Will SCOTUS Make It Harder to Sue Federal Officers?
Hosted by Kate Shaw, Leah Litman and Melissa Murray
- 1h 32m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode covers the Supreme Court oral arguments in Nielsen v. Watanabe, examining whether individuals can sue federal prison officials for violating constitutional rights, and Department of Labor v. Sun Orchards, which concerns agency enforcement against corporate labor abuses. The hosts discuss how these cases illustrate a broader trend of eliminating accountability for both the executive branch and powerful corporate interests. They also examine recent conservative judicial nominations, new developments in congressional oversight, and the urgent necessity of structural Supreme Court reform as an integral part of broader political change.
- Congress should enact a legislative Bivins fix to authorize damage suits against federal officers who violate constitutional rights. 48:31
- Federal lawmakers must prioritize comprehensive Supreme Court reform to ensure that democratically enacted regulations and laws survive judicial review. 38:00
- Voters and organizers should push newly elected representatives to hold oversight hearings examining the Supreme Court's role in public corruption and regulatory rollback. 1:22:43
Chapters
- 0:00Podcast Introduction and Advertisements
Hosts introduce the episode and the podcast, followed by a series of commercial spots.
- 2:27Hosts and Episode Overview
Leah, Kate, and Melissa explain the episode’s focus on Supreme Court reform and recent political events.
- 3:49Hegseth Impeachment Week and Veterans Day Incident
The hosts discuss the brief impeachment week and a viral moment involving a veteran at a Hegseth event.
- 6:05Supreme Court Reform Package Ideas
Kate and Leah outline potential reforms, including a new position to enforce decorum and oversight of justices.
- 6:41Mississippi Senate Race and Scott Colom’s Victory
They recap Scott Colom’s win, his background, and the political implications for federal appointments.
- 11:24Political Climate and Congressional Reform Needs
The hosts analyze the current political environment and the necessity of structural reforms to address accountability issues.
- 34:00Closing Reflections on Court Reform
The hosts conclude by emphasizing the importance of court reform and the role of public engagement.
- 41:39Supreme Court Cases: Nielsen v. Watanabe
They discuss the case’s implications for suing federal officers and the court’s likely stance on accountability.
- 48:14Congressional Response and Bivins Fix
Leah and Kate explain how Congress could address the court’s decisions through legislation.
- 49:02Supreme Court Cases: Department of Labor v. Sun Orchard
The episode covers another case involving corporate accountability and its connection to the Watanabe decision.
- 50:57Kagan Oral Argument Highlights
The episode examines Justice Kagan’s oral argument, focusing on the debate over whether enforcement actions should occur in agency proceedings or federal court.
- 55:25Border Wall Jurisdiction Decision
Hosts analyze the Supreme Court’s order that limited challenges to the border wall to constitutional claims, discussing implications for major questions doctrine.
Highlights
- 4:14
Arlington Guard Viral Momentstory
The hosts discuss a viral moment where an Arlington Guard yelled at Pete Hegseth's entourage for lacking respect at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, noting the resulting public shaming.
- 6:35
Mississippi Senate Victorystory
The hosts celebrate Scott Colom's historic Senate victory in Mississippi, noting his previous work defending gender-affirming care.
- 11:13
Supreme Court Justices on Fox Newsinsight
Three Supreme Court justices appeared in promotional videos filmed by the Federalist Society and aired on Fox News, raising questions about judicial independence.
- 41:44
Bivins Accountability Debatedebate
The hosts analyze oral arguments in Nielsen v. Watanabe, where the federal government and defendants argued that federal prison guards should not be sued under Bivins for deliberate indifference.
- 49:17
DOL Corporate Penalties Disputedata
The Supreme Court heard arguments in Department of Labor v. Sun Orchards regarding whether the DOL can use administrative proceedings to penalize agricultural employers.
- 55:25
Border Wall Construction Orderinsight
The Supreme Court issued a shadow docket order clearing the way for the Trump administration to build a border wall in Big Bend.
Quotes
“where federal courts are already overburdened, would likely grind the enforcement of some of these laws and regulations to a halt”
Kate Shaw · 52:15 “the major questions doctrine, which the lower court relied on, isn't constitutional, which actually, pretty enormous silver lining here, is great news.”
Kate Shaw · 56:16 “every single one of the ones that got challenged, got struck down either by a lower court or by the Supreme Court, every single one of them.”
Kate Shaw · 1:11:26
Sponsored segments
- Americans United for Separation of Church and State 0:00–0:56
- Regent Seven Seas Cruises 0:57–1:12
- Rubrik 1:13–1:43
- Quince 19:27–21:21
- Zbiotics 21:25–23:13
- OneSkin 38:16–40:09
- Aura Frames 40:09–41:12
- Alloy Health 1:03:48–1:06:43
- Crooked Media 1:06:45–1:08:05
- Crooked Store 1:25:58–1:26:44
About this episode
This week, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in two cases about accountability… or lack thereof. First, they heard a case that could make it more difficult to sue federal officers for Eight Amendment violations-- interesting timing when ICE is running rampant. Then, a case about holding corporations accountable for mistreating their workers contained a disturbing takeaway: this Supreme Court seems to be further to the right than the Trump administration on corporate accountability. Plus: Pete Hegseth’s attempted (and failed) impeachment, Scott Colom’s huge win in Mississippi, Senate Democrats skipping crucial judicial confirmation hearings, and a strange Fox news appearance from Justices Gorsuch, Barrett, and Kavanaugh. Finally, Somil Trivedi, advocacy director and senior counsel at Court Accountability, joins Leah to talk about what Democrats can do now that they have the gavels. Favorite Things: Leah: John Oliver https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LO5iHyYa0XM on Hegseth | Adam Serwer’s https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/11/scott-colom-us-senate-democrats/689395/?gift=Je3D9AQS-C17lUTOnl2W8JGHNLgohdkgM7Ei-07npYc&utm_source=copy-link&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=share Atlantic piece on Scott Colom | Sarah McBride https://bsky.app/profile/lizzieohreally.bsky.social/post/3mzt2aaslc22i at Crooked Con | Kaylor is Back! Kate: Judge Richard Posner’s incredible legacy https://news.bloomberglaw.com/environment-and-energy/posner-fearsome-on-the-bench-showed-us-the-fun-in-inquiry | Department of Fate https://bookshop.org/p/books/untitled-4542-crown/58ed66768ff9d802 by Rachel Maddow New Strict merch available here https://store.crooked.com/products/were-gonna-need-a-bigger-court-graphic-t-shirt. You can now listen to Strict Scrutiny for CLE credits in California, New York, Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Washington, and Oregon! More info at crooked.com/strict_cle http://crooked.com/strict_cleBuy Melissa’s book,The U. S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader https://bookshop.org/p/books/the-constitution-annotated-for-the-contemporary-reader-melissa-murray/8e7f0dfa472fc3ca?ean=9781668221938&next=t&Buy Leah’s book, Lawless https://bookshop.org/p/books/lawless-how-the-supreme-court-runs-on-conservative-grievance-fringe-theories-and-bad-vibes-leah-litman/5b562d6fcb316d6e?ean=9781668054642&next=t, now out in paperback Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/strictscrutinypodcast/?hl=en,Threads https://www.threads.net/@strictscrutinypodcast, andBluesky https://bsky.app/profile/strictscrutiny.bsky.socialFor a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny please email [email protected] mailto:[email protected]
Transcript
17,466 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Supreme Court
- Trump administration
- Department of Labor
- Court Accountability
- Nvidia
- CHIPS
- Veterans Day
- Sun Valley
- H2A program
- Citizens United
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated