Pod Insights The Binge Crimes Finding Mom's Killer | 3. The House on Wolf Road About this episode As Lieutenant Dave Messmore continues his search for Noreen, a series of clues leads him to a mysterious house in Erie, Pennsylvania.
Binge all episodes of Finding Mom's Killer, ad-free today by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge Crimes on Apple Podcasts and hit ‘subscribe’ or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access.
The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
Finding Mom’s Killer is part of The Binge - subscribe to listen to all episodes, all at once, ad-free right now.
From serial killer nurses to psychic scammers – The Binge is your home for true crime stories that pull you in and never let go.
Follow The Binge Crimes and The Binge Cases wherever you get your podcasts to get new stories on the first of the month, every month. Hit ‘Subscribe’ at the top of the Finding Mom’s Killer show page on Apple Podcasts or visit GetTheBinge.com. The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
A Sony Music Entertainment and Orbit Media production.
Find out more about The Binge and other podcasts from Sony Music Entertainment at sonymusic.com/podcasts and follow us @sonypodcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 At Edward Jones, we believe rich is about taking care of what gives your life meaning. That's why your financial advisor personalizes your plan to help you preserve your progress and create something that lasts. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones. Member SIPC.
0:15 Speaker 01 Listen to all episodes of Finding Mom's Killer ad-free right now by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge channel on Apple Podcasts and hit subscribe at the top of the page, or visit getthebinge.com to get access wherever you listen. The Binge: Feed your true crime obsession.
0:46 Speaker 02 It was around middle of January. My father says to me that he was gonna go to his office to pick up some paperwork. And he said, did I want to come along with him?
0:59 Speaker 01 By mid-January 1990, Noreen Boyle had been missing for about two weeks, and her 11-year-old son, Collier, was desperately trying to find her.
1:10 Speaker 02 We go to my father's office, and on the way back, we stop at a gas station. And my father used to, um, do you know what mallow cups are? They're like Reese cups with marshmallow in them. He was like really into mallow cups. So we went into the gas station to get those. But he left me in the truck. And I'm watching through the windshield, and I see him inside the gas station. And I just start rummaging through his truck, and I open up the center console. And that's when I find two photographs.
1:46 Speaker 02 One is of a house that I've never seen before. And the other one is of his girlfriend, Sherri Campbell, with her two kids, who I knew. And they're sitting in front of a fireplace that's like covered in plastic. So it looks like a new fireplace.
2:07 Speaker 01 What do these photos mean? Collier calls up Mansfield Police Lieutenant Dave Messmore, his partner in the hunt for his mother.
2:19 Speaker 02 And what does he say when you tell him about the photos?
2:23 Speaker 01 Hmm.
2:27 Speaker 01 And that was when things started to sort of get hairy.
2:37 Speaker 01 From Sony Music Entertainment and Orbit Media, this is Finding Mom's Killer. I'm Steve Fishman. Episode Three. The House on Wolf Road.
2:56 Speaker 03 At Edward Jones, we believe rich isn't about having life all figured out. It's opening yourself to all the possibilities. That's why your dedicated financial advisor provides long-term planning built around you, meeting you where you are, and helping you get closer to where you want to be. So no matter where you're starting from, you can move forward with confidence. The key to being rich is knowing what counts. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones. Member SIPC.
3:28 Speaker 04 You sound horrible.
3:29 Speaker 05 Oh, I feel worse. This flu is not playing around.
3:33 Speaker 06 Dad, you promised you'd be in my band, and it's showtime.
3:37 Speaker 04 Then it's Dayquil Intense Flu time.
3:39 Speaker 00 For fast and powerful relief of your flu symptoms, try Dayquil Intense Flu.
3:43 Speaker 04 Hit it. Yeah.
3:45 Speaker 00 Dayquil Intense Flu, the fast-acting daytime coughing, aching, aching, aching fever power-through-your-flu medicine. Use is directed, keep out of reach of children.
3:58 Speaker 01 The thing about active cases is that there are unpredictable turns. This one was no exception. Lieutenant Dave Messmore's investigation was about to relocate. Almost as soon as he began looking into the disappearance of Noreen Boyle, Dave learned that her husband was planning a disappearing act of his own. Dr. Jack Boyle was leaving town.
4:24 Speaker 07 What happened was Jack got a contract in Erie, Pennsylvania to work for a large company. He'd been traveling back and forth to Erie to set this whole clinic up.
4:37 Speaker 01 Dr. Jack Boyle had made no secret of the move. A month earlier, he placed an ad in the local paper informing patients that he was shutting down his practice.
4:48 Speaker 07 So I called up to Erie and had a detective work with me. And he started to talk to people that knew him or had met him.
4:56 Speaker 01 It didn't take long for the Erie detective to learn about Jack. He seemed to be setting up a new life in Erie. And he'd have the means to do it. At his new job, he stood to make a lot of money, about $500,000 a year, which would be worth over $1 million today.
5:15 Speaker 01 The detective learned that Jack had already bought a house in Erie, one a lot bigger than the Boyle house in Mansfield. 3,000 square feet, four bedrooms, a two-and-a-half-car garage, a new fireplace, and a huge unfinished basement. It was on a street called Wolf Road.
5:35 Speaker 07 The more this detective worked on it up there, he said, "That's just a lot of strange things going on with this guy." I said, "Yeah, I know."
5:45 Speaker 01 For instance, there was Jack's companion when looking at houses. Here's the realtor describing that companion.
5:53 Speaker 04 I'd say mid-20s, 26, 27. She was small, petite, brown hair, brown eyes, and very pregnant. He walked in and he shook my hand. He says, "I'm Jack Boyle. This is my wife, Sheri."
6:12 Speaker 01 Sheri, as in Sherri Campbell, was pregnant with Jack's child, but she wasn't his wife, not yet. Now, introducing your much younger, extremely pregnant girlfriend as your wife is hardly illegal, and it's a lot less complicated to explain to a stranger. But the situation did get complicated. There was something else the detective learned from the realtor. It wasn't just Jack's house. It was apparently Jack and Sheri's house.
6:46 Speaker 01 The contract of sale for the Wolf Road House was signed by two people, Jack Boyle and someone calling herself N. Sherry Boyle. N. Sherry Boyle was, of course, Jack's girlfriend.
7:01 Speaker 07 He presented her as his wife. And when she signed her name, it wasn't her name.
7:09 Speaker 01 Turned out, it was useful for Jack to have his quote/unquote "wife" with him to sign papers. Because of the divorce proceedings, Jack's finances were tied up with Noreen's. To get a mortgage, Jack had to get his wife's approval. And apparently, his wife did give her approval. The new wife, Mrs. N. Sherry Boyle.
7:35 Speaker 07 She forged the name.
7:39 Speaker 01 It was like Sherry was erasing Noreen. Now, as for Sherry's forgery, maybe all this was just a naive, lovestruck, young woman doing whatever her older, wealthier lover asked. Dave wasn't so sure. He wondered, was Sherry involved in Noreen's disappearance?
8:00 Speaker 07 Don't tell me she didn't know what was going on.
8:03 Speaker 01 Dave soon learned something else he found suspicious. Jack paid the house's full asking price, nearly $300,000, without negotiating, except for one condition. He wanted to move in two weeks early, before the end of the year. Jack said he was starting work in Erie in early January. The seller agreed, and Jack picked up the keys to the Wolf Road House at noon on December 30th. Noreen disappeared 15 hours later. Hmm. To Dave, the time was starting to seem meticulously planned. But to what end?
8:46 Speaker 01 Then, according to the Erie detective, the realtor made a strange comment. Here's what the detective recalls. There's something in my mind, she's, um, I can't think of it right now, but she says something just stands out. And she says, "I wish I could tell you," and I said, "Well..."
9:01 Speaker 02 So when you recall it, you have my number. Just give me a call at work and let me know.
9:07 Speaker 01 Remember those photos Junior Detective Collier Landry Boyle told Lieutenant Messmore he discovered in his father's truck? The unfamiliar house, Sherri Campbell and her children standing in front of a new fireplace? That was the Erie House, the one on Wolf Road. Dave's investigation had already led him to the new house, but he thanked Collier, praised his efforts. Dave had grown fond of Collier. He felt terrible for him. And the photos did help sharpen Dave's understanding. Collier was being supplanted, so was Noreen. Sherri and her kids, they were Jack's family now.
9:50 Speaker 07 Talked to Collier a lot about how his dad treated him, even as a small child. His dad didn't like him.
9:58 Speaker 01 Dave figured if Jack was hoping to make a fresh start in Erie with a new wife and a new house, then Noreen must have been in the way. Dave was now convinced the Erie House was a key to Noreen's disappearance.
10:16 Speaker 07 These little things kept narrowing it down to Erie, Pennsylvania.
10:26 Speaker 01 Collier constantly had more tidbits to report to Dave. He'd call Dave a couple of times a week. Any reason to reach out was a good one.
10:36 Speaker 02 I just needed to be reminded that there was somebody in my life that also remembered my mother that was doing something to try to find her. Somebody else is in this with me. It's not just me.
10:49 Speaker 01 So Collier kept sharing intel with Dave about his father's movements. And Jack was constantly on the move. By this point, December 1989 into January 1990, Jack was leading a kind of double life. He wasn't just going back and forth between Mansfield and Erie to relocate his office, a three-hour drive each way. He was staying at Sherry's place most nights, then getting up at 5:00 a.m. and hurrying back to the Boyle family residence, where, most mornings, Collier found him sleeping on the couch in the living room. Apparently, Jack was intent on keeping up appearances. But according to Collier, in other ways, he let his appearance slip.
11:35 Speaker 02 Because my father always had these really, really well-manicured hands. He was really particular about that. Because when you're a doctor, you're always washing your hands and stuff. So he was really careful with that. And so I start noticing there's cuts on his hands. And my father comes home one night. His shoulders hurt, are really sore. And he asked me to rub Bengay on his shoulders because he said he had been moving boxes all day. And there was some bruising on his arms, too. I thought that was weird. My father was not like a manual labor person.
12:10 Speaker 07 Collier told me that his dad came home from Erie, Pennsylvania, and his back and his arms were hurting. And Collier had to rub Bengay on him. I thought, you know, that's a little bizarre.
12:27 Speaker 01 And then a tip came into the Mansfield Police Department. This tip changed everything for Dave. An anonymous woman called. She said she worked for a friend of Jack's, and she'd rented a piece of machinery for Dr. Boyle, a jackhammer. Had Dr. Boyle taken up manual labor after all? So you find out that he rented a jackhammer.
12:52 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
12:53 Speaker 01 What's your reaction then?
12:56 Speaker 07 That's called a hint.
12:59 Speaker 01 The cops visited Easy Rental in Mansfield. According to the store manager, the man who rented the jackhammer was definitely Jack. He paid for it with a personal check, given his driver's license as ID. He picked up the jackhammer on December 29th. Noreen went missing in the early hours of December 31st. To Dave, the way those dates fit together sure seemed suspicious. Noreen disappears, and Dr. Boyle just happens to have a jackhammer handy. Hmm.
13:37 Speaker 07 I kept thinking, is it possible this guy actually would bury the body in his house?
13:45 Speaker 01 Keep in mind, Noreen is still just a missing person. There's no body, which means there's no murder. But what if Dave finds Noreen's body buried beneath the Wolf Road house? Well, that would change everything. But now Dave is worried. If Dr. Jack Boyle is a murderer, well, then Collier is living under a murderer's roof. And then Jack makes a proposal to Collier.
14:17 Speaker 02 We're having this conversation at the dinner table, and he says, "You know, Collier, I know this has been really hard for you with Mommy abandoning us. We're all having a really tough time, myself included. Like, I don't know why she would be doing this to us. I have a medical convention that's happening in Clearwater, Florida. He says to me that we should take a father and son trip together to go to this medical convention so I could have a break from everything."
14:58 Speaker 01 Father and son had taken trips to Florida before, but this one felt different. Collier was afraid.
15:05 Speaker 02 So the next morning, I go to school. I call Dave and I say, "This is what's happening."
15:10 Speaker 07 I said, "No, no, no, no, no." So I called Children's Services and I said to the head of it, I said, "Let me tell you what I'm doing." And I explained everything to him. I said, "Now this guy wants to take Collier on a vacation. My fear is that something will happen to Collier." And he goes, "Oh." He said, "All right." Called me back later and said, "We're going to remove Collier and put him in an approved home to stay with some people." I said, "Good, that's exactly what I want." I didn't trust Jack at all.
15:50 Speaker 01 By now, Dave is convinced that Jack's capable of anything, including killing his own son.
16:00 Speaker 01 A few days later, on January 25th, Collier awoke to some surprise visitors.
16:07 Speaker 02 There are these two people from Children's Services. They're coming to my room and they're like, "You've got 20 minutes to pack a bag. We're getting you out of here." And I can hear all this commotion downstairs, like all the, all hell breaking loose. My grandmother's yelling at somebody. I'm like, "What, like, what is happening?" And I start packing a bag for myself and I pack a bag for my sister with like her toys. So we're coming downstairs and there's Dave Messmore
16:43 Speaker 02 talking to my grandmother. So they take me to, to the principal of my school's house. And she kind of is telling me, "You know, you're going to stay here for a little bit while everything gets sorted out."
16:57 Speaker 01 Jack missed the whole thing. He'd left early that morning.
17:07 Speaker 01 That night camping out at his principal's home with his little sister, Collier had the worst asthma attack of his life and was brought to the hospital. Out of his house, away from his father, his breath recovered. He was in stable condition.
17:27 Speaker 01 The next morning, his principal, now his guardian, came into the hospital room. She had news for him.
17:35 Speaker 02 Collier,
17:38 Speaker 02 Lieutenant Messmore found your mother.
17:48 Speaker 03 Cool fall nights always make me want to entertain more. A few friends around the table, maybe a fire outside when the sun goes down. Before everyone comes over, I stop at Total Wine & More. Right now, there's a cranberry-flavored wine, a crisp apple wine, even a pumpkin spice cream that's perfect in coffee after dinner. And with the lowest prices, I can bring home a few different fall flavors for everyone to try. Find your favorite fall flavors at the lowest prices at Total Wine & More. Spirits are not sold in Virginia and North Carolina. Drink responsibly. Must be 21.
18:22 Speaker 00 Observe. The North American Dad. 50s. Great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, "Dang, that's a good offer." The highest form of approval. No haggling, no hassle, no one called him "boss." He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply.
18:56 Speaker 04 It was extremely interesting, like, it was so bizarre, you know, learning more about Dr. Boyle and what he was like.
19:08 Speaker 01 This is Mike Dugan, a detective in a suburb of Erie called Mill Creek Township. As it turned out, the house on Wolf Road was located in Mill Creek, which has its own police department. That's how Detective Dugan got involved.
19:24 Speaker 04 Once I was assigned the case, Dave Messmore was my go-to guy. He and I were constantly talking, and I know that he took this case really to heart because of the children, especially Collier.
19:37 Speaker 01 Because of Dave's intervention, Collier was now out of harm's way. On January 25th, Children's Services had taken him away from Jack. That same day, Lieutenant Dave Messmore and the Mansfield Police made another big move. They executed a search warrant on the Boyle household.
20:02 Speaker 01 The police made a big show of it, lots of equipment, lots of manpower, but they found nothing. No physical evidence, no blood, no indications of a struggle, nothing in the Boils' three cars. In short, no evidence of murder. But Dave was not discouraged. He wasn't the type to let go, which is why he had put a backup plan in motion. Here's Detective Mike Dugan again.
20:33 Speaker 04 We waited until they completed their execution of the search warrant in Mansfield, and when that turned up negative, that's when we went and applied for a search warrant to go and search the Wolf Road address.
20:49 Speaker 01 Just as police were coming up empty at the Boyle residence in Mansfield, police in Mill Creek Township, 180 miles away, were seeking a court order to search the house on Wolf Road. It wasn't clear they'd get it.
21:06 Speaker 01 As even Dave admits, that search warrant relied on some questionable leaps in logic and pretty thin evidence. After all, what was the evidence that there even was a body? Or that the body was in the Erie house?
21:21 Speaker 07 So I call up there in Erie and I said, "Look, here's what I've got." And I said, "I'm very, very interested in getting in that new house." And they said, "Oh, boy, do you have any more than that?"
21:39 Speaker 01 That's about the time that the Erie detective heard once again from the Realtor who'd sold Jack the house. Remember, she'd said there was one more strange thing about Jack, but at the time, she couldn't quite recall it. Well, she'd remembered it.
21:58 Speaker 07 He wanted a copy of the design plans, the blueprints, and he asked me to find out what the foundation of the home was. I said, "It's probably gravel." And he says, "No, no." He says, "If I were to break into the basement floor, what will I hit? What is underneath that floor if I ever want to lower the floor, you know, finish it off as a playroom for the kids?" I thought it was kind of strange because it had a really high ceiling. I'm tall and I had high heels on and I estimated 10 feet. I don't know what it is, but it's an extremely high basement. That is something that sticks in your mind. Why would he want to lower the basement? What was he gonna do?
22:44 Speaker 01 The Realtor's new information went into the application for the search warrant.
22:49 Speaker 07 And they said, "We have a judge that we will take this to." The judge had been a former prosecutor, and he went, "There you go."
22:59 Speaker 01 "There you go." Dave's supposedly flimsy application had been signed by a judge. Dave now had what he most wanted: a chance to search the house on Wolf Road. David fixated on that house, a fixation that his superiors did not share.
23:20 Speaker 07 My captain was not behind me. The day that I got ready to serve a search warrant...
23:29 Speaker 07 Captain said, "What are you doing?" And I told him what I was doing. He said, "You gotta be kidding." I said, "No." He said, "You really think that a doctor would kill somebody and take the body up to Erie, Pennsylvania?" I said, "I don't know, but I'm gonna find out."
23:50 Speaker 01 According to Lieutenant Messmore, his superiors were pretty much convinced that "Go It Alone, Dave" had gotten hooked on a wayward theory. And now, based on that theory, was gonna go tear up the house of a prominent local physician.
24:06 Speaker 07 He said, "You're gonna embarrass the police department." I said, "I don't care who he is. It has to be done."
24:15 Speaker 01 Maybe Dave's superiors had a point. Maybe he was too close to this one. For Dave, this wasn't just another case. This was personal. He was offended by Dr. Jack Boyle.
24:29 Speaker 07 Disgusted and insulted for what he did to his family. The way he treated Collier. It was with a lot of disdain.
24:44 Speaker 01 On the morning of January 25th, the search of the Boyle residence in Mansfield produced nothing. So Lieutenant Dave Messmore and a local prosecutor climbed into Dave's department-issued Oldsmobile and made the long drive to Erie. In Dave's recollection, it was a rough trip.
25:06 Speaker 07 The weather was bad. It was snowing and everything. So we drove up there through, oh, six inches of snow, and it got worse and worse.
25:15 Speaker 01 What should have been a three-hour drive turned into a five-hour slog. And for what?
25:23 Speaker 01 Let's be real. A doctor with no history of violent crime is going to murder his wife. A premeditated murder in their home with his mother and children sleeping nearby. Oh, and this mastermind is going to rent a jackhammer to dig his wife's grave using a personal check with his name on it? It's a little far-fetched, this whole thing. That doesn't seem to you like you're on a wild goose chase?
25:52 Speaker 07 You couldn't convince me there was anything more bizarre than this. I was not prepared to dismiss any viable theory.
26:02 Speaker 01 For Dave, this case was different from any other he'd worked on.
26:07 Speaker 07 I had an inclination to do things that maybe I wouldn't have done in other cases. Some people don't have any faith, and I have faith. I think God does lead you in the right directions a lot of times.
26:23 Speaker 01 And Dave believed God was leading him to Wolf Road.
26:28 Speaker 07 By the time we got there, we were late. And the lieutenant out there had four guys ready to work with us. They said, "Well, it's nice you got here." I said, "Well, I'm lucky I got here."
26:42 Speaker 01 When Dave arrived at Wolf Road, it was dark, already past 5:00, and the temperature was in the low 20s. He met a team of local technicians and cops, including Detective Mike Dugan.
26:55 Speaker 04 We actually got to the Wolf Road address around 20 after 5:00 or so, and no one answered the door.
27:05 Speaker 07 I kicked the door in. It was kind of enjoyable, yeah.
27:10 Speaker 01 The eerie cops had canvassed local hardware stores and discovered that Jack had purchased a large roll of indoor-outdoor carpeting, what you might know as AstroTurf.
27:22 Speaker 07 All over this two-and-a-half-car garage was indoor-outdoor carpeting. I said, "Well, it's gotta be under there."
27:30 Speaker 04 And we rolled up the carpeting.
27:34 Speaker 07 None of the concrete underneath was damaged or anything.
27:39 Speaker 01 This was not good news. Dave had half a dozen men traipsing around this big, empty house. Turned out, Jack and Cherry had not moved in, despite the rush to collect the keys. There was no furniture, though Dave did notice a working phone. They'd struck out in the garage, and according to Dave, some of the cops were getting antsy.
28:03 Speaker 07 That kind of made me concerned, that maybe, maybe that wasn't where I was gonna find her at.
28:13 Speaker 01 Dave led the other cops from the garage into the house, toward the only other room where a jackhammer might be used: the basement.
28:26 Speaker 07 There was almost like a dampness in the air. And as I opened the door to the basement, this wave of drying paint came up.
28:39 Speaker 04 The basement was not finished, other than the fact that the floor had been painted. And in one section was green indoor/outdoor carpeting that had been glued down. And on top of the indoor/outdoor carpeting, there was shelving units.
28:59 Speaker 07 Jack had a contractor come in and build two-by-four shelving all along one wall. So the technicians were working and looking all along the walls, and looking around that shelving that was built. And one of them said, "Guys, this is like, almost fresh concrete that didn't dry, splattered on the wall."
29:22 Speaker 04 And we got down on our hands and knees, we're feeling the long shelving, and there was a little bit of an indentation under the shelving, which was odd, because the rest of the basement was pristine.
29:34 Speaker 04 At that point in time, we decided that we're gonna have to take that shelving unit down.
29:41 Speaker 07 So, the other lieutenant said, "Go get sledgehammers."
29:46 Speaker 01 The cops knocked the shelving down with sledgehammers, having a good time destroying what Jack and Sherry had imagined as the children's playroom.
29:56 Speaker 07 And I'm thinking, "Oh, boy. How am I gonna explain this?"
30:00 Speaker 01 But Dave proceeded.
30:02 Speaker 07 Holding all bound, and then ripped up the carpeting that was glued to the floor.
30:08 Speaker 01 There was something else the cops had discovered when they were canvassing the local hardware stores. In addition to finding out about Jack's purchase of the indoor-outdoor carpeting, they learned he'd bought several bags of quick-drying concrete. Now, even quick-drying concrete can take up to a month to fully cure or harden. And as the cops discovered, in the basement of the Wolf Road House, under the shelving and the indoor-outdoor carpeting, there was a section of the floor that hadn't completely cured.
30:44 Speaker 04 And that area was six foot, eight inches in one direction, and two feet, six inches another. So it actually almost looked like a
30:56 Speaker 04 a gravesite, the size of a gravesite. At that point, we took the sledgehammer, and I hit, like, in the center of the uncured concrete. I broke it up a little bit and then got down and started digging it out.
31:13 Speaker 07 They did it with little tiny screwdrivers and everything, try not to disturb anything.
31:19 Speaker 01 The uncured concrete was about three inches thick. The team broke that up and hit dirt. And then, something caught Dave's eye.
31:29 Speaker 07 Then we found something I was looking for, and that was a green tarp.
31:34 Speaker 01 Something Collier had mentioned seeing around the Boyle House recently.
31:39 Speaker 04 And I reached in and grabbed the tarp and started pulling it up a little bit. And I got a distinct odor from the hole.
31:50 Speaker 04 And it was that of a dead body.
31:57 Speaker 04 Once you smell a dead body, you never forget that smell. So, uh...
32:04 Speaker 04 Woo!
32:06 Speaker 01 Hours passed. It was getting late.
32:10 Speaker 04 The tarp was wrapped with a rope.
32:14 Speaker 04 Cut the rope so that we could open up the tarp.
32:18 Speaker 01 And there was a woman's body.
32:22 Speaker 04 And because it had been wrapped, and it had been in a cool, moist grave, there wasn't any really decay.
32:33 Speaker 04 Found that she had a white plastic bag over her head, and that was tied around her neck. The only thing that she was wearing was, uh...were panties. She was naked. And that's all she had was just a pair of panties on, and then the jewelry.
32:52 Speaker 01 On her neck, there were two chains. She also had a wristwatch on, a Rolex.
32:59 Speaker 04 He went and actually cut the plastic bag to reveal the face.
33:07 Speaker 01 When the technicians cut the bag open, blonde hair tumbled out. It looked like the hair in a photo Dave had brought with him. A photo of Noreen.
33:18 Speaker 07 And I checked the picture I had of her. And it was very obvious, when I looked at her, that it was Noreen.
33:28 Speaker 04 He tentatively identified the body that we had just unearthed as Noreen Boyle.
33:43 Speaker 01 After taking one last look at the body in the basement, Lieutenant Dave Messmore walked upstairs with one thought on his mind.
33:52 Speaker 07 I can't wait to get my hands on Jack. It's time to lock him up.
34:01 Speaker 01 So Dave picked up Dr. Jack Boyle's house phone. He woke up his captain back in Mansfield. The same captain who, according to Dave, told him he was about to embarrass the department.
34:13 Speaker 07 And I said, "I've got Noreen's body up here." He said, "What?" And I said, "I've got Noreen's body. She's been murdered." And I said, "I want you to write up a murder warrant and take it and serve it on Jack before he gets away somewhere." And he said, "What, what, what, what, what? A murder warrant?" And I said, "Yep." He was shocked about the whole thing.
34:44 Speaker 01 In the early morning hours of January 26th, a phalanx of Mansfield Police headed to the Boyle house and knocked on the door.
34:53 Speaker 07 Jack was home. And he came out and they said, "You're under arrest for homicide." And he says, "Okay, I don't have anything to say. Nothing."
35:10 Speaker 05 Record $5 million bond set tonight in Mansfield for a doctor accused of murdering his wife.
35:16 Speaker 03 Tonight, 46-year-old Jack Boyle sits in the Richland County Jail on an aggravated murder charge.
35:22 Speaker 01 Dave was exhausted. So was the prosecutor he'd brought along. Still, they took a moment to celebrate. They headed to the nearest cheap motel. In their room, they drank beer, ate pizza. And Dave, in his glory, surveyed their surroundings.
35:41 Speaker 07 Looked over in a corner and there was a whole herd of ants eating somebody else's food. The thing was a dump and it was awful.
35:55 Speaker 01 The next day, Dave began the long drive back home to Mansfield. Noreen had been found, Jack had been locked up. That evening, Dave phoned the house where the Boyle children had been taken into care.
36:08 Speaker 07 I said, "I need to talk to Collier."
36:12 Speaker 01 At the home of Collier's foster family, Dave and Collier went into a small TV room, just the two of them. Dave sat on a chair facing Collier on a couch. Their knees were a few inches apart.
36:26 Speaker 02 He told me, you know, that they had found my mother's body. And it was buried underneath the house that I found the photos of. I remember asking him, "Did she look like she was at peace?" He said, "Yes." I'm sure he was lying. And I was really sad. I was also sad for Dave. Because I knew he wanted a different outcome, too. I knew he probably wanted more than anything to say. "I found her. She's okay. We've found her shopping and, you know. You know.
37:09 Speaker 02 She just needed a little break, but she's back now." I knew that's probably the story he would have rather have told me. But I also know that he wanted to be there to tell me about it. He was my partner in crime.
37:26 Speaker 07 I said, "It's better that you know what happened to her than than to go on for years and years and never, never find her." And I said, "Well, it's my job, Collier. It's for you." I said, "I'm really sorry."
37:42 Speaker 02 There's a finality to it. Because there's always that little, like, modicum of hope. And I believe I started crying, but I also was just, I my whole life was just, everything had just changed.
38:01 Speaker 01 Collier was, in effect, an orphan.
38:05 Speaker 02 I'm all alone. And the one person that can make it all better isn't there anymore.
38:20 Speaker 01 And it wasn't over yet. Before he left The Guardian's house that evening, Lieutenant Dave Messmore had a request for Collier.
38:30 Speaker 07 And I told him he might have to testify. It wasn't very often that prosecutors would use a young child to testify. But it was important. And he said, absolutely.
38:47 Speaker 01 In the trial of Dr. Jack Boyle for the murder of Noreen Boyle, their son Collier was to be the prosecution's star witness. And there would be a trial because Dr. Jack Boyle, despite the body found in his basement, pleaded not guilty.
39:07 Speaker 05 Did you, on or about December 31 of 1989, cause the death of Noreen Boyle? No, I did not.
39:15 Speaker 01 I never harmed her at all.
39:18 Speaker 01 What was Jack's defense? He was the innocent victim of a conspiracy to set him up.
39:33 Speaker 03 In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning it in gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepherd, and from CBC Podcasts and The Toronto Star, "The Most Wanted Olympian," available now.
40:11 Speaker 01 Finding Mom's Killer is a production of Orbit Media. Creator and host, Steve Fishman, that's me. Our senior producer is Drew Nellis. Our producer and production coordinator, Austin Smith. Our story editor, Emile Klein. Fact check by Ryan Alderman. Mixing and sound design by Scott Somerville. Our lawyers are at Davis Wright Tremaine. From Sony Music Entertainment, our executive producer is Jonathan Hirsch. Special thanks to Emily Rassik, Steve Ackerman, Catherine St. Louis, Sammy Allison, Fisher Stevens, Ria Julian, Dan Bobkoff. At WME, we'd like to thank Evan Krassik, Marissa Hurwitz, and Ben Davis.
40:56 Speaker 01 We want to also thank Carl Hunnall at The Richland Source for the generous use of his podcast studio. And a really warm thank you to Collier Landry for sharing his story and for his production assistance.
41:25 Speaker 03 In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game. Ryan's style is really gunning it in gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away. But he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding. He controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepherd, and from CBC Podcasts and The Toronto Star, The Most Wanted Olympian. Available now.
Previous Introducing: Finding Mom's Killer Next Finding Mom's Killer | 2. The Stories We Tell Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated