Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Did We Dodge a Recession? With Warren Pies About this episode Warren Pies, co-founder and strategist of 3Fourteen Research, joins Maggie Lake to explore why recent housing data might be pointing to a soft landing, what that means for the Fed's battle against inflation, and when the next recession could arrive. You can find more of Warren's work here: https://t.co/vM9jt9PPQe Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:32 Speaker 01 Did the US dodge a recession? Hi everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. With me today is Warren Pies, co-founder of 314 Research. Hi Warren, it's great to see you.
0:43 Speaker 02 Good to be back. Thanks for having me.
0:45 Speaker 01 So, we kicked off the week, for a lot of people it was a long weekend, here in the US anyway, with a federal holiday. And so we're in a trading shortened week, and everybody came back and we saw sort of stocks slide, give up some of those gains, although they did come off the lows of the day, helped maybe in part by home builders who did outperform after we had a stronger than expected housing report. I know that you've been looking into housing a lot too. So, what did you make of the number? What do we need to understand about what's happening in housing?
1:17 Speaker 02 Well, this is to me, we're laser focused on housing right now. Because to me, the most important question across assets is recession timing. Like, are we going to have a recession? And if so, when is that going to hit? And so, in our view, at 314, we've kind of created a little model of the US housing market. And when you go back into history, just to give you the quick background, you go back into history, in general, you see residential construction payrolls fall by 8% to 10%.
1:50 Speaker 02 Right before you get into a recession in the United States. So that's what we're looking for is a drawdown of eight to 10% in residential construction payrolls. And really, when you think about what drives payrolls, it's the number of units under construction. And when you back out from there, what drives units under construction? It's the number of houses that are started and then how long it takes to finish a house. And so those are the real moving parts. I mean, you can break the industry up into single family homes and multifamily homes. There's about three times as many workers for each single family unit over multifamily unit. But we model all this out because we're trying to find that eight to 10% decline in residential construction payrolls and when it hits. And so it's really important for us to track starts as a part of that.
2:35 Speaker 02 And today we got that all important new housing starts number. And it came in at, we were looking, it's been at like a 70,000 on a single family starts have been coming in about 70,000 new units per month. We were expecting in order to get to our recession timeline, which is Q1 of next year. We at 314 were expecting single family starts to fall to like 60,000 units per month. And today you got a crazy rebound to like 83,000 units in the month of May. So you're way off of the, the trajectory that you need to be to get to a recession. So that's single family.
3:17 Speaker 02 Multifamily is less economically sensitive, but still drives a big part of that residential construction employment. And we've seen a divergence in the economics of multifamily and single family over the course of this pandemic. So multifamily is not as shocking, but it still went from like 45,000 units a month to 52,000 units in May. So on single family and multifamily today was just a, a head scratcher. If you're a recession watcher and you're an economic, economic kind of timer, which is obviously a big part of macro investing. So that to me was the big news of the day.
3:54 Speaker 01 That's so interesting. What do you think is driving that strength? Why are we seeing a rebound?
3:59 Speaker 02 Well, there are a few theories. I think the number one theory is just very supply constrained, you know, and so the whole golden handcuffs concept, you know, the idea that mortgage rates, you know, have gone up so much and that anyone who has a 3% mortgage and just can think through common sense is not selling their house. So existing home supply is very low, which puts all the impetus back on the builders and on new construction, you know, and so that to me is the most likely culprit. When you dig into the geographic areas where we're seeing new starts, it's not the Northeast. You're seeing Midwest is kind of going crazy in this last report
4:42 Speaker 02 comparatively to other regions. So there's an idea that, you know, I'm just playing with ideas, that this new remote work trend is allowing people to migrate out of these urban centers and into more affordable regions of the country, which would be, you know, Midwest is in there. So that's, I think, part of it as well. But at the end of the day, the real straw that stirs the drink is affordability. And affordability has gone from, you know, $2,000 in real terms has been an area where we've seen housing activity slow consistently over the course of history. We went from, you know, $1,600 a month for housing payments, you know, before
5:26 Speaker 02 the pandemic to 3,000, almost a doubling in your monthly home payment on average in the United States. And so to me, that should slow activity, no matter what, even if we're talking about golden handcuffs or whatever. It's just, at some point, you can't get, you can't make the math work. Now, the only other thing that I didn't mention, but it's the last part that's kind of allowing, I think, Some of these new buyers to come into the market is builder buy down. So builders are buying down the interest rates. A lot of times that's temporary for for new home sales and allowing the math to work. But all of these things have a a limited runway that they can work. So I think this is just an important, it's one data point, you don't want to overreact.
6:10 Speaker 02 But if we stay on this trajectory, I mean, recession, in my view, at at seventy thousand new single family starts every month, you have a recession landing somewhere in the back half of two thousand twenty four. If you go up to eighty thousand a month, which is where we're at this report for the month of May, I just don't see a recession. That's that's not a contractionary number, in my view.
6:31 Speaker 01 Wow, which is which is incredible. And I think you really underscored why it's it's very, it's been very difficult. I mean, this is the most talked about recession. We say this all the time, and it's it's been such a moving target. By the way, those builder incentives you mentioned, both Brian and Melody commenting about that on the platform chat as well, as as one component. But as you say, it's sort of a mix of everything. I just want to back back up for a second, though, because I think that you're that that this is something that's really important and it doesn't get talked about a lot. We talk about housing and supply, the supply of new homes, you know, trying to to to meet that and the undersupply that existed. It's very interesting to me that you're really focused on residential construction payrolls.
7:16 Speaker 01 So it's sort of what's happening, not so much with the supply of homes, but what's happening with the workforce that you see as really critical here. That's so interesting to me that we don't hear that all the time.
7:28 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, you're always looking for a leading indicator, you know, the the whole, the recession is basically, if you can boil it down, you you need to see job losses if if we're going into recession. So we had a chart in our last report, I probably should have passed along, but I can describe it really quickly, is just we lined up aggregate payroll growth at the beginning of every recession, and we've just chugged higher here. Like, for the people who think we're already in a recession, this chart kind of disproves that notion immediately. So you just see payrolls chugging higher. Every single The recession is marked by job losses. That's what we're talking about. You can talk about PMIs and, you know, leading, leading economic indicators
8:10 Speaker 02 and all these indices and financial conditions. You can get into a lot of different rabbit holes here. But the bottom line is we need to see job losses and job losses in the residential construction industry precede job losses overall. And you can think about it's the most interest rate sensitive portion of the economy. Housing is really the economy. If the housing market, you know, sneezes, the rest of the economy catches a cold, basically. So this is the dynamic we're really trying to focus in. We're trying to find that leading indicator. The other stat that I pull out for people is even though construction is like 5% of total US payrolls in the average recession going back through modern history, it accounts for 15% of the jobs lost during recession.
8:55 Speaker 02 So this is kind of a, this is a labor force that's used to expanding and contracting more flexibly in these periods of weakness and strength. And so to me, this is a really important corner of the economic landscape that we should be paying attention to. The final thing is it's like four to six month lead between residential construction payrolls rolling over and your, your aggregate non-farm payrolls rolling over. And so that to me, it's the whole housing is the economy. So you need to focus on it. It's really difficult for me to envision a scenario where we have a true NBER defined recession and you don't get a slowdown in, in housing and residential construction payrolls.
9:39 Speaker 02 I mean, we're basically at the peak still. We're like fourth, we're very, we're really right at the peak. We've basically flatlined in the last four months, lost a little bit of a few jobs here. But for the most part, this is not the trajectory you expect for some kind of pending recession.
9:58 Speaker 01 Hey everyone, we're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:11 Speaker 01 So where is, so are we still seeing a shortage of workers? Is the, is the market tight? Or is it, is it sort of like balanced and tipping? Where do you think the momentum is for construction workers?
10:25 Speaker 02 So again, we really focus on
10:27 Speaker 01 I think we do have that chart somewhere. I don't know if Brian can find it in time, but I think it was in some of the material that, that you passed along. If we could find that, if you could look for Brian, that would be great.
10:36 Speaker 02 There was a scatter plot, Brian, if you have it. But if not, we're basically focused on units under construction. I think that's, and then you, you have to make a little bit of a couple of assumptions about how many multifamily units, because like I said, a single family unit employs three workers for every one worker that a multifamily unit employs. If you think about that and you mix that in your equation, the bottom line is when you think about the stock of units under construction in the United States right now, we've gone from exceedingly tight labor conditions in the residential construction market to balanced. So this move we've, we've seen from really one year ago to today, where we've had housing activity slow down, all that's done is gone from a place where I can't get an electrician
11:17 Speaker 02 to call me back, even if I have a big piece of work for them, to maybe they're going to return my call. So the market's gone from very tight to balanced. The next step, if you're looking for recession, you need to go from balanced to loose.
11:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:32 Speaker 02 You're not going to get there starting, building 80,000 new homes per month like we did in May.
11:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think when you said that getting an electrician to come to your house, like everybody just shook their head, raised their hand. Yeah, like we, we have all experienced that for what seems like a while now, where it's so difficult because they're just flat out on giant projects. So they don't want to, you know, they don't even have the time to return your call half the time. So, uh, super important stuff, Warren, and you really get in the weeds and break down the multifamily and, and single home, which is amazing. So
12:07 Speaker 01 The recession's pushed out, maybe not happening now, but we're talking, we're talking late 24 if it happens, based on what you're seeing now, or even further out than that.
12:16 Speaker 02 So our base case is Q1 of 2024. Again, those are with much more pessimistic assumptions than what we saw in today's data point.
12:27 Speaker 01 Right. So you're going to be watching now to see whether you have to change that even, push that out.
12:31 Speaker 02 Correct. Right. So our, to take it one step closer to the goals, we're looking for 7,000 residential construction jobs for the economy to shed 7,000 jobs every month from here into February, March of next year to hit that 8% drawdown number that we're talking about. Now, again, that assumes that starts back off to like 60,000 units a month. And I just, you know, today is a day to reflect on all that and to think like, there's a, for one, today's number, just at least on the margin, pushes that recession call back. So you can't, you have to adjust your model if you're looking at what we're looking at.
13:13 Speaker 02 So that's number one. If we stay at these levels, if we stay at these levels, then, you know, I think that the, like I said, we wouldn't even have a recession on the docket for 2024. That would be, yeah, it's, it's, it's really difficult to get to that place. So the, the question you have to ask yourself is, is this a re-acceleration? Is this a soft landing? How does this, you know, go from here? And the reason I think that's so important is because I do believe the stock market's moving as if it's in a new early cycle move here. And the bond market, on the other hand, is, is positioned as if the Fed is going to have
13:54 Speaker 02 to cut rates a lot in the next, call it 12 months at the very least, and if not sooner than that. And so you have a huge divergence in what the stock market is saying and what the bond market is saying. So the recession call to me, this is why we titled the report about this recession timing, the most important question, because in our view, once you tell me Where does the recession fall on the timeline?
14:19 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
14:20 Speaker 02 Every other asset that's on the menu, its relative value really flows from that answer. And so the, the stock market at this point, the, the recent rally, I do believe has, has fully baked this in. I mean, there is, it is fully pricing. So if we did have a bad, um, if the economy did weaken from here, I think stocks aren't priced for it. If the economy continues to strengthen like this, I think it's very negative for the bond market. So, you know, we've had, we have inversions, especially in the very front part of the curve, which should suggest the Fed's going to have to go in there and cut rates. Those cuts get priced out, that bleeds into the rest of the whole, the whole yield curve shifts higher in my view.
14:59 Speaker 02 So that's the, that's what's at stake with this recession call is really the, what's going to be, which market is going to be correct? The stock market with its positive outlook or the bond market with its negative pessimistic outlook?
15:11 Speaker 01 Absolutely. And as you point out, when we're talking, they're, they're way off, they're, they're in totally different universes right now. So, you know, they can't, they can't both be right. Is there a danger that they're both wrong though? You know, are we going to have a repeat where for reasons, both of those get hit? Like maybe, you know, how do you, this is like, I think what, why you're saying the timing is so important, isn't it?
15:35 Speaker 02 Correct. And that's kind of my base case. So my base case is that the, the recession, it, the stock market's going to be right in the near term, it's stock positive in the near term. But ultimately I think you get a pretty nasty saw for the stock market. We do have a recession. It's hard for me, going back to the affordability numbers that I cited, it's really difficult for me to see how this persists. Just, you know, builder incentives and, you know, all the different kind of levers that are being pulled. I mean, are, is, is the US consumer going to completely, uh, is everyone going to en masse? Cut 50% off the size of their new home builds? I, I don't see that. If you read through builder transcripts, that's not happening. The, the price points are still rising and things like that. So the numbers don't work.
16:20 Speaker 02 So at the end of this, still is a slowdown, is a recession. And I think that disappoints the stock market. Eventually, but before we get there, I think the the cycle is longer. It's just the theme has been a long cycle throughout. This year, we came into the year, everyone expecting a recession. And every time you get a data point like this, it pushes that cycle out. I think the first market to be frustrated will be the bond market. And the next market to be frustrated with the stock market. And so that's, that's how I see it, you know, we're ultimately the max amount of pain will be inflicted on all participants.
16:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, so this is, this is super important because for everyone listening. We're all gonna have to think about timeframe, right? So for the most part, you know, if you wanna, if you're, if you're trying to make some calculations. And, and if for keen viewers, you'll all remember that this issue of the timing of the recession has been the difference for a lot of forecasts. Cause Warren, we'll have people come on and say, well, that person's saying the opposite of what the person who was on yesterday is saying. And longer term, they might feel the same, but it's that timing of the recession. So Raul and Darius, for example, very different ideas about the timing of the recession when they were on together a few weeks ago. So everywhere we go, Jim Bianco was on last week.
17:36 Speaker 01 Everyone has a different theory, but like you, everyone's having to go back and revise it constantly because we're getting this information in, in real time. If you're trying to lead into the leading indicator. So a couple of people asking this question in the chat, including Colin and Joseph. So I'll, I'll use Joseph's. Does the Fed need to raise rates higher to hit payrolls? So what does this mean for the Fed? If the economy is showing this kind of resilience, you're at the Federal Reserve Board. You just decided to keep rates on hold or skip or pause, whatever you want to call it. What are you thinking? I mean, you're thinking you have to go again?
18:14 Speaker 02 On the margin, yeah. I mean, you may be able to, I think the Fed believes they're restrictive at the moment. I think there's evidence that suggests they're maybe not as restrictive as they, as they think. And so if the Fed, if you're in the Fed's shoes and you think you're already into sufficiently restrictive territory, then it's just a function of time from here that they need to, to let their, that rate policy. Work through the system. If it was me, I think what they could do is you're talking about the housing market. You're talking about borrowing channels. Raising that front end, what we've seen is it kind of is it has this kind of perversely stimulative effect where it actually increases this interest income to a certain small segment of the population who already have a lot of money.
18:58 Speaker 02 And then incentivizes economic activity through that channel. I think they need to really hit the borrowing channel. They want to slow the economy down and slow inflation down, slow down housing costs. And that would point to additional QT or more aggressive QT and balance sheet operations. And so to me, that's the, that has been an important point to watch for monetary policy is what they do with their balance sheet and quantitative tightening. And so to me, that's, that's what, if the world starts re-accelerating at a 7% mortgage rate, which sounds insane to me, and that starts, that housing disinflation that everyone expected to work through the system does not work through the system, then the Fed's going to have to
19:43 Speaker 02 figure out a way to push those mortgage rates up. And I think the easiest way to do that, if you go back in history during periods of QT, the spread between mortgages and 30-year treasury bonds goes from like 90 basis points to 300 basis points. So further QT where they're just, you know, they're letting more mortgages roll off their balance sheet, that's a real drag on borrowing costs for the housing market. And so, and that's where I think you end up eventually, you have the builder incentives and all that stuff, that's going to run out of, that's going to run out of steam. And there is an interest rate. I had somebody bring the builder incentives up to me. And they said, well, you know, this is just the golden handcuffs and rate buy downs and things like that.
20:25 Speaker 02 And the thought experiment, if you think that's what's going on is, okay, if rates go to 20% tomorrow, does that mean that, you know, builders are in even better position? Because it's going to have even fewer existing home sales. And I think that the thought experiment should reveal to you that no, that whether they're new or existing or anything, you have crossed a barrier where the economy can no longer support, housing starts at this level with interest rates at that, at that point. So that's the focus I think that the Fed's going to have is on their balance sheet and how they can impact those markets if they decide that that's fueling inflation further.
21:02 Speaker 01 We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
21:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's interesting, and we've been talking about the Fed being really between a rock and a hard place. Roger Hirst just did a masterclass with Diego Perea earlier today, and Diego, very worried about inflation and what he calls a series of systemic bubbles. Let's have a listen to a clip from that.
21:31 Speaker 03 This is not a zero-sum game in the sense that when we abuse monetary and fiscal, we delay, transfer, transform the problems, we're effectively creating even bigger issues. And I think that's where we're now. We're sort of trapped in this dynamic between systemic bubbles that are too big to fail and the problem of inflation as a result of this monetary and fiscal abuse. And this is, I think this framework is proven to be very resilient, and it can help explain pretty much every single behavior from central banks and governments, from energy subsidies to bailouts to all sorts of interventions. And I think it will continue to dominate a global macro and potentially is giving us a very strong hint of how the
22:16 Speaker 03 end game might look like.
22:17 Speaker 01 How are you thinking about the Fed's fight against inflation? I mean, is that the priority? Are we still, should we still be looking at systemically about what's happening with banks, about commercial real estate? How are you thinking about that?
22:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, from the, that sounds like a pretty big picture statement. I checked that clip out before we went on air today, and so I'm familiar with it. It's a very big picture thought. And so the big picture thought that I'm trying to keep in my mind as we navigate this cycle is just, we added $8 trillion of debt over a two-year period or three-year period. Basically, we've never done that before. You can go back to World War II. We've never done that before. And it's, you have to, everyone, myself included, everyone has to have a certain degree of humility about what happens next. And that, I think, has been really difficult for me. I'll be honest.
23:12 Speaker 02 It's been hard for me because we go, we are historians ultimately, we're quantitative researchers. And in this world, a quantitative researcher, you're just going through history and you're mining the data that you have. And we all have the same little slice of history to work off of. And now you go throw a variable like this into the mix and you add this much debt to the picture and you impair the supply side at the same time. So you impair supply via lockdowns and then you stimulate demand via all this spending and fiscal spending is much more impactful than anything on the monetary side. So you have these two forces that have hit each other. And of course, you're going to have inflation and how that spins from here
23:54 Speaker 02 is really anyone's guess. And that's why when you get a number like this, which is really a trend break in the housing world and you say, I can go back and say, okay, we haven't had housing this expensive since the 70s and 80s. We did see it in the 70s and 80s, $3,000 real home payments. But this is the first time really in 40 years or 45 years that we've had housing prices this much and we shouldn't be re-accelerating, but yet we are. And you have to ask yourself, am I missing something? Is that history that I'm studying too different from today to really inform my analysis? And so that's the thing that I consistently try to keep in the front of my mind, not in the back of my mind, but the front of my mind as we go through this. And so that's my kind of.
24:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, excellent, excellent point, excellent point. And none of us knows how long it's going to take to work its way through the system, if it has or not. I mean, those are the questions that we've been asking and that we talk about all the time on Real Vision. And Gianco, we talked about it with him last week. And whether some of these changes are permanent, or whether they're just taking longer to work their way through the system. You know, that was a huge, huge moment. So love that you made that point because I think it's easy to forget because we kind of think that it's behind us. But in a lot of ways, it's not. A couple of questions here. Want to ask this one. And I think it speaks to this point from Trillion X. What's your view on the end of the forbearance of student
25:20 Speaker 01 loan repayment on consumption in H2 and more economic slowdown?
25:25 Speaker 02 I mean, it's a definite drag. I think that like it goes back to my point, you know, we've seen it's kind of a removal of fiscal stimulus in a way. And so that'll be a drag. I don't see it being determinative in its by itself, but I also but it's certainly a drag. And so it's one of those things that it adds to our part of our base case, which is that we're headed towards a recession, a contraction, ultimately. I mean, everyone's been all over the liquidity bus. I mean, liquidity is going to be a headwind as we go forward. Student loan forbearance headwind as we go forward. You know, and up until today,
26:07 Speaker 02 I would say housing affordability, major headwind to the economy. And those are some big headwinds. Tailwinds falling oil and energy prices, but that can reverse. And obviously, a rally in the stock market, which is kind of can feed on itself, you get that positive wealth effect. So those are some of the counterbalancing forces that I see.
26:28 Speaker 01 A question from Andrew. Would Master Pies please offer his opinion on oil and gold? You just mentioned energy prices coming down. Boy, they have. What is your outlook there?
26:40 Speaker 02 I'm on an oil bull at this point. I think especially when you take the recession off the table, I think demand is, you know, everyone was so worried about a recession coming into the year. We thought it was a longer coming cycle, second half type of event, and we've had to revise our forecast even. So what you're seeing is, I think the way to interpret what's happening in the market, if I could offer my opinion, is that I don't think that this is a true early cycle reacceleration. I think this is a bunch of positioning getting unwound. I think everyone was too bearish on the economy, embarrassed on the stock market coming into the year, and those positions are being unwound. And so that's what's happening. And now we're all searching for a narrative to fit the price action. That's what my base
27:25 Speaker 02 case is, at the very least. I think part of that positioning that's going to have to get unwound is a whole bunch of short positions that got layered onto the oil market with the idea that We're all going, we're going to a recession, that the US is going to fall into a recession. That's negative for oil. It's a very simplistic way of thinking. If you go through whatever, I look at like the petroleum complex futures market, managed money positions. In the gas oil market, for instance, we've had hedge funds net short. That's very rare and usually occurs close to market bottom. So we've seen that and it's starting to unwind. We've seen a lot of short positions in the, in the US markets as well. So I think positioning these to be unwound. I don't think the demand is going to soften this year.
28:08 Speaker 02 And so ultimately, you know, we've had some one off supply factors that have kind of weighed on the market. But with the OPEC cuts and the full brunt of the Saudi cuts in particular, coming into effect this next month. I think we're going to get some serious upside in the price of oil. So in my view, before the year's over, we touch a hundred dollars a barrel again.
28:28 Speaker 01 Interesting. I, gold, we, gold was part of that too. What's your outlook? And Colin put some more meat on his gold question. Is the price action of gold telling investors fear is coming out of the monetary system?
28:40 Speaker 02 Personally, I, our models are bullish on gold and I like gold. In the, in a, so the pause playbook is stocks, gold, bonds, like basically buy it all. And I'm a, maybe I'm being too clever here, but I, I'm starting to doubt that playbook. Cause I'm, every single incremental data point we're getting says that this pause might be short-lived. That this might be a skip and not a true pause. And I do believe gold is that first asset that starts discounting a new cutting cycle for the Fed. So I think that's what, that's what gold keys off of is ultimately it's looking out like eight to 10 months before the Fed starts cutting rates. And rallies based off of that. And I think there's been a lot of confusion and cross currents in the gold market.
29:23 Speaker 02 And that's why we've seen it's up near all time highs. But that's why we've seen kind of this churning in the, in, in the last few months. I'm worried about it because of the, because of the, the possibility that the Fed has to go back in there. And at the very least, hold rates higher for longer and keep real rates across the curve for longer than maybe the market and the gold market in particular expects. So.
29:48 Speaker 01 And, and potentially QT, if you're right, and, and they, and they're watching that housing market.
29:54 Speaker 02 Correct. We're still trying to talk about where they hike next. We're not anywhere close to the place where they pause. You know, the best way I could think of this is. Are we in, the way we framed it a few months ago, we modestly increased our equity exposure was, are we in June 06 or June 07? And I think everyone is expecting us to be more like in June 07, where we were within six to nine months of the recession, whereas June 06 was when the Fed paused and the recession didn't hit for another 18 months. And the real serious stuff didn't hit for two, 24, 30 months. And so I think that's in the market, the stock market was up 16% the year following June of 06.
30:37 Speaker 02 A lot of people forget that, but you know, that's just the difference in timing that recession, that in the difference that timing can make for different asset returns.
30:47 Speaker 01 Fantastic stuff. Lena, I see your question about commercial real estate. We're not going to tackle it today because we're out of time, but Ash is doing a deep dive on commercial real estate on the platform. So look out for that and he may come join us and update us on a couple of great conversations he's had tomorrow. So we'll touch on that a little bit more deeply tomorrow. Before I let you go, Warren, so are you, are you, are you playing stocks short term? Do you think they can run up for here? Or are you worried about that turn? And you, and if so, what do you like? Cause it sounds like you're worried about bonds. Are you worried about both? And?
31:20 Speaker 02 I'm more worried about this, the shift has been from being worried about stocks to more worried about bonds. And that's been a gradual shift. We wrote a report in May. Everyone was talking about the horrible breadth in the market. And so what we saw was this breadth divergence. We called it a mega cap breadth divergence. Very rare where the top 10% 10 stocks in the S and P 500 outperformed the bottom 490. And the message we found from this is that there's really no predictive power following a mega cap divergence, except for the fact you get a lot of volatility, either a major rally or a rout. So we called our report rally or rout, 90 days to decide, because it happens in a really short timeframe. And the bottom line is if breadth for the bottom 490 improves, you have a serious rally
32:05 Speaker 02 on your hands. And so that's what we've seen really from the end of May forward, when we had that jobs report that came out. Late May, early June, I can't remember what the rest of the market, the more cyclical pockets of the market started participating in this rally. So you really, you know, you don't want to buy the rally, you want to rent the rally here, but you don't want to be fading it or, or, you know, it depends on your timeframe and what you're doing. But I don't want to stand in front of this thing right now because I think we're still broadening out and we're still having these people chasing from their, their underweight positions. But I don't see new all time highs or anything dramatic like that. I think ultimately that I honestly think if we're going to have a recession, then we're going to be making, we're going to at least be
32:48 Speaker 02 revisiting the October lows that we had. So that's how I see over the long term. So
32:53 Speaker 01 Over the long term, yeah. More fantastic stuff today. You gave us a lot to look at, to pay attention to and to think about as we all try to sort of game out this recession. Thank you so much. It's great to catch up with you.
33:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, thank you for having me.
33:07 Speaker 01 Thanks for all the smart questions, everyone. We'll be back tomorrow. As I said, we're gonna hopefully have Ash make a quick appearance and update us on some of the great conversations happening on the platform. And we've got Sean Hackett. A lot of you have been asking about weather, about the impact on agriculture, on those ag commodities that we've been all watching. So we're going to get the man himself in to sort of lay it all out for us. So hope to see you then. In the meantime, take care and good luck out there.
33:31 Speaker 04 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest and biggest names in finance.
Previous Surfing the AI Tsunami w/ Peter H. Diamandis & Salim Ismail Next Is The Global Food Supply At Risk? With Shawn Hackett Page updated October 24, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated