Pod Insights Talking Wealth Podcast: Stock Market Trading and Investing Education | Wealth Creation | Expert Share Market Analysis Morgans’ Tips CBA to dive to $100: Are They Right? About this episode This week on Talking Wealth, Janine challenges the forecast set for CBA shares by Morgans and other major institutions - how low could this ASX banking giant really go? Janine examines the chart of CBA to determine whether these bearish predictions are genuine warnings or exaggerated calls designed to spark panic selling and boost broker profits? Where is the current fall likely to stop?
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 This podcast is brought to you by Wealth Within, a global leader in stock market education. For more information on our courses, head over to wealthwithin.com.au. Please note that the information in this podcast should not be considered personal financial advice. Enjoy.
0:20 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to Talking Wealth. This is Janine Cox, Senior Investment Analyst at Wealth Within. Today, I want to talk about a stock that is always in the limelight, and that's Commonwealth Bank. But recently, it's come under scrutiny of the industry and is being talked down. That's right. Does it ever happen in the stock market? Well, it'd be a fool to think not. This is what happens. The market tends to be moved up and down. Stocks tend to be moved in different directions based on whether a stock is considered overvalued, fair valued, or undervalued. And the brokers have a heavy hand in moving the direction of a lot of these shares at times. We know when turns are likely to occur
1:03 Speaker 01 in stocks based on technical analysis. History tells us that. We also know approximately the price when a stock is due to turn. And look, Commonwealth Bank has been a stellar performer in the market, but it too can have dramatic falls, just as any stock in the market can. So don't ever think that that's not the case just because you're investing in the top 20 shares or the biggest stocks in our market. They too follow a pattern. And that means that there will be stellar rises and there will also be significant falls. Now, CBA has been earmarked by a number of brokers that its value is really $100,
1:46 Speaker 01 that it's overvalued, and they expect the price should come back to closer to $100.
1:53 Speaker 01 Now, to me, I think that's bollocks, if I can use that word, I'd rather say a different word, but it really frustrates me how they talk stocks down and then they they may be getting frustrated themselves that a stock's sitting up there, they can't explain why a stock is just way overvalued from where they believe that the share should be, but in a bull market, this is what often happens. And then they set a price that could be the bottom end of their target and then an article articles start popping out everywhere saying this is what the shares are worth. And then, of course, in this market where it's AI driven, all of this information starts to get factored in and then the share gets sold off. So we're seeing a fall in Commonwealth Bank shares.
2:36 Speaker 01 They've talked about it for months that it's been overvalued. We're now seeing this dramatic fall. The technical analysis was telling you that Commonwealth Bank was going to come back. It started to be sold off from its high and now we're seeing a much more solid move down. We think it's great that stocks get sold down, but I can't stand it how the industry sit there, you know, waving their flag, whatever it is, red, white, whatever you want to call it, suggesting these ridiculous levels for stocks. We're not in a bear market. We are, the stock is due for a low, so we know the timing of it is is due.
3:19 Speaker 01 The question is how far could it fall and what does the technical analysis indicate? So the most important thing that you can do is not just react to whatever is being said in some of these articles. The most important thing you can do is actually do your analysis first. Have a look at the trend, has the trend been broken? Have, has it crossed trend lines, up trend lines? That's one of the first things that are really important to look at, to to see whether the stock's actually gone through one of these lines, which could indicate that it may fall further. You may or may not have read Dale's book, How to Beat the Managed Funds by 20%. That one tells you all about the trend lines.
3:59 Speaker 01 It gives you work through examples showing how trend lines were applied and how that preserved capital through the GFC. So that book was actually updated prior to the GFC when the market topped and turned and stocks started to fall over and it showed many exit signals. So if you haven't managed to get a copy of that book, make sure you do. You might even have read it yourself and think that it would be a good idea to share that information with some younger people in your family. It could be a good starting point for them to get them on the right step in managing risk. So that's what it is all about, it's managing that risk. And we see information like this come out all the time.
4:42 Speaker 01 Morningstar themselves released that information and some people look at an article and think, well, they must be right, they're a big reputable organisation. Now, I'm not saying that Commonwealth Bank, there's no possible way that it could come back to that level 100% certain. What I'm saying is that right now, the probability of it falling that far is low. And, you know, what could it come back to is the real question. Where is Commonwealth Bank likely to settle? Is it likely to be on the upper end of where they're expecting it to fall? Or is it likely to go all the way to that bottom? Now, if there was a situation where our market was coming into a big, long-term low,
5:24 Speaker 01 then I would say, yep, banks, like any stock, is going to be sold off 50 or 60% into some of these major declines that occur on our market periodically. But the chart's actually not indicating that. But first, before I actually go to the chart, I want to just have a look at this article. The Morningstar article says, "The largest share trading on the ASX remains materially overvalued. Profit barely budges on the most expensive bank in the world."
5:54 Speaker 02 Hey, podcasters. Are you looking for a practical and easy way to profit consistently from the stock market so you take control of your investments? Get Dale's bestselling book, How to Beat the Managed Funds by 20% for free, just pay shipping. It's packed with powerful, simple strategies that will give you the confidence and know-how to beat the managed funds by 20%. Visit the shop on the Wealth Within website and secure your copy today.
6:20 Speaker 01 Now, they actually released their first quarter fiscal 2026 profit of 2.6 billion, up 1% on the average of the previous two quarters. And it wasn't a bad result. But the share price is being sold down and the main argument is about their fair value. So it's always about forward earnings and what that means looking ahead. The market's not happy with these elevated PEs. Historically, I can recall going all the way back through to the GFC that banks were typically in the order of either single digits or double digits into the, you know, they might have been
7:00 Speaker 01 14, 15, 13, 18 at a high, but not in the 20s. Typically, PEs of this level were for more growth stocks like mining stocks. We've got a complete reverse in our market at the moment. We've got the big miners at levels where we would expect to see banks and the banks at levels where we would expect to see the miners. So, but the market's seeing the banks as the safer option and more certainty about future earnings. That's what the real issue is here. And so can banks be valued on the high end? Sure. I mean, the other banks in the market are not at PEs as high as what Commonwealth Bank has been.
7:45 Speaker 01 So the industry is saying, well, we've got to bring Commonwealth Bank back. But it is a market leader and it's considered a safer investment. But if an investment can fall 20, 30, 40%, any investment can fall that amount. Why does it make Commonwealth Bank safer than anything else? Well, it is a highly liquid stock, which means that when you buy and sell this, you're always going to be guaranteed of being able to get in and out of the share at a reasonable price, you know, but it can move swiftly at times as we've seen just recently. And we'll get to that shortly when we look at the chart. I had a bit of a look online to see what was being said about Commonwealth Bank.
8:31 Speaker 01 At the moment, it's trading around one hundred and fifty five. And it was trading right up as high as one ninety, right? So it's already come back quite away from that high. What's a reasonable percentage? Typically, when the market pulls back, we've been seeing twenty percent declines. So the more volatile the stock, the greater the decline. It's already back twenty percent. That's what the market usually looks for. Could it come back further? Well, yes, I mean, the technical analysis indicates that there's a high probability that the stock will be back between one forty and one fifty.
9:13 Speaker 01 They're trying to talk it down lower, but that's where it looks like it wants to sit. At that level, there's a really strong level of support underneath there. And that's come about due to a confluence of analysis and a whole lot of analysis put together to determine where the most likely level is for the support for Commonwealth's share price. Now, this may shock you when I'm talking to you about this because you'll be thinking, well, Commonwealth Bank was almost at two hundred dollars and they're talking it down to fifty percent of that pretty much.
9:50 Speaker 01 Nothing catastrophic has happened. Are they concerned about, are their delinquency rates increasing? Are we having issues with people paying their debt? We're in a market where the consumer discretionary stocks have been going through the roof. Consumer spending's improved. Generally, you see that side of the market tip first before the market eventually peaks. And we haven't, we've seen consumer discretionary stocks come off, but we're going through the month of November and we'll soon see what happens with like Friday and how spending goes through that period. We've had three interest rate cuts this year, which has helped consumers and helped fuel
10:36 Speaker 01 the rise of the market. So where could CBA be in six months' time?
10:43 Speaker 01 Well, that that level I mentioned is is probably pretty right. Now, if we look at what's being said online, they're talking about the scenarios for upside and scenarios for downside. So if we see the economy stabilize or improve in some way, and we can see that it's quite strong, and mortgage stress is being talked about as low, lending growth improves, and the bank interest margins are maintained, then we could see CBA's share price go up to 171. That's what it says online. Downside scenario, guess what? They've said
11:27 Speaker 01 140. It's interesting, which marries up with what I'm looking at for the the target that I've just mentioned to you before. So combining what is being said online with what we can see on the chart is the best way to look at things. But does that mean that you should be holding it for that pullback? And that really is dependent on what your timeframe was for the trade, what your strategy was, what you were aiming to achieve when you bought it, not about when you bought it. Because if you bought it at the wrong time, so you bought it based on all the hype and news about CBA continuing to move
12:11 Speaker 01 up, then that's not a good reason to decide, well, I'll just keep holding it in case until it comes back to my buy price. That could be fraught with danger, especially if something happens, catastrophic happens, that causes the stock price to fall further. So what where would we be if Commonwealth Bank did fall to around that hundred dollar mark? Let's I'm just having a look at the chart to see, you know, what what's that indicating? That would mean that serious angles of the trend would be broken. You know, like, these are formed over many, many years, these trends, especially on bank stocks.
12:55 Speaker 01 Because they tend to trade in very rhythmic movements, so there are cycles to the market, there are cycles to the individual stocks on the market. And these banks will unfold according to these predefined cycles. They might not hit the low exactly to the day that you expect, because there's always a number of months either side of where the low or high could form. But it's like having a map, almost with a technical analysis, that it provides a bit of a map as to where Commonwealth Bank or any bank is likely to unfold.
13:34 Speaker 01 Now, once the stock comes down and settles into wherever it's going to find support, then we'll know how far it's likely to rise from there. But there's likely to be a really good opportunity to pick up Commonwealth Bank in future if you've got some really good rules to take advantage of that. So now's the time, if you haven't done your analysis on Commonwealth Bank, to really nut that out and work out what are the best rules to pick up some shares in this stock. Now, we could see our market run on, and this stock could run on into 2026 and be making new highs, even though they're talking it down right now. Or it could fall into early 2026.
14:18 Speaker 01 There's two possible scenarios for that, for the way that Commonwealth Bank could unfold. But typically, if we go back over the history of the stock, let's look at how far it tends to fall, if, sorry, Paul, if we're not in a major decline.
14:34 Speaker 02 Hey, podcasters. Feeling stuck with your trading? Have you tried everything and still not making money? Learn to master the strategies that will ensure you achieve consistent, profitable returns. Head over to Wealth Within and learn how our trading courses have changed people's lives, and they'll change yours too. Like all our graduates, you'll be glad you did.
14:57 Speaker 01 And it doesn't have these major falls that some stocks have that you might expect. It tends to be fairly steady and stable most of the time, although it can fall thirty percent. So that's something just to bear in mind, that it's possible for Commonwealth Bank to come back thirty percent. So let's have a look and see where Commonwealth Bank would sit if it fell thirty percent from its high. And that would bring it down to around a hundred and thirty five dollars. So I think that, you know, currently my preferred level is somewhere around that one forty. You know, it might find support at one fifty, but at lower end. Downside from there would be closer to around one thirty five.
15:43 Speaker 01 In this current pullback, if it came back quite strongly from here. But we're not actually due for a bottom right now, which is really interesting. According to the overall analysis, we were due for a top sometime.
16:02 Speaker 01 From, and it probably came in reasonably close to where I was expecting the top to come in. So it was sometime this year. Ideally, it would have occurred in October, November. That was where we were expecting the top to happen, but it looks like it's come in earlier. So therefore, that, when we see the highs come in earlier, sometimes that can indicate that we're actually going to see another run. Strong push back up. And because CBA got through that one sixty, because some time ago, my target was for it to get through one sixty. Or to trade thereabouts. Then I thought, well, okay, two hundred or two twenties on the cards for Commonwealth Bank as a stretch target for the stock.
16:45 Speaker 01 So it may actually have to move down a little bit more before it can get to that level.
16:52 Speaker 01 What else is being said about the bank? It's below fair value.
17:00 Speaker 01 You know, it's, it, it, when it's compared to its peers, it's, um, performing has performed well compared to its peers, but may actually be, um, still overvalued relative to the other banks in the market at the moment. And what does fair value mean anyway? Fair value is the price at which a stock would be traded in order, in an orderly transaction between a willing buyer and seller at a specific point in time, representing an asset's intrinsic worth. Now, the, the funny thing about it is if, um, these big brokers have done their, um, quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis and determined that the banks are worth a certain figure of what I've noticed over times, depending on which bank is if it's Goldman
17:45 Speaker 01 Sachs that comes out with it or Morgan's, quite often, um, the stock falls away after they've made their announcement and we're seeing a lot of, um, copycat trading coming in and they're chasing it down before it then turns back up again. So expect that volatility to happen and it makes sense thinking that when investors are putting all their money into ETFs, they're handing over the ability to make, um, decisions to a smaller group of people than before, because previously when people were investing in individual shares, you would see more of a domino effect of things happening rather and investors would pile out at the bottom.
18:30 Speaker 01 So that's where we see these crashes unfold at the bottom. So it's going to be very interesting to me to watch as the market unfolds, to see how well, um, orderly and fair our market is maintained through this next couple of years.
18:48 Speaker 01 So basically, the fair value is an estimate and serves as a benchmark, I guess, to help investors decide whether a stock's overvalued or undervalued or fairly priced. So, you know, in this market, what do you believe? The thing that, the only thing that we can believe is what the chart is showing us and the probability that we get from that information. I think the rest of it, there is too many self, there are too many self-interests out there looking to profit from the information that they release. That's my view and I'm sticking with that.
19:28 Speaker 01 So how do you, as an investor, think about stocks like Commonwealth Bank? On the monthly chart, Commonwealth Bank, it takes a lot of the noise out of trading in this stock. And sometimes it's much easier to find a set of rules on the monthly chart to trade with than there is, than it is on the weekly chart. Of course, when we look at our backtesting for Commonwealth Bank, we might have on the monthly chart, three to five entries over the history of a stock, whether it's Commonwealth Bank or any, any bank, any stock. And then compare that to the weekly rules and we may have many more. It could be double or triple the number of trades that happen.
20:12 Speaker 01 And that's something to think about as well. Because if you're trading bank stocks or, or a stock in the financial sector, say, over the medium term and you're trading on the weekly chart, you have to think about the purpose of why you're trading on that weekly chart. Because you might be thinking that the analysis says that there could be a top any time soon, so you take a shorter term strategy on the stock than if you're thinking that it may run on and have a much significant, another significant rise in the short to medium term. Commonwealth Bank, there were people piling into that with a medium to long-term perspective
20:55 Speaker 01 right before it made its high, when we're saying we think that it would be good for more shorter term because of where the stock is. Now, that doesn't mean that someone who's thinking, okay, I've got some money here and I've put it into top 20 shares, I'm going to leave it for 10 years. You know, that you can do, but it may mean this close to the, we're only a couple, two to three years out potentially from a significant peak in our market, based on our current analysis. And therefore, it would mean that you would have to be in those stocks for the long term to ride out any potential significant downturn.
21:36 Speaker 01 It could be that the stocks that you've picked make significant gains prior to that peak coming in. So that gives you a bit of a buffer, but it really, the timing of when you invest can have a significant impact on your overall return. If you invest prior to a sideways market and it lasts for a couple of years, there was a period from 2021 through to early 2024 where Commonwealth Bank did nothing. It traded sideways all that time. That was three years of no capital growth. So if you invested during that time, then depending on whether you managed to pick it at a really, really low point, which it would have been catching a falling knife
22:18 Speaker 01 at the time, but if you bought it somewhere in the middle, then obviously, you know, you've made nothing for those three, four years that you purchased it for and had to ride it out. Now, from time to time, the big stocks do that. Wesfarmers did that. We've just seen the banks go through that. Rio and BHP had these sideways moves for quite a while and then BHP and Rio fell away more recently and then they've come off their lows. So, stocks will go through those sideways moves for the long term. And when they come out the other side of that, often they'll have a decent rise from there. And it's just making that judgment call, at which point do you start looking at this
23:00 Speaker 01 and saying, well, I'm no longer in buying shares for the long term. Maybe you add to your positions as you're building up your portfolio and you're saving certain amounts. And Commonwealth Bank is a good stock to be putting money into and it's going to be an even better stock to be investing money into once this pullback has finished unfolding, given the way that it's come off. 20% off the high already could be another 10% to the downside before it actually starts to find some support.
23:34 Speaker 02 Hey podcasters, are you curious to learn how you can gain more confidence with your trading? Check out the Australian Stock Market Show on YouTube every Tuesday night from 7 to 8pm. Discover how you can become a more successful trader and take your trading to another level. Get your most burning questions answered with Dale and Janine. We look forward to you joining us.
23:59 Speaker 01 So, you know, these are opportunities as well. It's not to say that, you know, in future, the rules that are used for this stock could change too. That's something that you might not have heard us talk about with backtesting. Over time, the backtesting strategy might change because at some point it may stop working. Through those sideways moves, that could be a real challenge to maintain a set of rules that work really well. And it may be that, once the stock peaks out and then pulls back, like we're seeing now, we may find that we've got to adjust the strategy for Commonwealth Bank going forward because now it's showing that a different set of rules is important. It could be because of
24:40 Speaker 01 where it is in its biggest cycle on the market that determines whether that's the case, or it could be because of the volatility that the stock experiences. So, but look at the moment, if we were to put a trend line on Commonwealth Bank, and I've just got my chart open here and I'm having a look at it, and I've drawn a trend line, if you can imagine this, all the way from October 2023. This is sort of near the bottom of that long-term sideways move I was talking about. We can apply a nice uptrend line underneath that rise. Now, this month, it's actually closing below so far. It doesn't mean that
25:20 Speaker 01 it will close at the end of the month below this level. It could, given the forecast for the downside. It's a possibility, but it may just go sideways around this level for a while. It might not be ready to make that low. Or it could make it really quickly and then reverse and then push back up again. But where is it then, once it's done that? It's going to be sitting underneath that medium to long term, well, it's actually a long term uptrend line. So the question is, you know, where, how do you make an assessment of that? Because it could rise up to that level and then hit it just as a bouncing ball.
25:59 Speaker 01 We watch a bouncing ball bounce on the trend line and that book, How to Beat the Managed Funds, explains that really nicely. And then when it crosses it and comes down, then these lines act as resistance to going back up again. So that's, that's where the, the next challenge lies is in then deciding, well, where is the appropriate entry? To pick up Commonwealth Bank after it's fallen away. So there's always the risk that the industry will call it lower and might try to push it lower. Remembering that some of these big funds, they're the ones controlling the stocks because they've got the, they've got huge volumes or huge value, if you like, whichever way you want to look at it.
26:43 Speaker 01 They've got huge quantities of shares that they're controlling. So they're much more able to create the volatility in the market than they were before. But of course, the ones that have mandates, so the funds that have mandates have to have, you know, like the industry, the, um, sorry, the index funds, they actually have to balance their investment according to the value of the, um, the weighting, if you like, and the value of the stocks in them. So if Commonwealth Bank's falling away, obviously that could give rise to them having to change their position at some point in Commonwealth Bank.
27:25 Speaker 01 But if they're just managing towards an index, they're just, it's sort of leveling out. It will, it will just balance itself out as time goes along. If they're, if they're, they have a specialty.
27:39 Speaker 01 ETF that actually has certain specifications about what they can invest in. Then of course, that's different. In the case of direct equities, if you're managing your own portfolio, then you're going to be using special rules to buy and sell a stock. You're not going to be concerned about the weightings of each individual share and rebalancing like a big fund might have to do. This is where you've got to set the criteria for your portfolio and how you're going to manage stocks like Commonwealth Bank. Some people do it when they go into the stock market. They start out and they've only got a small amount of money. They might have $10,000 and so they put maybe $2,000 into five different shares, as they'll talks about in that book.
28:23 Speaker 01 And then adds $2,000 with another different stock to that until they build up to between eight and 12 shares. That's a fairly low risk way of doing things because a fall like this on Commonwealth Bank then is not going to have a huge impact on your overall portfolio. But if you've got 40% of your portfolio in Commonwealth Bank, you only have to do a few calculations to understand what a 40 or 50% fall in Commonwealth Bank would be in terms of your overall portfolio and how that can affect the whole thing. Whereas if you had decided that you were going to manage this on rules, maybe you're going to manage it on a monthly trend line,
29:05 Speaker 01 which is not triggered yet, but it may do at the end of the month. And then money goes out of Commonwealth Bank. Then it frees up cash to put into another stock. So then you put it into the cash pool and wait until another stock triggers an entry. Or look at your Commonwealth Bank shares and maybe you'll get back in when Commonwealth Bank turns around again and have set rules for how you're going to add that back to your portfolio. So I really get annoyed when the industry talks stocks down based on whether something is fair value. Because Commonwealth Bank is a very strong company, doing really well. Are we seeing a lot of mortgage stress?
29:49 Speaker 01 There's always going to be mortgage stress and what they choose to focus on will justify their own position when they're taking one about our financial industry or any bank. But I strongly suggest if you haven't invested in yourself and learnt how to analyse stocks that you do, because it's going to be increasingly more important as we go through the next couple of years, not just from shares that you're holding, but also for decisions that you're going to be making about your own super, which many super funds give you the flexibility to make those choices, not just switching out of one fund and into another, but in terms of having a platform so that you can invest in direct equities. And they
30:31 Speaker 01 might have restrictions on how you can do all that, so it's important that you understand it. Some clients talk to us about self-managed super funds, whether to do that. Obviously, we can't give advice about that, but it's really important that you do your research on the ATO's website for that. You may decide to invest in banks in your super fund. That's really good strategy because they provide that income and capital growth. I'm Janine Cox, Senior Analyst at Wealth Within. I hope you've enjoyed my discussion today. Bye for now.
31:03 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to our Talking Wealth podcast. For more exclusive content covering topics like the stock market, real estate, business, performance and psychology and more, check out talkingwealth.com today.
Previous 8 ASX Tech Stocks Just Hit Rock Bottom: Time to Buy Next Mechanical vs Discretionary Trading in 2026: What Wins Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated