Pod Insights The Big Picture The 25 Best Movies of the Century: No. 3 - '25th Hour’ About this episode Sean and Amanda return to continue their yearlong project of listing the 25 best movies of the 21st century so far. Today, they discuss Spike Lee’s ‘25th Hour,’ one of the most present tense films ever made. They discuss its fascinating legacy as a somewhat under-discussed masterpiece, explain why Lee’s stylistic choices are deeply moving, and identify the impressive fricative tension in all of the movie’s ideas.
Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins
Producer: Jack Sanders
Shopping. Streaming. Celebrating. It’s on Prime.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Sean Fennessey? This episode of The Big Picture is brought to you by Amazon Prime. What pairs with a good comedy? The cozy blanket arriving with Prime. What pairs with a nail biting thriller? Snacks arriving with Prime. What pairs with big game on Prime Video? That new couch arriving with Prime. Whatever feeling you're after, Prime helps bring it to life with great entertainment and fast shipping that delivers what the moment calls for. From streaming to fast shipping, it's on Prime. This episode is brought to you by LinkedIn Ads. Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first but didn't live up to the hype? Marketers know that feeling. They optimize for the numbers that look great, impressions, reach and reacts. But when they don't show revenue, well, that's a not so great conversation with the CFO. LinkedIn has a word for that: bull spend. Instead, why not invest in what looks good to your CFO?
0:45 Sean Fennessey? LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title and more. So cut the bull spend, advertise on LinkedIn, the network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. That's LinkedIn.com/thebigpicture. Terms and conditions apply.
1:22 Sean Fennessey? I'm Sean Fennessey.
1:23 Amanda Dobbins? I'm Amanda Dobbins.
1:24 Sean Fennessey? And this is 25 for 25, a Big Picture special conversation show about 25th hour. And this life came so close to never happening. Amanda.
1:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
1:33 Sean Fennessey? I believe that this is the mystery movie on our list.
1:37 Amanda Dobbins? It is.
1:37 Sean Fennessey? This is the movie that I have seen vanishingly few people figure out what would be on our list, which I find interesting for a variety of reasons. Now, this movie is of course directed by Spike Lee. It is written by David Benioff, based on his novel. It stars Edward Norton, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Barry Pepper, Rosario Dawson, Anna Paquin, Brian Cox, a number of Spike Lee all-star character actors. Shot by Rodrigo Prieto, music by Terrence Blanchard.
2:04 Sean Fennessey? And if you've been listening to this show.
2:08 Amanda Dobbins? You know that it's coming, or you should, but.
2:11 Sean Fennessey? This is a big movie. It's a big movie for me and a movie that I know you've always loved too. So it has been interesting that people have struggled to identify, one, that we would do a Spike movie. Because we both love Spike.
2:23 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
2:24 Sean Fennessey? And two, that this would be one of the movies, but for whatever reason, on social media.
2:28 Amanda Dobbins? It's true.
2:29 Sean Fennessey? And even among friends, people have just not known what would have been in our top three.
2:32 Amanda Dobbins? Our good friend Dan Riley has been trying to guess for two weeks now because we had been talking about, there's one surprise left. There's one thing that you won't see coming and that we were very excited about. And Dan has been trying to guess for weeks and he's just like not even close. And I told him, I was like, you, you can keep texting me and I will keep saying no, but he didn't, he didn't get there. But we've talked about it many times before on the podcast and even this year, there have been clues when Spike Lee came on this podcast. He identified 25th Hour and I was like, oh no, is everyone going to guess now?
3:04 Sean Fennessey? And I reacted so excitedly when he said 25th Hour.
3:07 Amanda Dobbins? And then I drafted it in the New York City movie draft and like, you know, with a shot straight to the heart at Chris Ryan. Because this is also one of his favorite movies. So it was a no brainer to both of us when we were making the list. And you, I put together a long list, you did a ranking and let's talk about it now. This film was originally number two on our list.
3:31 Sean Fennessey? It was.
3:32 Amanda Dobbins? And yesterday you had a crisis of confidence.
3:34 Sean Fennessey? I did.
3:35 Amanda Dobbins? And you presented to me the case for switching number two and number three. And I said, okay. I said, I understand it. I think that in my own world, this would still be at number two instead of number three. But we can even, we'll talk a bit about that when we get to number two, which is also just out and out masterpieces. It's only masterpieces from this point out.
3:57 Sean Fennessey? I would argue it's probably 25 masterpieces on the list, but you know, that was kind of the idea.
4:01 Amanda Dobbins? But it was never a question that it would be top five and we didn't even talk about it. You just slotted it at a number two and I was like, yes, perfect.
4:10 Sean Fennessey? We never, we never strategized around this.
4:12 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. So why do you, like, some of it is just that that's how we work and it's unspoken and we're like, great, okay, we don't need to talk about this, but. Have you thought about that? Like, what's your theory about why it is that high? Like, in this list of films that we have?
4:27 Sean Fennessey? Well, there's a variety of reasons. I mean, I think that that probably goes toward explaining why we chose it in the first place, too.
4:35 Sean Fennessey? This is probably revealing some, the direction of where we're headed on the list, but I think most fans of the show and listen for regular listeners will know where we're headed here. And I see this very much as like, a story of America in three parts. And that this movie is kind of, when we were coming of age, and right around the time when we were moving to New York, this was the story of the present. This is one of the most present tense films ever made. And the reason for that is obvious. This is a story about a guy named Monty Brogan, who is a New York City drug dealer, a guy who's from Brooklyn, who gets arrested and is sentenced to seven years in prison. And the 25 hours that we see in the film is the final day before he goes to prison.
5:16 Sean Fennessey? And this film was made, was in development and then in production during and in the aftermath of the attacks on 9/11. And so this is like, there's not really a lot of kind of big scale, corporately distributed works of art that are about this moment in history. And like, for me, I was in college at this time. I shortly moved to New York thereafter. Same for you.
5:40 Amanda Dobbins? As a senior in high school, yeah.
5:42 Sean Fennessey? It's a 9/11, of course, a world changing event for anyone in America. But as someone who was born and raised in New York, whose entire family lived in New York, was, you know, earth shaking in so many ways. And also, Spike Lee, just a insanely influential and inspiring person to me. Somebody like an artist who I just really have always been interested in since I first saw whatever that link in the chain of movies was from Do the Right Thing, Jungle Fever, Malcolm X, Mo Better Blues, Crooklyn. Like, I saw all those movies kind of in quick succession as a teenager and have just been locked into his world. So this movie, to me, is like a major, major convergence. And it
6:23 Sean Fennessey? It isn't on the New York Times list, you know? It isn't.
6:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
6:27 Sean Fennessey? And so it exists in this kind of space where like, if you bring it up to people who've seen it, they're like, oh, I love that movie.
6:31 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
6:32 Sean Fennessey? But maybe not ever, maybe it has not been distributed in quite the same way. When you mentioned the Spike thing when he was on the show, and he pointed that out as like a movie that he thinks is still a little undiscovered
6:41 Amanda Dobbins? Mm-hmm.
6:41 Sean Fennessey? out of his filmography. But then I talked to Noah Baumbach on the show last week, and I asked him the same question that I asked Spike. And he was like, well, what did Spike say? And I said, 25th Hour. And he was like, 25th Hour? That's like, everybody loves that movie. You know, like, he didn't think that that was, that movie even made sense, so.
6:57 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, it's, um, it's, I guess, it's an unspoken masterpiece, or not even, not even forgotten, but kind of ignored, I guess, or just, it, you have to jog people's memory about it. And I don't know if that's because of the 9/11 of it all. Um, and.
7:16 Sean Fennessey? Meaning people don't want to spend time thinking about that?
7:18 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and also because it's, as you said, it's very present moment. So when we think about 9/11 now, we contextualize it, we politicize it, or we put it in the arc of American history as we understand it, or we make a joke out of it at this point, um, which is not respectful at all, but is how we deal with.
7:39 Sean Fennessey? Blank was my 9/11 or whatever.
7:40 Amanda Dobbins? Exactly.
7:41 Sean Fennessey? Yeah. It's almost been like memified, this tragic event.
7:43 Amanda Dobbins? The death of irony of 9/11, and then the, and then it resurged and became even more messed up. So this, this film isolates the feelings of uncertainty and anger and fear and total discombobulation that we had in that moment. And it's just not what you summon when you bring back that time period.
8:09 Sean Fennessey? Mm-hmm.
8:09 Amanda Dobbins? Um, or at least not what I do, because I repress all things. Um, but I think we as Americans definitely repress, and this is a movie about a lot of Irish guys who can't talk about their feelings. So they're repressing too. And then, um, I do think also, so this came out in 2002, and.
8:29 Amanda Dobbins? After 9/11, Hollywood and movies and culture and what we valued as like good or important, or how we were processing things, or even the types of films we wanted to see, like really changed. And so I think it just got lost a bit in the shuffle of a reinvention of our understanding of like Hollywood American output in the early 2000s.
8:52 Sean Fennessey? I think that's right on the money. There is also, this is also the time of Sam Raimi Spider-Man movies, which were also New York set movies about heroism. And that there was something, I think, I think part of that movie's success, obviously, it's a Spider-Man film, people love Spider-Man, but there was something uplifting about watching Tobey Maguire, who produced this movie, and who is the one who located the David Benioff book and eventually got the ball rolling on the whole film. Those films popped in part because we were looking for something a little bit more hopeful in the aftermath of this event. This is a movie that very much leans into the specifics of the event. It's not a movie about 9/11, and it is a movie surrounded by 9/11. And
9:36 Sean Fennessey? because it is so present tense, and because it is a tough movie with no simple answers, that is basically defined by his deeply flawed characters, you could make the case that every character in this movie is kind of a creep, or a loser, or somebody with maybe the exception of Natura, that there's the kind of no, it's like a loss of innocence movie in a lot of ways. And 9/11, for a generation of people, is a real loss of innocence moment. And so it's just a hard movie. And there are funny things about it. It is amusing, you know? Anyone ever tell you you look like an optical illusion? You know, like there's stuff in the movie that it has a great energy and vitality to it, and it does have a sense of humor, but it's quite sad.
10:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, no, I mean, it's brutal. It has two of the great scenes of the 21st century, in my opinion, as well. And I mean that both emotionally, but just like actual filmmaking, the writing, and then the way that Lee adapts it, and his, like, his particular style put to the subject of New York. In the like the fuck you rant and then and then the ending, which is like, some of the reason that this movie is on the list for me is just technically speaking, it is an out and out masterpiece. It is the best ending of a movie in the 21st century.
10:56 Sean Fennessey? I I put that question in the doc.
10:57 Amanda Dobbins? Straight up.
10:58 Sean Fennessey? I I think that there are some contenders. I think it is over it is I consistently cry at the end of the movie.
11:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
11:05 Sean Fennessey? And that's there's not a lot of movies that like I can see on eighth time and still feel very moved by.
11:10 Amanda Dobbins? I cry at something different every single time.
11:12 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, a moment.
11:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
11:14 Sean Fennessey? It's funny, there's definitely, this is gonna be one of the lesser seen movies, I think, in the top 10. And there are probably people listening to the episode who have not seen this movie. I I highly encourage you to see it. We're gonna talk about all the details of it throughout this conversation. I do want to go back to Lee because he I I wrote down that this is his last out and out masterpiece. I think he's made very good films. I think if we were talking about what is this standing in for? The next best contender for the 21st century for him would probably be Inside Man, a movie we both love, which is just an absolute corker, like a really entertaining thriller, a good New York movie, you know,
11:47 Amanda Dobbins? A great Denzel movie.
11:49 Sean Fennessey? Performance, totally.
11:50 Amanda Dobbins? And I think that I think this is where we reveal that we don't have a Denzel film on our list.
11:54 Sean Fennessey? I hadn't even thought about that. Yeah.
11:55 Amanda Dobbins? We talked about it a bit in terms of at the the selection committee, but yeah.
12:00 Sean Fennessey? Right, okay. Yeah, so there's no Denzel, but the and that's a movie I really like. That movie feels a little bit more thematically thin. It's just like, to me, it's a real, really good genre movie.
12:11 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
12:12 Sean Fennessey? And has some ideas in it, but this movie is like overloaded with ideas. And as I watched it again last night, I was just making notes. It was becoming more revealed to me, all the things that it makes me feel and try to understand. But for Spike, like you said, that style that he brings to every film, where he's got these six or seven moves that he makes in movies. And sometimes when they're in his world, it can feel a bit like a closed loop. I find in his 21st century movies sometimes,
12:39 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
12:40 Sean Fennessey? it feels a little iterative, where I'm like, especially with movies he's written, I'm like, I kind of know why you're putting this character in this position and when you're doing the double dolly and what the character's mind state is. This movie, because it's based on this Benioff book, because it's in a it's in a similar world to what you would see in his films, but the register is a little bit more somber. I think his stylistic moves are more surprising and even more emotionally moving. It reminds me a little bit of seeing Malcolm X for the first time where you're like, oh, he's using all of the stuff he's figured out to tell this big story.
13:11 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
13:11 Sean Fennessey? But in this case, he's kind of shrunk it down to this really tight character piece.
13:14 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and it is, I always think of the John David Washington anecdote from making Black Klansman. Where he just kept asking Spike Lee, like, when's the double dolly shot? When's the double dolly shot? And you do, there is that moment, you grow up, you get used to watching his films and you are expecting them. But as you mentioned, when he's, when he's meeting some other material, and this is like a true work of adaptation because this novel was written before 9/11. And so the way, and it's set in New York, but what Spike Lee is doing in the moment to make this a film about New York and America in that specific time is additive, right?
13:57 Amanda Dobbins? And he's finding different, and so it's a, it is truly like when two great minds and two great skillsets like meet and elevate the other. And so it doesn't, you are excited to see who gets the double dolly shot. And it also, you know, conveys like a significance about, oh, okay, now I'm like supposed to pay attention. I know this is a, you're saying something to me. But because it's not just a combination of all of those moves that there is, that he's working through some other stuff and from some other sources, it's really, really exciting.
14:32 Sean Fennessey? It's really powerful. I think you can also feel a lot of actors in this movie who really want to be working with Spike. Edward Norton, who is the star of the movie. Let's spend some time talking about him.
14:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
14:42 Sean Fennessey? So he is, in 2002, at the absolute center of Hollywood.
14:49 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
14:50 Sean Fennessey? He's 32 years old. He's already had two acting Academy Award nominations. He has gone from wonderkin, where did this guy come from? In Primal Fear in 1996.
15:01 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
15:02 Sean Fennessey? To headlining four films that year. In 2002, he was the star of Death to Smoochy, Frida, Red Dragon, and 25th Hour. He was also dating Salma Hayek at the time.
15:14 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
15:15 Sean Fennessey? He'd been trying to get, he basically had been saying to Spike for seven years, "Let's do something. I really, really want to do something." So, you know, I think originally Tobey Maguire thought he might play this part. He had a conflict with Spider-Man and it eventually became an Edward Norton movie. And I've said this before, I probably said it on the Primal Fear pod, rewatchables podcast, but I was like, "This was my guy. This was, this was my favorite actor." Like, this was the person who, when I was 15 and really getting into movies, it was like, this guy showed up in a Milo Schormann film. He was like showing up in Spike Lee movies. He was doing American History X. He seemed really brave and audacious and really interested in transforming in every part. I was really into him. His career has been a little funny in the last 20 years.
15:58 Sean Fennessey? He really has more, he's had leading roles, but really hasn't been a leading man since this period of time.
16:05 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
16:06 Sean Fennessey? So I see this very much as like a time capsule, but it's also an amazing representation of what kind of actor he is and not in the ways that he was exercising before this. So in the past, he would be very big. He would do accents. He would have big speeches. He would raise his voice and get angry, or he would be twitchy or something. Monty Brogan is more like a, he's like a Brando or like a Pacino character. You know, he's a 70s tragic loser.
16:36 Amanda Dobbins? He is, but he has even like tamped down the charisma. You know, there's something, and, and the anger, like it's, this is a, this is a really angry movie. But in the most famously angry scene, that's, it's done through a mirror. And it's not even the actual, it's, I mean, it is Edward Norton as Monty performing it, but it's his reflection in a mirror that takes over and starts yelling all of these things because the actual character can't access any of it.
17:08 Sean Fennessey? That's what it is. Yeah, it's an internal monologue that is made external. He's, Monty goes to the bathroom while he's having one last drink with his dad before he goes to prison.
17:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
17:17 Sean Fennessey? And in that moment, he gives this fuck you monologue, which is in the novel.
17:22 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
17:23 Sean Fennessey? Even though it, this, the novel predates 9/11, it is still very much about. The way that a lot of New Yorkers are, which is that they are constantly aware of who is around them and making their life more difficult. And sometimes that comes out in aggression, but ultimately it speaks to like a self-loathing or self frustration or self pitying.
17:44 Amanda Dobbins? But also, this is, that segment is a love letter to New York also. In, in like, it is filled with like hate speech. And is like, is very ugly and relies on stereotypes. And is also written in a way that observes and understands how New York works.
18:02 Sean Fennessey? And Yes, it's very true.
18:03 Amanda Dobbins? Because it is, and listen, you have to be angry to live in New York and you have to
18:09 Sean Fennessey? It'll be tough.
18:09 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, you have to put your like, your hood up and just like, get through because it's crowded and everybody's gonna be like throwing their elbow.
18:17 Sean Fennessey? Yep.
18:18 Amanda Dobbins? Trying to make their own thing. But, um, but it's, it's written from such like a knowingness and observation that only comes from like truly understanding the place.
18:26 Sean Fennessey? Mm hmm.
18:28 Amanda Dobbins? But even that, it's like, it is separated from the character. And so the rest, Monty is like, he's not seething like Pacino. He's not, there's no last like fight left in him like there is in Brando. Like there usually is in Brando. It's just, he's, it's resignation.
18:46 Sean Fennessey? It's a movie of regret in so many ways. Cause this is a guy who was obviously very smart. He gets into this private school on a scholarship, even though he comes from seemingly a lower middle class background. And he fucks up because he starts dealing drugs in school. He gets kicked out of school and then he becomes a career drug dealer. And he gets a little greedy and he gets pinched. And that's when his life starts to unravel a bit.
19:10 Sean Fennessey? Using a single person's moment of inexplicable.
19:18 Sean Fennessey? Sadness and frustration and this sense of my, the feeling of my life is over.
19:22 Amanda Dobbins? It's done.
19:23 Sean Fennessey? Which is exactly how everybody felt in New York for a period of time.
19:26 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
19:27 Sean Fennessey? And you can say it's happenstance or great artistry making that connection. Or you can say it's an act of critical fusion that some, some of us who think hard about movies brought all of these things together.
19:38 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
19:38 Sean Fennessey? But like.
19:39 Amanda Dobbins? It's textual.
19:40 Sean Fennessey? It totally, it totally makes you go back to the very specific place. Like, I remember my feelings at the time as a fucking 18 year old. Who didn't know anything, who didn't understand the global context, who didn't know what Al Qaeda was. Who didn't, but just, there was a very specific combination of rage, sadness. What I would describe as like a weird bloodlust that found its way into the culture.
20:04 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, I just vividly remember sitting, you know, I still lived in Atlanta. But we just like sat there watching the news and just like watching live footage of, of bombs that the United States was dropping on places that were not the United States in some sort of, like, I don't even remember where, which is one of many parts of the problem.
20:26 Sean Fennessey? Totally, but that, that would, and that, those actions felt like manifestations of the same feelings that people were having on.
20:32 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
20:33 Sean Fennessey? September 12th, you know, which were obviously completely wrong and misguided and awful. And obviously continued a terrible cycle. But this movie, like really, within these characters, I think completely manifests all of those feelings that people were having and at no greater moment, I think, than in the fuck you rant that he gives.
20:51 Amanda Dobbins? Right, well, and, but there's also, it literalizes that there is a scene filmed above ground zero. And it's where Barry Pepper's character, Francis Xavier, I can't remember his last name.
21:02 Sean Fennessey? Slattery.
21:03 Amanda Dobbins? Slattery Frank, uh, lives. And the Philip Seymour Hoffman character comes to meet him and they like sit in the window, quite literally looking over ground zero and the cleanup site. And they have a conversation about how the air is bad down there. And, you know, fuck the times, I read the New York Post, just like iconic.
21:23 Sean Fennessey? Incredible line.
21:23 Amanda Dobbins? Uh, Barry Pepper stuff.
21:24 Sean Fennessey? What happened to Barry Pepper?
21:25 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I don't, I don't know, I Googled that last night.
21:27 Sean Fennessey? He's so extraordinary in this movie.
21:28 Amanda Dobbins? He's so good in this.
21:28 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
21:31 Amanda Dobbins? And then the conversation turns to Monty and it goes from nine 11 to Monty's like impending prison sentence and how they as friends are going to deal with it. And I had forgotten this, but the very last line after very Frank is like, we'll never see him again. It's over. He says, it's over after tonight, Jake. Wake the fuck up. And then the camera pans up from them to the ground zero cleaning site and you watch the trucks moving through, sweeping up with like, the Terrence Blanchard score is unreal, but at that moment is like really going for it.
22:09 Sean Fennessey? Totally appropriate for the big swells that he is known for.
22:12 Amanda Dobbins? But, and I was just like, oh, so it's literally, it's over after this is quite literally about America in this moment. And I'm, I'm watching what the camera wants me to watch and thinking about it.
22:23 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, there's so many things that are, it does like a mixed media quality to a lot of this too. Because like, one of the things that Monty mentions in his fuck you monologue is Enron executives.
22:34 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
22:34 Sean Fennessey? And the idea of like, the way that corporate power kind of led us to this place. There's obviously no greater representation of corporate power in New York City than the, than the Twin Towers. And the idea of trying to smash that and that being under attack. But then also this kind of divergent feeling, this oppositional feeling of corporate power also attacking regular people, like regular, middle-class people living in New York City and the encroachment that they all feel in their lives. This movie has like a really affricative tension in all of its ideas. Like, it's just not a clean and simple movie. You mentioned that Frank in that scene says like, it's over, Monty's never coming back. You're never going to see him. And Jacob, Philip Seymour Hoffman's character, will not accept that. But then later in the film, we see a long conversation between Frank and Monty, and Frank is insisting,
23:18 Sean Fennessey? like, you're going to survive, you're going to make it, I'm going to be there for you when you get out.
23:21 Amanda Dobbins? We'll start something together, yeah.
23:23 Sean Fennessey? Yes. Which is just like heartbreaking, you know? And he's like, is he lying to himself? Has he convinced himself over that night? Is this just something that friends do for each other? Like, the truth is kind of all in the middle there somewhere, but...
23:36 Sean Fennessey? I've been saying to you the last day or so, like, this is really a movie about how how men are with each other.
23:40 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
23:41 Sean Fennessey? And how they like, kind of don't know how to tell the truth to each other sometimes. And they feel that they need to support each other, but also break each other's balls at the same time. And like, there's gotta be one guy who's like, I'm the truth teller in the group. And there's gotta be one guy who's like, I'm the empathetic guy. But then like, people's personalities merge and they split apart. And as I was watching the movie very closely, I was like, ah, the, you know. I think the Benioff idea of the movie is that these three friends.
24:05 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
24:06 Sean Fennessey? That Jacob and Frank and Monty are kind of like, they're kind of the male psyche. They're the they're the ego and the superego and the id, you know. Monty is the ego, Frank is the superego and, or no. Jacob is the superego and Frank is the id. Like, when you put them all together, they seem like a person.
24:26 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
24:26 Sean Fennessey? But individually, they have all of these trademarks where like, they're kind of bouncing off of each other throughout this movie. Which is also a clever idea about what happens to friends you have in high school. Right, where you're like, you could never be closer to somebody than when you're 16. And then 10, cut to 10 years later and you're like, why was I friends with this person? What do we, what did we see in each other?
24:46 Amanda Dobbins? I think that I spend like, a moderate amount of time thinking about the male psyche when watching this movie. Like, I'm not really breaking it down into parts, which is also possibly just how much time I devote to it in general.
25:00 Sean Fennessey? Yeah.
25:00 Amanda Dobbins? But.
25:01 Sean Fennessey? You're confronted by it on a regular basis.
25:02 Amanda Dobbins? Right, and so, and this is a very familiar version and a very perceptive version of what I am confronted with. With a bunch of guys who are connected and sort of devoted to each other, but it's very complicated. And they just like, can't figure it out. We were talking about.
25:20 Sean Fennessey? What percentile do you think I would be in in the bachelor scale if I were single? Don't answer that.
25:27 Amanda Dobbins? Let's see, money and, what's the other thing Jacob fails on?
25:31 Sean Fennessey? Bad breath.
25:32 Amanda Dobbins? Bad breath, yeah, I can't really speak to that.
25:34 Sean Fennessey? Okay, thanks.
25:34 Amanda Dobbins? Um, you don't really eat any food with like, flavor.
25:38 Sean Fennessey? I drink a lot of coffee.
25:40 Amanda Dobbins? That's true, but it doesn't make it this far.
25:42 Sean Fennessey? Fortunately for everyone involved, I've been married for some time.
25:47 Amanda Dobbins? But I was thinking last night about our conversation around the movie Friendship, The 2025, which was another, I thought, perceptive and rare movie about how men don't know how to talk to each other or be friends, or how complicated it is. And we're very familiar with the women genre of that. Yes. But this is definitely the same type of movie. It is. It's hard to exist as a person in the world, or a man in the world, and it's also hard to know how to talk to each other.
26:18 Speaker 02 When the sun goes down, the appetizers come out. Yeah, you heard that right. Late night, half-priced appetizers are here at Applebee's. Saucy, sweet and spicy boneless wings, crispy, cheesy mozzarella sticks, creamy spinach and artichoke dip. Your favorite apps half-price, available every single night because why should appetizers have curfews? Tap the banner to learn more. Dining only for a limited time at participating locations. Restrictions apply. Copyright 2026 Applebee's Restaurant, LLC.
26:50 Speaker 03 FanDuel is now available everywhere in the US.
26:58 Speaker 03 So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places.
27:07 Speaker 03 Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
27:20 Amanda Dobbins? This episode is brought to you by Amazon Prime. Like an action blockbuster, the holidays move quick. But with Prime, fast, free delivery means those last-minute gifts arrive right when you need them. Last year, while watching Singin' in the Rain with my son, I realized a pair of tap shoes would be a perfect Christmas gift, and I had them under the tree for him on Christmas Day. Prime's fast shipping is always there for you during the holidays, especially when it's last minute and just can't wait. Last-minute holiday magic? It's on Prime. Head to amazon.com/prime to shop now.
27:49 Sean Fennessey? I think there's some struggles of expression and you have this moment late in the movie where Monty wants to get beaten up so that he goes into prison looking less pretty than Edward Norton is. And, you know, that whole scene where they're beating the shit out of each other is this conclusive moment of like, this is how men feel sometimes, you know, like they want to just bash each other's heads in. I think that there is a lot of other like really rich stuff inside of the movie. Monty getting arrested and the kind of staying and the idea of who has ratted on him is a strong narrative through line. And so for some of the film, he feels that Naturelle, his girlfriend,
28:31 Sean Fennessey? played by Rosaria Dawson in the movie, may have been the woman, the person who told the cops that he was hiding money and drugs in his couch cushion. It's possible that it's maybe someone in the criminal organization that he works for, the Russian mobsters that he's working for. So in that process of him getting arrested and being questioned by police officers, you get what feels like really classic Spike Lee material where you've got, you know, Clay from The Wire before The Wire doing she's. And in the conversations that he's having with Monty, they're full of very specific explanatory language about mandatory minimums, Rockefeller laws, the kind of like
29:15 Sean Fennessey? late-stage capitalism of the war on drugs, you know, that in the early 2000s, I say this as somebody who was raised by somebody who was working in this space. You know, this was kind of a pre-fentanyl, like rise of heroin moment, I would say, in the drug trade. And it was still kind of like a high-class, low-class situation. There's some very savvy stuff about the Simon character, who's the first character we see in the movie approaching Monty, sitting on the park bench, who's an addict who looks really rundown. And then in a flashback sequence, we see much earlier in the movie, he's a businessman wearing a suit, buying from Monty. And kind of
29:55 Sean Fennessey? just the way that this world, what Monty is doing is evil and soulless. And also the way that-
30:03 Sean Fennessey? People who become incarcerated or treated is also extremely dark and in some cases corrupt. And the film is trying to leave the nuance up to you. It's like, nobody thinks that the cops in this movie are the good guys, even though we know Monty is a piece of shit.
30:17 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
30:18 Sean Fennessey? Literally, his best friends say he's a piece of shit, and yet we still, we feel affection for him.
30:22 Amanda Dobbins? He's not, he's not just like immoral, you know, and a bad guy, but he also fucked up. Like, he got caught.
30:29 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
30:29 Amanda Dobbins? He wasn't even
30:31 Sean Fennessey? Wasn't even smart.
30:31 Amanda Dobbins? Good at being a bad guy.
30:33 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
30:33 Amanda Dobbins? He just totally screwed up and, and for what?
30:38 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I think that that is, this is the, I would say that this is the most 70s movie that we have on our 21st century list.
30:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, I guess so. I mean, definitely the whole statutory relationship aspect of it.
30:51 Sean Fennessey? We can discuss that if you'd like. There's definitely something, in addition to the male friendship quality.
30:56 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
30:56 Sean Fennessey? I think this is a movie that's pretty tough on the perils of masculinity in general. You know, if you look at the fact that Natcheurel is seduced when she is 17 years old on a playground, wearing a Catholic schoolgirl's uniform.
31:10 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
31:11 Sean Fennessey? And then later in the film, obviously Jacob's student, who's played by Ada Paquin, who is also 17.
31:16 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
31:16 Sean Fennessey? And lured into a club.
31:18 Amanda Dobbins? Hold on, I gotta add, this movie is standing in for
31:21 Sean Fennessey? Okay.
31:21 Amanda Dobbins? There's another one.
31:23 Sean Fennessey? Um.
31:23 Amanda Dobbins? Putting it down.
31:24 Sean Fennessey? You know, it's not an accident
31:26 Amanda Dobbins? No.
31:27 Sean Fennessey? That there's two different examples of men cruising for underage women
31:30 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
31:31 Sean Fennessey? in New York City in this movie and not really letting them off the hook. And it's, they've cast actors in Hoffman and Norton who are like inherently sympathetic. You know, when you see them in a movie, you're like,
31:42 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
31:42 Sean Fennessey? Um, I, I hope that person's okay, but they're creeps. You know, it's a, it's a movie about the creepiness of dudes as well, among a million other ideas.
31:50 Amanda Dobbins? As always, an incredible Hoffman performance. The, the scene in the teacher's lounge, just absolutely brutal. And then when they're
32:00 Sean Fennessey? The one when she comes in
32:01 Amanda Dobbins? When she comes in and sees
32:02 Sean Fennessey? Ask why did I get a B?
32:03 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah. And the, he is not doing anything and is also completely turned on and freaked out and panicking all at once.
32:12 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
32:12 Amanda Dobbins? Um, while so very still. And then I just also, the, the physical acting of in the club when he's just like this with his hands over his face
32:21 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
32:21 Amanda Dobbins? For a while.
32:23 Sean Fennessey? He's the embodiment of shame.
32:25 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
32:25 Sean Fennessey? He doesn't, he Didn't get laid enough when he was a teenager and now doesn't know how to relate to women.
32:31 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
32:31 Sean Fennessey? And is identified as like a, you know, rich kid.
32:34 Amanda Dobbins? A trust fund kid, yeah.
32:36 Sean Fennessey? And has no experience in the world beyond the world of ideas that he likes to teach. And so he's totally arrested. He's like arrested in the, in his development as a person. I mean, there's-
32:46 Amanda Dobbins? He's not actually arrested in the course of the film.
32:48 Sean Fennessey? No, other people are arrested in the film.
32:50 Amanda Dobbins? It's like not, outlook not good for him.
32:53 Sean Fennessey? He might make some mistakes.
32:54 Amanda Dobbins? Well, no, when he's just begging her, could you like, please not talk about this at school? I mean, you're gonna, you're gonna get fired, sir.
33:01 Sean Fennessey? There is literally an R. Kelly joke-
33:03 Amanda Dobbins? I know.
33:03 Sean Fennessey? -in the club scene. And this is, obviously, there were many rumors and maybe even the tape had been circulating at this time. The, of R. Kelly's heinous acts, but this is before Ignition Remix even came out. Like, this was in the culture and this movie is putting that stuff in, into the culture again and, and kind of making us confront it. And then the other thing too about Monty being kind of soulless is-
33:27 Sean Fennessey? Monty wants money so that he can feel safe and have power. And that is also a kind of an inherent characteristic of New York. There is a status-seeking quality about New York City, at least that I felt when I lived there.
33:38 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, of course.
33:39 Sean Fennessey? Where it was sort of like, what are you wearing? Where are you going? Did you get, are you going to that club tonight? You know, what, what, what street do you live on?
33:46 Amanda Dobbins? Well, I mean, what do you do? And what does that say about your, your level in the world and how much money you have?
33:52 Sean Fennessey? Yes. And even when we see the Anna Paquin character come in, like, enter the club with these guys.
33:58 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
33:58 Sean Fennessey? She's like, is your friend like famous or what is he? Because he has like all these connections and power and talking to the Patrice O'Neal character at the, at the club door. And it's pretty savvy about that too, you know, that-
34:11 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
34:11 Sean Fennessey? I, I did go to clubs in my twenties in New York. It was really fun. It did feel exciting. It was, like, it felt special, you know, and it's seductive. You can get kind of really trapped inside of that world very quickly. And it can ruin your life pretty quickly as well.
34:27 Amanda Dobbins? There's also the, the introductory scene we get for Frank is on the trading floor anticipating unemployment numbers. And how they will affect, you know, inflation and wage and investments and everything. And then people cheering when the, you know, at an, at an unemployment number and what it means for their money-making. It's, it's, if you want to talk about like soulless commodification of actual people, it is exemplified. And then- His boss is like really mad at him for, you know, taking some bet, but also like you need to come out with us tonight?
35:02 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
35:02 Amanda Dobbins? It's all right there in one scene.
35:04 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, Al Palagonia, who is one of Spike's best friends and who often does literally sit courtside with Spike and is so funny in that movie as Frank's boss. And there's a number of other very familiar people. I mentioned, you know, Clay from The Wire, Isaiah Whitlock Jr. and Michael Ganné, who's been in a couple of his films. And you've got like also very memorable people in very small roles, like Aaron Stanford shows up very quickly as one of Frank's colleagues. Vanessa Forlito is Rosario Dawson's friend. Are you familiar with Tony Siragusa, the guy who plays Nikolai, or Kostya, rather?
35:37 Amanda Dobbins? Only from 25th Hour.
35:38 Sean Fennessey? So that's the only, that's the only way you've seen. Do you know anything about him?
35:41 Amanda Dobbins? No. Should I? Do I?
35:43 Sean Fennessey? Well, I'll tell you who he is. He was a defensive tackle for the Colts and the Ravens for 10 years in the NFL. He won a Super Bowl with the Baltimore Ravens.
35:51 Amanda Dobbins? Makes sense based on his shape.
35:53 Sean Fennessey? He is not Russian and was born in New Jersey.
35:55 Amanda Dobbins? Okay. Well, he clarifies that he's Ukrainian.
35:59 Sean Fennessey? Sorry, Ukrainian. Would you have guessed that?
36:04 Amanda Dobbins? No, but now that you say it, you know, he does look like a cartoon of a football player that's in like the 1970s book about New York that we read our children, just like from a triangular shape.
36:16 Sean Fennessey? He was a talented and useful player and he played on arguably the most fearsome defense in the history of the NFL.
36:23 Amanda Dobbins? Okay.
36:24 Sean Fennessey? He just passed away a few years ago. I didn't realize that. His casting in this was like somewhat lampooned. It's a pretty bold stroke in a movie that is very naturalistic.
36:35 Sean Fennessey? I think it actually works. I know some people would disagree. They would say like, this is a flaw of this movie, the idea of putting Siragusa in it, but like the idea, like a non-professional actor who's in the middle of his NFL career, just showing up in this movie as a Ukrainian gangster is just another wild like Spike Lee stroke. Anyway, I just thought it was notable.
36:50 Amanda Dobbins? I learned about it just now and I think this is an excellent film, so I don't have a problem with it.
36:55 Sean Fennessey? The movie is also just very personally resonant for me.
36:59 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
36:59 Sean Fennessey? It's about Irish guys who spend a lot of their time in bars, talking around how they feel, using sports as like a entry point into their relationship with their parents or their friends. You know, the conversation between Frank and Monty later in the film when they're like, "We're two Irish kids from Brooklyn, how can we not have a bar?" You know, Frank saying, "I'm Irish, I can't get drunk, I know exactly what I'm saying." Like, there's just like a tonality
37:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
37:28 Sean Fennessey? to the way that these guys talk that just feels very familiar to me. That feels like, like when you're watching Fried Green Tomatoes and you're like, "This is exactly what my life is like," you know?
37:38 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, this does fit in, as do all Spike Lee movies, are like foundation for my understanding of New York. And I think, you know, I mostly talk about how I moved to New York because of Nora Ephron movies, but I had seen more Spike Lee-based New York movies than Nora Ephron movies.
37:54 Sean Fennessey? There are more.
37:54 Amanda Dobbins? Exactly. And I had seen all of them. And I am very, very hard on my high school in many ways, but they did show us do the right thing in high school.
38:01 Sean Fennessey? Wow, pretty good.
38:02 Amanda Dobbins? So, to me, it's familiar and like my understanding of what New York is and how New York people talk to each other. And, you know, it's funny, like, when I talk to your dad, I definitely am reminded of these scenes, but it's like, you know, he's familiar to me from 25th Hour, and instead of 25th Hour being familiar to me because of your dad.
38:23 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
38:23 Amanda Dobbins? But they are, it's, you know, it's a cortex.
38:26 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I think, I'm very struck by the conversations between Brian Cox and Edward Norton in the movie. And I would say my dad has a little bit less of the melancholy that Cox's character has, because like he's kind of dealing with grief and he's lost his wife and that kind of shattered his world. And he's a recovering alcoholic and, but there's just something in their relationship, which is like sincere and close, but there's something strained about it. There's something that can't be said. And Monty is at this breaking point in his life and he's almost trying to say to his dad in the film, like, "This is how it really is." Like, "Your optimism is sweet, but it's useless right now."
39:00 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
39:01 Sean Fennessey? And then that gets flipped on its head at the end of the film and you mention the ending. So, you know, at the ending of the movie, Frank's, or excuse me, uh, Monty's been beaten up by Frank.
39:12 Amanda Dobbins? On purpose.
39:12 Sean Fennessey? On purpose.
39:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
39:14 Sean Fennessey? And his dad picks him up and he's ready to take him to Otisville, up to prison. And they get in the car and on their drive, Brian Cox just kind of starts to lean into what could be, which is what if, instead of stopping at Otisville, and I love how he's like, describing the details of the directions, like, we'll take the Spring Brook Parkway, which is like such a New York thing.
39:37 Amanda Dobbins? And even the springboard into the, you know, the imagined sequences, like, I could just take a right here and we'll take the George Washington Bridge West.
39:45 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
39:45 Amanda Dobbins? You know, get you stitched up and keep going.
39:47 Sean Fennessey? Right. You've never been west of Philadelphia, have you? And he's, the, the movie starts showing us what could be and what we want to be.
39:56 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
39:56 Sean Fennessey? You know, we really want Monty, despite everything he's done, having spent this whole day with him, we want him to, to break free, you know, to not have to go to prison, to not have to confront this terrible thing. And I don't know if I can really think of another sequence like this in Spike's career that looks and feels like this.
40:15 Amanda Dobbins? I-
40:16 Sean Fennessey? Like, dreamlike, but, but real.
40:19 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
40:19 Sean Fennessey? You know, like, the color palette is kind of washed.
40:22 Amanda Dobbins? And it's, it's set up throughout the film. There are flashbacks, um, where we learn about how Monty's gotten to this situation, but they're introduced as, um,
40:36 Amanda Dobbins? as happening at the same time. And they're not shot like in a different film stock or, you know.
40:40 Sean Fennessey? Yes.
40:41 Amanda Dobbins? There is, it takes you a minute to realize, oh, like, I'm watching something that happened before.
40:45 Sean Fennessey? The first flashback, like, wrong foots you.
40:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yes.
40:46 Sean Fennessey? Yes, they get out of the bath to answer the door.
40:48 Amanda Dobbins? Exactly. And so, um,
40:51 Sean Fennessey? That's a slick filmmaking move, by the way.
40:53 Amanda Dobbins? And exactly, but so it then makes, sets you up so that you're watching and you're like, oh, did they turn? Like, is this happening? And, and you know it's not. It becomes like a little bit hazier and the Brian Cox is just, is narrating it in sort of like the, the subjunctive tense. But, um, it's-
41:11 Amanda Dobbins? The longing and also the knowing in the moment that this actually is not happening, but you want it to so badly, or you're so afraid of what is happening instead. Is, it's astonishing. I've never experienced anything like it in a movie.
41:32 Sean Fennessey? There's a ton of setups and a ton of individual, small moments we see about what his life could be done in this very quick montage. I mean, it is less than 10 minutes and photographed so beautifully. The whole movie is photographed so beautifully, you know.
41:44 Amanda Dobbins? The bus shot.
41:46 Sean Fennessey? Yes, when the bus moves away, they're standing there and she, I know. It's honestly, it's incredible. Like, I think this is like a full-blown out-and-out masterpiece. And I think a lot of people do agree, but it just does not have the same reputation as a lot of the movies that we've talked about that people are calling for. How could you not include this? How could you not include that? I was thinking about Prieto. I don't even know how Prieto got on this movie. I assume maybe because he shot Frida for Salma Hayek, and obviously Norton was involved in that film.
42:12 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
42:13 Sean Fennessey? And so in two, so Prieto, you know,
42:18 Sean Fennessey? got, made his name on Amores Peros with Inari Tu in 2000. And then he starts getting hired for Hollywood films. He shoots this movie, Original Sin, with Angelina Jolie and Antonio Banderas. And then in 2002, he makes Frida, Eight Mile and Twenty-Fifth Hour. And then 21 Grams, and then Alexander with Oliver Stone, and then he shoots Brokeback Mountain. And he's, you know, off to the races. And then he becomes Scorsese cinematographer, and he's like, he's one of the great living cinematographers, has not won an Academy Award. I think we talked about him a little bit during the Wolf of Wall Street episode. He's a, he is a genius. He is an amazing filmmaker.
42:51 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
42:52 Sean Fennessey? And he's still pretty young at this time. He's had plenty of experience in Mexico, but certainly in Hollywood films. And his, him colliding with Spike, and I don't think that they ever work together again, has also, I think, brings something special out of Spike. So with Spike, you've got Barry Alexander Brown cutting the movie. He cuts all of Spike's movies. You've got Terrence Blanchard, as you said, doing the score. Like, those are familiar voices.
43:13 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
43:14 Sean Fennessey? Adding Benioff and adding Prieto.
43:16 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
43:17 Sean Fennessey? I just feel like lifts this movie above some of his other work because it just gives it a different texture, a different sensibility and makes it feel special.
43:28 Amanda Dobbins? All the, the club scene, but especially the scene of Frank and Monty. Are they like in a ba- what is the overlooking the blue room? You know, and it's just all shot in that blue.
43:38 Sean Fennessey? It looks like a private party room, yeah, above the club.
43:40 Amanda Dobbins? But at some point, like you forget that it's just completely blue, but it looks so beautiful. And all the lights there and I mean, the, the montage and I'd forgotten one part of the ending is,
43:56 Amanda Dobbins? before Brian Cox starts the, you know, imagination, they're just driving through New York and you see all of the people in like in one shot from, from the fuck you montage. Or not all of them, but many of them. And they're all smiling. Uh, and then the little boy in the, um, the bus who writes his name. I mean, it's just.
44:17 Sean Fennessey? Beautiful. It's gorgeous.
44:19 Amanda Dobbins? It's incredible.
44:21 Sean Fennessey? Couple of other things about this. So, oh, one thing about the, the blue room. You know, the, the other room in, in kind of parallel action during that sequence is Jacob and Mary in the red room.
44:33 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
44:33 Sean Fennessey? And you know, there is the real, like the heavenly safe space. Frank and Monty moments before, you know, they're, they're forced to plunge below where Jacob is, where he is making a huge mistake and basically banishing himself to hell.
44:46 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
44:47 Sean Fennessey? Not that subtle, but still looks beautiful.
44:51 Amanda Dobbins? Colors are good. We don't use them enough.
44:53 Sean Fennessey? Of course, they're essential. We talked about them when we talked about Mulholland Drive 2.
44:58 Sean Fennessey? So what's the film's legacy? So A. O. Scott in The Times gave this a rave. Roger Ebert gave it three and a half stars. He overtly compared Monty to Enron in his review and said that this guy, no matter how, whatever we feel for Monty, he is just as bad and that he is a representative also of like the way that corporate America has kind of violated our trust.
45:23 Sean Fennessey? This movie is nine, is number 26 on the 2016 21st Century BBC poll. It was number 24 on the Rolling Stone 21st Century poll. And it, it didn't make the New York Times list, as I mentioned, and no Spike Lee movies made the New York Times list.
45:39 Amanda Dobbins? Well, this would be it, right? I mean, I
45:41 Sean Fennessey? I think so.
45:42 Amanda Dobbins? I love Inside Man.
45:43 Sean Fennessey? Mm-hmm.
45:44 Amanda Dobbins? And everything else is 20th century.
45:49 Sean Fennessey? Well, you know, this is kind of difficult to... I don't think, you couldn't do this because this is a four-parter, but I think when the Levis broke.
45:57 Amanda Dobbins? Sure.
45:58 Sean Fennessey? The Hurricane Katrina documentary that he made for HBO, which is like also a major accomplishment, a huge work of his. I guess it's considered a television miniseries and not a film.
46:07 Amanda Dobbins? We also didn't do documentaries on this list.
46:10 Sean Fennessey? We didn't, but I meant for the Times.
46:11 Amanda Dobbins? Sure, yeah.
46:12 Sean Fennessey? The Times definitely has documentaries. We did not do any nonfiction on this list.
46:17 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, I don't know. To me, from the moment I saw it, I was like, this is so fucking major. This like hit me right in the heart. And it does seem like the people who, like the real ones know.
46:27 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
46:28 Sean Fennessey? But it doesn't totally, I hope this will be like an act of celebration, preservation, whatever you want to call it.
46:34 Amanda Dobbins? So as well, it does tickle me a little.
46:37 Amanda Dobbins? I kept holding it close. Well, yeah, you know, I was like, I, I, I don't feel like this is celebrated enough. And so as all the other lists went by and people were sleeping on it, I was like, oh, we get to have this special moment.
46:49 Sean Fennessey? I agree. I agree.
46:50 Amanda Dobbins? Because I think it really is a special movie.
46:52 Sean Fennessey? I'm grateful that you can have that feeling without it feeling like you're pulling a trick or something, you know?
46:57 Amanda Dobbins? Right.
46:57 Sean Fennessey? I don't want to troll.
46:58 Amanda Dobbins? Well, that's, and that's why we switched it. It used to be a number two and now it's a number three.
47:01 Sean Fennessey? Now it's a number three. I feel good about that. Okay, so we mentioned Inside Man is what this is standing in for. I wrote down some other 21st century movies that are set in New York City.
47:10 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
47:10 Sean Fennessey? So Frances Ha, which came up in our Lady Bird conversation, of course. Good Time and Uncut Gems, the Safdie Brothers movies. I think if we were, if we were going to go to the next New York movie, I probably would have picked Uncut Gems. I, I, that probably, that's definitely in the like 25 to 30 range for me in terms of just like the most fun I've had with a movie.
47:28 Amanda Dobbins? I'm with it.
47:28 Sean Fennessey? Another version of living in New York is kind of the Uncut Gems anxiety.
47:31 Amanda Dobbins? 100% agree.
47:33 Sean Fennessey? If Beale Street Talk, Barry Jenkins's movie, which is a very good New York film, Synecdoche New York. Requiem for a Dream, which, you know, was kind of paired with this, a movie about drugs and paranoia.
47:43 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
47:45 Sean Fennessey? Did you write in Margaret?
47:46 Amanda Dobbins? I just put Margaret in. That's what I scrolled down, because just Anna Paquin being a nightmare teen.
47:50 Sean Fennessey? Oh, yeah. This was quite a run.
47:52 Amanda Dobbins? In New York.
47:52 Sean Fennessey? Yeah, right on the heel, right on the verge of true blood.
47:55 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
47:57 Sean Fennessey? And then drug dealer movies, like, I was never gonna put any of these movies on the list, but American Gangster, Traffic, Blow.
48:02 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
48:03 Sean Fennessey? There was an era from 2000 to 2010, especially during the rise of like a very specific kind of
48:10 Sean Fennessey? New York, East Coast centric era in hip hop.
48:12 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
48:13 Sean Fennessey? Where the glorification, the kind of scar facification of a certain kind of drug dealer movie was happening. This is not that.
48:21 Amanda Dobbins? No.
48:21 Sean Fennessey? This is a much sadder movie than that, but it is at least in relationship to it. So, speaking of recommended, if you like, a couple of titles. Carlito's Way, I think would be a great double feature with this movie.
48:32 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
48:33 Sean Fennessey? Brian De Palma's drug dealer movie about Al Pacino's character. Clockers, the Spike movie, which is also about drug dealers. Kind of the different side of that story, like, you know, black kids in the projects as opposed to a white kid working for the Ukrainians. Boys in the Hood, which is a movie about high school friendship and about how it can get broken up pretty quickly. Trainspotting, also a friendship movie centered around drugs. Midnight Express, the darkest version of this story. Once upon a time in America, people committing crime in New York. Midnight Cowboy. Anything else?
49:08 Amanda Dobbins? I always think about how Chris Ryan compares the ending of Lady Bird to this ending. They're very, very different movies in every single way, but since we had Lady Bird recently on our list, if you're into that, bring it on over.
49:21 Sean Fennessey? That's interesting.
49:21 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
49:22 Sean Fennessey? I guess there's something to that, that's sort of like the open-endedness.
49:25 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah, and the separation from reality and like what's actually happened and like the wishfulness or the wistfulness.
49:34 Sean Fennessey? Do you believe that Monty, while he is sleeping, is on his way to Otisville, or do you believe he's on his way to Albuquerque?
49:40 Amanda Dobbins? I think he's on his way to Otisville.
49:41 Sean Fennessey? I think so too.
49:42 Amanda Dobbins? Yeah.
49:42 Sean Fennessey? That's why you and I are cynics.
49:46 Sean Fennessey? Any closing thoughts? Feeling good about Three?
49:48 Amanda Dobbins? I love this film.
49:49 Sean Fennessey? Me too.
49:50 Amanda Dobbins? I mean, it's a gut punch in the best way, every time. But it's a treat to re-watch it.
49:55 Sean Fennessey? I agree. Was happy to talk to you about it. Thanks to our producer, Jack Sanders, for his work on this episode. Later this week, we have a post-Thanksgiving treat. We built the Robert Redford Hall of Fame with our friend Tracy Lutz.
50:07 Amanda Dobbins? We sure did.
50:08 Sean Fennessey? You did the work, he did the work.
50:10 Amanda Dobbins? He watched TV.
50:12 Sean Fennessey? He watched old TV episodes. And we did our best to build it. We've zagged a couple of times.
50:19 Amanda Dobbins? I feel fine.
50:20 Sean Fennessey? I feel good about it, too. We'll see you then.
Previous Best Picture Power Rankings and the Super-Sincerity of ‘Sentimental Value,’ With Joachim Trier! Plus: Regretting ‘Regretting You.’ Next The Robert Redford Hall of Fame Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated