Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk More Than a Few Qs About this episode Today, a passel of Q&A: 3:07 Understanding Active vs. Passive Management 5:43 Exploring Callable and Non-callable CDs 9:06 Investing Strategies for Young Couples 13:32 Navigating Investment Options for Retirement 18:06 Customizing a Target Date 529 Fund 22:23 Roth Conversions and Tax Implications Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:04 Speaker 00 Reality Radio for a really great future. We're talking real money.
0:09 Speaker 01 Well, look what happens. I let Tom and Roxy do a Q and A last week and your questions just flooded in at TalkingRealMoney.com on the little contact us form there. Got a bunch of them. Thank you for most of them. Not all of them, but thank you for most of them. Hi, everybody. I'm Don McDonald. Welcome to the question and answer edition of Talking Real Money, which is something that happens on Fridays. Generally, we try to do a Q and A on Fridays. Sometimes we'll do others. I do most of them from your questions that you have spoken when you hit the contact form at TalkingRealMoney.com. It's really,
0:53 Speaker 01 really easy to do. It's so much easier than making a phone call even. You just go to TalkingRealMoney.com, hit the contact us button, and then look for the mic, and then you record your question using the mic on your computer, or on your tablet, or on your phone, or whatever you have. So, try it. It works really well. In fact, to show you how well it works, here's a question.
1:14 Speaker 02 Good morning, Don. I was wondering about this AVG you keep recommending. I looked it up, and it says that it's actively managed. Is that something we want? I know you're against active managed funds. Could you help us out here? Thank you.
1:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, I will. Okay, it's not... It's all in how you define active. And we define active a little bit differently than Avantis and Dimensional define what they do. They... To them, passive means...
1:51 Speaker 01 Not doing anything. And see, for us, passive kind of includes everything from index funds to funds that are rules-based, that aren't trying to actively predict the future. And that's really the word, the qualifier that we probably need to use more often is actively predict. The traditional definition of active management has been actively trying to pick the right stocks, the right sectors, to get in at the right time, to get out when the wrong time is approaching, to try to time the market, to predict future trends, that
2:33 Speaker 01 kind of thing. That's what we believe active management is. Now, Avantis and Dimensional don't follow a strict index, so they don't, they can't be called index funds because they're not. But they just dislike the term passive, because there is some activity involved, but it's not picking. It's based on rules. They overweight to small companies. They overweight to value-oriented stocks. And they have certain criteria that those stocks must meet to be included in the portfolio. If they don't meet them, they're not included. It's a disciplined, rules-based approach that these two groups take, but it is a far
3:14 Speaker 01 cry from what we think of as active and have thought of for so long, and that is the picking of stocks. Thanks for the question. It's a good one. Yes, we do like AVGE and Avantis Funds and the DFA Funds. And by the way, to the person who wrote the review, we don't get anything from those guys. We get nothing from Avantis or Dimensional Funds. We just like the academic tilts that are built into them. Yes, they are more expensive than index funds.
3:45 Speaker 01 You're paying that for those rules that make it more complicated to buy and manage the fund to buy and sell the securities. So, thank you very much for your question. And you see, it worked really well. Now let's go to the next one.
3:58 Speaker 03 Hi, guys. Thanks for everything you do. I enjoy listening to your show a lot. My question is about callable CDs and non-callable CDs. If I wanted to find right now, the highest non-callable CD rate for two years, let's say, where would I go? I use Fidelity right now, and I can look on the Fidelity site and find what Fidelity offers, but I'm trying to see even outside of Fidelity, which is the main company I use for investing, what kind of rates I may be able to find. So, the question is, where can someone go online right now to find the highest non-callable
4:41 Speaker 03 CD for one year, or in my case, I really want two years? Thanks so much.
4:46 Speaker 01 Well, I don't know of one central clearinghouse where you can find all of the brokered CDs out there, because these are all done between the banks and the brokerage firms with whom they work. And because it's a finite supply usually, so they'll take them to one firm or a couple of firms and say, here, sell these many millions of dollars worth of CDs for us because we need to raise some capital. And we'll pay a slightly higher rate than we're going to pay the customers who come in through the door, and they also give a little bit to the brokerage firm for doing it. Now, I use Schwab because I have an account at Schwab. Now, I've looked in the past, and the yields at Schwab are competitive with the yields
5:31 Speaker 01 at Fidelity and the yields elsewhere. However, I found the best list, the most robust, the largest list of brokered CDs, both callable and non-callable. And by the way, the difference is, if you get a callable CD and rates go down, the bank can take that CD away from you, even though it's a two or three-year term. So, they're going to pay you more now, but if rates go down, you've got the risk of losing that high return. Something to be aware of. But I found that Vanguard's list was amazing. It was huge. I found hundreds, if not a couple thousand. CDs at various maturities.
6:15 Speaker 01 So go into Google, type Brokered CDs Vanguard, and it'll bring up a general page and then there's a button where you can, you can look at the general yields that they have. And you can go into more specifics, just click on the more details button and you can look for specific issues. But it'll give you the highest yield. You can get the highest yield on a similar page at Schwab and at Fidelity and you're going to find that they're going to be very competitive with each other. There might be slight differences day to day, but it's not generally, at least, at least not from my research, big enough to make it worth all the trouble.
6:54 Speaker 01 Particularly in terms of a disciplined approach where you're doing a ladder or something. But check Vanguard out, it was a great resource. And that gets us through a couple of calls, but we have many more because we have a lot of them piled up. So this is going to be, I think the most calls, questions we've taken in a Friday Q and A podcast. Let's go to the next one.
7:13 Speaker 04 Hey, Tom and Don, my name is Joel. Been listening to you guys for about a year. Tried to meet up in Chilean, but our paths didn't quite cross. Do look forward to meeting you guys and seeing you at retire meet in February. My wife and I will be attending and my parents will be joining us as well. I have a question. I'm 37 years old, as is my wife. We have about $360,000 saved in our retirement funds thus far. We're maxing out our 401ks each year for both her and myself. We're self-employed in a small business and we do have a 401k through a company called Guideline. We have limited choices in Guideline and with some old funds for retirement, we've already switched it all over to AVGE
7:53 Speaker 04 with our fidelity stuff. At Guideline, there's some really good choices, but none of them would be a total market equivalent like AVGE. Instead, they have US and international split up. So I kind of have two questions for you and keep in mind, I did take your risk quiz. I scored 82. And group five, if that helps you. The question is, first of all, should I have any bonds? I think I've heard you say that at our relatively young age, a investor willing to take on risk may not need bonds yet at this point. And that would be my hope at this point. And certainly would like to know when I should start folding some bonds into my portfolio. And question number two is US or domestic versus international? In some sense, I want to buy the market like AVGE,
8:39 Speaker 04 but also I'm OK with having some home country bias, a little bit at least toward the US. So I'm thinking an 80 20 split, maybe 75 25 or even 70 30, which I think would still have some home country bias built into it. But curious what you would say to that. Lastly, the funds that I would be picking from at guideline are VTIAX for the international, a total international, and then VTSAX for the total US market. Thanks again. Look forward to your input.
9:09 Speaker 01 Hey, Joel. Yeah, I remember. Sorry to have missed you out there. We had so much stuff going on because there was family and friends and all these things going on. So, but yeah, we'll see what retire me. Now, you've got a lot of moving parts here in this question. Bonds, do you need them with your risk quiz score? No, I wouldn't even consider them, not yet. You need them when you start worrying more about market declines. When you start thinking, oh, my gosh, if the market goes way down, this could now affect my long-term future more. When you're in this phase of life, you're accumulating. So you should love market declines.
9:51 Speaker 01 When you get to withdrawals, then you start to hate market declines. But when you're buying, some people hate them, but they shouldn't. When you're putting money away, you should be so excited when the market goes down a lot. So no, no bonds now. Oh, I, OK. US international, 70 30 would be the most I would do US. You're going to love the fact that you have a sizable portion of international stocks someday, I believe. I truly believe that because it's happened before.
10:35 Speaker 01 During the 2000s, if you had international, you did pretty well. If you had just US, you lost money. If, you know, back in the 70s, you heavily invested in Japan like so many did. It took forever to recover from that.
10:56 Speaker 01 I think that's the least amount of global diversification you should have. If you went 60-40, I'd be happier, but 70-30, that'd be great. Uh, let's see, is there anything else I missed? Uh, VTIAX and VTSAX? Perfect. Perfect. Great options. Having a small cap value? Awesome. Yeah, I'm with you. You're doing great. You're going to have a comfortable retirement if you keep doing what you're doing. I just don't see how you could miss. Don't see how you can miss. Thanks so much for being a part of the show and we'll see you at retire meet.
11:34 Speaker 01 That's coming up really soon. And let's grab another call question online thing like this.
11:43 Speaker 05 Hi, Donna and Tom. This is Mike from Minnesota, longtime listener and an occasional caller. Today I have a question for you relating to my fiance's finances. Now, just a little more context. My fiance and I are both in our 60s. I just recently retired and she is semi-retired. Now, next month, she's going to receive a payoff on a previous property she owned and she financed them on a contract for deed. The payoff amount is $270,000. She's looking for some advice on an investment vehicle for this $270,000. There's a couple of different options and I would like to get your input.
12:25 Speaker 05 The first option is to just take the $270,000, put it in a relatively safe investment vehicle and draw $3,000 per month to supplement her current income. Now, if she were to choose this option, do you have any investment vehicles in mind? Whether it be a balanced index fund, a high-yield savings, or potentially a money market?
12:53 Speaker 05 Now, option two, and this might not happen for a year or two, would be for her to invest this money in a recreational lake property somewhere in Minnesota. Now, that money would need to be a little bit more liquid than if she were to choose option one, knowing that if we found the right property, that money would have to be available to purchase the property. Now, if you have any investment recommendations in mind, investment vehicles, we'd appreciate to know what those might be, whether it be a balanced index, a money market, a high-yield savings, or something else. Thanks, I'll look forward to your replies.
13:34 Speaker 01 Oh, there's so much more I need to know. I need so much more information. Uh, let's just start with the basics. In a vacuum, it's hard to tell you, or her, what she should do with the money, because we need to know more about the other monies and what her needs are, what her needs are right now and then going forward. Now, you mentioned the $3,000 per month in a safe vehicle. That leads me to believe that she needs $3,000 a month right now.
14:13 Speaker 01 If she needs $3,000 a month from this 270, she's in trouble. Because if you take, if you invest that safely, the best she can expect is a little less than 5% per year, if you're talking real safe. If that's the case, that money's gone in about nine years.
14:44 Speaker 01 Vanished, nothing left. So there goes the 3,000 a month. That's not adjusting it for inflation. That's just a flat 3,000 a month. Now, I don't understand the lake property part of it because I don't believe that lake property is an investment. That's not something you should be investing in. It could be a lifestyle thing, but if she needs $3,000 a month, it sounds like a lifestyle she can't afford. So I would throw that one right out the window. And if she needs 3,000 a month, that means that she's going to have to take more than a little risk. You're going to have to take quite a bit. I really think you've got to, you, you both need to sit down with a financial planner
15:29 Speaker 01 or a fee only 100% fiduciary advisor and go over all of your things, all of your sources of income, all of the assets that you have, and create a plan for this. You can't just do what we as investors have done for so long. And I blame Wall Street. I blame the brokerage industry for this. Try to pick the right place at the right time for the, the nebulous needs that we don't even understand. It's, the plan must come first. The knowledge of your situation must come first before
16:09 Speaker 01 anybody thinks about a place to put the money. Yeah, I mean, park it in short-term, high-yield savings for now until you figure that out. But you gotta figure out what the needs are. Thanks for the question. I really appreciate it. And let's grab another, shall we?
16:26 Speaker 06 Hey, Tom and Don, question for you. Trying to create a custom target date 529 fund for my son. Basically creating a normal 529 fund using VTI and VX US with a 25% equity allocation to DFA small cap value. So not much to it. Just want a small cap value portion to it. I'm having issues with the equity portion. The choices are BND.
17:03 Speaker 06 Short-term government treasuries tips and they have a stable value fund and an FDIC checking. I noticed that within the Vanguard 529 funds, they have 60% of the funds when the student is in college inside a stable value fund. I'm just curious, I know you guys normally don't talk highly of stable value funds inside any kind of retirement savings, but it's just weird that every, every target date fund I look at in a 529 has a really large portion inside stable value and a lot of
17:45 Speaker 06 them have a large portion inside checking in the fixed income portion. So just curious what your thoughts were using those five funds, what you would use the, all the, it is the Utah, Utah 529 plan. So, uh, I mean, if you wanted to look up any others, there are a few others in there, but some of them didn't look like they were worth anything, just those five. Curious to hear your thoughts. Thanks a lot, guys. Bye now.
18:10 Speaker 01 Well, we're, when we talk about not liking stable value funds, it's not that we don't like them. It's that we think there may be better options for retirement accounts and that's 99% of what we talk about, not 529s. The reason being retirement accounts draw down very slowly. So the slightly higher, well, the, the degree of volatility that a BND or a bond fund would have is not really a big concern and you're likely to make just a little more money from the bond fund than you will stable value. So that's one of the reasons.
18:50 Speaker 01 The checking thing, no, just no, just, you know, not until it's the money that you're going to use for the next tuition payment, then maybe. But when it comes to a 529, if this is a 529 that is going to be drawn, it depends on the circumstances when you get there. Is all of the money going to be drawn down for a four or six-year college program or eight-year, whatever? If so, then.
19:20 Speaker 01 Stable value starts to make a lot of sense for the money coming up for need in the next year or so. So it might be something like this. For the early, early years, it's almost all equities. Then as you get within, I don't know, five or six years of needing the money, then you start moving into bonds. And then when you get within a year of using the money, then you might go to stable value. And then when you get within a semester, then you go to, to the checking possibly, or just keep it in the stable value. That would work fine. But it's different than retirement. So that's why I think they make more sense in this scenario, because there is no volatility. However, the volatility of bond, of the kind of bond
20:05 Speaker 01 funds we like, like BND, or the short-term government, not TIPS, cross out TIPS, the volatility of those is really pretty low. Even in the worst times, it wasn't disastrous to a college education if you'd been in that alone. Because again, you're not going to draw it all down. You're just going to draw a portion of it down. So you only have a portion of it that in a, in a year where rates grows dramatically, the value fell. So I would not, I wouldn't agonize too much over it, but I can see how it might make sense, might make you feel a little better to have stable value at the end. Probably not even
20:50 Speaker 01 checking, but stable value. Thank you so much. And I think we're going to do, wow, we're going long today. Six questions. That's a long show. All right, let's do the last one.
21:01 Speaker 07 Hey, guys. I've heard you say multiple times that when you want to roll an old employer 401k over to an IRA, that if you want to convert those funds to Roth, you should never use the money inside the traditional 401k to pay the taxes for the Roth conversion. I wanted to see if you could go a little in-depth on the math on why that is the case, or if there's ever a case. When that would work for an individual, such as in my case, I have 30 plus years for the funds to grow tax-free. I feel like even with paying the taxes out of the traditional
21:41 Speaker 07 account for the conversion, that I would still come out on top with the tax-free growth after 30 years. The rollover would only be about $20,000 of traditional money. And then also on top of that, last time I did a rollover, I had a broker who did the rollover for me. I have since gotten rid of that broker, based on your guys' advice. And I'm now with Vanguard with a Roth account. And I wanted to see, is there an easy way to rollover funds from an employer into a Vanguard account, whether it's traditional or Roth? Thank you very much for all that you guys do. We appreciate it.
22:22 Speaker 01 Thank you for the question that made me do a lot of math. And I hate doing math. Uh, easy way to, to make the transfers, to do a rollover, to do a transfer into a Roth is just to have your cust- your new custodian, your IRA custodian do it. Have them bring it over in, in kind, and then make the, the changes necessary. I still don't believe that even Roth conversions necessarily make sense. Even less sense, though, when you have to pay the taxes out of the Roth conversion because of the loss of earning power on that money that you have to give to the IRS right now. You can't wait to give
23:06 Speaker 01 it to them. That's the advantage of having it in a tax-deferred IRA for the next 30 years, is that you put off giving it to them. So I played with some numbers, and I decided to make the numbers manageable and realistic for a lot of people. So you've got 30 years to retirement, and let's say right now you have $30,000, 3030, $30,000 in your regular 401k that you're going to convert to a Roth IRA. Well, if you're in the 25% bracket, that means when all is said and done, you're going to move 22,500 only. You're not moving 30, you're moving 22,500 because you paid taxes out of it.
23:48 Speaker 01 And so you don't have $7,500 earning, growing, becoming larger over that next 30 years. And that difference makes a huge difference in your nest egg at the end of that time. Let's look at that $30,000 in the regular IRA invested for 30 years at 7%. I'm just using hypotheticals, okay? All hypotheticals. At the end of the 30 years, you would have about $243,000. Okay? If you put the 22.5, that's the amount you had left after paying the taxes, away for
24:32 Speaker 01 30 years at 7%, you'd have about $182,000, 182 and change. All right? So now you're gonna have more. Ah, but you say, yeah, but then I have to pay the taxes then. Okay, let's assume you're in the 25% bracket. And you take everything out in 30 years. Not something you're likely to do, just for argument's sake. Guess how much you're gonna have after you pay the 25% in taxes? About $182,000. Or almost exactly the same amount of money, than $1,000, less than $1,000, that you would have had by paying the taxes now, converting it to a Roth,
25:17 Speaker 01 and letting it grow at the same rate. So there was no gain in paying the taxes and going to the Roth. None. However, in retirement, you don't take the money out all at once, you take it out slowly. So let's say you want a net of $1,500 a month from your portfolio. In the regular IRA, you're gonna have to take out 2,000, pay the taxes to give you the 1,500. If you do that, that money will, at the same rate, will last you about 22 years. Taking out 1,500 a month after taxes, taking out 2,000 before.
26:00 Speaker 01 If you take 1,500 a month out of the 182,000 in the Roth, over a course of years, same rates, same assumptions, everything, at 1,500 a month after taxes, because you don't pay any taxes on the Roth, the money lasts 14 years.
26:18 Speaker 01 So you would, in this hypothetical scenario, you'd be better off not transferring to the Roth. However, if you pay the taxes out of other money, then you still have the 7,500 growing tax-free in the Roth, which makes these numbers far different. So, yeah, you've got to pay the money out of other monies. It does not work, generally speaking. Either it, no, it doesn't, either it comes close to making no difference at all, that's about as good as this scenario can be, or you end up with less money, unless you're in a much higher tax bracket when you retire and start taking money out, and that's a
27:03 Speaker 01 whole nother scenario. And by the way, that's not one that's particularly likely. If you're particularly, if you're a high wage earner in your working years, it's not likely you're going to be in a higher bracket in retirement unless you're filthy rich. So, I don't think the numbers work, but we appreciate you calling and listening, and all the rest of you too. We really, truly do. And hope you'll tell friends and hope you'll send your questions in at TalkingRealMoney.com on the Contact Us form. You can type them there, or you can speak them there. I like the speaking ones, but that's personal bias. Um, let's see.
27:43 Speaker 01 Oh, and by the way, every Saturday, if you would like to have a conversation with us, well, you can, because starting at 3:00 PM Eastern, we go on the radio with a talk show that becomes a podcast, and you can call us at 855-935-TALK, which if you type it out in numbers is 8255. 855-935-TALK, that's noon to 2:00 Pacific Time, 3:00 to 5:00 Eastern, every Saturday, unless it's like a huge holiday, and we don't have any of those coming up for a while. So, do that too. We love it when you call us on Saturday. Tom gets so excited. He loves the, the, the idea of setting new caller records, so make him feel better.
28:27 Speaker 01 Call us on Saturday, 855-935-TALK, 855-935-8255. If you like what you hear too, in addition to telling people... Go to Apple Podcasts and leave a review because we've got a couple of grumpy people. Well, we've got one grumpy person in particular who keeps going in and leaving a new, long-winded review talking about how awful we are because we don't like Bitcoin. And those one-star reviews skew everything down. We still have great reviews for the most part, but you know, there are a couple of people who don't like the banter and somebody who accused us of getting a kickback. You know, if you're going to accuse us of kickbacks, you should probably have some proof, but you know, because we don't, we don't get
29:12 Speaker 01 any kickbacks. We tell you, we make money because we work for a firm that advises people. And yeah, we send you to them if you really can't find anybody else, but we don't believe they're the only source of great information on investing either. So we, we're upfront about everything we have an interest in. We tell you. Thanks for being there. Thanks for telling people. Thanks for calling in. Thanks for asking questions and thanks for being a part of Talking Real Money.
29:44 Speaker 00 The opinions and views expressed in this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money
30:27 Speaker 00 is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor.
30:42 Speaker 00 ...for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening, and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast. Oh, I think I need a nap.
Previous A Few Good Stocks Next Like Moths... Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated