possible that you are a member of the group? And maybe this is your signal to us that, you know, you're done doing things? I'm not done doing anything. That stupid cranks like this. Okay, well, I'm just asking. I'm trying to understand, like you said yourself, you don't know what through your stupid.
34:26 Speaker 01 They go from the fires to the man's background to the fires again.
34:30 Speaker 06 He was calm. He was very calm and collected.
34:33 Speaker 01 Ken also tells me he was struck by the changes in the suspect's demeanor.
34:38 Speaker 06 He went from a very effeminate person when we first got him, building up to like he's a tough guy, you know, almost like very indignant to going back to almost childlike. Without really answering any questions, we could not pin him down. It was a very strange interview.
34:54 Speaker 01 Ken gets the impression that his suspect is trying to suss out what the task force knows.
34:59 Speaker 06 He wanted to talk, but he wasn't talking. He was fishing.
35:03 Speaker 01 Ken holds back the details.
35:05 Speaker 06 We don't want to run at home and starting to destroy evidence and stuff like that.
35:11 Speaker 01 By this time, it's after nine thirty in the morning. Ken is confident he's got all he can from the interview, at least for now.
35:21 Speaker 06 He wasn't going to give us anything.
35:25 Speaker 01 The interview is over. They send the man back to a holding cell. Later that day, they'll let him go.
35:33 Speaker 01 The mood in the police station is celebratory. They've got a suspect. And even though he'll walk free, they're going to watch him like a hawk.
35:42 Speaker 01 But not everyone is celebrating. Warren Jerms, the local guy who loves jogging in the preserves, is about to receive a phone call that will change his life forever.
35:55 Speaker 01 My wife Mia called me and told me that Mark had been arrested as the arsonist. Mark Sands, his running buddy and hiking partner. He was what I would call my best friend. The guy he sat next to at church while they poured over a copy of the Phoenix New Times interview with the arsonist.
36:20 Speaker 01 I said to her, I said, "No.
36:26 Speaker 01 It can't be."
36:28 Speaker 04 I didn't believe it.
36:31 Speaker 04 I just didn't believe that it could be Mark.
36:39 Speaker 01 Next time on The Arsonist Next Door, Mark Sands has been hiding some dark secrets, and his best friend Warren is pulled into a spiral of lies.
36:49 Speaker 04 Mark thought that I was an angel helping him, but it turned out that I was the serpent in an unexpected place.
37:05 Speaker 01 You're smart, right? You should get paid up to two days early. With Ally's early direct deposit, you can better manage your funds and have money for when life is actually happening. So go ahead. Make Wednesday the new Friday. Level up Thursday's date night and be ready when those tickets go on sale Friday. Ally: Banking Built for Life Today. Ally Bank, Member FDIC.
37:46 Speaker 01 The Arsonist Next Door is an original production of Sony Music Entertainment and Novel. This series was written and reported by me, Sam Anderson. It was produced and reported by Leona Hamid. Our assistant producer is Madeline Parr. Research by Zeyana Youssef. Additional production from Tom Wright and G. Stiles. Our editor is Dave Anderson. Additional story editing from Max O'Brien. From Novel, our executive producers are Max O'Brien and Craig Strachan. From Sony Music Entertainment, our executive producers are Catherine St. Louis and Jonathan Hirsch. Sound design, mixing, and scoring by Nicholas Alexander and Daniel Kemson. Our original theme song was composed and performed by Nicholas Alexander.
38:30 Speaker 01 Production management from Cherie Houston, Joe Savage, Saratobin, and Charlotte Wolf. Fact checking by Danya Solayman. Story development by Nell Gray Andrews. Novel's director of development is Selena Metta, and Willard Foxton is Novel's creative director of development. Special thanks to Jen Feifield, Libby Goff, Bob Kahn, Xander Adams, Anthony Wallace, Steve Ackerman, Carolyn Shirlevin, and the team at Reviewed and Cleared, Mario Caciutolo, Isaac Fisher, Kevin Lee Karas, Jess Swinburne, Sunny Marr, Carly Frankel, and the team at WME.
39:33 Speaker 01 Honey, that flu keeping you up? Yeah, I don't got this. You need NyQuil Intense Flu. Undo your flu symptoms with NyQuil Intense Flu. The nighttime sniffling, aching, aching fever, best sleep with a flu medicine. You do got this. Uses directed, keep out of reach of children.
Previous The Arsonist Next Door | 3: The Big Scoop Next The Arsonist Next Door | 5: The Confession Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated