Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Recession Plot Thickens ft. Mikael Sarwe About this episode In the second installment of our Crash or Boom series, Andreas Steno Larsen welcomes Mikael Sarwe, head of equity strategy and quant at Nordea, for an in-depth exploration of recessionary risks in the U. S., Europe, and China. Are financial markets pricing these risks correctly? And, how should investors think about asset allocation in this economic environment? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:35 Speaker 01 Hi everyone. Welcome to the second installment of our special series Crash or Boom: How to Profit from What's Coming. So Raul kicked things off with his overview of what he expects over the next eight to 10 months. And not surprisingly, he's bullish. He thinks the recession that everyone's been waiting for is already here. It already happened and may actually be ending. He's not worried about inflation. Instead, the big issue for Raul is the ballooning debt and the government's need to finance it. That debt dynamic is core to his belief that tech and crypto offer the best opportunity in the next year. But we've got some pushback in the comments as we expected. William M. pointed out that Raul may be in the minority, and many of you raised issues about commodity prices and
1:19 Speaker 01 the impact of China, to name just a few. So to drill down on some of these points and give us their view on crash or boom, I'm joined by my colleague Andreas Denna-Larsson and Mikel Sarwe. Andreas, take it away.
1:33 Speaker 02 Thank you so much, Maggie, and great to see you as well, Michael. You recently wrote a piece called "The Plot Thickens," and it relates to the discrepancy that we've seen between the gross domestic product and the gross domestic income in the US. One is pointing to a recession, the other is pointing towards maybe even above trend growth at the current juncture. So what do you make of this crash or boom question initially here? Are we already in a recession?
2:03 Speaker 03 Ja, det är en väldigt intressant fråga och det finns indikatorer som visar det här sättet, skulle jag säga. Men ochvid markeds och ekonomer följer gdp-nummer och unemployedn nummer och de är inte där nog. Och debatt om grossdomestic inkomst versus grossdomestic product är en intressant sak i den här mening. Att berorna på att normalt skulle de alltså bevisna samma och nu är de inte. Om vi ser historiskt, har det varit det fall som, till exempel i den fördagskrise, du sett en släckning i grossdomestic inkomst förra gdp. Så det var ett leading indikator sedan, det var också ett leading indikator, skulle jag säga, i de första 90-talet.
2:46 Speaker 03 Och det匹配 mycket med många andra indikationer av en recession. Som du kan se i den seniöra loven officera survey med kreditegjorde mycket, du kan se det i filer av bankrobos för att uppställa sig i USA. Du kan se det nu också i jobbåtverk som faller väldigt i USA med läjof på cyklikens högsta och så vidare. Så för mig är det en indikation att kanske gdp-nummer överstår hur bra ekonomen är nu. Och som jag sa, gdi har följt att vara ett leading indikator i det tiden.
3:28 Speaker 02 Michael, i full transparencia, du är min förmångare från Norge Bank och vi har arbetat på ett uppbyggande makromodeller under gång. Och jag tänker sincerely att du har den bästa modellpacket på earth när det gäller att förkastera grossdomestic produktutveckling överallt på planet. Så om vi ser på din gdp-modell för USA nu, det skrämmer basically recessionen, inte det? Jag tror att vi kan få det upp på skrinen här.
3:54 Speaker 03 Yes, it does, and it has been doing so for a while. And if we look back in the past, basically, it has historically never been wrong when it's pointed to recession. We of course also know that GDP numbers and for that matter, labor market numbers as well, they are a little bit difficult turning points. There tends to be quite large revisions. So we'll see how this plays out. I mean, I tend to follow my models very closely and right now, it's clearly so that the US one has been wrong. But on the other hand, if we look at sort of my Swedish one or my European one, they are continuously spot on in terms of pointing to recession.
4:38 Speaker 03 So I guess the plot has taken.
4:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, it has indeed. And if you look at the current discrepancy between your model and the actual outcomes in the cross domestic problem in the US economy, are there any reasons to sort of believe that the US economy is resilient relative to what we've been used to and what the model sort of used to forecast based on?
5:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, of course, you should always think that your model can crash and there could be periods where other factors are important. I guess one thing right now that could be of importance is both the old stimulus checks from COVID, how much money actually was left of those heading into 2023. And then secondly, in some sense, also the Inflation Reduction Act and kind of the policy effects from that. Those are two reasons that maybe means that the economy is moving along more smoothly
5:41 Speaker 03 than my indicator is pointing to. And on top of that, I guess if you add a little bit of what I've been calling the nominal illusion in terms of looking at other economies that we see that volumes are falling in many countries in terms of industrial orders and so on. It's not true for the nominal side because of inflation. And of course, companies has a bottom line which is nominal and as long as the bottom line looks okay, I think perhaps that is another explanation why it drags on this time.
6:17 Speaker 02 I can actually bring up a chart on that exact effect from the Inflation Reduction Act. I've relabeled it to the Inflation Refueling Act instead. Watching the developments in the US economy right now. It's a chart showing the construction financing across various sub-sectors in the manufacturing sector, it's chart number three. And the financing for manufacturing construction is basically through the roof over the past, say, eight to 12 months here, likely as a consequence, among other things, of the IRA and also the Chips and Science Act. So without that stimulus from the public sector, would the US be in a recession right now?
7:01 Speaker 02 Is that a fair assumption to make, Michael, based on the deficit that we see in the US now compared to peers as well?
7:08 Speaker 03 I would guess so, that that would be the case. Then I guess another point to make here is that, I guess, as Manny pointed to as well, we have a housing market where the existing home sales market is more or less dead because you basically can't move, can't afford sort of higher interest rates. On the other hand, it's still the case that the interest rate on the outstanding stock of mortgage loans are quite low. So in normal circumstances, rate hikes of the significance we see now should have started to affect the economy, but it seems that it might be a longer lead this time. Of course, normally, if you take monetary tightening and look at the maximum negative
7:53 Speaker 03 effect on any economy, it tends to be sort of one and a half year out in time. And of course, the Fed was still hiking rates fairly recently. So I would still think that the lagging effects of the monetary policy tightening will be with us a far way into 2024, in my opinion.
8:16 Speaker 02 If we look at the cyclical components of the US economy relative to the stickier components in, for example, the service sector and the leisure sector, in the healthcare sector and stuff like that, where do you find the manufacturing versus the service sector to be at this juncture in the US economy? I know you have a tremendous chart on truck transportation, chart four, that we can bring up in this discussion.
8:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, it is. I think in general, looking at various types of labor market data, clearly it's been the case, and clearly it's been the case since after the COVID problem started to disappear, that there's been a shift back to services, clearly, after the huge increase in more goods consumption before that. And clearly, the labor market has also been continuously strong. However, there are a lot of indicators, cyclical indicators of the labor market where we're starting to see a change. This is a truck transportation cost. Clearly, it's affected by the yellow bankruptcy. But still, it tends to be a very
9:25 Speaker 03 clear cyclical indicator when employment here starts falling. The same is true with temp jobs that we've seen falling now for a number of months. So, looking at these indicators and looking at kind of the service versus goods side, and kind of the ISM and ISM non-manufacturing, if you want, it still looks like services are keeping up. However, with the monetary tightening, I would suspect that those things are now turning the other way, while perhaps the manufacturing cycle, looking at the ISM, could be bottoming at some point here. And what the net effect there will be for markets is quite tricky to say. I would say still, of course, if you look at the service sector in the US,
10:07 Speaker 03 it's like 85% of the economy. So if that slows down the way I expect, that's an effect of higher interest rates and cash flow effects on that down the line, then that would be more important. But markets often have a tendency to look at a lot of manufacturing data as well.
10:24 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone. We're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:36 Speaker 02 Michael, you're obviously based in Stockholm, Sweden. And I guess Sweden is one of the most interest rate sensitive countries on earth. I think that's fair to say, also given the exposure to variable interest rates in mortgages, et cetera. So as international investors, is there anything that we can learn from the developments that we've seen in the Swedish economy, say, over the past one or two quarters here?
11:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think so. I mean, it's been so in the past that Sweden has relatively often been a little bit of a canary in the coal mine for the global economy. So when Sweden is running into problems, which we have been doing now for a while, then it's usually an early sign that you'll see other parts of the world going the same way, kind of like Germany is doing now and what have you. And of course, one part of that is the small, open economy that Sweden is, with a large export sector that fairly early picks up on trends turning either positively or negatively. And then the second part is what you alluded to, which is households having higher debt here than elsewhere,
11:46 Speaker 03 and a lot of variable rate loans, particularly on the mortgage side. So when we see rate hikes here in Sweden, it tends to affect the house prices quite directly, and house prices then leading to also affecting consumption. So of course, what we have been seeing in Sweden is a clear slump in personal consumption over the past year or so, and in retail sales. And what we now are seeing is basically a full stop on more the construction side, where building permits have plummeted and we now see clearly a much lower activity.
12:26 Speaker 03 On the export side, I think also it's important to note that Swedish companies that are held by a very weak currency still now see in various business services that the order intake, the new order intake, is deteriorating quite rapidly, while they still have fairly good order books with old orders, basically stemming back from the Covid years. So I think the fact that Sweden is in a recession and will continuously be in a recession into 2024 is to me an early sign that the rest of the world will follow.
13:02 Speaker 02 I think we can bring up a chart on that exact new order survey from Sweden. It's chart number six and it doesn't look pretty, to say the least, with recessionary vibes since late last year and obviously also given the forward-looking nature of this survey with recessionary vibes into next year. If you look at the German economy, obviously one that is tracked by many also in the US, Michael, what do you make of the current state of affairs in Germany and the recession risks in the eurozone overall? Are we already there?
13:41 Speaker 03 Germany, I think so. I mean, unemployment bottomed, I don't know exactly, but maybe six months ago or something and has increased since. GDP is negative in Germany year over year, even though it's a small negative. I guess the whole euro area isn't really there yet, but clearly Germany is. And of course, in Germany, we see similar signs as Sweden, but with a little bit of a lag in terms of the real estate market moving into problems. And also here nowadays, building permits plummeting in a way that basically is telling us that construction will be basically dead for 2024. And so Germany is really following a lot of what we're seeing in Sweden. We've seen quite weak order numbers out.
14:27 Speaker 03 The IFO that started to bounce up as the energy crisis was getting less severe has now turned down again, following, I would say, once again, the monetary tightening rulebook, i.e. with kind of one to one and a half years lag, or rather one and a half years lag. You should expect the monetary tightening to hit the economy and particularly start to hit the service sector, which we're also starting to see now in PMIs around Europe.
14:56 Speaker 02 One of the key themes in our campaign over these two weeks is how to profit from this crash or boom binary scenario, Michael. And I received the latest copy of Bank of America's Fund Manager Survey today. They conduct this survey among money managers each and every month. And they, for example, ask the managers for their current positioning relative to benchmarks. And I noted that Europe is truly out of fashion again in this survey, while the US is among the top picks. So when we talk about the US economy being more resilient than Europe, it may already be priced in, at least if we listen to this Fund Manager Survey.
15:39 Speaker 02 So what do you make of the positioning also with your sparing partners in Northern Europe? Is the US still the consensus long story out there?
15:49 Speaker 03 I think so. And I guess talking about Europe and saying it's easier to have people believe in you when you say that Europe is heading into recession compared to saying the same about the US. And I think that also is clearly what you see in positioning. And of course, Europe, if you look at forward P on the median company in Europe and the median company in US, I trying to scale away these magnificent seven, then Europe is looking cheap, very cheap compared to history. But of course, the reason is that everyone believes that, or everyone most believe that
16:31 Speaker 03 Europe is in a recession, while almost everyone believes that the US will not be. And then you end up with that type of position and that type of relative valuation, in a sense. And then I guess what I'm saying is that I expect the US to follow Europe down into recession and then this quite large valuation difference compared to history perhaps looks too large.
16:55 Speaker 02 Yeah. Fair point, Michael. And where does China rank in all of this? I went to the US, was it three, four months ago, with my front page of the slide deck stating that Chinese assets are the cheapest on earth. And there might be a reason why they're the cheapest on earth, but how do you rank China in all of this also, given what's ongoing in Chinese real estate?
17:22 Speaker 03 I mean, looking at China and sort of my view was heading into 2023 that when we were starting to see this reopening story, that that would falter, which it to some extent has done now, partly because of the property market and the real estate market and very much for domestic reasons. But I guess also in a sense which you can see now and that is that imports from China to the US has basically slumped, which seems to be at least partly a political story, I would assume, which means that to my mind, it would be
18:03 Speaker 03 difficult to sort of believe in this reopening story fully. And I guess now that has turned out to be true at this instant. I mean, that doesn't mean that that that things will continue to look that that way. And of course, now we are seeing a lot of measures being taken. So I've been cautious about China, which has been correct in a sense. But now everyone is getting very bearish, on the other hand. So maybe I think it's time to scale back on that bearishness and hawkishness because of everyone else. And and I have to note that what we've seen recently is is the the the Bank of China adding a lot of liquidity through their open market operations. And when we've seen that in the past, it has
18:47 Speaker 03 at least temporarily created a cushion for the equity market and equities have tended to go up a little bit during those periods in China. It has a very strong link between what the PBOC is doing with these open market operations and the stock market. So that makes me a lot less negative than I was if you go back three, four months on it. And we'll see about that.
19:14 Speaker 02 If we look at the current price developments in oil space in particular, but also in broader commodities, we've seen a tendency towards higher prices over the past couple of months now. And it may be related to a rebound in China. We're not fully sort of certain of that story yet. But what do you make of this spike in commodity prices, given that we are, if not amidst, and at least on the verge of a recession around the West?
19:45 Speaker 03 No, it looks a little bit odd, I have to admit, and particularly with my more negative tilt. And but of course, prices are what they are, and oil prices are booming here.
19:56 Speaker 03 And it's also a little bit different to see in terms of the balance of demand and supply right now on the oil market. But so whether how much this is speculation or not, we will see. But it clearly doesn't rhyme fully with my more negative tilt. However, of course, my negative tilt is right now more tilted towards kind of service sectors and consumption sides of the economy, perhaps rather than the manufacturing side. But anyway, so it looks a little bit odd, but I guess and and and the sort of side effect of it will likely be that right now, when when a lot of investors and a lot of
20:37 Speaker 03 economists are expecting that we basically have passed the peak now in terms of Fed Funds target rates, and for that matter, I guess the same is true what the market is counting for the ECB. I guess this is something that could change that, because what will happen now is, of course, on the back of this increase, we will see all the classic price components of ISMs and PMIs shooting up again, and perhaps shooting up quite markedly. And and and that is something that normally, I guess, the bond market and central banks do not like. We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
21:21 Speaker 02 I had a tremendous discussion with Hugh Hendry, the former hedge fund manager at Real Vision, a couple of months ago on how to tail hedge for a recession in the US. And he was of the view that calls on TLTs, or the far end of the yield curve in the US, made sense also from a price perspective at the point if you wanted to hedge yourself against that recession risk. But given the price spikes that we see in oil space, given the lack of true progress towards that 2% inflation target, can one hide in bonds into such a recession in the US here, Michael? Is it as safe bet as it used to be?
22:02 Speaker 03 It's less safe, let's say it like that. And I would have agreed with him. And I mean, if I go back here and, you know, think about what I was, what my focus was then, I back then guessed that by now it would be more clear that also the US was entering recession and that that would lead to a clear bond rally. However, as time has progressed, you know, I've come to the conclusion that that's probably too early, which it has been so far. And clearly now, a lot of my leading inflation indicators, and you know a lot of them, I mean, they're not looking as benign as they did before. I have a US CPI model that looks, you know, six months out to something.
22:46 Speaker 03 And for the US, and basically it's, it picked the development very well on the way up and very well on the way down. Now it's saying that it's not going to improve anymore. We're going to have a US CPI at above 3% also the early parts of next year. And that makes, of course, a more difficult situation if you want to be a bond bull. Clearly, at the end of the day, however, if we get the more severe recession, that will definitely seal the deal for bonds, I think. But for now, what I've been saying since before the summer is that the risk and sort of the trend for the bond yields would continue to be up. Because central banks are quite clear with the idea that whatever happens in terms of where the peak
23:30 Speaker 03 is in policy rates, rate cuts are very, very far away. And as said, it's such. And then looking at today with all the inflation indicators, perhaps, you know, signaling that it's not going to be as easy to get inflation down next year. Then you end up with the risk that we should see new highs on the US 10-year yield again here. Before, if I'm right, there's a recession scenario comes into play perhaps around year end or something.
24:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, I basically lean the same way. And earlier today, we got the monthly survey from the NFIB. Basically, a survey conducted among small and medium sized companies in the US. Eighty percent services based ish. And the price plans ahead actually re-increased in the survey again. So when they look three, six months ahead, the CEOs of these small, medium sized companies, they actually expect both compensation of employees and price plans to be a tad higher than they did just a couple of months ago. It may be related to the commodity price spike. But it basically rhymes with what you're saying, Michael, that we will get at least
24:44 Speaker 02 a local bottom clearly above two percent in US inflation. So in relation to the market pricing right now of the Federal Reserve, no one believes in a hike here in September, but there's still, I'd say, a decent chance priced in for another hike this year, but then next year, cuts, cuts, cuts, right? So what do you make of that cocktail? Is it too early to price that, all of that in, given the recession risks?
25:08 Speaker 03 I think so. And I think what we will continue to hear from the Fed and for that matter, from the ECB is that they will disagree with the discounting of rate cuts next year. And basically sending the signal that 2024, we will be on hold.
25:25 Speaker 03 And so we need to see a lot more evidence of the recession and particularly the US recession before you can embrace a more bond friendly environment and a more normal cyclical bond rally. I mean, if you look at macro, if you build a macro models on kind of long yields or five, 10 year yields for the US and look at it right now, with inflation where it is, where the labor market where it is, where wage growth where it is, with the Fed where it is, you should expect bond yields actually to be clearly higher than they are today. So let's call it the macro magnet is still for higher yields. So as long as the economy, you know, moves along nicely here, yields should continue to climb.
26:11 Speaker 03 We need to see those clearly higher unemployment numbers, I would suspect, before we get into a more bond friendly environment.
26:19 Speaker 02 If we look at some of your forward-looking employment models for the US, I know that you've typically used job openings as an early indicator of non-farm payrolls further down the road. What do you make of the job opening gauge right now, given that we've entered a slide from a very, very, very elevated level of job openings? Is it still a feasible indicator to watch?
26:45 Speaker 03 I guess we will see. I think so, because, yes, we entered it with a very high number of job openings. But we also entered it with a very high employment to population ratio in the US. So, of course, that rhymes. So the starting point is one where we've had a lot more people employed versus the population than historically. So in that sense, even if it's dropping from a high level of job openings, it should still have an effect, as far as I can see. And particularly now, when we're also starting to see layoffs actually increase in the challenging statistics or data, I think so too. And what I find very important right now, and which it has historically been,
27:30 Speaker 03 as I see it, very important coincident indicator is that households within the Consumer Confidence Survey now is signaling that it's starting to get harder to get a job. So the so-called job B C versus job sort to get component is now moving in the wrong direction. And that has historically been a very, very strong indication that the unemployment is about to start rising.
27:56 Speaker 02 If we look at the risk of rising unemployment relative to the equity market, one of the discussions you and I have had over the course of the past year, actually, is whether the actual timing of rising unemployment is the actual timing of a new sell-off in equity markets. What do you make of that comparison at this juncture? Is it feasible to expect that markets will sell off once unemployment actually kicks in?
28:28 Speaker 03 Yeah, that would be my guess. I mean, if we go back a bit and look at the bear market that was in 2022, I guess that was, compared to history, the odd bear market, because it happened when the economy was still doing fine.
28:46 Speaker 03 Driven by interest rates going up in a way that the equity market had not expected. And it was a valuation story. But if you look at more traditional bear markets for the last 25 years or so,
29:00 Speaker 03 they have normally not happened until unemployment has started to move up. So that's true both for the early 2000s setback in the equity market and also the financial crisis. So the key indicator in the past have been rising unemployment. And I think that boils down to two things. The first thing is that it's when unemployment starts to increasing, starts increasing that people will get more worried about the earnings outlook and not just believing that it's going to be a small bump in the road. So I think that's one part of it. The other part is, of course, that when as unemployment starts to increasing, that's also when you normally see households taking out money from the equity market,
29:43 Speaker 03 both because they need them, but also to reduce their risk. And that has been a clear pattern in the past. While this year so far, of course, I would say that the retail money has been piling into the equity market. So to me, I still find that if unemployment starts increases in the way that I believe into next year, then I do think that we have one quite clear leg left in this bear market on equities.
30:10 Speaker 02 If we look at bonds versus equities into such a scenario, Michael, with bonds not looking optimal at this juncture, given that the inflation outlook is still too hot.
30:25 Speaker 03 So you're breaking up, Andreas. I don't know what happened here.
30:29 Speaker 02 I can still hear you at least, Michael, but we'll check the sound while I'll walk the audience through a couple of indicators that relates to the discussion that we just had. In terms of the outlook for prices in the US, we can bring up Chart 9, maybe Mario, where we have the prices paid by. The US big companies in the ISM survey relative to US gasoline prices. And if we look at the gasoline prices lately, obviously, given the spike that we've seen in oil prices, there is a clear possibility that this commodity price spike will spill over
31:10 Speaker 02 to a continued rise in the both prices paid, but also the expectations for selling prices among companies. And I think we frankly only seen the first signs of that re-acceleration in price expectations among companies over the course of the past couple of weeks in surveys. Given what's been ongoing in oil markets, we should probably expect more of the same over the course of the next couple of months until and we find an end to this oil price rally. We briefly touched upon it, Michael and I, this oil price rally and the underlying fundamentals behind it. I can note that the OPEC
31:54 Speaker 02 OPEC basically published their monthly report today with updated projections on the oil market supply and demand during the fourth quarter. Also, given the supply cuts announced by the Saudi Arabian administration just a week ago. And the OPEC report now projects a deficit of 3 million barrels of oil a day throughout the fourth quarter. To me, it looks a tad exaggerated, but it goes without saying that there is a daily deficit in oil markets. And Joe Biden can obviously decide to counter that via the Strategic Petroleum reserves. But in case he decides to do so, he will quickly run out of ammunition.
32:38 Speaker 02 Say that he will decide to release one and a half or 2 million barrels a day. It will leave him with no ammunition left in maybe 150 days to 200 days from now, way before the election. So to me, cynically speaking, that sounds like an odd timing. It seems like we have you back, Michael. Yes, I hope so. I was referring to the OPEC reporter released earlier today citing the risk of a 3 million barrel Deficit a day in the oil market. And one of the things that we've had questions on over the course of the past weeks here on the platform is whether Joe Biden will be willing to sort of counter that by the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. So do we have any strong views on whether we should expect retaliation from the US administration?
33:21 Speaker 02 Given the decisions taken by both the Russians and the Saudi Arabians on supply cuts?
33:27 Speaker 03 And this is clearly a very tricky question and it is, I would say, outside of what I usually talk about. So I would say that I don't have any informed view. You probably can get an answer from someone else in a better way than than here. So so I think I'll stay with that.
33:46 Speaker 02 Absolutely fair, Michael. Before you lost the connection, I I asked the question that I think you struggled to hear on the relative pricing of equities and bonds in a scenario where inflation struggles to get back to 2%, but a recession is around the corner. So if you look at the relative pricing between bonds and equities with this recession being just around the corner in your base case, what do you make of the relative pricing? What's the best bet if you need to take a bet in either equity or bond space?
34:21 Speaker 03 I would argue here in the short term, it's probably to buy T bills, if anything, to be honest. I mean, if you look at the S and P earnings yield right now, it's trading below a US T bill. And I don't expect the T bill yield to drop in the foreseeable future. Rather, what we're hearing is the risk, they will probably have perhaps even a little bit higher yields going forward and then stay stay at those levels for quite a long time. And of course, with my recession scenario for the US and thereby an extremely low risk premium equity market, I would sort of take that risk free alternative. I mean, looking at if you calculate the equity risk premium for the S and P 500
35:05 Speaker 03 and then looking at US tenure yields as the comparison point and from a forward P, it's now down to about one percentage point. Normally, it used to be around three, between three and four. In recessions, we've seen it spiking to six. So it's a very, very low risk premium ex ante, even in a quite benign scenario. And I would much rather put my money in the risk-free option thereby. Comparing it to bonds is a little bit tricky because of course what I'm saying is that there is a risk that bond yields continue to climb a little bit here, i.e. that you will lose a little bit more. But then I'm clearly in the camp saying that the next larger move
35:49 Speaker 03 in the bond market will be towards lower government bond yields. So but for now, I think I would be happy to take those, you know, T-bil yields.
36:02 Speaker 02 Michael, if if we look at equities on a sector-by-sector basis, we mentioned in the intro that technology could be an odd performer in this environment, at least it has been throughout this year, given the sort of competitiveness and the market power of these mega tech stocks. Do you have any preferences in terms of equity sectors, equity styles that will perform better than others in this kind of environment?
36:29 Speaker 03 I think what we have been advising our clients into this year has been that, given that we have a view of an earnings recession and an earnings recession that will be with us for longer than the analysts have been indicating and of course now with the no-landings scenario that many has, that basically analysts are saying that is over now. What we've been saying is that what you should look at is not so much sectors and things like that. But normally, what performs during that type of environment is what we would call quality stocks. And what are quality stocks? Well, there are a number of quality traits, but
37:12 Speaker 03 the two that usually sticks out are companies with a very strong free cash flow yield and companies that has shown stability when it comes to return on capital employed. Those types of companies are the companies that historically during recessions have been the ones that have been performing. And even though it's been A quite odd equity market this year with more equally weighted indices basically treading water since January and I guess the Nordic index for instance is basically down actually since early December. Quality stocks have been a place to hide. If you take the MSCI
37:51 Speaker 03 quality definition, there's been a clear outperformance of quality stocks compared to the to the market. And also you can see in the Nordics that that the quality stocks have performed a little bit better than the market, not much. But clearly, if you have avoided sort of the bottom companies in terms of quality, then you would have done very well as well. So I continue to point to the the fact that if we are right, that this earnings recession, that analysts now are assuming is over, that we will have more legs to the downside into 2024, then it's quality you should look for.
38:28 Speaker 02 If we look at this discussion on the cyclical component of the US economy relative to the stickier component in services, do you find any value in the spread between cyclical equities and non-cyclical equities given this discussion, Mike?
38:46 Speaker 03 Yeah, clearly. And of course, what we've seen now is that cyclicals have fared a lot better for a while and then defensives in the US and also globally, which rhymes with the fact that at least up until now, GDP numbers and labor market numbers are indicating that we aren't in a recession. But of course, in in in in my scenario, looking ahead like six, nine months, then we should come back to a a a period where sectors of more defensive characters should outperform. That's usually what happens up until the day that the authorities turn around fully and go all in in terms of stimulus. And then everything, you know,
39:28 Speaker 03 turns around. But but clearly, in all previous recessions, you had you you you should have hidden in in in more defensive sectors. And we're simply not there yet. But I think that that would also be something that that that worked very well during the bear market in 2022. I think it will work very well if we go back to more cyclical recessionary in bear markets.
39:53 Speaker 02 Michael, in relation to this discussion on whether and when authorities will go all in to counter this recession scenario, our CEO Raoul spoke about it yesterday, that ultimately it is very hard to imagine a scenario where authorities will not backstop asset prices, given the level of debt globally and all that. What do you make of, say, the potential for QE over the next 12 to 24 months, given that we have these struggles of bringing inflation back to target? Is it a game changer for global central banks? Could we actually face a recessionary environment in assets without them going all in saving assets?
40:37 Speaker 03 I have no illusions here. So I mean, I would guess that if they once upon a time have decided that QE is a good thing, they could definitely push that button again. That I agree with fully. However, I would assume that they wouldn't want to do that as long as they feel that inflation is a true problem. And for me, that means that it should take longer before any such decisions than it has been doing, than has been the case since the financial crisis. Because of course, now we're seeing potentially at least the dark side of QE, and I guess particularly the dark side of QE combined with fiscal
41:20 Speaker 03 policy measures. So it should take longer this time in my sense. And I also have the feeling that, I mean, central banks, it should be a lot less willing to push down real yields into very negative territory again.
41:40 Speaker 02 And pardon my French here, Michael, but you're a bit older than I am, and you probably have a bit of experience from markets where fiscal policy played a bigger role in defining asset prices and economic trends. So is it a game changer that fiscal policy is back as a tool in the toolbox for both the US administration, but also for the European administrations with bigger deficits than what we're used to?
42:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, game changer, game changer. I mean, clearly, it's they've at least now that also showed itself during the kind of energy crisis that we had last year that it's it's getting easier to push push through those stimulus packages than it perhaps was for a long, long period, despite the fact that that's already very, very high. And and what the end game in that is, I don't have a clue, but but but clearly, and they also had this kind of, of course, odd cycle where basically the debt is kind of financed through their own central banks, which you can feel is perhaps not the best way of doing it if
42:49 Speaker 03 you want to get the long term, you know, the long the long term trends in a better shape. But but but, yes, I think we saw it when when when energy prices spiked, that they're willing to go in with with with also in in Europe with with various packages to help that out. And of course, we have the Inflation Reduction Act in the U.S. now and so on. So it's probably part of the picture. And right now, of course, interest rates haven't shot up massively. So that that we have some inflation now, as as long as bond deals do not spike further here, of course, it kind of deflate, sorry, inflates away some of
43:32 Speaker 03 the debt. But here, clearly, the risk is, of course, that the bond market at some point will say that now enough is enough. And if bond deals start spiking more viciously, then this trick will will end in tears in terms of sort of fiscal policy, as a as one of the more active measure to counter stuff.
43:54 Speaker 02 Michael, I'll allow you to conclude on how you see the recession risk risks being priced in across assets and geographies before we bring Maggie back for the Q and A session as the last part of of this show for the hour here. So, Michael, where where is the recession priced in? Where is it not priced in in a few words?
44:17 Speaker 03 But I guess it's starting to get priced in in Swedish real estate. We can start there. You know, that slumped massively last year and clearly, you know, as I've seen the recession happening as well. So that would be one where it is priced in. Otherwise, I don't think it is that much priced in more or less anywhere in a sense. You could claim it's partly priced in in Europe with valuation levels a lot lower than, for instance, in the US. But still, if you would calculate the equity risk premium also in Europe, it's still very low for a recession scenario.
44:57 Speaker 03 So I would say it is, it's not priced in. And then if you then turn to sort of the corporate bond market. I mean, right now, if you have an investment grade 10-year bond on the corporate side in the US, it's trading basically in line with a T-bill yield. So you don't really get paid to take on any risk there as well. And spreads have, of course, tightened also in the high yield space. So it's very difficult to say that there are any recession scenario discounted there. And of course, we talked about the US market and what normally happens. And that is that risk premiums tend to spike between three and four percentage points in recessions. And currently, they are at the cyclical low.
45:42 Speaker 03 So they haven't even increased at all. So that is also why I would prefer to stay very, very, you know, boring and buy a T. T-bill, sorry.
45:56 Speaker 02 Maggie, I know that you've been tracking the chats and commentary sections for questions. So anything that pops up as the question of the hour here?
46:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think so. We've got an issue that sort of been lurking in the background in terms of risks. By the way, fascinating conversation. I think the timing of this recession has just been so difficult. So great, great charts on that. Kyle asking, could it be that CRE, commercial real estate, hasn't repriced due to the lack of liquidity and the sector is holding on to the Fed cuts rates? But what happens if the dot plots start moving for 24 or higher due to energy? So this issue of that maybe being delayed, what you see coming. Michael, how long can CRE funds gate redemptions?
46:46 Speaker 03 No, I mean, that's a billion-dollar question, of course, even more than that, I would assume. I mean, we can make the analogy with Sweden, which of course has had borrowing much shorter in on the yield curve in a sense. And what we see here, of course, is that for a while, yes, things will keep together, but as long the longer that the period is with high interest rates, you will have to roll your debt. And you will end up in problems. And of course, that is true for the CRE market in the US as well. And at this juncture, at least I don't interpret the Fed as being that worried about it,
47:29 Speaker 03 which tells me that there could be a period, exactly what you described, that they push up the dot plus because of inflation trends and then at some point, you know that you need to roll your debt and then you get into problem and it could become clearly a much bigger issue than it is today. Then, of course, I'm no CRE expert in the US, but we can see what's been happening, going on in the Swedish market and what's now going on in Germany, which could be a little bit of a leading indicator of what could happen in the US.
48:00 Speaker 01 Andreas, you have any thoughts on that?
48:02 Speaker 02 So I perfectly agree with Michael that everything that we see trend-wise in Sweden and Germany right now will likely arrive in the US with a time lag due to the differences in the duration of interest rate hedges of CRE companies in the US relative to Sweden, for example. I've worked for the second biggest asset manager within the real estate space in Europe until a year ago or so. And it is my impression that the typical interest rate coverage is so the amount of cash flow that you generate as a CRE company relative to the interest rate payments will approach one, that ratio, throughout the course of 2024 without rate cuts in Germany and Sweden on a sector basis.
48:47 Speaker 02 Meaning that they will only generate the exact cash flows to pay interest rates. Good luck paying your employees after that, right? It is a big mess if we do not get rate cuts in Europe for this sector. And ultimately, this will arrive with probably an eighteen to twenty-four months time lag in the US due to longer duration profiles. And I honestly, much more prudent risk management within CRE companies in the US relative to Sweden. So yes, actually CRE companies have been much more prudent than European peers ahead of this interest rate hike.
49:20 Speaker 01 Michael, it brings up a good point, though. I think that the sort of behind that question is, if you think there's a deeper recession coming, it's just taking longer to get here. Does it break something, right? Is it the labor market that has to break? I mean, he's there of asking, is commercial real estate going to break? That's kind of what everyone's looking for. What craters? And then does that bring central banks in? That's the tricky part.
49:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, and it is clearly a very important question. Again, comparing to Sweden, I guess what we're seeing here is that the real estate side of things are cracking clearly. However, it hasn't had so far any broader consequences for the whole economy. And at this point, the central bank or the Riksbank is very, very, it's not that worried about it. And I guess that comes back to that what we're seeing is, of course, that real estate companies are moving more into bank financing. And banks, I would say, generally speaking, in Sweden and for that matter in the US, of course, they have a lot better balance sheets today than they had ahead of the financial crisis
50:33 Speaker 03 and can cope with it in another way. I think that's one part of why it's not so worrying right now. And even though I sort of come across as very gloomy here, I understand that and I'm happy to be that. I'm not foreseeing a sort of a financial crisis type of scenario. To me, this is more of a, I would call it a speed bump recession in terms of when you hike interest rates as fast as you've been doing, something will give in terms of the cycle at some point. Now that timing is, as you say, very, very difficult. Uh, but if you look at, once again, the normal patterns between monetary tightening and the economy,
51:14 Speaker 03 it should occur, the worst part of it should be towards the middle of next year and a bit later than that. But as I said, to me, this is not the financial crisis two point zero. It's it's more of a regular recession, but with the added uh uh problem that risk premiums in very, in in large parts of of of the asset market is very, very low. Uh, and and and I doubt that they would be able to swallow even a normal recession.
51:40 Speaker 01 Hmm, that's a great point. And so Joseph asking, um, I know you talked about hiding in T bills, you know, given this outlook. And Joseph asking, do you have a forecast for gold? How do you feel about gold?
51:52 Speaker 03 That's a typical Andreas question.
51:54 Speaker 01 I see Andreas laughing, by the way.
51:56 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, by.
51:57 Speaker 01 He's been sneaking in the chat as Joseph. No, he was too busy.
52:02 Speaker 02 No, I'm I'm always long gold to a certain extent, um, but not by a large percentage of of my portfolio. Uh, and I've actually scaled down a bit on gold uh over the course of this year due to the, I think, lack of transparency on when we will get uh financial repression back from central banks. Gold likes a an environment of low interest rates and high inflation, but gold does not necessarily like an environment of high interest rates and high inflation. Uh, so it it it matters whether central banks will continue to hike or not for this gold case. But if if we're going to sniff out an early move towards some sort of orchestrated coordinated pause
52:48 Speaker 02 from central banks across the globe, then you better get your gold longs ready. Um, but I'm I'm not there yet, but I'm I'm getting there, I'd say.
52:57 Speaker 01 Michael, what about you?
52:59 Speaker 03 No, I think Andreas has a very good point here. Given that real rates have been going up quite significantly, and I talk about long, expected long-term real rates, not in the short run of the yield curve. Normally, you would have expected gold to do a lot worse than it has. And I guess that comes down to partly what Andreas is saying, that as long as inflation is high, people still see it as an inflation hedge. And I guess, secondly, that there are still a lot of people out there, I guess, be included, seeing that what sort of the end game of all this should be some sort of crash for assets. And then you're often very, very, you know, then gold is somewhere to hide as well.
53:41 Speaker 03 But of course, if we are in a situation where real yields continue to climb and stay high, at some point, that would probably be problematic for gold. But here and now, given my more gloomy view on the economy and gloomy view on kind of the, I mean, it's kind of a stagflationary idea that I have, that then I guess gold would probably be fine.
54:05 Speaker 01 Yeah. So, and that's exactly what I'm walking away from this, Andreas. I'd love to get your thoughts. It does sound like you do see an economic downturn. You're looking at Sweden, some of the early signs in Europe. It's just lag to get here in the US, but inflation's a problem in the near term. Those prices being sticky are going to keep the Fed with rates higher for longer, and that's going to be a problem. And neither stocks or bonds look like a good place. It's too early for the bond move, so you've got to hide in the short end in T-bills to try to get that return. Does that match up with your thoughts? And Andreas, what are your takeaways from this conversation?
54:48 Speaker 02 I guess the main takeaway is that a payroll recession is still very likely in the US. So the 80% of the economy related to the service sector will likely struggle into next year as a consequence of rising input costs from labor relative to what they're able to get for their products. If we look at historical recessions, we've often seen how the price of labor has sort of outpaced the overall price inflation during inflection points. And it is exactly what Michael is alluding to here, that wage growth is too high and the cost base will likely drag down the labor market into next year. And I perfectly concur with that view.
55:28 Speaker 02 If you want to find pockets of strength in this kind of economy, take a look at how sales to employee ratios have boomed for the energy sector. They're making a truckload of money and they have no employees. That's essentially exactly what you want to invest in into next year, in my opinion.
55:48 Speaker 01 Michael, any closing thoughts from you?
55:51 Speaker 03 I mean, I think as a final comment, it is, to me, still, the big problem in markets is kind of a risk premium problem. And entering a cyclical downturn, it's never a good idea, usually to own assets with a very, very low risk premium. And I see a low risk premium basically both in the equity market and in corporate bonds. And even in a more benign scenario, the risk premium will still look very, very low.
56:23 Speaker 01 Gentlemen, thank you both. Fantastic conversation. You couldn't have named your research paper better. The plot thickens indeed. We're gonna have to steal that all week, Michael. Thank you. Thank you both.
56:36 Speaker 02 Thank you.
56:37 Speaker 01 Listen, keep the conversation going. We're reading all the comments. It's been fantastic, fantastic. Next up in the series, I'm gonna sit down with David Rosenberg and Lizanne Sanders. It's gonna be super interesting to get their view on what's ahead. David Rosenberg has sort of believed we're already in recession, so super interested to get an update on that from him. That's happening at 11:00 AM Eastern on Wednesday. And of course, we'll be back at 4:00 PM today with the daily briefing. We hope to see you all then. Thanks so much.
57:11 Speaker 04 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest, and biggest names in finance.
Previous Crash or Boom: Week 2 Wrap-Up Next Energy Crisis Part II? Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated