Pod Insights The Binge Crimes Finding Mom's Killer | 6. The Confessions of Jack Boyle About this episode 35 years after Noreen’s death, Steve gets a call from Jack and Collier has an excruciating decision to make.
Binge all episodes of Finding Mom's Killer, ad-free today by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge Crimes on Apple Podcasts and hit ‘subscribe’ or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access.
The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
Finding Mom’s Killer is part of The Binge - subscribe to listen to all episodes, all at once, ad-free right now. If you want to hear more about Collier's story follow him @CollierLandry on all social platforms.
From serial killer nurses to psychic scammers – The Binge is your home for true crime stories that pull you in and never let go.
Follow The Binge Crimes and The Binge Cases wherever you get your podcasts to get new stories on the first of the month, every month. Hit ‘Subscribe’ at the top of the Finding Mom’s Killer show page on Apple Podcasts or visit GetTheBinge.com. The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
A Sony Music Entertainment and Orbit Media production.
Find out more about The Binge and other podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts and follow us @sonypodcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:04 Speaker 00 Welcome to The Haunted Library.
0:08 Speaker 00 Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human.
0:24 Speaker 00 Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.
0:30 Speaker 01 Listen to all episodes of Finding Mom's Killer ad-free right now by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge channel on Apple Podcasts and hit Subscribe at the top of the page, or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access wherever you listen. The Binge: Feed your true crime obsession.
1:01 Speaker 02 Hello, this is a prepaid debit call from Jack Boyle. An inmate at the Marion Correctional Institution. To accept this call
1:11 Speaker 03 Hey, Jack, can you hear me?
1:13 Speaker 04 Yes, yes, I hear you.
1:16 Speaker 03 Okay.
1:18 Speaker 01 Jack Boyle and I have been speaking regularly for several months. I sometimes wonder why he makes the effort. I ask a lot of intrusive questions.
1:29 Speaker 03 So what did you think when you learned that Sherry was pregnant?
1:33 Speaker 04 Well, I was kind of surprised, too, on birth control pills. You know, you're kind of like, hmm.
1:39 Speaker 01 Still, Jack keeps calling. He also emails me via the prison's messaging system, GTL, and via the post office, sends documents and photos of himself in prison. It seems he has things to tell me. He mentions, among other things, that he wants to come clean.
2:03 Speaker 01 But I know there's another reason he's in touch. Maybe the real reason. Jack knows I'm speaking to Collier. And Jack, he still wants to be a father to his son.
2:16 Speaker 04 He used to sleep on the floor next to his crib, you know, all those kind of nervous father things. He was a good baby, a good young man. And I expect he still is.
2:29 Speaker 04 I still wanted to have a relationship as my, as my son and a father. I always wanted that. I never, I, I want that to this moment.
2:39 Speaker 01 But Collier hasn't responded to an email from Jack in 16 years. And this moment, right now, is complicated. Jack has been behind bars for almost 35 years. Jack is up for parole later this year. He's already been denied twice. He'll be 82 when he sees the parole board. This may be his final chance. And Jack is convinced that Collier holds the key to his freedom.
3:11 Speaker 04 His input as a victim, son of the victim, child of the mother killed, you know, it's important stuff.
3:20 Speaker 01 You think it really all comes down to Collier at this point?
3:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, I really do, yeah. Yeah.
3:27 Speaker 02 You have one minute remaining.
3:30 Speaker 04 And don't forget the last picture I sent you. Would you scan it to Collier?
3:34 Speaker 01 Yes, definitely, I will.
3:36 Speaker 04 Tell him I said hello and I love him.
3:38 Speaker 01 I sure will.
3:40 Speaker 02 Thank you for using TTL.
3:44 Speaker 01 A few days later, we helped Collier navigate the prison bureaucracy and set up his own email account. There's a message waiting for him.
3:54 Speaker 05 So I have an email from my father.
3:58 Speaker 05 "Bumper, please let me know if this email gets through to you. Hoping this works, Dad."
4:05 Speaker 05 "To the point, very succinct.
4:08 Speaker 05 I, uh, you know, I've, I've put up some boundaries, obviously.
4:14 Speaker 05 And boundaries are good for protecting one's mental health.
4:18 Speaker 05 But it is, in a way, too, it's, it's nice to, you know, be able to communicate with him. So I guess here we go."
4:28 Speaker 01 Collier starts typing.
4:30 Speaker 05 Hi, Pop. What do I say? Nice to talk to you. Long time.
4:38 Speaker 05 I don't. I don't really know.
4:42 Speaker 05 I mean, it's been such a, it's been a while, right?
4:47 Speaker 05 So now I'm analyzing what I wrote because he's my father and he might be critical of my writing.
4:56 Speaker 05 So now I'm like, oh, I don't, sending it. Let me grammatically correct this really fast.
5:02 Speaker 05 I guess some things never change. All right, sending.
5:08 Speaker 01 Should a son rescue a father who may not deserve to be rescued? Collier has a decision to make.
5:18 Speaker 01 From Sony Music Entertainment and Orbit Media, this is Finding Mom's Killer. I'm Steve Fishman. Episode six.
5:29 Speaker 01 The Confessions of Jack Boyle.
5:38 Speaker 06 In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning it in gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepherd and from CBC Podcasts and The Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. Available now.
6:11 Speaker 01 At this point, Jack Boyle and I have spoken for hours and hours.
6:18 Speaker 01 My wife isn't thrilled that I spent so much time chatting with a convicted wife killer. But if someone wants to understand what really happened, you have to talk to Jack.
6:32 Speaker 01 Jack is the black hole at the center of this story. For years, people who followed this murder talked and talked about Jack. But Jack, he wouldn't talk to anyone.
6:47 Speaker 04 The things I'm talking with you, I've never talked to anybody after the trial.
6:53 Speaker 04 I tried to sequester this, as painful and bad as it was, in a part of my mind that I wouldn't have to ever think about again.
7:02 Speaker 01 On the witness stand almost four decades ago, Jack swore he had nothing to do with his wife's death. He said he had no idea how she ended up buried in his basement. But it's been a long time since that testimony. A lot has changed. Jack says he's changed. He says he's ready to tell what really happened to Noreen. So let's call this Jack's version.
7:32 Speaker 01 Jack starts at the beginning, the night Noreen disappeared. It's a little before 3:00 in the morning on December 31, 1989, at the Boyle residence in Mansfield, Ohio. 11-year-old Collier is asleep in his bedroom, upstairs, with his Batman clock and his Garfield toys. Noreen retired early to her bedroom, also upstairs. Jack's mother is staying with them for the holiday.
8:03 Speaker 04 And when I came home, uh, at night, my mom made a cup of tea and put a piece of cake out for me. She came and put it and was on that table. So, uh, with, with the cake, of course, my mother being proper, there was a cake knife and a little cake fork and all that stuff.
8:28 Speaker 01 Noreen's bedroom is across the hall from Collier's, but according to Jack, she isn't there because she's marched down the stairs to the first-floor living room. The living room has been pretty much Jack's bedroom for years. He sleeps there on the couch, usually undisturbed, but tonight, he says, Noreen shakes him awake.
8:50 Speaker 04 I never expected that kind of behavior from her, where she would be so irate.
8:58 Speaker 01 According to Jack, Noreen is furious. And there's something else unusual about her.
9:05 Speaker 04 She wasn't wearing clothes.
9:09 Speaker 01 Well, so was she, was she naked?
9:12 Speaker 04 No, she had her panties on, that's all.
9:15 Speaker 01 That's unusual. That's like, what is going on? This is a couple that hasn't slept together in years.
9:25 Speaker 04 I think maybe she wanted to get me upset over the divorce. Oh, look, you're gonna lose something terrific.
9:42 Speaker 01 According to Jack, Noreen picks a fight about, well, about everything. The Boyles' divorce proceedings officially started about a month earlier, and Noreen, according to Jack's theory, is just now coming to grips with her future. He reasons that after years of being a physician's wife, with the leisure time and the disposable income that comes along with it, Noreen hates the idea of working again, which is what a judge said was in her future.
10:14 Speaker 04 When the judge said that, I think that blew her whole world up.
10:19 Speaker 01 But back to the living room.
10:22 Speaker 01 Noreen and Jack are arguing.
10:26 Speaker 04 She started ranting and raving about she didn't like Mansfield, she didn't like this town. She should have never left Philadelphia. She should have never married me, you know? And of course, I was adding more logs to the fire. I said, "Well, I guess you're right. You shouldn't have married me."
10:48 Speaker 01 Jack says he was surprised by Noreen's intense anger. Their relationship was frosty, not heated.
10:56 Speaker 04 I just, I never, never saw that anywhere in her. As Noreen and I were sitting there and she was getting more upset, I'm pretty sure she grabbed a knife.
11:16 Speaker 04 She could have grabbed the fork, but I'm pretty sure she grabbed the cake knife. I waved it in front of you.
11:23 Speaker 01 A cake knife is pretty much a butter knife, blunt and rounded. So Noreen is up now waving the cake knife. Jack sits on the couch below her, then stands up. He's six foot three, she's five four.
11:38 Speaker 04 And that's when I pushed her away from me. And I backpedaled off the sofa and hit the floor. And of course, she went the other direction. There was another chair off on the side, a single chair with a footstool. And that's what she hit her head on.
11:55 Speaker 04 That footstool.
11:59 Speaker 01 A heavy wooden footstool.
12:02 Speaker 01 Now, according to Jack, Noreen is lying motionless on the floor. So what does Dr. Jack Boyle think?
12:09 Speaker 04 I said, I gotta get out of here.
12:13 Speaker 04 Then I went up to grab my little gym bag. I didn't know where I was going to go. Probably go back to my office and sleep on a chair or something. So I was upstairs, probably 10 minutes, maybe 15 minutes.
12:26 Speaker 01 And then what happens? You come down and what?
12:30 Speaker 04 She was right there on the floor where I left her. And I said, oh, my God, now what?
12:36 Speaker 01 And she's not getting up. Noreen is not moving at all.
12:41 Speaker 04 And then I went to kind of battle stations, looking for a pulse and looking for a breath. And I said, oh, my God.
12:49 Speaker 01 Jack said he did CPR, chest compressions for 15 minutes.
12:53 Speaker 04 Yeah. All went downhill from there.
12:57 Speaker 01 Jack, what are you thinking?
13:00 Speaker 04 This is unbelievable that this has occurred. You know, like, oh, my God. I, I, I just can't.
13:10 Speaker 04 Look at this.
13:13 Speaker 01 So Jack is staring at Noreen. She's on her back, motionless, almost naked, lying on their beige living room carpet. Her head next to the footstool.
13:29 Speaker 01 What did she look like?
13:31 Speaker 04 Oh, boy. She looked...
13:35 Speaker 04 In a sense, she looked serene and quiet.
13:39 Speaker 04 As if she was, uh, sleeping.
13:44 Speaker 04 You know? In a sense, she looked peaceful.
13:49 Speaker 04 I just couldn't... I just emotionally could not look at, uh, her body. Like that. Her face.
13:58 Speaker 01 What was wrong with her face that you couldn't look at?
14:03 Speaker 04 I mean, the fact that she was dead.
14:11 Speaker 01 Jack goes to the kitchen and gets a garbage bag, white and opaque. He slipped it over Noreen's head.
14:20 Speaker 04 And the reason I tied it, I didn't want the, the, the bag to come off.
14:26 Speaker 01 So you're sure she was, she was dead?
14:30 Speaker 04 Positive. I am positive, which is all part of my, my panic. I was like, what am I gonna do? What do I do? I don't know what to do.
14:45 Speaker 04 And somewhere in all that, uh, disjointed thinking, uh, came the idea, says, oh, I could take the body up to, uh, Erie and bury the body.
14:56 Speaker 01 To Erie, to the house he'd bought just two weeks earlier.
15:01 Speaker 04 The stupid, uh, jackhammer was in the car. It was just an incidental thing.
15:07 Speaker 01 Jack had rented the jackhammer two days earlier to do home repairs, he said. The prosecution claimed this was evidence of premeditation.
15:18 Speaker 04 So I think those were just happenstances.
15:21 Speaker 01 And what was the instinct about the tarp?
15:25 Speaker 04 Oh, the tarp?
15:26 Speaker 01 Yeah.
15:26 Speaker 04 The same thing. I mean, the...
15:31 Speaker 04 What am I going to do here? The, the tarp happened to be convenient. It was on the back porch. Again, trying to figure out, how am I gonna correct this or fix this? Uh, even if I'm able to fix it, who knows? I figured,
15:48 Speaker 04 let me dig up the basement. And that's, that's where we went.
15:54 Speaker 01 So Jack lifts Noreen's body onto the tarp, wraps her, and carries her to his pickup truck, which is in the driveway. The automatic light from the garage suddenly turns on. No one's around. He places Noreen on the seat in the second row. And then Jack returns to the couch, turns the news on the TV, takes a shower. Collier comes downstairs. Jack tells Collier mommy took a little vacation. And then he puts the kids and his mother into his other car, the Range Rover, and drives them to McDonald's for breakfast. After that, he runs an errand to Columbus, an hour away,
16:38 Speaker 01 apparently not showing any of the panic he recently experienced. In the afternoon, Jack takes his pickup truck on a three-hour drive to Erie. The trip to Erie is one he planned on making for good sometime soon, leaving behind his old life, starting a new one. Now with his wife's body in the backseat of his pickup truck, Jack carries his past with him. On the road to Erie, Jack recalls a spitting rain. So, wipers on, the highway slick. Jack doesn't speed, not his nature.
17:22 Speaker 01 It's quiet in the car. So in your irrational thinking, what are you thinking?
17:33 Speaker 04 The mindset was to keep moving for somehow, maybe psychologically thinking I'm distancing myself from the tragedy by moving, by driving to Erie.
17:49 Speaker 01 When he arrives at the house on Wolf Road, Jack opens the garage door with the key he'd fortunately retrieved just a day before.
17:59 Speaker 01 He carries Noreen's body into the house, into the kitchen.
18:03 Speaker 04 Yeah, I was happy. I was happy.
18:09 Speaker 01 The house is completely empty. The sound of Jack's footsteps must echo. The basement stairs start at the kitchen. Jack can't reach the light switch. It's awkward with Noreen's body in his arms, so he sets her down for a minute. The basement is huge and silent except for the hum of the furnace. Jack heads to a nook at the far end where he and his girlfriend Sheri had discussed putting a kid's playroom. He fetches the jackhammer.
18:41 Speaker 04 Of course, I didn't know how to use it, but you know.
18:48 Speaker 04 Just an absolute mess. Absolute mess.
18:54 Speaker 01 Jack places the tarp with Noreen inside against a wall, the bag still over her head. He figures out how to work the jackhammer. It makes an incredible noise, bouncing off the concrete floor and walls. Luckily, his neighbors aren't close. It takes several hours to jackhammer through the basement floor and dig out the dirt below with a shovel.
19:21 Speaker 01 Then, there's the body.
19:24 Speaker 04 I just kind of drug it, dragged it over and put it in the hole.
19:31 Speaker 04 Such a naivete of trying to, I think it's going to go away on its own or disappear on its own, thinking if I covered it up, it would never be discovered and I would never have to see it again or think about it.
19:47 Speaker 01 For me, the most disturbing part is what happens next. How does Jack move through the world after burying his wife? He acts as if nothing has happened.
20:01 Speaker 01 He washed his clothes to get rid of the evidence. He drove back to Mansfield and took a shower. And calmly, blithely, he proceeded to tell lie after lie.
20:17 Speaker 01 In the ensuing weeks, no one notices that Jack is under stress. Maybe he's not. Maybe the panic has just melted away.
20:28 Speaker 01 Jerry doesn't sense anything crazy going on?
20:33 Speaker 04 Uh...
20:36 Speaker 04 Well, I guess I must have been because no one ever said anything to me. Uh...
20:44 Speaker 04 So I must have had some kind of... Kept up some kind of a front.
20:51 Speaker 01 So that's Jack's version. And whatever truth value one assigns to his account, it makes me think of one of the last things Jack told the jurors shortly before they found him guilty. "I'm human and normal, just like you." Jack, I don't think so.
21:13 Speaker 01 As for Jack's assertion that Noreen's death was an accident, well, it does fit the details. Why was Noreen's body naked when cops dug it up? Because Noreen came downstairs naked. The thuds Collier heard? Jack falling and Noreen falling. The footsteps Collier heard in the hallway? Jack's as he went to a closet to grab his getaway bag. The blunt force trauma listed in the autopsy? The result of Noreen falling against the footstool. And then Jack doesn't have with him the concrete to fill in the grave or the astroturf to cover it. He buys those days later.
21:57 Speaker 01 Maybe he didn't plan this in advance. But for me, another question looms over Jack's account. Jack was the only one present when Noreen died and when she was buried. There's no way to verify many of the details.
22:14 Speaker 01 A lot of people are gonna say, "Well, he's lied so much in the past. Why should I believe him now?"
22:20 Speaker 04 Well, they're absolutely correct. I mean, I have lied in the past, and I admit to that, to doing that. Noreen's death will always remain a tragedy forever into eternity. And I'm the one responsible for that, accidental or otherwise.
22:42 Speaker 01 Accidental or otherwise. Let's consider this a minute, because even if you accept that Noreen's death was an accident, that the evidence used to prove premeditation was really just happenstance, and that the true reason for the body in the basement is that Jack simply panicked, there's another problem with his story.
23:06 Speaker 01 How about the blunt force trauma? That couldn't have killed her?
23:10 Speaker 03 No, it wasn't that bad.
23:13 Speaker 01 According to this expert in autopsies.
23:23 Speaker 03 Football Sundays are at my house this year, so I've been making a Total Wine & More run before every kickoff. Cold beer for the group is a given, but this time of year, I like to bring in some fall flavors. A bottle of maple whiskey and a salted caramel whiskey that even my friends who don't drink whiskey end up trying. I get everything I need at the lowest prices at Total Wine. Discover your new favorite fall flavors at Total Wine & More. Spirits are not sold in Virginia and North Carolina. Drink responsibly. Must be 21. Shaq here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvana 100% online and get it delivered to your door? Let me tell you. Your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvana guy. Can't wait to take it for a spin. Only the best for you, Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big, tall, and handsome? Not all the way.
24:06 Speaker 05 I was 6'10" once. Seven days to love it or return it, Mr. Shack. Not that I would. You never do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven-day return policy at carvana.com.
24:22 Speaker 01 How many autopsies do you think you've done?
24:24 Speaker 03 Well, over 10,000. I love the work.
24:28 Speaker 01 Cutting open dead bodies is fun?
24:31 Speaker 03 Uh, solving mysteries is fun. Okay, let's not waste time. Go ahead. What do you want to know?
24:39 Speaker 01 This is Dr. Donald Jason. He's been a medical examiner for 40 years, a professor for 20, and my guess is impatient forever. I asked him to review the autopsy report and evaluate the cause of death. Jack told me Noreen died after hitting her head on a footstool. He said he tried to resuscitate her to no avail. In his telling, the plastic bag was just a cosmetic thing. He couldn't bear to look at her face.
25:12 Speaker 01 According to the original autopsy, Noreen did suffer blunt force trauma, which Dr. Jason concurs, could have come from the fall.
25:22 Speaker 03 She did have a head trauma that could have knocked her out.
25:27 Speaker 01 But here's the surprise.
25:29 Speaker 03 That's not a cause of death by itself.
25:32 Speaker 01 So the cause of death?
25:34 Speaker 03 Plastic bag suffocation.
25:37 Speaker 01 So wait, it's not the blow to the head that kills her. That only knocked her unconscious. It's the bag that Jack slips over her head. Could Jack Boyle, an experienced physician, have accidentally missed that Noreen was still alive when he came down the stairs? He saw her motionless on the carpet. He says he checked her pulse and her breathing.
26:03 Speaker 01 I mean, is there any chance you were premature with the bag over the head?
26:11 Speaker 04 Well, there always could be, not sure.
26:16 Speaker 01 So accidentally or otherwise, it appears that Jack did in fact kill Noreen by suffocating her.
26:29 Speaker 01 Why didn't he just admit all this from the start? Say it was an accident. He might have been charged with a lesser crime, spent a lot less time in prison. Why look at the jury and swear you had nothing to do with her death? Jack says he was basically trying to get away with it. He didn't have a plan. He had panic. So he went to the witness stand and he lied. Whatever came into his head. Though, Jack, you did stick with the lie for years. Well past the point of whatever initial panic gripped you.
27:05 Speaker 04 I mean, I know full well that I was responsible. I was guilty.
27:12 Speaker 01 But now, it's as if a switch flips. It's weird. Jack now says he takes responsibility for Noreen's death and for lying his ass off. But still somehow believes he was railroaded. Seriously. That's the word he uses.
27:30 Speaker 04 Yes, I think that I was being railroaded. These guys all were in collusion of some sort. Jack is the new guy in town. We don't care about him. We're the old timers here in town.
27:44 Speaker 01 Old timers. According to Jack, they were all in cahoots. Including his own lawyer, the judge, the prosecutors, and certainly Dave Messmore, who he says shaped Collier's testimony.
27:59 Speaker 04 You know, you gotta sit back and look and wonder about a lot of things. Maybe these guys had it out for me.
28:06 Speaker 01 And maybe Collier did too.
28:09 Speaker 04 What Collier did...
28:13 Speaker 04 So here we go. Daddy's the bad guy and he killed mommy. I'm never gonna talk to daddy again.
28:21 Speaker 01 But now, Collier is talking to daddy again. Though with reservations.
28:27 Speaker 05 Anyways.
28:30 Speaker 05 I'm sort of struggling a lot lately with what I'm gonna say to my father. Because it's been so long.
28:40 Speaker 05 I don't know.
28:51 Speaker 01 Have you received any of the mail, the two Manila envoys get?
28:57 Speaker 01 I have. One result of my conversations with Jack, an overflowing mailbox. Jack wants to show me all the programs he's completed in prison. Cage Your Rage, Victim Awareness, Resolving Conflict. Jack must have taken every course the prison offers. Toastmasters and Flag Etiquette are among his credits. Jack is also a peer social worker recruited by the administration and a religious advisor. Jack says all this has made him a different person.
29:32 Speaker 04 You have to hit the rock bottom. And then when you hit the bottom, then you can start to move forward.
29:39 Speaker 01 Rock Bottom was 1997. Sherry had left him, unaware that Jack had lied to her too. He'd exhausted his legal appeals. He felt like life was over.
29:53 Speaker 04 Thinking about suicide, thinking about harming yourself, thinking about what a terrible person you are, thinking about there's no future anywhere in anything you do.
30:06 Speaker 01 Then one day, Jack is sitting in the prison's dayroom, among inmates watching TV, playing cards. He's leafing through the Old Testament when he feels something.
30:17 Speaker 04 It was not the skies opening up and the flutter of angels' wings and starburst or whatever. I just had a very warm sense and a calming presence all over me. And that's when my actual life turned around.
30:40 Speaker 01 Did God forgive you?
30:45 Speaker 04 Well, yes, God does forgive.
30:49 Speaker 01 But will anyone else? In 2010, after two decades in prison, Jack was finally eligible for parole. He was denied. The board told him to try again in 10 years. So in 2020, he did. He was denied again.
31:09 Speaker 04 What am I doing wrong that they don't want me out of prison? And they keep telling me, "Keep doing what you're doing." Should I take any special program? No. Should I do something special? No. Just keep doing what you're doing.
31:23 Speaker 01 And so, Jack became convinced that Collier was blocking his parole. And as Jack sees it, Collier speaks for his mother, which gives him a powerful voice.
31:35 Speaker 04 I mean, he'd just have to say, "I love you, Daddy. And I think you were a bad boy, and you should stay in prison." Well, they're gonna take that as keeping me here for life. That's how they do.
31:47 Speaker 01 In the past, Jack had tried to enlist Collier's support.
31:51 Speaker 04 I'd asked him, by way of emails, if he would write a letter of support, supporting my parole. And of course, I never got an answer back. It's not funny, you know? I can't think of the right word. But, you know, because of this whole thing, he's now become my arch-enemy, so to speak.
32:11 Speaker 01 Of course, if anyone has good reason to oppose Jack's parole, it's Collier. The question now is, will he ever believe that his father's crime is forgivable?
32:23 Speaker 05 I think my father was controlling. I think he's a psychopath. And I think he wanted to have control of my mother. And he wanted her to be right underneath his feet.
32:31 Speaker 05 I'll give some sick twist to chip.
32:34 Speaker 01 Okay. Collier doesn't buy the accident version. But guess what? None of this means Collier opposes Jack going free. How are you feeling about his parole?
32:50 Speaker 05 I don't know how I feel about his parole.
32:55 Speaker 01 I visited Collier one day at his apartment in Santa Monica, California. At 47, he's nearly the same age as his father was when, well, when everything happened. These days, he's more SoCal than Midwest. He's got bleach blonde highlights, a gym addiction, ambitions in the entertainment industry. He lives in a nice one-bedroom apartment that's part-work space. It's lined with tripods and cameras. There's a podcast studio upstairs. Yes, Collier has a podcast. It's autobiographical.
33:36 Speaker 05 Hey, movers. Welcome back to another episode of Moving Past Murder. I'm your host, Collier Landry, and what's going on? Ah, never gets old. It really doesn't. I love doing it.
33:51 Speaker 01 So Collier is still captivated by his family history. He doesn't always seem to want to put it behind him. Instead, he goes deeper, keeps unburying secrets. He's learned a lot about his father's. One day, talking to his aunt, his mother's sister, Collier learns about Noreen's secrets.
34:13 Speaker 01 For instance, there are the stories his mom told about her wealthy childhood as a member of Philadelphia's Schmidt Brewery family.
34:23 Speaker 05 I remember asking these questions about my mother to her and learning about that the brewery didn't exist. We didn't come from this wealthy family, which, I mean, I guess probably, deep down inside, I realized.
34:40 Speaker 01 Noreen's roots were modest, middle-class, just like Jack's. One reason they connected, I guess. Another was that they were both in on a con, both trying to appear more than they were. I imagine them at a dinner table of guests, one listening to the other spin fictions about their pasts.
34:59 Speaker 05 In a lot of ways, I almost deified my mother. But when I found out about that, I think it almost humanized her in a way with me. It kind of...
35:16 Speaker 05 Knocked her down off Olympus a little bit. And she came down to the land of the mortals and I realized that she was a human being with real flaws.
35:31 Speaker 01 Collier made peace with his mother's lies. Jack's are different. They hurt people. And for Collier, that's fraught. His father's parole is fast approaching. And he still isn't sure what to do. But other people are.
35:48 Speaker 03 I went 30 years with Collier. Trying to convince him. That his dad was a liar. And he'd say, well, maybe he'll get out and he can live with me.
36:04 Speaker 01 Dave Messmore is 81 now, the same age as Jack. He retired decades ago. Unlike Jack and Collier, he doesn't seem to have changed much. The same stoic, mustachioed, mild-mannered cop who showed up on the Boyle's doorstep and actually listened to the hyper-articulate 11-year-old worried about his mom. Dave's still devoted to Collier. What does he think about Jack living with Collier?
36:34 Speaker 03 I said, oh, that's a good idea. I said, it's just a matter of time until he kills you. You're the one that testified against him. If you think he doesn't forget that, you're very, very mistaken.
36:53 Speaker 01 As far as Dave is concerned, Jack should die in prison. And he'll tell the parole board that again this year. Nothing Jack can do about this roadblock. But Collier, despite the influence of Dave, has a more complex view.
37:09 Speaker 05 On the one side, you have this, you know, man who's a monster, who did all these very destructive things. On the other hand, he's my father and I do love him and I want to make sure he's okay.
37:20 Speaker 01 Since we helped set up his email, Collier's been sending Jack photos of himself, his girlfriend, his dog. But he's nervous about speaking on the phone. And they've arranged a call.
37:36 Speaker 05 So I don't know. I don't know what his, uh...
37:41 Speaker 05 what he's gonna say or do or anything like that, so... It's just, it's all a lot. It's a lot.
37:50 Speaker 01 Then one day, after years of silence, Collier's phone rings.
37:56 Speaker 04 Thank you for using GTL.
37:58 Speaker 05 Dad, you there?
38:01 Speaker 05 Hello?
38:03 Speaker 05 Can you hear me?
38:05 Speaker 04 Can hear you. Can't you hear me?
38:07 Speaker 05 I can hear you. I just couldn't hear you back. Now I can hear you, yeah.
38:10 Speaker 01 The prison's phone system is spotty, which seems like a metaphor. Will this father and son be able to hear each other, to connect? As it happens, the Super Bowl is on as Jack calls. The pair has always talked sports. And Philadelphia, Jack's hometown, is competing.
38:30 Speaker 05 So the game is about ready to have its first snap. The Eagles, um, Kansas City won the toss and deferred to the Eagles.
38:38 Speaker 04 I hope, uh, they win. They deserve it. They work hard this last couple of years to get there. So we'll see what happens.
38:47 Speaker 01 With the ice broken, they chat about family illnesses. Yeah, they're a family again, apparently. And then, Collier turns to the subject that's on both their minds.
39:00 Speaker 05 What is your plan with August?
39:03 Speaker 01 August is when Jack expects to go to the parole board.
39:07 Speaker 04 I'm all prepared. That's, uh, I'm, I'm prepared to, there's not a problem or anything there. Uh, you, what are you talking about? A place to go after I leave here, you mean?
39:16 Speaker 05 Uh, yeah.
39:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, right. And, uh, I will go to the Tynway Embark House in Franklin County for 90 days.
39:27 Speaker 01 Jack has a halfway house lined up, but that's only for a short time.
39:32 Speaker 05 So then where would you go?
39:35 Speaker 04 Uh, that's a good question. I, I think I should be okay in terms of getting some kind of a job without any problems. You know, I'm a hard worker. I, I go where I gotta go, so I'm good. You know?
39:57 Speaker 01 Jack is optimistic about making parole. He's optimistic about a lot of things. Apparently, Jack believes that at 82, he will jump back into the workforce, fend for himself. He must know that the parole board wants assurance that a parolee won't be a burden on society. What Jack really needs is a family member to take him in. Weirdly, it's the same situation Collier once faced.
40:25 Speaker 01 And so Jack asks about a subject that's constantly on his mind.
40:31 Speaker 04 You're not speaking about putting me in your garage or something, are you?
40:34 Speaker 05 I don't have a garage to put you in anyways.
40:37 Speaker 01 And then the phone cuts Jack off. Collier can't hear his dad. His words become a kind of absurdist monologue, which I find heartbreaking.
40:53 Speaker 05 Hello? Dad, can you hear me?
40:57 Speaker 05 Think I lost you.
41:00 Speaker 05 I'll wait for it to circle back around.
41:05 Speaker 05 You there?
41:09 Speaker 05 You there, Pop? Hello? Dad, can you hear me?
41:15 Speaker 01 Later, I asked Jack about the call, his first call with Collier in years. Jack felt great about it, relieved. He felt a real connection.
41:27 Speaker 04 I asked him, "Do you have a room for me or a place in the garage?" And then he said, "No, I don't have a garage in my house." So that was like a joke about,
41:39 Speaker 04 if Daddy moves in with Collier, Daddy's gonna move into the garage. That kind of thing. Just a joke kind of thing, that's all.
41:49 Speaker 01 Was it? Yeah, and then you backed off.
41:53 Speaker 04 But I, I, I, yeah, I didn't wanna, I didn't want him to think I was obligating him to find a place for me to live in his house. I mean, he may offer that down the road, I don't know.
42:09 Speaker 01 Jack and Collier roommates? I'm not too sure about that. Neither is Collier.
42:16 Speaker 05 I don't feel vengeful towards my father and me investigating with Dave and the trial and him going to prison and all of that. I think that I was satisfied with that outcome. That was the vengeance. But it doesn't mean that we can skip down the yellow brick road, holding hands and being like, ah, you know, everything's great, you know? Part of me feels sad for him, like feels sad because he's my dad. Like, he's gonna be released from prison and not have the, you know, everything has changed so much. It almost feels unfair to release somebody like that. I can't take care of him.
42:59 Speaker 05 Um, I don't even know. I don't even know what to say. It's a lot. It's a lot. Man. I'm gonna figure it out. This is all the stuff I think about on a continual basis, all the time. I mean, look, um...
43:32 Speaker 01 Collier's thoughts drift between sadness, love, practicality, and even vengeance. He wavers. I understand. You understand. Jack has ruined people's lives. He undid Collier's.
43:50 Speaker 05 Like, is my support even necessary at this point? If he's been in there for 35 years? I mean, let the guy out.
44:01 Speaker 01 Collier says "the guy." He doesn't say daddy, he doesn't say pop. Maybe it's not personal at this point. The boy who put his father in prison is gone. Today, his life is his own. Maybe Collier is, in his way, free of his past, free to use it, no longer subject to it. And so maybe Collier can extend that chance to his father, too. Allow him the ultimate grace, to be untethered from his past. Thirty-five years is a long time. So yeah, let the guy have his shot at freedom, too. Forgiveness is a blessing, of course, for the one who receives. But maybe more so for the person who offers.
44:58 Speaker 06 In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning it in gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepherd, and from CBC Podcasts and The Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. Available now.
45:36 Speaker 01 Finding Mom's Killer is a production of Orbit Media. Creator and host, Steve Fishman, that's me. Our senior producer is Drew Nellis. Our producer and production coordinator, Austin Smith. Our story editor, Emile Klein. Fact check by Ryan Alderman. Mixing and sound design by Scott Somerville. Our lawyers are at Davis Wright Tremaine. From Sony Music Entertainment, our executive producer is Jonathan Hirsch. Special thanks to Emily Rassik, Steve Ackerman, Catherine St. Louis, Sammy Allison, Fisher Stevens, Ria Julian, Dan Bobkoff. At WME, we'd like to thank Evan Crassick, Marissa Hurwitz, and Ben Davis.
46:21 Speaker 01 We want to also thank Carl Hunnall at The Richland Source for the generous use of his podcast studio. And a really warm thank you to Collier Landry for sharing his story and for his production assistance.
46:54 Speaker 00 Welcome to The Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.
Previous Finding Mom's Killer | 5. Lost Boy Next Introducing: The Arsonist Next Door Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated