Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Update from Raoul on the Dollar, Rates, Growth, and Crypto. About this episode DB-April9,2021: Real Vision CEO and co-founder Raoul Pal joins senior editor Ash Bennington to make sense of a market in flux and share opportunities on his radar. Raoul updates his macro views on the dollar, interest rates, and economic growth before he discusses new developments in the crypto world such as the IPO of Coinbase as well as the U. S. listing of Galaxy Digital. Raoul also shares his latest views on ARK Innovation ETFs as part of his belief in durable secular trends driven by technology that abide by Metcalfe’s Law. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:12 Speaker 00 Happy Friday, everyone. Welcome to Real Vision Daily Briefing. I'm Ash Bennington, live without a net with our CEO and co-founder, Raoul Pal. Raul, welcome.
0:20 Speaker 01 I didn't realize we were live. I would have put makeup on and had big hair.
0:26 Speaker 00 Break out the hairdryer, Raul. It's time to go live.
0:29 Speaker 01 I'm ready. Let's do it.
0:31 Speaker 00 So, Raul, we were talking a little bit off camera. What's on your mind? Interesting time in markets?
0:38 Speaker 01 It's interesting, not interesting, right? Basically, the macro sphere, it's absolutely dull as dishwater. Nothing's really going anywhere. Bomb markets correcting a bit, the dollar's kind of gone up a bit, but not doing a lot, and the equity market's grinding high. So, there's not a lot going on, but beneath the scene, we had something very interesting, and I would take it as a unique signal. I've been warning about the excessive leverage in the financial system, and I know that Weston on the Real Vision Exchange has been talking about this, and he's doing a piece on it. Something very interesting happened, which was Archegos blowing up. It's a story of excess leverage and hubris and the usual financial market stuff that we've all grown up with.
1:22 Speaker 01 But if you remember, I'd isolated the issues of the leverage within the system and how it was layered with option market makers, record short gamma, all of these traders, record long options, you know, record low cash, record high hedge fund exposure, all of that. So, we have a massive event that basically wipes out something like 10 to 12 billion of money off the investment banks who take it on the chin. And nothing happened.
1:55 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:56 Speaker 01 The markets didn't go anywhere, volatility didn't move. As retail investors have started going back to work, the call buying from stimuluses don't seem to be applying. So the leverage is slowly coming out. My guess is some of the hedge funds degrossed in this environment. So we've got into a slightly less risky situation than we were. And that's fascinating. People are pretty fully invested in markets. I'm not saying that's gone, but we had the bar shock and it was a big one. I mean, Robin Hood and all of that, none of that blew up $12 billion worth of money off the prime booking balance sheets. But this did and nothing happened. So it makes me think that the market is much more robust than people are imagining.
2:41 Speaker 01 And, you know, it always concerns people to say that, but to me it looks bulletproof. And it looks bulletproof from another angle is, and I've talked about this at length is once you adjust the S and P or the NASDAQ or any of these assets by and change the denominator to the Fed balance sheet as opposed to the US dollar. So I, the S and P divided by the Fed balance sheet. That takes into account the excess printing or the debasement of fiat currency. And what we found at the S and P in 2008 collapsed about 80% in balance sheet terms. And then traded sideways for the next 12 years.
3:25 Speaker 01 And it tells me that the markets aren't wildly expensive. When I look at the S and P versus gold or the S and P versus real estate or real estate versus the S and P. They all are in normal valuations. So something else is going on. I think that what it's telling us is any expansion of the Fed balance sheet is a devaluation of fiat currency. It's not the mechanism that most people thought that Fed printing equals more money leaking out of banks into the markets because volumes don't show that. What it's actually showing is the denominator is going down. And so therefore, once you adjust for that, these markets, I think, have a lot further they can run because we're only going to see more balance sheet expansion from these fiscal policies.
4:08 Speaker 01 If bond yields go up too much and we have yield curve control, then they're going to buy the bonds, which is more balance sheet expansion. If the stock market falls, they're going to do more QE, more balance sheet expansion. So we've got balance sheet expansion in a normal scenario, balance sheet expansion in a fall in the equity market, balance sheet expansion in a reflationary trade where bond yields go up. That only tells you markets are going up.
4:36 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:37 Speaker 01 I know people would like to hear that, but they're going up. And they're going up because the value of the denominator is falling. So to explain that a bit clearer, the Venezuelan stock market looks like this in Bolivar. When you adjust it for US dollars, it looks like this because the Bolivar went down in value. So we're seeing something similar to that. And it's a lot to get people's heads around. I'll probably do a whole big piece on it over the weekend that I'll put out next week. But that's what's going on.
5:07 Speaker 00 So, yeah.
5:08 Speaker 01 There's nothing going on in markets, but there's everything going on.
5:10 Speaker 00 Well, you know, it's so interesting because it's counterintuitive to people, especially if they're new to the macro space. You know, effectively, the too long didn't read version is if the economy improves, stocks are going to go up. If the economy goes down or stays stagnant, there's going to be Fed action and policy action coordinated globally and stocks are going to go up. That's hard for people to get their head around, Ralph.
5:34 Speaker 01 Oh, God, yes. It's very difficult. And so this is why valuations don't make sense. And again, I've divided much of the valuation stuff by the Fed balance sheet and everything makes sense. Everything looks normal when you do it. There's a, it's going to take a while to get people's heads around what I'm talking about. I have written about it in Macro Insiders. I will put something out on Real Vision just to show people what I'm talking about when you talk about the change in the denominator. But the too long didn't read is it's almost impossible for stocks to go down except a small, you know, a sharp spike. And if nobody learned any lessons from what just happened, then nobody's paying attention.
6:16 Speaker 01 We had the biggest economic recession the world has ever seen at one point.
6:24 Speaker 01 And the markets fell like a stone for a month and rallied then on. And everyone's like, why? This makes no sense to me. Of course, it makes no sense. It's because we're looking at everything wrong. So I think it's a really, really important. This is why Bitcoin goes up. It's because it's the inverse of the Fed balance sheet and more. It's a really, really important thing for people to understand.
6:50 Speaker 00 Yeah. And of course Ethereum too, up over 2000 as we have this conversation here today.
6:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's up over 175% this year. You know, there's network effects and a lot going on. And again, I'll do a whole piece on this, a long, deep dive in my thinking. Cause I've got a lot of extended thinking I want to get across to people to try and bring people up on the knowledge journey of where I've got to in my overall thought process. Cause it's changing a lot. You know, I'm even changing the global macro investor, I've not kind of wheeled it out yet. Changing the potential hypothesis for my entire investment framework. Just as an aside, a lot of people hit me up and say, you know, what happened to the insolvency phase? And that's a great question. The insolvency phase, if you remember, was the final phase of a recession where we're left with a bunch of companies and or people who basically can't pay their bills.
7:40 Speaker 01 Because there's a lot of debt out there and economic growth have vaporized.
7:45 Speaker 01 Well, what we saw was the largest ever central bank and government combined response in all recorded history.
7:52 Speaker 00 Right.
7:52 Speaker 01 And what we've created is a bunch of zombies. So the stimulus payments are zombie payments to keep people alive until their jobs kick in. We don't know what the structural unemployment is going to be from all of the people in retail jobs, et cetera. We are doing the same with corporations too. If, interestingly, I used to talk about those triple B entities and the chance of them going tits up in this recession because of cash flow. Well, divide the price of GE by the Fed balance sheet. It's basically a zero. It's a zombie. It's only the denominator that makes it look not like a zombie. The same with most of these, AT&T, any of these, they just look like they're zeros.
8:36 Speaker 01 There's a very different world, you see it, and that's the insolvency, it's there, but it's hidden by the excess printing of money. So I think this economic recovery probably takes longer than most people imagine because there is a lot of insolvency and impairment of balance sheets. But other parts are just going to keep exploding higher. So it's going to be a really complicated world, but I think it's a world where equities go higher.
9:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a lot to get people's heads around, especially if they're new to the space. And interestingly enough, those two stories intersect, the things we were talking about at the beginning. So you've got this money illusion with price and US equities. And simultaneously, you have this breakdown at Archegos, Archegos, the family office that nobody knows how to pronounce. And nothing happens, silence, deafening, all because of the intervention that we see.
9:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, again, step back, you're dead right. So we have one of the largest blowups of recent times
9:37 Speaker 01 in terms of this Archegos, and nothing happened.
9:41 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:41 Speaker 01 We have the largest recession of all recorded history, as far as we can tell, and nothing happened.
9:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:49 Speaker 01 So either we're not looking at it right, or something has changed. And, you know, we should all be asking ourselves these questions. The intellectual honest answer is not, well, you know, the Fed have just stopped a recession, they're just making it worse. Maybe everything is wrong that we assume. And I don't know what that even means. So I'm not, well, I do have a lot of answers, but I'm not prepared to present them yet until I more robustly test them. But I think we're looking at it wrong. And that's all I can really explain at the moment.
10:23 Speaker 00 Well, you know, another really fascinating point, and you and I were just talking about this off camera before we started the show. This sounds in many ways when we hear about the Archegos story. It sounds like an Asian story. Obviously, Mr. Huang was born in Korea. He was involved in Asian funds. There were a lot of Asian stocks involved in this. But Mr. Huang lives directly across the river, right there in New Jersey. This is not a story that takes place somewhere else. This is a story right here, based on Wall Street.
10:52 Speaker 01 It's also a story of family offices and the shift of power on Wall Street. So I know internally, the big salespeople, the guys who get paid the big bucks at Goldman, or the big investment of JP Morgan, that shifts around depending where the action is, where the real money is. You know, I was lucky to be in part of that sphere when it was the hedge fund salespeople. We were the big swinging dicks. We were the guys who got paid the most. We had all the glory. We could spend the wine on our customers. That's all changed. That changed about seven years ago, and it went to family offices. So the people who are getting paid the big bucks as salesmen now are people selling to family offices. Because family offices are lucrative.
11:36 Speaker 01 They use a wide range of services, and they tend to be less price sensitive than hedge funds who have huge staff to beat down every single price. So they're very attractive, high-margin customers because there's everything from nice juicy lending businesses through to securities businesses. They tend to buy a lot of more expensive derivative products, all sorts of stuff.
12:01 Speaker 01 But in order to capture them, when that race is on, investment banks always do the same thing, which is start offering ridiculous incentives. I first started hearing about non-recourse loans about seven years ago, that non-recourse loans are being offered to family offices, basically just giving them free money on the understanding that they spent that free money within the investment bank. I mean, friends of mine bought houses on non-recourse loans from Swiss investment banks. I'm like, really? So what that means to the average person is you don't have to pay them back. It's like the money your dad lends you. You kind of never have to pay it back. And the idea was for them to spray that money around and it would multiply across the investment bank.
12:45 Speaker 01 And I think the Archegos story is going to be about that. Hidden beneath it is the perverse incentives of investment bank salespeople and leverage. And the more leverage you can offer, and this was the same story of long-term capital.
13:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:02 Speaker 01 We as salespeople, and I was one of those people, would put on obscene leverage at ridiculous rates because they did so much business. And our job was kind of to turn a blind eye because we got paid on how much business we did. But in the end, we all did too much business. And the story for me with that is I was on a nineteen ninety-eight, summer ninety-eight, I'm on a fishing boat at a mate's stag in Kilkenny in southern Ireland. And I'm on a boat with a whole group of friends of mine, we all happen to work in financial markets. And I spoke to a mate of mine who's at Salomon. I'm like, who's your biggest customer? And he's like, long-term capital. He was in equity derivatives. I said, how much have you got?
13:46 Speaker 01 He's like, probably about a couple of billion dollars worth in equity derivatives. I said, what about you? And there's another mate of mine, and he was, I think it was a JP Morgan, and he was in equity derivatives. I said, what have you got? Biggest customer, long-term capital, by a country mile. How much have you got? I don't know, two or three billion? I'm like, okay, so that's now already larger than their entire fund. Because at the time, they were like three billion dollars, I can't remember. So then I'm like, huh. Then a friend of mine was head of Bund trading at Deutsche Bank. I'm like, Justin, how much have you got? He's like, twenty billion. Whatever the number was, right? Like ten times, because fixed income markets are less volatile, so you can have more leverage.
14:30 Speaker 00 Right.
14:31 Speaker 01 And then I'm like, okay, and I was at NatWest, and I'm like, we've probably got four billion just in equity derivatives, proving obviously that I was a better salesman than my friends, because I'd done more business. And then, realising with horror that this was a house of cards, I went back to the office on the Monday and went to see our head of risk and said, we've got a huge problem here.
14:54 Speaker 01 I think we managed to get out of it without any losses, actually. I can't remember how we unwound it or how we reduced some of the risk, but we didn't really. We didn't really get hit, but a lot of people did. Obviously, by 1998, I mean, everybody blew up in that. I've got a just did a great masterclass interview about this with uh with um Mike Varanos, who runs Ellington, is one of 10 billion dollar legend of the hedge fund industry, structured finance. He blew up in in 98 because of long term capital and when leverage gets pulled. But leverage didn't get pulled last week.
15:30 Speaker 00 Right. But it's all those same forces, Ralph. Listen to the
15:34 Speaker 01 It's it's exactly the same, right?
15:36 Speaker 00 Right.
15:37 Speaker 01 Finance people, we have shorter attention spans and and, you know, fat wallets. So, you know, everyone wants to get paid and it's the same way. Banks only get paid from leverage and number of transactions. That's it. There's no other way of getting paid. So we're always incentivized to do the same thing.
15:53 Speaker 00 Leverage, principal agency conflict, multiple banks exposed to the same large exogenous shock from the buy side.
16:00 Speaker 01 And we all do this. I can't hear you. Sorry. You haven't got any positions, have you? No, we haven't either. Because no salesman wants to miss out and no risk manager doesn't want to allow the business to happen. Nobody wants to get fired by the big boss. Why aren't you doing business with that family office? They're all getting rich. I mean, we've all been there.
16:20 Speaker 00 Absolutely. And it's amazing to me also how rarely this comes up in the academic literature around this. This principal agency conflict between the sales guys and the house. I remember many years ago, working at a bank, I won't name it, and mentioning a product to to someone. And and the guy looked at me like I'd just gotten off the turnip truck and he said, the YTB is too low. I said, what the hell is the YTB? And he said, yield to broker. And he walked away, right? I mean, this extent to which this is driven by individuals making decisions that are in their own economic self-interest, always, always a factor.
16:56 Speaker 01 But that's all businesses. All business is the same, right? It's either high up margin, high volume. There's very few businesses in the world that are high volume, high margin. Those become massive. When I was first at Goldman, we used to charge a premium because we were Goldman Sachs and we're snobbish and we're a partnership. And we do high volume. That was great. Then Deutsche Bank came in, kind of completely changed the economics. And Lehman, and so we all went to Low margin, high volumes.
17:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:24 Speaker 01 And always the search was the high margin product and it ended up in 2008 being CLOs and all of that stuff, right?
17:33 Speaker 00 And by the way, none of those deals we've gotten done at Goldman were still a partnership.
17:38 Speaker 01 No, of course not.
17:39 Speaker 00 Shit.
17:39 Speaker 01 So CBS, all of this stuff.
17:43 Speaker 01 Because they were high margin, but over time they've become low margin because everybody goes into them. That's an interesting story. So John Goodfriend. There was an interview with him, I think in about 2010. So he retired years ago, right? It's one of the most legendary Chairman of Solomon, one of the most legendary traders in the history of Wall Street. And there was an interview with John Goodfriend, I don't know how old he was at the interview, but 80 or something. And somebody took him out and he said, I haven't given an interview for a long time. But I just want to say, I'm sorry. I think some of this, maybe all of this is my fault. And I'm like, John, how can that be? You've not been active, you've not been involved. He said,
18:25 Speaker 01 it all started when I made the decision to turn to make Solomon a public company. He said, when we moved away from being a partnership, everybody followed. And when everybody followed, we stopped taking partners' risk and we had unlimited risk. And that was what led to this amount of leverage. It could never have happened before. And I think that's true, you know, the Goldman partnership model, all of that.
18:52 Speaker 01 So fascinating, but it's all the same. Every business is the same. Either high margin, low volume, high volume, low margin. And as a salesperson, the easiest way to sell the highest margin project he can in the largest size until it blows up.
19:09 Speaker 00 And it all, and it all did start at Solomon Brothers, of course.
19:12 Speaker 01 Your downside is you lose your job. Your upside is a call option. It's phenomenal.
19:18 Speaker 00 Right.
19:20 Speaker 00 It's a twisted incentive structure and we joke about it.
19:25 Speaker 01 But every sales shop is the same. Just because we're dealing with money, everything gets a little spicier when you're just dealing with money. It's like the reason why the network effects of Bitcoin and crypto is so large is because it's money. Humans get funny around money. It's like the ring. It's like my precious in Lord of the Rings. People get all kind of, it's money. They become obsessed.
19:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. And then you add leverage to the system, right?
19:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's just a way of making more of that precious money. It's hilarious. We're humans. It's what we do.
20:03 Speaker 00 You know, Ralph, I don't know if you had a chance to see, but earlier today I did a live with Harry Krishnan, talking about some of these issues, about price instability, about the regime shifts that we see when normal markets turn into routes, talking about the book that Harry and I are writing together called Market Tremors, which is all about this topic.
20:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's super interesting. I can't wait to see what that book's about and how the story plays out.
20:32 Speaker 00 Yeah. It's good to partner with someone who's much smarter than you are. That's my.
20:36 Speaker 01 That's always the rule of thumb. Somebody's uglier than you, but smarter generally works.
20:44 Speaker 01 The other things that are interesting that should be on people's radar screens, Coinbase, everyone knows about it, everyone's had the story, blah, blah, blah.
20:54 Speaker 01 Coinbase has 56 million accounts. If I checked right, Robin Hood is about 13 million accounts.
21:03 Speaker 00 Yep.
21:05 Speaker 01 Four times the size. It's the size of Fidelity and Robin Hood added together. If people don't understand the magnitude of this crypto thing that's going on, look no further. And people say, yeah, but it's a bubble. That's why. And I'll say, no, it's network effects. That's why. The more people come into it, the more important it becomes. But it's extraordinary to see that. It's extraordinary to see. I just double checked, you know? One of my great mistakes was recommending to macro insiders, customers, clients to buy Galaxy at.
21:42 Speaker 01 I can't remember what it was, about three dollars or something, and it went up like a hundred percent in a month. So I sold it, patted myself on the back. Galaxy, last time I checked, is up three, two thousand nine hundred percent in a year.
21:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:59 Speaker 01 Two thousand nine hundred percent. That's an equity listed in Canada. That is a crypto play and their earnings are exploding with it. So that that's been a very interesting thing I've been watching.
22:12 Speaker 00 I just saw the numbers. Q four comprehensive net income at Galaxy excluding non controlling interest up eleven hundred and seventy five percent. Q four per Tanzil Octar CoinDesk.
22:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, this is big stuff going on. People still are not going to get it. Talking of not getting it, the other story amused me greatly. And again, I'll reveal it more in due course. My change of framework, but I'm very interested in Kathy Wood's Ark Invest.
22:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:45 Speaker 01 A very interesting for two reasons. One is everybody hates it. Every old man railing at the internet is Kathy Wood. She, she, her funds, they double dip, they're, they're, they're, they're, they've got the same investments. She's got illiquid things and it's criminal and those, it's all going to blow up and it's all going to go wrong. She owns Tesla. She's an idiot. Her price target's wrong. She doesn't understand what she's doing. This is a narrative that is pervasive.
23:21 Speaker 01 I, I'm interested when I hear a narrative like that because I've talked to Kathy and she's very smart, very rational.
23:30 Speaker 01 And then, so I started looking at what she's doing.
23:34 Speaker 01 And her investment themes, I believe, are absolutely spot on. I think she is so far ahead of understanding the exponential world that we are in and moving in towards. That most people don't understand. People don't like to see a fund manager outperform everybody else by that order of magnitude.
23:59 Speaker 01 It must be a bubble, said in mixes of small caps and big caps. You know, it's criminal, it's fraud, there's something. No, she, I would say, I'm guessing that, and it could fall a bit further from here, no real issue with where it goes in the short term. But my view is, I think this thing is going to go up another 20x from here, maybe even 50x. If, if my hypothesis is right, that basically almost every one of her themes is spot on. Um, because none of these are valuation based businesses that use traditional valuations. All of them are based on Metcalfe's law. And my bit, understanding of Bitcoin has got me a big understanding of some of the huge changes
24:43 Speaker 01 that are actually taking place in the world. And I'm not going to go through it in, in huge detail. But to Ark Invest, keep it on people's radar screens. You might hate it, question why you hate it. Do you hate its success? Are you going to blame how it's constructed? Have you actually gone and asked other fund managers why they have a price target on their AT&T stock and their assumptions? No, you're doing it because of jealousy of Kathy Wood's performance and that she has outrageous price targets and they've been right.
25:13 Speaker 00 Question why you hate it is great advice for anything new that you don't understand.
25:21 Speaker 01 But it is dead true, you know, because we all, you know, I've been questioning why I never ever got Amazon right. You know, can't you see it's got a P of 800, which is what it traded most of the 2000s in?
25:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
25:39 Speaker 01 Well, can't you see it's, it sells, it's worth more than every book sold on earth every year? It's worth more than all the booksellers added together. Guess what? It was never a book company.
25:50 Speaker 00 Right.
25:50 Speaker 01 It was a network adoption business and none of us saw it. Some, few people did. And in fact, the only person who actually made money of owning Amazon all this time was Jeff Bezos, because he, only he could see really what he was doing. Which is, that's why these network effects opportunities are hard. Facebook's been the same. Yeah, Facebook has another chance of creating another whole network effect, which is. It's got VR and anybody who's seen the Pierce kicks video and understands the meta metaverse understands that VR is not a small thing. This is a huge future. It is also launching DM, which is basically a crypto payment rails, a stablecoin payment
26:34 Speaker 01 rails across the largest network on earth. Those two things give it a gigantic quantum leap into where the future of the world is going, which is the digital universe. So is there a chance that Facebook is undervalued? I hate Facebook as a company for its privacy reasons, and I thought that they run out of network effect because of Facebook itself and WhatsApp seeming to have peeking out and and Instagram the same. But if they get this next bet right, this thing's off to the races again.
27:14 Speaker 00 Yeah.
27:15 Speaker 01 It's all network effects all over again. Because if you can bring all the digital global shopping transactions and wallets on the Facebook network, you've just exponentially increased the network value. People don't understand this yet. And I'm only trying to get my head around it.
27:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, the new Oculus VR headset, pretty impressive piece of hardware as well.
27:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, anybody who's picked up an Oculus, put it on, turn it on, you you're in a room and it's gorgeous. And it's the moment you put that thing on, forget the games, and you sit, look around this room and you're like, wow, I'd like to live here. You realize everything's changed.
27:55 Speaker 00 Well, I want to live in your house.
27:58 Speaker 01 You don't. I've got builders in and my mom is there. She's been over. She's been over. She went through quarantine and she's been staying with us. So we got we got the mom, I got mom, we've got people redoing the garden and a bunch of builders. You don't want to be in my house.
28:14 Speaker 00 I hope she's down on the beach at least a few steps away.
28:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, she's not too far. She's been on the beach.
28:19 Speaker 00 By the way, we should say, just so we don't sound like we're completely engaged in euphoric thinking here, talking about Amazon, which is a great metaphor to understand the broad scope of the way we think about.
28:29 Speaker 01 Why are you apologizing? Interesting. Stop. Why are you apologizing for euphoric thinking? Why? The question is, and I know this, you're a mean reversionist, as is most of us.
28:42 Speaker 00 I'm not.
28:43 Speaker 01 No, hold on. This time. Can't be different because it gives everybody the fear to say it's going up. Because everybody doesn't want to be told, well, see, it was expensive, you idiot, you bought. It's a really interesting thing and I wasn't calling you out, but I see this all the time.
29:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:04 Speaker 01 And I do it is a terrible fear of having an opinion about upside. It's very comfortable for everybody to say, well, stock market's overvalued, that any day now, this can collapse. That's accepted universally.
29:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:20 Speaker 01 As he's being smart and acknowledging the downside.
29:26 Speaker 01 But if you say, like Cathy would, I think Tesla's going to three thousand, they say you're an idiot. Fascinating, just what observe that and the clarification statements that people make around. Euphoria, euphoria. Really interesting.
29:47 Speaker 00 Well, it's such a fascinating point, Rowan, I think you're spot on with this because I think that if you look at the general trend, if you look at technology. We understand and we've now seen over the last twenty years, the enormous gains in productivity, efficiency. Uh, and the changes, the massive changes to the world that technology has created. But the interesting thing is if you look at, if you look at Amazon, which is, I think in many ways, a great metaphor for the way we think about the, the technology. Uh, that we're looking at today, whether it's on the digital asset side, uh, or on the equity side, which is that Amazon had a max drawdown. I think about ninety-three percent was the highest max draw.
30:26 Speaker 01 So this is another thing that I've, I'm trying to rethink the world, you know, when the facts change, I change and. I've been very slow to change because I hadn't realized it. There is a narrative. The narrative is, well, two thousand was a stock market bubble and we all learned the hard way.
30:47 Speaker 01 No, it wasn't. It was a minor blip on an exponential chart of the internet.
30:58 Speaker 01 Anybody who did nothing over that period of time but held on
31:03 Speaker 01 has made a fortune. And yes, somebody's going to go, yeah, but Oracle or whatever stock XYZ stock never made it back to the high. The market did. So if you'd held the NASDAQ, it was a blip. And I've learnt that now with Bitcoin as well, is that exponential trends, these little F's curve bumps are bumps. So that 90% fall in Amazon was irrelevant. So now what's interesting is I know exactly what's going on through the heads of 75% of the people watching this as we speak. They're going to be going, you know, the top's in, right? You know, the top's in. Look at Raul, he's getting all balled up. The top's in. It's going to collapse any day now.
31:45 Speaker 01 The market's going to go down 2% over the next week and they go, see, that idiot, he called the top. That is mean reversionist thinking. It's fascinating. But over time, it's proven that all of these trends are exponential and they're not linear. There's many linear things. Any value stock you want to choose, that's a linear trend. Nothing wrong with value, but you won't make as much money as an exponential trend.
32:11 Speaker 00 Right. So how do you reconcile those two positions, Raul? How do you think about it? How do you think about time horizons? How do you think about risk tolerance? And how do you think about this in a way that allows you to protect against the downside? But participate in what is clearly a massive shift?
32:28 Speaker 01 I don't know yet because I've not been investing in it. I've, you know, crypto is the better bet right now. But there'll be a time when that will change. And I've realised, I wrote this on Twitter some time ago, if I had my time again, I'd just invest in network effect
32:45 Speaker 01 opportunities. It's far better. It's far better. Because you basically get a higher concentration of returns over a shorter period of time in that strategy than you do in, let's say, the concentrated returns that you get out of macro, out of macro shocks. It's just a better use of capital over time. Now, can you overlay the two together and capture macro shocks and exponential effects? I think you can, and I think that's what Stan Druckenmiller is doing as well. If I think back about his technology investment and how the world's changed, he basically runs a core long tech and then macro hedge that he over levers in down cycles and that's what's protecting him. I kind of like that as a strategy.
33:30 Speaker 01 Um, I just don't know what the macro shock is anymore because the problem is, is I don't think they're going to let the dollar go anywhere and I don't think rates are going anywhere. So what's the macro?
33:40 Speaker 01 Macro is equity. There's nothing left to trade.
33:44 Speaker 01 If, if, if the dollar and rates are kind of range bound because so say the central banks, then equity is the game. And equity can't go down because of the mechanism we talked about at the beginning.
33:58 Speaker 00 Right.
33:58 Speaker 01 If equity goes down, central bank prints fascinating scudrus reward. And I know people go, well, you figure this out now, wouldn't you tell us in March last year when you closed out your shorts on the low, you should have gone record long. Yeah, I'm an idiot. I'll take that on the chin all day. But it's, I'm actually not talking about, you know, the next 10% or 15%. I'm talking about
34:21 Speaker 01 opportunities and not just with stock markets in general, not that interested in the stock market. I'm interested in a lot of sectors that will, that will exhibit this kind of trend. And the best of all, obviously is crypto.
34:33 Speaker 00 Yeah. By the way, talking about the tech bubble, the alleged tech bubble, which now we see as the technology has matured, the processes have come into place. Oracle took out its 2000 high in 2017. Looks like it's up about 80% there from 2000. So 17 years, but far above its high.
34:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, but the compound average return is not great.
34:57 Speaker 00 Not great, yeah.
34:58 Speaker 01 The market overall has done absolutely fine. And some of these have done, have been some of the best performing stocks in all recorded history.
35:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
35:08 Speaker 01 You know, I, I looked at Microsoft, Microsoft's a fascinating company because it's had two, it's had an S curve and had, had two network effect adoption cycles. One was obviously software, PC software.
35:20 Speaker 00 Yep.
35:20 Speaker 01 And then it peaked out as a company. And, you know, the Steve Baumier years kind of, it was like going nowhere. And then change of CEO. Cloud, gaming.
35:33 Speaker 00 Yeah.
35:33 Speaker 01 And you've got two new exponential adoption curves because both of those became went from small things to very, very big things. And Microsoft captured both of them and a few more in between.
35:49 Speaker 00 Microsoft is a fascinating story because they missed the internet and they missed cloud and then they managed to get back in both of those games and and absolutely crushed it.
35:59 Speaker 01 Well, they didn't really get the internet, so they missed that whole bit. As I said, that 2000 to about 2000 and whenever the whenever they changed CEO, let's say 2014, 15, I can't remember the exact time.
36:12 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:12 Speaker 01 Dead money because they had no strategy, they missed it. And then they figured out cloud and they went massively into that and they figured out gaming, which was, you know, not as big. And then they had that they're obviously their core software business and it's like, oh, my God, you get a company that big and you get to reinvent yourself again. Astonishing, astonishing story.
36:35 Speaker 00 Yeah. Yeah. One of the great, one of the great comeback stories in American industry and certainly in tech history.
36:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, without question. Amazing. Like the Apple comeback was as well.
36:46 Speaker 00 Indeed. Just to shift gears here a little bit to talk about Janet Yellen's remarks to the IMF. I know this is also something that you've been looking about on the macro side.
36:58 Speaker 01 So remember I put out that video called the Bitcoin life raft because the IMF have started putting statements out about a new Bretton Woods.
37:07 Speaker 01 And I had conjecture that within the new Bretton Woods, it was something to do with maybe stabilizing exchange rates, maybe agreeing on a a
37:21 Speaker 01 combined fiscal stimulus.
37:25 Speaker 01 And Janet Yellen came out this week talking about Bretton Woods and talking about the IMF meeting she's going to, which was an interesting turn of phrase. And she was talking about a global minimum corporate tax rate, because everybody needs to raise taxes, which is another very important thing. So another important mega trend that's coming. So she talks about the new Bretton Woods, clearly part of it is going to be the US pushing for a tax rate. My guess is other countries are going to pushing for dollar stability and maybe this
38:01 Speaker 01 idea of a of a currency block. I think that's on the table. And I think that a combined cohesive fiscal stimulus that's coordinated is also on offer. Let's wait and see, but it feels like these are fourth turning moments when truly big things are up for grabs. Whether that happens this time around, doesn't matter. What it means is it's being talked about. And these are really big things, like the central bank digital currencies. These are gigantic changes to the system, fourth turning system.
38:43 Speaker 00 Yeah. How do you even begin to think about the framework around such a monumental shift in the baseline for how the global economy functions? That's a that's a hard thing to even conceptualize.
38:58 Speaker 01 Yeah. There's a great example of this is in, I think it's New Market Wizards, the interview with Stan Druckenmiller and trying to figure out what happens to the German currency, the German stock market and German rates on reunification of Germany. It's really difficult to figure out. And the market took the wrong bet and Stan figured it out and got it right and made a fortune from it. It's really hard. We will see because the market will tell us. But what it's also going to offer is opportunities and complexities. So fascinating time, you know, as a macro thinker, you don't get anything better than this. You
39:37 Speaker 01 don't get massive structural changes where we're not just talking about, oh, there's too much leverage in the world. We kind of all know that shit now. We all know about the demographic crisis, but we've got.
39:52 Speaker 01 Huge changes of which we don't even understand the magnitude and that's really, really interesting to me. Because when you change the, when you're not just changing the secular cycle, but you're changing the cyclical aspect, but you're changing the secular story, that's when macro gets really interesting because you could be early and being early in secular stuff is where you make the big, big bucks.
40:17 Speaker 00 Yeah. I know we've got a lot of activity coming in from our subscribers, from the audience, people who want to get some questions answered. We'll start out with this one.
40:26 Speaker 01 How many of them are saying, it must be the top?
40:31 Speaker 00 I see, I see one on that, on that topic. Ralph, if you capitulate on equities, could this mean the top is in? Seriously? Thank you as always.
40:46 Speaker 00 Here's another one coming to us from Viv. How much reading slash analysis does Ralph do to be so in sync with everything around the world? I'm blown away with his knowledge and especially with his ability to explain things.
41:02 Speaker 01 You know, I don't know. It's weird. I don't, I'm not the guy who's reading every article. You know, if you'll send me an article, I'll skim read it. But I'm a guy who keeps narratives in his head visually and I see them. I can't explain it. It's all like a 3D jigsaw puzzle that I see and I absorb bits of information, whether it's price action on Bloomberg, or it's observable behavior, people hating Kathy Wood, or it's my own hypothesis that I'm clinging on to that feels now like it's been disproven, or it's something else, or it's a snippet of conversation. So I'm not one who reads people's analysis. I have no interest in it. You know, I'm actually paid to do my own analysis for people. So
41:44 Speaker 01 I need to think more than anything else. And it's only really when I get time to think that I get time to really get more, to get better at quality ideas. So thinking is more important than reading. But you need to have a broad exposure that you can stop teasing together. Why was that headline there? What did that mean? How did that happen? What could that all be? Maybe it's nothing. I'll just park it over here, come back to it three years later. That's what I do.
42:14 Speaker 00 Yeah. I find the longer I do this, the more I try to restrict the amount of time I spend reading the news.
42:22 Speaker 01 Yes, I skim read the FT because it is useful and I'm starting to even skim Twitter less because I'm finding less value. There's too much noise and not enough signal.
42:37 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a great question from Sergio, which ties into everything we've been talking about here, which is how do you spot nascent network effects? So when these are just rolling up, how do you spot it at the beginning of the S-curve?
42:51 Speaker 01 You can't. At that point, it's a guess. It's true, right? Every token right now that's operating a new amazing protocol that could be the future, you do not know. So that is the hard part. And some people are good at that, and I'm not. I can guess that the whole space is going like that. I have no idea which ones, but some people be great at that. You know, many friends of mine are making 100X in all of these smaller tokens because they really understand the technology and the early adoption phase. You know, Andras and Horowitz are phenomenally good at that. I'm just not. So the answer is I don't know. If you know, let me find out. But really, I think that requires detailed analysis of
43:35 Speaker 01 individual opportunities and a conviction and an understanding that you can be wrong. So it's a sizing and time horizon issue. You know, you need to size those bets small while you can size Amazon pretty big if you think Amazon's network effect continues.
43:51 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a kind of a narrow question. I can take this one or you can, or it's up to you. Jared, is Bitcoin in cold storage the new cash on the sidelines?
44:04 Speaker 00 Great question.
44:05 Speaker 01 No, because it never gets spent. There is, I've been thinking this through about Bitcoin, and one of the problems of the potential outcomes of Bitcoin being money is it's too deflationary. And everyone's like, oh, we want deflationary currency. It makes our savings go up. Problem is, it makes the value of everything else go down as a denominator. Right. So you are incentivized never to spend your money because everything is cheaper tomorrow.
44:41 Speaker 01 If it's very deflationary, then you've got a huge problem because why spend on anything? Why invest any corporate capital? Why do anything at all? So it's interesting. So I don't think it is cash on the sidelines, but it's a problem because there's going to be more and more of that cash. Because right now you get an 8% yield if you put it in Tether or 3% or 2% in Bitcoin. And why bother putting it into anything else? As I said, Bitcoin's eating the world right now. It's the supermassive black hole that outperforms everything. So there's no point putting it anywhere else.
45:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, this is such a key point about deflation. This is one of the interesting things that has yet to shake out, which is the store of value function versus the medium of exchange function. Really very much an open question. Specifically, and I'll give a little bit more narrow answer to Jared's question, which is, is the cash in cold wallets? The new cash on the sidelines? We don't know. I think what's interesting about Bitcoin is that we haven't had enough time, obviously, to observe all these correlations yet. But these on-chain metrics give us the ability to see things, not just with Bitcoin, but across the digital asset universe at a far more detailed and granular level than we've ever had before. So when we start to look at this, it's going to be really interesting to see how those correlations do play into other metrics.
46:03 Speaker 01 And then imagine what it's like when we've got central bank digital currencies. Imagine the granularity of economic understanding in real time that we will have. It's extraordinary. Talk about game changing. It's totally mind blowing, the kind of information we will have with digital currencies.
46:23 Speaker 00 And the ability to respond in real time.
46:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's astonishing. People don't understand any of this yet.
46:31 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a question, it's a macro question that comes to us from Hugh. Any thoughts as far as this short-term blip in inflation? Will it be a blip or will it be something that's more problematic in the longer term?
46:45 Speaker 01 Julian and I had a long, Julian Brigden and myself, who both write Macro Insiders, had a big debate about this on the Insiders Talks this week.
46:54 Speaker 01 I'm a deflationist, he's an inflationist.
46:57 Speaker 01 We don't know. My view is, my view is, this is a blip. And supply comes back on market as the economies open up. So the supply restrictions ease off, technology, globalization and the ongoing pressures continue to crush inflation over time and the economy won't be as strong as expected. Flip side of that is more stimulus is coming. You know, maybe, maybe fiscal stimulus spending on infrastructure is more inflationary. Maybe wages get spread higher and maybe it gets out of control. That is the other argument. I have no idea, but why do we care right now? Why we, why we used to care is because it drove bonds.
47:41 Speaker 01 That was the old world. Bond yields go up above 2%, the Fed's buying them, so they're not going there. And if, if interest rates get down to 0%, the Fed's doing anything else it can do to avoid it. So you've got 2% range in bonds. So why do we care about the inflation narrative? We should be thinking about the demand narrative. If commodities is your play, is there real demand or is this pricing pressure? You know, is it going to wipe out the future expected return of tech stocks if inflation goes up? My guess is not, because we've noticed the, how tech stocks have actually outperformed the Fed balance sheet. They've actually ended up being a place that outperforms inflation too.
48:24 Speaker 01 So it's not the discounted model, it's the, it's the, it's the quality, it's the quality of the earnings that matter to people right now. So, don't know, not sure it matters as much. Yes, it matters to savings and what you do with it. But I think most people have adjusted for that already. I don't think many people are sitting with all their savings in cash. I think many people have got exposure in gold, Bitcoin, commodities, real estate.
48:49 Speaker 00 Yeah. As we get sort of close to the end here, I know we're about to get yelled at for running over time, Ralph, as we always do. I should say, if you have a moment and you'd like to hit the subscribe button on YouTube, if you're watching on the platform, we appreciate that so we can get more of this information out to you. We enjoy doing this and it's fun to do it live. As always, it's super fun, obviously, to get questions from the audience and to have this interactive dialogue across the world.
49:15 Speaker 01 Give us one more question, just because we can, and it'll annoy Nick.
49:21 Speaker 00 Let's see. Oh, this is a really interesting one. Comes to us from Mike. What are your thoughts on residential and commercial real estate in this macro environment? A really interesting question with the shifts we've seen with COVID.
49:32 Speaker 01 So, real estate, if you divide the Schiller, Case Schiller index by the Fed balance sheet, has basically been trading sideways. So, real estate's been doing its job. It's kind of offsetting the devaluation of money. So, at a basic core level, it's fine. It's not doing anything amazing. There are structural shifts with commercial real estate. I've no idea how this is going to play out. I can't imagine us going back into our offices in Manhattan in the same way that we were.
50:00 Speaker 00 Do we still have an office in Manhattan, Ralph?
50:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, we're still paying a fortune for it, I bet, because we can't get out of a bloody lease till October, but...
50:08 Speaker 00 You're the only person who goes in, it's right.
50:10 Speaker 01 Max.
50:10 Speaker 00 Max.
50:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, he's the only person, the one, the office over sprawling over two floors. He's probably living in that apartment, the old studio, the old Keith Richards apartment. He's probably living there. We don't even know, right?
50:22 Speaker 00 Probably, maybe. He does his, like, his Zoom calls, like, our internal Zoom calls from, like, the boardroom.
50:28 Speaker 01 He's probably just moved in there. It's got free rent on this huge apartment in, you know, in Midtown. He's a smart kid. He's going somewhere. So, yeah, so I don't really know with the real estate question. I think, you know, I'm looking here at the Cayman Islands and everything is being sold off Zoom to Canadians, Brits, and Americans, particularly Canadians. Sight unseen on Zoom, $5 million apartments are trading in an hour. Why? Because...
50:59 Speaker 01 Taxes. So there's a story here.
51:03 Speaker 00 Yeah.
51:03 Speaker 01 Miami, same story. Different tax regime, but similar. It's trading. What's happening is clearly a lot of millennials have moved out of the city in New York and other cities and they've got more space. But my guess is you'll end up lowering the rent enough to attract other people back into the city. So it comes, it changes over time. Real estate is not a market I fully understand investing in. I don't see any particular problems for the asset class per se, but ever it's all about stock picking, you know, which market you buy, which market you sell.
51:38 Speaker 00 By the way, top tax rate, New York State, combined federal, state and local, going up to fifty two percent.
51:45 Speaker 01 And the top tax rate in the Cayman Islands, last time I checked was zero.
51:52 Speaker 01 Well, but we do pay like thirty percent import duty. Yeah, as I've said before, the supermarkets, like shopping at fucking Harrods here, it's so expensive. You know, it's a lettuce, some eggs, you know, can of coke and, you know, a pack of La Croix water and it's like eight hundred bucks. It's ridiculous.
52:13 Speaker 00 And of course, Americans pay taxes abroad, wherever they are. So less of an incentive than for Brits and Canadians.
52:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's right. And that's why here staffed by South Africans and ex-British Commonwealth countries, because they have the same legal and taxation Commonwealth law rules. So that's why that applies. But that's why, you know, different markets have different drivers to them.
52:36 Speaker 01 And so, you know, they're all nuanced. So you need to understand your own market. So there's no broad brush.
52:40 Speaker 00 Yeah. Ralph, final thoughts in the, in the weeks to come, what are you going to be watching to give some of the folks who are listening to this conversation, a dashboard of things to think about and look at?
52:54 Speaker 01 Bitcoin?
52:57 Speaker 01 Full stop. You know, I keep bleating on about it. It's all I care about. The crypto market, that is the best bet in the world still. It is where it is outperforming everything by a massive margin. There is nothing close. There is almost no point putting my attention span into any other thing. Now, I don't do that because I'm a macro guy and I want to keep aware because things will change and shift. And I say this flippantly, but this is the opportunity and it remains the opportunity. But other things to look at, you know, you might want to keep ARC on your radar screen. I don't think it's a story for right now, so I'm not that fussed about it. You know, I'm always interested in India because that is also going through the digital revolution. But it's not the
53:41 Speaker 01 time for it now. I don't see the time. It's not the time for it now is the answer to everything except crypto.
53:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, you know, I made a major life decision a few months ago that I am focusing on right now. I am coding again. And I'm thinking very seriously about doing an Ethereum development certification because I'm fascinated by it. And I want to actually understand this at the mechanical nuts and bolts level. And the deeper I get in, the more it sucks me down. Fascinating stuff.
54:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, I just want to understand it on my P and L.
54:12 Speaker 00 Right. I don't think we can improve upon that as an exit.
54:16 Speaker 01 And again, I'm being flippant. I actually care about this whole space a lot. But you know, it's good to be given opportunities. And yeah, that's I've been telling everybody, pounding the drum is this is the opportunity that you've all been waiting for your whole lives. And it's still in play. And the opportunity is not going away. And it's not going away just because we might finish the cycle at the end of this year. It's not going away because regulators, it's not going away from quantum computers, not going away because of green energy. It's not going away. It's getting bigger. There's another 100x from this whole space to come over the next 10 to 20 years. 100x.
54:53 Speaker 00 And we're going to be here to cover it.
54:55 Speaker 01 We are indeed.
54:57 Speaker 00 Ralph, thanks for joining us.
54:59 Speaker 01 Good. Have a good weekend, everybody. Enjoy yourselves and think Bitcoin.
55:04 Speaker 00 Thanks for watching, everyone.
Previous The Roaring Twenties:Inflation, Equity Melt-Ups, and Extreme Bond Pain ( w/ Jared Dillian ) Next Felix Zulauf's Outlook on Equities, Bonds, Currencies, and Commodities (w/Raoul Pal) Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated