HAUNTED: Clarita Villanueva

In 1953, 17-year-old Clarita Villanueva was incarcerated in the Philippines. Only a few days into her stay, she began suffering vicious attacks from unseen entities, including bite marks that appeared on her skin out of nowhere. An American pastor led her exorcism, making Clarita's case global news. And to this day, many people believe her story holds more supernatural evidence than any other demonic possession case in history.

Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

• 0:02Speaker 00

  There's something scary about losing control. Honestly, as a professional and a mom, I think it might be one of my biggest fears. Whether it's a sudden change in plans, or getting sick right when you have an important day at work, or even a little bit of turbulence on an airplane, all of it makes me uncomfortable and a little stressed. But for the most part, we get through it, right? But what happens when you lose control of your mind? I think that is what might terrify me most of all. And it's why there is one supernatural genre that haunts my dreams over all the rest: demonic possession.

• 0:42Speaker 00

  Imagine being totally at the mercy of something you cannot see, let alone fight, being a prisoner trapped inside your own body, unable to escape. Do you give in? Do you surrender? Or do you do everything in your power to fight back and regain control? In the case of a young woman named Clarita Villanueva, she chose the latter. I'm Ashley Flowers, and welcome back to So Supernatural.

• 1:23Yvette Gentile?

  Y'all, what comes to mind when I think of demonic possession is exactly what Ashley said. Losing control of your mind and your body has to be the most terrifying experience you could ever have. Growing up as a kid, I absolutely refused to watch The Exorcist. We just recently did the episode on the Gary, Indiana demon house, which is also about possessions, and researching that was terrifying. So I know that we've been down this road before. We've talked about demons and possessions and exorcism. And you might think if you've heard one of these stories, you've heard them all.

• 2:03Yvette Gentile?

  But I promise you, today's case is full of twists and turns you'll never see coming. I'm Yvette Gentile.

• 2:12Rasha Pecoraro?

  And I'm Rasha Pecoraro. And this week, we're talking about a 17-year-old girl named Clarita Villanueva.

• 2:21Rasha Pecoraro?

  So in the 1950s, Clarita was sent to a prison in the Philippines after soliciting a police officer for sex. But only days into her sentence, she began to experience some pretty otherworldly torment from unseen forces. When doctors and city officials couldn't figure out how to help her, they called in a local American pastor who took matters into his own hands.

• 2:44Yvette Gentile?

  But what made Clarita's story so mind blowing was the evidence.

• 2:49Rasha Pecoraro?

  Evidence that she may have collected from the demon itself.

• 3:00Speaker 03

  When an intruder approaches a home, they expect a camera. What they don't expect. Stop. This is Simply Safe. Police are on the way. Using smart AI cameras, live US-based agents help deter intruders in under 30 seconds. Don't just record a break-in, stop it from ever happening. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplysafe.com/truecrime.

• 3:23Speaker 04

  30 seconds response time requires monitoring plan with outdoor protection starting at $49.99 a month. Visit simplysafe.com/licenses for alarm license information.

• 3:32Yvette Gentile?

  I know we've talked about this before, but just as a reminder, when it comes to religion, Rasha and I were both brought up pretty differently.

• 3:41Rasha Pecoraro?

  It is true. We are 11 years apart, and I think by the time I came around, mom just wasn't into going to church every Sunday. I think the only time we ever went to church was when we were seeing a friend perform or sing. So I was not raised in the church in any capacity.

• 3:58Yvette Gentile?

  Right. And for me, I was definitely raised in the Christian church because that's where mom was raised as well, in Reno. So I was in the choir, I was performing in the Christmas plays, I was doing all the things in the church.

• 4:11Rasha Pecoraro?

  Yeah, but even if we weren't going to church every Sunday by the time I came around, there's one thing that we've always agreed on. Evil forces are out there.

• 4:21Yvette Gentile?

  So when we talk about evil forces, Rasha and I did a podcast called Root of Evil with our entire family. And there's a lot that was left on the cutting room floor, but there is one episode where we actually went into the Franklin House where our great-grandfather George Hodel lived. And when you talk about an evil presence, when you walk into that house, when you walk into that basement, it is unlike anything you will ever experience. Because I do believe energy stays stagnant in places where god awful things have happened. So when we look at religion or we look at the dark side, right?

• 5:05Yvette Gentile?

  It's always good versus evil. But exorcisms, well, these aren't just performed in Christianity. They're also seen in Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, just to name a few. And while you may think that anyone who turns to exorcisms is very religious, well, think again, because that isn't necessarily true.

• 5:28Rasha Pecoraro?

  As was the case with seventeen year old Clarita Villanueva. Clarita was born in the mid nineteen thirties on a small island in the Philippines. And from what I could tell, she may have been Catholic, like most Filipinos, but she wasn't really brought up that way. She was raised by a single mother who, by some accounts, was a fortune teller and dabbled in the occult for work. But unfortunately, she passed away when Clarita was young, somewhere between the ages of twelve and fourteen. So overnight, Clarita suddenly finds herself on her own. And that's when she first thinks of getting in contact with her father. Clarita didn't grow up knowing her dad. At this point, she's not even sure if he's still alive.

• 6:13Rasha Pecoraro?

  The only thing she knows about him is that he's from Manila, the capital of the Philippines. So she decides to head out there, hoping to find whatever family she might have left to care for her. This kind of reminds me of when our mom was looking for her birth mother. She had no interest in finding her birth father, but she did go on the Nancy Drew adventure of finding her birth mother in Honolulu, Hawaii.

• 6:36Yvette Gentile?

  That's right. And she had her birth certificate in hand. But mom was in her twenties at this point. Now, remember, Clarita is no older than fourteen. She was really brave, I mean, to set off on this journey to find her dad, a lot like our mom, Rasha, like what you just said. But she must have been terrified moving to a new city alone. And Clarita grew up in poverty, so she's showing up with nothing, probably just the clothes on her back. But still, Clarita is resourceful. She makes it work. And in order to do that, she has to just focus on making ends meet, which means that she has to put the search for her dad aside, at least for a while.

• 7:22Yvette Gentile?

  She gets a job as a maid, then another where she's a hostess at some restaurants and bars. And at that job, she starts dancing for a little extra cash. Which, at that age, well, I'm just gonna say, that is no life for a 14-year-old, period.

• 7:40Rasha Pecoraro?

  I can't even imagine, especially being mother to a 13-year-old girl. Can you imagine, Yvette, your niece dancing to make ends meet? It breaks my heart.

• 7:51Yvette Gentile?

  No, no, not at all. And Auntie would be there and snatch her off that stage, straight away.

• 7:58Rasha Pecoraro?

  I know you would. I know you would. But 14-year-old Clarita, at this point, is really all alone in the world. So she takes the job opportunity and does it for a while. And before she knows it, Clarita has spent three years in Manila. She's built a new life for herself, and it seems like finding her father is no longer top of mind. Because by 17, Clarita has a new man in her life. Someone she's fallen madly in love with, who seems like he can support her and give her the life she never had. Only, when they go to elope, she finds out this guy's got a wife. All of Clarita's hopes and dreams come crashing down

• 8:41Rasha Pecoraro?

  in a way that really leaves her struggling, both emotionally and financially. And that's when Clarita makes a life choice that will sort of change the course of everything. Clarita turns to sex work. This seems to work with her lifestyle. She goes back to the bar she used to dance at to find her clients, and that keeps her afloat for a while. But on May 7, 1953, Clarita's job, which is still very illegal, mind you, even today in the Philippines, lands her in some pretty hot water. Because that evening, Clarita accidentally solicits a plainclothes police officer. He arrests her on the spot

• 9:24Rasha Pecoraro?

  and takes her to Manila's infamous old bilibid prison, where she'll wait for her trial and sentencing.

• 9:31Yvette Gentile?

  Now, this isn't just any prison. It is a really dark place. And to paint a picture for you, it's where Spanish conquerors imprisoned their victims in the 19th century and where the Japanese confined prisoners of war during World War II. All to say, you don't want to end up there, especially if you're a teenage orphan who spent the last several years on the street. Because remember, Clarita is still technically underage. She's only 17.

• 10:04Rasha Pecoraro?

  Right, an old bilibid is supposed to be a prison for adults. So not only is Clarita feeling out of place, she's probably incredibly traumatized. Luckily, she manages to survive the first couple of days without incident. But on the night of May 9, things take a significant turn. Out of nowhere that night, Clarita just starts screaming. And I don't mean like, just a startled scream. These are loud, blood-curdling shrieks. The other inmates stop what they're doing and watch as Clarita collapses to the ground and literally starts flailing her entire body. She looks like she's trying to fight someone or something,

• 10:49Rasha Pecoraro?

  except there's nobody around. But it's very clear that whatever Clarita sees, it's very, very real to her. And she's terrified of it. The guards and the prison doctors hurry over to check on Clarita, and they immediately notice something incredibly freaky. She has bite marks all over her body. Now, I know what you're thinking, but no. According to witnesses, the other inmates haven't touched her, and it couldn't have been Clarita herself, because some of these marks are in impossible-to-reach places, like on her neck. Plus, while the guards and doctors are watching her,

• 11:30Rasha Pecoraro?

  they see new bite marks appear on Clarita's body in front of their very eyes. Supposedly, there's even blood and saliva on them. It's like invisible things are digging into Clarita's skin.

• 11:45Yvette Gentile?

  The thing is about this, you have guards, you have doctors. Like, they are there witnessing these bite marks appear on her neck out of nowhere. That has to be the freakiest thing you could ever imagine seeing.

• 12:00Rasha Pecoraro?

  Yeah, I mean, look, this whole thing is unlike any possession story I think you or I have ever heard before.

• 12:09Yvette Gentile?

  100%.

• 12:10Rasha Pecoraro?

  And when they ask her, like, what in the world just happened? She insists that she was bitten by two male attackers, and describes them as evil-looking men.

• 12:22Yvette Gentile?

  Now, if it wasn't for the bites, they might have just thought that Clarita was having some kind of hallucination, right? But something is physically harming her, leaving marks on her body.

• 12:35Rasha Pecoraro?

  It's pretty darn convincing. Even when she's seen by a prison doctor, they have no idea how to help her. And obviously, the guards are even less equipped to deal with something like this. So the only thing they can think of is to send Clarita to their boss, the head jailer. This guy's name is Captain Antonio Ganibi.

• 12:57Yvette Gentile?

  And it just so happens that when she gets to Antonio's office, the demons that are tormenting Clarita return.

• 13:06Yvette Gentile?

  She drops to all fours and crawls under his desk claiming the demons are touching her and she doesn't know how to make it stop. That's when she makes a strange request. See, Clarita normally wore a small metal crucifix and she asked Antonio to return it to her, which I think we can assume she had removed any of her jewelry upon entry into the prison. Anyway, Antonio has no idea what she's talking about. He hasn't taken anything from her, but she insists that he check his pockets. So he does, and that's when he feels a metal crucifix sitting right there in his pocket,

• 13:51Yvette Gentile?

  just like Clarita said. So you can imagine Antonio is super creeped out now. He can't explain how it ended up there, so he just hands the crucifix to Clarita and hopes that she'll just calm down. But instead of saying "thank you," Clarita shouts at Antonio, telling him that he's going to die unexpectedly. I mean, the whole situation is so strange and unbelievable that it kind of gets lost in the chaos. And in the moment, no one really takes this prediction seriously. That is, until a few weeks later, when Clarita's message comes true.

• 14:33Yvette Gentile?

  Antonio really does pass away suddenly. And the creepiest of all, the coroner can't identify his cause of death. Like, what the heck?

• 14:46Rasha Pecoraro?

  And that's not the only spot-on premonition she has. After meeting with Ganevi, Clarita continues to have these fits where she develops new bite marks. Now, I don't know what takes them so long, but 10 days later, the guards finally send Clarita to an actual hospital for an exam. But even at the hospital, doctors are dumbfounded by Clarita's symptoms. Although one doctor by the name of Manuel Ramos thinks this has to be some kind of hoax, he reportedly gets into a standoff with Clarita, where she tells him the same thing she told Antonio: "You will die."

• 15:28Rasha Pecoraro?

  Only this time, 24 hours later, to the actual hour, Dr. Ramos suffers a fatal heart attack. Until then, he had been perfectly healthy.

• 15:41Yvette Gentile?

  To say you don't want to find yourself on Clarita's bad side is a complete understatement.

• 15:47Rasha Pecoraro?

  I mean, I know I wouldn't want to be on her bad side. By this point, gossip about this whole thing is spreading well beyond the walls of the prison and the hospital. Eventually, it reaches the Manila Police Department's chief medical examiner, Dr. Mariano Laura. Now, Dr. Laura doesn't believe in demonic possessions, so he just figures Clarita's behavior is a lot more explainable. To him, she's clearly living with a mental health condition. So he sends a bunch of people to examine her in prison. I'm talking doctors, professors, medical interns, and a ton of other specialists just to try and get to the bottom of this. Allegedly, while Clarita was in one of her possessed states,

• 16:32Rasha Pecoraro?

  they even pricked her with pins to see if she would respond to the pain. And apparently, she didn't even flinch. Now, to be honest, I'm not sure what other tests they run on Clarita, but I know the doctors and psychiatrists go back to Dr. Lara and say, "Clarita is mentally sound," which means that there's no psychological explanation for what is going on.

• 16:57Yvette Gentile?

  So, I mean, this is a huge deal. You have to imagine that a team of experts would be so quick to write this off as a mental health condition, if for no other reason than to just explain what's going on here. Because whatever is happening is so far-fetched. But, no, that is not the case.

• 17:20Rasha Pecoraro?

  It's all very bizarre and very creepy. And news about Clarita continues to spread across the city of Manila, to the point where even the mayor of Manila himself can't resist paying Clarita a visit.

• 17:34Yvette Gentile?

  I mean, I can't really blame the guy. He wants to see what all the commotion is about. And honestly, I probably would too if I was the mayor.

• 17:42Rasha Pecoraro?

  I don't know if I'd want to see, especially with all her premonitions coming out.

• 17:46Yvette Gentile?

  That's true.

• 17:47Rasha Pecoraro?

  But let's just say he gets what he bargained for. Because only 15 minutes into their meeting, the mayor watches in absolute horror as bite marks appear on Clarita's neck and index finger. When he grabs her hand and takes a closer look at the bite marks, he notices that it looks like they came from human teeth.

• 18:09Rasha Pecoraro?

  And while he's holding her hand, he sees new bites appear on her palm. The mayor is, as you can imagine, beside himself at this point. He has to know more. So he gives Clarita a pencil and paper, and he asks her to draw a picture of whatever's attacking her. But the minute she touches the pencil, it flies out of her hand.

• 18:31Yvette Gentile?

  And we don't even have to take the mayor's word for it, because this whole meeting apparently happened in front of a reporter too. And that reporter turns around, and of course, you know what happens, goes and publishes a story, and it doesn't take long for the news to make it around the world. From Manila to New York, everyone is reporting on this. Like, I'm talking front page news. But Clarita doesn't have to go that far to find help, because there's one man willing to stake his entire career on saving her life.

• 19:11Yvette Gentile?

  And guess what? He's already in Manila.

• 19:19Speaker 03

  The real cost of a break-in isn't your valuables. It's the feeling that your home stopped being safe. SimpliSafe keeps danger away from your family with three layers of protection. One, smart AI cameras and live US-based agents help stop intruders before they break in. Two, we sound the alarm at points of entry. Three, our agents request emergency response. Plans starting around $1 a day. Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com/truecrime. Outdoor deterrence plans start at $49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com/licenses for alarm license information.

• 19:49Rasha Pecoraro?

  I fell in love with Chime watching my beloved WNBA Portland Fire play this season because Chime is their VIP sponsor. A bank who supports women's sports instills confidence in my eyes. Most of us picked a bank when we were 16, got used to random monthly charges, overdraft penalties, and minimum balance requirements, and just accepted it as a part of life. But life adds up fast. That is where Chime comes in. Chime is completely changing the way people bank. Chime offers the most rewarding fee-free banking with no monthly fees, no overdraft fees, and no minimum balance fees. Plus, you get 5% cash back on your Chime card in a category of your choice.

• 20:34Rasha Pecoraro?

  Join the millions who are already banking fee-free with America's number one choice for banking. Head to chime.com/supernatural. That is chime.com/supernatural. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chimes Bank Partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. Go to chime.com/disclosures for details.

• 21:09Yvette Gentile?

  It's May 1953 in the city of Manila in the Philippines. An American pastor named Lester Summerall happens to be living in the city. He's there temporarily doing some mission work and helping locals build churches, when something on the radio catches his attention. It's a story about a woman at Old Bilibid Prison, and how supposedly she's been dealing with a demonic possession that no one can tame. And of course, her name is Clarita Villanueva.

• 21:45Rasha Pecoraro?

  The broadcaster actually warns his listeners, and this is a direct quote: "If you have a weak heart, please turn your radio off." But as a self-proclaimed man of faith, Lester reaches for the dial and turns the volume up. He's tuned in just in time to hear a recording of Clarita during one of her attacks. And while her screams are bone chilling, to Lester, it sounds all too familiar. He's heard similar cries in the past, because according to his accounts, he's dealt with demonic possessions before. Lester knows right away that Clarita isn't struggling with some medical or mental health condition.

• 22:28Rasha Pecoraro?

  In his mind, she's being attacked by something straight out of hell.

• 22:34Yvette Gentile?

  Let's just say Lester's the kind of guy who might also see this as an opportunity. See, he's kind of a big deal in the Pentecostal religious community back in the States. And while he came to the Philippines to help build a church, he has deeper motives. Lester's real mission is to convert the locals, who are very, very heavily Roman Catholic, to his religion, Pentecostalism. And I'm not going to get into the ins and outs of religion here. All you need to know is that Lester's attempts aren't sitting well with the community in Manila. They aren't exactly jumping at the opportunity to convert. So his mission so far has kind of been a bust.

• 23:19Rasha Pecoraro?

  Which of course is a blow to Lester. But after hearing about Clarita, he figures he might be able to turn a corner. Maybe he can use this as an opportunity to show the powers of Pentecostalism.

• 23:33Rasha Pecoraro?

  So Lester makes a few phone calls and soon the contractor on the church he's building gives him access to the mayor of Manila. And the mayor is basically like, sure, come on down to the prison. We'll take all the help we can get with her. Under one condition, of course. If something bad happens to Lester, the mayor is not responsible. To which Lester thinks, challenge accepted.

• 23:58Yvette Gentile?

  I mean, Raj, doesn't this totally feel like a publicity stunt on Lester's end?

• 24:03Rasha Pecoraro?

  I mean, maybe. Does he really think he can help? That's possible, too. Either way, on the morning of May 18th, 1953, he heads down to old Bilibid Prison. He's not ready to meet Clarita just yet. He says he needs to mentally prepare if he's going to fight the devil. But he does talk to Dr. Mariano Lara, the chief medical examiner for the Manila Police Department. You know, the guy that didn't believe in demonic possession and who insisted Clarita was living with a mental health condition? Well, I guess Lester wants to get both sides of the story before he fully commits to this quest. But during that first day, he also gives Dr.

• 24:47Rasha Pecoraro?

  Lara, who seems to be Clarita's primary doctor at this point, a few guidelines to follow. One, do not let anyone give Clarita any medication. He needs her fully coherent for her exorcism. Two, she can't have her rosary beads anymore. See, Clarita was given these rosaries by someone in the prison as a means of protection. She'd pray with them, she'd kiss them, she'd sleep with them, and they seemed to be making her feel better. But Lester doesn't want any of that. He thinks these things are making it worse. He says they're infested with evil spirits and Dr. Lara needs to take them away from her right away. And his third and final rule?

• 25:32Rasha Pecoraro?

  Lester says no other groups should come in and pray for Clarita. Now, look, I don't know if Lester actually believes that the Catholic prayers and rosaries are making things worse, or if he just wants to make sure his faith and his methods get all the credit. Frankly, in my opinion, it seems like the latter. But either way, Dr. Lara seemingly agrees to all of these demands. And that evening, Lester leaves the prison feeling prepared. Tomorrow, heal me Clarita, face to face.

• 26:06Yvette Gentile?

  At 8:00 a.m. on the morning of May 19, Lester returns to the prison, rested and ready to start the exorcism. Only to his surprise, Dr. Lara has called a bunch of his friends to come and watch the pastor in action. And we're talking doctors, professors, policemen, and members of the press. All in all, Lester counts about 105 spectators.

• 26:37Rasha Pecoraro?

  The only thing missing is the popcorn at this point.

• 26:41Yvette Gentile?

  Look, Lester's probably liking the attention. I mean, after all, he really wants the credit for saving Clarita. But there are so many observers, and absolutely zero way for any of them to see all of this in Clarita's cell. So instead, they lead the whole crowd to the prison chapel. And actually, to call it a chapel might be overstating it. It's got a simple altar and these steel barred windows, but it's a little bit bigger than Clarita's usual cell. So all the spectators can actually see inside.

• 27:22Rasha Pecoraro?

  As Clarita enters, she takes a good look at the people in the room. But when she gets to the pastor, her eyes get big, and she shouts, "I don't like you." But Lester is not phased. He just says this is more proof that the devil is speaking through her. And from there, he pretty much rolls up his sleeves and gets to work. He prays for the demons to leave Clarita, but his words don't do much to make her feel better. She actually interrupts him shouting, "No, no, they will kill me." Then Lester reaches out and grabs Clarita's head with both hands. But the moment he touches her, bite marks appear all over her arms and neck.

• 28:07Rasha Pecoraro?

  He can see that the blood vessels are broken underneath her skin, and then she faints.

• 28:14Yvette Gentile?

  Okay, so we have these bite marks appearing out of nowhere. I mean, that would turn even the biggest skeptics into believers, right?

• 28:23Rasha Pecoraro?

  Hundred percent. Because apparently, even Dr. Lara, the medical examiner who was her biggest skeptic, he's beside himself in this moment. He tells Lester they should give her a break, because based on Clarita's past fits, he knows it usually takes a few hours for her to wake up and come to her senses. But Lester's not a very patient guy. He doesn't want to come back tomorrow if he can help it. He wants to get these demons out of her today. So he props Clarita's chin up and demands she open her eyes, and she does. Which, okay, that doesn't sound like much, but Clarita's doctors are in shock. They've never been able to wake her up that easily before.

• 29:05Rasha Pecoraro?

  Now Clarita tells the pastor she's actually in a ton of pain.

• 29:10Yvette Gentile?

  I mean, of course she is. She has a bunch of fresh wounds all over her body.

• 29:16Rasha Pecoraro?

  Exactly. So she cries, begging Lester to leave her alone. But he doesn't listen. He's in the thick of it now. He confronts the demons and says, quote, "Come out of her in Jesus's name." He keeps on repeating that phrase over and over for the next four hours.

• 29:37Rasha Pecoraro?

  Each time Clarita curses him and new bite marks appear, it's like the demons are fighting back and Clarita's body is their battlefield. Meanwhile, Lester stays persistent. Even though he's probably exhausted by this point, he's determined to heal her. Only, she's barely showing any signs of improvement. Until around noon, when all of the activity just stops. Clarita stops cursing, the biting goes away. At this point, Lester is drenched in sweat and totally spent. The exorcism has taken its toll on both of them.

• 30:15Yvette Gentile?

  And one would hope the worst is over.

• 30:18Rasha Pecoraro?

  I mean, all of those spectators sure seem to think so. Many of them are in tears. They think they've just witnessed a miracle. Only, Lester isn't so convinced. Yes, Clarita seems to be feeling better now. But devils don't just disappear. They tend to come back stronger and with a vengeance. So Lester heads home to fast and pray. Because tomorrow, he's in for the battle of a lifetime.

• 30:51Speaker 03

  The real cost of a break-in isn't your valuables. It's the feeling that your home stopped being safe. SimpliSafe keeps danger away from your family with three layers of protection. One, smart AI cameras and live US-based agents help stop intruders before they break in. Two, we sound the alarm at points of entry. Three, our agents request emergency response. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com/truecrime. Outdoor deterrence plans start at $49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com/licenses for alarm license information.

• 31:24Rasha Pecoraro?

  When over 100 witnesses watch Lester Somerall exorcise 17-year-old Clarita Villanueva, it seems like her demons might really be gone forever. But Lester, well, he's not so sure. He has this gut feeling that the devil might still be dormant in Clarita, ready to resurface and continue the torment at any moment. So he returns to old Billibid Prison the next morning to check on her. When he gets there, an official tells him that Clarita hasn't developed any new bites since the exorcism yesterday. Which sounds great, but as soon as Lester sees Clarita, she screams at him with the same familiar hostility that she had shown during her possession.

• 32:09Rasha Pecoraro?

  So to Lester, this means only one thing: the demons are still there.

• 32:15Yvette Gentile?

  Which isn't great for Lester because his reputation as a pastor is on the line. If he doesn't get rid of these demons, well, I mean, what does that say for his church and for his faith as a whole?

• 32:28Rasha Pecoraro?

  Which is why Lester came ready for another fight. For the second day in a row, another huge audience gathers to watch, and today's crowd might even be bigger than yesterday's. Lester asks everyone in the room to kneel. Like, it doesn't matter if you're a member of the press, a doctor, a policeman, or a prison official. These are his orders, and if you're in the room, you have to obey. Then, once everyone is in position, Lester begins the exorcism. It doesn't take long for him to get locked into this exhausting cycle. This time, two other ministers of his faith are with him, and they each take turns praying and singing songs. Then, the demons leave for a minute before they come raging back.

• 33:14Rasha Pecoraro?

  Every time it seems like Clarita's free, she suddenly jerks or screams, and they're right back where they started.

• 33:23Rasha Pecoraro?

  But finally, after an hour or so, Lester senses something different.

• 33:28Rasha Pecoraro?

  I'm not sure what's changed exactly, but he seems convinced that this time around, the demons are gone for good. When Lester asks Clarita if she feels the same way, she nods. And when he asks where they went, she points and says that the demons went out through the window.

• 33:47Yvette Gentile?

  I feel like we fell for this once already. So that's not really the end of the story, is it?

• 33:53Rasha Pecoraro?

  Hardly. Just when Lester's ready to pack up and go, Clarita lets out this blood-curdling scream. She says the demons are back. This time, they even speak through her and say, quote, "She is unclean and we have a right to live with her." So Lester starts the whole routine over. I'm not sure how long this goes on for, but eventually, he banishes the demons again. And before he leaves, he leads Clarita in one last prayer. He warns her that the demons will almost definitely return after he goes. But now, she has the power to make them leave on her own next time.

• 34:36Rasha Pecoraro?

  All she has to do is say, "Go in Jesus's name." The rest of that afternoon goes by without any issues, even after Lester and all of the spectators leave. By nighttime, Clarita still hasn't suffered any new attacks. It seems like she might really be cured. Around 8:00 PM, she asks a guard for his pocket knife so she can trim her fingernails. Like any sensible prison, Old Billabid has a policy that keeps inmates from having access to sharp objects. But this guard watched Clarita's exorcism, and he feels sorry for her. He's not going to hand over his knife, but he offers to cut her nails for her.

• 35:21Rasha Pecoraro?

  Now, the guard only trims one nail before Clarita lets out this blood-curdling scream. Then she contorts her body like she's trying to defend herself. The demons are back. She yells out the prayer Lester taught her, and then she staggers up and grabs at something the guard can't see. She clenches her fist, and then she faints. The guard calls for help, and a few other prison officials and doctors rush over. It seems like Clarita has slipped into a coma, so they move her to a safer spot where Dr. Lara can treat her. That's when they notice that Clarita's hand is still clenched in a tight fist.

• 36:02Rasha Pecoraro?

  Dr. Lara needs to use all of his strength to force her fingers open. And that's where they find something that honestly blows my mind. Inside her fist is a handful of jet-black curly hair.

• 36:19Rasha Pecoraro?

  Dr. Lara examines the hair under a microscope and it confuses him for several reasons. First, it looks like it didn't come from a human. And second, he's pretty positive it's not Clarita's hair. Dr. Lara actually has no good explanation for where it came from.

• 36:36Yvette Gentile?

  Of all the twists and turns in this story, this one might be the most incredible. Especially if you remember her description of these entities. Because, remember, Clarita had described one of her attackers as having dark curly hair all over his body. So you have to wonder, did she actually manage to collect evidence from, I don't know, some unseen demonic force?

• 37:03Rasha Pecoraro?

  It's as if Clarita fought back against her demons in that moment and actually won. Because after this hair-pulling incident, the invisible tormentors are gone. All of the demonic activity stops, and for good this time. The following week, Clarita goes before a judge for the vagrancy charges she was arrested on. He sentences her to a brief stay in a women's facility where she can get on her feet again. And it seems to really help. Once Clarita is out of prison, she goes on to live a normal, uneventful life in the Northern Philippines, a happily-ever-after sort of ending.

• 37:42Yvette Gentile?

  To go from being possessed by demons one day and then back to normal life the next day? I mean, y'all, it sounds stranger than fiction. But this was Clarita's reality in May of 1953. And it must have been pure relief to be finally rid of this evil. I mean, one that seemed to have come out of nowhere. And I will say, though, it seems like Lester achieved his goals in all of this, too. Because thanks to the press coverage of the exorcism, Lester draws tens of thousands of people out to his sermons when he's back in the States. He also writes a popular book about the experience, which goes on to sell pretty well.

• 38:26Yvette Gentile?

  And Lester also accomplishes his dream of converting a lot of Filipinos over to Pentecostalism. Over the next three decades, the church he was building in Manila sees thousands of new members. And the church known as the Cathedral of Praise is still active today, with four locations in Manila and more branches all over the Philippines, the United Arab Emirates, and Hawaii. It's safe to say, if this was all just one big publicity stunt, well, it worked, which is why his massive success does raise questions about his intentions. Like, did he actually care about Clarita?

• 39:09Yvette Gentile?

  Or did he just perform the exorcism to get famous? Which then begs the question, was Clarita ever really possessed in the first place?

• 39:22Rasha Pecoraro?

  Okay, this is interesting because, yes, this whole thing does seem to serve Lester. And a lot of details about Clarita's exorcism come directly from his book. But there were also some details about Clarita's life that, looking back, could be seen as suspicious. Remember how we talked about Clarita's mother being a fortune teller and dabbling in the occult for work? Well, there are some sources that say that as a little girl, Clarita watched her mother hold seances, predict people's futures, you know, that sort of thing. But supposedly, it was all an act. Her mother didn't have any supernatural abilities. She just knew how to fake it to make it.

• 40:03Rasha Pecoraro?

  And that's something that might have made a big impression on a young Clarita. Something she might have even used to, I don't know, get out of jail, maybe? Which seemed to work because remember, the judge only sentenced her to that brief stay in the women's facility. And while Dr. Lara and his team said they found no evidence of a mental health condition in Clarita, that might not have been the case. Because among that group of people watching the exorcism, there were two doctors from what's now known as the National Center for Mental Health in Manila. And they said Clarita showed signs of a personality disorder called hysterical

• 40:43Rasha Pecoraro?

  psychoneurosis, which leads to symptoms like aggressiveness and repression. And that she showed signs of malnutrition and dehydration, which could have led to violent delusions.

• 40:55Yvette Gentile?

  Okay, I totally hear you, but when you take everything into consideration, I think there's a lot of evidence that shows Clarita really was dealing with some supernatural force. Just think about it. Come on, bite marks appearing all over her body when no one is touching her? And the clumps of hair she seemed to pull from some invisible being? I mean, that alone makes me think there's something to this story. And yes, while Lester Sumrell might have taken advantage of the situation, I'm not sure that that makes Clarita's story any less credible. Especially because in the end, Lester wasn't the one who saved Clarita. She saved herself.

• 41:39Rasha Pecoraro?

  I think you bring up an excellent point. Whether you believe the demons Clarita was fighting were literal or figurative, they seemed to be very real to her. And the only way she could defeat them was by asserting her own power. How cool is that? Her entire life, Clarita had been on her own. She fell through the cracks of society and no one was really able or willing to help her.

• 42:07Yvette Gentile?

  But then in her darkest moment, she realized that she had the tools to stand up for herself, to take control of her own life, which goes to show, sometimes we have to be pushed to our greatest limits to see what we are truly capable of.

• 42:37Rasha Pecoraro?

  This is So Supernatural, an Audiochuck original, produced by Crime House. You can connect with us on Instagram at So Supernatural Pod and visit our website at sosupernaturalpodcast.com. Join Yvette and me next Friday for an all-new episode. So what do you think, Chuck? Do you approve?

• 43:01Speaker 03

  I've been having a hard time trying to explain what Midnight Burger is. How about I let them give it a shot?

• 43:07Speaker 05

  Your podcast is amazing. It's such an amazing show altogether.

• 43:10Speaker 06

  You guys have actively ruined all of their audio dramas for me. You can't get people to understand the humaning that happens in this damn show. Keep doing what you're doing, because it's awesome. You might not think it, but you are far more important than you realize. Thank you.

• 43:24Speaker 03

  At the nexus of all things, there is a diner. Look for Midnight Burger on your favorite podcasting app, or just go to weopenat6.com.