Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Tiger Cub Investing in Technologies Driving the Future of Agriculture About this episode The Interview: Dwight Anderson of Ospraie Ag Science is well known as one of Julian Robertson’s famous "Tiger Cubs" and, for the last 20 years, has been one of the leading investors in agriculture and farming. After realizing the headwinds on the horizon for farmers and traditional agriculture investments, his focus has shifted to the cutting edge of agriculture technologies that will help farmers combat these headwinds by farming smarter, more efficiently, and more sustainably. In addition to highlighting the most important trends and technologies in agtech, Anderson will discuss the case for agtech as an ESG investment for carbon reduction, illustrate the ways agtech can help fight nutritional disparities in the U. S., and break down the difference in opportunity sets between public and private markets. Recorded on April 16, 2021 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:11 Speaker 00 Hello everyone and welcome to Real Vision. I'm Max Weethie and today I'm joined by Dwight Anderson of Osprey Ag Science. Dwight, thank you so much for being with me today.
0:20 Speaker 01 Max, I appreciate you having me.
0:22 Speaker 00 Alright, so before we get into ag science and ag tech, why don't we get a little bit about you and your background and how you got into this business?
0:31 Speaker 01 So, if we're gonna go all the way back in terms of the origin story.
0:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, let's go back.
0:35 Speaker 01 When I came out of college, and my background has always been in basic industries. I went into manufacturing consulting. I took a job with a client to actually become a plant manager for a paper printing and coating plant. And then, after passing through Goldman Sachs' J R and Commodity Division in the Cocoa and Coffee Group and J B Morgan's Oil Group, very briefly for both, I went and joined Julian Robertson's Tiger Management, where after a couple of months, because of the departure of the senior person in the firm, Julian gave me the opportunity to run the Basic Industries Group, so investing publicly and privately and in commodities. And so did that for four years and nine months.
1:16 Speaker 01 And that's really where I developed the broad-ranging expertise beyond just commodity futures or how to do it operationally, but actually investing across the space. And after having done that for a number of years, you always wanted to see, can you do this yourself? And I felt that I had paid Julian back for the risk he had taken, for giving me the responsibility and the opportunity I had. And relative to the evolution of the firm and my ability still to really contribute relative to the much broader, more liquid markets they were pursuing at the time, I thought it was the right time to give it a risk, a chance.
1:56 Speaker 01 And so partnered with Jason Maras to run the trading desk and operational side. We started Osprey in July of 1999, partnered with Tudor Investment Corp. We had a partnership offers from two other firms. Tudor offered the lowest payout and the lowest assets. But relative to cultural fit and skill set fit, but most importantly, you know, in doing our due diligence, every person who had worked at Tudor, whether they had succeeded or failed, said that Tudor was good to the spirit of a relationship. As you don't know how the path will go and the troubles that might occur, especially early in a relationship when you're still building trust and knowledge for each other.
2:35 Speaker 01 That reliability and that that culture was one that we thought was the most important to maximize our probability of success.
2:44 Speaker 01 And it was actually their lawyer who pushed us in the end with a name that we chose and that we had looked at a number of different names and had thousands of suggestions from friends, you know, you know, 20 pages of a yellow pad of suggestions in one friend. But in the end, we actually hold off publishing our prospectus a couple of days because we didn't have a name. And Tudor's lawyer, Andrew Paul, just in order of frustration said, just take a name you like, change its spelling and go with it. And so Osprey is a bird that has the highest hit rate in terms of percentage when it actually chooses to strike. So it'll circle for a long period of time hunting. But when it does, it is the highest hit rate of actually coming up with a successful kill or prey. And it's also hung out by the beach and waters and protected by the US government.
3:26 Speaker 01 So we thought that would be a good combination. So we went with William Shakespeare's, the Old English of Osprey is how we came up with the O S P R A I E, which confuses people both in spelling and pronunciation, but one that is one that we're happy to have chosen because of what it's about.
3:43 Speaker 00 Okay. And so is hit rate just part of your ethos? Is that something that you guys strive for to have just a really high hit rate? Or are you looking for those home runs that that pay for the for the losers?
3:54 Speaker 01 Unfortunately, we do have losers, okay? But the way in which we try to overcome that is, yes, both with probability and skew. And we try to really focus and fixate on getting an above-average number of our investments successful and profitable. But we also, especially in Osprey Ag Science, have really focused on what the far-right tail could be. And so we've had the good fortune so far that unlike many venture entities, we've had no failures, nothing that is not at least moving along towards its targets and its milestones. So we've been very lucky on that so far.
4:35 Speaker 01 So that would give you a good probability and also relative to the addressable market and the levels we're getting for some of those companies and what the payout could be. We do believe that some of them could still be home runs as well.
4:48 Speaker 00 All right. So let's talk about that addressable market and really investing in agriculture as well as ag tech more broadly. It's not a sector that everybody is familiar with or has exposure to, and it requires, you know, a special expertise. So what are the things that people should know about investing in that sector before they get in there?
5:08 Speaker 01 Let me give you a little bit of our background in ag so that Gabe is comfortable to, uh, two decades on to add on ag tech as a complementary part of our portfolio. So began by just doing years of research, especially from the commodity futures, understanding the economics of agricultural production. Having started in cocoa and coffee, expanded into rogue drops, and also having been materially involved in the late 90s into the next decade, the first part of the century, in the seed companies. And really starting to understand, you know, how the economics for a Monsanto worked via the acquisitions of the companies of people like Pioneer Hybrid or DeKalb. And we were materially involved with a company called Delta and Highland, which was twice acquired by Monsanto.
5:53 Speaker 01 One time the DOJ annulled it and the second time it went through. And so how you could wrap different features and stack them within the seed and make that complementary to an ag camp portfolio. We began investing in farmland privately in Argentina in two thousand and two after the evaluation. The hurdle I had set for my analysts in that space was that they had to beat the government bonds, which was a cash return of the low twenty percent. To be able to buy farmland after the evaluation in the mid-high twenty percent cash return was an exceptional and unique opportunity. After buying a few farms, we also understood and appreciated the scale needed. So we continued those farms in some cash and combined with George Soros as a Deco Agro entity.
6:39 Speaker 01 And then we're involving them roughly from two thousand and two through two thousand and fifteen to build out one of the larger South American farming companies, both road crops and sugar production. At the same time, Matt, is I took a look at the US after having seen the scale of farming down in South America, and I couldn't understand why we didn't have the same scale. And also why there was no institutional outlet for investment into farmland of any scale. In that we've been approached multiple times by our investors, especially endowments, to be able to support them for timber investments, because it gave real pricing over time. At the time, commodities as an asset class was something that was exploding as endowment and institutional portfolios.
7:22 Speaker 01 And it was a theme that we think commodity investing from the long side is something that's more cyclical and structural. And especially when you look at agricultural crops, there's a horrible negative yield most of the time in agricultural commodity futures. And so to be able to be long farmland, which is your positive cash flow and a positive yield versus the commodity futures seemed to us just a complete home run. And also having seen something like a wheat, like a plum creek in timber. And so since we couldn't find any entity out there, we decided to build one. So we spent eighteen months interviewing different managing teams and business plans for the space.
8:02 Speaker 01 We selected one led by Richard Holderman and Zerel Gray called Tigs River right outside of Indianapolis. We spent another eighteen months incubating, allowing them to build their management team in those three. Years, we're buying farmland as well. Until finally, in roughly two thousand and seven, we rolled our farmland and another four hundred and fifty million dollars into the entity that became Taze River. And Taze River has subsequently grown to become one of the biggest farming companies in America, with material footprint in organic dairy, in table grapes and carrots, but also, you know, probably one of the biggest seed producers, again, for the ag chem companies in the world as well. And so we remain partnered and aligned in advisory with
8:45 Speaker 01 Medecalagro, Taze River, and longtime friends and partners there. So that was our connection on the farming side, Max. We talked about the ag chem side. My analyst that decade, Yogesh Magro, who was the one responsible for the Monsanto and Laded investments, we developed a relationship with a person who was then CFO, Carl Cassali, who moved on to become CEO of CHS, which is the biggest farm co-op that's out there. And so we have a sixteen-year history with Carl and Monsanto going back then and the same analysts. Yogesh is now one of our partners focused full-time on atmospheric science, and Carl is actually the partner who leads that investment area.
9:26 Speaker 01 So is being able to pull in their decades of expertise on that.
9:33 Speaker 01 We've, obviously, we're involved materially in the midstream logistic storage from the acquisition of Gadalon and building, you know, those assets out, which was led by Greg Heckman, and now the entire management team of Bungie is our former Gadalon management team, which we sold for a little over four billion to Maro Benny and NGL earlier last decade. And so we've now been involved in the seed companies publicly, the ag chem, farming, logistics. But in terms of pure ag tech and the inputs and that evolution, it was something that, as a customer, you know, we were and remain some of the largest farmers in the world. And on the production side, we've been involved in understanding, you know, production economics from the commodity futures.
10:17 Speaker 01 And yet, we had really struggled, okay, to develop a individual investments, let alone a portfolio of critical mass and size in Agtech, because there were a number of variables that we had trouble lining up all at once. Is, you need to believe in the economics of the individual investments area and structure. You need to believe that the individual companies, you get your critical mass in terms of products, that they have an economically competitive model that can't be competed away by the large companies like the Deere's or the Monsanto buyers of the world who can bundle. You need the right valuation, the right management team. Taking all those boxes is something that we had struggled to find in a company that had the sort of proper scale and yet understandable valuation.
11:01 Speaker 01 And so, we had literally, you know, for over a decade, searched and interviewed and stayed on top, but hadn't found something that allowed us an attractive enough entry point. And so, and as it is, as I said, we're one of the larger customers for these products in the farming area. And so, finally, going back to late sixteen into early seventeen, a company that we had met with before, that had a volatile path due to a number of exogenous issues, Meron Bio, led by Pam Meron, came in and it was obvious to us that they needed to be recapped and restructured. And we finally had found something that had a portfolio of products, that had a really
11:44 Speaker 01 sort of a unique approach to the industry that was separate and that we could see how it economic valued. And that was really our entry point max. And so, that's how we began saying, okay, we finally now have our bellwether and our entry in terms of the space. For us, it's the aspect also of getting the best people and the best team. And that, we have a tremendous capital markets background, you know, a lot of understanding of the economics and background of the industries, but each industry always has people much better and more knowledgeable than us. And so in doing the due diligence and the investment on Marone, we reconnected with Carl Casali. And oddly enough, he was a customer who actually used Marone products for his blueberries.
12:30 Speaker 01 While we were doing due diligence, we were in touch with Brad Griffith of Compass. And he was a consumer of another Marone product. And Tom Wiltshire, a someone that we'd been involved and partnered with back at Remington in Tayside River in the Sealy. And Tom Wiltshire was the head of Down Agro's Strategy and Seed Division. And a gentleman named Bob Woods, who is CEO for North and South America for St. Gento. And so we were able to package these historic friendships, but also partnerships and knowledge of some of the best in the industry. To say, hey, we're going to actually make this a dedicated portfolio and product out there in Agtech. And so we'll come to what that portfolio is and became later. But does that sort of give you the history of how we got there?
13:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, it does. So, I mean, it makes sense, Marone being a recap and restructure, that there's obviously some opportunity for you to get a good entry point. But I'm looking at your website right now and your portfolio of companies, and it's much more than just that one company. So obviously, something switched in the industry that gave you this opportunity to get into not just Marone, but all of these other investments. So what is it, how did the sector mature in the last, you know, it sounds like five years, really, that gave you this opportunity to get into all these other portfolio companies of yours?
13:44 Speaker 01 So we had always approached agricultural investing from the traditional land ownership. And that was because we had taken a look at this, Max, you know, back at the start of this decade. And when you took a look at land investing versus almost any other fixed income asset class, whether it was timber, mortgages, you name it, on a one, three, five, 10, 30, 50 year timeframe, it outperformed in real terms. And so putting together the scale of opportunity, which other people have then since copied, to allow capital to come in to arbitrage that, created some really great first mover advantages. But unfortunately, generally, and until there's some sort of a geopolitical disruption or some sort of an economic shock,
14:28 Speaker 01 you know, the ability to deploy capital at scale to earn, to outperform, and actually earn alpha in terms of your returns in pure robust agriculture, adjusted for the illiquidity and the supply and weather variable risk. is somewhat limited. So we believe that right now in terms of sort of private row crop production agriculture, you're in the middle of a two or three year window of windfall profits, tremendous free cash, very good profitability for the farmers, and you should probably be harvesting pay those profits because we have real concerns about row crop profitability for the second half of this decade due to concerns over transportation fuel demand, productivity growth in the space,
15:08 Speaker 01 demographic issues, changing forward diet, and so in interest rates. And farmland is one of the most sensitive areas to interest rates. So while it will probably outperform most common fixed income investments, we're not sure it'll be a great absolute return investment anymore. Once you get beyond this two or three year window of windfall profitability. So having and been harvesting our capital out of traditional agriculture left us, you know, with the area of, okay, how do we actually benefit from some of those headwinds? Okay, for row crops and what's driving that productivity? And also, what's our competitive advantage? When you take a look at the majority of ag jack funds out there,
15:52 Speaker 01 they go farm to table and they spread themselves incredibly thin. And like we talked earlier about probability of success in investing in individual investments, we struggle to see how they can have a competitive advantage when they're across the entire spectrum. And we thought about what we had done and who we knew. And our network and our experience is farming. Max, we've been farmers, our partners are farmers, that's our network. And so as such, we're in touch with what the farmers need and use and what the real world reality of actually what you're trying to do when you're sitting on your combine in the middle of the field and what makes sense or not and just sort of on a daily basis.
16:32 Speaker 00 I'm trying to picture you on a combine.
16:34 Speaker 01 I have photos, okay? Uh, that aspect is we decided that we would focus only on investments in ag tech tied to productive agriculture. So whether it's outdoor agriculture or indoor agriculture, which is an evolving space for a niche, which plays great to some of the evolving tailwinds for the space, that's how we focus. And so by focusing our limited capital, because it's internal capital and resources, just in what we knew, we could take advantage of our farmer network to sort of truth source, you know, the, the need for a product as well as its efficacy and probability. Uh, and then we sort of began what we call the double network effect. So is in due diligence in Marone,
17:17 Speaker 01 we found out that we knew a number of people who were the customers. And so we could actually diligence what's the probability of the product? And also that they had not been marketed to anywhere near the number of customers possible out there who wanted and could use that. Uh, what we have focused on is how do we reduce inputs? Okay. And especially chemical and artificial inputs focused on chemicals at to start, but eventually ideally cutting nutrients and water use as well too. How to do this in a natural way? Uh, and then also sensors diagnostics to drive those decisions. And then, as we said, controlled environment. So after making the investment Marone and putting the team together to allow us to evaluate this correctly with
18:02 Speaker 01 Carl and Tom and Bob Woods and Yojish and dedicated analysts, there's a gentleman who we've who came from North Dakota farming and his masters out there. Uh, the, the real question gets into is where do we go? And so it's a focus on not just the stem or crop input space, but each individual company needs to potentially make our other company better. So we looked at an investment called Terramera up in Vancouver led by a visionary CEO named Carl Manus. And what that product, Active Aid allows you to do is cut potentially individual synthetic chemicals used by 90%. But also apparently in pro forma, we'll see if it works in the fields too. But seen a dramatically increase the efficacy of Marone's products.
18:46 Speaker 01 So Marone's science are excited by it, our farmers are excited by it. And so that's a follow on investment. We next came across an investment led by two young men down in Charlottesville called Agrospheres. And Pyam and Amir are phenomenal gifted individuals who came up with a lipid coating that allows the chemicals to adhere to the bottom of the plant, so you can spray less, gives the field more use, less dramatic economic benefit. But also, one of the problems with biologics, which are Merone's products. And just a quick aside, biologics have been around for 2,000 years. Those are any naturally occurring element or microorganism that can be used on farming to benefit yield, but that where the crop can still be called organic.
19:31 Speaker 01 And so, when the Romans were putting copper or copper sulfate on their graves, it was the first biologic. And so, Merone's products are all biologic. The issue with that, though, is that they're much more temperamental when it comes to extremes of heat, or humidity, or other aspects, which are common in the field. And so, the areas where you can get 100% consistent use, like you can synthetic chemicals, are more limited. Agrospheres coating, okay, their micro-sym, potentially corrects that, in terms of it protects them. It allows you to control the ferocity and the time release, but also protection from heat and humidity. And so, the Terra Marilla science and the Merone people were incredibly excited about the possibility and probability of Agrospheres.
20:15 Speaker 01 And so, Agrospheres made those better and also gave us greater comfort in the investment. And so, as you can see, that pyramid effect of how, hopefully, in terms of more sustainable, less negatively impactful to the environment, just as competitive economic impact to the farmer, we're getting this pyramid of beneficial companies to each other and to the farmer in sustainable crop inputs. And so, that's where we talked about the double network effect of working with the farmers, understanding their need, each company, you know, whether it's a relevant product, and then our other companies, in terms of due diligence on whether it would be beneficial to them, if that makes sense, man.
20:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, it does. And I have a few questions there. One would be, it sounds like a lot of these companies already have products. So what stage in the maturity, I'm sure it differs from company to company, but are they now at the customer acquisition stage? Is there still proving out efficacy? Are you waiting for the trends around sustainable and getting away from synthetic chemicals and towards naturals to catch on? What is the big move that needs to happen for the demand to really take off?
21:22 Speaker 01 So when we were due diligence in these different companies, we spoke to the head of commercial operations for North America for Syngenta. And he said, look, we are desperate for these products. The time is now. The issue isn't the end use, the market pressure, whatever else. It's the efficacy and economics of the products, the consistency, the reliability, the scale of market that they're actually equally as competitive for. Give me more products and we'll buy them. And so the individual companies have commercial products, Terra Mera did, Maroon did. AgroSphere is much earlier and has a very broad range of end markets that it can be in. Plant Healthcare is a company that has existing products.
22:06 Speaker 01 We usually like to have the lab risk taken out. So it's actually been trialed in some sort of a field, shows probability of use. It doesn't actually have to be selling yet, Max. But investing in concept is something that is so risky that, again, relative to our ability to be comfortable on the probability of success, it tends not to be there. So very early stage micro investing, we tend not to do. We have a network of other friends and feeders who we invest in, who do that and are expert in, will incubate the companies. And we'll look to see them after they've lived with them for one, three, seven years. And actually have developed a product where there's some data on is normally the time period where we would invest.
22:52 Speaker 00 Okay. And so what's the blend within your portfolio of companies that have their product? It's commercially ready to go versus more in that proving out the market fit stage?
23:05 Speaker 01 I'd give you somewhere in that eighty, twenty, ninety, ten in that, you know, the vast majority, I'd say, you know, ninety percent plus actually have some sort of a commercial product that is ready to be trialed at a minimum by farmers on a commercial basis.
23:20 Speaker 00 Okay, and it it sounds like agro-spheres really plays into a lot of the other products that you guys have. Is it really like a linchpin investment? Like you need, is there anything that makes the rest of them all work?
23:33 Speaker 01 Well, as I said, agro-spheres would be in the ten, okay? And so it's one of the most exciting, but also one of the most early stage. But, I mean, it is potentially, they're coating the agro-sell in the agri-cell they have that potentially allows delivery of RNAi, which we're now all familiar with from the vaccines that a number of us have. But there's been billions spent to try to get its applicability into agriculture. But finding a way to actually deliver it in a safe and efficacious manner is something that entities have struggled with. Not only is agro-spheres potentially beneficial to a biologic company or a synthetic company in terms of its delivery mechanism, it potentially has applicability in terms of RNAi. And so whether
24:16 Speaker 01 you view it as a linchpin, an accelerator, you know, something that's all encompassing, if we're successful, and if it's successful, the scale of what it's addressed in market, what it could do for the world and for agriculture is the biggest of all of our companies.
24:31 Speaker 00 So I I think at this point, we've been a little bit high level. And I'm sure there are some people who still don't fully grasp like what exactly agtech is. So I think it would be helpful to to go back and talk about, and we can, we can take a specific company as an example. But some of the things like that you were doing with measuring the the the composition of topsoil, I think that's a great place to go to understand what exactly agtech is and how it can help farmers.
25:01 Speaker 01 So let's start with just an underlying definition. For us, agtech is a new technology, okay, that potentially helps improve the productivity.
25:15 Speaker 01 As you define in multiple different levels for different aspects of agriculture. So it could be, you know, something that improves yields. And by improving yield, it could be because you eliminate a disease or a pest, or because you produce more kernels of corn, okay? Or because you do something for another portfolio that cuts down on the waste and transit. So ag tech is anything that really sort of, you know, improves the total cost, including stakeholder cost and environmental cost for agriculture to either the producer and/or the end consumer. So just as a starting point, what we define it as. And so in terms of topsoil, there's a brilliant gentleman, Dave Friedberg,
25:59 Speaker 01 who helped create Climate Corp. And led that for a while after selling it to Monsanto and then left. And created the Production Board, which has a broad range of investments across agricultural and food. And we had been involved via an investment that Carl Casalli had led into trace genomics, which was early on for something similar that has commercial kits out there to help people assess the pathogens and the like in their soil that's being sold by Will Relus. But Pattern for us was that next step up in terms of an easy to use, very bottom line beneficial solution to help actually map what is in your soil. What's the microbial community that you can do there?
26:42 Speaker 01 So because if you can understand the aggregate of the nutrient and the potential latent disease risk, you can better actually map now that we have much more precise ability to apply pesticides, herbicides, fertilizer, water, and much more grander level per acre than you had historically, where you just dump it from the sky as much as possible. Okay, is more and more farms have the ability to adjust based on squares even within the same acre, within the same farm. And so something like Pattern coming in to actually be able to help you figure out what your latent risks are, what are the current problems in terms of how that's creating issues in the yield and health for your crops, is something that has dramatic, you know, per year, intra-year benefit
27:27 Speaker 01 for farmers on controlling the problems and improving their crops, but in a way that's much less damaging to the just, you know, you know, Roundup, okay, or D E T solutions of decades past.
27:41 Speaker 00 Okay, it sounds almost analogous to what's happening with personalized medicine.
27:45 Speaker 01 Oh, yes, yes. But I mean, the answer is, is our individual knowledge and unraveling of our DNA and our cells and our code and then the body is, you know, two decades ahead of where we are in agriculture. And so we try to learn from the business models of Big Pharma and biotech and the others that are ahead of us in terms of both science and applicability and how you roll that model out. But the aspect of that, those industries to agricultural and ag tech is pretty similar in that you had a really unique set of events, you know, in the three through five years ago.
28:25 Speaker 01 You had eight massive, big ag camp, ag input companies and also, you know, a separate number in terms of fertilizer nutrients, and they've all merged and combined. Now, you've had material consolidation into four and a half. So that's created some great opportunities for us because first off, it made many more, you know, incredibly capable people available than you had before either because they vested or they didn't want to work in the new culture or community that they were in. And also it led to an incredible internal focus in terms of those companies on cutting costs, eliminating projects, how do we focus our pipeline? But just like you've seen in consumer goods like beer or pharma,
29:06 Speaker 01 those same consolidations lead to a collapse of the growth for future products in the pipelines. And so that entrepreneurialism and the new products for small capital, we're talking, you know, you know, sub 100 million, sub 150 million sort of investment areas, is something that got completely eliminated in these behemoths. Okay. And so now, over the next two years, they're going to be emerging from this internal cost-cutting, project-cutting focus with dramatically reduced pipelines, but also a real need for growth. And at the same point, dramatic pressures on both their historic products and in the current to give things that are more sustainable, less impact. And so the aggregate biologic world.
29:51 Speaker 01 And what we call sustainable crop inputs is an area where we believe we're in that creative entrepreneurial segment, that those companies are going to be desperate to have to need to acquire, or JV, or merge with, in order to actually create the growth in their revenue companies for the next decades to come.
30:08 Speaker 00 So, we've touched on some trends already that you guys are trying to take advantage of. What are some of the other big trends that you think there's opportunity in that we haven't discussed yet?
30:18 Speaker 01 Well, there's pluses and minuses in trends out there, Max. You know, one of the real different things about investing in agriculture versus something like oil and gas, or metals and mining, is there is a unique positive about farming in that, on average, you grow more per year per acre. If you have an oil well, you know, it declines over time. If you have a mine, it depletes, and you have to go find more, and you have all the CapEx to do it. As long as you manage your water rights and your impact to your soil well and intelligently, proper stewardship, you will grow more over time per acre, you know, on average. It's whole, you know, the real impact agriculture in any one year is
30:58 Speaker 01 supply variability due to weather, but obviously that averages over time. So, it's a very different mindset of how you approach agriculture than the rest of basic industries. It's also an environment that you tend to get some form of agri-government support versus attack, okay? So, you know, is agriculture is probably one of the greatest opportunities to reduce carbon, if you're out of the chain, in terms of benefiting the world in carbon removal, which the other industries don't have, except by going away, right? And then, you also have the issues which are going to affect it over time, where you had a temporary repricing of corn in the decade from sort of 01 through 11, where it went from $2.8, because ethanol
31:43 Speaker 01 went from 1.5 billion gallons to 11.5 billion gallons, okay?
31:46 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:47 Speaker 01 And that surge of the biggest market in the world, which is energy, into agriculture, caused a temporary, okay, repricing to buy more acres, okay, and to create the supply for that. That phenomenal tailwind then, okay, we believe becomes a headwind at the second half of this decade. At the moment, you still have good ethanol demand. You're having a temporary effect from some renewable diesel that's coming in that we think could cause a real two-year window of potentially an explosion of vegetable oil prices, which will be good for the farmers in the intermediate areas like a Bungie. It's worrisome to me on a human level because it is one of the main staples for poor people's diets, especially in Asia.
32:31 Speaker 01 And so prices have already risen materially. If they double from here, the impact that has to people's ability to feed themselves, calories, is a real humanitarian issue. But the government programs in place causing that will probably react afterwards rather than on a forward-looking basis. So you have this window here where, as I said, row crop profitability is great. Some of that is also created by China is utterly revamping their protein and meat industry. They've had dramatic health issues and caused a possible halving of their hog and pork herd. And the anomalies within diet and meat and agriculture around the world are staggering to think about.
33:14 Speaker 01 China, you know, obviously is 15%, let's say, of the world's population, keep it simple. They produce and consume more than 50% of all the world's hogs and pork, and also lettuce, okay? And so you have these anomalies of diet. And so the way that was done was very different in terms of meat production than the U.S. In the U.S., as of two years ago, four companies produced over 80% of all the pork production. In China, four companies produced a little over 8%. The way in which the hogs were fed was on a much smaller individual farm or move area, and they'd be fed scraps and a random ration of what's available.
33:57 Speaker 01 The government has said, "We are going to corporatize and professionalize and commercialize, you know, this industry." So they're in a massive expansion. What that's done is it also commercializes their feeding. To standard grains, soy meal, D D Gs, you know, those sorts of inputs. And so it's leading to real expansion of their imports. At the same point, they've already had some phenomenal growth in their poultry and aquaculture industries to meet the gap caused by the decimation of their hoggers. And there's a geopolitical angle of pollution and the embarrassment over possible disease from their live meat and fresh meat and on non-commercial channels for meat production. And so as China is corporatizing their ration,
34:42 Speaker 01 it's leading to a material expansion of imports. At the same time, you have some of these other programs like the renewable diesel hitting home. That's what's creating this two, three year windfall that we spoke about for row crop agriculture. However, supply responds in agriculture. It's not like a mine that takes three, five, seven, 11 years to come on due to permitting and difficulty in financing and depth. Is it is capable of both adding acreage and growth in production. At the same point, you're in this complete time period where for most of the developed world's populations are hitting their peak in terms of size and also age. And so as you age and as you get wealthier, you eat more fruit, nuts and vegetables, less meat.
35:24 Speaker 01 China's per capita protein consumption is already higher than South Korea's and Japan's. So you're not going to get more protein per capita unless you have a complete change of diet to Argentina. Okay, which we expect, especially as they age, because your population is about to turn over. So you'll see a change in that composition. We believe more aquaculture, more poultry, more fruit, nuts and vegetables. But the most inefficient converter of grains to end protein is cattle and then pork. And so as Japan's already gone over its peak population, as Europe is potentially approaching that and definitely aging, as North America is aging, as China begins to age,
36:06 Speaker 01 that aspect of the composition of diet is going to lead to less red meat consumption, which is going to free up much more grain, which is one of our concerns for the second half of this decade about row crop. Okay, but at the same point, the kind of protein that you'll need, the one growth area in the near term, short term, is going to be India. But India is not going to eat beef. Okay, they're going to be poultry focused, aquaculture focused, which requires different sort of protein consumption. So how we've set up Our AgTech portfolio is designed to support farmers' variable costs to make them both environmentally friendly and lower, but also one that would work in a high and a low profitability environment.
36:51 Speaker 01 High profitability is better to get them to take risks to trial new stuff, but hopefully that'll be in place by the tail end of this decade. And at the same point, in terms of the crops we're focusing on, leafy green fruits, nuts and vegetables, and also controlled environment indoor production of that, is to take advantage of the change of diet, the change of location diet, the environmental pressure, and how it's sort of the evolution of what we think is the food delivery system.
37:14 Speaker 00 Let me, let's get into that evolution of the, of the food delivery system. What does that mean?
37:18 Speaker 01 They give you two great examples of people who are evolving to deal with that. One is Green Plains, which is a publicly traded, historically ethanol company, becoming a protein company, and one is controlled environment in general. Green Plains was a company that had a very simplistic product portfolio when it began. It took corn and broke it into distilled dry grains, D D Gs, and ethanol. Okay. Worked well in the beginning when the demand for ethanol was exploding per the government mandate, but the problem is, is there was a cap on the amount of room you needed for those calories to make fuel cleaner. And also just engineers are just so darn good that you're able to grow productivity
37:59 Speaker 01 per year, and so is able to grow faster than the end market for demand because of limited transportation fuel demand growth. The management team is visionary, they're great business people, entrepreneurial, and they had originally tried to use those windfall profits from the early years to increase their capital base and diversify their revenue streams into things like cattle that consume D D Gs, or vinegar, which was also fermentation. When the management team really had an epiphany from looking at a technology that we've looked at due diligence and invested with them, a company called Fluidquip. That allows you to consolidate your capital base, sold off the cattle, sold off the vinegar. You're using just your existing plants.
38:41 Speaker 01 And now you can crack a kernel of corn the way you can crack a barrel of oil. So in between, they've added corn oil, which is going to benefit materially in the next couple of years because of the explosion of vegetable oils. But now with Fluid Quips technology, corn ethanol plants can start to producing clean sugar, industrial sugar, because one of the fastest growing areas out there with a very consolidated industry is industrial sugar for fermentation, which is one of the fastest growing areas. You can produce high protein. The one structural area for growth, really, this decade next is aquaculture, in that we are still overfishing the world's sea population, as it is, the Chinese especially with the largest fleet, okay?
39:25 Speaker 01 And also the small fish for fish meal to feed land-based aquaculture. So you've had flat wild production and catch for over 30 years now, and yet per capita consumption of seafood continues to rise every year. And we think that's going to accelerate as the population ages, especially in China, and as India comes on. How do you meet that? It's land-based aquaculture. That requires a very certain, specific kind of food, a high-protein diet, which corn-based DDTs and protein can actually meet. It's some of the most sought-after high-protein out there for aquaculture. And so Green Plains is converting, using Fluid Quips technology, all of their plants to be able to produce that high-protein end market, dramatically improving their margin,
40:09 Speaker 01 and getting into a structural growth area as opposed to gasoline that because of EVs, whatever else, is going to be falling. So now, all of a sudden, they can produce five products, and we think eventually their corn plant using Fluid Quips will be able to produce 20 products. In Brazil, Fluidquip is selling to the sugar plants who convert into ethanol or sugar or powder to then also process corn so they can run all year round and also increase their variability. So you're turning these simple plants into the equivalent in complexity of petroleum refineries or even downstream chemical companies. And what that does of your ability to take advantage of the most expensive calorie, improve your margin, dramatically different end markets, get into markets that have true
40:54 Speaker 01 growth like aquaculture, fermentation, industrial clean sugar. And so Green Plains moving itself from a decaying gasoline transportation fuel market, okay, and DDGs get fed to beef and somewhat to pork, to now fermentation, clean sugar, and the structural growth and margins of that, but more importantly, high protein, which goes to aquaculture and some protein and some poultry, is a complete repositioning and flexibility for their plants on a focus limited capital base. And so Fluidquip is the enabling technology and we're involved with that with Green Plains. And that capitalizes on some of those different wins we spoke about.
41:34 Speaker 01 The next aspect is distributed ag or consolidated agriculture. We watched but didn't participate investment wise in the development of greenhouses, especially in Europe, as something that is actually competitive with outdoor ag for certain crops like lettuce. We missed those that have become in certain regions like the EU competitive with outdoor ag. So we never made any money on that. We'd been watching controlled environment for two decades, but always as something that was too expensive and also too carbon inefficient because of the amount of electricity it used. Finally, in the last three years, with the dramatic improvement in lighting and LED
42:18 Speaker 01 and efficiency, we were able to evaluate for certain very specific regions, areas that are off the main logistics channel, for certain specific high value products like a Bezel, okay.
42:31 Speaker 01 Controlled environment was able to compete with outdoor ag and they're able to compete in a dramatically more environmentally friendly way. No pesticides, no herbicides. They use ninety-five to ninety-nine percent less water, dramatically less waste generally because of local production. So to go through a couple terminology, indoor ag is anything produced indoors. But a greenhouse, you tend not to control the light because it's glass, okay? You don't really control the heat, the humidity, the CO2. True controlled environment is actually a closed off your room and walls where you control every variable. And so that's controlled environment versus indoor agriculture. The majority of companies that are now public and that you're familiar with are not actually
43:16 Speaker 01 anything that is going to completely disrupt agriculture. They're sort of the same model, but brought to indoors. And some brilliant people, there are some brilliant components, but all of them have a massive capital cost. So on an operating basis, because they've been funded by equity, they can potentially compete, but not in terms of a return. And they want to take every risk possible in the book. They want the science, tech, ag tech risk of developing the technology. They want to own the farms and farming is low return and capital intensive. And they want to build brands for their end products. Holy cow, that's a lot to get right and a lot to get wrong.
43:57 Speaker 01 We've pursued a distributed model that we think can absolutely truly transform agriculture. By going after and investing and focusing, supporting companies in the end container market where we will only invest in hardware or software for indoor agriculture. We will try to actually enable the world to feed itself and enable companies to grow and evolve. We will not actually compete with our customers and be the end customers. We also want to create something that is an affordable option. And so part of the thing I think that people have missed in controlled environment is if you think about your room, the biggie of your room is the harder it is to control the temperature or a draft humidity in the center of that room. We're trying to do that on a warehouse specific basis, which you can only do with an inordinate amount of Capital and automation.
44:42 Speaker 01 By making it a uniform box, uniform size, something in a container, okay? Is we can change the level of automation, we can do it at an affordable level. Does it cost you a hundred and forty thousand dollars for a freight farm farm? Or two hundred, or do you wanna go up to a million for something for local urban vegetables? Is we can customize, but what it allows us to do is arbitrage logistical inefficiencies. So if you wanna be in Aberdeen, South Dakota with a population of thirty thousand, they can't support the massive warehouses that those companies go for. The other companies are going for mass generic production. Okay, where they're trying to get the lowest cost possible, but of the lowest value product. And they're dealing with the most difficult customers.
45:23 Speaker 01 Whole Foods, Kroger, Food Lion, Walmart, those people are horrendous to negotiate with. And they're these ones, and you have to compete directly with Bruce Taylor and Outdoor Ag. And so the great thing about indoor ag, but especially controlled environment, is if you want me to create a tomato that tastes exactly in the same conditions as you would a Tuscan tomato from Italy, I can do that every day of the year, everywhere around the world. But the only way I get a return for that is in certain areas where those tomatoes are expensive, okay, or basil. So you have this logistics channel that goes basically from the bottom left to the top right of the US, and everything along that is competitive. That's also sort of population centric. That's where these large controlled environment companies are going for it. Our companies are going everything off of that.
46:08 Speaker 01 And at the same point, we're also trying to do something about the food deserts and also the food inequity that exists in the United States. Too much of the United States has bad diet, okay? You look at the inner cities. What we can do by working with a number of the different sort of social and service organizations in the cities. There's, you know, our farms are being used by battered women's shelter in Miami. The Boys and Girls Club of Houston will be doing this soon. And so they can own these farms. The local people can own the farms or the entity can get equity. They get the cash flow, they get jobs, they get environmentally friendly, nutritious blend of food. We can finally do something about nutritional inequity. Okay, and an affordable level.
46:51 Speaker 01 No one else has a solution that allows you to do that in those areas, both remote and urban. And so that distributed ag, we're the last mile. And so it's some combination, we're trying to be sort of Uber in that these small farms can grow what you want. Okay, you can grow a couple of different products. You can grow what you needed in your area, you're flexible. You're not monolithic production like the other large entities. Okay, and also trying to do something like what SAP has done. Develop a uniform operating system that works for all controlled environment. So we'll support our companies. We're going for hardware and software, current revenue, what recipes. And at the same point, rather than having one large central solution area. Like if you look at freight farms by the end of this year, they're going to have over 500 farms operating.
47:37 Speaker 01 In 49 states, the United States, we're missing North Dakota. We hope to solve that. Over 24 countries. And all of these farms are collaborating. You're getting the data on who's growing what, how, better. And so this best practices of having 500 different labs, which will soon be 1500 labs, which will be 3000. Okay, will allow us to dramatically move along the productivity curve and support them to make environmentally friendly, energy, carbon, nutritional affordable, and keep the equity and the profit in the communities. And so for us to be supporting that, that is truly agricultural disruptive. It's at the last mile, right there, no national trucking, no the waste that comes from all of that. And where the profit stays with the owners of the farms.
48:18 Speaker 01 And so that for us is what's going to be really evolutionary and disruptive for agriculture.
48:23 Speaker 00 I can see how excited you are about this trend and there's a lot of positives to discuss, but you opened the door to something that I think is important for us to discuss, especially because I'm sure there are some viewers who are excited to go look at ag tech opportunities. I want to talk about the business models that you don't like. What are the things that are out there that maybe are getting some buzz that you just think it doesn't work? Because we should protect investors here a little bit from putting good money after bad. You don't have to name any names or anything like that, but just things that you think it just doesn't make sense.
48:54 Speaker 01 So the answer that we've already touched on is I think the large-scale concentrated, high-volume, single-product facilities in controlled environment will not earn a sustainable return on capital, especially as the valuations are applying in the public market. I don't think they'll accomplish what we want to in terms of waste or carbon, and I think they're dealing with the most competitive customer base and the most competitive products. And so I would raise questions or concerns about those business model approaches. One of the things I would make people highly questionable about is the biggest source of dollars out there that companies are desperate to allocate to go out and promote and PR
49:36 Speaker 01 and check the box is that they're doing something about carbon. And some of the biggest ag tech companies out there, some of the biggest names and valuations are wrapping themselves in the "we're going to provide a carbon solution." And so they'll go to the companies out there like the FedExes of the world, and FedEx is desperate to say, "Hey, we're putting a billion dollars to work each year to balance out our carbon footprint." And so the real fixation I would urge people to do is, are the solutions that they do actually full-cycle doing anything to actually change the food waste and the carbon footprint? Carbon is something that everyone is saying within the ESG mantra, and that very few people are actually accomplishing. And that's as you and I spoke prior, I mean, I take
50:20 Speaker 01 a look at what's going on in the electrical vehicle world, and it's, to me, a disgrace how the government incentives are creating bad outcomes. So you have nickel that's mined and melted. Down and processed to create the batteries from Indonesia to China in a massively carbon polluting and energy intensive way that go into a Tesla car. The Tesla car is sold to in Germany and because there's only automotive carbon credits. When that Tesla is sold, they get that credit, which it then can sell to another car company or monetize. Okay. But Germany closed all their nukes. Okay. And so their backup power source that runs a good amount of those cars is they dug new lignite,
51:01 Speaker 01 low calorie, you know, low, you know, coal mines and created coal power plants. And so by our math, those Teslas in Germany from full cycle, from the nickel to the cars, the emissions are two to four times as carbon emitting as a VW diesel in Germany currently. That's a government mandate where all they do is say, hey, let's look at the tailpipe. They don't look at the total cycle. We look at a number of the other sort of more specific companies like what Green Plains is doing in terms of converting corn that takes CO2 out of the air and then a carbon sequestration pipeline is sequestering carbon. That's actually completely removing carbon from the environment and yet they don't get carbon credits today.
51:44 Speaker 01 I think that the government system and the different incentives will evolve. And a really underappreciated part of the potential profitability for Green Plains and other ag tech companies is the enablement of getting credit for true carbon sequestration, elimination and conversion from the environment versus false like Tesla in Germany, but we're not there yet. And so I would really urge investors to pay attention, not just to the business models, but to the full cycle environmental effect.
52:11 Speaker 00 And is there a lot, are there big lobbying efforts going on to get that changed?
52:16 Speaker 01 Uh, yes, there's a lobbying, negotiating, we can go through all the list of what's going on. I mean, the EU has created a more than trillion dollar incentive for agriculture and carbon in their stimulus program, but that hasn't been actually divvied up and allocated yet. Um, and there are even in the alternative vehicle space, like you're watching people react. So there's a company called Freyr, F R E Y R, that's going to make a carbon neutral battery for the EV up in Norway. And that's something that's reacting to try and get the better allocation of credit. But in agriculture, in the current stimulus bill that's being contemplated going forward in infrastructure and in the EU one, there is aggressive work by different parties, not all of them altruistic,
52:59 Speaker 01 to try and get those carbon credits allocated out. I hope that they're done in a way that's less directed, such as, you know, the government says, "Look at the tailpipe", and one that actually says, "Hey, let's use an independent party like the OMB does in terms of scoring the budget", to say, "Does this give total cycle carbon effect?"
53:20 Speaker 00 So we're coming down to the end. There is one question that we haven't gotten to that I wanted to touch on, which is the difference in opportunity sets between private and public markets and how you approach private investment versus public investment?
53:32 Speaker 01 Public investing, you know, it allows you to at least choose the size of your investment and manage and create your portfolio based on, you know, some constraint of liquidity, but generally what you view the risk return of each individual investment. And if you're wrong, you can get out, okay? Or if a better other opportunity comes along, you can get out. When you're in privately, the size of your investment, at least initially, is more based upon the liquidity needs of the company versus your assessment of the risk return. But because of the illiquid nature, the opportunity cost created by tying your capital up on certain exit, the opportunity cost is almost as big as the actual risk, okay?
54:17 Speaker 01 Because if you're wrong, you're stuck, and if something better comes along, you're stuck. So automatically, the return hurdle has to be so much higher investing privately. The difference, although in privately, is public, you're limited to what is public and what you can do. In the private, you can either build a solution, which we've done often, or you can go and find a solution for what you want. So there's a much greater breadth of investment opportunity, albeit higher risk compared to the illiquidity in the private markets. And so that ability to build a business and build a solution is something that is a phenomenal opportunity. Then when it hits a certain scale or certain capital needs, you have the public markets as an option potentially to go there, especially
55:01 Speaker 01 with how SPACs now at least allow growth companies to get a certain future valuation. But there's been a massive evolution of liquidity in the private markets too. So you can take companies to a trillion dollar size and not have to take them to the public markets earlier. And so much greater flexibility privately now than you had 10 and 20 years ago.
55:21 Speaker 00 And when you look at the opportunity set in each area, is one clearly more opportunity in private versus public?
55:31 Speaker 01 At the moment, relative again to the breadth of opportunities that you can find, invest in, and help grow and develop, I would say that the private is still more prolific than the public. People are moving more of those private opportunities into the public arena, and so those options are growing. But you're still talking a fraction of the ways to be able to express a view publicly than there are privately.
55:54 Speaker 00 Okay. Well Dwight, thank you so much for taking the time to speak with me today. I know I learned a lot about ag tech and the agricultural sector in general, and thank you to all the viewers at home.
56:06 Speaker 01 Max, very much appreciate the time and look forward to speaking to you going forward.
Previous Raoul Pal: The Dollar is the King Next What Currencies Are Saying About the Sell-Off ( w/ Andreas Steno Larsen ) Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated