Pod Insights Rental Income Podcast With Dan Lane The 1% Rule Doesn't Exist In His Area - Here's How He's Making Money With His Rentals With Matthew Crawford (Ep 280) About this episode Matthew's rentals do not meet the 1% rule, but his properties still cash flow. On this episode, we talk about what he's looking for in a rental instead.
We also look at one of his rentals and figure out what he paid for it, how much it's renting for, and how much cash flow it's generating.
Matthew also shares tips on how he is winning property bidding wars in a competitive market.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Inspiring interviews with today's top landlords. This is the Rental Income Podcast. And now, Dan Lane.
0:09 Speaker 01 There's lots of ways to analyze a rental property, but the very first thing that I look at when I'm looking to buy a new rental is it needs to meet the 1% rule, meaning that if I'm going to buy a property for $100,000, I need it to rent for 1% of the purchase price. So in the case of a $100,000 house, I need it to rent for $1,000 a month. That's always worked out pretty well for me, but Matthew, you don't really care too much about the 1% rule. Why not?
0:41 Speaker 02 Well, for the most part, Dan, the 1% rule doesn't even exist in our area. You can't find a deal that'll cash flow to 1%. So even the best deals I've found don't get there. But all the properties that I've got do cash flow pretty nicely. Maybe not the 1% rule, but they're all making good money.
1:01 Speaker 01 On the podcast today, we're going to talk about Matthew's strategy. We're going to take a look at his numbers and figure out how exactly he's able to be so profitable when he doesn't meet the 1% rule. Joining us on the podcast today from Nashville is Matthew Crawford. Let's take a real quick break. We'll come right back and we'll talk to Matthew. The first step in buying a rental property is to get pre-qualified. And I would suggest you work with a lender that specializes in working with investors because the last thing you want to have happen is to get to closing and find out the money's not there and you can't close. The lender that I recommend is Chaylee Ridge from Ridge Lending Group. She's a nationwide lender and she'll pre-qualify you for free
1:45 Speaker 01 if you mention Rental Income Podcast. Find out more today. Contact Chaylee at ridgelendinggroup.com. That's R-I-D-G-E lendinggroup.com. NMLS 42056.
1:59 Speaker 03 Hi, I'm Dr. Jake Goodman, host of Beyond the Script, the podcast where I sit down with pharmacists to answer the health questions you didn't even know you could ask at the pharmacy counter. GLP-1s are everywhere right now, but what should you know before taking one? In this episode, CVS pharmacist and district leader Victoria Motola joins me to break down side effects, costs, and what the treatment journey can look like.
2:24 Speaker 04 I remember a patient that was using a GLP-1 for the first time and experienced a lot of nausea and vomiting off the bat. They said, "I'm never taking a GLP-1 again. I feel awful." And at that point, they just didn't have the proper counseling of this is going to dissipate over time. So before the first dose, pharmacists and healthcare providers can review how the medications work, proper use, the common side effects, and what to expect as the treatment begins.
2:51 Speaker 03 Listen to new episodes of Beyond the Script on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
3:00 Speaker 01 Matthew, before we talk about the 1% rule, I want to try to understand where you're coming from. Can you tell me a little bit about the rentals and the types of neighborhoods that you're investing in?
3:12 Speaker 02 Sure. Yeah, the rentals that we have are all single-family rentals. And it's really, you know, there's a million different ways you can invest in real estate. And for us, what we really like are single-family rentals. And it's, I guess, because it's what we know.
3:28 Speaker 01 Right.
3:29 Speaker 02 And in the area that we're in, all these houses were built in the late 60s, early 70s. And they have a couple of things about them. They have brick veneer and hardwood floors. So those are, for whatever reason, those are my first boxes I check. And also, all the houses that were kind of built in that timeframe were just built really well. And you know that they've got dry crawl spaces, the framing is done well, you're not, the bones of the building are fine.
3:58 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
3:59 Speaker 02 It's all great neighborhoods. And as a matter of fact, my primary residence is within three miles of all of my rentals. And it's a, it's a lake town right outside of Nashville. You know, it's a growing town. It's got every amenity, parks, you know, you name it. Just a great town to live in, great schools, all that.
4:18 Speaker 01 Okay, so it's a solid town. Sounds like you're buying solid properties that are, that are in pretty good shape. So, so I want to talk to you about the 1% rule. So you mentioned that the 1% rule doesn't really exist in your area. Like, so you just can't find any deals that would meet the 1% rule?
4:39 Speaker 02 None that I've been able to find.
4:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
4:41 Speaker 02 You know, if you buy a $200,000 house there, you're not at least this point in time out in this town, you're not getting $2,000 a month rent. Nobody's paying that much for rent unless it's a fully furnished, you know, beautiful house on the lake or something along those lines.
4:56 Speaker 01 Right. So maybe like if you were looking at a different area, maybe like a like a maybe a rougher area or maybe an area that was further away away from the city. Could you maybe find a 1% rule deal around there?
5:14 Speaker 02 You probably could. If you found, if you found a place that, you know, needed a little bit more work, like a rehab, things like that, you could probably do it. But then, you know, all those things come with that. You've got more money to do the actual work. You've got probably higher rent or higher turnover for your tenants.
5:36 Speaker 01 Sure.
5:36 Speaker 02 So, you know, it's just, there's just more involved.
5:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
5:39 Speaker 02 The houses, the houses that I've got, the last one I bought, I literally brought a bucket of tools to the house and spent two hours and got it rent ready. So.
5:49 Speaker 01 Awesome. All right. Well, let's talk through some of the, some of the reasons why the 1% rule doesn't matter to you. So like what else? Like what are some of the, the reasons that, that you're comfortable overlooking that? The 1% rule?
6:05 Speaker 02 Well, I guess for me, the biggest thing is they all cash flow. Every one of them. And it's not like it's cash flowing a hundred dollars. Of the four, four single family houses that I have, they all cash flow over $500 a month.
6:20 Speaker 01 Okay. So let's talk some numbers. I just to understand, like say for one of your properties, can you tell me what you paid for it and what the rent is?
6:30 Speaker 02 Sure. I've got, the first one we bought was $185,000.
6:34 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:35 Speaker 02 We put 20%, 20% down and it rents for 1450.
6:39 Speaker 01 Okay, so 185, so you're, you're close to the 1% rule like, you know, just maybe that's like point eight or something.
6:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, not too far off there.
6:49 Speaker 01 Okay. And so you, you bought that property, you put 20% down, what's your mortgage payment on the house?
6:56 Speaker 02 Uh, it is 926.
6:58 Speaker 01 926, okay, so you've got $500 there so that if any, any issues come up, any repairs come up, you, you've got some extra money above the rent to pay for any, for, to pay for anything and then also to account for some vacancy as you have turnover from time to time.
7:17 Speaker 02 In a nutshell, Dan, I'm, you know, I'm looking at these as a long-term investment, so I'm not gonna, I'm not planning on flipping it in two years or something like that. We're gonna keep them and pay them off as soon as I get the quantity of rentals that will replace my income if they were paid off, we're gonna start paying them off.
7:36 Speaker 01 Okay, so how many rentals do you think you need?
7:40 Speaker 02 Seven to 10.
7:41 Speaker 01 Okay.
7:41 Speaker 02 Would kind of replace my income and make me feel comfortable, I guess.
7:46 Speaker 01 Okay, and you're at four right now?
7:48 Speaker 02 Yes.
7:48 Speaker 01 So just a few more rentals and, and, and you got this. So what, what's your plan for, for paying them off? Once you have your seven to 10, are you gonna start just whatever extra money you have, whatever extra cash flow you have, just start pounding away at, at those mortgages?
8:05 Speaker 02 Yeah, and like, like, I think I told you that we paid off our primary mortgage before we started any rentals. And the way we did that was, um, we put every penny we had, whether it was $20 or $2,000 out of our, you know, personal budget, we put that on the mortgage every month, whatever it was. And, uh, I'm gonna do the same thing here with the rental houses. So we're gonna pick one of them and attack it. So all the rental income, all of my, uh, residual income from my job, everything is gonna go on it. And the way I look at it is the quicker I do that, the quicker my cash flow goes up.
8:42 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm, absolutely. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, now, what about with, with financing? So with the interest rates being so low today, you can make a case that... You know, maybe you're better off keeping a mortgage at 3%. Like, what are the rates that you're getting when you're buying houses? Like, you just bought something recently.
9:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, three and a quarter.
9:05 Speaker 01 Three and a quarter. So, like, you could make a case that keeping a mortgage at three and a quarter makes a lot of sense. Like, did you ever think about maybe keeping the mortgage just because the money is so cheap? Or do you like the comfort of knowing you don't have a mortgage? Or the security of knowing you don't have a mortgage?
9:27 Speaker 02 Well, I agree with you. Yeah, that's some cheap money. That's about the cheapest money we've seen in a long time.
9:33 Speaker 02 But, and, you know, when I paid off my primary mortgage, there were a lot of people there. You know, you had kind of two schools of thought. Some people said, wow, great, good for you. And others said, that is the dumbest thing I've ever heard. That's the cheapest money. You've now you've missed your mortgage insurance write-off on your taxes. But for me, a couple of things. First off, knowing that I own it and that it's mine is, you know, a great feeling. And second, I don't have to pay the mortgage payment anymore.
10:02 Speaker 01 Right.
10:02 Speaker 02 So, you know, some of these are $900 or whatever. My cash flow just went up $900.
10:08 Speaker 01 Right, right.
10:09 Speaker 02 And my goal isn't to, you know, I'm not going to compare the numbers to the nth degree and say, well, I could have bought Tesla stock and made more money, you know, or whatever.
10:19 Speaker 01 Right.
10:20 Speaker 02 Um, my goal is to have them all paid off and my retirement job be unclogging toilets and repainting for the next tenant.
10:28 Speaker 01 Right, right. Yeah, that's not a bad strategy. And, you know, that's very safe. I mean, you can't get foreclosed on if you have a paid-off house as long as you pay the taxes every year. So, I think that's a good strategy. You know, the other benefit to you in living in Tennessee has got to be the property taxes. Your property taxes are pretty low there, right?
10:55 Speaker 02 They are, relatively speaking, yes, they are. You know, I don't want to pay any, but it's cheaper than a lot of areas.
11:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. So, you know, I think that's maybe another thing to consider with varying from the 1% rule is that, you know, if someone's in a higher-tax state like Texas or New York or Massachusetts.
11:21 Speaker 01 A 1% rule, like you almost need to go above 1% in some of those areas where with the low property tax, and you guys also don't have a state income tax, right?
11:32 Speaker 02 Right, we do not.
11:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I mean, that's, that's all stuff that I think you gotta take into account that the 1% rule, I think is a good rule of thumb, but it's not the end all be all that if something meets 1%, it's a great deal, you should buy it, and if it doesn't meet 1%, you should, you should run away.
11:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, I guess it's like anything, it's a good rule of thumb and good to, you know, kind of measure by, but, you know, there's so many different ways you can do what we're talking about, whether it's, you know, apartments, single-family houses, condos, whatever. A million different ways and a million different strategies, and for me, as long as I'm cash flowing them and somebody else is paying off the asset, it's a, it's a good deal to me.
12:19 Speaker 01 Right, so what kind of demand do you have, like in your area, like when you have a vacancy, are you able to rent the properties pretty quickly?
12:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, honestly, the last one that we bought, which was only a couple of months ago, it was insane. I, I put it on Facebook Marketplace and it blew up. I mean, I probably got 200 requests, you know, and that's not an exaggerated number, people calling me, messaging me, can I see the property, you know, yada, yada. So they're, they're flying like hotcakes. Of course, you have a lot of naysayers, I can't believe this, this house is gonna rent for that much, but then you got a lot of people that are willing to shell the money out like now for it, so.
13:02 Speaker 01 You might be able to push the rent a little bit. Have you thought about maybe going a little bit higher?
13:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I thought, you know, honestly, the, where we put the rent on this most recent house, it was $1,600. I thought, there's no way we'll get that. And that was with, then immediately after, you know, 200 people trying to rent it from me. So, yeah, I probably should have pushed that one up.
13:23 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:24 Speaker 02 Probably will next go around.
13:26 Speaker 01 I feel like with the demand that you have and with, with the neighborhoods your properties are in, that you're not meeting the 1% rule today, but you may in a couple of years, like as rents appreciate over time, I feel like there's a really good chance that... That if we're sitting here talking in three, four, five years, you might be at the 1% rule.
13:50 Speaker 02 I hope so.
13:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's something else. I think in just about every area, rents are going to appreciate over time. So, you know, even if you have a thin deal when you're getting in there, it's hopefully going to get better. And, you know, the other thing I like about your strategy is so you're working with a Realtor, it sounds like you're buying properties off the MLS, right?
14:16 Speaker 02 Exactly.
14:17 Speaker 01 So, it's just basic stuff. I mean, this is like real estate 101 that you're doing. It's nothing crazy complicated. You're working with a Realtor, the Realtor is finding you properties, and you're putting 20% down, and you're making 500 bucks a month on each property.
14:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. Honestly, my wife is finding most of the properties and then sending it to the Realtor saying, "Hey, what about this one? Can you give us a deets on it?"
14:43 Speaker 01 Oh, wow. Wow, okay. Now, is it competitive? It sounds like it's a really high, a really competitive rental market. Is it competitive to buy properties too?
14:54 Speaker 02 It is. We definitely celebrate when we get an offer accepted, and we've gotten a little bit creative with our offers, and that was from losing a couple. One of them we lost because they didn't have, they didn't include an appraisal contingency in the offer. I thought, wow, that's crazy that that was the difference in getting it or not getting it. So, we tried that on our last rental number three, and they took ours, which was not the highest offer, but because we didn't put an appraisal contingency in there, they accepted our offer. Of course, it appraised for the correct amount, so it worked great.
15:35 Speaker 01 That's good. So, the only risk to that is if the house doesn't appraise, you might have to put in a little bit of money on top of your down payment. But, you know, as long as you're comfortable with that risk, I mean, that's a great way to get a property that you probably wouldn't have gotten if you didn't do that.
15:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, and you know, for it's it's a good risk mitigation tool for the seller because they, you know, they don't want to have to come out of pocket or reduce the price if it doesn't appraise or something. So it's great for them.
16:04 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's awesome. Yeah, like, there's so many little things in there. I've waived the financing contingencies in in contracts before, which is risky, because if you can't get financing, you still have to buy the house or you're going to lose your deposit. But, you know, I just, you know, I just figured, you know, I've got good credit. I know I'm going to get approved, that I was comfortable with putting my deposit on the line. And, you know, luckily, everything worked out. How about anything else? Like, with with the prices going up, is are you using any escalation clauses or anything else in your offers?
16:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, actually, on that same one, I think that the asking price of the house was 190. And we assumed it would go much higher than that. So we did a escalation up to $201,000, a $1,000 escalation, and put in the offer at 190. I think I think it actually was listed at 189.9, put in at 190,000 escalation up to 201.
17:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's another good tip for anyone looking to buy a house. Like, maybe could you explain how the escalation clause works for anyone that isn't familiar with that?
17:17 Speaker 02 Sure. And, you know, you can pick your own numbers. But for this illustration, you, you know, you make an offer at like, for instance, 190, and the escalation clauses, it'll go up $1,000 to beat any other offer up to a certain number. And that way, you know, you kind of you cover an entire spectrum without showing all your cards. Because, you know, you could say, you could offer $225,000, but that's dumb if the lowest offer was 210. So you do the escalation, and then you're only paying $1,000 more than the highest offer.
17:52 Speaker 01 Right, yeah, that's a great way to to maybe not overbid on a on a property. And they have to show you the the other contract, right, to to show to you that they're not taking advantage of you. Well, that is awesome. Well, Matthew, congratulations. I really love your strategy. I think I think you're buying properties right. And I love that you're working on getting everything paid off. I think that's really great.
18:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, thank you. You know, one of the things I like about it is when you have to save 20% to put down, you know, we're not, we're not doing hard money lending, we're not getting investors or anything like that. It's just us. So when we save $20,000 or 20%, however much that ends up being, it gives you time to think between rentals. So you get a good opportunity to say, is this the right thing? Is this the right area? Is this the right property? So that's been a good kind of a gut check for us.
18:48 Speaker 01 Before we wrap things up, I just want to point out that Matthew is having a lot of success with this strategy because he's got the perfect storm of things working in his favor. He's got really high-quality properties in a really good neighborhood. He's able to attract really good tenants. He doesn't seem to have a lot of turnover, and when he does, he can rent the properties out very quickly. And his properties don't seem to have a lot of deferred maintenance, so the maintenance cost is very low. If you're looking at properties and you don't have all those things lining up, you're probably going to lose money if you follow the numbers that Matthew's using. If you have just an extra couple of weeks
19:31 Speaker 01 of vacancy, or you have more maintenance or more evictions, you're probably going to lose money following Matthew's strategy. So make sure you really understand your local market and go with the numbers that are going to be profitable in the area that you're looking to invest in. If anyone wants to reach out to Matthew, I've got his contact information on the website. You can find it at rentalincomepodcast.com/episode280. I'd like to thank today's sponsor for making this episode possible. It's Chailey Ridge from Ridge Lending Group. If Matthew inspired you and you want to buy a rental property, whether you're just getting started or you want to add to your portfolio, the lender
20:16 Speaker 01 that I recommend is Chailey Ridge. She's a nationwide lender, and she specializes in helping investors buy rental properties. She has a ton of different loan programs, and she can find some. Something that'll work for you in your situation. If you want to find out more or set up a time to talk to Jaylee, just go to ridgelendinggroup.com. That's R I D G E lendinggroup.com. If you mention rental income podcast, she will waive all the pre qualification fees. NMLS 42056. Thank you so much for listening to the podcast. Make sure you subscribe. We have new interviews every single Tuesday.
21:01 Speaker 01 And if you subscribe, you'll get notified as soon as they come out. My name is Dan Lane and this has been the Rental Income Podcast.
21:12 Speaker 05 Say what? Say epti v epti. Eptinism of JJMR treatment like I did. Tap the ad to learn more at v epti.com. Ask your doctor if it's time to.
21:26 Speaker 06 Think of Ammo Squared as your personal ammunition supply chain. Instead of waiting until you're almost out, build your reserves steadily over time. Set your budget, choose your calibers and start with as little as $5 a month. No membership fees. Your ammunition is stored in climate controlled facilities until you're ready to ship. If your needs change, exchange ammunition in your account at market value and put the credit toward a different caliber. Visit ammo squared.com and start building your reserve.
Previous How A Small Rental Portfolio Paid For Her To Travel The World With Tiffany Green (Ep 279) Next How To Make Your Rentals More Passive With Ron Faraci (Ep 281) Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated