Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Debt Ceiling, Are You Ready For It? w/ Peter Boockvar About this episode Peter Boockvar, Chief Investment Officer of Bleakley Financial Group and Editor of The Boock Report, joins Maggie Lake to break down recent remarks from the Federal Reserve, provide valuable insight into retail earnings, and identify potential areas of strength in the economy. More of Peter’s work at https://t.co/x9RdjtPQus Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey, everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:33 Speaker 01 The debt ceiling, are you ready for it? And hi, everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. With me today is Peter Bookvar, Chief Investment Officer at Bleakley Financial Group and editor of the book report. Hi, Peter.
0:44 Speaker 02 Hi, Maggie. Thanks for having me.
0:46 Speaker 01 Thanks for being on. We always love to see you. I feel like we're all in wait-and-see mode. We have Republican House Speaker Kevin McCarthy scheduled to meet in 90 minutes with President Biden to see if they can get a deal on raising the US debt ceiling and avoiding default. And the prevailing wisdom seems to be, at least in the market, seems to be that there will be a deal, even if it's ugly and drawn out at the 11th hour, they'll get one done. Is that the outcome? Is that what your sense that that's what the market's betting on? And is that wise?
1:19 Speaker 02 I mean, there will be a deal, just like there is always a deal. But I think there are sort of two different things that are going on that just investors generally have to prepare for. One is sort of logistics in the sense of if I own a T-bill that is maturing call between June 1 and June 15, so-called, you know, X-state range, and I need access to that cash on call it June 5, because I'm closing on a house June 6. And if there's a day or two of disruption, and I can't get my cash for that closing, then
2:03 Speaker 02 I have a problem. I don't expect, first of all, I expect a deal. You know, you're talking about two sides that are talking tough, but at the end of the day, no one wants to preside over not making an interest payment on a particular day. But let's just say we go there. I don't expect that to last more than a day or two. So this is all going to be bluster, as it always is. And then we'll wait a year or two and have this happen all over again. Stretching this out, though, I think it's sort of unveiling a bigger challenge for the US government and possibly markets in that it's exposing, obviously, how much debt
2:48 Speaker 02 we have. Not that we need this to expose it, you can go to a debt lock and see it. But looking at the US budget deficit as a percentage GDP, right now, we're at levels that usually coincides with the trough of a recession rather than a level that we're on the cusp of one, at 7.3%. And also, we have the dynamics of the Fed is selling Treasuries essentially through QT, banks are no longer loading up, foreign or central banks have been net sellers, and at the same time, to finance that budget deficit, which is 7.3%
3:30 Speaker 02 as a percentage GDP is at the end of April, we have a lot of supply. And once that debt ceiling gets raised, you're going to have a flood of supply in a very confined period of time as the Treasury refills their general accounts. I've seen estimates up to 500 billion within a month or two, and the worth of a trillion within the following six to 12 months. And just for perspective, the TGA is down to about 90 billion is each day and week that progresses from here, that'll get whittled down to zero. So what this all means in the short term is we're going to have the Treasury issue
4:10 Speaker 02 a lot of bonds over the coming couple of months. That will suck money out of the private sector, because that's where the financing comes from, and maybe that means that it gets diverted from other places like the stock market, we'll have to see. Again, past this, it's going to matter for what does the US dollar do, and can the US government continue to finance themselves at current levels, or do we need higher rates in order for them to do so?
4:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, which brings up a really, really interesting, critical point because we have the market anticipating that rates are going to go lower, right? I mean, that's what the forecast is.
4:52 Speaker 02 Well, I think the short end, the market definitely pricing in rate cuts after probably the Fed being done, even though they're certainly teasing us with maybe one more, or even if you're James Bullard, two more rate hikes. Now, we've reduced a bit of those odds and that we're only pricing in now maybe one hike by the end of this year, but a bunch next year. But the long end, you know, I have, I do my own work, but I listen to some other people, and I'm quite amazed that the confidence that some people have on where the 10-year yield is going to go. And that is because they're only looking at US growth
5:35 Speaker 02 and inflation and saying, inflation's slowing down, growth, we're going to recession, therefore you have to buy the 10-year yields are going down. And I just wish it was that easy of an analysis. I mean, look, today, the 10-year yield is closing at 372. And in my opinion, the economic growth story is only deteriorating. So I see slower growth, I see a tightening credit situation, and yields have gone up. So what does that tell you about the state of things? I can argue that the 10-year goes to 3% or even below, if we're just looking at growth and inflation. But I can argue that the 10-year goes to 4.5% and not for
6:17 Speaker 02 good reason. And I think we're getting a little bit of a taste of it over the past couple of weeks with this rise in the 10-year. And that we're, bigger picture, and maybe I'm speaking a little hyperbolic here, sorry, but we're unwinding the greatest financial bubble in the history of bubbles, and that's in sovereign bonds. So I just discount when some people have this very confident call on where the 10-year yield goes. I can be confident of where the short end goes because that's tied to Fed policy. But if we can in the next three months wake up and The Japanese wide and yield curve control, the ECB, as they further tighten and do QT, they lose some control of their bond market. The Bank of England is outright selling gilts,
7:01 Speaker 02 and maybe they run into an issue again. And the exploding debts and deficits in the US, the 10-year can easily go above 4, and not for good reason. So that's very much the wild card is the long end. Short end, yes, we can argue that rates will go down into next year. But, and then the whole conversation related to that is, how much will they go down if we do go into recession? And how much will the Fed be able to respond to that?
7:30 Speaker 01 That is such an important point that you just made. I just want to sort of underscore, underscore, put a note and a pin in that, because you don't hear a lot of people talking about that. And it's, except our really smart viewers, because right before you started, David Kelly asked, hello Peter, will there be ample buyers of Treasury once the debt limit is raised? So let me ask you, and I think you laid out a great argument of that, that that's not clear unless they, unless the rates go up, the yield goes up to attract those buyers. Do you think it's because there's just so much supply coming on? Or is this a bigger picture of just less demand for US Treasuries moving forward? Is it the glut?
8:15 Speaker 01 Or is it the overall attractiveness of US Treasuries?
8:19 Speaker 02 Well, it's definitely a glut, for sure. And then can that glut be absorbed? And, you know, it's going to be absorbed, but it's just a matter of what price. But losing the Fed as a buyer is a big deal. Losing foreign central banks as a buyer is a big deal. Losing the banks is a big deal. But on the other hand, insurance companies, pension funds are seeing yields they haven't seen in years. And we know money is flooding into money markets. Now, money markets, of course, are buying the short end. They're not buying the long end. But in terms of looking at the long end, are there enough buyers to offset? And it's very
9:01 Speaker 02 unclear at what the clearing price is for that supply to get absorbed. And that's why I push back on people that have so much confidence of where the 10-year yield goes. I think that it's just much more uncertain, as I stated.
9:21 Speaker 01 No, absolutely. So you mentioned before just the amount of debt that we're looking at heading into recession, not coming out. And I'm assuming a lot of that is related to the massive pandemic, you know, fiscal pandemic payouts and support. Isn't everyone in the same boat? I mean, the US is facing this, but isn't everyone kind of facing it because of what happened with the pandemic?
9:48 Speaker 02 Oh, for sure. But the US government, over two years, spent $5 trillion, which at the time was, what, a quarter GDP. The Europeans did not. Now, the Europeans have created a sort of a slush fund, I would call it, between loans and grants. But as a percent of the eurozone, or even EU GDP, was a fraction. It was really the US government that went hog wild with the spending relative to the size of our economy. I mean, we can just look back in 2020, and, you know, those collecting initial claims, that half the people that
10:32 Speaker 02 were collecting them were making more on unemployment than they were previously on their jobs. So our GDP has gone somewhat exponential here relative to, or I should say, our debt relative to GDP has gotten definitely exponential here, it seems.
10:52 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone. We're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
11:05 Speaker 01 So there, I think that we had Jared Dillian on. Some people are talking about in the chat, so I want to bring it up. We had him on, and I think he was touching on something similar, but just sort of saying, listen, the 10-year yield could go to 10%. I mean, just threw that out there. But is there, you said you don't know what the clearing price for that treasury supply to be absorbed is. But is there a range you're looking at? Or are we really kind of in uncharted territory?
11:32 Speaker 02 I mean, right now, it's, I'll take the easy way out, and I'll say three and a half to four and a half. But I think what's most important here is if we break above 4% in the 10-year, it's not for good reason. It's not because the US economy is growing in size again to its normalized rate of call it 2% to 3% and everything is fine. It's going to be because of the things that we talked about, but also maybe because inflation remains really sticky. I was talking about inflation in April, May 2020, when the supermarket shelves were empty.
12:15 Speaker 02 But so I would consider myself more hawkish when it comes to inflation. But I acknowledge that inflation is moderating and it will continue to through the end of the year. But when you go like this, you usually come down like this. The question is, is when you get to the other side, where does it settle out in? And I just don't believe, analysis that I've done, that inflation is going to settle out at 1% to 2% again. And that's going to be the sustainable rate of inflation for the next couple of years. I firmly believe it's going to be something more than like 3% to 4%. Well, in a 3% to 4% new world inflationary environment, while it's below where it is
12:55 Speaker 02 now, and certainly well below the 9% ish level that we saw last summer, that's a new interest rate regime. That's a new inflationary regime that we haven't seen in a while, that what 10-year yield should we put on that? I would say higher than we are today. So that's my worry, is that we get a rise in long rates and not for good reason.
13:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, I want to ask about the implications of that inflation in a moment. I just want to zip up the debt ceiling part of this discussion because so that's something beyond the sort of short-term headlines that everyone's looking at. That's a really important thing to watch and part of the market. Wondering if you're also thinking about the dollar. My colleague Andreas tackled some of these short-term issues around the debt ceiling in his latest Dino Signals that dropped on the platform. Let's have a listen to a clip from that and then we'll talk on the other side.
13:51 Speaker 03 I think the general narrative out there right now is that stress related to US funding, stress related to treasury markets will lead to a sell-off in the US dollar as a consequence of it. But if we look at the empirical evidence around partial shutdowns over the past few decades, we actually reach the exact opposite conclusion. So let's have a look at the dollar developments around the implementation of partial shutdowns in history. There is a tendency for the dollar to drop a bit ahead of the partial shutdown implementation, but as you can see from the chart here, in none of the four last shutdowns, the dollar
14:34 Speaker 03 has traded at a weaker level 100 days after the implementation of the partial shutdown. So it's essentially a 100% hit ratio, at least if we look at the last four, five instances here, to be long the US dollar from the exact timing of the partial shutdown, which is in very sharp contrast to the overall narrative out there and which is in sharp contrast to the market positioning, because currently we see a lot of active players in the market being short the US dollar in speculative positioning out there. So this could be a true game changer once we get to the point where the dollar trend reverses, if I'm right on my empirical analysis here of what happens in dollar markets once we reach the point where a partial shutdown is very likely.
15:19 Speaker 01 And obviously Andreas is talking about what happens if they have to do a shutdown. If things get messier than we're anticipating, but I love the fact that he points out that the market is sort of very much expecting one thing. It's worth, it's worth thinking about. That full interview, by the way, is available on our platform. If you're not a member, you can scan the QR code so that you can join and get access to all of the great material, including all the Steno signals, which drop weekly. So Peter, how are you thinking about this? Because, you know, as Andreas said, like everyone's kind of betting one way on the dollar. If there's a deal, that risk goes away, but how are you seeing this in the short term play out around the currency?
16:00 Speaker 02 When I look back on the dollar, and he can be right in the short term about how it sort of responds to a disruption, but a disruption is going to be, like I said, just a matter of days. If you look back at the dollar, what's been driving the dollar since 2021, right before it sort of took off? And I'm going to really distinguish here and differentiate the dollar against different currencies, because there's no such thing as king dollar.
16:29 Speaker 01 The dollar, right, exactly. It's always the cross. Weston used to say that all the time.
16:32 Speaker 02 Dollar's strong against some things and really trades like crap against others. So what drove the dollar rally? And the dollar, let's look, okay, let's start by saying, looking at the dollar index, the euro-yen-heavy DXY, where those two currencies make up about almost two-thirds of that index. It was June 2021, when at the FOMC meeting press conference, Jay Powell said, "We're finally thinking about tapering QE." That was the match that lit the fire under the dollar. And the dollar took off right after that meeting and topped out at the end of October 2022,
17:14 Speaker 02 just as the Fed was ending its fourth meeting in a row of 75 basis point rate increases. So the US dollar against the yen, the euro, the British pound, was really just a Fed-driven rally. The Fed was more aggressive than other central banks. But once the market sniffed out, the Fed was about to slow down the pace of the rate increases, that ended the dollar rally. Well, what does that say about the dollar? Okay, so let's talk about now. Two of the largest trading partners of the US economy is Mexico and Canada. Last week, the Mexican peso rose to its highest level against the US dollar since 2016.
17:58 Speaker 02 The Canadian dollar, which is somewhat of a commodity currency and with oil prices down close to 70, Well, in the face of that decline in oil prices, the Canadian dollar's been trading in a range at 135. It's really no different than where it was over the last bunch of years. So there's really no dollar strength against the Canadian dollar. You look at the dollar against some of the Asian currencies. Well, I'm gonna put aside the yuan, because the yuan is trading really off the reopening excitement, and then now there's some reopening reality when it comes to China. But the Singapore dollar is near the higher end of its range. So I don't really see King Dollar. Yeah, maybe there'll be a trade against the euro
18:43 Speaker 02 and the pound, and maybe against the yen. But the yen is being driven by what the BOJ is doing right now, not what the Fed is doing. And now the Fed is just about done raising interest rates and tying back to that budget deficit as a percent of GDP. And if you go back four years, there is a relationship between the dollar and that deficit as a percent of GDP. Outside of the trade, I don't see the upside argument here for the dollar.
19:11 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I just want to be clear, Andreas, I think is being very, because he does these weekly, very specific to the week and the risks, you know, that may result from the debt ceiling. You're talking about a little bit of a, yeah, a little bit of a longer-term thing, which is what the market, it seems like, is also anticipating. So if we are looking at, as you say, the potential where we may see the 10-year rate higher than expected because you've got to draw demand for treasuries, what are the implications for the real economy if we have a 10-year sitting at 4%?
19:47 Speaker 02 Well, this is a potential problem, obviously, just from the natural belief that, you know, higher rates is, will be a squeeze on borrowers. But... You know, taking this one step further, let's just say the US economy does go into a recession. And the Fed is seeing the dip in inflation and thinking, okay, well, inflation's now got a three handle. Maybe by year end, it's got a two handle that they can start cutting interest rates. Well, maybe, well, what does that do to the US dollar? This Fed starts cutting. You know, I just argued that the sole reason for the dollar rally was the aggressive tightening of the Fed.
20:28 Speaker 02 Well, where do I think the dollar is going to go if the Fed starts to cut? I would argue lower. And if the Fed starts getting aggressive with their cuts and the dollar continues to weaken, oil goes above 100. Well, the 10-year yield can go even well above 4% in a slowing economy. That would be a really difficult situation. So I'm not saying that that happens. I'm just saying that these are some realistic outcomes that tells me this has, there's more chapters to this book on where rates go. Because like I said earlier, we're unwinding an epic bubble in sovereign bonds where negative rates were, you know, the definition of that.
21:13 Speaker 02 And just to think that, okay, we ripped the Band-Aid off. Yields are higher and they're just, we're just going to go back to sort of pre-bubble trading and rates will stay low. I don't know. I'm not so confident in that. So like I said earlier, yields on the long end can go higher for wrong reasons and would sort of exaggerate the economic impact and make the Fed's job really difficult when they want to cut short-term interest rates in response to a weak economy.
21:46 Speaker 01 We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
21:57 Speaker 01 Does that put QE back on the table? So if the economy is weakening and the markets, the bond market is working against the Fed, they're going to have to do something other than cut rates, right?
22:07 Speaker 02 Right, well, that is a great question because that then begs, that situation begs that exact question is, let's just say 10-year yield went up for those bad reasons and the Fed was forced to do what they can to cap that. Well, would that be successful? Maybe, maybe not. After QE1 and QE2 was implemented in an effort to suppress long-term interest rates, long-term interest rates went up instead because the market said, you know, basically pushed back against the Fed. So you guys are trying to reflate. I'm going to sell off my long-term Treasuries.
22:42 Speaker 01 Right, right. This is why, this is why people talk about yield curve control, right?
22:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, that would be part of the conversation. But I think what we've learned from certainly the Japanese and most recently with the Reserve Bank of Australia, the yield curve control is an extraordinarily dangerous game. Because yeah, it's easy to get in, but boy, is it really difficult to get out of.
23:05 Speaker 01 And the market's going to push you until you, they're always going to test your resolve. So you're going to have to-
23:09 Speaker 02 There's no doubt about it.
23:10 Speaker 01 Throw a lot of ammunition at that line in the sand that you drew.
23:13 Speaker 02 Right, so yeah, it's easy on paper to say, yeah, yield curve control. But in practice, it's going to be really difficult. And so these are some really difficult choices and some situations that we're sort of gaming out here. And I think it's important to talk about it because these aren't low-probability situations. I would say that these are potential outcomes.
23:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, so truly, some of the questions I think we've answered as we went along. Cosmo's asking, why would the banks take on more US bonds if they're underwater with them already? You're sort of saying the banks would be out of that. That's part of the problem, that you don't have them as a buyer this time around.
23:53 Speaker 02 Correct, they loaded up on this paper the last couple of years. And if anything, they're going to let, they're going to try to shrink this part of their balance sheet. They're hoping they can do that through- You know, maturities rather than being a forced seller.
24:09 Speaker 01 Yeah.
24:09 Speaker 02 But yeah, the era of banks loading up. But you know, banks don't necessarily have to because one of the reasons why banks loaded up on treasuries and agency bonds is because they got flooded with deposits. They got flooded with deposits because of all the QE the Fed was doing. Well, now deposits are shrinking and they're shrinking every single week. So there's less pressure on banks to deploy these deposits. Now, the loan to deposit ratio for the US banking system is about 60%. The historical level is about 70. So there is some room there and that room, that ratio will compress relative to its
24:52 Speaker 02 long-term average, the more deposits leave. Now, the big banks don't mind deposits leaving because they have too many. It's the smaller banks that are obviously going to be challenged with the flight of deposits.
25:04 Speaker 01 Right. And John was asking, what does it mean for two to three-year duration treasuries? I think you made the case that they will follow Fed policy, but it's the 10-year that's going to see the effect. So you see the curve steepening with the longer end higher, right? What does that mean for stocks? This is not good news for stocks, I'm assuming.
25:25 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, I mean, it's tough to argue that 18, now 19 times earnings for the S and P is an attractive multiple in the face of possibly stickier inflation, more persistent inflation, albeit at lower levels than we're seeing, and higher for longer interest rates. So I agree, it creates a difficult scenario for stocks, particularly the ones that everyone's now piling into because someone said AI in their conference call.
25:56 Speaker 01 If we, if we, if we think about this and we think about these probabilities, if the Fed's easing and the shorter duration's going lower following the Fed, higher duration, do we see people, all the people sitting in money markets now, are they going to have to extend their duration if they're looking for that, if they're looking for that yield?
26:16 Speaker 02 No, I still think that. Well, yeah, I mean, if the Fed starts to cut, obviously, they'll lose some potential yield. But because of the risk to the long end that I gamed out, where you can see a rise in long-term interest rates while the Fed is cutting short-term interest rates, I still think that they'll be more comfortable in short-duration bonds, no more than, call it two years, three years tops. But a lot of that money, I think, will still stay in money markets where you're talking about T-bills instead.
26:48 Speaker 01 Yeah. So what do you like here? JB asking, are you still bullish on value and real assets over the next three to five years? Thoughts on TPL?
26:59 Speaker 02 So in the next couple of years, well, I should say over the next year, because looking past that, you're talking about commodities is difficult. So I'm still very bullish on energy. I think that energy prices are still going much higher over the next couple of years. I acknowledge the demand side impact of a slowing economy, a recession, and so on. But I still think that the supply side, you know, over time, is still going to be pretty cramped. So still bullish on them, on that sector, and thinking that some of the stocks, particularly the European energy stocks, are very cheap. Value stocks are just been painful here over the last month, as everyone piles into the big-cap tech stocks.
27:44 Speaker 02 But, you know, there's still a lot of cheap stuff out there. So if you like a name that's trading in a single-digit multiple, I'm willing to hold that for the next couple of years, assuming that the fundamental thesis is intact. You know, I think that buying the bigger names because of AI, I think that people are trying to sort of relive their high school years, thinking that owning the top 10 stocks, that that is going to be the workable playbook again. And it's just so easy just to get back into these names because they'll lead the way. But I need to make an important point here is that the top 10, like, call it the top
28:28 Speaker 02 eight stocks are doing business with the other 492.
28:33 Speaker 02 And look at the Russell 2000, which is near its, it's close to its October lows. So the 2,000 stocks in the Russell, the other 492, so you're talking about 2,500 stocks about. These eight companies that everyone's piling into, their customers are the other 2,500. We all breathe the same economic air. So you can't have it on a sustainable basis, eight stocks going up and everything else going down. Either everything else is going to catch up, or the eight stocks are going to experience some gravity. And if AI, which is extraordinarily impressive, we all agree, is going to do so much for the economy and productivity and efficiency, well, the 2,500 that are using AI should really see a benefit.
29:18 Speaker 02 But the market's not giving them any benefit. They're just giving benefit to the companies that are going to be sort of creating some picks and shovels. So there, there, there needs to be, so, so then this, this, this is not just a, a technical analyst theoretical debate of, okay, a few stocks are leading the way and that, that typically portends this. You know, there is a fundamental sort of disconnect that's happening here when, like I said, 2,500 stocks are going down and eight are going up, considering that they all do business together.
29:53 Speaker 01 That's, that's an amazing point. Do you have a view of whether the, that they catch up or the big ones come down to earth?
30:00 Speaker 02 I think it's the big ones that come down to earth based on the data that I'm seeing, all the conference calls that I'm listening to, where the common theme was challenging macroeconomic environment. And I'm listening to what companies are saying about how the data came out, how their numbers came out in the back half of March into April into May. Because to me, there's been a two-part economy this year. January, February, and the first 10 days of March. And then SVB goes down and everything posts SVB. You know, I was listening to, you know, I was reading the, the transcript of Foot Locker from Friday, and they talked about March slowed down, April bounced a little bit, and then May weakened again.
30:45 Speaker 02 And FedEx talked about January being good, February slowing down a bit, and then March really slowed down. There has been, the economy has slowed down post SVB. And to me, it's going to be the big names that catch up to the smaller ones if we're going to be fundamentally consistent here in our analysis.
31:06 Speaker 01 Fantastic stuff. Peter, some really, really interesting points you brought up. I think not a lot of people are talking about it, so it's certainly given us all a lot of food for thought and something to go away and think hard about because there are definitely some probabilities that are being ignored, which is always a dangerous thing. Thank you so much.
31:26 Speaker 02 Thanks, Maggie.
31:27 Speaker 01 Love the discussion. We've got a lot of great questions. We'll be back tomorrow with Greg Weldon, and we'll pick up some of this and also touch on some commodities and currencies as we always do, so be sure to join us for that. Peter, always fantastic to see you. Thank you so much. Thanks to all of you, and as always, take care and good luck out there.
Previous Steno's Signals: Liquidity Will Soon Be Drier than a Martini Next Time To Take Profits in Tech? w/ Greg Weldon Page updated October 24, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated