Pod Insights Talking Real Money - Investing Talk Friday, Again? About this episode In this extended Friday Q&A episode, Don answers six listener-submitted questions covering a wide range of personal finance and investing topics. He kicks off with a fiery takedown of cryptocurrency as a viable asset class, arguing it’s based on hype and the greater fool theory. Other questions explore whether pensions should count as fixed income in asset allocation, the performance of Dimensional and Avantis funds versus traditional index funds, the pros and cons of Collective Investment Trusts in 401(k)s, and the strategic timing of Social Security. He ends by clarifying a common misconception about RMDs and Secure Act 2.0. Expect smart insights, a little snark, and the kind of blunt honesty that’s rare in financial media. 0:04 Listener Q&A returns with an extra dose—six questions this time 1:07 Confusing podcast scheduling clarified (sort of) 2:11 Crypto as an asset class? Don calls it “entirely invented” and dismantles the use case hype 4:32 If civilization collapses, your Bitcoin won’t save you 6:06 Crypto = greater fool theory; Don braces for hate mail 7:30 Dimensional/Avantis vs. index funds—do the extra fees pay off? 9:13 A 15-year comparison: Dimensional Global Equity vs. VT 11:43 Should a pension count as fixed income? Don says no—it’s a volatility game, not income 15:48 CITs (Collective Investment Trusts) in 401(k)s—cheaper, but less transparent 18:58 Index funds should be your benchmark; Don suspects this one’s active 20:02 Claiming Social Security early to preserve Roth? Don says the math rarely supports it 23:59 Secure 2.0 and RMD confusion—born in 1959? You still take RMDs at 73, not 75 26:15 Tech keeps improving—Don urges retirees to stay sharp, stay curious Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:04 Speaker 00 Reality radio for a really great future. We're talking real money.
0:10 Speaker 01 And the Q and A responses continue to pour in. Thank you. Some of you are overachievers. There are a couple of you called in a lot of questions. So, uh, thank you for that. I'll spread them out over time. Uh, but we got a bunch. We got a bunch. Uh, so once again, we're going to do a, uh, usually five questions or comments is what I do in it in a Friday Q and A episode. But, uh, again, we're going to do six today because we've got, uh, gee, I've got enough for the next two plus weeks without any new ones. And if you want to send in a new question, that's easy to do. You just go to talkingrealmoney.com, click on that button that says contact us.
0:52 Speaker 01 And then you can type your question in or you can speak it. The spoken questions generally get answered on this Friday podcast, although some of them will get answered on the Saturday show, um, which turns into the generally the Tuesday or Wednesday podcast, unless there's a holiday like Columbus Day, and then there'll be the Wednesday and Thursday podcast. So I'm just trying to confuse you as best I can. And I know I'm doing a really good job of it. So, uh, there's another way to get in touch with us too. If you want to be even more confused, and that's to call that Saturday show on, well, Saturday, coincidentally.
1:32 Speaker 01 And that phone number is 855-935-TALK, 855-935-8255. So, without further ado, let's get to the first of our diverse array of questions for the day.
1:49 Speaker 02 Hey, Don, I know you guys don't have a bunch of questions right now, so I thought I'd ask you about your favorite subject, crypto.
1:55 Speaker 01 Ah, no, no. You're just gonna bring out the haters. Oh, don't do this to me. We have lots of questions. All right, go on.
2:06 Speaker 02 The reason I'm calling and asking about this is that I want to get your opinion on crypto as an asset class in general, and would it be a part of a diversified portfolio? I don't believe, just as you do as well, that crypto has a real world use case. I also believe that gold similarly does not have a real world use case. But I do consider both of these assets as almost like a commodity that could potentially belong in a diversified portfolio. Crypto is slowly becoming large enough as retail investors
2:49 Speaker 02 get into the investment and as companies create Bitcoin treasuries and stockpile it as well. The asset class continues to grow. So the big question is, when would you consider it a part of someone's diversified portfolio? Thanks.
3:09 Speaker 01 And again, you're gonna get me in trouble with the crypto bros. But you know, I believe for the most part, the crypto proponents are just hyping their own investments. That their, their arguments are self-serving. It's to enhance their personal wealth. I really believe that. So I'm gonna tell you what I really believe, and I don't believe this is an asset class. It is made from whole cloth. It is entirely invented. And, and let's talk about real world use. Maybe it could be used as a currency, but what does it give you? That's any more convenient than, I don't know, a dollar or a euro? I don't see that it does.
3:51 Speaker 01 There are arguments that, well, when those fiat currencies collapse, then crypto will be the currency of choice. Well, actually, there's where the other parts of the argument come totally apart. Maybe you could argue that for Bitcoin or Ethereum possibly because at least they have some heft in time, uh, history. But there are like 10,000 cryptocurrencies. And truly, the bulk of them are just somebody who made something up like Dogecoin. It's just made up stuff. They're going to fall apart someday.
4:32 Speaker 01 There's just no way it won't happen. Because people are eventually gonna go, "Well, I don't, why am I holding this? It's not gonna do anything." And then let's go back to the other really popular real-world use case that is bandied about, and that is, is in the case of a fiat currency collapse, an economic collapse that destroys the currencies of China, Europe, Great Britain, the United States, South America, Australia, Canada, all of this, that just totally destroyed.
5:06 Speaker 01 What is it likely to be like in such a scenario?
5:11 Speaker 01 Do you really believe that the internet is going to be fully functional when all these companies have gone bankrupt? Do you believe that? Computers are gonna work, maybe, might not even be electricity steadily. What good is crypto without a computer? There is nothing there if there isn't a machine tied to an internet that's fully functional and powered by a steady stream of electricity.
5:39 Speaker 01 It falls apart. I mean, I could make a better argument for gold, and gold has never made anybody any money, but it, it is sort of the prepper's hedge. Because at least you can carry it around with you and slice off a little bit to pay some idiot for his canned food. I don't know why you trade your canned food for gold, but hey, you might. Uh, but, uh, I can't make a case for it, I just can't do it. I've heard every argument, I've read thousands, and I literally mean thousands of articles. And I cannot come up with a use case that makes any sense to me as someone who doesn't have...
6:26 Speaker 01 A horse in this race. Now, if I had some Bitcoin and I was selfish, I would be telling you why it's so good, wouldn't I? Why would I be telling you that? Well, because I want you to buy my Bitcoin. It's it. Crypto relies on on the greater fool theory. And as long as there are greater fools, it will go up. Eventually, in every other historical case, we've run out of fools. So I'm gonna I'm gonna get the hate things again, but. Oh, so if you ask this question and you like the answer, you need to give us a positive review on Apple Podcasts
7:10 Speaker 01 to overcome the negative one I guarantee I'm gonna get for this. Because Don just doesn't get Bitcoin. You're right, Don just doesn't get Bitcoin. But I'm pretty sure I've probably read as much about it as you have. You get it because you own it, admit it. Let's go to the next question. Maybe it's a better one.
7:34 Speaker 03 Hello, Tom and Don. Thanks for all you guys do. Question. Are Dimensional and Advantage Funds, do they perform that much better than basic index funds from either Vanguard or Fidelity? Since typical index funds from Vanguard and Fidelity have a lower expense ratio, is it worthwhile still to purchase Dimensional and Advantage Funds, which tend to have a little bit higher of an expense ratio? Do they really perform better? Thank you.
8:07 Speaker 01 That's the question that people are always asking. Do they perform better? Well, you can't say they do because doing implies moving forward into the future. We only know done. And it depends on the timeframe you look at. The longer the timeframe.
8:29 Speaker 01 The more likely you'll see they've outperformed. They out, we believe they are likely to outperform in the future. Based on decades, almost a century of really great data. That shows that a tilt towards smaller companies, because they're riskier. And a tilt toward value oriented companies, because they're riskier. Has historically led to dramatically higher returns. However, we don't believe you should put all your eggs in those baskets. Because there's a very high degree of volatility with them because of that risk. So we, the expectation is that they should perform better. Now, we have a little problem making comparisons.
9:13 Speaker 01 Dimensional got into the ETF game a little late. So it's hard to do an ETF to ETF comparison with Vanguard or Fidelity. But we can do a fund to ETF comparison, which is actually pretty fair. Because the Dimensional Global Equity Fund, DGIX. Has been around for almost a couple of decades. And VT has been around for almost a couple of decades. The Vanguard Total Market Index, which is just an index. DGIX has a small value tilt. A factor tilt, as it's called. Over 15 years.
9:56 Speaker 01 Now DGIX has slightly higher, slightly higher expense ratio than VT. Well, it's a quarter of a, about a quarter of a percent. A little less than a quarter of a percent more. But over 15 years, DGIX has returned just over 11% per year. That's a pretty good number. VT, the Vanguard Total World Index, has returned just over 10 and 1/4% per year.
10:28 Speaker 01 When we talk about different expected returns, we're only talking about a percentage point or maybe less, which is exactly what we see here. Now, that doesn't mean that's going to continue to happen. We've seen long periods where value and small have dramatically underperformed large growth. We had a couple of decades there, and that's only recently changed, thanks to recent outperformance by value and small and by internationals. So, oh, and internationals also factored into these. So, yeah, I think we should see it. I can't guarantee we will see it.
11:11 Speaker 01 And if we look at 15-year comparison between those two funds, we have seen it, and in about the percentage that you would expect. Could it change? Of course. Growth could go back to being popular. Growth could fall apart, and value and small could go crazy. We just don't know. That's why we want to have that diversification, and we prefer to have, to pay that extra 20 basis points or so for that slight tilt to small and value.
11:43 Speaker 01 We believe it, based on the data we've seen. Thanks for your question. Send them in at TalkingRealMoney.com on the contact form. Speak them in preferably, because I like that better. You can type them if you must. You can also call us on Saturdays at 3:00 PM Eastern at 855-935-TALK. Here's the next one.
12:02 Speaker 04 Hi, Don and Tom. This is Bob from California. I'm a relatively new listener, and I enjoy your straightforward, common sense approach to investing. Don, I'm speaking this question as you prefer spoken questions to written. So, here you go. Is it appropriate and advisable to factor in a joint and survivor pension into one's fixed income allocation? For example, a $10,000 annual pension imputes an additional fixed income investment earning 4%. Of $250,000. So is it appropriate to add $250,000 to my fixed income investments?
12:46 Speaker 04 When calculating my current asset allocation? If not, why not? Thank you for your time.
12:53 Speaker 01 Well, based on conventional wisdom, that makes perfect sense because you own a fixed income. Conventional wisdom says you buy fixed income investments to provide you with a fixed income. Right? That's not what we believe. We believe you buy fixed income investments to maintain portfolio stability. And you do not look at your pension as part of your portfolio. If you had, let's say for a second, you had 100% of your portfolio in stocks because you've got this great pension, which is a great pension, by the way. So let's say you have a half a million dollar portfolio, 250,000 is in stocks. And I'm sorry, it's not a portfolio. You've got a half a million dollar value. You've got $250,000 invested in stocks and
13:38 Speaker 01 then this $250,000 valued annuity. Let's say 2008 happened again. Your $500,000 plunges to $125,000.
13:56 Speaker 01 Now, I know your logical brain is going to go, I'll be fine, I'll be fine. But the reality is people who said they'd be fine, said they'd be fine. In 2008, they were calling me saying, I'm not fine. I gotta get out. I'm gonna get out. I'll get out. I'll get back in when this is when things feel better because the economy is collapsing. At the time, we thought the economy was collapsing, which again implies future tense. It's going to collapse until, well, it feels better. When it feels better, I'll get back in. And that's what a lot of people did. That's what you're likely to do if you have 100% equity portfolio or too much in equities versus fixed income slash bonds. We believe you have
14:36 Speaker 01 a fixed income position to reduce the volatility if you can train your brain to look at your portfolio as one entity. So now your quarter of a million dollar portfolio is half in stocks and half in bonds. And 2008 happens. And now instead of dropping to $125,000, you drop to $180,000 or $190,000.
15:02 Speaker 01 Okay, I can handle that. That doesn't feel as bad. I didn't lose half my money. It's a psychological game we play with ourselves. And that's the reason we suggest fixed income. Not for the income it provides. We believe in taking income from your portfolio. Whatever additional income you need over and above your pension, you take that in aggregate from your whole portfolio, not just from the fixed income side. You take the income out, and then after, if the income's not enough, then you start rebalancing, using some of the capital gains, some of the money that you get from those sales, and you use that to add to your income. And that's actually worked really, really well. In the past, anyway.
15:48 Speaker 01 We've got more questions. I think we have still three. Yeah, let's go to the next one.
15:54 Speaker 05 Hi, Tom and Don. My question is regarding a recent change to the investment options in my 401K. My 401K is administered by Fidelity, and they recently removed a large-cap growth mutual fund and added a large-cap growth collective investment trust, CIT. From what I've read, the CIT is not governed by the SEC, and the primary benefit is a lower expense ratio. Here, it went from a 0.44 to a 0.375. My concern is that the CIT is not publicly traded, and it seems more opaque in the underlying investments. I can see the market sectors that it's invested in, but not what the stocks are, or how many stocks are in the fund. I wanted to get your thoughts on CITs
16:36 Speaker 05 and what the additional risks are versus a publicly traded mutual fund. As always, thanks for your input. I look forward to hearing what you have to say.
16:46 Speaker 01 CITs are just, I really believe they're just another Wall Street-y gimmicky thingy. They serve really very little useful purpose. Except, as you mentioned, because they don't have the regulation to make it a little bit cheaper. And it also gives managers a screen to hide behind. Because investors can't look all the time. And active managers love that. They love that. They don't like people looking at what they're buying. But in the case of Fidelity, it's less concerning. If this was another company, it might be more concerning, because I'm pretty sure that Fidelity creates these CITs.
17:32 Speaker 01 Almost identically to their fund. So there is kinda gonna be some transparency. But no, they don't have to report their portfolios. I don't like them. I do not like the lack of transparency. They can only be purchased in a 401k or 403B or, you know, that type of plan. They cannot be purchased in an IRA or a regular brokerage account. Therefore, they cannot be transferred when you leave that employer. They would have to be liquidated and moved. Uh, and here's my concern, just based on your call.
18:05 Speaker 01 Is that an actively managed fidelity fund? Because your cost, .44, that's not an index fund cost. That's too high. And the reduction from .44 to .375?
18:22 Speaker 01 That's hardly anything. There's no big benefit. Uh, it's, I'm probably better off for fidelity, uh, because they, they probably have a bigger reduction in costs than that. I don't know. I'm just guessing. Uh, no. Am I thrilled? Is it awful? I have to say no to both. I'm not thrilled and it's not awful. It is what it is. If it's what you have, although, man, you really need some index options. You should have, you should have funds that don't charge any more in aggregate than .25 in a 401k?
19:05 Speaker 01 If they were indexed like they should be, this is, I swear this is active. But again, it's fidelity, so I can trust them, but I don't like it. Thanks for your question. Here's our next one.
19:18 Speaker 06 I'm 60 and already retired. Each January, I pull years worth of expenses from my traditional IRA.
19:28 Speaker 06 I have a solid retirement amount with approximately equal parts in traditional IRA and Roth IRA.
19:38 Speaker 06 The only retirement question I haven't made yet is when to take social security.
19:46 Speaker 06 I don't need the money. I could wait until full retirement age or even 70. But I believe I have good arguments for taking it early. I would like your opinion on my arguments for taking social security early. Now, also, if I do take social security early, I would not be increasing my spending. So, therefore, I would take less out of my traditional IRA each year. By taking less out of the traditional IRA, it would last longer and therefore enable the Roth IRA to grow more.
20:26 Speaker 06 So my benefits of taking social security early stem from my Roth IRA being able to grow more. So here are my arguments. Number one, social security is up to 85% taxable. My Roth IRA growth is 0% taxable.
20:49 Speaker 06 Number two, I can't control what social security does. I can control my Roth IRA, however. And number three, my social security ends when I die. Any Roth IRA money left over, however, goes to my heirs.
21:14 Speaker 06 So those are my arguments for taking social security early. Again, I am 60 and already retired, so I am pulling out of my traditional IRA already. Please let me know your thoughts on my arguments for taking social security early. And thank you so much for all you do.
21:34 Speaker 01 You know, I can totally get why you believe that that, that those are sound arguments. I, it makes sense. At first glance, you go, yeah, you know, if I take the social security at 62, you still have to wait two years to do that. If you take it at 62, then you don't have to take as much out of your IRA. I, I get that. It's not good for you. I know it sounds good, but it's not good for you.
22:01 Speaker 01 But the difference between taking social security at 62 and 70 is huge. At 70, the amount you get is about twice as much as what you get at 62 if you wait till 70. That is a gigantic amount and you get that for the rest of your life.
22:26 Speaker 01 Economically, mathematically, financially, the only time it makes sense to start taking social security early is if honestly you believe, you truly believe based on family history or health issues you currently have, that you are not likely to live until 80. It might make sense. It might make sense. That's the only time.
23:02 Speaker 01 Cause you're not going to be in a high tax bracket. So the, the difference between lower taxes on social security and the higher taxes on IRA withdrawals is going to be negligible. Uh, the delaying is better. It's hard to do because you see the money sitting there. It's like, oh, it's a lot of money. I, I was only able to hold out until 69.
23:26 Speaker 01 And I'm supposed to be smarter than this, but no, I did. I took it. I took it at 69. I went, I'm just going to take it. I'm just going to do it. I just want to go enjoy. Maybe I die soon. I don't know. Just hedging my bets. Um, no, preserving the IRA is a short-term strategy and it really, for most people who live well into their 80s, it pencils out detrimentally. So no, do what you're doing and wait to take it. At least wait until FRA, full retirement age. And look at that. We have come to our last question for the episode. Want to send them in? Go to TalkingRealMoney.com, click on the contact form, or call us on Saturdays when
24:10 Speaker 01 we do our radio show, 855-935-TALK. Start calling at about 3:00 PM, a little after 3:00 PM Eastern Time. Here's the last one.
24:19 Speaker 07 Hello, Don and Tom. This is Ginger from California. My question is, you two always mention that the RMDs will start at 73 years of age, but I recently heard that the law was changed. And it was changed to if someone is still younger than 75 as of December 31, 2032, the RMDs will not be required until that person turns 75 in 2033. I was born
25:00 Speaker 07 in 1959, so it looks like I can wait until I'm 75 years of age before I can take my RMDs. It would be great if you could confirm that information. Thank you. Bye-bye.
25:13 Speaker 01 Well, I wish I could confirm that information, but it's not right. There was some initial confusion when Secure 2.0 first passed with the 73-75. Of course, leave it to the government to make it more confusing than it needs to be. But some thoughts that if you were born in 59, you could wait until 75. No. The rule is if you were born in 1960 or later, it's very clear, 1960 or later, you were born a year too early. You have to start taking
25:58 Speaker 01 RMDs at 73, like I do. So, we're in the same boat. Darn it. Yeah, sorry. Can't confirm that because it's not true. You've got to wait. You cannot wait till 75. You have to start taking it at 73.
26:15 Speaker 01 Thanks for the question, though. Thank you all for the great questions. Keep them coming. Just go to TalkingRealMoney.com, click the contact form, send the question in. You can just speak it with your computer mic or your phone mic. Do you know how good the phone mics are these days? Oh, my gosh. I mean, Apple's even advertising their phone mics as near broadcast quality. That's this quality. I mean, I'm on a $1,500 microphone, and they're getting quality that's not as good, but it's not too far off because of the technology they use. Technology is amazing. It really is. It's scary as all get out, but it's also pretty
26:59 Speaker 01 amazing. We just, you know, it behooves us to be up on it. It really, you gotta, you gotta. You can't, you're not going to be able to live in this relatively near future if you don't understand the power of the technologies that we're seeing. You've got to be aware. You've got to use them. You've got to keep yourself in the game. Keep that brain sharp. It's one of the things you should do for retirement. Keep that brain sharp. Well, thank you all for being there, and thank you to the new listeners like Bob and all of the others who haven't called, and the old listeners. Please keep telling people about the podcast because really, truly, it is helping us grow the podcast. And as
27:42 Speaker 01 long as we're growing, we're surviving and thriving. It's when you stop growing that you start declining, and eventually you go away. So don't let us decline. Let us keep moving forward. Take good care of yourselves, and remember to call us on Saturdays at 855935talk between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM Eastern. Take good care of yourselves. We'll be here for as long as you keep listening. Well, hopefully, Talking Real Money.
28:13 Speaker 00 The opinions and views expressed on this podcast were current on the date recorded. Opinions, estimates, forecasts, and statements of financial market trends that are based on current market conditions constitute our judgment and are subject to change without notice, including any forward-looking estimates or statements which are based on certain expectations and assumptions. Although information and opinions given have been obtained from or based on sources believed to be reliable, no warranty or representation is made as to their correctness, completeness, or accuracy. Information presented on the podcast is not personalized investment advice from Appella Wealth. The views and strategies described may not be suitable for everyone. This podcast does not identify all the risks, direct or indirect, or other considerations which might be material to you when entering any financial transaction. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and profitable results cannot be guaranteed. We hope you realize that the information provided on Talking Real Money is for informational,
28:57 Speaker 00 educational, and hopefully enjoyable purposes only. The podcast is not trying to get you to buy or sell any financial products or securities. Instead, the program is provided as a public service by Appella Wealth, a fee-only registered investment advisor. Please see Appella Wealth ADV Part 2A on our website for information regarding Appella's fees and services. Appella Capital LLC, DBA Appella Wealth, is an investment advisory firm registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The firm only transacts business in the states where it is properly registered, or excluded or exempt from registration requirements. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Appella does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing either stated or implied here should be inferred as providing such advice. Thanks for listening, and please visit TalkingRealMoney.com for more information and important
29:39 Speaker 00 disclosure related to performance of any specific index or fund quoted in this podcast. And the lawyers get richer.
Previous Nothing Wins Next Now or Later? Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated