Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Relentless Markets & Paper Cuts: The Return of Volatility? About this episode DB-Apr,23-2021: Real Vision senior editor Ash Bennington hosts managing editor Ed Harrison and editor Jack Farley for a live talk on the biggest market-moving stories as the week comes to a close. Harrison covers credit and shares additional thoughts on “The Great Biden Tax Grab.” Bennington makes sense of today’s economic data and takes a look at the cooling-off of crypto prices as well as the widening spread between the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust and its net asset value. Farley looks at price action in commodities such as lumber, oil, as well as the recent shocking news from Kimberly Clark that the bull market in toilet paper could be over. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,021 words · 3 speakers
0:12 Speaker 00 Real Vision Daily Briefing Friday Edition. Welcome back, everybody. Live without a net with Ed Harrison and Jack Farley. Welcome back, guys.
0:22 Speaker 01 Good to talk to you.
0:24 Speaker 02 Great to be here, Ash.
0:25 Speaker 00 Always great to have the old band back together again. We were talking a little bit off air. Lots going on. Let's start with you, Ed. What are you looking at these days?
0:35 Speaker 01 You know, we had a lot of numbers that came out today. I was looking at the market numbers in particular. That's the company that does the PMIs, and those were really good. You look at the composite PMI, 62.2 versus the previous month in March, 59.7. Obviously, 50 is the dividing line between when you have expansion and contraction. A number like 62 is pretty high. If you get above 60, that's considered a really robust economy. And then if you break it down into the component parts, look at services. The services sector PMI was 63.1.
1:14 Speaker 01 They only expected 61.9, and the previous month was 64. So still going up, but more than expected. And then finally, look at manufacturing. Previous month was 59.1. They expected 60.5, and we got 60.6. So you put all that together, and what it says is both the manufacturing and the services sector in the United States are expanding, and they're expanding at a more rapid rate than anticipated. And that has GDP now from the Atlanta Fed up 8% for Q1, and it looks like Q2 is continuing in that same bullish fashion.
1:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, we should say, in the spirit of covering the day's stories here now that we're live, US equity markets smiling on this news. S&P 500 up 1 spot 09% on the day to settle at 4180. Nasdaq up almost 1.5%, closing at 141681. Russell 2000 up 1 spot 78% to close at 2271.
2:24 Speaker 01 So the question is, is what are we supposed to make of this? You know, this is a good opportunity to throw it to Jack Farley because, I mean, I read David Rosenberg as an example. We're going to be talking to him in next week, I think. And he's like, yeah, 100% we're seeing upticks. But really, you know, you got to look at the macro picture, the big picture, and ask yourself, what happens after this initial burst of energy? What does the economy look like after people return to a new normal? Is it a robust economy? Or is it like the economy that we left two or three years ago, which was sort of secular stagnation?
3:06 Speaker 01 And that's the real, you know, $64,000 question.
3:10 Speaker 02 Yeah. Ed, so you mentioned that the composite PMI in the U.S. was good. What I had my eye on was that the services PMI showed particular strength, 63.1 relative to 61.5, as you mentioned. So I think the fact that the services are really recovering is important because, as both of you know, it was the service sector that was hit hardest by COVID and the corresponding lockdowns. Also, on the topic of PMIs, I believe Europe posted some very strong numbers from the UK, Germany, and France. So it seems that the recovery remains in good stead in the U.S. and in Europe.
3:48 Speaker 00 Yeah. I guess I always wonder, these days, in the wake of this recovery, what exactly are we measuring here? And what does it say? What does it mean? And why does it matter, if it matters? So Commerce Department report out today. New home sales surged, so up 21% month over month. This is on a quanta or count basis, not on a price basis. This is numbers of new homes sold. It's up 66.8%. That's roughly 2/3, almost exactly 2/3, I should say, year over year. But what are we measuring here? We're looking at dramatic low base effects, right? You see this just absolute carnage that happened 24 months ago. And the chart that I keep coming back to, I know we're live here today, it's not easy to pull charts up, so I'll just...
4:33 Speaker 00 Describe it for you, but really, if you think about the real economy, and I'm curious to hear what Ed thinks about this. I'm curious to hear what Jack thinks about this. I've been zoomed out, just trying to think about the big picture. And look, look at all employees, non-farm payrolls. This is the pay M's series, pay M's series at the Fred, the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis database. And it goes like this. It goes up for, you know, 50 years, incredibly sharp decline, right? That's the carnage that we experienced around the time that the virus broke here in the United States in March. And then the V-shaped recovery, but inverse radical. It stops, it goes up, and then there's an acceleration of the rate at which it's going up. That's a good sign, certainly, to see more hiring.
5:13 Speaker 00 But significantly, significantly below the numbers that we were at at the beginning of the crisis. And needless to say, also, way, way, way below trend, meaning where we would have been if that line had continued to get sketched up. Ed, what are your thoughts on the big picture? How you process the data that's come out today? How you frame the micro in context with the macro?
5:38 Speaker 01 You know, the first person that comes to mind when you say that is Daniel Lacalle, who I've interviewed twice recently. And his view had been last year, and again, it was this year when I spoke to him, that the US would outperform relative to Europe. So even though that picture that you presented is somewhat worrying, I think the first thing I think about is the PMIs that came out of Europe. If you look at the PMIs for Europe, you know, they were all above expectations. And the numbers were above the previous month's numbers, just like in the US. But if you look at the numbers, they're not anywhere near as robust, you know?
6:18 Speaker 01 So when you talk about the base effect, yes, the manufacturing PMI for April in Europe was 63. But the composite was 53.7. The services PMI in Europe was 50.3. That tells you that Europe is delayed relative to the United States. Obviously, lockdowns have a lot to do with that, but it tells you that the United States is really moving forward in a fast way. And the question is, is can we continue that? So that's my macro picture. Can we continue? Is it priced into the market? I think that it's a compelling point from Daniel's perspective
7:00 Speaker 01 that it gives you reason to continue to pay more of a market multiple for the United States over Europe because you're getting more growth for those shares.
7:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, such an important point. You know, obviously, as you're doing what you always do, Ed, which is adding yet another dimension to it, multiple time horizons, but also the comparative question about the performance of the US economy relative to the rest of the world and where investors are going to find that return. Jack, over to you. What are your thoughts about that precise point? And Ed's perspective, as well as the blending of the macro and the micro, processing the numbers that come out today in relationship to the bigger picture?
7:43 Speaker 02 Well, Ash, I'll quickly explain a phenomenon that you and Ed mentioned, which is base effects. And the simple fact of the matter is that most economic data, as well as a lot of financial data, is measured on a year-over-year change basis. And we're at the point now where if you compare current data to a year ago, you're going to get things that are very distorted. Because so, for example, a little over a year ago, or actually, you know, about a year ago, oil was negative. So are you going to look at the year-over-year change of oil? You know, it makes no sense. So that's what we're seeing in terms of inflation. There's like a deflationary spiral that was occurring last March, last April. So comparing year-over-year changes to the Consumer Price Index doesn't make a whole lot of sense. But one thing that I've got my on, Ash, is lumber,
8:28 Speaker 02 which is a key input in tons of infrastructure, which is obviously on the topic, but specifically housing. And, you know, as housing has surged for a variety of secular, as well as perhaps cyclical reasons, such as people leaving the big cities because they're getting taxed to death. Perhaps we'll get onto that. I know Ed's got some thoughts on that. But, you know, as people are bidding to buy all these houses. You know, the price of housing goes up, so therefore people are trying to build homes. So therefore, people want to buy a lot more lumber, lumber being treated wood, not timber, which is basically a tree that was just cut down. So in 2016, 2017, the price of front month futures lumber was well below $400.
9:11 Speaker 02 It's currently at $1,372 or almost $1,000 higher. And that has actually the front month futures, which is a financial contract. In terms of the spot price, if you look at the US lumber oriented strand board or OSB composite, which is a monthly index, which measures the price of OSB, it was at 999 for the month of March. I was just reading a report today that said, but from an exchange that said that they just closed a contract that was at $1,500 for spot lumber. So you could see the price going a lot, lot higher. So this, this trend is continuing and, you know, looking at this chart, Ash, it just reminds me of an exponential trend that is perhaps not mean reverting, at least for now.
9:54 Speaker 00 Hey, Jack, right, speaking of the point about people leaving New York City, a report today on the back of this Commerce Department report that shows this blowout number in new housing sales. Meanwhile, New York City rents down to new lows on the cycle per report out by Street Easy. So folks leaving New York City.
10:14 Speaker 01 So, you know, you spoke, by the way, Ash, to your friend James Altucher. In retrospect, now that you have a chance to look back at that, the death of cities, what's your, what's your take?
10:27 Speaker 00 I mean, look, I guess you could say it's still pretty early in the game here. You know, obviously you have this mass exodus. New York City has not been the most fun place to be during the pandemic, not because of the gloom and doomsayers who were saying, you know, that, that it's basically the warriors out there. That's not the case. Obviously, we've seen some upticks in crime, but the real challenge with being in New York is all the things that make New York great aren't happening right now. Obviously, you're not going to Broadway shows. You're not going out to packed nightclubs. There are a lot of great things about the city that are not, that are not happening. And also, if you've got to ride out a pandemic at home, you probably don't want to do it in a 480 square foot studio apartment. You probably would prefer to do it out in the suburbs with a car and you can,
11:09 Speaker 00 you know, jump in and go out to the park and play frisbee and enjoy your life. New York City is not a great place to be during the pandemic. So I think it's probably a little bit too soon to say, how the city is going to come back or not come back as the case may be. But we're going to have to, we're going to have to keep a very close eye on it. And I'm of course going to be keeping a close eye on it because I'm here.
11:29 Speaker 01 And where do you lean of thinking, is it going to come back? Is the, is the death of cities a legitimate likelihood? Or are you, or do you lean towards the optimistic?
11:40 Speaker 00 Well, I don't know. Look, we've had a, we've had a trend. What is it like the 250 year trend of urbanization in the United States? Obviously some, some ticks up and down on that. But obviously the secular trend is toward people, especially younger people, want to be in big cities, want to be in densely populated areas. We're going to have to see. And there's also the question about the individual cities themselves, specifically mismanagement and taxation, as Jack points out. I'll tell you a story that I've heard. Now, I can't confirm this. I don't know it firsthand. I've only heard it. But apparently, New York City dating apps, the fish are biting. Guys and gals both swiping furiously. I have friends telling me that they are getting more hits on their dating apps than ever before.
12:23 Speaker 00 So I don't know if that's a function of vaccination and, you know, the weather is starting to hopefully look up here in the city. But look, people want to be, especially younger, single people, urban professionals want to be in places where there are other people they can hang out with. So we'll have to see. But I do have to say, and maybe this is the, maybe this is the tie here, to bring us into the story that Jack was alluding to, which is, which is taxation. Some of these numbers are coming out. I know you've got a lot to say about it and I'll just read through some of the data and get some commentary from you, because it's an important story. Obviously, this rumor of capital gains tax increase, this is significant. Currently, capital gains taxes at 20% could rise to 39.6%.
13:03 Speaker 00 Under some circumstances, 43.4% proposed capital gains tax ceiling. But to take that to this story about cities, blue states. Look, California, that would add another 13.3%. Live in New York, 11.85%. Live in New York City, another 3.88% on top of the 11.85%. That starts to look pretty near 60% capital gains tax rates for residents of New York City.
13:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's, that's, that's a lot. You know, doubling any tax rate is, honestly, I don't think it's gonna fly. No, no one, you can debate the positives and negatives of, of increasing taxes. I'm probably negative in terms of increasing taxes. I don't necessarily know if I want to go into why, because, you know, we talked about taxes, Jack and I, yesterday, and that was a huge debate in the comments. But the thing is, is it's the step change. Going from 20 to almost 40%, that is a massive increase. So I don't really think that it's, it's gonna happen.
14:17 Speaker 01 This is interesting. If you look at the, the data, here's what Bloomberg says the proposal does. But he proposes doubling the tax rate to 39.6% for those earning $1 million or more, according to people who are familiar with the proposal, coupled with the existing surtax on investment income. That means that the federal tax rates could be as high as 43.4%. So the marginal rate 39.6%, but add in, you know, the surtax and you get up to 43.4%. He also, it says this would fulfill Biden's campaign pledge to subject capital gains tax to the top marginal income tax rate,
15:00 Speaker 01 which is 39.6%. Or being proposed to increase from 37 to 39.6% for people making $400,000 or more as a household. So it's really, to me, about equating the two together. The 39.6% level and the 39.6% level on capital gains.
15:25 Speaker 01 But that's a massive change, I have to say. And I think that there's going to be a lot of resistance to that.
15:31 Speaker 00 And just for context of politics aside, if something like this were to go through, in your view, you've been watching these markets for a very long time, thinking about these fiscal issues, what happens to investment? I mean, that's just an incredible distortion in terms of the base effect from where we are today to where the proposal is to take us.
15:51 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, there are two outcomes or two possible outcomes. Outcome number one is the same sort of thing that you get with inflation. When people talk about inflation, really oftentimes they're talking about a step change. That is, is that you're going from, you know, this level to this level plus 5%. And then, you know, you go back to the previous levels of inflation that you had before. So that's not a big deal. The other possibility is instead of, you know, now we get take the 16% hit. This is what David Rosenberg said yesterday in his piece, that when you put the corporate
16:32 Speaker 01 tax increase together with the capital gains tax, that's a 16% hit. If you, if you take that hit in a market that's overheated, it could potentially be the straw that broke the camel's back, causes people to reassess, and you have some sort of massive sell-off in equities.
16:52 Speaker 00 Right.
16:53 Speaker 01 You know, 16% over, over time, or a potential massive sell-off. Those are the two outcomes that I see if it passes. So it's distinctly negative for equities.
17:06 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:09 Speaker 00 Jack, any thoughts on that?
17:12 Speaker 02 Well, I think for a lot of people, approach taxes this way. If someone makes more than me, then they should be taxed higher because they're a plutocrat, and if they make less than me, they should pay more in taxes. You know, they need to learn the value of hard work. So I don't know. I don't quite know how to approach it, but in terms of its impact on the market. I saw a report today that increases in long-term capital gains historically have not harmed the returns of the S and P 500. However, I am thinking of that, you know, the huge Trump tax cut, which was on corporations, which, you know, many think, and I think probably is very likely to be one of the reasons that,
17:56 Speaker 02 you know, the stock market just absolutely soared before, you know, March of last year. So I think, I think that, you know, you can directly tie the cut in the corporate tax rate to the S and P 500. The question is, if you cut, excuse me, if you raise the capital gains tax, how does that impact the marginal investors' behavior? Are they going to say, oh, I'm actually not going to buy the S and P 500, I'm going to go buy bonds, let's say. Well, to me, that doesn't make a ton of sense because the S and P 500, still on a very long-term time view, will generate higher returns, no matter what your tax rate. Does it incentivize people to post a short-term gains if they have, you know, a certain reason to?
18:40 Speaker 02 Are people going to, you know, not conspire, but are people going to work with banks and tax advisors? So that if they have a huge taxable gain, they can borrow money against that and then sort of, you know, use that as a loss. Are they going to derivative hedge so that they actually can report a loss? I feel like, you know, I've read Matt Levine from Bloomberg, who used to be an equity structure at Goldman Sachs, that a lot of derivative hedges are actually people who want to sell their stock, but they're not allowed to sell their stock. So I think that it's, I don't know, it's a complicated issue. You know, when Ed and I were on yesterday, we reported that on news
19:22 Speaker 02 or not news, but on reports that Biden was going to go through with this, the S and P 500 plummeted the most in a 10-minute window, right as the news reported. But obviously, markets don't seem to be that worried today because the Nasdaq is up, S and P 500 is up, Russell is up, the Dow, even the Dow is up. So, yeah, I don't really know what to think, Ash. What do you think?
19:42 Speaker 01 You know, let me grab the ball. There and say that I think it's interesting that it's clear when you look at the proposal that what's happening is it's it's a fairness game. I mean, there are two aspects to it politically. One is the the the rate thirty nine point six on the one side and then the other side, which was thirty seven. For people with incomes of four hundred thousand dollars or more going to thirty nine point six. So basically what Biden's going to sell this as is thirty nine point six over here. Thirty nine point six percent over here. It's fair. I think that that's a good sell and I would I would agree with that. The the second a political issue is the the the level, the rate thirty nine point six percent. That's the real problem.
20:26 Speaker 01 Is that's a lo- a large rate when you add in local taxes, when you add in state taxes. You're looking at a massive tax grab and a lot of people will blanch as a result of that.
20:41 Speaker 02 Ed, was there a specific term that you had for that? The great something, something?
20:46 Speaker 01 Right. I I I wrote an article about this just because, you know, yesterday when you and I were talking, we. You know, you can talk for three or four minutes about taxes in a very hot political way. But it doesn't really get to the nitty gritty of what you're saying. So I wrote a whole article on credit write downs. It's it's outside the paywall. And yeah, I use the term the great Biden tax grab because I think that's really how people. Who are against this are going to be thinking about it because ultimately we're talking about increasing spending. And we're also talking about increasing taxes in order to fund that spending.
21:26 Speaker 01 And that's a paradigm that we used to see, you know, thirty or forty years ago. It seems like it's coming back. So when you think about this, just from a holistic perspective, what you're seeing now is a completely different world in terms of how we're thinking. Not just in terms of, yes, now you have massive deficit spending from Donald Trump and that's continued under Biden. But it's the same thing that's happening in Europe. The we're now in a world in which fiscal policy is a much more active than it used to be. So I think that it's something that we need to be thinking about in terms of what its impact is. Both on inflation and also especially with regard to taxes on the distribution of income.
22:13 Speaker 00 Yeah. So GBTG, not to be confused with GBTC, another hot topic of conversation.
22:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, why don't you make that that transition there because it's when you mentioned GBTC that I thought about my GBTG because they have similar monikers. What's what's going on with GBTC?
22:37 Speaker 00 Well, you know, I think probably the first thing to think about in in this framework is just looking at the broader crypto markets. Obviously, this has not been a great week for crypto. Crypto down right now significantly across the board. Bitcoin, I'm looking at the numbers off down Bitcoin trading at 51,140 right now. That's a 17% decline, trailing seven days and about 4% on the 24-hour trailing window. Ethereum down at 23,53, down about 2% on the week. Everything generally down. Doge, of course, where we've got a lot of comments, down 21%, trailing seven days.
23:19 Speaker 01 Look, why didn't you start with Doge? I mean, isn't that the new like coin that people care about?
23:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, I was gonna say, Ash, I don't really follow Bitcoin anymore. I mainly focus most of my intellectual energy on Doge.
23:33 Speaker 00 Terrible. Okay, so Doge, let's talk a little bit about Doge for people who may be following this. And I've given my sort of my thoughts about it, but there's and I saw there's some questions coming into us on the live doc right now.
23:45 Speaker 02 Yeah, what are they saying?
23:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, so I mean, listen, here's the deal. Doge was created like as a joke, right? Like, let's let's not lose track of that. The creator of Dogecoin has said it's a meme coin. It's a joke. It was something that we were doing sort of humorously, tongue in cheek. In addition, one of the main selling points of Bitcoin, which is the coin that most resembles, is that it is on a deflationary creation schedule. Dogecoin, exactly the opposite, an inflationary schedule. Look, to me, this is a meme and it's getting it's getting headlines because of the price action. And when the reason you're buying something, when the Use case for it in the digital asset space is I believe the price will go up because the price has already gone up. And I'll be able to sell it to someone else for a higher price.
24:31 Speaker 00 To me, that's not a very strong use case for understanding. There are so many important, powerful, interesting things that are going on in the space. Why Dogecoin? Because it's a really cute dog and the price has risen dramatically. But with all that said, the reality is it's almost like kind of like a Saez law effect here. Supply creates demand. When the price action starts moving in a certain direction and it gets a great deal of publicity. There are potentials for network effects. So could Dogecoin be used for something practical? Could someone come in? Could a group decide that Dogecoin has a practical value that it could be used for something? It's possible. I wouldn't rule it out. But at this point, you know, you're gambling. Let's call it what it is.
25:14 Speaker 00 And if you go and do it in Vegas, you get free cocktails and maybe you get free tickets to see Britney Spears if you spend enough money.
25:22 Speaker 01 So you're not, you're not a backer. You're not pro Doge. That's what you're telling me.
25:28 Speaker 00 Look, it's a really hard story to like, right? It's a really hard story to like. By the way, all of that said, could Dogecoin double in value? Could we be having this conversation next week and Dogecoin is trading at 86 or 87 cents? Absolutely. Anything's possible in this market. But to me, it starts to look, smell and taste a lot like gambling.
25:50 Speaker 01 So what's different about Doge in terms of the actual cryptography? Or let's call it the, the algorithm versus Bitcoin. How are they separate from one another?
26:04 Speaker 00 I think the, the algorithm is still the same. I think it's shot 256, but the creation schedule is different. The block structure is different. It's, it's something that is obviously a much lower value coin. So that there's some price bias, which is one of the reasons why people come into it. We know as we, people who've been in the financial space, that whether something is trading at 50,000 or 50 cents. Obviously, the economic result of investing a hundred dollars is the same relative to the total network value or market capitalization. But it seems to be that one of the major factors that's driving people to it is the price bias, price distortion effect. So I think that's a major factor. And again, to get back to the earlier point, Dogecoin has a really cute dog.
26:48 Speaker 02 Ash, I want to explore and scrutinize your claim that Dogecoin is inherently inflationary, whereas Bitcoin is inherently deflationary. I think it's not so much a question of how much of an asset there is, it's how much of that new supply there is relative to the demand. So for example, a failing industrial company that's buying back its own stock, they are actually decreasing the supply of their number of shares, but the stock can still go down because people realize that it's a total dog. Pun sort of not intended or intended. But now with the topic of Dogecoin and Bitcoin, obviously Bitcoin is deflationary relative
27:28 Speaker 02 to demand is increasing exponentially and relative to a supply, the growth rate of which is, or the absolute number of coins is decreasing exponentially, but it's still a fact that new Bitcoins are mined every day. So in an absolute sense, it is inflationary, even though it is in a sense, in terms of a currency, one of the most deflationary things that was ever invented. But Dogecoin, I actually think is more similar to Bitcoin than the US dollar in terms of its inflation schedule, because its absolute number of coins, or Dogecoin's per year, I believe, stays constant of about 5.6 billion. The absolute number of coins now, it's somewhere in the 130 billion.
28:09 Speaker 02 So year over year, as the absolute number of Dogecoin's gets larger, that 5 billion will decrease and decrease and decrease. And if you compare that to the M2, excuse me, money supply growth, I think actually that Dogecoin, it has an inflation schedule that resembles more closely to Bitcoin than the dollar, which, you know, it rises and falls with economic cycles and financial panics and the like. So, you know, what do you, why am I wrong?
28:33 Speaker 00 All right, Jack, you've done your homework. It's an elegant argument. I'm not sure it's the right one. It's an interesting conversation. Look, first of all, the metaphors between digital assets, particularly digital assets that have inherent value or the perception of inherent value that look like currencies versus equities, I'm not sure it's the right one. Obviously, you're looking at pricing equities on a price to earnings ratio. That's not something that exists. With the network value of some of these coins. The reality is that I would separate the supply schedule from the demand component. I think that that's probably muddying the waters a little bit. The reality is that Bitcoin has a schedule. First of all, both of them are expanding. The question is, it's about the second derivative.
29:17 Speaker 00 The total number of coins is rising in both cases. But the rate of creation of new coins on Bitcoin is falling. That's what you talk about when you hear the halving or the halving, which is the decrease in the rate of new coins being added. So that ratio of increase is declining. And in Dogecoin, there isn't that fixed schedule. Part of what makes Bitcoin Bitcoin, not just in the code, but in the culture, is that everyone knows it has this hard cap, 21 million. If that were to change, in theory, it could certainly if you had network agreement, theoretically, in terms of the of the way that the code base works. But the reality is culturally, what makes Bitcoin Bitcoin is that everyone knows and agrees ahead of time that there is this hard cap.
30:00 Speaker 00 And I just don't really see the use case right now today for Dogecoin being anything other than a cute puppy meme. And also something that you can buy today and hope to flip it tomorrow for a higher price. To me, that's not something that makes me feel really sanguine about the use case for Bitcoin. Obviously, really fascinating things happening, not just in the store value, digital gold function, but also in the capacity to do things like money transfers. We recently had Jack Mallor's on, talking about how Bitcoin could become a conduit for very low cost, near zero cost transfers of for transactional purposes. Lots of interesting stuff happening in Bitcoin for that reason that I just I just don't see with Doge.
30:45 Speaker 00 Again, I bring this to this when I said to Ral, I think, last week. Radical uncertainty means you need radical humility. So there's always the possibility that something could change tomorrow. But today, it's really hard to see. And again, that notwithstanding, price could double the next time we're having this conversation.
31:03 Speaker 02 So I would not at all be surprised.
31:05 Speaker 01 Hey, Jack, let me let me ask you a question that you. You asked me.
31:09 Speaker 02 Yeah.
31:10 Speaker 01 It's good. I have the opportunity to come back at you now. Dogecoin is trading at 24 cents. You asked me, I think it was trading at 33 on Monday, or it was Monday when you and I spoke. Perhaps we spoke again on Wednesday when we were talking about it. Long story short, if you had to go long or short,
31:32 Speaker 01 and you can't, you know, you can't just stay neutral, which would you do for Dogecoin and why?
31:38 Speaker 02 So it's so funny you asked me that, Ed, because I was about to ask Ash that. But I will give my answer and then I'll turn it back. I'll turn the laser eye, Bitcoin laser eyes back on Ash. So I would say my, if the third option is a choice, do nothing. That is what I want to do. And that is what I'm doing.
31:55 Speaker 01 But everyone wants to do that.
31:56 Speaker 02 In Dogecoin, if we have this, you know, gun to my head, long or short.
32:02 Speaker 02 You know, so it's funny. I asked this to Jared Dillian. He said short. I asked that to you yesterday. You said short. I would probably go long Dogecoin, just because I believe that there is a potential that it gets in that 60, 70 cent range, perhaps even a dollar. So, yeah, I sort of view it as a call option in terms of a long-term bet. Am I, you know, am I bullish? No. Short-term, am I bullish? Not really. But, you know, you asked me, long or short? I would have to go long. So now, Ash, let's turn the laser eyes back on you. How about, what do you say? You can't do nothing. Or you can't aggressively neutral.
32:37 Speaker 00 You can't be aggressively neutral. You can't do nothing. Actually, I would say, after making the bare case, easy question, I go long.
32:46 Speaker 01 Well, I'll get two shorts and two longs.
32:48 Speaker 00 Two reasons. One, because I think that this, the mania could still have room to run. And two, just the mechanical factor of I would prefer not to have to post collateral and leverage a position and go short on a margin account on something. So, but I think it's pretty easy. You go long.
33:07 Speaker 01 Well, you know, since we're talking about this, I almost feel like we should take a bet. And it reminds me of a bet that I know that our colleagues Travis Kimmel and Tyler Neville were making about the dollar. They were talking about, there was a push for the dollar to go higher. That's when rates were going higher. And at the time, I think we were around 93 on the on DXY, Dollar Index. Now, they made the bet, you know, about 92, I believe it was. Where is it going to be?
33:40 Speaker 01 Is it going to go below or above 92 in a week's time? And here we are today. And what's the Dollar Index, Ash?
33:48 Speaker 00 It's around 91.
33:50 Speaker 01 There you go. So a collapse in the US Dollar.
33:55 Speaker 01 What do you, what do you make of the collapse in the US Dollar? What's going on there that is causing the US Dollar to start to look weak once again?
34:06 Speaker 02 I think it's, easy cop out answer is the fall in real yields.
34:12 Speaker 02 Inflation breakevens have continued to rise as we've seen, you know, commodity inflation like lumber and oil. But yields have sort of trapped in a range. They sold off today, yields rose and bond yields sold off. But over the past month, bonds have been pretty flat, if not actually declining. So that combination of flat to down yields with rising inflation breakevens and what you get, you get falling real yields in terms of the actual purchasing power of what you can get with a US bond. And so when that happens, foreign capital or, you know, or capital period says, hey, I'd rather have put my money somewhere else. You know, I mean, one key reason why we had that huge surge in the dollar over the past
34:53 Speaker 02 few months has been that just the yield differential between, you know, US Treasuries and German Boons and other, you know, things that have negative yields just absolutely exploded. So people say, why would I get a negative yield when I can go the dollar? But, you know, you kind of had a reversal on that.
35:11 Speaker 00 Also, a simple answer to, which I think is also in effect, high base effect, right? We saw this massive flight to quality in March of 2020. It's obviously sold off below the level that it was trading at prior. For example, 18 and 19 were below those levels now. 90 spot 8.3 apparently last trade. But I think some of it probably also the roll-off mean reversion, high base effect.
35:34 Speaker 01 Yeah. Going to your relative value play there, Jack, I think it's interesting. If you look at, I'm looking at two charts now. I'm looking at the German 10-year and also the Swiss 10-year over the last three months. And if you look at that, what you see is, you know, the least negative for months for both of those rates. So on a relative basis, the U.S. doesn't look quite as interesting as it has done for quite some time. And I'm going to the German 10-year. It's been at least a year since the German 10-year was at the level that it is today. I have to go back here.
36:14 Speaker 01 Let me take a look to 2019 in order to get the German 10-year at a higher rate than a still minus 0.25%.
36:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, and I think also sort of very bullish America because America has Google and Facebook and technology and very business-friendly regulation. That has been the narrative for why U.S. assets have overperformed over the past 40 years. But just based on Jason Buck's conversation with Meb Faber, that actually doesn't really pass the smell test if you go be up before 1980, you know, 1940, 1950, 1960, 1970. Those were years where the U.S. stock market actually performed, you know, somewhat not so well against its competitors because everyone was, oh, it's all about Argentina. It's all about this, it's all about that. So the sort of U.S. overperformance, which, you know, everyone except perhaps our most venerated
37:13 Speaker 02 and, you know, very, very people at that advanced age, like above 80, you know, most people have been living in a world where U.S. assets outperform and that's not necessarily historical.
37:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, very interesting.
37:26 Speaker 00 Speaking of.
37:27 Speaker 01 I was gonna say, do you have any questions for us from people that you think now's the time to talk about?
37:35 Speaker 00 That's exactly where I was going, Ed. And the first question comes to us from Adrian. Can you guys comment on this week's hawkish comments by the Bank of Canada? And what it might signal for go forward central bank policy for other developed economies? For those who aren't watching this story, Bank of Canada came out and warned on inflation yesterday. Curious, Ed, that sounds like the kind of thing that you'd be watching. Any thoughts?
37:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, my general view is that it's a canary in the coal mine. You know, central banks, they move in packs. And it gives cover to other central banks if they want to, to start to move in that direction. They can take a look, see how it develops, both in terms of the real economy and in terms of the financial economy. But we know that Canada hasn't vaccinated very well. There's a lockdown right now in Ontario. And so the Bank of Canada has been taking action preemptively, if you will, from a monetary policy perspective.
38:43 Speaker 01 That has nothing to do with their wanting to continue accommodation because of the economy. Their economy is arguably worse off right now than the United States. So to me, that gives cover to the ECB. It gives cover to the United States. It gives cover to other major central banks.
39:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think I also saw Macklem not just talking about inflation, but tapering asset purchases. And I didn't read the minutes or anything, but I was reading Jared Dillian's newsletter today, the Daily Dirt Map, where he covered it. And you know, the US dollar relative to the Canadian dollar, it's at 125. It's backed off its peak of 1.45 just after, you know, it's a huge sell of. March last year and Jared saying, hey, it makes a lot more sense for it to be at 1.45, 1.65 because Canada is, has a lot of problems, you know, with, with debt, with current accounts balances, with growth, you know, they have a property bubble that is many, many more times or is much more
39:53 Speaker 02 extreme than the sort of surge in US housing that we've seen in the, in stateside. So yeah, I think, I think that's a great question, something, definitely something to keep your eye on. And, um, you know, Jared notes that FX traders call USCAD the truth. It's called the truth trade because it has the highest correlation to the macro environment. So, um, yeah, something to, something to keep my eye on.
40:14 Speaker 00 It's really a steep sell off, isn't it, Dan? I mean, it's just that you look at that chart for the, for the month of April and it's just, it's just straight down. One spot for basically down to the last trade where we are right now, one and a quarter dollar CAD.
40:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, I find that very interesting. It's definitely something to keep an eye on because you think about it from a fundamental perspective. When the economy in Canada is not really gangbusters, what does that mean? If the, if the currency is going up at that rate, it does suggest potentially that people believe the Fed now, that they believe that the Fed is going to continue to be dovish, that relative speaking, you know, interest rates are going to be higher in other countries, Germany, Switzerland, Canada, you name it, that they're going to be tightening before the US. Maybe that's the signal that we, we should be taking away from this.
41:07 Speaker 02 Hey, Ash, I want to hear the other questions that our audience has for us, but I also feel like there are two topics which we haven't yet discussed. One is the grayscale Bitcoin trust and the other is toilet paper. So you're the host, do with what you weigh, but I just want to let you know that we got, we got two things on the, on the, on the tray.
41:24 Speaker 00 You know, listen, I'll give the, and I would add one more to that as well, but I would add, uh, you know, I'm not sure exactly what's happening on the toilet paper tray, but I can speak to GBTC. This is a grayscale Bitcoin trust that you alluded to right now, trading at a steep discount to net asset value. This is a closed ended fund, uh, which means the shares are not redeemable. So you can have these sort of imbalances of the price relative to net asset value. Historically, this is traded at a premium to net asset value. But now it's trading at basically nineteen or so percent below net asset value. It's really taken a walloping in dollar terms and relative terms to the underlying asset. You know, this is an interesting question. I believe that Digital Currency Group has said that they're going to.
42:09 Speaker 00 The move is going to be to push this into an ETF. When those are reaching the clearance for the regulatory hurdles. But for right now, obviously, it's taken a hit. We were talking about this a little bit offline. Why would people want to own GBTC? The answer historically was if you're an institutional client and you were constrained because of your investment charter from directly investing in Bitcoin. It was a way that you could get the exposure. And hey, the premium was nice, too. Obviously, that is now reversed. So the story is a little bit different.
42:41 Speaker 02 Well, I'm sorry, you said the premium is nice, too. But that actually means they paid a premium. So they they were paying a lot more for Bitcoin than they got. Now, if you actually believe that one GBTC. You know, what one Bitcoin that GBTC owns is worth one Bitcoin in the real world. This is the mother of all arbitrage trades, if you if you believe that, yeah.
43:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, no, I mean, if you got in early and you saw the price rise relative to the price. You experienced that capital appreciation along with it, and that was a great trade. But now, obviously, that's reversed. But again, the question can be, listen, this is the challenge with net asset value. Talking about the fact that you're getting more Bitcoin for the dollar. But that's great as long as it continues to, if you believe in mean reversion. If you think that it could potentially continue to deteriorate on a relative basis. You can get whacked on that trade. And people who are a lot smarter than I am, I can assure you, have made similar misjudgments in the past with trying to trade things that were basically, you know, reversion plays against an asset that they believed would converge.
43:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think a comparison is you can think that the volatility is going to explode. So you buy something like VXX and volatility does explode, but you actually don't make as much money as you would think because you have to pay a lot in roll yield and a lot of the monthly costs of the VIX doesn't actually come from the VIX, excuse me, from the VXX, doesn't actually come from the VIX declining, but so much is from the, you have to pay the roll yield.
44:10 Speaker 00 Hey, Jack, speaking of negative roll yield, let's talk toilet paper.
44:14 Speaker 02 Okay, okay, okay. That is a great connection. So today, a lot of big companies reported their earnings, American Express, Kimberly Clark, and it's that latter one that I've got my on. They produce all sorts of wipes, face masks, tissue paper, and yes, toilet paper. So people at home, you might have remembered that when the pandemic first started, there was an absolute bubble in toilet paper. Let's put it like that. There was a boom in toilet paper. I remember I saw some guy try and walk into a Duane Reade and he had a basket and he had put about 30 rolls of toilet paper in that basket and he tried to check out and the cashier said, "Excuse me, sir, actually you were not allowed to buy more than one roll."
44:59 Speaker 02 So that was the world that we're in about a year ago and you could actually see it in the numbers of Kimberly Clark's consumer tissue segment, which is a segment of their business, consumer tissue, beating tissues, Kleenex, but also toilet paper. So those year-over-year growth, they posted about gains of 15%, which is quite eye-popping. However, now that we're in March and everyone is saying, "Oh, actually, we're not going to be in this lockdown forever. The reopening is already happening, if not on the horizon." And so they reported their earnings today and their revenue was down 12% in the consumer tissue sales. So there's a Bloomberg reporter who wrote an article called "Down the Tube."
45:42 Speaker 02 So I think it kind of marks a big, serious point in the road of how we are in COVID that there's no longer a bubble in toilet paper. It's over.
45:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, you know, listen, I think this is a really important point. And the one story that I really wanted to add was the story about what's happening with COVID. We were talking about this earlier. I think this is the single most important story in the world in terms of the impact to the real global economy. Obviously, there are some very difficult things that are happening right now in India, where we see the cases absolutely exploding, setting new records every day. In Brazil, where we see young people, people as young in their 20s and 30s, dying of COVID for reasons that experts cannot fully explain. This is something that I'd heard about anecdotally from people who had friends in Brazil, telling these terrible tales of people in their 30s dying.
46:34 Speaker 00 And now the statistical data seems to bail it out, bear it out. It's a terrible, terrible story. And it reminds me of this bias that we have, which is here in the state of New York. We've had a relative success in vaccination. People have been doing the right thing in terms of wearing masks and social distancing. You look at the numbers, clearly, the data is going down in terms of the positivity rate, hospitalization rate, everything in New York on a relative basis, day over day, week over week, looking quite good, quite optimistic. I think there was a rumor about Bill de Blasio potentially removing the mask requirements for outdoor use. All of these very positive signs, but the world is an incredibly heterogeneous place. That is the thing that we've learned with COVID, that
47:19 Speaker 00 you see these hotspots, these flare ups, terrible, terrible suffering in places like India, places like Brazil, and the impact to the global economy, the impact to supply chains, emerging markets, currency exchange rates, still very much an open question. And if you want to throw out the nightmare scenario, by no means is this a prediction. But the risk is if you have these very dense superclusters of spread of the disease, the potential for mutation that can break through the existing vaccines, while by no means a certainty, obviously a threat, a significant risk. I was reading an article in the Wall Street Journal that used the phrase double mutant strain. It sounds hellishly scary.
48:02 Speaker 00 There's some preliminary reports coming out of Israel that the B spot, one spot, three, five, one, South Africa virion has the capacity to break through the Pfizer vaccine. Some very scary things that are happening in the world. I wouldn't be doing an end zone dance just yet in terms of the global economy and the impacts. And to me, that's the single most important story, although it's not being priced into US equity markets. So there is that disconnect that we've spoken about throughout this entire crisis.
48:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, everything that we're doing right now, everything that we're talking about is under the assumption that we're just all going to get vaccinated up, we're going to reach a point where COVID is not really that big a problem. That's what we want, and that's what we're assuming. But this whole concept, let's just imagine that what you just said happens. That is, is that there's some mutant evading, there's an antibody evading mutant of COVID-19, and it sets back the vaccination effort and so forth, let's say, six months, nine months. I mean, that would be devastating to the timetable that people are thinking about. Suddenly, it throws everything up in the air.
49:15 Speaker 01 I would consider that a, you know, a known unknown. And let's just hope that we don't go there because there are a lot of potential negative outcomes from that.
49:27 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'd say definitely, you know, a lot of what we talk about here on the REDB is US-focused, just because that's where we happen to live, other than Ralph, who lives in the Cayman Islands. But, you know, our Real Vision audience really is global. We have a lot of subscribers in Europe, in the UK, we have subscribers in China, in India, in Brazil, in the places that are affected. So, yeah, you know, if you're watching now, our hearts go out to you and. Yeah, I would say that in terms of India, it's strange, it's actually not strange. It's exhibiting in terms of the stock market, the same phenomenon as we saw in the US. Whereas cases surged to unseen levels. That doesn't perturb the Indian stock market at all. If you look at something like the Sensex.
50:12 Speaker 02 I will say, Ash and Ed, it's my view, and this is just my own view, that in the US, the reopening is something of a foregone conclusion. And I don't think that, you know, we're going to go back to sort of that hellish scenario of a lockdown. It really would take a double mutant strain that is, you know, causing a lot of deaths for people who even have been vaccinated, I think, for that to happen. And that obviously is a hellish nightmare scenario. In terms of vaccinations, that the, you know, Ed, you and I went over some charts yesterday of how if you are vaccinated, you have a much like lower chance of being infected and how we're actually seeing that in the economic data of different age cohorts. What was the other thing I was going to say?
50:55 Speaker 02 Oh, that in the US, excuse me, you have, you know, all these people who are kind of very willing to and able to go out and that's baked into their expectation. So they're kind of, you know, they're ready for the roaring twenties. So I think the people in the US who are ready, ready, ready, willing and able for the roaring twenties is growing day by day. I did see an ominous chart of people in the US who actually say that they would not get vaccinated. That actually went up from 18% a few months ago to somewhere in the 40%. I believe that is a people who already haven't been vaccinated. So there's kind of a statistical effect of people who haven't been vaccinated are the ones who don't want to get vaccinated.
51:40 Speaker 02 But yeah, that's something I have my eye on. But I don't know, what do you guys think?
51:43 Speaker 01 My biggest reaction is that if lockdowns are definitely, I agree with you 100% Jack, that lockdowns are out. If we lock down again, people will not, basically, you know, there won't be compliance. You will not get people to comply. We've gone through this a whole year. Covid fatigue is severe and it just wouldn't work. So it's, the vaccines are bust at this point. Lockdowns are out. That's my personal view as well.
52:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think so too. And look, people are really suffering. The mental health impact of this on people, it's real. It is a difficult thing for people to go through. And so, you know, when we talk about COVID fatigue, it is a real thing and it has a real impact. You know, the other thing that I was thinking was, we talked about this story, is one of the things that I've found personally most irritating about the way that this has been covered, the story has been covered by the chatter class, by the media, is just the degree of politicization and finding stories and making stories up where they don't exist and overfitting data. I remember going back, whatever it was, 10 months or so, we heard these stories about comparing Germany to the United States. And the narrative, of
52:56 Speaker 00 course, was Donald Trump is bad. And, and obviously, Madame Merkel is very good because she has a background in the sciences and look at what she's going to do. And then we saw a catastrophic failure in Europe in general, and in Germany in particular, in the vaccine rollout. And I remember not that long ago, hearing stories about India saying, well, you know, the thing about India is there's a higher presence of certain pathogens. This is why people aren't getting ill at the same rate as Brazil. I mean, if you go back two weeks, you'll find these stories, very serious stories written by very serious publications, comparing India favorably to Brazil in terms of, in terms of positivity rates. All that's reversed. It seems like this is just a terrible, terrible disease
53:40 Speaker 00 that's been really gripping the entire world. The stories of, of this country versus that country, it's been, it's been a really, you know, challenging thing to try and put very specific kind of frameworks of causality around. The one thing that seems to be happening right now, that seems pretty clear, a real effect, is the vaccine is clearly helping. And we hope that continues. And we hope that people continue to stay safe and to, and to use reasonable precautions. And we hope that we don't have to go into lockdowns. And Jack, to share your sentiments to people who are around the world, who are in those places who are affected. This is also not just an economic story, it's a terrible, terrible human story. And obviously, our hearts and thoughts are with the people who are suffering from this terrible disease right now.
54:26 Speaker 01 Ash, you know, one thing that you said that caught my eye was when you talked about, you can't really say one way or the other, who's doing better than anyone else. Because at any one time, bad things could happen in one place or another. The only countries that seem to be immune, and I'm not thinking about the Asian countries in general, because there are some flare ups there, here and there, seem to be, at this point in time, Australia and New Zealand. This whole thing about basically closing the borders, it seems to be working for them. Am I premature in saying that, you know, they've done a good job?
55:09 Speaker 01 I mean, maybe we just have to wait until they do the vaccine rollout, and then they open up to other countries to see whether or not that approach actually worked.
55:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, New Zealand certainly seems to be doing a very good job. It's a relatively small country, I should say, it's actually a very small country. It's less than 5 million people. As the statistic is often cited, there are literally more sheep than humans. It is an island country, or actually a series of islands in the South Pacific. Very easy to control the borders, and it seems as though that that has been an exception. But, look, you know, it's fewer people than there are here in New York City, and they don't have Pennsylvania, Connecticut, and New Jersey on their borders, and Massachusetts. So, look, you know, it's something that is clearly, you know, kind of the demography is destiny, geography is destiny argument here.
56:03 Speaker 00 And it's just a significantly less challenging situation when you're a small island nation in the South Pacific.
56:10 Speaker 02 Ash, as we approach a close, are there any other questions, a final question from the audience?
56:17 Speaker 00 You know, interestingly enough, we've covered many of the questions before, lots of questions about Doge, lots of questions about crypto. But I will throw this one out. This is a question that's addressed directly to Ed, but I think it's an interesting question for all of us to perhaps weigh in on. The question comes to us from John, and the question is, does Ed think macro is dead?
56:38 Speaker 01 Wow, that's a good question. No, I don't think macro is dead. I don't even think that the, I don't even think that the insolvency phase is dead.
56:50 Speaker 01 Honestly, I think it's just like with the virus. It's too early to call because my macro view at this point, and no pun intended, is that we face the most important known unknown, and that is, is what consumer behavior will be when we have the full reopening, not just in the United States, but in Europe, in Japan, in Asia, in Latin America, in Africa. You know, when we're back to normal, so to speak, what's going to be different at that point in time? Because, you know, things at the margin matter.
57:28 Speaker 01 If at the margin, there's a difference of 10%, that could be death for certain industries, it could be death for certain companies in certain industries. If, you know, 20% of your business traffic dies up, and that's where you get your biggest margin from, that could be the end of your business. So the jury's still out on what this cycle looks like. So I don't think that macro's dead at all.
58:01 Speaker 00 Mr. Farley, is macro dead?
58:03 Speaker 02 I think when Ralph says macro is dead, I think he's referring to his style, the Stanley Druckenmull style, the George Soros style of, you know, shorting the pound, breaking the Bank of England, making those extremely long volatility bets that you don't have to put that much down, but if it pays off, you're going to feel like a god, to use a term that Ralph has used before. I think that style could be dead or dying because central banks have suppressed volatility to such an extreme. Not that, you know, I don't think it's necessarily new that they've suppressed volatility. I just think they've taken it to another level. So I think Ralph could, yeah, yeah, I think that macro could be dead. But that doesn't mean that macro as a whole is dead.
58:49 Speaker 02 Instead of buying long volatility, puts on the, excuse me, instead of buying calls on the DXY, you should be selling calls on the DXY. For every single trade, there's an opposite side of the trade that you should do. So if one side of the trade is Dead, you should take the the other side. I think that Ral does have a lot of interesting thoughts about the exponential age. And that's been something that I've been thinking about over the over the past week. And it's something that in the coming months at Real Vision, we are going to explore what are trends that are exponential, that are not mean reverting, that are not cyclical. Obviously, one of them, Ash, that you believe in, many believe is crypto. But I mean, you can sort of see them everywhere. If you look at something like Kimberly Clark, that stock was down a lot because of this whole toilet paper drama. And it did not have a great quarter.
59:34 Speaker 02 But if you just look at the chart from 1990 to now, it's an exponential trend. So I think in 2030, will Kimberly Clark be higher than it was today or it was yesterday? Yes. So I, short answer, no, I don't think macro is dead.
59:47 Speaker 00 Here's my answer. It's like the death of a king. Macro is dead. Long live macro. I think that it's this transition, the old world being reborn in a more digital context. You know, I think that Ral has some really incredible insights into this. Macro is dead is often a phrase that's used in contradistinction from the digital asset space, from the crypto asset space. My feeling, and I think Ral's feeling as well, and he's spoken very eloquently to this point, is what we're seeing is a union, a convergence of macro and digital assets. We're seeing, to some extent, digital assets being brought into the traditional system in terms of the legal regulatory compliance frameworks. And then we're also seeing
1:00:30 Speaker 00 digital assets rewriting some of the old rules. So macro is dead. Long live macro. I think macro, in some contexts, will always be here. It's a little bit of an evolution. I'm reminded perhaps of the great Francis Fukuyama's book in 1992, The End of History. History did not end. It just transmogrified into something else. So I think that while the old rules of the game are being replaced by new rules, I don't think I don't think that macro is dead. Because whatever sort of comes, it's almost like a self fulfilling prophecy or an identity property. Whatever comes in the wake of macro will be the new macro. And I think that that's what we're going to be talking about here on Real Vision and Real Vision Crypto. It's an incredibly exciting time.
1:01:15 Speaker 02 Very interesting stuff. I do think Francis Fukuyama, his statement that history is over, the end of history, I think that's not very well respected now based on things like 2016 elections, the rise of populism. So I think history was not dead in that case. But you do make very interesting points. I think with something like Bitcoin, I do view that as macro because I think the macro people who got into Bitcoin, they're like, okay, the central bank balance sheet is exploding. There's only 21 million. It's a pretty simple trade. I think that as people are getting more into Ethereum and I don't know, you know, other altcoins, I'm not going to name them, that is really about the technology and that is not necessarily about a central bank balance sheet. But I think there is a bridge and I think that bridge is kind of Bitcoin. So I think macro is not dead,
1:02:00 Speaker 02 but crypto is definitely close to macro, I would say.
1:02:03 Speaker 00 Guys, we've done it once again. We've completely blown through. We're like, we'll keep this at like 35 to 40 minutes. We're in over an hour here. A great conversation with both of you. Always enjoy these conversations. Ed, Jack, thank you so much for joining us.
1:02:19 Speaker 02 Thanks so much.
Previous Whispers of Tax Hikes Spook Stocks - Plus Defining "The New Normal" Next Inflation vs. Reflation: Why Risk Asset Prices Hinge on the Difference Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated