Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk More Questions! About this episode This Friday Q&A episode tackles several thoughtful listener questions covering 401(k) investment choices, Roth conversion strategies, bond market fears, inherited IRA planning, and investment club mechanics. Don explains why opaque collective investment trusts and “cycle” funds often hide market-timing strategies, cautions against making large Roth conversions based on predictions about future tax rates, and reassures investors worried about inflation and national debt that markets already incorporate widely known risks. The episode closes with a practical endorsement of a listener’s strategy to gradually withdraw from an inherited IRA to fund Roth contributions, emphasizing simplicity, discipline, and avoiding emotionally driven portfolio decisions.0:04 Don realizes the intro still says “radio” even though the show is now mostly a podcast.0:26 Friday Q&A format explained and reminder to submit questions at TalkingRealMoney.com.1:00 Question 1: 33-year-old with $330k in a 401(k) invested in opaque “intermediate cycle” and wealth-preservation funds.2:26 Don explains collective investment trusts (CITs) and why their lack of transparency is problematic.5:25 Market-timing strategies disguised as “cycle” funds and why simple equity funds may be better.6:47 Question 2: Listener corrects earlier discussion about transferring securities from investment clubs.8:37 How in-kind transfers can avoid capital gains when leaving an investment club—depending on club rules and brokerage policies.10:31 Question 3: Complex Roth conversion strategy involving IRMAA tiers and future tax assumptions.14:31 Don warns against making large conversions based on predictions about future tax rates.16:07 Why gradual conversions preserve flexibility compared with large upfront tax bets.17:28 Question 4: Concern about national debt and whether to replace BND with VTIP (TIPS).18:56 Don argues markets already price known risks like debt and inflation expectations.20:11 How TIPS work and when they actually help investors.21:46 Reminder that emotional reactions to economic fears often lead to bad portfolio decisions.22:10 Question 5: Using withdrawals from an inherited IRA to fund Roth IRA contributions.22:52 Strategy: withdraw gradually to fund Roth contributions while staying within tax brackets.24:15 Don endorses the plan as simple, tax-efficient, and compliant with the 10-year inherited IRA rule.25:09 Closing comments and reminder to submit questions. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoicesQuestions? Comments? Click!
Transcript 0:04 Speaker 00 Reality radio for a really great future. We're talking real money.
0:10 Speaker 01 Welcome to another exciting, albeit still semi-light edition of the Friday Talking Real Money question and answer edition of the podcast.
0:24 Speaker 01 A little light, not terrible though, not terrible. I always try to keep enough questions in abeyance for the following week's show, so I'm pretty sure I have it. This week I thought I did that, and then I checked and there were some problems, but we've gotten those rectified. And now I have my, my full light edition four-question setup. I was trying to think of what the word was for it, but I couldn't remember. Hmm, whatever. You know, I got some questions from people that sent them in, and how did they send them in? Well, it was easy. They went to TalkingRealMoney.com and then hit the contact button, and then they hit
1:07 Speaker 01 the, "I have a question," and then they recorded their question with their voice in their microphone on their device, and then I put it into a program that makes it sound even better. I don't know how they do this stuff, but it works, so it makes me happy, makes the show sound better. So we've got four questions. You can send yours in at TalkingRealMoney.com on the contact form. If you speak them, they go on the Friday Q and A podcast. If you type them, I can't tell you for sure when they're going to go on, because Tom hoards all of those, and, and then we don't know how he doles them out. It's a secret formula. So, uh, let's get this edition under the rug, under the rug.
1:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm not even gonna edit that out. I'm just gonna leave it. Let's get this one on the road, maybe. That could be more fun, don't you think?
1:59 Speaker 02 Hi, Don. It's Craig, formerly Pial up from the mountains. That's Seattle now. Had a quick question on the social security discussion between taking it at 62 and taking it at 70. I understand the math and the guaranteed 8%, but I'm curious, when you're doing the calculations and, and it's pretty much agreed that the break even point is closer to 80, if you take it at 62 versus 70. But when that calculation's being done, I'm curious, is it taking into account if you purely invest that money and don't use any of it? And as such, does it take into account compounding and dividends? Or is it just if you're taking that as an income source, starting at 62 versus 70?
2:40 Speaker 02 And I appreciate you giving me some clear guidance on whether or not I'm looking at this correctly. Thanks so much.
2:47 Speaker 01 Well, this, this one is a perfect example how this AI program improves quality. This thing was so compressed, it was so flat, it was hard to understand, there was very little dynamic range in the audio, so it sounded very much like a bad phone call. And, and that was actually pretty good. So, anyway, Craig, thanks for calling. Good to hear from you. The social security argument.
3:15 Speaker 01 We have this one a lot. We really do.
3:19 Speaker 01 When you, when you calculate, when we calculate the break even point, no, we don't take into account all of the, the investing and compounding, because that's all, those are all variables. So, let's just play with some really easy numbers, okay? Let's say your full retirement age benefit from social security is two grand. At 62, might be around 1,400 roughly, and if you wait till 70, maybe you're getting up around 2,500. So, let's say that from 62 to 70, you collect 134, that'd be about $134,000 total that you collect. And if you invest all of that, and let's say you're, because it's retirement money, so let's say 5% a year.
4:04 Speaker 01 Now that 134 is probably worth 155?
4:12 Speaker 01 But here's the thing. At age 70, the person who waited is getting 1,080 more a month. Okay? That's 13,000 more a year, and that's inflation adjusted, and that's guaranteed. There was no risk to get there.
4:29 Speaker 01 The, if you take the invested lump sum, you know, the break even moves up a couple of years. But it really doesn't move up that much. If you claim early and invest, it's, it's, you might be ahead of the game. If you get in the, you know, the eight range, you're taking a risk.
4:52 Speaker 01 Then you might be, if you get eight plus, you might be better off. But remember, that eight plus addition is guaranteed.
5:01 Speaker 01 And there's an inflation adjustment along the way. So it's still probably not worth it. I don't think it's a good trade off. I really don't. Greg, thanks so much for the question. It was a good one. And now to the next one. Digitally enhanced, of course.
5:18 Speaker 03 If I get enough overtime, I can make up to 120,000 gross. Five kids, two oldest planning to serve two-year missions after high school. The oldest will graduate in 2028, the second in 2029. Should I switch to traditional from Roth on retirement in 2028, savings for FAFSA?
5:38 Speaker 03 I do try to max out the 401k and my wife and mine IRAs. Then if you do think I should switch to that for FAFSA, should I do traditional? Should I stay traditional until all my kids are off my income for FAFSA? Thank you so much. Bye.
5:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, FAFSA, one, it's hard to say. And two, it's very confusing.
6:02 Speaker 01 The simple answer is at your income level with a couple of kids in college,
6:09 Speaker 01 it's not likely to make a big difference in the amount of aid they're eligible for. Even at your 120,000, they're going to have relatively high eligibility.
6:23 Speaker 01 But having said that, the rough numbers.
6:29 Speaker 01 Because here's what we're doing. We're, we're, we're trading off, uh, short-term gains for potential long-term benefits that we're giving up. And that's that tax-free growth for a long time. Now, we really don't know what that tax-free growth component is worth because we don't know the future. But here are a couple of things we do know. That, yes, there is a benefit right now for you switching your retirement contributions for the next four, or five, or six years, however long the kids are in school, uh, for a couple of reasons. One, because you're earning more. You're getting that overtime, so you're kicking yourself into a higher bracket, which makes the deduction more valuable to you. The, the
7:11 Speaker 01 fact that you're putting money in, uh, pre-tax, so you're actually able to contribute a little bit more. So there's a benefit there. And then the little bit of a FAFSA benefit adds to that. So we've got that bird in the hand thing. We know what you're going to get now. It's probably slightly beneficial versus the benefit of waiting. If your income drops in those intervening years, though, I would switch, probably switch back to Roth, because I think long-term, if you're not a high earner today and you're a good saver, that that Roth benefit is far more long-term valuable. So, again, the answer is probably, yeah. It's
7:53 Speaker 01 there, there's, there's very likely enough of a benefit to go with the regular, uh, tax deductible contributions and then pay the taxes on that. And you're going to have a little of both. So that's, I like having a little of both in retirement anyway. Gives you choices. Thanks so much for your question. And now, another.
8:15 Speaker 04 Hi, Tom and Don. Thank you for all the work you do. I really do appreciate all the great advice you've given me over the last couple of years. I promise that I will not ask a question about Avantis or Dimensional Funds. I'm 49 years old and plan to work for about 15 more years, maybe longer if I'm still having fun. I have a MetLife Group Variable Universal Life Policy through my employer. They pay the premiums and I pay the taxes. Currently, the policy has a death benefit of about 2.1 million with a cash value of 220,000. I'm able to use this like an investment account with limited options through MetLife, or just take 4% per year, quote, guaranteed. My understanding is that when I retire, assuming I do not die before then, I will cash this out and pay only taxes on the growth, but it will be ordinary income tax.
9:00 Speaker 04 They also tell me I have the option to withdraw up to the level of the premiums, which is about $190,000 at any time without paying taxes since they have already been paid. I realize that this will decrease the death benefit, but I don't feel that I need that much or more as it keeps increasing with my salary, given that I have a separate term life insurance policy as well that will expire at age 62. I was thinking withdrawing some of the cash value and moving that over to a brokerage account where I will have infinitely more options. Additionally, in the future, I would only pay capital gains taxes on those growths rather than ordinary income tax. I will have a solid pension in my retirement and some other retirement accounts, so I think that the income tax, especially of all at once, would be significantly more than capital gains tax on any growth.
9:44 Speaker 04 Am I missing something or does this make some sense? If so, would you recommend putting in an AVG E or AVG V? Just kidding. Again, I appreciate all the help that you have provided to me and so many others. Please keep it up.
9:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, I might recommend those funds. I might suggest those funds, you think? Maybe, yeah. I think I go with E though, not G. I don't know. It depends on what your portfolio is. And my answer to your question is going to depend on some things that we don't know, that I don't know. You know them, or maybe you can find out what they are. Is the company still contributing to this? It sounds like they are. And if they are, then you need to make sure that you can take the money. If you can take out all the money they put in and still continue the account, then yeah,
10:39 Speaker 01 I think it starts to make sense that because there are a couple of, you mentioned them, a couple of things going on. If you can take that $190,000 out tax-free because you've already paid taxes on it, you paid the taxes, then you can invest it the way you want, which means you can probably do better. Plus, there are fees associated with these variable universal policies that come out of the assets and they can run up to like 3% a year for all the policy and the insurance expenses. So, you know, their mortality charges, admin, subaccounts, all that stuff, and it can be 2% to 3% a year.
11:17 Speaker 01 And then the other advantage is now, instead of sitting in the, this is the thing that insurance people fail to tell you, yeah, you don't pay any taxes on the money in a, in an annuity type product or a universal life product until you take it out and then you pay at your tax rate, which you mentioned. By controlling it yourself, it's your capital gains rate and you can defer taxes with a smart portfolio using exchange traded funds that don't distribute a lot of income and then have your income oriented investments in tax advantaged accounts. So I really think if you're allowed to take that 190 out and still keep getting the free money from your company, you see, I want to make sure you're getting that free money.
12:01 Speaker 01 To me, that beats everything. If there is any threat to the free money, then let it ride here for a while and do it later. Do it when they stop contributing to this or when you leave the company or whatever it might be. But if you can take out the 190, keep the policy in force, continue to get contributions from your employer, free money on which you pay taxes, that's okay. It's free money. I'd rather pay taxes on free money than not have the free money. And I think you get that. So yeah, I would, I would take the 190 out and I would build a portfolio with it, add it to my existing portfolio, whatever that might be. Thank you very much for the, what sounded like it was going to be a really confusing question, but was pretty easy.
12:44 Speaker 01 And your company, by the way, they seem to be taking pretty good care of you. Oh, and I forgot to mention, you mentioned it, but I want to, I just want to really get clarity. You don't need the full death benefit. Your family situation is such that there is no one who would need that million plus or whatever the reduction's going to be. So that's another caveat. Let's go to our last question of this episode. That happened fast. Here we go.
13:16 Speaker 05 Hey, Don. I was listening to the Merriman Foundation podcast a couple of months ago and I was, it prompted a question I was thinking about that I really liked to get your feedback on. Chris Pedersen, one of his associates there was talking about public index funds that, that...
13:36 Speaker 05 Publicly lets you know when they're going to rebalance. And his comment that I've been kind of probing and thinking about is if you know that a public index fund is going to rebalance, the reason that the that the that the returns are going to be lower is because if people know upfront, when you're going to go ahead and rebalance, they're going to try to front run your trade and make you pay more for it, obviously. So it's just a concept I was thinking about and I'm wondering, you know, and that was one of his discussions about Avantis and Dimensional and things like that. But is that is that a valid concern? Is that if you put an index fund that's public, straight on, straight on apples to
14:21 Speaker 05 apples against a rules based index fund where they don't let you know when they're going to rebalance and they keep all that close to the vest? Does it make sense that they would go ahead and and and have higher returns because of that reason? I just wanted to get your feedback on that. Thanks.
14:42 Speaker 01 We and the Merriman Education Group are of very similar minds on on this rules based investing process. And what Chris touched on was just one small, tiny, little benefit to having a rules based fund versus an index fund. It's not that there the index fund is saying, we're going to rebalance on this date. It's that the index rebalances on the changes on that date. They take a fund out, they move another fund or not a fund, they take a company out, Dawn, and they put another company in its place. And everybody knows in advance because the indexes, like Standard and Poor's and the
15:26 Speaker 01 like, they they they tell you, they disclose that. So yes, there is a certain amount of front running that goes on, which causes the price of the stock that's coming in to to to appreciate before it actually comes in so that the funds are paying a little more than they should. The rules based funds don't have to buy the stock when somebody else tells them it's time to buy it. They buy it when they think it should be in their portfolio based on their rules and sell it when they think it should no longer be in that portfolio. And they've got some leeway as to when to do it and they don't have to tell the investing public that they're doing it in advance. Now, what does it add? A fraction of a percent, not much.
16:07 Speaker 01 However, with all of the other things that they're doing that are based on massive amounts of data and academic research, for example, they're overweighting value. There's another fraction of a percent, maybe more. They're overweighting small. There's another fraction of a percent or more. They have other rules that keep them out of initial public offerings so they don't pay up at the beginning when companies tend to have a lot of hype. So it's those rules that keep them in various areas that have shown benefit in the past. They don't always behave beneficially. Sometimes they don't.
16:50 Speaker 01 We saw value horribly underperform for almost a couple of decades. But over longer periods of time, these factors and these rules have increased returns enough that we believe those increases offset the slightly higher fees you pay because they're more complicated to run. You're still getting pretty cheap fund management because they're not actively trying to pick stocks. So you're not paying the six tenths, seven tenths, eight tenths, nine tenths, 1% a year with these rules-based funds. You're paying usually less than three tenths of a percent a year versus the less than one
17:32 Speaker 01 tenth that you might pay at a lot of funds at Vanguard. But we think it's worth it. Thank you. Thank you for those great questions. Thank you for, well, of course, listening. We really appreciate that. And it's so great to watch the show become more popular, thanks to all of you telling your friends and your neighbors and your acquaintances about. The thing we're trying to do here, and yeah, I know we're owned by an investment advisory firm, but folks, that's the only way to really make any money these days. But the one thing we do that's different, we're not trying to sell you indexed annuities
18:15 Speaker 01 or loaded mutual funds like the people who support another popular money, very popular money oriented show, and they're expensive. We do like you to become clients, but we don't try to push into that. As a matter of fact, we even really, truly, and we've done this for over 15 years now. We really, really, truly have full 100% fiduciary advisors that we will lend you for a little while. And they don't try to sell you on becoming a client. You're not going to feel any pressure and you're not going to be asked for any money. They'll help you for free. I promise for free.
18:58 Speaker 01 If not, call me or go to Talking Real Money and send me a nasty note or speak it. And because you won't, I just know you won't. Because here's the thing. We discovered something really interesting. Now, a lot of firms are all about the next quarter and making all the sales they can. They're sales oriented. We're relationship oriented. We know if we do something good for you, you don't have enough money to hire us. Okay? We're all right with that. We'll help you. We will totally help you. But you might know somebody who does, and they're not doing a good job, and you know it because you've listened to this show.
19:42 Speaker 01 What are you likely to, where are you likely to send them? You're going to say, oh yeah, go to, you know, that brokerage firm in the bank? No, you're going to send them to us or somebody like us. And we're not opposed to people like us doing well either. The more of us that do well, the better the industry is going to be in the long run. We like other firms like us. We even have their names on our website. We have a list of other firms. We'll send you to them. I feel a little like Santa Claus in Miracle on 34th Street sometimes. Anyway, if you have questions, go to TalkingRealMoney.com and send them in on the contact form. If you want to meet with an advisor, there's a button there that says "Meet an Advisor." And I promise you, it'll be easy and painless
20:25 Speaker 01 and valuable. It could even be Tom if you want. He'll do it. He likes those meetings. I have too much other stuff here. I'm gonna make the podcast up. And then on the contact form, please, when you hit the question button there, click on the microphone and speak your question. I'll make you sound really purdy with artificial intelligence, and then you'll know when to listen to on Fridays when we do Q and A right here on Talking Real Money.
20:55 Speaker 06 The opinions and views expressed in this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money
21:39 Speaker 06 is for informational, educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth's ADV Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital, LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information
22:22 Speaker 06 and important disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast. And the lawyers get richer.
Previous Questions Four Next Everything Ends Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated