Pod Insights The Binge Crimes The Arsonist Next Door | 1: You Build We Burn About this episode When Lee Benson’s nearly complete dream home burns to the ground, he thinks it must have been an accident. But then, a disturbing message is left at the scene. Are eco-terrorists behind this terrifying act?
Binge all episodes of The Arsonist Next Door, ad-free today by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge Crimes on Apple Podcasts and hit ‘subscribe’ or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access.
From serial killer nurses to psychic scammers – The Binge is your home for true crime stories that pull you in and never let go.
The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
A Sony Music Entertainment and Novel production.
Find out more about The Binge and other podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts and follow us @sonypodcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. The message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. OK, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
0:21 Speaker 01 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate for three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
0:30 Speaker 02 Listen to all episodes of The Arsonist Next Door ad-free right now by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge channel on Apple Podcasts and hit Subscribe at the top of the page, or visit getthebinge.com to get access wherever you listen. The Binge: Feed your true crime obsession.
1:09 Speaker 03 I just love the beauty of the desert.
1:14 Speaker 03 All the changing seasons, coyotes, javelina, bobcats, lots of rattlesnakes in the summertime.
1:23 Speaker 02 Phoenix, Arizona, the year 2000. Lee Benson is a local businessman. He's building his dream house. It's enormous. A custom-designed mansion close to the Phoenix Mountains Preserve, an area of wilderness set aside for conservation. This bumpy brown patch of desert is being transformed.
1:45 Speaker 03 The walls are up, the roof is on, all the wiring is in. Every day coming to the construction site and watching this thing go up, it was so much fun.
1:56 Speaker 02 Everything is going according to plan.
2:04 Speaker 04 All of a sudden, the lights kicked on the station. Waking up from a sound sleep, and it's kind of adrenaline rush. Your heart starts pounding. You're breathing fast.
2:14 Speaker 02 It's 11:38 on a Sunday night in April. Battalion Chief Brian Parks leaps out of his bunk at a Phoenix Fire Station.
2:22 Speaker 04 Get dressed quick. Get out to the truck. Pulling out of the station and heading south, you could see a glow in the sky.
2:32 Speaker 02 The glow is getting brighter and brighter, like a red dawn breaking over the mountains. But sunrise is still six hours away. What Brian's team is heading towards is something much more dangerous.
2:44 Speaker 04 The flames were licking up probably 40, 50 feet in the air, in the area of the mountain preserves.
2:50 Speaker 02 A huge plume of smoke billows from the base of Piestua Peak.
2:54 Speaker 04 Undisturbed desert is where it was. You get something in there, you're gonna have a brush fire.
2:59 Speaker 02 The fire truck careens through a winding neighborhood onto a narrow dirt road before coming to a dead end. Beyond is nothing but desert, a rugged valley covered in cactus and creosote bush.
3:11 Speaker 04 Very limited access, very, very dark. But you could see the glow the whole time, and you're just trying to get back there to get to work.
3:20 Speaker 02 Lee Benson's mansion, on the verge of completion, is engulfed in flames.
3:26 Speaker 04 The whole structure's ignited and burning at this point.
3:29 Speaker 02 Brian has to make a decision on whether to send his people inside the building.
3:33 Speaker 04 Rolling the window down, you could actually feel the heat.
3:36 Speaker 02 Because this is a construction site, Brian is hopeful there's no one inside to rescue. But even if there was, there's no way he can order his team into a fire like this.
3:46 Speaker 04 The wall could collapse, and you don't want to be in the area where the wall falls on you or some of our equipment.
3:54 Speaker 02 He tells his firefighters to stay back and try and contain the blaze from the outside.
4:01 Speaker 02 The air is filled with the smell of wood smoke.
4:04 Speaker 04 Like a big lumberyard fire, basically. You're gonna hear crackling, you're gonna hear crashes and stuff like that. You can actually hear the wind moving too. Because fire needs oxygen to burn.
4:16 Speaker 02 A strange howling sound pierces the air, as if the fire itself were alive.
4:21 Speaker 04 Out in an open environment, it's gonna consume as much oxygen as it can, and it's gonna grow fast.
4:29 Speaker 02 As the flames leap into the sky, fiery embers rain down over neighboring houses, igniting small brush fires in the surrounding desert.
4:39 Speaker 02 If this fragile landscape burns, it will take decades to recover.
4:50 Speaker 02 At 5:30 a.m. the following morning, the owner, Lee Benson, is woken up by a phone call.
4:56 Speaker 03 What? I've got all this time and money and effort to this point. Like, what the heck happened?
5:06 Speaker 02 When he arrives at the scene, the road is lined with trucks, their lights flashing red and white.
5:12 Speaker 03 It was so hot that the concrete was sort of chipped up and coming apart.
5:17 Speaker 02 Neighbors crowd around, craning their necks for a view of the destruction.
5:21 Speaker 04 When the fire was over, everything was burned. There was nothing left that wasn't burned in that house.
5:27 Speaker 02 The fire investigation team arrives to assess the damage.
5:33 Speaker 02 They're looking for clues to how it began. The point of origin.
5:38 Speaker 04 There's nothing natural that could have started that fire, other than somebody else doing it.
5:42 Speaker 02 In other words, arson.
5:46 Speaker 02 But Lee Benson, he's not so sure.
5:48 Speaker 03 It's probably just some kids smoking cigarettes, dropped a match. I just assumed that it was an accident.
5:54 Speaker 02 Sure, as someone who used to sneak into construction sites to smoke blunts with my friends when I was 16, I appreciate this theory. But then, a few weeks later...
6:05 Speaker 03 My builder put up a sign for his company, and somebody wrote on it, "You build, we burn again."
6:12 Speaker 02 "You build, we burn again." The word "burn" is underlined. And the message is signed with a mysterious acronym, CSP.
6:21 Speaker 03 OK, this was intentional.
6:23 Speaker 02 Who is CSP? And why are they targeting Lee?
6:27 Speaker 03 Could there be somebody that has an issue with me? I just needed answers.
6:33 Speaker 02 It's going to be a long time before Lee gets those answers, because CSP is far from done.
6:41 Speaker 02 There are dark times ahead for this quiet suburban neighborhood.
6:45 Speaker 05 You never want to think your next-door neighbor is the serial killer, but he lives next to somebody.
6:52 Speaker 02 This is just the beginning of the most notorious arson spree Phoenix has ever seen.
6:58 Speaker 06 Is he just gonna quit? We gonna catch him? Or is somebody gonna die? He was like the Road Runner zipping around the Arizona desert.
7:05 Speaker 07 My heart's starting to race now. Is this him? This is him. I know this is him. This has gotta be him.
7:10 Speaker 02 CSP's crimes will ignite a firestorm of media attention.
7:14 Speaker 06 He thought he was so smart that he could taunt us by manipulating the media.
7:18 Speaker 02 And divide the communities of Phoenix.
7:20 Speaker 06 Some people were rooting for this guy, like a folk hero. We were terrified. Everybody was.
7:31 Speaker 02 From Sony Music Entertainment and Novel, I'm Sam Anderson. This is The Arsonist Next Door.
8:01 Speaker 02 Episode 1. You build, we burn.
8:14 Speaker 02 We could see more days above 110 through the weekend. So unfortunately, we're all looking at the same forecast here. More hot days this last week of the month. I've come to the sweltering city of Phoenix to investigate this story that began a quarter century ago with that first fire at Lee Benson's place. Why? Because it's a story about going to the extreme, about the crazy things that seemingly ordinary people do under the right circumstances. And I want to understand what it takes to make someone go there, to send them over the edge.
8:54 Speaker 02 Personally, I'm already there. This heat is driving me absolutely insane.
9:05 Speaker 02 My producer, Leona, and I have perfected a mad dash from the air-conditioned apartment to our air-conditioned car, a bright red Mini Cooper. Oh, that's delicious. But the Mini takes a while to cool down. Well, if I've ever eaten a hot banana before. We're parked on a suburban street in North Phoenix, an area called Heritage Heights. It's just around the corner from Lee Benson's house, the scene of the crime, where it all began. I'm actually feeling kind of paranoid. You know when you're in a picture-perfect neighborhood and get that feeling like you're not supposed to be there? That's exactly the sort of place we're in right now. It's an affluent suburb where dozens of cul-de-sacs wind around each other.
9:47 Speaker 02 I'm seeing Spanish-style houses painted in desert colors, some with lawns neatly trimmed and well-watered, despite the heat, which makes no sense for the desert.
10:00 Speaker 02 We exit the car and start knocking on doors. Hi. Hello, my name's Sam Anderson. Hi. I'm a journalist. We're actually making a podcast. We want to understand what kind of place this is and what happened 25 years ago when that first house went up in flames. This is the perfect place to live in Phoenix, there. Absolutely the perfect place. Nestled between Freeway 51 to the north and a panoramic view of the Phoenix Mountains Preserve to the south, this area is filled with wildlife.
10:30 Speaker 05 Little teeny tiny gecko, new baby.
10:35 Speaker 02 And with an active homeowners association, everyone seems to have a pretty good idea of what everyone else is doing around here.
10:42 Speaker 05 I've had keys to every house in our cul-de-sac. Here, looking out for the kids, picking them up at school if somebody needs help.
10:52 Speaker 02 These folks aren't afraid to spill the tea about what their neighbors are up to.
10:56 Speaker 05 If you just wouldn't have had a noisy Doberman, nobody would have cared.
10:59 Speaker 02 From what I can tell, not a lot of bad stuff happens here.
11:03 Speaker 05 We just had our first squatter. Teenagers like to climb the fence and swim in the pool.
11:12 Speaker 02 The most shocking thing that ever happened in this neighborhood was that fateful day in April 2000, when the residents of Heritage Heights woke to the sound of sirens to find Lee Benson's soon-to-be mansion burned to the ground.
11:26 Speaker 05 We didn't have fires like that. A lot of us gathered and went down there with our bikes. I mean, it was a big fire. It was scary as hell.
11:37 Speaker 05 I remember one time running by there with Mark, and we just stopped and looked at the house and how it had burned down, and there was just nothing there.
11:46 Speaker 02 This is Warren Jerms. At the time of the fire, Warren also lived nearby. An accountant in his 40s, Warren was tall, wiry, and physically fit, built like an antelope. He lived with a wife and two young daughters. Before the fire, he'd frequently jog through the preserves with his running buddy Mark, passing Lee Benson's construction site along the way.
12:08 Speaker 05 It's just a rocky mountain trail that weaves and twists and turns.
12:12 Speaker 06 And goes ups and down and we ran by that one regularly.
12:16 Speaker 02 Warren and Mark watched as Lee's house sprouted up and out over the desert landscape, all 10,000 square feet of it, complete with a four-car garage and even a martial arts studio.
12:27 Speaker 06 It was much bigger than anything else in the neighborhood and it was encroaching on the desert.
12:33 Speaker 02 At the time, urban sprawl was a pretty big issue in Phoenix.
12:37 Speaker 06 Phoenix is just a large, growing city that was eating up the desert.
12:42 Speaker 02 The particular preserve that borders Heritage Heights is one of many scattered across the city, like desert islands emerging from a sea of residential housing. If you live next to one, it's like having a little bit of nature right on your doorstep. So Lee Benson's construction plans ruffled a few feathers. The locals are protective of these places, but was it really so out of place that someone would try to burn it down?
13:08 Speaker 03 It's my property and I get to do whatever I want with it.
13:11 Speaker 02 Lee was not going to be influenced by the tension in the neighborhood.
13:15 Speaker 03 I'm on private property that I purchase, not bordering any part of the preserve. It's all BS.
13:22 Speaker 02 What Lee is saying is true. The problem is, it's not always clear to locals where exactly the preserve ends and private land begins. It's easy to mistake a vacant desert lot right by the preserve as part of the preserve, when actually, it's just private land that no one's gotten around to building on yet. Technicalities aside, what mattered to Lee Benson's new neighbors was that an enormous mansion was being built, directly between their homes and their previously uninterrupted view of a beloved mountain landscape. And Lee Benson himself, well, he didn't quite fit in with the neighborhood either. This community was mostly upper-middle class, doctors, real estate agents, quiet
14:04 Speaker 02 professionals raising families. Lee was, and still is, a high-powered CEO. He's middle-aged with a buzz cut, bright blue eyes, and a charming smile. He's a business owner, an author, a martial arts teacher, and he even achieved that most glorious title we all aspire to: a podcaster.
14:26 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to the Show Your Value Podcast, where we explore the art of value creation in three macro buckets.
14:33 Speaker 02 Point is, the man is successful, and he's definitely perceived as a bit flashy.
14:40 Speaker 02 Back at the time of the fire, Lee was hard at work, creating value.
14:44 Speaker 03 Right around 2000, I'm running my full-time taekwondo martial arts school, and I'm operating three different aerospace-related businesses.
14:52 Speaker 02 Not only was the guy rich, he was fit, too.
14:55 Speaker 03 I've done lots of marathons, ultramarathons, competed in three different Ironmans. I just love to exercise.
15:02 Speaker 02 Not only was he rich and fit, he played guitar in a hard rock band.
15:10 Speaker 02 That's Lee on guitar.
15:12 Speaker 03 Band was called Three Degrees West, played over 1,000 nights on stages, clubs, concerts, all of that. So, music's going on, martial arts is going on, I've got my aerospace companies going on. Life is full and amazing.
15:25 Speaker 02 His life was so full and amazing that when his custom dream home got torched, he refused to let it set him back.
15:32 Speaker 03 Sometimes, bad things happen, and just deal with it.
15:36 Speaker 02 What was your reaction?
15:38 Speaker 03 There's no way I'm gonna let somebody like that win. No way. It's like, okay, this happened. What's the plan, and where do we go from here?
15:45 Speaker 02 The plan was this: rebuild, same as before. Put up a little security fencing, hire a security guard, but not a professional security guard, just someone he connected with through his taekwondo studio.
15:58 Speaker 03 Just somebody to be on the property with a phone to call if there was any issues.
16:04 Speaker 02 The security guard would drive over to Lee Benson's after work to sit in his car and watch over the place all night. He'd do this after working all day at his day job. Can you imagine working a desk job all day, just to sleep in your car while anxiously waking up every couple hours to make sure a mansion's not burned down? Sounds exhausting. That's probably why, on the morning of October 1st, six months after Lee's house burned down, the guy decides to leave a little bit early, around 5:15, about an hour before sunrise.
16:39 Speaker 03 He wasn't supposed to, but he did.
16:44 Speaker 02 By 5:34 a.m., Lee Benson's house is on fire again.
16:51 Speaker 02 Brian Parks and his firefighters rush to the scene.
16:54 Speaker 04 Coming in there a second time, you have a really weird feeling as, why is this being burned twice?
17:00 Speaker 02 And again, Lee shows up to see his grand vision reduced to a smoldering wreck.
17:08 Speaker 03 I was angry. I can't believe this. This is such a waste of resources.
17:14 Speaker 02 Standing before the burnt remains, Lee gazes across at the neighboring streets, full of single-family houses in neat rows.
17:23 Speaker 03 I remember looking at the houses and thinking, whoever it is lives there or knows somebody there, because somebody has to be watching to know this guy left a few minutes early that day.
17:36 Speaker 02 In the days after the second fire, another message is found at the scene of the crime, this time in the form of a letter. It contains a chilling message for Lee. Thou shalt not desecrate God's creation. Lee Benson, take your dream house out of the preserve.
18:07 Speaker 02 Carhartt's Holiday Gift Guides were built in collaboration with the greatest gift giver of all time, Santa Claus himself. Old Saint Nick counts on Carhartt's durable gear
18:16 Speaker 00 to have his back through rain, sleet, and snow on the biggest night of the year. Because when everyone's counting on you to do your job, what else would you wear to work? Tap the banner to grab a gift for every hard-working person on your holiday shopping list, or head to carhartt.com.
18:34 Speaker 00 Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. The message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch.
18:56 Speaker 01 Upfront payment of $45 for three-month plan, equivalent to $15 per month required. Intro rate for three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.
19:15 Speaker 02 Lieutenant Rob Handy is sitting in his office at the Phoenix Police Department headquarters. He's a big, serious-looking guy with a buzz cut. He's only in his early 30s, but he already has a reputation for being intense and pretty competitive when it comes to catching bad guys. In his hand is the note left behind at the scene of the second fire. Proof that Lee Benson's new home has been deliberately burnt down again.
19:40 Speaker 06 It says "warning" across the top that looks like it's been almost stenciled with two exclamation points.
19:47 Speaker 02 The fire department can't handle something like this alone, so they've called in the police. And Rob is tasked with leading the investigation. But so far, he only has one lead: the piece of paper in his hand. Whoever wrote the letter has taken steps to conceal their identity.
20:07 Speaker 06 Underneath it is type from a computer imprinted, but then the top looks like it's more scrawled.
20:12 Speaker 02 The letter goes straight into the ominous "thou shalt not desecrate God's creation" line.
20:17 Speaker 06 And then it has Revelations 14:10 and then Proverbs 17:19.
20:22 Speaker 02 The two biblical passages it refers to are kind of on the scarier side. Quote, "They too will drink the wine of God's fury, which has been poured full strength into the cup of his wrath."
20:34 Speaker 06 And then it says, "We are not done. Lee Benson, take your dream house out of the preserve. Security will be defeated again. We've been trained well. Thanks."
20:44 Speaker 02 At least this fire and brimstone arsonist is polite. Rob's eyes are drawn to the wheat. Is there a group behind this attack? And what's up with the signature? CSP again.
20:56 Speaker 06 With periods between it, as if it were an acronym.
20:59 Speaker 02 CSP is not an acronym Rob or his team have heard of before.
21:03 Speaker 06 The first thing that came to mind was, was this an environmental group?
21:06 Speaker 02 An environmental group with a sprinkling of religious extremism.
21:10 Speaker 06 So obviously, we were looking like crazy. And this is early on with the internet, too. It's not like it is today, right? I mean, we were just not able to find anything. We thought, this might be bogus. They might be trying to throw us off. Why would they identify themselves so easily? Or is this a group that's trying to establish themselves and this is their first foray into criminal activity?
21:34 Speaker 06 Remember what it felt like reading that note? Yeah, now he's messing with us.
21:39 Speaker 02 He, not they?
21:41 Speaker 06 Honestly, our consideration initially was it's somebody who hikes the trail every day. I mean, that's kind of what our thinking was to begin with, a pissed off neighbor.
21:50 Speaker 02 Rob's got a hunch that their perp is a lone actor, someone who lives nearby, someone who just does not like Lee Benson and his gaudy mansion. Probably a man, Rob thinks. After all, the vast majority of arsonists are men. And Lee, he thinks the same thing. To him, this feels personal.
22:10 Speaker 03 I was getting pressure from neighbors to donate the land to the preserve and people made me out to be like the devil. It was crazy.
22:18 Speaker 02 But as you've gathered already, Lee isn't the type to give up.
22:22 Speaker 03 For sure, I'm gonna build again.
22:26 Speaker 02 Only by this point, he's got a new problem.
22:29 Speaker 03 Nobody would insure me.
22:31 Speaker 02 Lee can't rebuild until CSP is caught.
22:34 Speaker 03 So then my efforts just focused on how do I help find this individual so I can start building it again?
22:41 Speaker 02 But then, news reaches Lee Benson that changes everything for the whole neighborhood.
22:48 Speaker 03 You know, it was super unfortunate and a little bit relieving for me personally when another home was burned down.
22:55 Speaker 02 A third fire, and this one didn't target Lee Benson. It was just a couple miles away, along the preserve border, another new home under construction. This one was owned by a family with young kids.
23:08 Speaker 00 And another house fire overnight may be the work of a serial arsonist.
23:12 Speaker 02 CSP strikes again, a fourth fire. This one was near Warren's place, the guy who would go running in the preserves. It was within a mile or so where I lived, on the Galle Mountains.
23:26 Speaker 02 The neighborhood is buzzing with speculation. We couldn't really figure. What the cause of it was. By now, the pattern is crystal clear. All the half-built homes that have been burned are big and fancy and situated along the edge of the mountains preserve. And it's not long before the letters, with all their religious fury, are leaked to the press. A frightening narrative begins to take shape in the local media. There's some radical, God-fearing environmentalists on the loose, and they're exacting revenge on anyone who dares to build too close to the preserve. A new letter appears, this time mailed directly to journalists who forward it to the police.
24:10 Speaker 02 The letter says, quote, "We enjoy watching the surveillance activity. No trap works unless you walk into it. Don't bet on it." And there, in the signature of that letter, is the answer to a question Lieutenant Rob Handy has been asking for months.
24:28 Speaker 06 Coalition to save the preserves.
24:30 Speaker 02 CSP stands for Coalition to Save the Preserves.
24:35 Speaker 06 There's an eco-terrorist group running around Phoenix burning homes.
24:41 Speaker 05 An environmental terrorist. Eco-terror campaign of arson. We may have an eco-terrorist on our hands.
24:55 Speaker 02 It's probably been a while since you heard the phrase eco-terrorism. It doesn't happen very often these days, but there was a time, not too long ago, in the late 1990s, when this was a big deal. At this particular moment in history, before 9/11, one of the biggest threats the feds were worried about wasn't terrorists flying airplanes into buildings, but left-wing environmentalists, and one group in particular, the Earth Liberation Front, or ELF.
25:28 Speaker 07 Members of the Earth Liberation Front say it's okay to destroy property in an effort to save the environment. The ELF is absolutely an environmental fundamentalist group. The group described-
25:39 Speaker 03 by the FBI as America's most serious domestic terrorist threat. If you're somebody else who's destroying the natural environment, you may be considered the next target of the ELF or group like them.
25:51 Speaker 02 By December of 2000, local journalists are really starting to run with the eco-terrorist story. Because you know what the ELF's favorite tactic was?
26:00 Speaker 00 For the first time since flames were spotted on Vale Mountain, investigators Thursday were willing to say the fires were caused by the criminal act of arson.
26:08 Speaker 02 One of the group's most famous acts of protest occurred just a few years earlier, in 1998.
26:14 Speaker 00 Vale residents awoke to shocking news Monday. Fire atop Vale Mountain had caused $12 million in damages.
26:22 Speaker 02 At the time, Vale was expanding its ski resort, encroaching on hundreds of acres of pristine wilderness that was home to endangered wildcats. The attack became the costliest act of so-called eco-terrorism in US history. And before long, ELF starts burning things down all over the country, always following an ideology of protecting the environment through property destruction without the loss of human life. And when the ELF burned down a building, they became known for leaving a particular catchphrase behind: The words "You build, we burn." It's the exact same phrase included on the letters from CSP in Phoenix. Looking at all these similarities,
27:07 Speaker 02 it seems a pretty good bet to journalists and investigators that the ELF is somehow involved in the Phoenix fires.
27:16 Speaker 02 The only problem is, the ELF signs their letters ELF, not CSP. Could this be a splinter group?
27:27 Speaker 02 Lieutenant Rob Handy is painfully aware of all this speculation. But despite the intrigue of a national activist cell emerging in Phoenix, he still has a hunch that the culprit might just be a local with a grudge against new houses. An extreme act of NIMBYism.
27:43 Speaker 06 Somebody's just trying to throw us off by this name, and there is no group.
27:46 Speaker 02 Which theory is right? Well, there's not much hard proof either way. The funny thing about fire is that it tends to destroy the evidence. So for now, Rob focuses on canvassing the neighborhood.
27:58 Speaker 06 We're looking for leads. We're asking for help. Our investigators were going door to door.
28:02 Speaker 02 So far, whoever's behind these fires has managed to get in and out without being seen.
28:08 Speaker 06 Always one step ahead of us initially. It just made you mad. It makes you more angry.
28:13 Speaker 02 Rob has spent hours just staring at the map of the fires, searching for a pattern. Where will CSP strike next?
28:22 Speaker 06 It's a chase. You know, you're chasing them. They're trying to get away. You're trying to catch them. And they're trying to not leave clues, and we're trying to find clues. It's like trying to solve a hard puzzle.
28:32 Speaker 02 Is it frustrating knowing that one guy or group of people is outsmarting like a whole police department?
28:39 Speaker 06 Oh, for sure. For sure. You know, how's this gonna stop? Is he just gonna quit? We gonna catch him? Or is somebody gonna die?
28:47 Speaker 02 The community is restless. It's December, around nine months since the first fire at Lee Benson's. The people living around the preserve are frustrated with the cops, who haven't made a single arrest, and seem totally incapable of protecting them from future attacks.
29:04 Speaker 06 There was a risk the entire time of it spreading to neighbors' homes or burning an entire neighborhood. I felt like it was my responsibility.
29:12 Speaker 02 Lieutenant Rob decides to call a community meeting.
29:16 Speaker 06 I asked for the meeting and asked if we could host it at Tim's house.
29:19 Speaker 02 Tim and his wife Peggy are victims of the fourth fire. Their $1.5 million home was nearly complete when it became a target of CSP. A room upstairs burnt, but the rest of the house was saved by the quick work of firefighters. After the fire, Tim and Peggy installed barbed wire fencing, motion sensors, and a lighting system. They started warning hikers out in the preserve to be on the lookout for strange behavior. Lieutenant Rob decides to hold a community meeting at Tim and Peggy's place, where the acrid smell of smoke still lingers.
29:58 Speaker 06 It was in his front living room. And that was the first big public interaction we had.
30:02 Speaker 02 It's Saturday morning. About a dozen community members gather around the empty room to learn whatever they can from the police. Everyone is waiting for Rob to speak.
30:13 Speaker 06 Starting off, like introducing ourselves, giving out our information, phone numbers, asking for information, sharing what limited information we could share and what we were doing and how important it was to us as a police department. Hear their ideas or their concerns and do what we could to address those.
30:29 Speaker 02 Some neighbors complain about slow response times from investigators. Others say not enough resources are being devoted to the case. One neighbor spells it all out. We're all threatened. It's not just neighbors building homes. Rob tries to reassure everyone that the case is a top priority. He's trying his best, but it's not going well.
30:52 Speaker 06 They're upset at a lot of things. This neighborhood sits up against the preserves. All these people are fearful. What's next? Is somebody gonna get hurt? Is somebody else's house gonna burn? Whose house? Is it my house? Is it your house?
31:04 Speaker 02 I imagine the neighbors exchanging paranoid glances. Any one of them could be an arsonist. Lieutenant Rob can't share everything his team is doing in front of this crowd of neighbors.
31:16 Speaker 06 We didn't know who was in the audience. And, I mean, that proved out.
31:21 Speaker 02 A blond-haired woman lingers in the back of the crowd. She's not one of the neighbors.
31:27 Speaker 06 Afterwards, she came up and introduced herself. She said, "Hey, I'm Terry from the FBI."
31:35 Speaker 02 I was probably in a suit, so that probably stood out because, you know, your typical FBI agent. This is Terry Kearns. At the time, an FBI special agent. She's young and new to Phoenix. Terry was a nurse before the FBI recruited her. She's confident, with a reassuring presence. But not to Rob.
31:55 Speaker 06 Honestly, I was offended she was there and didn't introduce herself to begin with. I didn't know who all was gonna be there. I didn't...
32:02 Speaker 05 Know what was going on. I really just wanted to see what was being done.
32:06 Speaker 02 Anyone who's ever watched a cop movie knows they hate it when another agency moves in on their turf.
32:11 Speaker 06 We felt it was a neighborhood problem. We didn't feel like it was a federal government problem, and I'd worked with the FBI before, and this isn't their forte.
32:19 Speaker 02 Houses have been burning for nine months by this point, and the Phoenix PD has basically nothing to show for it. So I'm not sure it's Rob's forte either. But Rob tells Terry he doesn't want to form a task force with the FBI. Phoenix PD can handle it on their own. But it's not long before things start spinning out of Rob's control.
32:41 Speaker 05 The phone rang about nine o'clock at night, and the cousin of one of my cousins lived around the corner from here. And she said, Amy, I hate to be an alarmist, but I think your house is on fire.
33:04 Speaker 04 Football Sundays are at my house this year, so I've been making a Total Wine & More run before every kickoff. Cold beer for the group is a given, but this time of year I like to bring in some fall flavors. A bottle of maple whiskey and a salted caramel whiskey that even my friends who don't drink whiskey end up trying. I get everything I need at the lowest prices at Total Wine. Discover your new favorite fall flavors at Total Wine & More. Spirits are not sold in Virginia and North Carolina. Drink responsibly. Must be 21. You're listening to a quick ad. You know what else is quick? Selling your car on Carvana. Just put in your vehicle information and we'll give you an offer. Done. No hassle, no negotiation, no guy from an online listing lowballing you. Which means by the time I'm done explaining this, you could have basically done it.
33:53 Speaker 04 Still haven't started? Hey, better late than ever. Sell your car today on Carvana. Pickup fees may apply.
34:16 Speaker 05 I was in a women's organization. And it was a luncheon. And I believe it was at the Phoenix Country Club.
34:25 Speaker 02 It's a mild and perfect day in December. Amy Gitler and her friends gaze out at the lush green golf course, which I'm sure consumes an absolutely obscene amount of water. But this is of no concern to the leading ladies of Phoenix, who I like to picture snacking on tiny, triangle-shaped sandwiches, served on a silver platter. Amy is a seasoned lawyer who once argued a case in front of the Supreme Court. She has short-cropped red hair and a serious but friendly personality. During the luncheon, one of her friends approaches, looking concerned.
34:58 Speaker 05 She came up and she said, "Amy, Amy, what about this arsonist who's burning down houses?"
35:04 Speaker 02 Amy and her husband are in the middle of building their new home. It's on a plot of land that happens to be located right on the edge of the Phoenix Mountains Preserve. But Amy tells her friend she isn't so concerned about these arson attacks.
35:18 Speaker 05 Miss, don't be silly, Karen. That's on the other side of the preserve.
35:21 Speaker 02 The fires are happening on the other side of the mountain from where Amy's new house is being built.
35:27 Speaker 05 And literally that night is the night that we got the phone call.
35:35 Speaker 02 Back at home, around 9:00 PM, Amy has just put her two kids to bed when the landline rings. It's a relative who lives nearby. They can see the red glow of a fire in the direction of Amy's new place. She rushes over.
35:51 Speaker 05 I see crowds of people in front, and they wouldn't let anybody through. I see huge flames billowing out, and it's carved off, and nobody's allowed up. And I said, "That's my house. I want up." And so they let us up.
36:05 Speaker 02 When Amy gets to the front of the crowd, she realizes those huge flames aren't from her own property, but the one next door.
36:14 Speaker 05 The lot next to us was fully framed, and they had not been building for about a year. That house was like tinder. I mean, you lit a match to that, and that went down in about 15 minutes.
36:31 Speaker 02 The neighbor's place is reduced to ash. Amy's house was set on fire too, but firefighters were able to put it out before the fire really got going. Luckily, only the bathroom is affected. But Amy is still shaken by what happened.
36:47 Speaker 05 I was barely functioning the next day. And I remember I had such a horrible headache, I took two codeine. I just remembered a sense of chaos. Law enforcement thought that likely he would return to our place.
37:03 Speaker 02 After all, CSP burned Lee Benson's house twice, and Amy's place was saved and shown on the news. So the cops set up camp inside Amy's construction site.
37:17 Speaker 05 In order to catch him if he came back. And keep in mind, there's no roof, it's just framed.
37:23 Speaker 02 Lieutenant Rob Handy and his team aren't just camping in this site, they're camping all over the place. Undercover cops are posted up in unmarked cars throughout the neighborhood, trying their best to not look like cops. But Rob's team is spread pretty thin. They don't have unlimited resources, and there's a huge area to cover. Meanwhile, someone or a group of people is sneaking around, somehow getting past you guys to light these houses on fire.
37:52 Speaker 06 Or we weren't in the right area, right? The preserve is enormous.
37:55 Speaker 02 But Rob is hopeful, because his team has finally uncovered a suspect.
38:00 Speaker 06 They had some hardcore environmental leanings and had some light criminal history.
38:06 Speaker 02 This guy had a sign in his window protesting development. Someone had called in to the police to report him as suspicious. And not only that...
38:14 Speaker 06 He lived up against a preserve in an old house and was kind of a hermit. They'd been there for a long time, development had gone on around him.
38:22 Speaker 02 Keep in mind, the Sonoran Desert is being rapidly gobbled up by developers at this time. A report in the Arizona Republic uses the phrase "an acre an hour" to describe how fast the city of Phoenix is expanding into the surrounding desert.
38:37 Speaker 06 We spent a lot of time surveilling him, watching him, doing everything we could. We did search warrants, we looked at his trash, we did all kinds of stuff.
38:47 Speaker 02 For the first time since this case began, Rob is starting to feel hopeful that he's on to something. But then...
38:56 Speaker 01 The entire sky over the mountain was glowing.
38:59 Speaker 02 Another house goes up in flames.
39:01 Speaker 06 People were upset, scared, fearful.
39:04 Speaker 02 Things are about to get a lot more complicated.
39:07 Speaker 06 I'm glad you guys are doing this story.
39:09 Speaker 02 This is a story about fire and betrayal with world-changing consequences.
39:15 Speaker 06 I believe it really had some consequences on world events. Think about every aspect of your life that that day changed. I mean, my god, that's real terrorism.
39:27 Speaker 02 That's coming up on The Arsonist Next Door.
39:35 Speaker 04 Carhartt's Holiday Gift Guides were built in collaboration with the greatest gift giver of all time, Santa Claus himself. Old Saint Nick counts on Carhartt's durable gear to have its back through rain, sleet, and snow on the biggest night of the year. Because when everyone's counting on you to do your job, what else would you wear to work? Tap the banner to grab a gift for every hard-working person on your holiday shopping list, or head to carhartt.com.
40:16 Speaker 02 The Arsonist Next Door is an original production of Sony Music Entertainment and Novel. This series was written and reported by Meen Sam Anderson. It was produced and reported by Leona Hamid. Our assistant producer is Madeline Parr. Research by Zeyana Youssef. Additional production from Tom Wright and G. Stiles. Our editor is Dave Anderson. Additional story editing from Max O'Brien. From Novel, our executive producers are Max O'Brien and Craig Strachan. From Sony Music Entertainment, our executive producers are Catherine St. Louis and Jonathan Hirsch. Sound design, mixing, and scoring by Nicholas Alexander and Daniel Kempson. Our original theme song was composed and performed by Nicholas Alexander.
41:00 Speaker 02 Production management from Cherie Houston, Joe Savage, Saratobin, and Charlotte Wolf. Fact-checking by Danya Soleiman. Story development by Nell Gray Andrews. Novel's director of development is Selena Metta, and Willard Foxton is Novel's creative director of development. Special thanks to Jen Feifield, Libby Goff, Bob Kahn, Xander Adams, Anthony Wallace, Steve Ackerman, Carolyn Shirleven and the team at Reviewed and Cleared, Mario Caciutolo, Isaac Fisher, Kevin Lee Karas, Jess Swinburne, Sonny Marr, Carly Frankel and the team at WME.
42:07 Speaker 04 Carhartt's Holiday Gift Guides were built in collaboration with the greatest gift giver of all time, Santa Claus himself. Old St. Nick counts on Carhartt's durable gear to have its back through rain, sleet and snow on the biggest night of the year. Because when everyone's counting on you to do your job, what else would you wear to work? Tap the banner to grab a gift for every hardworking person on your holiday shopping list, or head to carhartt.com.
Previous Introducing: The Arsonist Next Door Next The Arsonist Next Door | 2: Smoke and Mirrors Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated