Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Real Science with Bill Maher (Part 2) About this episode They say “Science thrives on controversy.” So do Neil deGrasse Tyson, Bill Maher, and Dr. David Grinspoon in Part 2 of Neil’s interview with the feisty comedian and host of “Real Time with Bill Maher.”
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 Meu Deus, és linda. Obrigado por mi vida. Translation: My God, you're beautiful. Thank you for listening. Yes, I'm talking to you, but I'm talking to you in Português. That is correct. You never know when you're gonna find yourself in Portugal, or when you're gonna talk to somebody from Brazil who also speaks Portuguese. You know, if you're gonna travel anywhere, you'd be surprised how much it helps to know the language, even if you don't know it fluently. But let's say you do wanna know it fluently. Well, I have an answer for both. Rosetta Stone. That's right. Rosetta Stone has just launched Rosetta Stone Sapphire, featuring Sapphire Studio,
0:43 Speaker 00 which lets you personalize your learning around what you actually care about right now. Now, we all know that I use Rosetta Stone so that I can understand what my mother-in-law is saying about me behind my back. But maybe you're traveling and you just wanna know, "Hey, what do I say when I check in? How do I talk to the taxi driver?" Rosetta Stone Sapphire is gonna allow you to talk to people in real-world situations in their own language. And the great thing is you can do it on your phone, on your tablet, at your own pace, on your own time schedule. So what are you waiting for? Go ahead and take your language skills to the next level. Don't wait to try Rosetta Stone Sapphire. StarTalk listeners can get 20% off their Rosetta Stone Sapphire subscription
1:27 Speaker 00 when they sign up today. This gets you access to Rosetta Stone Sapphire in 25 languages. So go to rosettastone.com and sign up today.
1:39 Speaker 01 Welcome to Science of Perception Box.
1:42 Speaker 02 Perception Box. Perception Box. One's own perception of consciousness.
1:45 Speaker 01 And the Perception Box. Hi, I'm Elizabeth Koch. What's a Perception Box? You could think of it as a kind of reality filter that's constantly shaping how we see ourselves, other people, and the world around us. Yet we often don't even recognize it's there. Your face is a mask, and you're behind this mask. Science of Perception Box.
2:04 Speaker 03 Listen and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. StarTalk Radio is presented by ChatGPT. ChatGPT Work, a new way to work in ChatGPT, helps you move from goals to real outcomes. ChatGPT Work can use info from your apps, files and plugins like Slack, calendars and meeting notes to help produce finished materials. Plus, it can stay with bigger projects for hours while you still remain in control. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects.
2:42 Speaker 03 Get started at chatgpt.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro Plans.
2:52 Speaker 04 Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide.
3:01 Speaker 04 StarTalk begins right now.
3:12 Speaker 04 Welcome to StarTalk Radio. I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. I'm an astrophysicist with the American Museum of Natural History in New York City, where I also serve as Director of the Hayden Planetarium. My co-host in studio in Manhattan this week is my friend and colleague, David Grin spoon. He's an astrobiologist. I don't think he was that his whole life. I mean, he started out as like a legitimate scientist. He's later turned to thinking about, I knew him as a planetary scientist and an astrophysicist, but lately he's like thinking about life in the universe. That's legitimate, of course, except you don't have any data, right?
3:52 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, we have a data about what the planets are like and data that we're learning about what life needs and has needed in the past, which at least allows us to, in an informed way, surmise where else in the universe there may be life, but we haven't found it yet.
4:06 Speaker 04 Using Earth as a foundation for those ideas.
4:09 David Grinspoon? We pretty much have to. We're stuck here as of now, mostly.
4:12 Speaker 04 So in these two hours, and this the final hour of today's show, I have an interview with Bill Maher. My last trip to LA, he agreed to do a sit-down interview from his offices. And we talked about everything under the sun. And it's very Bill Maherian in the way the information flowed. We talked about science, science literacy, we talked about religion. And then I have more clips to put in here. We talked about politics and how they all intersect. And David, I know you've done a lot of public speaking and you've written books. And so I bring you into studio just to sort of help me explore where the science is in
4:55 Speaker 04 the debates between scientists and politicians and those who are religious. And you have some exposure there, right? I presume.
5:04 David Grinspoon? Well, yeah, I work in a museum, as you do. And we're out west, we're of a slightly different population, so encounter a wide...
5:15 Speaker 04 Like a slightly different population, where everyone has a gun.
5:17 David Grinspoon? Yeah, not everyone. It's not mandatory yet that you must carry a gun, as far as I know. That's probably coming soon. But no, you know, we encounter a wide range of views. And that's sort of part of our job, is to be able to talk to a lot of different kinds of people.
5:32 Speaker 04 And at the basis of all of this is kind of what is your science education as a kid, right? Growing up, and what were your teachers like? What was the culture of your family like? And so I chatted with Bill Maher about his own sort of upbringing and what influence that might have had on him. Let's check it out. So Bill, where'd you grow up?
5:51 Speaker 06 That's a little personal, Doc.
5:53 Speaker 04 I didn't mean to get that personal on you.
5:56 Speaker 06 But this was about science. No, I grew up in New Jersey.
5:59 Speaker 04 What exit?
6:00 Speaker 06 Yeah, exactly. The most made fun of state, so. That's why I always like to say it with pride.
6:07 Speaker 04 Did you go to public schools there?
6:08 Speaker 06 Oh, yes, I had a very Leave it to Beaver upbringing, but it really bothers me that the current governor of New Jersey, Governor Fat Fatty, was asked recently what he thought of evolution and his answer was, "That's none of your business." Which really bothered me because, you know, as I say, we were so made fun of New Jersey, you know, what exit and it stinks, all that stuff. But the one thing we had was that, hey, we're one of the smarter states, I thought.
6:36 Speaker 04 In fact, New Jersey had the highest per capita number of PhDs. When you have all the universities there and they had all the think tanks and all the pharmaceutical companies, so you're right, it was one of the smartest states.
6:46 Speaker 06 Right, well, I didn't know that, but I did know that we weren't Kansas or Alabama and we had that to, you know, at least wear as a badge of pride. And so to find out that the governor of this state where I got a pretty good public school education was telling people, "None of your business," when they ask him about evolution, that's what you say when they ask if you made a baby with the maid for crying out loud. So that did not sit well with me.
7:13 Speaker 04 But you turned out okay, so you clearly were under the leadership of a previous governor.
7:18 Speaker 06 Well, it wasn't the governor, it was a different world back then when the Republicans weren't crazy and anti-intellectual. Uh, but yeah, I think New Jersey was a pretty darn good place to grow up.
7:30 Speaker 04 Just a couple of points there. Uh, when people joke about the exit, uh, the New Jersey turnpike goes the entire length of New Jersey and it's got like eighteen or twenty exits to it. And so people joke about what exit are you from and also about whether New Jersey stinks. It's not just a, a sentimental argument against it, it's that there are oil refineries not far from New York City in New Jersey and you drive through there and everyone says, "Roll down the window, who just cut the cheese?" It's actually the window is the problem because everything smells like rotten eggs in that, in that section. I don't know if you knew that, David.
8:07 David Grinspoon? I've been to New Jersey. Yeah, I, I saw the Grateful Dead there, you know, when I was in college.
8:11 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, yeah. And they've got some points of pride, you know. The boss is from Jersey.
8:16 David Grinspoon? Exactly, yeah, yeah. We all know about Jersey from Springsteen lyrics.
8:20 Speaker 04 Yeah, so but the theme here is what does your upbringing do for you and what's taught in the schools? So do you have strong opinions about this across the country? You know, our constitution does not specify how you educate people. And you're about to spend a year in Washington at the Library of Congress, where you have this new chair of astrobiology, the first occupant. And I don't think you are without influence as to how you can convince people of what should happen in the elementary schools.
8:52 David Grinspoon? Well, I do have strong opinions in that, you know, I absolutely think science should be taught in science class and religion shouldn't be taught in science class. Although it's funny, you know, when you hear this debate and you hear some of these bills about multiple views and the evidence for them should be presented in science class. And people rail against that because they think, oh, that's a secret plan to get religion in science class. Well, if they're really going to honestly talk about multiple views and really honestly talk about the evidence, then I'm all in favor of that. So it depends if you're really going to do that or use that as a subterfuge to start, you know, denying evolution.
9:28 Speaker 04 Well, of course, the difference is there are debatable topics on the frontier of science that scientists talk about all the time. And then there are issues in politics and religion that people bring to the science table and then they want to assert that these are legitimate controversies in science, when in fact, they're just not.
9:48 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I mean, science thrives on controversy. If we didn't have different views, we wouldn't be making progress. That's what we do. You put forward ideas and you shoot them down. But there's also sort of fake controversy that gets promoted sometimes by people with an interest in sort of muddying the waters. And, you know, then you can get into the whole climate question, which is a great example of that.
10:09 Speaker 04 Yeah, but what you have are politicians and media.
10:15 Speaker 04 Bringing the cultural diss- dissension towards scientific views and then asserting that as the actual controversy.
10:22 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I mean, that's, that's a problem because, again, scientists have to disagree with each other, but people can use that disagreement and say, aha, you don't all agree, and nobody knows anything, and therefore, we don't have to act. And you have to be able to have uncertainty and yet have an opinion about what's likely.
10:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, so when we come back, in our next segment, more with my interview with Bill Maher, and we start, we talk about how funding has influenced politics and what gets taught in schools. We'll be right back.
10:56 Speaker 04 We're back on StarTalk Radio. I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, a natural physicist at New York City's American Museum of Natural History. I also serve as the director of the Hayden Planetarium there, and I've got in studio, as my guest co-host, my friend and colleague, David Grin spoon, who of recent months has been, been knighted the Bloomberg Astrobiologist Chair. Is that right? Do I get that right?
11:21 David Grinspoon? Yeah, Chair of Astrobiology at the Library of Congress.
11:24 Speaker 04 That's just so cool. It sounds so lofty, and that's like a really awesome business card that when you get those made. I want one of those.
11:29 David Grinspoon? Absolutely.
11:30 Speaker 04 So, we've been listening to my interview with Bill Maher, and Bill Maher, the always guaranteed controversial Bill Maher, who speaks his mind, which is actually quite refreshing if you, if you like that sort of thing. I happen to love that sort of thing. And he's a political commentator and a comedian, host of HBO's Real Time with Bill Maher, and I interviewed him from his offices in Los Angeles in my last trip out there. And we were talking about how sort of politics and religion might influence science education, in particular how religion and their forces might try to get religious agendas in the school. But religion is not the only force out there. There's politics, right? There can be politics
12:11 Speaker 04 without religion that's trying to change agendas. And so I've, I've been intrigued by that. What would, how would you assess the political climate at your home, home base in Colorado, in Denver?
12:22 David Grinspoon? Well, you know, it's mixed. It's Colorado's traditionally sort of, you know, red state, whatever, Republican state. But there are these hotbeds of liberalism in more the urbanized areas, Denver, Boulder, Aspen.
12:39 Speaker 04 By the way, that's a general truth, that the closer you live to a city, the more liberal your views become. I've always found that to be an interesting demographic statistic.
12:50 David Grinspoon? Yeah, it is interesting. And, you know, there've been some battles about education in the schools. For the most part, I think that that has not been a huge problem, that science is still taught in science classes. And, you know, we have problems with our schools as far as them not having resources and the same kind of things that have everywhere. But it's not religious incursion is not really our biggest problem that we're having in the schools.
13:16 Speaker 04 So, of course, there's what forced religion either does or doesn't have in trying to shape the agenda. There's also the notions, particularly emergent in recent times, that there's a Republican war on science. And I never fully agreed with all of those claims that were made, because when I think of a war, I think of someone trying to withdraw funding. That's kind of what matters in Washington. What you say is irrelevant. It's what do you do about budget? Does your budget go up? Does it go down? And I noted that in most of the 20th century, that funding for science has been higher under Republican presidents than it has been under Democratic presidents.
13:58 Speaker 04 And that's sort of what I cue on, because that's what drives things. And in my interview with Bill Maher, I posed this to him, because he's very anti-Republican, especially of late. And I just was curious what his views were. Let's check that out.
14:13 Speaker 04 So I don't know if you know this, but over the last 50 years, funding for science in the country has been higher under Republican presidents than under Democratic presidents. And so the argument there is, well, because they're just funding their like Star Wars and all this other stuff, but it's just a fact. And so how would you work with that information?
14:31 Speaker 06 Well, first of all, if you're going back 50 years, the Republican Party was very different 50 years ago, it was very different 20 years ago. 50 years ago, there was such a thing as a liberal Republican, actual liberals who were Republicans, Nelson Rockefeller, John Lindsay, Everett Dirksen, Edward Brooke of Massachusetts, lots of liberal Republicans.
14:50 Speaker 04 That's a good list.
14:51 Speaker 06 It was a completely different party. 20 years ago, there were moderate Republicans. So, you know, in that environment, I'm not surprised, yet Republican Nixon started the EPA. Republicans, you know, before this recent era of insane Republicans, before this time when the left moved to the center and the right moved to the mental ward, yeah, Republicans did a lot of good things and they were not a party that you simply sneered at because there was no one in that party who was a weirdo. I keep calling them mental and crazy. I'm trying to find another way around it that seems more genteel, but I can't. I mean, there's nobody left in that party. There's no such thing anymore.
15:34 Speaker 04 Who do you blame? The candidates?
15:36 Speaker 06 As a moderate Republican.
15:37 Speaker 04 The candidates or the people who elect the candidates? I mean, these are our fellow countrymen.
15:41 Speaker 06 Absolutely. I always blame the people.
15:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, all right.
15:44 Speaker 06 I mean, it always goes back to the people. I mean, obviously politicians leave a lot to be desired, but they go where the votes are. That's why this is a representative democracy. So, yeah.
15:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, so they are us. That's what you're saying.
15:57 Speaker 06 They are us. If the Tea Party didn't exist, if the Tea Party, if the base of the Republican Party, which is the Tea Party, didn't believe what it believed, you would not hear politicians pander to that and, yeah.
16:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, so, okay, so he was, I didn't know he was not always anti-Republican. That's an emergent, he might have always voted Democrat, but he, the vehemence is particularly strong in recent, in recent years.
16:23 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
16:24 Speaker 04 What I'm interested, though, is if you look at the split of who is generally liberal and who is generally conservative, and you look at scientists, in my experience, scientists, particularly Astro folk, are like ninety-five percent like liberal Democrat anti-war. Is that consistent with your data, too?
16:42 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I would say so. I mean, and part of that's just, I think academics and intellectuals are typically more sort of progressive lefty or whatever, and I consider myself-
16:54 Speaker 04 But why?
16:55 David Grinspoon? ...that, although hopefully not knee-jerk lefty.
16:57 Speaker 04 What's your insight into what stimulates that?
17:00 David Grinspoon? Well, that's, that's an interesting question. I mean, you know, as, as a progressive lefty, I would say it's because those are enlightened positions, but I, but I, but I actually agree with what Bill Maher said, is that the Republican Party has a history of enlightened positions that are just different from the Democratic Party, and unfortunately, there are some very loud voices today, which do not represent the whole Republican Party, but are extremely visible, which are clearly anti-science. I mean, there are people saying that all of climate science is some crazy conspiracy, which it's not, and unfortunately, those tend to be Republican Tea Party-type people. That's not the entire Republican Party, certainly doesn't represent the history of the Republican
17:44 David Grinspoon? Party, but it's very loud right now, and that leads to some of this concept of a Republican war on science, which may be unfair.
17:51 Speaker 04 Right, especially since Abraham Lincoln was Republican.
17:54 David Grinspoon? Absolutely.
17:55 Speaker 04 And, in fact, he founded the National Academy of Sciences, as an advising body to Congress, so there's interesting legacies there. But what of the, the, the one in a hundred, or ten in a hundred perhaps, scientists who you can see being marched forward with views that are just counter to what the emergent consensus had been? What's your- What's your view of that? Because they they become very useful political pawns.
18:23 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
18:23 Speaker 04 Right? If you've got somebody who's denying climate change and they're scientists and they're pedigreed and they come from a fancy institution, they get they they are found, they are marched forward. And it's like, see, we got our guy and you got your guy, so therefore it's a controversy.
18:37 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, first of all, if you remove it from just the politics, we need those guys. Science needs its dissenters. You know, it's not science if everybody agrees.
18:44 Speaker 04 It needs its scientists who are dissenters.
18:46 David Grinspoon? Exactly. But what gets complicated is when people bring agendas to it, political agendas. And then some of these guys get put on pedestals and they say, aha, they don't agree. And then some of them, there's some dishonesty. You look at the agendas and some of these people are under the payroll of some company that maybe is going to benefit if we don't change our policy in a way that might be guided by the science. Certainly not all of them, but that's where it gets complicated is that there are these agendas that get brought into that arena and science.
19:15 Speaker 04 Well, that's because scientists are human beings, right? And we speak of the word agenda as though it's bad, but everybody's got an agenda. I've got an agenda. I want to sort of spread the love of science literacy. And so is that bad?
19:32 David Grinspoon? Well, it's bad when the science is skewed in a way that is not made clear. Like, say, somebody's.
19:39 Speaker 04 Oh, I see. So it influences the interpretation of the science?
19:42 David Grinspoon? Yeah, I mean, a classic example, there's a study of a drug that gets published showing that this drug really works and somebody's making a profit from that. And it turns out that that study was funded by the company that's making a profit. If that's not revealed, you've got a problem. If there's an agenda that is not just seeking the truth, which is ultimately what science is about.
20:02 Speaker 04 So, in fact, we're quite, you and I are quite insulated from this as astro folk.
20:08 David Grinspoon? Because there's no way anybody can make a profit doing what we do.
20:10 Speaker 04 They can't. Okay, it is true, I wrote a book on Pluto that about that controversy. But that book was not a bestseller, I'll have you know.
20:20 David Grinspoon? We can we can write books if and if they're if they're good, then then people ought to buy them and we ought to make money. But for actually doing our research and publishing papers, you know, we're. Basically, government funding is really the only game for that. And it's hard to imagine why somebody would have a strong agenda for one answer or another if that's your source of funding.
20:39 Speaker 04 It's funny, at my first political appointment, it actually turned out to be under George Bush, I had this long interview and testing my worthiness of such a post. And I was asked, have I ever been involved in any controversial issues? So I said, yes, the demotion of Pluto? I mean, they're ready for me to reveal some politically deep political issue here. When we come back, more of my interview with Bill Maher and my in-studio guest, friend and colleague, David James.
21:14 Speaker 00 Life on Earth can be hard. I mean, it's not even really our planet. It belongs to microbial organisms that are living in our gut and living on everything else, too. We're really just an Uber ride for all these organisms. And sometimes when we're giving those organisms a ride, they pay us with sickness and death.
21:41 Speaker 00 All right, maybe I'm getting a little dark here. You know, what I'm saying is Earth can be a lot. You know, everything from what I just said to the fact that there's a sun that's going to engulf us very soon, in about, I don't know, five billion years, give or take. Cosmically speaking, you've earned a break. So escape to Pluto TV. Yeah, I did it. Yeah, you heard it, I did it. Turn off all your earthly problems and turn on the movies and shows you already love. From Anchorman, The Legend of Ron Burgundy, to Dirty Dancing. Pluto TV is out there. Sure, it's not a planet anymore, but it is the best destination in the solar system. Sorry, Jupiter. And the number one reason why? Pluto TV is completely free.
22:26 Speaker 00 No subscription, no fees, zero dollars. And as any mathematician will tell you, zero is one of the most profound numbers ever conceived. Is it really a number? Is the absence of value a value? Who cares about that? The best things on TV are free. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never.
22:50 Speaker 01 We know life is busy. That's why saving money should be effortless. With Atlantic Union Bank's Roundup Savings, every time you use your debit card, your purchase rounds up to the nearest dollar and automatically goes into savings. So whether you're grabbing coffee, filling the tank, or picking up groceries, you're saving without even thinking about it. It's just one of the ways Atlantic Union Bank makes managing your money easy. Learn more at atlanticunionbank.com or stop by a branch today. Atlantic Union Bank, any way you bank.
23:18 Speaker 07 Hey, Richmond. Mark Smith, Midas Richmond. 2026. We have been doing what we do for 29 years. Total car care, total community care. In 2026, we are donating $365,000. $1,000 a day to the nonprofits we've historically supported. Gooch and Care, Shalom Farms, St. Joseph's Villa, Ask, the Colonial Heights Food Pantry, everybody we've helped over the years. These are important things making a big impact in our society right now. Total car care, total community care, that is Midas of Richmond.
23:52 Speaker 04 We're back on Star Talk Radio. We've been listening to my interview with Bill Maher. He's a comedian, of course, and a political commentator. Host of HBO's Real Time with Bill Maher. He's sort of a rabid leftist commentator, yet on every one of his shows, he's got a guest who's definitely from the right, unimpeachably from the right. So he loves hearing your views and then making fun of them. And, you know, politics can be an issue of life or death, not only, of course, in warfare, but in other, other elements of modern life, like the death penalty, abortion. These issues come up, and they're not completely intractable to scientific analysis. And I just wanted to explore what Bill Maher had to say on these topics. Check it out.
24:34 Speaker 04 You support the death penalty, according to my notes. Isn't it largely Republican?
24:39 Speaker 06 I don't, yeah.
24:40 Speaker 04 They might not have birthed the idea, but...
24:41 Speaker 06 I guess so. I mean, I have a lot of ideas that you might consider conservative, but I feel like on that, I'm just consistent, like the Pope is consistent. The Pope is consistently pro-life. I'm consistently pro-death. I'm for the death penalty, although I do believe in more DNA testing. I, my motto is, let's kill the right people. I'm pro-choice. I'm for assisted suicide. I'm for regular suicide. I'm for whatever gets the freeway moving. That's what I'm for.
25:10 Speaker 04 All right, wait, wait.
25:11 Speaker 06 It's too crowded. The planet is too crowded and we need to promote death.
25:14 Speaker 04 When I look at the Venn diagram of people who are pro-death penalty and pro-choice, I don't think they intersect. You may be the lone person in the world at that intersection.
25:25 Speaker 06 Absolutely not. I've met plenty of people who have the same feelings.
25:29 Speaker 04 Pro-choice and...
25:30 Speaker 06 Yeah, I mean, well, pro- I mean, you know, I'm not randomly going around in the streets saying, "Hey, we're gonna kill you." I mean, we're talking about people who've earned it. But as I say, you know...
25:39 Speaker 04 Kill the right people.
25:40 Speaker 06 Kill the right people. You know, there probably should be a moratorium on it until they can get it right. Because certainly you don't want more situations like they had down in Texas, and I'm sure other states, where, you know, the guys with lawyers who fell asleep and wound up being on death row and prejudice and lots of other ridiculous... But nowadays, I think it is possible.
26:02 Speaker 04 In principle, to get that right.
26:03 Speaker 06 Yeah, to get that right. And some of the heinous crimes people commit. I don't know what is more humane, actually, to warehouse someone in prison for their entire life. I mean, some lives, you know, if that's what the rest of your life is gonna be, you have no possibility of parole. I think it's actually...
26:21 Speaker 04 You're like four consecutive life sentences.
26:23 Speaker 06 Yeah, I mean, I think it's actually more humane to just snuff it out.
26:26 Speaker 04 I heard they got rid of the final dinner. You have to eat the prison food.
26:30 Speaker 06 Oh, now that's cruel and unusual. That's a violation of the Eighth Amendment. But I'm just not one of those people who thinks all life is precious, you know? I bet you a lot of people wouldn't say that, but if you're pro-choice, maybe that's really what you're thinking anyway. I mean, this is the big controversy that Rick Santorum brought up. He does not like prenatal testing because he says that leads to abortion, because people find out that they're gonna have a child who is not normal in some way, and they have an abortion because they don't want to raise a child with severe challenges. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. To not bring someone in the world whose life is gonna be so miserable in so many ways and so severely compromised. I mean, it's not that hard to
27:13 Speaker 06 create life. It's teeming everywhere. It's something a dog can do.
27:19 Speaker 04 It's in case you didn't know, dogs can create life. In studio with me is David Grin spoon. He's an astrobiologist, so you spend quite a bit of time thinking about life and possibly the value of life.
27:31 David Grinspoon? Absolutely.
27:31 Speaker 04 Where do those thoughts lead you?
27:33 David Grinspoon? Well, I, um, this isn't a scientific thought. I, um, maybe it's a scientific.
27:39 Speaker 04 You're allowed to not have.
27:40 David Grinspoon? Informed thought, but I think life is precious and partly why I'm interested in finding life elsewhere is I, I would love to find a universe full of life and if by some.
27:50 Speaker 04 Well, I have to interject, Earth does not think life is precious because it's responsible for rendering extinct 95% of all life that ever was.
27:58 David Grinspoon? Ah, but yet the biosphere itself looked at as a global kind of organism has persisted for four billion years.
28:05 Speaker 04 That's very new age of you.
28:06 David Grinspoon? Thank you. It's also very, very Guyian of me.
28:10 Speaker 04 Guyian, where Earth is an organism unto itself.
28:12 David Grinspoon? Yeah, but, but Earth does have this biosphere that has persisted. Species come and go, individuals come and go, and yet the, the stream of life that we're a part of continues. And I think that if for some reason we find out that the rest of the universe is barren, then I think there's an argument that we should spread life to other places. So I do hold that life itself is a, is a value, that life is better than non-life.
28:36 Speaker 04 Well, you raise an important branch point for me because when you see people who are sort of anti-abortion and then you part the curtains, in almost every case, they are deeply, deeply religious. And so it's, I think one can argue without much debate that religion is informing their, their motives for being anti-abortion. Are there ways that you think issues of science and the science analysis can inform these issues so that it can, so then, so then you have a basis, a political basis that has objectively verifiable foundations?
29:16 David Grinspoon? Well, absolutely. It can shed light on it. I mean, people are very black and white about this. They're pro or anti. Well, nobody's pro-abortion, I hope, but a lot of us are pro-choice. And the question is unwanted pregnancies. And science, of course, can add to the biological technology that can help us avoid more pregnancies, like if we came up with a good male pill, that would be great. But it can also inform-
29:40 Speaker 04 You take that along with the Viagra, right?
29:43 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
29:43 Speaker 04 And that's what you know?
29:44 David Grinspoon? The combination would be wonderful. No, but, you know, the day after conception, you know, is that a human being? It's a few cells, you know, a blastula. It's simpler-
29:58 Speaker 04 We have words for it, blastula.
29:59 David Grinspoon? Yeah, it's like eight cells, you know? That's not a human being. But the day before birth, that is a human being. So, I mean, science can tell us more about that developmental process and at least inform-
30:11 Speaker 04 And then influence how you then might vote. When we come back, more of my interview with Bill Maher and my in-studio guests.
30:26 Speaker 04 We're back on StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, and this week I've got David Gudspoon, astrobiologist. And together, we've been reacting to my interview with Bill Maher that I conducted with him in his Los Angeles offices. He's, of course, a political commentator and host of HBO's Real Time. You know, politics, David, it can have a strong influence on people's lives. And a political stance can include opinions about homosexuality, gambling, marijuana, drugs in general, just the sort of the morality of your community. And I asked Bill Maher, just what are his viewpoints on morality laws? Let's see what he said.
31:11 Speaker 04 You want to legalize gambling, prostitution, marijuana? Is that the trinity there?
31:15 Speaker 06 I think your notes are a little behind. I think gambling is pretty much legal since every state in the nation funds-
31:22 Speaker 04 Has a lottery, yeah.
31:23 Speaker 06 Funds higher education. How perverse is that? Through a lottery system which, you know, is mostly patronized by poor people. But we also have casinos all over. We have Indian casinos. I mean, you cannot, you know, swing a dead cat without hitting gambling in this country. Now, the other ones you mentioned were what? Marijuana?
31:41 Speaker 04 Uh, prostitution.
31:42 Speaker 06 Yeah, I mean, this is standard libertarian stuff. I mean, there's nothing complicated about the old theory that anything should be legal as long as it doesn't hurt another person. Now, you can always say, as the arguers on the other side say, "Well, marijuana, you could get high and get in the car and kill somebody." Of course you could. You could also do that with liquor.
32:01 Speaker 04 You were talking on a cellphone, yeah.
32:02 Speaker 06 Prescription, talking on a cellphone, putting on makeup. Prostitution, they exploit people. Yes, of course, we should stop that. I mean, but we have laws against that anyway. But let's not forget that there's just a lot of hoes in this country who are not being exploited, they just is hoes.
32:22 Speaker 04 The guy is funny crazy. And so, I want to get an astrobiologist's view on this. Is there, when we think of morality, one of them is, you know, "Thou shalt not kill." All right? Are we all there? If, if an alien landed on Earth and they're clearly intelligent and you kill them, there's actually no law against killing an alien from another planet.
32:44 David Grinspoon? I don't believe we have anything on the books about that.
32:46 Speaker 04 So, so you're gonna work to make that happen? And how about microbes? At what point are you saying this life, you know, we've all, well, some of us perhaps have, the first act of violence you ever did with a magnifying glass was like burning an ant on the sidewalk, right? I mean, so, there's certain lives that we care much less about, but you're an astrobiologist and you have to care about every single kind of life. Especially since, correct me if I'm wrong, the first life we are likely to find anywhere is probably microbial. So that's gonna be a very cherished discovery for you.
33:17 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, and we do actually have some laws or regulations that guide the way we treat potential alien microbes. So we have-
33:27 Speaker 04 So the "we" is who?
33:28 David Grinspoon? The astrobiology community, NASA, has planetary protection policies-
33:34 Speaker 04 But who are we protecting, Earth or protecting where we're going?
33:36 David Grinspoon? Well, both. Protecting Martians is the policy about what we call forward contamination, and protecting Earth is the policy about what we call back contamination, not accidentally bringing something back.
33:47 Speaker 04 Like in the Andromeda Stream?
33:49 David Grinspoon? For instance, yeah, yeah. But, I mean, we don't wanna inadvertently kill microbes on Mars for two reasons. The one reason is just science. If we perturb the environment before we get a chance to study it-
34:01 Speaker 04 On Mars?
34:02 David Grinspoon? On Mars, say. Then we've committed a law, you know, a crime against science. But then there's also these crimes against nature, if you will, the possibility that we will be inadvertently destroying a biosphere, a Martian biosphere, that might be just valuable intrinsically, and that's more of an ethical issue.
34:18 Speaker 04 Is there any way you can bring your scientific training in astrobiology to bear on morality here on Earth? Morality relates to the conduct of life-
34:29 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
34:30 Speaker 04 -in a society.
34:31 David Grinspoon? I think we can bring it to bear in indirect ways. I mean, Bill Maher mentioned the, you know, the drug laws. And, for instance, we can look at, we can study the health effects and the risks of different drugs. And he mentioned marijuana. Well, marijuana is incontrovertibly much safer than alcohol. Alcohol leads to so many deaths and so much disease and so forth, and marijuana-
34:54 Speaker 04 And addiction, yeah.
34:55 David Grinspoon? An addiction. And marijuana just doesn't. And yet, we have this prohibition. We tried prohibition with alcohol. It led to a lot of violence and crime. It didn't work.
35:02 Speaker 04 Okay, so these are non-evidence-based laws?
35:04 David Grinspoon? Exactly. So we can try to make our laws about moral issues evidence-based.
35:10 Speaker 04 And what are you doing in your part to make that happen?
35:14 David Grinspoon? Well, you know, I'm trying to educate the public to use science and reason in general. And so I would argue that in some way that that helps with these issues. I'm not going out and telling people what their moral beliefs should be.
35:29 Speaker 04 But if you get them from the beginning, thinking rationally, maybe that'll just follow.
35:32 David Grinspoon? Yeah, one would hope.
35:34 Speaker 04 When we come back on StarTalk Radio, there'll be more with my interview with Bill Maher. And I'm going to ask him, why is it that comedians are primarily liberal sorts? I mean, there's some who are conservative, but mostly they're liberal. You're listening to StarTalk Radio. And by the way, we're on the web at starTalkRadio.com. Check us out.
35:59 Speaker 00 Earth can be a lot. There's gravity, there's mosquitoes, and a sun that will expand and engulf us in about four or five billion years, give and take. Cosmically speaking, you've earned a break, so escape to Pluto. See what I did there? Turn off your earthly problems and turn on the movies and shows you already love. From Anchorman, The Legend of Ron Burgundy, to Dirty Dancing, from Alias to The X-Files. No subscription, no fees, zero dollars. The best things on TV are free. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never. Hey, everyone, it's Stavros Halakis, and I'm here to tell you about my podcast, Stavie's World.
36:41 Speaker 00 Each week, we're joined by great guests like Josh Safdie, Eric Andre, Caleb Heron, and more. It's sort of an interview show, but really, we're just messing around, making each other laugh, and hopefully making you laugh while you're washing the dishes, or grocery shopping, or on a long drive. Plus, I take listener calls, or we have honest conversations about dating, life, and everything in between. Imagine if your therapist was a vulgar degenerate whose office was in a Greek diner. No scripts, no polish, and absolutely no holding back. Listen to Stavie's World wherever you get your podcasts.
37:15 Speaker 01 If your child lives with type 1 diabetes, a low blood sugar is hard enough without trying to convince them to eat another chalky glucose tablet. That's where Glow Gummies come in. Delicious glucose gummies made with fast-acting dextrose to raise blood sugar quickly. In a soft gummy they'll actually want to eat. They're vegan, gluten-free, dye-free, don't melt or stick to teeth, and taste just as good as candy. Head to glowgummies.com, that's G-L-O-W gummies dot com, and use code PODCAST20 for 20% off.
37:47 Speaker 04 We're back on StarTalk Radio. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, your host. I'm an astrophysicist, by the way. And with me in studio is David Grin spoon. He's an astrobiologist. And we've been listening to my interview with Bill Maher. Of course, you know, he's a comedian, political commentator, host of HBO's Real Time with Bill Maher. And, you know, today, it seems that people are more divided than ever. I don't know if everyone of every age says that about the age in which they live, but it kind of feels more that way now. And I talk with Bill Maher about why so many artists and comedians tend to take a liberal stand
38:28 Speaker 04 on the political spectrum. And by the way, David, you and I discussed this about scientists earlier, but I want to bring it all together in this segment and just see where it takes us. But let's check out what Bill Maher's reaction to this fact. Check it out.
38:43 Speaker 06 Most people in the arts, not just comedians, are liberal. It goes with the territory.
38:48 Speaker 04 Why?
38:49 Speaker 06 Well, because I would like to think as we're smarter. There was a reason.
38:54 Speaker 04 Okay.
38:55 Speaker 06 And we're creative, and we're open-minded, and we're just better people. Okay. There was a study recently out of Canada. They tracked people for, I'm sure you saw this, it was about two or three weeks ago. They tracked people for a long period of time, and they came out with the finding that lower IQs tend to produce people who are conservative in their beliefs. They're more close-minded, they're more racist. You know, I would file this under top duh.
39:22 Speaker 04 I think I remember the study. There's an IQ difference, I thought. Is that the study that you're referencing?
39:26 Speaker 06 Yeah, lower IQs equal more conservative. Liberal means comes from the root, as we all know, for free, free thinking.
39:33 Speaker 04 I'd forgotten that. Thanks for reminding me.
39:35 Speaker 06 Same root as Libra, liberated. Liberal is not a dirty word. It certainly didn't used to be. It became one, and it shouldn't be. But most people in the arts, I mean, it's very hard to find in this town, the conservatives. The conservatives in this town would say that there is a whitelist, the opposite of a blacklist. They'd say, it's very hard to get work in this town when you're a conservative.
39:55 Speaker 04 This town is LA.
39:56 Speaker 06 This town being LA, of course Hollywood, because they say it's run by a bunch of liberals and it's obviously a large Jewish.
40:03 Speaker 04 Same thing is said in academia.
40:04 Speaker 06 Gay community, right, yeah. I don't know if there's a, there's no whitelist that's BS. I mean, if Clint Eastwood, who's a conservative, makes a good movie, as he has for thirty years, they hire him. Bruce Willis doesn't seem to have any trouble working. I mean, the reason why Scott Baio doesn't work that much is they don't want to hire him that much. It's not because he's conservative.
40:26 Speaker 04 There's also Charlton Heston. Charl come up too.
40:28 Speaker 06 Absolutely.
40:29 Speaker 04 The honorary head of the NRA.
40:30 Speaker 06 Yes, there's been plenty of conservatives.
40:33 Speaker 04 Plenty of work.
40:33 Speaker 06 Absolutely. And they certainly aren't prejudiced against the Scientologists, I'll tell you that.
40:40 Speaker 04 So it's, it is, I think it's a fascinating sociocultural point that artists, creative types, just simply tend to be more liberal, and scientists tend to be more liberal. David, what, do you see any common denominator there?
40:58 David Grinspoon? Well, you know, it's, it's strange. You know, you think of the word, he, he mentioned the origin of the word liberal. What's the origin of the word conservative? I mean, you think about conserving things and preserving the natural world would seem to be a part of that, and therefore, you know, a lot of what science leads a lot of us to think about, one would think these are conservative values, trying to understand what's happening to climate and conserve our ability to have a civilization on this planet.
41:30 Speaker 04 Wait, wait, wait.
41:30 David Grinspoon? Why is that liberal?
41:31 Speaker 04 Conservation is not the same thing as preservation. It's not, it's really not. I mean, so conservation, a conservative outlook can be, I don't want my way of life to change, no matter what else. Is going on with the birds and the bees. So, so, but go on.
41:48 David Grinspoon? Yeah, well, okay, that, that's an interesting point. And but, but, but, you know, also conservatives, I think, talk a lot about freedom, right? And freedom also is something that is very precious to academics and scientists, you know, being able to think about what we want and talk about.
42:05 Speaker 04 Without anybody looking over your shoulder.
42:06 David Grinspoon? Yeah. So, why isn't that, I mean, you think about the founding fathers and their, their notion of, of the kind of nation we were gonna have. And to me, that's very consistent with what I think about as, you know, sort of liberal values. So, I don't completely understand some of these schisms.
42:27 Speaker 04 Oh, so they're just artificial then, on some level?
42:30 David Grinspoon? To some degree.
42:30 Speaker 04 They're not really analytically explored to their natural conclusions.
42:35 David Grinspoon? Yeah.
42:35 Speaker 04 Yeah. So, when I, when I think of a nation divided, I think of it as one where everybody wants everybody to think just like they do. But, you know, if everybody were sort of rabid liberal and wanted just, I, I wonder if a country can actually function that way. What a country might need to be is to have that tension between these two extremes, because each extreme taken alone would destroy the country. But the combination of the two allow the country to function, not move to any whim that occurs. So you have some restoring force, but you need also someone to reach out and go where others hadn't been before. And so, I, I see it kind of like as, as, as oil
43:19 Speaker 04 and vinegar, as in your salad dressing. You would never make a salad with just oil or just vinegar. Do you, do you agree with that?
43:27 David Grinspoon? Well, yeah, I think, I think there's a model there also about the scientific process. Again, you really need these different viewpoints and the balance between them ultimately is what keeps us going forward.
43:37 Speaker 04 We gotta end on that. David, thanks for being in studio with me on StarTalk Radio. Oh, I gotta do a tweet. I got one. How about, "Odd that most people want everyone else to be just like them, but the best of all worlds, I think, is when we can all just be ourselves." You've been listening to StarTalk Radio, funded in part by the National Science Foundation. As always, keep looking up. We'll see you next time.
44:09 Speaker 02 One thing casual fans don't understand is how [bleep] good pro wrestling is. Think you know wrestling? Join us on the Busted Open Podcast every single day. The biggest stories, the biggest debates, no filters. If you're a wrestling fan, this is your daily stop. Wrestling is better when the fans are as excited as I am. Seven days a week, breaking news and interviews with the biggest names in wrestling. Every episode is waiting for you in the podcast feed, wherever you get your podcasts.
44:39 Speaker 01 To every clinician finishing notes at 9:00 PM, there is a faster way. Whisper Flow is a voice-to-text app. You talk, it types, in your EHR, your email, anywhere you type. Say the progress note, the referral letter, the patient instructions, and it comes out clean and formatted, with your terminology spelled right. Four times faster than typing and HIPAA-ready. Whisper Flow is free. Get it at whisperflow.ai. That's W-I-S-P-R-flow.ai.
Previous Packing for Mars (Part 2) Next StarTalk Live: The Particle Party (Part 1) Page updated October 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated