Pod Insights Success Story with Scott D. Clary Lessons - How Extreme Specialization Created an 8-Figure Growth Machine | Chris Dreyer - Rankings.io Founder About this episode ➡️ Like The Podcast? Leave A Rating: https://ratethispodcast.com/successstory In this “Lessons” episode, Chris Dreyer breaks down how modern SEO is being reshaped by AI overviews, changing user behavior, and evolving definitions of quality content. He explains that good content isn’t just well-written; it must effectively match user intent, reduce bounce rates, and encourage engagement. As AI-generated search results and zero-click scenarios take over, Chris highlights the growing importance of schema, trust signals, and becoming an “entity” within your niche. He also explores how Google’s layout increasingly prioritizes paid ads and local service placements over organic results, pushing businesses to rethink their strategy. While generative AI tools can streamline content creation, Chris stresses that human oversight remains essential to maintain credibility and results.➡️ Show Linkshttps://successstorypodcast.com YouTube: https://youtu.be/SCF1KLTtbgU Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/chris-dreyer-seo-strategist-how-extreme-specialization/id1484783544 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/270XMYpOuyJ2htFvGciSx4 ➡️ Watch the Podcast on YouTubehttps://www.youtube.com/c/scottdclary See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 In this lessons episode, discover how content quality is measured by how well it meets user intent. Learn why bounce rates and engagement reveal if your content is truly helpful. Learn how AI overviews and generative search tools are reshaping SEO strategy. And learn why relevance, trust signals, and human oversight still define success in today's search-driven world.
0:28 Speaker 00 Say you can write good content, and I'm curious, actually, what does good mean? Like, good is subjective.
0:35 Speaker 01 Does it answer the consumer's intent effectively?
0:38 Speaker 00 That's it. So it isn't so subjective.
0:40 Speaker 01 Well, I'd say that is the direct answer, but let me give you some complication here.
0:49 Speaker 01 A page can have multiple forms of intent that it needs to address. Okay? So if I had a page on car accidents, well, do they need a lawyer? Do they need to know what happens after a car accident? Are they wondering how many car accidents occur in a city? Do they...
1:10 Speaker 01 There may be many questions that consumer asks, so that page has to answer all of those. It can't answer just one version, because if it only answers the one version and a different consumer comes to the page, and it doesn't answer their intent, they leave? Well, that's a bad signal, right?
1:28 Speaker 01 Bounce rates, page on time, all those things. It's if someone comes to your website, and it's not a good piece of content, and it doesn't answer intent, and then they do another query similar, or they go to another website for the same query, it means potentially that they... that this website, this landing page, did not help them, or it wasn't helpful for them. And over time, if there's enough of that, Google will stop serving you in the number one position.
1:56 Speaker 00 That's scary because if you see a high bounce rate and low time on page, then you know that it's not answering all the questions, but you don't really know. Or I guess you could figure out what questions it's not answering.
2:08 Speaker 01 So there's always the asterisk, right? And it depends, right?
2:11 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:11 Speaker 01 There are, I would say the longer the query to, the more specific it is. You know, what are the steps I need to take after a car accident? Okay, here's the article. There's no guessing. The intent's defined in the query. But there are certain situations where a high bounce rate is absolutely okay. Because they could come to the page, get their intent answered, and then leave. They don't have to go to other websites. Maybe, take something like definitions, right? Nowadays, AI overview's even those up, but define this, okay? Well, like, do I need to write 10,000 words on this definition? Do I need multiple articles to explain? Do they need to visit other pages? They don't. They need to go there, they get the definition, they can leave.
2:54 Speaker 01 So it really depends, but
2:59 Speaker 01 it depends on your goals, on what you're trying to achieve. And a lot, but at the end of the day, it's great content. Does it answer the consumer's intent effectively? And is it endorsed by other people? Do other people vote and think it is a good piece of content?
3:19 Speaker 00 Interestingly, you mentioned AI overview. So AI overview, if you Google anything, it'll give you an AI overview right at the top.
3:28 Speaker 00 I'm assuming, tell me if this is a conspiracy theory. But I think that Google is doing this so that your page isn't ranking as high anymore. People aren't going to the pages. So then that means that you're forced to spend more ad dollars to get a sponsored position for your page to show up. Is that a conspiracy or is that what Google is doing?
3:47 Speaker 01 Absolutely accurate. They're a for-profit business. They make the majority of their publicly traded company's revenue from Google ads. If they can make more money there, they're gonna do it. I will say, It's not like the AI overview zero click scenarios didn't exist. We had rich snippets. They were zero click scenarios that showed the answer and you didn't have to click through through a website.
4:12 Speaker 01 And they have such market share domination. I think they're finally below 90%, but but still that they can create a less satisfactory user experience to supplement their ad revenue.
4:26 Speaker 00 And what does that mean for businesses and SEO?
4:29 Speaker 01 Well, it means, I'll tell you this right now, I've seen a dramatic shift in the benefit of pay per click ads and LSA as opposed to organic and maps. Even if you look at things like above the fold on a monitor,
4:46 Speaker 01 the things that are above the fold are typically local service ads and and Google Ads. After that, then you start getting AI overviews, you start getting the maps and organic. So they have the best positioning from a virtual real estate perspective. So what does that mean if you're if you're a firm or a business? Well, you need to reconsider Google Ads if you had tried it in the past or didn't have a lot of success because they're kind of forcing you to use it. Now you got to get all your economies and metrics right for cost per lead, cost per acquisition, ROAS and all the all the things. Right? But it's becoming more effective because of how Google's designing Google Search.
5:31 Speaker 00 Now, the interesting bit about AI is that those those AI overviews or the if you're using ChatGPT or Perplexity or I guess Claude wouldn't be used as or Gemini, I guess, as a search tool. Yeah, oh, Grok, exactly. That is obviously taking some of the traffic away from Google because people are using generative chat as search tools. But at the same time, the results in some cases are referenced to websites. So now you have an SEO game through generative chat. How do you play that game?
6:08 Speaker 01 Really like this question. So you're dead on. So there's two things that you want to do. First, focus on what I would say bottom of the funnel, the your your service pages, your sales pages, because it lends itself to optionality and choice, right?
6:26 Speaker 01 Back in the day, you could write a "What do you do after a car accident?" And like, maybe you could get a conversion out of that. But like, that's just like an evergreen topic and like, it's gonna be in the AI overview. But Car Accident Lawyer of Chicago, they're gonna give you some options to review. You know, how close is this firm to you? You know, what's their review rating? They're gonna give you optionality first. So I would say strategically, to kind of counter the AI component, the first thing is focus bottom up of the funnel. Instead of the top of the funnel where you're trying to get awareness, I really look at Google and search engine marketing, all encompassing everything on Google, as a capture play more so than an awareness play. So it is, it's capturing demand more so than creating demand.
7:12 Speaker 01 The next thing is your question about G E O, Generative Engine Optimization, the L L Ms.
7:19 Speaker 01 They, the truth is, no one really knows. But I will say that Schema and some of these highly trusted sites are cited.
7:31 Speaker 01 You go look at Perplexity, it'll definitely tell you where the citations are. And Chat G P T will, will, will give you, based upon their analysis, you can start to understand where they're pulling that from. I'll give you an example for myself. Right now, we rank like, third for S E O for lawyers. Above me is a competitor and then Clio. Well, I get on that and I remember before I was listed on Clio, I would say, you know, who's the best personal injury S E O company? And I wouldn't pop up.
8:07 Speaker 01 Yet, I'm on 20 other websites that say, "We're number one." Right? Clutch, Design Rush, competitor sites putting us number one. The one article we weren't on was Clio's. I get on that, you go type in the same thing for GPT, boom. So it's, it's the trust signals for certain sites are different. Wikipedia is a big one for LLMs. And so in different categories, there are different trusted entities.
8:42 Speaker 01 It's an association, an entity is an association with something, so. I go really down the rabbit hole here without trying to get too nerdy on this, sounds super nerdy.
8:51 Speaker 00 No, I love it. I love it because first of all, there is a lot of people that care about this stuff. A lot of entrepreneurs are trying to figure out this new game. They're smart, but also I'm seeing, I'll give you another example, something I noticed. Now I'm playing around with the deep search tools on perplexity and chat GPT and, and they both, chat GPT in particular. I think they both actually show their workflow as they're going through this. Chat GPT's deep search for any query, eight to 11 minutes, so it's long comparatively. But if you open up the sidebar, it shows every question that it has and the source that it's going to for the answer. And I'm just so curious, like some of these sources, like how does it pick this source?
9:33 Speaker 00 And that source, and it'll go through like 20 to 30 different sources to come out with a very complex answer. It'll be, it'll be cited in the actual output, but it'll also be cited in this source column as it's thinking and showing you all the websites it's navigating to.
9:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's, it's, it's unreal. It is.
9:52 Speaker 01 It's changing the game. And you know, even in the AI overviews, it's, it's citing the source, right? Where it's pulling from. So it's a combination of all that. And, but I think again, typically, even when you ask it, it's still going to give you multiple answers for like a business, like who are the top, whatever. Typically doesn't give you one.
10:16 Speaker 01 Even on a who's the best car accident lawyer? If we typed it.
10:20 Speaker 00 What was the, what was the nerdy rabbit hole that you were hesitant to go down?
10:24 Speaker 01 Well, I'm trying to think where, where I was gonna go with that. You know, with your schema and signals and things like that.
10:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm not sure, but I think we hit it on the head. It's, it's schema, it is entities. So, okay, so, so like on the entities component.
10:44 Speaker 01 They're basically entities are associations, right? And Google, if we go back to the beginning, Google's job is to organize the web. LLM, it's to pull accurate sources, right? Kind of combination of both. So you take something like St. Louis. One of the first things that probably popped in your mind when you're thinking about the city of St. Louis is the Arch. Right? That's an entity, right? If you can become an entity in the city, there's an association that will help you contribute to trust and to rank in that respective city.
11:17 Speaker 00 Is there any way for a business to become an entity in a city?
11:22 Speaker 01 I think, I think it's reputation, it's, it's word of mouth, it's being listed in other, other entities. So you take something like a Chamber of Commerce, right? In St. Louis, you're now listed as a business entity in this chamber. It goes back to old school, you know, SEO things and listings and citations, but the quicker you can do that, that's why a lot of businesses, when they're expanding to their secondary market, struggle. Because a lot of times they're getting a satellite office, they're not getting, they're not doing the full brick and morgue, they're not being a part of the community. Guess what? They're not a known entity in that market. That's, that's the issue.
12:01 Speaker 00 Last question on this, and I'm sure you get it a lot. What happens when you use a generative chat tool to write content?
12:08 Speaker 01 Well, it's significantly better. There's a lot of tools, Surfer, Jasper, uh, there's a ton of them and we've used.
12:16 Speaker 00 It still ranks?
12:17 Speaker 01 It still ranks, absolutely, but it still needs human oversight. It's
12:25 Speaker 01 it, it, it's, it's like a tool currently, it's not a standalone still, in my opinion. It's a tool to enhance productivity. So we see a lot more prompt engineering editors as opposed to, you know, manually sourcing and citing writers.
12:42 Speaker 01 There's a lot, lot of things that you can do here. You know, there's even other tools to check for AI, there's for originality, for voice. But it also, I was having a conversation with a, a big firm in San Antonio. And, and I use the language like, hey, we can do this old school because I don't really want to do it old school. I want to do cutting edge, right? I didn't want to.
13:04 Speaker 01 Be negative and talk down, but it is old school now. Like I can prompt engineer something to look and evaluate the top ranking pages to determine length, things I need to include to make my article better. I can take an existing piece of article and I can fill it in and say, you know, what are the weaknesses? What should I consider adding to this? So, right now it's a tool and enhances productivity and utilization, but you have to be careful because sometimes the sources are incorrect and so it's use with care.
13:39 Speaker 00 Thanks for tuning in. If you found this valuable, don't forget to hit that subscribe button so you never miss an episode. And if you want to dive deeper into this conversation, check out the links in the description to watch the full episode. See you in the next one.
Previous Gil Dezer - Developer & Visionary | From $500 Million Debt to Luxury Real Estate Empire Next Jeremy Miner - Sales Training Expert | The Sales Framework That Closes 93% More Deals Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated