Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Understanding the Macro Landscape and Market Narratives with Raoul Pal, Julian Brigden, and Roger Hirst About this episode 🔥 Ledger x RV: The Next Digital Assets Wave. Get Your FREE Ticket https://rvtv.io/3rPaoBzJulian Bridgen, co-founder of MI2 Partners, and Raoul Pal, co-founder and CEO of Real Vision, share the latest updates to their macro frameworks. This discussion was originally part of September's monthly Insider Talks for Pro Macro members. Then, in a snippet from a recent RVIP event in London, we’ll hear Roger Hirst discuss how investors can better understand the many competing narratives at play in markets today. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:24 Speaker 01 Hi everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. Today, we're going to do something a little bit different. As many of you know, we're in the middle of our two-day Festival of Learning, the next digital assets wave. The event is happening over on our website. Now, I know a lot of you were there with us today. There were some great conversations. If you missed out, you can still join us tomorrow. It's free. Just go to realvision.com/festival23 to sign up. Now, while we're busy wrapping on day one, we are going to unlock some content that is usually reserved for Real Vision members. In the first conversation, Raul and Julian Brigden talk about the heightened market volatility, what's causing it, and how investors can navigate it and maybe even profit from
1:09 Speaker 01 it. As you can probably guess, the two of them don't exactly see eye to eye.
1:13 Speaker 02 There are certain themes that resonate with me. We've been in the, we refer to as accelerative oscillations camp. So, we believe that the cycles and the markets are moving to this period where they will become increasingly unstable. So, I'm definitively in that camp. That definitionally pushes you towards more active management. It ain't easy, though, right? If you think you're going to catch every single one right, you're wrong because you will not because something will catch you out in this. This is a very dangerous period, we think, we're entering. In terms of the dollar, I haven't seen Luke's
1:57 Speaker 02 piece, so I'd have to go and see exactly where he's coming from. But I am and have been in the structurally bearish camp in fixed income, in treasury market. I think we are moving increasingly to, probably not this year, but we've already seen it arguably, I think, in the UK with the LDI situation. We're moving to a point where we are going to test The ability of global markets to absorb the amount of issuance that's coming.
2:31 Speaker 02 This is kind of referred to as technically as the fiscal limit. I think we are pushing our luck in terms of moving into a period that they refer to as fiscal dominance. It's not necessarily a bad thing, it's just very different from the monetary dominance that we've had up to now. And basically, which of the two levers controls inflation and controls the economy? Both can't, right? One has to be dominant, the other one has to be subservient to that.
3:04 Speaker 02 But I do think fiscal dominance is dangerous because it relies on the competency of politicians and the willingness of politicians or the ability of politicians to do things. It frequently occurs when you are moving to a period which demands collective policy response, right? This was what dominated the economic cycle or the nature of economic control from like 1933 to 1951. So right the way through the Second World War, it's how we funded ourselves, right? The Fed played second fiddle to what policymakers were doing in terms of fighting the war.
3:49 Speaker 02 I think we're fighting arguably three wars.
3:53 Speaker 02 Climate change war, kinetic war with Russia, Cold War with China. I mean, you could call it a demographic war as well, a fourth. All of them demand shitloads of fiscal spending. And I think it's going to be very, very hard for policymakers to step back from that. And I think it's going to drive changes to markets which we haven't seen yet. So I'm actually really structurally bearish fixed income, I think, for the next.
4:25 Speaker 02 Twenty years, the trend is up in rates. I know that Raoul had, you had that conversation with Minack about this and he's sort of in that camp too recently.
4:40 Speaker 02 Look, don't give it us, doesn't mean it's a linear one-way move, right? When you get your recession, bond yields will rally, but you'd sell the rally, you don't, you don't buy the dip.
4:51 Speaker 02 And I think that's kind of where I am. So I have a lot of sympathy that where we stand exactly right here, right now, we can go into. But I think these are very dangerous times.
5:05 Speaker 03 Raoul, what are you, what are you thinking on all this?
5:07 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone, we're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
5:20 Speaker 04 Look, there is a lot of complexity around because of the ability of the market to digest the amount of issuance that needs to happen. And the more rates go up, the more issuance has to happen. And that cycle is not a good cycle. My personal opinion of this is the Fed are very aware of it. It's just why they've been funding at the shorter end of the market and letting the reverse repo take the strain. You know, you've seen the Fed net liquidity has actually not gone anywhere, which is quite interesting considering. So the Fed are issuing at three months. Why are they doing that mainly? And from what I can tell is if they're issuing at three months, it note, they know that they have to bring down the long end. So they can issue further out the curve. So that they, their normal funding cycle is three to five years. So to do that,
6:04 Speaker 04 I think they want to undershoot on inflation. So I think their aim is to undershoot inflation and overshoot on unemployment. So I, you see both those dials moving and that gives them the cover that they need to get rates lower, to ease the amount of issuance that needs to take place and potentially monetize it. Considering that next year is obviously an election year as well. So I, I don't think things have changed.
6:31 Speaker 04 I think we are later in the cycle because the inflation pulse from, from, from post pandemic was so big that they have to kind of let that play through. And I think it will play through. So my, my idea is that this doesn't change. It actually, I'm with Rosenberg's camp that there is a recession out there. And it's probably Q4, Q1, but you know, my view has been that it's been priced in. So I'm very much and have been in the it's a boom camp. And don't forget, you know, we've had rates this high and the Nasdaq's up forty two percent this year. That tells you something. There's some informational value there, much like there's informational value in the bond market, bond yields at this
7:13 Speaker 04 point so late in the cycle being so high. Okay, there's informational value there too. And I don't think it's driven necessarily by inflation, but much more around these supply issues. But that somehow has to resolve itself. I'm not sure how it resolves itself. Now, is there a possibility of yield curve control? And they step in kind of like the UK and said, well, the market's not pricing this correctly any longer. Don't know. But really, we have to get to the Fed pivot, or at least the Fed on hold, ECB on hold before we can get there.
7:44 Speaker 01 That was part of the monthly conversations that Raul and Julian have exclusively on our website. Now, Raul and Julian aren't the only ones who see things differently. There are many different narratives out there right now, and it can get confusing. Next up, Roger Hirst breaks down the different camps and highlights some of the indicators that will ultimately show which thesis is playing out.
8:04 Speaker 05 We always talk about narratives. And what's fascinating right now is that there are multiple narratives. If you've been watching the most recent series of Crash and Boom, you've seen these narratives which are so incredibly different from incredibly credible individuals. You sort of think, how can that be? How can they be so different? You've had Raul saying recession's behind us and off we go. You've had David Rosenberg saying, ah, it's still down there and it's going to be terrible. And we had Juliet de Klerk saying, oh, reflation's here, we're going to get reflation. And all of these are plausible, and I listen and read everything that these people say. So what I'm going to do is go through some of these narratives and try and break them down. There's no right or wrong, because framework is the most important thing. And we've always said this at Real
8:49 Speaker 05 Vision, which is, you know, some people want that trade idea. They want a one trade idea and run with it and make money. If I gave a trade idea out to a client, it would be hitting maybe one in 10 if I was lucky. But a framework is valid for everyone, whether you're a day trader or a long-term investor. So I'm going to try and break down those narratives and sort of look at what those different ideas are. And basically go from there. So please do stop me at any point if there's anything you want to ask about because there is no right or wrong and I don't actually have an idea. At the beginning of this year, I said, this is going to be a really, really difficult year to predict. I held my hand up because I had no idea and I still don't, which is why I'm using everybody else's ideas to illustrate that very fact. So Vision Creative Labs, that's us.
9:34 Speaker 05 Doing stuff for other people, but more importantly, why the divergent narrative? So what I'm going to kick off with is normality. What would be my normality is? What is a normal recession? Because we're all talking about recession. What is it that we should expect? And there are one or two features that have existed in every single US recession without fail. And some of the narratives we're going to hear are saying that this is not going to happen this time, which could be valid. The first one is unemployment and recessions. Unemployment is the most important element of every single US recession since the war and probably before. And you can see here on this one, every single one of these recessions in grey, you have this massive acceleration in the unemployment rate.
10:19 Speaker 05 Without fail. So that's one of those factors that you need to have if you're going to have a recession. So far, we're starting to turn, but it's a minor turn. And if you look here, nearly all those turns happen well in advance of a recession. So if we've only just turned, that would suggest that if there is a recession, it's still quite a way off. But the important thing here is unemployment. Now revisions could come in and we could find out that actually unemployment was 5% today with revisions, but we'll only find out in 18 months' time. But right now, that's something we've got to be looking for. And the second thing people talk about is things like ISM. They go, oh, ISM's in contraction territory. This is the manufacturing below 50. That's a recession. Well, yes and no. You can see here that often you get
11:04 Speaker 05 The ISM manufacturing deep into negative territory, so below 50, so deep into negative territory. But there have been many, many occasions when ISM goes negative or goes sub 50 and we don't get a recession. We've only had a recession when we've had ISM below 50 and unemployment screaming higher. In fact, there's only one occasion really where we've had ISM below 50 and unemployment high without a recession. That was this one here, which was post the dot com crash. And that was because we were after it and we're just rolling back over on unemployment. So ISM is relevant, but it's nearly always coincident, but you need that unemployment. And then the third thing, which has been a factor of every single US recession, is that
11:45 Speaker 05 you get a tradable low on the equity market in and around every recession because some people are saying it's behind us. Now, there are, I'll give the caveats first, which is in the 1980s, you had little mini pullbacks in the market here and in 1991, a little mini pullback. This is a log scale, but generally you get big, big moves through and you get a tradable low, a tradable low, which is maybe not generational, but something pretty impressive. So if we're saying that we've seen the low, then we're saying again that this is very, very different. But that's normality. That's what we would normally look for and I've been looking for and I'm worrying that maybe my old framework is coming under pressure and might be wrong. So let's look at those three basic narratives that we've got.
12:29 Speaker 05 And the first one is the rearview recession, i.e. it's already gone, which is kind of rouse view.
12:34 Speaker 01 We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
12:41 Speaker 05 Now, some people say, oh, we had two quarters of negative GDP, which we did in the US here, two small ones. Probably the US is that's not the definition, that's the Eurostat definition in Europe. In the US, they have this, these three Ds, they call it, diffusion, dispersion and depth. So depth is it's got to be like this sort of thing. That's obviously a bit of an outlier, but you can see here, big moves down, negative GDP, this was quite small. Diffusion means it hits the whole of the economy, so it's not just one sector or another. And then duration, it lasts for a reasonable amount of time. So Covid was actually quite short. The dot com recession, actually you didn't have two consecutive negative quarters,
13:26 Speaker 05 but you had very weak GDP for a long period of time. So the US definition is actually quite subjective, but unemployment, rising unemployment again is that major factor. In 2015, I remember it well because I nearly got fully bearish with all my clients. I was fortunate away when the market turned back around, but you had a head and shoulders on the S and P. You had some really negative data, it felt terrible. And then they did a few tweaks, there was a bit of QE type stuff, and off we went to the races. And that head and shoulders that was forming got negated. That wasn't a recession. Unemployment was dropping back in 2015. So what else is the other reason why people think we've seen a recession already? Well, we've had this big
14:08 Speaker 05 drop in the S and P. So the 20% drop, as you can see here, with those yields going up. And a lot of people say, ah, that's it, that was the equity market pricing in a recession. But really, that was the equity market pricing at higher yields. And this was basically a rerating of the market. So the earnings multiples contracted. Now, you could say that actually that's retrospectively fitting multiples because the equity market sold off in anticipation of weakness because of higher rates. So you could argue that. But ultimately, one of the reasons people think the recession is behind us is because of that move in the S and P.
14:41 Speaker 05 But, and I think this is where that view of a rearview recession has some validity, is because we've not had that dispersion, that diffuse recession yet. But what we have had is we had little pockets of recession in parts of the economy or certain regions. And this is the consumer sentiment Michigan. And that was the worst reading that we've ever seen. And every single time we've been down there, we've always had a recession. Yet we didn't get a recession last year. But that was a recession for many households because that inflationary move was causing big problems. The buying of durable goods was off the cards. Similarly, small businesses. That was the worst outlook for the business, small business NFIB.
15:26 Speaker 05 But we didn't get a recession. Again, small businesses were price takers. So big companies, often hedged and often forcing higher prices onto people. Small businesses were having to take those. It was hitting their bottom line. And all of these were manufacturing based. So we saw this recessionary type of event in small businesses, in households. But it wasn't all at the same time. And I think Lizanne Saunders had said, "It's a rolling recession. It hit here and then it recovered. And then it hit here and recovered, but it never hit the whole economy in a single go." But nonetheless, you could say that maybe we did have a recession, but small pockets of it. So there's a future recession. David Rosenberg, why is he saying that? Well, I've got a chart from Deutsche Bank, which I've used many, many times. And it's about three months old now, but this is, if you have a rate hike,
16:11 Speaker 05 what is the time it takes for a recession after that first rate hike? And as you can see here, there's only one that took place before, in fact, two now, September 58. So that one, August 80, September 58. But basically, based on where they first raised rates, only two recessions out of the last 13 would have happened by this time. And this is something everyone talks about, it's that lag defect. And David Rosenberg talked about the lag defect. The lag means that by all sort of historical metrics since the war, you would expect a recession still to be in the future. I, we are still expecting that recession to come through. And this is David Rosenberg's big, big point.
16:50 Speaker 01 All of these conversations can be seen in full on our website. To join and get access, go to www.realvision.com. And you can still sign up for day two of the Festival of Learning, the next digital assets wave by going to realvision.com/festival23. It's totally free and we're going to be wrapping with a live AMA with RAL. So we hope you can join us for that. In the meantime, take care and good luck out there.
17:22 Speaker 06 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest and biggest names in finance.
Previous Is a Second Wave of Inflation Coming? With Vincent Deluard and Raoul Pal Next A Crypto Update & a Gold vs. Bitcoin Showdown with Raoul Pal, Kevin Kelly & Andreas Steno Larsen Page updated October 21, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated