Pod Insights Talking Wealth Podcast: Stock Market Trading and Investing Education | Wealth Creation | Expert Share Market Analysis Is BHP or RIO the Hottest Materials Play in 2026? About this episode This week on Talking Wealth, Janine dives into one of 2026’s hottest investment debates: which Materials heavyweight is set to outperform —BHP or RIO? With both miners poised for a pivotal year, she breaks down the catalysts, and shares what savvy investors should be watching. Should you back one or is owning both the smarter play?
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 This podcast is brought to you by Wealth Within, a global leader in stock market education. For more information on our courses, head over to wealthwithin.com.au. Please note that the information in this podcast should not be considered personal financial advice. Enjoy.
0:20 Speaker 01 Hello and welcome to Talking Wealth. I'm Janine Cox, Senior Analyst at Wealth Within. Well, I hope you're having a great start to the year. We're looking at some really interesting stocks today. BHP and Rio, of course, they're probably on the top of your list in terms of your medium term or even short to medium term portfolio. Some of you have been going for the miners because you're wanting dividend stocks. We did a show last year on the dividend stocks, big miners, and I urge you to have a look at past shows and just see how stocks have unfolded since. Well, for this particular week, we want to
1:01 Speaker 01 dive into one of 2026's hottest investment debates, whether it should be BHP leading the way or Rio Tinto. Both miners are poised to have a pivotal year in 2026. What are the catalysts? Should you back one or own both, which is a smarter investment, I guess, is the thing for 2026. People will be watching out for some of the material stocks next year with some interesting opportunities afoot. Now, first of all, obviously predominantly our analysis is on technical analysis. However, we do look at the fundamentals to understand
1:42 Speaker 01 where the stocks sit in terms of their P/E ratio, EPS, dividend yield and debt situation. As far as Rio and BHP are concerned, they're obviously linked tightly to the commodities cycle, in particular commodities like iron or copper, aluminium, lithium.
2:05 Speaker 01 There are, these are really key commodities for our big miners. And the way that they're valued can be slightly differently if you're looking at the fundamentals, depending on who you read. P ratios of the miners in recent years have been a lot lower than what we would historically see. So generally in the past, in a bull market, you would typically see the miners up in the twenties, if not more. And dividends would be typically quite low, whereas right now we've got the reverse situation. We've, we've had the reverse situation, I should say, with the miners having low P ratios in recent years, paying significant dividends versus their historical figures.
2:50 Speaker 01 So it was always that banks paid market average, miners and growth type stocks paid less than that, or paid a much higher dividend generally if they were trying to attract investors into their investment. And often these investments would be falling. I'm not talking about BHP and Rio in that scenario where the dividends are extremely high, talking about stocks that represent much higher risk. And therefore that's why they're offering the dividend at those levels. So BHP's been our big stock on our market. There's been a bit of a tussle between Commonwealth Bank and BHP over the years. And it changes from time to time.
3:34 Speaker 01 We saw Commonwealth Bank continue to grow its share price over many months. It's having a bit of a pullback and it'll be interesting to watch in 2026 to see how CommBank goes, but banks are likely to have a good run in 2026. Back to what's happening with BHP. We know that with BHP, its dividend yield has dropped recently because its share price has risen. So you've just got to watch out for that timing. And often when P ratios.
4:10 Speaker 01 I guess mismatched to what you'd expect to see. So if you if you're seeing low double digit P ratios or single digit P ratios even, that can often signal a potential gain ahead unless the stock is in freefall. And then it's really important to be watching that and not trying to second guess where stocks are going. But in the case of BHP, Rio and FMG, their P ratios have been a lot lower than what historically we would expect them to be. But we are starting to see that change there. We are starting to see
4:50 Speaker 01 more normal, if you like, a scenario for the the big miners. So if we have a look at the dividend yields, I mean, that's another important criteria. You've got to be looking at to see, you know, are you buying for yield or are you buying for growth or are you buying for both? Generally miners would be a growth play. And so what we're going to find is when these stocks change and they start to move higher and the dividend yields drop off, the dividend investors are going to be looking at these stocks thinking, well, you know, I can get better interest in the bank. But you're going to miss out on that capital growth as
5:31 Speaker 01 well, which that's got to be factored into the whole equation, not just the dividend yield, but what's your upside upside potential? You can't just have one without the other and ignore one side of the equation altogether and not even consider risk when you're looking at the dividend yield. That's just fraught with danger, especially on smaller stocks, not so much on the bigger ones, but on the smaller ones. And I'd urge you to to go back and have a look at the historical price charts of BHP and Rio and see what happened during the GFC. It's important to understand the what could happen on the downside if there's a big sell off at some point in the
6:14 Speaker 01 future, which historically, you know, it is cyclical and it does happen over and over again. And we've seen in the GFC, if we look at what occurred with BHP, we can see that BHP fell in the order of around 60%.
6:33 Speaker 01 Now, that was probably pretty close to the market average at the time. The all lords had fallen fifty five, around fifty five percent during that time. Rio Tinto, though, fell significantly more. And that's where a lot of people were taken by surprise. They had no idea that Rio could even fall by that amount. What was really interesting was that when its share price fell, it actually came back to a previous level of support. So I would, if you've been thinking about learning more about charting and how stocks move and better times to buy and sell, it's really important that you have a look
7:15 Speaker 01 at what we teach and learn how to set important levels on a stock. And also to understand what it means when a stock goes to blue sky. How high could it go? Where might Rio and BHP trade to in the future? So when I'm looking at Rio, I can see from its, there was some highs. There was a high in July 2021 and another in around January 2024. Now, that level of resistance is really important going forward. So not only was it resistance, but it has a potential to provide support in future.
7:57 Speaker 01 And also it gives us a bearing to understand how far could Rio rise from that level, for example. Now, looking at where I see Rio going forward, there's a potential for Rio to trade to around one hundred and sixty five, maybe one hundred and seventy dollars. And further than that, it could trade up closer to around one ninety. So in terms of the short term view, it's more or less around that sixty five, one seventy. It's probably short to medium term, depending on how you set a timeline for that. BHP, if we go and look at the chart of BHP.
8:42 Speaker 01 I can see that BHP's had a very similar unfolding to Rio. In fact, we can overlay a chart of BHP and Rio in our software. And when we look at that, it's quite incredible that the two follow each other. We know that over time, you know, they've had decent exposure to iron ore. And that has influenced their trajectory over time. However, looking at the way that they're unfolding more recently, Rio has actually led or appears to have gone ahead of BHP.
9:23 Speaker 01 Now, it's all relative. So if we look at the low that BHP had in March 2025, and then we look at the low that Rio had around that time and after that, because of course, one thing to consider is that Rio actually kept falling. So it actually continued down into June 2025, whereas BHP made a bottom and it came off that that low. Now, in the case of Rio, we know that its share price rose.
9:57 Speaker 01 If I just bring that up on my chart, it's around 40% from the low that occurred in early 2025. We go to BHP and it's really interesting to see that BHP rose in December to around 38, let's say 40% as well, close to 40%, probably closer to 38. But it was interesting to see both stocks move very similarly off their lows, even though Rio Tinto made a new all time high and BHP hasn't yet. Does that mean that BHP has the potential to rise further percentage wise than than Rio?
10:41 Speaker 01 Yes, it it does from the from the low if we're marking it from the low in early 2025. If I'm looking at the recent high that was formed on BHP though, and I'm considering that as a level of resistance and roughly if we look at where Rio is relative to where my targets are and where BHP has formed and maybe we take the high for the month, we can see that around the important levels are around 14%. So I did say on the show recently, I thought BHP could go to at least 52.
11:21 Speaker 01 And there's also a really important level at around 56 or 57 dollars and then another at around 62. So there are similar sorts of ranges. So the one at around 56, 57 is around 24% up and the one above that is around 34 or 35%, depending on exactly where you start, where your starting point is. But I aim to take it from the top of of the high in December. So there's really two good ranges there that indicate potential upside for BHP and
12:06 Speaker 01 the same sort of thing for Rio. So I I don't think they're any different. I I can't see them diverging from what historically has been a norm for decades, at least three, anyway, four.
12:23 Speaker 01 Have they followed similar trajectories, although at times they might fall slightly out of step. One might fall more than the other, one might rise slightly more than the other. But I guess it's also that risk that I was talking about before that is important to consider that we have seen higher volatility on Rio and BHP at times when we're comparing them to each other. And the actual pattern and the way that they unfolded into the 2016 low was different also. So with BHP, it actually made a new low below the GFC low.
13:04 Speaker 01 So when BHP bottomed for the GFC, when the GFC hit, it was late 2008 and it actually has taken that out when it pulled back in 2016. Now, we use all of the different moves on a stock to help us determine where a stock's likely to travel in future. So it is important, if BHP moves differently to Rio at times, because there may be some levels along the rise that could be slightly different from one stock to the other. But in terms of the
13:42 Speaker 01 overall, it looks pretty consistent, looking at where BHP and Rio could run. And so I'm suggesting that both of them could have decent rises still to come. And also that the upside is obviously the dollar value is different. So in the case of BHP over time, different corporate actions have changed the value of BHP. So Rio, no, not so much. It's share prices in the hundreds. BHP is less than that. Does that make BHP more popular for
14:22 Speaker 01 mums and dads? Yes, probably it does, because there's still this psychological issue around a stock that's traded through the hundred dollar level, even though we have more stocks that have traded above that level over time. I can remember when, I think it was CSL, they did a share split, or, and I think, yeah, they did a share split to reduce the value of the stock. Below a certain level, once it got to $100, I think that's what happened. But Rio and BHP are two different stocks in the sense that its appeal, in terms of their appeal to mums and dads investors, when psychologically people are thinking about,
15:07 Speaker 01 well, hang on, Rio's more expensive because it's trading at around, it's trading in well in excess of $100, whereas BHP trades well below that. In fact, it's been trading between 40 and 50. So, you know, that can factor in in terms of the, I guess, interest or demand into a stock at the consumer level or investor level. But that's totally irrelevant at the institutional level. Institutional level are more looking for valuations and what that means to the share price. So I've, I've gone and looked up some information on valuations of BHP and Rio and what the marketplace are thinking about the stocks.
15:54 Speaker 02 Hey, podcasters. Are you curious to learn how you can gain more confidence with your trading? Check out the Australian Stock Market Show on YouTube every Tuesday night from 7 to 8 p.m. Discover how you can become a more successful trader and take your trading to another level. Get your most burning questions answered with Dale and Janine. We look forward to you joining us.
16:19 Speaker 01 If we look at where BHP is at the moment, if we're looking at the, because BHP has actually been trading close around that 40, 40 odd dollar mark, as I said, its market capitalization is approximately 230 billion. And of course, by the time you hear this podcast, it could be different to that. The P/E, and so could some of these metrics. The P/E ratio was at 16.8 at the time of this recording, and the forward P/E is lower
16:57 Speaker 01 than that. So there are, the market are expecting the P/E ratio to fall. Dividend yield around 3.6% and earnings per share 2.7 or $2.70.
17:14 Speaker 01 So the the average 12 month price target for BHP, they're suggesting is 4320, which recently it's gone past that. So it's interesting to see the valuation come in. So of course, what the brokers do is once the stocks hit these levels and trade through them, then they'll stick a hold hold on the stocks or change their status from maybe buy or accumulate to hold until the data is updated and they've got more information and then the stocks will be rerated.
17:55 Speaker 01 Now, in saying that, the highest target that valuation on the share price was around $49. So that's right up near that all time high. So just so that you can understand, BHP's had an all time high
18:13 Speaker 01 of around 584, pretty close to that. Rio high was in December, so it's the recent high. And its high was 14353, I believe. So recent market commentary has been suggesting that BHP is priced at a fair or neutral level and not cheap and not rich. So it's not overpriced and it's not undervalued. And they're suggesting that there's modest upside potential.
18:54 Speaker 01 Dividend returns are an important factor for BHP for the popularity of the stock. That's what I was talking about before. So that's nothing new to us, we know that.
19:08 Speaker 01 And in terms of growth potential, they're looking at earnings projected to grow at around 4.1%.
19:15 Speaker 01 And the return on equity, they're saying is pretty healthy.
19:21 Speaker 01 Means that they're using the capital efficiently, so they're suggesting 17.7%.
19:28 Speaker 01 Now, they're saying that revenue expansion is slow. I don't know if we're going to see a change to that. We know that there's been a lot of controversy around deals between our miners and certain countries, including China, which will have a bearing on their profitability going forward. So we really need to keep an eye on that space. That's no secret. So BHP's critical minerals and copper, they're expanding demand, their investment on copper. Now, if we go and look at what I was checking before,
20:07 Speaker 01 which is Rio Tinto, Rio Tinto was trading around, at the time of this valuation, around 140, 143 market capitalization, just under 200 billion, and the PE ratio at around 12 or 13, so slightly lower than BHP. Dividend yield, 4% to 5%, and the forward PE slightly lower, indicates earnings expectations are stable. So that's what they're looking for, to see those healthy PE ratios and for them not to be marching away. If they're actually forecast to fall
20:48 Speaker 01 slightly, that's could be a good indication. So they're suggesting a value for Rio around 132, so below current levels, not necessarily suggesting that it's really overvalued, not suggesting it's undervalued either, because it's somewhere in the middle. It's a similar sort of scenario with BHP. It's sort of in some sort of happy medium, but that doesn't mean the share price won't fall, where they could come back temporarily before they move up again.
21:24 Speaker 01 Now, broker targets have varied a lot on Rio, which is interesting, because Rio's punched through the upper
21:34 Speaker 01 Um, upper end of that. So that's something that's to me is really quite positive. The fact that it hasn't been shy to get to those levels. Now, a more bullish scenario is indicating one hundred and ninety two. So when I look at what I'm suggesting on B H, on Rio, I had around twenty percent to my next target on Rio, one hundred and sixty seven, and around thirty eight or thirty seven percent at one hundred and eighty, eighty eight. So that's pretty close to that one ninety odd level that's been suggested. So that's what the technical analysis indicates. We just, the, the thing is, we need to continue to review these as price,
22:18 Speaker 01 more information on the price chart continues to unfold. It's not a static thing. I think that's one thing that people become confused about is just like more fundamental information comes to the for, to the forefront and that's used to then update, um, forecast. The same thing with technical analysis. If the chart does, if there's something forms on the right hand side of the chart that we weren't expecting, then we've got to review the way that the stock's unfolded and then make adjustments to that. So it's always about factoring it in the right hand. What we're suggesting is the most probable scenario at the time.
22:59 Speaker 01 But we just keep factoring in that information as we go forward, which is good, a good thing. A static forecast is basically useless. So the, I don't really understand why people get hung up on, well, you know, he said that the stock was likely to reach this level, or she said the stock was likely to reach this level, different level. Whether it's with the fundamentals that I've just read out, or whether it's with the technical approach, both need to be fluid so that we get a more current perspective on what the stocks are likely to do. Now, dividend returns, um, are higher, appear higher with Rio,
23:41 Speaker 01 but that obviously changes as the stock price moves. So you just need to keep an eye on that. If the income is something that's a priority for you. It may be that there are rules that you could use that allow you to take advantage of the dips in the share price to be able to buy either of these stocks at a better opportunity. And people are often surprised that a monthly chart can give really good entry rules on stocks like these that potentially could get you in earlier. So it's not just about using backtested strategies. There's a whole lot of different analysis that goes
24:21 Speaker 01 into making a, creating a forecast and also creating a strategy to use to buy and sell shares. But it's, it is important to understand how to do a good back test and how to do that so that you know that it's accurate, that when you're looking at the result, that it's reliable. Because it's basically useless if you, other than, you know, whatever, however the rules have been applied, more shorter term, but over the longer term, that's where the backtesting is really important. And the accuracy of it is, you know, you want to know that when you're applying analysis, you know how to identify the rules properly
25:05 Speaker 01 on the chart, not just assuming that, oh, you know, trying to copy what we've applied to a chart, for example, or what you've read in a book. It doesn't work that way. You really need that support and that encouragement and just the inside perspective on how to apply them in different circumstances. Because the bars on the chart, believe it or not, can look different at different times and decisions need to be made from a point of knowledge rather than from a point of a guess, if you like.
25:40 Speaker 02 Hey, podcasters. Are you trading the share market but want to take your knowledge to another level? Dale's award-winning book, Accelerate Your Wealth, will get you there. Learn to master the stock market with trading strategies that will exceed your expectations. Secure your copy now by visiting the shop on the Wealth Within website.
26:01 Speaker 01 So we've looked at fundamentals on BHP and Rio. We've looked at the technicals and what could happen. We know that there's always some headwind that can happen with mining companies. There could be issues that relate to the contract prices that they're able to secure. There can be issues with the underlying commodity prices. There can be challenges with managing the day-to-day activities. So the danger, safety's a big one in the mining industry. We'd like to see, you know, no reports about any incidents and accidents.
26:43 Speaker 01 That can have a short-term effect, although lesser than, say, for example, the, any outcome from a court case or something that's going on. The corporate action can have an impact if the industry are not happy. Because, let's face it, institutions occupy a large percent of the real estate or the shareholding these days because you've basically, I'm not saying you, because you might be the smart one, the smart ones and be investing directly in the stocks. But there's a lot of people who have skipped the step of learning the knowledge to jump into ETFs that don't understand it.
27:28 Speaker 01 So we're going to see the same sort of thing happen when the GFC scenario unfolds in the future, whatever that is, it won't be called a GFC or potentially it would be called something else. But when we see major market corrections in future, people will still not be lacking the information or the knowledge that they need to be able to make really good, informed risk management decisions about their investments. And we'll basically be flying blind. So, but look, with BHP and Rio, you can see over time that they can be volatile stocks. They tend to be, because they're in the top 20, tend to be a bit safer than picking other material stocks.
28:11 Speaker 01 But in saying that, you should still have a look at some of the smaller material stocks to see whether there are opportunities there. And there are. There are opportunities in all different sectors in the material space. So it may not be copper stocks that you're looking for, it could be you're looking for aluminium, it could be that you're looking for lithium, it could be that you want to stick with gold stocks. So BHP Rio Fortescue is another one, it's good to have, sometimes it's good to have a
28:45 Speaker 01 all three, or you might decide to have two of the big ones and a couple of the mid cap stocks. We've got big ones like South 32 and there's Pilbara Minerals in there, good top 100 stocks. And you might even pick a few more speculative ones, a couple, the odd one or two here and there, depending on how many stocks you want to have with exposure to this space. So Lioness was another one that took off Pilbara Minerals. So some of these stocks will pull back and provide more opportunities in 2026 for you to be able to profit from those. So make sure that you're prepared, that you're able to do some analysis.
29:29 Speaker 01 And even if you've done our Trading Mentor course, you actually have an understanding of the broader picture of how to look at stocks, how to look at their fundamentals from a really simplistic point of view, how to apply some technical analysis, including a strategy that I always use when I'm doing my back testing, it's the first one that I use. In fact, someone asked me something the other day through our trading support service about what I look for, and it's usually always that strategy first. If I can get a high enough result from that, that I know that with a bit more analysis, I can come up with a really good approach to trading that stock.
30:12 Speaker 01 So that's something that you've got to look for, is whether you want to start out small when you're learning and start off on a, say a course like the Trading Mentor course, or whether you know that you're going to be serious about it, you're going to want to generate an income from it, and therefore you're more likely to be on the short course or the diploma course. And look, let's face it, if you're going to do the short course, You've got to talk to someone about the funding options to do the diploma. If you really want to do more and you know that you want to do more, but maybe it's the financial side in the way. Just maybe there's a way to get around it, weigh up the cost of that, fully understand it.
30:54 Speaker 01 If you want to just dip your toe in the water, that's fine too. But I wouldn't be without modules four and five of the diploma. It's so important to know how to not just buy and sell a share and have good rules, but also know how high could the stock rise or how far could it fall? And I've just done an example with BHP and Rio. And I guess when we come down to it, the questions that were asked at the start, you know, are they buys right now? I still like BHP, Rio's just pushed to a new old time high. You know, I'd be waiting for that one to pull back. The other side of it is, do you have both?
31:36 Speaker 01 And there are times when you might decide to have both if the risk and the reward actually balance out. So sometimes it may be that the projected profit potential is not there to justify the risk that you might take when trading it. So it's about working out that equation and then making that decision. And sometimes it could be that you pick one of the two big ones and a mid cap or one of the two big ones, a mid cap and a small one and have three. So that you've got some exposure to that space. It may be materials across the board. It may not be any of the ones that I've mentioned in terms of the ones outside of BHP and Rio.
32:19 Speaker 01 You may have other stocks that you like to get involved in. And there are, there are loads of these things.
32:28 Speaker 01 So even stocks that are up and coming that could be interesting going into the future. You may be, you may have found some on the chart that are producing interesting patterns that you like. And you've seen us talk about that on the show. Just that little bit more knowledge that you need could make all the difference to be able to, to trade those stocks really well and manage your risk in them. Because remember what an individual can do is be much more nimble than any major fund could ever be. And you don't have the constraints that you might have.
33:04 Speaker 01 If in a fund, a fund will have constraints like an index fund obviously tends to be flattened out compared to the the growth potential that you can get on individual stocks. I think we've shown that on the show before and how that works. And so I wish you all the best with studying material stocks, in particular BHP and Rio. I hope you've enjoyed my discussion today. I've certainly enjoyed reviewing BHP and Rio. I'm Janine Cox, Senior Analyst at Wealth Within. Bye for now.
33:36 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to our Talking Wealth podcast. For more exclusive content covering topics like the stock market, real estate, business, performance and psychology and more, check out talkingwealth.com today.
Previous Your Success Today Depends on Your Consistency Next We Asked ChatGPT How to Day Trade: This is Our Take Page updated November 6, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated