Pod Insights Rental Income Podcast With Dan Lane How He Bought 11 Rentals Without Having A High Paying Job With Andy Samuelson (Ep 257) About this episode Andy is a teacher and doesn't make a lot of money. But, he has managed to buy 11 rentals over the last few years. On this episode, we talk about the different strategies that he has used to buy his properties, and how he manages his rentals with his full-time job.
We also talk about the unique way that he screens his tenants, and how he has been able to squeeze a little extra monthly cash flow out of his rentals.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Inspiring interviews with today's top landlords. This is the Rental Income Podcast. And now, Dan Lay.
0:10 Speaker 01 My guest on the podcast today is an elementary school teacher. So he's got a good, steady job, but he doesn't make a ton of money. Over the last couple of years, he's managed to buy 11 rentals. He's done it by using a couple of different creative strategies to come up with the down payments. So on the show today, we're going to figure out exactly what he did. He's also got a real interesting way that he screens tenants. It's something that I haven't heard of anybody doing before, but it's working out great for him. So what we're going to figure out what he's doing. Also, he's figured out a way to make his rentals just a little bit more profitable. So we'll talk to him about that. Joining us on the show today from Riverton, Wyoming is Andy Samuelson. We'll take a really quick break. We'll thank our sponsors.
0:55 Speaker 01 We'll come right back and we'll meet Andy. The first step in buying a rental property is to get pre-qualified. And I would suggest you work with a lender that specializes in working with investors, because the last thing you want to have happen is to get to closing and find out the money's not there and you can't close. The lender that I recommend is Chalie Ridge from Ridge Lending Group. She's a nationwide lender and she'll pre-qualify you for free if you mention Rental Income Podcast. Find out more today. Contact Chalie at ridgelendinggroup.com. That's R-I-D-G-E lendinggroup.com. NMLS 42056.
1:36 Speaker 01 It can be a real challenge to stay organized and keep track of all your rental income and expenses for tax time. Most people end up with a pile of receipts that you need to sort through and make sense of. I want to let you know about an easier way. It's a software that I use called Rental Hero. It was built specifically for rental property owners. They have a really easy to use web portal as well as an app where you can easily input all your income and expenses. You can take pictures of receipts and you're done with the payment. Paper receipts for good. They have a free 30 day trial. You can try it out. No credit card required. If you don't like it, there's nothing to cancel. Just go to rentaltrial.com. That's
2:21 Speaker 01 rental trial, T R I A L dot com. Andy, you've got a great job. You're a school teacher. You've got a stable job. You've got a job with a pension, which is pretty rare these days. Why did you even want to get involved with rentals?
2:38 Speaker 02 I guess the first thing was just to supplement our, our income.
2:40 Speaker 01 Okay.
2:41 Speaker 02 Uh, add retirement, just to have a great retirement. We thought we better have a little bit extra, um, besides our, our state retirement. We've got three little girls. Of course, we want to get them through college and, and, uh, get them started out on a good life as well.
2:58 Speaker 01 Okay, that all makes sense. So tell us what your portfolio looks like today.
3:05 Speaker 02 Uh, we've got 11 units right now. We've got a, they're split between our personal, um, portfolio. And then we've, my brother and I actually own a LLC that we started two years ago. In our personal, we've got two duplexes. So we've got the two duplexes and a single family home there. And then in the LLC, we've got three single families and a triplex.
3:27 Speaker 01 Now, how are you doing all this? I mean, you, you mentioned earlier that as a teacher, you don't have a huge salary. And I, I feel like this is something that holds a lot of people back is, is just coming up with the down payments. So how are you, how did you buy your properties?
3:44 Speaker 02 Well, we had a little bit of savings, uh, for the first one. That's, we saved up a little bit of money and we were able to buy it for a little under market value. And that gave us just enough where we could get into the first one. Uh, the second one, we worked with an, an owner who financed the down payment for us. And so the house needed some repairs and it probably wouldn't be sold on the, on the open market. Um,
4:18 Speaker 02 Just because a potential buyer might not be able to get financing on it.
4:21 Speaker 01 So, did you get a regular loan and then the seller kind of gave you a second mortgage for the down payment or did the seller finance the whole purchase for you?
4:31 Speaker 02 No, on that one, it was just a, he just financed the down payment.
4:36 Speaker 01 Okay.
4:36 Speaker 02 The bank was okay with it because it was a kind of specialized, you know, in-house loan and, and they understood, you know, kind of why we needed to do that.
4:46 Speaker 01 That's great. So you were able to buy that property with no money out of your pocket?
4:51 Speaker 02 Right.
4:51 Speaker 01 That is awesome.
4:52 Speaker 02 Just a, just a one-year loan to kind of figure out some other financing.
4:57 Speaker 01 Okay.
4:57 Speaker 02 And end up getting it paid back. So.
4:58 Speaker 01 Perfect. Okay. And then what about the other properties? Like, how did you, how did you come up with the down payment for them?
5:05 Speaker 02 Uh, when my brother and I started the LLC, we each agreed to put in $500 per month. And that gave us, our goal was to get one property per year and the $500 per month or a thousand between us, um, allowed us to get one property that way.
5:24 Speaker 01 Awesome. Okay. So you guys just set up a savings account, you each put in $500 and then after a year, you've got $12,000 and that was enough to, for a down payment in your area?
5:38 Speaker 02 Right.
5:38 Speaker 01 Awesome. Awesome. Okay. Well, that sounds really obtainable. So you've, are you buying basically a property a year?
5:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's, that was kind of our goal we originally set out. Um, for us, we had a, we had a 30% return on our, on our cash we're putting in these rentals.
5:57 Speaker 01 Now, a 30% return is, is pretty incredible. So what are you doing with that cash flow? Are you using that to supplement your, your life or to pay for things or like, what do you do with the profit every month?
6:10 Speaker 02 Well, we really try not to. We really try to just keep our, our rental money in our rental account for our personal ones and then the LLC money, um, in the LLC checking.
6:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
6:20 Speaker 02 And that's allowed us to, just our cash flow, um,
6:25 Speaker 02 Over the last six or seven years has allowed us to purchase more properties.
6:30 Speaker 01 Okay, awesome. All right. So now you've got enough properties and enough rental income every month where it's kind of starting to snowball. So your rentals are buying you more properties. That is awesome. I love that. You know, and it's like the more properties you buy, the more your cash flow is going to increase and the more frequent you're going to be able to buy properties. I mean, I'm sure at some point you'll be able to buy two properties a year just with the cash flow. That's great. So what's your long-term plan with the rentals? Like, what do you guys, you and your brother, shooting for long-term?
7:07 Speaker 02 Well, we don't really have a specific number. More just a cash flow number. Eventually, we'll get to the point where we've got enough rentals where the management, both the need for the management as far as time, as well as the monthly income, will allow me to leave education and just do rentals full-time.
7:33 Speaker 01 Awesome.
7:34 Speaker 02 Which I guess would be my long-term goal.
7:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. Now, that's a good point, though. So today, do you manage the properties yourself?
7:43 Speaker 02 Yes, I do. We do all the management, all the maintenance. We do hire out most of the cleaning, any plumbing and electrical, of course.
7:55 Speaker 01 Is that hard? I mean, so, you know, for someone that maybe has a job where they're working in an office and they can maybe sneak out over a lunch break to do a showing or maybe take some calls at work, you've got a job as a teacher where you really can't get out of the school, I imagine. Is that hard to have to put everything on hold during the school day?
8:20 Speaker 02 Um, I guess we, when we started, I mean, we started as teachers. So uh, it's been like that since the beginning. We've got, you know, from seven thirty to three thirty is school time. And between thirty, three thirty and five, that's go time for contacting, you know, utility companies and our county treasurer for taxes.
8:41 Speaker 01 Or any showings or anything?
8:42 Speaker 02 Realtor. Yeah, getting showings done. Those can happen in the evening, you know, a lot of times. Uh, stopping by the bank, everything like that has to happen between three thirty and five. So.
8:52 Speaker 01 So it, it almost sounds like it's maybe like kind of a part-time job after school. You might work on this for an hour or two.
8:59 Speaker 02 Yeah, it is. I, I would say I spend a couple hours a day.
9:05 Speaker 02 Not all of it is managing what we have. Some of it's looking for new properties or.
9:10 Speaker 01 Yeah. So let's talk about that. So when you find a new property, do you, are you looking for properties that are pretty much ready to go? Ready to rent out as soon as you buy them? Or are you looking for properties that you're going to need to fix up a little bit?
9:26 Speaker 02 Uh, we've done a little bit of everything. We've bought houses where the foundation, half of the foundation needed to be re-poured. We ended up uh, jacking up the whole house just a, just a bit, um, pouring a new foundation underneath it. A lot of ours though, they just need paint, maybe some new kitchen cabinets and countertops in the next couple of years. They're livable right now, but they're maybe not the best. Uh, we can get them at a fairly decent price, but they're going to need some work over time. You know, a lot of ours need new windows or they'll need a new roof in the next, you know, five years or so.
10:04 Speaker 01 And are you doing a lot of that rehab work yourself too?
10:08 Speaker 02 Yep. Yeah. We, a lot of our stuff, we, as soon as we get it, my dad's a painting contractor and so.
10:13 Speaker 01 Okay.
10:13 Speaker 02 You know, as soon as we get, you know, most things we put a coat of paint inside and outside.
10:19 Speaker 01 And how do you find the time to do that? I mean, with, with your day job and managing the rentals for an hour or two after school, how do you find the time to do the work?
10:33 Speaker 02 Well, the nice thing about teaching is we do have three months off in the summer. So our big projects, the ones who don't, that don't have to be done right away, they can wait till summertime. The ones we struggle with the most are the small things, you know, the water heater that goes out on a Tuesday afternoon or something.
10:52 Speaker 01 Right.
10:53 Speaker 02 They've got to go, you know, they might have to live without hot water for a day before we can.
10:59 Speaker 01 Get around to it.
11:00 Speaker 02 Three thirty the next day, go and get a water heater and go put it in.
11:03 Speaker 01 Talk to me about the house that you had to repair the foundation on. Now, that's one of those things that scares me a little bit. I don't know if I would feel comfortable buying a house with a foundation problem. But what I've found from owning rentals is that a lot of things that seem, that seemed really big, huge deals to me at the beginning, when I was getting started, I found out weren't really big deals. Is a foundation one of those things where it sounds like a big deal, but it's really not? Or are you just really skilled and you know how to do that?
11:36 Speaker 02 No, I would, I would say it's in between. It's a big deal. Uh, really didn't scare us too much. You know, we, we got a good price on, on that house. Like I said, he probably couldn't sell it on the open market, probably thirty thousand below market price.
11:51 Speaker 01 Okay. Yeah. I mean, that, that still scares me. I, I don't know if for a thirty thousand dollar discount, I, I would buy a house with a foundation problem.
12:00 Speaker 02 For two or three thousand dollars, we saved thirty.
12:03 Speaker 01 Well, okay. Yeah, that's a pretty good return. Yeah, yeah.
12:07 Speaker 02 Great return.
12:07 Speaker 01 Sure does. Yeah, that sounds great. Well, let's talk about when you have a vacancy. So when you have a property that comes vacant, how are you advertising it? Where are you finding the best tenants today?
12:20 Speaker 02 Probably seventy-five percent.
12:23 Speaker 02 Um, 75% of our hits are probably coming from Facebook.
12:28 Speaker 01 Is it really?
12:28 Speaker 02 A lot of them are, a lot of them are word of mouth also, you know, but.
12:32 Speaker 01 It's interesting, you know, it's like, I feel like Facebook Marketplace has really exploded a few years ago. I feel like nobody was getting tenants off Facebook Marketplace, but it, it seems like that is really a place people are looking today. So I, so now let's talk about when somebody comes to you, they, they've, uh, they, they like the property, they want to see it. You give them an application. Tell me about like what you're asking for and what you're looking for when you give them the application.
13:04 Speaker 02 We'll have them fill out an application right there on the spot. I've found if you hand people an application on a clipboard and a pen, they're way more likely to fill it out right then and there, rather than if you have them take it with them. They've got to take it with them.
13:18 Speaker 01 Yeah.
13:19 Speaker 02 You know, not lose it, fill it out, remember where to, you know, get it back and then get it back to you in a timely manner. So you can actually make a, a decision about it. So, um, that works well. On our, our application is just a fairly standard one. Um, just all their information. We do take their social security numbers and we have done background, credit and background checks on them. But recently I've kind of gotten away from that in the last probably three years I haven't done one.
13:52 Speaker 01 I, you, you haven't, you don't do any kind of, um, screening on them? Like you're not running their credit or anything?
14:00 Speaker 02 No, a lot of our, a lot of our tenants or prospective tenants in our area don't have the best credit, just kind of by default. You know, they'll be in the six, the six hundreds, you know, if they were running a 800, they'd probably uh, be in a position to buy their own house or, um, you know, figure out something else.
14:19 Speaker 01 Sure. Now what about just making sure that, you know, they, they're, they're not a felon or don't have any other evictions in their background? Like, wouldn't it be worth it to get, to do the background check just to, to get that information?
14:38 Speaker 02 Well, we used to pay the twenty nine ninety nine or wherever it was, you know, for a basic credit and and background check, but recently, well, at that same time too, we had a we had a spot at the bottom of our application and it just says that you're signing this and in signing it, you're agreeing to or you understand that we will pull a a background and credit check. Um, and then we leave a about a half a page full of lines there for them to explain what we might find and kind of their it's a spot for them to tell their side of the story.
15:14 Speaker 01 Hmm.
15:14 Speaker 02 And that has been the most valuable part of our application. We, we, we learned so much from what people write on those lines. And you'd be surprised at all the stuff that that they will tell you just by giving the opportunity, you know?
15:29 Speaker 01 That's interesting. Okay. So they think that you're gonna do a background check on them, but you're really not. And you're just saying-
15:37 Speaker 02 And I don't, I don't mean to say, you know, I don't mean to be dishonest with them.
15:41 Speaker 01 Right, right.
15:42 Speaker 02 There's no need to if they're gonna tell you everything honestly upfront.
15:46 Speaker 01 So what kind of stuff do they, what, what kind of stuff are they telling you? Like is someone like, oh, you know, I had a felony, but it was no big deal or like what, what? What kind of stuff do people write on, on the application?
15:58 Speaker 02 Uh, some people use it just for, to tell their whole personal life story, you know, they'll, they'll tell a half page summary of their whole life. Uh, you know, why they're here and what they're doing and you know, they got laid off two years ago and uh, now they're, you know, looking for another spot because they got a different job and um, other people, you know, they'll tell you all about their bankruptcy that they had.
16:21 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:22 Speaker 02 Um, after they went through a divorce or something and now it's all squared away and they've got a credit score of, you know, a seven fifteen and it's not the best, but it's, they're improving, you know?
16:33 Speaker 01 Right.
16:33 Speaker 02 And so if someone's gonna tell you all that, um,
16:38 Speaker 02 You know, there's really no reason to.
16:38 Speaker 01 That's interesting.
16:39 Speaker 02 The twenty nine ninety nine and then half the time that's not even on there.
16:43 Speaker 01 Right, right.
16:44 Speaker 02 It was just long enough ago that it doesn't show up or maybe I'm just doing the basic version instead of the pro version, you know, where you gotta pay
16:50 Speaker 01 Right.
16:51 Speaker 02 Forty nine ninety nine or something.
16:53 Speaker 01 So do you charge an application fee when they fill out the application?
16:57 Speaker 02 No, I don't. We, we, uh, in our area, I think some of the, the larger apartment complexes might, but we just, we've thought about it. We've talked to other landlords and, you know, we, we, uh, listen to different things or read it, you know, different newsletters and things like that, you know, and about fees and, and different opportunities to charge application fees, but we've, we just never really have.
17:24 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:25 Speaker 02 Tenants in our area.
17:26 Speaker 01 You know, I, it's working for you. It's, it seems like, you know, that, that's great. I, I always think it's a good idea to, to, to get in a background check and they're so cheap and most of the time you can charge the tenant, whatever it's going to cost, but in your area, it sounds like you're probably getting more applicants because you're not charging an application fee. It, would you say that's true?
17:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, I did. I did try it. Um, we tried to do a twenty dollar application fee one year. And this was probably five years ago. And there were so many people that I thought, man, that could have been a good renter that they just kind of said, well, okay.
18:03 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
18:04 Speaker 02 We'll think about it and if we're really serious, then we'll turn in the application and, um, I felt like we missed a lot of good tenants.
18:14 Speaker 01 Yeah.
18:14 Speaker 02 And maybe our places were empty, you know, for a month. Whereas now we try to have, you know, no gaps in our turnaround unless they're on purpose. If we need to paint the place or, you know, redo the kitchen or bath or something, you know?
18:28 Speaker 01 Right.
18:29 Speaker 02 We try not to have any.
18:31 Speaker 01 Now, let's talk about that. There's a couple of different things that you're doing to try to increase your rental income. And I want to talk through this. So one of the things that you've done is you're open to doing short-term rentals. Tell me how that works.
18:49 Speaker 02 We've found that offering people a six-month, six-month lease instead of a year, we do charge a, we do charge a fee. So we'll do $50 more for a six-month, just add it on to their monthly rent. So if it's 750 a month is what we have advertised with a year lease. If you want a six, six-month lease instead, it would just be 800 a month. And then for a three-month lease, even shorter, we'll go ahead and add another $50. So for 850, you can just do a three-month.
19:23 Speaker 01 Okay, so you're making more money. What always, I've thought about doing something similar before. And what always stops me is thinking, well, I'm going to have more vacancy when they move out. So like with turning the properties that much often, that more often doing a three-month or a six-month lease, do you find that you end up having more vacancy?
19:47 Speaker 02 Well, like I said, we try not to have any days empty. We might have days empty as far as people moving out and people moving back in. But paid days, we try to have people all paid up to the 30th, and then the next tenant will be paid from the first on.
20:05 Speaker 01 Okay, so you're showing it before, when the first tenant is in there, you're showing the property before they move out?
20:12 Speaker 02 We tried to only do, usually only one showing is all it takes. Because we're doing the open house style. We just schedule one time. And if we need to show it twice, we will. But usually, if we have five or six different parties who come by and stop by, at that time, we can choose out of those. And that's a big enough of a goal to find a qualified renter.
20:34 Speaker 01 I think that's great. I mean, that's an easy way to kind of juice your cash flow a little bit. Tell me about, I think this is an interesting story, too, where you bought a property that the owner wanted to leave behind all their furniture. Tell me what happened with that deal.
20:51 Speaker 02 Well, we found a, it's a two bedroom, one bath. Uh, they were gonna go live on their, on their boat in Alaska. Uh, they didn't need any of their furniture. They didn't need their dishes. They didn't need, you know, the pillows and the blankets on the bed, you know, everything was left behind. Um, of course, all the appliances and everything also. So we, uh, started renting it as a fully furnished place.
21:16 Speaker 01 So how much extra do you make doing it that way?
21:19 Speaker 02 If you take out the utilities and paying the cable and wifi, it's probably $300 a month extra.
21:27 Speaker 01 Okay. And you know, that's awesome. I mean, it's like you could have bought the property with all the furniture in there and dishes and you, you could have just paid a junk company to, to take everything out, but instead you, you turn that into a, a benefit and you're able to, to make more cash flow on it. I, I think that's really awesome.
21:50 Speaker 02 And we don't have a huge, we're not really a vacation destination here in the middle of Wyoming. Um, but we do have a lot of traveling nurses, a lot of traveling professionals. And so they'll, they'll rent it out at two or three months at a time. Uh, some interns that come through and we've had, we've had great luck with it. I think it's only been open two weeks in the last three years.
22:12 Speaker 01 I love it. Congratulations, Andy. You're doing a great job with your rentals. Keep up the great work. If Andy inspired you and you want to buy your first rental or you want to add to your portfolio, the lender that I recommend is Jay Lee Ridge from Ridge Lending Group. She's a nationwide lender and she specializes in helping investors buy rental properties. She has a ton of different loan programs and she can find something that'll work for you in your situation. If you want to find out more or set up a time to talk to Jay Lee personally, just go to ridge lending group.com. That's R I D G E lending group.com. If you
22:54 Speaker 01 mention rental income podcast, she will waive all the pre-qualification fees. NMLS 42056. Thank you so much for listening to the podcast. If this is your first time here, make sure you subscribe and you'll be notified as soon as we put out a new episode. My name is Dan Lane and this has been the Rental Income Podcast.
23:18 Speaker 03 Hi, I'm Dr. Jay Goodman, host of Beyond the Script, the podcast where I sit down with pharmacists to answer the health questions you didn't even know you could ask at the pharmacy counter. GLP-1s are everywhere right now, but what should you know before taking one? In this episode, CVS pharmacist and district leader Victoria Motola joins me to break down side effects, costs, and what the treatment journey can look like.
23:43 Speaker 04 I remember a patient that was using a GLP-1 for the first time and experienced a lot of nausea and vomiting off the bat. They said, "I'm never taking a GLP-1 again. I feel awful." And at that point, they just didn't have the proper counseling of this is going to dissipate over time. So before the first dose, pharmacists and healthcare providers can review how the medications work, proper use, the common side effects, and what to expect as the treatment begins.
24:10 Speaker 03 Listen to new episodes of Beyond the Script on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Bonus: How Changes To The Mortgage Market May Benefit Investors Next How He Replaced His Job Income With A Small Rental Portfolio With Chris Cucchiara (Ep 258) Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated