Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing An Update from the Fed: Coming to the Rescue? About this episode DB-Mar 17,2021: Real Vision’s Jack Farley hosts managing editor Ed Harrison to break down the Federal Reserve’s Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting and Fed Chair Jay Powell’s speech. Harrison and Farley interpret the Fed’s projections of GDP growth, inflation, as well as their “dot plot” of the future Federal Funds rate. Farley reviews the price action in bonds, gold, and the tech-heavy NASDAQ 100, and Harrison analyzes the challenges many European nations face as they attempt to vaccinate their population against COVID-19. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:12 Speaker 00 Fed Chair Jay Powell doubles down on asset purchases, reigniting risk assets such as growth stocks and gold. But will his unwillingness to go all in on yield curve control leave long bonds stranded? For all of this and more, I'm joined by Real Vision Managing Editor Ed Harrison. Ed, how are you doing?
0:28 Speaker 01 Very good and excited to go over with you what the Fed said and what it means.
0:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, you know, Fed, this, uh, excuse me, I called you Fed. That's how much I'm thinking about the Fed. Excuse me, Ed, today is a doubly important day. We're going to talk about the Fed, but I quickly want just to say to the Real Vision audience that today is actually the one year anniversary of the Real Vision Daily Briefing. So, you know, a big thank you to everyone at home for tuning in.
0:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, I saw that our friend and colleague Nick Correa, he's the one who pointed out to us that we've been doing it for a year. Actually, you know, it may have actually even been yesterday that it was the first anniversary. Whatever day it was, I believe that we were down like 12% a year ago. So, I mean, and we were in lockdown or going into lockdown. It was just a crazy world. I think things are a lot better. They look a lot better, a little more certain today.
1:26 Speaker 00 Completely, and I think a large part of that stability in markets is due to the unprecedented monetary stimulus as well as fiscal stimulus. And today, I think that's a great transition to talk about Fed Chair Jay Powell. The presentation of the FOMC that's been meeting over the past few days was released today. And Ed, what did you make of that? Because I think there were some surprises, but at the same time, I think no one was surprised. What did you make of that?
1:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think, by the way, just to give it the macro view, as you're saying, it is good that you mentioned that a lot of this is fiscal stimulus or monetary stimulus, I should say, because the Fed came in, you know, guns blazing within a week of when we started the Real Vision Daily Briefing, and that marked the low on the S and P 500, the low on the NASDAQ, etc. So they've been very instrumental in terms of engineering this, at least, financial market recovery. With regard to the real economy's recovery, you know, unprecedented levels of fiscal stimulus as well. And I think that's where the Fed
2:38 Speaker 01 comes into play with what they did. I mean, my takeaway is that it was a nothing burger in terms of Fed action. You know, some people, including Larry McDonald, who's running on our platform right now, was saying that there's a possibility that the Fed would talk about yield curve control, the Fed might do some calendar guidance, but not this time. Maybe next time they'll do it. The thing that I took away is that the Fed basically said, we're not doing anything different than we said that we're going to do before, but we are changing our economic projections massively. You know, they're talking about GDP growth
3:23 Speaker 01 being 6.5% for the year, which is a massive upgrade. They're talking about unemployment, the unemployment rate falling to 4.5% by the end of the year from 6.2%. So massive upgrade to the economy, inflation ahead of 2% projections, and yet they're saying it's steady as she goes, more QE, keeping rates at 0% through the end of 2023. So ultra-ultra dovish, and the market didn't blink by and large. You know, no negatives from the market as a result of that.
4:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, just to give a little bit of a price action of today, and this is a segment that I think we're going to do going forward on Real Vision someday. So the US 10-year, it opened the day at about 1.61 at that level. Midday, it was selling off and it got up to 1.68, 1.68 and a half. It did reach an equilibrium after the Fed meeting and it's now went back down to 1.662 as we're recording this now, right after market close. I did think, Ed, that that was due to, as you say, the Federal Reserve repludging itself to its asset purchases, at least $120 billion per month, at least $80 billion of treasuries,
4:44 Speaker 00 at least $40 billion of mortgage-backed securities. I think, though, the real question is about the maturity of those assets that it buys. A lot of those assets are in that early part of the curve, on the front end, the belly, and then the 10-year. Some people were wondering, as you say, like Barry McDonald and many others, is the Fed going to enact yield curve control, where the Fed pins yields at the long end of the curve? Yeah, you're right, absolutely. That Fed Chair Powell, he kind of punted on that question and he said, "Look, the Fed has its tools and we're happy with the tools now and perhaps we'll change the tools going forward." He basically dodged the question.
5:24 Speaker 00 And I'm interested to see, so if you have a look at a chart that we have here, the IEF, the IShares 7- to 10-year Treasury, actually went positive on the day. In other words, that 10-year bonds had a slight rally, but the IShares 20-plus Treasury, the TLT, the long-duration bonds, was actually down 0.7% on the day. I might also add that the Nasdaq and the gold were trading very similarly. They both rallied as the Fed recommitted itself to asset purchases. So I think the possibility of the Fed reining in the bond market, that, I guess, reignited risk assets such as the Nasdaq 100, Tesla, DocuSign, gold.
6:06 Speaker 00 It's funny to think of DocuSign and gold as sort of trading similarly today, but that's what you have. But long bonds, Ed, what about long bonds? What about yield curve control? What about Operation Twist? Some journalists, I think, said Operation Twist and I don't even think Powell, I think he dismissed it. What's the significance of that if yields can continue to rise on the long end? Obviously, it's good for banks, but what's the broader impact?
6:29 Speaker 01 Well, basically, the Fed said, we're not going to do any of that stuff. Operation Twist, all these other things to to muck around with the market because we don't have to. And interestingly enough, the price action for today at least says they don't have to. That the Fed is saying, okay, rates can rise, but we'll let them rise. And it's no skin off our backs. We're just going to continue to do the same thing. The narrative before today had been that, okay, if the Fed does that, then we're going to see a march higher in rates. We yet may still see that march higher. And that march higher would lead to yield curve control. It would lead to Operation Twist.
7:14 Speaker 01 But as yet, the Fed is still playing chicken with the market. And let's just see how that that pans out.
7:22 Speaker 00 Absolutely. And Ed, I just want to show a few more charts showing just the sort of the in the derivatives markets and the sell off in bonds. Because, you know, everyone knows, okay, the 30 years been selling off, the 10 years been selling off. But I think, you know, there is some important things in the euro-dollar markets as well as the Fed funds future markets that I just got today. If you look at the Fed funds 30-day or the one-month futures, that's sort of a weighted average of what that rate is going to be. In January 15th, the entire curve was below 20 basis points. Now, it's going into the middle half of 2022, or I guess the middle half of 2023.
8:03 Speaker 00 It's it's above 20 basis points and some at the very end of the 2025 is above 50 basis points. So we've had a massive, I don't want to say a sell-off, but it's been, you know, people basically betting that yields are going to rise. So it's not just in the spot, the underlying rates, it's in the derivatives. And then we've seen the similar thing for the the euro-dollar three-month curves where what the market is expecting rates are going to be for the three-month rate has steadily risen in lockstep with the the spot yields. Ed, I want to just talk about the the dot plot because we have Have, you know, the dot plot from December of 2020, December 16th.
8:44 Speaker 00 And there it was five people of the, I think actually 17 FOMC members, Federal Open Market Committees, who expected that they would raise rates. Now it was seven of, I believe, 18 members. So there is some wiggle room at the margin of some people on the board saying, okay, we're going to raise rates a little bit closer. Oh, and by the way, four of them indicated that they're going to raise rates in 2022. So even though Powell can put on a little bit of bold face, and when someone says the word taper to him, he can laugh in their face. You know, at the margin, you look at the people on the board and a few people on the board are saying, hey, maybe we should raise rates. Maybe, you know, inflation is picking up.
9:29 Speaker 00 Maybe, you know, we should price that in. What your thoughts?
9:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's marginal movement. So five to seven in 2023, and now we have four in 2022. That's still unprecedentedly loose, given the fact that here we are in the beginning of 2021 with the Fed predicting 6.5% GDP growth and also above 2% inflation. I think that they're predicting something like 2.3% for this year. Ultimately, I think that the question really, what it boils down to is, to the degree that people think that the Fed is going to cave, what do they do about that?
10:16 Speaker 01 And also to the degree that they think that the US is not a place that they want to hold assets, what do they do about that? One is, and the second question, the currency is the release valve. I think that it puts pressure, downward pressure on the dollar. But on the first question, that's what we're looking to find out. How much higher can yields go? And will the Fed eventually cry uncle? Will there be a break in the system? And if you look at parallels, the parallel I used to make is 2018, it took a whole year before we had some sort of breakage. So I think we still have a long way to go before we see any real movement here.
10:58 Speaker 01 The question is, how much higher can yields go? And will the Fed?
11:05 Speaker 01 Actually make a move in the here and now as a result of that. So these dot plot moves, to me, they're relatively minor and therefore they don't have that much importance.
11:17 Speaker 00 Ed, if the Federal Reserve were to step off the gas, and I agree with you that they showed no indication that they will, but if they were going to, what would that look like? Would that mean they would raise the federal funds rate? Would it mean they would taper their asset purchases? Is there something else they could do if they wanted to take some juice out of the economy?
11:35 Speaker 01 I think what they would do is they would say, you know, like when we think about the taper tantrum and we think about tapering assets, they would say that, you know, to use Larry McDonald's thing, we're going to start to give you guidance as to, you know, the conditions under which we'll do X. Or we'll give you some guidance on terms of what, when we're actually going to do Y. So X is probably more like yield curve control or Operation Twist. And Y is probably tapering of assets. So with regard to the tapering of assets and actually getting a calendar date, that's what precipitates things like the taper tantrum.
12:20 Speaker 01 Because now you know that they're, you know, they're going to stop buying assets and the next thing is going to be hiking rates. So as soon as they tell you what the timetable is for that, if that timetable is accelerated relative to expectations, then you could see rates go up as a result of that. The other is, you know, okay, in these conditions, if inflation gets to this level or if the real GDP gets to this level or interest rates get to that level, we will do Operation Twist or we will engage in yield curve control at the five year, the 10 year level.
13:02 Speaker 01 Those are things that would happen only if rates go up enough that the Fed needs to act against rates. But they're not saying that we're going to act against a specific rate. They're saying that if it goes to a level that's higher than the rate that we have today, we're going to act. So both of those are sort of like, they're saying, we're not going to do stuff now, but here are the preconditions for if we do do something. And in both cases, it's the Fed saying, Things have unraveled enough either in terms of the economy moving too hot or interest rates going up too much that we need to give you a little bit more forward guidance.
13:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, I was just thinking of what Larry McDonald said about forward guidance, that the Federal Reserve has to give very clear instructions to the market to calm it down. Ed, if I recall from what Larry shared his thoughts to you, he didn't so much as say that in this meeting that happened today, Fed Chair, he is going to step on the gas, he is going to enact your yield curve control, he is going to give all these calendar guidance. What I gathered was more he said if Fed Chair doesn't and he punts on a lot of these key issues, rates will continue to rise and that will be a systemic threat to businesses and to governments just because out of the sheer amount of debt that we have on our books.
14:33 Speaker 01 Right, yeah, that's what I got and that eventually he'll be forced and that he thinks that if it didn't happen this meeting, then it would happen next meeting in some capacity. I would agree, I think that it will happen eventually, but I don't necessarily think that it's going to happen in the immediate future. Again, you know, if you look at 2018, the way that it worked out in 2018, just so that people remember, is when we went into the year, the market was saying to us that we were going to have two hikes, 50 basis points, two 25 basis points hikes in 2018. The official guidance from the Fed was that we were going to have three hikes. And the market didn't believe the Fed.
15:18 Speaker 01 But not only did the Fed do three hikes, but as the year progressed, it started to use language to suggest it was going to do a fourth hike. And in fact, it did do the fourth hike in December and it's when that fourth hike happened, plus, you know, language that said we're going to continue to hike, that's when, you know, the shit hit the fan and that's when, you know, markets tumbled, credit markets started... To fall apart and then Powell was was forced to pivot. So that's the sort of scenario that I would expect to play out. It's a very longer term perspective. We're at what 164 something 162 to 164. That's not that terrible.
16:01 Speaker 01 The next level to worry about is 175. And then from there to 2%. So one of those two levels, I think, will be interesting to see. You know, how equities perform and what sort of jawboning we get from the Fed as a result of that.
16:18 Speaker 00 Ed, what's your outlook on gold? Gold shot up today, had quite a bump, as did technology stocks. The Nasdaq actually, I think, was down about 0.45%. Excuse me, no, it was down 1.4% and it actually ended the day in the green at about 0.4% up of the day. So that's quite a recovery. Obviously, you think of gold and tech stocks, growth stocks, as having a high duration. Their their cash flows are oriented towards the future. Obviously, cash, gold doesn't have a cash flow, but it does very well. It trades inversely with real rates. So what do you think of TLT selling off while these assets? While these assets that are, you know, are kind of linked to TLT, to long bonds, performed well. A little strange, don't you think?
17:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's just a one day move. I don't, I don't really, you know, what happens in an individual day? I don't really make anything of it. It could be, you know, people hedging their positions and it's just enough to move the market. But ultimately, I think to the degree that the market is trying to force the Fed in one direction or another, eventually that's going to have a positive impact on real yields. And that's not necessarily bullish for gold over the short to medium term.
17:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, I just, I don't know.
17:37 Speaker 00 If Powell did enough, I guess some people are wondering if Powell did enough because I was looking at a chart, it shows it indexes the 10-year treasury yield to 100 and it compares different sell-offs and it compares it to the June 2003 sell-off, the 1994 bond massacre, the April 2015 sell-off, the 2013 taper tantrum and this sell-off, we're only four or five weeks in, it's well above every other bond taper tantrum. So I think, is it possible that Chair Powell does not take this bond sell-off seriously or he thinks, yeah, rates are rising because growth is rising and that's good or because inflation is rising and who cares, you know, we're well below 2%?
18:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think it's the first, it's, you know, when you think about nominal GDP growth, you're thinking about growth, you know, real GDP growth and then you're thinking about inflation and what he's basically saying is there's so much real GDP growth in there that even if there is some inflation, ultimately it's positive. And then secondarily, by the way, I really care about the real economy, I care about unemployment and things like that. So if the markets take a breather, that's fine with me. I thought it was interesting on that level, if you look at the FT today, Martin Wolf, he had a commentary about that
18:58 Speaker 01 saying that obviously everyone knows the market's not the economy and so then the question is, do we really care if the market falls? If the market, you know, let's say has a 30% correction, doesn't really matter, especially if the real economy is doing well. And the answer obviously is no. If the real economy is doing well, then that's what really matters over the longer term, that's where we want to see action. And so I think that's kind of what Chairman Powell is saying is that he believes that the Fed is doing things to make the real economy do better and that's why rates are going up and so stay the course. That's the mantra that the Fed is trying to get behind.
19:45 Speaker 00 Absolutely. I might add, a serious decline, a material decline in the stock market, isn't necessarily bad for all investors. If you're under 35 years old, you're a net saver, and the vast majority of your nest egg you haven't made yet, in other words, that you basically have a, you have a high duration in terms of your savings. You know, if the stock market goes down, that could be good, because you'll just pile your additional money into it, and then you'll be taken on the ride back up.
20:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's like with the housing bubble. When the housing bubble burst, if you had available cash, and you were a renter, you had a stable income, maybe that was a good opportunity for you to be able to buy, whereas you were priced out of the market before. So at the end of the day, you know, stocks are just a discounting mechanism for future cash, and what the Fed is saying, and I'm not saying that I agree with anything the Fed's saying, I'm just trying to interpret what they're saying. The Fed's saying that, you know, irrespective of how you're discounting right now, I discount in a very positive way. The trends that are happening in the economy now are very positive for the economy, and
20:56 Speaker 01 ultimately, over the longer term, you should suspect that that would be positive for shares and for financial assets more generally.
21:05 Speaker 00 I think that's such a key point, Ed, and that's a great way to close this deep dive that we've done on the FOMC presentation and Fed Chair Powell's meeting. By the way, just for the people at home, that this has been our deep dive segment that I actually forgot to call out. But now let's move on to our next segment, which is on our radar. So Ed, we've talked about the Fed meeting. What else is on your radar in business, markets, and the global economy?
21:34 Speaker 01 Interestingly, I'm thinking about the runway to the full reopening, because what we've seen in Europe recently, Jack, is a bit worrying with regard to the lockdown in Italy, and then also, you know, case counts going up, and the...
21:55 Speaker 01 The positivity rate for infections going up in places like Germany and France. They're ahead of us here in the US, but perhaps that's something that's going to happen to the US. So, number one, the US is vaccinating better than Europe and that's positive. Number two, I think that we already see that the US is growing faster than Europe. So perhaps that means that there is room for a differential in terms of asset prices. You know, that premium that you pay for US assets, it could be that that premium will continue because of the disparity that we see in growth.
22:35 Speaker 01 But also, there's another outcome where what's happening in Europe actually boomerangs back and happens here in the United States as well.
22:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, the vaccine is so important. As you say, US, we are ahead of Europe, especially with that hiccup over AstraZeneca. I've been talking to Max, who's been working with many of our British colleagues, such as Roger Hurst and Jamie McDonald, and he says that the phrase that they use is called getting a jab. So, you know, I hope that you're able to get a jab soon, if you haven't already, and I hope me and my family, I hope everyone can get a jab as soon as possible.
23:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, and you know, the way that I think about it is in terms of hospitalization rates. And in America at this point now, the majority of over 65s, those are the people who are most vulnerable, have already had the jab. And if they've had the jab, what that means is the potential for hospital overload, the way that we've had in the past, has diminished significantly, and death, of course, as well. So, there is, you could make the case that the United States is running ahead of the new mutant variants in a way that allows it to avoid the lockdowns that we're seeing in Europe, because Europe is just not vaccinating quite as quickly, and the variants, they came
23:54 Speaker 01 up on Europe a lot more quickly than they have on the United States. But there is, there are scenarios in which, you know, we reopen, as we're doing now, and then... You know, lo and behold, at the tail end of this month or the beginning of of April, we see another sort of, you know, spike up that really causes the expected 6.5% growth to actually diminish. And maybe that means that we see a re-flattening of the yield curve. And we also see equities rotating out of the the growth, out of the value stocks,
24:36 Speaker 01 back into growth because there's a little bit of uncertainty about what the long-term trajectory is.
24:42 Speaker 00 Thanks, Ed. My final question for you is based on two stories that are on my radar. So about $410 billion is, that's the amount of the stimulus checks that have to go out. 242 billion of that is already out. So more than half of the stimulus check money is already out to people. And then my second story on my radar is that the IRS for, you know, taxes is planning to delay the tax filing of April 15th by about one month. So, you know, the fiscal authorities are sort of helping out. So, Ed, my question for you is, are the dominoes for a double pop reflation rally being lined up?
25:19 Speaker 01 You mean more, another boost to equities as a result of those of those outcomes?
25:26 Speaker 00 Yeah.
25:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't see anything on the near-term horizon that's saying definitively we need to to have a correction. What I see as the only real gray swan, if you will, is this this potential for the mutant variants to delay the lockdowns. But it seems like all systems are go with regard to the US economy at this point. And if anything, there's upside risk. And that upside risk is being played out in terms of, you know, inflation expectations going up and then also yields going up.
26:10 Speaker 01 And and I think that that's the the bigger risk at this particular juncture.
26:15 Speaker 00 Ed, thanks so much. I like, by the way, how you said gray swan, a smart move, because anytime you say black swan, someone's going to correct you and say it's a white swan. And anytime you say white swan, someone's going to correct you and say black swan. So, good call, hedging your bets.
26:27 Speaker 01 Thank you. I like that.
26:29 Speaker 00 All right. Thanks, Ed. Talk soon.
Previous Opposing Views: Pomp & Mike Green on Bitcoin Next How Are Rising Yields Impacting Retirement Portfolios? Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated