Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing "Our Conviction Is Very High" About this episode U. S. equity indexes traded mixed Thursday, as investors priced in murky economic data and the reality that Jerome Powell’s Federal Reserve shall not pivot from its inflation-fighting stance. “We think the CPI report was very important for the market,” said Eric Johnston, the Senior Managing Director and Head of Equity Derivatives and Cross Asset at Cantor Fitzgerald. “It showed that inflation does not magically come down and you can’t get it under control with a soft landing, an unemployment rate below 4%, and the S&P 500 at 4,000.” Eric joins Andreas Steno Larsen for today’s Daily Briefing to talk about why equities are holding up so well with global growth increasingly impaired and financial conditions more and more restrictive. Eric and Andreas also discuss key levels for major asset classes and positioning dynamics amid the many prevailing global geopolitical-macroeconomic crosscurrents. We also hear from Jason Trennert about the structural factors that will keep inflation higher for longer. Watch the full conversation featuring Jason Trennert and Ash Bennington here: https://rvtv.io/3dfUHvY. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, you should check out the full finance journey at realvision.com/rvpod to get the full view of what Real Vision is all about. A video on-demand platform you can watch anywhere. Our members get daily videos and analysis, plus access to more than 3,000 videos for beginners and experienced investors alike, and live events online. You'll join the most thoughtful community in finance. More than 300,000 people who trust Real Vision to be the anchor to truth in the financial world. To get started, visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for your first year. Enjoy the show.
0:52 Speaker 01 Hi everyone and welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. I'm Andreas Stenholsten from Real Vision, sending to you live Thursday, September 15th, after a tricky week in markets on the back of this shocking inflation report earlier this week. So today, we're going to ask the question, why are equities holding up so well, given this list of negatives surrounding the outlook for the economy? And with me today to debate that question, I've invited Eric Johnston, the Head of Equity Derivatives at Canada Fitzgerald. Eric, it's really good to see you again.
1:33 Speaker 02 Andreas, great to see you. Glad to be here.
1:36 Speaker 01 So Eric, first things first, this question that we are asking today, why are equities holding up so well? We're still a pretty decent distance from the lows seen earlier this early summer. What's your take on that question?
1:52 Speaker 02 So it's a great one. I've been very surprised myself that we've held up this well. So here's what I think is going on. So so far during the sell-off, institutions have brought down their exposure in a pretty significant way. So if you look at CTAs, their net short equities, they've sold a fair amount this year. If you look at mutual funds, they've raised their cash levels in their equity portfolios to some of the highest levels in a long time, possibly ever. They're at about 6.1%. And then hedge funds have brought down their gross exposure and have brought down their net exposure to, they're essentially in the 1 to 5th percentile over the last 10 years.
2:37 Speaker 02 But on the other side of that is the individual investor. And as you remember, during the run-up post-COVID, the individual investor put somewhere around 1.5 to 2 trillion dollars into the equity markets. And what's happened during this sell-off is that essentially none of that has come out yet. Okay, so the individual investor has not been selling equities. It shows up in the data, and I'm sure everyone, you know, watching this, people they talk to, family members, people have not have not sold. And so I think the next leg of this sell-off is going to come from those
3:23 Speaker 02 outflows from funds and the individual investor essentially reducing their exposure. If you look at the individual investor's allocation to equities, it's close to historic highs,
3:36 Speaker 02 somewhere north of 60%. So there is plenty of room for them to, you know, reduce their exposure. And I think they ultimately will, but so far has been, they have been very, very stubborn. And if you think about the amount that they added on the way up, you know, if they were to, you know, sell 1/3, a half of what they bought post-COVID, that would be enough to move the market sharply lower.
4:08 Speaker 01 That's a really interesting point, Eric. There is a big divergence between the positioning among institutions and the positioning among individuals. But if you're looking for sort of triggers for a sell-off among the individual investors, what could be the triggers that you're looking for?
4:27 Speaker 02 So I think there's a couple of things. So one of them is the alternative to equities. So we've had yield suppression now for essentially, you know, 12, 13 years, where the individual out there
4:45 Speaker 02 has been looking at an alternative to equities that's yielding, you know, anywhere from zero to a couple percent over the last 12, 13 years. And the recent move that we've seen in interest rates has been, you know, parabolic, right? And it's happened, and we can talk more about this related to the markets, but it's happened in a very short period of time. And so we're going to look up in three or four months, and money market funds are going to be yielding 4%. If someone said we were going to see a 4% money market yield a year ago, people would have thought you're crazy.
5:24 Speaker 02 And so that takes time for people to acknowledge that rates are higher and that they're going to be higher for longer, and they can actually get some yield. So I think what will be the catalyst for people selling equities and moving some into money market funds is going to be people, number one, sort of understanding and seeing these yields in very short-term paper. And then number two is, I think, losses. I think that as some of the larger-cap names, you know, come into play, where they might, you know, miss on earnings or what have you, that lower prices, I think, and lower and negative momentum
6:08 Speaker 02 is what's going to cause the selling. Because the individual investor has seen over the last 12 years, every dip is bought, just be patient, stocks will go higher. And at some point, as this sell-off continues and as it drags on, I think that patience will go down. The one other important point I would say is that if you look at some of the data that I think is really important, in the second quarter, there was about $300 billion that came out of deposits.
6:37 Speaker 02 At from checking accounts at banks. And, you know, in addition to that, you've seen this, you've seen credit usage surge over the last six months. And so what that tells you is that the consumer are starting to dip into different pockets, they're dipping into their deposits at checking accounts. They're increasing their balances on their credit card. The next thing that could come is I need to withdraw some money from my stock account to fund my lifestyle with this 10% inflation environment.
7:14 Speaker 01 If we look at a comparison between equities and interest rates on on short papers, one of the ways that you can do that is via the earnings yield on equities relative to the interest gained on, for example, short term treasuries. If you look at that ratio between the earnings yield in equity space and the yield on papers, what's your take on sort of the ratio between the two in a historical context?
7:44 Speaker 02 So if you if you look over the last 12 years since the financial crisis and this new regime that we've that we've been in, the equity risk premium, essentially the inverse of the PE, so the earnings yield, minus the 10-year yield. If you look at that that ratio, that index, what you'll see is that it's showing that the equity risk premium is actually at a 12-year low. So at a time when I think we would all agree that, you know, the risks around equities are extremely high right now, right? We have a Fed that's doing an experiment here
8:25 Speaker 02 that we've never seen before, going from the most accommodative Fed policy ever to the most restrictive Fed policy in the last 20 years. And it's all happening in a year. So the risks, including quantitative tightening, et cetera. So the risks right now are extremely high, yet the equity risk premium is at a 12-year low. So to me, that is going to correct itself. To the first question you asked, I'm surprised it hasn't so far, but feel confident that that it will.
8:58 Speaker 01 Eric, if we look at sort of implied levels, for example, in the S and P 500, that would allow the implied earnings yield on equities to sort of rise to levels that could accommodate new buying of equities. How low do we need to go in the S and P 500 to really accommodate new buying when we look at it from an initial perspective?
9:21 Speaker 02 So right now, the equity risk premium is at about 2.4% looking on forward earnings and assuming the estimates are correct that we see in print, which I don't think they are, but let's assume that they are. And so in nine of the last 11 years, the equity risk premium has hit 4%, has gone up to at least 4% in nine of the last 11 years. And so if you were to get to a 4% equity risk premium, you would be talking about a S and P in the low 3000s. And if the earnings are not accurate, then you could be talking about lower if earnings
10:03 Speaker 02 estimates are too high, which I think they are, but earnings have certainly proved resilient thus far.
10:08 Speaker 03 We're going to take a quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:15 Speaker 01 Let's talk about earnings because I know you have a really interesting point in terms of earnings relative to inflation in highly inflationary environments and you have a couple of charts that you can put up on the screen in relation to that exact point back from the 70s and the early 80s. What do you make of earnings in this highly inflationary environment right now?
10:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, so you know, I think it's when people talk about that inflation has peaked and that it's going to come down, that's something that I agree with and I think is going to happen. I think it's going to be much more stubborn than people think and I also think it's going to it's going to come down, not because of natural forces, but because of what the Fed is doing currently. And so, you know,
11:04 Speaker 02 When you look at, you know, earnings, earnings were helped by inflation. Earnings were helped by the supply chain issues that everyone was talking about. And so when people say inflation is going to come down, it seems like that's only, the conversation goes to, and hence the Fed is going to, can stop at four, four and a half percent. But the part that's missing in that is that corporate earnings, just like they benefited from inflation on the upside, they are going to get hurt when inflation comes down. So we looked at all of the times in history, in the last sixty, seventy years, when we've
11:48 Speaker 02 had these big spikes in inflation. We took a snapshot of the point where inflation peaked over the course of the next one to two years. And what happened to earnings as inflation numbers came down? And that's the chart that you see on your screen. And that's a snapshot of all those different times. And what you'll see is, in each of those cases, earnings came down. And the question is, why would that happen? Well, wages, employment costs are a very high percent of one's operating expenses.
12:28 Speaker 02 Those also tend to be much stickier and tend to lag other, the pricing of your goods and services. And so, on the way up, that lag helped. And then you can think about it in an environment where demand starts to degrade, which is what the Fed is trying, attempting to force to happen, then the price of your goods can come down a lot more sharply than your employment costs. So it's very easy to raise someone's wage, it's very difficult to cut someone's wage.
13:11 Speaker 02 And then as far as cutting the number of people that work for you, you know, there's been a mismatch in the labor force, and so companies will be much more hesitant to cut labor. And so this is what's going to cause, in our view, some margin contraction and ultimately an earnings hit.
13:32 Speaker 01 Speaking to this point of sticky inflation by wages, it's obviously fairly easy to get inflation from 10% year-over-year to, say, 6%, or at least manageable. But it's probably trickier to get inflation from, say, 6% back to 2%, the ultimate target for the Federal Reserve. So, speaking to this point of sticky inflation, do you think the Fed will actually try and bring equity prices down to get the next leg lower in inflation done?
14:07 Speaker 02 I do. I mean, I think that inflation now, you know, people talk about the word entrenched. It's been going on for, you know, somewhere, high inflation for somewhere around a year and a half. And there's no end, you know, in sight. So it is becoming entrenched. It is broadening out, right? Initially, it was supply chain. It was oil. Oil's now back to the high 80s. Supply chain has, you know, mostly rectified itself. And yet, we still have an inflation issue putting up a 0.6% month-over-month core number, or 7.2% a year and a half later. So it is becoming entrenched. And so, in order to get inflation down,
14:52 Speaker 02 it doesn't magically come down on its own when it's this high for this long. So if you have an unemployment rate at 3.8%, an S&P at, you know, 3,900, 4,000,
15:08 Speaker 02 and you have a soft landing, that's just not going to get inflation down. You have to get asset prices lower. You have to get wealth lower. Unemployment up. And as people have fewer assets, less wage growth, and more people are unemployed... Then demand to pay those prices goes down and the supply of goods becomes more competitive. And that's how there will be a shakeup in the economy to get prices to move lower and stay lower, which is the key.
15:50 Speaker 02 And so the Fed has a lot of work to do because we entered this with the economy in very strong shape. The labor force, you know, supply and demand completely out of balance. So that's going to take time. You know, we saw today the settlement with the labor union related to rails, a 24% increase in wages. It's still going on. Today, the Boeing CEO said, we're going to have inflation with us for the next five years. And so the whole idea is that it's going to be much more challenging to get it down to the 2% area that I think the market is giving credit for.
16:31 Speaker 01 A piece of anecdotal evidence in relation to this debate, Eric, from my side, I think we can bring up the tweet of the day in relation to that. I'm personally seeing more and more signs that inflation is also becoming sort of self-fulfilling in Europe. I'm contracting within private equity in the real estate sector in Europe. And right now, we see rental growth as a lagged consequence of the increase in prices in right about every corner of the economy. And the housing cost is one of the lacking components in the CPI index. We also saw that in this week's CPI report in the US with a month-on-month increase in
17:15 Speaker 01 the shelter cost of, was it just south of 0.8% month-on-month? So that's basically a crazy number if you analyze it. But that leads me to the housing market area because, I mean, we've been talking about it for quite a while. We've had another terrible monthly print out of the Canadian housing market today. But I still think that we sort of lack the final evidence that the US housing market is rolling over. What's your assessment of the housing market right now?
17:49 Speaker 02 So I think it's similar to the labor market. There was a mismatch post-COVID, a shift going on in how people live their lives. Remote work and everything that we know that changed post-COVID. So there was a imbalance, but the imbalance, I think, is quickly coming into balance. And there will be, I think prices will begin to move lower. The sharp rise in mortgage rates, clearly a headwind. The wealth effect outside of one's home is clearly getting hit based on bonds and stocks
18:32 Speaker 02 getting hit simultaneously. And I think also there is going to be a slow, from here, a slow back to work and less back to the office and less lenient policy. I'm not saying we're going anywhere close to what it was pre-COVID, but we're more and more, I think that's the direction we're going. And the opposite was what would help the housing market to begin with. So I think for all those factors, we are at the beginning of the weakening of the housing market. I think it's going on as we speak, and we know that housing is a slower moving asset
19:14 Speaker 02 price than equities, but I think it will head in a lower direction.
19:20 Speaker 01 I wanted to play a soundbite for you as well, Eric, today, and it's from a debate between Ash Bennington and Jason Trinidad on this higher for longer inflation narrative. So let's listen to this soundbite and get back to the discussion on inflation and housing.
19:39 Speaker 03 So Jason, what are the structural issues that you guys see in terms of keeping inflation higher for longer and how significant a threat do you think those structural issues are?
19:49 Speaker 04 Well, I would say, Ash, I think they're a threat. I don't think they're insurmountable threats, but they are things that are likely to keep inflation readings higher for longer than people perhaps are expecting. There's three in particular that I would focus on. The first would be wages. And as you may know, there are about twice as many job openings as there are people that are actively looking for work that don't have a job. And so particularly on the, I would say, entry level, service oriented jobs, there's a lot of pressure on wages because there's really only one way to solve that equation and that's through
20:29 Speaker 04 increasing price, increasing the price of labor. So to me, that's structural. Secondly, I think the housing market, while it's weakening a bit, if you can believe it, house prices in the US are up close to 20% year over year. That's very significant because housing prices tend to lead rents and homeowners equivalent rent is a very big part of the CPI, about 25% of the CPI. And so right now, I think there's going to continue to be upward pressure on rents. And then the third issue that's structural, it seems to me, and I don't want to offend anyone's politics here, but I do think that the West's environmental
21:09 Speaker 04 policies are keeping a price of fossil fuels higher, longer than they ought to be, given the fact that we have a war and there are other geopolitical considerations at play. But that's a decision that the West politicians have made. I think it's a very risky one politically, personally. But those three things are not easily fixed and I think are going to keep inflation a little bit higher longer than people think.
21:43 Speaker 01 The entire interview with Jason Turner is already available at the Real Vision platform for subscribers today. Back to you, Eric. If we take Jason's words for granted that we will be faced with an inflation pressure higher than what we've been used to over the past couple of decades for a prolonged period now, is there any way to sort of position for that in equity space outside of being outright short on index levels?
22:11 Speaker 02 Yes, so I think one interesting sector that has clearly done very well so far this year is energy, but I think it is something that is going to continue for a few different reasons. So the first is that we're going to have a situation where the supply dynamic is going to change over the next month and a half with the SPR release coming to an end. And simultaneous with that, we are going to sometime in the next, likely sometime within the next six months, you're probably going to see an easing of the zero COVID policy
22:52 Speaker 02 out of China, which is going to sharply increase the demand from their perspective. In concert with that, you have less capital spending that's going on, and that's part of this overall inflation for longer story is that as ESG becomes much more relevant by the day and the decarbonization spending and views move forward, then you're going to have less capital spending on drilling.
23:36 Speaker 02 And so you have that secular tailwind that's going to be behind you. So I think oil does very well. We know the gas situation where there should remain high demand for US natural gas.
23:56 Speaker 02 And in a world where it's very difficult to find companies that actually have fundamental momentum, good balance sheets, dividends, capital return stories, and have very good secular tailwinds, it's very hard to find. And energy is something that I think will do very well. I would add on to that, that I think healthcare does well. And I think healthcare can do well, just because it is less cyclical, has capital return in parts of the non-bio tech market, and will be, I think it'll be a place where people want
24:39 Speaker 02 to move dollars into as a way to be in a less cyclical group, and also get some yield while they're there.
24:51 Speaker 03 We're going to take another quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
24:59 Speaker 01 Speaking to this point of the zero COVID policy in China, we've had a couple of questions from the audience already surrounding the move that we've seen in the US dollar versus the Chinese yuan. I can add that it's fairly clear from the daily fixings being set by the People's Bank of China that they're trying to defend the yuan against weakening too fast right now. But is this yuan weakening on your radar in relation to the zero COVID story, Eric?
25:29 Speaker 02 So it's on my radar. I would say that it is much less so on the radar of equity investors. Clearly, the macro world is focused on it. But I would say equity investors are much less focused on it. And I think it should be. I think one of the things that...
25:52 Speaker 02 That's going on really across all so many different asset classes that you're seeing these very large moves, whether it's the rate market, the FX market. You know, today, gold was breaking down. And when you get these types of moves, whether it be in a two-year yield, right? When you look at a chart of that and it has absolutely surged. These things typically happen, typically something breaks. And whether it breaks in, you know, people's positioning, or it breaks a economy in the circumstance of rates.
26:34 Speaker 02 And it tells you that there's something going on under the cover that you should be concerned about and that risk levels, I think, right now are at some of the most elevated levels that I've seen in a long time.
26:50 Speaker 01 I can add that it's typically not a good signal when the yuan is weakening fast. It's probably the signal that Chinese capital is fleeing China. So quite the thing to worry about, in my opinion. Eric, we have a couple of questions in relation to derivatives because you're obviously also a derivatives expert. And we have a question from Bo in relation to the high volume of options. He's asking you whether this high volume of options is impeding price discovery and skewing prices and whether the market has sort of turned into a derivative of the derivatives. What do you make of that tricky question?
27:32 Speaker 02 So there's been, so the options market has been, you know, used more and more over the last couple of years by the, you know, individual investor. And at times, they've been able to move individual stocks based on very heavy option activity, typically with a duration of a day or a week. And they're able to, as a result, you know, move many stocks. I think if we look at it on a broader perspective, you know, there is clearly an increased use of options. One of the things that we're looking at right now is that
28:15 Speaker 02 Dealer gamma activity right now is, or gamma levels right now are very short. And that's one of the things that's causing the exacerbated intraday moves that we're seeing. So if you look at the S and P futures, the last 48 hours, the intraday moves have been violent. And the, one of the big reasons for that is that the active managers are fairly quiet. Much, they're kind of watching and it's really being dictated by gamma hedging that's going on from a very large, short gamma position.
28:52 Speaker 02 I would also say that if you, it's interesting, if you look at SKU in the S and P 500, it's really quite flat and you know, there's not, I would say there's a little bit of complacency around the potential downside in the market, meaning that there are, there's not as much demand for hedging for a large downside move in the S and P 500, which is one of the things that's keeping the SKU fairly flat relative to the, you know, at the money or near the money.
29:30 Speaker 01 Interesting observation. The final thing I wanted to debate with you, Eric, is whether you have any strong views in terms of sort of regional performance when it comes to geography. We obviously have a critical situation ongoing in Europe in relation to energy. But are you more or less concerned about European equity markets relative to the US equity market?
29:54 Speaker 02 So it's a tough question because I would say that I'm more concerned about the European economy. However, that's being reflected in the multiples that are being paid in, in Europe versus the US. So, you know, to give you an example, we talked about the equity risk premium.
30:20 Speaker 02 Being at a 12-year low. If you look at the equity risk premium, for example, for Japan, that's at a 12-year high. So, you know, there are markets are, there's a big divergence going on between markets. You know, the US market multiple is, you know, is far greater than, you know, rest of world and that spread has been widening. So it makes it tough because I think we would, you know, if we had a rank order where we want it to be, if we didn't know multiples, I think that would be a much easier exercise.
31:04 Speaker 02 And clearly, you know, the European outlook, I think is far worse than it is in the US. But when you actually do look at prices and multiples, it's, a lot of that is being reflected and that's what makes it tough. So, you know, if you ask me right now, you know, what trade would I put on Europe versus US, I wouldn't have a great answer because I think it's, I think that's a very tough, tough spread.
31:30 Speaker 01 Yeah. I tend to agree, even though I'm, I'm being long US equities versus European equities, but I am probably also pondering whether to close down that spread for now after quite a decent performance this, this year. But Eric, it was a great pleasure talking to you this afternoon again, and I wanted to sort of highlight your key takeaways for the equity risk premium in the US to return to sort of most palatable levels. In a historical context, we would probably need to see the SPX moving to the low 3000s.
32:11 Speaker 01 It is very tricky to say whether the European equity market will have an even more sour outlook than the US equity market, but the European economy is certainly in a bad spot. So it's not easy to say whether there is any place to hide on the globe from, from this list of negatives in relation to equities. And then the final point is that we should watch the positioning among individual investors because that's essentially the shoe that needs to drop before the next leg lower in equities. Have I gotten this right, Eric?
32:44 Speaker 02 Yes.
32:46 Speaker 01 All good. Thank you so much for joining the
32:48 Speaker 02 Andreas, thank you very much.
32:50 Speaker 01 It was a pleasure hosting you and thank you out there for watching the daily briefing again today. My colleague Maggie Lake will be back with more tomorrow. So see you there.
33:05 Speaker 05 What's up revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest and biggest names in finance.
Previous What To Do at the Acceptance Stage of the Tightening Cycle Next My Life in 4 Trades - How To Recover From a Huge Loss Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated