Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Why Bond Yields Are the True Reflation Toggle: DB - Jan13,2021 About this episode Real Vision managing editor Ed Harrison joins Max Wiethe to discuss why he thinks US treasury yields—and not the dollar—is the key to the success or failure of the reflation trade. Together Ed and Max discuss the recent action in the bond market, the knock-on effects this has had for other reflation assets like precious metals, commodities, and equities, and the three discrete outcomes that Ed believes could arise in 2021 depending on the direction and speed of bond market moves. In the intro, Nick Correa provides an overview of the latest Consumer Price Index data. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:11 Speaker 00 Hello, everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. My name is Max Wiethe. I'm joined today by Ed Harrison. But before I sit down with Ed, let's kick it over to Nick Correa for today's stories.
0:21 Speaker 01 Thanks, Max. Today, I'm going to provide a rundown for newly released December data for the Consumer Price Index. For this past December, the data shows the CPI experienced a 0.4% gain, seasonally adjusted. This is on par with economists' projections of a 0.4% increase in the CPI, and this follows a 0.2% gain in November. The Bureau of Labor Statistics attributes this gain to an increase in the gasoline index, which experienced an 8.4% gain and contributed to more than a 60% increase in the overall CPI. Overall, demand for all grades of gasoline still is lower, with prices per gallon now about 10% below than they were a year ago, as virus-related restrictions are being implemented
1:04 Speaker 01 and consumers are staying at home and therefore reducing their driving. The cost of food has also increased 0.4%, as both groceries and eating out have gone up by 0.4%. This follows 0.1% decrease in November. All items less food and energy rose about 0.1% in December. For 2020 overall, CPI rose 1.4%, which is less than the 2.3% increase in 2019, and is the smallest December-to-December increase since 2015. The average rise in inflation for the past 10 years has been 1.7%. If you want more on the inflation, Stephen Van Meter and Michael Ashton today did a deep dive on the subject and on the interplay between inflation, interest rates, and the dollar. To flesh this out and more, let's go back to Max and Ed.
1:49 Speaker 00 Thank you, Nick. Well, Ed, back again on Wednesday. Glad to be here.
1:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's good to talk to you. And we have some interesting stuff to talk about. We had a good back-and-forth, literally right before we came on now, about the reflation trade.
2:04 Speaker 00 Yes, I'm excited to hear your nuance that you're adding to it. It's certainly not something that is a new topic. Everybody is talking about the reflation trade, and when everybody's talking about it, that leads to bad takes. So you're going to help our viewers dissect a little bit about what they should be paying attention to, because they're going to be hearing about this, at least for now.
2:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, I have two main themes, I think. Theme number one is what the toggle is in the reflation trade. And theme number two are what are the discrete outcomes that we should be thinking about. So the first on the toggle, when we talk about the reflation trade, we're talking about a reflation that is, you know, things going up as a result of economic stimulus, the economic goodness that comes from the vaccine, as well as anything else that might be like pent up demand out there. And so the result is, we see commodities going up, we see equities going up,
3:08 Speaker 02 we see yields going up. And we also, interestingly enough, see the dollar going down because of that reflation trade, because there's an insipid sort of inflationary expectation there. All of those things are put together in terms of this one nexus, the reflation trade. And usually, most people call the toggle the US dollar. So when the dollar's down, and it was down to really low levels, and it kept on going further and further, hey, great, it's, it means more reflation trade, everything else goes up. But now the dollar's reversed. I would say, actually, the reason the dollar's reversed is actually because it's not the toggle. The toggle is the bonds,
3:49 Speaker 02 10-year bonds in the United States. And over the, you know, past week, past week and a half, we've seen a massive rally in 10-year, 10-year notes, 10-year bonds. We went from basically flatlining for this month, or even three months since November, to a massive upward spike of in the order of 26 basis points at its worst, when we got to almost 119 on the 10-year. This is something I talked to Peter Bookvar about yesterday. And to me, that unwound everything else, partially, and actually, mostly because this is a rise in real rates, as opposed to a rise in inflation,
4:33 Speaker 02 and that really put a dent on all the reflation trades that people were talking about. It put a dent on gold, it put a dent on Bitcoin, it put a dent on the dollar, the dollar moving higher.
4:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I mean, I think the the relationship between real yields and gold is pretty well established. And obviously, if you have yields rising and inflation expectations are keeping up with it, real yields are going to creep up and that's going to put pressure on gold. But some of the other assets, it might not be as clear to to viewers how how what's happening with the bond market is is playing out of those other assets. So how how directly is it is it playing out, say, in equity markets?
5:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, so you know, this whole it's the DCF stupid thing that I started because of holder's shape. It's I I think it has some some merit. What I would say is actually the framework that I'm looking at in terms of where it has merit is it goes like this. It's that when you look at long dated assets like equities, basically what you're looking at is a discounted cash flows. And if the discount factor is greater, everything else equal, the near term present value of the present value of those assets is less. So the question is, is when does that matter?
5:54 Speaker 02 Because we've been, I would say, in the midst of a speculative mania, a reflationary mania where multiples are expanding. But at some point in time, the DCF matters. And what we're seeing is is we're approaching those levels right now. So a part of it is not necessarily level, but also step change in the level, meaning that perhaps it's not just that we're moving to 120, 125, 130 potentially on the 10 year. It's really that the 10 year yield went up so abruptly that it really put a shock into the system and caused people to readjust their expectations about discount factors and it wound back the whole reflationary trade.
6:41 Speaker 00 Well, before there was the reflation trade, there was the rotation trade. And that was the rotation from the high-flying growth names into the dogs that were lagging. And these were value stocks and stocks that generally would benefit in an environment where yields are rising, where the yield curve is steepening and where growth is no longer scarce. So are you saying here that, yes, that is true, that those stocks tend to do better in those periods, but they're already at valuations that are lofty because of the low rates and because of the DCF? And so that although, you know, maybe in other periods of time where we see the steepening, maybe we're heading into a period of higher growth, it doesn't matter because they're already so frothy
7:23 Speaker 00 and that the DCF is actually outweighing this sort of cyclical rotation that would happen in these types of periods?
7:32 Speaker 02 You know, value, I think, is just taking a pause by and large. I wouldn't necessarily say that value certainly is frothy. I mean, the froth is on the other side with the Tesla's of the world, even with the Fang stocks of the world. I would look at a chart that you and I were looking at literally right before we came on, the commodities chart that the economist posted on commodity prices from January of 2000 to today as being representative of the kind of action, the price action that you're seeing in equities. So if you look at what's going on there, you basically see that there has been a reflation of commodities across the board with iron ore in particular going up the most.
8:17 Speaker 02 But interestingly, the commodities all did relatively well in that first period from January through April when we had the shutdown. Oil is the one that collapsed. And so even though oil has gone up at the same amount, it's lagged the others in terms of it's going up. So you could look at equities as, okay, we rotated into these plays. Now we're looking for other plays to take advantage of. The same thing is probably true in commodities, that, you know, people got into copper early. Copper's run up, but maybe there's still some juice left in oil and oil-related stocks.
9:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, and that's why you're seeing some of the flows dynamics playing out with XLE ETF. I saw two sources actually talking about this. Chris Sidle was saying that there's some real flows moving into XLE and should this continue, it would put some real legs behind the rotation trade. And then as well, there was an article from Zero Hedge talking about a similar dynamic and the potential for a gamma squeeze. So there is a little bit of positioning behind that narrative. I want to switch, though, to those discrete outcomes that you hinted at before. What do you think are the discrete outcomes? And what is the current situation in terms of where we're headed most likely? Or at least the trajectory we're on?
9:41 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I think this is where you and I, we had the best back and forth about what does this mean? The three outcomes that I'm thinking about are, one, outcome number one, which is the trajectory that we were on before we pulled back. And that is a steepening yield curve before we reach the post-vaccine stage. By and large, everyone's thinking that we're going through a dark winter, that we're going through a fallow period, we just lost 100 and some thousand jobs. And that could potentially continue into the new year. But people are looking through that into mid-year, into the fall. And that's when good things are going to happen.
10:25 Speaker 02 But we're getting the steepening now, well before that happens. And that's not necessarily a good scenario. So that's scenario number one. Scenario number two is where we continue to flatline. We backed off the 119 level. The last I saw, we were at like 106. Two days of good auctions, you back up five basis points, you back up another six basis points, and now suddenly you're back in action to where you were before. Maybe we flatlined for a very long period of time. 119, it was just a phantom move. And we get to nirvana, post-vaccine nirvana, and then the yield curve steepens. That is a really bullish move because that's where the reflation should be. That tells you...
11:10 Speaker 02 The move is up because now we're getting this pent up demand, people are coming back, they're buying stuff. The third scenario is that actually what's happened, the move to 119 was premature. The reflation trade actually was somewhat premature and the yield curve re-flattens. And we get a flattening of the yield curve because this dark period, the light before the end of the tunnel, the tunnel gets longer and it has much more of a negative impact. And you know, that that third scenario is sort of representative of the, when I talked to Jack, I was telling him I was looking at three different bond proxies.
11:52 Speaker 02 One was HYG versus, you know, the ETF for investment grade bonds. This is a proxy for that. If we see a bad scenario where you see the yield curve flattening, then you would expect to see more defaults and therefore you would expect to see spreads go up. But then there are other, there are two other things. One is I'm looking for TIPS versus Treasuries and that's where you get to see what the real yields are looking like. And then finally, it's just the overall rate of the 10-year. You know, what's happening with the overall rate, what's happening with inflation, and then what's happening with credit?
12:37 Speaker 00 Okay, so you know, you you kind of said scenario three is potentially a bad scenario and scenario one is potentially a bad scenario. Scenario three sounds to me like a return to, you know, growth is scarce, the the yield curve is incredibly flat and that benefits the, you know, the high growth FAANG names that were the darlings before this rotation trade kicked off. Is that the outcome for assets that you think would occur in that in that scenario?
13:06 Speaker 02 I think, you know, we're going back to that scenario, but the difference is we're going back to it after we've already seen, you know, cracks. And so then, you know, we're in a new paradigm, so to speak. We don't know whether or not we're going to go back to the nirvana of FAANG doing really well and all these other stocks doing well in that same way. It may well be that people then realize, oh, wait a minute, things are different now. We need to, we need to price accordingly. But it's the, it's the scenario that's most similar to the, to the earlier world that we were living in, in say, September, October timeframe.
13:46 Speaker 00 Okay, and then as well in scenario one, you, you said that's also potentially a dangerous scenario because the market is getting ahead of itself. So is that just creating a scenario really for the transition from one to three? That, that's the risk is that we skip two and go from one to three? And that's why you think one is really also potentially a dangerous scenario?
14:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I think one leads to two. That is, the, the real problem with one is both the level of rates, but also potentially the rate of increase as well as the, you know, the real rates. Because what's happening now, or what did happen when we got to 119 in the 10-year is that real rates were going up. Rates were going up quickly, real rates were going up quickly. And it, and the reflationary trade as a result completely unwound because the toggle being rates went down into the dollar and the nexus of the dollar started to unwind everything else.
14:48 Speaker 02 So we had real rates going up, the dollar being more attractive as a result of that. A sell-off in gold, a sell-off in Bitcoin as a result of that, a sell-off in some commodities. And all of that started to unwind. And if, if, if that were to happen in greater measure, then you could potentially get a, a serious credit event and, and that would be very negative.
15:16 Speaker 00 Interestingly though, not oil. Oil didn't really participate in that sell-off and that goes back to that chart that you showed, which has oil as, as the laggard of the reflation assets.
15:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I think that is interesting. And also, if you look at oil, I think it's also interesting to look at where the kink in the line is on that chart. I think that, you know, oil went up. The rate of change started to roll over and then there was a re-acceleration around just before the November election. So right in that range, October, November, we, you know, the rate of change started to steepen a little bit. People potentially were believing in the oil store. It's not just necessarily supply and demand. They were believing in the reflation trade as manifest in that kink.
16:08 Speaker 00 Okay, well, I think now is the time to give you or something to, you know, pay attention to, to see which scenario really plays out. So you talked about the level of yields, but you also talked about the rate of change of yields. So what are the sort of key levels and the speed that people need to be paying attention to, to determine which one of these three discrete outcomes we're really trending towards?
16:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, and you're actually harkening back to a question that I asked Peter Bookvar yesterday, and we were talking about that. The question to him was, what level do you have to get to before this whole nirvana falls apart? And he was already saying, you know, we're really close, you know, 120, 125, et cetera. I'm starting to tend towards the view that it's not just the level per se, but rather that it is also the rate of change. So if you get to 125 in a heartbeat from 100, that's a different story than if you
17:09 Speaker 02 get to 125 from 100 over a longer extended period of time. So where we are now, where we've retraced back to 106, I think that, you know, legitimately, if we were to
17:24 Speaker 02 Go up quickly, you know, thirty, thirty-five basis points. That would be enough to trigger a sell-off in that whole reflation nexus. The absolute level that I would look at is one fifty. That's been my bogey for some time, is one point five in a ten-year. Irrespective of how you get there, I think that that's a number that will be difficult for markets to digest over the longer term.
17:49 Speaker 00 All right. Well, Ed, I know we're working you hard this week. You're going to be on RBDB every day, so I'm not going to take all your good ideas. I'll leave you a few for Thursday and Friday, and we'll end it there. But, you know, thank you for this. It gives us a lot to think about.
18:02 Speaker 02 Very good. And, you know, you had much less pushback here in our open forum than you had when we teased out the ideas a little bit right before we came on. But I think that you did a great job in sort of like, you know, peppering me. If there's anything else you want to pepper me with, any sort of doubts that you might have, speak now or forever hold your peace.
18:28 Speaker 00 I still have some thinking to do. I still have some thinking to do. And, yeah, you know, it's always nice to be able to push back in our private calls. But, you know, I put on the jacket, show the respect, you know. You got to do that, got to do that. So, all right, Ed, I'll talk to you soon.
18:44 Speaker 02 You bet.
Previous How Inflationary Risk Could Corner the Fed: DB- Jan12, 2021 Next Looking Forward at Interest Rates, the U.S. Dollar, Volatility, and the B117 Variant: DB-Jan15,2021 Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated