Skip to content

#331 Scott Payne - FBI Undercover Agent Reveals the Most Disturbing Cases of His Career

Shawn Ryan Show

Hosted by Shawn Ryan

5h 4m
Transcript

Original podcast

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode features retired FBI undercover agent Scott Payne, who discusses his two-decade career infiltrating drug traffickers, outlaw motorcycle clubs, and violent extremist organizations. Payne details harrowing operations, including posing as the leader of an international theft ring while embedded with the Outlaws Motorcycle Club in Massachusetts and infiltrating a violent neo-Nazi accelerationist group known as The Base. He and the host discuss the brutal realities of cartel violence, the psychological toll of deep undercover work, and the silent struggles with mental health that many military members and first responders face.

  • Monitor your children's online activity closely, as bad actors actively use online platforms to target vulnerable youths. 4:58:42
  • Recognize that seeking professional psychological help is a sign of strength rather than weakness. 3:09:30
  • Establish a support network and make the necessary phone calls when facing mental health crises.

Chapters

  1. 0:36
    Host Introduction and Guest Arrival

    The host welcomes retired FBI agent Scott Payne to the show.

  2. 4:00
    Teenage Experimentation and Spiritual Shift

    Scott explains how his family divorce led him to explore Satanism and witchcraft during high school.

  3. 6:40
    Undercover Gear and EDC Evolution

    Scott discusses his firearms and everyday carry choices during his FBI career.

  4. 9:51
    Early Life and Family Background

    Scott recounts his upbringing in Greenville, South Carolina, family dynamics, and early interests.

  5. 26:38
    Path to Law Enforcement and Early Career

    Scott describes his transition from college to law enforcement, including bouncer work and police academy.

  6. 32:00
    Field Operations and Tactical Planning

    He describes coordinating a covert operation, including weapon setups and undercover roles.

  7. 35:16
    Early Police Experiences and Challenges

    Scott shares anecdotes from his early days as a police officer, including ride-alongs and job struggles.

  8. 45:46
    FBI Undercover Training and Operations

    Scott outlines his FBI training, undercover work, and the skills required for deep undercover assignments.

  9. 47:57
    Undercover Beginnings in Rural Tennessee

    Scott Payne recounts his first six months undercover in a rural East Tennessee county, highlighting the challenges of maintaining anonymity.

  10. 51:33
    Gambling Ring Infiltration Tactics

    Strategies for entering and gathering evidence in gambling operations.

  11. 52:17
    Source Development Techniques

    Payne explains various methods for cultivating informants, from arrests to building relationships.

  12. 56:19
    FBI Career Path and Training

    Payne details his transition to the FBI, the rigorous selection process, and his training at Quantico.

  13. 1:08:20
    Border Operations and Cartel Activity

    Insight into border enforcement, cartel tactics, and the complexities of cross-border investigations.

  14. 1:18:28
    First Major Bust Experience

    Payne recounts his first significant drug bust in New York, illustrating the scale and impact.

  15. 1:34:14
    Cartel Violence and Early Encounters

    The episode opens with a chilling recount of cartel brutality, setting the tone for the dark world the host will explore.

  16. 1:34:56
    The Lion and the Midget: Graphic Torture Tactics

    The speaker details grotesque torture methods used by cartels, including a lion and a midget, illustrating the extreme violence they employ.

  17. 1:36:13
    Kidnapping and Rescue: The Arizona Incident

    A personal kidnapping story unfolds, showing how the FBI intervened to rescue a family and expose cartel operations.

  18. 1:38:19
    Cartel Enforcement and Power Struggles

    The speaker explains cartel enforcement structures and the power vacuum created when key figures are removed, leading to turf wars.

  19. 1:55:30
    The Farm‑Food Connection & Moink Promotion

    A brief ad segment promotes Moink, linking family farms to consumers, before the host returns to crime discussion.

  20. 2:03:18
    Undercover Training Overview

    The host outlines the rigorous FBI undercover training process, including the UC school and HRT, and the challenges of becoming an operative.

  21. 2:06:00
    Infiltrating the Outlaws Motorcycle Club

    The speaker recounts his undercover infiltration of the Outlaws Motorcycle Club, detailing how he built trust, navigated gang politics, and balanced law‑enforcement duties.

  22. 2:18:27
    Escalation: From Infiltration to Criminal Collaboration

    The narrative shifts to the host’s deeper involvement with criminal operations, including carjacking and stolen property, blurring lines between undercover work and illicit activity.

  23. 2:21:01
    Moral Ambiguity and the Thin Line

    The episode concludes with a contemplative look at the moral gray areas faced by undercover agents and the potential for crossing into criminality.

  24. 2:21:49
    Introduction and Early Case Setup

    The episode opens with the host setting the stage for Scott Payne’s undercover FBI work, highlighting the dangers and moral complexities of infiltrating outlaw motorcycle gangs.

  25. 2:23:01
    Bonding with the Outlaw and Family Parallels

    Payne discusses how he built trust with the gang by sharing personal stories, especially about his daughter, to create a believable cover.

  26. 3:06:31
    SWAT Raid and Prison Release

    The episode opens with a recount of a SWAT raid that led to a man's imprisonment, setting the stage for discussions about law enforcement and personal accountability.

  27. 3:32:27
    Opening Remarks and Context

    The host sets the stage, introducing the topic and the guest’s background.

  28. 4:45:28
    Physical Injury and Recovery

    The guest recounts a back injury that delayed a mission and details his rehabilitation.

  29. 4:47:27
    Logistics and Transportation Challenges

    The narrative covers travel complications, vehicle issues, and the use of Uber for covert movement.

  30. 4:48:23
    Arrest Operations and SWAT Coordination

    Details of a stealth arrest operation, ruse tactics, and SWAT team involvement.

  31. 4:49:56
    Uncovering FBI Infiltration

    The guest reveals the discovery of an FBI undercover agent within the extremist group.

  32. 4:51:54
    Retirement and Career Reflections

    He reflects on retirement, career satisfaction, and the impact of COVID on his transition.

  33. 4:54:57
    Post-Career Activities and Media Work

    The guest discusses his work on film sets, weapons handling, and cameo appearances.

  34. 4:57:24
    Advice to Families on Online Safety

    The guest offers practical tips for parents to monitor and protect children from extremist content.

  35. 4:59:52
    Future Threats and Technology

    He discusses emerging threats from AI and peer‑to‑peer networks, emphasizing vigilance.

  36. 5:01:28
    Closing Reflections and Farewell

    The host and guest wrap up, expressing gratitude and encouraging listeners to stay vigilant.

Highlights

  • 5:20

    Uncovering Cheap Murder For Hireinsight

    The guest explains that contrary to Hollywood depictions, murder-for-hire contracts in the United States are often shockingly inexpensive, sometimes ranging from just two thousand to ten thousand dollars.

  • 2:35:53

    Strip-Searched at Gunpointstory

    The guest recalls a terrifying moment during an undercover operation with the Outlaws Motorcycle Club when members took him to a basement, drew their weapons, and forced him to strip to check for a wire.

  • 2:52:58

    Hitting the Wall of Exhaustionstory

    The guest describes reaching a breaking point after three years of continuous undercover work, resulting in a severe psychological and physical crash that led to his diagnosis of being over-assigned.

  • 4:11:46

    Ritual Sacrifice of a Goatstory

    The guest details a bizarre and dark Halloween ceremony performed by members of The Base in Georgia, which involved stealing a neighbor's goat, sacrificing it, and drinking its blood.

Quotes

  • “I didn't want to stop mentally, but my body said, you're done.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:26
  • “For me, to see somebody get $100,000 to murder somebody, that's, that was more TV stuff.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:24
  • “I was a cop. I was a fed.”
    Unnamed speaker · 38:51
  • “I mean, with the, I mean, just picture facial recognition and say, I've got three different identities.”
    Unnamed speaker · 48:26
  • “I'm like, I went overseas, what if I did, I mean, I didn't, but what if I did go covertly in the past?”
    Unnamed speaker · 48:54
  • “I know I had a 38. I don't remember any of this. I tried to study geometry and algebra again and all this stuff and I was like.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:05:43
  • “The midget was in the room. The guy was crying, he was getting ready, he was getting ready to be tortured a little bit. Get raped by a midget.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:37:15
  • “The cartel coughed up two undocumented aliens coming from Yemen.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:37:58
  • “At least when I was there, it was like every two weeks you had to pay. If you didn't pay, they'll kidnap you.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:38:38
  • “The cartel was like, we don't want this kind of heat. Hey, FBI, we got two people.”
    Unnamed speaker · 1:38:03
  • Moink 2:02:55–2:03:12
  • Armora 2:48:51–2:49:13
  • Helix 3:28:00–3:29:00
  • Glacier 4:16:02–4:18:21

About this episode

Scott Payne is a retired FBI Special Agent who spent twenty-eight years in law enforcement investigating drug trafficking organizations, human traffickers, outlaw motorcycle clubs, gangs, public corruption, and domestic terrorists. He served as the primary undercover agent on dozens of operations, including infiltrations of the Outlaws Motorcycle Club and The Base, a violent neo-Nazi accelerationist group. Payne also served on an FBI SWAT team and trained agents in firearms, tactics, active-shooter response, and undercover operations. He is the New York Times bestselling author of Code Name: Pale Horse: How I Went Undercover to Expose America’s Nazis. Privacy Isn't Paranoia. It's Protection. Download Glacier - https://srs.site/glacierapp Website - https://theglacierapp.com Shawn Ryan Show Sponsors: Visit https://drinkag1.com/SRS to get a FREE AG1 Pro Yeti Shaker in your AG1 Pro Welcome Kit Try ZipRecruiter for FREE today at https://ziprecruiter.com/SRS and meet great candidates who’ll go the extra step for your job. Don’t sleep on [@ultrapouches]. New customers get 15% Off with code SRS at https://takeultra.com! #UltraPouches #ad Go to https://moinkbox.com/SRS to get free chicken wings in every box for a year as long as you're a paying customer. Get 30% off your first subscription order at https://armra.com/srs or enter code SRS at checkout. Go to https://helixsleep.com/SRS for up to 30% off. Make sure you enter our show name after checkout so they know we sent you! Scott Payne Links: Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/scottpaynebigcountry Book - https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Code-Name-Pale-Horse/Scott-Payne/9781668032916 Website - scottpaynebigcountry.com X - https://x.com/Scott_D_Payne Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
5:04:17

57,481 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • FBI
  • base
  • Seven Six Four
  • Maryland
  • Michigan
  • Delaware
  • Napster
  • Bark
  • Detroit
  • Pacific Northwest

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated