Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing What's Driving Down Oil Prices? About this episode 🚀 The Exponential Age is going to permanently change the world on every level, including your day-to-day life. Have it work in your favor - https://rvtv.io/3FAb8hjThe market rallies as investors look ahead to Wednesday's Fed meeting. Doomberg, the energy expert and editor of the Domberg Substack, joins Maggie Lake to discuss the geopolitical tension in the Middle East, its impact on oil, and how artificial intelligence will impact commodity markets. You can find more of Doomberg's excellent research here: https://doomberg.substack.comAnd don’t forget to check out the Exponentialist, Raoul Pal and David Mattin's new research service on how technology is reshaping our world and what the Exponential Age means for investors: https://www.realvision.com/thefutureUnlock the potential to showcase your brand to our global audience. Contact us at [email protected] for advertising inquiries. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 People are going to lose their minds. This is a moment in history unlike anything humanity's gone through. It's a very different world for humans to come.
0:07 Speaker 01 Take a step back and see the broad picture, which is the way all these technologies are interlinked.
0:13 Speaker 00 Because this is all about exponentiality, and humans can't think in exponential terms.
0:17 Speaker 01 How consequential do you want to say machine intelligence is? It's almost certainly as consequential as writing. How long did writing take to disseminate through the human population? You know, hundreds, thousands of years. And we're dealing with it now on a scale of months.
0:33 Speaker 00 But in this kind of world, you're compounding 100% growth every year, and the numbers become astronomical.
0:40 Speaker 01 AI is going to spot patterns in the world that were just completely invisible to us.
0:45 Speaker 00 Even if you think that the AI and the robots are your demise, you might as well bloody invest in them and make some money out of it. If not, you're just going to be angry man shaking your fists at the clouds.
1:09 Speaker 02 What's pushing oil prices lower? Hi, everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. With me today is Doomburg, author of the Doomburg Substack. Hi, Doomburg, welcome back.
1:19 Speaker 03 Maggie, great to be here. I see that you dressed appropriately for your occasion. I must say, I'm very, very humble, but you would think of me.
1:26 Speaker 02 It was subconscious. It was subconscious, but I must have had the green chicken in my mind, for sure.
1:31 Speaker 03 Either that or it's your Halloween costume.
1:32 Speaker 02 Yes, exactly.
1:36 Speaker 02 It is great to see you. So we're kicking off the, I mean, maybe we're both, we're both subconscious because we're reflecting the markets, right? We're kicking off the week with a big rally in US stocks. Steady Treasury yields and oil down about 3%, sitting right around $82 a barrel for WTI. As you look across the dynamics of the market, and they've been pretty volatile so far this, this autumn. There's been an awful lot going on. Just broadly, you know, what's top of mind for you when you look at the dynamics?
2:05 Speaker 03 So specifically when it comes to the price of oil, we think that for the moment at least, during periods of heightened geopolitical tension like we're experiencing at least, the price of oil is really the market's proxy for its bet on whether things are getting better or worse as it pertains to tail risks. And obviously with the terrible events that transpired in Israel and then I would say the rather limited response by Israel thus far compared to initial market fears that drove oil higher, the lack of spreading of conflict to Iran in particular, although we saw some headlines today that did give us a little bit of pause. But during such times, the market tends to be voting on whether or not things are getting
2:49 Speaker 03 better or worse and it would seem that the market at least believes that the situation is not going to spiral, at least not to the worst case scenarios that were initially feared in the aftermath of the horrible attacks by Hamas on Israel. Having said that, I would counter that heading into the Russia-Ukraine conflict, the market was sending very similar signals where it had probably underestimated the seriousness of Putin's intention. And so we shall see. During times like this, I think fundamentals are always important, but take a second row seat to geopolitical events on the ground. And for Western analysts looking from the outside, this is really kind of incredibly difficult to model.
3:34 Speaker 03 And so I certainly have no particular geopolitical expertise as it pertains to the decades-long Israeli-Palestinian question. And so we just have to watch and react like everybody else.
3:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a great point. And also an excellent point that it is very hard to model this and the market tends to run from one extreme to the other, you know, so it can change quickly. What is happening on the supply front with fundamentals? Because I think, okay, even if you're able to sort of say... You know, not the worst case scenario, at least for now, some of the worst fears sort of at least on hold. So you can take that, you know, out of the equation for the moment. But from a, from a fundamental point of view, we're still getting pretty strong numbers coming out of the US. What are the supply, what's the supply side of the equation look like? Are people looking at that and concerned about that? Or are they anticipating the fact
4:30 Speaker 02 that, you know, maybe that's going to slow down and that we will see demand start to move lower?
4:36 Speaker 03 I would say, sitting in the mid eighties for Brent in particular, is kind of the sweet spot for both sides. And I think, absent any geopolitical risk, I think both the Saudis and the, you know, OPEC plus in general, along with the major oil consuming countries, would be happy with a low volatile oil price range bound between 70 and 90. In those price regimes, producers can make good money, governments can fund their fiscal obligations, and the economy is not really thrown into much strain. These are the, you know, recession risks that typically comes when we see super spikes in the price of oil. So I think mid eighties
5:19 Speaker 03 is high historically. It's probably roughly three times the sort of multi-decade average price of oil back when such things were being actively managed versus the US dollar. And so it is important to remember that at $80 oil, there's a lot of people making a lot of money in the energy sector. Of course, the day-to-day movements of equities are always measured against forward expectations and not necessarily absolute values. And the changing market expectations relative to what they had previously thought are usually responsible for the ticks up and ticks down. I would say, supply in the US has remained more robust than some people had feared. And demand in China has remained more robust than some people had feared.
6:03 Speaker 03 And the market is kind of roughly balanced. Again, whenever I see the oil range bound between 70 and 90 like this, it tells you that supply and demand are roughly well matched. And I do think the swings we're seeing, you know, up $3, down $4, up $5. This is just headline risk manifested in the daily action.
6:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, and you are right that it's that sweet spot because, you know, certainly, especially when it comes to OPEC, we know all the producers like to see it there. What's this, what is the, on the supply side for the US, there were a lot of fears, a lot of headlines about the depleted SPR. Where's the supply coming from? And is it sustainable? Or is the US sort of vulnerable as we're entering this stage of the cycle for, to sort of be able to manage any geopolitical spike or spike that would come on the back of geopolitical events?
7:01 Speaker 03 The SPR has been drained to the point where it's unlikely to be a cap on oil prices going forward. But you have to remember that in its place, OPEC plus, and most specifically Russia and Saudi Arabia have artificially taken offline substantial production volume that could be brought back into the market on a moment's notice. And I think this is the next sort of cap of, capping pressure on the price of oil and might explain why we're range bound here. In fact, if the Saudis and the Russians hadn't decreased their supply, we'd probably be in the 50s or 60s. And so that's where we were certainly headed in the aftermath of Biden's political emptying of the SPR. And that's not a partisan statement.
7:46 Speaker 03 I think that's a perfectly objective analysis of what he did. There seems to be a few headlines around the desire to eventually maybe potentially refill some small portion of the SPR, but our view has always been that the SPR won't ever be refilled. And it's no longer really an issue that market participants need to ponder as they wonder which direction the price is going to go. And in fact, China has a very large and quite full strategic petroleum reserve of its own, and it has its own interests in maintaining a cap on oil prices. And we suspect that they would behave in ways that are far less transparent to market participants. And so there are two sort of caps to the price of oil, which is when it spiked up here
8:30 Speaker 03 recently to the mid 90s. You see it now again back down into the mid 80s, which is sort of that comfortable equilibrium price, if I may, or a phrase from physics, where both sides seem to be relatively happy. But the SPR was drained by roughly 50%. I think it was at 690 million barrels total, and it's now in the 350s range. But it's no longer thought, at least, that the US can actively deploy a million barrels a day of incremental supply to bring the price of oil under control, which it did quite successfully. That is actually a pretty fascinating data point, by the way. 1% of global supply is enough to knock 30% of the price of oil.
9:13 Speaker 03 That tells you just how inelastic the price is and how sensitive it is to such disruptions, which is why, again, back to the original question, we think that the price of oil today and the price of oil tomorrow and the price of oil on Wednesday and Thursday is really just a reflection of the market's belief about whether the situation in the Middle East is heating or cooling.
9:32 Speaker 02 That's so interesting. So you don't think that they'll refill it and you think, sort of, China will play that role now?
9:38 Speaker 03 Well, the US is a net energy exporter, so you have to remember that the SPR was constructed and filled at a time when the belief amongst the US political elite was that we had reached and long ago surpassed peak oil production in the US. And there's a piece that we've been contemplating for a while that would explain some of the fallacies of US foreign policy through that lens, where they underestimated the technological capabilities of the domestic energy producers and went about on various foreign adventures in search of reliable supply of oil. And of course, the revolution and the shale patch changed all of that.
10:21 Speaker 03 And so the US now, unlike when the SPR was conceived, constructed and filled, is a net energy exporter. Now, look, we have some flows that don't make sense because of some nuances in our refining capacity, especially when compared to the types of oil that are coming out of the shale patch versus the types of oil that were being refined when those refineries were originally constructed. But on balance, the US produces an enormous amount of energy. It is a net exporter of refined products. It still imports oil, but it also exports oil, again, to match refining nuances. But I just don't, it's very difficult for me to imagine a scenario where the Democrats who control the Senate
11:06 Speaker 03 and the White House are ever going to be in a position to what they would call subsidize the oil and gas industry by putting a put under the price of oil. And in fact, you only have to look when oil went negative, in the days after oil went negative and was trading in the low teens, President Trump tried to actually buy the lows. And he was gleefully overruled in the Senate by Chuck Schumer. And if we can't refill the SPR or top off the SPR, when oil is at $10 a barrel or $20 a barrel, there's no way we're going to do it at 75 or 80 or 90. And so I just don't see a world in which the Democrats have less than 40 votes in the Senate, and that this is going to be politically palatable.
11:49 Speaker 02 Hey, everyone. We're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
12:02 Speaker 02 So what is this, what is your feeling about how the energy component is going to factor into the Fed? Because they're looking for inflation to come down. From what you described, we might not see spiraling oil or a much higher oil price, but are we going to see a low enough oil price to take some of the, you know, the pressure off of the inflation scenario? How are you thinking about inflation here?
12:29 Speaker 03 I think on balance, oil is an inflation headwind for the Fed. I think the cost of incremental production is probably, Luke Roman would peg it at between 7% and 9% a year, which would explain some of the sustained inflationary pressures that the Fed is confronting. And in fact, there's an argument to be made that elevated interest rates only feed back into the energy sector because financing becomes more difficult to come by and more expensive, which then requires a higher price of oil for the incremental producer to make a reasonable return on capital. Now, there was a time when the stock market
13:09 Speaker 03 was rewarding growth above profits and people were willing to lever long and destroy value by producing excess oil in the name of growth, hoping to make it up on the sale of their equities. That time has long since passed, and so we shall see. But our view is that there's a sort of interesting contrarian view that elevated interest rates are in fact pro-inflationary because it acts as a form of fiscal stimulus. Obviously, the interest payments on new debt goes to people who are investors, of course, and maybe the velocity of that money is not quite as high as as direct handouts that we saw in the aftermath of the COVID lockdowns. But nonetheless, we are running huge fiscal deficits in large
13:53 Speaker 03 part because interest payments are approaching a trillion dollars. Well, that money ends up in the economy. It floats around. It ends up in your brokerage account if you hold T-bills and treasury bonds and so on, and it gets spent. And so we've never really raised interest rates at this rate with this much debt before. And so we are really running an uncontrolled experiment. But to your specific question, I think on balance, the technology developments in the oil sector are deflationary.
14:24 Speaker 03 But there's, you know, at reasonable prices, there's an infinite demand for a while. And so this is the constant tug of war that we see.
14:32 Speaker 02 By the way, on the point of debt, I every time see one of these headlines, it's always so shocking. There was one today, Treasury announced it's going to borrow 776 billion in the last three months of the year. That's lower than than than some of the forecasts. So there's actually some leap on that, but it just gives you an indication. They thought it was going to be north of a trillion, I think, or in the 800s, but in total, the high end of that. Well, it gives you a sense of where we are at this level of debt.
15:02 Speaker 03 Do the math. We have, what, 7 to 10 trillion coming due in the next year or two at 5% interest rates? I mean, if you just do 5% times 33 trillion, you could see what the run rate, if we had to refinance all of it would be. Then you look at the term structure of US debt and you see that we have this wall of refinancing it. It's very similar to sort of commercial real estate. Everybody knows that this is coming. This wall of refinancing and a famous Kyle Bass line, I think, well, at least I heard it from him, which is a rolling alone collects no loss, which is such a great, great way to say it. Everyone's going to extend and pretend, I suppose, but I don't know how you fund the US government
15:43 Speaker 03 with 33 trillion in debt and counting at 5% interest rates when interest rates are a greater expense than military expenditures. And Lord knows that we're going to be amping those up here as we enter various wars. And so it's truly a historic time.
16:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, it certainly is. We've got some good questions coming in. I just want to touch on a couple more things before we get to them. So don't do not fret. By the way, David Stiles says, hello, back from the Austin F1 race. Texans are burning a lot of oil. I'm sure that was awesome. I hope you enjoyed that, David. F1 certainly getting around to all these American cities, really trying to grow that brand here. So, Duneberg, when, I know you've been looking, you mentioned China and the SPR. I know you've been looking at what they're doing, the role they're playing in natural resources and how they're building it up and some of the advantages that they have.
16:41 Speaker 02 How do we need to be thinking about China in this space, especially when it comes to some of those critical minerals?
16:46 Speaker 03 We need to be thinking about China as an adversary. And we need to admit that we're in an economic war with China. And we just put out a piece which raised a few eyebrows called geopolitical warfare, where we talk about our commodity producers.
17:00 Speaker 03 Forget about innovation and so on. The number one driver of cost is the answer to one simple question. How much are you allowed to pollute? And in the Western world, we have correctly implemented expensive pollution controls because we like to live in a society where the water is clean and you can breathe the air and you don't have to wipe dark stuff off your face when you walk outside because there's, you know, the PM 2.5 number is 250 that day. Having been to China several times in my career and having competed against Chinese state-owned enterprises, we have said on several podcast appearances that when your competitor's idea of a water treatment plant is a pipeline to the river, no American company can beat on cost.
17:43 Speaker 03 And commodities are price takers. You know, commodity producers are price takers. And so if there is a series of industries that we feel we need to have domestically, then we need to recognize that the Chinese are competing unfairly and we need to subsidize those industries, pay them to implement the pollution controls that we find acceptable and offset the competitive disadvantage that they find themselves in. Because otherwise, what happens is what we see happening. The Chinese effectively illegally subsidize their domestic producers by allowing them to pollute. They degrade their local environment in exchange for geopolitical power and then they spend that geopolitical power aggressively. The latest example is their moves against graphite exports, which is going to cripple much of the electric vehicle space.
18:29 Speaker 03 I don't believe the market has fully digested the seriousness of this move. Perhaps they're underestimating whether or not China will follow through on it. We would argue, having seen this rodeo many times, that this bull is trying to buck us off. And they will probably follow through on it. But it's the same if you look at gallium, if you look at germanium, if you look at the whole solar industry, if you look at battery materials. Whatever China decides is strategic.
18:54 Speaker 03 And happens to be environmentally taxing to produce, they put us out of business. I've been put out of business by China in my career. I've seen how Western procurement teams will ignore what China is doing. They'll steal intellectual property, they'll pollute, anything to put Western companies out of business and get a chokehold. 100% of the rare earths produced in the world are processed by China. Why? Processing rare earths is incredibly environmentally damaging, if done poorly. It's expensive to do it in an environmentally friendly way. We should measure the difference between how we would do it here and how China's doing it and pay those companies to implement those pollution controls because we view the domestic
19:39 Speaker 03 manufacturing sector to be a national security issue. Look, there's three things that the market fails to properly address when it comes to energy. Energy is different than downstream high-value manufacturing. There, once you have abundant energy, the free market is in fact the most powerful force. But when it comes to energy and closely related industries, there are three market failures. One, environmental degradation is underpriced. It just is. Left to their own devices, companies will pollute for short-term profit and they will leave the problems they create for future generations to handle. That's just simply undeniable and anybody who thinks otherwise is either naive or never worked in industry. And we should just know that and we should accept that as an axiom.
20:22 Speaker 03 The second is, energy is different than the other sectors. The GDP measurement of energy is particularly terrible measure of its geopolitical importance. And we saw this when Russia invaded Ukraine and various Western analysts were saying, "Oh, Russia's economy is tiny on a GDP basis and they have no power." That is a terrible measure of their geopolitical power. It just is. Like, energy is life and if you control energy, then you control everything. And then the third thing that is not properly priced is the national security implications of allowing a geopolitical enemy to monopolize certain choke points. And we've done that. The military is caught off guard because of decades of Wall Street-driven financialization and driving these industries offshore.
21:07 Speaker 03 And we all know it's a problem, so we put out a piece trying at least to propose a set of solutions, which is, one... Decide which industries we need to have domestically or in the hands of trusted allies. Two, identify most effective technology for the production of those materials. And then three, support those companies that are willing to do it. It's a lot cheaper than what we're doing with the Inflation Reduction Act. I mean, it is very straightforward.
21:34 Speaker 02 We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
21:45 Speaker 02 So we have this fight for critical minerals on the one hand. And then, you know, you just brought up this issue of technology. And I don't know that they're always contrary, but in some instances, there's this, you know, arms race for minerals. And then you have the tech revolution, which some say is going to change all of the rules. I want to play a clip from a conversation that Raul had with Jordi Visser, who had some thoughts on this, and then we'll talk on the other side.
22:13 Speaker 04 So we were worried about not having enough food. We have too much food based on obesity. We may not have enough food for the rest of the globe, but we've wasted so much food that I believe aside from the solutions through nano and through getting to having resistant crops and all the things you said, which are innovation, which are happening, we're going to get through the efficiency side and the productivity side. We're going to eliminate waste. And if you think about what happened with fracking, you can divine it as many ways as you want, but we went from inefficient searching for oil in the ocean. And I can just remember when Petrobras was in the middle and it was like to find it. And we were planting flags at the bottom of the Arctic Ocean to try and find oil because
22:58 Speaker 04 we were running out. And then we had fracking, which is really about efficiency and the ability of getting this on. So I just think people underestimate when it comes to commodities that when you argue that we're going to have more people and we're going to run out of them, I think we've wasted an enormous amount and AI is going to help us be more efficient, but it's also going to come up with other solutions.
23:19 Speaker 02 And that entire conversation is available on our website. If you are joining us on YouTube and you are not a full Real Vision member, hit the link, jump on a trial and come find out what you're missing. So Dumar, it's so interesting to think about this. So do we have to sort of? Think about technology and maybe not against this argument of scarcity because that is what drives commodities or certainly a lot of energy is that supply versus demand. Is this going to be a game changer? Or how are you thinking about that?
23:51 Speaker 03 So we would broadly be in the camp of techno optimists. We think the market has difficulty modeling exponential growth. And in that way, we would agree that the latest developments, for example, in artificial intelligence, but broadly in computer, supercomputer power and modeling have indeed fed an exponential growth explosion in our capacity to more efficiently procure such materials at reasonable prices. We would, we're researching a piece on Singularity is Near. You know, this book is published almost 20 years ago now.
24:32 Speaker 03 It's incredible. But Ray Kurzweil's book, which is everybody who's sort of ended up in science reads at some point in their careers, made some pretty amazing predictions. And we're going to go back and look at them and then talk about how the main driver for us in looking at that piece, in fact, is that we believe that the energy needs to feed the computers that are doing all of this AI compute is going to potentially normalize nuclear energy again because SMRs, small modular reactors, represent the most viable way to power all of this. And we have this belief, unsubstantiated hypothesis, conjecture, that humans will organize around feeding this ever increasing desire
25:14 Speaker 03 to power more and more computers. And we should just take that as an axiom and then measure the market accordingly. I'm sure somebody else has a fancier name that they've already thought about this and applied to it. But
25:27 Speaker 03 With respect to the oil and gas companies, I think the market routinely and radically underestimates the intellectual horsepower embedded in these companies. I mean, having grown up in that space, I can tell you that there are thousands and thousands and thousands of brilliant PhDs and engineers and technologists working every day to make the miracles of modern life happen. And when the sanctions were rolled out against Russia and we were objecting to them and explaining why they would fail, one of the things we pointed out is there's 10,000 engineers a day being cranked out of Chinese universities in the petroleum sector, far more than we're producing, and India and the IIT universities of the world,
26:10 Speaker 03 and Fudan and the great schools in Asia that we'd never even think about are producing all these brilliant people that are going to Russia and are going to help them keep these commodities online. And I think we, you and I maybe even talked about Zihan last time I was on and his sort of techno pessimism in this space. We would be firmly in the camp that humans will successfully figure out how to extract more and more energy out of the ground in ever more efficient ways. And betting against the innovation potential of humanity has been a losing trade since The Limits to Growth was published in the 1970s, and we expect very little to change in the decades ahead.
26:49 Speaker 02 Amazing. I have a much more pedestrian way of looking at it, but I feel like the sci-fi guys are always right. If you read any, right? It's like, they've always been, that's always been their assertion and it continues to prove out. Okay, let's get to some of these questions. So, just on that point, what's your view on uranium after the recent rally? I mean, it sounds like long-term, you just kind of painted a very bullish long-term picture.
27:13 Speaker 03 Sure. You know, our mutual friend Tony Greer likes to say, when you have runs like this, it's okay to participate. We aren't in uranium, we have no position, it's been in a pretty good run. The bull case is always there, especially near the top. If it were me, you know, again, not investment advice, I would probably be harvesting a few gains here and waiting and seeing how things go forward from here.
27:35 Speaker 02 Yeah. What, let's see, Gee Blackburn, Doomburg subscriber here. Hey, Doomi, why is decarbonization the goal? Isn't there still room for debate on that?
27:49 Speaker 03 I don't remember making that the goal. But we have a bit of a nuanced view on decarbonization, which is it need. We call it the ultimate trade-off equation. And we just produced a an hour-long presentation for our approach here this morning called King Doomburg, what we would do if we were in charge of U.S. energy policy. And the ultimate trade-off equation, in our view, is net energy produced in the numerator divided by some combination of pollution and emissions in the denominator. And as soon as you understand that there's a trade-off, that energy is life, more is better, more is geopolitical power, more is a higher standard of living, and we have to recognize the environmental costs at the same time, then you can have an intelligent conversation about sensible trade-offs.
28:31 Speaker 03 In his view, perhaps carbon emissions are the least damaging trade-off we can make. Others would disagree. But in our view, framing the discussion to measure the trade-offs is a win, because right now, as it is presented, fossil fuels can do no good and only do harm, and renewables can do no harm and only do good. And neither of those things are true.
28:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, I feel like the conversation is moving further along to recognize that that more nuanced transition, but there's still a lot of room to go. Both Paul and Ralph are asking about your thoughts on the direction of nat gas.
29:09 Speaker 03 Well, nat gas is, of course, subject to geopolitical whims, and in particular subject to the weather. I checked in on the weather in Western Europe just this morning, and it seems to be trending slightly above average, which is good. Dutch TTF is probably up 60, 70% off the lows, but that is still a fraction of where it was at the apex of the energy crisis last year. U.S. natural gas is just a function of LNG demand at this point. We produce so much of it that we can't give it away. Just to benchmark you, at $3 per million BTU natural gas in the U.S., which is where Henry Hub is last time I checked, I could be wrong by 10 or 20%, that's the equivalent of $18 to $20 a barrel oil on an energy content basis.
29:54 Speaker 03 We are giving away. One of the cleanest fossil fuels that we can produce because we just have too much of it. And one of the main drivers of this is the associated natural gas that comes out of the production in the Permian Basin, which is still the greatest source of growth in the oil markets in the world. And so as long as we have the stranded natural gas in the U.S., it's going to be difficult to normalize prices. At $16 million BTU, Dutch TTF, that's basically energy parity with oil. And because there's some switching capabilities, I think in Europe, that price makes sense. Coal at $130 a ton, all of these prices are not screaming crisis, they're screaming relatively well-balanced markets.
30:38 Speaker 02 And let's squeeze one more in. Philip asking, will Venezuela's breaking of Biden deal on free elections by banning the opposition cause Biden to not allow their oil sales?
30:51 Speaker 03 I would take the over on the amount of oil that Biden lets into the country. As we wrote in a recent piece, you know, Venezuelan oil is the type of oil that the current fleet of U.S. refineries were built to process. And that explains why it is that we're kind of bending over backwards to get this deal done. It makes a lot more sense once you sort of understand the molecular nature of what's transpiring. And so we wrote this piece called Molecular Tourism on September 20th that went into this in pretty good detail. At its apex, Venezuela was importing upwards of 1.5 million barrels a day into
31:34 Speaker 03 the U.S., which by comparison is more than we were draining from the SPR. And so with the SPR no longer being a tool for President Biden, I think the heavy grades of Venezuelan crude look pretty attractive. And I would also say probably makes him regret killing the Keystone Pipeline, which would have brought similar grades of crude from Canada directly to the refineries that are best able to process it.
32:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, fantastic point. Duneberg, great conversation. We've been getting a lot of questions on energy, so it was just so fantastic to have you on today and get into this a little bit with you. We appreciate it.
32:13 Speaker 03 Anytime, Meg. It's always a pleasure.
32:15 Speaker 02 Fantastic. And of course, all of the full reports are on Duneberg Substack. Thanks so much for all your smart questions. Love it. We will see you again tomorrow. And don't forget, there's a town hall for members happening. I think it might be for everyone, but I'll check on that. But certainly, if you have any issues, questions about any of the things we've been unveiling lately, we're going to go over it, Ral and I, all on Wednesday. So make sure you watch for the time of that. In the meantime, take care and good luck out there, everybody.
32:40 Speaker 00 People are going to lose their minds. This is a moment in history unlike anything humanity's gone through. It's a very different world for humans to come.
32:48 Speaker 01 Take a step back and see the broad picture, which is the way all these technologies are interlinked.
32:54 Speaker 00 Because this is all about exponentiality, and humans can't think in exponential terms.
32:59 Speaker 01 How consequential do you want to say machine intelligence is? It's almost certainly as consequential as writing. How long did writing take to disseminate through the human population? You know, hundreds, thousands of years, and we're dealing with it now on a scale of months.
33:14 Speaker 00 But in this kind of world, you're compounding 100% growth every year, and the numbers become astronomical.
33:21 Speaker 01 AI is going to spot patterns in the world that were just completely invisible to us.
33:26 Speaker 00 Even if you think that the AI and the robots are your demise, you might as well bloody invest in them and make some money out of it. If not, you're just going to be angry man shaking your fists at the clouds.
Previous Peter Zeihan on the Israel-Hamas War Next Is the Fed About to Spook the Markets? Page updated October 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated