Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Is It All Over for Energy Bulls? About this episode Price action continues to reflect investors’ collective ambivalence about what comes next, with Wall Street warning of grim prospects for both stocks and growth in 2023. As Jason De Sena Trennert sees it, the “greatest risk to the economy and markets may be the Fed’s need to tighten more than risk markets anticipate.” That crude oil is probing near-term lows even as China eases some “COVID zero” restrictions is just one point of confusion. Trennert, the founder and CEO of Strategas Securities, joins Andreas Steno Larsen to break down what crude oil and other key markets are telling us right now, how inflation will become “sticky,” and why the Federal Reserve will have to go higher for longer. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:07 Speaker 00 Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. My name is Andreas Dino, and today it's Wednesday, December 7. We are going to ask the question today whether one should be bullish or bearish energy. And we've actually gathered both an energy bull and an energy bear in this studio today. So I'm pleased to be joined by Jason DeSoto, the CEO of Strategas, the energy bear today. Welcome to the show, Jason.
0:42 Speaker 01 I'm happy to be here. I'm the energy bull, though.
0:45 Speaker 00 You're the energy bull, of course. I mixed it up. But Jason, let's talk about energy first. Why is energy still a good bet, in your view?
0:57 Speaker 01 It's still a good bet, in my opinion, because we've largely created, I would argue, an artificial scarcity of oil and natural gas. And I see no give when it comes to policymakers as far as having a supply-side response. When I look at production of oil, generally speaking, about 100 billion barrels a day, we still have a large portion of the population globally that has never had access to energy. And so that population is going to continue to grow, while I think even in a recession,
1:38 Speaker 01 which I think is possible next year, if not likely, generally speaking, demand is a fall all that much. But it largely has to do with the idea that I believe that Western countries, unfortunately, have created an artificial scarcity of the product.
1:58 Speaker 00 But Jason, when you watch the price action over the past few days here, energy stocks at the bottom of the index for like two, three days in a row, oil in a bearish trend, what makes you optimistic right now on energy?
2:16 Speaker 01 I think part of it is that I travel around and meet with a lot of institutional investors globally. I think despite the fact that energy was best performing sector in the S and P 500 last year, up 50%, despite the fact that it's the best performing sector in the S and P 500 this year, I think up 57, it's still only about 5% of the S and P 500. And so it doesn't suggest to me that it's over-owned. I find that there's a lot of institutional investors that can't buy energy because of certain ESG mandates.
2:55 Speaker 01 And then there's another group of investors that have seen how poorly companies have managed their capital over time and are fearful about getting involved. In my opinion, though, the world has changed quite a bit and the companies are far more focused on being good stewards of capital.
3:22 Speaker 00 I can certainly confirm your view that a lot of pension funds, a lot of asset managers cannot buy energy, also in Europe where I'm from, simply due to ESG rules, policies set by the board of various asset managers and pension funds. But Jason, I've read a lot of your notes recently and you've sort of opened the door for a recession next year, giving it in between 50 and 75% probability of a recession within the next 24 months. So how does that rhyme with a long energy view?
4:02 Speaker 01 No, it's a very good question and generally speaking, it is somewhat incongruous. Our other two overweight sectors are healthcare and consumer staples. So we're overweight, very defensive sectors. Energy, though, again, I think is a bit different now. And that's mainly because there continues to be a strong demand for the product. I think it's still, despite all of the efforts to move to renewables, there's still a very strong hunger, thirst for fossil fuels that I don't think is going to go away anytime soon. And in past recessions, generally speaking, demand might fall by a million, maybe a million and a half barrels a day. Even during COVID, you went from 100 million barrels a day,
4:48 Speaker 01 85 million barrels a day in production and consumption. And that was with everything being shut down. Now, it seems to me, especially with the possibility of China reopening, I think it's a little dangerous personally to be particularly short the commodity. At least, I would also say the stocks, to me, the difference between the stocks and the commodity, stocks make a lot of sense, in my opinion, at anything over $60 a barrel.
5:20 Speaker 00 And one could obviously argue that cash flows are important again. But if we look at earnings into next year across sectors, Jason, obviously, when we look at P/E multiples right now in forward terms, they seem to be sort of in the middle of the park from a historical perspective. But what do you make of the E in the P/E multiple into next year?
5:46 Speaker 01 Well, again, I think, you know, a lot of this is, I would say, a lot of the companies at least, they have an ability to control the G to a certain extent, partly because they're not spending as much on CapEx as they have in the past. And as a result, I think the price of the commodity is going to stay a bit higher. I think I have a chart here. I just wanted to show people for a moment. And this is just in the U.S. But to me, the chart, I think, tells you a lot about what's happening in the States. And the dash line is the price of the commodity.
6:25 Speaker 01 And the blue line is twelve month trailing spending on capital expenditures. And what you can see is that there's been a very big difference between the price of commodity and the willingness of energy companies to punch holes in the ground. I think one of the great ironies about the energy industry, at least in the United States over the last several years, is that the Trump administration loves the energy industry, absolutely loves it, and yet, in many ways, it fed into the worst instincts of people that run energy companies and actually made them bad investments. And now you're in the Biden administration, which is no fan of the fossil fuel industry.
7:10 Speaker 01 And the irony, of course, is the Biden administration plus the ESG movement has made the companies much better investments, mainly because they're being incentivized to return money to shareholders in the form of dividends for share purchases. So I guess my view is that there's a capital discipline in the energy industry in the States that I have not seen really in my career over thirty years. It's normally the way it works is that the money burns a hole in the pockets of people that run energy companies, and when prices move higher, they tend to be their own worst enemies by punching holes in the ground. And if that is at half, it's not around.
7:54 Speaker 00 Jason, if we look at earnings estimates across other sectors than energy in today's year, I think the consensus is for an increase of roughly 2% in earnings per share next year for the S and P 500. What do you make of that consensus estimate compared to your expectations?
8:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, we actually have, uh, we actually have earnings down, uh, next year. And, um, so the, there's never been a recession without earnings being down. Even in inflationary periods, I think sometimes people make the argument that, that earnings can stay a bit higher than, than normal, uh, because earnings are a nominal terms. Uh, but even during the seventies, every recession you had was accompanied by fine earnings. So to use the actual numbers for the S and P 500, um, earnings this year should come in about $222, $223. We see earnings next year at $200 figure.
9:01 Speaker 01 Uh, and if we place a multiple on that 15 or 16 times, um, that leads us to believe there's more risk overall in the, in the equity market.
9:12 Speaker 00 So from a, from an allocation perspective, which sectors do you like and which sectors do you dislike as a consequence of this earnings call?
9:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, so we talked about, we talked about energy and I do think energy companies have some pricing power. So I like energy. We like consumer staples because we, we think here again, it's a defensive sector. Stocks are on cheap. I, I have no, I have no real, um, enthusiasm for buying things that are trading at 25 times earnings that are growing at 2%. But by the same token, it seems to me that staples are, are going to have a, a better, um, time of it in terms of maintaining pricing power in other sectors. And I also like healthcare because again, it's defensive and people don't have a lot of choices in terms of, uh, not necessarily spending on their healthcare. So those are the sectors I like the most.
10:06 Speaker 01 As far as the U S sectors, uh, I would be very careful on consumer discretionary. Uh, I think we've been living beyond our means for a very long period of time. Uh, I think we've also And subsidized by very cheap rates and quantitative easing for a long period of time and it's over. I'd also be very careful on real estate. I think that's, that's an area where particularly in commercial real estate, it seems to me that there's, there's come up as very likely in the next, next several years. So we're just at the very beginning of it.
10:39 Speaker 02 We're going to take a quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:48 Speaker 00 I almost perfectly agree with your views, Jason, but one thing that could wrongfoot our view is a very swift pivot from the Fed. So why don't we talk about the Federal Reserve for a second? What do you make of the most recent rhetoric from Jay Powell and the Federal Reserve regarding the pivot?
11:12 Speaker 01 That's a, it's a good question. And I think it, it certainly depends on how you're defining the pivot. And I, in my opinion, I really define a pivot as moving from tight monetary policy to easy monetary policy. And I, I don't think that's going to happen for at least a year. I, I think even if there's a financial crisis, I would be more willing to think that the size of balance sheet asset sales would, that would, that would slow down more than they would be willing to cut rates. I think right now the Fed is very focused on, on getting inflation under control. There are some signs that it's, their policies
11:54 Speaker 01 are working, but we still have it on, we still have an inflation rate in the U.S. of, based on the CPI of 7.7%. To me, the Fed is not really going to think about a true pivot or move to easier policy until you see positive real rates on the short end, or if you see real weakness in the labor market. And thus far, neither of those conditions really have been met. So I think it's very difficult for the Fed to move easier or more accommodative monetary policy anytime soon. Certainly, I do think that within the next several months, it would not be surprising me if they stop increasing rates just to see how their policies are working. But I'm not sure that's enough to really...
12:39 Speaker 01 Certainly, I don't think it's enough by growth stocks, let's put it that way. I think that that world has changed mainly because going back to quantitative easing and subsidized levels of interest rates, I think, is very, very unlike anytime soon.
12:53 Speaker 00 So, Jason, where does this leave the outlook for inflation?
12:59 Speaker 01 I'm of the view, at our shop, we would not quibble with the idea that inflation probably peaked. We've probably seen a high watermark for inflation in this cycle. By the same token, I think there are structural reasons why inflation may be sticky, that it's going to be difficult, at least in the US, where inflation can come down. First point I would simply make is that about 60% of the US federal budgets is indexed to inflation, plus interest expenses, which is another 10 or 12% of the budget. So the Fed is going to be fighting government spending in many ways this year.
13:44 Speaker 01 Social Security, our pension scheme, our public pension plan, the cost of living adjustment this year is 8.7%. The same is true for Medicare, Medicaid, our healthcare systems. And then interest on the debt is exploding in size because interest rates have gone up as much as they have. So the first thing I would say is government spending is going to remain pretty robust in the States. Second point I would make is that at least as it stands now, there's a labor shortage in the US, where there are many more job openings than there are people looking for work. That keeps wage inflation quite high.
14:25 Speaker 01 I think de-globalization is another long-term trend, which probably leads to higher inflation in the US over time. And then finally, I do think, as we talked about before, I do think that... There is going to continue to be a bid in the price of oil and the price of gas without any sort of supply-side response, any attempt to increase supply in the United States. So I don't quibble with the idea that inflation's probably peaked, but I think the Fed getting to its target of 2% could be a tall order, could take a long time to get there.
15:02 Speaker 00 Jason, if we assume that you're right, that inflation will be sort of stickier than anticipated by many, what does that mean to equity allocation within sectors? Which sectors perform in a sticky inflation environment?
15:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, I think it's much more, I think it's much more about the balance sheet. And so sectors are important, but I'd also say that the real trick, I think, is for companies to be self-funding, which is to say that they don't necessarily have to rely on the kindness of strangers and the capital markets for an ability to grow. And so companies that generate a lot of cash flow, it seems to me, are going to be very well-posed to weather the storms. I'm not saying that they won't hurt in some way in a recession. Almost everything is susceptible in a recession.
16:01 Speaker 01 But it's really more, I think, in this environment, outperformance, at least among institutional money managers, is going to be driven much more by what you don't own as opposed to what you do own. And what, in my opinion, what you don't want to own are companies that are highly leveraged, that are very focused, that need a lot of variable debt, and that don't have much in the way of cash flow or earnings to support what was previously really just kind of a free pass to grow. The world, in my opinion, has changed dramatically. A year ago, companies were strongly incentivized to grow at any cost. There was a lot of private capital there to help them do that.
16:44 Speaker 01 This time around, it's not here, the cost of debt capital. Significantly and equity capital is significantly higher. And so those companies are either going to have to shrink or figure out a way to generate their own own profits and cash flow if they want to survive.
17:02 Speaker 00 Jason, you obviously have a bunch of professional accountants and speaking partners. What's your assessment of positioning in equities right now?
17:13 Speaker 01 That's that's another great question. And what I find when I talk to our clients is that there is a feeling that people on my side of the business, the sell side, are all bearish.
17:27 Speaker 01 And as a result, people say, well, how can this be correct? If everyone's, everyone has the same view, if everyone's bearish, how can that be correct? Isn't that already in price? But when I thought, when I look at positioning on buy side, I find that it's very rare to see people that are really defensively positioned. And I still see, if you look at single sector flows into ETFs, the energy sector has received, despite the fact that it's down close to thirty percent this year, the technology sector has received inflows this year. ARC, as an example, at the Woods ARC Fund, is down about sixty percent this year. It's received inflows of one and a half billion dollars.
18:12 Speaker 01 And so I would argue that you just don't have seen, especially in the tech world, I'm not sure you've seen the capitulation that you would normally see at the end of the bear market. And I think unfortunately, that may be the next shoe to drop.
18:29 Speaker 00 And I may add that if you are a portfolio manager, you can move the needle as much. But if your clients start withdrawing money from your fund due to unemployment, whatever, a recession, then you basically need to sell stocks, no matter you view on the market, right? But Jason, you sent me a very exhaustive list of bull and bear arguments for the equity market right now. And I would actually like to go through the pros and cons of being bullish right now. I think that's a really interesting discussion because to me, we are sort of standing at crossroads. It's very difficult to assess. But why don't you give us the sort of top down picture of
19:13 Speaker 00 the pros and cons of being long the equity market right now?
19:18 Speaker 01 So the pros to start out with that, and again, that's not my view, but the pros would be first is that Federal Reserve has created an awful lot of money. M2 is 40% higher today than it was before the pandemic. We still have a lot of liquidity in the system. Pros too are that you have, you still have negative real rates. So the equity risk premium actually is somewhat attractive. I would argue those are probably the most compelling arguments to be along the equity market. I also would say China is likely to open up a bit more. Old trade might do a little bit better.
20:00 Speaker 01 But those, I would argue, those are probably the strongest arguments to be along. On the other side, I think that if you're looking at the flow as opposed to the stock of money, M2 now is only growing at about 1.5% year-over-year. It was growing at 27% year-over-year at the start of 2021. So that's a pretty strong headwind. Second thing I would say is you never want to fight the Fed, and I would argue the Fed is still tightening. We have not seen the full impact of the Fed's tightening campaign. I would say that's the case.
20:41 Speaker 01 Third, I would say that in that environment, you're likely to see a slowdown in the economy from the interest rate sectors. You're already seeing that. You haven't seen something that normally occurs with that, which would be an increase in layoffs. And right now, the US economy is pretty close to full employment, despite the fact that profit growth is slowing. And I don't think those things are, I don't think they're consistent with one another. So it seems to me that consumer spending and consumer confidence is likely to hit next year as you see an increase, as you see an increase in layoffs. But the strongest arguments largely, and this is maybe when I grew up in the business, it's really the late 80s.
21:26 Speaker 01 I spent a lot of time thinking about liquidity and money growth. And if I'm using that as kind of my North Star, I would say it's hard to get really bullish on risk assets from here, generally speaking. It's going to be harder just because the central banks are now tight.
21:46 Speaker 00 Obviously, the Fed is trying at least to withdraw liquidity month after month.
21:52 Speaker 02 We're going to take another quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
22:01 Speaker 00 One thing that I wanted to discuss with you is the level of the so-called Fed put. It's obviously a question that we investors ask ourselves on a running basis. Where is the Fed put? Do we see a level at which the Fed will turn around? What's your take on the level of the Fed put in the current inflationary environment?
22:24 Speaker 01 This sounds, this may sound a little crazy, but given where inflation is right now, I don't think there's a Fed put, at least as far as interest rates are concerned. If there is a Fed put, it would be the pace at which you see asset sales from the Fed's balance sheet. So it would be the rate of change and quantitative tightening would be maybe the mechanism for which the Fed would deal with a financial crisis. But if there's a financial crisis right now, it seems to be the Fed has a very, very, have very different times of cutting interest rates, given the fact that inflation is still such an issue and is such an important political issue. As you may know, we just had our midterm
23:07 Speaker 01 elections in the U.S. about three weeks ago. Inflation was a top two or top three issue among just people. And so it's a very politically charged issue. And the Fed, for a long time, was able to focus on one part of its mandate, which was full employment. I would say now it has to focus a lot more on what was originally their own mandate, which is price to burn.
23:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, I perfectly agree. We have time for a couple of questions from our members, Jason, and we have a question from a member asking you, can you please discuss how de-globalization might affect equity markets globally?
23:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think, listen, I think free trade is always a source of,
23:59 Speaker 01 in my opinion, of growth and or inflation. I think we could debate whether we really had free trade after the Berlin Wall came down or after China joined the WTO, but there's very little question that it resulted in lower inflation or disinflation in the developed world, but no, I wouldn't quibble with that. I do think part and parcel of the idea of decolonization was the idea that non-Western countries might become more Western. And I think over the last couple of years, there are real questions about that, whether it's Russia's incursion into Ukraine or China's dealing with the pandemic. And so there's going to be much more of a bias in the US to do onshoring, which bring
24:44 Speaker 01 more of our manufacturing back to the United States, or what they call friendshoring, bringing them to other parts of the world that we have strong geopolitical allies, which is all, it's a good development, not a bad development, but it's simply more expensive. And it strikes me that that would have an impact on profit margins, could have a positive impact on employment in the States, but it's also going to have a deleterious impact on profit margins and profit growth, at least without productivity, you know, meaningful productivity gains. Unfortunately, productivity in the US is quite poor as it stands right now.
25:24 Speaker 00 Let me follow up with the question. Until recently, I was head of allocation at one of the biggest funds in Europe. I listened in through a bunch of earnings calls with American CEOs, and it seemed to me like they talked a lot about bringing supply chains back to the US or nearer to the US borders, but they didn't do a lot about it. Do you concur with that view?
25:51 Speaker 01 I do, and I think part of the problem, even though there there might be a desire to do that, practically speaking, in the United States, it's we don't have the workers, we don't have labor. As you may know, in the States, labor force participation rate is quite low. There's a lot of theories to why that is, why that's the case. But one of the theories is that there are a lot of people that are close to retirement age before the pandemic. And then once the pandemic hit, they didn't come back to work. You know, they didn't, once the pandemic was over, they kind of, they rather liked being retired than come back to work. In any event, we simply have, as I mentioned before, we have about
26:34 Speaker 01 three million more job openings than we have people that are actively looking for work. So while it's a good idea, it's a nice idea. I don't think practically speaking, it can happen anytime soon. Now, perhaps if you get a recession and you get more slack in the labor markets, it's something that they consider. But right now, frankly, we have a hard enough time producing what we need to produce with the the industry mix that we have in the States as it stands today.
27:05 Speaker 00 As I've said recently, I think the best labor market supply reform that you can make right now is to allow the housing market and the equity market to sell off rapidly. That would allow a lot of people to return to the labor force. And a bit of anecdotal evidence from my side, running my own company in Europe right now, it's actually very difficult to get anyone to show up. And I think that's a symptom of people getting too rich. Jason, it's been a great pleasure to host you. Any final thoughts for the audience here?
27:36 Speaker 01 No, I would, I would just, on your last point, I would very much concur. We're trying to hire people here in New York on our trading desk. And we had a very hard time finding two people that would actually want to work five days a week in the office. That was that seemed to be a bridge too far. But it strikes me that the Fed, to the extent to which you're either going to have to create a position in which you get productivity to allow inflation to come down, or you have to destroy demand. There's one of the two things have to happen if you want inflation to be lower. And right now, it strikes me that
28:14 Speaker 01 Fed's decision is to destroy demand is seems to be the choice that they're making at that point.
28:22 Speaker 00 So let's sum up for the audience, the Fed has more work to do. We should lean bearish on equities overall, but there are sectors with strong cash flows that you actually can buy in the current environment. And before we leave you out there, I would like to show the meme of the day because I've been leaning clearly bearish on energy in recent weeks with a lot of success, but after speaking to Jason, I don't really know anymore. It's kind of a 50 50 to me. Jason Tredor, CEO of Strategus, it was a pleasure to host you.
29:00 Speaker 01 It was my pleasure. Thank you for your time.
29:03 Speaker 00 Thank you, Jason. And Maggie Lake, my colleague, will be back tomorrow with some work big visiting the show. Thank you for watching the Real Vision Daily Briefing today.
29:19 Speaker 03 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest and biggest names in finance.
Previous From the Macro to the Micro Next From Crisis to Recovery Page updated October 28, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated