Rental Income Podcast With Dan Lane
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
Are beach rentals a good investment? Today on the podcast, Michael Luce shares his experience owning a beach rental.
3,530 words · 3 speakers
This is the Rental Income Podcast, where we talk to owners of rental properties and give you actionable tips and advice that will help you make more money while dealing with less hassle. And now your host, Dan Lane.
I put together a list of seven things I wish I knew earlier about renting properties, and you can download your free copy. Just go to my website, freelandlordgift.com. Joining me on the show today is Michael Luce, and Michael has a really interesting story. He owns a beach house, and I want to learn more about this. I don't know a whole lot about beach rentals, but from what I imagine, there's three big advantages to owning a beach property. Number one, there's a premium that you can charge people being at the beach. Number two, you can make more money when you charge people weekly than you could if you had somebody on a year lease. And number three, and probably best of all, is that as long as you have your
expenses covered, you can vacation there whenever you want for free. I want to ask Michael a bunch of questions, but before we get into the interview, I want to thank our sponsor Handy.com, the easiest way to book experienced home cleaners and handymen. As a rental owner, managing several properties can be exhausting. Take the hassle out of maintenance and let Handy do the heavy lifting. Get $25 off your first home cleaning or handyman service when you use promo code RENTAL at Handy.com. Are you an Airbnb host? You can use the same code, that's RENTAL, to get $25 off a vacation rental cleaning
for your Airbnb listing when you visit Handy.com/host. Michael, thank you so much for joining us on the show. I've got a lot of things I want to ask you. The first question that comes to mind is, you live really far away from your beach property. You live in Maryland. The property is in the Virgin Islands. Obviously, that's a very big distance. How do you deal with any issues that might come up being so far away?
Well, number one, yes, I am far away from St. Croix, farther away than I'd care to be. I'd love to be down there full-time, but the economics of things simply don't allow for that. So I do think it's very important to get down there two to three times a year. I can currently do that for about 10 days at a time. I think it's important to do that to assess what's going on. But yes, that means a lot of the year I'm not there. So I've built up a network of associates who do take care of the property for me. And they don't do it out of the goodness of their own heart, of course. I do pay them for that service, but I have neighbors and professionals who will stop by on a regular basis when I'm not there or when renters are not there.
And they do check for leaks. They also attend to any damage that frankly, the climate brings because the Caribbean is very harsh. A lot of ultraviolet and it can be dry, it can be wet, all sorts of things like that. So the people who I have worked with over the years are people I keep very close.
With having so many people constantly coming in and out of the property, is there a lot of wear and tear? Are you constantly having to do touch-up paint and fix little things?
So far, it seems I have been blessed with very good renters. And right now, just to clarify, the house is on the short-term, weekly rental market. I haven't had anybody stay for a long period of time. I think that the general theory is that short-term rentals can be terribly abusive of property, and I worry about that. But it has not been an issue yet, thankfully. There's also a security deposit which has worked into the agreement. So if there's a big problem, while I wouldn't like to resort to this, I would retain the security deposit to help fix up things. But you know, now that I look back on it, I have visited the property after a few of the renters have been there, and they've taken care of things very well.
Sure, there are a few issues here and there. I think that's inevitable. They've been minor at this point. And it hasn't really been a problem, but I think it's important to vet your renters as much as possible. I'm not comfortable with the idea of simply getting an inquiry and saying, "I want to reserve the place from this date to that date, and do you accept?" I really want to know a little bit more about the people who are going to be down there.
That's a really good point. How do you vet someone to see if they're going to be a good renter? Most of our listeners are renting to people for a year, maybe longer. And when someone applies, we're looking at their credit, we're looking at their employment, we're looking at their prior rental history. Those are all really good indicators on if someone's going to be a good tenant for the long term. But when you're looking at somebody renting a property for a week, what are you looking at? How do you tell if someone's going to be a good renter?
And I don't want to make it sound as though I look down my long nose at them, and they must fit every little perfect idea I have in mind. It's not quite that way. But what I do like to do is to have a little bit of email correspondence. I think it's just basically an intuitive situation. I have talked on the phone with most of these folks prior to renting to them, not all of them. But it's just a feel of decency, somebody who really is looking forward to a nice week or two on the island. So far, I've not been disappointed by my intuition in this regard. But it's just, I would say, a right-brain
sensation as to whether or not this is someone who's going to work out. I'll give you a quick example of the opposite feeling I had. One of the first potential renters was, I think, and he seemed like a nice enough guy, but he was a 22-year-old. And he said he wanted to come down to the island for 10 days with a couple of his friends, all of whom were in their mid-20s. And it just set off all kinds of alarms in my head. He could be the most wonderful guy in the world, but I remember what I was like when I was 22 or 23, and I'm not comfortable renting the house in that situation. So I would like to think that most people who have the wherewithal to visit the Caribbean
probably have established some degree of responsibility. And I think in general, I'm just getting a good pool of potential renters.
How do you find them? What are you doing to market the property?
I'm using primarily VRBO. And as I'm sure you know, VRBO has a number of sister sites. HomeAway and I think VacationRental.com. So my listing is featured on a number of the VRBO affiliated websites. That's the primary means by which I've been working. There's a competitive site to VRBO that I'm also listed on. Haven't had as much luck with them. And I recently put up a Facebook page. I'm woefully negligent in getting my own website set up, but I need to do that too, because I do understand that this is really all about marketing.
And it's a learning process for me. But with regards to the VRBO listing, I've put a lot of effort into it. The pictures, if I do say so myself, are very good. I've posted a video. I put up a few videos through YouTube. So obviously, everything these days is about the internet. And that's what I'm doing.
Is it a lot of work dealing with the inquiries? Do you ever feel overwhelmed that you have so many emails to respond to?
Well, I don't want to say I'm overwhelmed, because I'm just plain grateful to have the opportunity to do it. But it is a lot of work. Yes, when you get an inquiry in, maybe 9:30 at night, nine times out of 10, I'm not going to simply wait until the next morning to deal with it. Because in fact, that can affect the standing of your listing on some of these sites. The speediness with which you reply often figures into how well you're rated on the search results. So I do believe that, like owning your own business, you never really are off the clock.
When I was down on the island a few trips ago,
I was thankful to actually finalize a few reservations for the house. So yeah, I suppose theoretically you go away and you're on vacation, but you're never really on vacation. Again, no complaints because what I have is a beautiful piece of property in the Caribbean. But yeah, it's always an ongoing task to, let's say, to negotiate with a few renters, to follow up on some of their requests. Maybe they want an inflatable mattress for the pool that you had not previously had. And you know, you run around to Home Depot, what have you. You take care of that sort of stuff, but I like it. I have to say it's been a lot of fun. Sometimes a headache, but on the balance, very personally rewarding.
It seems like there's more of a customer service aspect with a beach rental than there is with a regular rental. And I know you've talked about your communication with them before they come to the property when you're booking it. Do you have a lot of communication while they're actually at the property?
Well, my feeling is I want the guest to feel they can reach out to me anytime. I really want them to have that feel about my availability. The last thing I want to do is be a bother to them. I certainly don't want to nitpick or harass them during their trips. So generally what I do is I maintain some degree of semi-regular contact with them prior to the trip, maybe even the night before. I say, I hope you have a great time. Remember you can reach out to me anytime. And then I kind of leave them alone during the time they're on the island. Now, my property manager with Caldwell Banker usually picks them up at the airport,
where they get their rental car and accompanies them back to the east end of the island where the house is. They stop at a grocery store on the way.
And the property manager also is available to them for any questions or problems they may have, as am I. So I'm here for them, but I leave them alone when they're on their trip because that's their time away.
On your team, you've got, obviously, yourself, you've got your property manager, and then you've got the other person you talked about, your maintenance person, that would fix any issues that come up. If something happens, say, there is a light bulb that burnt out, who do they call? Are they contacting the maintenance person directly? Are they going to the property manager? Or are they calling you?
Well, the only people I really tell my renters about are me, of course, and the property manager on island, the Caldwell Banker person. And if we need to elevate to, say, the level of a plumber or an electrician, then we take care of contacting those professionals ourselves. Either I will contact them, or my property manager on the island. And she and I, of course, are always coordinating. So we don't involve the guests of the house with anything beyond that.
I feel like there's almost a different standard with a beach house than you would have for a regular rental. If you're a tenant, and you're in a house, and something breaks, you understand things are going to break from time to time, and maybe a plumber's going to have to come over and fix it. But if you're on vacation, and a plumber has to come over, I would think you'd be really mad, that maybe you'd feel like it's an inconvenience, or it's ruining your vacation. Am I off-base on this?
I take that very seriously. Yes, I do, because before the renters come, although I really need to commit it to written form, but we have something along the lines of a checklist. It's not simply a question of sealing up the house after the last renters leave, not worrying at all until the next renters come in. Not like that at all. We certainly have check-out housekeeping when a guest leaves. And when that guest is out, and after the place has been cleaned up, of course, my regular folks are in there to keep tabs on things. And then when I have an impending rental, we go through the house and make sure everything is as it should be, including those light bulbs, and the water pressure, and any number of issues like that. Because, yes, as much as humanly possible,
I don't want these renters to have a want in the world. In fact, yes, once in a while, something is going to happen. We had a little water pressure issue on a Sunday, and I, of course, was crestfallen by this, because I wanted everything to be perfect. But thankfully, when this problem developed...
The renter was so easygoing about it because they knew I was doing everything in my power to make it a good trip for them. And in fact, it had been, I'd like to say, a very good trip. I'm thinking of this particular instance here. So when this little problem developed, and it wasn't even a big deal, they were so relaxed in general about their stay at the island, they just kicked back for a few hours while the plumber attended to the issue. And it worked out beautifully. And I got a good review from them, too. That's always a big point of concern for me. I, not only from a professional point of view, do I want this to work out with the guests, but it's a deeply personal thing to me as well. Probably too much. Maybe I'm not being a good businessman, because this thing's been
in the family forever. It means something personally to me, that these people like the house. And I know you can't control everything in this universe, and perhaps inevitably, I'm going to run across somebody who just doesn't like it. Thankfully, that hasn't happened. But I'd like to think it's because not only of my, my professional dedication to the property, but my, my feeling for the property as well.
Are you able to rent the house year round? Or do you have busy seasons and slow seasons?
The in-season down there is generally considered to be November or December, depending upon your point of view, through about mid-April. Now, it is a, technically speaking, it's a subtropic climate. And for you or me, that means it's beautiful and warm year round. Believe me, you get on your airplane, you go down there any time of the year, you're going to love it. But there is a slight difference in temperature from, say, well, maybe a little more than slight. But the ideal time to be on the island is when I laid it out for you. November, December through April, because you've got a lot of breezes blowing. And it's just slightly cooler, but very super comfortable.
And let's face it, up here, the weather is usually something other than delightful. So you'll want to head down there. Now, the off season, which kicks in April through November or December, the island is a little bit slower because things tend to, the businesses tend to maybe operate at reduced hours. There's more of a concern about bad weather when you get into the season for the H word. I'm trying not to say hurricane, but that's what it is, hurricane season. So there's some concern about that in the off season. But people also come to the island in the off season because the rates are generally better, including hours to stay at the house. The airlines tend to run better deals at that time of the year.
So yes, what, see, we're in May right now and things are a little light. But I have a renter coming in July. In fact, we just solidified that deal before you and I started talking.
Awesome. Congratulations. Let me shift gears a little bit and ask you about budgeting for repairs. How much do you set aside for issues coming up? Do you have a certain amount that you set aside every time someone stays at the property? Is it a monthly amount that you put away? How much do you budget for repairs?
Well, all of the money that I make on the house goes into its own account. And, and every expense that I have on the house is paid out of that account. So yes, I guess you could say I do budget for that. And ideally, when all is said and done, and hopefully the day will come where I don't have to rent out the house and I can live there, then I'll find myself in a super advantageous position. But yes, I try to be very militant about that. And thankfully, right now, I'm in a situation where I can do this, where all the money coming in comes, goes into a specific account. And by the same token, yes, I pay all of my utility bills for the house and my repairs. Out of that very same account.
If anyone's planning a vacation to St. Croix, I would definitely recommend staying at Michael's house. It's just a beautiful house. If you want to see the listing, go to rentalincome podcast.com/episode37 and we will put a link to his listing there in the show notes. Michael, I understand that you have a name for the house, too?
We call it Grape Tree Escape. And we do that because it's in an area of St. Croix called Grape Tree Bay. And we just thought that the house represents an escape from everyday life up here on the mainland, hence Grape Tree Escape. So that is my plug for the house, and thank you for that.
Of course, no problem. Well, it is time now for us to get into my favorite part of the show. It's the lightning round.
Now, the Rental Income Podcast Lightning Round. Five rapid-fire questions and answers in 60 seconds.
The first question is, what's your favorite real estate book?
I haven't read it yet, but I'm sure when I do read it, it's going to be great.
Okay. Number two, the number one fear that I hear from people all the time on why they don't want to own a rental property is they don't want to get a call at 3 a.m. that a toilet's clogged. As a landlord, have you ever gotten this call?
The closest I've gotten to that, and I mentioned it briefly earlier, was a water pressure issue on a Sunday in the middle of the day. I was deeply worried about it, but thankfully, I did solve the problem. And as far as that fabled three o'clock in the morning call, if it comes, you just have to deal with it. It's the price of doing business.
Number three, if your property was sitting vacant for six months, and you had a potential renter apply that you weren't so sure about, would you take a chance on them and rent to them, or let the property sit?
I would rather let it sit.
Number four, if you could give one piece of advice to a new landlord, what would it be?
Be prepared for a lot of work on the property.
Number five, would you rent the property to your best friend?
Short answer is yes, because I'd like to think I assess my friends well. Hopefully, they have good character and would treat the house as well as I'd hope they would.
You came so close to almost beating the buzzer. But thank you so much, Michael, for coming on the show. I really appreciate it. And thank you so much for listening and for subscribing to the Rental Income Podcast. My name is Dan Lane, and we'll see you with a brand-new interview next Tuesday.
Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated